Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Shame-Retribution Trauma and Borderline Personality
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob as a part of spring cleaning, I thought we would actually really
- 0:04try this time for serious and answer all the emails that we've had for a
- 0:09long time. I've been cataloging these emails about borderline personality disorder. Oh yeah,
- 0:14so let's get to it. What do you say? Sure? So
- 0:16this first email is from patrons Susie from Dayton, Ohio. She says,
- 0:22hi, doctor Hannah. I thought this reddit thread asking for an explain like,
- 0:26I'm so just chiming in here. Do you know reddit at all?
- 0:29Do you look at Reddit? Not? I think I've looked at it twice.
- 0:32So there's one subreddit which is like its own forum, if you will.
- 0:37That is called explain like I'm five or l l I five. And
- 0:44it's a great subreddit because people ask questions like explain general relativity, and so
- 0:51someone who knows their stuff will explain it as if they're explaining it to a
- 0:57five year old. That's awesome. So there was someone that did an E
- 1:00L I five explain like I'm five about borderline. So I thought we would
- 1:06read some people's summaries. What do you say? Oh, this would be
- 1:07interesting. So this person unit Zeron says, you know how sometimes you feel
- 1:15happy or sad and other times you feel really happy or very sad. You
- 1:22know, really happy or very sad. That's what it's like all the time.
- 1:26So just chiming in here or what do you think about that? They're
- 1:29saying that folks with borderline personality just sort of have big range of affect right,
- 1:38Does that feel accurate to you so far? I mean, yeah,
- 1:41I don't think I would ever describe BPD that way. It's sort of like,
- 1:44oh, I'm happy as opposed to well, there's a reason the trigger
- 1:48that mat set off usually not happy, right. I feel like this is
- 1:53one of the things that is focused on. It's focused on in the DSM
- 1:57by the way, but we all understand a d SAM is not your pathway
- 2:01to understanding any personality sorder. It is a list of behavioral indications that a
- 2:09clinician can reliably use as a way of zeroing in on a diagnosis. Yeah,
- 2:16it's not a way to understand what's happening. And this highlighted notion of
- 2:24being really happy and really sad is what causes people to confuse borderline with bipolar,
- 2:30right, you know, and also even for bipolar, it's not just
- 2:36being really happy and really sad, unless you also really emphasize the fact that
- 2:40when people are manic, it's a particular kind of thing. It's funny people
- 2:46miss that. Oh you have to just spend five minutes with somebody who's actually
- 2:49in a manic state to understand that's what that is. Yeah, and if
- 2:53you've never seen mania or heard about it at length, you probably don't really
- 2:59understand it because it's it's really quite particular. Yeah, going on going on
- 3:04their brain makes it so they only have big feelings, So just that make
- 3:09that means that they don't often get to have the in between feelings that you
- 3:15and I have, and sometimes can go from feeling okay to having really big
- 3:19feelings. Really, this is getting worse as it's as it's going. It
- 3:22feels fast to us, but it's normal for them. It can be really
- 3:25hard work to have big feelings all the time like they do, and that's
- 3:30part of why they're so tired all the time. Did you see fatigue in
- 3:36the DSM? Is that one of those uh yeah, I mean I think
- 3:38this individual was saying so the beginning was they were actually talking to an actual
- 3:45five year old, their own child. I think about someone else and their
- 3:47family, So I think maybe they're trying to explain that in particular. Yeah,
- 3:53so that that's a pretty and so that's the top. So that that
- 3:55one has over that one has twenty four hundred up votes, which means that
- 4:00there's a lot of people saying, yes, that's a good explain, Like
- 4:02I'm five in the guarding borderline. Yeah, let's read another one. People
- 4:10have skin to protect us, so a person with and this one has seventy
- 4:15three ufotes, So this one's even higher UPFOTA and a lot of people gave
- 4:19this person, like these little rewards you can give each other, these little
- 4:23gold stamps and stuff. People have skin to protect us, so a person
- 4:27with no skin would feel extreme pain at even being touched. People with BPD
- 4:31have little to no emotional skin, so they can feel extreme emotional pain in
- 4:38response to small triggers. How are they doing so far now? So it's
- 4:45like someone was born with no skin. I mean, come on, man,
- 4:48people with porderland personalities order. I mean, yeah, nature nurture all
- 4:53that, but like this comes from something. These are not just thin skinned
- 4:56people. So where here's what I really don't like about it. It's dismissive
- 5:00of Oh, that person's just thin skinned. They you know, we don't
- 5:03have to take their feelings seriously because obviously they're just being dramatic or whatever.
- 5:06That's their thin skin as opposed to well, nobody ever chose any feeling they
- 5:12ever had in the history of feelings. How would you do explain, like
- 5:15I'm five, borderline personage starter, Yeah, Oh, these are folks who
- 5:19have been hurt pretty bad as little people, and as a result, their
- 5:23brains have developed in such a way that they perceive Well, you don't just
- 5:29perceive it. I mean that gets a little bit complicated. But where the
- 5:35pains of youth show up in adulthood just like everybody else. I mean everybody
- 5:41has that to some degree others. So it's not really a you have it
- 5:43or you don't have it. It's more like a continuum, which is what
- 5:46you often will talk about here, is that you know these things are on
- 5:49a continuum. Yeah. If I were to try to explain, like I'm
- 5:54like someone was five, I would say to a five year old, have
- 5:59you ever had your feelings hurt and it made you want to cry? It
- 6:03hurt your feelings like really badly? Have that ever happened to you. The
- 6:08kid would say, yeah, that has happened to me on the playground when
- 6:11Johnny wouldn't let me play with him. Okay, kid, Johnny, Yeah,
- 6:15And I'd say, okay, well, so when you have your feelings
- 6:18hurt, what helps you? Right? And the kid would say, well,
- 6:21I would cry, or I would go to you, or I would
- 6:26tell the teacher, I would tell Johnny to stop it, or I would
- 6:29play with another friend. Okay, So when you do those things, do
- 6:32you feel better? I'd say, yeah, I feel I feel better.
- 6:35Why do you feel better? Well, I feel better because I don't have
- 6:40to deal with Johnny anymore, or something like that. Whatever, be ok
- 6:43Okay. So you have when your feelings hurt, you have a way to
- 6:46relieve it, to find a way to feel better. Yeah okay, meaning
- 6:53that later in the day your feelings aren't hurt anymore, right, yeah,
- 6:57okay. Well, imagine if you have your feelings hurt and you never have
- 7:02any way to feel better, no one is there to help you, and
- 7:08it's so often that your feelings are being hurt by sometimes it's your parents,
- 7:13that you're pretty much in a constant state of having your feelings hurt, and
- 7:18you grow up and you still have that constant state of hurt feelings. I
- 7:25guess i'd ask the five year old another question of like, so, when
- 7:29your feelings hurt, are you in a bad mood? Maybe hopefully? I
- 7:31mean some five year olds had enough and yeah, I'm in a bad mood.
- 7:35And then when you feel better, you're in a better mood. Yeah,
- 7:39I'm in a better mood. Okay, Well, imagine if your feelings
- 7:41are hurt a lot as a kid, there's no way to feel better,
- 7:44no one's there to listen to you, and you're in a constant bad mood.
- 7:48And so if anything happens, particularly if someone hurts your feelings, it
- 7:55feels like one hurt feeling too far. And there's a lot of hurt that
- 8:01comes, you know, forward from someone because they have no way to feel
- 8:05better. There's so much built up inside of them. Maybe I'd even use
- 8:07some sort of metaphor of a container that was overflowing with hurt there was no
- 8:13way to drain the container or something. But the way that people typically will
- 8:20talk about it is this first one where it's like you have big emotions,
- 8:22which is really just missing the point entirely. And this is why there's so
- 8:26many people that talk about quiet borderline because they'll be like, the way people
- 8:31talk about borderline, I'm not like that, And it's like, well,
- 8:35yeah, because people don't know what the fuck they're talking about. It doesn't
- 8:37mean we need another label. It just means we need to tell people you
- 8:41don't know what you're talking about when you're talking about borderline. Anyway, So
- 8:46going on, but I will say that this one's a little better. This
- 8:48second one is that the individual is they can feel extreme emotional pain and response
- 8:56to small triggers. I mean, at least that's better than you just have
- 9:00wild mood swings. Yeah. Right, it goes on. For example,
- 9:05boyfriend hasn't texted in several days. The person without borderline person disorder might be
- 9:09miffed. Person with borderline personality disorder has a brain that informs them he's abandoned
- 9:16you. Now you are completely alone in the world, maybe with a side
- 9:20of he abandoned you just like everyone else does, because you are such a
- 9:24piece of shit and you deserve it. I don't recommend swearing to a five
- 9:26year old, but what do you think about that bit? Yeah, that
- 9:30one captures the experience of rejection. Yeah, yeah, yeah, so that
- 9:33one has more up votes and that's better. And then let's look at one
- 9:39more. Cop says, it's an emotional regulation disorder. Okay, right away,
- 9:46we have a problem. It's not an emotional regulation disorder. It's an
- 9:52abandonedment trauma disorder. Things that might hurt us a little emotionally or make us
- 9:58feel loved will make it an individual with borderline person I sort of feel extreme
- 10:01forms of those emotions. This creates stress in their social relationships, which feeds
- 10:07into their borderline symptoms. Internally, it can lead to intense feelings of loneliness
- 10:13abandonment, which can cause self harm or suicide. What do you think about
- 10:18that one? Yeah, I'm with that for the most part. What do
- 10:22you think? Yeah, I mean it's fine, it's not extremely sufficient,
- 10:24and it doesn't mention the trauma. No, so let's answer another email here
- 10:31up your patron, rain Lions says, dear Psychology and Seattle, thank you
- 10:35again for your capassionate and thoughtful insights concerning cluster bees. And then she goes
- 10:41on to describe her schemas as a result of her relational traumas, which I'll
- 10:45skip over, and then she says, what truly is the most effective way
- 10:50of dealing with this to become healthy in our relationships to ourselves and others?
- 10:56EMDR. I was so close to getting into that with my last great therapist,
- 11:01but we had too much here and now that we were bogged down with
- 11:05Do you know what she means by that here and now? I imagined that
- 11:09they were dealing with their relationship with one another. That's what I would guess,
- 11:16But maybe here now was you know, stuff happening in her life,
- 11:20like her job or whatever. Right, yeah, it could be either of
- 11:22those. I've been through DBT and it's incredibly helpful, but sometimes I lose
- 11:28sight of it any other specific suggestions. So she's saying, I have a
- 11:35lot of issues in the cluster B area, whether that's borderline or histrionic or
- 11:39narcissistic. And she's saying, do I do EMDR. What's the most effective
- 11:46way? I've done DBT and it's helpful, But she says she loses So
- 11:50what do you think she means by I lose sight of it? DBT?
- 11:54It's easy to forget skills. What do you suggest to people? I've had
- 11:58people returned to d for a tune up, you know, like a little
- 12:01a little refresher. So we used to we used to say to people,
- 12:05if you join our class, you have to join for a year. But
- 12:09anybody that's graduated from a DBT program somewhere else can join us or US can
- 12:13join us for six months, just once through the curriculum. That's what it
- 12:16takes. Six months. So that's a possibility for them if they found it
- 12:18helpful, then yeah, but there's probably not kind of going to be any
- 12:22substitute for a personal counseling. That has to do with what is the experience
- 12:28of the connection with the therapist and hanging in with that and writing it out
- 12:35ups and downs and having that be safe. Yeah, yeah, Andy R.
- 12:43Yeah, you can certainly do it if you want to focus on specific
- 12:46traumas traumas right, yeah. And with EMDR therapists sometimes they will either on
- 12:54purpose or inadvertently have a corrective emotional experience involved where there's a solid relationship there.
- 13:01But in line with what Bomb is saying, I always just recommend people
- 13:05look for what Bob is talking about, which is a relationship, corrective experience
- 13:11with the therapist that you can heal and generalize to relationships outside of the therapy
- 13:16office. Praises to look for our attachment focus or the phrase corrective experiences,
- 13:22which I don't usually hear people using these days. Or exposure based therapies might
- 13:30also help, but that's not transference based or transference focus is another term you
- 13:35might look for. A relational, relational psychoonamic, relational psychoanalytic therapists interpersonal people,
- 13:43intersubjective people, but it's hard to know until you actually interview them and
- 13:48say, okay, I have these schema's. Long term therapy with you would
- 13:54look like what exactly and the kind of things you're looking for is if they
- 13:58say, well what I do with you is or people with those schemes is
- 14:03one we try to become aware of them and two I want to help you
- 14:07to learn that those schemas are not true about you and you have to actually
- 14:15experience things that challenge that and go in a different direction where in normal situations
- 14:22you'll experience abandonment or someone not caring about you, and with me, you'll
- 14:28experience actually someone who doesn't abandon you and someone who does care about you,
- 14:31someone it doesn't exploit you and neurologically, over time, things will change and
- 14:37so you'll just be less reactive and less likely to assume that that those things
- 14:43are happening in the outside world. And so that's what you look for.
- 14:46The sad thing is it's hard to find. And you could call fifty therapists
- 14:52and maybe one or two would say the things that I'm saying, and both
- 14:56those therapists might suck or not really what they're doing. So, you know,
- 15:01I hate to put it out there now. There are a lot of
- 15:05great therapists out there listening. There's a lot of people listening who have great
- 15:07therapists. Bob's therapist, you know, as someone that's great along these lines,
- 15:13and they're out there. But it's hard, but it's recommended for sure.
- 15:20Have any thoughts of that. No. Patron Esther from Ohio. She
- 15:26says, Hello, Kirk and Bob. I come from a deep, abusive
- 15:30and problematic family of origin. I have complex PTSD, disorganized attachment and a
- 15:35dissociative disorder, so esther a lot of abuse and it's disorganized attachment and association.
- 15:43A few years ago, my therapist of four years terminated me very suddenly.
- 15:48He is an attachment oriented therapist, and we did a lot of very
- 15:54intense work together. In the beginning of our work together, I was terrified
- 15:56he would terminate. He would reassure me he would not terminate unless he moved
- 16:02or died. So just chiming in here. So that would be something that
- 16:04I would tell people with borderline that that phrase, because I wouldn't normally have
- 16:11to even think about that, particularly in the beginning of my career when I
- 16:15was twenty six years old. But I would into it and check in with
- 16:21myself before I could commit to that. But I would eventually say things like
- 16:25that to people with borderline, and I would continue to do that. Yeah,
- 16:27I would saying because in between sessions it's normal for someone with borderline to
- 16:33start to become paranoid and worry and terrified of being abandoned, not necessarily even
- 16:38by my choice, but by circumstances, right like changing jobs or that sort
- 16:44of thing. And so I would feel compelled to tell clients I love Seattle,
- 16:49so I'm never leaving, I'm never moving. I can almost guarantee you
- 16:52that I'm young and I'm pretty healthy, so it's not likely I'm going to
- 16:56die anytime soon. And three, I will never terminate with you. You
- 17:02will be the one terminating for me. Yeah, I mean unless you do
- 17:06something really agree just like you try to kill me. There is zero chance
- 17:10that I will ever think of you as someone that I should be distincting myself
- 17:15from. I am dedicated to being a therapist and by extension, to you,
- 17:19So I'm never going to say you're annoying, you're too much for me,
- 17:23you're a burden, I don't like the way you talk to me or
- 17:27think about I'll never do that because I know what's happening. I can see
- 17:33what's happening, and I'm not going to say it's not gonna hurt my feelings.
- 17:37I'm not going to say it's not going to stress me out. But
- 17:38I will never leave. You can leave me whenever you want, but I
- 17:42will never leave you. And I might have to say that for fifteen minutes
- 17:48every session, sure, because it's part of the corrective experience, a lifetime
- 17:53of feeling abandoned, of being abandoned. It's not going to just go away
- 17:56over night because some therapist said one time. Hey, Nope, as far
- 18:00as I know, I'm not retiring anytime soon. So I'm here right and
- 18:06I don't know if you picked up on it, and if I really kind
- 18:08of poured it on, which I would do at times, because I would
- 18:11really want it to be felt by them. You know, the I wasn't
- 18:15just informing them of a data point, right, and the way I role
- 18:19played it, I was really trying to get under their skin because because I
- 18:23want them to feel it, right, because it's true. And I might
- 18:27even say things like when I decided to become a therapist years ago, working
- 18:33with someone like you is exactly why I wanted to be a therapist. And
- 18:38I'm also very angry at a lot of therapists that will terminate with clients for
- 18:45reasons that boggle me. So I'm there's a lot of passion inside of me
- 18:52independent of you, honestly that would cause me never to leave you. But
- 18:56in addition to that, I like you as a human being, and I
- 18:59like working with you. I look forward to talking to you, and I
- 19:03will just never do that. It's just not in my soul. I'll do
- 19:07everything in my everything I can possibly do to avoid that. I want to
- 19:12reassure you that, and if you ever want me to reassure you that,
- 19:15I will resure that so similar to if you have a spouse or a friend
- 19:22or a family member. If imagine if they said that to you, like,
- 19:25no matter what happens here, I'm never going to divorce you, or
- 19:27I'm never going to break up with you. I'm never going to leave you
- 19:30because of all these reasons, because of you, because of us, because
- 19:34of me and my values. You know, it just feels better. You
- 19:38know, there's that whole thing and that I mentioned earlier about the happy feelings
- 19:42that folks would borderland personality have and in the dsmity talking about an idealization of
- 19:48another human. But I was thinking about it the following way. You've had
- 19:51a life of abandonment, abuse, mistreatment, rejection. When somebody shows up
- 19:57who cares, you're going to be elated. That's like going through the desert
- 20:03and finally getting a drink of water. You're definitely going to be focused on
- 20:07what it's like to have your thirst quenched and want some more of that.
- 20:11Maybe have mixed feelings about it, maybe be scary to trust that there really
- 20:15is going to be another cup of water they're waiting on you. But nonetheless,
- 20:19when you think about idealization, that's really what it is is somebody who's
- 20:25gotten soothing after a life of never being soothed. So I would say a
- 20:30break, we get back more questions about borderline? What do you say?
- 20:33Yep, all right, we're back from the break with you, Bob.
- 20:40If I might ask, you have a similar desire and need and trauma,
- 20:47but it doesn't manifest an idealization, right, Oh, I think it has.
- 20:52I don't think. I wouldn't say to an extreme, well, how
- 20:56would I know? Yeah, occasionally I've idealized people. Then in retrospect sort
- 21:00of like thought, oh, yeah, my sense of that person is,
- 21:03you know, distorted. Would you say it's in the borderline direction or probably?
- 21:08What do you mean? I'm thinking of somebody that I know who when
- 21:14I first was friends with them, they were very kind to me. They
- 21:18made a place for me in their life, and spend a lot of time
- 21:22with them and not you. And although it's true you and I when we
- 21:27first met, it's true that spent a lot of time. I lived at
- 21:30your house for parts of each week. Yeah, in retrospect, I'm looked
- 21:34back on that and I see ways in which I was idealizing of them that
- 21:41ignored some of the parts of that friendship that were unwholesome for me. Yeah,
- 21:48it's interesting because I will often talk about disorganized attachment and borderline instriotic narcissistic
- 21:56in a similar paragraph, but they're not the same. There's overlap. Maybe
- 22:02I'll do a deep dive trying to delineate it just for myself, because with
- 22:07quintessential borderline, I would say it's fairly often the case that that individual does
- 22:15have disorganized attachment exhibits what I would call it disorganized attachment. But not everyone
- 22:22with disorganized attachment manifests in a borderline way, which is kind of interesting because
- 22:27because yeah, I would not characterize you as even being close to say,
- 22:33even twenty percent borderline spectrum really but definitely disorganized attachment, and that you will
- 22:41desperately want to be close to people, but be very afraid the closer you
- 22:45get to people. Right, I have no idea what that is well all
- 22:48the time, right, and for some people with borderline that is what happens,
- 22:52But there's an additional way of seeing it. Maybe that's what it is.
- 22:57And that's also kind of interesting to think. If you're okay talking about
- 23:00this is you don't qualify for any disorder for any personality disorder. Really,
- 23:07you're there's not really a person even though you have clear disorganized attachment signs.
- 23:12There's no personality sort of spectrum that I would say characterizes yet. No,
- 23:17I probably don't fit any any of them, though I have traits of being
- 23:22borderline. I have some of that in me. Yeah, yeah, I
- 23:25don't think I have narcissism, my might. I don't think so. I
- 23:27haven't noticed that. I'm not histrionic. I'm not, I mean, maybe
- 23:33paranoid, but not paranoid, maybe not OCP. You're not a perfectionist,
- 23:38it's dependent. You're not a perfectionist, right, I don't think so.
- 23:41No, Yeah, you're not any social for sure, you're not any social.
- 23:45Yeah. Yeah. That's interesting though, to think that we don't have
- 23:51a common personality sort of spectrum that would describe your issue, because your issue
- 23:57is just as significant as any personality disorder. Maybe we don't have a category
- 24:03for it. We don't have a way to conceptualizing and distill into a category
- 24:11someone like me, though I think someone like me is actually fairly well understood
- 24:15outside of that nomenclature, right, I mean, there is personality sorder not
- 24:19otherwise specified I'm just trying to think, like I'm going to walk myself through
- 24:23this if you don't mind at all. So the way I see personality disorders
- 24:29is that as a result of you could argue disposition plays a role, but
- 24:34because of early childhood experience is related to attachment figures, the individual neurologically changes
- 24:42or adapts or develops in a way that results in the individual later on in
- 24:48life having significant distortions around their perception of self and other such that it causes
- 24:57a lot of suffering themselves and their relationships. The key is that the disorder
- 25:03is a disorder of perception. So like, for if we apply that to
- 25:11you, when Colleen is maybe distant from you because you've been distant from her
- 25:19or something, I'm just hypothetical, and she's a little she's hurt or giving
- 25:26up for that day or something, and you see her doing that, Well,
- 25:30no, that's actually not a good example. A better example would be
- 25:33she's she's not having any feelings other than positive or neutral towards you, and
- 25:40you have this desire, this this like upwelling of desire to get close to
- 25:45Colleen, because of course you do, and then immediately so then you say
- 25:49you go to her, you get up out of the garage and you go
- 25:53see her. She's what is she usually doing? Watching TV or something?
- 25:57She might be crocheting. Yeah, okay, and you see her and I'm
- 26:03exaggerating a little bit, but there's zero indication that she's upset. And she
- 26:08actually is not upset at you. But you see her crocheting in front of
- 26:11the TV. And because you have that disorganized, I want to get close.
- 26:18Oh my god, I'm terrified. There's a perception that she's angry at
- 26:22you, or she's gonna hurt you. She's gonna not abandon you, right,
- 26:26but she just doesn't like you. She's an unsafe object of one's attachment
- 26:33needs. Right what will happen for me at least what comes to mind right
- 26:37now isn't so much that is if it's an expression of my desire, could
- 26:44be sex, could be other things. What I'll notice is that I won't
- 26:48speak it. I feel like going out to dinner tonight and I won't speak.
- 26:52I won't say, hey, how about we go out to dinner tonight?
- 26:55Or And what's the perceptual distortion? If one exists that results and you're
- 27:00not speaking it, it's embarrassment like like I have now a zip might fly.
- 27:06That's the crap way to put it. But but you know it feels
- 27:08right, Yeah, like I'm now exposed, Like I work pretty hard at
- 27:12not being open vulnerable. Yeah, but there's nothing wrong with being exposed.
- 27:18There's only something There's also nothing wrong with falling. It's only wrong if you
- 27:22hit the ground, right, there's nothing wrong with being exposed. There's something
- 27:26wrong with what what my experience of being exposed is it's going to get exploited.
- 27:30Okay, I'm going to get hurt, right, So that's the distortion.
- 27:36Yeah, there's there's no rationality to that. Note that if you were
- 27:40to want to get closer or say hey let's hang out or let's go to
- 27:44dinner, that with that exposure of your vulnerable self. It's interesting that you
- 27:52go to your crotch, but you know it's a very vulnerable spot. And
- 27:57if we have particular traumas around those vulnerable spots, then that's what metaphorically will
- 28:03It'll feel like and you have this distortion, this perceptual projection or displacement that
- 28:11she is gonna exploit you and she's gonna get you. Yeah, she's going
- 28:18to use it against you. Yes, I do have that. Yeah,
- 28:22even though intellectually, for decades now, you've been telling yourself otherwise, Like
- 28:27intellectually you're like, no, that's not it doesn't happen, it's not going
- 28:30to happen. Even if it does, you know, we'll roll with it
- 28:33whatever. But it feels so overwhelming, the fear and the thoughts are so
- 28:40overwhelming and intrusive, you'll go back into your garage. Oh yeah, for
- 28:44sure. Yeah. Yeah, Like there isn't there isn't really anything about me
- 28:47Colleen doesn't know, isn't aware of, And I still feel like there's parts
- 28:51of me, even the things that she knows, that she doesn't know or
- 28:56wouldn't like, right, Yeah, and so that is the basis of a
- 29:00precise order to me. Yeah, there's just not a name for that one.
- 29:06Yeah, if you could make up a name for this, what would
- 29:08you call it? Like, you know, we would call borderline, like
- 29:11abandonment, schema, abandonment trauma. What would you call this one? Um,
- 29:18shame retribution, shame retribution. I'm ashamed, and also there will be
- 29:22retribution on me shame shame slash retribution. So I'm ashamed. Yeah, and
- 29:33I'm shameful. Yeah, I should be ashamed, right, there's something shameful
- 29:37about me. Yes, I'm going to experience retribution, Yeah, for sure,
- 29:41retribution. Tell me more about that word. Oh um, righteous rain
- 29:48of fire, like a not just a slap in the face, but like
- 29:55a flurry of blows. Yeah. Yeah, and I was kid. Did
- 30:00I tell you this story? We used to go home for lunch. I
- 30:03ever tell you about this? I don't know. Well, my school was
- 30:06down the street from where I lived, and if you got a note from
- 30:07your parents, you could go home for lunch, which was sort of a
- 30:11treat, you know. So, oh, this would have been maybe third
- 30:18maybe third grade? Yeah, I think it was third grade. How far
- 30:21do you live from school? Three blocks? Oh? Yeah, Like I
- 30:25lived about one hundred yards maybe one hundred fifty yards from my school. Yeah,
- 30:29it's still there. Actually you got knocked down. It's now just a
- 30:30field. It's weird that happened a couple of years ago, probably because there's
- 30:36no kids that live in that neighborhood anymore. There's a new crop. But
- 30:40but the school got sold years ago, and then whoever, Anyways, it
- 30:44doesn't matter. So I got a note to go home for lunch. And
- 30:48I got home. My mom made me an egg sandwich on toast, which
- 30:49is really good, like egg salad sandwich, just scrambled eggs on a scrambled
- 30:56eggs yeah, scrambled eggs on a piece of toast with some butter. And
- 31:00I was sitting at the counter eating it. And it was this girl's birthday
- 31:03at school, and I didn't want to tell her whose birthday it was.
- 31:07I didn't even want to tell her it was a girl. So she asked
- 31:10me who it was, and I didn't say, and she asked again and
- 31:15I didn't say, and she asked again and I wouldn't say, and she
- 31:18started to raise her voice because I wasn't going to say whose birthday it was.
- 31:22And the more she raised her voice, the more I didn't chew.
- 31:25So I had this wad of toast and egg chewed up in my mouth,
- 31:33and she's screaming at me because I won't tell her whose birthday it is,
- 31:37you know, And I'm thinking she could call to school and whatever, and
- 31:41you know, I don't know what's going to happen. And finally she just
- 31:45got fed up with me, and she stumped off and went upstairs and Jesus
- 31:51Christ God, go. Yeah, that's awful. That's the kind of ship
- 31:57that goes on at my house. You know, she's eighty two years old
- 32:02and she has Alzheimer's and it's getting worse, but it's not much different,
- 32:09still not different. She's she won't do this with me anymore because I I
- 32:15have distanced myself immensely from her. My sibs who live nearby, you know,
- 32:21they have a different kind of relationship with her, and some of that's
- 32:23based on her need for care. And she'll still mistreat, mistreat, and
- 32:30she's really sensitive to my mom's Dedmentia's side pretty fucked up. What do you
- 32:36think? What do you think she was going through in that moment with the
- 32:38big sandwich? Was she feeling rejected? I think that she sees herself as
- 32:43innocent, and therefore why wouldn't somebody want to just go ahead and be playing
- 32:47and open with her because she hasn't done anything bad or wrong to incur in
- 32:52this case my reticence. So I'm behaving in a really unjust way towards her
- 32:59big because she didn't do anything bad or wrong, and so she felt like
- 33:04your reticence was an act of you thought she had done something wrong and you
- 33:10were. I think she sees herself as innocent and therefore any response I have
- 33:16is completely unreasonable because any because she hasn't done anything to earn me being shy
- 33:23or reticence. So what's wrong with me? When I have you know,
- 33:30when I say, when I refused to do something, there must be something
- 33:32wrong with me. Is it possible that she felt rejected? Yeah, I'm
- 33:37sure she did feel rejected, like at the foundation of it. Yeah,
- 33:43no one, but for sure she felt rejected and unjustly so because so rejection
- 33:49and unjust, unjust rejection my mother, Yeah, that's it. Yeah,
- 33:53I mean, to be clear, doesn't make any sense, you know,
- 33:58not she would interpret it that. It's like one who cares to How about
- 34:06some emotional regulation in the moment, Yeah, your kid just whatever, you
- 34:09know. Also, it's not hard to into it. Some possible candidates as
- 34:15to why a third grader would not want to answer that question. Maybe they
- 34:20have a crush on her, or it was Jennifer lush Man. Jennifer lush
- 34:27I mean, that's a stripper name right there, Lush lush So, yeah,
- 34:35yeah, that's awful. That's an awful awful story, and of course
- 34:37you know it's one among thousands, right yeah, I mean to just scream
- 34:44at you and the storm out of the room like Jesus Christ, like what
- 34:47what do you do with that? And then your own shame was why you
- 34:52were not answering the question to begin with. The historical shaming resulted in you
- 34:59not wanting to answer that question. Because it's interesting how how that dynamic played
- 35:05out, because if you would have just answered the question in a different universe,
- 35:08you know, in that moment, she would have just moved on.
- 35:13She wasn't on a mission in that moment to scream at you and emotionally abuse
- 35:16you. But because of her sensitivities, it results you, your mom,
- 35:22and your dad, resulted in you having this shame retribution dynamic, which in
- 35:30turn causes more shame retribution moments. Right oh yeah, it begets itself.
- 35:37Yeah yeah. Now, a third grader not answering a question like that is
- 35:42not actual shame and doesn't deserve any kind of retribution. I mean, I
- 35:47can't tell you how many times are we talking, particularly to quiet third graders,
- 35:52and you'll ask them a question and they don't answer the question like it's
- 35:55a part of life if you if you're not used to that, particularly as
- 36:00the parent of the child, because I'm guessing you had other behaviors in this
- 36:04vein, and they the fact that they just couldn't roll with and be like,
- 36:10well, you know, I hope you have fun. Yeah, her
- 36:15kid's gonna tell me whose birthday it was? So okay? Yeah, somehow
- 36:20you know your life about that data well, and clearly she's been through some
- 36:23stuff and didn't have enough therapy in her life to recover from that. And
- 36:29yeah, that's pretty awful that I would never heard that sort of for I
- 36:32would remember that. Did you ever swallow? No? I didn't finish the
- 36:37lunch. It's walked home. I watched the back school or what I think.
- 36:39I spit what I had in my mouth out and I left the plate.
- 36:43That's interesting, you spit it out? Yeah, what do you think
- 36:46that was about? It was kind of gross in my mouth. It's sort
- 36:50of been there for a long time, just mushed up. Was it a
- 36:53freeze response? Oh for sure, yeah. And then it was like a
- 37:00shame response like I don't deserve to eat. Huh, so I won't eat?
- 37:04God, damn, this is like a prayer for Owen Meanie John Irving,
- 37:09John Irving chapter. Yeah, I put this one in my book like
- 37:14a dark a dark moment, Yeah, and a complicated childhood story. There's
- 37:22so many symbols in that, right, the egg sandwich. They're coming home,
- 37:25Hey mom, Hey, let me make you a sandwich. And then
- 37:30this whole thing happens, and there's somebody's birthday at school. We're having cupcakes.
- 37:32Oh whose birthday is? And then clam and then you spit it out.
- 37:37Yeah, and you didn't want to eat the rest of the toast.
- 37:42No, it would have been shameful. It would have been a bad thing
- 37:45to take that food, to take it to what do you mean shameful?
- 37:49Like now I'm I'm not only have I'm frustrated what she wanted. I'm gonna
- 37:55actually take take something from her. Wow. Yeah, that like it like
- 38:00it's selfish of you. Dude. That ship is with me all the time.
- 38:04Not the big sandwich. I mean that comes and goes because I remember
- 38:07that theme all the time. Yeah. Yeah, I feel like that story
- 38:13really encapsulates a lot. Yeah, and of course pre third grade you have
- 38:19a lot of experiences that are leading up to that. In a table,
- 38:22Yeah, so the by third grade, it's already locked in stone. Yeah,
- 38:29and my parents should not have had children. They just shouldn't. They're
- 38:32not bad people, but they were just not prepared to be parents. Yeah,
- 38:36God damn. Of course their parents probably shouldn't have had children either.
- 38:40Oh, you have a copy of Love's Executioner on your wall? There,
- 38:45I do. We were assigned it when we were in graduate school. Already
- 38:49read it twice by the time we got to grad school, and I for
- 38:52thos a. No. It's by rban Yallam, and it's ten chapters on
- 38:57ten clients. That's right. It's really great book if you want to learn
- 39:00about therapy. He's a great one to learn from because he writes in a
- 39:02very personal way. He writes very matter of factly, and he does not
- 39:07make himself out to be any kind of saint. He's a good guy.
- 39:10But it's like he's not shy about just saying, you know, his opinion
- 39:15about stuff, or his his transferential response is to kind of transferential responses.
- 39:19He's pretty plain about that. But he also writes in a really articulate way.
- 39:22And if you want to learn about humanistic psychology or is a good guy,
- 39:28Yeah, to learn from. Yeah, and we were assigned this book
- 39:31in our first quarter. I believe which class was it? Do you remember?
- 39:35I feel like it was pro sim in my head. Really, I
- 39:37mean that would make sense, right, Yeah, And I gave my copy
- 39:44away at some point, so I did I rebought it? Yeah, Yeah,
- 39:49So shame retribution. Shame retribution fits that scenario. Yeah, shame retribute
- 39:59not just like kind of shame, but like very definitive, pointed, seemingly
- 40:08obvious shame right, seemingly obvious. There's no question about it. You're definitely
- 40:17shameful. There's something shameful about you. Your mom leaves the room. Because
- 40:24if I were in this, because I'm such an eater with food and me
- 40:28and my family were a bunch of eaters that's like a food food food food
- 40:34food. And I'm just imagining myself with my pre third grade years that were
- 40:40different than yours, and I had had something like that happened, I definitely
- 40:45would have finished the rest of that egg sandwich because it's lunchtime and I'm not
- 40:53gonna not eat Plus why why not eat it? So the fact that she's
- 41:00gone out of the room, like to me, I don't know why.
- 41:04That kind of sticks out to me as sort of a why in the road,
- 41:07here foot stomping up the steps with these wood steps and hear her bedroom
- 41:12door slam shot. Goddamn, I mean nobody else to tell my brothers.
- 41:15My brothers and my sister were at school. They didn't come home for lunch
- 41:17that day. So did she ever recover? Like, she never said she
- 41:22was sorry, She never acknowledged it. Just oh, whose birthday is it?
- 41:30I don't know whose birthday? You know? I just I don't under
- 41:32like. It's so bizarre and that difference between me as a third grader,
- 41:39even if that had happened that I it's strange that I'm focusing on that deep.
- 41:45It shows so much that you would self not police, but that it
- 41:50was obvious. Look at me, I'm a piece of crap. I don't
- 41:53deserve to eat this. Yeah, she made this for me. I'm so
- 41:57low. I'm such a piece of shit that I don't even deserve even if
- 42:01no one's around, and intellectually I know this is just going to get thrown
- 42:05away. But I'm such a piece of shit. I don't deserve to eat
- 42:07this toast. Yeah, Like that's how low you felt about yourself. Oh
- 42:14it's still the case. I still have shit like that in me. Yeah
- 42:17yeah, yeah, yeah. So I don't know what we call it,
- 42:22but it definitely belongs in the book somewhere. Well, I don't know,
- 42:27shame retribution, shame slash retribution. Yeah, it's not intuitive based on the
- 42:31name, but it's appropriate. So if you named it, you know,
- 42:37shame slash distribution personality spectrum, it would make sense, and it would capsually
- 42:45I'm guessing a lot of people. In fact, I think it would capture
- 42:49a lot of low self esteemers who don't have narcissism or borderline or histrionic,
- 42:55a paranoid or OCPD, you know, they don't have these more notice and
- 43:00I wonder if shame retribution personality is not discussed very often because folks like yourself
- 43:09don't bother other people, you know, you don't get in the way.
- 43:17Yeah, I mean, I guess we could throw Butler in there as well.
- 43:22I guess if we had a criterion there would would Yeah, it goes
- 43:27from there, right, Yeah, Butler's right, you do if you're going
- 43:30to be invisible, then avoid getting you know, on the radar. And
- 43:37also if you do anything you can be a servant. Yeah, you can
- 43:43be useful to someone else, right, but you don't get on people's cases
- 43:47if they don't let you be useful. Right, I don't think so,
- 43:51right, get on too many cases for much of anything. Yeah, yeah,
- 43:55Yeah, it's just interesting to think about the millions of people around the
- 44:04world who are suffering in a commensurate way with any other personalise order. But
- 44:09because it's not like histrionic where it's very obvious, or borderline where it's causes
- 44:15a lot of interpersonal problems, or narcissistic where it's also very noticeable and causes
- 44:21interpersonal problems, can be harmful. That for people with your suffering, there's
- 44:27no literature, very little literature, very little acknowledgement or awareness. Like I
- 44:32said, we could just call it disorganized attachment. But a lot of disorganized
- 44:37attachment can manifest in a lot of the personality sources. So what you know,
- 44:42it's like, what is it about you? Do? You just have
- 44:44no no personality disorder. But I would say that in my definition of what
- 44:50a personise sort, you know that that perceptual distortion based on trauma that is
- 44:55very hard to shake, you know, to talk to someone with borderline and
- 44:59convince that that they're not going to be betrayed and they're not going to be
- 45:02abandoned, or that they're worth not being abandoned, and that they can trust
- 45:07other people. You know, me trying to convince someone with moderate to severe
- 45:12borderline that I'm not secretly thinking about terminating with them, and all the evidence
- 45:19is to the contrary. The client will still believe one hundred percent that I
- 45:22am thinking about abandoning them and I do want to desperately terminate with them.
- 45:30That's a's And then I can get to their executive function and eventually convince that
- 45:35part of them, and they will intellectually get it, but they don't really
- 45:39feel it's true. They're like, I hear you, but yeah, I
- 45:44just don't. I can't feel it. It doesn't feel right to me.
- 45:49I'm pretty convinced that you want to leave me. I just I guess I
- 45:52think you're just lying to me, honest or the same goes for this for
- 45:58you. You know, it's a perceptual distortion that even if your intellectual mind
- 46:01understands that Colleen is not going to take retribution, if you unzip your pants
- 46:07and expose yourself and say I would like a toast? Can you make me
- 46:14some toast? Or can you just talk to me for five minutes? You
- 46:20know, there's a perceptual distortion that she will absolutely, you know, attack
- 46:24you and ridicule you and make you low and not only make you feel bad,
- 46:30but it will expose the true shamefulness of who you are. Right,
- 46:40Okay, Bob, So we're back from the break. Sorry to the deserving
- 46:45listeners out there who just experience a very sudden break. Bob and I went
- 46:51down a very long hour and a half rabbit hole talking about a lot of
- 46:55different personal things that I just cut out of the show. Bob and I
- 47:01went down a road and then Bob and I was wondering because I thought this
- 47:05is too personal even for the podcast. And then you said this can't go
- 47:08on the podcast, and I was like, yeah, I should, I
- 47:10should think so, so I stopped recording, and then we just suddenly realized
- 47:15that we have microphones in front of us and we should probably finish the podcast.
- 47:21So let's continue with Esther's email. So she says, my questions are
- 47:27this, how do I internalize his reassurance her therapist when I have the experience
- 47:32that I have had. I think that's what she's talking about. Yeah,
- 47:37especially got the therapists specializes the associated source. So how do I internalize his
- 47:44reassurance? How do I move past the terror of being abandoned? Do you
- 47:49think a corrective experience is still possible at this point? How do I stop
- 47:52the fixation on the relationship with the therapist? Bob? What do you think?
- 47:57I wonder? I think that reassurance offered that hasn't been requested doesn't go
- 48:02as far as reassurance that's actually requested and asked for. So I'm wondering about
- 48:07Garrier. If the person I forgive me my memories, sometimes I can't remember
- 48:12esther, Esther, sorry, esther, If esther would do well to ask
- 48:17for the reassurance that she needs as opposed to the therapist offering it, And
- 48:22if perhaps Esther would do well to describe the terror associated with or the shame,
- 48:29if that's what it is, or whatever it is that comes up with
- 48:31reaching for reassurance. And I think that the corrective experience is enhanced when in
- 48:38my own therapy, asking for the thing that I need is more powerful than
- 48:44it just being offered. And then the other hand, is this maybe it's
- 48:49not a binary thing like someday you'll be free of terror. Maybe what we're
- 48:52talking about here is turning the volume down and help having it be less of
- 48:55an impingement or less of an obstacle to having the kind of life you want
- 49:00to have. Maybe to some degree. At this point in life, we
- 49:05are what we are, and we can chip away, right, chip away.
- 49:09I don't regret being alive, and I don't regret the life that I
- 49:14have. I like my life for the most part. There are things about
- 49:17it that are painful and lonely and you know, fearful, lots of shame,
- 49:22whatever, blah blah blah. But I don't think I'll regret I know,
- 49:25I won't regret having lived, even though my life has these elements in
- 49:30it. Yeah, that's important, patron, and Christina says, hi,
- 49:36doctor Honda and Bob, do you think it is possible that this organized attachment
- 49:39has the least information on it because those affected are so unlikely to get help.
- 49:45What do you think? Well, you know, you said as much
- 49:47a little while back. You're like, maybe they don't have a name for
- 49:51this because you know, people like me, we don't make any noise.
- 49:54We don't possible. I don't actually know the answer to this question, though,
- 49:58what do you think? I think that there's not a lot of talk
- 50:02about disorganized attachment because there's not a lot of talk about attachment outside of hop
- 50:08psychology simplistic language, which is fine. It's a introduction into the vast field
- 50:15of attachment theory and research and understanding and experience, so there's not a lot
- 50:21to talk about that at all. Plus in our field, and thus outside
- 50:25and among the lay individuals, they will focus on the DSM, and there's
- 50:30nothing in the DSM about disorganized attachment. We have a couple early childhood or
- 50:37childhood attachment disorders, but those are rare manifestations of attachment issues. They're manifestations,
- 50:44but they don't encapsulate everything. I can't remember when I figure this out
- 50:47or hypothesize this or conceptualize that. A lot of the things in the DSM
- 50:52are basically just symptoms of attachment problems. But there's no mention of that.
- 50:58Yeah, and I get it. The DSM is not set out to do
- 51:02that, but it's almost like and there have been other authors and groups of
- 51:06authors who have come forward with different dsms. If you will, like there's
- 51:12a psychodynamic angle of the DSM. They'll literally just have the entire DSM layout,
- 51:19but they will have their own psychodynamic angle on it or something like that,
- 51:22but they never really take off in a way that I would wish they
- 51:29did. So, you know, I think there's that. Plus, there's
- 51:32just a lot of misunderstanding about disorganized attachment in general. A lot of you
- 51:37out there may have heard, even if you are a clinician taking a training
- 51:40or a graduate student in school, that that disorganized attachment is a mixture of
- 51:46preoccupied and avoidant, which is just not the case. I mean, you
- 51:52could make an argument that that's like a topic sentence maybe, but it really
- 51:58does not describe it and is a massive misunderstanding of the observed behaviors that were
- 52:05first observed by Mary Maine and Solomon I believe were the ones who came up
- 52:13with the disorganized angle. Ainsworth first did the Strange experiment, and if I
- 52:20remember my history right, they identified secure, preoccupied in avoidant kids. But
- 52:24then ten years later Ish Solomon and Maine replicated the study and found that there
- 52:30was a rarer fourth category of disorganized or fearful attachment. So Patron and ASHLEYN
- 52:37from Idaho says, I'm curious about how growing up with a parent with borderline
- 52:42can affect a child's development. In your experience, how does growing up with
- 52:46a parent affected development of child by what do you think? That's it's hard
- 52:52to say. I mean, one of the things I've noticed about the couples
- 52:54that I see who have children is oftentimes they are very good parents, but
- 53:00they've never had a model. They didn't have a growing up experience that provided
- 53:04them a model for how to do that. So, in other words,
- 53:07they may have grown up insecure in some way, but they're able to provide
- 53:10a really secure home life for their kids. So I would have thought before,
- 53:17I would have thought, if you had a messed up childhood, you're
- 53:21gonna raise messed up kids because that's the internal model you have. And I
- 53:24haven't found that to be true at least the people that I see is they're
- 53:28often very good parents despite the fact that they have these personal things that you
- 53:31know, insecurities, that's the way to put it. And so I don't
- 53:36think that somebody having borderline personality disorder is necessarily an indicator of anything particularly going
- 53:39to happen to their kid. Maybe it is. Yeah, Yeah, the
- 53:45distinction I think has to be made of all the different manifestations and presentations of
- 53:51borderline. I think what you're talking about ashela and I didn't read your whole
- 53:54email, and I'm just gonna summarize it. Basically, you're saying that you
- 54:00grew up with your mother who had you say, fairly severe borderline, and
- 54:06that you were the emotional support child, as your therapist puts it, and
- 54:09that as a result of the emotional trauma that you've been through, you've had
- 54:15a lot of suicidality, a lot of complex PTSD depression, panic. And
- 54:21you say here, so much of your content about people with borderline is based
- 54:24on an empathetic and understanding perspective. I find that so hard for me to
- 54:28accept that. And she goes on to kind of explain that, and yeah,
- 54:32yeah, absolutely, I do that because that's how I think, even
- 54:37of abusive borderline people. I've worked with a lot of people of various genders
- 54:45who had what I would conceptualize as borderline, who are absolutely really awful to
- 54:51their partners, to their children. They would overreact, they would get triggered,
- 54:55they would be very vindictive, very sure of themselves and a constant emotional
- 55:05abuser of the people around them while making people walk on eggshells. Maybe literally
- 55:10being physically abusive that happens. Borderline can be the basis of that. But
- 55:16to say that borderline people do that is not true. It's just a potential
- 55:22factor. And of course you could be abusive and not have any personise,
- 55:24right, right. But yeah, and if you and I know a lot
- 55:30of people will agree with you that the way that Bob and I talk about
- 55:35it, it might feel hurtful because you had someone with borderline and maybe in
- 55:39your life and maybe our perspective is accurate, but it de emphasizes the destruction
- 55:45and the abuse and the horribleness that you went through. We wouldn't want to
- 55:47do that. Yeah, So you know, there's a lot of angles to
- 55:50this, and I know deeply apologize for that because if it came across like
- 55:58somehow it was discount that you went through that that is it's not okay.
- 56:02It's not okay. And you ask, how can having a borderline parent affect
- 56:07children once they become adults. So the thing that I will say, and
- 56:13this is to peegyback on what Bob says, is you really have to zero
- 56:16in on the behavior, not necessarily someone that has borderline, because if whether
- 56:22or not they have borderline is maybe a factor, but really that the thing
- 56:27that happened was you were abused, you were treated in a way, and
- 56:30you could say there's a particular flavor of abuse that would happen from a borderline
- 56:34parent, someone that does depend on you, someone that is very, very
- 56:38sensitive to your rejection, to real or imagine rejection from you, even when
- 56:45you're four years old, like for you, Bob the egg sandwich thing.
- 56:50You know, I don't know what diagnosis you would say your mom had,
- 56:52but it's in that vein of So you're going to interpret your seven eight year
- 56:58old sons saying or just not answering the question as to whose birth. You're
- 57:02going to interpret that as a massive rejection of who you are, and you're
- 57:07going to regress to a place where you're basically five years old or ten years
- 57:10old, and you storm up to your room and you slam the door like
- 57:14you were when you're a kid. It's not rational to do that. So
- 57:19there's a flavor of abusiveness and emotional destruction that can happen from someone that's borderline
- 57:23that might be different from someone else, say narcissistic or someone that doesn't have
- 57:28precise order and so, but it's really the abuse that we want to talk
- 57:34about, you know, the control, the guilt tripping, the denial of
- 57:37your needs, the abusive in measurement. So if we focus on the abusive
- 57:42in measurement, which is what it kind of sounded like, was that as
- 57:45adults, typically not everyone, because of the early childhood experience of having someone
- 57:52just completely dominate you emotionally and not let you be yourself and not be attuned
- 57:57to you, then for the adult, they will have a greater likelihood of
- 58:00not being connection with themselves. They don't know their needs, they don't know
- 58:02their wants, they don't know emotions, and this can be really pervasive.
- 58:07This can be very difficult. There's a lot of clients that I work with
- 58:10for years trying to help them to get in connection with that, and even
- 58:15as they get in connection with it, there's a lot of confusion. There's
- 58:19a lot of so what do I do with these feelings? And a lot
- 58:23of backstepping. So that's one. Two is a lot of anger, sometimes
- 58:30passive and hidden, but a lot of rage and anger that's justified, that
- 58:35can be there for the child and the adult and having never expressed it,
- 58:39you know what I mean. Also, potentially overfunctioning in codependency. You know,
- 58:45because you had to take care of your own parent and your worth was
- 58:49based on that. There could have been a lot of anxiety if you took
- 58:52your eyes off your parent. So that anxiety and that superiority also is a
- 59:00part of overfunctioning code dependency in that role, that way of getting attention and
- 59:05love. Another is potential lack of boundaries in general, because you've never been
- 59:08modeled how to create boundaries and or how to respect other people's boundaries. Also,
- 59:15you might attract narcissistic people who want to be focused on or under functioners
- 59:19as another possibility. Also, if you partner with a relatively healthy person,
- 59:24you might annoy them because you don't talk about your own feelings or what you
- 59:29want. That can be another problem because you know in relationships, close relationships,
- 59:35they want it to be mutual. It one because it doesn't feel right
- 59:37for it not to be, and two because if you don't offer your own
- 59:42selfhood into the relationship, it feels rejecting. It doesn't feel like you care
- 59:46enough you know, when I talk with a cashier at the home depot,
- 59:51I'm not offering myself up to them, and even if they wanted me to,
- 59:55I would say no, thank you. But if my wife wants me
- 1:00:00to open up and offer myself my vulnerability by needs, my underbelly, if
- 1:00:07you will, then I will want to do that because I value the relationship
- 1:00:13where I see it as this is where I do this. And if you
- 1:00:15don't do it with anyone, other people can misinterpret that as you're treating like
- 1:00:21the cashier at the home depot. Right, it feels bad, it's rejecting.
- 1:00:24It's not your fault, but that can be an effect. That's the
- 1:00:27experience. Yeah, another question you ask, how are we supposed to ever
- 1:00:30let go of the bad blood towards that parent, let alone view them with
- 1:00:35the empathy that seems to come so naturally to you. Oh wait a minute
- 1:00:40now, I don't want a second. I do not feel empathic towards my
- 1:00:45folks A lot of the time. I feel angry a lot of the time.
- 1:00:50I think, though, that what that tells me isn't so much about
- 1:00:52them, is about me, is about this undigested pain. If that's an
- 1:00:55okay, way to put it that deserves or needs my tension, So I
- 1:01:01don't. I think it's important to talk about these, to talk in a
- 1:01:06non judgmental way, about the psychopathology, if that's the way to put it,
- 1:01:12or insecure attachment, whatever, it's it's important to talk about in a
- 1:01:15non judgmental way. But that doesn't mean that we don't have feelings. I
- 1:01:19don't think being angry. Being angry, it's not the same as being judge.
- 1:01:22And even if I am judge, so what sometimes I feel really angry
- 1:01:27and judgmental, and there it is. Yeah, I don't feel empathic a
- 1:01:32lot of the time. The last time we were together talking about this,
- 1:01:37you said, oh, I've never heard you say that your dad's that you
- 1:01:38see your dad as a good guy. My dad was a good guy.
- 1:01:40My mom's a good person too. But I also have some painful feelings,
- 1:01:46yeah, anger, jame, fear that come up in those relationships. Yeah.
- 1:01:52I think there's a wisdom that emerges over time. Yeah. That involves
- 1:02:00a lot of nuances where you can have a lot of gray areas, a
- 1:02:06lot of different elements that seem incompatible but do actually fit together. Once you
- 1:02:12develop that wisdom, which is if I might sort of summarize your position,
- 1:02:16and you know, piggyback on what you said earlier, is that you're saying
- 1:02:21that you a lot of the time don't have empathy. We might expand that
- 1:02:29word to be that you're not like looking them through a sympathetic lense. You're
- 1:02:34angry at them. You don't give excuses for them. You blame them,
- 1:02:38I do. You're upset at them, you have bad feelings about them.
- 1:02:45You might not even forgive them. Nope, they haven't asked for forgiveness.
- 1:02:49But even still, you regardless might never forgive them. You might always choose
- 1:02:58not to go down a road trying to trying to transform those feelings of negativity
- 1:03:05into positivity. And at the same time, you can have a conceptualization that
- 1:03:09involves some compassion about what they went through that, yeah, they went through
- 1:03:15some serious stuff when they were young. They did. I can hold that.
- 1:03:19At the same time, I can feel bad for them. I can
- 1:03:22have an explanation that doesn't blame there. It's not like they woke up in
- 1:03:25the morning and decided they wanted to hurt you. Yeah, you can interact
- 1:03:30with your parents. Your dad has past but your mom is alive, she's
- 1:03:37experienced a lot of dementia. But you know, in the internet intervening years
- 1:03:39with your dad, you can hang out with them, you could go to
- 1:03:43dinner with him, you could laugh with them, maybe even open up to
- 1:03:46him. At the same time that you're still very angry and you don't forgive
- 1:03:51him and you don't forget all those things can happen at the same time.
- 1:03:57Yeah, that's right. They all do happen and at the same time.
- 1:04:00So I would I would want the person that is it esther, No,
- 1:04:05I think it's Ashlin. Sorry, sorry my memory. I would want that
- 1:04:11person to be kind to themselves about those days, for those days when you
- 1:04:15don't feel empathic or you feel angry and judgmental, that's okay, let's have
- 1:04:20empathy and care for that. Yeah, because it's not like that's a bad
- 1:04:25thing. It's not a bad thing. It's just a thing in part for
- 1:04:28the course. So okay. Yeah, some days are harder than others,
- 1:04:31and some days you're in more pain than others, and some days you're angry
- 1:04:34than others. Okay, fine, so be it. The last thing you
- 1:04:38need to do is poop on yourself for it. Yeah. The key is
- 1:04:42is what do you need. Yeah, that's a good key, you know.
- 1:04:45If you need to be angry, be angry. If you need to
- 1:04:49not think about it, don't think about it. If you need to,
- 1:04:51for example, stuff it down deep so that you can just deal with Christmas
- 1:04:58and hang out out with your family of origin for however much of time you
- 1:05:03can tolerate, then that's what you do, because it's not worth getting into
- 1:05:08a big family chaotic drama to draw a boundary of not going to Christmas.
- 1:05:15If you need to oh, yeah, right, good point. If you
- 1:05:16need to go to Christmas and secretly look at your mother and hater, if
- 1:05:21you need to draw boundary, if you need to say I'm not going to
- 1:05:25Christmas. The key is it's now your time. You have been the parent
- 1:05:30of your parent your whole life. Now it's time for you to be the
- 1:05:32parent of yourself and let yourself just do what needs to be done. Because
- 1:05:40you don't owe your mom anything. You don't owe her anything. It'll feel
- 1:05:45that way, but you do not owe her anything she owes you. The
- 1:05:49ledger is in your favor. Another question you ask is how does growing up
- 1:05:56with a parent of borderline affect the development of the child actually looked up the
- 1:06:00research and it depends on the presentation of borderline, of course, but it
- 1:06:04can result, according to research, in a four to twenty times more likelihood
- 1:06:11of developing borderline yourself or perhaps another precise order, but particularly borderline. So
- 1:06:17and it makes sense because the abandonment and the modeling that is sometimes very prevalent
- 1:06:27in early childhood experiencing a borderline parent can be the exact scheme of development that
- 1:06:32will develop in borderline itself, meaning that you know, if you have a
- 1:06:36parent that is not a tune to your feelings, is getting angry at you
- 1:06:42for just being you, abandoning you, you know, running upstairs for example,
- 1:06:46because you don't want to give the answer of the kid that's having the
- 1:06:49birthday. It is shaming, it feels rejecting. Obviously, you feel like
- 1:06:55there's something wrong with you, and at any moment someone could just pick up
- 1:06:59and leave you emotionally or physically. So that's the breeding ground for borderling.
- 1:07:05Another result in the research is attachment and security, of course makes sense right,
- 1:07:11if you have a borderline parent, you're much more likely to have attachment
- 1:07:15in security, particularly disorganized actually you're more likely to develop passive, aggressive,
- 1:07:20or dependent personality or paranoid personality sort. You're more likely to have poor emotional
- 1:07:27regulation. You're more likely to have greater fears of abandonment. Related to borderline,
- 1:07:31You're more likely to have a shameful self representation you know something wrong with
- 1:07:36me, like Bob's feeling of defectiveness at the core, right, there's a
- 1:07:43representation presentation of the self of shame just inherently, and higher rates of depression,
- 1:07:49sometimes higher rates of depression for adults adult children of borderline parents. Rumination,
- 1:07:57which is a research term that refers to ruminating on negative things or past
- 1:08:03behaviors of yourself that you're ashamed of, self criticism, excessive reassurance seeking,
- 1:08:12more psychiatric disorders in general liked for example, Yeah, low self esteem obviously
- 1:08:18and higher chronic stress. So a lot of a lot of unpleasant results potentially,
- 1:08:29but makes sense, right, And really, again, we should be
- 1:08:31focusing on abusive because I've worked with borderline people who have children, and I've
- 1:08:39worked with families where one of the parents where borderline and the kids didn't exhibit
- 1:08:43any of these risks because for whatever reason, the borderline parent didn't interpret child
- 1:08:49or their own children's behavior as abandoning or betraying. They would only get triggered
- 1:08:57by their partner, or their therapists or their friends. And they, to
- 1:09:02some extent, we're even better as parents because they would pour a lot of
- 1:09:08their goodness and goodwill towards defenseless little ones. You know. Sometimes it can
- 1:09:15be the same with pets. Some people with borderline can be very good as
- 1:09:18pet owners, but it can go the opposite direction. You can have a
- 1:09:23borderline individual who is not particularly triggered by partners or friends or family, but
- 1:09:30it's particularly triggered by kids. So it just kind of depends on what the
- 1:09:33associations are for that borderline individual. You know, you can have a borderline
- 1:09:39friend who will never get triggered by you. You could have a borderline friend
- 1:09:43who is only triggered by you and not triggered by anyone else. It just
- 1:09:47it's associations. Some people, for whatever reason, given the way they are
- 1:09:51raised, they just have particular associations with particular kinds of relationships. Now,
- 1:09:59for some people with a borderline, the problem is such that every relationship is
- 1:10:03associated with it. So I'm not saying that people with porderline always have this,
- 1:10:09this bifurcation or something. But so, Bob, this episode is getting
- 1:10:12a little along. I want to answer all the emails about Borderline, but
- 1:10:16let's make the rest of this episode just for patrons of the podcast. What
- 1:10:19are you saying, Oh, lucky for you, Yeah, lucky for you.
- 1:10:23So if you are not a patroon, you're not going to hear the
- 1:10:25rest of this episode. But if you want to hear the rest of this
- 1:10:27episode, become a Patreon. Go to patreon dot com, do it now,
- 1:10:30and take care of yourself because you deserve it. You really do.