Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Fact-Checking the ABA: What the Data Actually Shows on Credit Union Business Lending
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker: Hey everyone.
- 0:01This is Mark TriCal with another episode with Flying Colors.
- 0:04Today's episode is going to be a little bit different.
- 0:06I'm going to respond directly to a podcast put out by the American
- 0:10Bankers Association, the A BA on what they're calling the dangers of
- 0:15Credit Union member Business Lending.
- 0:18To be specific, March 30th, they issued a podcast called Our Credit
- 0:22Union Commercial Loans Risky Business.
- 0:25It's, uh, not that long of a podcast.
- 0:27I made it about halfway through and heard so many.
- 0:33Wrong statements that I decided I was gonna do a podcast at that juncture.
- 0:37So I've been researching my memory on some things and putting a a, a script together.
- 0:42I typically don't use much of a script when I do these
- 0:44things, and it's very clear.
- 0:46The podcast that I'm referring to didn't use a script because
- 0:49they didn't even use any.
- 0:50Facts, quite frankly a lot of their stuff was squishy.
- 0:53A lot of their stuff was wrong.
- 0:55And it's, uh, something I wanted to deal with here because credit unions do a good
- 0:59job in commercial lending generally, and I kind of wanna set the record straight
- 1:03so if you're listening to this for the first time, uh, I spent 33 years at NCUA.
- 1:09I was.
- 1:09The executive director at NCUA for the last eight years of my career.
- 1:14And I also spent another five and a half years since then in consulting.
- 1:18So in October I'll have 40 years in the credit union industry.
- 1:23And, uh, so I know a lot about credit unions.
- 1:25I know a lot, lot about.
- 1:27Uh, how NCA deals with credit unions.
- 1:30I was there when a lot of the things that the A BA claimed happened happened.
- 1:35And so I kind of want to give you my take on this and my facts on this.
- 1:40And again, uh, the A BA has every right to advocate for its members.
- 1:44That's literally what they're paid to do.
- 1:48Banks and credit unions compete.
- 1:50Now, that's a real reality.
- 1:52And when credit unions expand into commercial lending, banks feel
- 1:56it, then they call their trade association and they say, push back.
- 2:00So I understand that, but call it what it is.
- 2:04Advocacy addressed as analysis, and the range of what's going
- 2:07on here is pretty wide at best.
- 2:10This is sloppy.
- 2:12At worst, it's an attempt to mislead the public about the credit union industry.
- 2:17I'll let you decide where on that spectrum this falls, but either way it doesn't go
- 2:22unanswered 'cause I'm gonna answer it.
- 2:24So a former colleague of mine.
- 2:28Had a phrase that he used called Roughly correct.
- 2:32It meant you're in the ballpark, the direction is right,
- 2:35even if the details are off.
- 2:37He would use it at the NCA board table when he didn't wanna
- 2:40embarrass an NCA board member when they got it roughly correct and
- 2:44wanted to keep the meeting going.
- 2:47. But the reality is what's in the A BA podcast isn't even roughly correct.
- 2:53The host invents a waiver process that doesn't exist.
- 2:56The economist conflates two completely different regulatory mechanisms.
- 3:01The stress testing argument ignores the most relevant data
- 3:04point in the entire discussion.
- 3:06That's not roughly correct.
- 3:08That's just wrong.
- 3:10. So I listen to a lot of podcasts, a lot of sports podcasts.
- 3:13A lot of banking podcasts.
- 3:15I do it when I'm.
- 3:17Getting ready to go to bed.
- 3:18I do it when I wake up and go for a walk.
- 3:20If it's not music I'm listening to a podcast and one of my favorite sports
- 3:25podcast is a show called Check the Mic.
- 3:28They have a segment on that show once a week where they talk about
- 3:32the shouty shows, as they call them.
- 3:34Shows where people shout.
- 3:37That's the name they give for shows.
- 3:39By Skip Bayless and Stephen, a Smith type content, loud opinions,
- 3:44selective facts, and maximum outrage.
- 3:48They take a real topic, they strip out all the nuance, they pick the most alarming
- 3:54angle, and then they yell it confidently.
- 3:56It makes great content, but it's not analysis.
- 4:01In my opinions, that's what this episode of the A BA podcast is.
- 4:05It's the Shouty show version of their take on credit unions.
- 4:10And today I'm gonna do some fact checking.
- 4:12So fair warning, this episode's gonna, this episode is gonna run
- 4:17longer than the one I'm responding to.
- 4:19They made their case in about 12 and a half minutes.
- 4:22It's gonna take me longer to fact check.
- 4:24Their mistakes or their claims, if you will.
- 4:28And one more thing before we jump into, uh, the specifics.
- 4:33I love credit unions.
- 4:35The a BA loves banks.
- 4:37We both have a bias.
- 4:39I'm gonna do my best to stick to the facts and show you my work.
- 4:43They didn't do either.
- 4:45So I, you know, again, I spent my career inside the agency that regulates
- 4:49credit unions and the last five years helping credit unions from the other
- 4:52side, having changed teams, if you will.
- 4:55I've seen examinations, I've seen the data.
- 4:59I've sat in the rooms where these decisions get made.
- 5:02So, and been in on some of these decisions that they're criticizing.
- 5:05So let's go through their claims one by one and look at
- 5:08what the data actually shows.
- 5:11So claim number one, but first, actually before I get into claim
- 5:15number one, a little history of the the a BA hopes that you've forgotten.
- 5:19I.
- 5:21Before I get into these specific claims, I want to give you some history
- 5:25because the A BA presents this as if it's a new concern driven by new data.
- 5:31It isn't.
- 5:31This is a 35 year campaign and understanding where it started tells
- 5:36you everything you need to know about what risks really motivating it.
- 5:40Today, the A BA filed a lawsuit, challenging credit union
- 5:45field membership, specifically multiple common bond membership.
- 5:50Back in 1990.
- 5:53Why field of membership?
- 5:54Because more members meant more competition, more deposits,
- 5:58more loans, more relationships.
- 6:00The A BA wanted to slow that growth, that case wound its way through the
- 6:05courts and ended up in the Supreme Court.
- 6:08And guess what?
- 6:08The A BA was, right?
- 6:10And they won by a vote of five to four, written by Justice Thomas, the attorney
- 6:15who argued that case for the A BA.
- 6:18A fellow by the name of John Roberts.
- 6:20Yes, the current Chief Justice of the United States.
- 6:23He won that case for the bankers.
- 6:27The Supreme Court decision threatened the existence of over a
- 6:30thousand credit unions overnight.
- 6:32Congressional Congress responded with HR 1151, the Credit Union Membership
- 6:37Access Act signed into law in 1998.
- 6:42It fixed the field membership problem.
- 6:45The A BA lost the legislative battle, so they won the court battle.
- 6:51Credit unions rallied.
- 6:52Congress said, Hey.
- 6:54These credit unions have a lot of power.
- 6:56We like credit unions, so they came up with a fix.
- 6:59Now this is what it, where it becomes interesting to get
- 7:02HR 1151 through the Senate.
- 7:05There had to be a compromise, and that compromise was the 12 and a quarter
- 7:09percent member business lending cap.
- 7:13Now there's another podcast, credit Union Conversations with Mark Ritter who had
- 7:18Todd Harper and Mike Radway, formerly of NCUA, and formerly involved in 1151 and
- 7:25other things in Congress, uh, on, on.
- 7:27And I had listened to that podcast and I know some of the history,
- 7:31but I'm connecting now going to.
- 7:34In a little bit, I'll be connecting the podcast that Mark Riter did on 1151 and
- 7:40the a b, a podcast that I'm talking about that, that came out a couple days ago.
- 7:44So Mike Radway, who helped draft that legislation and was
- 7:49in the room when it happened.
- 7:51Described it plainly in a recent episode of the Credit Union Conversation podcast.
- 7:55The cap was there to assuage this is, this is Mike's word, assuage
- 8:01Senator Richard Shelby of Alabama.
- 8:03Shelby needed something he could point to and say to the bankers, I voted for
- 8:08this bill, but I got you something.
- 8:11And that something was the MBL cap.
- 8:14Now think about that for a moment.
- 8:16The A BA didn't sue over business lending.
- 8:18They sued over field of membership, but when Congress handed them a legislative
- 8:23defeat on field of membership, they were happy to take a cap on
- 8:27commercial loans as part of the deal.
- 8:29Law and sausage, right?
- 8:31What are the two things you don't wanna see being made?
- 8:33Law and sausage, because commercial loans.
- 8:36Are where the fees are.
- 8:37Origination fees, servicing fees, relationship banking, cross sells.
- 8:42That is a very profitable line of business.
- 8:46The cap was a two for one.
- 8:47They lost on field of membership, but walked away with a constraint
- 8:51on the most lucrative product.
- 8:53Banks offered their members.
- 8:54That wasn't about protecting safety and soundness as alluded to in the, uh, a BA.
- 9:02Banking journal podcasts.
- 9:04This was about protecting bank revenue.
- 9:08There's one more historical irony worth noting.
- 9:11The cap that was designed to limit credit union business lending
- 9:14actually had the opposite effect.
- 9:16According to Mark Ritter, the host of Credit Union Conversation podcast.
- 9:21Who featured this history lesson made an observation that stuck with me.
- 9:25He said the cap jumpstarted, the credit union business lending industry.
- 9:29It helped create the QSO ecosystem.
- 9:32It helped credit unions working together and raise the flag that said, if that
- 9:36said, this is a legitimate thing to do.
- 9:39Mike Radway called it The Law of Unintended Consequences.
- 9:43You put in place A limit thinking you're going to stop something, and
- 9:47all you did was rave wave a red flag.
- 9:50So the next time you hear the A, BA, talking about safety and soundness
- 9:53concerns around credit union business lending, remember they created the
- 9:57conditions that produced the cap.
- 10:00They extracted it as a consolation prize after losing on field of membership,
- 10:05and the cap ended up growing the very industry they were trying to constrain.
- 10:10Keep all of that in mind as we go through their claims.
- 10:13So claim one was the 2016 rule change was a relaxation
- 10:18that opened up the floodgates.
- 10:21Let me start with a direct quote from the A BA podcast because I want you to
- 10:25hear exactly what they said the host asked about, and I'm quoting these
- 10:30waivers that come from NCA to operate above the cap, and whether it's a
- 10:34rubber stamp for credit unions to exceed the 12 and a quarter percent limit.
- 10:39The economists respond at the 20, the 26th.
- 10:43Teen change had to do with the change in the waiver process where pretty much
- 10:47you could go ahead and self-certify and really there was a relaxation there.
- 10:52End quote.
- 10:53These are two separate errors running together in that exchange.
- 10:57And I wanna untangle them both because they go to the heart of whether this
- 11:01is sloppy work or something else.
- 11:05Or something, whether this is sloppy work or something worse.
- 11:08Error one, the host says NCUA, issues waivers to let credit unions operate
- 11:13above the 12 point a quarter percent cap.
- 11:16That's just factually wrong.
- 11:17There are no such waivers, there never were.
- 11:20The cap is set by statute, by the Federal Credit Union Act itself.
- 11:25To operate above it, you either had to be a Credit Union chartered specifically for
- 11:31the purpose of member business lending.
- 11:34Or hold a low income designation.
- 11:37Both of these are statutory provisions.
- 11:40Congress put them there.
- 11:43NCUA has no authority to waive the statutory cap, and the economist sitting
- 11:47right there never corrected the host.
- 11:50That alone should tell you something about the rigor of their analysis.
- 11:54Error two.
- 11:55What NCA actually eliminated in 2016 were loan level underwriting waivers
- 12:00under part 7 23 of N NCAA's regulations.
- 12:04Under the old rule, credit unions had to come to NCA and get case by case approval
- 12:09for specific underwriting exceptions, things like making a commercial loan above
- 12:1480% loan to value, waiving the 25% equity.
- 12:18Interest requirement or waiving the personal guarantee requirement.
- 12:22NCA was literally approving individual loan parameters and individual loans.
- 12:27And here's what N NCAA's own record shows by.
- 12:31By the time the 2016 change, there were over 1000 active MBL waivers.
- 12:37Over 1000 NCA itself acknowledged the waivers had become the
- 12:41norm rather than the exception.
- 12:44This is not a well-functioning regulatory system.
- 12:47This was a bureaucratic bottleneck.
- 12:49So what did NCA do?
- 12:51They eliminated the prescriptive requirements that were generating
- 12:54all those waivers, the specific LTV ratios, the equity minimums,
- 13:00the portfolio concentration limits.
- 13:02And replace them with a principles based framework requiring board approved
- 13:07policies, qualified lending staff, and demonstrated risk management programs.
- 13:12The federal register for the 2016 rule is explicit quote.
- 13:17The removal of the prescriptive requirements does not relieve the credit
- 13:21unions from setting appropriate limits.
- 13:23The NCA Board believes these internal constraints are necessary.
- 13:27Risk mitigation practices, end quote, oversight didn't weaken.
- 13:32It shifted from checking boxes to evaluating whether the risk
- 13:36management processes actually works.
- 13:39That's what every other financial regulator in the country does.
- 13:43The A BA calls that a election, NCUA called it modernization.
- 13:48I was there then and it was modernization.
- 13:51I spent 33 years at the agency and it eliminating a thousand waiver
- 13:56backlog of case by case loan approval.
- 14:01Eliminating a thousand waiver backlog of case by case loan approvals
- 14:05and replacing it with the same supervisory framework that OCC and F
- 14:10DS uses is not loosening oversight.
- 14:13It's finally catching up to how the rest of the industry already operates.
- 14:17Come on guys.
- 14:18The a BA economist described the elimination of a loan level underwriting
- 14:23waiver process as if it were loosening.
- 14:26Of the CAP oversight, those two complete, those are two completely different things.
- 14:30One is a supervision methodology.
- 14:32The other is a statutory lending limit.
- 14:35Conflating them is either misunderstanding of how NCA
- 14:38regulations works or it's deliberate.
- 14:41You decide which claim two, the member business lending cap is.
- 14:46Notional.
- 14:47The A BA podcast argues that between low income designation, exemptions,
- 14:52waivers, and bank acquisitions, the MBL cap has become essentially meaningless.
- 14:57Their words, not mine.
- 14:59I already told you where the cap came from.
- 15:01It was a political deal, not a carefully calibrated safety and soundness limit.
- 15:06So when the A BA complains that the cap is full of holes, what they're
- 15:10saying is that the political bargain, their industry helped negotiate in 1998
- 15:15didn't hold up the way we had hoped.
- 15:17That's a political grievance, not a regulatory.
- 15:20And every single mechanism they're complaining about was put there
- 15:24by Congress, not by NCUA, acting unilaterally, not by credit unions
- 15:29gaming the system by Congress.
- 15:32The low income designation exemption is in the Federal Credit Union Act itself.
- 15:37The act of Congress, the waiver process, has statutory basis.
- 15:42The bank acquisition pathway was never prohibited.
- 15:46By the way, they got into banks.
- 15:48If the a BA thinks those statutory exemptions shouldn't exist, they should
- 15:53go to Congress and make that case.
- 15:55But calling it circumvention implies credit unions are
- 15:58doing something underhanded.
- 16:00They're not.
- 16:01They're using mechanisms.
- 16:02Congress deliberately authorized using a lawful exemption isn't
- 16:08circumvention, it's compliance.
- 16:10I pulled the number of credit unions currently operating above the 12 and a
- 16:13quarter percent cap from NCA call report data as of the end of the year, 2025.
- 16:20It's 285 up from the 184 in 2021.
- 16:26But every one of those credit unions is using a mechanism Congress authorized.
- 16:31That's not a loophole.
- 16:32That's the system working as designed.
- 16:36Claim.
- 16:37Three, the low income designation explosion, the A
- 16:40BA makes a lot of the fact.
- 16:42That the share of credit unions with a low income designation rose from
- 16:466% in the year 2000 to over 54%.
- 16:50Today.
- 16:51They frame this as suspicious as if credit unions are gaming a designation.
- 16:55To avoid the MBL cap, let's look at what the data actually shows.
- 17:00And Sue's call report analysis confirms the total number of federally insured
- 17:05credit unions has fallen from 5,000.
- 17:0948 in 2021 to 4,374.
- 17:14By year end 2025, a drop of over 13% in just four years.
- 17:21The industry is caught consolidating rapidly.
- 17:23I recently did a podcast on mergers couple weeks back.
- 17:27If you're interested in that data, take a look, uh, on.
- 17:31The podcast from mid-March, so when the A BA points to a rising percentage
- 17:36of low income designation credit unions, part of what they're seeing
- 17:39is simply a shrinking denominator.
- 17:41Fewer total credit unions means the percentage rises even if the
- 17:45raw count of low income designated institutions stays flat or declines.
- 17:50And the lid, credit unions who take advantage of subordinated debt so they can
- 17:54serve their members who take advantage of not having the member business loan cap.
- 17:59So that they can make loans in their community make sense that those
- 18:03might be the ones that would survive.
- 18:05'cause they're serving the entire purpose of what they
- 18:09can do, but more fundamentally.
- 18:11Why has eligibility grown?
- 18:13The criteria for low income designations, again, shocker, are
- 18:18set by statute and regulation.
- 18:20They haven't been dramatically loosened.
- 18:22What changed is that NCA has done outreach to encourage eligible credit
- 18:26unions to apply for a designation.
- 18:28They were already entitled to.
- 18:31Demographic changes over the past 25 years have genuine, genuinely
- 18:36expanded the universe of credit unions serving lower income communities.
- 18:41The A BA wants you to see a conspiracy.
- 18:44The data shows a regulator encouraging eligible institutions to take advantage
- 18:49of a congressionally created designation.
- 18:54Claim four.
- 18:55All of these are laughable, but this one is quite laughable.
- 18:58N two A lacks the expertise to supervise commercial lending.
- 19:02I take that personally, and I say that as someone who's, again, spent 33
- 19:06years at NCA, the A BA says, and I'm paraphrasing, the NCA, probably lacks
- 19:12both historical and current expertise to supervise commercial lending.
- 19:16Their evidence.
- 19:17Bankers on their commercial real estate committees say that credit
- 19:20unions will do some loans that bank regulators wouldn't allow.
- 19:25So, let me get this right.
- 19:26Low income designated credit unions are getting served by credit unions
- 19:31making loans, and they must be bad loans 'cause banks wouldn't make them.
- 19:35That's not evidence of supervisory failure.
- 19:38That's evidence of competition.
- 19:40When a credit union offers a loan that a bank won't.
- 19:43Or at a lower rate.
- 19:44It might mean the credit union has looser standards as they implied, or it might
- 19:49mean the bank regulators are overly conservative, or it might mean that the
- 19:52bank is overly conserv conservative.
- 19:55Or it might mean the credit union has a different relationship
- 19:58with that borrow borrower.
- 19:59You can't tell from that anecdote.
- 20:03What I can tell you that NCUA has had member business lending regulations
- 20:07since the 1980s, updated comprehensively in 2003 and modernized again in 2016
- 20:14by one of my members of my team, VIN Vitton, who helped rewrite the rule.
- 20:20NCUA has specialized commercial lending examiners.
- 20:25They have, some would argue they have too many commercial lending specialists,
- 20:29but it's not an area they ignore.
- 20:31It's an area they get hyper aggressive on.
- 20:34The agency also has concentration risk, guidance, interest rate, risk
- 20:37requirements, and net worth standards that apply to commercial lending activity.
- 20:42So as N C's Commercial Lending supervision identical to what
- 20:45the OCC does for large banks?
- 20:47No.
- 20:48Should it be no credit unions are different.
- 20:51They're member owned cooperatives, not investor owned corporations, but
- 20:55the claim that NCUA is asleep at the wheel on commercial lending supervision
- 20:59simply doesn't match the reality.
- 21:02Now, I'll throw one caveat out there.
- 21:04Okay.
- 21:04NCUA, I've talked about this a lot.
- 21:06NCA has lost 27% of their staff.
- 21:08They lost a lot of good staff, but the one area they were overhired in, in
- 21:12my opinion, was an regional lending specialist, which includes the super, the.
- 21:17The specialization of commercial lending and understanding that environment.
- 21:22And by the way, every banking regulator is dealing with that because they all had
- 21:26to deal with the Trump mandate to shrink.
- 21:28So is the a BA criticizing banks and the OCC, uh, for shrinking?
- 21:34No, they're not.
- 21:35They just wanna attack credit unions, in my opinion.
- 21:38That is.
- 21:39Claim five, the bank acquisition, commercial loan comparison.
- 21:43The ABAs economists pointed out that credit unions that have acquired
- 21:47banks carely nearly 20 times the level of commercial loans as credit
- 21:51unions that haven't done acquisitions.
- 21:53They present this as alarming.
- 21:55I want you to think about this for one moment.
- 21:58When a credit union acquires a commercial bank, what does it acquire?
- 22:03A commercial bank's portfolio.
- 22:05Of course, the commercial loan balance is dramatically higher.
- 22:09Part of that's because.
- 22:11They didn't have a 12.25%
- 22:13cap thrust upon them because the banks wanted it to be there.
- 22:16Why?
- 22:17Because it's profitable.
- 22:19So that's the entire nature of this transaction.
- 22:21That's the A mathematical identity dressed up as an alarming finding.
- 22:27It tells you nothing about underwriting quality.
- 22:29It tells you nothing about delinquency rates.
- 22:32It tells you nothing about whether NCO a's supervision is adequate.
- 22:35It tells you that when you merge a commercial bank into a credit
- 22:39union, the credit union ends up with more commercial loans.
- 22:43Oftentimes, that's the whole point of the merger.
- 22:45Now, if the a BA wants to make an argument that post-acquisition
- 22:49integration creates examination challenges, or that the combined entities
- 22:53need enhanced supervisory attention, that's a legitimate conversation.
- 22:57I've had that myself, but that's not what they said.
- 23:00They presented a mathematical inevitability as evidence of a problem.
- 23:06Claim number six.
- 23:07These loans haven't been through a stress scenario.
- 23:11The A BA argues that because most of the growth in member business lending
- 23:14happened during an economic expansion, we don't know how this portfolio will
- 23:19perform when things get tough and on the surface that sounds reasonable,
- 23:24but let me tell, give you a comparison.
- 23:26Comparison.
- 23:26They conveniently left out bank commercial real estate delinquencies peaked at 9%.
- 23:339% in 2009 and 2010 following the financial crisis.
- 23:409%, and that was under the supervision of the OCC and the
- 23:44FDIC and the Federal Reserve.
- 23:47The very regulators, the A BA is holding up as the experts that NCUA should
- 23:52inspire to emulate current credit union commercial loan delinquency
- 23:56as of year end 2025, about 1%.
- 24:00I know that because I pulled it myself from N NCAA's call
- 24:03report data, and if you use this.
- 24:05The 60 plus day delinquency definition, which is actually more standard
- 24:09comparison to bank CRE figures, it's 0.44%
- 24:15against the 9% worst case in 2008, 2009.
- 24:20Now, to be fair, credit union commercial loan delinquency has been
- 24:23rising, and that's worth watching.
- 24:25I've talked about it here, that delinquency.
- 24:29Collectively in the industry is over 1% for the first time in more than a decade.
- 24:34NCA itself has identified credit risk as a supervisory priority, but
- 24:39we're talking about a delinquency rate that is a fraction of what
- 24:42bank CRE produced during the actual stress scenario of 2008 and 2009.
- 24:48And oh, by the way, NCUA does have credit union stress there.
- 24:54They do stress tests on their, when they have concentration risks.
- 24:57I've seen it when I was at NCUA and I see it and hear about it.
- 25:00In my conversations with credit unions today, the, these
- 25:04loans haven't been tested.
- 25:06Argument cuts both ways.
- 25:08History shows us which system pro produced the systemic crisis.
- 25:12It was banks, not credit unions which.
- 25:17Institutions had horrific delinquency in, in oh 8, 0 9 banks, not credit unions.
- 25:23So again, you be the judge of what they're trying to do here.
- 25:27And here's something, the A BA really doesn't want you to think about.
- 25:30Former NCA Chairman Todd Harper, someone who spent years overseeing
- 25:34the credit union system from the top said it plainly in a, in the
- 25:39same podcast I mentioned before,
- 25:42well-written and well underwritten member business loans have the ability to
- 25:46perform differently in different economic cycles than auto loans or mortgage loans.
- 25:51And that he said is good.
- 25:53From a safety and soundness perspective, diversification into business lending
- 25:57isn't a risk to the system done right.
- 26:00It's a protection for this system.
- 26:02The A BA is arguing it exactly.
- 26:06Backwards claim seven.
- 26:08The small business satisfaction data, the A BA Economist cites the
- 26:12Federal Reserve Small Business Credit Survey to argue that small businesses
- 26:16consistently prefer banks over credit unions for their lending needs.
- 26:21And they're right that the survey shows higher sinis
- 26:23satisfaction scores for banks.
- 26:26But here's the methodological problem.
- 26:28They don't mention that survey measures satisfaction among approved applicants
- 26:33at institutions they chose to apply to.
- 26:36If credit unions have membership eligibility requirements that filters
- 26:40who applies in the first place,
- 26:42you're comparing different populations like apples to bananas.
- 26:46The members who chose their credit union and got approved for a loan
- 26:49is a fundamentally different survey respondent than the small business
- 26:53owner who walked into a community bank.
- 26:57Beyond that credit unions cons consistently score among the highest
- 27:00of any financial institution, type in the American customer satisfaction in
- 27:05index year after year, across the full membership, not just business borrowers.
- 27:10The A BA knows this.
- 27:11They chose a survey that supports their argument.
- 27:15That's advocacy.
- 27:16That's fine, but don't call it objective economic research claim eight.
- 27:22The level playing field and the tax exemption.
- 27:25The A BA argues that the combination of credit union tax exemption and what
- 27:29they characterize as looser underwriting creates an unfair pricing advantage.
- 27:35This is the oldest argument in the ABAs playbook.
- 27:38They've been making it since the 1990s.
- 27:41The credit union tax exemption exists because credit unions
- 27:44are member owned cooperatives.
- 27:47They don't have outside shareholders.
- 27:49Their earnings return to members through lower rates on loans, higher
- 27:53returns on deposits, and reduced fees.
- 27:56Tax treatment reflects the co cooperative structure, not a subsidy that Congress
- 28:02has overlooked and banks are not exactly operating without tax advantages of
- 28:07their loans deductions, tax exempt bond income, FDIC, deposit insurance, federal
- 28:12Home Loan Bank access, the playing field is not even in as the A BA would have
- 28:17you believe Congress has reviewed the credit union tax exemption many times.
- 28:23Over many decades and has chosen to maintain it.
- 28:26That's not an accident.
- 28:30What this is really about.
- 28:32I wanna be clear about something.
- 28:34The competitive tension between banks and credit unions is real.
- 28:37You know that better than me?
- 28:39'cause you're listening to this podcast.
- 28:41When credit unions grow, when they expand their field of membership,
- 28:44when they acquire banks and take on commercial lending portfolios,
- 28:48community banks feel that that's real comp competition for real customers.
- 28:53I'm not dismissing that, . But there's a difference between making a legitimate
- 28:57competitive argument in producing what is essentially a podcast dressed up with.
- 29:03Charts that we can't see and data points that don't make sense.
- 29:09The a BA podcast presented advocacy as analysis.
- 29:13In my opinion is cited data selectively, in my opinion, and I think if you
- 29:19listen to what I said before this, you probably agree, it made alarming
- 29:22claims about systemic risk based on a commercial delinquency rate.
- 29:26That is a fraction of what the commercial rate was when during the crisis.
- 29:32And if you compare the crisis rate in banks to the what
- 29:36happened in credit unions.
- 29:38It was 8, 7, 8 9 fold, and their proposed solution, congressional hearings, or an
- 29:45enhanced oversight conveniently aligns with the Abba's longstanding legislative
- 29:50agenda to restrict credit union growth when the solution happens to match
- 29:55the advocate's preexisting agenda.
- 29:59That's always worth noting.
- 30:01What does the actual data show?
- 30:03Credit Union net income for the full year ending 2025 was up over 30% over 2024.
- 30:09I pulled that from their call report data.
- 30:12The aggregate net worth for federally insured credit union stands at 11.28%
- 30:17as of the end of the year.
- 30:18Well above the 7% well capitalized threshold and member business
- 30:23lending has grown steadily.
- 30:25From 109 billion in 2021 to 185 billion in 2025.
- 30:32That's real growth, but it is steady, consistent growth.
- 30:36Growth over four years, not the explosion, the A BA describes.
- 30:44So I understand rough justice sometimes you made a broad point
- 30:48and the details aren't perfect.
- 30:49I use it myself sometimes, and I say the term rough justice, but rough
- 30:54justice that produces wrong collude.
- 30:56Conclusions and leaves innuendos hanging in the air about an industry's safety.
- 31:01And soundness is not analysis.
- 31:04It's a talking point.
- 31:05The A BA is entitled to their talking points.
- 31:09The credit union is entitled, credit Union Industry is entitled
- 31:12to the Facts, the ABAs Framing of this as a systemic risk emergency
- 31:19requiring congressional intervention.
- 31:22That's a political argument, not a safety and soundness argument.
- 31:25And credit union people should know the difference.
- 31:28And up to this point in time, Congress has known the difference too.
- 31:32So my takeaway for credit unions, if you're a credit union executive or
- 31:36board member, here's what I want you to walk away from with this episode.
- 31:40First.
- 31:41Know this, know that this argument isn't going away.
- 31:45The A BA will keep making the case that credit unions have strayed
- 31:48from their original mission.
- 31:50They have the resources to fund studies, generate media coverage, and
- 31:54push this narrative on Capitol Hill.
- 31:57You need to be prepared to counter it with facts, with your own story,
- 32:01with data about who you serve and what you do for your members.
- 32:05That's why I go to America's Credit Union's, GAC.
- 32:08That's why I'm thrilled.
- 32:09Every time I see 6,000 credit union people there hiking the hill, you hike that hill,
- 32:14you tell your story, and you will keep this nonsense from the a, b, A at bay.
- 32:19Second, the best defense against these arguments is running a good credit union.
- 32:24Maintaining appropriate capital, having strong underwriting standards for
- 32:28your business loans, building in the risk management infrastructure that
- 32:34justifies the trust that your members place in you when your institution
- 32:38is well run the ABAs arguments find.
- 32:42Who wants to listen.
- 32:43Third, engage in NCO a's supervisory process proactively.
- 32:48Don't wait for the examiners to find problems with your
- 32:51commercial lending program.
- 32:52Have the policies, the staff, the concentration monitoring,
- 32:56and do your annual follow-ups.
- 32:57By the way, that's one of the things when we get brought in to have
- 33:02conversations with credit unions and commercial lending, the one thing that.
- 33:06That can always be done a little bit better is those annual reviews show
- 33:11the examiners you're on top of it.
- 33:13That's how you get through your exam with flying colors, and that's
- 33:17what we're here to help you do.
- 33:19And fourth, be skeptical of data without context.
- 33:22When someone cites a statistic without explaining what it means.
- 33:26What it's being compared to and what they're leaving out.
- 33:30That's usually a sign that you're dealing with advocacy, not analysis.
- 33:36All right.
- 33:36That's all I've got for you today.
- 33:38I hope you found this episode helpful.
- 33:40If you wonder how I come up with my podcast topics,
- 33:43sometimes it's listening to.
- 33:45Another podcast and concluding, hell no, that's wrong.
- 33:49And that's what this podcast was about.
- 33:52As always, I wanna thank you for watching.
- 33:54Thank you for listening.
- 33:56This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.
- 34:01I.