Latest / Surrounded / 1 Moderate vs 20 Progressives (ft. Tim Pool)
Transcript
- 0:00You have a lot of politicians on the Democrat
- 0:01side who got behind authoritarian practices during COVID.
- 0:04I'm not going to support those individuals,
- 0:06but the authoritarian practices today,
- 0:08you're willing to look past
- 0:09some of them,
- 0:10yes.
- 0:11Come on,
- 0:11man.
- 0:12The mainstream political left commits more
- 0:14violence than the mainstream political right.
- 0:16None of what you're saying makes any sense.
- 0:18It sounds like you're honestly grifting a lot.
- 0:21You can say that.
- 0:21Let me ask you a question every fucking year and it doesn't happen,
- 0:24and I never,
- 0:24it just hasn't happened yet.
- 0:26Do you want me to get you a soapbox?
- 0:27It's really I can leave.
- 0:27You want me,
- 0:28I'm really easy to do what you do.
- 0:30It's really easy to do what you do.
- 0:31Is the United States.
- 0:32Tracking towards civil war
- 0:34or is America more united than it seems?
- 0:37Hi everyone,
- 0:37I'm Paris Rose and I'll be filling in for John today
- 0:40from Jubilee Media.
- 0:41This is Surrounded,
- 0:42where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:46Today we're debating which political party is more violent
- 0:49is authoritarianism on the rise in America
- 0:51and have both parties abandoned their oath to the Constitution?
- 0:54I'm here with our future guest,
- 0:56moderate political commentator
- 0:58Tim Poole.
- 0:58Hi,
- 0:58I'm Tim Poole.
- 0:59I'm the host of Timcast IRL and today I'm surrounded by progressives.
- 1:09My first surrounded claim
- 1:10is that the mainstream left commits more violence than the mainstream right.
- 1:15If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:16get to the chair in 321.
- 1:25How's it going?
- 1:25Great to meet you,
- 1:26buddy.
- 1:26How you doing?
- 1:27Pretty good,
- 1:27pretty good.
- 1:27There seems to be like a broader implication
- 1:29with your prompt that there's this domestic threat
- 1:31from mainstream left politicians.
- 1:34Like,
- 1:34do you really think Hillary Clinton's like leading the Vanguard Revolution Party?
- 1:37Like,
- 1:38no,
- 1:38what,
- 1:38what is your take?
- 1:39When you look at the violence that we do see.
- 1:42Uh,
- 1:42there's,
- 1:42it's,
- 1:42it's,
- 1:43it's,
- 1:43uh,
- 1:43from,
- 1:44I,
- 1:44I,
- 1:44I describe it as from blunt to acute,
- 1:46which is
- 1:47with the fringe extreme right you'll see extreme,
- 1:49uh,
- 1:50mass shootings.
- 1:50You'll see,
- 1:51you know,
- 1:51someone will show up and unload on people,
- 1:53things like that.
- 1:54On the left though,
- 1:55you'll see riots,
- 1:56vandalism that you don't see from the right,
- 1:58but.
- 1:59The point I'm making is that when you break down
- 2:01the ideology that motivates individuals that commit political violence,
- 2:04there is more,
- 2:05more often an overlap between what the Democratic Party espouses ideologically
- 2:09and what we see in street level violence,
- 2:11as well as maybe assassinations.
- 2:13What is is what the Republicans would espouse.
- 2:15I mean,
- 2:15I couldn't disagree more.
- 2:16What,
- 2:17what ideologies that the Democratic Party is promoting
- 2:19that leads to these types of violence.
- 2:21Anytime you see an act of violence that's typically attributed to the left,
- 2:24it is immediately condemned by every Democrat.
- 2:26Politician.
- 2:26You couldn't point to one that actually endorses that
- 2:29where you have somebody like Donald Trump who's
- 2:31literally the president of the United States saying that
- 2:33we should call for the death of congressional members
- 2:36who are fulfilling their civic duty and saying,
- 2:38hey,
- 2:38maybe you shouldn't,
- 2:39uh,
- 2:39fulfill illegal orders if you're in the military,
- 2:42and Donald Trump's asking for them to be put to death.
- 2:44How is that not inciting to violence?
- 2:46No,
- 2:46that is,
- 2:46that's absolutely terrifying.
- 2:48I completely disagree with that.
- 2:49My,
- 2:49my point more so is that when you see,
- 2:51say,
- 2:51uh,
- 2:52the George Floyd or the BLM riots.
- 2:54You end up with,
- 2:55uh,
- 2:55Biden and Kamala themselves promoting fundraisers
- 2:57for those accused of committing these crimes
- 3:00during which crimes,
- 3:00which crimes could you point to?
- 3:02So in Minnesota you had,
- 3:03uh,
- 3:03uh,
- 3:03there was famously there was a firefighter who opened a sports bar.
- 3:06It was burned down.
- 3:07In fact,
- 3:07when the,
- 3:07when the,
- 3:08when the,
- 3:08uh,
- 3:08local news went to interview him.
- 3:11About his dream bar being burnt to the ground,
- 3:13it was ransacked.
- 3:14I don't think it was burnt to the ground.
- 3:15They,
- 3:15uh,
- 3:16while they're filming the story,
- 3:17there were people looting a safe and stealing it.
- 3:20Well,
- 3:20I think that there's absolutely a big
- 3:21difference between a lot of the private buildings
- 3:23or private enterprises that were targeted versus
- 3:26like public institutions like the police precinct.
- 3:28Like
- 3:28you're somebody who I've seen the iconography on your show,
- 3:31you're,
- 3:31you're a big patriotic guy.
- 3:32Love 1776,
- 3:33right?
- 3:34That wasn't the most peaceful way that we had,
- 3:36you know,
- 3:37criticizing our government or saying that tyranny
- 3:38shouldn't exist with the Revolutionary War,
- 3:40but I will say on before they signed,
- 3:41I will say,
- 3:42I will say that the police precincts,
- 3:44that the same people who committed a brutal murder
- 3:46using state violence in order to justify that,
- 3:48we,
- 3:48I think we can understand why people would rightfully be,
- 3:51be mad without any accountability control
- 3:51of the police department in Minneapolis.
- 3:55That that is not the central,
- 3:56first of all,
- 3:57we're talking about the mainstream political left,
- 3:58which politicians are endorsing that type of
- 4:01ever said politicians were endorsing it.
- 4:02Then what's the mainstream left?
- 4:03So you have
- 4:04activists
- 4:05whose ideology aligns with politicians who are you say
- 4:08that those activists identify with the Democratic Party,
- 4:10the ones that are committed by the Democratic Party because let me tell you,
- 4:13the,
- 4:13the,
- 4:13the leftists that you could talk to,
- 4:15not the biggest fans of the Democratic Party Party in favor of Black Lives Matter.
- 4:18I,
- 4:19I would say yeah,
- 4:19I,
- 4:19I'd say even most moderates,
- 4:21I'd say actual moderates,
- 4:22not,
- 4:23not right leaning conservatives who claim to be moderates riots.
- 4:25Usually those people also agree that police violence is something
- 4:28that should be the riots Black Lives Matter motivated?
- 4:31They were motivated
- 4:32by Black Lives Matter.
- 4:33So that ideology is espoused by,
- 4:36so my point is Black Lives Matter is not encouraging violence.
- 4:38Black Lives Matter is recognizing systemic inequality where they were,
- 4:41they were telling people to go be violent.
- 4:42I'm saying that there are violent individuals
- 4:45and with the riots,
- 4:45a lot of them,
- 4:46which we've seen,
- 4:47can you tell me how about this,
- 4:47Chris?
- 4:48Tell me who Chris Wray is.
- 4:49Do you know who Chris Wray is?
- 4:50Explain it to me.
- 4:51Well,
- 4:51you,
- 4:51you have a show talking about politics every day.
- 4:53I would think that you know,
- 4:54but Chris Wray was the former,
- 4:55let's not,
- 4:55let's not do this.
- 4:56If you have a point to make,
- 4:56let's make a point.
- 4:57Let's not try and play these games.
- 4:58So Chris Wray was the former FBI director under Donald Trump's first term.
- 5:02He said that
- 5:03he even agreed with the findings from both the congressional research session
- 5:06that
- 5:07right-wing violence is way more proliferate
- 5:09in this country than left-wing violence.
- 5:11That's not,
- 5:11that's not meaningful to a voter.
- 5:13Let me explain.
- 5:14The Republican Party rejects neo-Nazism,
- 5:16correct?
- 5:17No,
- 5:17Donald Trump invited Nick Fuentes to have dinner with him,
- 5:19with Kanye West.
- 5:20So tell me one politician who went out and campaigned for the neo-Nazi vote.
- 5:24Uh,
- 5:25I'm blanking on his name,
- 5:25but Gawzer,
- 5:26uh,
- 5:26Gozar,
- 5:27and that,
- 5:27is that a main Arizona view in this,
- 5:29in this country?
- 5:29Well,
- 5:30we could talk about Gozar,
- 5:31we could talk about Matt Gates.
- 5:32We could talk about Gates.
- 5:33I'm not endorsing neo-Nazism,
- 5:34and Donald Trump said you kidding me?
- 5:35Nazis should be condemned entirely.
- 5:37No,
- 5:37he is literally partnering with the America First movement.
- 5:39He was a America and neo-Nazism are totally different,
- 5:42bro.
- 5:42So you don't think neo,
- 5:43do you think Nick Fuentes is a neo-Nazi?
- 5:45Oh,
- 5:45I forgot you've had him on your show.
- 5:46Oh my God,
- 5:47I would literally forget.
- 5:48I wouldn't describe Nick Fuentes as a neo-Nazi.
- 5:50You don't think that Nick Fuentes celebrating
- 5:52Adolf Hitler is not neo-Nazi adjacent.
- 5:55I think you have to be very specific on what your terms are.
- 5:57And so when you go to an American voter and say something like,
- 6:00this is our moderate,
- 6:00by the way,
- 6:01everybody,
- 6:01this is our moderate indeed.
- 6:03Keep going.
- 6:04So
- 6:04when you go to a regular American and ask them
- 6:07what is meaningful to them in terms of an election.
- 6:09You don't have Democrats or Republicans endorsing violence,
- 6:13but you also don't have,
- 6:14uh,
- 6:14Charlie Kirk's a good example.
- 6:15He threw out Nick Fuentes,
- 6:17he threw out white identitarians,
- 6:19white nationalists from his events.
- 6:20They were not welcome.
- 6:21That's mainstream.
- 6:23You don't have riots coming from.
- 6:25The Republican Party and the right,
- 6:26although you do have January 6th and things like that.
- 6:28When you take a look at the,
- 6:30say,
- 6:30the shootings of the Tesla facilities,
- 6:32the execution of Aaron Danielson,
- 6:33the assassination of Charlie Kirk,
- 6:35and
- 6:36one of the attempted assassinations on Donald Trump,
- 6:38not the,
- 6:39not the Pennsylvania one.
- 6:40You can see the underlying ideologies overlap with the Democratic Party.
- 6:43When you take a look at like Nick Fuentes,
- 6:45he's opposed to the Republican Party.
- 6:46He's actively,
- 6:47he's been actively endorsing Democrats right now.
- 6:49He's been saying that the Republican Party is too left for him.
- 6:52It's not that he's opposed to the Republican Party in principle.
- 6:54This is literally my point.
- 6:56Nick Fuentes comes out and says,
- 6:57do not vote for Trump.
- 6:59The mainstream Republican Party is at odds with these people.
- 7:01No,
- 7:02again.
- 7:02You're looking at all of the empirical data,
- 7:04the violence is way more on the right.
- 7:06So you can say what your feelings are.
- 7:08You can say that feeling nor the claim.
- 7:10It is not meaningful to a voter to say
- 7:12we don't like neo-Nazis and white supremacists
- 7:14because the Republican Party is not saying
- 7:16they want to say let's be objective of where the violence is coming from,
- 7:19and if it's more substantially coming from the right,
- 7:21that is a problem that needs to be tackled coming from Charlie Kirk.
- 7:25OK,
- 7:26we're not talking about Charlie Kirk,
- 7:27we're talking about the overall ideologies.
- 7:29In fact,
- 7:29we're not.
- 7:29So you're telling me,
- 7:31you're telling me that the prioritization of hierarchies,
- 7:33both ethnic,
- 7:34both cultural,
- 7:35that is not a dangerous ideology,
- 7:37but something like BLM that says,
- 7:38hey,
- 7:39maybe we should take back police violence,
- 7:41maybe you should have accountability for people who are
- 7:43in charge of certain aspects of our nation,
- 7:46committing violence on citizens,
- 7:47those are absolutely completely different ideologies.
- 7:49Apologies
- 7:50and the fact that you're saying it is more motivating
- 7:52for violence that the left wing is encouraging people to take
- 7:55those that are committing violence accountable in the last 10 years
- 7:59there have been over 465 incidents of left motivated political violence
- 8:04that aligns with the Democratic Party,
- 8:05and there's been one
- 8:06on the Republican side,
- 8:07which is January 6th,
- 8:08which,
- 8:08which admittedly is particularly egregious.
- 8:11January 6th was that's why we talk about blunt versus acute.
- 8:14Now the problem is I already know what all you're gonna say.
- 8:16You're gonna cite FBI stats and Cato,
- 8:18but it's not meaningful to me or any voter
- 8:20to tell me why white supremacists are
- 8:21violent because I don't like white supremacists,
- 8:23nor will I vote for them.
- 8:24And more importantly,
- 8:25you bring up Nick Fuentes.
- 8:26He is not aligned with Republicans and he's advocated against them.
- 8:29And I think,
- 8:30I think for somebody who don't like him,
- 8:31I think for somebody who has a political show
- 8:33where you talk about this stuff every day,
- 8:35you are completely misreading the conversation
- 8:37when you're saying that those that are engaged in like civil disobedience or like.
- 8:41I'm not talking about voters.
- 8:42You're,
- 8:42you're telling me that those people are
- 8:44canvassing for Democratic politician said that,
- 8:45which is actually not true,
- 8:47absolutely in favor of canvassing.
- 8:48I'm in favor of,
- 8:49uh,
- 8:49protesting.
- 8:49I'm saying that you're,
- 8:50I'm not saying that you're against that.
- 8:52I'm saying don't try and frame my argument
- 8:53like I'm upset with protests because I've defended,
- 8:56I've defended Black Lives Matter blocking streets.
- 8:58I've defended left aligned progressive groups like uh
- 9:01anti-capitalist groups blocking streets and environmental groups.
- 9:03I stand with civil disobedience and I've defended them every single time.
- 9:07If you want to block.
- 9:07A road,
- 9:08there's what is it that you're saying is more violent on the left.
- 9:11You mentioned Black Lives Matter.
- 9:13You mentioned these.
- 9:13Let's talk about uh the Tesla facilities being unloaded upon or shot up,
- 9:17right?
- 9:18These are motivated by an ideology that you will hear from Elizabeth Warren.
- 9:22Now,
- 9:22of course,
- 9:22she's not telling people to shoot anybody,
- 9:24but she is coming out saying Elon Musk is a dangerous threat to this country.
- 9:27And then you end up with someone going and pulling a rifle up and shooting up a Tesla.
- 9:31It's when you understand that the right always says politicians.
- 9:34Are not responsible for individual actions.
- 9:36Elizabeth Warren saying,
- 9:37hey,
- 9:37maybe we should have the same sort of economic policies they have in Scandinavia.
- 9:41That is not her encouraging,
- 9:42go shoot up a Tesla facility where Donald Trump's saying,
- 9:45let's hang the people.
- 9:46Let's hang the people who encourage
- 9:48those in the military to actually fulfill their duties.
- 9:51That is completely my claim is not that the
- 9:52right is completely the leader of the Republican Party,
- 9:54my dear.
- 9:55I to say that these are equivocal at all
- 9:57is completely condemn 100% what Donald Trump said,
- 9:59calling for the death of those politicians.
- 10:02We have to move on.
- 10:03Great to meet you,
- 10:04Tim.
- 10:04Likewise.
- 10:06If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 10:07get to the chair in 321.
- 10:12Hello.
- 10:14Hi.
- 10:16What I find really interesting is the whole premise of
- 10:19like the Occupy Wall Street movement was to protest,
- 10:22right?
- 10:22It was specifically geared towards making sure that
- 10:26the general public
- 10:28was understanding the situation at the time,
- 10:31which had a lot to do with anti-capitalist,
- 10:34um,
- 10:34motives,
- 10:35right?
- 10:36And so when we're talking about who's more violent
- 10:39than who we have to be very specific that.
- 10:42The violence that is uh recorded in the data
- 10:46is not ideological violence.
- 10:48It's not this like rhetoric.
- 10:49It has to be evidentiary.
- 10:51So
- 10:52if you're going to say like,
- 10:53oh,
- 10:54Black Lives Matter,
- 10:55um,
- 10:55and any leftists uh that are associated with that are automatically violent,
- 11:00that's just not the case and but that's what you're implying I'm.
- 11:05that
- 11:06when you have riots in this country,
- 11:08overwhelmingly,
- 11:09the underlying ideology aligns with the mainstream left ideology of this country.
- 11:13But what you're saying
- 11:15in your prompt
- 11:16that you wrote
- 11:17is that
- 11:18the left is more violent than the right.
- 11:20The mainstream political left commits more
- 11:23violence than the mainstream political right,
- 11:24right,
- 11:24the mainstream.
- 11:26And what I'm trying to tell you is that.
- 11:28The data is not showing that that is the actual evidence.
- 11:31If you're talking,
- 11:32no,
- 11:32it doesn't 775/10 years,
- 11:3575 to 80%
- 11:38of violence,
- 11:39actual violence that is being tracked
- 11:42as domestic terrorism
- 11:44comes from the right.
- 11:45It's white supremacist groups and white supremacists are not,
- 11:48uh,
- 11:48in,
- 11:48in a large political party getting voted for.
- 11:50Yes they are.
- 11:51The Republican Party
- 11:52is a very largely right wing.
- 11:54It is very far right.
- 11:56If you,
- 11:56but they're not white supremacists,
- 11:58nor would,
- 11:58nor are the Americans voting for Republican Party because
- 12:00they want white supremacy Make America Great Again means?
- 12:03I think it means making the economy improve.
- 12:05I think it means
- 12:07building our cultural institutions.
- 12:09Well,
- 12:09you can according to what time?
- 12:11According to what time?
- 12:11I'll give you that.
- 12:12Probably the 80s
- 12:13because Trump's an old man.
- 12:15I,
- 12:16I would,
- 12:16I would say the 90s seriously doubt he meant the 80s.
- 12:18He's much older than the 80s.
- 12:20Well,
- 12:20your,
- 12:20your interpretation of
- 12:22Donald Trump's opinions is separate from
- 12:25when we see a riot,
- 12:26what is motivating the riot,
- 12:28when we sees an assassination policies,
- 12:30don't they?
- 12:31Indeed,
- 12:31and nobody,
- 12:32no one,
- 12:32no one here is making the claim that Donald Trump is innocent,
- 12:35nor
- 12:36does he not.
- 12:36have individuals who you're attempting to make a claim that his
- 12:40type of ideology that leads his policy is not nearly as violent
- 12:45as the left,
- 12:46how many riots have there been largely anti-capitalist,
- 12:49which is largely anti-fascist.
- 12:51None of what you're saying makes any sense.
- 12:53It sounds like you're honestly grifting a lot.
- 12:55How many,
- 12:56how many Republican riots have there been?
- 12:58Um,
- 12:59I don't know the exact number,
- 13:01but what are you classifying as a riot?
- 13:04What?
- 13:04Because if you're completing protesting with rioting,
- 13:07that's a very different thing.
- 13:08No,
- 13:09we're talking specifically about people
- 13:11ransacking Tesla facilities,
- 13:13vehicles,
- 13:13charging stations.
- 13:14You're so obsessed with the Tesla thing.
- 13:16Why don't we actually talk about,
- 13:17I think it might be.
- 13:18I don't a rifle and I don't shooting is like investing in your company or something,
- 13:22but let's like remove the Tesla out of it.
- 13:25That has nothing to do with what your actual prompt is saying.
- 13:27No,
- 13:27that's actually what is.
- 13:29No,
- 13:29it sounds a lot like then you're arguing something decided no,
- 13:32you're arguing something else because it sounds like you went from somebody who
- 13:35was doing really important work in Occupy Wall Street to then grifting all.
- 13:39All the way to defending the far right people,
- 13:41that's crazy.
- 13:42What was the important work?
- 13:44What important work?
- 13:45You said,
- 13:45in terms of Occupy Wall Street,
- 13:47I,
- 13:47I think,
- 13:48you know,
- 13:48in terms of that movement,
- 13:49I thought it was,
- 13:50um,
- 13:51it,
- 13:51it was one of the first times in our generation that we were able to see
- 13:55an actual organization against capital.
- 13:58Can I ask you how old you are?
- 13:59No,
- 14:00you cannot ask me how were you politically active during Occupy Wall Street?
- 14:02Yes,
- 14:03I was.
- 14:03Did you follow the news about me during during Occupy Wall Street?
- 14:06Uh,
- 14:07not specifically,
- 14:08and the news was that Occupy denounced the violence.
- 14:11I had filmed leftists deflating police tires who physically attacked me,
- 14:15and I was attacked by a masked individual smacking my camera out of his hand.
- 14:19Occupy Wall Street vendetta for you then gave me indeed,
- 14:23if you're taking,
- 14:23if you're getting emotional about this and you don't want to have an argument,
- 14:25that's fine.
- 14:26Do I look emotional?
- 14:27You do because you don't know what happened during Occupy.
- 14:30And your argument is off because you don't.
- 14:32This honestly sounds like you have a personal vendetta from your
- 14:35history that has absolutely nothing with what your actions prompted,
- 14:39which is around far right people being much more violent than the left.
- 14:43We have to pause.
- 14:44Love the passion,
- 14:45but pause.
- 14:47All right.
- 14:50If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 14:51please get to the chair in 321.
- 14:57You got it.
- 14:58Nice to meet you.
- 14:59How's it going?
- 15:00Good.
- 15:02I think we should just get to the heart of it.
- 15:03Donald Trump is a fascist.
- 15:05He has Nazis in his administration,
- 15:08his entire messaging
- 15:09was resonating with Nazis from the very beginning.
- 15:12Donald Trump,
- 15:13when rallying for 2024,
- 15:16had a massive rally in Madison Square Garden.
- 15:18What was the significance of that rally?
- 15:21You tell me.
- 15:22Yeah,
- 15:22it's the same place,
- 15:23same date as the Nazis
- 15:25in the 1940s.
- 15:27Literally.
- 15:28Um,
- 15:29Donald Trump said that,
- 15:30uh,
- 15:31immigrants are poisoning the blood of America.
- 15:34In their varmint.
- 15:35Who also said that?
- 15:37You tell me.
- 15:38Hitler.
- 15:39Literally,
- 15:40Donald Trump has openly
- 15:42said things as dog whistles.
- 15:44So you may say that it's not mainstream,
- 15:46but the entire ideology of the right
- 15:49speaks to those people.
- 15:50Let me ask you,
- 15:50what,
- 15:50what do you mean by fascist?
- 15:52Uh,
- 15:52far-right,
- 15:53authoritarian,
- 15:54ultra-nationalistic,
- 15:5514 tens of fascism,
- 15:57all that.
- 15:57But there's a specific definition of fascist.
- 15:59Do you just mean that
- 16:00he's,
- 16:00he's an authoritarian?
- 16:02No,
- 16:02I mean that he meets all 14 tenets of fascism,
- 16:04fascism,
- 16:05which is what.
- 16:06Do you want to go through all 14 points.
- 16:08I don't.
- 16:08I,
- 16:08I'm trying to understand your argument,
- 16:10but so,
- 16:10so my point largely is we see people say Trump is a fascist,
- 16:13but there's,
- 16:14you know,
- 16:14if,
- 16:15if you go to,
- 16:15if you go to an academic and you look at fascism,
- 16:16say Italy,
- 16:17there,
- 16:18there's a common argument that you have the,
- 16:19the,
- 16:20the,
- 16:20the merger of corporate corporation and state as the defining
- 16:23element of what fascism is.
- 16:25There's different forms of fascism,
- 16:27right?
- 16:27And the actual premise is the authoritarian.
- 16:30Donald Trump is absolutely a fascist,
- 16:32he's,
- 16:33uh,
- 16:33like I said,
- 16:34he has Nazis in his administration.
- 16:36I think we're shifting,
- 16:37um,
- 16:38Pete Hesset.
- 16:40How,
- 16:40how is Heck and literally has a proud Nazi tattoo on his chest.
- 16:43Stephen Miller is absolutely a Nazi.
- 16:45Stephen Miller does not have a Nazi tattoo on his chest.
- 16:48That's,
- 16:48yeah,
- 16:49no,
- 16:49he does not have.
- 16:49He has a Catholic cross on his chest.
- 16:51OK.
- 16:52All right,
- 16:52cool.
- 16:53Um,
- 16:53I mean,
- 16:54guys,
- 16:54look,
- 16:54I,
- 16:54I,
- 16:54I went to Catholic school when I was little.
- 16:56I left,
- 16:56I left in 5th grade.
- 16:58Pete Hegseth is not a Nazi.
- 16:59Yeah,
- 16:59that's that,
- 17:00OK,
- 17:00cool.
- 17:00Um,
- 17:01question for you.
- 17:02When Donald Trump and his
- 17:04administration specifically actually implement policies
- 17:08that go at the heart of what Nazis want,
- 17:10like,
- 17:11targeting
- 17:11the first group of people they targeted was the transgender community,
- 17:14same thing as the Nazi.
- 17:16The,
- 17:16the actual Nazis specifically targeted
- 17:19people that weren't like them.
- 17:20There's been a persistent and consistent attack on undocumented immigrants,
- 17:24black people,
- 17:25women,
- 17:26anyone that's not a straight white male in America.
- 17:29My,
- 17:30my,
- 17:30uh,
- 17:30principal claim is not that Donald Trump is innocent,
- 17:32nor perfect nor good.
- 17:33My claim is that when you look at street level violence,
- 17:35domestic terror,
- 17:36etc.
- 17:37you'll,
- 17:37you'll,
- 17:37you'll find more violence coming from the mainstream
- 17:40left as opposed to the mainstream right.
- 17:42Because I do think it's fair to point out white supremacists are violent,
- 17:45they do evil and horrible things,
- 17:46and we all,
- 17:47we all condemn that.
- 17:47The white supremacists are a part of the mainstream right.
- 17:50Oh,
- 17:50they're not.
- 17:51They,
- 17:51they literally are.
- 17:52There's no circumstance where you can go on TV.
- 17:55Thank you.
- 17:56You can return to your seat.
- 17:57You've been voted out.
- 17:57Nice meeting you.
- 18:02Alright,
- 18:02if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 18:03please get to the chair in 321.
- 18:09How's it going?
- 18:09That was,
- 18:09that was an easy grab.
- 18:10You're right there.
- 18:12So
- 18:12the first thing I'll say is I think it's
- 18:14a bit disingenuous to characterize any of the,
- 18:16all of the property damage committed during BLM as
- 18:19left-wing violence because there are gonna be rogue opportunists,
- 18:22opportunists during the biggest civil rights protests in American history.
- 18:26That's first and foremost.
- 18:27Um,
- 18:28the second thing I would,
- 18:29I would like to say is
- 18:30I don't think it makes sense to confine political violence strictly.
- 18:34In the context of individuals acting with political motive violently,
- 18:38I think it ignores institutional violence.
- 18:40Theoretically,
- 18:40you could say the 1960s,
- 18:42uh,
- 18:43civil rights movement was more violent than the,
- 18:45uh,
- 18:46counter protesters,
- 18:47but
- 18:47obviously the institutional violence
- 18:49of segregation,
- 18:51right?
- 18:51So,
- 18:52so what I would say is that the Republican Party is,
- 18:54um,
- 18:55and the mainstream political right is far more violent
- 18:57because they support.
- 18:58Uh,
- 18:59ICE ripping and separating families from one another,
- 19:01even from people who have no criminal background.
- 19:04Uh,
- 19:04you know,
- 19:05ICE deaths under ICE custody has skyrocketed even as a matter of parade,
- 19:09war abroad,
- 19:09etc.
- 19:10But domestic,
- 19:11I,
- 19:11I'd love to talk the war stuff.
- 19:12I'm a sure,
- 19:12you know,
- 19:12a big foreign policy guy,
- 19:13but,
- 19:13uh,
- 19:13uh,
- 19:14domestically,
- 19:14did this not happen during,
- 19:15uh,
- 19:15Barack Obama's administration?
- 19:17Uh,
- 19:17it did,
- 19:17but not to the same extent.
- 19:19And,
- 19:19but,
- 19:19and he,
- 19:19and Barack Obama was criticized for it by who,
- 19:22the political left.
- 19:23Agreed.
- 19:24So my point is not to say again that there's no violence on the right,
- 19:27uh,
- 19:27and I think the institutional argument is actually a good one.
- 19:29However,
- 19:30I,
- 19:30my,
- 19:30my,
- 19:31my view largely is when you look at Occupy Wall Street,
- 19:33for which I was there and I watched police instigate fights,
- 19:36or when I was,
- 19:37I was on the ground during the,
- 19:38uh,
- 19:39the,
- 19:39the,
- 19:39the,
- 19:39the,
- 19:39the protests in,
- 19:40uh,
- 19:41on West Florissant Avenue,
- 19:42and I saw police throw a flash bang grenade
- 19:45at protesters who were not doing anything violent.
- 19:48The issue is these police are under Democrat administrations still where their,
- 19:52their chiefs are often appointed by Democrat politicians.
- 19:54So again,
- 19:55I understand the
- 19:56the left and progressives.
- 19:57That to me is also a little disingenuous because it's not as though the police,
- 20:01as a matter of its institution is a left wing institution.
- 20:05No,
- 20:05in fact,
- 20:05in fact,
- 20:06usually the police are protecting and on the other side
- 20:09of left wing the protesters that IC under Trump,
- 20:11I'll make the argument of police under the Democrats,
- 20:13sir.
- 20:13Well,
- 20:14I,
- 20:14I don't know.
- 20:15Well,
- 20:15the
- 20:16Which is it does law enforcement defer to their,
- 20:18to their politicians or not?
- 20:19It,
- 20:19it,
- 20:20it depends with because ICE is an executive agency.
- 20:23They,
- 20:23they do,
- 20:23they do,
- 20:24and the police department in Minneapolis is under the Democrats.
- 20:27Yes,
- 20:27right.
- 20:27And we all agree that there's problems there,
- 20:29but they're criticized and often on the other end of,
- 20:31of left wing protesters.
- 20:32So for instance,
- 20:34the protest against ICE here in Los Angeles,
- 20:36it's usually against left wing.
- 20:37So what is it,
- 20:38left on left violence?
- 20:39Is that what you're claiming?
- 20:40You think,
- 20:40you think police protesting against,
- 20:42uh.
- 20:43Or committing violence against left wing protesters,
- 20:46that's left on left violence,
- 20:48really?
- 20:48Yes,
- 20:49I think that's,
- 20:49I think that's ridiculous and absurd.
- 20:51The police who live in these cities tend to tend,
- 20:52they,
- 20:53they tend to be more moderate,
- 20:54but they're not hard conservatives.
- 20:55But is the institution is the policing as an institution,
- 20:58particularly left wing institution in New York?
- 21:00Well,
- 21:00I,
- 21:01I define a left-wing institution.
- 21:03Exactly.
- 21:03What I would say is
- 21:05Democrat politicians are the ones appointing these police chiefs
- 21:07and these administrations who are enacting these policies.
- 21:09But are they so when you're voting for someone.
- 21:11One
- 21:11into office.
- 21:12This is not conservatives doing it.
- 21:14It's not mainstream right wingers putting in police that beat protesters.
- 21:17But who,
- 21:17but who politically supports the police as a matter of their
- 21:20rhetoric and ideology,
- 21:22the right or the left,
- 21:23right,
- 21:23but the right,
- 21:23the right doesn't live in these places,
- 21:25yeah,
- 21:25but nor do they appoint these people.
- 21:27Sure,
- 21:27but don't,
- 21:27don't tell me that ICE under Donald Trump,
- 21:29but not police under Democratic politicians.
- 21:30Hold on.
- 21:31The left doesn't appoint,
- 21:33also doesn't appoint protesters who commit
- 21:35random acts of violence against property.
- 21:37That's not my argument.
- 21:38I know,
- 21:38I know.
- 21:38But what you earlier you were making the case that
- 21:41it's the ideology that motivates what these rioters are doing,
- 21:44and that's the reason why the left is ultimately responsible.
- 21:47The underlying ideology is overlapping with the Democratic Party.
- 21:50Sure.
- 21:50And so what I'm saying is that if you want to be consistent,
- 21:52the underlying ideology that supports the police and as,
- 21:55as a matter of institution,
- 21:57and when the police are cracking down on left wing protesters,
- 22:00that's overwhelmingly on the side of conservatives,
- 22:02except they're not in very large in these places and you're applying a locality.
- 22:05To the nation,
- 22:06they may not make sense.
- 22:07They,
- 22:07they may not be like technically in police in power are not motivated by the
- 22:12Republican Party to go out under a Democratic mayor to arrest protesters.
- 22:14The problem is that this,
- 22:16the police is still,
- 22:16as a matter of institution is more of a right wing institution than a left,
- 22:20certainly even,
- 22:20even on the other side of,
- 22:22but the point is a police officer who goes out in New York
- 22:25and arrests a protester does so at the best of a Democratic politician.
- 22:28I,
- 22:28I don't,
- 22:29I don't think it's true.
- 22:30You've been voted out by the majority.
- 22:32Please you.
- 22:36Alright,
- 22:36if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 22:38please get to the chair in 321.
- 22:44What's up young man?
- 22:46Listen,
- 22:46oh yeah,
- 22:47I haven't been young for a minute.
- 22:49No,
- 22:49slow down with that.
- 22:50Listen,
- 22:50I think it's,
- 22:51it's,
- 22:51uh,
- 22:52really quick that I condemn,
- 22:53I condemn,
- 22:53I condemn is a really cheap cop out.
- 22:55That's not gonna work.
- 22:56It's because the people around us are not low IQ like your average viewer.
- 22:59It's important to recognize,
- 23:00make an argument.
- 23:01So I'm,
- 23:02I'm about to.
- 23:02You don't have one,
- 23:03is that it?
- 23:04If you want,
- 23:04you wanna be insults,
- 23:05we can go for insults and I'm just,
- 23:06I'm about to,
- 23:06we can wrap.
- 23:07I'm about to wrap.
- 23:08Stop delaying my time.
- 23:09So it's important to recognize that a simply I condemn is
- 23:12not sufficient when the Republican Party has created a permission structure
- 23:15for individuals to go out and do violence against,
- 23:18I'm about to tell you with impunity.
- 23:19Immigration and Customs Enforcement is a good example.
- 23:21Trump administration.
- 23:22The Trump,
- 23:23they electoral process,
- 23:24you know,
- 23:24they lost in the courts 10,000 times,
- 23:26right?
- 23:26That's not true.
- 23:27It is true.
- 23:28But actually released a report on it.
- 23:29Yeah,
- 23:29they lost 10,000 times it would be like 1000.
- 23:31They murdered numerous American citizens,
- 23:33and guess what happened to the individuals that carried out those killings?
- 23:35What happened to them?
- 23:36What happened to them?
- 23:36Have they been prosecuted?
- 23:37Any
- 23:38investigations,
- 23:38do you know?
- 23:38I,
- 23:39I believe they have not.
- 23:40Why?
- 23:41It's almost as if when you commit violence,
- 23:43you're wrong,
- 23:43you're going to be protected.
- 23:45That's what's going on.
- 23:46That's why Christine No went out and said that Alex Freddy was a domestic terrorist.
- 23:49That's why Stephen Miller said the same thing,
- 23:50and everybody in the entire Republican Party
- 23:52apparatus is echoing those talking points,
- 23:54because whenever there's violence,
- 23:55they,
- 23:55they don't condemn it.
- 23:56They condone it.
- 23:57They,
- 23:57they congratulate it,
- 23:59and they pardon it.
- 23:59Law enforcement's duly elected by a by a population that voted in
- 24:03plurality for ICE to go out and engage in these behaviors citizens,
- 24:06which sometimes,
- 24:06yes,
- 24:07absolutely.
- 24:07And oh,
- 24:08they voted for ICE to kill American citizens,
- 24:10really?
- 24:10Yes.
- 24:12Do you,
- 24:12do you,
- 24:13do you,
- 24:13the,
- 24:13the average Republican,
- 24:14I don't think they're that who said the average Republican would vote,
- 24:16but do you not believe that there are people in
- 24:17this country that would vote for ICE to harm people?
- 24:20Is that your,
- 24:20is this your argument?
- 24:21Do you believe this is terrible.
- 24:23So you think not a single person in this country wants to harm illegal irrelevance.
- 24:26We're talking about the fact that there is
- 24:28a top-down approach by Republicans like Donald Trump.
- 24:30Can I ask you the question again?
- 24:32Can you?
- 24:32Can you answer the question and allow it to happen,
- 24:34foment violence in.
- 24:35Can you,
- 24:35can you answer you're running cover for it.
- 24:37Can you can you actually,
- 24:38you just did.
- 24:38No,
- 24:39I didn't.
- 24:39See,
- 24:39I'm,
- 24:40I'm pointing at ICE violence.
- 24:41You're saying that people vote for it or whatever.
- 24:43You don't think that there are white supremacists
- 24:44voting for ICE to go and harm migrants.
- 24:46Are you saying that white supremacists voted for
- 24:48Donald Trump so they could kill migrants?
- 24:49Yes,
- 24:50I am.
- 24:51OK,
- 24:51good to know that white supremacists make up part of
- 24:53the Republican Party and Donald Trump's doing their bidding.
- 24:55Yes,
- 24:55I,
- 24:56I,
- 24:56I certainly believe they do.
- 24:57OK.
- 24:58The initial claim that I'm making is that there is absolutely violence on the right.
- 25:01I already agree with one of the previous debaters
- 25:02that there's institutional violence from the right as well.
- 25:05The best argument against my.
- 25:07actually is that the right when they get levers of power,
- 25:09will use law enforcement
- 25:11as their as their vehicle for the violence that they want to engage in.
- 25:14Those things are all fair.
- 25:16My point is that we are not seeing a nice long drawn out concession.
- 25:18Thank you for,
- 25:19but it's not a concession because maybe,
- 25:21maybe we agree.
- 25:23Oh,
- 25:23OK.
- 25:24See,
- 25:24I,
- 25:24I,
- 25:24I think,
- 25:25didn't you say the modern political left
- 25:26commits more violence than modern political right?
- 25:27So now you're saying just because
- 25:29there are riots coming from the left does not mean they're morally right
- 25:33or wrong or does not mean the right is better or worse.
- 25:35This is a statement about volume of violence that
- 25:38we see and a meaningful issue to a voter
- 25:40as to what is the underlying motivation that we see pushing
- 25:44violence in this country.
- 25:45So when you have ICE going out and engaging in these actions,
- 25:48this is like a Clarence Thomas level of interpretation with that prompt.
- 25:51That is not what I,
- 25:52I,
- 25:52I don't know why you're trying so hard
- 25:53to disagree when we actually have common ground.
- 25:56Pause,
- 25:56we are out of time.
- 25:58Thank you.
- 26:06Nicotine,
- 26:07the ultimate biohacker's secret weapon,
- 26:09has made a wild comeback.
- 26:10But why is that clean lifestyle still fueled by big tobacco's chemical laden slop?
- 26:15For those who switch out LEDs for incandescence,
- 26:17source raw milk,
- 26:19and read every single label,
- 26:20it's time to stop compromising.
- 26:23Introducing
- 26:24Knick Knack,
- 26:25the nicotine solution that actually complements a clean routine.
- 26:28This family owned company
- 26:30manufactures a superior nicotine lozenge
- 26:33right here
- 26:34in the USA.
- 26:35Affectionately known as a lip brick,
- 26:37this fully dissolvable option is crafted with just 6 premium ingredients,
- 26:42including real essential oils for authentic flavor.
- 26:45There are no pH adjusters,
- 26:47no plastic pouches,
- 26:48and absolute.
- 26:50no waste.
- 26:51Available in 3
- 26:52and 6 mg strengths,
- 26:53this is nicotine perfected.
- 26:56Reject the compromise and raise the standard.
- 26:59Go to knickknack.com/surrounded and use code surrounded for 20% off
- 27:04or use the store locator to find knickknacks near you.
- 27:07Warning,
- 27:07this product contains nicotine.
- 27:09Nicotine is an addictive chemical.
- 27:12My next surrounded claim is that the Democratic Party
- 27:15has embraced authoritarianism.
- 27:17If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 27:18please get to the chair in 321.
- 27:24Uh,
- 27:25that was fast.
- 27:26Nice to meet you.
- 27:27Let's start off not by,
- 27:28oh God,
- 27:28don't make me defend Republicans,
- 27:30but let's,
- 27:30let's go.
- 27:30Let's go.
- 27:31All right,
- 27:31let's talk about authoritarianism.
- 27:33What does an authoritarian government do?
- 27:35So it's typically,
- 27:36and,
- 27:36and particularly in my claim,
- 27:37it's a reference to suppression of dissent,
- 27:39suppression of speech,
- 27:40uh,
- 27:41control of voting or manipulation of voting for the power,
- 27:44uh,
- 27:44uh,
- 27:44for the,
- 27:44uh,
- 27:46let's just call it,
- 27:46uh,
- 27:47control by a particular group of politically or claims one at a time,
- 27:50yeah,
- 27:51first on suppression of.
- 27:52Speech indeed just a few hours ago today,
- 27:55Trump subpoenaed reporters
- 27:56for trying to report accurate information on the war in Iran.
- 28:00He said no,
- 28:00that can't happen.
- 28:01Awful.
- 28:02That's way more authoritarian than what we're seeing on the left here.
- 28:05Well,
- 28:05I mean,
- 28:05if it's,
- 28:06it's hard to quantify what is more or less authoritarian,
- 28:08but certainly bad when when President Trump is trying to stifle speech.
- 28:12Wait,
- 28:12can you,
- 28:13do you want any example of Biden doing anything even comparable to that?
- 28:16I can.
- 28:16We can start with Alex Berenson,
- 28:18who is currently in a lawsuit because the Biden.
- 28:20Administration personally went to social media platforms
- 28:22using his name to be suspended
- 28:24for his reporting on COVID vaccination and and and mandates.
- 28:28OK,
- 28:29at a top level though,
- 28:30who's doing the majority of the like
- 28:33actual suppression of speech here?
- 28:34I,
- 28:34I,
- 28:35I don't really have good words for the Republican Party,
- 28:37to be honest.
- 28:37My,
- 28:37my,
- 28:38my issue with this debate is,
- 28:39is in fact what we're seeing right now is that
- 28:41I'll make a claim about the Democratic Party which has done awful things,
- 28:44and the immediate response is,
- 28:45but the Republicans,
- 28:46and I don't like Republicans.
- 28:47Here's the thing.
- 28:48We live in a two party system,
- 28:50right?
- 28:50We can have this great grift of like,
- 28:52oh
- 28:53well,
- 28:53the Democrats are bad,
- 28:55but we can,
- 28:56and the Republicans,
- 28:56they might be worse,
- 28:57but the Democrats are still bad.
- 28:59But the option is between Democrats and Republicans.
- 29:01So if Republicans are worse,
- 29:03it doesn't really matter if Democrats are slightly bad.
- 29:05But
- 29:07I think we don't love Democrats,
- 29:08but we feel that Republicans are way worse
- 29:11when they institute these far more authoritarian policies.
- 29:14It's,
- 29:14it's hard to quantify more.
- 29:16And the question is,
- 29:17does it suppress speech,
- 29:18and I certainly think Donald Trump has taken actions.
- 29:20There was a human,
- 29:21let's look at human lives.
- 29:22If we want to do like a quantification here,
- 29:24let's look at ICE.
- 29:253 American citizens have been killed by ICE.
- 29:28That's way more than the number of
- 29:30American citizens killed by immigration enforcement under,
- 29:32say,
- 29:32Obama,
- 29:33but it's way less than the amount of American citizens killed by Barack Obama.
- 29:36No,
- 29:37it is true.
- 29:38Yes,
- 29:38it is.
- 29:39OK.
- 29:40Well,
- 29:40look,
- 29:40look,
- 29:40I,
- 29:40I,
- 29:41I don't want to be disrespectful,
- 29:41but,
- 29:42um,
- 29:42one of,
- 29:42one of the biggest issues to me.
- 29:43The extrajudicial assassination of Abdul Rahman
- 29:45al-Awlaki by the Obama administration,
- 29:47and this is what early on in my life
- 29:50when I was very anti-war,
- 29:51very lefty,
- 29:51still anti-war,
- 29:52and voted for Barack Obama,
- 29:54and then he murdered in favor of the war in Iran.
- 29:56Absolutely not.
- 29:56And Barack Obama killed a sixteen-year-old American citizen
- 29:58who was at a civilian restaurant in Yemen.
- 30:00We can.
- 30:01These are all bad things.
- 30:02We can be like,
- 30:02oh well,
- 30:02both parties are pretty bad,
- 30:04but like we have to,
- 30:05when they go to the ballot office,
- 30:06when I go to the ballot office as a voter,
- 30:08I have to actually put in a vote.
- 30:10I have to decide Democrat.
- 30:11A Republican or throw my vote away and vote for some third party,
- 30:14libertarian.
- 30:16If I'm picking between those and there's one candidate
- 30:18who just brought us into a war in Iran,
- 30:20is causing this massive conflict,
- 30:22tons of human suffering,
- 30:23that's foreign.
- 30:24That's foreign policy.
- 30:25Domestically,
- 30:26we see ICE attacks on American citizens.
- 30:28We see 56 people dying in ICE detention camps in just a singular year.
- 30:33You compare that to under Obama,
- 30:35the deporter in chief.
- 30:36Across 8 years,
- 30:3752 people died.
- 30:39Way,
- 30:39way,
- 30:40way fewer.
- 30:41What we're seeing is dangerous conditions domestically.
- 30:43Way more people are dying,
- 30:45right?
- 30:45We have a lot of this like qualitative discussion.
- 30:47You bring up a lot of anecdotes,
- 30:49but if you actually like quantify the number of
- 30:51deaths that are occurring through these authoritarian mechanisms,
- 30:54it's very,
- 30:54very clear that when I vote,
- 30:56I'm choosing the lesser of two evils and voting Democrat.
- 30:58Let's talk,
- 30:59let's talk about a few structures of authoritarianism.
- 31:01Uh,
- 31:01we'll,
- 31:01we'll go with 2016,
- 31:03and you brought up Donald Trump subpoenaing these journalists,
- 31:05so we'll get,
- 31:06we'll get broad on this one.
- 31:07In 2016,
- 31:08Gizmodo published an article that Facebook had been,
- 31:10had been suppressing news and information from conservative outlets.
- 31:13This is Gizmodo.
- 31:14They're a progressive outlet.
- 31:14In fact,
- 31:15I worked for the company that owned them,
- 31:16and I,
- 31:17I was a Bernie supporter in 2016.
- 31:19And so agreeing with this reporting and knowing the reporters behind it,
- 31:22I reported this.
- 31:23NBC News,
- 31:24all of these major institutions then claimed
- 31:26I was a right-wing conspiracy theorist.
- 31:28Let me finish,
- 31:29for,
- 31:29for,
- 31:30for claiming that these things were happening that they reported on.
- 31:33Then what we learned is that
- 31:34under,
- 31:35under
- 31:35Obama,
- 31:36under Obama and under Biden,
- 31:37and don't get me wrong,
- 31:38this was under Trump as well,
- 31:39there was an active effort from the FBI.
- 31:41They,
- 31:41they were given a backdoor access to Twitter and Facebook
- 31:44to remove.
- 31:44Content that they thought objectionable to the government
- 31:47and it was not done at the behest of Trump or for his benefit,
- 31:50but to the benefit of those who had been defending him in the press.
- 31:53So notably myself,
- 31:54who was calling out these censorship practice
- 31:56practices.
- 31:57I was falsely slandered and maligned by the media over this.
- 32:00These are institutions.
- 32:01Now when you say that Donald Trump is mad at them,
- 32:03I agree subpoenaing journalists depending on the issue can be bad,
- 32:06but to see that from Obama
- 32:08through Trump and into Biden,
- 32:09they were.
- 32:10given access.
- 32:11This is a violation of the Fourth Amendment.
- 32:13It's a violation of the 1st Amendment.
- 32:14We're missing something really important.
- 32:16We're lumping together all of these different
- 32:18types of sort of suppression of speech,
- 32:20but there's a fundamental difference.
- 32:21When we see like left-leaning suppression of speech,
- 32:24often that happens from like a bottom up,
- 32:26where you see what I'm taking an action.
- 32:28No,
- 32:28I gave you a specific example of the Biden
- 32:30administration going to a major big tech company,
- 32:32giving them specific instructions to remove people who are saying not.
- 32:36We saw that in the context of COVID,
- 32:38where vaccinations was really,
- 32:39really important.
- 32:40In fact,
- 32:40800,000 lives were saved by vaccines.
- 32:43We have a really strong,
- 32:44you can give me every reason for why you want to be an authoritarian.
- 32:47They always have a reason,
- 32:48and saving lives is always wonderful.
- 32:49There's a fundamental difference between suppressing free speech on,
- 32:52say,
- 32:52the war in Iran,
- 32:53where there's really bad stuff going on and we need to talk about it,
- 32:56and say,
- 32:57spreading vaccine misinformation.
- 32:58In the US we've had really long moral versus.
- 33:01Differences of importance and that's fine.
- 33:03Clear and present danger test but we're
- 33:04talking about authoritarianism has many different reasons.
- 33:07Did you think
- 33:08that all the tyrants of the world never gave a reason as to why they,
- 33:11they needed absolute authority?
- 33:12They always did,
- 33:12and they always do.
- 33:13And even today it's the case whether it's Trump or anybody else.
- 33:16So when Biden's administration said,
- 33:18because COVID misinformation kills,
- 33:19we will silence you,
- 33:21that's authoritarianism.
- 33:22You can argue that you agree with it,
- 33:23but it still is authoritarianism.
- 33:25How about we can use Cuomo in New York as an example.
- 33:27He shut down churches in violation of the First Amendment,
- 33:30and when he was sued and lost,
- 33:32he issued a secondary executive order changing
- 33:34the words to keep the churches closed.
- 33:36That is authoritarianism.
- 33:38And you,
- 33:38you right now defending it is my point.
- 33:41I have no problem saying Trump should not go after journalists,
- 33:44but you seem to have a problem saying that the Democratic
- 33:46administrations should not be doing what they're doing as well.
- 33:48OK,
- 33:48pause,
- 33:49pause.
- 33:49You've been voted out by the majority.
- 33:51Please return to your seat.
- 33:52Yeah,
- 33:52yeah,
- 33:52yeah.
- 33:56If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 33:57please get to the chair in 321.
- 34:03Long distance from back.
- 34:04You made it.
- 34:05I'm surprised you made it.
- 34:07So one of the key parts about authoritarianism is influence over elections,
- 34:12and we've seen that throughout the history of right wing and left wing,
- 34:17the right wing
- 34:18side of this country has constantly been election deniers.
- 34:21Famously,
- 34:22Trump tried to find votes in Georgia to win the 2020 election,
- 34:26and now we're seeing that they're claiming voter fraud
- 34:28in the city of Los Angeles mayor's race.
- 34:30Well,
- 34:30can I ask you a question?
- 34:32Uh,
- 34:32how many,
- 34:32uh,
- 34:33uh,
- 34:33how many presidential elections in the last 20 years were denied by Democrats?
- 34:37Were denied by Democrats.
- 34:38Yes,
- 34:38but mainstream members of Congress going on the floor,
- 34:40rejecting it.
- 34:41None,
- 34:42all of them.
- 34:44Do you see the Democratic Party trying to create an alternate slate of electors
- 34:49to actually try and overturn a democratically elected,
- 34:52certainly a different argument,
- 34:53but no,
- 34:53that,
- 34:54that was in,
- 34:54uh,
- 34:54I,
- 34:54I think that would have been 1960,
- 34:56but.
- 34:57Certainly not in the last 20 years.
- 34:58So,
- 34:59uh,
- 34:59we can completely agree Trump's efforts in 2020 were substantially different
- 35:03from,
- 35:03say,
- 35:04a handful of members of Congress and high profile
- 35:06personalities coming out and saying the election is illegitimate.
- 35:08But I will say,
- 35:09while it is not particularly mainstream,
- 35:11there,
- 35:11there actively are groups across social media
- 35:13that believe the election was stolen,
- 35:14just go on threads for for a few minutes.
- 35:16threads.
- 35:17You will see tons of.
- 35:18Progressives arguing the election was stolen.
- 35:20Tons of bots,
- 35:21you know,
- 35:21I'm really,
- 35:22you don't think the internet,
- 35:23theory.
- 35:24I agree with the
- 35:25theory actually.
- 35:25So,
- 35:26so look,
- 35:26but,
- 35:26but,
- 35:27so then if you're talking about the right or to the left overall again,
- 35:29we are talking about the overall picture here.
- 35:32Where is the majority of this coming from?
- 35:33Well,
- 35:33let me,
- 35:33let me ask you a question.
- 35:34You mentioned California.
- 35:36Uh,
- 35:36I wanna ask you a question.
- 35:37Uh,
- 35:38let's,
- 35:38let's say there's an election that takes place
- 35:40and a ballot comes in 3 days after that election.
- 35:43It's signed with a picture of Mickey Mouse,
- 35:45and it's hand dated.
- 35:46Do you think that is a real vote?
- 35:48So guess what?
- 35:49In California,
- 35:49when you don't have a correct signature,
- 35:51you can do this thing called ballot hearing,
- 35:53where you take that ballot back to the voter and you say,
- 35:55is this really you?
- 35:56And you have to get that signature again.
- 35:57And that.
- 35:58I don't think they registered with the Mickey Mouse signature.
- 36:00Well,
- 36:00that's actually legal in California.
- 36:02In fact,
- 36:02the,
- 36:02the example given,
- 36:03I think,
- 36:04in Santa Barbara is a Kirby Starr image.
- 36:06Now the challenge,
- 36:07uh,
- 36:07with this is,
- 36:08and,
- 36:08and that's why I'm not a fan of the fraud argument from Republicans.
- 36:11I just stop,
- 36:11stop saying fraud.
- 36:12This is legal in California.
- 36:14In California,
- 36:14you can draw a picture of Kirby Starr in any manifestation.
- 36:17Now the problem is signatures are supposed to
- 36:19be unique to an individual because they're,
- 36:20they're,
- 36:21they would be falsifiable,
- 36:22meaning I've never seen your signature before.
- 36:24How can I match it?
- 36:25But if you sign,
- 36:26uh,
- 36:26if you sign up,
- 36:27if register to vote with a picture of Kirby,
- 36:29anyone in the world can draw the picture of Kirby.
- 36:31So in California,
- 36:32the challenge that I,
- 36:33not everybody has the same name,
- 36:34the same Social Security.
- 36:35I know,
- 36:36but the point is,
- 36:37if a ballot is received by a homeless shelter,
- 36:39anyone can fill it out and draw a picture of Kirby Starr.
- 36:42So there's a limited number of ballots that get sent to registered
- 36:44voters who are registered with the state and universal mail-in voting.
- 36:48And for instance,
- 36:48there was a homeless shelter in Venice Beach that
- 36:50received 185 mail-in votes despite no one living there.
- 36:52And so yes,
- 36:53because people that live on the street have addresses registered
- 36:55to shelters completely don't have anywhere else to get mail.
- 36:57And so what we've already seen is undercover video
- 37:00showing that activists do go to places like Skid Row
- 37:03and secure a voter registration
- 37:05where in one video,
- 37:06a man who's clearly not a woman says his name is Teresa.
- 37:09Sure,
- 37:09he'll fill it out.
- 37:10Now the problem is that man will fill this out under the name Teresa.
- 37:13He will sign,
- 37:14he'll put an X,
- 37:15a mark,
- 37:15which is legal in California.
- 37:16The other issue is that.
- 37:18Ballots can be received,
- 37:19so it,
- 37:20it gets complicated,
- 37:21but in California,
- 37:22if a ballot is received before the election,
- 37:24it can be hand dated.
- 37:25If it's received after the election,
- 37:26it has to be postdated.
- 37:28However,
- 37:28a ballot can only be rejected if two independent
- 37:31independent officials can prove beyond a reasonable doubt
- 37:33it has violated one of these tenants.
- 37:35So I do take issue with Republicans saying voter fraud,
- 37:37voter fraud all the time when it's legal to do this in California.
- 37:41But I think if you go to a regular,
- 37:42a regular American and say.
- 37:43You ask him this question,
- 37:44and I'll ask you this question.
- 37:45How did Nitia Raman surpass Karen Bass,
- 37:47both Democrats in mail-in votes only after Election Day?
- 37:50Because
- 37:51young people vote later and Nita Raman won the young vote.
- 37:53Well,
- 37:54the,
- 37:54the,
- 37:54the truth is that the DSA on their website advocates for ballot harvesting,
- 37:57which is legal,
- 37:57and they're allowed to do it,
- 37:58and
- 37:59more power to them.
- 38:00It's very smart.
- 38:00So do the Republicans.
- 38:01They go to security to senior centers all
- 38:03across the country and we're gonna pause here.
- 38:05You've been voted out by the majority.
- 38:07Good talking with you.
- 38:11If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 38:12please get to the chair in 321.
- 38:18No contest
- 38:19likewise
- 38:20elections as you were talking about the other person before,
- 38:22I think are sacred.
- 38:23I think elections are sacred
- 38:25and I believe that they are the most fundamental thing
- 38:29to American values and democracy.
- 38:31We have never seen.
- 38:33Ever in American history,
- 38:34the attempt to subvert a free and fair election
- 38:37compared to how Donald Trump and his cronies did on January 6th,
- 38:41and I think that it's absolutely ridiculous to claim
- 38:44that that is somehow comparable
- 38:46to the Biden administration,
- 38:48uh,
- 38:48talking to Facebook and certain social media platforms to ban Donald Trump.
- 38:52When
- 38:53social media platforms have been under attack by Donald Trump as well,
- 38:56we had in Florida how the right now chair of the RNC was,
- 39:00is now,
- 39:01uh,
- 39:01pursuing
- 39:02legal action
- 39:04against,
- 39:05uh,
- 39:05Facebook,
- 39:06Twitter,
- 39:06etc.
- 39:07for banning Donald Trump,
- 39:08which was a decision that they made.
- 39:11Without Biden's interference,
- 39:13well,
- 39:13I,
- 39:13I don't think,
- 39:14I don't think arguing like a civil litigation is a,
- 39:16it's,
- 39:16it's hard to,
- 39:17it's hard to argue civil litigation as a big political issue.
- 39:19If,
- 39:19if there was,
- 39:20if there was a contract violation committed by a company and Trump wants to sue them.
- 39:23Certainly if you have the opinion,
- 39:24you don't believe that there's,
- 39:26you believe there's malice there's the current RNC chair,
- 39:29right,
- 39:29right,
- 39:29right.
- 39:29My,
- 39:29my,
- 39:30my argument is pursuing like regulatory action against them
- 39:33for banning Donald Trump,
- 39:34right?
- 39:35So,
- 39:35so these are civil issues
- 39:36and the challenge is,
- 39:37I don't know the facts.
- 39:38You don't know the facts.
- 39:39You don't think civil issues can be political.
- 39:41They certainly can,
- 39:42but the point I'm making is that
- 39:44sometimes companies do bad things and we need regulatory bodies to go after them.
- 39:47I'm I'm in favor of that.
- 39:48Now the question is,
- 39:49are the Republicans bad for doing it?
- 39:50Honestly,
- 39:51I don't know because I don't know the underlying issues of the case.
- 39:53Maybe they are,
- 39:53maybe they're not.
- 39:54So I'll bring up another instance.
- 39:55I mean,
- 39:55in Massachusetts,
- 39:56for example,
- 39:57we just had two Republicans who were
- 39:59running for Attorney General and lieutenant governor
- 40:01who were literally faking signatures on their ballots up,
- 40:05literal dead people lock them who,
- 40:07and,
- 40:07and if you look at the papers,
- 40:09they're the same signature.
- 40:10Down the ballot,
- 40:11it's the same person this uh out this uh third party that they hired who was literally
- 40:17didn't have the same exact handwriting
- 40:20and they,
- 40:20they tried like to lock them up
- 40:22thousands of signatures across Massachusetts were
- 40:25then considered moot because they were
- 40:26literal dead people from all across the state and those are two Republicans
- 40:31and you have,
- 40:31I mean,
- 40:32there are countless instances of Republicans,
- 40:34not.
- 40:34Donald Trump
- 40:35trying to subvert American elections,
- 40:37and I think that is one of the most authoritarian things that anybody
- 40:41in this country can do is to subvert the free and fair elections.
- 40:44United States,
- 40:45I think certainly that we have a problem with
- 40:47two,
- 40:49ancient political parties.
- 40:50I think the real,
- 40:51the real big picture is here,
- 40:52and I'm not,
- 40:52and I'm not saying this to dismiss your,
- 40:54uh,
- 40:54your,
- 40:54your,
- 40:55your,
- 40:55your anger over what these Republicans did.
- 40:56That's,
- 40:57you're certainly warranted to believe that.
- 40:58Uh,
- 40:58I agree.
- 40:59I think they should go to jail for that stuff.
- 41:00The problem is both political parties are playing this,
- 41:03this procedural game of trying to steal elections through the pop procedure
- 41:07instead of convincing people.
- 41:07The Republicans are redistricting in all of these different
- 41:10states to give themselves January 6th was procedure.
- 41:13I'm not,
- 41:13I'm,
- 41:13I'm,
- 41:14I'm talking right now about
- 41:15both parties and,
- 41:16yeah,
- 41:16certainly January 6th was a riot and it was very,
- 41:18very bad.
- 41:18You,
- 41:19we can,
- 41:19we can,
- 41:19we can agree on those things.
- 41:20I'm saying that both parties have these procedural efforts to increase their,
- 41:23their ability to win elections.
- 41:25Right now.
- 41:25Republicans are redistricting.
- 41:26I fundamentally disagree with that because Republicans were the ones that voted
- 41:29against a bill to ban gerrymandering federally in the United States.
- 41:34Republicans were the ones that continuously deny the fact that
- 41:37Joe Biden won the 2020 election free and fair.
- 41:40Democrats have not.
- 41:41Once and have been,
- 41:42they have been very consistent on this,
- 41:44on protecting American elections.
- 41:46It's in our name.
- 41:47Democrats in 2016 accused Donald Trump and his associates of being Russian assets
- 41:51and trying to steal the election at the pest of a foreign adversary,
- 41:54going so far to accuse the President of the United States of treason.
- 41:57There was a multi-year investigation that cost tens of
- 41:59millions of dollars that ended up being nothing.
- 42:01That's election denial.
- 42:02Now I don't think that's as bad as a bunch of people storming the Capitol.
- 42:04That's terrifying and substantially worse,
- 42:07physical violence.
- 42:08But
- 42:08yeah,
- 42:08I think if you look.
- 42:09Back at the history of this country going back decades,
- 42:11it would be a bit naive to say that
- 42:13the political parties aren't doing everything in
- 42:15their power to steal power from each other
- 42:17again,
- 42:17so I mean we can,
- 42:18I don't want to pivot to Mueller,
- 42:20um,
- 42:20which in fact also,
- 42:21also when
- 42:23when Mueller,
- 42:24when Mueller passed away,
- 42:25rest in peace,
- 42:25an American hero,
- 42:26uh,
- 42:27he,
- 42:27Donald Trump literally said,
- 42:29I'm glad he's dead and he no longer can hurt innocent people.
- 42:32I know.
- 42:32So like,
- 42:33again,
- 42:33another instance of Republicans,
- 42:35I would consider threats against people like that.
- 42:37Throw him out there.
- 42:38When he said that,
- 42:38I said it was disgusting.
- 42:39I mean,
- 42:39it's horrifying.
- 42:40But it doesn't,
- 42:41doesn't change the fact that Bernie Sanders,
- 42:43Bernie Sanders had the election taken away from him illicitly.
- 42:46I think,
- 42:46uh,
- 42:47in 2016,
- 42:48I was fervent for Bernie.
- 42:49He was talking about securing borders because the Koch brothers,
- 42:52industrialists,
- 42:52wanted to bring in cheap labor.
- 42:54He was talking about getting better wages for the working class,
- 42:56supporting unions,
- 42:57and I said this is the only guy who's been speaking to issues for the past 20 years
- 43:00that actually matter to the right to working class American people.
- 43:03And what did the Democratic,
- 43:04absolutely,
- 43:04and what did the Democratic Party do?
- 43:06They use superdelegates to make sure he could not win.
- 43:08OK,
- 43:09so first off,
- 43:09I actually,
- 43:10I'm,
- 43:10I'm a big fan of Bernie myself.
- 43:11So I guess it's something you could agree on there.
- 43:13I will say that if you,
- 43:14you as a supporter of Donald Trump,
- 43:16I find it kind of ironic that you
- 43:17believe in anything closely related to Bernie Sanders.
- 43:20I'll give you a few examples.
- 43:219 million people who are Democrats voted for Donald Trump in 2016.
- 43:24Yeah,
- 43:25and,
- 43:25and
- 43:25I also say
- 43:273 million,
- 43:27like millions of people,
- 43:28I think it was a couple million in West Virginia,
- 43:31uh,
- 43:31your state that voted for Bernie Sanders in the primary.
- 43:34Then had to switch to Donald Trump.
- 43:35I criticize my own party for that,
- 43:37and I think that that was wrong.
- 43:38My point is not,
- 43:39my point is not that the Democratic Party has never,
- 43:42ever,
- 43:43ever
- 43:43used something or participated,
- 43:45I would say,
- 43:46in bad faith in elections.
- 43:47My point is that we see consistently from Republicans,
- 43:51like consistently over and over again,
- 43:54again,
- 43:54I think that that's like the both parties are all bad.
- 43:56You literally had Donald Trump try to subvert the election.
- 43:59You've been voted out by the majority.
- 44:01Good talking with you,
- 44:01man.
- 44:02Good.
- 44:06If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 44:07please head to the chair in 321.
- 44:13Nice to meet you.
- 44:14Nice to meet you.
- 44:14Thanks for coming.
- 44:15Appreciate it.
- 44:15So
- 44:16yeah,
- 44:16you're not gonna have me defending the Democratic Party.
- 44:18I mean,
- 44:18let's go.
- 44:19I feel like a lot of people,
- 44:20yeah,
- 44:20and I don't wanna defend Republicans moving towards,
- 44:23uh,
- 44:23fascism on both sides.
- 44:25Uh,
- 44:25I do want to bring up two unique things
- 44:27that Trump has done that no one has ever done in United States history.
- 44:31So two is suing a pollster for a poll he didn't like in the state of Idaho.
- 44:35And I think the biggest issue is the Israel issue.
- 44:37So you have someone like Trump who,
- 44:39you know,
- 44:39sold TikTok to Larry Ellison,
- 44:41and he also owns CBS News.
- 44:45He also entirely,
- 44:46right?
- 44:46I think we both agree that's just not good where you give
- 44:49someone a media apparatus,
- 44:51you know,
- 44:51and a social media apparatus like TikTok,
- 44:53um.
- 44:54I,
- 44:55I,
- 44:55I,
- 44:55uh,
- 44:56I,
- 44:56these things worry me for sure,
- 44:58um,
- 44:58I,
- 44:59you know,
- 44:59I think,
- 44:59I think where we're gonna agree with like Democrat and Republicans is,
- 45:02uh,
- 45:02the issue of Israel particularly
- 45:04that,
- 45:04that,
- 45:04that
- 45:05if we're talking about authoritarianism,
- 45:06this is why I say like don't make me defend Republicans.
- 45:08Like there's some things I will,
- 45:09but,
- 45:09but the Democratic Party and the Republican Party,
- 45:11I,
- 45:12I feel like as an establishment
- 45:14largely aligned with each other and then there are these like lesser issues that,
- 45:17that,
- 45:18that divide,
- 45:19and I think,
- 45:19uh.
- 45:20When you look at uh TikTok,
- 45:22when you look,
- 45:22I,
- 45:22I,
- 45:22I,
- 45:23I'll tell you this,
- 45:23the,
- 45:24the TikTok was sold
- 45:25explicitly because of Israel.
- 45:28The,
- 45:28uh,
- 45:28so the story is this,
- 45:29um,
- 45:30initially Republicans were very mad about TikTok because
- 45:32it seemed to promote progressive uh content,
- 45:34progressive ideology.
- 45:36Republicans had been banned.
- 45:37People supporting Trump had been banned.
- 45:38So the Republicans come out and say we got ban TikTok.
- 45:40We,
- 45:40we can't do this.
- 45:41Democrats said no,
- 45:43but then something changed after October 7th,
- 45:45we saw the rise of
- 45:47conduct critical of Israel and supportive of Palestine.
- 45:49All of a sudden the Democrats are like,
- 45:51you know what,
- 45:51now we agree with Republicans and we've got to ban TikTok.
- 45:54And then Trump comes out and says no,
- 45:55no,
- 45:55we're not gonna ban it,
- 45:56which he does not have the authority to do.
- 45:58The bill was passed.
- 45:59It was signed by the president.
- 46:00When Trump came in office,
- 46:01he was supposed to initiate that ban,
- 46:02but instead,
- 46:03what did he do?
- 46:04He sold it to a supporter of his
- 46:05to change the structure of that content to benefit
- 46:08his worldview,
- 46:09which does align largely with many establishment Democrats.
- 46:12Yeah,
- 46:12I agree,
- 46:13and you know,
- 46:13you have him sanctioning the ICC,
- 46:15the prosecutors.
- 46:17I mean this is the fascism we're talking about
- 46:19so when you have you know Russia and China that
- 46:22don't wanna participate in the the Western system this is why
- 46:25then you have France you know that's.
- 46:28That's trying to get away from the tech companies because
- 46:31our own politicians in those uh uh that legislation.
- 46:35Uh,
- 46:35they put that they were,
- 46:36um,
- 46:37that any country that has these databases will,
- 46:39will be forced to give the data to them.
- 46:40I think,
- 46:41so I think if,
- 46:42if it's not a singular issue of Donald Trump,
- 46:44like,
- 46:44clearly the Democratic Party joined in,
- 46:46in the,
- 46:46in the cheering on of the banning of TikTok because of his content.
- 46:49And so I think that just shows that we've got an authoritarian problem in this,
- 46:54you know,
- 46:54elite circle of
- 46:55whatever the military industrial complex or,
- 46:57or big banks and all of these,
- 46:58you know,
- 46:59wealthy groups,
- 47:00they're,
- 47:00they're interested in similar things.
- 47:02No,
- 47:02yeah,
- 47:02I agree,
- 47:03but we're gonna pause here.
- 47:04You've been voted out by the majority.
- 47:06Well,
- 47:06we got,
- 47:06we got a little bit.
- 47:07Nice meeting you.
- 47:11If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 47:13please get to the chair in 321.
- 47:19Nice to meet you.
- 47:20Gotta say I'm not a fan of either party,
- 47:21to be honest,
- 47:22same boat as you on that one.
- 47:26the left embracing authoritarianism.
- 47:28Right now that they don't have the House,
- 47:30they don't have the Senate,
- 47:31they don't have the White House,
- 47:32they don't have a majority
- 47:34in the Supreme Court.
- 47:35If these guys are authoritarian,
- 47:36they're the crappest authoritarians I've ever seen.
- 47:38They gotta go back to authoritarian school and learn how to be authoritarians.
- 47:41Well,
- 47:42or how to win,
- 47:43right?
- 47:43Losing,
- 47:44you can still be an authoritarian,
- 47:45like Nazis lose power,
- 47:46but they're still Nazis.
- 47:47Well,
- 47:47they're losing,
- 47:47they're losing at all levels,
- 47:48they're losing everywhere.
- 47:49I,
- 47:49yeah,
- 47:50yeah,
- 47:50the the Republicans crushed them,
- 47:51and I think doesn't mean they're authoritarians though.
- 47:53Well,
- 47:53no,
- 47:53I mean you can be an authoritarian and lose,
- 47:55right?
- 47:56OK,
- 47:56so there's 3 actual elements that we need
- 47:59to talk about authoritarianism.
- 48:00One is dismantling of institutions.
- 48:02One is eliminating your opponent
- 48:04and suspending elections.
- 48:05Those are,
- 48:05those are very specific claims to some authoritarians.
- 48:08I haven't seen elements,
- 48:10those elements present within the left at all.
- 48:12Donald Trump was arrested several times with except with the exception of one
- 48:16that was the eliminating opposition.
- 48:18I did see it,
- 48:19but it was when,
- 48:19when they arrested Donald Trump several times and then tried to get a.
- 48:22They,
- 48:22they filed a suit to the Supreme Court
- 48:24to get Trump banned from being able to run.
- 48:26I don't remember that,
- 48:27but I do remember you don't remember that guy at a rally going,
- 48:29the 14th Amendment her up,
- 48:30lock her up.
- 48:31Who is that person again?
- 48:32I forget.
- 48:33All right,
- 48:33it was the same guy who weaponized the DOJ against all his
- 48:36political opponents or deployed the National Guard to beat down our protesters,
- 48:40deployed to terrorize families and tear apart communities,
- 48:43or launched the Save Act to try and
- 48:46just
- 48:46put voter suppression tactics in place so we could steal.
- 48:48An election,
- 48:49imprison protesters for 10 years for marching down the streets.
- 48:52I think tell the Proud Boys to stand back and stand by.
- 48:55I'm ready to mobilize you to launch another insurrection.
- 48:58Let's go.
- 48:58Oh like a soapbox.
- 48:59Who is that guy again?
- 49:00I forgot.
- 49:01If you'd like a soapbox,
- 49:02we can set one up for you.
- 49:03But if you want to have a conversation,
- 49:04I'm sitting right here.
- 49:05Go for it.
- 49:05I think the position is indefensible,
- 49:06but I'd love to hear your take.
- 49:07Go for it.
- 49:08Well,
- 49:08you're allowed to not like Trump.
- 49:09He's done a lot of bad things.
- 49:10Thank you.
- 49:10Now we're talking about the Democratic Party,
- 49:12the things they've done,
- 49:12and you've,
- 49:13I think.
- 49:14And I'm not saying this derisively,
- 49:15but I think there's many things that you're
- 49:16ignorant of the Democratic Party has done.
- 49:18You talk about suppression of their political opponent.
- 49:19Well,
- 49:20yeah,
- 49:20they sued so that Trump could not run for office.
- 49:22They,
- 49:23they
- 49:23tried to claim he was an insurrectionist.
- 49:24He was ineligible.
- 49:25He was arrested several times.
- 49:27They arrested his lawyers.
- 49:28Now,
- 49:29by all means,
- 49:30every authoritarian makes the argument they're justified in their use
- 49:33of of authoritarian tactics to remove their political opponents.
- 49:36That doesn't change the idea,
- 49:38or I should say the philosophy behind what they're doing.
- 49:40So if You want to accuse Jenna Ellis,
- 49:42for instance,
- 49:42of doing something wrong because she drafted a letter arguing on Trump's behalf.
- 49:46That's,
- 49:46that's authoritarianism.
- 49:47By all means you can say she was wrong to do it.
- 49:49She's a criminal,
- 49:50but we are seeing
- 49:51when you start going after people's lawyers,
- 49:53by all means tell me you think she's a criminal and deserves it,
- 49:56and I will tell you
- 49:57the people of this country now stand in fear that Democrats
- 50:00are going to arrest them if they engage in illegal practices.
- 50:02We're going to pause here.
- 50:03We are out of time
- 50:06at home.
- 50:10My next surrounding claim
- 50:12is that the United States is tracking towards a civil war.
- 50:15If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 50:16please head to the chair in 321.
- 50:23Welcome back.
- 50:25You miss me.
- 50:26So
- 50:27listen,
- 50:27I,
- 50:27I think that we are getting closer towards,
- 50:29uh,
- 50:29a a peak of civil unrest in this country,
- 50:31and in all honesty,
- 50:32I'm gonna blame people like you.
- 50:33This entire time you've been trying to blur the line between what
- 50:36separates you and a person like me and everybody in the circle.
- 50:39The truth is you don't agree
- 50:40on your show.
- 50:41You have 5 white supremacists around you and 1 liberal,
- 50:43uh,
- 50:43lawyer talking about why we should protect the Constitution on Twitter.
- 50:46You're mentioning the civil war and why we need to have a civil war,
- 50:49civil war 24/7.
- 50:50Now you've said civil war numerous times.
- 50:54Slates of screenshots over the last 4 years alone I'm not
- 50:57talking about shooting ivermectin up your ass all the time.
- 51:00I've never advocating for ivermectin.
- 51:02It's,
- 51:02you have literally no idea what you're talking about.
- 51:04You've not done any research and you've never used Google.
- 51:06I've never advocated for ivermectin,
- 51:08not once.
- 51:08He's not gonna stop.
- 51:09I've never used it.
- 51:10I've never used iver.
- 51:11I,
- 51:11I said no,
- 51:12you shouldn't use it.
- 51:12I'm gonna get to if you wanna make things
- 51:15up,
- 51:15you wanna,
- 51:16you wanna just waste time,
- 51:16then we can waste time.
- 51:17But if you haven't.
- 51:18You're wasting time right now.
- 51:19Yeah,
- 51:19so if I'm about to give it to you agree with me on the issue,
- 51:20but you don't like me,
- 51:21then we can agree and you can.
- 51:22No,
- 51:22I think you're responsible.
- 51:23I think you're responsible.
- 51:24You can get an individual like your man.
- 51:25If you,
- 51:25you just don't want to finish,
- 51:26you know where I'm gonna go with this.
- 51:27Do you agree?
- 51:28You,
- 51:28you,
- 51:28you so mistrust you're allowed to blame me all you want,
- 51:31and then we can agree and you can leave.
- 51:33You just want to run away from the conversation.
- 51:34Are you here to dispute my claim or agree with it?
- 51:36I think you're responsible.
- 51:37That's fantastic.
- 51:37Thank you and have a nice day.
- 51:38Oh,
- 51:38you don't want to hear why you're responsible.
- 51:39It doesn't matter because you're here to dispute my claims,
- 51:41right?
- 51:41Not agree doesn't matter.
- 51:42You don't.
- 51:42All of a sudden you want to stick to the definition of your claims,
- 51:44but when it comes to just about everything,
- 51:45everything else you wanna agree with me and you.
- 51:47You're not gonna stop talking,
- 51:48are you?
- 51:48Are you,
- 51:48are you gonna sit here and agree with me you control yourself?
- 51:49You're like 50 years old.
- 51:50You're gonna calm down with me.
- 51:51Calm down.
- 51:52You come down.
- 51:52I don't agree with you.
- 51:53I disagree with you on everything.
- 51:54You make fake claims.
- 51:55Of course I do.
- 51:55If if anybody's doing something that I don't actually believe
- 51:57in it because you're getting paid by other country,
- 51:59I argue you're Joe Rogan for adversaries,
- 52:01bro.
- 52:01I advocated on Joe Rogan's show,
- 52:04David,
- 52:05can you please address the claim?
- 52:07I think America is getting closer to civil war
- 52:09and it's all because of people like Timple.
- 52:10Thank you for agreeing with me.
- 52:11Have a nice day.
- 52:11Yeah,
- 52:11you're a coward,
- 52:12bro.
- 52:13Well,
- 52:13if you don't agree with me,
- 52:14I don't know why you're here.
- 52:15Also,
- 52:16I would recommend doing research before you apply you come to a place like this.
- 52:19If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 52:20please head to the chair in 321.
- 52:26Welcome back.
- 52:27Good to see you again.
- 52:28Great to see you again.
- 52:29Yeah,
- 52:30um,
- 52:30the first time you talked about this was in 2019,
- 52:32so it's been quite a while.
- 52:33I think it was before that calling for civil war.
- 52:35I've never called for civil war,
- 52:36or not calling for,
- 52:37I'm sorry,
- 52:37uh,
- 52:37said that we're on the brink of,
- 52:39of civil war.
- 52:39And what was the citation I had for when I said that?
- 52:41I would love you.
- 52:42It was The Atlantic,
- 52:43and it was a journalist who interviewed several national security experts who said
- 52:47that there is a range of opinions in the national security
- 52:49space that the US is trending towards a civil war,
- 52:51notably.
- 52:52That when you,
- 52:53when you cite people like Stephen Marsh,
- 52:54journalist,
- 52:54as well as Barbara F.
- 52:55Walter,
- 52:55former CIA,
- 52:56the US academics describe the period that we're in as civil strife,
- 53:00meaning
- 53:01there's a,
- 53:02there's a criteria of death that has occurred
- 53:04for political reasons over the past year or years
- 53:06for which the next phase would be civil war.
- 53:09However,
- 53:10tracking,
- 53:10we'll make my point,
- 53:11tracking towards it,
- 53:12uh,
- 53:12I,
- 53:12I've not said that it will happen.
- 53:15Although there have been many people who have said that we are
- 53:17in a cold civil war or some kind of cultural civil war,
- 53:19I always,
- 53:21always caveat because I,
- 53:22I don't actually have a strong prediction that acts,
- 53:25first of all,
- 53:26you do have a strong prediction if you've been saying this since 2019.
- 53:28There's 40 articles about it people can look this up.
- 53:30There's 42 of your titles that have the.
- 53:32Word civil war in it with big fonts on the front.
- 53:35They sure do.
- 53:35So why is that?
- 53:36It's sensationalist.
- 53:37It's easy to get clicks on that.
- 53:38There's a reason why you say it because it's very profitable for your business.
- 53:42But there's a,
- 53:42we have 1600 episodes of just IRL.
- 53:46There comes a point where people stop taking your predictions seriously.
- 53:49Are you gonna make an argument,
- 53:50or are you mad at me?
- 53:51I'm not mad at you.
- 53:51OK,
- 53:52then,
- 53:52let's make an argument about whether or not we are tracking.
- 53:54No,
- 53:54no,
- 53:54no,
- 53:54no,
- 53:54no,
- 53:55no,
- 53:55no,
- 53:55no,
- 53:55no.
- 53:55If you're making an argument you don't like my thumbnails or you don't,
- 53:58you should I say my name over and over I'm
- 54:00saying that you say bullshit in order to get money.
- 54:02But what,
- 54:02let me ask you,
- 54:03let me ask you a question predictions.
- 54:04Let me ask you,
- 54:04let me ask you a question.
- 54:05You can.
- 54:05I will agree with you that there's increased polarization.
- 54:07I,
- 54:08I would attribute a lot of that to people being specifically online.
- 54:10Let me ask,
- 54:11uh,
- 54:11there's a lot less interaction with people that are,
- 54:13are in different camps.
- 54:14Let me ask you.
- 54:14Question,
- 54:15you're gonna sit here and tell me that we're way
- 54:17more polarized than Alexander Ham Hamilton and Aaron Burr,
- 54:21who like shot each other with their disagreements.
- 54:23You're gonna why was that Aaron Andrew Jackson,
- 54:24who's the sitting president,
- 54:25do you wanna have a conversation,
- 54:26or are you just gonna be?
- 54:28Why was Aaron Danielson shot the shot in the chest twice?
- 54:30Sorry,
- 54:31why was Aaron Danielson shot in the chest,
- 54:32uh,
- 54:33I the chest twice disagreeing that political violence is taking the place.
- 54:36You say Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr,
- 54:38but.
- 54:38When I ask you a question about an assassination,
- 54:40you,
- 54:40you,
- 54:40you,
- 54:41you,
- 54:41you,
- 54:41you defer where you can say that.
- 54:43Let me ask you a question war every fucking year and it doesn't happen and I never,
- 54:46it just hasn't happened yet.
- 54:47Let me ask you.
- 54:47Or if it does happen,
- 54:48you say,
- 54:48see,
- 54:49I've had it all.
- 54:49Let me ask you a question you're the same thing as like the Christian rapture
- 54:52people who say that the rapture's coming every
- 54:54fucking year and when it doesn't happen,
- 54:55do you want a soapbox?
- 54:56Do you want me to get you a soapbox?
- 54:57It's really I can leave.
- 54:58You want me,
- 54:58it's really easy to like do what you do.
- 55:00It's really easy to do what you do.
- 55:02Like you literally just say
- 55:04the Civil War is happening next year.
- 55:07Civil war is happening next year,
- 55:08it's coming.
- 55:08Make sure you subscribe to Timcast.
- 55:10Continue to watch my videos,
- 55:12please.
- 55:12Follow us on YouTube,
- 55:13follow us on Instagram.
- 55:14It's,
- 55:15it's easy to do what you do,
- 55:16bro.
- 55:17Well,
- 55:18we're gonna have.
- 55:20So for your uh.
- 55:23Tim,
- 55:23thank you for returning.
- 55:26No one's actually had a debate yet.
- 55:28Are we going to actually talk about whether it will or will not happen?
- 55:30I mean,
- 55:31sounds like it's gonna.
- 55:33All right,
- 55:34if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 55:35please head to the chair in 321.
- 55:42Welcome.
- 55:43Nice to meet you.
- 55:43Hey,
- 55:44nice to meet you.
- 55:45I think we are
- 55:46being constantly fueled
- 55:48by the people that are already in charge,
- 55:50that are up on top,
- 55:51that are already wealthy
- 55:53and that already have power over the entire government.
- 55:56Donald Trump has
- 55:578 billionaires in his administration,
- 55:59including himself.
- 56:01You see his sons profiting,
- 56:02you see his friends profiting,
- 56:03you see everyone in close ties with him profiting.
- 56:06OK,
- 56:07they're not gonna give up this power.
- 56:08I don't think we're on the verge of a civil war.
- 56:11I think we're due for a revolution.
- 56:12Well,
- 56:12and I don't,
- 56:13I hope that's peaceful.
- 56:14I hope that's not violent.
- 56:15I hope
- 56:16we change.
- 56:17This is fantastic.
- 56:18No,
- 56:18no,
- 56:18no,
- 56:18I appreciate this.
- 56:19Can I ask you some questions?
- 56:19Yeah.
- 56:20Do you believe that Donald,
- 56:21and I'm,
- 56:21I'm not trying to accuse you of believing this,
- 56:22but do you think that Donald Trump is a fascist?
- 56:25Um,
- 56:26yes,
- 56:26I do.
- 56:26Do you,
- 56:27do you think that there are Nazis in his,
- 56:29in his administration,
- 56:29in his administration,
- 56:31do you,
- 56:31do you think that,
- 56:32uh,
- 56:32they,
- 56:33uh,
- 56:33I mean,
- 56:34how do you feel about them using the military to go after,
- 56:36uh,
- 56:37undocumented migrants in this country?
- 56:39I think it is an unnecessary use of force when we should be targeting
- 56:43violent criminals that have come into this country illegally illegally.
- 56:47That should be the sole focus when 70% of detainees in ICE custody
- 56:51do not have a criminal conviction.
- 56:53We're wasting resources and trying to use a show of militaristic power,
- 56:57which is a huge,
- 56:58huge proponent of fascism.
- 57:00Uh,
- 57:01how do you feel about the death of,
- 57:02uh,
- 57:02Renee Good and,
- 57:03and Alex Predi?
- 57:03Unjustified.
- 57:04Are you gonna do anything about it?
- 57:07I'm gonna rally everyone here.
- 57:08I'm is rallying going to stop murder?
- 57:10I,
- 57:10I don't do this.
- 57:11Is rallying gonna stop the killing of annoy my few 100
- 57:14friends and followers on my Instagram post by reposting news stories.
- 57:17Do you think rallying will stop the killing of people?
- 57:19What I'm doing here now
- 57:20is trying to show people that they need to speak up,
- 57:23that we're not against each other,
- 57:24right and left.
- 57:25Do you believe speaking up will stop ICE from killing people?
- 57:27I think speaking up will get us to the right.
- 57:29Process of voting people in the midterms
- 57:32and in the next election
- 57:33so that we can make changes the constitutional way.
- 57:36How many people do you think will die between now and then?
- 57:38Too many.
- 57:39There's already been too many people that have died.
- 57:41So my,
- 57:41my,
- 57:42again,
- 57:42this is largely based off,
- 57:43I,
- 57:43I don't know if it's,
- 57:44so are you trying to incite a civil war?
- 57:46No.
- 57:46Do you want a civil war?
- 57:47I'm asking what do you actually believe do you want to do against ICE?
- 57:51I like ICE
- 57:52and you're happy that they're killing people.
- 57:54No,
- 57:54OK,
- 57:55so what are you gonna do?
- 57:56I'm gonna vote for Trump again.
- 57:58He's the one that's allowing guys to kill people.
- 57:59He's not voting for JD Vance,
- 58:01as I just said,
- 58:01he's the one not taking accountability.
- 58:03See,
- 58:03I,
- 58:04see,
- 58:04I,
- 58:04I think there's a distinction here.
- 58:05For one,
- 58:05the claim is meant to be like nonpartisan,
- 58:08but I have,
- 58:09of course,
- 58:09my partisan views.
- 58:10I like the Trump administration though they've done a lot of bad things,
- 58:13and that's fine,
- 58:13and we can call it those bad things,
- 58:15but I'm going to continue to support it.
- 58:16My point largely is either
- 58:18the progressives will stand up against what they
- 58:20perceive as fascism or fascism takes over,
- 58:22which they are by all means we just had the
- 58:24largest protest in the history of the United States.
- 58:26We're gonna pause here.
- 58:28Thank you.
- 58:29You've been by the majority.
- 58:32If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 58:34please head to the chair in 321.
- 58:40OK,
- 58:40so the whole thing about civil war
- 58:42is that I do think that you need some sort of leadership,
- 58:46you know,
- 58:46that is being financially disenfranchised to incentivize a civil war,
- 58:50and we don't really have any strong progressive leaders in office currently
- 58:55that are being meaningfully financially disenfranchised,
- 58:58um,
- 58:59the way slavers were.
- 59:00So I think that you don't,
- 59:02that's the challenge,
- 59:02I think.
- 59:03That is absolutely,
- 59:04yes,
- 59:04that is you don't if you take a look at civil wars throughout history,
- 59:06we can use the Syrian civil war as an example.
- 59:08It started with a dozen or so disparate factions,
- 59:10largely of locals
- 59:12and various ideologies that ultimately coalesced around 11 group,
- 59:15either the Free Syrian Army,
- 59:17but then ultimately got taken over.
- 59:18So civil wars can be fomented through small factions that bubble up.
- 59:22Certainly,
- 59:22but I,
- 59:23I think that you are vastly overestimating the uh.
- 59:27You know,
- 59:27kind of militant,
- 59:29uh,
- 59:29capacity of the American left
- 59:32like we truly do not have
- 59:34like a far left in the US that would be willing to take up arms.
- 59:38It is so,
- 59:39so,
- 59:39so small.
- 59:40Furthermore,
- 59:41I do think that
- 59:43technology wise
- 59:44it's not,
- 59:45you know,
- 59:45it's,
- 59:46it's not an even battle anymore
- 59:48like
- 59:48the military,
- 59:49the US military,
- 59:50which is largely conservative and currently,
- 59:52you know,
- 59:52uh,
- 59:52Trump is in charge of them.
- 59:54Uh,
- 59:55the,
- 59:55the technology that they have to track,
- 59:58surveil,
- 59:59to,
- 59:59uh,
- 1:00:00remotely kill people
- 1:00:01would be absurd.
- 1:00:02I mean,
- 1:00:02I guess we could do some sort of guerrilla warfare,
- 1:00:05but this is American territory.
- 1:00:06It wouldn't go down like Vietnam,
- 1:00:07you know,
- 1:00:07like we know where we are,
- 1:00:08we know where we're going.
- 1:00:09It's just this is actually,
- 1:00:10this is a fantastic point,
- 1:00:11by the way,
- 1:00:11and this gets into what's known as the generations.
- 1:00:14Warfare.
- 1:00:15So the earliest generation of warfare,
- 1:00:16obviously is a guy punching a guy
- 1:00:18as we got into,
- 1:00:19uh,
- 1:00:19you know,
- 1:00:20the 1700s,
- 1:00:20well,
- 1:00:21maybe even before then,
- 1:00:22you get field battles and drums and trumpets and this,
- 1:00:24they,
- 1:00:24they,
- 1:00:25they refer to this largely as like 3rd generation.
- 1:00:264th generation is what they refer to as insurgency,
- 1:00:29terror,
- 1:00:29guerrilla warfare tactics which we saw
- 1:00:31famously people bring up during the American Revolution.
- 1:00:34Many people refer to the period we're now in as 5th generational warfare,
- 1:00:37and the,
- 1:00:37the question is,
- 1:00:38what is the purpose of conflict?
- 1:00:39And it's to typically,
- 1:00:41not always,
- 1:00:41but to gain control of resources or a political group.
- 1:00:44Usually it's to gain control of something,
- 1:00:46and it could be for ideological reasons or economic reasons.
- 1:00:49What we're witnessing now,
- 1:00:50which what I,
- 1:00:50I would say maybe we're not going to have a
- 1:00:52what's called a hot civil war but remain cold,
- 1:00:55is the use of information technology for the
- 1:00:56purpose of controlling populations like you've described.
- 1:00:59So
- 1:00:59for the,
- 1:01:00in the broader picture.
- 1:01:01I would argue that what we are seeing now
- 1:01:02with TikTok and Instagram may actually stop kinetic conflict,
- 1:01:06which would be people shooting each other,
- 1:01:08and we may actually just end up with people being brainwashed and,
- 1:01:10you know,
- 1:01:11waving Israeli flags or something.
- 1:01:12Well,
- 1:01:12I mean,
- 1:01:12we're,
- 1:01:13we're already kind of there.
- 1:01:14I mean,
- 1:01:14like
- 1:01:15Peter Thiel and Elon Musk are,
- 1:01:16you know,
- 1:01:17the two most powerful tech dudes,
- 1:01:18and even Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos to some degree,
- 1:01:21they're in Trump's pocket or maybe Trump is in theirs,
- 1:01:24um,
- 1:01:25and
- 1:01:25there's just.
- 1:01:27You know,
- 1:01:27online there really isn't a way for the left to meaningfully take control,
- 1:01:32not in a,
- 1:01:32a real sense.
- 1:01:34I just,
- 1:01:35I think that yes,
- 1:01:36the country will continue to get polarized,
- 1:01:37but will we have a civil war?
- 1:01:40No.
- 1:01:40pause here.
- 1:01:41Thank you.
- 1:01:42You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:01:43good thank you.
- 1:01:47Alright,
- 1:01:48if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:01:49please head to the chair in 321.
- 1:01:55Hello
- 1:01:57When January 6th happened,
- 1:02:00I actually thought we were headed towards the Civil war then I thought,
- 1:02:03oh my God,
- 1:02:04this is really
- 1:02:05bad
- 1:02:06and um,
- 1:02:07so much so that what ended up happening is that gun sales
- 1:02:12increased
- 1:02:13predominantly on the left because
- 1:02:15they were so afraid of what was gonna.
- 1:02:17Happen
- 1:02:18and we had been seeing documentaries and
- 1:02:21um you know news networks talking about the far right extremists who
- 1:02:25were already training with like AR fifteens and things like that that were
- 1:02:29attempting to
- 1:02:30potentially start a coup
- 1:02:32and so
- 1:02:33if we were talking back then I would actually agree with you.
- 1:02:37The reason I disagree with you now
- 1:02:39is because we don't have a um a faction of the left
- 1:02:46that is nearly as uh violently motivated as the right is
- 1:02:52so
- 1:02:52if we were to talk about a hypothetical civil war,
- 1:02:55then I would argue the far right would start it specifically because of what.
- 1:03:00You just said you said
- 1:03:01that you would like to re-elect Trump,
- 1:03:03that you would vote for him
- 1:03:05for a third
- 1:03:06time,
- 1:03:07but you didn't say Vance,
- 1:03:08you said Trump,
- 1:03:08right?
- 1:03:09And I think,
- 1:03:10and I think
- 1:03:11that goes down to the ideology of
- 1:03:14again your argument around the Constitution.
- 1:03:17He,
- 1:03:18there is a faction of MAGA that wants him to run again.
- 1:03:22And skirt the constitution so that MAGA can stay in power.
- 1:03:27I think
- 1:03:28in a hypothetical
- 1:03:30that would lead towards a civil war
- 1:03:32and so,
- 1:03:33OK,
- 1:03:34but people like yourself who continue to spew this type of rhetoric of
- 1:03:38is it gonna happen?
- 1:03:39Is it gonna happen?
- 1:03:40I think you're want it to happen.
- 1:03:42I think you're exaggerating the,
- 1:03:43the things that I've said about it.
- 1:03:44I mean,
- 1:03:44I think that last conversation was absolutely fantastic everything
- 1:03:46that you talked about is online and people,
- 1:03:48so I think,
- 1:03:48I think,
- 1:03:49I think I've interviewed national security experts to ask
- 1:03:51them if they think this is going to happen
- 1:03:53when you have one gentleman saying yes and it's my fault.
- 1:03:56I,
- 1:03:56I,
- 1:03:57he doesn't have to like me.
- 1:03:57You don't have to like my opinions or what I do.
- 1:03:59But I think when you also say that
- 1:04:01when MAGA wants to elect Trump for a 3rd time,
- 1:04:04you are correct,
- 1:04:04they do.
- 1:04:04And I,
- 1:04:05I also agree this is going to create an untenable situation for the country
- 1:04:08that I don't believe progressives or Democrats will accept.
- 1:04:11I don't see Trump and his base backing down,
- 1:04:13and I don't see the,
- 1:04:15the,
- 1:04:15the left,
- 1:04:15liberals,
- 1:04:16Democrats,
- 1:04:16or otherwise
- 1:04:17agreeing to back down.
- 1:04:17It's a simple question.
- 1:04:19Would anyone in this room sit back as Trump
- 1:04:21seized a third term in power?
- 1:04:23They,
- 1:04:23I don't think they would do it.
- 1:04:25So you,
- 1:04:25you,
- 1:04:25you can have a fascist takeover,
- 1:04:27a revolution,
- 1:04:28or you can have a civil war if this is the case,
- 1:04:29and I hope to God it's not,
- 1:04:31because you know what I'd prefer?
- 1:04:32I'd prefer to watch the,
- 1:04:33the,
- 1:04:33the,
- 1:04:33the soccer match and have some chicken wings.
- 1:04:35I don't,
- 1:04:35I don't wanna
- 1:04:36deal with conflict crisis.
- 1:04:37I don't like having to live in a,
- 1:04:39you know,
- 1:04:39I have multiple bodyguards with me today.
- 1:04:41I have to,
- 1:04:42I,
- 1:04:42I have to have people standing outside of my house because we got,
- 1:04:44I got you scared of the progressives in here?
- 1:04:46I'm not scared of anybody in here actually.
- 1:04:47I think you guys have been absolutely lovely,
- 1:04:49but there are lunatics.
- 1:04:50In December of last year,
- 1:04:51someone drove by my property and opened fire on,
- 1:04:54on,
- 1:04:54on our buildings,
- 1:04:55and I,
- 1:04:55I,
- 1:04:56you're gonna blame that on the left too.
- 1:04:57I'm,
- 1:04:57it was a left aligned.
- 1:04:58Individual who did it,
- 1:04:59but I mean,
- 1:05:00I'm not blaming you guys for doing it,
- 1:05:02and I certainly would acknowledge that there are people on
- 1:05:03the right who engage in violence all the same.
- 1:05:05What I'm saying is I don't want you to be in fear,
- 1:05:07uh,
- 1:05:07in fear of your life.
- 1:05:09I don't want to be in fear of my life.
- 1:05:10I prefer this.
- 1:05:11This is you guys have been absolutely awesome.
- 1:05:12We disagree.
- 1:05:13I mean that guy really hates me,
- 1:05:14but I got,
- 1:05:14I don't want him hurt or anything like that.
- 1:05:16I don't want to live in a country where people
- 1:05:17are attacking each other without trying to understand each other,
- 1:05:20right,
- 1:05:20but the rhetoric that you're spewing is leading towards that.
- 1:05:23You want Trump again,
- 1:05:26which means the rhetoric that you're spewing online,
- 1:05:28the political commentary that you're spewing online,
- 1:05:31is teasing it.
- 1:05:32It's like it's like,
- 1:05:33will they,
- 1:05:34won't they,
- 1:05:34will they,
- 1:05:34won't they?
- 1:05:35I don't want.
- 1:05:35Donald Trump for a third term,
- 1:05:37but I,
- 1:05:37I would,
- 1:05:37I,
- 1:05:38I would prefer,
- 1:05:38uh,
- 1:05:39you know,
- 1:05:39JD Vance,
- 1:05:40maybe Rubio,
- 1:05:41but
- 1:05:43and indeed,
- 1:05:43and understand that Trump won the plurality of the vote in 2024 and
- 1:05:47he has a large support base despite his polls being very low.
- 1:05:49He does,
- 1:05:50and we'll see what happens with the Republican Party in 2026 and 20208.
- 1:05:54But you can't just
- 1:05:56wish away the existence of a polar of a of a another political faction
- 1:06:00with a polarized worldview compared to yours.
- 1:06:02I do not see a reality
- 1:06:04where Republicans accept the worldview of the of the
- 1:06:06progressives who are gaining ground in multiple places,
- 1:06:09namely in New York,
- 1:06:10and I don't see the progressives accepting
- 1:06:12the,
- 1:06:12the,
- 1:06:12the Trump worldview as you've described it.
- 1:06:14And the reason that we're not going to accept it is because people
- 1:06:18like you and the reason we don't accept it is people like it.
- 1:06:23If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:06:24please head to the chair in 321.
- 1:06:30Nice to meet you.
- 1:06:30Nice to meet you,
- 1:06:31Jeremiah.
- 1:06:32OK,
- 1:06:33so we know that the USA is very resilient,
- 1:06:35right?
- 1:06:36We've weathered so much.
- 1:06:37So we've weathered,
- 1:06:38we've stayed in,
- 1:06:39we've stayed intact,
- 1:06:40and we weathered,
- 1:06:41um,
- 1:06:411968 riots,
- 1:06:43McCarthyism.
- 1:06:44Um,
- 1:06:45what else?
- 1:06:46Civil rights era,
- 1:06:47um,
- 1:06:48civil war,
- 1:06:49so,
- 1:06:50but the thing is we stayed intact,
- 1:06:51right?
- 1:06:52So
- 1:06:53my thing is,
- 1:06:54is that
- 1:06:55we can have polarizing views,
- 1:06:56right,
- 1:06:57but
- 1:06:58nothing that we're dealing with right now is as
- 1:07:00intense as anything we've that I've just mentioned,
- 1:07:02and none of those things led to a civil war,
- 1:07:04so I'm.
- 1:07:05Unless the right plans to enslave the left,
- 1:07:07where,
- 1:07:08how are we gonna have a civil war?
- 1:07:09So one example that I often cite,
- 1:07:10which I don't know that,
- 1:07:11you know,
- 1:07:12a,
- 1:07:12a lot of this is probabilistic,
- 1:07:13uh,
- 1:07:14I,
- 1:07:14I like to use Colorado as an example.
- 1:07:16Colorado allows for abortion up to the point of birth,
- 1:07:18the woman's discretion,
- 1:07:19but Oklahoma bans it,
- 1:07:20and they share a border.
- 1:07:21So you have a potential for conflict in that regard because if a woman is with a man.
- 1:07:25And she's 7 or 8 months pregnant and she decides
- 1:07:28to get an abortion in Colorado where it's legal,
- 1:07:30the state will try to stop her.
- 1:07:31We have already had an instance where I'm not sure it was a Southern state,
- 1:07:33it might have been Mississippi or Alabama where they accused,
- 1:07:35they,
- 1:07:35they charged,
- 1:07:36I believe they attempted to charge a woman
- 1:07:38with conspiracy to commit abortion by fleeing the state.
- 1:07:40And so the issue that arises is at the ground level when a man says.
- 1:07:44You are taking my child to be murdered and the woman says,
- 1:07:47no,
- 1:07:47it's a,
- 1:07:47it's,
- 1:07:47it's a fetus.
- 1:07:48I'm getting an abortion,
- 1:07:49and this results in people on the ground
- 1:07:51traveling between jurisdictions with different laws,
- 1:07:54which creates a problem for Colorado and a problem
- 1:07:56for Oklahoma which probably don't want to fight.
- 1:07:58So but what I'm saying is that if,
- 1:07:59if you,
- 1:08:00you're saying the nation would fight,
- 1:08:01we don't even see internal fights within the states,
- 1:08:04like separate states.
- 1:08:05I would think that we would see that first before we'd see the nation.
- 1:08:08Well,
- 1:08:08we saw in Texas when the Biden administration deployed uh federal,
- 1:08:12federal police and the Texas National Guard came and they
- 1:08:15were actually in dispute over the concertina wire on the border
- 1:08:18because Texas doesn't have the constitutional authority to deport.
- 1:08:20They sent out their state National Guard in defiance and we
- 1:08:23of the federal overreach here in California when Trump did that,
- 1:08:26um,
- 1:08:27overreaching sending the Marines.
- 1:08:28But guess what?
- 1:08:29But the thing is military hasn't defected.
- 1:08:31The claim is that we are tracking towards one,
- 1:08:33and I think that's an academic claim,
- 1:08:35but it's also possible we have a revolution tracking,
- 1:08:37tracking like in 1100 years,
- 1:08:39like,
- 1:08:39no,
- 1:08:39no,
- 1:08:40no,
- 1:08:40tracking means that what we have seen over the past 10 years
- 1:08:43historically runs parallel to other stories that have
- 1:08:45culminated in civil war but don't always.
- 1:08:47So that's why academics say today's period in
- 1:08:49the United States is called civil strife.
- 1:08:50the civil,
- 1:08:51the civil rights era was civil strife as well.
- 1:08:52We're gonna pause here.
- 1:08:53I think you've been voted out in the majority.
- 1:08:59If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:09:01please head to the chair in 321.
- 1:09:06Welcome.
- 1:09:06Hi,
- 1:09:07nice jacket.
- 1:09:07Hi,
- 1:09:07thank you.
- 1:09:09When you say that the US is heading towards civil war,
- 1:09:11um,
- 1:09:11I fundamentally disagree with this claim because I think
- 1:09:13that for any country to go through civil war,
- 1:09:153 key things need to happen.
- 1:09:16The first is geographic fracture.
- 1:09:18The second is the military defecting,
- 1:09:21and the third is institutional collapse,
- 1:09:23none of which we see in the United States.
- 1:09:24Well,
- 1:09:24let,
- 1:09:24let's address the claim number 1.
- 1:09:26We actually have seen massive internal migration from,
- 1:09:28uh,
- 1:09:29blue states to red states and red states to blue states.
- 1:09:31So the geographic hyper polarization absolutely is happening.
- 1:09:33I didn't say polarization.
- 1:09:34I said geographic fracture.
- 1:09:35There are plenty,
- 1:09:36there are plenty of blue cities in red states,
- 1:09:39so where's the fracture?
- 1:09:40Has anybody,
- 1:09:41has,
- 1:09:41has any,
- 1:09:41has any state tried to secede?
- 1:09:43There have been,
- 1:09:44there have been instances of states trying to secede from themselves,
- 1:09:46not really,
- 1:09:47no.
- 1:09:47What,
- 1:09:47what you are in,
- 1:09:48in eastern,
- 1:09:48which states are trying to secede?
- 1:09:49Northern California is trying to secede.
- 1:09:50You've got Eastern Oregon trying to secede.
- 1:09:52No,
- 1:09:52no,
- 1:09:52no.
- 1:09:52You've got,
- 1:09:52you got,
- 1:09:53you got a district what I'm what I mean,
- 1:09:54what I mean secede is not,
- 1:09:55are people wanting it to happen.
- 1:09:57Is there a little bit of a movement going on?
- 1:09:58Is there mass voting for a state to secede?
- 1:10:00No,
- 1:10:00there's not.
- 1:10:00The state of Jefferson,
- 1:10:01are you familiar?
- 1:10:02No,
- 1:10:02there's and greater Idaho.
- 1:10:03Did it happen?
- 1:10:03They,
- 1:10:04they're,
- 1:10:04they're,
- 1:10:04it doesn't happen.
- 1:10:05I believe we had 2 counties.
- 1:10:06Hold on,
- 1:10:07hold on.
- 1:10:07If you don't know this,
- 1:10:08don't just say you don't.
- 1:10:09Eastern Oregon had 2 counties voting to secede from the state to join Idaho.
- 1:10:12Did it happen?
- 1:10:13It,
- 1:10:13it did not.
- 1:10:14It does not happen,
- 1:10:14no,
- 1:10:15because,
- 1:10:15but whether it did or didn't happen in the in this country,
- 1:10:17people trying to make it happen.
- 1:10:18We're extremely polarized in this.
- 1:10:20Maryland tried to secede geographic fraction.
- 1:10:21Western Maryland voted to join West Virginia.
- 1:10:24People tried.
- 1:10:24People tried.
- 1:10:25It doesn't happen.
- 1:10:26I understand.
- 1:10:26I think a lot of people
- 1:10:28look at American history and,
- 1:10:29and then believe all civil wars happen in this context.
- 1:10:31But in fact,
- 1:10:32the United States is unique in this regard
- 1:10:34and that we are,
- 1:10:34we are,
- 1:10:35we were,
- 1:10:35we were positioned for civil war
- 1:10:37because.
- 1:10:37You had state jurisdictions with
- 1:10:40great authority that were in defiance of the federal government.
- 1:10:42You,
- 1:10:43you use this rhetoric a lot and it's very,
- 1:10:44very dangerous to use this rhetoric because it gets
- 1:10:46people up in arms and gets people rallied up.
- 1:10:48This kind of rhetoric is the same kind of rhetoric
- 1:10:49that Donald Trump uses to rally up right-wing conservatives.
- 1:10:51This is so dangerous that there are only
- 1:10:53two possibilities for why somebody would say this.
- 1:10:55Either they're blatantly exaggerating and grifting for money,
- 1:10:58or,
- 1:10:59or
- 1:11:00they genuinely believe what they say and they don't.
- 1:11:02Know,
- 1:11:02and they don't give their audience the 20 seconds of
- 1:11:04respect on Google it would take to learn otherwise.
- 1:11:06The US is not heading toward a civil war.
- 1:11:08There's clearly more than what's happening.
- 1:11:11There's clearly more than 2
- 1:11:13reasons why someone would say these things,
- 1:11:15there's not.
- 1:11:15And,
- 1:11:15and,
- 1:11:16and that's being intentionally derisive and not and not informing anybody.
- 1:11:19It's,
- 1:11:19it's the truth because we're not heading towards a civil war.
- 1:11:21I'm telling you pause it here.
- 1:11:22We're out of time.
- 1:11:24All right.
- 1:11:24Well,
- 1:11:24it was good talking to you.
- 1:11:25Nice to meet you.
- 1:11:31My final surrounding claim
- 1:11:32is that the Constitution effectively does not exist anymore.
- 1:11:36If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:11:37please head to the chair in 321.
- 1:11:43Nice to meet you.
- 1:11:44Nice to meet you.
- 1:11:44Doing well,
- 1:11:45going well.
- 1:11:45So
- 1:11:46what is the purpose of the claim?
- 1:11:48So,
- 1:11:49uh,
- 1:11:49the first question is what is a constitution.
- 1:11:51The constitution,
- 1:11:52it,
- 1:11:52it actually refers to what constitutes a body politic.
- 1:11:55As of right now,
- 1:11:56I would make the argument that first,
- 1:11:57what is known to most people,
- 1:11:59the interpretation of the Constitution dramatically has
- 1:12:01changed over the past several 100 years,
- 1:12:03not just with amendments,
- 1:12:04but with the language itself.
- 1:12:05Though
- 1:12:05many people might argue they're originalists,
- 1:12:08some might say they're textualists,
- 1:12:09it doesn't even matter if they claim those things
- 1:12:11because their view of the Constitution has changed.
- 1:12:12As of today,
- 1:12:13there's actually two distinct large body politics,
- 1:12:16if that's the way you say it.
- 1:12:17And they do not agree
- 1:12:19on the interpretation of the Constitution.
- 1:12:20Thus
- 1:12:21we are seeing claims the Supreme Court is no longer legitimate.
- 1:12:24We've seen that for some time now.
- 1:12:25We've seen,
- 1:12:26we see Republicans angry with Amy Coney Barrett and,
- 1:12:28uh,
- 1:12:28and Kavanaugh over their rulings,
- 1:12:30and we're now hearing,
- 1:12:31uh,
- 1:12:31uh,
- 1:12:32arguments that politicians should just ignore the
- 1:12:34Constitution outright or or the Supreme Court.
- 1:12:36I'm sorry,
- 1:12:36in this capacity,
- 1:12:37even though this would violate the Constitution.
- 1:12:39But that wouldn't necessarily work because if
- 1:12:41the founding fathers were creating the document,
- 1:12:43they knew that this was going to continuously progress because they believe.
- 1:12:46In the modernization of the United States
- 1:12:48that was going to continuously go forward.
- 1:12:50That's why you had Lincoln making the Reconstruction
- 1:12:52era amendments and even the progressive era amendments
- 1:12:54like the 16th Amendment with the income tax,
- 1:12:56the 17th Amendment.
- 1:12:57We're not arguing amendments,
- 1:12:58but what I'm saying is,
- 1:12:59is that the Constitution has always been able to progress and change.
- 1:13:02If you're looking for the issues when it comes to the Supreme Court
- 1:13:05and what everybody else believes,
- 1:13:06that happens on the left and on the right.
- 1:13:08Everyone has the disagreements when it comes to the Supreme Court,
- 1:13:10but the problem is when you look at the Trump administration,
- 1:13:13what they're currently doing right now is making.
- 1:13:15Executive orders saying that they're going to ask
- 1:13:18questions about the 14th Amendment when the reality
- 1:13:19is that he wanted to change the first section of the 14th Amendment to his own.
- 1:13:23Is anyone stopping him.
- 1:13:24Uh,
- 1:13:24the Supreme Court did actually.
- 1:13:26Not only did the Supreme Court stop them,
- 1:13:28uh,
- 1:13:28initially,
- 1:13:29that's what
- 1:13:30he was promised.
- 1:13:31He was,
- 1:13:31he was hoping did not have happened.
- 1:13:33That's why he was sitting in April
- 1:13:34with the Supreme Court trying to be basically
- 1:13:36the muscle of the executive in the judicial.
- 1:13:38So,
- 1:13:38so,
- 1:13:39so Trump,
- 1:13:39Trump hasn't stopped.
- 1:13:40In fact,
- 1:13:40they're preparing another executive order
- 1:13:42under the same,
- 1:13:43same line that was.
- 1:13:44Just rejected but targeting territories.
- 1:13:45But then you would agree with that the fault then would be coming from the
- 1:13:47political right then in this case because when it's not a question of fault,
- 1:13:50it's a question of we are not seeing
- 1:13:52the,
- 1:13:53the,
- 1:13:53but my point largely is
- 1:13:54there is a left and there's a right in this country that are
- 1:13:56so more they are so distinct neither views the Constitution as being upheld.
- 1:14:00But that's not necessarily true when you look at it,
- 1:14:02it is true.
- 1:14:03Well,
- 1:14:03well,
- 1:14:03I'll explain to you as the reason as to why it's not.
- 1:14:05You think Trump's upholding the Constitution.
- 1:14:06I don't think he's upholding the Constitution,
- 1:14:08but I know for a fact that the left has been or the Democrats have been
- 1:14:10actually holding up the Constitution a lot more.
- 1:14:12If you look at.
- 1:14:13For example,
- 1:14:13well,
- 1:14:13if you look,
- 1:14:14for example,
- 1:14:14with Bush,
- 1:14:16do you think Republicans believe the Democrats are upholding the Constitution?
- 1:14:18Do I think that the Republicans are holding it?
- 1:14:19Do Republicans in this country believe Democrats
- 1:14:21are holding true to the Constitution?
- 1:14:22They don't,
- 1:14:23but that's because that's the point.
- 1:14:24There is no unified body politic that operates under the Constitution.
- 1:14:27That's specifically opinion base.
- 1:14:28When you look at,
- 1:14:29well,
- 1:14:30hold on,
- 1:14:30when you look at different
- 1:14:31members and,
- 1:14:32uh,
- 1:14:32different
- 1:14:32presidential
- 1:14:33terms,
- 1:14:34you look at Trump,
- 1:14:35he's trying to take it down with the 14th Amendment through executive orders.
- 1:14:37The AUMF under Bush,
- 1:14:39he took away the ability for the Congress to actually.
- 1:14:41Player war with that simple,
- 1:14:43simple document because of September 11th.
- 1:14:45I haven't seen Obama do that.
- 1:14:46I haven't seen Biden try and do that whatsoever,
- 1:14:49especially when it comes to the past 20 years.
- 1:14:51The reason as to why we're in those situations is because of these two presidents.
- 1:14:54Now what my argument is,
- 1:14:55is that while they may say individuals may say this,
- 1:14:58what we're seeing is actual executive powers,
- 1:15:01exec exact legislative powers,
- 1:15:03actual judicial powers on the right that are specifically doing this.
- 1:15:06I pause.
- 1:15:08You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:15:09Good talking with you.
- 1:15:09Good talking with you too.
- 1:15:14If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:15:16please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:15:23How's it going?
- 1:15:23Nice to meet you.
- 1:15:24Um,
- 1:15:24an issue I kind of take with your interpretation of
- 1:15:26the Constitution is that you're kind of like taking this originalist
- 1:15:29approach to the Constitution and that every single word
- 1:15:31in the Constitution should be taken as literal.
- 1:15:33No,
- 1:15:33I'm not.
- 1:15:33So what,
- 1:15:34what,
- 1:15:34what do you mean essentially by like,
- 1:15:36so,
- 1:15:36uh,
- 1:15:36uh,
- 1:15:36uh,
- 1:15:36so the,
- 1:15:37the founding fathers,
- 1:15:38uh,
- 1:15:38it was a split between the Federalists and the Anti-Federalists.
- 1:15:40There was an argument as to whether we.
- 1:15:41We should,
- 1:15:42we should have an unwritten constitution
- 1:15:44or a written constitution.
- 1:15:45There was a fear that with an unwritten constitution,
- 1:15:47it would evolve too dramatically and you'd end up with tyranny.
- 1:15:50So,
- 1:15:50uh,
- 1:15:51one faction says,
- 1:15:52hey guys,
- 1:15:52write it down.
- 1:15:53In fact,
- 1:15:53they wanted not just a constitution,
- 1:15:54they wanted a bill of rights.
- 1:15:56So the,
- 1:15:56the argument is fundamentally a constitution
- 1:15:59is what constitutes the body politic.
- 1:16:01When you have a group of people that are largely morally aligned,
- 1:16:04they all basically agree,
- 1:16:05then you have a constitution.
- 1:16:07We are seeing an increase in,
- 1:16:08uh,
- 1:16:08geographic polarization.
- 1:16:10This is resulting in,
- 1:16:11uh,
- 1:16:11the Congress becoming equally polarized with
- 1:16:14radically different views of what the.
- 1:16:17Actually means so our Congress is very,
- 1:16:19very,
- 1:16:19very centered,
- 1:16:20right?
- 1:16:20Our Congress is very much in the political center.
- 1:16:22So to say that they're very these radical figures,
- 1:16:24I think it's,
- 1:16:25it's strikingly ironic.
- 1:16:25Well,
- 1:16:26no,
- 1:16:26they're,
- 1:16:26they're polarized,
- 1:16:27right?
- 1:16:27They vote on party line almost all the time,
- 1:16:29even when it doesn't make sense.
- 1:16:30And if you don't,
- 1:16:30Trump gets you removed from office like Massey.
- 1:16:33So,
- 1:16:33so that's polarization,
- 1:16:34right?
- 1:16:35So they're gonna vote for the agenda of the right or the agenda of the left,
- 1:16:38and I think that this way to explain it is.
- 1:16:41The amendments are the easiest way to approach this in understanding that the,
- 1:16:44the Constitution being largely in my view non-existent is
- 1:16:47the suppression of speech that we
- 1:16:48saw from Democratic Party administration officials.
- 1:16:51So that violates the First Amendment.
- 1:16:52You,
- 1:16:52you have to admit though,
- 1:16:53like the First Amendment doesn't mean that you can say whatever you want.
- 1:16:55Like it certainly means you can express political opinions,
- 1:16:57but it has continually targeted.
- 1:16:58It has continually,
- 1:16:59like our,
- 1:17:00our judges and our Supreme Court has continually
- 1:17:01ruled that there are limitations on free speech.
- 1:17:03I I can't,
- 1:17:04I can't scream that there's a fire in a movie.
- 1:17:06Yes,
- 1:17:06you can,
- 1:17:06Brandenburg v.
- 1:17:07Ohio.
- 1:17:07You're wrong.
- 1:17:09Like,
- 1:17:09like,
- 1:17:09there,
- 1:17:10there needs to be a precedent already.
- 1:17:12Like that doesn't,
- 1:17:12that doesn't really,
- 1:17:13there has to be a threat of imminent danger.
- 1:17:15That's not,
- 1:17:15yes,
- 1:17:16that's,
- 1:17:16that's true.
- 1:17:17You have to do that.
- 1:17:17Nice meeting you.
- 1:17:20If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:17:21please head to the chair
- 1:17:22in 321.
- 1:17:26Welcome back.
- 1:17:28Shake your hand again.
- 1:17:30All right,
- 1:17:30you're telling me that the Constitution effectively doesn't exist,
- 1:17:34right?
- 1:17:35Not that it's necessarily like low quality,
- 1:17:37but that it like effectively just does not exist at all.
- 1:17:39Well,
- 1:17:40let's not be super extreme.
- 1:17:40What I mean is
- 1:17:42there's obviously a document we know what it is,
- 1:17:43we use it for certain guiding principles.
- 1:17:45To the power that our parties want.
- 1:17:47My specific argument here is that the Constitution,
- 1:17:49whether or not it's being handled in like exactly the right way,
- 1:17:52it does exist.
- 1:17:54It's an important matter,
- 1:17:55then great.
- 1:17:56The thing is,
- 1:17:56I don't know what your personal views is.
- 1:17:58My job here is just to dispute your claim.
- 1:18:01The claim is
- 1:18:02that it effectively does not exist.
- 1:18:04My argument is,
- 1:18:05insofar as we're all talking about the Constitution,
- 1:18:08we have a court flawed or not,
- 1:18:09the Fourth Amendment being upheld that reviews
- 1:18:12the Constitution,
- 1:18:13is the Fourth Amendment being upheld?
- 1:18:14I'm not a constitutional scholar.
- 1:18:16I don't know,
- 1:18:17but there's active debate about it.
- 1:18:18The answer is,
- 1:18:19the answer is that it's not,
- 1:18:21and we've had a serious issue with flat cameras,
- 1:18:22for instance.
- 1:18:23One video I just watched where a guy got pulled over wrongly and arrested.
- 1:18:27Because
- 1:18:27a flat camera flagged his car down.
- 1:18:29Now when the police show up at your house and accuse
- 1:18:31you of a crime with fake evidence and you get arrested,
- 1:18:33that is a violation of your rights.
- 1:18:35Now,
- 1:18:35certainly we can argue that because of the Fourth Amendment,
- 1:18:37you can go and dispute it in court,
- 1:18:38but you could dispute it in court with or without
- 1:18:40the Fourth Am absolutely against those like flawed cameras.
- 1:18:42But again,
- 1:18:43that's not the point of this topic.
- 1:18:45When we're talking about does the Constitution exist
- 1:18:48insofar as there's still a court review system.
- 1:18:50Let's not be,
- 1:18:51let's,
- 1:18:51let's not argue semantics,
- 1:18:52sometimes there's not.
- 1:18:53Uh,
- 1:18:53a good example is the case of.
- 1:18:54Andrew Arnheimer,
- 1:18:55where he was arrested in Georgia and brought to New Jersey in
- 1:18:58violation of his constitutional rights and put in prison because of this,
- 1:19:01which ultimately resulted in him getting out.
- 1:19:03So I understand there is a constitution.
- 1:19:05I know there's a physical piece of paper,
- 1:19:06and I know that it does work,
- 1:19:08but I'm saying effectively,
- 1:19:09because what I'm saying is it has become so disputed
- 1:19:12and so ignored in most capacities that we may as like
- 1:19:16people are not abiding by it.
- 1:19:17The Democrats don't believe Republicans are.
- 1:19:19Republicans don't believe Democrats are.
- 1:19:20That's my point.
- 1:19:22That it,
- 1:19:22it's,
- 1:19:22it's,
- 1:19:22it's,
- 1:19:23it is an ineffective.
- 1:19:25Thank you.
- 1:19:25You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:19:27Good talking to you again.
- 1:19:32Alright,
- 1:19:32if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:19:34please head to the chair in 321.
- 1:19:39How's it going?
- 1:19:40Nice to meet you.
- 1:19:40Nice to meet you,
- 1:19:41Luke.
- 1:19:43What is the point of telling
- 1:19:45a bunch of different progressives
- 1:19:47that
- 1:19:48a bunch of things that we all agree with.
- 1:19:51I don't know,
- 1:19:51you tell me.
- 1:19:53What is the point of that?
- 1:19:54You're sitting within this pocket of safe moderation,
- 1:19:57right?
- 1:19:58You are a former Bernie bro,
- 1:19:59right?
- 1:19:59Oh yeah.
- 1:20:00Hell yeah,
- 1:20:01I agree with you.
- 1:20:01I was there when the bird landed on the podium in Portland.
- 1:20:04I was fucking there,
- 1:20:05man.
- 1:20:05I completely agree.
- 1:20:07And we both probably got disenfranchised by our
- 1:20:10party,
- 1:20:11right?
- 1:20:11I didn't vote for anybody in 2016.
- 1:20:13Sure,
- 1:20:13hell yeah,
- 1:20:14you did your part then.
- 1:20:16Right,
- 1:20:17so my question is,
- 1:20:18what is the point
- 1:20:20of arguing this with a bunch of people who agree with you?
- 1:20:22Shouldn't you be surrounded by a bunch of
- 1:20:25people that you so-called condemn?
- 1:20:26Um,
- 1:20:26I guess it's a production question.
- 1:20:29Yeah,
- 1:20:29I,
- 1:20:29that,
- 1:20:29that's it.
- 1:20:30I mean,
- 1:20:30I don't want you to say I,
- 1:20:31I have claims,
- 1:20:31and if,
- 1:20:32if we agree,
- 1:20:33I guess we can,
- 1:20:33we can all smile and shake hands.
- 1:20:35But like this is a direct question to you,
- 1:20:36like,
- 1:20:37why sit in this pocket of moderation if you
- 1:20:39so clearly condemn everything that's going on on the right,
- 1:20:42a group that is so clearly eroding
- 1:20:45the Constitution.
- 1:20:46Why are you sitting here arguing with people that agree with you?
- 1:20:49Is your,
- 1:20:49is your argument that I should be a progressive or a
- 1:20:51liberal because I don't like what's happened to the Constitution?
- 1:20:53No,
- 1:20:53I think you should be a little bit louder about the things that you actually believe
- 1:20:57instead of
- 1:20:58this like safe
- 1:20:59beanie wearing moderate.
- 1:21:01But what does that mean?
- 1:21:04Well,
- 1:21:04I condemn everything that the right has done.
- 1:21:06I didn't say I condemn everything the right has done.
- 1:21:07I,
- 1:21:08let's put it like this.
- 1:21:09When I look at the option in 2020 between Donald Trump and Joe Biden,
- 1:21:13I was actually supporting Tulsi Gabbard and Andrew Yang,
- 1:21:15and the Democratic Party does what the Democratic Party does.
- 1:21:17So I said,
- 1:21:17OK,
- 1:21:18well,
- 1:21:18who's the guy who's going to have my back more than them?
- 1:21:21These people I view as
- 1:21:22authoritarian,
- 1:21:24bad for a bunch of.
- 1:21:25Different reasons
- 1:21:26and and Trump's first term,
- 1:21:27it was a nightmare what they were doing.
- 1:21:29And Donald Trump put out a second term agenda and I said,
- 1:21:31you know what,
- 1:21:31there's a bunch of these things I agree with,
- 1:21:33and the Democratic Party I find to be it is untenable what they have done.
- 1:21:36Tim,
- 1:21:37like you are a smart guy.
- 1:21:38I,
- 1:21:39I'm,
- 1:21:39I'm not going to sit here and call you dumb and shake my head at you.
- 1:21:41You're a smart guy.
- 1:21:43How were you so easily conned?
- 1:21:45In what way?
- 1:21:46Saying that like,
- 1:21:47well,
- 1:21:47no,
- 1:21:48he's gonna do what he says he's gonna do.
- 1:21:50But
- 1:21:51what do you mean?
- 1:21:52Like,
- 1:21:52get,
- 1:21:53get,
- 1:21:53give me specifics.
- 1:21:54OK,
- 1:21:54um,
- 1:21:55like I appreciate that the,
- 1:21:56the line of thought,
- 1:21:57but you gotta be specific.
- 1:21:58Give me a specific about something that you voted for Donald Trump
- 1:22:01to do
- 1:22:02tariffs.
- 1:22:03How did that work out?
- 1:22:05Fantastic for me.
- 1:22:06Yeah,
- 1:22:06we're all rich,
- 1:22:07right?
- 1:22:07We're all,
- 1:22:07we're all cruising.
- 1:22:09That's,
- 1:22:09that's working out for us.
- 1:22:10Well,
- 1:22:10I think,
- 1:22:11I,
- 1:22:11I,
- 1:22:11I,
- 1:22:12I think,
- 1:22:12I think you,
- 1:22:13there's a fundamental fundamental misunderstanding among people who don't do
- 1:22:16manufacturing or run businesses on the issue of tariffs.
- 1:22:18So for me,
- 1:22:19the issue of.
- 1:22:20Trade control was extremely important.
- 1:22:22We don't see that from the Democratic Party,
- 1:22:23so I voted for that.
- 1:22:24Trump did it,
- 1:22:25and I fully acknowledge that there's negative repercussions,
- 1:22:28but it's called spending money to fix problems down the road.
- 1:22:30Why are you willing to erode the Constitution,
- 1:22:32something that you so vehemently fought for?
- 1:22:34No,
- 1:22:34I think,
- 1:22:35I think Democrats erode the Constitution substantially more.
- 1:22:38So,
- 1:22:39uh,
- 1:22:40we can talk about the 1st Amendment,
- 1:22:41we can talk about the Biden administration going in and get people banned.
- 1:22:44That's the easiest one.
- 1:22:45We can talk about the Fourth Amendment.
- 1:22:47I remember that nasty Democrat,
- 1:22:48uh,
- 1:22:49Brandon Carr,
- 1:22:50who,
- 1:22:50uh,
- 1:22:50took down
- 1:22:51Jimmy Kimmel,
- 1:22:52the stand-up comedian that I am.
- 1:22:54What what did Carr say?
- 1:22:55He,
- 1:22:56he made a call directly to NBC.
- 1:22:58Why should
- 1:22:59unilateral government power
- 1:23:01be used like that?
- 1:23:03And why are you
- 1:23:04just saying,
- 1:23:04I condemn that,
- 1:23:05but you're actively doing nothing to fight it?
- 1:23:07No,
- 1:23:07no,
- 1:23:07no,
- 1:23:08I think,
- 1:23:08I think the issue largely is regulatory bodies exist.
- 1:23:11I agree with the existence of regulatory bodies.
- 1:23:13Sometimes they do things you don't like.
- 1:23:14You didn't like it here,
- 1:23:15but I'm sure you like regulatory bodies elsewhere.
- 1:23:17So I'm not,
- 1:23:18I'm not,
- 1:23:18I'm not going to come out and pretend to be.
- 1:23:20Angry about something that is complicated or litigation we
- 1:23:22don't understand because it's it's tribal points for me.
- 1:23:25I'm going to say,
- 1:23:25what did Brendan Carr actually say?
- 1:23:26What did he actually say when he called NBC?
- 1:23:28You need to take Jimmy Kimmel down.
- 1:23:30He did not say that.
- 1:23:31Then what did he say?
- 1:23:31I don't know,
- 1:23:32and that's why I don't have a strong opinion about the issue right now.
- 1:23:34Right?
- 1:23:35So you can't tell me what he said.
- 1:23:36You can't pretend to be angry.
- 1:23:37We're going to pause here.
- 1:23:38Thank you so much.
- 1:23:39You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:23:40Boisterous.
- 1:23:43I appreciate it.
- 1:23:43Nice meeting you.
- 1:23:46If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:23:47please head to the chair in 321.
- 1:23:54Welcome back
- 1:23:56So the whole point of it being like,
- 1:23:58oh,
- 1:23:59it's the left,
- 1:23:59it's the right.
- 1:24:00I'm a constitutional abolitionist.
- 1:24:02I want it gone.
- 1:24:03Who's the constitution written for?
- 1:24:05It's written for the original American colonists who started this country,
- 1:24:09which were
- 1:24:10largely white Protestants.
- 1:24:12So it was written for white men that own land,
- 1:24:15right?
- 1:24:15Mostly,
- 1:24:15yes,
- 1:24:16yeah,
- 1:24:16perfect.
- 1:24:17And after that,
- 1:24:18everyone else has been given rights.
- 1:24:20Right,
- 1:24:20they've not been given rights.
- 1:24:22I would argue that over a long enough period of time,
- 1:24:25there's been advocacy to make the
- 1:24:26Constitution protect against a government infringement.
- 1:24:28The,
- 1:24:28the Constitutions given the rights that protect the white men that own land.
- 1:24:33Everyone else,
- 1:24:33I don't think we're disagreeing.
- 1:24:34I'm just,
- 1:24:35I'm saying we don't,
- 1:24:36the Congress doesn't give us the rights.
- 1:24:37It stops the government from doing things.
- 1:24:39Yeah,
- 1:24:39sure,
- 1:24:39it gives you the protection from blah blah blah.
- 1:24:42Fine.
- 1:24:42Yeah,
- 1:24:42and it was like overwhelmingly white European so the point that I'm,
- 1:24:45I'm making is
- 1:24:46we've seen throughout the history of our
- 1:24:48country that other people have been attacked,
- 1:24:49right?
- 1:24:50Every other marginalized group has been attacked.
- 1:24:53There's been amendments,
- 1:24:54there's been back and forth,
- 1:24:55whether people do or do not have access to rights.
- 1:24:58The whole point that I'm getting to is the United States Constitution
- 1:25:01needs to be thrown out completely.
- 1:25:03Thomas Jefferson agrees with me.
- 1:25:07Thomas Jefferson said that the Constitution should be rewritten every 19 years.
- 1:25:11Now,
- 1:25:12around that time they were dying early,
- 1:25:13so I'm thinking it's like 50 years or whatever,
- 1:25:16but he made the point that if we actually have,
- 1:25:18uh,
- 1:25:18legislation,
- 1:25:19laws,
- 1:25:20or a constitution that governs people
- 1:25:22in the future based off of what we've written,
- 1:25:24then we're doing an injustice.
- 1:25:25So saying that we should uphold something that was written 250 years ago
- 1:25:29when I was 3/5 of a person.
- 1:25:32Like,
- 1:25:32what are we doing?
- 1:25:33Oh,
- 1:25:33back then it was worse than that.
- 1:25:34That's compromising.
- 1:25:36Have you,
- 1:25:36uh,
- 1:25:36have you read the 1619 Project?
- 1:25:38Uh,
- 1:25:38I,
- 1:25:39no,
- 1:25:39OK,
- 1:25:39cool.
- 1:25:40The reason the Constitution and the,
- 1:25:42the way the United States government is set up,
- 1:25:43it's literally because the founding fathers were slave owners.
- 1:25:47They were racist slave owners that wanted to uphold that power,
- 1:25:50and they wanted to give the power
- 1:25:51to the states.
- 1:25:52Well,
- 1:25:53there's there's a lot of context missing from that.
- 1:25:54You're familiar with the,
- 1:25:55the,
- 1:25:55the,
- 1:25:56the,
- 1:25:56uh,
- 1:25:56issue of the Declaration of Declaration of
- 1:25:58Independence in South Carolina and Georgia.
- 1:25:59Thomas Jefferson was angry with the king for bringing slaves to the colonies.
- 1:26:02I'm not saying he wasn't a racist.
- 1:26:04He,
- 1:26:04he wanted to include a provision of the biggest reasons
- 1:26:06for the Revolutionary War is because Britain no longer wanted
- 1:26:09to uphold chattel slavery and the colonies wanted to because
- 1:26:13they had been so successful as far as making money.
- 1:26:15The colonies period.
- 1:26:16The Southern colonies.
- 1:26:17The colonies period after the Civil War,
- 1:26:21then they shifted away where you saw kind of a split where
- 1:26:24the northern colonies didn't want it as much as the southern colonies.
- 1:26:26Before the Civil Wars besides the point.
- 1:26:27This is around 1820,
- 1:26:28in fact.
- 1:26:29No,
- 1:26:29I'm saying after,
- 1:26:30after the,
- 1:26:30so around 18 after the Civil War,
- 1:26:32I'm sorry,
- 1:26:32after the Revolutionary War,
- 1:26:33right,
- 1:26:34right.
- 1:26:34So yes,
- 1:26:34yes,
- 1:26:35very shortly after the Revolutionary War,
- 1:26:37Thomas Jefferson had written a,
- 1:26:38a statement for the Declaration that stated
- 1:26:40the king has brought people to this land to wage war against us,
- 1:26:43something to that effect.
- 1:26:44And South Carolina and Georgia
- 1:26:46contested to its inclusion in the Declaration.
- 1:26:49Because they wanted slavery so bad,
- 1:26:51but don't get me wrong,
- 1:26:51one of the,
- 1:26:53one of the biggest drivers was the fact that there was a slave that was in the colonies
- 1:26:57and his slave owner took him to Britain,
- 1:26:59and Britain
- 1:27:00actually had a rule that no one could be slaves,
- 1:27:02and so he was able to win his freedom for being in Britain,
- 1:27:05and that shook the foundation
- 1:27:07of the colonies,
- 1:27:07which forced them to actually
- 1:27:09push for the Revolutionary War and then come with the United States Constitution.
- 1:27:13The point that I'm trying to make is the
- 1:27:14United States Constitution needs to be abolished because.
- 1:27:15It does not protect all the people.
- 1:27:17We need to completely rewrite the United States
- 1:27:19Constitution Constitution and give protections to everyone.
- 1:27:22Everyone needs to have
- 1:27:23equal rights under the protection of the law.
- 1:27:25We can,
- 1:27:25we can go back and forth about everything else.
- 1:27:27Do you,
- 1:27:27do you think that,
- 1:27:28uh,
- 1:27:29I,
- 1:27:29I,
- 1:27:29you're,
- 1:27:30you're allowed to have the opinion,
- 1:27:31you don't like the Constitution and all that stuff.
- 1:27:31I'm not gonna argue.
- 1:27:32Do you think,
- 1:27:33how do you think this country would react
- 1:27:34if you were successful in abolishing the Constitution?
- 1:27:37Yeah,
- 1:27:37I think that it'll be a violent revolution.
- 1:27:40Pause here.
- 1:27:41We're out of time.
- 1:27:42I,
- 1:27:43I appreciated that,
- 1:27:43yeah.
- 1:27:46All right,
- 1:27:46Tim,
- 1:27:46it is time for the final debate.
- 1:27:48You'll have 10 minutes uninterrupted.
- 1:27:51Now look around the room
- 1:27:53and choose who you like to continue the dialogue with.
- 1:27:56Uh,
- 1:27:57I think I'll go with,
- 1:27:58uh,
- 1:27:59I like this guy.
- 1:28:00Why did you choose Luke?
- 1:28:01He had asked me questions about why I believed what I
- 1:28:04believed or why I would vote the way that I did,
- 1:28:06and I thought,
- 1:28:07I thought it was genuine.
- 1:28:07I thought we could have a good conversation,
- 1:28:09so I'm interested in hearing also what he thinks and what he believes and
- 1:28:12where,
- 1:28:12where maybe we'll disagree and agree.
- 1:28:14My surrounding claim is that in 2026,
- 1:28:17all moderates are cowards.
- 1:28:24All right,
- 1:28:24well,
- 1:28:24uh,
- 1:28:26no,
- 1:28:27sure,
- 1:28:28and I certainly don't think,
- 1:28:29don't think I am.
- 1:28:30I think that,
- 1:28:30uh,
- 1:28:3211 of the biggest problems that we have in this country is,
- 1:28:34uh,
- 1:28:34uh,
- 1:28:34media polarization.
- 1:28:36There are,
- 1:28:37uh,
- 1:28:37family members of mine that only watch MS now,
- 1:28:40and there are family members of mine that only watch Fox News,
- 1:28:43and
- 1:28:44I watch both.
- 1:28:45And so then I see,
- 1:28:46you know,
- 1:28:46when,
- 1:28:47when I turn on MS now,
- 1:28:48the only thing they're talking about is going to be in one direction.
- 1:28:50I turn on Fox News,
- 1:28:51the only thing they're talking about is in the other direction.
- 1:28:53And this makes people really on edge,
- 1:28:55and then say,
- 1:28:56I need to be on one side.
- 1:28:57It crafts a moral worldview.
- 1:28:59Well,
- 1:28:59I certainly understand your point,
- 1:29:01you're,
- 1:29:01you,
- 1:29:01what I'm actually,
- 1:29:03let me do this.
- 1:29:03Are you saying take a side,
- 1:29:04stand up for something?
- 1:29:06More or less
- 1:29:07I'm saying that over the last we'll say 26 years,
- 1:29:11right,
- 1:29:12we have been,
- 1:29:13well,
- 1:29:14barring 2016,
- 1:29:15so from 2000 to 2016
- 1:29:18we were kind of controlled by a centrist government
- 1:29:20and
- 1:29:21I feel like that.
- 1:29:23Even though Barack Obama was a progressive for his time,
- 1:29:25we view him now as pretty centrist,
- 1:29:28right?
- 1:29:28Uh,
- 1:29:28we're in a room full of progressives,
- 1:29:30um,
- 1:29:30I would agree just even back then as well,
- 1:29:32right.
- 1:29:34That opened the door
- 1:29:37for someone like Donald Trump to come in
- 1:29:39and actively erode our Constitution
- 1:29:42and the very foundation that our country is supposed to be.
- 1:29:46Well,
- 1:29:46is it,
- 1:29:47is your argument that everyone should be against Donald Trump then?
- 1:29:50No.
- 1:29:51So then,
- 1:29:52then what's your gripe with the gripe with moderates?
- 1:29:56Centrism
- 1:29:57and moderation in 2026
- 1:30:00in the age of
- 1:30:01AIPAC money,
- 1:30:03in the age of
- 1:30:04Larry Ellison,
- 1:30:05Barry Weiss,
- 1:30:07all of these talking heads,
- 1:30:08all of these political entities,
- 1:30:10Peter Thiel,
- 1:30:10Mark Zuckerberg,
- 1:30:11all these,
- 1:30:12this technocracy that we are not far from,
- 1:30:14right?
- 1:30:16Why
- 1:30:17do you get
- 1:30:19to sit in the middle
- 1:30:21and argue both sides
- 1:30:23while raking in dollars
- 1:30:24from these exact entities?
- 1:30:27Well,
- 1:30:27what's your,
- 1:30:27what's your,
- 1:30:28what's your
- 1:30:28proposal?
- 1:30:29What's,
- 1:30:29I,
- 1:30:30I,
- 1:30:30I,
- 1:30:30I,
- 1:30:30I,
- 1:30:30I guess I'm trying to understand.
- 1:30:32Uh,
- 1:30:32my view of what it means to be moderate is that
- 1:30:34sometimes the right is correct and sometimes the left is correct.
- 1:30:36Sure,
- 1:30:36and I think my view is,
- 1:30:39I,
- 1:30:39I come from,
- 1:30:40uh,
- 1:30:40interestingly,
- 1:30:40the area of Chicago where I grew up has turned red.
- 1:30:43It's firefighters,
- 1:30:43it's cops,
- 1:30:44it's working class Joe's.
- 1:30:45Why is that?
- 1:30:46That it turned red?
- 1:30:47Yeah,
- 1:30:47I think for a lot of these people they feel that
- 1:30:49the,
- 1:30:50the Democratic establishment has abandoned them on a few issues.
- 1:30:53The,
- 1:30:54the mass migration that we saw or the large migration whatever you want,
- 1:30:56wasn't,
- 1:30:57wasn't there a huge,
- 1:30:58yeah,
- 1:30:58like you're saying,
- 1:30:58wasn't there a huge migration of blue
- 1:31:00to red and red to blue.
- 1:31:02Right,
- 1:31:02you,
- 1:31:02you,
- 1:31:02you made that claim.
- 1:31:03You mean like California to Texas,
- 1:31:04and,
- 1:31:05and New York,
- 1:31:06inner city Chicago to outer city Chicago suburbs,
- 1:31:08things like that.
- 1:31:08Yeah,
- 1:31:08the people in my neighborhood didn't really move.
- 1:31:10They don't have the money to do so.
- 1:31:11So there is a large migration.
- 1:31:12doesn't mean every neighborhood migrated,
- 1:31:14but
- 1:31:14particularly for where I grew up,
- 1:31:15it's interesting that the politics of the
- 1:31:17neighborhood kind of tracked alongside myself.
- 1:31:19Like
- 1:31:19in 2016,
- 1:31:20I was for Bernie.
- 1:31:21My the area where I grew up,
- 1:31:23it was like largely blue.
- 1:31:24Uh,
- 1:31:24I didn't vote for anybody.
- 1:31:25In 2020.
- 1:31:26I said,
- 1:31:26I guess I'm gonna vote for Trump.
- 1:31:27That's the things I don't like about him,
- 1:31:28but here's what I,
- 1:31:29what I agree with him,
- 1:31:30why I don't like Joe Biden vote for him.
- 1:31:32Well,
- 1:31:33unfortunately,
- 1:31:33I think one of the big issues with Afghanistan,
- 1:31:35and I'm not gonna say Trump's done well with Iran particularly,
- 1:31:38you know what I mean,
- 1:31:38but,
- 1:31:38uh,
- 1:31:39there was an issue of,
- 1:31:39uh,
- 1:31:40uh,
- 1:31:40for one,
- 1:31:41I was for Tulsi Gabbard.
- 1:31:42I donated the maximum to Tulsi and to,
- 1:31:44uh,
- 1:31:44uh,
- 1:31:44uh,
- 1:31:45to Andrew Yang,
- 1:31:46and,
- 1:31:46and Andrew Yang,
- 1:31:46how's Tulsi doing?
- 1:31:48moderately well.
- 1:31:49I mean she's not particularly in the political limelight as of right now,
- 1:31:51but I do believe she's gonna try and run a spoiler candidacy against Democrats.
- 1:31:54Sure,
- 1:31:55Andrew Andrew Yang doing?
- 1:31:57Andrew Yang not doing so well.
- 1:31:58I mean,
- 1:31:58he's got the Forward Party,
- 1:32:00but why do you think that?
- 1:32:01Why do I think what?
- 1:32:02Why do you think that Andrew Yang is not succeeding in today's day?
- 1:32:05Because I believe the Democratic machine,
- 1:32:06like they did to Bernie ices out anybody who
- 1:32:08wants to actually win on a populist grassroots level,
- 1:32:12and I don't know how to vote for someone like Joe Biden who I think is evil,
- 1:32:16and I think him and the administration,
- 1:32:18Hillary Clinton have done such horrible things
- 1:32:20that.
- 1:32:20I said we,
- 1:32:21we need,
- 1:32:22like Andrew Yang was my principal guy,
- 1:32:23a big fan of Tulsi as well,
- 1:32:25largely because she had military service and
- 1:32:26was in opposition to these foreign wars,
- 1:32:28and we didn't get it for the second time,
- 1:32:30I said,
- 1:32:30I guess I'm voting for Donald Trump
- 1:32:32for a few reasons.
- 1:32:33He was the only one talking about
- 1:32:34why we need trade controls,
- 1:32:36and I agree with these trade controls,
- 1:32:37but I fully recognize that they do cause short-term economic damage,
- 1:32:40and that's bad for a lot of people.
- 1:32:42I can recognize that.
- 1:32:43Why do we,
- 1:32:44why
- 1:32:45are we in the position.
- 1:32:46Or why,
- 1:32:47why as a country
- 1:32:48did we end up in that issue with trade?
- 1:32:50Why did that happen?
- 1:32:52There's a lot of arguments for it.
- 1:32:53If you go back to the 90s,
- 1:32:54you can look at these,
- 1:32:55these general free trade agreements.
- 1:32:56The belief from a lot of individuals is
- 1:32:58that when there's trade agreements between countries,
- 1:33:00you prevent war.
- 1:33:01Who passed those?
- 1:33:03These,
- 1:33:03these,
- 1:33:03these laws
- 1:33:04that go back to both parties over the since,
- 1:33:05since 1950.
- 1:33:08So in the 1950s,
- 1:33:08who passed them?
- 1:33:09Like what,
- 1:33:10what,
- 1:33:10what,
- 1:33:10where did they align politically?
- 1:33:12Both parties and we call it the,
- 1:33:13we call it the Unit Party.
- 1:33:14I would say they they'd probably be pretty close to the center,
- 1:33:17right?
- 1:33:17One would call them a moderate.
- 1:33:19We call them the Uni Party.
- 1:33:20I,
- 1:33:20I don't think moderates the right way to describe a cabal of elites who
- 1:33:23lie about their views to attract the most voters possible and steal power from,
- 1:33:26from the working class.
- 1:33:27Sure,
- 1:33:28like,
- 1:33:28like moderate is
- 1:33:29just means.
- 1:33:30So if you believe that,
- 1:33:31what are your views in 1950?
- 1:33:34Where are you voting?
- 1:33:35Where are you casting your vote?
- 1:33:36Oh,
- 1:33:36I'm not voting for any of these people.
- 1:33:37Well,
- 1:33:38to be,
- 1:33:38to be fair,
- 1:33:39I think we're the products of the 1950s.
- 1:33:40We'd have all strange,
- 1:33:41like very strange political.
- 1:33:42Views,
- 1:33:42but I would say right now,
- 1:33:43uh,
- 1:33:44are you familiar with the liberal economic order?
- 1:33:45Yes,
- 1:33:45I,
- 1:33:45I think it's,
- 1:33:46it was insane.
- 1:33:47And then the policies that we got from it leading up to before Trump came in
- 1:33:51was the continuance of this,
- 1:33:52this,
- 1:33:53this policy by which
- 1:33:54the United States imposes economic sanctions and military,
- 1:33:57uh,
- 1:33:57uh,
- 1:33:57uh,
- 1:33:58we'll just call it their military because it could be occupation or bombings
- 1:34:02on other countries unless they enter into debt
- 1:34:04with an international.
- 1:34:05Banking system
- 1:34:06and they thought,
- 1:34:06you know what,
- 1:34:07this will prevent World War II and it and did it?
- 1:34:09No.
- 1:34:09So they entered into foreign sovereign nations and took away
- 1:34:12the rights of the people to vote as they wish.
- 1:34:13How is that different like the central bank entity,
- 1:34:15right?
- 1:34:16How is that different than
- 1:34:18most of the individuals on the right taking money from AIPAC?
- 1:34:21That's not a good thing.
- 1:34:22I don't,
- 1:34:22I don't agree with that.
- 1:34:23Those are bad things.
- 1:34:24Then why do you actively support that?
- 1:34:26Why do you actively support a president who's made.
- 1:34:28Billions of dollars since he's taken office.
- 1:34:30Why do you support that as somebody who loved Bernie?
- 1:34:32The simple answer is the things that I align with,
- 1:34:35clearly you don't align with,
- 1:34:36and that puts me in a,
- 1:34:37in a Trump position as opposed to a Democrat position.
- 1:34:40Sure,
- 1:34:40you have a lot of politicians on the Democrat
- 1:34:42side who got behind authoritarian practices during COVID.
- 1:34:44I'm not going to support those individuals.
- 1:34:46I will,
- 1:34:47but the authoritarian practices today
- 1:34:49you're willing to look past
- 1:34:50some of them,
- 1:34:50yes.
- 1:34:52Come on man,
- 1:34:53come on,
- 1:34:53like do you want me to,
- 1:34:54do you want me to lie to you and equivocate and pretend that I think politicians are
- 1:34:57I don't want you to lie to me and I'm so thankful that you're being honest.
- 1:35:00And I'm glad these cameras can see that,
- 1:35:01and I hope your fan base can.
- 1:35:02And I'd say this every single night on my show.
- 1:35:04It,
- 1:35:05it is silly that you get people who come on here and try to defend the indefensible.
- 1:35:08Like sometimes you're a conservative and you're wrong.
- 1:35:11Sometimes you're a Democrat and you're wrong.
- 1:35:13It's,
- 1:35:13it's silly to come here and be like,
- 1:35:15no matter what the argument is,
- 1:35:16I have to tribalistically defend something that's stupid.
- 1:35:19But here's the issue.
- 1:35:20There are things that Democrats have done that terrify me,
- 1:35:23and I cannot support.
- 1:35:24Now that being said,
- 1:35:25is there good that they've done?
- 1:35:26There's a possibility,
- 1:35:27uh,
- 1:35:27you know,
- 1:35:27the one thing I like to,
- 1:35:28I like to shout out for,
- 1:35:29for Joe Biden is banking and ATM issues.
- 1:35:32I know it seems a little light,
- 1:35:34but I can't believe that the right attacked Joe Biden
- 1:35:36on the issue of trying to get,
- 1:35:37get rid of ATM fees.
- 1:35:39I know a guy.
- 1:35:39It might sound so light,
- 1:35:41but you gotta start from the bottom.
- 1:35:42It sounds like a very safe Republican moderate belief.
- 1:35:45And that's,
- 1:35:46and,
- 1:35:46and dude,
- 1:35:46you are entitled to have those beliefs and like
- 1:35:49we live in this country,
- 1:35:51we are allowed to disagree.
- 1:35:52This constitution that you allege that is fully eroded,
- 1:35:55we still have the ability to do this,
- 1:35:57and that rules,
- 1:35:58but
- 1:35:58I will say.
- 1:36:01We've all seen what's been going on in our country this summer.
- 1:36:04We,
- 1:36:04we've been holding the World Cup here.
- 1:36:06We've been seeing people come here and see this country for what it truly is,
- 1:36:10and they love it.
- 1:36:11They love it,
- 1:36:11right?
- 1:36:11It's great.
- 1:36:12What do they love about it?
- 1:36:14Well,
- 1:36:14I love when they went to Chicago and got the deep dish pizza.
- 1:36:17I,
- 1:36:17I love the people who said,
- 1:36:18where'd that deep dish pizza come from?
- 1:36:20Giordano's?
- 1:36:21Yeah.
- 1:36:22OK,
- 1:36:22that's that last name,
- 1:36:23that doesn't sound like an American last name.
- 1:36:25Where'd that pizza come from?
- 1:36:27It came from America.
- 1:36:28Immigrants.
- 1:36:28It didn't.
- 1:36:31No,
- 1:36:31it didn't Chicago style deep dish came,
- 1:36:32came from Chicago.
- 1:36:33But,
- 1:36:34but it's it's like the descendants of immigrants if you want to get technical.
- 1:36:38So
- 1:36:38what I'm saying is
- 1:36:39these because American style pizza was uniquely
- 1:36:41American and distinct from Italian style pizza.
- 1:36:43Totally.
- 1:36:43I know where chicken tikka masala comes,
- 1:36:45but it's still pizza.
- 1:36:46Do you know where chicken tikka masala is a British inclination.
- 1:36:48I get it.
- 1:36:48Like I fully get it,
- 1:36:49man.
- 1:36:50We agree it's amazing.
- 1:36:50You are talking to a 365 pound man with a knife tattoo.
- 1:36:54You think I don't know where tikka masala's from,
- 1:36:56Doc?
- 1:36:56Like,
- 1:36:57I,
- 1:36:57we love it,
- 1:36:58we agree.
- 1:36:58I mean,
- 1:36:58I,
- 1:36:59I don't love that it's their national dish.
- 1:37:00I think.
- 1:37:00I'm,
- 1:37:01I'm,
- 1:37:01I'm part Korean.
- 1:37:02My,
- 1:37:02my,
- 1:37:03my,
- 1:37:03my,
- 1:37:03my,
- 1:37:04I had,
- 1:37:04I had family who fled war and came to America
- 1:37:06and were welcomed in the beautiful bosom of this nation
- 1:37:08to live an amazing life.
- 1:37:09Then why are you voting for an entity that wants to erase that?
- 1:37:13They don't want to erase it.
- 1:37:14I think you have a misconception.
- 1:37:15I think,
- 1:37:15I think it comes down to,
- 1:37:17I look at a Biden administration
- 1:37:18that brings in a,
- 1:37:19a,
- 1:37:20there's wide estimates from 4 to even upwards of 20 million,
- 1:37:24right?
- 1:37:24And,
- 1:37:24and if you pick what number you think is right or what's wrong,
- 1:37:26it doesn't matter.
- 1:37:27We saw,
- 1:37:28we saw mass migration into this country
- 1:37:30on a large scale,
- 1:37:31and I think that is bad for the economy.
- 1:37:33I think it's bad for the younger generation,
- 1:37:35and I see ideologies pushed by Democratic Party
- 1:37:37politicians and activists that I think are detrimental
- 1:37:40to the future of the,
- 1:37:41of the younger generation in this country,
- 1:37:42namely my child.
- 1:37:43So,
- 1:37:43so we keep talking about the civil war issue,
- 1:37:46the secessions and everything.
- 1:37:47The big issue that's going on geopolitically
- 1:37:51is we've got a massive target on our back.
- 1:37:53Wouldn't you want more people to be in this country
- 1:37:56to fight against that?
- 1:37:57Wouldn't you want more hands the target?
- 1:37:59Like I mean like who's who's the threat?
- 1:38:01We are
- 1:38:02Israel.
- 1:38:04Through us
- 1:38:05is a threat.
- 1:38:06So we have,
- 1:38:07but you're saying like there's gonna be retaliation in the United States.
- 1:38:11They,
- 1:38:11they are hanging banners calling for the
- 1:38:13the assassination of our sitting president.
- 1:38:16And I,
- 1:38:16I,
- 1:38:17I don't agree with that.
- 1:38:18I don't want that to happen
- 1:38:19if that were to happen.
- 1:38:20I,
- 1:38:20I do not like the outcome that's going to,
- 1:38:22I don't,
- 1:38:23I,
- 1:38:24I don't see how bringing in more people from around the around the world,
- 1:38:26which,
- 1:38:27whether right or wrong,
- 1:38:28changes that.
- 1:38:29Wouldn't,
- 1:38:29isn't a larger country stronger?
- 1:38:32Isn't China vastly more advanced than we are?
- 1:38:34Not necessarily,
- 1:38:35no.
- 1:38:35Yes,
- 1:38:36they are.
- 1:38:36Is India,
- 1:38:37like they,
- 1:38:37they,
- 1:38:38they have,
- 1:38:38they have high levels of poverty in certain areas.
- 1:38:40I think they exist within a caste system that we're we're comparing.
- 1:38:44I think,
- 1:38:44I think the United States likes to put on these airs,
- 1:38:46particularly Republicans,
- 1:38:47about how everything's perfect and great.
- 1:38:48When it's not,
- 1:38:49you've got slums.
- 1:38:49Japan does this,
- 1:38:50China does this.
- 1:38:51Every,
- 1:38:52you know,
- 1:38:52it's,
- 1:38:52it's hard to gauge who's
- 1:38:54like which country is going to be the,
- 1:38:56the,
- 1:38:56the pinnacle of success of their,
- 1:38:57of their ground.
- 1:38:58I don't want us to be the pinnacle.
- 1:38:59I want us to be the country that we should be.
- 1:39:02Which is
- 1:39:03a country that continues to change and grow and develop and welcome people in.
- 1:39:07I'm gonna pause here.
- 1:39:08I'm gonna pause here.
- 1:39:09We are out of time,
- 1:39:11so I wanna thank you both.
- 1:39:12I wanna thank all the debaters.
- 1:39:14It was great,
- 1:39:14man.
- 1:39:19You guys brought a lot of passion.
- 1:39:22I loved it.
- 1:39:23Tim,
- 1:39:23I wanna thank you for taking them all on.
- 1:39:25That is not easy.
- 1:39:26Would you like to continue this conversation on our podcast?
- 1:39:29Yeah,
- 1:39:29absolutely.
- 1:39:30Love to hear it
- 1:39:31and I love that you guys watched and tuned in.
- 1:39:33Thank you for watching and catch us next time.
- 1:39:35I think it was great.
- 1:39:36I think,
- 1:39:36uh,
- 1:39:37everybody did a pretty good job
- 1:39:39as long as we're trying to have a real conversation and get to the heart of it,
- 1:39:41things usually work out well,
- 1:39:42although there was that one guy who seemed really mad at me,
- 1:39:45you know.
- 1:39:45I,
- 1:39:45I came here holding Tim to a very high standard.
- 1:39:48Um,
- 1:39:49that of at least a 5 year old
- 1:39:51in in grade school.
- 1:39:53I mostly think that Tim doesn't care about what the fallout of his rhetoric is.
- 1:39:57He's primarily focused on one thing and one thing only,
- 1:39:59and that's generating profit.
- 1:40:01Well,
- 1:40:01when you tell me that because I want to vote
- 1:40:03for what I believe and I'm making civil war happen,
- 1:40:04that's just proving my point.
- 1:40:05I think Tim
- 1:40:07stood on his own 2 ft about his beliefs.
- 1:40:09He did not
- 1:40:10lie about his perspective beliefs.
- 1:40:13But I do believe that his beliefs
- 1:40:16are
- 1:40:17inherently cowardly.
- 1:40:18People,
- 1:40:19they get their view of me from clips presented by progressives who,
- 1:40:24you know,
- 1:40:24they accuse me of grifting.
- 1:40:25I would counter with if they watched my show even one time,
- 1:40:29they wouldn't come to me and try and make arguments that I don't
- 1:40:31believe him.