Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / What Happened to Alexis Murphy? | The Disappearance of a 17-Year-Old
Transcript
- Nicholle: Content warning. This episode contains detailed discussions of the abduction, sexual assault, and murder of a minor. We will be discussing forensic evidence, courtroom testimony, and the psychological manipulation of a victim and her family. Listener discretion is strongly advised. Zalle: She was afraid of the dark, not in the way little kids are, not monsters under the bed or boogeyman in the closet. No, Alexis Murphy was afraid of the short stretch between her car and her front door, the place where the porch light didn't quite reach, so she had a system. She'd call the house from her car. Three rings, four sometimes, just long enough for her grandmother to wake up, shuffle to the switch, and flood that path with yellow light. Then Alexis would run. Fast, laughing at herself for being such a baby at 17. On August 3rd, 2013 the phone never rang. The porch light stayed on all night, and somewhere between a gas station and home, the dark one. Welcome to Coffee and Crying with Mom. I'm Zalle Nicholle: And I'm Nicholle, mom. Zalle: And to all our co conspirators out there, thanks for pressing play today. Nicholle: Today we're discussing the 2013 disappearance and murder of Alexis a 17-year-old from Nelson County, Virginia. Zalle: All information presented is sourced from publicly available records, newspapers, and official statements. Some details may be disturbing. We approach this case with the utmost respect for Alexis, her family, and all victims of violent crime. Alexis Tierra Murphy was not a kid who blended in. She was 17, about to start her senior year at Nelson County High School in Shipman, Virginia. She was co captain of the volleyball team. She had just gotten a raise at her job at Kid to Kid in Charlottesville, and she had roughly twelve thousand Twitter followers, which in twenty thirteen basically made her a local celebrity. Nicholle: Her family described her as the fashionista, the athlete, and the joker. She was obsessed with her hair, like obsessed. She never went anywhere without her iPhone. She was beautiful, the kind of beautiful that turns heads at a gas station. And that beauty may have been exactly what got her killed. Zalle: She lived with her mother Laura and her grandmother Gail in a house in Shipman. And here's something that breaks my heart. Her grandmother said Alex was actually a scared kind of person. When she came home at night, she would call the house multiple times from her car because she was afraid to walk from the driveway to the front door in the dark. Nicholle: Think about that. A kid who was afraid of the dark, a kid who called her grandma to make sure the porch light was on. And on the night of august third, twenty thirteen, that porch light stayed on all night because Alexis never came home. Zalle: August third, twenty thirteen, it was a Saturday, and Alexis told her mom she was driving to Lynchburg to buy hair extensions for her senior portraits. she hopped in her father's white two thousand three Nissan Maximum and tweeted two words Bergbaum. Nicholle: That tweet is timestamped. It's the last thing Alexis Murphy ever posted online. She made it to Lynchburg, she bought the hair extensions, and on her way back she stopped at the Liberty Gas Station on US Route twenty nine in Lovingston. It was around seven PM. Zalle: Now, the Liberty Gas Station wasn't just any gas station. It was a local hangout. Kids from Nelson County High would stop there after school for snacks and sodas, and one of the regulars, a guy who was practically part of the furniture there, was a forty eight year old man named Randy Allen Taylor. Nicholle: Randy Taylor drove a late model camouflage GMC suburban. He was heavily tattooed and he was a convicted sex offender. And according to the gas station employees, he had a habit of parking his SUV in the lot for hours, buying paw maw reds and beer and just watching, staring at teenage girls. Zalle: Disgusting. Nicholle: This guy. Zalle: One assistant manager, Tammy Hitt, would later say he was the last person you would want to be alone with. And on August 3rd, Alexis Murphy was alone with him. Nicholle: Surveillance footage shows Alexis walking in. She's wearing a pink shirt and shorts. She got her hair done. She's got those hair extensions she just bought. And then there's Randy Taylor. he's wearing a blue Miller light t-shirt. And he holds the door for her as she walks in. Zalle: He holds the door like a gentleman, like a predator pretending to be a gentleman. Nicholle: If you watch that footage and law enforcement studied it frame by frame, you see it all happen in real time. A teenage girl walking into a gas station to buy a soda, a grown man holding the door like it's nothing, and then both vehicles heading north on Route 29, her car following his, like she was being led into a trap she didn't even know was being set. Zalle: Another camera angle shows something chilling. Taylor Suburban pulls out of the lot and heads north on Route twenty nine, and right behind him, Alexis Murphy's white Nissan Maximum. Nicholle: Cashier Melissa Jarrell would later testify that she saw Alexis walk across the parking lot, turn her head as if someone spoke to her, and then walk over to Taylor's car. And they talked. That was the last time anyone saw Alexis Murphy alive. Zalle: before whatever happened in that parking lot, Alexis was just a normal teenager on a Saturday night and the people who saw her inside that store remembered her that way. Nicholle: Hearing someone describe her like that, happy, carefree, just living her life, it makes what happened next feel even more brutal because she wasn't worried. She had no reason to be. She was 17 years old in a town she knew at a gas station she'd been to a hundred times. Zalle: Yes. And so Alexis missed her eleven PM curfew. Her grandmother Gail woke up at 120 in the morning and knew immediately that something was wrong. The porch light was still on. Nicholle: I can feel that in my body. I have experienced that. It is terrifying. Luckily, it was never this. You Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: know, it's that feeling in your gut when you just know. Gail had that feeling. Zalle: Make something's wrong. Nicholle: Yeah. She called Alexis' phone, no answer. She called again, nothing. The family reported her missing and the Nelson County Sheriff's Office jumped on it. Fast. Zalle: They used the Find My iPhone app, which pinged her iPhone to a place called Oak Ridge Estate, a forty eight hundred acre property in Arrington, Virginia. Search teams swarmed the area dead end. The phone had been ditched or someone was messing with them. Nicholle: Then on August 6th, three days after she vanished, her white Nissan Maxima turned up. It was sitting in a Carmike Theater parking lot in Carmorl County, about twenty miles from Lovingston. Surveillance from a nearby armed forces recruiting station caught the car pulling in around 10 PM on Sunday, August 4th. Zalle: So her car showed up a full day after she disappears in a movie theater parking lot with no sign of Alexis. And here's where the case breaks wide open. Nicholle: Lead investigator Lieutenant Billy Mays was on the case from hour one. and by Monday, August 5th, less than forty-eight hours after Alexis went missing, Mays was face to face with Randy Taylor. Mays would later describe that first meeting in a way that still gives me chills. He said, quote, I don't know how to explain it in words. Just bad. He had a bad aura about him. Evil to say the least. Zalle: Mays showed Taylor a photo of Alexis. Taylor claimed he'd never seen her, didn't know her, had no idea who she was, but Mays had already seen the surveillance footage. He'd seen Taylor hold the door for her. He knew Taylor was lying, and by Monday afternoon, Randy Taylor was their prime suspect. Nicholle: On August 7th, investigators executed a search warrant on Taylor's camper, a cramped, dirty trailer off Route 29 in Lovingston. And what they found inside was a horror show of forensic evidence: a torn fingernail embedded in the carpet, a stud earring, strands of hair. Zalle: And the earring turned out to be her lip ring. It wasn't an actual earring. Nicholle: Mm, okay. Zalle: And so Lieutenant Mays said the lip ring didn't concern him as much because lip rings fall out. But the fingernail that was torn, ripped from the nail bed, and May said, quote, to me, it indicates something violent took place. Within 36 hours, FBI DNA analysis confirmed it. The hair, the fingernail, the lip ring, all Alexis Murphy's. Nicholle: But they weren't done. After Taylor's arrest, they went back for a second search. And under the couch, balled up and hidden, they found the blue Miller Light t shirt Taylor was wearing in the gas station surveillance video. Zalle: And inside that shirt, her false eyelashes, her press on eyelashes, gobs of hair extensions that had been weaved into her hair, all of it rolled up inside his shirt like a s like a souvenir. Mays believed Taylor was keeping trophies. He said, quote, people like that like to keep souvenirs of some sort, and I don't think he had any intention of getting rid of any of it. He literally had it stuffed like under up in his couch. Nicholle: Mm. Zalle: Just balled up in the shirt. Nicholle: Then on August 14th, specially trained dogs, dogs that can smell the glue inside cell phones, found Alexis' white iPhone in the grass, 70 to 80 feet from the front door of Taylor's camper, May said, quote, it's just, it it made the hair stand up on my neck. I couldn't believe it. Zalle: But the physical evidence was only half the story. The other half was Randy Taylor's movements in the hours and days after Alexis disappeared. On August 3rd at 5 21 PM, before Alexis even got to the gas station, surveillance from an adult sex shop called Ultimate Bliss in Charlottesville shows Taylor buying two videos. Nicholle: Then on the night of August 4th, the same night Alexis' car showed up at the movie theater, Taylor walks into an Applebee's near that theater. He's sweating, he orders two Heinegans, and he asks the bartender to call him a cab. he tells her his buddy was passed out outside. Zalle: But the bartender never saw anyone else. Nobody, no passenger, just Randy Taylor, sweating, drinking alone, and needing a ride out of there. The cab took him to Woods Mill, about three miles north of his camper. Why was he near the theater where Alexis' car was dumped? Why was he sweating? What had he just done? Nicholle: Those are questions that would haunt the investigation for the next seven years. Zalle: Randy Taylor was arrested on august eleventh, twenty thirteen, just eight days after Alexis vanished. He was charged with abduction. But by January 2014, a grand jury had indicted him on first degree murder, felony murder, and abduction with intent to defile. Nicholle: Here's the thing, they were going to trial without a body. In Virginia, at the time, there had been only one murder conviction without a body in the entire history of the state. The trial began on May 1, 2014, in Nelson County Circuit Court. Judge Michael Gamble presided. The Commonwealth's attorney, Anthony Martin, led the prosecution, and Michael Hall Hallahan defended Taylor. Zalle: The prosecution laid out the forensic evidence piece by piece, the DNA, the hair, the bloody shirt. They showed the jury surveillance footage of Taylor holding the door for Alexis, and they showed his suburban pulling out, followed by her Nissan. Nicholle: And then there was the defense. Taylor's story, the only story he ever told, was that Alexis showed up at his camper with another man named Damien Brown. They were there to buy a marijuana, and then they left together. Callahan argued that law enforcement never fully investigated Damian Brown, who left the state shortly after Alexis disappeared. He even floated the theory that Alexis might have been trafficked. Zalle: The jury didn't buy it. On May 8, 2014, they found Randy Taylor guilty on first degree murder in the commission of an abduction and abduction with intent to defile. Alexis' aunt, Angela Taylor, spoke to reporters outside the courthouse. She said, quote, this has been a terrible nightmare our family has had to deal with because of his actions. It doesn't end today. Nicholle: She was right. It didn't end. Zalle: On July twenty-third, twenty fourteen, Randy Taylor was sentenced to two life terms in prison. But before the judge handed down the sentence, something happened that tells you everything you need to know about who Randy Taylor really is. Nicholle: Through his attorney, Taylor offered a deal. He would reveal the location of Alexis Murphy's body, the thing her family had been begging for, but only if the judge reduced his sentence to about 20 years. He was willing to give up her body for a deal, for a reduced sentence. He was still negotiating, still playing games, and still holding her family high. Zalle: Prosecution rejected it. The Murphy family rejected it. And Judge Gamble imposed the full sentence, two life terms, no parole. Taylor appealed. The Virginia Court of Appeals denied him in May twenty fifteen. The Supreme Court of Virginia denied him in february twenty sixteen. Randy Taylor went to Red Onion State Prison, Virginia's Supermax to ride. Nicholle: But even from behind bars with two life sentences and no hope of parole, Randy Taylor would not stop talking. And what he had to say, well, you co-conspirators can decide for yourselves whether you believe a word of it. Zalle: I would hope that Alexis is alive. When she left my property, she was fine and dandy. That's what he said. From prison, after a jury convicted him of her murder, after the judge gave him two life sentences, after DNA, a torn fingernail, her hair, her eyelashes, and her phone were all found on his property. Fine and dandy. Nicholle: He also claimed the evidence was planted, that there was a third party, that he never offered to reveal her body for a reduced sentence, despite court records and multiple witnesses saying he did. He even tried to float Jesse Matthew as a possible suspect, which DNA test later ruled out completely. Zalle: But Alexis was still out there somewhere. Nicholle: For more than seven years the Murphy family had nobody to bury, no grave to visit, no closure. They held vigils, they kept her bedroom the same, and they repeated her words like a prayer. Keep hope alive. Zalle: Then in october twenty twenty something changed. Authorities transported Randy Taylor from Red Onion State Prison back to Nelson County, and for the first time since his conviction, he talked. He led investigators to a spot on private property near Stage Bridge Road along Route twenty nine in Lovingston. It was on the side of a mountain, about four miles north of his old camper, and there, buried in the earth. Were the remains of Alexis Thiera Murphy. Nicholle: The medical examiner positively identified her on February 5th, 2021. The family was notified and on February 17, 2021, Nelson County Sheriff David Hill made the announcement to the public. Delayed, he said, to forgive the family. Delayed, he said, to give the family time to grieve and make arrangements. Zalle: And here's the thing that still gets me. the Commonwealth's attorney made it crystal clear. There was no deal, no reduced sentence, no negotiation. Taylor gave up the location of her body and he got absolutely nothing in return. They said, quote, we don't negotiate with murderers, and you should not. Nicholle: You should not. But they did but they did give one more chance, but they did give one more piece of information. The medical examiner's report confirmed what Taylor finally admitted. Alexis Murphy had been suffocated, not strangled, as Lieutenant Mays had long believed. Suffocated. Held down, smothered, until she stopped fighting. Zalle: The poor baby. The Murphy family released a statement when the remains were found. I want to read part of it because I think it says everything about who they are. Nicholle: Our family is so grateful for the continuing love, support, and prayers for Alexis and our family over the past seven years. While we have been grieving the loss of Alexis since 2013, We remained hopeful that she would be found alive and well. Alexis was the fashionista, athlete, and joker of our family. We were blessed to have loved her for 17 years. And her memory will continue to live on through us. Through us all, our family would like to extend our heartfelt thanks and sincere gratitude to the citizens of Nelson County, the FBI, the Virginia State Police, the Nelson County Sheriff's Office, and all the search and rescue teams for your commitment and unwavering support to find Alexis. You all kept the promise made in 2013 to bring Alexis home. During this time, we ask that you continue to lift our family up in prayer. And in the words of Alexis, keep hope alive. Zalle: Alexis's aunt, Trina Murphy, later said something that I think is one of the most powerful things I've ever heard in a true crime case. She said she was able to forgive Randy Taylor. Nicholle: Forgiveness after everything, after the lies, the trial, the seven years of not knowing, the games he was playing. She forgave him. That's the kind of family Alexis Murphy came from. That's the kind of love she was surrounded by. And that's what makes what was taken from them so unspeakably cruel. Before we get to our opinions, there's one more thread we have to pull because Randy Taylor didn't just take Alexis Murphy. In 2010, three years before Alexis disappeared, a nineteen year old woman named Samantha Clark vanished from her mother's home in Orange County, Virginia. She was last known to have spoken with Randy Taylor. Phone records showed he called her six times the night she disappeared. Zalle: Six times. Taylor claimed he was just warning her about another man's criminal history. That's suspicious. Nicholle: Mm. Zalle: But Orange County police had been suspicious of him from the beginning. They even put a tracking device on his car in twenty eleven. He found it, sued the police, and the charges against him were dropped. In January of twenty twenty one, just weeks after Alexis's remains were identified. Orange County reclassified Samantha's case from a missing person's investigation to an abduction and homicide investigation. Nicholle: Randy Taylor has never been charged in Samantha Clark's disappearance. Her body has never been found. And Chief James Spinwick has said, quote, We know there's likely information that has not been shared. Zalle: Samantha's mother, Barbara, still keeps her daughter's prom pi her her daughter's prom photo as her Facebook profile picture. She told Dateline, I miss her smiles, her laughs, the funny things she would say to make me laugh. She's a happy girl. She would always stay happy. And if you were sad, she'd find a way to make you happy. Nicholle: Two girls, two families, and one monster. And one case that's still not fully closed. Zalle: Okay, co-conspirators. So that's the story. That's what happened to Alexis Murphy. And now we want to take a minute to give you our thoughts because this case, more than a lot of cases we've covered, really sticks with us. Nicholle: I don't even know where to start. I feel like it sounds like everybody that was investigating this case worked really hard and I'm so glad that not only were they able to find Alexis's body, but they're were able to link him back to Samantha's case. Hopefully they'll be able to find her somewhere one day. I just think this man is a monster and the fact that He was playing with the family and the system, offering to tell them where her body was, to get a reduced Zalle: Right. Nicholle: sentence of like twenty years. You know, that's ridiculous. And it shows you the kind of smarmy, ruthless, heartless individual he is. Zalle: Yeah, he was definitely scum. Scum. And then w the man that he pointed at, the Damian Brown, he was a young man. He wasn't that much older than Alexis at the time and he worked at what, a burger shop or a McDonalds Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: n connected or near the gas station. And that's how Taylor even knew who this man was. He didn't actually know him. They didn't know each other. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: He just was trying to point people in other directions. And same thing when he tried to throw that other person under the bus Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: and the whole time you were guilty. And when I was watching the HBO like doc you little episode they have about Alexis, they were saying that it really didn't matter what he did. All the evidence just kept pointing to him. And even after they found the hair there and the nail and the lip ring, he still was like, Yeah, that had nothing to do with me. And that was when he was like, Yeah, she came with somebody else. Cause at first he didn't say any of that. So he's garbage. And the police think that that whole part where the camera got, her turning around like somebody called her name and then walking to his truck, they believe Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: that he told her, you know, hey, do you want some weed? I sell weed or whatever. And so the Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: reason why she was following Kim back to the place was to buy weed from him before she went to go see whatever friend she was supposed to be going to see after that. And Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: the poor baby lost her life over that. Nicholle: I know, it's so sad. It's so sad. Alexis Tiara Murphy was 17 years old. She loved volleyball, she loved her hair, she loved making people laugh, and she should have graduated from Nelson County High School in twenty fourteen. her family received her diploma posthumously. Zalle: Randy Allen Taylor is currently serving two life sentences at Red Onion State Prison in Wise County, Virginia. He has maintained his innocence. No one believes him. Nicholle: Right, because now you've told us where her body we found her body. Zalle: We know where her body is. Right. How you innocent, but okay. Nicholle: If you have information about the disappearance of Samantha Clark, please contact the Orange County Police Department. Zalle: And if anything you heard today has affected you, please don't carry it along. Reach out to someone you trust and look up local victim services and crisis resources in your area. There are people who want to help. Nicholle: Thanks so much for being here today, co conspirators. whether you're on your morning commute, folding that mountain of laundry, or just need something to listen to while you drink your third cup of. Zalle: We see you, we appreciate you, and we are so glad you press play. Nicholle: Keep plotting, keep questioning, and we'll see you next week. Bye. That's Zalle: Howdy. Nicholle: hello.