Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Mutiny on the Bounty (1935)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. You ready to get nautical?
- 0:22Oh yeah. Yeah. We actually, so a little peek
- 0:27behind the curtain, we are filming three episodes
- 0:30today and two of which we're getting nautical.
- 0:33We are getting nautical. And you know what? I
- 0:36think this week actually we start getting nautical.
- 0:39This week we start. Oh, yes. Like in the releases.
- 0:43That's right. It's true. We got a lot to talk
- 0:46about in terms of sea sailing. And let me ask
- 0:50you this. Let's just go ahead and get this right
- 0:51off the bat. Not really applicable for this movie,
- 0:54but how do you feel about pirates? So I love
- 0:57pirates. Like I think just like any other growing
- 1:00young lad. So of Penzance fans? Oh, yeah. Okay.
- 1:05Caribbean? Big fan. What if they don't do anything?
- 1:09Pirates? Yeah. Like a day in the life of a pirate?
- 1:13This is how I know you didn't grow up a Christian.
- 1:16Because you don't know I'm talking about VeggieTales,
- 1:19the pirates who don't do anything. Oh, yeah,
- 1:21I've never veggied. Egg on your face. Tomato,
- 1:25maybe. Yeah, I made a face, and then you made
- 1:30the noise for the face I was making. Perfect.
- 1:33Great job. Yeah, pirates. Pirates, man. You know...
- 1:37I am a little bummed out that I don't know more
- 1:40pirate stuff. Pirates is one of those things
- 1:42where I'm like, man, I wish they made more pirate
- 1:44movies because they're great. And then I look
- 1:46at the list of pirate movies I've seen and it's
- 1:48like, Jack Sparrow, more Jack Sparrow. That's
- 1:52true. That changes. I should see more. With this
- 1:54most recent research. That's true. This week
- 1:56has helped bump up my pirate numbers. That's
- 1:59true. With that said, not a ton of pirates in
- 2:02Mutiny on the Bounty. The idea of sea sailing,
- 2:06everything you come for a pirate movie for, the
- 2:08swashbuckling nature, that's still present in
- 2:11this. It's just not nearly as much of a pirate
- 2:15movie like others. This is more a, honestly,
- 2:18you know what it felt like? It felt like a submarine.
- 2:20Kind of like thriller, like a dramatic thriller.
- 2:22Yeah. Let me start with this. This is a big one.
- 2:25Yeah. Have you seen Mutiny on the Bounty before?
- 2:28This was my first time. Okay. Mine too. This
- 2:31is a movie that I've heard of for a very long
- 2:33time, but I haven't seen. And as soon as we started
- 2:36talking about doing this iteration of the podcast,
- 2:38it was like, well, I have to hold out to see
- 2:40Mutiny on the Bounty for the pod. Yeah. To have
- 2:42like first reactions. And not like it's that
- 2:44good or anything, but it's just I've heard so
- 2:46much about it. So I wanted to kind of hold it.
- 2:48I don't know if you felt the same way. Yeah,
- 2:50it's and I don't even know if it's just this
- 2:53version of this movie, but like Mutiny on the
- 2:55Bounty has been done multiple times over. There's
- 2:58a Marlon Brando version that we'll be watching
- 2:59eventually. I think came out in the 50s. But
- 3:03yeah, this is just like one of those stories
- 3:05that has been told over and over again. So I'm
- 3:09with you. Like this has kind of like a notoriety
- 3:12to it. Where I've been interested, but I have
- 3:15been holding off specifically for the pod. Well,
- 3:18it has the notoriety behind it, but also this
- 3:21iteration of the movie does have that notoriety.
- 3:24Because not only is it Charles Lawton, but it
- 3:27pairs Charles Lawton with Clark Gable. Yes, it
- 3:30does. Which is kind of like a clash of two separate
- 3:33titans of what we've covered on this podcast.
- 3:35One of charm and wit, and another of dramatic
- 3:39gravitas, if you will. Yeah, for sure. So I was
- 3:42very excited to see that kind of a blending of
- 3:45two different acting styles. And it certainly
- 3:48has some results. So today we're talking about
- 3:50Mutiny on the Bounty. And we previously mentioned
- 3:53on the Informer episode kind of a recounting
- 3:56of how many nominations each movie has received.
- 3:59And Lives of a Bengalancer had seven nominations.
- 4:03We are now surpassing that with eight nominations
- 4:05for Mutiny on the Bounty. This had a nomination
- 4:09for music score for Herbert Stothart, film editing
- 4:13for Margaret Booth. The screenplay was for Talbot
- 4:17Jennings, Jules Ferdman, and Carrie Wilson. Actor,
- 4:21and this is strange. Yeah, it is. There are three
- 4:24best actor nominations for this movie. The first
- 4:27is for French O'Tone. The second is for Charles
- 4:30Lawton. And the third for Clark Gable. The Best
- 4:33Director nomination was for Frank Lloyd, and
- 4:35Outstanding Production was on behalf of Metro
- 4:38-Goldwyn -Mayer MGM. Yeah, so this was directed
- 4:41by Frank Lloyd, who we've dealt with previously
- 4:43with Cavalcade, and what was the other one? I
- 4:47just want to step in real quick. You said we've
- 4:49dealt with him? Yeah, we have. Like he's in a
- 4:51gutter somewhere? He's taken care of. Oh, East
- 4:57Lynn. East Lynn is the other movie. Of course,
- 4:58yeah. I kind of like Eastland well enough. I
- 5:06would say that I like Eastland more than I did
- 5:09Cavalcade, but it's still complicated. Cavalcade
- 5:11has a history of being known as one of the worst
- 5:14Best Picture winners of all time, so it does
- 5:17have that going against it. But we have Frank
- 5:19Lloyd here again, and I think that... We'll go
- 5:22into this agreeing, this might be his best outing
- 5:25yet. Of those three, absolutely. Yeah. So, honestly,
- 5:28my list of actors here, you've already named
- 5:31during the nominations. Charles Lawton, Clark
- 5:33Gable, and French O'Tone, all nominated for Best
- 5:36Actor, which is wild. And there's some things
- 5:39we can get into with that. I will say that Charles
- 5:41Lawton portrays Captain Bly, Clark Gable is Fletcher
- 5:45Christian, and French O'Tone is Roger Byam. Thing
- 5:50that's interesting about this is right off the
- 5:52bat, three actor nominations. Yeah. And that's
- 5:55because at the time there was no supporting actor
- 5:57nominee or, you know, award category. Thank you.
- 6:01That's the word. You got it. So this is the only
- 6:04film that ever received three nominations for
- 6:06best actor to this day. Because of that, the
- 6:09Academy does go on to introduce the best supporting
- 6:12actor Oscar. So that will exist in the future.
- 6:16I don't want to say this is exactly like the
- 6:18reason they're like, hey, because of Meeting
- 6:19on the Bounty. Is it? I'll tell you it is. Is
- 6:22it really? Next year we get the best supporting
- 6:23actor category. There you go. So it probably
- 6:26is. That's so interesting to me because I do
- 6:29like Roger Byam, the character, a lot in this.
- 6:31And Franchotone does a great job. But when you're
- 6:34talking about like keeping up with the stature.
- 6:39of someone like Charles Lawton and Clark Gable,
- 6:41that is quite a feat to get a nomination alongside
- 6:44them. But, I mean, I think we both agree, if
- 6:47Best Supporting Actor existed here, that would
- 6:49be the Franchotone nomination. Yeah, and if that
- 6:52were the case, like, I think that's definitely
- 6:54the category he deserves to be in. Do you think
- 6:56we would still get two best actors? I do. Yeah.
- 6:59Because I think that it is as much Charles Lawton's
- 7:01movie as it is. Maybe it's a little more Charles
- 7:04Lawton than Clark Gable. But, I mean, the whole
- 7:07mutiny is brought on by Clark Gable. That's true.
- 7:11You kind of have two sides of the same coin.
- 7:13And then there's also Roger. But, I mean, Roger's
- 7:15a big part of the movie, not to say he's not.
- 7:17No, yeah. And I think Franchotone is doing incredible
- 7:19work in it. Absolutely. So you mentioned the
- 7:22screenplay. This was adapted from a classic book,
- 7:25Mutiny on the Bounty, and its sequel, Men Against
- 7:28the Sea, by Charles Nordhoff and James Norman
- 7:30Hall. Again, this is a story that's going to
- 7:33be adapted time and time again. I've never dealt
- 7:36with any iteration of this story. I read that
- 7:41this takes some liberties with that story. I
- 7:44didn't really dive into what those liberties
- 7:46were because... We're not really judging the
- 7:49books. We're judging the movies. So whatever
- 7:51we get from this movie, that's what we're going
- 7:53by. I'm not familiar with the book. I really
- 7:56am only familiar with the movie. But the synopsis
- 7:58of this is that the ship, the bounty, is taking
- 8:02sail and bringing on multiple people. And in
- 8:05that process, we are introduced to three individuals.
- 8:08Roger Byam, who is a new recruit. Fletcher Christian,
- 8:11who's kind of the first man. I would take, or
- 8:14first mate, to the captain, who is Captain Bly,
- 8:17played by Charles Lawton. We see the overall
- 8:20process of what the wear and tear of this expedition
- 8:24does multiple years in sea, trying to recover
- 8:28resources for England. And in the process, Captain
- 8:31Bly is absolutely taking advantage of his crew
- 8:36and doesn't respect them. And Fletcher Christian
- 8:38has had enough, and he calls a mutiny on the
- 8:41bounty. This is a general synopsis. So what did
- 8:45you think? Overall, before we dive into the specifics
- 8:49here of Mutiny on the Bounty. When the movie
- 8:51started, I was excited. I was so thrilled. Because,
- 8:56like you said, this is a movie we've heard about
- 8:58forever. And it's, like, nautical. There's ships,
- 9:01and I'm thinking, okay, there's going to be sword
- 9:04fights. There's going to be cannon fights. And
- 9:08I think the vibe, the vibe, the aesthetic and
- 9:12everything of the movie, yeah, the vibe. Lit.
- 9:15Yeah, it is. It's lit, you know? They're all
- 9:17hanging out. They're drinking rum. Dope, bro.
- 9:19I don't think anybody's drinking rum. But I like
- 9:22the setup for the movie. I like that a lot of
- 9:24the crew were just people hanging out in town
- 9:27and they just get recruited. I forget what the
- 9:30specific word for that is. They're like, okay,
- 9:33you're part of the King's service now. I'd say
- 9:35it's a draft, but it really is just kind of like,
- 9:37you better not be in the room that Fletcher Christian
- 9:40comes in. Right. Like, by the way, you're in
- 9:42my team now. Yeah. I forget what they called
- 9:44it. It was like port scraping or something where
- 9:47they just scoop up people. And they almost literally
- 9:49did that. Yeah. Like, hey, my wife's pregnant
- 9:52and we're going to have our first child. Well,
- 9:53see him in two years. Yeah. He's like, cool.
- 9:55You can tell him you were on a ship. But I think
- 9:59the setup there is beautiful because you have
- 10:01all of these people who really don't want to
- 10:03be there. And instead of kind of being persuaded
- 10:07with, look, there's going to be adventure, you'll
- 10:09get paid, they end up on this ship. And Charles
- 10:13Lawton's character, Captain Bly, is maybe one
- 10:16of the biggest villains we've experienced on
- 10:18the show so far. Yes. I mean, he is notorious
- 10:22for, what is the word, lashing his men. with
- 10:27a whip for like the most minor error on their
- 10:31parts. One of the punishments he enacts is keel
- 10:34hauling, where he ties up one of the men and
- 10:38throws them off the back of the ship and just
- 10:40drags them in the water for a second. Like he's,
- 10:42he's terrible. He's awful. And I think all of
- 10:45the setup for this is great. I think once the
- 10:48mutiny approached, it's a little lackluster.
- 10:52And that kind of brought down my rating a little
- 10:55bit. I think, well, let me ask you how you felt
- 10:58before I go through the whole movie. Yeah, so
- 11:01I feel the same way. I think that as things were
- 11:03ramping up, like with the name of the movie,
- 11:06I think it kind of looms over the story a little
- 11:09bit. So you're kind of just waiting for the mutiny.
- 11:12Right. But also it's from the get go. We hear
- 11:14like how Captain Bly is this monster and very
- 11:17difficult to deal with. But you still see Fletcher
- 11:20Christian like, you know, yeah, we can handle
- 11:21it. No problem. I agree. I think the setup is
- 11:25exciting. And I was very I was very much looking
- 11:29forward to a movie that was pretty practically
- 11:32filmed. Right. I mean, a lot of filming on the
- 11:34soundstage of like a water tank and everything.
- 11:37But for the most part, they're on a ship. They're
- 11:39on a ship that's on water and it is moving. And
- 11:42there are some moments where it's just like,
- 11:43it is what you want to see in a movie. It is
- 11:46what you want to see when you're watching a movie
- 11:48about a crew on a ship. And I really enjoyed
- 11:51that. And I actually enjoyed the character work
- 11:54between. Roger, Fletcher, and Captain Bly. I
- 11:59think there was a nice little, there was a nice
- 12:01tension between someone on a lower level of the
- 12:04ship as Roger speaking with Fletcher, and then
- 12:08Fletcher speaking to Captain Bly. And you kind
- 12:10of see the balance of like what Fletcher has
- 12:12to deal with. And I think that work did really
- 12:15well. I thought that all three actors did a pretty
- 12:17fantastic job. But I agree with you, towards
- 12:20the end of this, it just got to be a little more...
- 12:23I don't know. I looked up some behind the scenes
- 12:25on this, and it kind of makes me think a little
- 12:26bit more that the whole idea of them landing
- 12:28in Tahiti was kind of like, we need to keep Clark
- 12:31Gable interested in this movie. Right. So that
- 12:35whole expedition to Tahiti and them going back
- 12:38and leaving and going back felt a little bit
- 12:40like unnecessary to the story. Right. And I don't
- 12:44know if that is the added content you mentioned
- 12:46that wasn't in the book. But to me, it just felt
- 12:48like that dragged the movie down a little bit.
- 12:51It's still allowed, and I appreciate this, some
- 12:53good character work. Like you get to see Roger
- 12:56kind of becoming more of a scholar of the area
- 12:59that he's in and the people that he's living
- 13:01with. And you get to see a little bit of a love
- 13:03interest from Clark Gable and his partner that
- 13:07he chooses on the island. But outside of that,
- 13:10it just kind of felt like this is a little too
- 13:12long than it should be. So I agree with you.
- 13:14It is, I don't want to say expertly made. It
- 13:17is extremely well made. And I enjoyed that aspect
- 13:20a lot. And I thought the acting was great. It's
- 13:22just long in the tooth. And there are segments
- 13:25that just don't feel like they belong. They drag
- 13:27quite a bit. Yeah. The Tahiti sections are really
- 13:30the big moments that feel just like filler and
- 13:33drag. And I wonder if that is an effort to bring
- 13:37like a variety of audiences in because you do
- 13:40get like a love story, even if it is kind of
- 13:43forced and maybe a little bit. problematic at
- 13:46times because like you said it's Christian and
- 13:49and Byam kind of just choose their wives on the
- 13:52island yeah and these are two actors uh the characters
- 13:56are Tahani and Maimiti played by Movida Castaneda
- 14:00and Momo Clark and like all of these sections
- 14:03really are fine it's it's just a complete drag
- 14:07because you have the mutiny that takes place
- 14:09and and even that feels like such a small piece
- 14:13of the movie in comparison to what comes before
- 14:16it, but even smaller in comparison to the Tahiti
- 14:20section that is kind of just a snooze. Yeah,
- 14:24it's... So the reason I say Clark Gable is that
- 14:28I read that Clark Gable wasn't very interested
- 14:30in making this movie. I know there's a pretty
- 14:33big disinterest of working with someone like
- 14:35Charles Lawton. I know that Clark Gable was known
- 14:39to be a little homophobic in that sense. And
- 14:42even though he's married to Elsa Lanchester,
- 14:44Charles Lawton had homosexual tendencies. I guess
- 14:47the best way to put it. I know he had partners.
- 14:50he was a little hesitant to work on this movie.
- 14:53I have a feeling that the idea of introducing
- 14:55Tahiti and, you know, finding wives on Tahiti
- 14:59was an aspect of, we got to keep someone interested
- 15:02in this production because you never see Charles
- 15:05Lawton on Tahiti. He just stays on the ship.
- 15:08Right. And other people will leave. So to me,
- 15:10it just, you can feel it being extra and you
- 15:13can feel it even not knowing the context of that.
- 15:15It just feels like it kind of elongates the movie
- 15:17for not a great reason. Right. It does provide
- 15:21the context of what Fletcher Christian goes on
- 15:23to do later on in the story. But outside of that,
- 15:27it just feels, like you said, filler. Yeah. It's
- 15:29not fantastic. It's really a drag. You know,
- 15:31and I mentioned before we started recording that
- 15:34I did some research and I was kind of bummed
- 15:36at things that I found out with this movie. Going
- 15:39into this, I didn't know that Charles Lawton
- 15:41was a homosexual, was queer. Yes. And I certainly
- 15:47didn't know that Clark Gable was homophobic.
- 15:49So this was one of those moments where I'm doing
- 15:51my research and I'm like, oh, well, but I like
- 15:54Clark Gable. Don't meet your heroes, man. Or
- 15:58don't watch more than two movies from your heroes,
- 16:00man. Let's take a quick break from Mutiny on
- 16:03the Bounty and have a conversation about that.
- 16:04How do you feel about separating the art from
- 16:07the artist? So I think it depends on the media,
- 16:10for one. If it is something that is... made by
- 16:14a singular person, I have a real hard time with
- 16:17that. Because to me, that is them. That is their
- 16:19project. Right. I think movies are one of those
- 16:22where I have an easier time because it is such
- 16:24a compilation of effort. But I certainly very
- 16:29quickly start losing interest in the individual,
- 16:32regardless of how good the project is. This is
- 16:36one of those examples where I'm like, ugh. Yeah.
- 16:40It's like a... How do I put that? It's like a
- 16:43thumbtack in cereal. Yeah. When you're just like,
- 16:46yeah, the cereal's good, but man, that thumbtack
- 16:48just kind of takes me out of it. One bad thumbtack
- 16:51spoils the whole bunch, is what I always say.
- 16:53And that's a bad... It's a bad metaphor for me
- 16:57to make because that's not how I feel. I feel
- 16:58like I can enjoy a movie even with like a problematic
- 17:00individual that's involved in the movie. Right.
- 17:03And you know, that's the ones we know about.
- 17:05Like there's a lot of scenarios in the movies
- 17:07we're watching at that time period where there
- 17:09are individuals that have mindsets that don't
- 17:12reflect more of a progressive nature of where
- 17:13we are now. Right. So that's difficult. And I
- 17:16agree with you. Like, you know, we as a country
- 17:19used to listen to R. Kelly all the time. And
- 17:22then the allegations came out and the case came
- 17:24out. And I'm generally of the belief of like,
- 17:27I can separate art from the artist. There is
- 17:29so much of his cases and his like alleged nature.
- 17:33I mean, it's true. It's what happened. Right.
- 17:35But like so much of that crime in his music that
- 17:39when I went back and heard it, I was like, oh,
- 17:40no, that's there. Right. That is who he is. And
- 17:43he was saying that. And we just didn't listen.
- 17:45So I have to turn that off. So there are some
- 17:48that you can't because that is just so ingrained
- 17:51in their. character i guess is the best way to
- 17:54put it or like what you listen to them for yeah
- 17:56with movies the whole idea is that they are portraying
- 17:59a different character so you can kind of get
- 18:01you know not them from that role even if it's
- 18:04them so i agree with you with a movie it's it's
- 18:08the this the whole of it and not just the the
- 18:11individual parts right right and i mean for for
- 18:15you listeners i know that this is kind of like
- 18:17a controversial Some people are like, yeah, I
- 18:21can separate the art from the artist. That's
- 18:22fine. And some people can't do it. And that's
- 18:25fine. I totally understand that. There are some
- 18:28people where if there is one actor who is problematic,
- 18:32like that is off limits. That movie is now gone
- 18:35to them. Right. And I totally understand that.
- 18:37And I want to take the time to say, like, we're
- 18:41going to come into contact with this a lot. And
- 18:45not to like put levels on these controversies
- 18:48and things, but this is very minor in comparison
- 18:50to some of the things we're going to cover later
- 18:52on. There's, I think, at least two Roman Polanski
- 18:57movies that we're going to be covering. And those
- 18:59are going to be, you know. Woody Allen will come
- 19:00up. Yeah, yeah. It's all going to be very, very
- 19:03contentious and difficult to speak about and
- 19:06probably harder to listen to for a lot of people.
- 19:10That's right. But just know that like we do.
- 19:13condemn all of this behavior it's just you every
- 19:18best picture nominee from 1927 to today that's
- 19:21right a lot a lot comes in between that and i
- 19:24guess the best way to put it is just you know
- 19:26both in pod and off pod just don't live with
- 19:29hate yeah just live your life don't worry about
- 19:32what other people are doing maybe be more supportive
- 19:34of every individual and what that's going through
- 19:37in their lives and then we'll get through it
- 19:39otherwise We have a responsibility to cover these
- 19:43movies and the good and bad that comes with it.
- 19:46So, I think you and I are pretty clear on where
- 19:48we stand on things. And the best way to put it
- 19:51is just don't live with hate. That's the biggest
- 19:53thing. Absolutely. Now, I do want to dive pretty
- 19:56quickly into Charles Lawton in this movie. Okay,
- 19:59cool. That's better than what I was going to
- 20:00say. What were you going to say? I was going
- 20:02to live with hate and bash Clark Gable. Clark
- 20:05Gable's no mustache look. Yeah. So, okay. Let's
- 20:08start there. So, start. 20 minutes of the pod.
- 20:12Let's continue there. So Clark Gable, well known
- 20:15for his mustache. You know, he just came off
- 20:17of It Happened One Night. And he has to shave
- 20:19this off. Because to be accurate to the time
- 20:23and the scenario of being an Englishman on sea,
- 20:28he can't have a mustache. No facial hair. Right.
- 20:31Right. And he looks... You want to just go ahead
- 20:34and say it? He looks awful. It looks so weird.
- 20:36Yeah. Like it doesn't, I mean, he's Clark Gable
- 20:38very clearly. Yeah. I shouldn't say it looks
- 20:40awful. And again, I feel bad being like, yeah,
- 20:43I really lost all, all respect, you know, for
- 20:47the behavior of Clark Gable in this movie. He
- 20:48was very mean to Charles Lawton. Also his mustache
- 20:51was terrible, terrible, but like, you know, it
- 20:55feels very mean girls. It does. But in, it happened
- 20:57one night, like. he he is a very attractive man
- 21:02he's very smooth and charming red butler what
- 21:05he goes on to do yeah which i'm kind of unfamiliar
- 21:07with but i know like he's well known for he has
- 21:10the mustache spoiler but like all of that that
- 21:15beauty and charm is completely gone in this performance
- 21:18to me that mustache is is the The sign seal and
- 21:23deliver. Oh, that's interesting. For me, I still
- 21:25thought it was a good performance from him until
- 21:28they get to Tahiti. When they get to Tahiti,
- 21:30it just feels kind of like I was able to find
- 21:34someone who I now am in love with. So now I'm
- 21:39standing up for all my fellow men. Right. Because
- 21:41before that, it's kind of like, guys, you got
- 21:43to listen to the captain. You got to do what
- 21:44he says. And yeah, sometimes he's unfair, but
- 21:47that's just who he is. And it's like he found
- 21:49his morality on Tahiti. right and it doesn't
- 21:52that doesn't really make a lot of sense to me
- 21:53he watched people be beat and killed and he's
- 21:56like yeah but duty calls and then he sees a woman
- 22:01now he can be separated from the woman and he's
- 22:03like no that doesn't fly he's like i have found
- 22:05my tender nature yeah it's like all right man
- 22:08and and to clarify i don't think he's his performance
- 22:12is bad in this movie yes i just think that like
- 22:15the charm is gone yeah the fawning that i did
- 22:18during it happened one night That is gone. Okay,
- 22:21fair. Yeah, I don't think I did a lot of fawning
- 22:23in this movie. No, not for him. That's, well,
- 22:26no, never mind. We'll talk about that on the
- 22:28next episode. There was someone that I was like,
- 22:30oh, look at that. But, well, not even the way
- 22:32you think. There's a little cliffhanger for everybody.
- 22:37I liked him fine. I think his performance is
- 22:39great in this. I really like, I don't understand
- 22:43the morality play from him in Tahiti. But I think
- 22:47when he starts standing up for his crewmates.
- 22:50That's when I was really invested in his story.
- 22:52Right. And I was invested in what was happening.
- 22:54Which is probably when the crew started investing
- 22:56in it, too. That's true. They're like, yeah,
- 22:57us too, Fletcher. But honestly, I think kind
- 23:01of, I know I said this as a supporting actor
- 23:03thing, but I think that the majority of the story
- 23:05and the morality comes from Roger Byam. Frank
- 23:08O'Tone's performance. I think that early on,
- 23:12it's kind of easy to see him blend in with the
- 23:14background. Yeah. But as the story continues,
- 23:16you see him kind of like finding the balance
- 23:20between the anger and hatred and ruling under
- 23:23a Iron Fist. Iron Fist. Of Captain Bly. The best
- 23:29Netflix show. Exactly. Wow. Let it be known.
- 23:32Kyle thinks that Iron Fist is the best of the
- 23:34Defender series. We're talking problematic all
- 23:37over the place. Jesus. And then you have Fletcher,
- 23:42and Fletcher thinks that he is doing the right
- 23:44thing by issuing a mutiny to get Captain Bly
- 23:48and his supporters off of the ship. Right. And
- 23:51then you have Roger that's kind of like the middle
- 23:54ground of, well, what he did was wrong, but what
- 23:57we're doing is also technically wrong by the
- 23:59court of law. And by English law standards, this
- 24:03isn't right. Yeah. So it's an interesting, like...
- 24:07between the three of them. And that's why I think
- 24:09if you had to pick a movie that has three acting
- 24:12nominations for best actor, it makes sense that
- 24:16it's this one. So even if I don't love that movie,
- 24:19so to say, I still think that the acting is really
- 24:24top -notch between the three of them. Absolutely.
- 24:27I would say that my favorite performance in this
- 24:30movie overall, though, is Charles Lawton. Well,
- 24:32how can you not? He's... He is just chewing every
- 24:37scene he is in. He might be one of my favorite
- 24:41actors of the time. He's not been in all of our
- 24:45favorite movies. We're not lovers of Barretts
- 24:48of Wimple Street. Not big on Ruggles of Red Gap.
- 24:51But he's never really the problem in the movie
- 24:54to me. I know you were kind of lukewarm on Private
- 24:58Life of Henry VIII. But I really think he's always
- 25:01giving it his all. And I think in this, like,
- 25:04he's the perfect fit for this really, really
- 25:06strict tyrant of a captain. And I just had a
- 25:10lot of fun with him, even though he's awful.
- 25:13I won't say he's one of my favorite actors or
- 25:16my favorite actor, but I will say that he is
- 25:19certainly one of the best. I think that we have
- 25:22seen him do just about everything. Now, comedy,
- 25:25I mean, drama, clearly. And I think that he is
- 25:29the one that, regardless of who you put him with,
- 25:31he is... chewing scenery and he's not stealing
- 25:34the movie yeah he is supporting that individual
- 25:36um i think that les mis went a very long way
- 25:40in course correcting charles lawton to me sure
- 25:43of kind of understanding who he is it's not just
- 25:46the charles lawton show i think private lives
- 25:48of henry the eighth uh was kind of to me i mean
- 25:53first off let's go ahead and rip the bandit off
- 25:55i don't love a period piece sure like that had
- 25:57it going against it too but that's just for me
- 26:00Charles Lawton that felt like this is my movie
- 26:02and no one else can really have that. Now there's
- 26:05some signs of him being able to kind of balance
- 26:08that better with some of the wives that he had
- 26:11and balancing the screen time with them. But
- 26:14then as we went on, I was just kind of, yeah,
- 26:16this is just kind of what he does. And then Barrett's
- 26:18at Wimple Street. It didn't even feel like he
- 26:20was letting anyone else breathe in that movie.
- 26:22It was just him. Yeah. Les Mis was really like,
- 26:24oh, now I'm seeing like how even though it's
- 26:27not your story, you're not trying to take the
- 26:29lead on this. And it really is like the balance
- 26:31of your story versus Frederick March, your morality
- 26:34versus his morality, or rather your lack of morality
- 26:37to his morality. And that to me was like, oh,
- 26:41cool. I get Charles Lawton now. Yeah. This is
- 26:44the third movie that we've had to cover for this
- 26:47year. Is that right? So Les Mis, Ruggles of Red
- 26:49Gap, and Mutiny on the Bounty are the three movies
- 26:53that Charles Lawton starred in this year that
- 26:56were nominated. I'm sure he did even more. Just
- 26:58nonstop. Nonstop. And that's the thing. You can
- 27:01say, yeah, he did a lot of movies, sure. But
- 27:04when you look at the movies that he did, and
- 27:05three of those were nominated for Best Picture,
- 27:07and two of them are very good. Right. Then...
- 27:12It's hard to argue against that he's one of the
- 27:16best actors at this time. Yeah, that's a reoccurring
- 27:19thing for us, too, where an actor shows up and
- 27:21they're in a bunch of these Best Picture nominees
- 27:24in a single year. Wallace Berry did the same
- 27:26thing in the year that he was in Grand Hotel.
- 27:28I think that was the same year as The Champ and
- 27:31one other movie. I'm not going to flip back and
- 27:33look, but it keeps happening, you know? I will.
- 27:36You really want to know? You know who else did
- 27:39this? Una O 'Connor. Yeah, yeah, she shows up
- 27:42a lot. She can't stop showing up in these movies.
- 27:44Oh, only two. He did The Champ and Grand Hotel.
- 27:47Okay. Because I don't think he was in Shanghai
- 27:48Express. I would have loved to have seen that.
- 27:50Yeah, yeah. I do want to say, if we're going
- 27:53to talk about Charles Lawton in this movie, we
- 27:56got to talk about his monologue. You know what
- 27:57I mean? Yeah. I loved this monologue. When the
- 28:01mutiny happens and Fletcher and his team start
- 28:05finding all of the defenders of Captain Bly.
- 28:10They cast them all off onto a smaller ship. They
- 28:13give them all the resources they need, right?
- 28:15They're not trying to kill anyone. They just
- 28:17want to send them out and let the sea handle
- 28:19them, how it sees fit. No pun intended. And as
- 28:22they do that and they send them off, they all
- 28:25go to the back of the ship to watch them sail
- 28:27away. And as they do, I actually have the clip
- 28:30pulled, or the clip, the line pulled up here.
- 28:32Charles Lawton, as Captain William Bly says.
- 28:36casting me adrift 3 ,500 miles from a port of
- 28:39call. You're sending me to my doom, eh? Well,
- 28:42you're wrong, Christian. I'll take this boat
- 28:45as she floats to England if I must. I'll live
- 28:47to see you, all of you, hanging from the highest
- 28:50yardum in the British fleet. And... I'm not going
- 28:54to scream it the way that Charles Lawton does,
- 28:56but he screams it, especially when he's like,
- 28:58well, you're wrong. Yeah. Then screams the rest
- 29:02of it. And again, this is filmed pretty practically.
- 29:04So they are on a boat on like at least a body
- 29:07of water. I think it's a tank at this point,
- 29:09but they're on a body of water and he's shouting
- 29:12this at them as other people are just like rowing
- 29:16away. Yeah. And it is so good. It is so good,
- 29:21especially cutting back to see. Fletcher Christian
- 29:23just kind of be like, nah, whatever. Just kind
- 29:25of like write it off. It's one of those things
- 29:27where from his point of view, it's like, and
- 29:29don't you forget never. As he gets further and
- 29:32further in the distance. This is just Alvin and
- 29:34the Chipmunks -ing him. Yeah. Look, this was
- 29:37when I was, Charles Lawton is just chewing every
- 29:39scene he's in and he's so good. But that line
- 29:42specifically, that moment was like, yeah, this
- 29:44guy's got it. Yeah. You know, reading some behind
- 29:47the scenes, he was really intimidated about appearing
- 29:51alongside Clark Gable. Because again, Clark Gable
- 29:53is known as this heartthrob. And Charles Lawton,
- 29:56he doesn't see himself that way. He lived with
- 29:58a lot of body dysmorphia and things like that.
- 30:02So he lost 30 pounds for this role. Oh, because
- 30:05he wanted to portray the character exactly the
- 30:07way that he was. Right. So he felt he had to
- 30:10lose 30 pounds to do that. Well, he also wanted
- 30:12to look thinner next to Clark Gable. That's true.
- 30:14That was the other thing. And I did read something
- 30:17very funny. And this would drive me nuts if I...
- 30:20got to work with charles lawton but apparently
- 30:23he was well known for doing this thing where
- 30:26right before he finished a take and the director
- 30:29was about to say cut he would yell out something
- 30:32to just ruin that take so he'd do like his his
- 30:36whole monologue for instance and right before
- 30:39frank lloyd yells cut he goes well i missed all
- 30:42my marks guess i'll have to do it again I know
- 30:45the missed all my marks quote is one that the
- 30:47crew specifically laughed at with him. So they
- 30:50had a good time with that one. But other ones,
- 30:52he would just kind of like ad lib lines. Yeah.
- 30:54So it just kind of cuts the line or that cuts
- 30:57the take. I saw a TikTok today of like crew members
- 31:02on the next Avengers movie watching the cast
- 31:05mess up purposefully for blooper reels. And they're
- 31:08just sitting there and they're like, no, Robert
- 31:10Downey Jr. is dancing again. And that's just
- 31:12what I imagined. The crew on this is like, they're
- 31:15like, Charles, we had the shot. And then Charles
- 31:19hits the nae nae. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, he can't
- 31:22stop that guy from hitting that. I wanted to
- 31:24point out to you that not only was the acting
- 31:26on all three individuals fantastic in this, but
- 31:30it was also kind of catered to be this way. Because
- 31:32Irving Thalberg actually cast Clark Gable and
- 31:36Charles Lawton, hoping they'd be rivals. Right.
- 31:39We've talked about how the... real life nature
- 31:43of who charles lawton is and what he what his
- 31:46proclivities he's gay let's just go ahead and
- 31:47say that so and with how god i really just hate
- 31:51saying the word with how homophobic uh clark
- 31:54gable was he was hoping even irving thalberg
- 31:58that this would cast division between them wild
- 32:01and uh i mean he's right because you can you
- 32:04can sense the tension on screen between the two
- 32:06of them totally it never comes across as like
- 32:09they're about to throw fists at each other like
- 32:11in real life but it does kind of obviously the
- 32:14tension is there between these two characters
- 32:16captain bly and fletcher christian yeah it just
- 32:19sucks that we are intended to see the villainy
- 32:22in captain bly but we know flipped that it's
- 32:26difficult so like it's difficult for us to feel
- 32:28that way so that being said the tension that
- 32:32they intentionally put into this movie because
- 32:34of that great and not even just for like you
- 32:36know their uh real life uh the way they live
- 32:40their lives outside of screen but specifically
- 32:42let's remember that clark gable won best actor
- 32:44for it happened one night yeah and lawton had
- 32:47felt that he should have won for barrett's wimple
- 32:49street which okay i hate taking gable side on
- 32:54this one but sorry lawton no it's funny because
- 32:57i think in general if you're like yeah clark
- 32:59gable shouldn't have won that year should have
- 33:00been charles lawton i'd be like I don't know
- 33:02what you're talking about, but I agree. Yeah.
- 33:04But in that year, I'm like, no. Right. No, I'm
- 33:06on team. It happened one night on that one. Yeah.
- 33:10I don't want to say team Gable. But that's all
- 33:13present on the screen. Totally. You can feel
- 33:15now kind of Lawton rising to the occasion of,
- 33:18well, hey, now I'm going to kind of earn that
- 33:21nomination and that win over you. Which he didn't.
- 33:25Well, and that's the great thing is Clark Gable
- 33:27didn't win for this. Yeah. Well, neither did
- 33:29Lawton. Right, exactly. And neither did Tone.
- 33:32Tone's just like, hey, guys. Hey, guys. Which,
- 33:36that was another pairing where Thalberg thought,
- 33:39oh, Gable and Tone, they're going to get along
- 33:41great. So this will work fantastic. They did
- 33:45not when they first arrived on set together because
- 33:47they both were pursuing Joan Crawford. And they
- 33:52were like, hey, she's my gal. No, she's my gal.
- 33:55And then they ended up on Tahiti. And they pursued
- 33:57the other girls, and they were like, oh, we're
- 34:00friends now. Yeah. We both like women. They became
- 34:03close allies after that, which, again, I don't
- 34:06think we learned the lesson we should have there,
- 34:08but that's okay. That's okay. I wanted to point
- 34:10out while we're talking about acting, did you
- 34:12recognize any other faces in this movie? No,
- 34:15but I tried to. I read the trivia first, and
- 34:18I was like, where is he? Okay. I couldn't find
- 34:20him. Is it funnier if I tell the story and then
- 34:25the individual? I think it is. So this individual
- 34:28was actually on vacation and was just sailing
- 34:31in his personal boat. And while he was sailing,
- 34:37he actually saw the production for Mutiny on
- 34:39the Bounty. And he is pretty good friends with
- 34:41Frank Lloyd. So he pulls up on the ship. almost
- 34:45like his own, like, mutiny, shows up and asks
- 34:47Frank Lloyd if he could have a part in the film,
- 34:49and they just gave him, like, a background costume.
- 34:53Yeah. And he is just in the background. James
- 34:55Cagney is in this movie. Yeah. And I also was
- 34:59looking for James Cagney, who is pretty, like,
- 35:01noticeable of an individual. Yeah, yeah. And
- 35:04I couldn't find him, but he is somewhere in the
- 35:07movie. Yeah, apparently towards the beginning,
- 35:09he's supposed to be really easy to spot. I couldn't
- 35:13do it. But the funny thing in that story is I
- 35:17think that he was at odds with the studio at
- 35:20the time. So he hadn't been working for a little
- 35:22bit. Nothing serious. But when he pulled up and
- 35:25he's like, hey, Lloyd, can I get a part in the
- 35:27picture? He specifically said, like, I could
- 35:29really use the money. And he was just joking.
- 35:32But that's very funny to me that James Cagney
- 35:35is like, I'm down and out. What you got? There
- 35:38is something hysterical to me about the idea
- 35:41of them being like. so you're on vacation where
- 35:44we're filming? He's like, yeah, yeah. Right.
- 35:47And in reality, he's just like, Frank is where?
- 35:50He's like, time for me to go on vacation. I love
- 35:52the idea of like, I don't know, there's a, like
- 35:56a grocery store epic being filmed the next year
- 35:59and he just rolls up and he's shopping in the
- 36:01store and he's like, oh my God, Frank. I didn't
- 36:05know you were here. You need any help? His boat's
- 36:08parked outside. Yeah. I have a question for you.
- 36:11As an actor who is familiar with background work.
- 36:14Yeah. How would you feel if, well, actually,
- 36:18let me take that back. Do you always, or not
- 36:20always, do you often feel like there are moments
- 36:23where you're like, oh, I feel like this could
- 36:24probably get me a little like attention. Like
- 36:27this part feels a little meatier. I think this
- 36:30could get me a little bit more than what I've
- 36:32done previously. Yeah. Yeah, I've had those moments.
- 36:34How do you think you would feel if you felt that
- 36:37way? And then James Cagney pulls up and he's
- 36:39like, I'm also a background worker today. Listen,
- 36:42there's a guy I met doing background that the
- 36:46first time I was with him, we were doing some
- 36:49like running movie, like jogging or what are
- 36:52they called? Marathon. Way less. Office race.
- 36:58You ever hear of that? Oh, that's the name of
- 37:00the movie? No, I haven't heard of that. Yeah,
- 37:02that makes sense. I'm familiar with an office
- 37:04race, but I don't know the movie. That's what
- 37:06it was. It's rough. But when I met him, he was
- 37:09wearing a hot dog mascot costume. I'm listening.
- 37:13Because we were at some race. And I got partnered
- 37:16up where I have to pantomime talking with him.
- 37:19And he did this thing where every time he would
- 37:21pretend to say a line, he would just open his
- 37:23mouth and go. Like audibly you'd hear the smack?
- 37:28Yes. And I'm like. Please stop. Please stop because
- 37:31we have to be quiet or else we're going to have
- 37:33to do this again. Right. And just drove me nuts.
- 37:37Since I've met him, this man has stolen parts
- 37:41from me so many times. And it's like I got picked
- 37:46to be a stand in on like a Jessica Lange movie.
- 37:50And I did it for one day and I was like, wow,
- 37:52this is really cool. Then the next day I was
- 37:55background and I look over and who's standing
- 37:58in for the guy? lip smacker himself yep well
- 38:01exactly so he's my james cagney he really is
- 38:06he really is wow i had a feeling that this is
- 38:09like i'm just thinking about all those poor individuals
- 38:11because there's a lot of background work in this
- 38:13movie like you have to pretty much cast an entire
- 38:16like ship yeah uh of people not just the ship
- 38:19itself but you do and I felt so bad. I was like,
- 38:24can you imagine them being like, hey, honey,
- 38:25I'm working with Charles Lawton and Clark Gable.
- 38:27Is that James Cagney? Who's this guy in the hot
- 38:31dog costume? It's James Cagney. Now that's what
- 38:35I want to see. One last thing about James Cagney.
- 38:38I have heard going into this iteration of the
- 38:41podcast, I had heard so much of James Cagney
- 38:44and every single bit of it was just gangster
- 38:46film. mobster film this is now i think the third
- 38:50time that we've seen him on screen and every
- 38:53time i'm just like i did not expect this yeah
- 38:55all with james cadney and what's to come i did
- 38:58not expect from james cadney so i'm excited to
- 39:01get closer to the 40s where we have more of the
- 39:03like mobster uh cinema from him to kind of see
- 39:06that i don't know if you're gonna be seeing it
- 39:09oh that's right it wasn't really nominated yeah
- 39:11if you if you want that you're gonna have to
- 39:13seek it out Which I have been doing. As we've
- 39:16been watching these movies and I'm getting more
- 39:18familiar with some of these actors, as I find
- 39:20films that are of that era that are not even
- 39:22nominated, I'm more interested and I'm picking
- 39:24them up. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Let's move into
- 39:27some of the other categories that received nominations
- 39:29this year. A big one is the scoring. Yes. Pretty
- 39:33epic score. Yeah. Really fits well with the movie
- 39:38and everything that's going on. I think... I
- 39:40like when a movie opens up and right away you
- 39:44get hit with a score because you just know, like,
- 39:47okay, this is going to be a ride through this
- 39:49whole movie. And I think early on when the ship
- 39:53first sets sail from when it collects all of
- 39:56its crew at the port, there are a lot of those
- 40:00great scenes of like the sails coming down and
- 40:02everybody manning the deck. tying knots and stuff
- 40:07keep going huh it's super cool and the music
- 40:10is just pumping and it you you really feel like
- 40:13you're about to set sail on this adventure with
- 40:15this crew and the score done here by herbert
- 40:19stothart is fantastic it's really good and honestly
- 40:23the biggest thing is it just it fits the aesthetic
- 40:26and it fits the story so well yeah so With a
- 40:30movie like this, especially one that is well
- 40:32over two hours, it just feels like it could very
- 40:35easily go the wrong way if you're not invested
- 40:38throughout the story. The score goes a long way
- 40:40in remedying that. Yeah, and I think this year
- 40:42overall is when we start getting scores that
- 40:45feel kind of modern. I think the musical style
- 40:48is very much set in the 30s, but just the level
- 40:53and the quality of the score and how much it
- 40:56does fit with... what's taking place on screen,
- 40:59it feels very modern. Herbert Stoddard here was
- 41:03nominated for 10 different scores throughout
- 41:06his career. He did win one time. Do you know
- 41:10what it was for? I don't. The Wizard of Oz. Oh,
- 41:13wow. So like this guy is the man, you know? The
- 41:17weird thing now with the score and the nominees
- 41:19is that it doesn't go to the composer. So at
- 41:23this time, like... Oh, right, it was going to
- 41:25the MGM department. Yeah, the head of the department,
- 41:28and that's Nate W. Finston. So it is kind of
- 41:31a bummer. I feel like this could have been his
- 41:3311th nomination, but technically it's not. I'm
- 41:36glad that they've corrected a lot of that stuff.
- 41:38Yeah. Feels weird. Especially because now we
- 41:41wouldn't be where we are with, you know, having
- 41:43the names, name recognition of some of these
- 41:46composers if it was just going to the department
- 41:49head. Yeah. Now that does further emphasize like
- 41:52how much control the studios had over everything.
- 41:55The individuals weren't really getting the awards
- 41:57here. It was the studios themselves. And thankfully
- 42:01that changes. Yes, it does. How do you feel about
- 42:03the film editing? I think this is another great
- 42:06example of not only action being cut together
- 42:10really, really well, but this is a woman editor
- 42:13doing fantastic work. And I love how many women
- 42:18are in charge of this whole process in filmmaking.
- 42:22Did it stand out to you in a big way? It did,
- 42:24especially with how much of the filming was done
- 42:27practically on a ship, either at sea or in a
- 42:31tank, and how well. Everything blended together.
- 42:36Again, I feel like any of the issues that I had
- 42:38with the pacing and the story involve the locations
- 42:42and the actual reasoning for that than it was
- 42:46the editing. So I thought the editing was great
- 42:48here. No issues. I read up on Margaret Booth,
- 42:51the editor, and she is fascinating. Really? She
- 42:55worked early as a patcher for D .W. Griffith
- 43:00in the early silent films that he worked on.
- 43:03And later she was recruited by Louis B. Mayer
- 43:06to come and work as an editor for MGM. And she
- 43:10ended up being the first official editor for
- 43:13MGM. She worked almost for her entire career.
- 43:17I think she did like 40 or 50 years at MGM from
- 43:21like their inception to when she left. She was
- 43:25fired. But like. In the same way that like Douglas
- 43:29Shearer kind of touched everything when it came
- 43:32to the sound department at MGM, she had her hands
- 43:35on every film that came through MGM as far as
- 43:39editing go. And if she didn't physically, like
- 43:41she wasn't the one actually cutting, she was
- 43:44overseeing every single film. It's really refreshing
- 43:48when you see a behind the scenes role that a
- 43:51woman has because I think at this time it's very
- 43:54easy to see like acting. And that's kind of where
- 43:57things end. But I agree. Film editing specifically
- 44:00is one that it's just really exciting to see
- 44:02that we don't have to wait much longer to see
- 44:05that kind of representation. It's already happening
- 44:06at this time. Yeah. And I mean, I think this
- 44:09is one of the coolest things in the Academy Awards
- 44:12is how often women are getting nominated in this
- 44:15category. She never won. an editing award but
- 44:19she did receive an honorary award in 1977 and
- 44:23she lived to be 104 years old wow yeah she's
- 44:28she's just very cool and like there there are
- 44:30so many editors that i just want to explore their
- 44:33their story and their history and all of that
- 44:35and she is definitely one of them i do think
- 44:38that this film wouldn't be as effective if it
- 44:41wasn't for the screenplay Obviously, a big part
- 44:43of that is going to be the acting that comes
- 44:45from it, especially the Charles Lawton. But I
- 44:48think that the screenplay itself does a really
- 44:50good job in keeping this feeling cohesive. And
- 44:53you feel like you understand every character
- 44:56for the most part. I still think that there's
- 44:58a little bit of Captain Bly that to me feels
- 45:01kind of inconsistent. It's really just when he
- 45:04is sent off in the mutiny and he has his team
- 45:08of supporters in the boat with him. And that
- 45:11whole sequence, I mean, prior to that, he has
- 45:14been, like we said, ruling with an iron fist.
- 45:16And this sequence, to me, feels very much like
- 45:19it conveys him being like, I've learned my lesson.
- 45:22And you know what, man? Save your energy. Because
- 45:24we're going to need it. And we need to do the
- 45:27best. Like, I am part of it with you now. And
- 45:29we're doing this together. And you kind of get
- 45:32the feeling, you know what? You've changed. And
- 45:35you see, like, this mutiny has changed you. And
- 45:37as soon as we see him again, he's like, no. Yeah.
- 45:40Nope. You guys are going to die. And I'm going
- 45:42to make sure that the English courts see to it.
- 45:46And it just it doesn't come across as petty.
- 45:48It comes across as like, psych, you thought.
- 45:50Yeah. And he's just back to his normal self.
- 45:53So that to me doesn't feel very like it's like
- 45:56he just got what he needed from his team and
- 45:58then like cast them aside. It was more like,
- 46:00oh, these are my supporters. I think I need to
- 46:03like keep you close to my chest. But then anyone
- 46:06who's not my supporter, I'm going to ruin their
- 46:08lives. Yeah. I kind of like that, like, he's
- 46:12terrible, he's a tyrant and all of that. And
- 46:14when he is set into a position where, like, he's
- 46:18got to survive now, he's out on this little dinghy
- 46:21with 10 people or whatever, he does it. He survives
- 46:24because he is an excellent captain. It's just
- 46:27that his tactics and his, you know, the way he
- 46:32handles things is terrible. So I think that kind
- 46:35of plays well into his character of... Yeah,
- 46:38he's just always awful, but it kind of works,
- 46:40and that... That's a bummer. But he's very good
- 46:42at this. Yeah. Because it's worth mentioning
- 46:44that the whole reason the mutiny even kind of
- 46:46happens from the first place isn't just that
- 46:48he is lashing his people and that he is very
- 46:51unfair in his punishments, but it's also that
- 46:54he is withholding water from the crewmates because
- 46:57he wants to make sure the plants that they took
- 46:59from Tahiti are fully fed. And now he is cutting
- 47:03portions of the food to make sure that he and
- 47:06his team can eat and the crews can't. Right.
- 47:09He is being unfair and being unjust with that,
- 47:12and Fletcher calls this out, and obviously he
- 47:15has an issue with this. That was the only issue
- 47:18in the script that to me felt like I can't really
- 47:20see that. But it sounds like you're right. He's
- 47:23a very good captain. He just also happens to
- 47:25be a horrible person. So we just have to take
- 47:27that balance. But the screenplay by Talbot, Jules,
- 47:31and Carrie I thought was really effective there
- 47:33as well. Yeah, I think it's great. It's just
- 47:35that Tahiti section slows down so much. It does.
- 47:39I feel like we haven't had a lot of opportunity
- 47:42to talk about him as much as like Charles Lyon
- 47:44and Clark Gable. But again, Frank O'Tone is doing
- 47:47really, really good work as Roger Byam. And he
- 47:49ends up having this excellent monologue towards
- 47:52the end when he is in the court system. And to
- 47:55me, this is kind of where he earns that nomination
- 47:58single -handedly when he stands up for himself.
- 48:01There's a whole, the scene in which he goes to
- 48:04learn whether or not he has been found guilty
- 48:06or non -guilty of this treason. he's told, look,
- 48:11there's going to be a blade on the table. And
- 48:13if the blade is facing to the side, they found
- 48:17you innocent. But if it's facing you, they found
- 48:19you guilty. And when he walks in, the camera
- 48:22does a very intentional cut to his face and then
- 48:25to the table where you see the blade facing him.
- 48:28And I thought this would ruin the tension of
- 48:30the scene. You should see him looking at the
- 48:34table and then realizing and looking away. And
- 48:36then we have to wonder, based on what they're
- 48:38saying, what's going to happen. So when that
- 48:41showed that, I was kind of disappointed at first.
- 48:42But then that brings on his monologue, which
- 48:45is fantastic. So it really subverted my expectations
- 48:48of how that scene was going to go. And a big
- 48:51part of that was Franchotone. But we talked about
- 48:54actors a good bit. Do you want to say anything
- 48:56about Franchotone before we bring up direction?
- 48:58No, no, let's move in his direction. So, Frank
- 49:00Lloyd, you mentioned that of his three movies
- 49:02that we've covered so far, East Lynn and Calvacade,
- 49:05that this is the one that we enjoyed the most
- 49:08or the best. Absolutely. And I think that's right.
- 49:11This is the one that it feels like is the biggest
- 49:13production of what he's done, not just in time
- 49:15spanning, that would be Calvacade, but just in
- 49:18sheer scope. of the movie it's this and i think
- 49:22he rose the occasion uh everything looks fantastic
- 49:24uh it's cut really well and i think that it paces
- 49:28for the most part pretty well um tahiti does
- 49:32a very big part or has a very big part in dragging
- 49:35that down yeah um so i don't think it's perfect
- 49:38but again I think that's more in what they had
- 49:41to include from you know a Clark Gable aspect
- 49:44and what they felt they needed to do to complete
- 49:47that story so I won't hold that super against
- 49:50Frank Lloyd but I think he did a great job on
- 49:52this and I agree with you easily the most enjoyable
- 49:54of the three that we've seen from so far yes
- 49:57this is going to be the movie that I I will use
- 50:00to kind of define Frank Lloyd he appreciates
- 50:03that oh I'm glad I'm glad When I roll up like
- 50:06Cagney. Don't forget that, Frank Lloyd. The interesting
- 50:09thing to me about Frank Lloyd. You love being
- 50:11on vacation on your personal boat. I do, especially
- 50:14in Tahiti. I've always wanted to go to Tahiti.
- 50:17Shout out to Endless Summer. You ever see that
- 50:20movie? The surfing movie? No. Tahiti's beautiful.
- 50:23It's amazing to me that you're such a big fan
- 50:26of surfing. I didn't know that before. Should
- 50:28I knock this surfboard over a second time? Well,
- 50:31I never would have. invited you to be on the
- 50:33podcast had I known you were so anti -surfing?
- 50:35No, I'm not anti -surfing. Tell that to my surfboard.
- 50:37First off, I have no rebuttal. That surfboard
- 50:43was in my way. Sure, yeah. I'm going to tell
- 50:46you the same thing that I've heard so many other
- 50:48people say to me about car accidents. That surfboard
- 50:51came out of nowhere. It did. All right. It did.
- 50:53It's the way it's staring at you right now. It's
- 50:56side -eyeing. The interesting thing about Frank
- 50:59Lloyd to me here is Not only was he a founder
- 51:02of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences,
- 51:06he was president from 1934 to 1935. Do you know
- 51:10if at this time he was president? I mean, he
- 51:13would have to be. Oh, when he was making the
- 51:14movie, of course. Yeah. I meant when it was released.
- 51:16But yes, when he's making it, he'd have to be.
- 51:17Yeah. So I wonder if during selection of nomination,
- 51:23I couldn't find exactly like when. a presidency
- 51:26runs from. Like if there's every year during
- 51:29this period, we vote. So I don't know if the
- 51:33nominees would have came out during his presidency
- 51:35or after, but that's always something where I'm
- 51:38like, hmm. Interesting. Nominated, were you?
- 51:43But in this instance, I would say deserved. Yeah.
- 51:46Yeah. I'm not against that. It's just always
- 51:47kind of funny to me. Yeah. And honestly, the
- 51:50one of two years in which there's 12 nominations,
- 51:52there's a lot of opportunity for an additional.
- 51:54That's true. I think just the amount of times
- 51:56that like assistant director pops up, but directing
- 51:59doesn't. I'm always like, well, what happened
- 52:02there? What qualified one over the other? Well,
- 52:04this brings up a good point because we mentioned
- 52:07that it has eight or had eight nominations for
- 52:09the Academy Awards. But it actually enters a
- 52:13rare air, both of the Broadway Melody and Grand
- 52:15Hotel, as a Best Picture winner that won no other
- 52:18awards. And the thing that's interesting to point
- 52:21out with this is, you know, I say rare air, and
- 52:25you're going to be like, Ryan, it happened two
- 52:26other times in the less than a year that you
- 52:28guys have covered the Oscars. Right. Here's the
- 52:31thing to note. This is the last film to do this.
- 52:34And I'm going to argue the last time this will
- 52:37ever happen. I mean, the way that things happen
- 52:39now, I think there's more of a tally system of
- 52:42how many, we talked about this on the 2026 Oscars,
- 52:45but there's a tally system of how many below
- 52:49the line nominations and above the line nominations
- 52:51or awards that you've won. And that kind of like
- 52:54teetering to whether you deserve the best picture
- 52:56or not. Yeah. We saw that happen with one battle
- 52:59after another versus Sinners. So that was something
- 53:03that I think we look at now in a more modern
- 53:06sense of the nominations and wins. So I think
- 53:08you're right. I think that's the last time it's
- 53:10going to happen. I wouldn't be surprised if we
- 53:13see like an out of nowhere win in the future
- 53:16for like a campaign that's made about a movie.
- 53:18Yeah. Because I think things are shifting. You
- 53:20can really feel a shift in movies right now,
- 53:22both in theaters and just in general. You can
- 53:25feel like the way that people are watching movies
- 53:27and the way they're supporting them. There's
- 53:29a, I mean, horror is doing so well this year.
- 53:33Yeah. You can really feel people kind of like
- 53:35clamoring for something like that again. So I
- 53:37could see it happening, not so much this year,
- 53:39but in the future. I think you're right. I think
- 53:42this is the last time this is going to happen.
- 53:43Yeah, and just the fact that it hasn't happened
- 53:45in the 90 -something years. To point out the
- 53:49other two times it did happen, the first was
- 53:51the Broadway melody of 1929, to be clear, and
- 53:54Grand Hotel. So, yeah, it's interesting. I think
- 53:58the fact that it happened as early as it did
- 54:00in this very close... together set of movies
- 54:03that's just further evidence that this is bygone
- 54:07it's also i brought this up to just point out
- 54:09that it's interesting that he was the director
- 54:12of motion pictures and won best picture for this
- 54:15with those eight nominations but nothing else
- 54:16sus frank sus love that you're busting out vibes
- 54:20and sus on the mutiny on the bounty episode look
- 54:23i'm i'm young hip What is that? That's Austin
- 54:29Powers. Oh. I'm young. I'm hip. And he has kind
- 54:32of like a bounce. I've never seen Austin Powers.
- 54:35Really? Yeah. That's not even one of those movies
- 54:38you have to see. It's just kind of surprising.
- 54:39I would have thought you would have seen that.
- 54:41Comedy. Oh, sure. You know me. I'll fix it one
- 54:44day. I gotta get you to watch So Married and
- 54:46Axe Murderer before Austin Powers, though. Yeah,
- 54:48yeah. Although I think you would like Austin
- 54:49Powers as a, not even takedown, but just like
- 54:52a parody of the Bond movies. Right, yeah. So
- 54:55maybe you'll like that, but... Yeah, that's fair.
- 54:57My God, I did not think we'd get to Austin Powers
- 54:59from Beauty and the Bounty. That's better than
- 55:00some of our other deviations, so... Is it? Have
- 55:04we done some cursed ones? I've brought up Norma
- 55:06Shearer and Blastoise. Like... So... If Norma
- 55:12Shearer had an element in Pokemon between fire,
- 55:17water, lightning, and... Is it ground? Earth?
- 55:20Earth, yeah. What do you think Norma Shearer
- 55:22is? Well, I mean, now it gets weird. There's
- 55:24fighting. There's psychic. There's ghost. There's
- 55:27fairy. We're not getting into this. Lightning.
- 55:28She's lightning. She is lightning. That's what
- 55:31I was thinking, too. Fire or lightning, I think,
- 55:33is what I would give Norma Shearer. Yeah. Well,
- 55:35I think it's, like... You're shocked, you know,
- 55:38when you see Norma Shearer. You're like, wait
- 55:39a minute. Because we haven't gotten anything
- 55:41that's like a fiery performance from her where
- 55:43it just feels like she's like taking people down.
- 55:44It's just more she's electric on screen. Yeah,
- 55:46fire I reserve kind of, oh, maybe for Myrna Loy.
- 55:50Now, if we were to introduce the other ones that
- 55:53you mentioned, fighting, right? Yeah. She's like,
- 55:57Chester Morris, get real. Karate chop to the
- 56:01throat. Yeah. Hey, there's one thing that this
- 56:05wasn't nominated for that I think it kind of
- 56:06deserved a little bit. And that's cinematography.
- 56:09Yeah. Man, I love that whole sequence I was talking
- 56:13about with the ships setting the sails and all
- 56:16of that with the music going. And this was Arthur
- 56:19Edison was the cinematographer here. Someone
- 56:22we've talked about quite a bit. He was the cinematographer
- 56:26on All Quiet on the Western Front. We'll see
- 56:29him in, oh, and here comes the Navy. Can't leave
- 56:31that out. But we'll see him a lot moving forward
- 56:33with Casablanca and the Maltese Falcon. And he
- 56:37also did a lot of the James Whale horror. So
- 56:40if you want to hear more about him, be sure to
- 56:42check out Horror of the Overlooked, our side
- 56:44podcast we release every 13th of every month.
- 56:47Patreon exclusive. Exactly. Yeah. So check out
- 56:50patreon .com slash OUTAO podcast. Another movie
- 56:53he did, though, was In Old Arizona. And I found
- 56:57out that was the first 70mm wide film. Really?
- 57:02Yeah. I feel like we completely skipped over
- 57:04that, and now we have to start the podcast over.
- 57:06I have to go back and watch that movie now. So
- 57:08on our third iteration of the podcast, we're
- 57:10going to get all of the facts. Yeah. Tune in
- 57:14to hear me talk about my third hearing aid that
- 57:17I'll need when we cover that. And tune in when
- 57:19I'm not on the third iteration, because I'm not
- 57:22doing it again. It's me talking. Oh, never mind.
- 57:24You with somebody else. I thought you meant you
- 57:25died. Yeah, well, you know, we'll see. I was
- 57:29going to say it's me talking to your urn. And
- 57:32whenever I think you're going to speak, I'll
- 57:33just hit your urn with my cane or something.
- 57:36Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding. Good point,
- 57:38Kyle. Yeah. I was going to just do the Robin
- 57:41Williams as a hot dog. That's you in the urn?
- 57:46In the urn, yeah. Yeah, okay. This took a turn.
- 57:49It did. You want to get into ratings? Yeah, let's
- 57:51get into ratings. We didn't do a play -by -play
- 57:53of this, because I do think it kind of needs
- 57:54to be seen. It does. Just know that the mutiny
- 57:57happens, and then you go to Tahiti, and that's
- 57:59why our ratings are what they are. Yep. So for
- 58:02this, I gave it three and a half stars. We gave
- 58:06it three and a half stars. Oh, huggies. Look
- 58:08at that. I think that's deserved. I think three
- 58:11and a half stars. It's a great movie. It earns
- 58:14the best picture win that it takes here. And
- 58:18it is a highlight of Frank Lloyd's career by
- 58:21far. For sure. I do think that the, you know
- 58:25what? The Mutiny, big fan. The Bounty, big fan.
- 58:29Yeah. What wasn't listed in the title was Tahiti.
- 58:31And Tahiti to me slows it down. And I just wasn't
- 58:34a big fan. I feel like this is an epic movie
- 58:37except for the parts where it's not. And you
- 58:39know what? Honestly, again, I defend Roger Byam's
- 58:43part of Tahiti. Because that to me feels like
- 58:46I'm bringing scholar and everything that I want
- 58:48to bring to England to Tahiti. And I'm finding
- 58:51a life here. And I'm actually like blending in
- 58:54with the culture. It is Fletcher Christian's
- 58:57part in Tahiti that feels kind of like... You
- 58:59mean I can sleep with women on this island? Yeah.
- 59:01That just feels kind of like, what are we doing
- 59:03here? So it's just, again, I know it's a morality
- 59:06play and it's like seeing the difference between
- 59:08these two individuals, even though you're on,
- 59:10they're on one side, technically, not really.
- 59:13And it just slows it down. Couldn't be for me.
- 59:16It does. It does. I wish we would have spent
- 59:18less time talking about how slow Tahiti is and
- 59:21more of like the behind the scenes stuff. We
- 59:23glazed over like the death that occurred while
- 59:26filming this. Yes. There was a capsized ship
- 59:31from the second unit film crew, and cameraman
- 59:34Glenn Strong passed away during that. And then
- 59:38there was a bounty replica that got lost at sea
- 59:40for two days, where they were just out there
- 59:43floating around until someone came to the rescue.
- 59:46So I read about this, and when it said lost at
- 59:48sea, I was like, so it could still be out there?
- 59:50For two days. Yeah. Never mind. For two days.
- 59:53I mean, two days is still a long time, don't
- 59:55get me wrong, but hearing lost at sea, I'm like...
- 59:58It still is. I never want to be lost at sea for
- 1:00:00any duration of time. No. That's terrifying.
- 1:00:02Well, here's the thing. Aren't you... We're getting
- 1:00:07a little theoretical here. I don't mean to open
- 1:00:09your third eye to this, but if you're on the
- 1:00:12sea at all, aren't you consistently lost at sea?
- 1:00:15Like, even if you know where you're going. I
- 1:00:17am. I think the people manning the crew have
- 1:00:21a little bit of an idea. You're just... You are
- 1:00:24a dog in a car. yeah you're just panicked you're
- 1:00:26like i don't know where we're going this is great
- 1:00:28i hope you know yeah okay true yeah three and
- 1:00:33a half stars feels right on this totally and
- 1:00:34that's that's a positive three and a half stars
- 1:00:36it's not like oh this is disappointing right
- 1:00:38agreed so worth checking out the physical media
- 1:00:40before we get into our double feature this can
- 1:00:42be found in a multitude of ways yeah this is
- 1:00:45one of the the biggest release uh films we've
- 1:00:48covered warner archive collection uh there are
- 1:00:52a couple of warner brother like collections themselves
- 1:00:55the 75 years of warner brothers i think has this
- 1:00:58movie i think there's a 50 year that came out
- 1:01:01as well no that doesn't make sense but like a
- 1:01:0350 movie collection right and then there's actually
- 1:01:05a digibook as well i've seen the digibook before
- 1:01:08i wish i would have picked it up digibooks digital
- 1:01:10movies digital movies with books keep going that's
- 1:01:16it you got it nailed it um yeah so if you want
- 1:01:19to see this on physical like it's out there you
- 1:01:22can find it very easily probably in stores uh
- 1:01:25granted more like used ones like your secondhand
- 1:01:28uh retailers but also uh online you're not gonna
- 1:01:32have a problem finding this one this is pretty
- 1:01:34readily available because of its uh notoriety
- 1:01:36yeah like three years ago i would almost assume
- 1:01:38you'd be able to find this like walking down
- 1:01:40best buy yeah Yeah, I think it's that popular.
- 1:01:43Oh, man. I know, it's crazy. Let's get into these
- 1:01:45double features. Look, I'm just going to go ahead
- 1:01:48and say it. I picked Pirates of the Caribbean,
- 1:01:49Curse of the Black Pearl. 2001, directed by Gore
- 1:01:52Verbinski. Now, did I pick it because of Big
- 1:01:55Boat on Sea? Yes. But was there another reason
- 1:01:58that I picked it? Yes. Oh, I thought that the
- 1:02:00separation of the crew based on who was pro and
- 1:02:05anti Captain Bly was very similar to the idea
- 1:02:10of the Barbosa's crew coming back from the dead.
- 1:02:15And it felt like bringing back like that crew
- 1:02:17that to me felt very similar. Right. To meeting
- 1:02:20on the bounty. Obviously, one's a zombified crew
- 1:02:22and the other one's just I like mean guy. But
- 1:02:26both are kind of true to Barbosa. Yeah. Jack
- 1:02:28Sparrow's kind of like the biome there. Oh, disagreed.
- 1:02:33No, no, no, no. Well, in the sense of, hey, I'm
- 1:02:36not going to participate in the mutiny. Like,
- 1:02:39he's the one that got mutinized against. I see
- 1:02:42what you're saying. And he said, no, I don't
- 1:02:44want the gold. If anything, I was going to say
- 1:02:45Barbossa is Captain Bly. Jack Sparrow is Fletcher.
- 1:02:49Will. Will. is definitely the Roger Byam. I see
- 1:02:53it that way, too. Yeah, for sure. But I hear
- 1:02:55what you're saying with that. So I think that
- 1:02:57there are similarities to Curse of the Black
- 1:02:59Pearl outside of just Ship at Sea. Right. But
- 1:03:02I thought that was an interesting kind of comparison
- 1:03:04between the crew of The Bounty and the crew of
- 1:03:06The Black Pearl. Totally, totally. And this is
- 1:03:08just further proof that we need more pirate movies.
- 1:03:11Give us more. And you know what? We'll give you
- 1:03:13one next week. Well, actually, next episode.
- 1:03:15Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. My double feature here,
- 1:03:17I went with the... The effects of a mutiny and
- 1:03:23what takes place hundreds of years later. And
- 1:03:27also kind of like the infighting between the
- 1:03:30bad guys. Not the bad guys, but people. I went
- 1:03:33with the Goonies. Because you have One -Eyed
- 1:03:37Willie who was mutinized against and killed and
- 1:03:41abandoned with his treasure. And now these little
- 1:03:43kids have to go find it. And the villains in
- 1:03:46that, there is tons of infighting. Can you imagine
- 1:03:50the Goonies, but with Charles Lawton in that
- 1:03:53role? Playing who? Like Captain, who was mutinized.
- 1:03:56Oh, okay. I thought you meant like... Him as
- 1:03:59Sloth? Sloth, yeah. Oh my God, can you imagine?
- 1:04:03Hey, you guys. I want that so bad now. Or Charles
- 1:04:11Lawton as Chunk. Yeah, doing the truffle shuffle.
- 1:04:16Yeah, that would work. I think that'd be good.
- 1:04:20Yeah. So those are our double features. Only
- 1:04:22us. Only us. Hey, let us know what your double
- 1:04:25feature is for Mutiny on the Bounty. And if there
- 1:04:27are like really, really good pirate movies that
- 1:04:29we're missing out on. Yeah. Shoot us an email
- 1:04:31at OUTAOPodcast at gmail .com. We are slowly
- 1:04:36but surely making our way towards the ceremony
- 1:04:39episode. Finally, of this 12 movie. Be sure to
- 1:04:43get your thoughts in about all of these movies
- 1:04:46by August 23rd. That's a Sunday. We do read those
- 1:04:50responses on the show. And I mentioned the Patreon
- 1:04:54earlier, patreon .com slash OUTAO podcast. Check
- 1:04:58that out. And next episode, we are covering Captain
- 1:05:01Blood. We keep the pirate themes going. We do.
- 1:05:04That's going to do it for this episode. As always,
- 1:05:07I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the
- 1:05:11movies. Thank you.