Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS to Decide Trump Immunity & Bump Stock Ban
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:11Speaker 2: The US Supreme Court says it will rule on Donald
- 0:14Speaker 2: Trump's bid for presidential immunity from criminal prosecution, taking up
- 0:19Speaker 2: a historic case that will determine whether the former president
- 0:22Speaker 2: can stand trial for twenty twenty election interference while campaigning
- 0:26Speaker 2: for a return to the White House. The move keeps
- 0:29Speaker 2: that election interference trial on hold, and the question is
- 0:33Speaker 2: whether there'll be time for the special counsel to bring
- 0:35Speaker 2: that case before the election. Joining me now is Bloomberg
- 0:39Speaker 2: Supreme Court reporter Greg's Store. Greg. Most people expected, and
- 0:44Speaker 2: include myself here, that the Justices would be turning away
- 0:47Speaker 2: Trump's case. It's taken an awful lot of time for
- 0:51Speaker 2: them to decide to take it.
- 0:53Speaker 3: It did take an awful lot of time for them
- 0:55Speaker 3: just to decide whether to take it. Trump filed his
- 0:57Speaker 3: request on February the twelfth, and Jack Smith, saying you know,
- 1:02Speaker 3: if you are going to hear arguments, do it quickly,
- 1:04Speaker 3: had suggested the court hear arguments in March. Instead, the
- 1:07Speaker 3: Court is going to hear arguments in April. So the
- 1:10Speaker 3: Court did drag its feet a little bit on this.
- 1:13Speaker 3: You know, I think people are going to be scrutinizing
- 1:15Speaker 3: this order trying to figure out exactly what it means.
- 1:18Speaker 2: Also, Jack Smith asked them to decide this issue months
- 1:22Speaker 2: ago and they turned him down. So my question is
- 1:26Speaker 2: why now when it will delay the trial.
- 1:29Speaker 3: Yes, it's hard to say, June, You're right, Jack Smith
- 1:32Speaker 3: asked the Court to do something very unusual back in January,
- 1:35Speaker 3: asking them to bypass the appeals court stage, and the
- 1:39Speaker 3: court the client Supreme Court declined to do that instead
- 1:42Speaker 3: let the appeals court go ahead. The appeals court ruled
- 1:44Speaker 3: against Donald Trump, saying he's not entitled to immunity. That
- 1:49Speaker 3: was a potential way for the Court to speed things up,
- 1:52Speaker 3: and now it has. The Court has apparently decided that
- 1:56Speaker 3: it needs to be the one to make the ultimate
- 1:58Speaker 3: decision here. It will of course have the benefit of
- 2:00Speaker 3: that appeals court decision, and perhaps the Court thanks that
- 2:03Speaker 3: will let it do a better job deciding this issue.
- 2:06Speaker 2: So this expedited schedule is it as expedited as you've
- 2:12Speaker 2: seen in past cases where the Supreme Court has done this.
- 2:15Speaker 3: No, Just to take one data point, if you look
- 2:18Speaker 3: at the Colorado ballot case, that the Court is going
- 2:21Speaker 3: to be deciding at some point. In that case, it
- 2:24Speaker 3: was thirty six days between when Donald Trump filed his
- 2:28Speaker 3: appeal and when the Supreme Court hurt arguments. In this case,
- 2:31Speaker 3: we're going to be talking more like seventy days or
- 2:34Speaker 3: even more than that, so about double that time. It
- 2:37Speaker 3: is not as expedited as the Colorado ballot case. And
- 2:40Speaker 3: then you can look at some other data points like
- 2:42Speaker 3: bushby Gore, which was much much faster. It is expedited,
- 2:46Speaker 3: certainly faster than the Supreme Court normally does things, but
- 2:49Speaker 3: not as fast as Jack Smith and some others would
- 2:52Speaker 3: have liked.
- 2:53Speaker 2: And Greg if they have oral arguments in April, we
- 2:56Speaker 2: know that they'll come down with a decision by June
- 2:59Speaker 2: because going on vacation. But I mean, is it likely
- 3:02Speaker 2: that in a case like this, with an unprecedented question,
- 3:06Speaker 2: that they're going to come down with a decision before June?
- 3:09Speaker 3: You know, I'd hate to predict that, just because every
- 3:13Speaker 3: time I try to predict when a Supreme Court ruling
- 3:15Speaker 3: is going to come out, I tend to be very,
- 3:17Speaker 3: very wrong. It's conceivable they know what's going on. They
- 3:22Speaker 3: understand that there is an election out there, so they'll
- 3:25Speaker 3: be aware of that, But as you said, this is
- 3:28Speaker 3: a very big constitutional issue and it's not the kind
- 3:31Speaker 3: of thing you would normally think the Supreme Court would
- 3:33Speaker 3: want to rush through. So I would certainly not be
- 3:36Speaker 3: surprised if it's not until June and even late June
- 3:39Speaker 3: before they issue their decision joining us now.
- 3:41Speaker 2: Is former federal prosecutor Robert Mintz a partner McCarter in English, Bob,
- 3:46Speaker 2: we have talked often about Trump's delay delay, the way
- 3:50Speaker 2: he handles not only his criminal cases but his civil cases,
- 3:54Speaker 2: and it appears to have worked here.
- 3:56Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 3:57Speaker 1: Sure, No, that's exactly right. And one in any defense
- 4:01Speaker 1: team's playbook is to try to delay. Here. We've seen
- 4:05Speaker 1: that done again and again by former President Trump's lawyers,
- 4:09Speaker 1: and it has special significance here given the fact that
- 4:12Speaker 1: there is an upcoming election, and so the decision here
- 4:16Speaker 1: as to whether and how quickly mister Trump could go
- 4:19Speaker 1: to trial is especially critical because it could not only
- 4:23Speaker 1: affect his election prospects, but should he be re elected,
- 4:27Speaker 1: it would actually affect the Department of Justice ability to
- 4:30Speaker 1: bring this case at all, since once he's president, he
- 4:33Speaker 1: could simply direct his Attorney general to dismiss the case
- 4:36Speaker 1: that was pending against him, So it has particular significance
- 4:41Speaker 1: due to the timing, because not only the election, but
- 4:44Speaker 1: also the possibility that as president, he could effectively end
- 4:47Speaker 1: this prosecution.
- 4:48Speaker 2: If the Supreme Court hands down a decision in June
- 4:51Speaker 2: and then decides that he doesn't have presidential immunity from prosecution,
- 4:56Speaker 2: is it possible for the DC case, which will be
- 4:59Speaker 2: on hold until then, to go forward before the election.
- 5:04Speaker 1: That will really be entirely up to the trial judge.
- 5:08Speaker 1: The district court judge in Diestrah of Columbia who's handling
- 5:11Speaker 1: this case, has shown every indication to get this case
- 5:14Speaker 1: moving as quickly as possible. Obviously, these appeals have taken
- 5:18Speaker 1: that out of her hands. But when the Supreme Court rules,
- 5:22Speaker 1: if they do decide to reject the immunity claim to
- 5:25Speaker 1: follow the lead of the appeals court which unanimously rejected
- 5:29Speaker 1: the immunity claim, I think we will see her bringing
- 5:31Speaker 1: the parties in and setting a very aggressive schedule to
- 5:34Speaker 1: bring this case to trial. She's going to suggest that
- 5:37Speaker 1: the defense team had plenty of time to prepare for
- 5:40Speaker 1: this trial even while the stay was pending, because this appeal,
- 5:44Speaker 1: they could have been working on their preparation for their defense,
- 5:47Speaker 1: and so I don't think she's going to give them
- 5:48Speaker 1: a lot of time once that decision comes down. Should
- 5:51Speaker 1: the Supreme Court agree with the Court of Appeals and
- 5:55Speaker 1: decide to reject the immunity claim, I think we'll see
- 5:57Speaker 1: that case go to trial fairly quickly.
- 6:00Speaker 2: This will be the Court's second sort of unprecedented Trump
- 6:04Speaker 2: showdown this term, and with their approval numbers so low,
- 6:09Speaker 2: I thought they might want to stay out of the
- 6:12Speaker 2: presidential election so as not to suffer any comparisons with
- 6:16Speaker 2: Bush v. Gore.
- 6:17Speaker 3: Well, Bushy Gore certainly dealt a blow to their reputation,
- 6:23Speaker 3: and it remains to be seen what's going to happen
- 6:25Speaker 3: with this case and the other Trump case. One can
- 6:29Speaker 3: certainly imagine a world where they decide one one way
- 6:33Speaker 3: and one the other way. Say that Donald Trump can
- 6:35Speaker 3: stay on the ballot but is not to immunity. I'm
- 6:39Speaker 3: not sure what that would do for their approval ratings.
- 6:43Speaker 3: And probably when they're looking at a case like this,
- 6:46Speaker 3: they are not thinking too hard about that. They are
- 6:49Speaker 3: thinking about the legal issues and really whether they have
- 6:53Speaker 3: to be the ones to decide this issue rather than
- 6:56Speaker 3: living it up to a federal appeals court, as they
- 6:59Speaker 3: apparently decided.
- 7:01Speaker 2: Bob, do you think that this was just too important
- 7:04Speaker 2: an issue for them to rely on a decision by
- 7:08Speaker 2: the DC Court. Even on that decision, I mean, most
- 7:11Speaker 2: people who have read it thought it was very thorough, excellent,
- 7:16Speaker 2: covered all the bases.
- 7:18Speaker 1: Yeah, it was. It was an extremely thorough decision. They
- 7:21Speaker 1: gave a lot of attention to every single argument that
- 7:26Speaker 1: was raised by the Trump defense team in order to
- 7:30Speaker 1: try to persuade them that there was immunity here. And
- 7:33Speaker 1: ultimately the decision, which was unanimous to democratically appointed judges
- 7:38Speaker 1: and one appointed by George HW. Bush, all agreed that
- 7:42Speaker 1: the immunity would not stand. That essentially, what that would
- 7:46Speaker 1: have done would have been to allow a president to
- 7:51Speaker 1: commit a crime while in office and forever be barred
- 7:54Speaker 1: from being prostituted for it. It was a pretty strong decision.
- 7:58Speaker 1: But it turns out that the Supreme Court has decided
- 8:01Speaker 1: to weigh in as well on this issue. It seems
- 8:05Speaker 1: like the issues have been pretty thoroughly briefed and argued before.
- 8:09Speaker 1: We'll see the same arguments I think again before the
- 8:13Speaker 1: Supreme Court. But for whatever reason, they decided, perhaps because
- 8:17Speaker 1: of the tremendous significance of this decision that the Supreme
- 8:20Speaker 1: Court should be the last word on this issue.
- 8:23Speaker 2: So, Greg, I have to ask you the Supreme Court reporters,
- 8:25Speaker 2: were they surprised when this came out this afternoon?
- 8:28Speaker 3: Late this afternoon, I wouldn't say surprised. This was certainly
- 8:32Speaker 3: one of the possibilities that you know, we'd all been
- 8:36Speaker 3: debating which were the most likely possibilities, But this was
- 8:39Speaker 3: certainly certainly in the mix. I think my only surprise
- 8:43Speaker 3: is that I thought that if they were going to
- 8:45Speaker 3: do this, they would have done it sooner. Since they
- 8:48Speaker 3: are expediting this case, I might have thought they would
- 8:51Speaker 3: have done that as soon as all the briefing was done,
- 8:54Speaker 3: instead of waiting the two weeks.
- 8:56Speaker 2: There is this Justice Department policy of not bringing these
- 9:01Speaker 2: kinds of trials involving politicians close to an election. Would
- 9:06Speaker 2: that affect whether this trial goes as well the election
- 9:09Speaker 2: interference trial?
- 9:11Speaker 1: Well, there is a general rule, in a general policy
- 9:13Speaker 1: in the Department of Justice that you don't want to
- 9:16Speaker 1: bring criminal charges close enough to election that it might
- 9:20Speaker 1: affect the outcome of the election. In other words, you
- 9:22Speaker 1: don't want to see an indictment returned within sixty days
- 9:26Speaker 1: of an election, because at that point a defendant, someone
- 9:30Speaker 1: who may be running for office, will simply be charged
- 9:33Speaker 1: with a crime and will not have had an opportunity
- 9:35Speaker 1: to defend themselves prior to the election. This is a
- 9:39Speaker 1: circumstance where all of those issues have resentually gone out
- 9:42Speaker 1: of the window, because this whole process has become still
- 9:45Speaker 1: politicized in the sense that it has always been a
- 9:47Speaker 1: race against the political clock because of the campaign, because
- 9:51Speaker 1: of the upcoming election. And one of the arguments that
- 9:53Speaker 1: the defense has runs raised here that the Trump defense
- 9:56Speaker 1: has argued over and over it again, is they tried
- 9:58Speaker 1: to turn this prosecute into effectively a campaign interference case,
- 10:03Speaker 1: saying that it was brought precisely for the purpose of
- 10:07Speaker 1: trying to prevent former President Trump of campaigning for the presidency.
- 10:12Speaker 1: They made that argument in front of the Manhattan Juigesh's
- 10:15Speaker 1: hearing the trial that begins, as you said, on March
- 10:17Speaker 1: twenty fifth, and in response to that, the judge simply
- 10:20Speaker 1: said that that was not a legal argument, and he
- 10:23Speaker 1: dismissed it. But as this gets closer and closer to
- 10:27Speaker 1: the election, you're going to see more and more arguments
- 10:29Speaker 1: being made that this case cannot be tried and can hear,
- 10:33Speaker 1: cannot be concluded in a way that will not ultimately
- 10:36Speaker 1: interfere with the election. It's an open question as to
- 10:40Speaker 1: what might happen if there is a conviction here and
- 10:42Speaker 1: if former President Trump is sentenced to jail.
- 10:44Speaker 2: Thank you so much, Robert Mins from maccarter and English
- 10:47Speaker 2: and our own Greg Store Bloomberg, New Supreme Court reporter,
- 10:51Speaker 2: coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show. There were
- 10:54Speaker 2: oral arguments today and the justices seemed divided on whether
- 10:57Speaker 2: or not to strike down the federal ban on bump stocks.
- 11:01Speaker 2: That's coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm
- 11:03Speaker 2: June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:06Speaker 4: The Aigens accelerator at the original bumpstock shot at six
- 11:09Speaker 4: hundred and fifty rounds a minute, and the devices at
- 11:11Speaker 4: issue here are represented to shoot between four hundred and
- 11:14Speaker 4: eight hundred rounds a minute, so right in that range
- 11:16Speaker 4: with the M sixteen the M fourteen.
- 11:18Speaker 2: Brian Fletcher, representing the Biden administration, explained to the Supreme
- 11:23Speaker 2: Court justices today that bump stocks allow a semi automatic
- 11:27Speaker 2: rifle to fire at speeds comparable to machine guns like
- 11:31Speaker 2: the M sixteen and M fourteen issued to the military.
- 11:35Speaker 2: The question was whether the justices would strike down a
- 11:38Speaker 2: ban on bump stocks that was imposed by the Trump
- 11:41Speaker 2: administration after the deadliest mass shooting in US history at
- 11:46Speaker 2: a Las Vegas concert in twenty seventeen. The liberal justices
- 11:50Speaker 2: like Elena Kagan seemed to think it was plausible that
- 11:54Speaker 2: the one hundred year old law aimed at banning machine
- 11:57Speaker 2: guns could cover bump stocks.
- 12:00Speaker 5: But the entire point of this device is that you
- 12:03Speaker 5: exert forward pressure and you have your finger on the trigger,
- 12:07Speaker 5: and then a torrent of bullets shoots out. So I
- 12:10Speaker 5: don't understand why it's any different different from pushing a
- 12:13Speaker 5: button and holding the trigger, pushing the barrel and holding
- 12:16Speaker 5: the trigger.
- 12:17Speaker 2: But conservative justices like Amy Cony Barrett and Neil Gorsich
- 12:21Speaker 2: well see me to acknowledge the government's argument, then question
- 12:25Speaker 2: whether banning bump stocks was up to the court.
- 12:28Speaker 6: Look, intuitively, I am entirely sympathetic to your argument. I mean,
- 12:32Speaker 6: and it seems like, yes, this is functioning like a
- 12:34Speaker 6: machine gun would. But you know, looking at that definition,
- 12:38Speaker 6: I think the question is why didn't Congress pass that litigation,
- 12:41Speaker 6: I mean that legislation to make this coverent more clearly,
- 12:46Speaker 6: I can.
- 12:46Speaker 7: Certainly understand why these items should be made illegal, but
- 12:52Speaker 7: we're dealing with the statue is enacted in the nineteen thirties,
- 12:56Speaker 7: and through many administrations, the government took the position that
- 13:02Speaker 7: these bump stocks are not machine guns.
- 13:05Speaker 2: Joining me is Andrew Willinger, Executive director of the Duke
- 13:09Speaker 2: Center for Firearms Law. Andrews start by giving us a
- 13:12Speaker 2: little bit of the history of the federal ban on
- 13:14Speaker 2: bump stocks.
- 13:16Speaker 8: So this is an ATF regulation that categorizes bump stock
- 13:22Speaker 8: devices as machine guns under the National Firearms Act, and
- 13:27Speaker 8: so therefore those devices are banned. This regulation was promulgated
- 13:32Speaker 8: after the twenty seventeen Las Vegas shooting, the deadliest mass
- 13:36Speaker 8: shooting in US history, where the shooter used bump stocks.
- 13:41Speaker 8: And after that shooting, there was some discussion about whether
- 13:45Speaker 8: Congress might act through legislation to specifically say that, you know,
- 13:50Speaker 8: bump stocks are prohibited or bump stocks are a machine guns,
- 13:53Speaker 8: and ultimately that did not happen. Instead, the ATF under
- 13:57Speaker 8: the Trump administrationated this regulation, and you know it's I
- 14:03Speaker 8: guess worth noting here that the ATF has sort of
- 14:07Speaker 8: had in the previous decade or so since these devices
- 14:12Speaker 8: started to appear, gone back and forth on how it
- 14:15Speaker 8: categorized them in informal guidance to the industry. These sort
- 14:19Speaker 8: of letters that the ATF would send to companies that
- 14:21Speaker 8: were making bump stocks, occasionally saying that some of these
- 14:25Speaker 8: devices were not machine guns and could be produced and sold.
- 14:28Speaker 8: And so there this regulation in twenty eighteen kind of
- 14:32Speaker 8: settled that matter. But again it's the culmination of a
- 14:34Speaker 8: little bit of a back and forth from the ATF.
- 14:37Speaker 2: So this isn't about the Second Amendment, then, it's about
- 14:41Speaker 2: the reach of this federal statute and how the ATF
- 14:45Speaker 2: interpreted it.
- 14:47Speaker 8: Yeah, exactly, it's a little bit complicated. It's not, I
- 14:49Speaker 8: guess to start, it's a lot complicated. Yeah, the justices certainly,
- 14:54Speaker 8: I think you're struggling with this one as well. So
- 14:56Speaker 8: to start, you know, you're right, it's not a Second
- 14:58Speaker 8: Amendment case. That's been pretty clear from the get go.
- 15:01Speaker 8: One of the justices I forget who actually explicitly asked
- 15:05Speaker 8: this question to the Cargill's attorney and he said, you know, no,
- 15:09Speaker 8: we have not made a Second Amendment claim. He even
- 15:11Speaker 8: actually suggested that maybe bump stocks are outside the scope
- 15:15Speaker 8: of Second Amendment protection because they are dangerous and unusual,
- 15:18Speaker 8: but that's not at issue in this case, and there
- 15:21Speaker 8: weren't any Second Amendment arguments being made today. This is really,
- 15:25Speaker 8: as I see it, just sort of at this point,
- 15:27Speaker 8: really a pure statutory interpretation question. And then the question
- 15:31Speaker 8: is whether the ATFS interpretation of machine gun to include
- 15:35Speaker 8: bump stocks was in accord with the statute, with what
- 15:40Speaker 8: the statute mean, what the intent was when the statute
- 15:42Speaker 8: was written. There has been and then there have been
- 15:46Speaker 8: a number of cases challenging this regulation from the time
- 15:51Speaker 8: that was enacted, and there have been a number of
- 15:53Speaker 8: federal appellate courts that have upheld the rule under some
- 15:58Speaker 8: kind of deference roach. So basically saying that, you know,
- 16:02Speaker 8: we can't really make heads or tails of whether this
- 16:05Speaker 8: statutory language includes bump stocks or doesn't include bump stocks.
- 16:08Speaker 8: We think the language is pretty ambiguous, but we're going
- 16:11Speaker 8: to defer to the ATF's interpretation of the language. So
- 16:14Speaker 8: there are a number of appellate courts that upheld the
- 16:17Speaker 8: rule under that theory. The government before the Supreme Court
- 16:21Speaker 8: here has not asked explicitly for different So for that reason,
- 16:25Speaker 8: what with the arguments that we heard really focused on
- 16:28Speaker 8: just this question of what does the relevant statutory language
- 16:33Speaker 8: single function of the trigger automatically? What do those words mean?
- 16:36Speaker 2: And we should mention that the ultra conservative Fifth Circuit
- 16:41Speaker 2: did rule that the ban was unlawful.
- 16:44Speaker 8: So the sort of plurality in the Fifth Circuit said
- 16:48Speaker 8: that unambiguous in their view, language in the statute does
- 16:52Speaker 8: not extend to bumpstock devices. There was a group of
- 16:56Speaker 8: judges who had basically said, well, we don't know, the
- 17:00Speaker 8: language might be ambiguous, but because there are criminal penalties here,
- 17:04Speaker 8: we think the rule of lenity should apply.
- 17:07Speaker 2: But yeah, I guess another favorite the rule of lenity basically,
- 17:10Speaker 2: when a law is ambiguous, the court interprets it in
- 17:13Speaker 2: the way most favorable to the defendant. Let's move on
- 17:16Speaker 2: quickly now from the law of lenity. I have to
- 17:19Speaker 2: say I found these arguments so confusing, with the justices
- 17:24Speaker 2: seeming to struggle over the technical aspects of bump stocks
- 17:29Speaker 2: over you know, are you pushing a button, are you pulling?
- 17:31Speaker 2: Are you exerting pressure on it? Why was that important?
- 17:35Speaker 8: Yeah? I mean, yeah, there was I think a lot
- 17:37Speaker 8: of confusion and a lot of hypothetical you know, revolving
- 17:40Speaker 8: around buttons and trip wires and those types of things.
- 17:44Speaker 8: But I think ultimately the issue sort of reduces to
- 17:49Speaker 8: the perspective from which you view this phrase single function
- 17:53Speaker 8: of the trigger. So the government's argument, it really just
- 17:56Speaker 8: just boiled down, is that single function of the trigger
- 18:00Speaker 8: really means single pull of the trigger. So you're focused
- 18:03Speaker 8: on the act of the shooter and what the shooter
- 18:07Speaker 8: does in pulling the trigger, and that because that pull
- 18:10Speaker 8: of the trigger initiates the bump firing sequence when you're
- 18:14Speaker 8: using a bump stock, that therefore the gun is firing
- 18:19Speaker 8: multiple rounds with a single function of the trigger. Cargill,
- 18:22Speaker 8: on the other hand, says, you don't look at this
- 18:25Speaker 8: from the perspective of the shooter. Instead, you're looking at
- 18:29Speaker 8: the actual mechanical function of the trigger. What does the
- 18:32Speaker 8: trigger of the gun do? And the way again, according
- 18:37Speaker 8: to Cargo's argument and his attorney today, the way that
- 18:40Speaker 8: that works is that when you are bump firing a
- 18:43Speaker 8: semi automatic weapon, the trigger still has to go back
- 18:46Speaker 8: and forth and only one round is expelled each time.
- 18:50Speaker 8: The trigger goes back and forth. It just happens very quickly.
- 18:53Speaker 2: So is this all to see whether it fits within
- 18:55Speaker 2: the definition of machine gun?
- 18:58Speaker 8: Yes, that's correct.
- 19:00Speaker 2: Liberals seemed to suggest that bump stocks fell within what
- 19:05Speaker 2: Congress intended when it banned machine guns, and particularly Justice
- 19:09Speaker 2: Elena Kagan, you know, went at this over and over
- 19:12Speaker 2: again with Cargo's attorney, and you know, appeared incredulous that
- 19:17Speaker 2: a weapon that can fire a torrent of bullets could
- 19:20Speaker 2: not be defined as a machine gun. I mean, do
- 19:23Speaker 2: you think that the liberals were on that side?
- 19:26Speaker 8: Yeah? I think so. I mean I think what I
- 19:28Speaker 8: detected from Justice Kagan, probably Justice Jackson, maybe Justice Soda
- 19:33Speaker 8: Mayor was sort of this maybe consequentialist approach to this statue,
- 19:39Speaker 8: which is, well, how does it make any sense to
- 19:41Speaker 8: read the statue to exclude from its scope devices that
- 19:47Speaker 8: would allow you to achieve the same high rate of
- 19:50Speaker 8: fire as you know, a machine gun like the sixteen
- 19:53Speaker 8: for example, Right in their view, I think that seemed
- 19:56Speaker 8: but something of an absurd result, given the evidence that
- 19:59Speaker 8: maybe we have have about the National Firearms Act and
- 20:02Speaker 8: what the congressional intent was there.
- 20:05Speaker 2: So it seemed like several conservatives were acknowledging that it's
- 20:10Speaker 2: functioning like a machine gun. So Amy Cony Barrett said
- 20:13Speaker 2: that intuitively, I'm entirely sympathetic to your argument, and Justice
- 20:19Speaker 2: Gorsa said, I can certainly understand why these items should
- 20:22Speaker 2: be made illegal. Then the buts came and they both
- 20:26Speaker 2: thought that this is something that Congress should do.
- 20:29Speaker 8: Yeah, I think that's right. I think they thought that
- 20:31Speaker 8: this is something Congress should do that you know, cannot
- 20:34Speaker 8: be accomplished through regulation. And I also think there was
- 20:38Speaker 8: a strong view, you know, among some of the conservative justices,
- 20:42Speaker 8: Justice Gorsas, just as Kavanaugh, maybe Justice Alito that you know,
- 20:46Speaker 8: they were very concerned about the potential confusion and the
- 20:51Speaker 8: potential for sort of people who own these devices to
- 20:54Speaker 8: be kind of almost trapped, right and be like, well
- 20:56Speaker 8: that they're not sure what the legal status is, and
- 20:59Speaker 8: yet they could be prosecuted criminally for having these devices.
- 21:03Speaker 8: And so a lot of concern about sort of what
- 21:04Speaker 8: the practical impact of this rule would be on people
- 21:08Speaker 8: who have owned bump stock devices at various points of time.
- 21:11Speaker 2: I thought that was a ridiculous concern. Would people be
- 21:15Speaker 2: so confused if the ATF said bump stocks are now illegal.
- 21:21Speaker 2: I mean laws change asked the Supreme Court about abortion.
- 21:25Speaker 8: Maybe the key point here is that actually, I don't
- 21:28Speaker 8: know how much this matters. And there were a few
- 21:30Speaker 8: justices who pressed, you know, the government attorney on this issue.
- 21:33Speaker 8: The government is not really bringing criminal prosecutions as far
- 21:37Speaker 8: as I know of those who have possessed bump stock devices, right,
- 21:41Speaker 8: And I would suspect that they that they wouldn't do
- 21:43Speaker 8: that until this litigation sort of resolves, at least That's
- 21:47Speaker 8: what I'm reading between the lines a little bit of
- 21:49Speaker 8: the sg's response here. That's kind of what I what
- 21:51Speaker 8: I took away, And I mean, I think it's certainly
- 21:55Speaker 8: you know, and then this is this is another thing
- 21:57Speaker 8: that was raised and response, This is not unique. This
- 21:59Speaker 8: issue is not unique to bump stocks. Right. There are
- 22:02Speaker 8: sort of frequently circuits disagree on various issues of criminal law.
- 22:06Speaker 5: Right.
- 22:06Speaker 8: That doesn't mean that, you know, the criminal penalties can't
- 22:09Speaker 8: be invoked. But I do think it's the concern that
- 22:12Speaker 8: that members of the court, especially on the conservative side, boys,
- 22:15Speaker 8: during oral arguments.
- 22:16Speaker 2: Do you have a feel for how they might rule
- 22:20Speaker 2: or you know who's on which side? Right?
- 22:23Speaker 8: So I thought one of the interesting aspects. Listening to
- 22:26Speaker 8: the oral argument today is that, again, you know, this
- 22:28Speaker 8: is not a Second Amendment case. It of course involves
- 22:31Speaker 8: firearms and firearm accessories, but it's not a Second Amendment case.
- 22:36Speaker 8: And that might initially lead one to think, well, maybe
- 22:39Speaker 8: the justices will break down differently right than they than
- 22:42Speaker 8: they have in their most recent Second Amendment decisions. After
- 22:46Speaker 8: listening to the argument, I'm not so sure that's true.
- 22:49Speaker 8: I think you can pretty confidently say that, you know,
- 22:53Speaker 8: Justices Soda, Mayor, Kagan, and Jackson, they're they're they're probably
- 23:00Speaker 8: you know, on the side of the government here. I
- 23:03Speaker 8: think I suspect that they would vote to reverse the
- 23:05Speaker 8: Fifth Circuit decision Justice Alito, Justice Kavanaugh, Justice Gorsa, and
- 23:10Speaker 8: probably just this Thomas, I would guess, you know, it
- 23:12Speaker 8: seems a little bit more sympathetic to Cargill's position. So
- 23:15Speaker 8: then you have, of course Justice Barrett and Chief Justice,
- 23:18Speaker 8: who are sort of up in the air. The Chief
- 23:21Speaker 8: Justice specifically, you know, didn't say a whole lot during
- 23:23Speaker 8: oral arguments, but I think, you know, putting all that together,
- 23:27Speaker 8: I expect this to be a very close case, potentially
- 23:31Speaker 8: a five to four decision. I'm not really sure which
- 23:34Speaker 8: way it will go. But again, you sort of have
- 23:37Speaker 8: those same justices Barrett and Roberts that are kind of
- 23:41Speaker 8: the key votes in the Second Amendment area, also being
- 23:43Speaker 8: the key.
- 23:44Speaker 2: Votes here coming up next, state supreme courts are rebuking
- 23:48Speaker 2: the Supreme Court for its position on guns. This is Bloomberg.
- 23:52Speaker 2: I've been talking to Andrew Willinger, executive director of the
- 23:55Speaker 2: Duke Center for Firearms Law, about Supreme Court oral arguments
- 23:59Speaker 2: today over whether the federal ban on bump stocks will stand.
- 24:04Speaker 2: Would the Conservative justices anti the administrative state stance, and
- 24:10Speaker 2: you know, the effort to curtail federal agencies. Would that
- 24:14Speaker 2: play in here with an effort to curtail the ats?
- 24:17Speaker 8: I think potentially. And actually, you know, one other interesting
- 24:21Speaker 8: aspect of this case is that, of course, the Supreme
- 24:24Speaker 8: Court heard argument in the Loper case last month, which
- 24:30Speaker 8: deals with Chevron deference, and you know, a major administrative
- 24:35Speaker 8: law case where essentially the Court is deciding whether to
- 24:38Speaker 8: keep a relatively deferential approach to accepting agency interpretations of
- 24:46Speaker 8: ambiguous statutory language. And so yeah, I mean, I wonder
- 24:51Speaker 8: whether there is at least a chance that you see
- 24:56Speaker 8: depending on what the Court says in Loper, maybe it
- 24:58Speaker 8: articulates some slightly us deferential framework for how courts should
- 25:04Speaker 8: approach these situations. Maybe you could see the court in
- 25:08Speaker 8: Cargill sending the case back and saying, you know, look,
- 25:11Speaker 8: we think this language is ambiguous, but you need to
- 25:13Speaker 8: apply this new framework that we've articulated, or you need
- 25:16Speaker 8: to consider these new factors that we've sort of added
- 25:19Speaker 8: to Chevron. So I think it's interesting to think about
- 25:21Speaker 8: the interaction between those two cases.
- 25:23Speaker 2: In the other gun case before the Court, where the
- 25:28Speaker 2: justices are deciding about a federal law intended to keep
- 25:31Speaker 2: guns away from people under domestic violence restraining orders. In
- 25:35Speaker 2: that case, do you think the justices were leaning toward
- 25:39Speaker 2: keeping guns away from people under domestic violence restraining orders.
- 25:44Speaker 8: Yes, so my read of the oral argument, and this
- 25:46Speaker 8: is the Rahimi case that you've mentioned where the court
- 25:50Speaker 8: hurt argument, I believe in November, my takeaway after that
- 25:55Speaker 8: argument was that the Court is highly likely to revert
- 26:00Speaker 8: the lower decision and uphold the federal ban on possessing
- 26:05Speaker 8: guns while under certain domestic violence restraining orders.
- 26:09Speaker 2: The Supreme Court has expanded gun rights in three major
- 26:13Speaker 2: rulings since two thousand and eight. And the country right
- 26:17Speaker 2: now is reeling from these mass shootings, and this rule
- 26:21Speaker 2: was enacted because, as you mentioned, one of the deadliest
- 26:25Speaker 2: mass shootings in the country's history. So do the justices
- 26:28Speaker 2: consider that there might be backlash if they don't allow
- 26:32Speaker 2: even this kind of a regulation.
- 26:35Speaker 8: I mean, I think again, it sort of gets to
- 26:36Speaker 8: the Congress versus the executive branch, point right. I actually
- 26:41Speaker 8: think it was one of the justices I actually asked
- 26:44Speaker 8: Cargill's attorney point blank towards the end of the argument,
- 26:48Speaker 8: what would Congress have to do?
- 26:49Speaker 5: Right?
- 26:49Speaker 8: If Congress, you know, if a congressman came up to
- 26:51Speaker 8: you and said, you know, we want to ban bump stocks,
- 26:54Speaker 8: we want to pass a law, what would they have
- 26:56Speaker 8: to do? What would they have to stay?
- 26:57Speaker 2: Right?
- 26:57Speaker 8: What would you what would be enough? So I think,
- 27:01Speaker 8: you know, my takeaway from today is that the Court
- 27:05Speaker 8: isn't really concerned about that because in this specific case,
- 27:11Speaker 8: because many of the justices think that this is something
- 27:15Speaker 8: that Congress should have done. Right, So they're not saying, well,
- 27:17Speaker 8: this is off the table. They're saying this was not
- 27:19Speaker 8: something that could be accomplished through the regulatory state.
- 27:23Speaker 2: And with Congress barely being able to keep the country open.
- 27:27Speaker 2: I'm not sure there's much hope of them doing anything
- 27:29Speaker 2: with bump stocks, although this was a case where the
- 27:32Speaker 2: Biden administration and the Trump administration agreed.
- 27:35Speaker 8: Right, that's right, and I think I'm inclined to agree
- 27:39Speaker 8: with you that today it's unlikely, if this case comes
- 27:43Speaker 8: out in favor of Cargill, it's unlikely that we would
- 27:46Speaker 8: see Congress act going back to twenty eighteen. Is that true?
- 27:50Speaker 8: I don't know, right, it seemed like maybe at that
- 27:52Speaker 8: time there was we were getting sort of close to
- 27:55Speaker 8: a critical momentum to take some kind of legislative action,
- 27:59Speaker 8: but of course that to happen.
- 28:01Speaker 2: So I want to turn to some state Supreme Court
- 28:04Speaker 2: decisions because there are two state Supreme courts that it
- 28:09Speaker 2: seems to me are fighting back at the Supreme Court's
- 28:13Speaker 2: Bruin decision. So first explain briefly the Brewin decision and
- 28:18Speaker 2: how the court decided there to rely on history.
- 28:23Speaker 8: Yeah, So Bruin was decided in June twenty twenty two,
- 28:28Speaker 8: and this was a culmination of sort of a ten
- 28:31Speaker 8: or twelve year period where the Court had said in
- 28:35Speaker 8: a pair of earlier decisions that the Second Amendment protects
- 28:39Speaker 8: an individual right at least to keep a gun in
- 28:41Speaker 8: the home for self defense. The Second Amendment is not
- 28:45Speaker 8: limited to the militia context. But the Court had not
- 28:49Speaker 8: set forth any kind of implementing tests for how lower
- 28:55Speaker 8: court judges should determine whether a certain law, you know,
- 28:59Speaker 8: violate it's the Second Amendment or not. And so in
- 29:02Speaker 8: the absence of that guidance, the lower federal court had
- 29:06Speaker 8: developed a two step test. They would first ask whether
- 29:10Speaker 8: the conduct being regulated implicated the Second Amendment at all.
- 29:14Speaker 8: Certain people, certain conducts, certain types of weapons, of course,
- 29:19Speaker 8: don't even get you to the Second Amendment. But if
- 29:22Speaker 8: the Second Amendment was implicated, then the court would apply
- 29:25Speaker 8: a form of scrutiny, most often intermediate scrutiny, which asks
- 29:29Speaker 8: whether the objective is substantially related to an important government interest.
- 29:36Speaker 8: The court would essentially do some amount of balancing of
- 29:39Speaker 8: the government's regulatory interest in the law at issue and
- 29:44Speaker 8: the impact on self defense. And so that was the
- 29:47Speaker 8: approach that prevailed up until Bruin in Brewin, the Supreme
- 29:51Speaker 8: Court threw out the second part of that test. So
- 29:54Speaker 8: this scrutiny step, where courts were weighing the government interest
- 30:00Speaker 8: a'inst the burden on self defense. The courts that that
- 30:03Speaker 8: piece of the test was inconsistent with its earlier decisions,
- 30:07Speaker 8: namely the Heller decision, and instead the Court said that
- 30:12Speaker 8: when there's a Second Amendment challenge, at least the operative
- 30:15Speaker 8: test is whether the law is consistent with the nation's
- 30:19Speaker 8: historical tradition of firearm regulation. And that requires, broadly speaking,
- 30:24Speaker 8: some comparison to historical laws. So the government needs to
- 30:30Speaker 8: come forward with analogous or similar historical regulation, probably from
- 30:35Speaker 8: around the time of the founding, maybe also from the
- 30:37Speaker 8: mid nineteenth century.
- 30:39Speaker 2: So there are two state supreme courts that seemed to
- 30:43Speaker 2: say the Supreme Court was wrong in the way that
- 30:46Speaker 2: it decided that case. The Hawaii Supreme Court earlier this month,
- 30:51Speaker 2: in a unanimous decision, upheld the state's laws barring carrying
- 30:55Speaker 2: guns in public without a license, and in appointed rebuke
- 30:59Speaker 2: of the Supreme Court, Justice Todd Eddens wrote, time traveling
- 31:03Speaker 2: to seventeen ninety one or eighteen sixty eight to collar
- 31:06Speaker 2: how a state regulates lethal weapons is a dangerous way
- 31:09Speaker 2: to look at the federal Constitution. The Constitution is not
- 31:13Speaker 2: a suicide pact. And then last week, the Pennsylvania Supreme
- 31:17Speaker 2: Court also seemed to criticize and ignore the Supreme Court.
- 31:21Speaker 2: In Brewin, it upheld a zoning ordinance that prohibits shooting
- 31:25Speaker 2: ranges in residential areas, and the court said, we're not
- 31:29Speaker 2: so sure about the history that was used in Heller
- 31:31Speaker 2: and Bruin, and we note some serious skepticism with how
- 31:35Speaker 2: the Supreme Court is handling these Second Amendment cases. But
- 31:38Speaker 2: we can play amateur historian as well as the next guy.
- 31:42Speaker 2: So it seems as if these courts, these two at
- 31:45Speaker 2: least Supreme courts, don't agree with Brewin and are just
- 31:49Speaker 2: not following it.
- 31:51Speaker 8: Yeah, So I think if I'll start with a Hawaii cases,
- 31:54Speaker 8: I think that's actually maybe the more fascinating one. And
- 31:57Speaker 8: this is actually not a very difficult question even under Bruin.
- 32:03Speaker 8: What I think is fascinating about this opinion is that
- 32:05Speaker 8: there's a brief portion at the end. I think it's
- 32:08Speaker 8: two or three pages, and this is a fifty plus
- 32:11Speaker 8: page opinion that deals with the federal constitutional challenge. Most
- 32:16Speaker 8: of this opinion is interpreting the provision in the Hawaii
- 32:20Speaker 8: state constitution that mirrors is almost exactly identical to the
- 32:24Speaker 8: US Second Amendment, and the Court ends up saying, after
- 32:28Speaker 8: a lengthy analysis during which, as some of the language
- 32:32Speaker 8: you quoted, it is very critical of Bruin and the
- 32:35Speaker 8: US Supreme Court and the Justice, the Hawaii justices end
- 32:38Speaker 8: up saying that this state provision is limited to the
- 32:42Speaker 8: militia context. It does not protect an individual right, at
- 32:46Speaker 8: least not an individual right to carry weapons in public.
- 32:49Speaker 8: But after doing that, the justices then spend a very
- 32:53Speaker 8: short portion of the opinion saying, our holding here is
- 32:57Speaker 8: also you know, cord with Bruin, right. This is the
- 32:59Speaker 8: result that you get even going through the Bruin analysis,
- 33:04Speaker 8: and I think that's right. Brewin doesn't say that there
- 33:07Speaker 8: is a right to carry guns in public, concealed firearms
- 33:12Speaker 8: in public without a license. Instead, the Court says, it's
- 33:15Speaker 8: perfectly fine for states to have objective licensing requirements. They
- 33:20Speaker 8: just can't have the type of discretionary law that New
- 33:24Speaker 8: York and several other states, including Hawaii did at the
- 33:27Speaker 8: time the Bruin decision was issued. So again, this is
- 33:31Speaker 8: actually a pretty easy case under Bruin. There's nothing in
- 33:35Speaker 8: that opinion, at least as I read it, that requires
- 33:38Speaker 8: permitless carry to be permitted. But I think what you
- 33:41Speaker 8: see in the Justice's choice to spend most of the
- 33:45Speaker 8: opinion on the state constitutional issue is kind of them
- 33:48Speaker 8: trying to express that they think the direction the Supreme
- 33:52Speaker 8: Court is headed may be problematic and trying to sort
- 33:56Speaker 8: of explain their view of why Hawaii might be different.
- 34:00Speaker 2: And what about the Pennsylvania decision. How often do you
- 34:03Speaker 2: see state supreme courts issuing rebukes to the US Supreme Court.
- 34:08Speaker 8: Yeah, I think that's totally right. It's rare, although I
- 34:11Speaker 8: will say that Bruin has prompted some of this, even
- 34:15Speaker 8: from federal judges. There have been federal judges that have
- 34:17Speaker 8: written opinions that are very critical of the test, saying,
- 34:21Speaker 8: you know, we need more guidance, right, And that's kind
- 34:23Speaker 8: of the Pennsylvania decision, in contrast to the Hawaii one,
- 34:27Speaker 8: I think is more of a plea for the Court
- 34:30Speaker 8: in Marahemi or a future case to provide more guidance
- 34:35Speaker 8: about how the historical test should work in practice. So,
- 34:39Speaker 8: the Pennsylvania case deals with a zoning ordinance that essentially
- 34:44Speaker 8: banned firing ranges on property that was zoned for residential purposes,
- 34:50Speaker 8: limited the area in which shooting ranges could operate. The
- 34:54Speaker 8: plaintiff in this case as somebody who had built a
- 34:56Speaker 8: firing range on his own property and as a result
- 34:59Speaker 8: of this change to the zoning ordinance, that was no
- 35:02Speaker 8: longer permitted. And so this is an issue that has
- 35:06Speaker 8: come up before in some context, and it implicates the
- 35:10Speaker 8: question of sort of what the whether the Second Amendment
- 35:13Speaker 8: protects an ancillary right to practice or train with firearms.
- 35:19Speaker 8: The Pennsylvania Court, actually, I think, takes a pretty middle
- 35:22Speaker 8: of the road approach here and says that, yes, there
- 35:26Speaker 8: is a right to train or practice with firearms that's
- 35:31Speaker 8: protected by the Second Amendment. So this conduct of building
- 35:35Speaker 8: a firing range on this individual's property is within the
- 35:40Speaker 8: scope of the Second Amendment. I think that's interesting. I
- 35:42Speaker 8: don't know that that's I don't know that that's correct. Right.
- 35:45Speaker 8: This is somebody who, I think it's important to note,
- 35:48Speaker 8: could have gone to a firing range somewhere else. But nevertheless,
- 35:53Speaker 8: the court says this is within the scope of the
- 35:54Speaker 8: Second Amendment, and then relies on historical laws restricting the
- 36:00Speaker 8: charge of firearms and urban areas and restricting where shooting
- 36:05Speaker 8: ranges could be built that those laws exist historically and
- 36:08Speaker 8: says this is a pretty clear type case where the
- 36:10Speaker 8: historical evidence supports the regulation.
- 36:14Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show. That's Andrew Willinger,
- 36:17Speaker 2: Executive director of the Duke Center for Firearms Law. And
- 36:20Speaker 2: that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show.
- 36:23Speaker 2: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 36:25Speaker 2: subscribing to the Bloomberg Law Podcast or downloading this show
- 36:29Speaker 2: at Bloomberg dot com. Slash podcast, Slash Law and attorneys
- 36:33Speaker 2: get the latest in AI powered legal analytics, business insights
- 36:38Speaker 2: and workflow tools at Bloomberg law dot com. With guidance
- 36:42Speaker 2: from our experts, you'll grasp the latest trends in the
- 36:44Speaker 2: legal industry, helping you achieve better results for the practice
- 36:49Speaker 2: of law, the business of law, the future of law.
- 36:52Speaker 2: Visit Bloomberg Law dot com. I'm Joombroanco and you're listening
- 36:56Speaker 2: to Bloomberg