Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Yellow Journalism: The Architecture of Modern Manipulation
Transcript
- 0:00They'll tell you Hearst was a newspaperman, a rich boy who
- 0:03sold headlines. That's the myth.
- 0:06And the myth is worth doing exactly what it was built to do,
- 0:09which is to keep you from looking any closer.
- 0:11Because the truth is faster than that, and darker and a lot more
- 0:15precise. Hearst didn't just report the
- 0:17news, he manufactured it. He fabricated atrocities.
- 0:21He bribed sources. And when that wasn't enough, he
- 0:24simply bought the people who mattered.
- 0:26He bought reporters, politicians, and in the end he
- 0:29bought himself a war and the Spanish American War.
- 0:33The thing they teach you as a conflict just sort of happened
- 0:36that way. And that wasn't the conflict at
- 0:38all. It was a product.
- 0:40It was designed, it was packaged, and it was delivered.
- 0:43These men didn't cover history. They wrote it.
- 0:46And they did it with nothing but ink, a printing press and a
- 0:49private Telegraph line. This is the template, the
- 0:52original playbook, America's first engineered war.
- 0:56And by the end of this video, you're going to know exactly how
- 0:59it was done. Welcome back to hidden Forces in
- 1:19History. I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan
- 1:21Slate, CEO of Command Your Brand.
- 1:24You can find us at commandyourbrand.com.
- 1:27Now our story, Two men built this machine and you have to
- 1:31understand both of them is they came at it from opposite ends of
- 1:34everything. One of them from nothing and the
- 1:36other came from everything else. By rights, they should have
- 1:40never met. But in New York in the 1890s was
- 1:43kind of city that crushed men together until something finally
- 1:46caught fire. Joseph Pulitzer arrived in
- 1:49America in 1864 and he was 17 years old.
- 1:53He spoke no English and had no money and no connections to
- 1:57speak of. He'd actually been recruited off
- 1:58the streets of Hamburg and come over to fight in the Union Army,
- 2:02and the man who stepped off the boat in Boston Harbor was not
- 2:05impressive in any way you could point to.
- 2:08He was hungry. That was the only asset he had,
- 2:11and it turned out to be enough. After the war he drifted to
- 2:14Saint Louis and taught himself English by reading in the Public
- 2:18Library, sleeping in doorways, and shoveling coal to stay
- 2:22alive. He worked his way into a German
- 2:24language newspaper, and then another, and then another.
- 2:28Until 1878 he owned the Saint Louis Post Dispatch outright.
- 2:33By 1883 he set its sights on New York, where he bought the
- 2:36struggling New York World for $346,000.
- 2:40The paper was bleeding money and it had maybe 15,000 readers, so
- 2:45nobody thought it was a good bet.
- 2:46But Pulitzer wasn't trying to sell newspapers to people who
- 2:50already bought newspapers. He was going after everyone
- 2:52else. He was going after the Irish
- 2:54stock workers, the Jewish garment workers, the Italian
- 2:57laborers, all the people the city ran on and nobody printed
- 3:01for. And here's the scale of it.
- 3:03By 1890, once you counted both the foreign born and their
- 3:06American born children, roughly 4/5 of New York City's
- 3:10population had immigrant roots. Every other newspaper on Park
- 3:13Row treated these people as if they were invisible.
- 3:16Pulitzers treated them like readers, which is to say, he
- 3:19treated them like they mattered. So he sent reporters down into
- 3:23the tenements and the opium dents, into police courts and
- 3:26into sweatshops. He ran the story of the toddler
- 3:29who fell from A5 Story Rooftop on Orchard St.
- 3:32He wrote about the beatings the cops were handing out in the
- 3:35streets. He wrote about the beatings the
- 3:37cops were handing out in the streets, and he wrote about the
- 3:40kickbacks the bosses were pocketing over at Tammany Hall.
- 3:44He hired Nellie Bly, the first full time female reporter in
- 3:47American history, and he sent her undercover into a women's
- 3:51asylum on Blackwell's Island. And the story she came back with
- 3:54were genuinely horrifying. And something happened that had
- 3:57never happened before. People who had never bought a
- 4:00newspaper in their lives started buying the world every single
- 4:04morning. By 1890, circulation passed
- 4:071,000,000, and no newspaper in American history had ever done
- 4:10that. Pulitzer built himself a new
- 4:12headquarters on Park Row, and for a brief moment, it was the
- 4:15tallest building in New York. There's a detail here that's
- 4:18almost too poetic to be real. The hotel he tore down to build
- 4:22that tower was the same hotel that had thrown him out as a
- 4:26penniless immigrant 20 years earlier.
- 4:28So he bought it, he tore it down, and he built a skyscraper
- 4:32in its place. At the dedication, he declared
- 4:35that the building would be the home to a newspaper, forever
- 4:38fighting for every form of wrong, forever wedded to the
- 4:41truly democratic ideas. And he meant it.
- 4:44He also meant to make money. And that tension right there
- 4:48between the mission and the prophet is the exact crack that
- 4:51Hearst would drive a wedge into. Because William Randolph Hearst
- 4:55was everything Pulitzer wasn't. He was the son of a California
- 4:59mining millionaire. George Hurst had made his
- 5:02fortune in the Comstock load, in the Anaconda copper mine, in the
- 5:07Homestead gold mine, the kind of wealth that doesn't run out.
- 5:10And when his son wanted a newspaper, George Hurst simply
- 5:13handed him one. The paper was the San Francisco
- 5:16Examiner, a failed sheet that George had taken as payment for
- 5:20a gambling debt, and William took it over in 1887 at 24 years
- 5:24old. He'd never run a newspaper in
- 5:26his life, but had unlimited money, no patience, and an
- 5:30enormous appetite for more. And within a few years, the
- 5:33Examiner was actually turning a profit.
- 5:35And what Hearst had figured out, Pulitzer had never figured out
- 5:39independently. And the formula they both landed
- 5:41on was about as simple as it gets.
- 5:44Sensationalism cells. Fear cells.
- 5:47Outreach cells. But Hearst took it further than
- 5:50Pulitzer ever dared, because he understood something darker
- 5:53underneath all of it. He understood that people really
- 5:56don't want to be informed. What they want is to be
- 5:58activated. They want enemies.
- 6:00They want a story with heroes and villains in it.
- 6:03And if the villains didn't happen to exist, well, Hearst
- 6:06would just invent them. In 1895, he turned his attention
- 6:09to New York, where he bought the struggling New York Journal and
- 6:12cut the price to a single penny, half of what the world was
- 6:16charging. And then he started raiding
- 6:18Pulitzer's staff, not just offering higher salaries, but
- 6:21offering outright fortunes. He poached the editors, the
- 6:25reporters, the cartoonist. The entire Sunday staff of the
- 6:29world walked out on a Saturday and showed up at the Journal on
- 6:32Monday morning. Hulitzer was blindsided.
- 6:35So he hired all of them back at even higher wages.
- 6:38And then Hearst hired them back again, and even higher still.
- 6:41This wasn't a business negotiation at this point.
- 6:44This was war. And Hearst had one very simple
- 6:47strategy. He had more money than Pulitzer
- 6:49did, and he fully intended to spend every dollar until he won.
- 6:53Ark Row in the 1890s was unlike anything that existed in
- 6:57American media today, and you have to picture it physically to
- 7:00understand it. Every major newspaper in the
- 7:03city, the Herald, the Tribune, the Sun, the Times, the world
- 7:07the Journal had its office, was when shouting distance of each
- 7:10other, all of them packed into a few blocks, all of them fighting
- 7:14for the same readers and the same stories.
- 7:16At News Stands St. vendors were screaming headlines at people
- 7:19walking by, Newsboys are running through the streets, and extras
- 7:23got printed multiple times a day whenever something broke.
- 7:27The competition was vicious in a way that's honestly hard to
- 7:30picture now, because these weren't just competing
- 7:32businesses. They were competing worldviews,
- 7:36competing political machines, competing egos with their own
- 7:39names carved into the buildings and the Newsboys themselves.
- 7:44This is the part people forget. The Newsboys were children,
- 7:47thousands of them. Orphaned or homeless or just
- 7:49poor. Here's how it worked.
- 7:51They bought the papers up front at $0.50 per hundred.
- 7:54Then they sold them on the street for a penny each.
- 7:57If they didn't sell all the papers, they ate the losses
- 8:00themselves, and if they sold every last one, they made $0.50.
- 8:05That was the entire business model.
- 8:07Child labor, your Commission. No safety net underneath any of
- 8:10it, and both Pulitzer and Hearst depended on these boys to move
- 8:14the product. They were the distribution
- 8:16network. They were the algorithm before
- 8:18which there was such a thing as an algorithm.
- 8:21Now, in 1895, there was a cartoonist named Richard Outcolt
- 8:26drawing a comic strip for Pulitzer's world, and it was
- 8:28called Hogan's Alley. The strip was set in a fictional
- 8:31Lower East Side tenement yard full of kids and immigrants and
- 8:35pure urban chaos, and the main character was a bald kid in a
- 8:39yellow night shirt who never said bunch.
- 8:42But the kid captured something true about the life at the
- 8:45bottom of New York, and people loved him.
- 8:46He became an honest to God cultural phenomenon.
- 8:49Hurst, doing the thing Hurst always did, simply hired Occult
- 8:53away, and Pulitzer refused to lose the strip, so he hired a
- 8:56different cartoonist to keep drawing it, which meant that for
- 8:59a stretch, both papers were running their own version of the
- 9:02Yellow Kid at the same time. It was confusing, it was faintly
- 9:06absurd, and it was probably good for circulation at both papers.
- 9:11So critics and rival editors started calling the yellow kid
- 9:14papers, and that became the yellow kid journalism, and that
- 9:17became yellow journalism. The term was never meant as a
- 9:20compliment, but it stuck, and it describes something real because
- 9:25by 1897, both papers had crossed the line, and it wasn't really
- 9:29about exaggeration anymore. It became about fabrication.
- 9:33In February of 1897, Hirsch Journal ran a story that stopped
- 9:36the whole city cold. The front page headline screamed
- 9:40that a Spanish official down in Cuba had strip searched 3 Cuban
- 9:43women aboard an American ship, a ship called the Olivet, and the
- 9:48Journal ran an illustration with it, showing a Spanish officer
- 9:51leering at naked women while thugs held her down.
- 9:54The story was lurid, it was enraging, and it sold.
- 9:58It also wasn't true. The search had actually been
- 10:00carried out by a female matron, not a male officer, and the
- 10:04journal knew that before they ever printed the illustration.
- 10:07They printed it anyway when the world exposed the lie.
- 10:11First response is the part you really want to pay attention to
- 10:14because it tells you everything. He didn't apologize and he
- 10:17didn't retract. Instead, he claimed the world
- 10:19was defending Spanish brutality. He took the correction and
- 10:23turned it into another attack. And that right there is a
- 10:26playbook in the purest form. Step one is you fabricate an
- 10:29atrocity. Step 2 is you use the outrage to
- 10:32sell papers. And Step 3 is when somebody
- 10:35catches you, you accuse your accuser of being complicit.
- 10:39And it worked. Florida State Urse had grasped
- 10:41something that would echo through the next 100 years of
- 10:44American media. The correction never catches up
- 10:47with the headline. The lie travels twice around the
- 10:50world while the truth is still putting its shoes on.
- 10:52Richard Outcolt, the cartoonist, knew exactly what was happening,
- 10:57and years later, he looked back in those days and said it just
- 10:59plainly. He said they were faking the
- 11:02news, faking the pictures, faking the war.
- 11:04But those drawings were like the moving pictures of today, that
- 11:07they'd stir the people up. And that it paid.
- 11:10And that's the line that matters most.
- 11:12It paid. The mechanism was profitable,
- 11:15and once a mechanism is profitable, it starts to
- 11:18perpetuate itself. Then came Evangelina Cisneros
- 11:22and her story was real, at least in part.
- 11:24She was a young Cuban woman whose father had joined the
- 11:27rebellion against Spain, and the Spanish authorities arrested her
- 11:30and locked her up in the notorious Casa de Rey Congardas
- 11:34in Havana, and she was just 18 years old.
- 11:37Hurst looked at her and saw the perfect story, a beautiful young
- 11:40woman imprisoned unjustly by a foreign power.
- 11:43So the Journal turned her into a cause and a front page campaign
- 11:47that ran day after day and week after week, until hundreds of
- 11:50thousands of readers had signed petitions demanding her release.
- 11:54And when diplomacy failed, Hurst escalated.
- 11:57He sent a reporter named Carl Decker down to Havana with a
- 11:59single mission, which was to break her out of prison.
- 12:02Decker rented a house near the prison.
- 12:05He bribed the guards he arranged to the skies, and on October
- 12:097th, 1897, Cisneros climbed through a window and escaped.
- 12:14Decker smuggled her onto the American steamer, and she
- 12:17arrived in New York to a hero's welcome.
- 12:19Hearst organized a parade. He held a rally at Madison
- 12:22Square Garden, and he put her up on stage next to the governor of
- 12:26New York. The Journal didn't report that
- 12:28story. The Journal was the story, and
- 12:30this is the thing to sit with. That wasn't journalism, it was
- 12:34theater. It was a publicity stunt dressed
- 12:36up as a rescue mission. But it proves something.
- 12:38Hearst would never forget that. If you controlled the narrative,
- 12:42you controlled reality itself. You didn't have to wait for
- 12:45events to happen anymore. You could just manufacture them.
- 12:48On February 15th, 1898, the USS Maine exploded in Havana harbor.
- 12:53The ship had been sent down to Cuba to protect American
- 12:56interests during the rebellion against Spain, and at 9:40 that
- 12:59night, a massive blast tore through the forward section of
- 13:02the ship and The Maine sank in minutes. 266 American sailors
- 13:08died. It was a catastrophe, and it was
- 13:10also an opportunity. Within hours, Hearst's journal
- 13:13was running the headline that the warship Maine had been split
- 13:17in two by an enemy's secret infernal machine.
- 13:20There is no evidence for that. There was no investigation.
- 13:23There was just a headline that happened to fit the narrative
- 13:26they already wanted. And Pulitzer's world was only
- 13:29slightly more restrained. It ran a front page with
- 13:32diagrams showing exactly where a mine must have been placed.
- 13:36Both papers offered rewards for the capture of whomever did it
- 13:39$50,000, which it was an enormous sum.
- 13:42In 1898. The journal ran illustrations of
- 13:45Spanish saboteurs attaching mines to the hull.
- 13:48It ran accounts of Spanish celebrations after the
- 13:51explosion. It ran stories of Spanish
- 13:53insults hurled at the American dead.
- 13:56The evidence was nowhere to be found.
- 13:57The conclusions were everywhere. A modern investigation would
- 14:00eventually determine that the explosion was almost certainly
- 14:03an accident, a coal bunker fire that ignited the powder
- 14:06magazines. But in 1898, the truth simply
- 14:09didn't matter. The story mattered, and the
- 14:11story was war. And this is where the most
- 14:14famous line in the history of American journalism enters the
- 14:17myth. First, it sent the artist
- 14:19Frederick Remington down to Cuba to document the rebellion.
- 14:23And Remington got there, looked around and cabled back that
- 14:26there was no war here, that everything was quiet and Hearst
- 14:29supposedly cabled back. You furnish the pictures, I'll
- 14:33furnish the war. Now, historians argue about
- 14:35whether that exchange actually happened.
- 14:37The original telegrams have never been found.
- 14:40But here's what matters more than the exact words.
- 14:43The sentiment was precisely accurate.
- 14:45Whether he said it or not, it's exactly what he did.
- 14:49He furnished the war. The Journal ran stories of
- 14:51Spanish atrocities that had never occurred.
- 14:54It ran drawings of battles that had never been fought.
- 14:57It ran interviews with sources who didn't exist.
- 15:00And when the Spanish government protested, Hirsch simply refused
- 15:03to print their denials. He declared everything the
- 15:06Spanish source untrustworthy, and in doing that, he created a
- 15:09closed information loop. The Journal reported the
- 15:12atrocities. Spain denied them.
- 15:14And then the Journal reported Spain's denials as proof of
- 15:17guilt. There was no escape from it.
- 15:19The machine was now feeding itself.
- 15:21On April 11th, 1898, President William McKinley asked Congress
- 15:25for a declaration of war. Congress approved it, and the
- 15:28Spanish American War began. It lasted four months and cost
- 15:32relatively few American lives. And at the end of it, the United
- 15:35States walked away with control over Cuba, Puerto Rico, Guam and
- 15:39the Philippines. That was the moment America
- 15:42became imperial power, and the whole thing had been pushed over
- 15:45the edge by two newspapermen in a circulation war.
- 15:48This wasn't a conflict. It was a product designed,
- 15:51packaged and delivered. And Hurst himself went down to
- 15:54Cuba, where he didn't just report on the war, he
- 15:57participated in it. He chartered A steamship, and he
- 15:59sailed in the Cuban waters. He personally LED a party of
- 16:02journal reporters that captured a small Spanish Garrison.
- 16:06He handed the prisoners over to the US Navy.
- 16:08And then he filed the story himself.
- 16:11The newspaper publisher had become a combatant, and the line
- 16:14between the observer and the participant have been erased
- 16:16completely, and it would never really be drawn again.
- 16:19Here's the point of this story that most historians miss.
- 16:22The war itself wasn't actually profitable for the newspapers.
- 16:26Hearst spent more money covering it than he ever made from it,
- 16:29and his papers ramped enormous debts doing it.
- 16:32The circulation spike during the war years was real, and the
- 16:35Journal and the world each sold more than 1,000,000 copies a day
- 16:39during the crisis. But the cost of the reporting,
- 16:43the cost of running all those extraditions, the cost of the
- 16:46stunts, all of that ate the revenue alive.
- 16:49So the war was not a business success, it was a power success.
- 16:54And that's a different thing entirely, because Hearst had
- 16:56proven that he could do something no private citizen in
- 16:59American history had ever done before.
- 17:01He had manufactured a war. He had pushed a reluctant
- 17:04president and a divided Congress into a military action, not
- 17:09through bribery, not through blackmail, but through
- 17:12information, through the strategic deployment of outrage.
- 17:16The mechanism was now proven. And once the mechanism is
- 17:19proven, it doesn't disappear. It just gets refined.
- 17:23And the Newsboys understood this before anybody else did.
- 17:26In the summer of 1899, Hurst and Pulitzer raised the wholesale
- 17:29price of their newspapers to $0.60 per 100, up from 50, a 10
- 17:34cent increase that came down to just pennies per boy a day.
- 17:37But for those kids, pennies were the difference between eating
- 17:41and not eating. So on July 18th, the Newsboys
- 17:44went on strike, thousands of them children between 8 and 17
- 17:48years old. They stopped selling the Journal
- 17:50and the world. They organized.
- 17:52They held rallies. They blocked the delivery
- 17:55wagons. They fought the scabs in the
- 17:57streets. They shut down the distribution
- 17:59network of the two most powerful newspapers in the country.
- 18:03And they won. The publishers didn't roll back
- 18:05the price increase, but they did agree to buy back the unsold
- 18:08newspapers, which was something no newsboy had ever been offered
- 18:12before. The children had done what the
- 18:14Spanish government couldn't do. They had forced Hertz and
- 18:17Pulitzer to bend. But the strike revealed
- 18:20something else, something deeper.
- 18:22It revealed the machine from the bottom.
- 18:25The entire edifice of yellow journalism was resting on the
- 18:28backs of children. Children standing on street
- 18:30corners in the freezing rain, getting beaten by the police,
- 18:34sleeping in doorways with stacks of papers they couldn't sell.
- 18:38The circulation war had always been fought by the people who
- 18:41never once saw the profits. And with that, the template was
- 18:45complete. The mechanism they built never
- 18:47went away. It just changed platforms.
- 18:50Same playbook, different century, and the steps haven't
- 18:53changed at all. You identify an enemy, you
- 18:56manufacture the outrage, you make the audience feel
- 18:59personally threatened. You demand action, and then you
- 19:03profit from the outrage. Cable news refined it, talk
- 19:06radio amplified it, and social media perfected it.
- 19:09But the architecture was poured on Park Row back in 1897.
- 19:13Every algorithm that rewards outrage over accuracy is a
- 19:17direct descendant of the Yellow Kid.
- 19:19Every pundit who fabricates a crisis to drive his ratings is
- 19:23the Hearst playbook. And every closed information
- 19:25loop that treats the other side's denials as proof of
- 19:28guilt? That's the same system, just on
- 19:30different screens. Now, Hearst didn't invent
- 19:32propaganda. Governments have been lying to
- 19:35their populations for centuries before he was ever born.
- 19:38What Hearst invented was something more dangerous than
- 19:41that. He proved that private citizens
- 19:43could do it at scale. He proved that outrage was a
- 19:46commodity, a raw material, something that could be mined
- 19:49and refined and sold by the barrel.
- 19:51And he proved that a media empire didn't need to reflect
- 19:54public opinion. It could manufacture public
- 19:57opinion. Once that was proven, it could
- 20:00never be unproven. The genie was out.
- 20:02Pulitzer died in 1911, and he left behind a complicated
- 20:05legacy. A man who pioneered
- 20:07sensationalism also endowed the Columbia School of Journalism.
- 20:11He created the Pulitzer Prize. And he spent his final years
- 20:15trying to lift journalism back out of the gutter that he
- 20:18himself had dug. But the machine he helped to
- 20:20build didn't die with him. Hurst lived all the way up until
- 20:231951, and by the end, he owned 28 newspapers, 18 magazines,
- 20:28radio stations and film companies.
- 20:31He'd been elected to Congress. He'd nearly been elected
- 20:34president. And he built a castle in
- 20:36California so vast that no one exactly knew how many rooms it
- 20:40had. He died one of the most powerful
- 20:42man in American history, and the method he perfected in 1897 was
- 20:46still working. It's still working right now.
- 20:49Every time you see a headline that's designed to make you
- 20:51angry rather than to inform you, every time a story breaks that's
- 20:55just a little too perfectly aligned with somebody's agenda
- 20:59to be an accident. Every time you feel the surge of
- 21:01outrage that demands to be shared, to be posted, to be
- 21:04echoed, in those moments, you are standing on Park Row, you're
- 21:08holding a penny paper, and somewhere out there, someone is
- 21:11counting on you to buy exactly what they're selling.
- 21:14They didn't cover history. They wrote it.
- 21:17And the ink has never tried. This has been hidden forces in
- 21:20history. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 21:22Please like these video, Leave us a comment and smash the
- 21:25subscribe button if you want more hidden forces in history.