Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Inside the NCUA Annual Report — A Strong System with Quiet Warning Signs with Mike Macchiarola
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trekel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04I am back here today with Mike Mola, a partner at Olden Lane.
- 0:08Mike, how you doing today?
- 0:10Mick Mac: Doing great, mark.
- 0:11Thanks for having me.
- 0:12Mark Treichel: You got it.
- 0:12Glad to hear it.
- 0:13Now, one of, one of the episodes you and I have done and I can't remember
- 0:16if we've done this two times or just once, but we've talked about the NC
- 0:20annual NCUA annual report and your takeaways, and then my takeaways about
- 0:26your takeaways, but that's most of what we're gonna talk about here today.
- 0:31For listeners or watchers who have not seen you or heard you on the
- 0:36podcast before, could you give a little bit of background of yourself
- 0:39and Olden Lane and what it is you're all doing for the system?
- 0:43Mick Mac: Sure.
- 0:44Olden Lane is located in Bridgewater, New Jersey.
- 0:48We've got nine professionals working here now and we fashion ourselves as the.
- 0:53Only to our mind investment bank that deals exclusively with credit
- 0:58union and credit union issues.
- 0:59We represent credit unions, large and small, all across the country.
- 1:03If we've made our name anywhere, it's been predominantly insubordinate debt
- 1:07where we've done about 60% of the deals that have happened in the last.
- 1:11Six or seven years by either deal count or dollar amount.
- 1:15We're increasingly moving into the m and a sphere because that's
- 1:18a pronounced need in this in this environment and in this movement.
- 1:23And as of yesterday we're announcing this is a worldwide
- 1:25scoop for Mark Tris podcast.
- 1:28As of yesterday, we're announcing that we're taking our talents, if you will.
- 1:32LeBron said to Stifel.
- 1:34We will be joining Stifel Nicholas and Company very shortly.
- 1:38We are tremendously excited about that because our two business lines slot in
- 1:43perfectly with what they already have.
- 1:46They're a massive player in the credit union space and we are just
- 1:50thrilled about what we can do together.
- 1:52Mark Treichel: That's exciting.
- 1:53I know, when you and I when you told me about that, and it was explaining
- 1:56how what you do and what they do fit.
- 1:58Yin, ying, yin and yang.
- 2:00Yin and yang.
- 2:00I'm gonna get part of that wrong.
- 2:02The Chinese is not my expertise, but it's, it seems like it's a great
- 2:05fit and I'm excited for you and your clients and of course for Stifel.
- 2:10Mick Mac: Yeah, we've got a lot more capabilities.
- 2:11We've got a bigger team and a and we add, smarts all across the board,
- 2:15and we've worked with them on a number of projects over the years,
- 2:18and we could not be happier about the quality of the person we're joining.
- 2:21So it's going to be great.
- 2:23Mark Treichel: That's awesome.
- 2:24It's so we're recording this April 21st.
- 2:28This episode will be out April 28th, I think, next Tuesday.
- 2:32And, as we're sitting here I've got my half zip on and that's it.
- 2:36You referenced LeBron James.
- 2:38So I'm gonna reference Peyton Manning.
- 2:40I've got my Peyton Manny inspired half zip 'cause it's really cold where I'm at
- 2:44today and the NFL draft is on Thursday.
- 2:47Your New York Giants I think have a couple, two of the top 10 draft picks.
- 2:52I'm hoping they screw those up.
- 2:53So some guys fall to my Vikings, but,
- 2:55Mick Mac: don't worry, they'll screw it up.
- 2:58What do they say?
- 2:59Past performance is not necessarily indicative of.
- 3:03Mark Treichel: I love it.
- 3:04I love it.
- 3:05All and by the time this plays more people will know about your merger
- 3:08and how that's all gonna work out.
- 3:10And more pe and everybody will know who their teams picked or should have picked.
- 3:13So with that.
- 3:15Let's jump into the annual report and I saw your LinkedIn post and you broke
- 3:20it into the Mag Magnificent seven.
- 3:23So I'm gonna, I'm gonna walk through the seven topics you brought up and we'll walk
- 3:28through that and then maybe do a cleanup at the end if there's anything else
- 3:31that that we still need to chat about.
- 3:32Sound good?
- 3:33Mick Mac: Perfect.
- 3:34Mark Treichel: All right.
- 3:35So item number one.
- 3:36Your takeaway from the annual report was that the system is strong, but
- 3:41the tone is cautious and rightly slow.
- 3:43Rightly can you dive into that?
- 3:46Mick Mac: Sure.
- 3:47The first thing I would say is that I have a sign above my desk and it says, the laws
- 3:52of economics are like the laws of gravity.
- 3:56They are non-negotiable.
- 3:58So that's the lens through which we look at everything here at Olden Lane, and
- 4:03when you look through that lens you've got to be honest about what's going on.
- 4:07So the count of credit unions we're at 42 87 at the time of this report.
- 4:13It.
- 4:14Down from 44 55 last year.
- 4:17So a three and a half, 3.7%
- 4:20decline.
- 4:20Why consolidation?
- 4:22Mostly right.
- 4:23We've had a few liquidations in the last year but it's really consolidation
- 4:28and with 4,200 left on the playing field, losing close to 200 a year,
- 4:34you can do the math mark on how long we can continue to do that.
- 4:38On the creation side, we talk a lot about de novo.
- 4:42I know Chairman Halman cares a lot about de novo, but we're nowhere near
- 4:46where we need to be on de novo, and we're not de novo ing, if you will.
- 4:50I'm turning it into a verb new credit unions that are significant in terms
- 4:54of size, shape, and member reach.
- 4:57If we're going to be replacing folks, we need to replace 'em with
- 5:01credit unions of Hef, then frankly the regulations don't allow it.
- 5:04We can go into how you can grow a credit union, but you
- 5:06can't start big and grow big.
- 5:08You have to start small and it takes many years and a slow growth
- 5:12pattern to get anywhere of size.
- 5:15Asset level, we're at 2.43,
- 5:172.43
- 5:18trillion at the time of this report up slightly from last year.
- 5:21Nothing to say there.
- 5:22That's natural growth.
- 5:25Average asset size per credit union.
- 5:28Interesting.
- 5:29We've gone to 568 million up from five 18.
- 5:32That's a 10% increase in a year, so our credit unions are getting bigger.
- 5:37Why?
- 5:38The ones that we're losing are on the smaller end of the barbell.
- 5:42So the asset size is gaining some good news.
- 5:46The average ROA at a credit union up to 79 bips from 63 bips a year ago.
- 5:51I think that's part of the story we're seeing, repair in the overall
- 5:55macroeconomic picture, although again, I'd be a little cautious.
- 6:00We've got 144.7
- 6:02million members up from 142 million.
- 6:06I hate the member number.
- 6:07I think we've talked about this before.
- 6:09It's a tough number to put your arms around.
- 6:11I don't know who's a member of multiple credit unions.
- 6:14I don't know how many of these members are true core members in a geography
- 6:18or a seg base versus indirect members or foundational associational members.
- 6:23So it's hard to say anything about a membership number per se.
- 6:27I can tell you that the membership skews heavily to larger credit unions.
- 6:32If you were to plot out over the last decade where the growth is, all of
- 6:36it is in the larger credit unions.
- 6:39The largest cohort of credit unions is growing at about 10% annually.
- 6:43Over the last decade, the smallest group of credit unions
- 6:47are declining in membership.
- 6:48In fact, the median credit union in the US has negative member
- 6:52growth for the last six quarters.
- 6:56New membership per branch is in a free fall.
- 6:59It's now half of what it was in quarter two of 2023, and the cost of acquiring
- 7:06a new member is insanely expensive.
- 7:10About to touch $900 per member.
- 7:12Mark Treichel: Wow.
- 7:13Mick Mac: That's up from $400 per member just two, three years ago.
- 7:20So there's a lot underneath.
- 7:21The net worth is healthy at 11.3,
- 7:23but I always caution people the median or mean net worth credit union
- 7:28is not what you're worried about.
- 7:30It's the one on the low end and there is some error, if you will,
- 7:35or some artificial bolstering of that number because there's still
- 7:39tax credits that are in there from the employee retention tax credit.
- 7:44I can tell you we worked with firms and added $250 million
- 7:47by ourselves to net income.
- 7:50I would assume that the industry probably did about three or four times that number.
- 7:54And that's still in that retained earnings or in that capital number.
- 7:58The other thing that's in that capital number is the effects of the generational
- 8:02capital that came from the EIP program, the US Treasury bolstered to the tune
- 8:07of about north of $2 billion bolstered this industry with 30 year capital.
- 8:13So again, overall good numbers, but there's reason for caution.
- 8:20Mark Treichel: When I wrote down a few different things that you said.
- 8:22The median credit union has shrunk for six quarters.
- 8:26That's like a wow statement to me, and I think as you said it, I
- 8:30think of some other analysis I did, and it's a reminder of that, but.
- 8:34And of course you're a bigger math guy than I am, but the
- 8:37median is the middle most, right?
- 8:39That's the one smack dab in the middle asset side wise.
- 8:42But to have shrunk in, is it members, right?
- 8:45For six straight quarters?
- 8:46That's that's off the hook.
- 8:47Crazy.
- 8:48When you think about that, what and the odds are those less than that are nine
- 8:51times outta 10 doing something similarly.
- 8:56The one other item, as you're talking about new charters.
- 9:00And I don't know, every time I go to nnc.gov,
- 9:03I wonder if they're gonna change the photo on the front.
- 9:05'cause the photo on the front is nnc a Charter's Haven Federal Credit
- 9:09Union, which happened, I don't know, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 months ago.
- 9:12They haven't, they've been doing a lot of things, updating regulations, but they're
- 9:16not dropping that into their headline.
- 9:17They're they're proud of one charter.
- 9:20And those new charters that come in, some of 'em.
- 9:23Survived two years.
- 9:24Some of 'em survived five years, some of 'em survived 10 years.
- 9:26Meanwhile, you've got fintechs doing a lot, which we're gonna get into.
- 9:30And you've got the Trump administration.
- 9:33Being appearing to be willing to charter some new banks, which is gonna create some
- 9:37more competition for credit unions and in particular, those small credit unions.
- 9:42Yeah, it's a, the numbers look good but there's challenges rolled up
- 9:46underneath and brewing, which goes to that headline of the numbers.
- 9:49I gotta pull back.
- 9:50Let's see.
- 9:51I got your notes here on the.
- 9:53Yeah, but the tone is cautious, right?
- 9:55That links back to the tone is cautious in my mind.
- 9:58Mick Mac: You've also got, look, we, you guys, like you and I,
- 10:01we dig deep in these numbers.
- 10:03We live in this world every day and we pay a lot of attention to it, and we get
- 10:06a lot of insight baseball, but we have to pull back and we have to remember.
- 10:12All of these institutions combined are 60% of JP Morgan, give or take.
- 10:17Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 10:17Mick Mac: So somebody wakes up on the wrong side of the bed in terms of
- 10:22a policymaker or a real influencer.
- 10:24And we may all be looking at something very different tomorrow.
- 10:27And you gotta fight.
- 10:28Like you're the somebody told me you gotta fight like you're the third monkey
- 10:32and Noah's Ark is only bringing two.
- 10:34That's kinda what it is every day.
- 10:36And you're doing it obviously for a good reason and on behalf of members.
- 10:40Mark Treichel: Absolutely.
- 10:40Mick Mac: But, let's understand the world in which we're playing
- 10:44and, one of the pieces we did about six months ago was, SoFi, which
- 10:48is not a top 50 bank in the us.
- 10:50They gathered as many new members in Q3 of 2025 as the 4,400 institutions
- 10:57that we call credit unions.
- 10:58And that's just staggering.
- 11:00Mark Treichel: Staggering indeed.
- 11:02Mick Mac: The other thing is for caution.
- 11:04If you take delinquent loans and charge offs and add 'em together,
- 11:09and then you put 'em all on top of the average loans at a credit union,
- 11:13we're now at about a decade long high.
- 11:17So the credit quality of what we're holding is still tenuous.
- 11:22Now, it's not breaking the glass kind of nervousness yet, but
- 11:29the trend line is not great.
- 11:32With that trend line is a lot of the deflating of the air that came from some
- 11:37of the pickup we had because of this COVID relief and some of the changes that
- 11:40happened behaviorally among our members and among our ability to staff things.
- 11:45So opex is flying.
- 11:48It's hard to control.
- 11:49We're in an inflationary environment.
- 11:51The biggest contributor to everybody's opex is their staffing.
- 11:54And everybody seems to be, not able to reduce head count and or having to
- 11:59continue to put more fuel in the furnace.
- 12:02And so it's weighing on our prospects.
- 12:05Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:05And
- 12:05Mick Mac: then, and then the other thing go ahead Mark.
- 12:06Mark Treichel: No, I was just gonna say, even though the ro
- 12:09a's up, what, 16 basis points?
- 12:11That can be eaten up real quick with with a little bit more delinquency,
- 12:1510 15 more basis points of delinquency that turns into charge-offs which
- 12:20then hyper hyper impacts your Cecil.
- 12:23And I, we, Cecil would behold, I was just doing some analysis on
- 12:27how the funding is in Cecil, right?
- 12:29And there's, some folks out there looking through rose collar glasses and.
- 12:34Exams will eventually pick up on that.
- 12:36But yeah.
- 12:37So you were gonna say something, I'm sorry.
- 12:38Mick Mac: The last thing I would say is, I deal in the world of
- 12:42aggregates in a certain sense.
- 12:44So you and I get together and I say this is my view of the overall industry.
- 12:47We, the last piece we did on our newsletter, I think it
- 12:51was entitled, everything Has a Season And the point of it was.
- 12:55Each credit union not only has to understand where it is in the
- 12:58macroeconomic picture, which again we can understand in a big way, but
- 13:02also has geographic particularities.
- 13:06But the other thing is you have to understand where you are in
- 13:08your own business maturation.
- 13:11How far along in your tech refresh are you, how far along are you in your core
- 13:16that you're gonna be looking at a core conversion next year, or you just got
- 13:19it behind you and it's free sailing?
- 13:21Where is your member base and how old are they vis-a-vis where you need them to be?
- 13:25And so what we've said to people is you've got to understand not only.
- 13:29The best practices of the industry and where you are in
- 13:32a big, broad, macro picture.
- 13:34But you have to understand your own decision making with a tailored
- 13:38approach that accounts for the specific time, place, and prospects
- 13:42of your business, all of which are unique credit union by Credit Union.
- 13:47Mark Treichel: No, makes total sense.
- 13:48And I like your reference to the Mamas and papa songs under the seasons there.
- 13:51That's awesome.
- 13:53A me.
- 13:54So no.
- 13:54Let's pivot to number two.
- 13:55A meaningful shift in regulatory philosophy is in full swing.
- 14:01Mick Mac: Okay.
- 14:01This is, this is a way of just saying there are Democrats in the world
- 14:04and there are Republicans in the world and sometimes Republicans take
- 14:08control and have a philosophy, and sometimes Democrats have control.
- 14:11Look, it's not lost on anybody that this is thematic.
- 14:15It's similar to.
- 14:17What's happening in the banking world?
- 14:19We're seeing the elimination of certain things.
- 14:21We're seeing an emphasis on deregulation or, whatever buzzword you want to
- 14:27you wanna use, but essentially more permissive from the regulatory standpoint.
- 14:34We can argue about whether that's good or bad, but that's a pendulum.
- 14:36It swings, it often swings too far in one direction, only to swing
- 14:40too far in the other direction.
- 14:41When we sweep in a new government.
- 14:44But we're seeing things like the elimination of reputational risk
- 14:48a formal rejection of what they call regulation by enforcement.
- 14:51This is a particular one for Chairman Halman.
- 14:54They've extended exam cycles and we're seeing, I think we saw today, number
- 15:0010, in the deregulation efforts.
- 15:03Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 15:03Mick Mac: Today's was particularly interesting.
- 15:05I haven't read it yet, but certainly I, pulled it out, looked at it.
- 15:11Mark Treichel: Yeah, so number 10 was.
- 15:14Lightening up the rules on credit unions being acquired by banks and I don't know.
- 15:20Chairman Halman, if you're listening, how about coming out or finalizing or
- 15:24providing some guidance on credit unions, purchasing banks that was promised a
- 15:28long time ago in a proposed regulation.
- 15:31And Mike, I'm gonna go down a rabbit hole here.
- 15:34And in that proposed regulation, it said that we will disclose in the
- 15:38National Supervision policy manual.
- 15:40How you can how you can structure your packages for for acquisitions
- 15:46of banks and we'll put it in a national superposition policy manual.
- 15:49Since then they haven't done it.
- 15:51They haven't finalized the regulation, which they're not gonna do, because
- 15:54Trump doesn't want regulations.
- 15:56And you can be on either side of where you wanna be on that.
- 15:58But the link where they used to actually show.
- 16:01A little bit of what they looked at on, on acquisitions is dead.
- 16:05And it's not redacted.
- 16:06It's just dead.
- 16:07Which is a whole other issue I bring up occasionally.
- 16:10The NSPM, but and on the regulatory philosophy in my seven and a half
- 16:15years as executive director, I worked for four NCA board chair and it
- 16:19swung back and forth DRDR, or RDRD.
- 16:23And one of the things that was exhausting for me.
- 16:25Was when orange was per, orange was orange one day, and the next day orange
- 16:29was purple, and purple was orange.
- 16:31And having to, circle the wagons and go in the other direction.
- 16:34And that's just the, that's partially the beauty of the country we live in is that
- 16:38the pendulum swings and you go too far this way and you get Brock back this way.
- 16:42And and the middle is where the most of us are in reality other than the
- 16:46fringes, although the fringes seem to control conversations sometimes.
- 16:50But that was one of the things that, you know made me wanna depart from
- 16:54government work and get out and work in the real world with credit unions.
- 16:57Not that NCA wasn't the real world.
- 17:00But that politics side of it where the pendulum can swing is pretty dramatic.
- 17:05And, the items you raised are substantially different than what it
- 17:09would've been under Harper, what it would've been under Matt's Rick Metzker
- 17:13and the, the extended exam cycle, I know that staff is a little worried about
- 17:18losing 27% of staff and delinquencies at the highest point in time in how
- 17:24many years charge offs are high.
- 17:26And the agency is pushing innovation which is great innovation.
- 17:31You need to innovate or die, right?
- 17:33But having less people to look at that and then going in less frequently is a, is a.
- 17:40Recipe for insurance fund losses and credit unions, smaller credit
- 17:44unions that are gonna go away.
- 17:46And again, that's just, it's part of the cycle.
- 17:49Mick Mac: Yep.
- 17:50No, I listen I agree a hundred percent, but we see it, those of us that have been
- 17:54around long enough or somewhat used to it.
- 17:55And just again, have your head on a swivel and understand the
- 17:58environment in which you're playing.
- 17:59There's not much to say other than.
- 18:01You know that, that's understand, how the deal is dealt.
- 18:05Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 18:06You gotta, everything in life is a game with rules, right?
- 18:09You gotta figure out the game, figure out the rules, and then
- 18:11figure out how to succeed.
- 18:12Yep.
- 18:15So item three on the magnificent seven, innovation is no longer peripheral.
- 18:19It is central to the agenda.
- 18:23Mick Mac: Look, it's difficult for a regulator to do much here to push the
- 18:28horse out of the barn, but they're doing as good a job as they can.
- 18:33They're telling you, look, you're gonna have to innovate.
- 18:35To your point earlier, let's take stable coin for example.
- 18:40They set out in, in, in early 2026 some rulemaking.
- 18:44Trying to remove the ambiguity, trying to tell credit unions, you can embrace it.
- 18:48It's now permissible, albeit through a subsidiary signaling that they're not
- 18:52prohibited, they're legitimate, and, go get 'em and don't complain that others
- 18:57are doing it faster because it's not gonna really be the NCUA that's in your way.
- 19:02Of course there's a lot of other things to navigate here, including a coordination
- 19:06problem and a, and an understanding about your own bigness and your own ability
- 19:10to survive with a coin that may or not, may not get adopted on a broad scope.
- 19:15But again, it's early days and here's where the regulators
- 19:19doing the best they can.
- 19:20And they're, we've seen it time and again.
- 19:23We saw it in derivatives.
- 19:26The regulator was actually faster to tell people to use them than
- 19:30the people were to adopt them.
- 19:31And those that understood it could read the tea leaves and got in
- 19:35front of it were probably helped.
- 19:37When we had the interest rate volatility that we had.
- 19:41I, I believe the NCA was early on the pro permission to up the
- 19:46ability to take non-member shares.
- 19:48They upped that limit earlier than people needed it.
- 19:51And honestly, when people did need it, it bailed them out
- 19:53of a hell of a lot of trouble.
- 19:55Mark Treichel: Yeah, great point.
- 19:56Mick Mac: And I think we're slow to give credit to the regulator where
- 19:59the regulator is actually further down the road than we're willing to adopt.
- 20:03So again, I think.
- 20:05Them signaling out loud that, we're open for innovation.
- 20:08Of course Chairman Halman has been a proponent of everything,
- 20:12innovative from crypto to stablecoin, to, to anything in between.
- 20:16Certainly we will love to have those conversations and is not shied away
- 20:20from embracing people who want to get into that realm in a responsible way.
- 20:24There's a lot of work to do.
- 20:26It's still early days.
- 20:28Just by nature, their size, their shape.
- 20:30Credit unions are not gonna be the tip of the spear at the
- 20:33innovation here, most likely.
- 20:34But you gotta be a fast follower and you gotta understand a path and
- 20:37you gotta keep an eye on it because otherwise you're gonna be swept away.
- 20:42Mark Treichel: Great point.
- 20:43And I saw chairman Hotman speak at GAC and he talked a little bit about,
- 20:49about, crypto and stable coins.
- 20:52And made a reference that I hadn't heard before and then
- 20:55did a little bit of research.
- 20:56And it's it's a narrative that I am growing to understand, but essentially
- 21:00that if stable coins help the US dollar re remain the focal currency
- 21:05in the world, that's a positive thing.
- 21:08And I think to me, that's a better.
- 21:10That's a better use case than I've heard from other things
- 21:13where people are thinking stable coin is going to make sense.
- 21:17And then earlier last week I was listening to the FinTech Takes podcast.
- 21:21A great podcast out there.
- 21:23And there was a passing reference to North Korea stealing 80, I don't know,
- 21:2770 or $80 million of stablecoin from a provider within like a seven hour window
- 21:34where they hacked it and took it over and now this money is in North Korea.
- 21:38And I'm thinking I thought crypto and.
- 21:40Stablecoin, we're supposed to be like the most ultimately secure thing and
- 21:44better than all the systems we got now.
- 21:46And if you don't have that with Stablecoin, what do you have?
- 21:48I took a screenshot of that podcast.
- 21:51I'm gonna go back and try and research that for a future episode.
- 21:54But that kind of didn't surprise me, but it surprised me.
- 21:57Mick Mac: Yeah, there's two things I would say.
- 21:59One is I have long thought.
- 22:04Designed it this way, but it's, when you look at the collateralization and
- 22:07the requirement that it's supported by treasuries you can back quickly
- 22:11into an understanding that it creates demand, albeit, artificial or real
- 22:16demand for us treasuries, probably, that otherwise wouldn't be there.
- 22:21And that is a defense of the US dollar.
- 22:23And that's probably not by accident.
- 22:25Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 22:26Yeah.
- 22:26It's,
- 22:27Mick Mac: second thing is I've
- 22:28Mark Treichel: always probably got by accident that's, I'm glad
- 22:30they're talking about it now is 'cause I was always trying to figure
- 22:32out, so what does this really do?
- 22:33If that's what it does, it's awesome.
- 22:36Mick Mac: Yeah.
- 22:36The second thing I would say is look like every new innovation technology,
- 22:40there's always a, a blow up.
- 22:42Someone, we're going down the highway, everything looks great, and someone
- 22:45blows a flat tire and it is what it is, and they'll be the poster boy.
- 22:49And, then we will address it and, understand it and fix it, repair
- 22:53it and hopefully have a better, smoother ride going forward.
- 22:57But, look, it, it's being adopted quickly.
- 23:00It's certainly got legs, and again, the whole thing could come to a screeching
- 23:04halt if we change administrations and they change their view on it.
- 23:07But, for now, you've got to understand where you are in that ecosystem
- 23:11and have a plan of some sort.
- 23:13Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 23:13And remember, there are no blockbusters and there are no horses.
- 23:16When you go outside, you're not gonna see any horses and buggies
- 23:19unless you're in in Pennsylvania.
- 23:21Let's pivot to consolidations.
- 23:23So consolidations continue.
- 23:25We touched on that a little bit, but there's a lot there to unpack.
- 23:29Mick Mac: Yeah.
- 23:30Look, we've talked about how many are disappearing.
- 23:33They're disappearing either, mostly by consolidation.
- 23:37The charts are crazy.
- 23:39There's a few things you have to understand in the background.
- 23:41The first thing is, even with the numbers that we have, even the good credit
- 23:44unions, we're a little bit miscast.
- 23:47One of the things that we're discovering here is that the average age of a credit
- 23:50union member is just simply too high.
- 23:53It's sitting at 53 today.
- 23:55The average age of a US person is 38 and a half.
- 23:58So we're aiming at.
- 24:00Customers who are older, and that's not per se bad except when you start getting
- 24:04into the habits and whether they make a good customer for a financial institution.
- 24:10Baby boomers represent the largest share of credit union members today.
- 24:13They're about 39% of credit union members.
- 24:15That's up from about 28% a year a decade ago.
- 24:19And credit unions are falling behind in new account openings.
- 24:22If you asked respondents in a recent survey, did you
- 24:25open a new deposit account?
- 24:2710% of those people opened it at a credit union, and that's down
- 24:30from about 16% a few years ago.
- 24:33So what does it mean?
- 24:34It means that the group that we're facing are in the baby boomer
- 24:37generation, and we talk about that generation as being between 62 and 79.
- 24:41Right now, 62 is important.
- 24:44It's the age of retirement.
- 24:4570 nine's important.
- 24:46It's the age of life expectancy.
- 24:48So if you're in that group, you're not a great banking customer.
- 24:52In reality because you're drawing down savings.
- 24:55You're not adding to savings, you're giving away your savings to the next
- 24:58generation, and they may be going to a different financial institution
- 25:02and you're not originating loans.
- 25:04In terms of profitability, you're not a great solution for credit unions today.
- 25:09So the answer lies in finding the younger customer who you
- 25:12gain some lifetime value with.
- 25:15And here the number is, are startling because while we have a big advantage,
- 25:21we're sitting on $2 trillion of deposits in the credit union space.
- 25:25Fintech's up to about 127 billion.
- 25:28When we look at a group, a basket of FinTech, it's SoFi, Robinhood,
- 25:32Wealthfront, Coinbase, none of them have massive deposits yet, but what's scary is
- 25:40the way in which they gather deposits and the competition and how it comes from.
- 25:44So those names I gave you, SoFi Robinhood Wealth Front, coin Base,
- 25:48together, they have zero branches.
- 25:51Credit unions together have 20,000 branches.
- 25:55It's gonna cost us a lot more money to acquire members than it's gonna
- 25:59cost a digital only alternative.
- 26:02And let's look at the member growth.
- 26:04The member growth in the credit union space by mean is about
- 26:09one point a half percent.
- 26:12The digital composite that I just gave you, those same group, 15% growth
- 26:16last year on year member growth.
- 26:18SoFi itself grew members by 38% last year.
- 26:25Robinhood seven, wealth Front, 16.9
- 26:28Coinbase, 10% numerical member growth.
- 26:33The digital platform grew by 6.3.
- 26:37Credit unions only by 2.4.
- 26:41And then you start looking at that and you say, okay, we've got a great head start,
- 26:44but our acquisition costs are higher and our growth prospects and are much slower.
- 26:50So over time, I don't have to be a genius in mathematics.
- 26:54And again, I tell you the laws of mathematics are laws.
- 26:56They're not suggestions.
- 26:58We're gonna get caught and we're gonna get passed and it's only going
- 27:03to accelerate short of knee capping them, which I wouldn't recommend
- 27:08and I don't think is street legal.
- 27:11We've gotta up our own game.
- 27:14We've really gotta start addressing how do we face customers?
- 27:17How do we gather customers, and that's gonna get us, we're not there yet,
- 27:20but I think later in this discussion, we're gonna get to a bigness question.
- 27:25We're gonna get to, am I right at facing customers and potential customers,
- 27:30members and potential members?
- 27:32And if I'm not, how do I address that?
- 27:35And can I do it by myself organically, or is it gonna take something exogenous?
- 27:42Mark Treichel: Thought provoking a lot packed in there.
- 27:44You mentioned Robinhood.
- 27:45I think I heard that the Trump accounts the thousand dollars that
- 27:49kids are gonna get are gonna be.
- 27:51I don't know if pigeonholes the right way, but they're gonna be pushed towards
- 27:54Robinhood, which is a I think there's, I,
- 27:57Mick Mac: it's Robinhood and Bo,
- 27:58Mark Treichel: what I
- 27:58Mick Mac: think bank, I think Bank of New York has a piece, but I think it's
- 28:01Mark Treichel: Robinhood, you're right, it is Bank of New York and Robinhood
- 28:03together collectively are gonna one one's the safe keeper or, what's
- 28:07the term you write into those deals?
- 28:09I think it's the safe keeper but Robin Hood's growth is gonna be more than 7%.
- 28:12If every kid gets an account, oh, by the way, they're kids.
- 28:16Those are the youth that we're talking about.
- 28:18And as you were talking about that, I thought about another.
- 28:22Stat I heard in a podcast where it was a larger bank, had done some
- 28:26analysis about what their members were and where they were weak.
- 28:29Where they were strong.
- 28:31And when they got done looking at it, they realized they had more
- 28:3490 year olds than 19 year olds.
- 28:39And that's not
- 28:39Mick Mac: gonna last long.
- 28:40Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 28:41Yeah.
- 28:43Yeah.
- 28:43That's not gonna last long.
- 28:44'cause those 90 year olds are 11 years beyond the.
- 28:47The life expectancy already.
- 28:49So
- 28:50Mick Mac: 11 years of borrowed time.
- 28:52Mark Treichel: I hear you right?
- 28:52Yeah.
- 28:52Yep.
- 28:53Was it my pink Floyd said shorter or shorter of breath,
- 28:56and one day closer to death.
- 28:57Okay.
- 28:57That's a little macab, but that gets into mergers, right?
- 29:01Very good.
- 29:02All right.
- 29:02And consumer financial, consumer protection remains
- 29:06a steady underlying theme.
- 29:09Mick Mac: Yeah.
- 29:09Look, are customer consumer complaints and inquiries, and there were a fine number,
- 29:13I think they were 49,000 last year.
- 29:16They, handled them well, at least according to their own
- 29:19annual report at the NCUA.
- 29:22The bottom line is this is gonna be de-emphasized and again it's probably
- 29:25politics and this is a subject that chairman Harper cared a lot about.
- 29:29And Chairman Helpmann doesn't care as much about right.
- 29:33And I'm not saying he doesn't care about it, I'm saying
- 29:35it's not a point of emphasis.
- 29:36And so what I wrote in the piece is, the takeaway here is subtle but important.
- 29:41The agency wants credit unions to believe that the priority has not
- 29:44diminished, but the allocation of attention tells us otherwise.
- 29:50So do it that with you will.
- 29:54Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 29:54It's it has been deis regardless of what they say there.
- 29:57And it is the politics and, the, in my mind, one of the things that happens
- 30:03when that happens is the states can still pursue what they wanna do.
- 30:06And so the burden like with the CFPB not being funded and them not being
- 30:11able theoretically to do the mission that they're charged with with them
- 30:15doing less what happens in courts and what happens in the individual states.
- 30:19Can override and take the momentum.
- 30:22And what I anticipate obviously would be whenever there's a transition back to a
- 30:26d is they'll jack up the funding of CFPB and credit union exams will have more
- 30:32consumer protection teeth to it, although, they haven't, Harper had expanded on that.
- 30:39NCA had never really pursued that to the extent of the banks with
- 30:42their separate with their separate consumer compliance exams, et cetera.
- 30:46All so next up, technology and cybersecurity remain front and center.
- 30:52Mick Mac: Yeah, not much to say here.
- 30:53Obviously you've gotta keep your cybersecurity PS and QS up.
- 30:56These things are evolving.
- 30:59AI and agentic AI make it even more difficult, and we gotta continue to
- 31:03make that fight, a fight that we win every single day to protect our data,
- 31:07to protect our customer's information.
- 31:10One of the things I always find interesting here is I think there
- 31:12was some more jawboning about the NCA wants and needs, the tools to go after
- 31:17credit union service organizations.
- 31:19Kusos funny because number one, I don't think it's in the
- 31:22political cards, and number two is.
- 31:25It's really interesting that they're asking for more to do at the same time
- 31:29as they're extending the schedule of exams at credit unions themselves.
- 31:33So it's really be careful what you ask for.
- 31:37Stick to your knitting and stay in your lane.
- 31:39They're not gonna get that.
- 31:40And I know they're not gonna get that.
- 31:42Mark Treichel: And as I said, when I was executive director to somebody who was
- 31:45recommending, we put that on our agenda.
- 31:47I said, I see what we're doing here.
- 31:49If it blows up, we ask for it.
- 31:50We know we're not gonna get it.
- 31:51And then we can say, we told you 18 years in a row, we needed more authority.
- 31:56And you're not gonna, you're not gonna.
- 31:58And that's why it's there.
- 31:59They know they're not gonna get it.
- 32:00They gotta ask for it 'cause it's a authority that if they had.
- 32:05They might be able to do something, might exactly.
- 32:08Or might.
- 32:09Very good.
- 32:09All right the agency itself is changing structurally and operationally.
- 32:15Mick Mac: A couple of observations, as you pointed out earlier, it's not technically
- 32:18a reduction in force, but they had about, right around a quarter of their
- 32:21people take the plan and exit the agency.
- 32:24That's, of course, going to have knock-on effects on everything they do.
- 32:28They've reallocated resources toward technology and efficiency initiatives,
- 32:32and kudos to them for doing that.
- 32:34I think they've been pretty good about that, honestly.
- 32:37They continue to streamline a lot of internal processes
- 32:40and again, kudos for that.
- 32:42More importantly, look let's get myself in some trouble.
- 32:45Chairman Halman has been a good soldier.
- 32:47He's staying past his appointed time because someone has to guide the agency.
- 32:52He did point out at one point, if he just left, it would be zero on the board.
- 32:56I will tell you, I was down there for a board hearing a few weeks ago.
- 33:00It was very strange to be at a board table where it was Chairman Halman, one glass
- 33:05of water, one gavel, one chair, and then I was on the other side of a massive table.
- 33:10It was a very strange board meeting.
- 33:12But there I was.
- 33:14Look, former Chairman Harper is entitled to his day in court.
- 33:18He has a judiciable claim and good for him.
- 33:22I wish we could make an arrangement where he probably started to understand all he
- 33:27is gonna get if he won and I don't think he's going to win, but all he would get
- 33:30is a period victory anyway, because time is pushing everybody's timing out anyway.
- 33:35Again, the president is boxed.
- 33:37I can see why he doesn't wanna make his appointment.
- 33:39But he probably should get on with what he needs to do, whether it be
- 33:42one appointment or three appointments just to allow the agency to move.
- 33:47Again, if you compare it to banking, and we were at a banking conference
- 33:51one of my colleagues and I about a couple months ago in Arizona.
- 33:56Banking, the message was clear.
- 33:58The window is open.
- 33:59We don't know how long it's gonna be open, but do what you need to do,
- 34:03whether it be a merger or it be a reorganization or it'd be anything that
- 34:07needs the permission of the agency.
- 34:10We are not even there yet because we've got.
- 34:13By virtue of the reality of what we have a lame duck leadership
- 34:18that's doing its best but is boxed.
- 34:20We have a president who's boxed on his appointment and we're losing time.
- 34:25We're losing that window whereby we would have this win that our back
- 34:30to do the things we need to do to get in shape to right size and to
- 34:34do some of the permissible activity.
- 34:36We're by definition being slowed down and that's unfortunate for the credit units.
- 34:42Mark Treichel: All great points.
- 34:43I was in charge of a reorganization at NCA where we closed two regions, and I think,
- 34:48I was proud of how we communicated it.
- 34:51I was proud how we handled it with staff.
- 34:54And I, at the time, I would always refer people to a Machiavelli quote.
- 34:59It's just not a person you want to quote in theory very often.
- 35:02But the quote was from the prince, which was, it must be considered that
- 35:07there's nothing more difficult to carry out, nor more doubtful of success.
- 35:11No more dangerous to handle than to initiate a new order of things in bracket.
- 35:16A reorg, yes, for the reformer has the enemies in all those who profit
- 35:22by the older order and lukewarm defenders in those who gain.
- 35:28And I can tell you.
- 35:30I experienced some of that when I led an NCA reorganization.
- 35:35And I can tell you the rumblings out of NCA is those that are losing aren't happy.
- 35:40Those that are losing are doing more with less.
- 35:43Those who are gaining aren't happy.
- 35:45And then when you layer on top of it that they have not communicated
- 35:49to the industry what they're planning on do doing, and they are.
- 35:57I don't wanna say hiding behind, but they're saying we have
- 36:00to negotiate with the union.
- 36:02And now out of nowhere they say that they're gonna finalize it in 2027.
- 36:05So is that they really need to finalize it in 2027 or they don't
- 36:10want to talk about it now and they want the next board to do it.
- 36:13That's someone at n someone who left NCUA who's talking to people at NCA.
- 36:20Theory that to me, I don't know if it's true or not, but I will tell you
- 36:23the morale's challenge, any place that goes down 27% is gonna be challenging.
- 36:27Then when you're told this is what the reorg is gonna be, and
- 36:30then it never gets finalized.
- 36:32And this might be an instance where the union is doing some things.
- 36:34I tend to think maybe not, but anyway, alright, that I went down a rabbit hole.
- 36:37You don't need to comment on that, but you're more than
- 36:39likely you can, if you'd like.
- 36:42Mick Mac: The only thing I would say is that hopefully we've improved from
- 36:45the transition of Machiavelli to Machia because I'm hoping that our reorganization
- 36:51into Stifel goes a lot better.
- 36:54Boom.
- 36:54It's far so good.
- 36:57Mark Treichel: Oh, that was perfect, man.
- 37:01That's awesome.
- 37:03Very good.
- 37:03Very good.
- 37:04Bigness, you, we let's talk about, the law of large numbers.
- 37:09Mick Mac: Yeah.
- 37:09Here's where I, look again, sometimes my job over here is to
- 37:14deliver what my father would say.
- 37:15Tough love.
- 37:17And honestly, this comes from love.
- 37:20It comes from a deep desire to protect the overall franchise that is credit unions.
- 37:26And we've gotta be smart about how we allocate our collective resource.
- 37:32And when I look at numbers, and we do this every quarter, and Ryan, Mark
- 37:36Martin in my office is the guy who is, gets me screaming at 'em from the
- 37:40minute they're out to get me all these numbers fashioned, all kinds of ways.
- 37:45What we try to do is we try to break things down by tier group and so you
- 37:50know, the under 100 million, the 100 to 500, however we decide to sort
- 37:56them, we're sorting them by size and the numbers are just staggering.
- 38:01Mark.
- 38:02I don't think people truly appreciate like a few things to look at right
- 38:07now in the credit union system.
- 38:09If I were to just take the people who are under 500 million of total assets, that
- 38:15group of credit unions makes up 73% of the count by institution, and collectively
- 38:24they have 13% of the assets in the system.
- 38:28So how does that express itself?
- 38:30Number one is a regulator.
- 38:31It makes it difficult, right?
- 38:32Because now I have to send resources all over the place.
- 38:36The second thing, the 21 credit unions that are in the $10 billion plus club,
- 38:43they have 25% of the movement's assets.
- 38:48So we've got to address this.
- 38:49Now, here's the other thing.
- 38:51Every single financial ratio you look at improves with size.
- 38:58So the opex at the under 100 million is a full point higher.
- 39:04Than the bigger credit units.
- 39:06The ROA is lower.
- 39:10Here's one that you know, the loan to share is lower.
- 39:14This is the definition of what you're supposed to do.
- 39:17You are a credit union.
- 39:19Your job is to extend credit, and I understand why.
- 39:23When you're smaller, you have to have a margin of safety and you
- 39:25can't lend as frequently or as much.
- 39:28But we're at a 61% loan to share on the under 100 million.
- 39:33We're at 85% in the over 10 billion.
- 39:38So what are we trying to achieve in this movement?
- 39:40We're trying to extend credit to people who need it.
- 39:43The better extender of credit is the bigger credit union because all of
- 39:48those efficiencies that come with bigness, that come with the law of
- 39:52large numbers that come with the diversity of a bigger portfolio that
- 39:55come with the spreading of costs over a larger base of assets, that all
- 40:00accrues to the benefit of more lending.
- 40:04It also means a better dividend for the members.
- 40:08The dividend grows with size.
- 40:11So it's just difficult to reflexively defend the smaller
- 40:16credit union time and time again.
- 40:18I get it.
- 40:19I love them.
- 40:20We work with them all, but you've got to be able to deliver value, and that
- 40:24value has to be expressed in the numbers.
- 40:27Then the value has to be in, am I giving them better loan rate
- 40:30or a better deposit rate to my customers than the guy next door?
- 40:33Whether the guy next door would be bigger or smaller.
- 40:36Because that's the competition.
- 40:37And the guy next door, incidentally, is not the credit union next door, it's the
- 40:40credit union next door, it's the community bank and it's Robinhood or SoFi or Chime.
- 40:47That's the reality of the bigness question.
- 40:50Mark Treichel: Challenging time to be a credit union, more challenging
- 40:53to be a small credit union.
- 40:5573% of the credit unions are under 500 million, I think is what
- 41:00you said, which is 13% and then.
- 41:03Top 21 or twice that in percentage that that pretty much says it all.
- 41:08Mick Mac: It is, it's remarkable.
- 41:10It's remarkable.
- 41:12Mark Treichel: Any last thoughts as it relates to, that's a great place to
- 41:15end, but is there anything we wanted to talk about here relative to the annual
- 41:18report or anything else before we wrap?
- 41:21Today's episode, Mike.
- 41:23Mick Mac: No, again, the agency's doing what it's supposed to do.
- 41:26The report tells us that I think they're emphasizing and hitting on
- 41:30things that they think are important.
- 41:31And, I think they're pretty much square on.
- 41:33We can argue at the fringes.
- 41:35But again, I think from the outside, whether it be the President or Chairman
- 41:39Harper or Chairman Altman, somebody's gotta figure that out to get the
- 41:43next appointment in the chair and to get us moving with some alacrity.
- 41:48Mark Treichel: I like it.
- 41:48I like it.
- 41:49And if someone is listening and they want to chat with you about.
- 41:53How you all help credit unions?
- 41:55What's the best way for them to reach out?
- 41:57Mick Mac: For the next few days, they can reach us at Olden Lane.
- 42:02We have a website, www.oldenlane.com
- 42:05that will remain functional for a little while.
- 42:07I'm certainly fairly prolific on LinkedIn, although those rules will
- 42:11probably change for me shortly.
- 42:13And we're.
- 42:14Dan Preso myself are pretty accessible within the ecosystem of credit unions.
- 42:19Mark Treichel: Very,
- 42:19Mick Mac: We're looking forward to the change that's coming for us.
- 42:22And, we'll be back to you with our new names and addresses.
- 42:24Mark Treichel: That's right.
- 42:25Yeah.
- 42:25We gotta get those new email addresses and and you're still gonna be in the
- 42:29movement and you're gonna be able to help more credit unions under the
- 42:33new structure as I understand it.
- 42:34So that's
- 42:35Mick Mac: absolutely,
- 42:35Mark Treichel: That's exciting.
- 42:36All right, Mike thank you for your time as always.
- 42:38I enjoy chatting with you.
- 42:39I hope your giants do stupid things on Thursday.
- 42:43Yeah,
- 42:43Mick Mac: thanks Mark.
- 42:44Mark Treichel: And and I hope my Vikings hit it outta the park.
- 42:47Mick Mac: Awesome.
- 42:48Good luck.
- 42:49Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 42:49Thank Mike.
- 42:49Thank you, sir.
- 42:49Michael and listeners, I and watchers, I wanna thank you for watching or listening.
- 42:53I hope you'll do the same soon.
- 42:55This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.