Latest / Bloomberg Law / The Court's Blow to LGBTQ Rights
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: In a major blow to LGBTQ rights, on the last
- 0:03Speaker 1: day of the term, the Supreme Court's conservative majority rule
- 0:07Speaker 1: that a Christian graphic artist doesn't have to create wedding
- 0:11Speaker 1: websites for same sex couples, saying forcing Laurie Smith to
- 0:16Speaker 1: do so would violate her free speech rights. Transportation Secretary
- 0:20Speaker 1: Pete Buddha Judge told CNN that Smith appeared to have
- 0:24Speaker 1: gone into the wedding business to create a case for
- 0:27Speaker 1: the court.
- 0:28Speaker 2: In that sense, I think there's something in common between
- 0:30Speaker 2: this Supreme Court ruling and what we're seeing happening in
- 0:33Speaker 2: state legislatures across the country, which is kind of a
- 0:36Speaker 2: solution looking for a problem, in other words, sending these
- 0:40Speaker 2: kinds of things to the courts and sending these kinds
- 0:42Speaker 2: of things to state legislatures for the clear purpose of
- 0:46Speaker 2: chipping away at the equality and the rights that have
- 0:49Speaker 2: so recently been one in the LGBTQ plus community.
- 0:54Speaker 1: And there are fears the decision will not only chip
- 0:56Speaker 1: away at the rights of LGBTQ people, but will also
- 1:00Speaker 1: opened the door to discrimination on the basis of race, religion, sex, disability, age,
- 1:06Speaker 1: and other protected categories in a wide range of businesses,
- 1:10Speaker 1: something Justice Katanji Brown Jackson was concerned about during the
- 1:14Speaker 1: oral arguments.
- 1:16Speaker 3: Historically, opposition to interracial marriages and to integration in many
- 1:22Speaker 3: instances was on religious grounds. So I don't know that
- 1:26Speaker 3: we can say that just because we have a religious
- 1:29Speaker 3: objection to same sex marriage in this situation, that wouldn't
- 1:34Speaker 3: necessarily implicate religious objections to other kinds of situations.
- 1:39Speaker 1: My guest is Catherine Frankie, director of the Center for
- 1:42Speaker 1: Gender and Sexuality Law at Columbia Law School. How big
- 1:47Speaker 1: a blow is this to LGBTQ rights.
- 1:51Speaker 4: Well, the three or three creative case from the Supreme
- 1:53Speaker 4: Court is an enormous blow for LGBT rights, but not
- 1:57Speaker 4: only What's shocking about this decision is how broad it
- 2:01Speaker 4: was that the Court actually wrote a decision that gives
- 2:05Speaker 4: anybody who has an opinion in opposition to a law
- 2:09Speaker 4: a First Amendment right to not abide by that law,
- 2:12Speaker 4: whether it's LGBT equality rights or laws to prohibit race discrimination,
- 2:17Speaker 4: or you could refuse to serve Jewish people or interracial couples,
- 2:21Speaker 4: or for that matter, if you don't believe that climate
- 2:24Speaker 4: change is a real thing, you could not comply with
- 2:28Speaker 4: local regulations about the kind of air conditioning that you
- 2:31Speaker 4: have to have in your business, or really any law,
- 2:33Speaker 4: minimum wage laws, labor laws, etc.
- 2:36Speaker 1: Do you think the Court saw the implications of its decision,
- 2:40Speaker 1: how far ranging the implications are.
- 2:43Speaker 4: The Court had to understand that the ruling that they
- 2:46Speaker 4: were issuing was very broad. And part of why I
- 2:50Speaker 4: think that's the case is that the oral argument in
- 2:53Speaker 4: the case last fall, most of that argument was taken
- 2:57Speaker 4: up with a set of hypotheticals about how could you
- 2:59Speaker 4: put a limiting conditions on this very broad First Amendment speech? Right,
- 3:04Speaker 4: There were all sorts of questions that what turned out
- 3:07Speaker 4: to be the dissenting justices were asking of the lawyer
- 3:11Speaker 4: defending Laurie Smith, the owner of three ZHO three Creative,
- 3:14Speaker 4: about how we could possibly contain such a broad rule.
- 3:19Speaker 4: And the lawyer was unwilling to offer any kind of
- 3:22Speaker 4: limiting provisions or terms for this decision. And we see
- 3:26Speaker 4: that very very broad ruling in the Court's decisions from
- 3:29Speaker 4: last week.
- 3:30Speaker 1: And I remember Justice Kagan pointing out during oral arguments
- 3:35Speaker 1: that you designing a website is not necessarily expressive. You
- 3:40Speaker 1: could just be filling in the blanks with the couple's
- 3:43Speaker 1: name and things like that. So how does this tell
- 3:46Speaker 1: us what is expressive? What businesses are expressive?
- 3:50Speaker 4: Well, that's part of why this decision is so broad,
- 3:53Speaker 4: is that the court gives us very little about what
- 3:55Speaker 4: would count in future cases as a business that was
- 3:58Speaker 4: engaged in express of activity. So a few examples that
- 4:02Speaker 4: are very possible to be the next cases are things
- 4:06Speaker 4: like Applebee's a family restaurant. What does it mean for
- 4:09Speaker 4: a restaurant to be a family restaurant? Or a romantic
- 4:13Speaker 4: hotel in the Poconos, you know they're curating a kind
- 4:16Speaker 4: of experience for their customers. Or a theme park around
- 4:20Speaker 4: a plantation theme may not want to serve black customers
- 4:24Speaker 4: because black people were only enclaved on those plantations, not
- 4:27Speaker 4: people who were participating in the main life of the plantation.
- 4:31Speaker 4: So businesses create experiences for their customers all the time,
- 4:36Speaker 4: and that requires some kind of creative, expressive activity. Are
- 4:40Speaker 4: all of them also going to follow this rule that
- 4:43Speaker 4: they can refuse to serve customers that would violate the
- 4:46Speaker 4: sort of expressive core of their business purpose. As I
- 4:51Speaker 4: read the Supreme Court's three h three creative decision, it
- 4:54Speaker 4: opens the door for pretty much any business to be
- 4:57Speaker 4: able to say there's something creative about what we do,
- 5:00Speaker 4: and therefore complying with a human rights law or any
- 5:03Speaker 4: other law is forcing that we're expressing a viewpoint we
- 5:07Speaker 4: don't agree with. So one thing with a close reading
- 5:10Speaker 4: of the three h three Creative decision that I think
- 5:13Speaker 4: is worth noting is that the court decides that there's
- 5:16Speaker 4: a free speech right for Laurie Smith, the owner of
- 5:20Speaker 4: this business, and in doing so, normally, what happens is
- 5:24Speaker 4: it triggers a certain analysis from the court, which we
- 5:26Speaker 4: call strict scrutiny, like does the government have a compelling
- 5:30Speaker 4: interest to burden her free speech rights? And are they
- 5:34Speaker 4: furthering that interest in the most narrowly tailored fashion that
- 5:38Speaker 4: they could. What's remarkable is Justice Gorsuch doesn't engage in
- 5:41Speaker 4: any of that strict scrutiny reasoning. They just say that, yes,
- 5:45Speaker 4: she's engaged in speech protected by the First Amendment, and
- 5:48Speaker 4: that's the end of it. So what we're seeing is
- 5:51Speaker 4: not only a kind of creative and broad reading of
- 5:54Speaker 4: free speech rights, but then saying that these rights are absolute,
- 5:58Speaker 4: which we don't see in any other contexts where strict
- 6:01Speaker 4: scrutiny is triggered. So the standards for protecting the free
- 6:05Speaker 4: speech rights of evangelical Christians is elevated in three h
- 6:09Speaker 4: three creative in ways that I think should concern everyone.
- 6:13Speaker 1: I've always questioned why the court even took this case.
- 6:18Speaker 1: The website designer doesn't seem to have standing, she hasn't
- 6:22Speaker 1: been injured.
- 6:23Speaker 4: Well, that was a concern that many people had from
- 6:26Speaker 4: the very beginning, is that the lawsuit was filed before
- 6:28Speaker 4: she had even opened up her business. She was thinking
- 6:31Speaker 4: about starting a wedding website business, and she knew she
- 6:35Speaker 4: was in a state that prohibited sexual orientation and other
- 6:38Speaker 4: forms of discrimination by all businesses, and so she went
- 6:42Speaker 4: to court basically to get a get out of jail
- 6:44Speaker 4: free card before she'd even started her business. Now there's
- 6:48Speaker 4: been some to do in the media about there being
- 6:51Speaker 4: a couple who called a same sex couple who had
- 6:54Speaker 4: called her for a wedding site, and then it turned
- 6:56Speaker 4: out later that that was a fabricated couple. That actually
- 7:00Speaker 4: it doesn't matter because the lawsuit was filed before that
- 7:03Speaker 4: fake call came in, and the basis of the lawsuit
- 7:06Speaker 4: didn't turn on her actually even having opened her business yet,
- 7:10Speaker 4: let alone refuse service to any actual couple. She wanted
- 7:14Speaker 4: to know that the courts were going to insulate her
- 7:16Speaker 4: from any liability once she started serving customers, but only
- 7:20Speaker 4: had her sexual customers.
- 7:22Speaker 1: Does this tell us this case that even if a
- 7:25Speaker 1: state provides protections against bigotry as public accommodation's laws in
- 7:30Speaker 1: some twenty two states do that religious interests will trump that.
- 7:37Speaker 4: Well, what's surprising about this case is that it's actually
- 7:40Speaker 4: not a religious liberty case. It's a free speech case.
- 7:44Speaker 4: So if it had been a religious liberty case, she
- 7:46Speaker 4: would have to say, I have a sincerely held religious
- 7:50Speaker 4: belief that the institution of marriage is one man and
- 7:53Speaker 4: one woman, and I therefore don't want to serve or
- 7:55Speaker 4: endorse same sex marriages. That's a more narrow right than
- 7:59Speaker 4: what the court secured here, which is that I have
- 8:01Speaker 4: an opinion that opposes same sex marriage or prefers different
- 8:06Speaker 4: sex marriages. She doesn't have to show that that opinion
- 8:09Speaker 4: is religious at all. So it's a much broader right.
- 8:12Speaker 4: And what it says is that the Court is going
- 8:15Speaker 4: even further in a trend I've been watching with this court,
- 8:19Speaker 4: which is the creation of first class or top tier
- 8:22Speaker 4: constitutional rights and those are the rights of speech, religion,
- 8:27Speaker 4: gun right. And then below that, I would say, are
- 8:30Speaker 4: these second tier rights, rights to equality, whether it's race
- 8:33Speaker 4: based equality, sex based equality, reproductive rights, voting rights, or
- 8:38Speaker 4: LGBT equality. And when those second tier rights come into
- 8:43Speaker 4: some kind of tension with a first tier right, what
- 8:46Speaker 4: Justice Gorsuch said in three or three Creatives is that
- 8:49Speaker 4: the first tier right always wins. And this is a
- 8:52Speaker 4: totally different way to think about rights than we've ever
- 8:55Speaker 4: seen before.
- 8:56Speaker 1: There have been several decisions. There was the Colorado baker,
- 9:01Speaker 1: the Masterpiece cake Shop case, there was the Catholic Adoption Agency.
- 9:06Speaker 1: It seems to point to the court allowing religious groups
- 9:11Speaker 1: to discriminate.
- 9:13Speaker 4: It does whether it's discriminate or just not have the
- 9:16Speaker 4: law apply to them, because they quite frankly, feel that
- 9:19Speaker 4: they have to have fidelity to a higher law, you know,
- 9:23Speaker 4: God made law. And so it runs really contrary to
- 9:26Speaker 4: the idea of a secular society. And it's also, I
- 9:29Speaker 4: think a deeply anti democratic way to think about rights. Normally,
- 9:34Speaker 4: when the state passes the law that you don't agree with,
- 9:37Speaker 4: you go back to the legislature, you try to elect
- 9:39Speaker 4: different people, you try to get the law reversed, you
- 9:42Speaker 4: go back through the democratic process, and what we're seeing
- 9:45Speaker 4: now is that people are just raising their hand and saying, hey,
- 9:48Speaker 4: I don't agree with this law for religious reason or
- 9:51Speaker 4: any reason, and therefore I don't have to abide by it.
- 9:54Speaker 4: It's a real end run around the democratic process, where
- 9:58Speaker 4: often laws or passed you don't agree with. But part
- 10:01Speaker 4: of living in a democratic society is that you have
- 10:04Speaker 4: to abide by all the laws that are generally enacted
- 10:08Speaker 4: by the legislature. And that worries me as much as
- 10:11Speaker 4: the hit to LGBT rights here.
- 10:14Speaker 1: This decision doesn't really give guidelines to lower courts what's
- 10:19Speaker 1: an expressive business or not. Does that mean that it's
- 10:22Speaker 1: going to be sort of like the Second Amendment case
- 10:24Speaker 1: last term, which has led to all kinds of lower
- 10:28Speaker 1: court cases trying to figure out what that Second Amendment
- 10:32Speaker 1: right is that wasn't defined very well by the Court.
- 10:36Speaker 4: I think that's absolutely right, and the same was true
- 10:39Speaker 4: with Dobbs, that the Court is deciding these cases in
- 10:42Speaker 4: such broad terms, and particularly with Dobbs and saying, well,
- 10:45Speaker 4: the issue of abortion really doesn't belong in the Supreme Court.
- 10:49Speaker 4: It's something that should get dealt with in state legislatures.
- 10:52Speaker 4: But there were so many open questions left in that
- 10:55Speaker 4: decision and in bruin the gun control case, that there's
- 10:59Speaker 4: been a kind of of lawsuits filed in the aftermath
- 11:02Speaker 4: where trial courts are trying to figure out how to
- 11:04Speaker 4: apply these extremely broad rules. And also know that these
- 11:09Speaker 4: cases are brought by very well financed, very large evangelical
- 11:14Speaker 4: Christian advocacy groups that have been pushing and pushing and
- 11:18Speaker 4: pushing for these rules, and they have teed up already
- 11:21Speaker 4: after a case like three oh three Creative, what the
- 11:24Speaker 4: next cases will be and the cases after that. But
- 11:27Speaker 4: one thing I think is going to be interesting to
- 11:29Speaker 4: look for, and I call it a goose and gander problem,
- 11:32Speaker 4: is that what's good for the goose will be good
- 11:34Speaker 4: for the gander. And this First Amendment free speech right
- 11:37Speaker 4: that kind of insulated three h three Creative in its
- 11:40Speaker 4: owner Laurie Smith from complying with a human rights bar
- 11:44Speaker 4: or the equality laws in Colorado. That same ruling or
- 11:47Speaker 4: that same constitutional principle could be used by proponents of
- 11:52Speaker 4: abortion rights to extent that there are people who are
- 11:55Speaker 4: let's say, supporting people and getting access to abortion or
- 11:59Speaker 4: a medication of order in their states, they could say
- 12:01Speaker 4: that what they're doing is expressive or creative in nature,
- 12:05Speaker 4: and that for that reason, applying with the state's official
- 12:08Speaker 4: position on abortion violates their free speech right. So I
- 12:12Speaker 4: think it'll be interesting to see how this new rule
- 12:15Speaker 4: is deployed both by the right wing and the left wing,
- 12:18Speaker 4: both by those who oppose gay rights and reproductive rights,
- 12:22Speaker 4: but also those who support gay rights, racial justice, and
- 12:25Speaker 4: reproductive rights. So stay tuned. This is going to be
- 12:28Speaker 4: very interesting period over the next couple of years.
- 12:31Speaker 1: This conservative legal group, Alliance Defending Freedom, that brought this
- 12:36Speaker 1: case on behalf of the web designer, was the same
- 12:40Speaker 1: group that brought the Masterpiece cake Shop case on behalf
- 12:44Speaker 1: of the baker. So are they bringing more cases to
- 12:48Speaker 1: the forefront.
- 12:49Speaker 4: Oh, they absolutely are. One case to really keep an
- 12:52Speaker 4: eye on comes out of the fifth Circuit out of Texas,
- 12:54Speaker 4: and it was just decided two weeks ago, and it
- 12:56Speaker 4: was a case of a kind of mega doowner, conservative
- 12:59Speaker 4: Trump donor in Texas who owns a number of businesses,
- 13:03Speaker 4: employs a lot of people, and he's an evangelical Christian
- 13:06Speaker 4: and he says, I don't want to have to employ
- 13:09Speaker 4: anybody who isn't heterosexual or cisgendered. And so I want
- 13:14Speaker 4: to know in advance that I can be insulated from
- 13:16Speaker 4: discrimination charges against me and my business if I refuse
- 13:20Speaker 4: to hire gay people or trans people, or people who
- 13:23Speaker 4: are other than sisgendered. And I have a religious reason
- 13:27Speaker 4: for wanting an exemption basically from Title seven, a federal
- 13:30Speaker 4: anti discrimination and employment law. And the Fifth Circuit issued
- 13:34Speaker 4: a very very broad decision upholding his religious exemption claim,
- 13:39Speaker 4: carving a huge hole in the middle of Title seven.
- 13:42Speaker 4: That case will surely go to the Supreme Court in
- 13:45Speaker 4: the next month or so to see if they'll take it,
- 13:48Speaker 4: and that could easily be on the docket next year.
- 13:50Speaker 4: And that's one to watch out for. And it's the
- 13:52Speaker 4: same evangelical Christian law firm behind that case as all
- 13:57Speaker 4: these others. You know, as much as I think their
- 13:59Speaker 4: strategy is a complicated one and a wrong headed under
- 14:02Speaker 4: the Constitution, they are smart lawyers and they are really
- 14:06Speaker 4: gaining the favor of the Supreme Court in these kinds
- 14:08Speaker 4: of arguments.
- 14:10Speaker 1: Was it surprising or perhaps a disappointment that it was
- 14:14Speaker 1: Justice Neil Gorsich who wrote the majority opinion here when
- 14:18Speaker 1: he was the one who wrote the majority opinion in
- 14:21Speaker 1: boss Stock in twenty twenty that said Title seven protected
- 14:27Speaker 1: gay and transgender workers.
- 14:29Speaker 4: It wasn't shocking to me because what the Court is
- 14:31Speaker 4: actually telling us through the pen if you will, of
- 14:34Speaker 4: Justice Gorsich, is that they're prepared to recognize the rights
- 14:38Speaker 4: of the LGBT community so long as those rights don't
- 14:42Speaker 4: come into conflicts with a more important right like free
- 14:44Speaker 4: speech or religious liberty. And that's exactly what happened in
- 14:48Speaker 4: this three h three creative case. I'd also say that
- 14:51Speaker 4: the decision in Bostock, while the end result was a
- 14:55Speaker 4: good one, the reasoning was horrible and it didn't give
- 14:58Speaker 4: us anything to work with in this future to expand
- 15:01Speaker 4: or build on the equality rights the Court gave us
- 15:04Speaker 4: in that case. It's very mechanistic kind of technical reasoning
- 15:08Speaker 4: that says nothing about the values that underlie equality statutes
- 15:12Speaker 4: and why we care about as an important American value
- 15:15Speaker 4: treating everybody fairly in the workplace or elsewhere. But when
- 15:19Speaker 4: you get Gorstch or Alito or Thomas or the more
- 15:21Speaker 4: conservative members of the Court writing about religious liberty, they
- 15:25Speaker 4: go on and on about how important respecting religion is
- 15:29Speaker 4: as a fundamental American value. They just don't do the
- 15:33Speaker 4: same with respect to racial equality, sex based equality, or
- 15:37Speaker 4: LGBT equality. So it's a mechanistic decision, that Boss Stok
- 15:40Speaker 4: decision that actually doesn't really have legs.
- 15:43Speaker 1: Unfortunately, many people are asking the question whether same sex
- 15:49Speaker 1: marriage could be next.
- 15:51Speaker 4: Well, if we read Justice Thomas and his writings, his sense,
- 15:55Speaker 4: and his concurrences in the Supreme Court's Jurisprudens recently, he's
- 15:59Speaker 4: given us a pretty thorough to do list beyond overturning
- 16:03Speaker 4: Rovers's Wade and same sex marriage, even Lawrence versus Texas,
- 16:07Speaker 4: the case it said it was unconstitutional to criminalize sex
- 16:10Speaker 4: between two people of the same sex, but that is
- 16:13Speaker 4: also on the chopping block, along with rights to contraception.
- 16:17Speaker 4: All of those sexuality decisions that most people regarded as
- 16:21Speaker 4: settled law and really untouchable. In Justice Thomas's view, those
- 16:26Speaker 4: are next. So I think we have to wait and see.
- 16:29Speaker 4: Hopefully the Court won't move so quickly and so radically.
- 16:33Speaker 4: But what we saw on the Supreme Court this term
- 16:36Speaker 4: shows that they don't seem to be holding back in
- 16:39Speaker 4: a pretty radical right wing turn in their decisions.
- 16:42Speaker 1: Also, i'd just like you to talk a little bit
- 16:45Speaker 1: about this spike in legislation in state houses this year,
- 16:52Speaker 1: with more than five hundred and twenty five anti LGBTQ
- 16:56Speaker 1: bills introduced more than seventy signs so far, that's more
- 17:01Speaker 1: than double last year's number.
- 17:04Speaker 5: Well, one would.
- 17:04Speaker 4: Think that there was actually a crisis of trans kids
- 17:08Speaker 4: or gender nonconforming kids across the country. You know, I
- 17:11Speaker 4: think of a state like Idaho or Montana, and really
- 17:14Speaker 4: how many trans children are there in those states. But
- 17:18Speaker 4: from the amount of energy that's been brought to passing
- 17:20Speaker 4: these statutes, one would think that there's a real emergency
- 17:23Speaker 4: going on in those states, which of course is not
- 17:25Speaker 4: the case at all. But what we're seeing is groups
- 17:28Speaker 4: like Alliance Defending Freedom and others Family Research Council, these
- 17:32Speaker 4: conservative evangelical groups are cranking out model bills, providing them
- 17:37Speaker 4: to like minded state legislators who are using this just
- 17:42Speaker 4: seem spirited, hateful appeal to the sort of evil or
- 17:46Speaker 4: problem of trans kids as a way to mobilize their base.
- 17:51Speaker 4: A few years ago, they really realized that opposing same
- 17:54Speaker 4: sex marriage and regular gay people wasn't getting the bang
- 17:58Speaker 4: for the buck that they had hoped, and mobilizing the base.
- 18:01Speaker 4: So they shifted to the transgender and gender identity issue,
- 18:04Speaker 4: and it has been quite effective. They have really moved
- 18:07Speaker 4: the needle, I think, in public opinion about whether gender
- 18:10Speaker 4: affirming care is appropriate for young people, and really maintaining
- 18:14Speaker 4: the idea that trans people are monsters, they're somehow subhumans,
- 18:18Speaker 4: and it's a frightening time to be in this country,
- 18:21Speaker 4: and particularly to be a person who doesn't conform to
- 18:23Speaker 4: traditional gender norms. What I will say though, about these
- 18:27Speaker 4: new laws is that almost all of them have been
- 18:30Speaker 4: challenged in the court, and we're really kind of on
- 18:32Speaker 4: a winning streak, at least in the lower district courts,
- 18:36Speaker 4: where even conservative Trump appointed judges have found those laws
- 18:40Speaker 4: to be unconstitutional, and they've done so in ways that
- 18:44Speaker 4: clarify and strengthen parental rights to decide about the health
- 18:48Speaker 4: and well being of their children, but also about the
- 18:51Speaker 4: constitutional status of trans people in ways that I think
- 18:56Speaker 4: is kind of backfiring for those who oppose trans right.
- 19:00Speaker 4: So we'll see what happens to these cases those opinions
- 19:03Speaker 4: when they get appealed to the intermediate appellate courts and
- 19:06Speaker 4: then hopefully don't go to the Supreme court, although they could,
- 19:09Speaker 4: but for now I think the strategy, at least in
- 19:12Speaker 4: A and the federal courts, has backfired for those who
- 19:15Speaker 4: are targeting transsensitive care and gender nonconforming kids.
- 19:20Speaker 1: Thanks so much for your insights, Catherine. That's Professor Catherine Frankee,
- 19:23Speaker 1: director of the Center for Gender and Sexuality Law at
- 19:27Speaker 1: Columbia Law School. New York City is on the cutting
- 19:31Speaker 1: edge of setting rules for how companies can use artificial
- 19:34Speaker 1: intelligence in hiring and promotion decisions. New York City's Automated
- 19:39Speaker 1: Employment Decision Tool law requires employers that use AI and
- 19:43Speaker 1: other machine learning technology as part of their hiring process
- 19:47Speaker 1: to perform an annual audit of their technology. Failure to
- 19:51Speaker 1: comply with the new law, which is mandatory for any
- 19:53Speaker 1: company operating and hiring in New York City, could result
- 19:57Speaker 1: in fine starting at five hundred dollars the maximum penalty
- 20:01Speaker 1: of fifteen hundred dollars per instance. Joining me is labor
- 20:05Speaker 1: and employment attorney Nicholas Pappez, a partner at Dorsey and Whitney.
- 20:10Speaker 1: How has AI impacted hiring and promotion decisions?
- 20:14Speaker 5: A number of articles and studies out there indicating that
- 20:19Speaker 5: it's widely used by employers and has been for a
- 20:23Speaker 5: long time. There's one study that says as many as
- 20:27Speaker 5: eighty three percent of employers to ninety nine percent of
- 20:31Speaker 5: Fortune five hundred companies use AI to screen or rank
- 20:36Speaker 5: candidates for hire. So that suggests it's out there. Is
- 20:41Speaker 5: not only affected workers, but it's sort of part of
- 20:44Speaker 5: the fabric of the workplace. Now in the United States, how.
- 20:49Speaker 1: Are organizations allowed to use AI? How are they not
- 20:54Speaker 1: allowed to use AI? Let's say they want to enhance diversity.
- 21:00Speaker 1: Can they use AI to do that?
- 21:03Speaker 5: Well, that's a tricky question. The easier approach is what
- 21:08Speaker 5: are you not allowed to do with AI? You're certainly
- 21:11Speaker 5: not allowed to use AI in a way that has
- 21:15Speaker 5: a disparate what's called a disparate impact on workers with
- 21:21Speaker 5: protected characteristics, so for example, race, religion, sex, national origin, etc.
- 21:29Speaker 5: When I say disparate impact, that's a technical term that
- 21:33Speaker 5: employment lawyers and the law use to say that if
- 21:38Speaker 5: something has a disproportionate effect on those types of persons
- 21:43Speaker 5: in those classifications, that rule or law or practice will
- 21:50Speaker 5: be prohibited. In Title seven of the Civil Rights Act
- 21:53Speaker 5: of nineteen sixty four is the law that says that
- 21:56Speaker 5: the practice is prohibited unless the practice or rule is
- 22:01Speaker 5: what's described as job related for the position in question
- 22:06Speaker 5: and consistent with business necessity. Right. So there's a way
- 22:10Speaker 5: to justify rules or practices that have a disparate impact,
- 22:15Speaker 5: but the burden falls on the employer to justify those
- 22:19Speaker 5: types of practices.
- 22:21Speaker 1: So tell us about this New York City law.
- 22:24Speaker 5: So the New York City law, it's known as Local
- 22:27Speaker 5: Law one forty four, and that law affects what the
- 22:33Speaker 5: law describes as automated employment decision tools, which that's a
- 22:37Speaker 5: long way of saying AI artificial intelligence, right, And the
- 22:42Speaker 5: law defines automated employment decision tools as any computational process
- 22:48Speaker 5: derived from machine learning, statistical modeling, data analytics, or artificial
- 22:54Speaker 5: intelligence that issues simplified output, including a score, classification, or recommendation,
- 23:02Speaker 5: that is used to substantially assist or replace discretionary decision
- 23:06Speaker 5: making for making employment decisions that impact natural persons. So
- 23:11Speaker 5: that's a long description of AI. But if it's something
- 23:14Speaker 5: that is substantially used to assist or replace discretionary decision making,
- 23:19Speaker 5: you cannot use AI for hiring or promotions unless you
- 23:25Speaker 5: go through under this law what is called a bias
- 23:29Speaker 5: audit so the law requires that employers, before using AI
- 23:33Speaker 5: do an audit of the tool, also to disclose on
- 23:38Speaker 5: their websites a summary of the audit. And third that
- 23:42Speaker 5: the employer using AI give individual notice to candidates residing
- 23:48Speaker 5: in New York City that there'll be subject to the
- 23:52Speaker 5: use of this AI tool. And in that same notice,
- 23:56Speaker 5: the employer has to allow the candidate to quest some
- 24:00Speaker 5: alternative process or an accommodation. The notice also has to
- 24:05Speaker 5: describe the job qualifications and characteristics that the AI tool
- 24:11Speaker 5: will use in the assessment of the candidate. So that's
- 24:16Speaker 5: a lot of very technical compliance requirements. So starting today,
- 24:21Speaker 5: the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection will be enforcing
- 24:26Speaker 5: this law. And in effect, if the Department of Consumer
- 24:30Speaker 5: Worker Protection learns that AI is being used without compliance,
- 24:35Speaker 5: employers will be subject to a host of penalties.
- 24:39Speaker 1: How do you see the department enforcing.
- 24:43Speaker 5: This, Well, the department can receive complaints, the department can
- 24:48Speaker 5: do investigations. So are there any number of ways any
- 24:52Speaker 5: an enforcement agency can learn about the use of AI.
- 24:56Speaker 5: And so the law really is built upon requiring employers
- 24:59Speaker 5: to you self police and you know, in effect, if
- 25:03Speaker 5: you are using AI as an employer, you know it
- 25:07Speaker 5: and so you should be doing these disclosures and doing
- 25:10Speaker 5: the compliance.
- 25:11Speaker 1: So do you think that employers will have to start
- 25:14Speaker 1: hiring outside experts to make sure that you know they're incompliance.
- 25:20Speaker 5: Absolutely, In fact, that's required by the law. They mentioned
- 25:24Speaker 5: that the law requires a bias audit. The bias audit
- 25:28Speaker 5: has to be done as an impartial evaluation by an
- 25:34Speaker 5: independent auditor. So, in other words, a bias audit cannot
- 25:38Speaker 5: be done by the employer acting alone. The employer needs
- 25:42Speaker 5: to hire an independent auditor. That technology expert then has
- 25:47Speaker 5: to do a number of assessments. You have to look
- 25:50Speaker 5: at the algorithm, the technology that's being used, and then
- 25:56Speaker 5: calculate something called a selection rate, a score boring rate,
- 26:01Speaker 5: and determine an impact ratio for sex, race, ethnicity, and
- 26:07Speaker 5: also what's called intersectional categories of race, sex, and ethnicity.
- 26:12Speaker 5: So it's quite a complicated task and one of the
- 26:15Speaker 5: things employers may wish to do before publishing its bias
- 26:20Speaker 5: audit to do some testing. You know, before you go live.
- 26:25Speaker 5: You may want to have an expert look at these
- 26:28Speaker 5: things to assess whether it's permissible. I mean, one of
- 26:32Speaker 5: the things this bias audit would reveal is if there
- 26:36Speaker 5: is a disparate impact, which is prohibited by federal, state,
- 26:40Speaker 5: and local law.
- 26:41Speaker 1: Can you give us some examples of the kind of
- 26:44Speaker 1: tools that employers are using to screen out applicants.
- 26:49Speaker 5: The one that's most common and probably has been used
- 26:52Speaker 5: for a long time is what I would call a
- 26:55Speaker 5: resume screening tool. So a resume screening tool in effect
- 27:00Speaker 5: uses keyword searching, which if you've done a Google search,
- 27:03Speaker 5: you know what a keyword search is.
- 27:05Speaker 3: You.
- 27:05Speaker 5: So, if an employer is advertising for a job, an
- 27:09Speaker 5: employer may get a thousand resumes, but you don't want
- 27:13Speaker 5: to have to interview a thousand people necessarily. So in
- 27:16Speaker 5: order to efficiently go through the thousand resumes, maybe I'm
- 27:20Speaker 5: going to use a keyword search term that limits the
- 27:25Speaker 5: number of resumes I'm going to look at. So let's
- 27:27Speaker 5: say my job, in my fictitious job advertisement requires a
- 27:31Speaker 5: master's degree. If you don't have a master's degree, I
- 27:34Speaker 5: don't need to spend my time to interview you. So
- 27:37Speaker 5: I can, you know, perhaps do a search for the
- 27:40Speaker 5: different ways one might identify a master's degree, and so
- 27:44Speaker 5: call down my thousand resumes down to you know, fifty
- 27:49Speaker 5: or one hundred resumes. That will be a classic or
- 27:52Speaker 5: a simple way of using AI, just the simple use
- 27:54Speaker 5: of a search term. Another one that is very common
- 27:58Speaker 5: and one that where AI apparently is becoming used more
- 28:01Speaker 5: and more is video interview analysis. So video interview analysis
- 28:06Speaker 5: is basically recording candidates, which has probably become more used
- 28:12Speaker 5: during the pandemic when we're social distancing, right, you know,
- 28:15Speaker 5: for some employers they would require candidates to record themselves.
- 28:21Speaker 5: So let's say I'm searching and I want to use
- 28:24Speaker 5: this video interview analysis. I may have a set of
- 28:29Speaker 5: questions that I will have my candidates answer and record
- 28:33Speaker 5: themselves answering this series of questions. As the employer, I
- 28:37Speaker 5: get back a series of recordings of candidates answering these questions.
- 28:41Speaker 5: Well what do I do with that? Right, And this
- 28:43Speaker 5: is where AI comes in. The AI tool might analyze
- 28:48Speaker 5: facial expressions, tone of voice, body language, nonverbal cues, speech patterns, gestures,
- 28:57Speaker 5: you know, language, things like that, and based on that analysis,
- 29:01Speaker 5: the tool allows the employer to reach conclusions about the
- 29:05Speaker 5: employee based on their personalities, communication skills, problem solving skills, aptitudes, motivation,
- 29:13Speaker 5: and cognitive skills, and from those conclusions forecast how the
- 29:18Speaker 5: candidate might behave in the workplace.
- 29:21Speaker 1: Thanks for being on the show. That's Nicholas Poppis of
- 29:24Speaker 1: Dorsey and Whitney and that's it for this edition of
- 29:27Speaker 1: The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the
- 29:29Speaker 1: latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can
- 29:33Speaker 1: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
- 29:37Speaker 1: bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and remember to
- 29:41Speaker 1: tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten
- 29:44Speaker 1: pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 29:48Speaker 1: to Bloomberg