Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / BC Religious Property Tax Exemption and No Power for Cryptocurrency
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: time for our regularly scheduled segment.
- 0:02Adam Stirling: Joining us now, Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: It's Michael Mulligan.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Michael morning, Welcome to Legally Speaking.
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: How you doing.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: I'm doing great.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: All right, what is on the agenda for UNI today?
- 0:16Michael Mulligan: The first case of the agenda today deals with the issue of who does and who does not pay property tax, and it's a bit more complicated than I think many people would think.
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: First of all, we're, all you know, we're used to discussing property taxes that are imposed by municipalities.
- 0:34Michael Mulligan: Right, that process is going on right now in various municipalities.
- 0:38Michael Mulligan: But don't think that you can avoid property taxes by simply getting out of all the municipalities they thought of that.
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: There's no escape.
- 0:47Michael Mulligan: We have in British Columbia an act called the Rural Area Taxation Act which provides for the taxation of real property that's not in any municipality at all.
- 0:59Michael Mulligan: So there's no getting around it that way.
- 1:01Michael Mulligan: You can't just get far enough away.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: And the particular issue that was just dealt with in court by the BC Supreme Court was an appeal concerning whether there should be taxation applied to a 31 acre island located just off of Schwartz Bay.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: It's a island assessed at being worth $8.5 million.
- 1:28Michael Mulligan: It's called NAP Island, KNAPP Island.
- 1:32Michael Mulligan: And the particular issue there is that that act that I mentioned, that the Rural Area Taxation Act, provides a number of exceptions to who can avoid paying any property tax, and the exemptions are similar but not exactly the same as the exemptions which exist in the community charter, which exempts a bunch of categories of property from paying any property tax in a municipality.
- 2:00Michael Mulligan: And that act, by the way, is quite interesting.
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: What we've chosen to exempt, like we've exempted some things which you would say, yeah, that's kind of as obvious, like buildings owned by the municipality itself.
- 2:12Michael Mulligan: They don't have to pay themselves tax.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: That would be a ridiculous process.
- 2:15Michael Mulligan: We've also exempted things like hospitals don't have to pay property tax.
- 2:19Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that probably makes sense.
- 2:20Michael Mulligan: Everyone's using those a public facility.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: Other unusual things, though, include fruit trees are exempt.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: You don't pay property tax based on increased value created by fruit trees.
- 2:31Michael Mulligan: We've also, oddly, exempted what amounts to things like bomb shelters.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: So if you construct something designed to provide protection either for people or, frankly, domestic animals, not farm animals in the event of an emergency within the meaning of the emergency and disaster management act, no tax on the cost of that.
- 2:53Michael Mulligan: So if you want to have a super deluxe underground bomb shelter for you and your dog.
- 2:56Michael Mulligan: You're in good shape.
- 2:58Michael Mulligan: Your property taxes can't go up thanks to that exemption to the community charter waiting for some person to make their whole house the bomb shelter, but yes, correct.
- 3:06Michael Mulligan: There's gonna be some shack above ground and a police should mention below ground.
- 3:10Michael Mulligan: No property tax.
- 3:12Michael Mulligan: Just don't get a farm animal in there.
- 3:14Michael Mulligan: As long as it's for you and your domestic animals, you're in good shape.
- 3:17Adam Stirling: Absolutely.
- 3:18Michael Mulligan: That's right.
- 3:18Michael Mulligan: So you might want to redesign that house, and so one of the other exemptions that exists in the community charter and has a similar provision in that act that deals with rural property is an exemption for religious buildings.
- 3:37Michael Mulligan: That's really interesting.
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: The language is different for that exemption in the community charter from the areas outside of municipality.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: They're similar but not quite the same Now, I should say, on both fronts.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: That does raise, I think, a really interesting public policy question people should think about, which would be should we be as a matter of public policy exempting?
- 4:03Michael Mulligan: I mean, community charter exempts things like buildings set apart for public worship and the land on which the building stands, and there's the similar exemption exists in that for rural areas.
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: But one of the things people should just think about, of course, is that when municipalities are setting their mill rate, like their tax rate, they kind of figure out how much money they need and then they set the tax rate accordingly.
- 4:26Michael Mulligan: And if you exempt a bunch of things like fruit trees and bomb shelters from having to pay tax, well that means everyone else's tax rate is higher, right.
- 4:35Michael Mulligan: And so in Canada, of course, we have a constitutional right to freedom of conscience and religion, right.
- 4:42Michael Mulligan: But part of that includes a freedom from being compelled to do religious things right.
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: And here, given how the legislation works, you are effectively compelled to subsidize buildings for public worship.
- 4:58Michael Mulligan: Whether you like it or not, whether you agree with the religion or not, whether you're a member of any religion or not, you're subsidizing them.
- 5:05Michael Mulligan: That's what's going on, right.
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: The same public services are being consumed, and if you don't tax them, it's going to come out somewhere, just like if you don't tax bomb shelters, everyone else's taxes are just a little bit higher.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: So that's something people should think about generally.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: Now, with all that background, the particular issue with respect to the half-million dollar island near Schwartz Bay involved whether that island amounted to a quote place of public worship close quote, which is the language used in that rural area taxation act and it was an interesting state of affairs.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: The island itself was owned by the spouser partner of a Shinto priest, and that person the partner, had owned that island for some time they're going back more than 20 years and the Shinto priest and his partner had for many years lived on Salt Spring Island, where they had a facility there which was exempt from taxation, and that area on Salt Spring Island was called Brightwoods and it was exempted.
- 6:16Michael Mulligan: It was a seven and a half acre site, involved meeting rooms and smaller rooms in a sacred forest or walking paths in a shrine, and nobody lived there, all right, and so that fell within that exemption under the community charters, so it didn't pay any tax.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: Well, they decided to shut down that facility and decommissioned it in 2021 and move to this island.
- 6:39Michael Mulligan: The island had facilities on it which are related to religious practices, and there was evidence about the particular religion, which includes things like trees being a particular importance to it, encourages prayer practices, seated or walking together or guided or not, and it encourages a relationship with nature, and there were things built on the island which were designed to facilitate all of that walking trails and buildings and water treatment facilities and various things.
- 7:16Michael Mulligan: Yes, and so when the couple moved there, they applied for the exemption under that, the terms of the act, and they said, okay, well, you know, this is now our area for public worship and so therefore, we wished to not pay any tax on it, just like we didn't pay any tax on Salt Spring Island and the facility there they shut down.
- 7:41Michael Mulligan: The challenge became, first of all, at the first level of the first level of assessment about the property assessment appeal board.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: They looked at, well, was this really an area for public worship?
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: And they pointed out that, for example, for the last 20 years, all the same improvements existed on the island, but they were for private use, right, guests could be invited there if the owners could go there if they wished.
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: And they pointed out that the claim transition from private worship to public worship would not be apparent to anyone who was sailing past the island.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: Nothing changed.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: And, for example, they pointed out that in large type, there was a big sign at the only way you could get to the island saying Private Harbor.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: That's stuck up there at the only access place.
- 8:29Michael Mulligan: That is not compelling A piece of evidence when you're trying to argue that this is an area for public worship.
- 8:35Michael Mulligan: There's no other way to get to the island.
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: And so they didn't succeed.
- 8:40Michael Mulligan: I know we forgot something.
- 8:43Michael Mulligan: We should have taken down the sign.
- 8:47Michael Mulligan: And so the board found that the principal use of the improvements were for private worship, not public worship, because there was just no way somebody could conclude that they could go there.
- 8:57Michael Mulligan: Right, I guess it'd be interesting if somebody did show up there and tried to use the trails for the intended purpose, what the response would be.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: But there was no evidence about that, and so the appeal to the BC Supreme Court was an appeal based, and I must say they didn't disagree with those factual findings I guess it's pretty hard to disagree with.
- 9:17Michael Mulligan: Obviously there's a sign there and there just wasn't a disagreement about those things.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: But they made an argument premised on a principle that the Supreme Court has talked about when interpreting statutes, and the concept there is there should be a presumption against discrimination when you're interpreting.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: Well, what does something mean?
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: You should have a non-discriminatory interpretation of things so that people are treated the same way.
- 9:47Michael Mulligan: Right, people are treated the same way, and so their argument amounted to well, look, this facility we had for some 20 years on Salt Spring Island, that was sort of the equivalent.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: We really were moving our operation from there to the island and so therefore the island ought to be treated the same way, and that it would be.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: You should not discriminate between these two facilities.
- 10:10Michael Mulligan: That was really the essence of the argument.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: It did not succeed in the BC Supreme Court on the judicial review.
- 10:16Michael Mulligan: They found that that finding, given the particular circumstances here including, by the way, the couple lived on the island right, they weren't living at the facility that used to exist on Salt Spring Island, this was their new residence.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: Right, they moved there.
- 10:32Michael Mulligan: There was a house, I think a couple of other places people could stay, who were invited guests, who got passed the sign, and so they found that that principle really didn't have any application here and this wasn't an area for public worship, and so they are going to need to pay tax on the $8.5 million assessed value of the private island.
- 10:55Michael Mulligan: But again, the big policy thing to think about is that what should be exempted?
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: Should areas for public worship be exempted at all, because that does impose a burden on people that aren't using those things, and it's sort of dissimilar to some of the other exemptions that you would say well, like a hospital or the municipal yard or the city hall or something, right?
- 11:19Michael Mulligan: Well, this is just sort of a facility for everyone, right?
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: As I said, the concept of freedom of religion means that you also have a freedom from being forced to participate in something.
- 11:31Michael Mulligan: And here, whether you like it or not, all across province of British Columbia, whether you're in or outside of municipality, you are compelled to financially subsidize places of public worship.
- 11:42Michael Mulligan: So I hope people think about whether that's appropriate or not, but in any case that won't be an issue with respect to the island out by Schwartz Bay.
- 11:50Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 11:52Adam Stirling: Legally speaking will continue right after this.
- 11:54Adam Stirling: Laterally speaking continues.
- 11:57Adam Stirling: On CFAQ stand seven, he joined with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 12:00Adam Stirling: Up next, michael, it says you're a forestry company trying to diversify into.
- 12:05Adam Stirling: Does that say cryptocurrency?
- 12:08Michael Mulligan: That is a hard right turn for being a forestry company Now, isn't?
- 12:11Adam Stirling: it.
- 12:11Adam Stirling: That is, that is how did it go Not well?
- 12:16Michael Mulligan: Oh, so you're exactly right.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: This was a case involving a forestry company that decided that wanted to quote, diversify, close quote into cryptocurrency mining, and not in a small way.
- 12:28Michael Mulligan: The forestry company, which interestingly claimed that it was doing so in partnership with the First Nation, and that became interesting in its judgment wished to construct large facilities, data centers, in northern British Columbia to be used for the purpose of cryptocurrency mining, and to do so they needed power, a lot of power, and they filed an application to get hooked up to BC Hydro, which you can do, and BC Hydro has, broadly speaking, a monopoly over the provision of electrical power in British Columbia, and so the starting point would be that if you need to hook up for electricity, they've got to provide it.
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: Otherwise, your house, your business, is going to be pretty dark and not working so well.
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: Now, if you do that, you do have an obligation to pay for system infrastructure.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: That's only for your sole benefit.
- 13:31Michael Mulligan: So if you need some thick wires or a new transformer or poles put in or whatever, you can be on the hook for paying for it.
- 13:38Michael Mulligan: But what happened here is that the Lieutenant Governor and Council BC government issued an order in council back in 2022 directing that the BC Hydro stop hooking up cryptocurrency mining companies to the power system why, you might ask.
- 14:02Michael Mulligan: Well, to give you an idea, this particular project and there's a affidavit from the CEO of BC Hydro indicated that the amount of power being requested here was 2.5 million megawatt hours of electricity per year.
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: And you might wonder what is 2.5 million megawatt hours per year?
- 14:21Michael Mulligan: Well, to provide some scope and scale to that figure, the CEO indicated that BC Hydro's nine largest customers they deliver no more than 500,000 megawatt hours of electrical power to each and the nine sites require something in there of a million megawatt hours per year.
- 14:41Michael Mulligan: So it would be like two and a half times the amount of power used by the current nine largest customers of BC Hydro every year.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: There was some dispute about whether that would amount to sucking up something in the order of half of the power that would be produced by Site C.
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: That's a lot of power and this is for cryptocurrency, Cryptocurrency mining Great.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: So half of Site C turned into power supply for the cryptocurrency mining venture by the forestry company, and so they were told no and based on this order in council, which is what got challenged in court and there were a couple of arguments that were made, or a few arguments are made.
- 15:21Michael Mulligan: One argument interesting one was the sort of non-discrimination argument like we talked about in the moving the religious center to the island by Schwartz Bay saying, well, hey, you shouldn't discriminate against us, we're just asking for power.
- 15:37Michael Mulligan: Bc Hydro has been awfully supplier of electricity in British Columbia and so it's just not fair that you could have an order in council just singling out some particular industry saying no power for cryptocurrency mining, but we give power to whatever aluminum smelting or something else.
- 15:55Michael Mulligan: On that basis, the court analyzed all of that but ultimately concluded that this wasn't the case of discrimination in that legal sense.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: The issue here was the concern about the cost of service, which is what exactly would be implications of this enormous additional power draw in terms of the cost of producing that power, what that would mean we'd have to immediately start working another dam to supply those needs, and so it wasn't found to be discriminatory.
- 16:30Michael Mulligan: The other interesting argument was this one, and it's interesting in the context of the controversy lately about proposed amendments by the government to the land act, arguing that they need to be brought in line with the declaration of the rights of indigenous people act right.
- 16:49Michael Mulligan: And one of the other arguments the company made was hey, you didn't consult with First Nations before turning down this application.
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: And they pointed to the Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act and said, hey, that says you should be doing that.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: What's going on?
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: You didn't consult with our proposed, with our partner here.
- 17:13Michael Mulligan: Your decision to turn this down should be struck down on the basis that you fail to consult with them.
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: That was an interesting argument and it would be, I think, even more interesting if that Land Act proposals were passed.
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: But here the judge, analyzing it, concluded that the applicant for this review, the particular applicant, was the forestry company wanting to become a cryptocurrency mining company on the side, and the applicant wasn't the First Nation.
- 17:46Michael Mulligan: And so, on that basis, the judge found that there just wasn't enough evidentiary basis here to conclude that the First Nation was part of this or what exactly their role would be, and it wasn't them bringing the challenge to the you can't plug in here order.
- 18:07Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that the DRIPA Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act was not breached when the government did not consult with the proposed partner for the cryptocurrency mining facility.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: And so the outcome of this is no extension cord to the Sightseed Dam, and the forestry company will have to come up with some other plan if they wish to diversify away from cutting down trees.
- 18:39Adam Stirling: I'm just sitting here imagining the hardware that would require two and a half million megawatt hours a year.
- 18:44Adam Stirling: It's hilarious.
- 18:48Michael Mulligan: You might as well go to Home Depot and get a really, really thick extension cord.
- 18:51Adam Stirling: Well, I was just thinking, because I'm doing the math in my head and I'm thinking without much computational horsepower could you actually corner global markets and make huge money?
- 18:59Adam Stirling: It's one of those thought experiment type scale projects that I never thought anybody would actually be audacious enough to attempt, or ask to attempt, as it were.
- 19:07Adam Stirling: We've got one more.
- 19:08Adam Stirling: It says in proper cross examination by Crown about the attractiveness of a complainant in a sexual assault case and unbalanced scrutiny of evidence by a judge.
- 19:18Adam Stirling: And the result Three minutes.
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: Yeah, I think I can do it in three minutes.
- 19:22Michael Mulligan: This is the case of a Duncan and it's a sexual assault case where the Crown decided to cross examine the accused who testified and testified that he did not sexually assault the complainant, and the Crown embarked on a line of cross examination about whether the accused thought the woman was attractive and whether she was pretty or whether she was I don't know if you use sexy, but was cross examining about that and the accused was left sort of stumbling over.
- 19:53Michael Mulligan: You know, I don't think that's not appropriate and the judge relied in part on the accused not saying yes, this person was attractive when the judge thought the person was attractive.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: And so the judge and one of the reasons for convicting the accused was the judge concluded that they thought they, the judge thought the complainant was attractive and found that the accused not acknowledging that she was attractive was an indication that he wasn't telling the truth when he said that he didn't sexually assault her Very interesting reasoning that has been considered in other cases.
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: The Ontario court of appeal concluded a number of years ago that it was not appropriate for Crown to be asking questions but whether the accused thought somebody was pretty or attractive or sexually attractive and that that's not relevant consideration to whether somebody committed a criminal act of sexual assault.
- 20:55Michael Mulligan: And similarly, the DC court of appeal has cited that case and also concluded that it's not appropriate to, for example, cross, get across, examine somebody in a sexual assault case and accused about their sexual orientation.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: Um, and the court of court of appeal in British Columbia approving of that Ontario case thing, you it's not appropriate to be asking questions about whether you think the complainant is sexy.
- 21:20Michael Mulligan: Um also confirmed that it's not appropriate to, for example, ask somebody whether they're um heterosexual or homosexual.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: Uh, uh, for example, in the context of an allegation of sexually assaulting a child, finding it's just not appropriate that somehow you would suggest that because somebody might uh be a particular sexual orientation is more likely they would have sexually assaulted a child.
- 21:43Michael Mulligan: And so there's been a lot of judicial cold water poured on that line of thinking, I think quite appropriately Uh.
- 21:50Michael Mulligan: And so here uh the judge's decision to uh first of all allow the crown to engage in that line of cross examination and then, in fact, relying upon it, um, in deciding not to accept the accused's denial that he committed the offense, uh was found on appeal to be inappropriate Um and not a sound basis to uh, have rejected uh his evidence, and also not appropriate that the judge would be using their own formulation about whether they thought the person was, um, attractive or pretty, uh, and so all of that led to the result that the conviction has been overturned, uh, and there's been a new trial order, um.
- 22:37Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan defense lawyers legally speak.