Latest / The So What? / Elections: A Historic Shift to the Middle
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:25Hello and as always a very warm welcome to this podcast which accompanies JP's latest
- 0:34newsletter dated the 17th of June 2024. And if you look at that date then of course it
- 0:40has to be elections. But the subtitle is interesting, a historic shift to the middle. JP you start
- 0:48with a whole list of things that you say did not happen and which are almost as important
- 0:56as what did happen. Yes absolutely. I identified six things that people predicted beforehand
- 1:03with great intensity and certainty will happen in this election and it did not happen. And
- 1:10you know Winston Churchill said if you want to look forward all you have to do is look
- 1:14backwards. And so if we look a little bit backwards to what did not happen in this election campaign
- 1:20over the last two or three months and particularly in the last month then we learn quite a few
- 1:25things. And the first thing that we learn is that all the predictions about violence
- 1:30did not materialise. We had all manner of threats being made from all sides. The commentary
- 1:37art joined in and predicted how bad will it be. Security groups released all kinds of
- 1:43cautionaries on how people must defend their properties and themselves and so on and so
- 1:47forth. And in the end the violence did not really materialise. Also if you go a little
- 1:53bit deeper and you look at political assassinations, so far this year, and it is now June so it's
- 1:59only half a year, but so far this year 11 people have been killed in political assassinations.
- 2:06Last year that number was 30 and the year before that was 41. Now our 11 political murders
- 2:1311 too many? Absolutely. Is it less than 30 and 41? Absolutely. So the violence thing
- 2:20that did not occur and a reduced level of political assassinations I think is something
- 2:25to note and to celebrate. The second thing that did not happen was the threat of huge
- 2:31disruptions either on election day or on a day that the results were announced. Well
- 2:37again none of that happened. Quite apart from violence, if we just talk old fashioned disruption,
- 2:44it did not happen. And once again it tells us that our institutions are holding that
- 2:50the majority of our people are actually not the radical kind of rabble rousers that people
- 2:57predict them to be. The third thing and probably the most important thing is the fear that
- 3:02if the ANC loses power it will cling to power and will not let go. Well that was proved
- 3:07and wrong in quite a spectacular way. Within two weeks the ANC moved from being a majority
- 3:14party to a minority party dependent on other people, other smaller parties and doing that
- 3:22transition in two weeks. It was absolutely quite astonishing. The results were announced
- 3:27on the 2nd of June and 12 days later on the 14th of June the DA and other opposition parties
- 3:33signed the coalition agreement. I think it is something that again we take for granted.
- 3:37We think that's the way it should be. But of course it's not necessarily the way it
- 3:41should be as we saw in the United States in the presidential election of 2020. The fourth
- 3:47thing that did not happen was that Cyril Ramaphosa was not kicked out by the ANC when the ANC
- 3:53support dropped to 40%. This was widely predicted by a number of analysts and members of the
- 3:59commentary art. It did not happen. The fifth thing that did not happen was that load shedding
- 4:05did not start or recommence the day after the votes were counted. Now of course load
- 4:11shedding can come back. I think that's a given. But give credit where it's due. For 80 days
- 4:17we haven't had load shedding and it's not because we burned more diesel. The diesel
- 4:22numbers have been made public. They're well known. They're out there. No we did not or
- 4:28ESCOM did not burn more diesel. Yet in fact they've burned about a tenth of what they
- 4:33burned last year this time. It was a dramatic reduction in diesel burning and in spite of
- 4:39that load shedding did not return. So maybe time to take our default cynicism and temperate
- 4:46a bit. And then the last observation I want to make is the polls were not wrong. As polls
- 4:53were published in the election period and results came out and people saw different
- 4:58trends and so on. There were a variety of people that you would expect. They're actually
- 5:03a bit more better informed. That's a better formulation. Dismissed the polls and said
- 5:13it's not, you know, it can't be. It's probably wrong and so on. And in the end no poll got
- 5:20the numbers 100% correct. No poll did that. But the polls did tell us about the big trends.
- 5:26It did tell us about the big breaks coming and it has transpired in that way. So Ruda
- 5:31you can make of these six non-happenings as I call them. You can make of these six non-happenings
- 5:37whatever you want, whatever you wish. But for me what stands out is the point I've already
- 5:43made. Most sub-africans are not radical. They do not sit on the extremes. They sit in the
- 5:49middle and all they want to see is a peaceful at ease country with itself and I think we
- 5:55saw that. And the second thing that came out is our institutions are robust. They were
- 6:00attacked. They were threatened. They were put under pressure. They came through with
- 6:05flying colors. And the third thing I think which is quite clear is that we have the capacity
- 6:11in the country to conduct world quality, global quality polls and also after the first election
- 6:18results come in global quality projections of what the final result would be. Most of
- 6:24the projections were absolutely spot on and even those that were a little bit shaky in
- 6:30the beginning corrected themselves and gave us a projection very early on in the counting
- 6:35phase which gave us the final result. And I think that's something that we as sub-africans
- 6:41can be proud of.
- 6:43And if we look at where we are now which looked so impossible just a day before the election
- 6:50results were announced, you did write about the possibility of a Toenadring, a moving
- 6:57closer between the DA and the ANC, twice in 2023. Remind us.
- 7:02Yes, a year ago, 13 months ago in May 2023, I did a note where I said exactly that that
- 7:09I think we need in the country a grand coalition. I define the grand coalition as the big parties
- 7:16of the middle, the ANC and the DA coming together reinforcing the middle ground. Of course, there
- 7:22were people who didn't like the suggestion. But a couple of months later in August 2023,
- 7:28I did a follow-up note in which I pointed out the developments that are taking place
- 7:33at that stage have taken place in our body politic, which pointed clearly that we're
- 7:39moving towards coalition territory. So that was in May and in August. And then of course,
- 7:45in May this year, the actual election result, the fact that the ANC was pushed to 40% pushed
- 7:51us very firmly into coalition territory. So that is where we are now.
- 7:57Why the government of national unity rather than a coalition?
- 8:02I think that was a very sophisticated finesse, if I can use breach terms, that was played
- 8:10by the ANC. What did the ANC achieve by talking about the government of national unity? First
- 8:17of all, they avoided a binary choice between either the DA or the EFF MK. The entire world,
- 8:24South Africa, the global media, everybody, when the election results became clear, bought
- 8:29into this binary choice. It'll have to be either this one or that one. And the ANC,
- 8:34which have always been good political operators, sidestepped that binary choice by introducing
- 8:40the notion of a government of national unity. With that, they got the initiative back, they
- 8:45avoided the binary choice, and they were sort of in charge of the process. And that brought
- 8:49the second consequence of the ANC doing that by inviting people to join the government
- 8:56of national unity based on common values. And then they made predominant, the common
- 9:02values are adherence to the constitution, adherence to the rule of law. By putting that
- 9:08upfront very strongly, they effectively sidelined or marginalized the EFF and MK because both
- 9:17those two parties cannot meet those preconditions.
- 9:21Well, especially MK.
- 9:23They're in favor of replacing the entire constitution. But the ANC didn't have to make a song and
- 9:30dance about it. They just put up the precondition and the other two parties then walked away.
- 9:37So they marginalized themselves, which puts the ANC in a better political position.
- 9:42You also make an interesting point about how our electoral system actually gave rise to
- 9:50where we're at now.
- 9:52Yeah, I feel very strongly about that. In 1994, our forefathers and mothers gave us
- 9:58an electoral system which is based on proportional representation or also called party lists.
- 10:05Now we did a bit of a survey and what we found is there are 87 countries in the world with
- 10:10proportional representation electoral systems. And two-thirds of those countries, two-thirds
- 10:17of those 87 countries do not have a majority party. They all run along the lines of coalitions.
- 10:25In a proportional system, unlike a constituency system, every vote counts the same. It's very
- 10:31different from a constituency first, past, or post system. So if you live in Ruda in
- 10:36Bupumalanga in a rural area or you live in a city in Cape Town, your vote counts exactly
- 10:43the same. And those votes are all, doesn't matter who you vote for in different part
- 10:48of the countries, it all gets added together for one party or one movement. So everybody
- 10:54is represented in parliament on a basis of equal weighting of the votes. You cannot get
- 11:00a situation that we had in the UK, for example, as recently as 2019, when the Tories won an
- 11:07election were 45% of the popular vote, but 55% of the seats in parliament. It's a nonsense
- 11:14situation. And so what did the Tories do with their 55% parliamentary majority? They rammed
- 11:20through Brexit. We had a similar thing in South Africa in 1948, when the National Party
- 11:25came into power and started apartheid legislation. The National Party didn't have a majority
- 11:32of votes in 48. They were sitting somewhere in the 40%, but they got more than 50% of
- 11:38the seats in parliament. In fact, the National Party only got a majority of the popular vote
- 11:4310 years later in 1958. For 10 years, they ruled on a minority of votes, but a majority
- 11:50of seats. Now that's the nonsense that you end up with in the constituency system. A
- 11:55proportional system is much more representative. That's the point. And everybody gets a bite
- 12:01at the apple, so to speak. So that is the system our founding fathers and mothers gave
- 12:07us. I think it works well for this country. And what it also means, if we look at other
- 12:13countries in the world, I don't think we will soon, I don't think in my lifetime, maybe
- 12:19in young people's lifetimes, we may again see a party with 50% plus one of the vote.
- 12:24But it is the exception. In a proportional system, many parties get votes and they have
- 12:32to come together to form a coalition government. So I think it's quite a big change that took
- 12:37place in the governments that we elect.
- 12:40Many South Africans will be quite worried about this because coalitions at local government
- 12:46level have been disastrous.
- 12:49Absolutely. You're quite right. After 2016 and 2021 local government elections, when
- 12:54we started getting coalition governments at local government level, things have not worked
- 13:00out well. It was a terrible experience. Why? And I think the answer is that those coalition
- 13:07parties that formed coalition governments in various municipalities focused on the who,
- 13:13not on the how.
- 13:15In other words, who gets the job?
- 13:16Who gets the job? Who gets the salary? Who's the mayor? Who's the speaker? Who's the chairman
- 13:21of committees? Who's getting the bigger package? Instead of focusing on how, how are we going
- 13:28to govern? What are we going to try and do? And how are we going to try and achieve those
- 13:32goals? It's a very big difference. It's a switching of the same letters, who and how,
- 13:38but it's a very different outcome.
- 13:40Now there's an interesting thing that happened in KZN about a year ago. The DA and IFP, in
- 13:47Qatar freedom party, signed a coalition agreement for the 13 municipalities in which they had
- 13:53coalition majorities. They ruled the municipality. It's a unique document in South Africa because
- 13:58what did they do or what does it do? They started out by saying what their values are.
- 14:04What are the things that they believe in? Constitution, rule of law, merit-based appointments,
- 14:11evidence-based policymaking, items like that.
- 14:14Secondly, what did they want to achieve in the five years that they formed the coalition
- 14:18government in the municipality? And it's basic things like water, basic services, upgrading
- 14:25our facilities and so on. And then thirdly, how are they going to do it? And for example,
- 14:32one item in the how to do list is that 8% of municipal budgets will be spent on maintenance.
- 14:40Now that may sound like a very sort of minor point, but in South Africa our big problem
- 14:44is maintenance. And the fact that these two parties put that into their agreement and
- 14:48it's part of how they're going to govern, I think is important. So we've got this agreement
- 14:54encased in and by all accounts it is working reasonably well.
- 14:59Now the national agreement which was signed by the ANC and the DA on the 14th of June
- 15:04follow exactly the same pattern. They start with a preamble of where the country is and
- 15:10I think we can all relate to those descriptions. Then they've got 10 foundational values and
- 15:17that includes the constitution, rule of law, merit-based appointments, evidence-based policymaking
- 15:24and so forth. And then thirdly, what they want to achieve. And there they talk about
- 15:29nine priorities. So this agreement which has now been signed by smaller parties as well
- 15:36is about 10 foundational values, nine priorities. So this coalition government has to work towards
- 15:42that. And that's what they will do over the next five years. And I think that's an important
- 15:47break with the chaos that we've seen in the past with local government coalitions.
- 15:52I think it's important to note that you attached that as an addendum to the newsletter so people
- 15:58can go to the website and find it.
- 16:01Yes, they can. Absolutely. It's at the end, it's an addendum. It's quite interesting just
- 16:04to look at those foundational values and priorities. And it gives you a feel that it's not just
- 16:09airy-fairy stuff. It's very practical. It's very real.
- 16:14But we all thought that those two parties, those two main parties were so far apart ideologically
- 16:21that they could never sit around the same fire. And the rhetoric on both sides was fiery
- 16:30to call it that.
- 16:32Yeah, you're quite right. There's the perception, very widely spread and very widely held, that
- 16:39the ANC and the DA are poles apart. As you know, I've never bought into that. I've always
- 16:45thought that the commonalities between those two parties, they both broadly parties to
- 16:49the middle. They both have their radicals. The ANC has got RDT people. Thanks to Mr.
- 16:54Zuma, a lot of them have left, but they are still RDT people in the ANC. And the DA has
- 16:59got its radicals. But the big critical mass of both parties are sitting in the middle.
- 17:06And I've always held that view about them.
- 17:09So you don't think that the ANC and the MK-EFF combination are better bedfellows?
- 17:17No, absolutely not. If you look at policy and you're concerned about policy, then there
- 17:22are bigger differences between the ANC and MK-ANC-EFF than ANC-DA. Let me give you a
- 17:30few examples. MK is very clear. They want to abolish the current constitution. They
- 17:35want to go back to the old South Africa arrangement where parliament is the sovereign authority
- 17:41in the state. Parliament makes a law, then that is the sovereign authority. Under our
- 17:45constitution and Bill of Rights, the constitution is the sovereign authority and it's applied
- 17:49by the constitutional court. It's two very different positions. And it's clear where
- 17:54the ANC is coming from. It's equally clear where MK is coming from. They're very much,
- 17:59much further apart than the ANC and the DA on that point. If you look at the EFF, you
- 18:05find a similar thing. The EFF is in favour of all land in the country. All property must
- 18:11belong to the state and the state will then dish out property, houses, buildings, farms
- 18:16and so on to whoever they deem appropriate. The ANC's position is exactly the opposite.
- 18:22The ANC's position is that land is a, individual citizens have the right to own their own land
- 18:29directly, i.e. they can have title deeds. And that's why you see a constant effort,
- 18:35particularly at election time, where the ANC dishes out title deeds. Very different from
- 18:40the EFF. So no, those two parties, MK and EFF, are both offspring of the ANC. That doesn't
- 18:50mean they're the same as the ANC. COPE was an offspring of the ANC and look where that
- 18:55is. Bantu Hulamisa's UDM is an offspring. Look where that is policy-wise. No, I think
- 19:01the reality is if you look beyond race and you say it's not just about where the parties
- 19:07are black, whether they come from a black constituency, if you actually look at policy,
- 19:13those parties are further away from the ANC than what the DA is.
- 19:17What do you make of talk about a national dialogue in the near future?
- 19:24That is one of the elements covered in the agreement that all the parties to the coalition
- 19:29agreement commit themselves to have such a dialogue. So I suspect we will see action
- 19:33over the next year. It's an idea that was launched by Talbot Mbeki just before the election.
- 19:38And the idea is that you try and develop a national consensus between everybody, white,
- 19:43black, old, young, business, labor, employed, unemployed, small business, big business,
- 19:49on where the country must go. It's really an issue of social capital, social cohesion,
- 19:54unity of purpose. Now, this is a noisy country. It's a noisy democracy. We've got many, many
- 20:00old players, many of them punching way above their small weight. So whether you can pull
- 20:06off such a national dialogue, we'll have to see. But that is future music.
- 20:13So what do you see happening when it comes to appointment to who gets the jobs?
- 20:19Well, the president must be in terms of the constitution section 87, I think, must be
- 20:26must take office within five days of his election. He was elected on Friday night. So it's Saturday,
- 20:31Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday. So Wednesday the 19th, he must be inaugurated, assume office,
- 20:37that'll take place at the Union building since Rwany. And then there's no stipulation on
- 20:42by when he must appoint a cabinet, but obviously he must then appoint a cabinet.
- 20:45And that's his prerogative.
- 20:46That's his prerogative. There's no time stipulation in the constitution. But I think the expectation
- 20:52and the political pressure is such that he will move. And there are some suggestions
- 20:56that he will do it by Friday the 21st. Let's see. Let's see. So that is as far as appointments
- 21:02go.
- 21:03Indications of who will be in that cabinet?
- 21:05No, no, I have no idea.
- 21:09So I can't
- 21:10Not even party affiliations?
- 21:12Well, party affiliations will certainly play a role. In fact, it is in the agreement that
- 21:17although it's the president's prerogative to appoint, he has to give due consideration
- 21:23to the seats that parties got in the national parliament. So it will follow more or less
- 21:29the party composition. I think you can say that the president can appoint two ministers
- 21:34and two deputy ministers from outside parliament. And we'll have to see whether he makes use
- 21:39of that freedom.
- 21:42Economic policy? Do you see any changes?
- 21:44No, I don't see any changes. I think on economic policy, you can summarize it in one word.
- 21:49The word is vulandlela. Vulandlela means opened away. And this was started way back by the
- 21:59president and way back when Titumu Buwini was minister of finance. This unit, vulandlela,
- 22:04has become a permanent unit inside the presidency. And they've scored significant policy victories.
- 22:09For example, spectrum release, which was delayed for 10 years under the previous president.
- 22:16Eventually they pulled that off and spectrum was released and we've got a new, as you know,
- 22:20a new dispensation. Secondly, energy, electricity. Electricity has been turned on its head, driven
- 22:27partly by the crisis with load shedding years. But you know, it's not good enough just to
- 22:31have a crisis. You must also have a way out of the crisis. And that's what vulandlela
- 22:35gave in electricity. In visa reform, we have seen recently announcements around making
- 22:41visas easier. So, vulandlela scored a number of important victories. It's an important
- 22:46institution, informal as it is. Now they focused on water, ports, railways, railway infrastructure.
- 22:58Those are the three main areas now where they're focusing. Now, the president has made it clear
- 23:04in a letter which he published after the election, but before his election in that two week period,
- 23:10he made it clear that it is absolutely imperative that this program of vulandlela carries on.
- 23:17It's a program of deep structural reform that will change the country quite fundamentally.
- 23:22And the DA has also expressed their support, not so?
- 23:25The DA is absolutely on side. It fits into what they also would like to see. So yeah,
- 23:31I think the two main parties are not going to jeopardize the implementation of railway
- 23:35reform, ports reform, water reform, and so on.
- 23:40And then in the last two weeks, there was a report from the Bureau for Economic Research
- 23:45at Stellenbosch. Very interesting.
- 23:47Yeah, very interesting. Also interesting politically in the fact that the president quoted it by
- 23:51name in his letter and what the Bureau for Economic Research do. The researchers there
- 23:58asked themselves the question, what needs to be done to change South Africa from a one
- 24:02and a half percent growth economy? One percent, if it's going well, we grow at one and a half.
- 24:08What can we do to change from a one and a half percent growth economy to a three and
- 24:13a half percent growth economy? And the relevance of those numbers are simply that population
- 24:18growth is 1.8. If you grow at one and a half, you're getting poorer. You're making more
- 24:23babies than what you're creating economy. On the other hand, if you grow at three and
- 24:27a half percent, that's almost double 1.8 percent population growth. Now you're cooking with
- 24:33gas. If you can carry on with three and a half percent versus 1.8 percent for five years
- 24:39or 10 years, you really change the country. That's what South Africa did in the first
- 24:4320 years of democracy. Economic growth far exceeded population growth and that gave you
- 24:49a substantial period of progress. So what the Bureau for Economic Research found in
- 24:55their work is that if you want to change from a one and a half percent to a three and a
- 24:59half percent economy, you don't have to do anything new. You don't have to do anything
- 25:03different. We don't need new policies. All we need is an energetic implementation of
- 25:08the Voluntary Lela program. So that's where economic policy will be after the election.
- 25:14It was also interesting to hear the references to the National Development Plan over the
- 25:20last while, because the National Development Plan was first published in what, 2012? And
- 25:25it seemed to have faded for a while, but it's now being brought. And as you say, the BER
- 25:31now came to the conclusion, we don't need new plans and new policies. We must just do
- 25:36what we said we were going to do.
- 25:38Yeah. I wouldn't put that much status on the National Development Plan. You're quite right.
- 25:42It has been referred to. It has been referenced more. But I don't think, as you know from
- 25:49the work that I've done at the National Planning Commission, I don't think there's a government-wide
- 25:53commitment and embracing of the National Development Plan. So I think Voluntary Lela is much more
- 26:00concrete. It's much more measurable. It's much more definite. And that's where I'm going
- 26:05to focus my work over the next year or so.
- 26:10What do you see happening as far as the budget's concerned?
- 26:13On the budget, I think it's quite clear. I hope, I don't know, but I hope that the current
- 26:19Minister of Finance, Eno Konugwana, will be reappointed. He's made it quite clear that
- 26:24he's not going to step away from bringing down South Africa's debt to GDP load. In fact,
- 26:30in this current year's budget, the year in which we are now, which will end on 31 March
- 26:34next year, he has penciled in an amount of more than $60 billion as a primary surplus.
- 26:40Now, a primary surplus simply means government has more income than expenditure if you exclude
- 26:46interest expense. And it's a vital tool that you need if you want to start breaking down
- 26:51or moving down your debt to GDP ratio. We had a primary surplus in this past year for
- 26:58the first time in 15 years. So the minister has done it. If you look back, he's penciled
- 27:04it in for this year, and I think he will stick to that policy. And as the debt to GDP ratio
- 27:10comes down, interest rate pressure will come down, and in general, things will improve.
- 27:17Now, currently, debt to GDP is sitting at about 74%, and the DAE has formally proposed
- 27:23to the coalition government that they would like to see a level of 67%. So that's clear
- 27:28where they're standing. So I think there's broad agreement, and that's the way the budget
- 27:32will go.
- 27:33What happens when there are disagreements, as surely there will be?
- 27:38Then there are mechanisms written into that agreement between the DAE and the ANC, well,
- 27:46all parties to the government of national unity, on what must be done to solve disagreements.
- 27:53There's a process of talking, and then eventually, the final step is sufficient consensus, and
- 28:01sufficient consensus is defined as 60% of 60% support in parliament. Now, of course,
- 28:07the two big parties, DA and ANC, make 60%. So that's the way you will move forward. And
- 28:16I think, Ruda, what we have to accept, we must now get out of the mindset of having
- 28:22a majority party who can decide alone, and that's the end of the story. But we must also
- 28:27accept that if you're the minority party in a coalition, that doesn't mean you can dictate
- 28:32what must happen. Everybody will have to compromise. And that's when I think one of the foundational
- 28:39values of evidence-based policymaking is an important point, because when you then have
- 28:46disagreements, you can say, right, let's get in the experts, let's get in the hard data,
- 28:52and see what should shape the decision that we have to make.
- 28:56I'm quite sure the one thing that South Africans are good at, we make a hell of a noise, but
- 29:01once we're in the room, we actually compromise. We've got an ability to make deals. That's
- 29:07how the new South Africa was built. So I'm not too worried about that. There are processes,
- 29:11you work through the processes, you overcome your differences.
- 29:15Doesn't the phrase sufficient consensus come from 94?
- 29:18Exactly, exactly. And now the phrase is back. It gave us the constitution, it gave us the
- 29:23democracy, and it will play its role now as well in the coalition government.
- 29:27Might we see movement in local governments before the next local government election,
- 29:34which is what, 2026?
- 29:36Oh, absolutely. You'll see that before this podcast goes out. We've already seen it. The
- 29:41ANC has recalled that rather suboptimal mayor that was in Durban, he's been kicked upstairs
- 29:48to the National Council of Provinces. You can go sit there and it's Hillary. He's been removed.
- 29:53The ANC mayor of Ekorilei has also fired the EFF council responsible for finance. He was
- 30:01only appointed a few weeks ago when there was a temporary coalition agreement.
- 30:07Just for the weekend, no?
- 30:08Yeah, it was more or less two weekends. So, and I think you're going to see them much
- 30:14more. I think what's going to happen in the next couple of weeks is that coalition governments
- 30:19across the country, where the ANC and the DA are not working together, but they are
- 30:25in partnership of all kinds of funny small parties, that will be cleared up. You will
- 30:30get coalition agreements between the people who serve in the government of national unity.
- 30:35That means it'll affect Nelson Mandela Bay, it'll affect Johannesburg, it'll affect Ekorilei,
- 30:41it'll affect Twane, probably Tehkwini as well. A number of municipalities, I think, will
- 30:47get onto a new trajectory and that should make a difference, at least in some local
- 30:53governments.
- 30:54So, in summary, so what?
- 30:57I think, first of all, it is quite a thing that happened, that the ANC lost the majority
- 31:02that they had for 30 years, that they accepted it and that they moved to a new dispensation,
- 31:08a new governance dispensation within two weeks. I think that's a phenomenal performance. As
- 31:14I've said, it didn't even happen in America in 2020. We will see what happens this year
- 31:18in America, but for the South Africans, it's a point of pride and something we can feel
- 31:23very good about. On matters economic, it is quite clear that the middle has been strengthened
- 31:29considerably. This pseudo warfare, this phony war that we had between the DA and the ANC,
- 31:36which I never bought into, as I've said, that can now be set aside and you can, like
- 31:41adults, talk about what needs to be done to grow the economy.
- 31:45The third, so what, is it would be wrong to say that the DA will stop transformation in
- 31:52the country. That is the general accusation which is against the DA. But if you look at
- 31:57the foundational principles which were signed by the DA, those foundational principles are
- 32:02very clear that we have a particular legacy in this country, that we have to overcome
- 32:07that legacy and that that requires specific proactive measures. That's also, by the way,
- 32:13not just in this national agreement, it is also in the agreement which the DA signed
- 32:17to the IFP in KwaZulu-Natal a year ago in respect of local government. So it's not a
- 32:22new idea. I don't see any stop to the process of making the economy more inclusive to black
- 32:29people taking steps necessary to overcome our past. And I think those two things, much
- 32:36higher economic growth, much more inclusion, that will dominate for the next five years.
- 32:42And then I think the big so what is that we've seen a substantial move to the middle. Yes,
- 32:47MK did quite well and kudos to them, but Julius Malema was cut down and he moved from an 11%
- 32:58party to a 9.5% party. He must be terribly disappointed. He's been repudiated clearly
- 33:05by the country. MK did only did well in KZN. I think they've got a little bit of support
- 33:11in Mpumalanga and they've got one member of parliament in the free state. So for me, the
- 33:18majority of people in this country actually do not want radicalism. They don't want right
- 33:23wing radicalism and they don't want RET radicalism. So there's a coming together in the middle,
- 33:29which I think is absolutely great. And your last point is there's hope for local governments,
- 33:36which makes me very happy. Yeah, I think we will see a reorganization of local government,
- 33:41a political reorganization, whether that then feeds through quickly into better bureaucratic
- 33:46performance, better service delivery that we will have to see. But at least as a businessman
- 33:52has remarked in this case of Johannesburg, fix the politics and then you can start fixing
- 33:57the city. And at least now we're busy fixing the politics. So we may see improvement in
- 34:06the city service delivery as well. Thank you very much to the listeners. Thank you for
- 34:11your time, for your attention. Enjoy this breath of fresh air that is blowing through
- 34:17the country and stay warm. Indeed. Thank you very much. Thank you for listening to the
- 34:24So What podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and
- 34:30a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes. Also
- 34:35tell your friends. Remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at JPLandman.co.za