Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Occupiers' Liability, Wills Variation and Judical Case Managers
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment with Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defene Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: Good morning, michael Mulligan.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: How are you doing?
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Hey, I'm doing great.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: What is on our agenda for today?
- 0:12Michael Mulligan: The first case on our agenda deals with a pothole at 7-Eleven and how that can cause or how it did cause in this case very serious problems.
- 0:22Michael Mulligan: A pothole and ultimately a pothole Okay, and how that connects to the Occupiers Liability Act and why you need to be careful to make sure you fill in your potholes.
- 0:32Michael Mulligan: And so the factual background here involved a woman who was on her way to work.
- 0:38Michael Mulligan: She worked doing a physically demanding job at a nursery planting trees, as she'd done for many years and she stopped with some co-workers to get morning coffee at 7-Eleven and on the way back to the vehicle she tripped in a pothole and broke her ankle very seriously in three places.
- 1:02Michael Mulligan: She reluctantly went to the hospital after having somebody take some pictures of the pothole, and the injury turned out to be much more serious than expected.
- 1:15Michael Mulligan: She wound up being off work for several months.
- 1:18Michael Mulligan: She wound up on crutches, eventually in a wheelchair, and then she walked with mobility impairment in a limp and as a result of those problems, she fell down some stairs and injured her back.
- 1:30Michael Mulligan: So it really didn't go well.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: The result of this was a lawsuit suing 7-Eleven, and so you might wonder how is 7-Eleven responsible for tripping in the parking lot 7-Eleven, and so you might wonder how is 7-Eleven responsible for tripping in the parking lot?
- 1:49Michael Mulligan: Well, the legal answer to that comes from a BC Act called the Occupiers Liability Act, and the idea of that act is that in many circumstances, somebody who's like an occupier of property and that could be like the owner of the property, or it could be, for example, when property is leased like it would be to a business 7-Eleven.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: They are the occupier under the Occupier Liability Act, and what that act does is it imposes a duty of care on the occupier to take care with respect to things, including the condition of the premises and activities on the premises and even conduct of other people on the premises.
- 2:26Michael Mulligan: And the reason that's important is one of the starting points for whether you can sue somebody for negligence like that's being careless, right, and that's distinct from suing somebody, for example, over a contract right Civil claim negligence.
- 2:41Michael Mulligan: One of the things you need to establish is that the person that you're suing owes you a duty of care, right?
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: It's like is that person responsible for being careful?
- 2:51Michael Mulligan: And so this act makes it clear that somebody who's an occupier has the statutory duty of care to take care about things, including in this case, the relevant thing was the condition of the premises.
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: Now I should pause here for a moment to say there are some exceptions set out in the Occupiers Liability Act.
- 3:10Michael Mulligan: One of the exceptions in there is that you don't owe a duty of care under that act to somebody who comes on.
- 3:17Michael Mulligan: Is trespassing on premises?
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: Well, committing or intending to commit a criminal act?
- 3:22Michael Mulligan: The idea is they've deemed to have willfully assumed all risks, and so that might be.
- 3:27Michael Mulligan: For example, let's say a burglar is trying to, you know, climb in your window using your ladder or something, and it turns out the ladder is in poor condition.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: They fall down and get hurt.
- 3:37Michael Mulligan: Right, you'd be able to say, well, look, maybe I didn't maintain my ladder that well, but this person was using my ladder to break into my house to steal things, and so tough luck, at least under the Occupiers' Liability Act.
- 3:48Michael Mulligan: And then there are some other exceptions that apply dealing with things like rural properties.
- 3:56Michael Mulligan: And when you think about what I've told you about how the Occupiers' Liability Act works, you might have some concern.
- 4:02Michael Mulligan: If, let's say, you're a farmer and you've got a big farm, people are cutting through it or you know, own some piece of undeveloped land.
- 4:08Michael Mulligan: Well, oh no, now what?
- 4:10Michael Mulligan: And so they've carved out exceptions whereby a person is with respect to premises like that, whereby somebody is either trespassing or on property for recreational activity, and the person who owns the property is receiving no payment and the person's not paying to live there.
- 4:31Michael Mulligan: And so there are then categories of places where it doesn't apply, for example, rural premises which are used for forestry and range purposes, like if you have a big land lot that you might want to log at some point you're not going to wind up in trouble under the Occupiers Liability Act or forested wilderness premises or private roads marked clearly as private roads or recreational trails, which explains why in some cases you would see those things marked in that way.
- 5:00Michael Mulligan: Also excluded are utility rights of way.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: Like you know, for example, sometimes there are places where hydro lines go down and people would use them for recreational purposes, like hiking through there or whatnot.
- 5:11Michael Mulligan: You're also off the hook there.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: So the Occupiers Liability Act is a starting point here for the pothole in the parking lot.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: But there's another exemption under the Occupiers Liability Act where the occupier is able to rebut the presumption that they have this duty, where they can show that they have a reasonable system of inspections and maintenance in place.
- 5:38Michael Mulligan: And that's really what this case turned on.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: We don't have a standard of perfection.
- 5:42Michael Mulligan: Bearing in mind, the concept is sort of you have to have a duty of care and somebody has to have sort of breached what that duty of care is.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: Your duty of care isn't to ensure perfection.
- 5:52Michael Mulligan: You don't need to, if you're 7-Eleven, ensure that you know absolute, you know you can't have a twig on your parking lot or whatnot.
- 6:00Michael Mulligan: And so here the case turned on things like well, what does 7-Eleven do to make sure there aren't things like potholes you might trip on when you're coming out with your morning coffee?
- 6:09Michael Mulligan: No-transcript if somebody you know trips in your pothole and badly, badly breaks their ankle.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: And 7-Eleven pointed to the fact that each new employee is required to take an online safety course called quote Working Safely that's well named and then complete five answers at the end of it, and they have to get a mark of 80%.
- 6:53Michael Mulligan: And the course included a section entitled Slips, trips and Falls quote Exterior Hazards.
- 7:00Michael Mulligan: So that seems sort of relevant.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: And so the judge wound up looking at well, how was that managed?
- 7:05Michael Mulligan: Did everyone have to do this?
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: Was this enough?
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: And here, interestingly, even though 7-Eleven was sophisticated enough to have such a class, including that particular course, including that particular section, the judge found that that wasn't really sufficient and they looked at a number of things, including there was no written material on site.
- 7:27Michael Mulligan: It was sort of unclear who all took this thing.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: 7-eleven had changed its policy to have a policy where people should or would be encouraged to take this, like on an annual basis, this online course, but there was no consequence for not doing it.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: And also looked interestingly at the fact and this is a credit to the woman who badly broke her ankle she asked a friend to take a picture of the pothole at the time and then went back and took pictures that had been filled in the next day and that went a long way to responding to 7-Eleven's claim that oh, this really wasn't anything and you couldn't have tripped on this thing or whatnot.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: And so at the end of the day, pursuant to the Occupiers Liability Act, found that they hadn't taken sufficient steps to maintain the property.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: She had indeed tripped in this thing.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: She was vigorously challenged on that.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: But the judge accepted her evidence and then had to go on and figure out.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: Well, what compensation should she be due for this injury?
- 8:26Michael Mulligan: And in that respect, as in many cases involving personal injury, the judge would look at a number of things.
- 8:32Michael Mulligan: They would include a concept of non-pecuniary damages, which is like pain and suffering.
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: And in this case this altered this woman's life terribly.
- 8:42Michael Mulligan: You know, she gained weight, she couldn't work, she wound up in poverty.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: It just totally devastated her life and ongoing pain and issues.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: And so the judge awarded her $175,000 for the pain and suffering.
- 8:57Michael Mulligan: Now I must say, sometimes when you see those figures you think, well, that's a lot of money.
- 9:00Michael Mulligan: But on the other hand, if I said to you, if I can turn your life from a happy, productive state of affairs where everything's going great, to this terrible state of affairs, would you do that for $175,000?
- 9:11Michael Mulligan: Many people, they have toRP.
- 9:12Michael Mulligan: Absolutely not.
- 9:13Michael Mulligan: That's totally not putting me back into where I was, but that's what was done.
- 9:18Michael Mulligan: And then the judge also has other heads of damages, like future loss of income.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: So the judge would have to look at what would you have been able to make doing the work you were doing but you can no longer make because you can't lift trees and do the work you've done for many years and on that ground.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: That was the largest set of damages.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: That was $494,000.
- 9:42Michael Mulligan: Both of those things now, of course, under no fault in car accidents, which are the most common way people are injured either, don't exist at all.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: There is no award at all for, like, pain and suffering that's gone under no fault.
- 9:54Michael Mulligan: Um, and the future lost income is not analyzed on the base of what would you actually have made.
- 10:01Michael Mulligan: It's got like artificial caps and deductions and percentages and all these things.
- 10:05Michael Mulligan: So it doesn't uh, come out the way it used to, but it still applies for these other kinds of injuries.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: And then adding it all up, uh, including things like cost of future care and specific losses, specific costs and things like what's your wheelchair going to cost for the rest of your life or crutches, that kind of thing.
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: She was awarded $907,363.
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: Wow, so very substantial loss and just a cautionary tale for all involved If you're a small business person.
- 10:32Michael Mulligan: If you're a homeowner, if you are a like, you have a condo right.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: You and the Strata Corporation need to be aware of these things, because this sort of thing can happen if you're not being diligent and have some system in place to prove that you're diligent, right, about all the kinds of things.
- 10:51Michael Mulligan: What about potholes?
- 10:52Michael Mulligan: Are you cleaning the snow off of your steps?
- 10:54Michael Mulligan: Are you just taking reasonable steps to ensure the safety of that place that you own or are responsible for?
- 11:02Michael Mulligan: If you're leasing it and many people aren't going to be 7-Eleven, and I'm sure if you asked a lot of, like small restaurants or small businesses, you know what is your policy in place about training your employees to ensure the safety of the entrance to your premises.
- 11:16Michael Mulligan: It's going to produce a blank stare, and so this is just important to be aware of it.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: It's also why it's so important in any of those circumstances to have proper insurance.
- 11:28Michael Mulligan: Otherwise, you might wind up on the hook for a very large amount of money if somebody like this poor woman winds up with just a devastating consequence when they trip in your unfilled-in pothole.
- 11:40Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from 7-11, the Occupiers Liability Act and what you need to do to act reasonably to keep people safe.
- 11:47Adam Stirling: All right, we're going to take a quick break.
- 11:49Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers continues right after this, back on the air here at CFax 1070.
- 11:55Adam Stirling: As we continue legally speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers, michael, our next story has to do with someone's last will and testament, multiple siblings and whether or not equal or fair shares of one's assets were actually provided to each.
- 12:11Adam Stirling: How does all that work?
- 12:13Michael Mulligan: Well, it's very interesting.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: There seem to be an increasing number of these cases in BC and they are cases under what is now called the Wills of States and Secession Act, section 60.
- 12:25Michael Mulligan: And that section deals with what used to be in the past the Wills Variation Act.
- 12:31Michael Mulligan: And the idea behind that part of the WESA is that if somebody doesn't make adequate provision for the support of their spouse or children in their will, an application can be made to vary the will.
- 12:46Michael Mulligan: And it's interesting to see just how that's been applied.
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: And this particular case one of the conclusions eventually the judge reaches here is asks the question this way the question is whether there is a legitimate basis for departing from the reasonable expectation that adult children will share equally in their parents' estate.
- 13:10Michael Mulligan: And I'll tell you this is an interesting fact pattern, but that's how the judge approaches it.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: And I'll tell you this is an interesting fact pattern, but that's how the judge approaches it.
- 13:16Michael Mulligan: So there's now a would seem to be a quite a strong legal presumption that that will be what happens with somebody's estate.
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: And if they don't do that without some judge referring to it as valid and rational reason, it's very likely the will just isn't going to be implemented, it'll be modified, which raises just interesting questions about.
- 13:34Michael Mulligan: You know, what degree of autonomy do people have in terms of their estate?
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: And the interesting fact pattern here is it involves three sisters and they originally lived in Macau and then later in Hong Kong before they all wound up moving to Canada a family of various different times and the father who eventually passed away, and he had an estate of $584,000,.
- 13:58Michael Mulligan: He provided that two of his biological children would share equally, but the third child, who is the applicant of this case, would receive $10,000 US, and the Factual background of that is that when that third child was only four years old, she was taken from her home where she lived in Macau and was left to live with the father's sister and I think it was her husband and she grew up in Hong Kong with them serving as her parents effectively, and the background appears to the rationale for that may well have been financial.
- 14:41Michael Mulligan: The description was that the two daughters who lived with the biological father who passed away.
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: The conditions that included living in an apartment with seven or eight people without flush toilets, hot water, no refrigerator, no television and food was scarce.
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: In contrast, the daughter who was the applicant of this case, who went and lived with her aunt and uncle effectively, she referred to them as mother and father lived in a prestigious neighborhood in Hong Kong in a spacious modern home with indoor plumbing, hot water appliances, servants' quarters, a large backyard, abundant food, stylish clothing, lots of toys and so material wealth.
- 15:26Michael Mulligan: Yes, but the evidence was she was always confused and upset at the fact that, from her perspective, she was abandoned to that circumstance.
- 15:37Michael Mulligan: Set of the fact that, from her perspective, she was abandoned to that circumstance, even though she lived in material abundance unlike her sisters.
- 15:42Michael Mulligan: She knew, because this happened at age four, that this was her aunt and uncle and not her mother and father.
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: And, interestingly, the father in his will referred to her as his nephew in the will, even though he was her biological daughter.
- 15:59Michael Mulligan: And one of the issues that arose here was the issue about whether the aunt and uncle had adopted her.
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: Because if she was adopted, what was the Will of Reaction Act, now WESA, requires that there be adequate support, and that doesn't mean just if you're impoverished, you have to be supported.
- 16:17Michael Mulligan: Adequate support for is like spouses or children, and if she was in fact adopted by the aunt and uncle, she would then no longer be the child of the person who made the will, and so that was one of the issues at the trial.
- 16:30Michael Mulligan: Ultimately, the sisters who were defending this claim by the end of the case the judge said accepted that she had not in fact been adopted, so she did have authority to, under this act, make this application.
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: And so the judge then had to go through, as in many of these cases, like the whole background of how these people grew up and you know who got support at this time or that time.
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: You know who got help buying a house and what happened when they moved to Canada to go to university and all of these things.
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: But the and then also looked at things like the nature of their relationship, like later in life, and there wasn't much of a relationship between the biological daughter plaintiff and her biological father, in large part, the judge found, because of that childhood background and how strained that made their relationship.
- 17:23Michael Mulligan: And it was clear the other daughters did have an ongoing good relationship with their father despite some of the financial challenges that they had.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: And so at the end of the day, as I indicated at the outset, the judge assessed it from the perspective of whether there was a legitimate basis for deviating from that reasonable expectation that adult children would share equally.
- 17:49Michael Mulligan: And the judge found that there was not.
- 17:50Michael Mulligan: And the test under that act isn't looking at whether there's a legal claim to money.
- 17:59Michael Mulligan: There isn't right, there's no legal obligation to support your adult children.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: But it's analyzed from the perspective of moral obligation.
- 18:06Michael Mulligan: And the judge found that indeed there was a moral obligation, and maybe a greater one because of that childhood background, despite the fact that the daughter grew up in material, with material wealth.
- 18:19Michael Mulligan: And so at the end of the day the judge modified the will and all three sisters will share equally.
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: The daughter who made the claim will be entitled to her costs of the litigation that will lead into some of it.
- 18:33Michael Mulligan: But I thought it was just an interesting case in fact pattern for people to be aware of that.
- 18:37Michael Mulligan: There is now in the law a strong presumption of what the judge indicated.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: There was equal sharing by adult children in a will, and if somebody is departing from it they better have a good reason expressed in the will why that's happening and the judge did allude to.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: You know, sometimes there could be explanations like well, you know, a parent provided much more support to one of the children when they were alive, for example.
- 19:01Michael Mulligan: Or somebody said, well, I helped this child buy a home or something, right, and so that's why I'm going to treat the other children differently.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: But there has to be that kind of valid reason, or else this kind of an application can occur.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: The other thing to know is that there are no constraints on what somebody might do when they're alive, right, you don't have a legal obligation to support your adult children, and so parents, while they're alive, can do whatever they want, but in their will.
- 19:27Michael Mulligan: If it doesn't meet this legal criteria of adequate support, which is quite liberally interpreted in BC, this is the sort of change that can occur.
- 19:40Michael Mulligan: So that was an interesting fact pattern and just a cautionary tale in terms of how people are trying to organize their affairs.
- 19:47Adam Stirling: All right, we've got two minutes left and one more story on the agenda.
- 19:51Adam Stirling: What is a judicial case manager and what do they do?
- 19:56Michael Mulligan: Yeah, this is important to know.
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: So judicial case managers work in the provincial court in British Columbia and the way that works is that they have authority which is delegated to them under the Provincial Court Act, and that act allows the chief judge of the province to delegate responsibilities to other judicial officers, and judicial case managers wind up doing all kinds of things they actually sit in court like.
- 20:25Michael Mulligan: Often if somebody goes to court, like for a first appearance on a criminal case, the person sitting there is unlikely to be a judge.
- 20:32Michael Mulligan: They're much more likely to be a judicial case manager, and the idea there is to have judges focusing all of their time on things you need judges for, like conducting trials and doing sentencings and things of that sort, and then some of the other tasks can be delegated to other judicial officials and judicial case managers.
- 20:51Michael Mulligan: One of their principal obligations is to do things like schedule trial dates and sentencings and so on, and that's complicated.
- 21:01Michael Mulligan: Many, many years ago it might have been some judge sitting up there with a big, thick book and a calendar, but those days are way gone and so that's a very complicated thing.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: But they do all kinds of other things, like dealing with adjournments and appearances and making all kinds of orders where there is consent, like if you have the Crown and the defense agreeing that, for example, a case should be adjourned for something to happen.
- 21:22Michael Mulligan: The idea is you could have a judicial case manager do that and not have to have a judge hear that.
- 21:26Michael Mulligan: And there's also been a real push over the past number of years to get as many things as they possibly can dealt with, like in writing, by counsel, with a judicial case manager, to reduce the just otherwise overwhelming flood of people would have to in the past show up every single week or whatever every two weeks in criminal cases, and so judicial case managers can deal with all of those sort of things as well, things like amending or vacating a bench warrant where that's by consent, or implementing bans on publication when that's by consent, or adjourning cases when it's by consent.
- 22:03Michael Mulligan: So they fulfill a very important role, and there was just a recent update specifying again what precisely all of their powers are.
- 22:11Michael Mulligan: So if you wind up going to court, you may well find yourself looking up at a judicial case manager for many of the administrative appearances rather than a provincial court judge.
- 22:21Adam Stirling: So that's what they are Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 22:28Adam Stirling: Michael, pleasure as always.
- 22:29Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:30Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 22:31Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 22:32Adam Stirling: All right, you too.
- 22:33Adam Stirling: Quick break.
- 22:33Adam Stirling: We're back right after this.