Latest / Taylor Tailored / The Green Party Is Rising Fast — But Its New Momentum Comes With Hard Questions
Transcript
- 0:00The Green Party is rising fast, but its new momentum comes with
- 0:05hard questions. Why?
- 0:06The Green Party's surge is not as innocent as it looks.
- 0:11The Green Party's rise is not really about recycling bins,
- 0:14cycle lanes, or middle class climate guilt anymore.
- 0:17That version of the party still exists, but it no longer
- 0:21explains the scale of the shift. The modern Green surge is being
- 0:25driven by something sharper. Anger at Labor, distrust of the
- 0:29old parties, younger voters priced out of stability,
- 0:33progressive activists furious over Gaza and a leader trying to
- 0:37turn the Greens from a pressure group into a mass anti
- 0:40establishment movement. That is why the party's rise
- 0:44matters. This is also why it deserves
- 0:47scrutiny. The Green Party of England and
- 0:50Wales won a record 4 seats at the 2024 general election, a
- 0:55breakthrough confirmed in parliamentary election analysis.
- 0:58Since then, its parliamentary presence has grown further after
- 1:02Hannah Spencer won the Gorton and Denton by election on
- 1:05February 26th, 2026, becoming the party's fifth MP.
- 1:09Official parliamentary records confirmed Spencer has held the
- 1:13seat since that by election. That, by election, was not a
- 1:18polite protest. It was a warning shot.
- 1:21A traditional Labor seat fell to the Greens, Labor dropped a
- 1:25third, and the contest showed that the party can now hurt
- 1:28Labor directly in urban, diverse working class areas, not just in
- 1:32university towns or environmentally liberal
- 1:35enclaves. The Greens are surging because
- 1:38they have found the gap Labor left open.
- 1:40But the price of occupying that gap is that the party's more
- 1:44radical positions are moving from activist meetings into
- 1:48mainstream electoral politics. Why are the Greens surging?
- 1:53There are 4 main reasons. First, Laboux's left flank is
- 1:58exposed. Keir Starmer's government has
- 2:01disappointed parts of the progressive coalition that
- 2:04helped deliver Labour's 2024 landslide on climate welfare,
- 2:10Gaza migration and public spending.
- 2:13Many left wing voters see Labour as cautious, managerial and too
- 2:18willing to triangulate. Second, the Greens have become a
- 2:22protest vehicle for voters who dislike Reform UK but share the
- 2:26same broad anti establishment mood.
- 2:29Reform channels anger to the right, the Greens channel anger
- 2:36to the left. Third, Zach Polanski has changed
- 2:40the party's style since becoming leader in September 2025.
- 2:45He has pushed a more aggressive, emotionally direct pitch that
- 2:49links climate policy to rent bills, billionaires, public
- 2:53services and anti corporate politics.
- 2:55The Green Party's own announcement confirmed
- 2:57Polanski's election as leader on September 2nd, 2025, while later
- 3:03reporting noted party membership reached 100,000 for the first
- 3:06time after he became leader. 4th The Greens have benefited from
- 3:12the collapse of old political loyalty in an era where Labour,
- 3:16the Conservatives Reform, the Liberal Democrats and the Greens
- 3:20are all fighting over a more fragmented electorate.
- 3:23A smaller party no longer needs to win everyone, it just needs
- 3:26enough intensity in the right places.
- 3:30That is exactly what happened in Gorton and Denton.
- 3:33Who is voting Green? The Green vote is younger, more
- 3:37educated and more progressive than the national average.
- 3:41At the 2024 general election, Ipsos estimated Green support
- 3:45was strongest among younger voters, with the party
- 3:48performing particularly well among 18 to 24 year olds
- 3:51compared with older age groups. Ipsos also found Green support
- 3:56was higher among voters with degrees than among those with no
- 4:00formal qualifications. That tells the real story.
- 4:05The Green Party's modern voter base is not simply
- 4:08environmentalist. It is disproportionately young,
- 4:11socially liberal, highly educated, urban or university
- 4:15adjacent and deeply dissatisfied with Labour's caution.
- 4:19Polling in 2026 suggested the party was making serious
- 4:24national gains. A March 2026 You Gov poll
- 4:27reported by Sky News put the Greens ahead of Labor, only two
- 4:31points behind Reform UKA striking signal of how far the
- 4:34party had moved from the margins.
- 4:36That does not mean the Greens are only a student party.
- 4:40Hannah Spencer's Gorton and Denton victory complicates that
- 4:44stereotype. It showed the Greens can compete
- 4:46in places where Labor once assumed its local machine.
- 4:50Ethnic minority support, public sector vote, and anti
- 4:53conservative instincts would be enough.
- 4:55Their challenge is obvious. They are trying to sound like a
- 4:58mass movement while still carrying policies and cultural
- 5:01instincts that many mainstream voters may see as niche,
- 5:04ideological, or extreme. Do a lot of immigrants vote
- 5:09Green? The honest answer is there is no
- 5:12clean evidence that immigrants as a single group are voting
- 5:15green in large numbers. That framing is too broad.
- 5:20Immigrants are not one block. They vary by age, class,
- 5:26religion, ethnicity, country of origin, generation, income,
- 5:31geography and political priority.
- 5:33What can be said is more precise.
- 5:37Ethnic minority voters in Britain have historically leaned
- 5:40more towards Labour and other progressive parties than white
- 5:43voters, although that relationship is changing.
- 5:46AUK in a changing Europe. Vocal Data report on the 2024
- 5:50election found that ethnic minority voters were more likely
- 5:54than white voters to support Labor, Greens or the Liberal
- 5:59Democrats collectively. But that does not isolate Green
- 6:02support specifically and does not prove immigrants are driving
- 6:06the Green surge. The Greens may have benefited in
- 6:10some diverse urban areas from Labor anger over Gaza, migration
- 6:14rhetoric, and the perception that Labor has moved rightward
- 6:17on social issues. The Gorton and Denton result is
- 6:21the clearest recent warning sign for Labor.
- 6:24The Greens can now speak to progressive Muslim student and
- 6:28working class discontent in the same seat.
- 6:30But it would be misleading to say immigrants vote Green as a
- 6:34general rule. The stronger claim is this.
- 6:37The Greens are increasingly attractive to progressive
- 6:39minority voters, Muslim voters angry over Gaza, younger urban
- 6:44voters and Labor defectors in diverse constituencies.
- 6:48That is not the same as saying immigrants broadly vote Green.
- 6:52The migration problem for the Greens On immigration, the Green
- 6:58Party's position is among the most liberal and mainstream
- 7:02British politics. The party's migration policy
- 7:05says it wants a fair and humane alternative that treats new
- 7:08migrants as potential citizens. It's refugee and asylum policy
- 7:13calls for safe routes, faster and fairer asylum decisions and
- 7:17the right for asylum seekers to work while claims are processed.
- 7:21Supporters see that as humane and principled.
- 7:24Critics see a serious political vulnerability at a time when
- 7:29immigration is one of the most sensitive issues in British
- 7:32politics. The Greens have chosen moral
- 7:34clarity over border control, reassurance that may help them
- 7:38with young progressives, students, activists, minority
- 7:42communities and voters appalled by hardline rhetoric.
- 7:45But it may also limit their reach with voters who support
- 7:48public services in redistribution but worry about
- 7:51housing, wage pressure, integration, community cohesion
- 7:56and state capacity. This is one of the
- 7:58contradictions inside the Green search.
- 8:01The party talks about the cost of living.
- 8:04It talks about public services. It talks about housing.
- 8:09But its migration position can look to skeptics as if it
- 8:14assumes the state has unlimited absorptive capacity.
- 8:17That is where the Greens could run into trouble if they move
- 8:20from protest politics to serious governing scrutiny.
- 8:24The gender stance is a major flashpoint.
- 8:27The Green Party's position on gender identity is another
- 8:31serious controversy. The party and its affiliated
- 8:34groups have repeatedly adopted strongly trans inclusive
- 8:38language. Young Greens stated in 2025 that
- 8:42they agreed with Green Party policy saying trans men are men,
- 8:47trans women are women, and non binary identities are real and
- 8:52valid. Local Green materials have used
- 8:55similar wording, recognizing trans men as men, trans women as
- 9:00women, and non binary identities as valid.
- 9:04For trans rights supporters, that clarity is the point.
- 9:08For critics, especially gender critical feminists, it is
- 9:13exactly the problem. The legal context changed
- 9:16dramatically after the UK Supreme Court's April 2025
- 9:21judgment in for Women's Scotland.
- 9:23The court unanimously held that the terms man, woman and sex in
- 9:28the Equality Act 2010 refer to biological sex.
- 9:32The Equality and Human Rights Commission later summarized the
- 9:35ruling by saying that for Equality Act purposes, legal sex
- 9:39is the sex recorded at birth and that obtaining a gender
- 9:42recognition certificate does not change legal sex for Equality
- 9:46Act purposes. That leaves the Greens in a
- 9:49difficult place. They are politically committed
- 9:52to a trans inclusive position that many activists consider non
- 9:56negotiable. But the legal landscape now
- 9:59gives greater weight to biological Sex Inequality Act
- 10:02interpretation that creates tension over single sex spaces,
- 10:07women's rights, sports, prisons, safeguarding language and
- 10:12internal party discipline. There have also been public,
- 10:15legal and internal disputes involving gender critical
- 10:19Greens, who argue that the party has become hostile to women who
- 10:22believe sex is immutable. Supporters argue the party is
- 10:27defending trans members from exclusion and harassment.
- 10:30Critics argue it is punishing dissent on a question now
- 10:34directly affected by law. Either way, this is no longer an
- 10:39obscure internal dispute. It is a national credibility
- 10:45test. The Piers Morgan interview
- 10:47exposed the Green Party's weakest cultural flank.
- 10:51The gender issue became much harder for Polanski to dodge
- 10:55after his appearance on Piers Morgan Uncensored, Morgan asked
- 10:59the blunt question that now defines this debate in British
- 11:01politics. Can a woman have a penis?
- 11:04Polanski answered yes. Reports of the exchange say
- 11:09Polanski framed the answer around transition, saying that
- 11:12if a woman is transitioning then she can have a penis.
- 11:16And Morgan pushed back strongly. To Polanski supporters, this was
- 11:20brave trans allyship. To critics, it was exactly the
- 11:24kind of answer that makes the Green Party look detached from
- 11:27ordinary voters instincts about sex, women's rights and
- 11:30biological reality. Morgan's line of questioning was
- 11:34direct, uncomfortable and designed to strip away activist
- 11:38language. That was the point.
- 11:40He kept dragging the answer back to plain English, while Polanski
- 11:44tried to widen the discussion into NHS waiting lists,
- 11:47inequality, women's rights more broadly and what he called
- 11:51nuance and complexity. But politically, Morgan probably
- 11:56landed the sharper blow. Polanski accused Morgan of
- 11:59laughing at it and asked why he was punching down.
- 12:02While Morgan pressed the point that Polanski had said women
- 12:05could have penises, a sympathetic LGBT outlet praised
- 12:09Polanski's response. But even that coverage shows the
- 12:12basic political problem. The clip was not built around a
- 12:15detailed policy discussion. It was built around 1 brutal,
- 12:19memorable question. The exchange matters because
- 12:22Morgan did what hostile interviewers often do well.
- 12:26He forced a politician to choose between activist approval and
- 12:29mass voter clarity. Polanski chose the activist
- 12:32position that may strengthen him with young progressives, Green
- 12:37members and trans rights campaigners.
- 12:40But it also hands opponents a simple attack.
- 12:43If the Green Party cannot give a common sense answer on what a
- 12:46woman is, why should voters trust it On schools,
- 12:50safeguarding prisons, sports, health policy or public
- 12:54services? The Greens can argue that this
- 12:57is a manufactured culture war trap.
- 13:00Morgan's critics will say he was baiting Polanski, reducing a
- 13:04sensitive issue to a slogan and using trans people as a
- 13:08political weapon. But that does not erase the
- 13:10electoral reality. Many voters here a woman can
- 13:14have a penis and immediately conclude the party is operating
- 13:17from a world view they do not share.
- 13:19That is why the interview was so revealing.
- 13:23Piers Morgan did not need to win a full philosophical debate.
- 13:28He only needed to make the Green leader sound like he was
- 13:31speaking a language ordinary voters would not recognize.
- 13:34For a party trying to break out of its activist comfort zone,
- 13:38that is a serious problem. Zach Polanski's own
- 13:42controversies Polanski is the reason the Greens feel louder,
- 13:46faster and more dangerous to Labor.
- 13:49He is also a vulnerability. The most embarrassing
- 13:53controversy concerns his former work as a hypnotherapist.
- 13:57In 2013, before entering frontline politics, Polanski was
- 14:02involved in an article about hypnosis and breast enlargement.
- 14:06He later apologized and said the episode was misrepresented.
- 14:10But the controversy resurfaced in 2026 after an old broadcast
- 14:14interview appeared to show him defending the idea more strongly
- 14:18than his later account suggested.
- 14:20Reporting said he had referred to the episode as a successful
- 14:24project and mentioned anecdotal evidence of breast growth.
- 14:28For voters already inclined to like him, this may look like old
- 14:32nonsense from a pre politics career.
- 14:35For skeptics, it raises A sharper question.
- 14:39Judgment. Then there is anti-Semitism and
- 14:43Gaza. Polanski is Jewish and has
- 14:47spoken strongly against conflating criticism of Israel
- 14:50with anti-Semitism. He has called for consideration,
- 14:54care and nuance and how anti-Semitism is discussed.
- 14:59But the Green Party has faced scrutiny over candidate comments
- 15:03and internal handling of anti-Semitism concerns,
- 15:06particularly around Gaza and Israel.
- 15:09In April 2026, Polanski also faced criticism after reposting
- 15:14a comment suggesting police had used excessive force while
- 15:17arresting A suspect after the Golders Green stabbing incident,
- 15:21which was widely recognized as anti-Semitic.
- 15:24That matters because it exposes A wider problem for the Greens.
- 15:28Activist instincts can collide with national leadership
- 15:31expectations. A protest movement can react
- 15:35quickly. A governing party has to react
- 15:39carefully. What most people miss about the
- 15:42Green surge The Green Party is not rising because Britain has
- 15:47suddenly become a nation of committed environmentalists.
- 15:51It is rising because the old political map is breaking.
- 15:54Labour is losing some voters who think it has become too
- 15:57cautious, too establishment, too pro management, too weak on
- 16:01Gaza, too nervous on climate and too willing to echo right wing
- 16:05language on migration. The Conservatives are still
- 16:09damaged. The Liberal Democrats remain
- 16:11strong in some local and tactical contexts but do not
- 16:15carry the same. Insurgent energy reform has
- 16:19become the dominant protest force on the right.
- 16:22That leaves the Greens as the most obvious protest force on
- 16:26the left. Their rise is therefore not just
- 16:30ideological, it is structural. They are benefiting from a
- 16:35moment when millions of voters no longer feel emotionally loyal
- 16:40to the 2 main parties. But the same forces that make
- 16:43the Greens exciting to supporters make them alarming to
- 16:46critics. Their migration stance is highly
- 16:50liberal. Their gender position is
- 16:52hardline trans inclusive. Their economic agenda leans
- 16:56heavily into wealth taxes, rent politics and anti corporate
- 17:01messaging. Their foreign policy language,
- 17:03particularly around Gaza, energizes some voters while
- 17:07alienating others. Their leader is charismatic,
- 17:11online, combative, and controversial.
- 17:15That combination can surge quickly.
- 17:18It can also hit a ceiling quickly.
- 17:21The Green Party's real test. The Greens are now entering the
- 17:26hardest phase of political growth, The moment when people
- 17:29stop treating you as a protest and start asking what would
- 17:32happen if you had power. That is where the scrutiny
- 17:36changes. It is easy to promise moral
- 17:39clarity from the outside. It is harder to explain
- 17:43trade-offs. It is easy to attack Labour for
- 17:47caution. It is harder to show how
- 17:49spending, migration, energy security, taxation, defense,
- 17:54housing and public services would work together in
- 17:57government. The Green Party's rise is real.
- 18:01Its demographic base is clear. Its appeal to younger,
- 18:06progressive, educated and Labor disillusioned voters is obvious.
- 18:10But the controversies are not side issues.
- 18:15They go directly to the question of whether the Greens are a
- 18:17broad electoral movement or an activist party temporarily
- 18:21riding a wave of anti Labor frustration.
- 18:24The answer may decide whether this is a breakthrough or just
- 18:27another protest surge that looks bigger than it was.