Latest / Newcomer Pod / We Saw This Movie. Everybody Died at the End (w/Rick Heitzmann)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome everybody. We're here with dead cat.
- 0:15Is there newcomer? I'm here with Tom and Katie and
- 0:18we've got Rick. Heintzman who is a Firstmark
- 0:21Capital? We were talking about the
- 0:22markets. I was like oh can you just come
- 0:24on the podcast? Actually, just tell everybody
- 0:26this because I feel like yeah you know I tried.
- 0:30Try to for the newsletter, you know, accumulate bunch of views
- 0:34from Smart, Venture, capitalists about what you know the public
- 0:39markets mean, for the private markets because they're not
- 0:42always sort of 121. And Rick is one of my go-to son
- 0:46sort of translating. I think, you know, talks to
- 0:49smart people in the problem Marcus.
- 0:50Anyway, Rick thanks, thanks for being here.
- 0:53Hey, thanks for having me on. This is awesome long, time
- 0:55listener. So excited to be part of it.
- 0:57And it's excited to be on be on the record for Yeah, I mean,
- 1:01what is your eye level take away?
- 1:02Or, I mean, do you think this is?
- 1:04I mean, this is the hardest prediction to make.
- 1:05But I mean, you think this will stick.
- 1:08I mean, I think a lot of people we saw, you know, March 2020,
- 1:12where it seemed like that, that was the end of the world.
- 1:14And then everything rebound saw, somebody tweeting out that bill
- 1:17girly has correctly predicted five of the last two recessions.
- 1:21So there's certainly no shame in saying the word entering a bad
- 1:25period. But what's your?
- 1:26What's your honest take? Yeah, I thought will girly.
- 1:29I Yeah, I can make it like to make predictions about girly but
- 1:33I will make it slightly more difficult operations about the
- 1:36market. I think we've entered into a new
- 1:39normal. I am not going to call the
- 1:41bottom because I think that's hard to do, and there's too many
- 1:45things at work here, but I think we've entered into a new period
- 1:48where capital is not free and it's going to be more and more
- 1:51expensive even as the tenure is kind of popping up over three
- 1:55percent. People are saying oh you know
- 1:57this is, this is Well, then we're still at historic levels,
- 2:02so you're going to see dollars kind of trickle out a macro
- 2:06sense out of risk categories, out of it liquids and into more
- 2:10liquid, you know, fixed income where they've been before, and
- 2:14that's just going to recalibrate the supply and demand for
- 2:16venture capital and therefore make Venture Capital more
- 2:20expensive and more competitive for everyone.
- 2:22Could we maybe back up for a second here?
- 2:24And just maybe set up for listeners like from a macro
- 2:28economic standpoint or are, you know, A financial industry
- 2:31standpoint. What were the parameters and
- 2:33environment that kind of LED towards the last 10, however,
- 2:37many years of venture capital Investments?
- 2:39I mean like, what exactly were we working under that allowed
- 2:42for so much Venture Capital to enter the industry at what you
- 2:45say is cheap money. So, you know, compared to
- 2:48compared to Historic levels. When I was in the 90s when I was
- 2:51in college, they folks said, hey you had to have ten percent in
- 2:55cash, 60% and bonds and 30% inequities all act.
- 3:00He's in a small portion of that, could be a liquid equities and
- 3:03what happened was both would stimulus put kind of in the
- 3:08early 2000s. Post that recession and
- 3:11September 11th and then increasing stimulus and
- 3:14concluded quantitative. Easing post the financial
- 3:17crisis. We were seeing is unprecedented
- 3:20new lows in the and the in the fixed income Market in the
- 3:24high-yield market and what you could get for your risk free
- 3:27rate. So your cost of capital, Capital
- 3:31decreased tremendously. And so if you were an
- 3:34Institutional money manager, if you were a pension fund a
- 3:37foundation, someone like that. You said, well if I'm not
- 3:40getting any yield and fixed income, what could I go and put
- 3:45money in to get yield and as, you know, as more of that money
- 3:49kind of trickled out of fixed income and trickled into
- 3:53equities, you know, some portion of that trickled into venture
- 3:56capital and what we saw was interest rates Need to fall and
- 4:01there was kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy where
- 4:04culminated in the early days of the pandemic, I think April or
- 4:09May of 2020 where interest rates were effectively zero here and -
- 4:14in large parts of the world as correctly.
- 4:17The FED said, hey we need to stimulate this and we need to
- 4:20figure out what's going to happen on the other side of this
- 4:22pandemic. We want to make sure the economy
- 4:24doesn't crumble as well as everything else going on.
- 4:28So money effectively became free.
- 4:29A or even negative yielding and therefore people wanted to put
- 4:35money in whatever was happening and there is no discount for
- 4:38companies that weren't making a profit, but making a profit
- 4:41later and therefore, tremendous dollars, transferred into risky,
- 4:46but a liquid venture capital and the startup ecosystem on the
- 4:50whole dollars from where, by the way.
- 4:52I mean, where did you see kind of a new class of investors
- 4:55during that period starts a enter, enter the, you know,
- 4:58investment or LP or Whatever stage Market you're shaking from
- 5:01everywhere. So you know, there are there
- 5:03were firms that were allocating more dollars into venture
- 5:06capital or private Equity as a liquid.
- 5:09People call it Alternatives, liquids vcp was showing better
- 5:14returns, right? Because you're seeing that same
- 5:16supply-demand, Dynamic happening among the lp class and you are
- 5:19seeing worse returns among fixed income.
- 5:22So with that gradual transition and that's a self-fulfilling
- 5:26prophecy, right? The more money you put into a
- 5:28small asset Class the more that asset class is going to grow in
- 5:32the more it'll create yields. Therefore, as interest, rates
- 5:35are falling on the fixed income side and returns are growing on
- 5:38the Venture Capital private Equity side.
- 5:40It increases that that transition or increases the
- 5:43velocity of that transition, right?
- 5:46Saddam this down, even more. I means interest rates, were
- 5:49low, people, loved risky companies.
- 5:52With what produces the best risky.
- 5:54High-growth companies Venture Capital people flooded in to the
- 5:58private markets. And then the riskiest companies,
- 6:02raising a lot of money. So then the good companies, you
- 6:06know, sort of software businesses with high margins,
- 6:09were trading at extreme multiples earlier and earlier,
- 6:12because relative to sort of cash burning businesses, there was so
- 6:16much appetite to get in them that they drove valuations foot
- 6:21way up. Well put yeah, yeah.
- 6:24Money has if there's no risk associated with capital and no,
- 6:26yield required, people are just going to dump more and more.
- 6:29R capital in and that could be startups or that could be crypto
- 6:32or that could be an f and that's kind of how we saw during you
- 6:35know the spring and summer of 2020.
- 6:38Really up through most of last year.
- 6:41These companies, raising these bunkers around especially like
- 6:43fintech companies at insanely High multiples.
- 6:47I mean I was covering media during the time.
- 6:48So I was seeing this incredible rebound from, you know,
- 6:52initially everyone fearing that there was going to be no money
- 6:55in advertising to an abundance of advertising and companies
- 6:58kind of Really looking like they were doing really great.
- 7:01I mean it was this kind of 18-month Euphoria of what your
- 7:05what we're talking about here, right?
- 7:06Well, there's flooding in the system, the Fed was flooding the
- 7:09system with money and therefore they were more consumer
- 7:12companies being funded who wanted to spend that money on
- 7:14Advertising. Traditional companies were more
- 7:17than happy to spend money on Advertising because their
- 7:19threshold to return on their investment on Advertising was
- 7:22much lower. So every, you know, every part
- 7:25of the economy dollars were slashing around and therefore
- 7:29or, you know, everything was good.
- 7:31Okay. Let's and just for context for
- 7:34people. The NASDAQ Composite is down
- 7:3624%, right now? Year-to-date, yep.
- 7:40And then, as of today, it's down like two percent.
- 7:43So that I mean and yesterday I'm talking about Thursday, it was
- 7:48down in that terrified. Everybody was down about five
- 7:50percent. So that's that's that's what's
- 7:53got us scared. And and just to highlight one
- 7:55thing, I mean, it is amazing. You know, if you're not in the
- 7:58finance World, it Wasn't the pandemic.
- 8:01The terrified the stock market. It was the FED moving to raise
- 8:05interest rates. So it that is why this
- 8:06conversation Roots around interest rates so much that,
- 8:09that contrast pandemic. Nope, markets are fine, interest
- 8:13rates, that drives company, prices and everything and that's
- 8:17that's why we're sort of reacting at this moment.
- 8:20I mean let's split into like with our private Market Focus
- 8:23here and what this means for the private Market sort of the bull
- 8:26case and sort of the bear case for you know in a good Situation
- 8:30and a bad situation like to me in this in this, okay, things
- 8:34are going to be okay? The okay Market is there's still
- 8:37a ton of venture capital, there aren't sort of systemic risks,
- 8:41you know. They're, I don't know, what's
- 8:42the bull case. So there's a bull case is and
- 8:45I'm an optimist, right? So I'm always pulling for the
- 8:48bull case I'm always optimistic about what's going to happen.
- 8:51So yeah, and I want this to happen in the worst way.
- 8:54What you're seeing is that the digitization of every single
- 8:58industry were probably In the early Innings now you're seeing
- 9:02disruption happening every industry and whether it's a
- 9:05shift to streaming and media or whether it's a shift to The
- 9:08Internet of Things in railroad cars.
- 9:11So you're seeing a gradual disruption of traditional
- 9:13business practices. And disruption in the most
- 9:15sincere way, I mean, people use Spotify you exactly you're using
- 9:19Netflix, your parents use cable, and you're like, what's wrong
- 9:21with you? Like there is a most people are
- 9:24still using cable TV, there's still plenty of room for things
- 9:27to shift, over to the disruption that most millennials.
- 9:29Has already accepted as as meaningful.
- 9:31Exactly. And people are finding jobs on
- 9:33their on their phone and they're rare, and they're ordering food
- 9:36on their phone and all these things which are not only
- 9:39disruptive, but are more efficient, right?
- 9:41Your there's less, there's less aspects of the activity chain
- 9:45and traditional toll takers who were resellers or losing value,
- 9:50right? So you have to pay your cable
- 9:52company who then turn around and pay ESPN for you to EXs ESPN.
- 9:56Now you can just go on your phone and subscribe.
- 9:58So a lot of This out of these elements of digitization are
- 10:02creating a much more efficient economy.
- 10:04And so, all that's good. There's High return on
- 10:06investment and your, we still, we think we're in the early
- 10:10Innings of that, and it's coming waves.
- 10:12And I think the availability of free money led to a lot of
- 10:16Entrepreneurship. It's coming democratize is
- 10:18becoming Global and we're seeing great ideas come from
- 10:21everywhere. So from a fundamental, most
- 10:25macro basis digitization and the push for entrepreneurship Is
- 10:29making everything work better than it did before, and that's
- 10:33creating better companies than before.
- 10:35And those companies are also able to use completely new, go
- 10:39to market channels and reach more people more quickly than
- 10:42ever before. So if we started a company and
- 10:44we knew we were looking for chicago-based pizza makers, we
- 10:50go on Facebook or Google and advertise immediately to all
- 10:52those chicago-based pizza makers overnight and you know,
- 10:55therefore business has become better and more efficient.
- 10:58So that that's a Rate Tailwind there.
- 11:01So these companies are getting started, you know, there's also
- 11:04a much more evolved ecosystem in the funding of these companies
- 11:07through their seed, investors incubator seed, investor series
- 11:10a growth, all those things and all each element of that call it
- 11:15Financial activity chain has been well funded over the last
- 11:19period of time, you know. They're even the revolution rise
- 11:22to the rest funds, it will to deal with the large parts of the
- 11:24countries that were Venture Capital deserts individual
- 11:29Industries. Actors have individual Venture
- 11:31Capital firms are well capitalized and every make sure
- 11:34maybe maybe you know we talked here about like d1's the world
- 11:37like tigers, like firms can either redirect to the private
- 11:41Market. I'm sorry from the private
- 11:42markets to the public markets. That's where it's most
- 11:44dangerous, right? Right, that PSI, right.
- 11:46And we're still talking about the Brown case and they still
- 11:48have tons of if you're Henry or if you're it's hard not to talk
- 11:52about the the barricade. Yeah.
- 11:54So, so we're still saying These Guys, these guys have a ton of
- 11:58money and you know time Doing more at the series and series
- 12:01pay level. So you know, you're seeing more
- 12:04dollars and more parts of the ecosystem than you've ever seen
- 12:07before seed and a are still, I would call them frothy, you're
- 12:10still right? I mean, would you say that?
- 12:12I think we just begun to see valuation expectations reset.
- 12:17So usually it flows back through the system, right?
- 12:20Because the feedback loop is longer the further you are.
- 12:23If you're if you're trading a liquid stock you get feedback
- 12:26every second of whether that was a good trade, if you're doing a
- 12:29seed it Takes you years to get feedback and therefore this
- 12:32adjustment takes longer to get feedback into your cycle and
- 12:36decision-making. So we're seeing the reset on
- 12:39pricing happen at the sea at the series a now and it'll probably
- 12:42happen in the season series over the next quarter.
- 12:45But you know overall the ecosystem from a very macro
- 12:48perspective is great companies are creating value there.
- 12:52You know, these companies are also more profitable sooner than
- 12:55ever before, as there's a bunch of tools become Capital
- 12:58efficient and it's a Old funded activity chain to get companies
- 13:02from idea to the public markets in a relatively efficient way,
- 13:06that's the bull case. So you're going to the bear
- 13:08case, there's more companies than ever before and there's
- 13:13going to be a lot less Capital. So there you know as Eric said
- 13:17in the in the growth stage in the later stage companies,
- 13:20there's probably you know eighty to ninety percent down from last
- 13:25year, certain players have left the market completely that were
- 13:28top 10 players. In the private markets.
- 13:30Last year, other players are down significantly.
- 13:33This is the third longest time without a tech IPO this Century.
- 13:38I didn't know that after after, after the early aughts, and
- 13:41after the global financial crisis and the big IPOs
- 13:43coinbase, Robin Hood of 2021 are looking terrible.
- 13:47So yeah, it are looking to and there's, yeah, there's a
- 13:50hangover. So the people who bought the
- 13:52IPOs last year, which also because their crossover funds
- 13:55tended invested heavily in the privates last year or so.
- 14:00Wow, the things I took out last year, I wasn't as smart as I
- 14:03thought these things are down 70% on average and the things I
- 14:07invested in last year thinking they were going public this
- 14:10year. I'm either getting liquidity,
- 14:12nor evaluation pop. I'm going to take a second and
- 14:15figure out where this Market really is.
- 14:18So I'm just going to sit, I'm going to sit and wait because it
- 14:20doesn't feel like I'm missing out on anything.
- 14:22As you know, I was everybody else is sitting on the market.
- 14:26I can invest in anything I want including these these IP Rosa
- 14:29last year that are on set. So they're so the late stage
- 14:33Market is completely pause with very few deals getting done so
- 14:37just to make that specific, if I'm a big investor and I'm
- 14:41looking at Snowflake and data. Bricks snowflake is liquid, I
- 14:45can exit it. It's been marked down data
- 14:47bricks is, you know, presumably still valued at whatever it was
- 14:51in August, you know, of last year.
- 14:54And so, are you really going to do a big growth around now
- 14:57obviously fundamentals? You know, how the companies
- 14:59actually I mean matters. So there will be cases, where
- 15:03people still invest in the private company, but you have to
- 15:05overcome sort of a huge, you know, that this the fact that
- 15:10you've really been marked down without that ever getting any
- 15:13new shade, a flip. I mean for the first time in my
- 15:16career, you know, going back to 20, 25 years last year, there
- 15:20was a private company, premium, meaning that people were willing
- 15:23to pay a premium multiple to get into private companies.
- 15:27Or historically, there was always a private company disk.
- 15:29Count for, as you said, Eric liquidity, right?
- 15:32So you know, you're able to if you buy Snowflake today and then
- 15:35side tomorrow you don't want to be in data infrastructure.
- 15:38Software companies you could sell it if you bought data
- 15:41bricks, if you let around at data bricks today you know
- 15:43you're in that for a couple of years until they go public and
- 15:47even after they go public because there's a lock-up and
- 15:49everything else and with so much uncertainty everything from a
- 15:53shooting War to a resurgent pandemic to political
- 15:57Crosswinds. You know do you really want to
- 15:59I'm going to lock up my capital for a year or two and most
- 16:03people are saying no for all Dimitri's to me the big question
- 16:07on the bear case and this sort of moving into Tom's World Nara,
- 16:10is whether there will be a company that really, like blows
- 16:13up or like particularly even if they don't blow up, if there
- 16:16will be our expectations for what a company, like, Uber or
- 16:22instacart. You know, we saw lift drop by a
- 16:25third right after earnings this. So so Caldo de, oh, go online to
- 16:30offline market, we've never the market.
- 16:32They those companies have existed fully in this sort of
- 16:36bullish period and we really have no understanding of what
- 16:39the true pricing of this industry and seemingly
- 16:42overnight. I think that was what those kind
- 16:44of incredible about it is, you know, walk?
- 16:46Yes. Yeah, it was the fourth quarter
- 16:49of last year overnight, everything changed and you saw
- 16:53it as part of the budgeting process last year and, you know,
- 16:56entrepreneurs were whipsawed, you know, you said 30 days ago,
- 16:59Most three, three, most important things were growth
- 17:02growth and growth. Now, you're saying the three
- 17:04most important things, our profitability unit, economics
- 17:08and long-term sustainable business model.
- 17:11And if I'm trying to create a budget, oftentimes, there's are
- 17:14going in different directions. And therefore, I might need a
- 17:17new team, a new thought process, everything and, you know, it's
- 17:21easy for an investor, like me to sit there and just cross things
- 17:24off on a piece of paper and rewrite my top three goals, but
- 17:28to operationally Change. That is awful, right?
- 17:31I mean, it's almost like that. Cartoonish depiction of Wall
- 17:33Street Traders, we're like in one sense.
- 17:35You see them all saying like bye?
- 17:36Bye. Bye.
- 17:37And they're running around with the papers and then like, you
- 17:39know, the color changes on the monitor there, like, sal sal sal
- 17:42and they don't really understand, you know, fully what
- 17:44happened to them. I mean, was it was fascinating.
- 17:47I covered the earnings for Uber Lyft and doordash in the last
- 17:51week and it was very interesting seeing the media, the way that
- 17:55the media tried to explain what had happened because you They
- 17:59would say, oh, lift higher earnings report, you know, Bob
- 18:03shall embarrassment as it in is just like, no, it was actually
- 18:06pretty good. They like beat their numbers.
- 18:08You know, the thing that really killed them is the fact that
- 18:10they're going to be investing more in and Driver growth, which
- 18:14like, soon to be great news last year when they were doing it.
- 18:17And then hilariously Uber decides to move up their
- 18:20earnings. Pre-market to kind of circumvent
- 18:23what they assume, you know, was a very specific lifts disease
- 18:26because they're like, well, they're they're bad, we have
- 18:28great earnings and I think that's like the first time since
- 18:31the financial crisis rise as klieman brothers.
- 18:34Right? That did the banks.
- 18:35Yeah, move us. Exactly after Lehman, Bryce's
- 18:38Lehman Brothers collapse, every bank had to rush to the street
- 18:41to tell him, right? I'm not dead.
- 18:43Yeah, I had people from Uber. I can include those people from
- 18:46over, like, kind of spitting to me being, like, Pool Lift,
- 18:48really missed the memo on how to run a profitable company.
- 18:51Yeah, and, you know, that clearly was like and then they
- 18:54decided to move up their earnings.
- 18:55Uber does their things dropped seven or eight per sec?
- 18:58She drops 10%, Immediately upon Market open and then doordash,
- 19:03which actually has a very strong quarter.
- 19:05I thought a lot of their fundamentals with great.
- 19:07They have you no good growth. They have better Ibiza than
- 19:10ubereats even their down like sixteen percent right now and
- 19:15it's I think it must just be maddening inside these companies
- 19:18as they kind of optimized for a very specific style of
- 19:22projection and and signaling to the street to suddenly be told
- 19:26everything. What you've done everything that
- 19:28you've done is wrong. Yes, an Operationalize that
- 19:30probably takes a year of rethinking about that and
- 19:33they're hitting the expectations.
- 19:35They set out but someone moved the goalposts.
- 19:37When you say that, somebody moved the goalpost, like how
- 19:40much of a recognition is there that the goal post is being
- 19:43moved outside of the valley and outside of the industry by
- 19:45things like the Federal Reserve? And how much recognition is
- 19:47there? That the reason those metrics
- 19:49could have been important and the people could have focused on
- 19:52those things is because the market was willing to both take
- 19:54the risk and pay for them. And when I say the market, I
- 19:56mean the broader Market is influenced by fixed.
- 19:59Come commercial, real estate. I mean, so when we keep saying,
- 20:02somebody move the goalposts, actually not like an unknown,
- 20:05somebody it was. So it's probably Public Market
- 20:07investors, right? And that's the, that's the key
- 20:10linchpin that they said, you know?
- 20:12Hey, I'm unwilling, we in a rising rate environment.
- 20:15I'm unwilling to fund losses in the long term.
- 20:19So I need to see some definitive point where you're going to be
- 20:22profitable and I need to see what this business looks like in
- 20:25a run rate and companies who didn't respond to that got
- 20:29crushed. Rushed and then, you know, then
- 20:31private crossover investors or growth investors said, hey look,
- 20:35they're crushing people who aren't Pro focus on
- 20:37profitability. We're never going to be able to
- 20:39get our company public. Unless we're profitable, then
- 20:42they go back to the board and say, hey, rest of the board.
- 20:45Did you see these companies got crushed?
- 20:47They're focused on growth. And we're support, says yes, we
- 20:50have profits and we want to see us, and that's the same guy who
- 20:53said growth. What do you want from me?
- 20:55I'm 60 days ago. Yes, maybe just made from the
- 20:59outside. It I mean, like I said, I'm not
- 21:01in over the industry or just outside of the industry.
- 21:03It actually looked pretty logical to me.
- 21:06I mean, when you look at all these other points, Eric had
- 21:07this great newsletter looking all the times when people said
- 21:11the bear markets going to happen.
- 21:13And the one thing that wasn't really happening in those other
- 21:16supposed inflection points is the rate, environment was not
- 21:19changing. And so, I think it was basically
- 21:21almost in tandem with this stock Slaughter, you saw the Federal
- 21:25Reserve come out and say not just that they're raising rates
- 21:27but they were immediately. Lee starting to not raise rates,
- 21:31but to take some of the other measures off the table, that
- 21:34weren't rate. Raises that had artificially had
- 21:37the impact of keeping us most of the era that I've learned
- 21:41business in that, I don't even know what the opposite of
- 21:43quantitative easing is called. It's like so many things were so
- 21:50many things it, because so many things were implemented post
- 21:53financial crisis. And then post pandemic and post,
- 21:56post post whatever you want. It wasn't just great.
- 21:59Going up and down, right? It was buying back your own
- 22:02paper. It was you know, it was all
- 22:03these sorts of Market manipulation it's like people
- 22:05like Eric go into Rick, be like explain to me the time of
- 22:08tightening. Well, you've never seen before
- 22:16we haven't seen this since to since when 2010 - tightening.
- 22:22I don't think we've ever seen because I think that there was
- 22:24quantitative each other. Yes, that's created during
- 22:28crunchy, beings was crazy are in the Financial crisis.
- 22:30Absolutely. The help of the banks and they
- 22:32said what main problem is, like a lot of things.
- 22:34Some is good, more is better. That thing we used in the
- 22:36financial crisis, we could use that again, the pandemic.
- 22:39And if we use some of that before, let's just lather that
- 22:41on everywhere. And now, they like, at some
- 22:43point, we have to reverse that and they still really hadn't
- 22:47reversed what they did in the financial crisis.
- 22:49And now they have to reverse all that, but even a 50 basis, point
- 22:54change in in the Fed rate, hadn't happened in 20 years.
- 22:58Absolutely. 2000. So they're doing a lot of stuff.
- 23:02Yeah, it was when people were like well rates, haven't moved
- 23:04yet. So why is this downturn
- 23:06happening? It's like, what wasn't just the
- 23:07rates again to your point. All the things create around
- 23:10quantity, using those things were being quietly, dismantled
- 23:12and expectations drive, so much of it.
- 23:15Also, obviously you have the effect for everything has been
- 23:18implemented, but so look, very perfectly logical to me from the
- 23:21outside. I was like, yeah, of course.
- 23:22And we don't know the floor of this, but I mean, obviously, you
- 23:26know, fed policy keeps a lot of people employed, they focus on
- 23:29Unemployment, we got to enjoy sort of this booming economy and
- 23:34I mean there is some culpability for investors where it's, you
- 23:37know, you know, it's not like no one everyone in the world thinks
- 23:42that YouTuber is a money-losing business, you know, there we've
- 23:45gone, there are lots of, you know, it wasn't a secret and
- 23:48that both these companies lost a lot of money.
- 23:50And that there would be come a pivot point where people sort of
- 23:54reoriented, their thinking and sort of short-termism and Hedge
- 23:59funds, get paid once a year. There are lots of reasons and
- 24:03incentives that drive people to chase, you know, growth that
- 24:06will come to an end. Well though it's the old thing
- 24:08that your turkeys go further and further out on the risk curve
- 24:11before they get slaughtered. So people knew that eventually
- 24:14we're going to have to build a profitable company or if it's
- 24:17self-sustaining financial company and then you kept
- 24:20getting rewarded for not I like the turkeys.
- 24:23I also like swimming without shorts.
- 24:25I think we should put together a full list of all of the
- 24:27analogies made. For people who take Too much
- 24:29risk. Yeah, that was, that was the
- 24:37Warren Buffett. When the tide goes out naked.
- 24:45Yes, yes. Yes.
- 24:46We can write the three questions that the Precast analogy is
- 24:54driving the situation. I mean, in my piece, which I'll
- 24:58include a link to In the post with this.
- 25:01I mean, I had to charge from Red point where they showed and a
- 25:05private investment dollars after 2008 and private investment
- 25:10after the.com crash. And the point is, basically at
- 25:13this is 08, you know, there was resilience and.com, you know,
- 25:17investment, really, really dropped Katie.
- 25:20You were sort of making the point that a key.
- 25:23Key question. There is the interest rate
- 25:25environment. Yeah, and I like a nerd.
- 25:27I was like, Eric, I really wish they'd overlay Did you know him
- 25:30here? I made a note to myself, look
- 25:40this up before the cast, but then instead, I got on the
- 25:42phone, with all these people, for, for the other things I do.
- 25:47But in May 2000 fed raised rates 50 basis points the last time
- 25:51before, before this week, and so not only were was the tech
- 25:56Market crashing, but people had a safe.
- 25:58We had another Halfway up somewhere to go differently than
- 26:02maybe the pandemic where they drop rates tremendously and
- 26:06folks like well I'm not going to go there they're not going to
- 26:08give me any yield I might as well stay here and see what
- 26:11happens in growth right? And obviously the complicating
- 26:14thing for Tech in the pandemic is also everyone moves to zoom
- 26:17sort of the technology industry. Sees companies, he Revenue skip
- 26:21ahead because people are adopting stuff faster.
- 26:23Now we're coming out of the pandemic and we're seeing sort
- 26:26of the opposite where tech people wanted To believe things
- 26:30would be stickier than they are. And in some cases, you know,
- 26:32we're seeing companies like hoppin where there are questions
- 26:35about whether sort of the tremendous growth is really
- 26:38sustainable. So there there are.
- 26:39There are there are other obviously any time you try and
- 26:42tell a big story about the overall economy.
- 26:45There are lots of pieces of play play at once.
- 26:49Can I ask a somewhat hypothetical question?
- 26:51Sure. Because you mentioned 2000 and
- 26:54the basis of my move then and we saw a couple of things.
- 26:58Obviously, a market crash. And a big fraud, right?
- 27:00And Ron Worldcom fast-forward, 2007, the feds like okay, this
- 27:05housing markets, very overheated.
- 27:07We have rates move, we have a big crisis, the momentum stocks
- 27:10were weirdly banks at the time, but we see them get crushed big
- 27:14fraud. Bernie Madoff.
- 27:15Here we are in 2022. Rates are moving up, momentum.
- 27:18Stocks are down. What's going to be the big
- 27:20fraud? It seems like a Tom question to
- 27:23you. Like who's our next Enron or
- 27:33Bernie Madoff laughs? Like, that's the good stuff.
- 27:36I mean we saw the Archer goes thing, right?
- 27:38I mean there are only like, I don't know, like a slam dunk,
- 27:42but it's definitely the canary in the coal mine.
- 27:43I do think that Eric has a point there that I think that a lot of
- 27:46people who are using margin loans are might be the might be,
- 27:50they might not be committing fraud.
- 27:51They might not be a maid off. They went up being Enron but
- 27:53they might be using a lot more leverage than they let on and
- 27:57that could be a hedge fund. It could be a private Be fun.
- 28:00It could be a growth fund. It could be an individual that I
- 28:03think you're going to see things blow up because interest rates
- 28:06are going up and their collateral base is going down.
- 28:10And there's going to be folks who could not have modeled out
- 28:14that their collateral base is down 70%.
- 28:16And there's going to be margin calls and I think that's going
- 28:19to be the, the overuse of Leverage when people thought
- 28:23money was free and therefore, they could juice their returns
- 28:27is going to. I would say, is an obvious Isis
- 28:30or sing the things I've heard you know, could be one of the
- 28:33one of these great disasters. I mean, and there's always the
- 28:35cynical argument that Things become crimes.
- 28:38When they go really poorly, the government is unhappy when
- 28:41sophisticated people don't make things work.
- 28:44But I mean, yeah. Without talking about crime at
- 28:46all, I mean, you can just see sort of the interconnectedness,
- 28:50you know, I mean, we had SoftBank, oh, huge softbank's a
- 28:54big investor in Uber dd-do, you know, Uber is a stakeholder and
- 28:58Didi, you know? A lot of internet connectedness
- 29:00in the big risky bets. Then we see tiger Global
- 29:04takeover, invest deeply in Internet.
- 29:06So, they're just these players who are willing to deploy a ton
- 29:10of money. They were taking correlated
- 29:13risk. So if the correlations go, the
- 29:15other way, they're going to have sort of a big negative impact
- 29:18that doesn't mean they're doing anything.
- 29:20I mean that to me, I mean maybe that will change what's amazing
- 29:23about this time. Is it feels like it was?
- 29:25It's so obvious. There was no secret.
- 29:27There was no like hidden. Nothing.
- 29:29Like we work, which I mean we work was the case of sort of the
- 29:32market can sustain it. The sort of collapse isn't
- 29:35bringing the system down but to some degree you know we yeah we
- 29:40saw it and people were just willing to take a risk because
- 29:44what else what else were they going to do?
- 29:45I don't know, in correlated concentration risk was that's
- 29:49that was kind of having a caught at mispronouncing but our chain
- 29:53has or kano's and it was they they were in 10 media companies
- 29:57that they were highly. Highly correlated and they used
- 30:01additional leverage and crowded people out and what might be an
- 30:04illegal way. But, you know, if you're
- 30:06SoftBank and you're using leverage and your have highly
- 30:09concentrated, highly correlated positions.
- 30:11If this thing on whines, you know what happens?
- 30:14It's interesting to me. Also the Foreclosure of the IPO
- 30:18and the effect that that's going to happen.
- 30:20A lot of these companies to write because you know we saw
- 30:23the whole spak craze from a couple of years ago being the
- 30:26quick way for a lot of these companies to go public and
- 30:28honestly. It probably good that this back
- 30:31window, is entirely closed. Now during this period because
- 30:34things could have been truly disastrous if you had a lot of
- 30:37companies sort of immediately going public and you know
- 30:41getting crushed by the new expectations of what a company
- 30:44is. But I'm also interested in a lot
- 30:46of these Venture debt rounds, that companies have been doing
- 30:49these sort of like bridge to IPO rounds.
- 30:51Like we saw go puff do one earlier this year.
- 30:54Vice has this kind of onerous is a slightly different situation
- 30:58but there's a very His relationship with tpg where they
- 31:02you know gave them what's akin to like some sort of a
- 31:04convertible debt. Round no vices in a really tough
- 31:07spot right now. I'm, you know, I think a company
- 31:10that sort of relied on that with the expectation that like, well,
- 31:13it's not going to be a big deal because we can go public.
- 31:15And, you know, these shares will convert.
- 31:17They don't, it could get ugly very quickly.
- 31:19Don't you think that even historically Square, which is
- 31:22now block had. That is one of its reasons to go
- 31:24public. They had structured debt that,
- 31:27you know, picked at a high Interest rates the longer, they
- 31:30wait to go public. And I think you're right that
- 31:32people thought the window to go public after being open for so
- 31:36long would always be 0 and now it's closed.
- 31:39You know, the other thing you're not hitting on, but is a guy
- 31:42tied to this is, you know, the things that make investors
- 31:46invest and put more Capital out is feeling good in driving
- 31:49returns, right? So if you have a company, go
- 31:51public, you think you're smart because you invested early, and
- 31:55therefore your, you want to invest more and that the
- 31:58opposite True. So the lack of liquidity either
- 32:02descend back to your limited partners or the ability to think
- 32:05that you're really good at this and therefore you should do it a
- 32:07lot more that that decreases investor confidence and
- 32:11decreases LP confidence and that slows down the whole machine,
- 32:14right? Keep thinking Katie back to your
- 32:16question. I'm like what the next implosion
- 32:18is going to be and using the analogies to Madoff or, or Enron
- 32:22and Worldcom what connects all of those to me was the fact that
- 32:26everyone who cover the space knew that These companies were
- 32:30not sustainable, right? It was sort of like an Open
- 32:33Secret. I mean maybe made off slightly
- 32:34differently although I feel like it's a little different but I
- 32:36think bear Stearns was probably a better because like taking
- 32:40criminal like you know. Yeah but like people knew that
- 32:44bear was over-leveraged. They knew that LeMans real
- 32:47estate portfolio is over leveraged.
- 32:49You know there was a sense that something was wrong but saying
- 32:53that something's wrong when everything's going up.
- 32:55As we know as reporters is the most thankless task ever because
- 32:58nobody believes you And they make fun of you.
- 33:00Okay? So like my guess is that it's
- 33:02going to be a company or a group of companies that we all sort of
- 33:06knew, were not sustainable that we all could tell as they were
- 33:10raising money and more and more leveraged ways was a possible.
- 33:14You know, like it had a clock ticking next to them, but
- 33:18because things get getting pushed further and further out
- 33:20during quantitative easing and this easy access to Capital, no
- 33:23one really was concerned about it, but when it dies when it
- 33:26implodes, when it becomes, you know, the next whatever.
- 33:29Worldcom it will have been so obvious to all of us.
- 33:32Yeah. And we will be embarrassed that
- 33:34that was not the stories that we've been writing for the last.
- 33:36I mean, if you have a lot of my coverage and when I was trying
- 33:38to show in the piece yesterday, is that these companies got so
- 33:42big people made so much money, they exited like they got away.
- 33:46It's just like, the money has been made and not, I'm just
- 33:49what's my point? Like, I guess in the case, where
- 33:51Uber like, say, Uber is the test case or, you know, I think it's
- 33:56Uber, could be, you know, like a five billion dollar company
- 33:58instead of a You know our company today, that doesn't mean
- 34:00it goes bankrupt or anything, but like if that, if that would
- 34:04be the case, I still, I think they're all be.
- 34:07These people will be like, I knew it, we were always like,
- 34:10like a crock the whole time but it's like what.
- 34:13But you didn't know that people would make a whole Fortune.
- 34:15I mean, how long do companies stay humongous valuable
- 34:19companies, you know, you understand the point I'm making
- 34:22like, well I'm a guest in Bolt and bull markets though.
- 34:25The rules home was always in the last 18 months of Above a
- 34:2910-year bull market. Most of the money is made, so
- 34:33that's why people are always afraid to get off the get off
- 34:36the tread, right? You guys are an investor and
- 34:39Postmates, right? We were so young.
- 34:41Are you happy right now? Three billion sale?
- 34:44It's an interesting. I mean, somebody was making the
- 34:46point on totally different company slack, the slack sales
- 34:50looking great. Now, there are these sales where
- 34:53it's all American. A lot of things last year were
- 34:55software, companies were selling at 50 to 250 times Revenue.
- 34:58You feel Really good about that mean.
- 35:00We Postmates, we sold to Ubers. We got a talk so we were able to
- 35:03ride that up and then pick our exit point.
- 35:06So that was quite nice. But I yeah, I would say that
- 35:09you're right. The company is where you, you
- 35:11know, you talk to people outside of our Echo chamber and they're
- 35:14like, I don't understand how I could get a bar of soap,
- 35:16delivered to me cheaper than going to Walgreens or CVS by a
- 35:20guy who's going to drive here in 15 minutes and then you explain
- 35:24what you do for a living in their life.
- 35:41All over the streets of New York, the Joker's, the Getters
- 35:45that you know, all those things are going to be like, oh, you
- 35:48know, we saw Cosmo, we saw it didn't work and then we just did
- 35:53the same thing with another right?
- 35:54And the 10 billion dollars. Yeah, I mean that's been sort of
- 35:57like the core of every story that The mainstream pubs write
- 36:00about them is like, yes, all of these companies were
- 36:03embarrassments during the early.com era, but this time
- 36:07it's different. Yes.
- 36:08Why we saw, we saw this movie, everybody died at the end.
- 36:12And now, we're gonna, now, we're wondering why in the sequel?
- 36:15No. Beings.
- 36:15We give me a happy ending. This time.
- 36:17Venture Capital firms, have more axis liquidity for longer
- 36:20periods of time. They have a far so that right
- 36:22helpful to the point like, you know, there's people who made
- 36:25money at we work. They rode that up and said,
- 36:27well, you know, I do Management and people made money there and
- 36:32therefore it's fine or people made money and in some of the
- 36:36ride sharing things and then we're going to see how much, how
- 36:39many if you have to pay somebody to go get that bar of soap for
- 36:42you. Someone has to pay for that or
- 36:45you know, it's not going to work, right?
- 36:47And I guess it gets down to the intrinsic value of the service,
- 36:50right? If this truly is something that
- 36:52a broad number, people want to do at an elevated price point,
- 36:55then it's a good thing then I think there actually is some,
- 36:58some larger value to it. It's just purely about it being
- 37:01cheap and the second the price goes up, you are basically not
- 37:05interested in it. Then it wasn't a great service
- 37:06to begin with. It was just free money
- 37:08essentially or a free service. I think that's kind of the
- 37:11perfect storm here to write seeing at a moment.
- 37:14Where the price for the bar of soap has to hit 14 dollars or
- 37:17whatever and the consumers willingness to pay $14 go down
- 37:21at literally the same moment when consumers might have been
- 37:26happy to do it five years ago, like that seeing that At those
- 37:29two Trends come together, I find really fascinating.
- 37:32The funny thing we haven't talked about is crypto which in
- 37:35Venture world has been sort of the the thing that still doing.
- 37:39Well, you know, crypto funds have been raising.
- 37:41There's been a lot of money made Bitcoin is down.
- 37:45I think it's 20 plus percent so far this year, but but yeah,
- 37:50it's funny that I don't know, right.
- 37:52Now, people don't know whether there's a totally different
- 37:55world where we say. Cruel this tends to be the last,
- 37:58the last To go, right? Because the first the tends to
- 38:01be the first ones, first people you tend to evacuate the
- 38:04Tactical things, right? So you're able to say, you know,
- 38:06software is a service. We know how this Stacks up, we
- 38:10know how Revenue grows and therefore I could pencil out a
- 38:13way to this type of exit in that period of time.
- 38:16And if everybody rates, we know what someone's paying for it.
- 38:19The things that are completely asymmetric crypto where you're
- 38:23not, you can't pencil out what you think that crypto is going
- 38:26to be worth or what nft is going to be worth.
- 38:29People are still willing to take a symmetric risks on because no
- 38:32one could pencil out that they're wrong.
- 38:34So you're seeing, you know, people with risk Capital shift
- 38:38to a symmetric risks or things that could still be big because
- 38:43there's a lot of confidence in a space.
- 38:44Do you have a piece of advice or like I guess if maybe, you know,
- 38:49if I'm a sort of tech worker looking up for my next job?
- 38:53I don't know. What, what advice would you give
- 38:55them, right? Yeah, I was gonna say the
- 38:56audience could be Tech, CEO Tech worker.
- 38:59Our young BC, probably all different advice.
- 39:02So, you know, the advice were giving around borders.
- 39:05Now, you know, we had thought that 2020 and then obviously
- 39:092021 who's great times to raise money, wasn't, you know?
- 39:13And I've been investing since the mid-90s, if, you know, if it
- 39:16wasn't 1999, it was pretty close as, you know, an a, if not 8 +
- 39:20time to raise Capital. So we advise people to, you
- 39:23know, to people, react, to three rounds.
- 39:25Some of them. Yeah.
- 39:26Take the money of its Very, very cheap insurance.
- 39:31So you take that money and then we talk about having a fortress
- 39:34balance sheet that can withstand a lot of external turmoil.
- 39:37If you have a fortress balance sheet, and have you been a not
- 39:40necessarily having fortress on your balance sheet, should be
- 39:43terrified, the exact opposite? Yes, you don't want that.
- 39:48The, so you have a fortress balance sheet, you can withstand
- 39:51Market turmoil and you eliminate Financial Risk.
- 39:54And, you know, having been an entrepreneur in the early aughts
- 39:56where there was no financing elimination of financing risk is
- 39:59Thing that I think about a lot. And then being able to say, all
- 40:04right, now you have a fortress balance sheet, how could you
- 40:07make sure your team is great and you increasingly your hearing
- 40:11very quietly? That folks are saying,
- 40:13especially as returned to office is showing up that are the is my
- 40:17team, great. If my team is not great, how do
- 40:20I turn over the folks who aren't great?
- 40:22And then I, how do I go out to people in the market and say,
- 40:25hey I have a fortress Bounty, I have four hundred million
- 40:27dollars in cash. I have A million dollars of
- 40:30Revenue. I don't care.
- 40:31If I can't get public next year, I'm going to get public and I'm
- 40:34going to be one of the great companies that survive this.
- 40:36You should be on my team with the All-Stars and they're
- 40:39starting to do selective kind of rifle.
- 40:42Shot hires of All-Stars from from companies where might have
- 40:47been hard to take them out of because that All-Star might have
- 40:49had a significant Found the courage to read between the
- 40:52lines a little bit. Lot of poaching, a lot of work.
- 40:55Well there, you know on Twitter know what he's going to say like
- 40:57layoffs are good and You know, I don't want to be the person to
- 41:00say that but there is a degree to which when everything's going
- 41:03great, your company wants to be happy, your employees don't want
- 41:06you to fire anybody but then kind of liars and during a
- 41:08pandemic right? And but you know you you need to
- 41:12be able good companies. Don't just keep everybody they
- 41:16ever hired and they make mistakes and people don't work
- 41:18out. And so this is an excuse to sort
- 41:21of say who are the people that we want the company and that can
- 41:24be good, good for companies and bad for.
- 41:28So just what they're seeing. Be who they want to be on
- 41:29companies and then so they're saying, hey, I'm going to build
- 41:32an A Team. I'm gonna call the herd and
- 41:34maybe do a layoff where different maybe in the past.
- 41:37The strong companies are doing a layoff because they feel like
- 41:40that they have a provision position of strength, either be
- 41:43a strong, balance sheet or Market position.
- 41:46And then you know we're saying wait until maybe the second half
- 41:49of the year and then you could be aggressive on the acquisition
- 41:52side because you're going to start to see we're already
- 41:54starting to see a lot of companies have extra cash,
- 41:57right? Because it was so easy to raise.
- 41:58Some Will raise twice last year, but maybe only are now getting
- 42:02the memo of hey unit Economics, work, and they're not going to
- 42:05be able to refactor their business in time to do another
- 42:08raise. We're seeing a lot of duress
- 42:10distress sales already but there's going to be a lot more
- 42:13in the second half of the year. You think sort of superteam
- 42:16startups like merge with each other to try.
- 42:18Or you think it's more when the challenge with Acquisitions has
- 42:22been the antitrust situation and that there are a couple dominant
- 42:25tech companies that can't buy and I'm saying less like know,
- 42:29Less Google, buying something for tens of billions of dollars.
- 42:33This is more. This is you know a Deca corn or
- 42:36you know unicorn type startup who's able to pull in teams or
- 42:39able to pull and product functionality, like, hey, we
- 42:42always like this team but they said they wanted 150 times
- 42:46revenue and now they're willing to take two times rope, right?
- 42:49And because they don't have a whole lot of truth.
- 42:51They're not into independently financeable.
- 42:54And those teams that which, you know, create a fortress balance
- 42:57sheet, build an A-Plus, Audi team and then go out and say,
- 43:01hey, it's going to be two times Revenue.
- 43:02I know that's not what you expected, but you could join
- 43:05this team. We have all the capital we need.
- 43:08We have a great team that you could be a key player on.
- 43:11And when this thing all clears in two years, them IPO Market
- 43:14opens, we're going to be a decided winner.
- 43:17Do you think also there's going to be a shift towards more
- 43:19salary based comp rather than equity-based if we're in a
- 43:23market where it might take a couple of years for you know
- 43:26shares to appreciate in a big way or there to be a strong?
- 43:29Kind of exit opportunity. Oh, that's not what's happened
- 43:31in the past. And frankly, you know, in other
- 43:34downturns you've seen salaries that rear the remain relatively
- 43:38flat but Equity comp, be go down just because, you know, Equity
- 43:43cash comp is gone up a lot. And if you see a renormalization
- 43:47in the, in the labor market, everyone's getting laid off
- 43:50employees have left less bar. Just let her so they're going to
- 43:52get paid less. Yeah, so I think people are
- 43:54going to say, I'm going to keep my same salary bands which are
- 43:56up 30% from two years ago. And you know, people are just
- 44:00going to make less money if they don't believe in the equity
- 44:02portion here. But if you join the super team
- 44:05that's going to go public, you have a better chance of making
- 44:08money as opposed to this company, which seems like you're
- 44:10going to run out of money and so many instacart resetting
- 44:12valuations. You think you'll see startups,
- 44:15just try to artificially reset the valuation.
- 44:18They give to employees. It depends mean that's a very
- 44:21unique situation with a very high price and their whole comp
- 44:24set of, you know, is was down in 7580 percent.
- 44:27So that was It's a very specific.
- 44:30Hey, I'm close to IPO every one of my Common Sense down
- 44:33tremendously. It's going to be really hard to
- 44:36recruit especially with a ton of preference ahead of me.
- 44:39If people are bearish on the sector, we haven't seen, we've
- 44:42seen that in the past that people have reset 49 out.
- 44:45Maybe valuations, especially if the company has raised a lot of
- 44:47money and has a lot of preference ahead of the
- 44:49employees. We haven't seen any investors,
- 44:52don't root for it. Well, no, we generally do
- 44:56because we think the team, you know, if the team Is the most
- 44:59important thing in a start-up and you think you're not going
- 45:02to be able to recruit a great team, or you're going to lose
- 45:04people because they don't think their Equity is going to be
- 45:07worth that much. You know, you'd rather you'd
- 45:10rather keep your best, your best players and you'd rather recruit
- 45:13the best team. So, you know, most good
- 45:15investors were actually route for a loaf or on any
- 45:18presidential publicly. We want the most Fair
- 45:22third-party value for an a price, but as a director, I'm
- 45:25looking for that price to be low.
- 45:27So people get excited about the equity.
- 45:29The opportunity. What would you see?
- 45:31If you could name a couple of companies as winners that out of
- 45:34this period companies that you think are slightly under the
- 45:37radar but because of their capital structure or you know
- 45:41they're having a more sustainable business model could
- 45:44surprise people and end up looking very strong in the next
- 45:47two years. I still think that Healthcare is
- 45:51an industry. It's going to change
- 45:52tremendously and I think, you know, companies that are coming
- 45:55at it and a holistic approach and Going to be winners in the
- 46:00space. That can there's a glaring
- 46:02consolidators in the space are going to be really important.
- 46:04Now, one example is row or Roman Health that, you know, came out
- 46:08of the gate, strong grew very quickly has an excellent team
- 46:12and even in the last year, where there was less consolidation,
- 46:16they bought a handful of companies that failed product
- 46:19needs. As they brought build out their
- 46:20full portfolio both in terms of delivery ecosystems as well as
- 46:25and use your products. And you know I think that's a
- 46:28good kind of case. Study or an example of you have
- 46:31a big balance sheet, you're in a big Market, you've gotten to
- 46:35millions of customers and now you're going to be able to use
- 46:38that balance sheet. Not only defensively, but
- 46:40offensive ly to build a really because that's what the market
- 46:43reopen. How many, right?
- 46:44Yes. Have full disclosure it spoil
- 46:46their, their male fertility company, right?
- 46:50They have male and female, that is proof.
- 46:59Is generally recession-proof we also like we think the reopening
- 47:02is going to be real. We'd like to travel sector are
- 47:05being do as a form or folio company.
- 47:07That put up, great numbers, everything around travel.
- 47:11As consumers ships from people are traditionally 70% of
- 47:16consumer spending is on services and that could be restaurants or
- 47:19travel, or whatever it is. 30% is on hard Goods or home that
- 47:23shifted during the pandemic. And I think there's a lot of
- 47:26pent-up demand for that to shift back.
- 47:28So, so, you know, we believe in, you know, restaurants reopening
- 47:31travel reopening, etc, etc. Nice.
- 47:33I like that, it's sort of like digital, you know, telemedicine,
- 47:36but also travel. So it's like seeing people
- 47:38remotely and also actually going and going to places.
- 47:42Yeah, I think there's going to be a mix.
- 47:43I think some of the IRL is obviously coming back and that's
- 47:45great. And some of the things I think
- 47:48wall still have zoom accounts forever.
- 47:50Rick, thanks so much for coming on.
- 47:51We really appreciate it. Awesome, saying everybody, thank
- 47:54you for having me. Thank you.
- 48:08Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 48:09Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.