Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Honda’s $15B EV Reset, Rivian Bets on R2, Farley Fights for the Clutch
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning, it is Friday, March 13th. Yes, Friday the 13th. This is the Automotive State of the Us- Union. We're not superstitious. We might be a little stitious, but I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mountsier.
- 0:10We're talking about Honda's $15 billion reset, Rivian- And, uh, Jim Farley fighting for a clutch. For a clutch. It's a fight worth fighting. I don't know what we're fighting for anymore. I do. You know? I know.
- 0:23I mean, we're fighting for humans. That's right. We know that. What's more human than a stick shift? That's true. [laughs] You have... I mean, you need a him- human to use a stick shift. Yeah, you- So- You do...
- 0:34bring it back, baby I mean, I guess they could figure that out. [laughs] I mean, I guess.
- 0:36I'm sure they'd be like, it's just, like, moving over there beside you just to give you the feeling of, like, "Hey, I got a manual transmission." But I mean, that's stupid. How's it feel to be back in your office?
- 0:44It's great. You know, I had a great time out looking at the mountains. It was beautiful. I don't think I told you this, but I'm driving away.
- 0:53I was, I was viting- visiting a group called, um, Murdoch Auto Team, uh, out there in, uh, Salt Lake City. And I'm, like, driving, I'm in the Uber on the way back to the hotel, and it hits my brain.
- 1:07I'm a- I'm actually in an Audi e-tron. Oh. And I'm talking to this guy about his EV, and it hits my brain, what the heck? [laughs] I couldn't be more than 10 minutes away from Alex's Lawrence EV auto.
- 1:20[laughs] As you're in an EV. And I, I was right. Did he buy his- I was- Did he buy his e-tron there? No, no. Oh. But he'd been there before to, like, uh, talk to them about a couple things.
- 1:28But I, uh, I was eight minutes away and I was like, "Uber driver, how do I add a stop?" I add a stop, I go in. Alex isn't there. He- I, I, I got a big selfie with his team. Oh, man. Got... Yeah. But look,
- 1:42here's the thing. I went to that j- there was this Genesis store, and then I went in EV auto.
- 1:47And I think I said this yesterday, but if you're n- if you're building anything new and not going out and starting to look at some of the stores that are being built with, like, a retail customer- Experience in mind...
- 1:58with environment in mind. And you can curate it however you want. You got Alex with graffiti and large video screens. You got the zen moment in the, in the Genesis store.
- 2:07You can curate that customer experience, and whether it's up to the OEM or not, you can partner with the OEM to create an experience that's altogether different that people will actually want to come to.
- 2:16Man, I- there you go. Words of wisdom. Words of wisdom. So if you're in the middle of that new build right now or planning it out- Slow down, baby...
- 2:23it might be- slow down, it might be worth taking a little trip to see some stuff, right? Try something different. Literally do your very best to try something different. If- I mean, if there's a Lexus store
- 2:32in Lehigh Valley that has a koi pond and a bridge that you have to walk over- [laughs]... before you get in the showroom- Yeah... you can figure it out too. You can figure it out. You know what I'm saying?
- 2:39Uh, [laughs] thanks to our friends, uh, at iPacket for sponsoring the show this week. Before you drop the price, validate it.
- 2:45iPacket value anchors every vehicle to its true OEM build, looking at options, packages, and everything that lets you customize comparison- comparisons that match the market. How about that?
- 2:56And with your merchandising health, you'll know if the vehicle's been properly presented to the customer before you touch the price. Less panic pricing, more intentional moves.
- 3:04And that's how you protect gross and momentum. Learn about more at iPacket.us. iPacket.us. Fantastic. Oh, we have a congrat- I like protecting gross.
- 3:14Yeah, I think everybody would raise their hand and say they do, and then you look at what they're doing, you're like, "Well, you know what I mean?"
- 3:19If, if, if- The question is, can you protect gross and customer experience at the same time? 100% without a doubt. That's the trick. A lot of people protect gross at all costs, right? [laughs] Ooh.
- 3:27That's, that's the problem Dangerous. Don't do that. That's, that's a slippery slope. Oh man, I wish he had a confetti popper. We want to congratulate our good close friend, brother- [cheering]...
- 3:36third amigo, Michael Cirullo, on 700 episodes of the original Automotive podcast. Wow. Don't get confused with all this new stuff. It's called The Dealer Playbook. He crossed 700 episodes.
- 3:50You should go to The Dealer Playbook on Spotify, on YouTube, on Apple Music, and you should listen to it because he's, he's kind of an OG. He's kind of like the Obi-Wan, the Yoda of automotive industry podcasting.
- 4:01He doesn't get enough love over that. Not around- Yeah... not around here. I mean, that's an impressive feat.
- 4:07We, you know, we've done a lot of episodes, but that's because we just put in this, like, 15 minute every single day thing. Yeah.
- 4:13But to do 700 episodes of, like, interview content on a weekly basis, that is a different, that's a different level of commitment and energy and time that you have to put into having those conversations, so kudos.
- 4:25Oh my gosh. Tell, tell me one thing that... Uh, uh, this isn't for you, Kyle. This is for just everyone. This, this is general. Tell me one thing you've done 700 episodes or 700 weeks in a row. 700 weeks in a row?
- 4:38Aside from, like- Wake up... waking up and eating- That's about it. [laughs]... and other things we'll mention, right? Nothing. Man. Michael Cirullo, we have a bow for you this morning.
- 4:49[laughs] I feel like he deserves a bow. Uh, we have another episode of our Auto Collabs, uh, podcast, where Michael, Kyle, and I all get together and interview people.
- 4:58Um, we're talking about Chinese EVs, Amazon, and the future of the dealership model with Ted Smith, president of Florida Auto Dealer Association. It's a great call.
- 5:08Ted is dialed in on what's going on, on how we can maneuver things, and how we can empower franchise retail dealers to actually be the best way to buy a car in the country, which we believe it is. Yeah.
- 5:19We, we still believe it is. So you can go to autocollabs.com, check that out. We have a bunch of other stuff going on, a webinar- Let's get into it... a Soduko. Let's get into it.
- 5:26But we gotta talk about- You know about a Soduko. I know. You know. I know.
- 5:28You do know that's under 60 days, and if you don't get your tickets soon, you're gonna not get a hotel room in the main event hotel at a Soduko.com. Whoops, don't want that.
- 5:35All right, Honda is taking a massive $15.7 billion write down as it cancels several EV programs and pivots back toward hybrids, underscoring how quickly the EV demand outlook has shifted.
- 5:46Uh, Honda's canceling three planned US EVs, the Honda 0 Saloon, the Honda 0 SUV, and the Acura RSX just months before production was supposed to begin, as well as reviewing the future direction of the Sony-Honda mobility joint venture.
- 6:03Whoop. I mean, somebody came in like the Grim Reaper with a sickle and was like- Oh, boyJust slashing.
- 6:10Uh, it's like, it is like Walmart out there, baby, slashing prices That's tough, 'cause I was just starting to get excited about these things finally, like, getting in production mode. I know.
- 6:16Uh, the automaker's Honda Prologue built by General Motors in Mexico, read that sentence again and think about it, uh, could also disappear after its current production run ends in December with no plans for a Gen 2 vehicle.
- 6:29The Prologue launched in 2024, sold nearly 30 thou- $39,000, uh, 39,000 units in 2025, but after the tax credit was eliminated, sales plunged 74% this year. Honda will instead- Yikes...
- 6:41lean heavily into hybrids in the US, where dealers say customers are voting with their wallets.
- 6:45Honda, GM, Ford, and Stellantis have now written down nearly a combined $70 billion in EV investments as companies scale back. What? That's a big number. That just blows my mind.
- 6:59I am fearing that because of the pace at which we approached EVs at the beginning, and what our expectations became of government subsidies, we're actually making a dramatic overcorrection- I agree...
- 7:13that's gonna actually harm us. I totally agree with that. Because,
- 7:19yes, the last seven months have been a hurt because of the a- accelerated adoption that we had due to the EV tax credits ending, but I think we're actually at a point where we could be crossing an EV barrier over the next 18 months, and if all of these R&D efforts get thrown to the waste,
- 7:37I think we're gonna be in a weird position as an industry. I th- uh- Globally speaking... we- globally.
- 7:43We, we, we obviously argued for the hybrid approach over the last three years, but if we would've gone at that hybrid move to EV approach over the last three years, we'd be in a lot pos- better position now.
- 7:54But the overcorrection is extremely dangerous to me. I mean, this is what happens- I don't know where we're gonna be... let, let's talk about why we got here. This is what happens when the government manufactures demand.
- 8:04There it is. Right? It says, "No, people wanna have EVs. They have to drive EVs, so let's, let's put a bunch of government money to basically force the automakers into having to do it, and people...
- 8:15And to have this option." But people aren't gonna buy what they don't wanna buy, and the money went away because we were artificially propping up an industry, and now I think you're exactly right.
- 8:24The overcorrection is, is, like, very real.
- 8:28And I do think that companies that are, like, riding the middle lane, I think Hyundai, I think Kia, I think Toyota, I think they're gonna end up in the best place because they have-- they're not gonna experience this whiplash.
- 8:40Yes. So it makes me sad because I thought the Prologue was an amazing vehicle. Um- Dope-looking car... I think of those 39,000 vehicles that they sold, I think Brian Benstock sold 38,000 of them. God.
- 8:51I'll tell you what, that man- Got him... that man figured out how to sell Prologue in New York City. Like, give that man some ketchup popsicle- That's strong... to people wearing white gloves.
- 8:58No, but there's a lot of value, beautiful vehicles, and so I hope, like you, that this does- isn't an overcorrection and people stay measured.
- 9:04Because if you back out and zoom out for a second and look at the situation globally, we need to keep up with EV technology or everything we've been talking about, right?
- 9:13Chinese EVs are gonna find their way into the country, low-cost vehicles, and they're gonna have the best technology, and it's gonna be very hard for US automakers to keep up with that.
- 9:22People, people want a great vehicle to drive, right? Man. One way or another. It's wild to me. All right. What are we talking about? Oh, [laughs] that's right. We lined these stories up perfectly. Line them up, baby.
- 9:31Kicking it 80s. Line them up. [upbeat music] All right. The hits keep coming. The hits keep coming.
- 9:35So, like, as Honda's pulling back, Rivian is attempting one of the toughest transitions into the auto industry, moving from a niche EV startup into selling a $90,000 adventure truck as a true mass market brand now.
- 9:47CEO RJ Scaringe calls the upcoming R2 SUV a make or break product for Rivian as the company tries to scale beyond, uh, the wealthy early adopters. The R2 launches this spring.
- 9:57It is, like, right on the verge of launching, with a 57,990 version offering 330 miles of range, followed soon shortly after with the $45,000 base model next year. That might be a little too little too late.
- 10:11Rivian has sold about 42,000 vehicles annually so far, and if you remember, Honda sold 39,000 Prologues, so Rivian, that's all their vehicles. That's it.
- 10:19But the Georgia plant being built for the R2 could eventually produce up to 400,000 a year.
- 10:23The new model will use technology from Rivian's $5.8 billion software and electrical architecture joint venture with Volkswagen- Ooh... giving VW access to EV tech. Scout. But I mean- [clears throat]
- 10:35As Rivian's chief, uh, software officer put it, "We know there are two companies in the US who know how to do it, Tesla and us." So Honda pulling back, Rivian saying, like, "We're putting one out there.
- 10:47This is make or break." Yeah, it's kind of interesting. Obviously they've, they've, they've helped make the Scoutian, uh, uh, as, as I'm calling it. They look kind of so similar, it's so sad. Uh, but it, it...
- 10:57Being a software-first company is what's necessary to be a player in the EV game. I think the legacy manufacturers struggle with that.
- 11:03Here's, here's what I'm following here, is any time you're going to market with a, with, with some sort of niche, niche brand, think about the way that Apple went to market initially.
- 11:14They only sold high price, no discount, uh, phones, and then everybody wanted them, and they started introducing these, these SEs or these, these smaller sized phones, smaller sized cameras at a market price that more, more could adopt, s- uh,
- 11:29seeing as themselves, like, a higher level clientele.
- 11:33So I think that this, this brand play is gonna work out great because people are gonna get into this quote-unquote "entry-level model" and, and kind of have that halo effect of the brand, uh, relationship.
- 11:44Um, uh, you know, Rivian's not going away. I think that getting to know these vehicles and getting to know the competitive set that you might be, that you might be going up against now- Yep...
- 11:55that you maybe weren't previously in that 90K price point. But when people are shopping, like, your mid-size SUV or, or crossover utility vehicle against the, the, the Rivian 45 to $60,000 vehicle- Yeah...
- 12:08it's gonna be, it's gonna be a new go for a, a lot of stores. So, so getting your people used to that competitive set I think is gonna be important. I can't think of another...
- 12:16There's not really a competitive vehicle to the R2 on the market today. Um, like Tesla's Model Y does not have the SUV feel at all. The R2 absolutely has the SUV feel. I can't think of another manufacturer.
- 12:28Like, anything else that has an EV is, like, either way bigger or smaller, and so I think it's a good product niche.
- 12:34As of this morning, the average new vehicle price is 50,100 and something, under 50,000, under fift- about 50,000. Yep.
- 12:42So if they come in at 45-Like to be able to sell a new EV that is beautifully designed for under the average new car selling price, I think that's a winner. Uh, we'll see.
- 12:53I think, I think there are enough people in that middle market at the $57,000 price point who will consider it. Um, and every Rivian I've ever seen, I've just been really impressed with, uh, the fit and the finish.
- 13:04We'll see if they can continue to get this one across the line. I do agree it's a make or break vehicle for them. Uh, I guess we'll just have to wait and see what people want. You always wanna know what people want.
- 13:13Speaking of knowing what people want. Yeah. Segway. Time.
- 13:19Well, manual transmissions are disappearing across the industry, but Ford CEO Jim Farley says the Mustang will keep its third pedal for as long as the company has a choice.
- 13:28[laughs] He was speaking at the Australian Grand Prix, and he doubled down on Ford's stance, although it wasn't the most natural phrasing. "Out of our cold, dead hands will not h- w- will we not have a manual Mustang."
- 13:42[laughs] That's wild. The commitment stands out as many automakers, including performance brands, moves toward automatics and dual clutch gearboxes.
- 13:49BMW recently confirmed it isn't developing a new manual transmission for future high-performance M cars, citing the high cost of engineering for a shrinking market.
- 13:58Even when manuals sell well, like the BMW M2, where all, about half of US buyers choose the stick, uh, the overall volume is still too small to justify new transmission development for BMW.
- 14:09Farley framed the decision a part of Ford's identity, saying the brand aims to serve, quote, "working people and enthusiast drivers, and keep building cars that aren't boring." I mean, anyone who's had a stick shift.
- 14:20My first car was a stick shift, and it was amazing, and I would drive a stick shift. I wouldn't wanna drive one all the time. We were just talking to, uh, Steve Greenfield, who's got a, a stick shift incoming.
- 14:30And- Yeah... you know, for, for, I think it's like a stick shift Mustang, if you can do it, I think Ford's the one to pull it off, right? Like- Yeah...
- 14:37how much transmission- I mean, the question is, I mean, to, to BMW's point, like is the juice worth the squeeze on, you know, having to build those cars on the line and, and keeping the R&D, you know, cost going on what's the next thing to come out?
- 14:48But I, I hope that, I hope that some stick shifts stick around for, uh, f- for a little while because I think that visceral part of owning a car, uh, and even learning about it, like I, I wanna teach my car- my kids how to drive a stick shift because- I'm literally thinking about that right now...
- 15:04because it's like y- you know, that's like a part of learning about a car, right? Yeah. It's like, yeah, you ha- you hand write in school- [laughs]... even though you're gonna use AI 98% of your life- I know, right?
- 15:15[laughs]... right? But you hand write because you have to learn the nature of that, you know? I know. And then, well, and then you get EVs that just like, it is not part of driving that car. It's not. You're right.
- 15:23It is a single band. There's no gears anymore. I don't know. Now I- No... I literally have an insane desire right now to drive a stick shift. It's been so long- I know... since I've, we even- I'm feeling it right now.
- 15:32I'm like, "Let's get up there." All right. Ka, ka, ka, ka. We're going to the Ford dealer down the street, see if they have a stick shift Mustang on the lot. We're gonna take it for a little test drive today.
- 15:38We hope you have an amazing Friday. Go out there, take care of the people around you so we can keep making this industry one that people fight to join. [upbeat music] Keep fighting. Keep fighting.
- 15:50Keep fighting and lead the way. Keep fighting. Keep fighting. Keep fighting and lead the way.