Latest / Sages, Icons & Heretics / A Conversation with Richard Mizuno
Transcript
- Sages Icons and Heretics A Conversation with Richard Mizuno Mix: Hello and welcome to the next episode of our podcast on management consulting. Today I'm joined by Richard Mazzuno. Richard and I were overlapped at Deloitte Consulting for about 14 years. And most recently for about 12 years now, we've been colleagues and leaders in Calypso. Welcome, Richard. Great. Thank you, Steve. Glad to be here. Yeah, for our what I call the podcast Sage's icons and heretics, I think you probably most qualify as a sage based on your reputation and brand and in the firm and prior to that. So I'm really looking forward to our conversation today. So I thought we'd just start from the beginning is why and how did you get into consulting? Was it planned and purposeful or opportunistic or how did you land here? I probably put myself in the first category there, planned and purposeful. Not to say I knew exactly what I was getting into, but I have an older brother. He's five years older than me. And our careers took similar paths for a long time. He went to Stanford, I went to Berkeley, he went to MIT for his MBA, I went to Carnegie Mellon. So he wa he had gone into consulting coming out of his MBA program. Like I said, he was five years older than me and he was doing the consulting thing, traveling a lot, meeting with big name companies, working doing projects for them, et cetera. And as I was in my engineering curriculum undergrad, as well as in my early career as an industrial engineer, it's like, well, that sounds interesting. The other aspect of it is this was the early to mid eighties, right? And so back in that era it was common path for people to go get MBAs in order to get into either consulting or investment banking. And so that's the route I took. So I knew from my when I came out of high school into college that was a path that I wanted to pursue. Again, didn't know that much about the industry or anything, but it just sounded kind of like an interesting career path. My my brother was enjoying it, seemed like he was doing pretty interesting things, doing an interesting lifestyle. And so that was the course I plotted. And then so did you find your way into it to Deloitte via the campus program when you're getting MBA? I did. Yeah, I did. Touche Ross back then, recruited on campus. And I was in graduate school in Pittsburgh, but one of the I don't know what he was at the time, senior managers or partners there was from Pittsburgh, so he was recruiting at the same with the Tush Ross team. to the Houston office and so I was invited down for second rounds of interviews on in in Houston and one thing led to another and ended up joining Touch Ross in August nineteen eighty eight. Was it just hundred percent going after consulting or did you consider anything else with your engineering background combined? When I was in graduate school, again, my background's in engineering, and so I took the opportunity while I was in graduate school to explore a variety of other potential careers and and options like finance and manufacturing management and so forth. Yeah, I just thought that was a great opportunity to do that. And so I tried to exploit that as much as possible. All roads ultimately led back to consulting at that point in time. There was something for me as well about being purposeful. And the attraction of of getting into the business. I was a a retailer for about five years and thought that being an operator site was a bit insane, reactionary, and not terribly strategic. And so I thought maybe looking at it from the other side, the consulting lens might be more interesting way to do it. I did a session with Greg Atkins like this, and he was he also was very purposeful about his pursuit. You and I grew up for you know for decades now. grounded in core consulting capabilities or the core consulting process. It's so fundamental to everything we've done and continue to do. What what is the consulting process to you and why has it been so important? Greg answered it well in one of your prior podcasts. I forgot the words that you and he used at the time, but some of the attributes if I recall that you described it with were time tested, proven. It's a process that I think exists in the industry. The industry's existed for a hundred years or so now. It fundamentally works. I would say there's I would I guess I would add to what you all talked about in a couple ways. To me, there's a alignment and socialization step at the end. Fundamentally what you're trying to do is assess a current state, envision a future state. define the gaps and build a roadmap around that. So that's a very fairly linear analytical process. The thing that makes it work and has worked over time and that fundamentally differentiates good consultants from bad consultants would be that you want to do that in a manner that when you're done, you have alignment with your key stakeholders or your clients on how to move forward. Right. So in my mind, those who execute the consulting process better are those that when you're done are able to move forward or encourage effectively encourage your clients to move forward with those recommendations, with that plan, with that roadmap pretty quickly, as opposed to doing the assessment, doing the analysis, and then have a nice presentation at the end, but no action gets taken. Great add-on to that. I I always sort of simply think about the consulting process as the scientific method applied to business. And just like there's good scientists and bad scientists, there's good consultants and bad consultants applying the process. So yeah, those lessons learned make sense to me. How did you learn the consulting process? And if you could maybe just comment along the way any any particularly memorable or impactful projects or memorable or impactful partners or leaders that led you through that. hadn't really thought about that question ever in my life. I guess the words we commonly use is the profession itself is an apprenticeship model, right? You learn best and most effectively by seeing others do it, watching learning, and then doing it yourself with coaching and guidance, right? And I would probably suggest even though all the firms that You and I have been with invests tons and tons of money in training and training people and so forth. Ultimately, on this particular front, I would say the best learning process is doing it under the tutelage of senior people who do it well, which is the major apprenticeship model. I've certainly had a lot of great mentors, project managers, coaches over my career. probably two too many to name. I've had a lot of good projects, a lot of frankly difficult projects. Yeah, I'd say sometimes the more difficult or challenging projects are the ones that you learn best from on a whole different level. So yeah, if I look back through my career, actually the two or three that I can look at two or three projects that were actually not there were good outcomes, but not very difficult to execute. And as really more impactful to I think the consultant I became than the easy fun projects. I agree with difficult, challenging kind of work. I was on our I think we this is back in the early nineties. I was on a project where we had over a hundred consultants. I was a retail guy that suddenly got thrown into the manufacturing floor of a manufacturing client for about two years, didn't know where the shipping dock was, didn't know where the receiving was, and just got forced through that to learn under senior managers and managers at the time to do consulting in a completely different environment than than I'd ever been in before. Yeah. Yeah. And I had a couple of good experiences in that regard as well, working in state healthcare environments or something like that, which I had no inkling I would ever have to do or have the opportunity to do. Same thing, I think it I think those are good experiences if you have a good security net around you to hone your skills as a consultant, 'cause you don't know you don't have the domain expertise, right? You don't have the industry expertise, so you have to rely upon good fundamental consulting skills to be successful. Yeah, so you were and I were raised and pounded into our hedge that you gotta be get comfortable being uncomfortable, which you've you started going down that path. Yeah, so what what does that really mean? how do you know the difference between being completely unprepared and reckless versus being comfortable, being uncomfortable going into a a new project? Yeah, that's a very good question. It comes back to having that solid grounding, that honing in a core set of skills, be it something called the consulting process. Then you add to that fundamental professional skills and emotional intelligence and interpersonal skills and just plain old smarts and curiosity, right? Where if you know you're about to get thrown into a a new environment or a difficult environment, I think most of us would take a few extra cycles of trying to prepare, right? Learn everything you can about the industry, about the company, go into every meeting explicitly, as you always should, with some degree of preparation. And maybe do that a little bit more diligently if you're not in a comfortable environment or we don't know the terminology and so forth. But yeah, I think ultimately being comfortable in uncomfortable environments is a poly upon itself a skill, right? Or a collection of skills that allow you to be effective in environments that are foreign to you. You could be walking into a project, and we see this all the time, right? We do one one project very successfully for a company in an industry and then we sell the next one to a s what we think is a very similar company in the industry. And it turns out that the culture, the program leaders, very different styles, very different approaches. And you know, you could go from a high of a very successful project. And we you know, we saw this you know a few years back in our business, right? You know, we had a team that went from one medical device company with a very successful program went basically that same team popped over to another one and was a disastrous program, right? It was very difficult to work with, a lot of issues, and we ended up having to evacate that that client sooner than we wanted to. We wanna keep those to a minimum, but they happen, right? And sometimes we have to quote, fire ourselves our moment with the client. In a situation where you can't be successful or you can't make your client successful. There's really only one outcome. And those are unfortunate. Every firm has them. I think the smart thing to do is recognize that early and then have professional conversations with the client on how to divorce each other. I had one about eighteen months ago that you know about where we were it wasn't going well on a with an account. on a project and I met with the global head of supply chain and just said, this isn't going well. We know unless you think these two or three things can happen, you should dismiss us. And he had three other people on the call with him that was his team and he said, Can you step off the call for ten minutes and then I'll ping you and come back on and came back on ten minutes, he said, Yes, we agreed, you're right. You guys should stop right now. So it does happen along the way. Fortunately very seldom, but Just like any partnership or marriage, right? Sometimes you Yeah. So we we've been talking a lot about the consulting process and how it's been around for a hundred years and stood the test of time. Do you think as a model is it disruptible? So remember during the dot-com era, there was this idea that e-com was gonna blow up, you know, the model, that you could have things like there's this thing from Ernst and Young called Ernie, where you could you could ask questions and now That didn't really work out. And now the advent of all things AI have the potential to disrupt all kinds of businesses. Do you think this model that we've known for a hundred years is disruptible? Or will it continue to perpetuate? I don't think the fundamental model will be disrupted. I'm not going to say it can't be disrupted. I would say I haven't seen anything yet or heard of anything yet that I would say fundamentally changes the profession. Or specifically you ask about the consulting process or the consulting process. I think the mechanics and the methods can change. And that's something we're looking at ourselves, right? In in other words, how are there ways to apply new methods, new technologies to enhance and or allow us to execute a project more cost effectively, more quickly, whatever metric you want to try to move. But I don't think it changes the steps in the process, right? It in other words, maybe using AI, generative AI capabilities and other tools, you can do a more extensive current state assessment, you know, collect more data and then with these tools to analyze it. The trade off right as you know is every time you can d a lot more interviews or collect more data, but that in in typically in the current model causes you to have to spend more time analyzing it and synthesizing, et cetera, right? So therefore you had to find that balance point between what's the right number of people, what's the right amount of data to collect before moving to the next step. With these tools, could you do a more exhaustive survey of a current state and current environment and analyze it just as quick or even faster because you have better tools, right? That as an example question one might pose here. Yeah, I think that that's very possible. But if it had to assess the current state. Exactly. Yeah. And I think as you move to hypothesis development around how to solve the problems you identify in the current state, certainly leveraging AI tools to generate, maybe NC patterns you couldn't see to where maybe it puts what we do in our people in a bit more of a curation role as these things come up than maybe we would have in the past. But that, yeah, that all makes sense to me. So I want to shift gears now a little bit and maybe shed some insight for the audience based on based on your career. So the the odds of going from a Carnegie Mellon MBA to being a a partner for several decades is pretty low to get through that whole process and and stick with it. Maybe talk a little bit about what were some of your successes and challenges climbing the ranks and getting to getting to partner and maybe maintaining success at the partner level. Yeah, yeah, there's a few I would probably point to and it may be different for your path, while on paper may sound similar to mine, was probably very different at the day to day level, right? Yeah, I guess if I focus just on myself and people that I work very closely with, there's probably two or three things and this is not an exhaustive list, but two or three things that stand out, right? So I think one is we use the term sometimes, right? Consulting stamina, and this is probably applies to any career for quite frankly, but consulting is somewhat unique. It's not you know the most unique probably profession in the world, but it's somewhat unique in that it's kind of a profession, a la law or medicine or whatever, but you're but it's a profession where you're traveling to your customer or your client as opposed to them coming to your office, right? type of thing. So there's a lifestyle component to the profession, as there are in all professions. That's part of the profession in my opinion. So there's a certain amount of stamina that's required to do it for decades. Right. I think that's one part of why you see turnover after three to five years as people try it. They may like the work and love the work, etc, but aren't bought into, you know, the lifestyle component of the profession or want to invest their time and energies in a different way. That's all fine and good, right? So I think one part of it is just the stamina to do it. I think the second part of it is I think you need to be wired a certain way, right? And I've always contended that there are people that are good at running things. And there are people that are good at changing things. And then there's a very few number of people that can do both equally well over time. Right. And so I think if you're a consultant, if you're a person who gravitates to consulting, you're a person who is probably more wired to changing things. Right. Solving a problem, figuring out what that problem is, and then implementing a set of solutions to solve that problem and put your client on a better path versus the person who wants to go run run an operation, right? Run a department, run a function. run a business, right? I think there's some fundamental difference in how people are wired. And I guess I've discovered for myself, I'm just better wired towards helping people change what they're doing as opposed to sitting in sitting in a role for a long period of time trying to r run an operation. Okay. So I think that's part of it as well. and then you've gotta like the challenge of having different customers There's a cycle to it, right? I think you might have heard me say over the years, consulting's a pretty simple business. sell work, you deliver work, you develop staff and bill for your time, and then you rinse and repeat, right? And you got to enjoy that cycle. So those are some thoughts that I think have kept me in the profession. in other words, I discovered that I'm wired to Helping people change things as opposed to run things. I've discovered this is a job that I like and I enjoy and I I don't count hours, et cetera. And then I yeah, I just like kinda like the challenge of the work. It's interesting you said you're wired to change things because you've actually both here and at your roles prior to clip, so you were also operating and leading and running things. So I might argue you're good at both. Maybe you don't like one of them, but me the it's kinda interesting. What I found is I can only do one of those roles for about three years. And I would argue with you. That's why I've always advocated for some type of kind of term limits on some of these leadership roles, right? For me, I appreciate your comment, but I can't I can only do one of those roles for about three years before I think I go stale or it's time for fresh ideas or whatever. Right. It just And if you look at my history, that's about the term limits I put on myself in each of these roles. That makes sense. I've heard that from really senior leaders in other firms that some of the strategy houses view leadership as not an aspiration to climb to the top, but it's actually your turn in the seat on behalf of everybody else as a duty. Yeah, I think that's what you're what you're proposing or go. There's lot to looking at it that way. So Just going back to climbing the ranks, was there can you think of a time where either you said I I don't really wanna do this for them anymore or I'm not sure they want me to do this for them as you were you know climbing up? Was there any particular moment where you know you were unsure that you were gonna continue to progress through, you know, to partner level and beyond? Yeah, for sure. So in the Deloitte days, I think there was I guess we've we've branded it the Valley of Despair. I don't think I ever found myself in the Valley of Despair, but I probably found myself at a fork in the road, three to five, I don't recall the exact years it was, but it was in the three to five years in range, right? Where you've been doing it, you discover that you can do it pretty well, but you gotta decide, am I gonna commit to that next level? Right. The job becomes progressively harder and more difficult for most people. And as you've probably experienced your career than as I did. The worst role in a consulting organization, I believe, is senior manager. And well before you get there, and I and you've heard me encourage younger staff this, right? you know, before you get there, you should actually figure out if you want to be a partner, principal, director, 'cause that step before it is extremely painful and difficult and challenging. So I think there were two points in time. I think there was one when I was three to five years into my career, and it's like, okay, well, I gotta decide if I'm gonna keep doing this or go look for the proverbial real job or whatever. And then you know, kinda in that senior manager era where it's like, do I really want to commit to this? Is the path that I'm being directed towards what I really want to do, etc. And in both cases I looked outside of consulting, you know, not super diligently. I did some interviews, talked to some companies, network, etcetera. And you know, I just kept coming back to consulting. I was like, well, I those are fine, good companies, but I just I think I'll get bored in the work. I like the challenge of what I'm doing. You know, I think generally the rewards in the consulting career are generally still pretty good relative to other professions. So I just kept coming back to what I was doing. I I discovered I was pretty good at it and So why go chase something that you're not sure you're so good at? Right. There's definitely the moments of doubt along the way for everybody. I know I had those as well. So I'm gonna shift to thinking about some of our people in the audience that may be super earlier in their career. When you, I guess you're doing recruiting or you're going to staff a project. What are the I mean, what do you look for in a consultant to put, you know, either bring in the firm or put on a project? What are some of the attributes that you're looking at. There's things we look at in all consultants, but are there any two, three, four that really stand out for you that differentiate folks? I think these are criteria that have largely stood the test of time. know it's not really so much what's on the resume, though you're always looking for the person with the exact right experience that you're looking for, but it really comes down to personal qualities, right? What you're looking for is smart people. And smart and talented over skilled and experienced is the differentiator there. Not to say skill and experience aren't critically valuable. It's just that our profession changes. The type of services I do and deliver today are vastly different than what I thought I would be doing when I joined Tush Ross in nineteen eighty eight. And you talk to a lot of people, senior people in the industry, people retired from the industry, and they'll talk about how they're they had three or four careers in consulting. Right. And in order to make those switches with the market, you have to have just some real innate horsepower upstairs. Yeah, horsepower and curiosity and interest in moving with the market. Ultimately it comes down to people that are smart enough and adept enough to make those switches and move with the market. That's one big thing. Second big thing is inter interpersonal skills, emotional intelligence, that whole bundle of things. 'Cause ultimately you hear this a lot, we're still a people business, right? And the buzzword that a lot of people use in our current the company that bought us currently uses as well, actually. They talk about trying to be a trusted advisor. As if you can just walk in and and become one, right? Well, you can't. That's a position that is earned, right? You have to do a lot of things to get to that stature with your clients, including actually dispense trustworthy advice. But you gotta do that in a ego-less manner. You're either a trusted advisor or you're there to sell advice, right? Those aren't necessarily the same thing. So you need to have great interpersonal skills and great emotional intelligence because you're ultimately trying to help either convince a client to do something that they didn't realize they need to do or don't want to do, or you need to guide them in a difficult journey. and all that requires strong interpersonal skills and engagement. And then you need to be need great communicators, because you know, fundamentally that's what we do. We could have all the great answers we want, but if we can't communicate them effectively, crisply, simply, in a manner that most people can understand, then you're just not going to get very far. So those would be two or three things I look for. People that are inherently smart and curious and want to figure things out. Second category be around interpersonal skills, you know, ability to affect behavioral change in people on a one on one or group basis, strong communicators. And then you gotta be a little bit selfless because we're we're here to help others achieve success. And through that we achieve our success. And it's gotta be about the client, not about you. Yeah, I love those. I'd love to do lists of things. One of our offsites is probably five years ago. I was doing a presentation on what do I look for in a consultant when going to staffing. And I came with my top ten and I'm like, it's 14. My I have 14 of my top ten things I look for that it keeps growing. But the two things I'd add on to yours is the combination of work, ethic, and commitment. So that suddenly you gotta do something over the weekend and it's due on Monday. that you can rely on that colleague to to get it done with you that it's gonna happen. And then the other for me is it's selfish. It's the easy button. So is the, you know, colleague I'm working with, staff person I'm working with, proactive, thinking ahead, and therefore making my life easier, anticipating things that are coming down the road that we should be prepared for. Those are both excellent and yeah, should be on the list. You're looking for leadership is the you know, another I think. I would take your second ad and put in that category. Early in your career, a lot of the job is doing what you're asked to do. But you're exactly right. Those who are in the profession for a long period of time are those that figure out what needs to be done next and are, you know, willing to raise their hand and get it done, thus making you more productive or allowing you to do other things. Okay. I want to move on to I guess another topic. You've you've had a unique leadership roles inside Calypso, prior companies. So I wondered if you had any lessons learned, leading practices about managing this population of people that are tend to be bright, high maintenance, ungovernable often. What's been some of the secrets to your success in leading groups like that over the years? Well mentioned a few that I have recognized or thought about over those years. Some are probably pretty pretty obvious and basic and others might be some that maybe I I was surprised by too. Let me start there. The one thing I encourage people and I've encouraged my successors and some of my roles to think about is, you know, it kind of gets back to the premise of your question, right? It's oftentimes consultants or populations of consultants are not governable, right? They're not you know you're really not trying to manage a professional services organization more than lead, guide, steward, I don't know, I don't know what the right words are, but this traditional manager relationship isn't really one that I don't think works very well in our industry. Sometimes it's not what you do, it's what you choose not to do. Okay. The prime examples of that are you get a you know tons of emails every day from people Who want you to wade into something, want you to opine on something, just want to whine about something, whatever. There are a lot of people, I see it in younger leaders or where they feel obligated to respond to everything. And I found there's also a art to not responding to everything. There's a lot of things that would run across your desk or your email that it's like, yeah, I okay, I hear that. This person's got a you know, particular issue problem today, but yeah, I assume if they have three more conversations on the topic, it'll resolve itself because I can only see one practical outcome of this whole conversation. So why should I should I weigh in and say, hey, there's only one practical outcome to the situation, or should I let them go figure that out themselves? And I think a manager's leaders of organizations made up of a lot of smart people should think about not having to respond to every note or question that comes across their plate. Right. And you probably get a ton of them yourself, Steve, right? And sometimes the best thing to do is just not respond. I think I've actually been on the receiving end of that from you, Richard, as well. You probably have, and it probably all turned out okay, right? It did. It did. Yeah. So that's the one thing that says struck me over the years. I could respond to this. Maybe these guys just need to go figure it out themselves. And if they do, they're only going to come up with one of two options which are both fine by me. Right. In my prior firm, we were interviewing a senior person from the industry outside the firm for a senior role in ours and you know, he he made a very interesting point. He said, Look, if I come in I want this role and frankly you guys shouldn't worry about that too much because anybody in this role will make eighty percent of the time make the same decisions. So then on the and we have a governance process if you don't like the other twenty percent. Yeah, it's like, yeah, that's a good point. eighty percent of the time if we're all wired similarly, if we're all executing a diligent process, even in our day to day work that looks like a consulting process, we should be getting the same answer eighty plus percent of time. Right? You're just asking me to try to circumvent that process for you and maybe I don't want to do that. So that's one. You know, it's this I found it's a good capacity management technique as well as I think a good leadership technique to not feel obligated to respond to every thing that comes across your plate. You you have to let people figure stuff out for themselves. So that's one. I think the other one is we, as you know, emphasize leadership over management. I think that's very similar. I think the other thing, and I'm always surprised by this and let me see if I can characterize it crisply here, which is there's a lot of problems, a lot of topics that get elevated to your level or my level that our consultants deal with every day at the clients, right? If there's an issue or something, our consultants know how to escalate that, how to get it resolved in a timely manner and move on. But for some reason within the confines of click where other firms have been with, people put on their employee hat, right? And forget that if You deal with these types of things every day at your clients. Why is it within the four walls of the firm? You gotta forget how to deal with these things. Some of what I do is also challenge people and say, Well, if we were at a client, how would you deal with this situation? And why are you trying to deal with it differently now type of rapport? There's a couple of things that are outside of the usual things you'd expect, I think, to hear, which is, you know, obviously you'd need to have done the job. All the firms I've been with and probably you as well are leader led, the people who have respect in the organization or people who've done the job, done jobs successfully over time, et cetera, et cetera, all those help, right? You've seen some firms that we've acquired, for example, where the owner or the leader of that organization didn't necessarily come out of that business. There's differences in levels of respect and so forth, where, people that have grown up in the business, have done the job, have done been responsive on weekends as you the example you gave earlier, sold work, delivered work, have traveled extensively, it's lot easier for them to gain the respect of junior people in the industry, in the firm. You know, if you can say, well, yeah, I've done that. I still do that. Leading by example, if you would. Well, good, yeah, great sage advice from a a sage here. So we're, you know, nearing the end of our time here. What I thought I'd just close out with is a little bit more philosophical. So looking back on Your consulting journey and where it's led you to this point. How has this profession impacted you in your life, reflecting back? Yeah, interesting question. Yeah, so obviously it's been very I don't want to use the word lucrative. I think it's it's provided me and my family a good lifestyle. That's number one. But that's not unique about it. So the you know, the rewards in the profession, like as I alluded to earlier, are still, you know, still good. I don't know how they compare to other professions these days, but if you can do it, you can do it successfully. There there's good rewards associated with it. I think the more impactful part is, you know, a lot of my best friends are people that I met in the career path, in the professions of the firms that I've been with. I think the opportunity to do interesting work through your career and meet interesting companies and and work across a variety of industries and I think from professional standpoint, it's just one of those unique professions where you get to sample a lot of things. You don't you're you don't feel like you're only working with one one business or one company. 'Cause you're not, right? You're servicing a variety of clients over a variety of years. But yeah, I think the probably the most rewarding part is kind of twofold is being able to look back over the course of your career and see a variety of clients and more importantly a variety of people both on the client side and the consulting side that you've helped become successful in their careers. Right. So those would be the two or three things I'd point to in terms of how it's impacted my life. It's, certainly given me a comfortable living, but it has also given me a huge amounts of personal satisfaction and rewards over time. And then, a a network a cadre of people that you know will be they're not all going to be close friends but lifelong colleagues right it's not atypical to pick up the phone and call somebody that you worked with five, eight years ago and pick up where you left off, right? And so that's immensely rewarding and valuable throughout your career. It's clear you made the right career decision to go into consulting. You've been successful. I've really enjoyed working with you. You've made a huge imprint on your clients and on all the people you've led in the organization. So I think we'll head and wrap up with that. Thank you, Richard, for participating in our podcast today and look forward to continuing to work with you. Yeah, Steve, thank you very much. And thank you for those kind words saying back to you and hope we continue this journey for several more years. All right. Thank you.