Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Overjustification Effect Quietly Kills Your Motivation
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this classic study from the seventies where researchers took a bunch of kids who loved drawing and started paying them for each picture. Within a few weeks, those kids stopped drawing on their own. The reward had quietly killed the joy. Luna: That's the overjustification effect, right? When you add an external reason for something you already enjoy, your brain kind of rewrites the story. ‘I do this for the reward,’ not ‘I do this because I love it.’ Lucas: Exactly. And it shows up all over the office. I was reading about a sales team at a mid-sized software company — they used to love the chase, the craft of the pitch. Then management introduced a tiered commission structure with monthly bonuses. Within two quarters, the team's enthusiasm just flatlined. They were hitting targets, but the energy was gone. Luna: So the money didn't motivate them more — it actually replaced the intrinsic driver. And that's the trap. We assume more rewards equals more motivation, but psychology says the opposite under the right conditions. Lucas: Right. The research is pretty clear: when the task itself is interesting, adding a tangible reward tends to reduce intrinsic motivation. But when the task is boring, rewards can actually help. So it's not that bonuses are bad — it's that we apply them uniformly without thinking about what's driving people. Luna: That's a useful way to frame it. Because I've seen it in creative teams too. A design department I worked with had an ‘employee of the month’ plaque. The designers started competing for it, but the quality of work dropped. They were spending more time politicking than designing. Lucas: And that's a perfect example of the effect in action. The recognition became the goal, not the work. So what do we do with this in our own careers? I think the first step is to notice when it's happening. Luna: How do you notice it? Like, if you're feeling less excited after a promotion, is that a sign? Lucas: It can be. The classic sign is a dip in motivation right after a reward is introduced or increased. You might catch yourself thinking, ‘I'm only doing this for the money now.’ That's your brain reclassifying the activity. Luna: So what's the fix? You can't exactly tell your boss, ‘Hey, your bonus is making me less motivated.’ Lucas: Ha — that would be a tough conversation. But you can reframe your own relationship with the work. Focus on the why. Remind yourself of the aspects you genuinely enjoy. And if you're a manager, the better play is to build autonomy, mastery, and purpose into the role — the things that feed intrinsic motivation. Luna: That's the Daniel Pink framework, right? Autonomy, mastery, purpose. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just theoretical. There's a famous case at a tech company where they gave engineers one day a week to work on any project they wanted — no strings, no review. That was more motivating than any bonus they'd ever paid. Luna: I love that. It's like the difference between a bribe and a gift. A bribe says, ‘Do this and you'll get that.’ A gift says, ‘I trust you and I value what you love.’ Lucas: That's a nice way to put it. And the research backs you up. When people feel trusted with their own time, they're more engaged and more creative. The overjustification effect is really about how our brains interpret the why behind our actions. Luna: So if I'm in a job where the rewards are starting to feel hollow, what's a practical step I can take this week? Lucas: I'd say reconnect with the craft. Pick one task you used to love and find a way to do it without any external pressure. Maybe it's a side project, maybe it's volunteering to mentor someone, maybe it's just spending an hour on something you're curious about. The goal is to remind your brain that you do this because you like it. Luna: And that's also a career strategy. You want to stay with the company that values your intrinsic strengths, not just the one that throws the biggest bonus at you. Lucas: And we actually talk about that kind of career decision a lot on this show. If we've helped you think through a move, a negotiation, or just how to navigate your workplace, that's what keeps us going — and we're glad to keep it ad-free. If that's been valuable to you, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep these conversations going. Luna: Yeah, every bit helps. And we're not going anywhere — just saying, that's how you can be part of it if you want. Lucas: So back to the overjustification effect — the other side of this is what happens when you're the manager. It's not just about avoiding the wrong rewards. It's about actively designing work that's worth doing for its own sake. Luna: Give us a concrete example of that. Lucas: Sure. Think about a customer support team. The job can feel repetitive. If you just tie everything to call handle time, you'll get people who are fast but cold. But if you give them the autonomy to solve problems in their own way and the mastery to learn new tools, they'll be more engaged and actually provide better service. Luna: That's a good one. I've also heard of companies that do ‘gratitude visits’ — where you take time to thank a colleague directly. That's a recognition that doesn't come with a badge or a bonus, and it seems to have a real effect. Lucas: That's a great example of social reward, which is different from tangible reward. Social rewards — like praise from a peer — tend to reinforce intrinsic motivation rather than undermine it. It's the tangible, expected rewards that cause the trouble. Luna: So the takeaway is, be careful what you reward, because you might get exactly what you ask for — but lose what you didn't ask for. Lucas: And that's the thing to keep in mind. The next time you're thinking about motivation — yours or your team's — ask yourself: would I still want to do this if there were no reward attached? If the answer is no, then the reward is the only thing keeping you. And that's a fragile foundation.