Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Grid 'scandal', AR8 pricing, and is it decom's day?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 0:05The weekly news podcast that keeps you up to date on the
- 0:08hottest stories from the UK energy.
- 0:10Market. Grid scandal AR-8 prices
- 0:15revealed and is decommissioning finally happening in the North
- 0:18Sea? That's a lot to talk about if
- 0:19you're just me Aberdeen features lead Ryan Daft, but thankfully
- 0:22I'm joined this week with a crack team of reporters.
- 0:25Up first, renewables reporter Michael Baer.
- 0:28How are you doing this week? I'm.
- 0:29Doing great, like you said, we've had a lot of AR-8 chat
- 0:32this week so I've been sinking my teeth into that.
- 0:34Yeah, we've got AR-8 coming out of our ears.
- 0:37But you know what, Ed? You've also been looking at
- 0:40scandal. It was the one by using that
- 0:42that was the word Claire continue used.
- 0:44But has your week been scandalous?
- 0:46What have you been up? To I'm not sure I'd go so far as
- 0:49to say scandalous. I would say mildly askance
- 0:53might, might, might cover my cover my week.
- 0:56I mean, I feel so look, I'm, I'm, I'm down in the South and I
- 0:59feel like it's just getting hot again.
- 1:01And I, like many people in England I'm sure, are again
- 1:06looking at air conditioning as essentially a human right, or
- 1:10possibly even swimming pools as a human right.
- 1:12Ed Reed, you know the the reason he gets paid the big bucks as E
- 1:16Forward editor is the the vocabulary he had on display
- 1:18there. But we also know that he is very
- 1:21damp this week and now is could the grid handle everyone in
- 1:27London getting air conditioning units?
- 1:29That would be a massive drain on energy, especially after what we
- 1:33heard this. Week.
- 1:33Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think that's, that is,
- 1:36is is actually, you know, back in the news again.
- 1:39So. So, you know, shadow Secretary
- 1:42of State Claire Catino was in the House of Commons this week
- 1:46decrying what she said was a scandal.
- 1:48Nothing short of a scandal, she said.
- 1:50Basically the whole thing kind of goes back to the 23rd of
- 1:53June, which was pretty much the sort of the first day when it
- 1:55was super hot. I think it got to 3536 down
- 1:59here, which was frankly way out of my comfort zone, but it turns
- 2:03out maybe it's also out of Nisa's comfort zone.
- 2:06So Nisa with obviously responsibility for the grid,
- 2:11among various things that it's got to do is it's got to keep
- 2:13the grid to the right frequency, right?
- 2:15So frequency for the grid is important to keep sort of
- 2:18electrical, you know, things working.
- 2:21If it varies too wildly, essentially our electrics start
- 2:24to suffer. So it's obviously kind of like a
- 2:26crucial requirement for, for, for, for Nisa to be on top of on
- 2:31the 23rd of June. As I say, it's hot day.
- 2:34Solar panels don't work so well in the heat.
- 2:38Gas power plants also struggle to, to, to get the same amount
- 2:42of power. So essentially, we were sort of,
- 2:44you know, running a bit short, Niso said.
- 2:46Oh, you know, crumbs. We're going to need some extra
- 2:48power. They kind of squeaked through,
- 2:51or did they? So Coutinho has alleged that
- 2:56Niso's corporate affairs managers and senior managers
- 3:00were involved in control room operations.
- 3:05Actually sort of taking control from the kind of the people who
- 3:08you know, who are really the sort of the hands on engineers.
- 3:11And she said that they stepped in that they have done things
- 3:14that they shouldn't. They would essentially trying to
- 3:17manage Nisa's reputation rather than trying to keep the grid,
- 3:22you know, in the, in the right frequency.
- 3:24So, and look, it's, it's clear that the, the, the grid was, was
- 3:26struggling that day. So essentially Nisa is supposed
- 3:29to kind of keep it at, at about 50 Hertz, right, with a little
- 3:32bit of wiggle room. So that day it dropped to 49.67
- 3:39Hertz. So that is, I mean, look, it's
- 3:43sort of the things. We I was going to say, that
- 3:44doesn't sound like a massive variation, right?
- 3:47How important is is that? What point?
- 3:50So. Quick maths .3.
- 3:52Three like it's, it's, it's a small wiggle, but actually
- 3:56essentially so look, so NISO is has like an operational sort of
- 4:00standard where it says it, it tries to keep it in basically
- 4:04above 49.8 Hertz. So obviously it fell below that,
- 4:08but then on the on the sort of the, the absolute sort of
- 4:10minimum minimum, it says it's can't let it go beneath 49.5.
- 4:16So essentially it was kind of dropped out of its operational
- 4:20bound, but didn't kind of fall too late, right.
- 4:23So. So is this is this like, you
- 4:25know, when when you're at work and you have kind of forgotten
- 4:29to do what you're needing to do? You know, I know I've got one
- 4:32more thing that I need to get done today and I can't remember
- 4:34what it is. And you remember just as your
- 4:36boss walks in and you go, no, I'm on it now.
- 4:39Thanks. Yeah, no, don't worry about it.
- 4:40It's like jobs are good. And is that is that kind of
- 4:42what's happened? Like they scraped by, they just
- 4:44got. Yeah, yeah.
- 4:46So I mean, they did scrape by like the day was obviously you
- 4:48see a bit of a struggle. We came through it without a,
- 4:51without any problems, without any blackouts, right.
- 4:53So look, essentially we're a bit squeezed, but we were OK.
- 4:57It's kind of actually how it turned out.
- 4:59The thing is though, which is kind of where the continue
- 5:02intervention is, is actually, look, Niso has got
- 5:07responsibility for delivering the grid frequency, right.
- 5:11But it feels like maybe the the continued allegation is actually
- 5:15that they were trying to massage the figures, right?
- 5:17The cover up essentially being kind of essentially worse than,
- 5:20I don't want to say crime, but the cover up is worse than the,
- 5:23the, the, the, you know, the accident or the yeah, the fact,
- 5:26the sort of self. Yeah, the thing in itself.
- 5:30And I think that's the thing, right?
- 5:31Like, I feel like, look, there is this kind of question around
- 5:33kind of grid stability. But this isn't new, right?
- 5:34We've seen points in, you know, grid stability in the past.
- 5:37In December 2023, when Claire Coutinho was running the show
- 5:41right as head of Des Nez, we had a bit of a wobble at that point.
- 5:46Grid frequency fell lower than it did on the 23rd of June.
- 5:49Coutinho didn't at that point, you know, sort of, you know,
- 5:51sound the alarm. This time she is.
- 5:54And I think it's look, it's larger because, you know, God,
- 5:56the world has changed, right? The conservatives and Reform of
- 5:59course, are seeing an opportunity to sort of, you
- 6:01know, say, you know, the people in charge of running the energy
- 6:05sector are no longer reliable. They don't have their their eyes
- 6:10on sort of delivering actually what the country needs.
- 6:12So it's good for being a sort of like an operational engineering
- 6:14question to being a political question.
- 6:16Yeah. And then that's thing.
- 6:17And, you know, we've spoken about this before, about how,
- 6:19you know, in the past few years, we've gone from being
- 6:23essentially, you know, predominantly writing about
- 6:26contracts delivered and, you know, you know, operations and
- 6:29THSE updates and like very industry focused stuff to, you
- 6:34know, almost being political reporters at times, like energy
- 6:37has become the the the forefront of the sort of political agenda.
- 6:42So, I mean, you know, if, if this proves to be true, what
- 6:47continue has said, this is a it was a serious stick that, you
- 6:51know, the opposition and reform can sort of beat the the Labour
- 6:56Party with and kind of say, well, look, you're, you're sort
- 6:58of doubling down on renewables isn't providing the security
- 7:01that you say it is, which is interesting because obviously
- 7:05we've we've spoken about sort of what is energy security over the
- 7:08past few years and you know, is increased renewables energy
- 7:12security is increased oil and gas supply energy security.
- 7:16Obviously, the argument against oil is it gets traded on
- 7:19international markets. There's no guarantee it's going
- 7:21to be here. But renewables are intermittent,
- 7:25so, you know, there's got to be a middle ground somewhere.
- 7:29Yeah. It almost feels like whenever I
- 7:31hear these debates that neither side gets the full picture
- 7:33because the how polarized it gets.
- 7:35And maybe this is me being slightly controversial, but you
- 7:38know, this whole idea that, you know, it's one or the other kind
- 7:41of just it's, it's getting more and more to me that I'm just
- 7:45getting more and more frustrated with it, if you get what I mean.
- 7:49Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I think, I think that's the
- 7:52thing, right? Like I feel like there is this
- 7:54kind of, you know, renewables question, isn't that right?
- 7:56That actually obviously that kind of the conservatives and
- 7:59Reform see, you know, there is kind of an opportunity there.
- 8:04But like in many ways it feels like actually the kind of the
- 8:06reality of the situation is that like God, like the, the problem
- 8:09on the 23rd of June wasn't really so much about renewables.
- 8:11It was about like kind of capacity and engineering some of
- 8:14those sort of decisions, right? But obviously there is a sort of
- 8:18a slightly wilful elision of those sort of slightly sort of
- 8:23separate topics, you know, being used as a stick to beat the
- 8:28government via Nisa. And Nisa, of course.
- 8:30Look, you know, in the past it wasn't, you know, state-run,
- 8:32right? Like it's it's it's now since
- 8:35those days has been, you know, kind of part of of of the kind
- 8:37of state apparatus. And it feels like there is, Nisa
- 8:41has by default become a sort of a political actor.
- 8:45And as a result, it's sort of struggling with that role,
- 8:47right? And like, we don't know, we
- 8:48don't know what the truth of the matter is about the 23rd of
- 8:51June, right? Like quite how bad things got,
- 8:54like who stepped in where, how those decisions were taken,
- 8:56right? Niso is sort of, you know,
- 8:59moving towards sort of saying something, but we've not
- 9:01actually seen any kind of results yet.
- 9:04But the problem is that clearly Neesis is that the problem?
- 9:07And look, I'm going to say like I've been sort of, you know,
- 9:09ringing around as one does at this point, trying to get people
- 9:12to sort of come and explain, you know, the sort of the issues to
- 9:14me, you know, consultants, you know, kind of think tanks, all
- 9:18these sorts of people. And everyone is staying away
- 9:21from it because people are just, you know, terrified of the
- 9:24politics, right? And it's become a thing where
- 9:26actually people are worried about taking a political
- 9:29position where in the past like, God, this is this is just like
- 9:31an engineering issue, right? And it's like actually one of
- 9:34the steps need to take to make sure that the grid is working
- 9:37shouldn't be a political question, but increasingly is.
- 9:41And that is a going to be an increasing problem.
- 9:44Well, Ed, our conversation is going to have to wrap up there
- 9:47because we're running out of time.
- 9:48But we've spoken about frequencies an awful lot, and
- 9:50you shouldn't touch that dial because after this break we'll
- 9:53be speaking about AR-8 strike prices.
- 9:56Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 10:00Voice app, available to download for free.
- 10:03You get features like saving the articles you want to return to,
- 10:07access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 10:10You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 10:14Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 10:19sector, stay in the loop by saving the Energy Voice app to
- 10:22your home screen. Download the app through the
- 10:25Apple App Store or Google Play for breaking energy news.
- 10:29On the go. By searching Energy voice app.
- 10:33So Michael, we touched on it at the very top of the the show ARA
- 10:37allocation round, the government's go to round for,
- 10:42you know, providing cash for renewables projects in the UK.
- 10:45We got we got some, some guidance or well, we got the
- 10:49full, full shebang on how much they're willing to spend on each
- 10:53technology this week. But what does that mean?
- 10:56Yeah, I mean, ARAI think the, the big, we've had a whole raft
- 11:00of these parameters come out, but the big one is obviously
- 11:04going to be the money. So the big sort of headline
- 11:09news, there's a bunch of things I'll cover, try and cover all of
- 11:12them. But the big one is that they've
- 11:14revealed that the strike prices that is the the maximum amount
- 11:17of money you can get for your, for your bid basically is going
- 11:22to be kept the same as in AR 7. So for offshore wind that is
- 11:27going to be 113 lbs per MW hour and for floating wind that's
- 11:31going to be 271 lbs per MW hour. Now, I think the, the big
- 11:36question is kind of what kind of price signal this this is going
- 11:38to say the Offshore Renewable Energy Catapult called it a bit
- 11:42of a mixed outcome for renewable UK.
- 11:44They came out and said, look, this is probably a good thing as
- 11:47it's just giving us clarity. They didn't really say whether
- 11:50the the decision to keep the price level was good or bad,
- 11:54just that, well, I guess we know where we stand.
- 11:56So that might be damning with faint praise on that one for a
- 11:59long time. You know the well, the last two
- 12:02options we've seen prices go up for anyone who's not a big, big
- 12:07aficionado of the history of the EU KS allocation rounds AR-1 to
- 12:12four. We basically saw prices coming
- 12:14down steadily. As you know, the the government
- 12:17is basically using it as a formal price discovery.
- 12:19They're saying right, you've delivered offshore wind power at
- 12:24this price. The lacks last option.
- 12:26Can you take it down? Can you take it down until we
- 12:28hit AR5, in which case they put it down too low.
- 12:31No one bid. The industry said no, we can't
- 12:33deliver at that price. So AR six and seven have been
- 12:37prices going back up, especially, you know, not just,
- 12:41you know, to make sure that offshore wind developers can get
- 12:44a competitive price, but we've seen inflation coming in and
- 12:48really pushing up prices. So AR 7, I think, you know,
- 12:52we've digested it. Has anyone heard that AR 7
- 12:55wasn't a success? You know what, right, So this is
- 12:57the thing if we're speaking about prices, I've, I've
- 12:59definitely heard, sorry, you know, push back from, from some
- 13:03people about the, the, the price is paid.
- 13:06And obviously we got that over was it 20 years instead of 10,
- 13:09which was the previous agreement for a contract for difference
- 13:1315. Sorry, you know which obviously
- 13:16if the prices are higher and we're locked in for longer, I, I
- 13:20definitely heard around the time, you know, people's are
- 13:23pushed back on that. But I also, I was writing our
- 13:26live blog the day the allocation round seven happened and Mr. Ed
- 13:31Reed gave his two cents at the time as well.
- 13:34Do you stand by what you said at the time?
- 13:36Do you remember what you said at the?
- 13:37Time 2 minutes. I do not remember what I said at
- 13:39the time, but I'm sure it was shockingly insightful.
- 13:43I suppose, look, I suppose, look, just thinking about sort
- 13:45of ARA, right? I feel like there's this kind of
- 13:47administrative strike price kind of performance that we all go
- 13:50through, right? And kind of coming back to
- 13:51Claire Coutinho, she was, you know, kind of firing into, you
- 13:56know, the sort of strike prices and being like, oh, look at how
- 13:59Miliband's throwing around your hard earned tax dollars all
- 14:02this. And it's like, actually look,
- 14:04the, the, the difference between the, the, the sort of
- 14:06administrative strike price and the actual price that the, the
- 14:09technology gets away at, right? Is, is not the same, right?
- 14:13Like obviously the, the government says, look, we're,
- 14:16we're kind of willing to look up to this point, but actually the
- 14:18price that they strand the deals at is about 20% lower.
- 14:21So like in AR 7, it was something like, what, 90 lbs for
- 14:27offshore wind, and that's about 20% lower than the actual thing.
- 14:31But now, obviously, they're also changing the rules for CFD
- 14:34allocations, right? So increasingly, the government
- 14:37can see how companies are putting together their bids.
- 14:40So it feels a bit like what is the point of this sort of
- 14:43performance of putting out strike prices if the government
- 14:46is seeing like the calculations that companies are working on
- 14:49behind the scenes? You're like this.
- 14:51You don't need like a like a like a like a this kind of
- 14:54strike price idea. You can usually like look, how
- 14:57much is it going to cost you? That's too much.
- 15:00Make me a lower offer. Like it just feels like a weird
- 15:02performance to go you've. Come out in the past and say, do
- 15:05we need the allocation round system at all?
- 15:08And I've heard like developers say, yeah, the allocation round
- 15:12system, on the one hand, you know, it's a good system.
- 15:15It's, you know, other countries kind of look at it and go, yeah,
- 15:17we should do this. On the other hand, the fact that
- 15:21all of these companies get their deals at the same time is a
- 15:24massive burden on the supply chain because you've got all
- 15:29these developers with all these wind farms, incredibly expensive
- 15:32and complicated projects sitting on their asses waiting to to get
- 15:37the all clear to actually go ahead, sign the contract and
- 15:40say, yeah, we're going to get the money to build this.
- 15:42Then they all have to rush out to market at the same time.
- 15:46So the fact that, yeah, that there is this behind the scenes,
- 15:50we kind of know what's going on. A lot of this doesn't line up.
- 15:53It just. Do we need it just feels right,
- 15:55it just feels that like allocation runs were really good
- 15:58to kind of get the industry going, right?
- 15:59Like really successful, like a great way to sort of do price
- 16:02discovery. And look, look, the UK has been
- 16:04really good at actually kind of building out renewables, right?
- 16:07We have decarbonized, obviously some of that is
- 16:09deindustrialization, but actually in terms of sort of
- 16:11building, you know, renewables, we have been successful.
- 16:13And I feel like we shouldn't say that we, you know, that that
- 16:16that's a failure, right? Like that has been a really
- 16:18striking success. But I just feel like, you know,
- 16:20as time's gone on, we've got a tendency in this country to
- 16:23build on things rather than change things, right?
- 16:28And sometimes there's just, there's just comes a point where
- 16:30you're like God, like this is not even an auction anymore.
- 16:33Like why are we going through this, You know, Facade, Like
- 16:36there are better ways we could be doing this.
- 16:38We could be like, look, God allocation rounds have worked
- 16:40well in the past. We can change this.
- 16:42We can we can find new ways of doing this now we know how the
- 16:44industry works. Now we've got like, you know,
- 16:46ideas about supply chain, all these things.
- 16:48Like it just feels like there are these opportunities you can
- 16:51be like, you know, we could do something a bit more
- 16:53interesting, a bit different and we could, you know, be a bit
- 16:56more dynamic and, you know, start getting kind of, as you
- 16:59say, Michael, kind of tackling that kind of lumpy supply chain
- 17:02problem. But obviously, you know, there's
- 17:05a kind of a, there's a challenge, isn't there, about
- 17:07kind of actually how you go about thinking?
- 17:08So are you, are you advocating for more of like an out of round
- 17:12kind of style and allocation where you would have sort of the
- 17:16budget would be set for the year and if CDs were to stick around
- 17:21instead of them all coming around on award day, they would
- 17:23sort of be parcel out throughout the year in the same way that
- 17:26sort of Dcos are are approved sort of in a steady flow
- 17:30through? Yeah, I mean, look, look, I'm,
- 17:31I'm, I'm going to say look, I'm not like I don't have the
- 17:35perfect answer, right. Like I feel like there are there
- 17:37are ways of. Taking you to this day, and
- 17:38you're going to. Come up, go away and write a
- 17:41position paper about how it should be done.
- 17:42But look, I feel like, yes, look, there are ways in which we
- 17:45could be rethinking it, right? Like, and I feel like we are
- 17:48seeing how this is evolving, right, with the government
- 17:50looking at the bid step with, you know, this question around
- 17:52strike prices. Like I feel like things are
- 17:54changing the the allocation rounds should change to reflect
- 17:58these changes. And I feel like, as you say,
- 18:00Ryan, like some ways would be like actually, when companies
- 18:03have the right contract at the right price and they can come to
- 18:06the government and say, God, look, do you know what?
- 18:07I can build something offshore. I don't know Edinburgh for 80
- 18:13lbs a MW hour. How about a 20 year CFD?
- 18:16Can we do a deal like that Should be like, yeah, let's
- 18:19let's let's do negotiations then, right?
- 18:20Like I feel like there are better ways of doing it and.
- 18:23One thing that I thought that kind of that went under the
- 18:25radar a little was that they're changing some of the clearing
- 18:28price structures. So, you know, for a long time
- 18:31that it was the you put in your bids, but everyone gets the same
- 18:34price that they changed that to kind of break it down so that
- 18:39English and Scottish projects would have a different clearing
- 18:41prices. And this has caused some angst,
- 18:45some agitation around around some of the Scottish developers
- 18:49because they point out, well, our transmission charges are a
- 18:52lot more expensive than in the sort of South of England.
- 18:56So we have to put in a, a bid that's higher than theirs that
- 18:59factors in that. But they're getting the same
- 19:02price as us. So they're actually getting this
- 19:03much heftier chunk of profit essentially.
- 19:07So by breaking down the the link between English and Scottish
- 19:10price projects, you know, that sort of dealt with that a
- 19:15little. Now they're talking about
- 19:18different clearing prices depending on where you plug in,
- 19:21which is obviously an issue around transmission charging.
- 19:24Now, I don't know if this is going to assuage any of those
- 19:28concerns from Scottish developers.
- 19:29It feels like it's less helping them and more just meaning that
- 19:32the Southern English projects are not just getting these
- 19:34massive extra bonuses essentially, but the fact that
- 19:38they're, they're really breaking down this clearing price
- 19:41structure that all the projects get the same price does kind of
- 19:44add to what you're saying, Ed, that well, why do we need this
- 19:47option structure then if everyone can essentially start
- 19:49getting a different price based on the individual economics of
- 19:54their project, that people, you know, that the authorities can
- 19:57see their bids. You know, I think maybe we're
- 19:59actually talking about is less, is AR-8 going to build on the
- 20:02success of AR 7? Do we even need another
- 20:06allocation round after this? Do we need AR9?
- 20:08Yeah, I mean, I, I want to, I want to, I want to jump in
- 20:10quickly on, on, on tenuous also because I feel like this is
- 20:13another symptom where like, God, it's like just like it's just
- 20:15grown, right? Like it's just evolved and it
- 20:18started off, you know, maybe being sort of fit for purpose,
- 20:20but clearly it's not working anymore, right?
- 20:22Like it's not sending enough locational signal and it should
- 20:25either be saying, look, God, we're going to put a real
- 20:27premium on like transmission charging from Scotland to be
- 20:30like, actually there is a challenge around where is demand
- 20:33or they should be, you know, sort of incentivizing the kind
- 20:36of the build out of Scottish renewables and throwing a lot
- 20:39more money into the grid to tackle that challenge.
- 20:41At the moment it's kind of neither fish nor fowl, right?
- 20:43Like we nobody knows what's going on year to year on 10 US
- 20:46charges. And it just like this is no way
- 20:48to run a blooming electricity. System.
- 20:50And before we go, I think it's worth bringing up deep water
- 20:53wind. So the floating offshore wind
- 20:57has basically been joined in its pot by its sort of hybrid
- 21:01friend, deep water wind. This is specific foundation in
- 21:05specific water depth. There's kind of the intermediary
- 21:07between where fixed bottom stops being feasible, but not quite
- 21:13into the kind of insane depth that floating offshore wind can
- 21:16operate in. Now this is probably me, you
- 21:19know, a bit of a mere call, but when I learned about this, it
- 21:22felt like it was going to be floating offshore winds and it's
- 21:25plus ones, you know, it's little little sort of friends that
- 21:28nobody really cares about. I think I was wrong.
- 21:31We've had people coming in going deep water wind, I think is
- 21:34going to be a much bigger opportunity than than floating
- 21:39offshore winds. So for example, we saw two
- 21:41companies, can't remember exactly who they are.
- 21:43It was, it was Wood Fillstead and Copenhagen Offshore Wind
- 21:48offshore partners. They've created a new venture
- 21:51specifically targeting deep water wind.
- 21:55So this might create an issue for floating wind that
- 22:01essentially you've almost like percent putting in with a
- 22:05competitor that might be eating it's lunch a little bit.
- 22:08And again, offshore or catapult, they came out and said, look,
- 22:13maybe it's not a good idea putting them in together that
- 22:15they're essentially in very different places in terms of
- 22:19technological feasibility. You know, floating winds a
- 22:21little bit further along in its development, whereas you know
- 22:25the proponents of deepwater wind have been pointing out, well
- 22:29actually is going to be easier to roll out because it makes
- 22:32much better use of existing supply chains and resources.
- 22:35I feel like in a way like it, it's, it's kind of going to be
- 22:40tackling floating wind. No, like, I mean, I think I feel
- 22:43like floating wind is going to be much more expensive than
- 22:45something that's, you know, sort of slightly maybe like there's
- 22:47like a bit of an innovation risk, but I feel like.
- 22:51Well, that's because because you've got higher sort of
- 22:54component costs with with when you've got with floating when
- 22:57you've got sort of more, I think you've also got an issue with
- 23:00them UK ports, right? You know, there's only a finite
- 23:03amount that can get house floating wind farms, but you
- 23:07know, when it comes to air floating wind turbines, but when
- 23:09it comes to deep water, when from my understanding at least,
- 23:12it's much easier to roll out from UK ports, which would imply
- 23:16that it's maybe a little bit easier to deliver here.
- 23:19But sorry, I jumped. From what I've seen of the
- 23:21diagrams of some of the sort of deep water foundations is almost
- 23:26essentially, if you can handle a monopole, which we know a lot of
- 23:30ports can, you can handle these as opposed to these massive
- 23:33floaters, which are essentially almost like a sort of small ship
- 23:37or more comparable to an oil rig.
- 23:39Yeah, it's. Going to be super interesting,
- 23:40isn't it? See actually who comes out
- 23:42ahead, right? Like you can see sort of, you
- 23:44know, like floating wind is maybe look a bit further down
- 23:46the road, but like the, the kind of the the kind of cost
- 23:49competitiveness of this table to win is is going to be the the
- 23:52key thing. So look, I think it could go
- 23:53either way, but I feel like actually making them compete for
- 23:56the same pot of money, right, for the same price, that's going
- 23:58to be the challenge. Well, I mean, this week we, I
- 24:00think we saw pretty much the last of the underdog competitors
- 24:04in the World Cup get knocked out.
- 24:05So is this our new underdog? Is this what we're going to be
- 24:08looking at with bated breath going, oh, can they do it?
- 24:10Is it deep wind? Who knows, Maybe it's something
- 24:13to keep an eye out for, but that does it for this segment.
- 24:16Thank you for thank you for providing your insights there.
- 24:19Michael was a really interesting chat and stick around because
- 24:22after this break we'll be speaking about decomp in the
- 24:24North Sea. Hey guys, guess what?
- 24:26What is it, Erica? Energy Voice is on WhatsApp.
- 24:30Is that what's been making my phone buzz all?
- 24:31Day it really is. I mean, I can't stop buzzing
- 24:35about this. It's a great way to get the
- 24:37latest updates from Energy Voice because any time the latest
- 24:42story hits the site, it's out on WhatsApp and then you get to
- 24:46find out what's going on. And that makes a lot of sense
- 24:48because I mean, let's face it, that's how everyone shares their
- 24:51newses. And you text it to your pals,
- 24:52you WhatsApp it to your pals. So your pals are energy always
- 24:55making sure that they're whatsapping.
- 24:57You with the latest headlines. So decommissioning it's, it's
- 25:01been one of those things that's been speaking, spoken about is
- 25:03this sort of prize on the horizon for North Sea supply
- 25:07chain firms for, for some time now, but it's, it never seems to
- 25:12actually deliver. You know, I remember, was it
- 25:15offshore Europe? And was that last year we had,
- 25:19we had the, the founder of well safe solutions sort of standing
- 25:23up and going well, hold on a minute.
- 25:24I, you know, started this, I started this company, this rig
- 25:29operator that's, that's entirely focused on decommissioning
- 25:33because we were told there was this opportunity on the horizon.
- 25:37Then it's, it's not really happening and, you know,
- 25:40liabilities being pushed to the side and so on and so forth.
- 25:44And we've seen, you know, the Nstas are the moan developers
- 25:48are operators pushing back their pushing back their liabilities.
- 25:54And you know, that resulted in that's resulted in fines and
- 25:58naming and shaming from the regulator.
- 26:01But this week felt like there was there was a lot happening in
- 26:05decommissioning. So it raises the question for me
- 26:07as which is, you know, have we crested that hell is the
- 26:14decommissioning, you know, opportunity no longer on the
- 26:17horizon, but actually here And it's, you know, for context,
- 26:22we've had well safe solutions bag the bag a second contract
- 26:28Apache after it secured work to to decommission the the
- 26:34legendary. There's a fairway to describe
- 26:36the 40s field. It also got another household
- 26:40name for anyone who keeps tabs in the North Sea.
- 26:42The the barrel field is also being decommissioned and it's
- 26:46partnered up with with Archer and the Aberdeen based NMC
- 26:52energy as well for that that second one.
- 26:56We've also this week seen that Alfie Sheen, Alfie Sheen, sorry,
- 27:02the founder of Ace Winches, who people may know from that saga
- 27:06in which he sold his company to Balmoral and then the court
- 27:10case, he ended up taking it back and then sold it to Ashtead.
- 27:13Later he started a new company all focused on decommissioning
- 27:18as well. So my question to to my my
- 27:22esteemed colleagues is, has decommissioning finally arrived?
- 27:27I mean, look it, it always feels like it's a risky move to say
- 27:32yes, but it does feel like actually this is kind of like a
- 27:35big move, doesn't it? Like, I mean, look, so look at
- 27:37looking well, safe, you know, for a moment, right?
- 27:40They had three rigs, didn't they parked, parked for a while.
- 27:43And that was obviously like a real challenge.
- 27:46And to actually now they're all in in action, I think.
- 27:50And that's that. I mean, that feels like a big
- 27:52step, right? To to be actually like God, like
- 27:54a company just solely focused on decommissioning, like to be
- 27:58actually, how do you move ahead with this?
- 27:59And suddenly they're all going right.
- 28:01Like I feel like there is there is something changing.
- 28:03But I mean, just to turn it around, Ryan, what has, what has
- 28:07changed? There's made companies think, oh
- 28:09God, that's enough. We're going to actually start
- 28:11doing this work, right. They've been putting it off and
- 28:13putting it off and putting it off for years.
- 28:14As you say, the NSDA has been increasingly touchy about it.
- 28:17Is it just a case of the the regulator being sufficiently
- 28:19touchy that companies can no longer ignore it, or is there
- 28:22something else? You know, I think it could just
- 28:24be that, if I'm honest, because I was thinking about it this
- 28:26morning and I think it might just be the regulator and it has
- 28:29become a bit of a pet project of, of the regulator to sort of,
- 28:34you know, ham up their importance on decommissioning.
- 28:37I say ham up. It's a very important thing.
- 28:39And you know, when, when you're awarded a license, it comes with
- 28:42the agreement that you will responsibly get rid of, get rid
- 28:46of these, this infrastructure in the North Sea.
- 28:50And, you know, earlier this year we saw the NSTA fine inquest,
- 28:53£16.5 million on a slow decommissioning.
- 28:58And you know, I mean, I, I did, I remember Tom Baxter, a
- 29:04columnist of ours and, you know, academic from Aberdeen
- 29:08University, he's got a background in, in the industry
- 29:11as well, but he, he kind of questioned whether this 16.5
- 29:15million was just a now the cost of doing business going, oh,
- 29:18well, it's, it's not that much in the grand scheme of things
- 29:21when you look at the expenses of a decommissioning contract.
- 29:25So maybe it was more the the Nstas move to a certain name and
- 29:31shame that if you remember, they were sort of threatening to do
- 29:35that for forever and they and they ended up doing it in
- 29:41December last year where they identified 153 inactive wells
- 29:47that were out of consent. They pointed to Neo.
- 29:50It was at the time Neonix energy.
- 29:52Now Neonix plus inquest was obviously there at Ithaca Cerica
- 29:58Cenoch. You know, there's there's a list
- 30:01of folks that were that we're sort of behind and that's our
- 30:06highlighted the scale of the problem.
- 30:08This week. I was speaking to a blue ocean
- 30:10decon that that new firm that I mentioned that Alfie Cheaton
- 30:13started. I was speaking to their managing
- 30:15director, Ross Anderson, and you know, I was speaking to him
- 30:19about, you know, is is now the right time to get into the North
- 30:22Sea? Is now the right time to do it?
- 30:24And he said that he definitely sees an opportunity now.
- 30:27Obviously he's just starting a business, you know, so focus
- 30:31entirely on D com. So you would assume that he
- 30:34would say yes, however he was. He did kind of mention that
- 30:38there's like it's a handful of areas that he's looking at
- 30:41regions he's looking at the Middle East being one of them.
- 30:44The North Sea, Asia and Australia are the sort of the,
- 30:48the main, main target regions. And he was saying that really
- 30:52he, he feels like they'll probably build up a portfolio of
- 30:55work in the Middle East and Asia outside essentially all the
- 30:58regions outside the North Sea to then be able to move into the
- 31:02North Sea and say, look, we have a proven track record we can
- 31:05deliver. So I think that that's, you
- 31:09know, that that was kind of his justification for why maybe
- 31:12they, you won't see a glut of North Sea contracts being
- 31:15delivered for him just now. But then that raises another
- 31:19question around is, is that an opportunity within the, the
- 31:23supply chain? We've seen reports in the past
- 31:25is suggesting that, you know, decommissioning could deliver to
- 31:3125 to the 25,000 jobs, sorry in the UK about £15.8 billion.
- 31:40Is, is there a worry that, you know, firms setting up in the UK
- 31:45need to sort of go overseas to earn their stripes before they
- 31:49go here? I don't know, that's maybe
- 31:50another, another thing that could delay things.
- 31:53But what do you guys think of that?
- 31:55Do you think that the UK standard is too high perhaps?
- 31:58Or are we? Are we just right?
- 32:02Yeah, look, I think look, it's, it's a global market, isn't it,
- 32:04right. And it feels like as a company,
- 32:07you've got to think about where the activity is.
- 32:09And clearly the UK has been challenged over the last few
- 32:12years for various reasons, including, of course, right,
- 32:15like the windfall tax and the sort of the hostile regulatory
- 32:18environment. So it it makes sense to actually
- 32:21just be like, oh, look, you know, we are mobile, we can go,
- 32:25we can go other places and other places are doing, you know what
- 32:28I mean? Like, you know, I was taking a
- 32:29look at Australia a couple weeks ago and the, the kind of the
- 32:32pace and the speed at which, you know, kind of things are
- 32:34happening. You can see, look clearly there.
- 32:36There is, there is, there is, there are opportunities that you
- 32:39can, you can pursue there. And it feels like why not,
- 32:42right? Like, why not like, you know,
- 32:44kind of encourage that and, and then be the beneficiaries of
- 32:46that, right in the UK and North Sea, right?
- 32:48We don't, I feel like there's a sort of a slight sort of
- 32:51arrogance about like, oh, we've got to be kind of like a kind of
- 32:53a global leader in this. Like, why?
- 32:55Like we let's, let's, let's, let's see what we can do.
- 32:57Let's, let's, let's try and benefit from expertise gained in
- 33:00other places. Let's you know, kind of, you
- 33:02know, I, I, I think there's, there's a challenge there around
- 33:05kind of contracting and the sort of the pipeline of, of
- 33:07contracts, isn't it right. Obviously with decommissioning,
- 33:10you want to keep the costs low. So it'd be more efficient in
- 33:13many ways to kind of keep assets in the North Sea ticking over,
- 33:17doing like multi operator contracts and you know, kind of
- 33:20really kind of squeezing those margins.
- 33:22But that's clear that that model is clearly challenged.
- 33:25And so in the meantime, yeah, go to, you know, go to Australia,
- 33:28go to the Middle East, go and go and find the activity.
- 33:31Go and, you know, get this expertise and then come back I.
- 33:34Think that's it. And yeah, we we've touched on
- 33:36the the sort of scale of the opportunity here and you know,
- 33:39for, for the North Sea. But yeah, I mean, it's not just
- 33:42the North Sea that has assets offshore, you know, it, it's
- 33:47yeah, WA I've sort of seen many times over the years sort of ads
- 33:54and, you know, the Western Australian government saying why
- 33:56don't you come here and, and work with us?
- 33:58And we, we see firms based out of Peterhead in the North Sea
- 34:02are in in Aberdeen, just off Aberdeen.
- 34:04So are going well, let's let's you know, let's work with them,
- 34:08you know, so it's definitely, definitely an appealing market
- 34:12to move to and sort of like whenever you speak to auk firm
- 34:16that's doing that, they do. So I still champion that world
- 34:19leading angle and say, oh, well, we've, you know, we've learned
- 34:22our we've earned our stripes in the North Sea.
- 34:24Now we're going to move, move into other regions.
- 34:28Feels like, you know, blue ocean decoms kind of doing the other
- 34:31way around, which I'll be interesting to see.
- 34:33But Alfie Chien does have a a sort of proven track record of
- 34:38delivering, delivering large firms in the North Seas are
- 34:42seeing success within that market.
- 34:44So we'll see how it goes. But you know, if you're
- 34:47listening to this and you're going, you know, I think that
- 34:50the decommissioning opportunity is still not here or you're
- 34:52thinking, you know what? It's it's finally arrived.
- 34:55Let us know because you can tell us on our social media
- 34:57platforms. You can find us on LinkedIn,
- 35:00Facebook, Blue Sky, Twitter, even read it if you fancy.
- 35:04And yeah, let us know what you have to say.
- 35:07And that wraps up this weeks episode.
- 35:10Michael, Ed, thank you very much for joining me and thank you
- 35:14very much for listening. If you want to hear more from
- 35:16us, while you can find us the same time, same place next week.