Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 11 - Why The Best Ops Leaders Know When To Trust Their Instincts
Transcript
- Keith: Hi everyone, episode 11. Last week we had a bit of a reflective episode as it was our 10 episode anniversary. We did a lot of reflection on the podcast we've recorded so far. It got us talking a little bit about reflecting on the 25 plus 30 years we've both been involved in supply chain. Dan Culverhouse: Yes. Keith: and it was fascinating the decisions we had to make back then versus the decisions you have to make now and we thought what's changed what's the same what skills have we taken with us along the years and it's incomparable I remember as a courier. You know the decisions I had to make every day as head guru were very much around This is our workload How are we going to get it done? With the number of people we have to the best of my abilities based on my muscle memory almost my knowledge of London What's a reasonable amount of drops for and collections for each person to do there was no math It was just me going, okay, it looks about even but that one takes an hour that one takes and I'd make it even I used to get therapy complaints from from the couriers are you giving me an overloaded run this afternoon? Yeah, but Sorry, but I mean someone had to do it. It was in your area. Now these decisions that you wouldn't have to make them at all. They would be optimized Dan Culverhouse: Expecting too much. Keith: by one of the many apps or platforms out there. Now it's a completely different game, know. Now that drop density is so important and everyone expects deliveries as and when they want them. I mean, what about you? You started in Tesco, I mean, massive warehouse. Dan Culverhouse: Even before that I was I was with a warehouse that supplied Marks and Spencer's. I guess similar. Big big warehouse. it it's very funny to to to to think back and it's almost scary to think how basic it was. So when I was first in warehousing, when I was first working in a warehouse, picking and supervising, So the orders would come through on some kind of computer system and I couldn't even tell you what it was, but they kind of came down overnight. There was some kind of batch process and they would print out on a printer. So we just get all these sheets, almost A3 sheets of paper. Remember the lined, the sort of blue and white lined paper? So they would just all print out. So you just come in and they'd just be big wedge of paper. Keith: Now paper. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: because we had no warehouse management system. The stock was managed on stock cards. So literally every SKU, every item had a card in like a rotordex type thing, like a stack of cards, all written in pencil on it. So at the top you'd have the the product number and a description. Literally it's just a long list of take that palette from that location and put it there. Take that one there. Or all manually written out, worked out in my head by going through the stock card, rubbing out that palette because that one's going to be used and adding it to the pick slot. and then you basically rip up all of the orders into individual orders and everyone would go out and Just walk around the warehouse On all of the orders, you had to write down where the pick slot was. So you'd have to write down so that's AA123, that's A B. So the the guys could walk round and and but what you found was everybody just knew where they were. You know, you could have there was probably a more than a thousand products in the range that we used to pick in that. And and you when they got to Tesco, it was many hundreds, many thousands. But people just knew where stuff was because they did it every day and they could go around and they knew it, they knew the product numbers. As soon as they knew the product numbers, they knew what the product was and they knew where it was kept in the warehouse. So they were it was incredible that the the things that people carried around in their head. but basically, yeah, so you do all that, that picking, and and then you know, at the end of the day you had to go back through and make all the amendments to the stock cards. Keith: guess it was part of the training wasn't it? Dan Culverhouse: To say, right, we picked thirty out of that. and so at the end of the day the stock cars were, we hoped, accurate to what we had actually done. But it was all done on cards and pieces of paper and and pencils. No no systems whatsoever. You know, and that's mind blowing, but Keith: So yeah, the training must have been based around memorizing locations. So what made somebody good? Because I'm thinking back as being a courier, you know, everyone aimed for the title super courier and obviously, you know, knowing the A to Z was a big part of my role. So being good with maps, thinking on my feet, being quite personable because I work out. get to know everyone, work out what to do, know how to get to the the front of the queue. I could organise people quite well, I could motivate people quite well, I spent a long time every day photocopying documents, building files, writing routes, and it sounds like you spent a lot of your day deciphering these big A3 sheets. Did you think back in those days, like the person who could decipher that information was seen as a good leader rather than the people on the floor? Do you think skills have changed somehow? Dan Culverhouse: I think people, it was just honestly, it was just the way things were done. I don't know that anyone was particularly impressed by it. It was just that's what that was like their job. Their job was to interpret or my job was to interpret all of that and prepare it. Most of the time actually you used to moan at them because you didn't like what they gave you or they got it wrong. They made a mistake and we got there and there was nothing there or that's not the right product or We've run out of this. So most of the time you just bloody criticized them and and and thought they were doing an awful job. Even though actually when you think about what they were doing, it was really complicated and and needed real attention to do it without making an error. Whereas today, right, you just press a button and ping, it's it's all done and it's all done perfectly accurately. and and so I think that what is impressive was that attention to detail, that focus. and because generally the stock Keith: Yes, I had the same experience, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: was more or less right. You know, I mean yeah, you didn't always pick up errors as quick as possible, but as we would today, but, you know, it worked. I think people's minds were effectively programmed differently because you you never had the tools to help you. It's a bit like before there was a calculator. Everybody was incredibly good at mental arithmetic. And once you've got a calculator, no no one does it anymore. No one can add it up in their head anymore very quickly. Or very few people can. And all these things just you lose the ability when you don't do it. But because you had no other tools, you had a remarkable ability to remember locations of where stock is. Keith: It was a skill we learnt because we needed to learn it, yeah. No, no, I think that's a good point. Dan Culverhouse: you he saw a product number and you knew what that product was. And I mean it's just insane what you used to be able to remember. I mean, you used to remember everybody's phone number, right? Before my mobile phones you used to remember everybody's phone number. Keith: did, yeah of course we did but... Exactly. But you know it's like your brain is stored with disinformation. I guess that's part of the point of what we were we were talking about. what information have we retained and what have we discarded? And I think as managers, I think we'll keep returning to this point, you do need to retain as a leader some of that awareness. I think we'll get to that later on. That instinct that because we both have a shared shared passion for being on the floor. You need that instinct to know what's happening. yes, certainly there's a lot of information talking about it. Our memory's a bit rusty because we've had to discard a lot of information. But you know, we're not here to do a history lesson. We're talking about how our decision-making changed as our careers evolved and are quite long careers. Dan Culverhouse: Some longer than others. Keith: And how as leaders we became some, you know, completely different? Were we the same? Are we the same? I think we're the same people. But what are some of the leadership skills that we no longer have to, or people no longer possess because they don't have to? So I think we start with pre-internet. We both started pre-internet. Some people might, well, I don't think anyone would be surprised at that, but we started pre-mobile phone pre-internet. Dan Culverhouse: Mm-hmm. Keith: We had walkie-talkies and we thought they were pretty good but you know using them while driving it mean that it's crazy and no room optimisation so it was before you ever had that efficiency of fuel I mean we must have been spending a fortune on fuel but let's start with an order coming in I guess before Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah, they were pretty cool. Well it wasn't that expensive then. Keith: dashboards and when everything was paper-based we had to trust the information that came to us the phone call the facts or even before the facts the memo we had to trust it didn't we Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I think so We weren't markets and spenses, we were a supplier to them. So there was an exchange between companies when you when you dispatch the goods. And what and the thing that I really remember is of course you you do all that picking and I've described the very manual nature of the picking. you know, and you'd stack them up, you'd stretch wrap it, load up those twenty pallets, and we would basically just have a form and we would just fill out the form. So you got, you know, fifty cases of this product number, 40 cases of that and he just listed it out and it was the store number, you know, it was the bath store, so it was O three four five the store, the store number. I don't know if that actually is what it is. I'm not that good at remembering. But you would always remember what the store numbers were. So I'm going to bath, it's this store. And basically that was the dispatch note. You just hand wrote it out. And then, you know, we used to photocopy it because the The lady in the office needed a copy of it so she could type out the invoice. And so she would take that and she would type that out into an invoice with all the prices on it and post it to the store. So the delivery would go with a handwritten delivery note and they would then type out an invoice of right, this is what the it cost. And you know, then they they would send that to the to the store via the post. And of course you get paid like a month. Keith: So had to trust the post. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, you d you just so you sent the product, you sent the invoice separately in the post. and and and then then at some point you would get paid for it. and I'm guessing in those days would you get generally paid for with a check. Like they would post a check back to you and somebody have to go to the bank and bank it. You know, 'cause I don't think there was backs payments in those days. so th there was a serious amount of trust. I mean, you were sending whole truckloads of stock any record really, just a handwritten note and an invoice that went by the post. Keith: Now, talking about it, it's obvious why these efficiencies were developed. The amount of waiting and hoping... One of my young memories, my mum used to deliver parcels with Gratin. Do you remember Gratin? She used to receive a delivery in a truck... Dan Culverhouse: Mm-hmm. I do. Keith: in our house in the street and they would unload the parcels in a big sack that they'd obviously sorted into her zone and then very much like me as the fleet manager, her head courier, she would have to sort these out into order, put them in the back of the car and remember and constantly check of course that she was delivering the right order sometimes it'd be I should have done that I should have done that first that I can't believe I've got to go all the way back there I forgot this one but generally she was quite efficient and she enjoyed doing that but just think of the whole supply chain here people would get a catalogue see something they liked send send in a post from the catalogue the order form Dan Culverhouse: I used to love looking through those catalogues. Keith: I assumed there were multiple order forms in memory, but I can't remember. And then you would trust that that order would reach the depot. The depot would pick it, sort it, send it to the individual driver, members of public like my mum, who would then deliver it to you. And it probably took a couple of weeks minimum, 28 days rather. Dan Culverhouse: East, yeah. But but you know what's amazing about that? When you when you when you describe it and then you think, Well, the kind of is exactly the same as what happens now, but there are just steps in it that are most of it is instant and, you know, electronically sent. But effectively you still you know, you make an order online, it goes in, it gets picked. I mean the payment is all automatic, of course. Keith: Yeah, just longer. Dan Culverhouse: that just speed It's even less than twenty-eight hours, right? Quite often it's within the same day, twelve hours, five hours, six hours later, from ordering it online to someone knocking on your door and giving it to you. And that's a pretty remarkable stat of change. But the process is effectively the same. There's just lots of tools that have speeded it up and made it more accurate and made it more efficient. But actually the process that you're going through is not changed. Really, not really. Keith: Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, I'm wondering what managers biggest pressure was back then. I'm thinking of when the internet came, fraud was exposed or enabled, maybe enabled is the word and therefore it became a bigger problem. I'm assuming fraud was always a problem, but it wouldn't have been keeping the manager up at night maybe in the catalog days. Dan Culverhouse: Certainly feared. For sure. My impression, my memory is the pressure was less. I think the pressure was less. You know, I think you knew less. Yeah, so you weren't carrying as much shall we say performance data around with you. you saw much less. It was much more simplistic. I don't think there was this drive for speed. Keith: We'd have to cast our mind back. What would have been their biggest pressures? Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Right. You know, you you talk about the mail order being twenty eight days, but no one thought that was unreasonable. I worked in organized retail and you would get the order come through in the morning, you know, you'd pick it during that day and it would be loaded at night and would be delivered at some point the following day. within so within forty eight hours, it's pretty quick. But that's a very organized closed, you know, DC to store. It's not nowhere near as complex as a as a direct to consumer order. Keith: people's expectations were... Well, it wasn't such a thing, was there? Because you would go to the store or you would have your parcel delivered by the driver that you'd ordered in from the catalogue or you'd go to Argos. So when you talking about performance data there, do you think that we had a lot less customer data as well? So therefore there was a lot less, where is my order type stuff? Dan Culverhouse: There was there was some, but it's I think the pressure was less because I think there was Yeah. Keith: because you just go to the shop or you would get your parcel delivered. we know what changed customers' expectation around speed and convenience. We'll get to that. But do you think that the data wasn't assessed and therefore less of a pressure because it wasn't there and the customers just had less course to complain? Dan Culverhouse: the expectations of consumers, you know, probably stayed relatively static for quite a long period of time until certain technologies and innovations changed it. let's just keep it to direct to consumer for now, right? When you first started direct to consumer, it was processed, it was picked, it was a twenty eight day process, right? No one thought that was outrageous, that was just what it was. And the fact that you could have it delivered to your home was a big thing. And and I don't think that there was necessarily while that was happening, a pressure that we need to make this faster but I think what happened was there were certain technologies that came in, not necessarily for that purpose, but enabled something to change. you could go into the bank and just pay something and change it over, or you can send an order on an electronic mail, you know, through the internet. the internet wasn't invented for retail, right? it created an opportunity which drove a massive change in expectations, you know, because someone said, You know what? you can look at your catalogue on the screen. You can click on what you want and I will know within five minutes that that's what your order is. And then so I can deliver it to you this week. Suddenly 28 days to this week would have been like, wow, brilliant. You know, but it took somebody to innovate that using the technology that had become available. Keith: I remember the early days, the dot com bubble, the initial formative websites like Myspace. online shopping didn't catch on immediately? It certainly didn't. Dan Culverhouse: a major trust issue right to begin with. I mean who who in early days would have felt comfortable to put a credit card number into an into an internet order? It was like, no way. I think the online payment was a second phase of you could place the order on the internet, but you used to still do something separate. Keith: Well, the banking technology had to adapt. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: And then of course, fraud became an industry. And then of course, cyber security became an industry. it built and built and built. But obviously I was there for the early days, we had to build our own order management system, warehouse management system, because there was nothing designed for it. it became like a Jenga board, it was, it did what we needed it to do because obviously massive pallet warehouses switching to individual orders. We were in house as well. I mean, we had everything in house at the beginning. Innovation always drives improvements, it really moved fast from there. And when done, and Netiputte, the champion of proving you could get fine fashion to women anywhere in the world within a couple of days. Yeah, everyone followed, everyone wanted to sell online. Dan Culverhouse: during this time I was working for a predominantly food retail business in Tesco. yes, they had a a a growing non food side to the business which the internet really drove hard. but initially the internet orders for Tesco were food, right? you know, which was a very Yeah, kinda guess interesting journey. The convenience factor was huge, like that. Someone's gonna pick your shopping for you and bring it to your house, fantastic. You know, it was really popular. But what people weren't willing to do was pay a lot for that. You know, they weren't willing to pay for that person to go around the shop and and pick it, and then pay for the delivery, you know, and of course all the supermarkets were starting to do this. And I remember there were these two distinct approaches. So there was start building effectively what we you would call a dark store or start picking in your you know separate apart your warehouse where you would lay out all the order so you could pick individual items. Really expensive, took up loads of space. you know, it cost. so it's like a whole separate warehouse was being set up just to do these orders. and of course you couldn't be too far from the customer because you know you couldn't travel too far with these little orders. And then what Tesco did, which at the time was really kind of set them apart and really allowed them to accelerate this really fast and make money from it. was that they used the stores to pick. So instead of instead of trying to pick, you know, these orders in warehouses to go directly, they used to allow the supply chain to stay exactly as it was. You replenished the store, but they used to pick the orders in the store in the evening or at night when there's nobody in the store. So the stores were the warehouse for the direct to consumer, which made it very cost efficient. somebody made a very, very smart decision to utilize the store as the warehouse for for dot com. Keith: a key word you used there was decision. How does the supply chain leaders decision making process and their focus change at that point? Did you become less of a trust or process oriented leader to more of a data and innovation based leader? Is that what happened? Is that what happened to us without us realizing? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. I don't know who made that decision, but they're a hero. Keith: Obviously you would look at leaders around you, wouldn't you, and think, he's a stick in the mud. they don't like change. And it was certainly a time of change. And I think that to embrace that change allowed you to be. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. And you get these sliding doors moments where you can see you've got this, you know, this sudden this new demand or changing demand where people want you to deliver it to home. That's a really expensive process. And you, you know, they've got these you got to make a decision. How am I approaching this? and I don't know who made that decision in Tesco, but that what's that? 20 plus years ago now that started? That is still how it's done. You go Tesco any day now and you see dot com workers picking orders in the store. So that that model has lasted a long time and it's I it saved Tesco a fortune in investment but you know, if nobody had made that decision and everyone had gone down the other road, it still would have happened, I think, but it would have happened a lot slower because the cost And the investment needed to set yourself up to have these separate places to do e-commerce orders when they weren't that common at that time was would you know would have been an extremely difficult business case to to sell. But so you know you've got these technology innovations that come, then you've got these people who see how you can adopt that to drive new demand or change shopping behavior and things like that, and then you've got these really smart people in the background that just See these opportunities on how to do this efficiently and effectively. And yeah, and it transforms, you know, the speed of adoption, the speed of of delivery, you know, and of course we can't go too far down this journey without talking about the game changer, the innovator of all things retail. Keith: and was happening alongside this, yeah, Amazon. absolutely miles ahead and... To some degree they still are in many ways. But yeah, this is where people's expectations really started changing because the whole ethos was built around convenience. How much are we prepared to pay for convenience and speed? And then that became the benchmark. on it, obviously early innovators, let's put it early innovators, we obviously had a completely different goal. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. Keith: But you couldn't ignore it because that influenced shopping habits. I mean that's what people wanted. We then had to provide the same day service. That was down to my bus, Steve. That's a shout out for Steve. You know, it's not like there were no hurdles. It's an investment. All these drivers that went out, had the uniform was great, the experience was great. It was a huge generator of wealth for the business. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, maybe yeah. Keith: But there were some real headaches, know, trying to manage this in terms of the fact that customers only really wanted deliveries in the morning or the evening. So you had a lot of peaks and troughs and idle time and strange hours. And, you know, I looked at Paris Premier and all this other stuff. And, yeah, of course, that's where... becomes a headache. finds an opportunity, he's worked in the industry and that's where route optimization came in. But Amazon certainly changed the all of our expectations because how can we go back? I mean I think people are purposefully slowing down in some respects. Some people choosing to slow down, prepare to wait for what they want but Dan Culverhouse: Okay. Keith: If go into a shop and something's not there, many people reach their phone because they know that they're going to get something the very next day and it's not a big deal. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. I I mean when Amazon first really kind of you know, and they didn't only revolutionize retail shopping, they revolutionized, the supply chain behind it as well. you know, i it's what they created. And and you know, it's it's really interesting because I remember back when the Tesco shopping home shopping was starting and that innovation of using the stores so they could do it rapidly and cost effectively right from the beginning. So it didn't lose loads of money while they tried to get it established. Whereas Amazon took a completely different view. They just doesn't matter what it costs. It doesn't matter if we lose in money. I mean Amazon lost money for 10 years, right? They were a multi billion dollar business still losing money. Keith: Mmm. Dan Culverhouse: But still attracting investment because people saw what it was, what it was g what it was growing to. And now it's probably one of the most profitable companies in the world. but so they took this attitude. It doesn't matter if it costs more to do it than it does than we're making right now, because they had a very clear vision of what they were going to achieve. And they just went for it, right? I mean, it's the you have to admire the balls of people sometimes. But Keith: Absolutely. Dan Culverhouse: You know, that they they invested a huge amount of money to completely revolutionise. And they did successfully, did it? You know, we went from three to five days is a perfectly acceptable delivery on for an e-commerce order, to within a couple of years, next day was standard, same day was a premium, you know, and you know, when then we start with prime, I mean it's incredible now. and and if you weren't able to do that, you weren't just considered slow, you were you were considered to be broken compared to, you know, Amazon and you were not gonna survive if you couldn't match what they did. So they shook up the industry. Yeah. Keith: speed and convenience became the product and you either chased the speed or you suffered. I it just became the focus and you know sometimes the pursuit of speed in e-commerce neglected all the other areas. i.e. quality and value. now people try to bring that back, brand awareness and brand reputation and actual quality. And the rules that are being put in place are there to help maintain that quality as well. So it's changing, it's always changing, it's never stopped changing. Dan Culverhouse: So yeah, so I think there's this Amazon has continued to lead and to innovate and to drive how mass retail is done. I mean they they they they rule it, right? And and everybody else kind of follows, really, other than those that very purposefully go down a different path. So, you know, you'll get very much more of the environmental sustainability, quality that now very very loud at saying we're not Amazon. You cannot have this tomorrow. It's gonna take a week. But what you get is a fabulous product that's delivered to you in an environmentally friendly way. Keith: We spoke about leadership and how we had to change and adapt. Or did we? Because originally attention to detail was very important and judgment. Working amongst people, we've had to adapt to be more data oriented, but that still relies on attention to detail. People skills and judgment just in a different framing. And now with the advent of AI, you still need to have that attention to detail. So have we really needed to change or have we do we retain the same skills and apply them? I think we've dropped a lot of information we don't need anymore. But do you think that you have maintained the same skill set? You've adapted it, you've built on it, but Dan Culverhouse: just kind of managed you know, you you managed a lot and things slipped between the s you know, the process wasn't always optimized. What we've what we've developed with the amount of data and insight that we have is the ability to be a specialist. I'm an efficiency specialist. and I can I can look into that and I'll find you every little minute inefficiency and I can you know highlight it to you so you can change it. And so I think that's there's huge power in that, and I think it's a great thing. you know, I don't think we had that. thirty years ago when I was when I was running my first warehouses, it was all really on my shoulders. And you you took some on you missed Keith: I had to become a compliance specialist as we grew. Based on the amount of countries we were shipping to, the import element, the product compliance element, but I had to do that. But I did still retain my generalistic skillset. I always kept involved with multiple stakeholders and I found that comes very... useful when working for startups, being that generalist, but then understanding when the specialist is needed. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. I'm sure there's always been specialists, but it wasn't so prevalent for sure. You know, the generalist ruled, right? If you knew the end to end, you knew Yeah, and and then you overlooked certain things that you didn't really know much about. Keith: No, we were lumped more into the supply chain bracket, you know, manager workforce rather than a little bit different. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. And and and whereas now you have the specialists that can give you that and we have all of the bloody data we would ever need on every nook and cranny of every process so to be able to analyze it to death. and that's all good. I think that's it's all progress. But the danger here, and what you see is more and more people are becoming remote from each other, from operations. So I I I always remember when I first started in you know, in in sort of management and supervising and warehouse, I remember my boss just sharing with me, you know, the way you learn and the way you become the most effective is by walking about. Management by walking about was a real thing where You spent your day out on the shop floor seeing, feeling, you know, understanding, talking to the people that were doing it and looking at understanding problems, seeing issues as they had occurred, and then getting involved and saying, okay, we'll change that, we'll change this. And I think as we become more and more and more data driven and technology and we get insight through our screens, that we become we're getting further and further away from from Keith: People trust the data way more than their instincts. Dan Culverhouse: That instinct and that sense and that team. you know, I'm an operator, right? I've been an operator all my life and I know you when you work in a team when there's a leader of that team and they're they really motivate and inspire and they can kind of encompass this collective belief in getting the job done. matter what the data says. Doesn't matter if it says you've got twenty percent more orders than you can complete in day. A good inspiring aux leader could get everybody singing at the best of their ability and get it over the line. You see a lot less of that now. Now it's kind of like, well the data says this, so you know, you're supposed to pick a hundred and fifty units an hour. You're only picking at 140. Step it up. and and you know, but it's done That's not leadership, that's not operations management, right? It's good insight, it helps to see that you're you're tracking above or you know, it's not that it's bad, but it should not replace that person being out on the floor, seeing it, sensing it, motivating, you know, helping them go in and pick a couple of orders with the guys and Keith: More individualistic, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: you know, make people feel like we're all in this together, we're on a mission to deliver, rather than just having a big countdown clock that says fifty orders to go, 49 orders to go, and or you're you're twenty-two minutes behind the plan, you know, and that that that stuff depresses me enormously. It's good insight, you know. I remember so, you know, if we had to pick I don't know, ten thousand cases in a in a day or in a shift or something, you know, as a supervisor, you'd have your you'd you'd have your your pickers. And you right, well, they can do a hundred each an hour. So I I you know, I want to be able each hour, this is what I want to achieve. And you would go around and you would just, you know, how much do you be done? How much have you done the last hour? Let's have a at your orders, you know, and you just write it down and you would add it up. And then the the guy that was running the whole warehouse would go around and see the supervisors every hour. Say, Okay, so what do you pick this hour? What'd you pick this hour? that's good. What was the problem? You're a bit behind, is there an issue? And you know, it was all a conversation and a sense. Whereas now it's just all electronic, you can sit. the other side of the world and manage a warehouse, you know, manage a warehouse from a data perspective. Yeah. Manage the you but there's this this risk that there's the all this information, all this technology is creating a a lack of teamwork, a lack of collective community spirited action to achieve. Keith: You could think you can manage a warehouse. On the other side of the world. I don't think you can. Dan Culverhouse: You know, it's kind of like the computer says no now. And and that nothing drives me more insane than just saying, Well, we've calculated, we ran it through the model and it says we can't achieve it. So no one even bothers trying, right? And it's like, no, we can. Let's get out there and let's do it. Let's see what we can do. You know, let's just camaraderie kind of you know, and I know I'm getting a bit excited and passionate because I love that about operations when it used to be, guys. We've got a massive job on our hands today. But everybody would be up for it and it'd be like, Yeah, come on, let's do it. You know, it's like Get it all done and I'll buy you a beer or I'll buy you a pizza at the end of the shift. You know, that stuff. You know, that's what Keith: Are you looking back with those Tinti glasses? but people were moaning left, right and centre. I mean, I was calling for these efficiencies. If only I knew how many orders people were picking every hour more accurately. You know, I thought it was a revelation. It's just how you use it, isn't it? There's always that human element and not using things blind, understanding the pressures, involving them in the journey. You hope to free them from the jobs that prohibit their progression. So for me it was, there's pros and cons. It's how you manage it. I do think there's a lot more sort of office-based warehouse experts though, that have never really set foot in the warehouse and don't really understand the motivations of a warehouse team. They forget that element, but that's an opportunity as leaders for us to bring them closer together and improve everybody. Dan Culverhouse: Yes. And and all of these developers all these developments are are are incredible. Like the automation stuff that you can do, it's created, you know, operations that can do way more than they used to be able to do. It's great. But don't believe it replaces good leadership or good management or good instinct motivation. the message I'm always giving to people is automation doesn't replace people, it enhances them. The best automation solutions are a collaboration of man and machine and they they do a lot of the heavy repetitive stuff that hurts people and but it enhances people's abilities. So the type of people that can work in a warehouse has changed, right? It used to be a young, fit, strong person's job. Well yeah that's not necessarily the next the need anymore. Yeah. Keith: It's an enabler. It's an enabler. All of this is an enabler which has always kept me interested. There's always a different side to it though because in that rush to tick a box We didn't know what was to come when we were young. But what did we bet on that was completely wrong? That never happened. mean one that comes to mind is drones. I don't think I did think there'd be drones flying everywhere to be honest. I don't think people really want that. I might be wrong. I might be speaking from personal bias. I'm not really... Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, maybe it will happen one day, but it it's been in it's been out there for a long time and it's not it's not really a realistic prospect. Keith: Been choked about for a long time hasn't it? I mean you get those things in America, the little things that trundle along and people kick them over and put them in the river but... Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Actually there's some there are some in the UK as well. But RFID is a is one that I always remember. When RFID happened, it was going to revolutionize you're gonna have a little chip in everything, right? It would be it'd be made en masse, it would get so cheap that even you know, even a cheap t shirt could have an RFID tag. my memory of it is like so when you know when a pallet of goods enters the warehouse Keith: That's an interesting one. Dan Culverhouse: You pass through an archway, it would read every RFID tag. You instantly received it, and you knew exactly what stock you had. That has never happened. I've never seen that successfully work. And we were talking RFID tags 20 years ago. and and don't get me wrong, RFID tag technology works. But it's still really luxury items and you know, it's never really become the mass. The go-to way, you know, we still receive using barcodes and that. Why is it? Well, I don't think we've ever made that technology to be that consistently reliable to that you can just walk through the door and it just captures everything. It's not consistently managed to do that. and I think it's also creating well, two things. One making it cheap enough. Keith: And why this stuff? Dan Culverhouse: To make it really ineffec in a an inconsequential cost in a in a garment, right? Yeah. So if a garment's expensive enough, it's worth putting it in, but otherwise you wouldn't. but secondly, I think they always struggled with what was the dominant, I don't know what the word is, solution. the best analogy I can do is we all remember when video started and you had VHS and you had Betamax. Keith: Someone's got to apply to tax. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: And there were the two around for a while and then eventually VHS one had become the sole solution. But I think RFID struggled with that. There were a number of different technologies that did it, and not one of them ever became really dominant, in my understanding. somebody might Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: might be listening to this and go, you're full of shit. That absolutely has been fixed and it is there. And I'd be I'd love to hear about it. But in my perspective, that was what stopped it ever becoming the standard. And I always thought that's where it was going. Keith: Me and the luxury world, I've probably seen a little bit more benefit, yeah, but not the mass mass product. Yeah, I get the issues. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, you know, my food background it never became part of food. Keith: Everything can be. Dan Culverhouse: So another way of thinking about this, when you think back, what seemed like that's never gonna be possible but now is just every day. That we just it's just every day. Keith: that everybody would spend hours on their phone and do everything on their phone shop on their phone obviously i saw the possibilities early on because of my fortunate career path but yeah but even when we started you know how social media was going to influence things how you know the very word influences we're going to become so so big and and that's changed and Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. Keith: how generations consume their information and how they went to shop that's changed but you know it just keeps it fresh doesn't it Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. And and in supply chain, come on tell tell me what tech what what's happened in supply chain that that is normal now that you would have thought was a bit impossible thirty years ago. You know, when you if someone said to you thirty years ago same day deliveries is a big one. Keith: you know, change, change and develop and... Well, it's interesting, isn't it? Because I wasn't asking for certain things at the time. And anything I did need, I sort of tried to create myself. I've always had that sort of entrepreneurial, innovative, creative element to me. Dan Culverhouse: Well, there's definitely that. There's there's a lot of things there's a lot of things we have today that you never would have asked for because you just wouldn't have thought of it, right? 'Cause it took a few iterations of changing technology to drive that. you know, one one of the things that I always I think about is is how easy it is to have a personalized item. No, the kind of customization of product. That was a really big deal, you know, where you wanted to have you know, something written on a t shirt. Keith: Yeah, I wouldn't have asked for it, but it's hot. Dan Culverhouse: You know, you would never, you know, kids' birthday parties now, right? You just go and you order twenty T shirts with some ice and it's like you get it tomorrow. But yeah, but that would have been a really big deal. And and you just would never you just wouldn't consider it because it would cost a fortune. you know, whereas now it's just it's just the norm. I guess the other one, you know, just to sort of really sort of geeking out a little bit on supply chain is product level Keith: yeah, place an order. weeks and a vat. Yeah. Moonpick. Dan Culverhouse: demand planning and forecasting. We you know, we used to used to do it at very much at a you know, a a a kind of almost at a warehouse level or a range level. But now it's absolute everything is calculated by product and just built up from there. And I I if you'd have said that to me, I would have thought that was impossible years ago. Keith: I would have loved... I think that always seemed like a realistic dream to me. Things like that. But I've always had it like what would make things easier with... yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, see yeah. For me it was like, Come on, that's ridiculous. We got twenty thousand products in this warehouse, you're gonna plan every single one? That's crazy. Keith: I've always liked to think that as long as the data is there you can get that information quicker. none of the stuff like EAN or anything like that, none of the electronic invoicing, any of that has surprised me because you know if you're living that journey and you're questioning all the long, you're like I'm always asking how can we get rid of this the glorious task. It's always been one of my drivers like this is holding my team back. So yeah, I've always been involved in that sort of stuff. how do we... looking at waste, always looking at waste. So whatever is creating the biggest waste. I don't think people would have anticipated the effect on the high street when they started shopping online. So that's a by-product. That's a by-product. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. No, no. Keith: and of course that effect the related effect on communities etc. It's not simply down to online shopping of course it isn't but I don't think people would I think people would have thought there was a little bit more of a balance and a choice but we all choose convenience that that's definitely changed. Dan Culverhouse: But Yeah, I think people have predicted the end of high street retail, right? I mean it's you know, I I don't think the last time that happened was COVID. to some degree, yeah. It's changed, right? What what the shops you get in the high street are just very different. Yeah. Keith: they have written, they have as it's happened, Not necessarily, well yeah I think you're right actually. Like people now are saying AI is going to take over the world and everyone's jobs. I've always been hopeful it just enhance our jobs but there's always someone saying... Dan Culverhouse: Automation and robotics in warehousing, right? I mean, people have been saying for years, the role of the warehouseman it will die. It won't. I really don't see that happening. So not in the end. You know? of course eventually you'll be able to create a humanoid kind of robot that is cost effective enough to but pfft you know. Keith: No, I haven't been to many pure robot warehouses in my life. Dan Culverhouse: The nuances in in operations, I think. If you haven't worked in operations, you don't really understand the level of nuance and gut instinct that makes operations successful. It's not just data decisions. to conclude we talked a lot about all the changes and how wildly different it has changed in in relatively short period of time. in your mind is it's like what's important for people to recognise? You know, we've talked a lot about it went from this to this and this has changed. What does it matter? What what should people think about and reflect on and consider for the future? You know? Keith: I think we must always retain knowledge and judgement and a feel for what you're doing. I think if you just think it's numbers and it's not people and it's not customers and it's not experience and joy and all the things that come with human behaviour, what's the point? mean the purpose disappears. Dan Culverhouse: Mm. Keith: you're not looking at a supply chain then I think. think like if we're talking about entry-level jobs for example and where they're going from here, we have to maintain even if we certain the British tusks are removed and you know the ones that are holding people back and wasting people's time just not to be too distant. from what's actually happening. think that's where we maintained a whole end-to-end purpose of what we're doing. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Absolutely. I couldn't agree more. And I think, when I started in logistics and supply chain, you very much felt like this was just a backroom, necessary evil, a means to an end. It's just a cost of doing business, right? It was just and that's shifted now. Now I think it's become a game changing opportunities. Keith: Guess the warehouse, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Companies that really embrace their supply chain and and work can create a real differentiator between them and competitors. you know, I think those those that don't find scaling very hard. so I think whereas it was just a cost, you know, and you just accepted that this is what needed to happen. Making an effective, agile supply chain for your business can be the difference between surviving and going bankrupt. It could be the difference between becoming a growing business and one that's just slowly dying. and you know, you've got to create an edge. And I think what you've seen probably in the last 10 years more than anything, is that suddenly supply chain is seen as it can be a real differentiator. Whereas before it was just something that happened. You know, we were just the back room boys, no one cared about it. It was never talked about at board level, right? Never. Whereas now you'll regularly see a chief supply chain officer on a board. it's a part. Keith: and you're seeing a lot more CEOs have had a supply chain background and I'm really glad to see that. think one of the last questions we can put to ourselves is there's still issues we deal with every day. If you could have one game changer innovation that changes the way we do business now in future. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, it it it yeah. Keith: What would it be? I'm going to go first. I would love to crack the returns issue. Dan Culverhouse: Damn it, that was gonna be mine. Keith: What shoes? You have to have something else. Dan Culverhouse: we've got a whole other episode about returns. there's no doubt that there's a lot to talk about there. But yeah, tell us what you mean. What what do we need to fix with returns? Keith: That's for future episodes. So, yeah, but I'd love to crack that. Dan Culverhouse: I still got one. I think our obsession with consumerism will will dilute. I think we're as we move forward as a as a people, as a race, whatever I'm getting a bit philosophical now, I know. But I think that we will become a little bit more balanced I think that returns is very much part of that discussion so my prediction is the environment, sustainability, economics and technology will all start to influence us in a way that we start to become a little bit more balanced in in the what we do, that there won't just be this relentless drive to have things. I think we'll value what we have more because I think they're just gonna become more expensive. So, you know, the quality will become a bigger driver Keith: You trust the quality, et cetera. But we're drifting into three or four different predictions. So I think we can agree that supply chain has changed that's why you have so much to talk about. It's changed so much in our careers, more than a lot of industries. Dan Culverhouse: Revolution might have just Keith: It's had to because with innovation supply chain has to keep up. So it's it's changed more than most industries have And it's only going to get quicker So let's embrace it Dan Culverhouse: However, however, there are some underlying things that will never change. And that is the people. It requires people and instinct and judgment and trust maybe to succeed. You know, I think all the technology in the world, an AI machine will never be able to wander the floor and be able to understand. the motivation of people, there's always gonna be a need for good people to be able to pull it together and get it over the line and leadership and human connection and community will never change in my view. Or I can say is God, I hope they don't anyway. Keith: We'll be back next week, same time. Subscribe, like, share, comment, share your own experiences in the supply chain. We'll see you next week. Dan Culverhouse: Every Thursday we'll be here. Thank you.