Latest / The Vegan Report / Hollywood Has a Vegan Problem | Ep. 121
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, this is Ryan and you're listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. Today we're talking about
- 0:07vegan representation in movies. Basically, how
- 0:10does Hollywood portray us vegans to an audience
- 0:15of millions? Why do movies so often miss the
- 0:19mark, misunderstanding us, or turning us into
- 0:23the butt of the joke? Why do science fiction
- 0:26movies so often imagine the future as vegan?
- 0:31Is Okja a good vegan movie or not? Those are
- 0:35some of the questions we'll be answering today.
- 0:38And by the way, I listed all the movies we referenced
- 0:42in the episode notes, so you now have a solid
- 0:46watch list. To discuss this topic, I have with
- 0:49me Glenn Merzer, a returning guest and fellow
- 0:53podcaster at the helm of the Glenn Merzer show.
- 0:57Glenn knows a thing or two about vegan representation
- 1:01in movies because, beyond being a podcaster,
- 1:05he's also a playwright, screenwriter, and author.
- 1:09He recently wrote and directed a new movie called
- 1:13Buddhist Blues, whose protagonist is vegan. A
- 1:17vegan character created by a vegan writer in
- 1:20a movie directed by a vegan. We had a lot of
- 1:24fun talking about the movie. Go support Glenn
- 1:28by watching Buddhist Blues online at BuddhistBlues
- 1:32.com. Also joining us is another returning guest,
- 1:37Alex Ventimia. Alex is a professor in the Department
- 1:41of English and Film Studies at the University
- 1:44of Alberta. He's also an animal rights activist
- 1:47and serves on the board of egg -truth .org. You
- 1:52may remember Alex from our deep dive into Jurassic
- 1:55Park, which was a lot of fun, and from another
- 1:59episode where we compared Jane Goodall and David
- 2:03Attenborough. You'll find links to both episodes
- 2:06in the show notes. But before we jump in, if
- 2:10you enjoy conversations like this, Don't forget
- 2:14to follow The Vegan Report, leave a review and
- 2:17share the podcast with the vegans you know. It
- 2:21really helps the podcast reach more people. I
- 2:25truly appreciate your support. Thank you. To
- 2:29break the ice, I was wondering, what was the
- 2:32latest movie you've watched and would you recommend
- 2:36it? I think the latest movie I watched was The
- 2:40Sheep Detectives. and I would recommend it. I
- 2:45thought it was a pretty good vegan movie. What
- 2:48was it about? Well, it's a movie with talking
- 2:55sheep, right? So it's, if you will, kind of an
- 3:00animated movie. But there's a message in it about
- 3:08not killing and eating sheep. didn't know that
- 3:13going in. I was pleased to discover that as I
- 3:16was watching. About halfway through, I said to
- 3:18myself, oh, this is a vegan movie. Now, there's
- 3:24a farm there that still shears the sheep's wool.
- 3:30And I know that that's controversial. Sometimes
- 3:34in the animal rights movement, I guess the situation
- 3:38is that Naturally, sheep wouldn't need to be
- 3:43sheared, but because of the way they've been
- 3:45bred, some sheep do need to be shear. So that's
- 3:50a controversy I don't think you need to go into
- 3:52to watch the movie and enjoy it. So, you know,
- 3:58I thought it was pretty good. Thank you, Glenn.
- 4:02Alex. Well, so the last movie I watched was actually
- 4:07remarkably, I'm sorry, well, Buddhist blues.
- 4:11But we're going to talk about that later in the
- 4:14episode. So before that, I think the latest movie
- 4:19I watched that wasn't a rewatch, because I'm
- 4:21constantly rewatching stuff that I like, was
- 4:24actually Remarkably Bright Creatures. So I think
- 4:28most people who listen to your podcast may be
- 4:29familiar with it. It's about an octopus and sort
- 4:34of like the role that the octopus plays. to bring
- 4:38this family back together. I don't want to spoil
- 4:42it beyond that, but it was a brilliant movie.
- 4:46One of the things that I think we've talked about
- 4:48this before that has always sort of concerned
- 4:51me is that when people talk about animal rights
- 4:53or conservation, the focus is primarily on mammals.
- 4:58People talk about sheep, about cows, about lions
- 5:01and tigers and zebras, but not a lot about things
- 5:04like octopuses. I think that's sort of changing
- 5:06nowadays. And this film was kind of like at the
- 5:12forefront of that representational shift, right?
- 5:15We're starting to pay attention to the fact that
- 5:16octopuses are brilliant animals, right? And,
- 5:19you know, not to say that intelligence should
- 5:21be a factor in whether we care about an animal
- 5:23or not, but when it comes to octopuses, I think
- 5:27there's something uncanny about their intelligence
- 5:30that if anybody just paid a little more attention
- 5:32to them, perhaps regardless, As more equal, right?
- 5:37So it was in that sense. It was a brilliant movie.
- 5:39It was a bit cheesy, of course, right? But but
- 5:42but overall, I thought it was great. Amazing.
- 5:46Thank you, Alex. So my first question is, does
- 5:50it matter that we have vegan movies or vegan
- 5:55representation out there in movies and media
- 5:58in general? Does it make a difference? Does it
- 6:03make? make an impact in the culture? Well, I
- 6:06think it does. I mean, I think if you look at
- 6:09the history of the gay rights movement, it gained
- 6:14considerably from representation in the media,
- 6:22sitcoms and talk shows and so forth that portrayed
- 6:30the truth. gay people are just people like everyone
- 6:34else and have the same concerns. And there was
- 6:40growing acceptance more and more gay people were
- 6:45openly gay. And people began to ask why shouldn't
- 6:51gay people have the same right to marry as everyone
- 6:54else. And next thing you know, we had gay marriage
- 6:57in the States, which I went to predict it would
- 6:59have happened so soon. And I really think it's
- 7:02more because of the media than anything else.
- 7:05The politicians were following public sentiment
- 7:10and public sentiment was being shaped by the
- 7:12media. Yeah, I would have to 100 % agree with
- 7:17that. I can sort of extrapolate a little bit
- 7:21because as Glenn just pointed out, the shift,
- 7:26the cultural shift was comparatively speaking,
- 7:32tremendously fast. We went from Barack Obama
- 7:36running on no gay marriage in 2082, the White
- 7:39House died in rainbow colors four, eight years
- 7:42later. And that had a lot to do with the fact
- 7:45that suddenly it was out there. There was gay
- 7:49representation, LGBTQ representation everywhere.
- 7:52And so of course it's important to have more
- 7:57positive representations of, well, I think of
- 8:02animal sentience and animal suffering and the
- 8:06stuff that animals go through, but also the people
- 8:07who represent those values, right? Because I
- 8:11think we're going to talk about this. So maybe
- 8:13I'm not going to get ahead of myself, but by
- 8:15and large, vegan representation in the media
- 8:17is sorely lacking. There is very little of it
- 8:21and whatever is out there is usually not particularly
- 8:24positive. A lot of mocking, a lot of mockery,
- 8:31plenty of characters who make very little sense.
- 8:33And I think that veganism is supposed to be a
- 8:36part of that, right? And so that sort of misrepresentation
- 8:40is an obstacle that needs to be overcome, I think.
- 8:48Glenn, you did make a movie with a vegan team,
- 8:53a strong vegan team. Did you make it out of inspiration
- 9:00or was it an agenda that you had? I really want
- 9:05to give more representation to vegan ideas. Well,
- 9:13the movie Buddhist Blues has a vegan protagonist
- 9:18and he has a girlfriend who's vegetarian and
- 9:23then there are two other characters who are not
- 9:26on our team. So I wrote it first as a stage play
- 9:36and I wrote the play just wanting to tell the
- 9:44story of two Jewish cousins, one of whom has
- 9:49been estranged from the family and living outside
- 9:52of the law, and the other cousin is trying to
- 9:55invite him back into the family. And as I wrote
- 10:01it, and my vegan hero got developed as a character,
- 10:11it became more and more important to me to to
- 10:18show that side of him as being crucial to the
- 10:24story in a sense, even though, even though it's,
- 10:29you know, I don't think anybody would watch the
- 10:31movie and say, oh, it's a movie about veganism,
- 10:34but it's there and it's part of who he is and
- 10:39it's part of why he has trouble fitting into
- 10:43society. And it's part of the conflict between
- 10:47him and his family. And so it just became an
- 10:55important part of the movie. And yet, if you
- 10:58were to do a graph of how many words are in the
- 11:05movie and how many of them are about veganism,
- 11:07it's a small percentage. But it's there and it's
- 11:11important. And it became more important to me
- 11:14as I wrote it and then as I was directing the
- 11:18movie. Alex, do you think we need more people
- 11:24like Glenn who are vegans to make vegan movies?
- 11:29Because we talked about the gay movement. Well,
- 11:31there are plenty of gay artists in the world
- 11:34of cinema, so it's easy to think they would make
- 11:38great gay characters and gay themed movies. But
- 11:43what about veganism? Do we need more Glenn, artists
- 11:48like Glenn in the world of cinema? Yeah, that's
- 11:53a great question. I think it certainly helps.
- 11:56I mean, if if you think about the. Some of the
- 12:04critiques that have been. leverage against some
- 12:07LGBTQ representation in the media about it being
- 12:10unrealistic or not representative of what the
- 12:15LGBTQ experience is. Those criticisms are usually
- 12:20leveraged against people who made films about
- 12:23that community that don't actually belong to
- 12:26it. I think not coming from that experience and
- 12:30trying to represent it, Even if we step aside
- 12:33from questions of whether it's appropriate or
- 12:36what have you, I think there's just a lack of
- 12:42depth, right? Because you only know what you've
- 12:45heard about. You're not a part of it. Glenn,
- 12:48it sounds like you're a part of the community,
- 12:50right? We haven't met before, so I'm just assuming
- 12:51you've made a couple of references. 35 years.
- 12:55There you go. And you're talking about how you're
- 12:59in your So on the film on Buddhist blues, the
- 13:02character mentions that he's vegan and it's relevant
- 13:05to the story, but it's not overt, right? It doesn't
- 13:09take over the narrative, which I think could
- 13:12happen if somebody who's not part of the vegan
- 13:14community tried to make a film about veganism,
- 13:17right? They would misrepresent the character.
- 13:20They would make them flat, right? All about his
- 13:22veganism and he would probably have no other
- 13:25trait, right? But Well, and that happens. That
- 13:29happens all the time, especially on popular media,
- 13:32right? You'll see a black character in a movie
- 13:35that is about African Americans, but the director
- 13:38is not black, and so the hero is reduced to a
- 13:40stereotype, right? This doesn't happen in the
- 13:43movie. This doesn't happen in Buddhist blues.
- 13:45And I think it's because you coming from the
- 13:47community, you know that it doesn't mean that
- 13:50that's who you are. It's a part of you, and it's
- 13:52an important part of you, but it doesn't define
- 13:54you as a human being. And that shines through
- 13:57your film, I think. I was talking to Rayann for
- 14:03a few minutes before you showed up. And I pointed
- 14:05out that I was thoroughly captivated by the dialogue
- 14:09in the film. And now that you mentioned that
- 14:11it was originally a screenplay, right? You said
- 14:13it was supposed to be a play. That makes perfect
- 14:16sense now. Because it's the dialogue that really
- 14:19captivates you, right? And like you said, the
- 14:22veganism of the character doesn't take over is
- 14:26persona, right? But it shines through as a defining
- 14:29factor. And as you mentioned, I think if you
- 14:31make close attention to what's happening and
- 14:32the discussions they're having, you realize that
- 14:34it warms his struggles. And so in that sense,
- 14:38I think we should absolutely have more directors
- 14:41or producers like Len. Well, let me push a bit
- 14:46against that. You think we should have less like
- 14:51that? Well, you know, We're talking about good
- 14:56representation versus bad representation of veganism.
- 15:00Well, wouldn't it be better to have bad representations
- 15:04instead of no representations at all? I feel
- 15:08like even with bad representations of veganism,
- 15:11people would feel a bit more familiar with veganism.
- 15:15It's less strange and maybe that will make them
- 15:20curious and they will go online and look up,
- 15:24you know, what's that veganism all about? What
- 15:28do you make of that? Well, I don't think black
- 15:31people were better off with the step and fetch
- 15:34it early representations that they had in the
- 15:38media. I think I think the quality of the representation
- 15:41you have in the media is important. Yeah, I would
- 15:47have to agree, although I'll say this. So recently
- 15:50I've been watching The Simpsons with my kid,
- 15:53right? Because every now and then, you know,
- 15:54he's six years old, so he doesn't know The Simpsons.
- 15:57He didn't grow up with them. I did. And so sometimes
- 15:59I'll make a joke that references The Simpsons,
- 16:02then it goes over his head. So I got tired of
- 16:03that. OK, that's it. We're going to watch. And
- 16:07we ended up watching the episode on which Lisa
- 16:10becomes a vegetarian. And at the end of that
- 16:14episode, she realizes that she's not alone because
- 16:18Apu is actually not just a vegetarian but a vegan,
- 16:21right? And Lisa says something along the lines
- 16:24of, oh, when will people realize that you can
- 16:26be perfectly happy with salads and this and that
- 16:29and milk and cheese. And Apu says, no way, that's
- 16:33disgusting. Lisa then says, oh, you must think
- 16:36I'm a monster. And Apu says, oh yes, yes, I think
- 16:38you're a monster, right? So that's a misrepresentation
- 16:40of. There's no vegan. I think perhaps there are
- 16:43some vegans who think that way. I think most
- 16:45of us are a little more taller than that. But
- 16:47even that, I think I distinctly remember that
- 16:49being the first time I ever, I even thought about
- 16:53the possibility of not eating eggs and milk and
- 16:56meat. So perhaps there are certain instances
- 16:59on which what we could call bad representations
- 17:04of veganism are perhaps not bad. but more like
- 17:10in a gray area. And in those instances, of course,
- 17:15just being out there, just the fact that it's
- 17:17on screen potentially makes a difference. So
- 17:21yeah, perhaps we shouldn't think of it as a dichotomy.
- 17:24We should think of it as good or bad representations.
- 17:27I think there's more of a gradient. And so yeah,
- 17:30but I also would agree with Glenn that there
- 17:32are some serious mischaracterizations there that
- 17:34are not helping anyone. Glenn, have you had a
- 17:40similar turning point as Alex had, watching something,
- 17:47a movie perhaps, and encountering a vegan character
- 17:52and being just shocked, surprised, or feeling
- 17:57challenged by that? I think you may have stumped
- 18:02me on that one. I don't often watch movies and
- 18:05discover a vegan character. It just isn't mentioned
- 18:11most of the time. And in most American movies,
- 18:17the characters eat like Americans. So I just,
- 18:23I can't remember coming across many vegan characters
- 18:27recently. And so that's part of what I'm proud
- 18:30of with the movie is that it's not only do I
- 18:33have a vegan protagonist, And by the way, it's
- 18:37set in 1993. So he calls himself vegetarian,
- 18:41but he declines the cake because of the milk
- 18:44and the eggs. So I think we could assume he's
- 18:46a vegan. I wanted to talk about that. So I hope
- 18:48we can come back to that because I noted that
- 18:50and I thought it was brilliant, but I want to
- 18:52come back. Thank you. But I've rarely come across
- 19:02you know, vegan characters in cinema. There was
- 19:07a movie called Coffee Wars, which was about a
- 19:11woman who has a vegan coffee shop. But I rarely
- 19:19come across it. And so it was important to me
- 19:25to, you know, kind of bring it bring it forward
- 19:33as son to make the case that vegans are people
- 19:36too and We have some you know in this case. It's
- 19:40a movie about it's a family drama. There are
- 19:43family issues that You know cut across dietary
- 19:48style and But it's central to who the guy is
- 19:56and it's central the fact that he is more sensitive
- 20:01than most of the people around him is kind of
- 20:06central to his problem fitting in in society.
- 20:12OK, one last point about the value of vegan representation
- 20:17in movies. What about the fact that movies are
- 20:25right now losing their cultural power? We have
- 20:28so many content creators on YouTube, on Instagram,
- 20:32and so on. And I feel like people are more focused
- 20:36on that, on social media, instead of watching
- 20:40movies like they used to. And even movies have
- 20:44been kind of diluted in a way. I would go on
- 20:48Prime Video and find a movie featuring, I don't
- 20:52know, Brad Pitt. And I would think, wow. That's
- 20:56a movie with Brad Pitt. How come I never heard
- 20:58about the release of that movie? When I was a
- 21:02kid, I think that type of movie with a rank like
- 21:06actors it would you would hear about it, but
- 21:09not anymore. You have big productions and you
- 21:13find them on streaming services and it's like
- 21:17no cultural momentum around them. And so either
- 21:22are. And there's also AI, of course, that people
- 21:26are predicting that AI will be making all sorts
- 21:29of amazing high quality movies in the future.
- 21:33And so there will be an explosion of movies,
- 21:37TV series, and so on. And so is it that important
- 21:43that lane in terms of cultural importance? Alex,
- 21:51you want to field that one or should I? I'll
- 21:54give it a go, but I want to hear what you have
- 21:56to say. And I think when I last came on the podcast,
- 22:02I mentioned that my research is about documentaries
- 22:10that have to do with environmental issues. And
- 22:13one of them is veganism. I primarily look at
- 22:15things that have to do with biodiversity laws.
- 22:19Because of my background, I think I'm committed
- 22:23to the idea that it matters, right? And I think
- 22:27we can disagree on to what extent it matters
- 22:30to have that sort of representation out there.
- 22:32But I'll put it like this. I think that even
- 22:38though I cannot disagree with the fact that that
- 22:44films and television are changing as media, right?
- 22:48And that change is heavily influenced by social
- 22:51media, because they have to compete with social
- 22:54media. And frankly, I think in some ways they
- 22:57just can't. They can't keep up with the pace
- 23:02of change. But what I'll tell you is that I think,
- 23:08at least, and this is, again, influenced by my
- 23:10background, my demographic and all that stuff,
- 23:12but I... I think that when people get together
- 23:15and talk about what they've watched and what
- 23:17they've done for fun, right? They still talk
- 23:19about movies and shows to some extent, right?
- 23:23And I think that is probably not going to die
- 23:27out as quickly as people would like to predict.
- 23:30Now, what is the goal here, right? Because if
- 23:36we're thinking about how to put the message out
- 23:41there in a way that it makes a difference. Well,
- 23:44then the question becomes, to what extent do
- 23:46you want to make a difference? To what extent
- 23:48is it realistic? If one person watches Lance
- 23:52film and it touches them, well, perhaps the investment
- 23:57seems to not match up to the change that it made,
- 23:59but it made a difference, didn't it? And so whenever
- 24:03you find something like that out there that speaks
- 24:06to you in some way, I think it already made a
- 24:10difference. Now, Should we perhaps not put all
- 24:13of our money on film and television? Yeah, most
- 24:16likely there's got to be stuff out there in social
- 24:18media as well, right? Yeah, so that's what I
- 24:22would say. I think all forms of representation
- 24:24matter. I think film and television are perhaps
- 24:27the old guard now, but it's still current. I'll
- 24:37add that I... participate in different forms
- 24:42of media. I have my own podcast. That's where
- 24:45we met, Ryan. I write books and people say nobody
- 24:51reads books anymore. And I have some royalty
- 24:54statements that will confirm that. But, you know,
- 24:59I write books to try to make the case often on
- 25:02the nutritional side of why it is insane to eat
- 25:07animals instead of eating human food. I have
- 25:11a podcast where I talk with people like yourselves
- 25:14about their journeys to veganism and about other
- 25:18issues. And if I have an idea for a play or a
- 25:23movie, I'm going to write it. And there's more
- 25:28aesthetic satisfaction to making a movie for
- 25:33me than even a good podcast. And so, you know,
- 25:39it's it's, you know, part of being human to want
- 25:43to express yourself. And you always just kind
- 25:46of cross your fingers and hope, well, maybe this
- 25:49book or this movie will strike a chord and somehow
- 25:52break through the noise and get a following.
- 25:56But it's very, very difficult to do. OK, so we
- 26:01talked about how some. of the existing vegan
- 26:06representation out there in movies is very demeaning
- 26:10and not up to the standards that we would want
- 26:16to see. Can you talk more about that? Are we
- 26:22talking about a presentation that is more comical?
- 26:26So basically being vegan is a joke or representing,
- 26:32casting a light on veganism, you know, with the
- 26:37idea that it is a radical thing, a thing reserved
- 26:42for maybe extreme people, extremists, marginal
- 26:48people. So what kind of perspective are we talking
- 26:54about here and why do you think there is that
- 26:58bad representation of vegans and veganism in
- 27:02media. Well, I think the media follows the culture.
- 27:08And I mean, you know, I've heard, you know, for
- 27:14example, there's a Senate race in Texas and the
- 27:18Democrat got attacked by the Republican for being
- 27:21a vegan and he's not even a vegan. So he had
- 27:24to then eat ribs on camera. to prove he's not
- 27:28a vegan. Because if he were a vegan, he probably
- 27:32couldn't get elected senator in Texas. So, you
- 27:38know, that's the culture we're in. And, you know,
- 27:43if you ask me right now to name a movie where
- 27:45I saw vegans represented badly, I don't think
- 27:48I could name one. But I think whenever I've come
- 27:51across it, that's what it's been either the vegan
- 27:53has been the end. the stereotype of the annoying
- 27:57vegan or the extreme vegan. And that's that's
- 28:01what you hear on podcasts when we're attacked
- 28:04by the, you know, the meat eating bros on some
- 28:08of their kinds of, you know, macho podcasts.
- 28:14And, you know, from my point of view, it's just
- 28:19so clear that that the cruelty that we're inflicting
- 28:26on animals is unnecessary because nobody in human
- 28:32history has ever looked at a cow and wanted to
- 28:36bite into it. We're just not carnivores. We're
- 28:41not meat eaters. It goes against our nature.
- 28:46So if you could imagine a vegan world where suddenly
- 28:52tomorrow everybody is eating the way I eat, the
- 28:57way we all eat. And imagine a child saying, mom,
- 29:05dad, how would it taste if we chopped up that
- 29:10cow and grilled it? Nobody would ever say that.
- 29:13Nobody would ever think of it, I don't think.
- 29:16It's only the fact that it has come down to us
- 29:20in culture. that people eat this way. And so
- 29:24we are fighting a battle against culture. You
- 29:31know, people think of culture as a good thing.
- 29:33There are many good aspects of culture, you know,
- 29:36music and dance and so forth. But culinary culture
- 29:40is destroying the planet the way it exists now.
- 29:45I mean, you could keep the spices, but you got
- 29:47to change. what's at the center of the plate
- 29:51in a lot of these cultures. And so I just feel
- 29:57that we need to use every every avenue we could
- 30:05use to try to get people wean from their cultures
- 30:10and face the fact that they're human beings and
- 30:13human beings are not carnivores. Thank you, Claren.
- 30:18Alex? Yeah, I mean, I agree with the vast majority
- 30:26of what Glenn just said. One thing I would add
- 30:30is that, again, right, because I don't know,
- 30:34because of my interest in audiovisual media,
- 30:38I try to think about when these instances do
- 30:45surface on film, right? So for example, I remember
- 30:50on Black Panther, there is an entire tribe of
- 30:56people from Wakanda who are said to be vegetarians,
- 31:00right? And here I'm going to do kind of what
- 31:02you did on the film. And again, I want to finish
- 31:04this intervention with a question about, and
- 31:07I'm going to collapse vegetarianism with veganism
- 31:10because I think historically the two have been
- 31:14kind of seen along the same Lines right like
- 31:17they've seen on their scene on the same light
- 31:19so so in this case right i'm talking about a
- 31:22character who is technically a vegetarian not
- 31:24a vegan but but i do remember thinking that that
- 31:27was it was interesting to see that on that film
- 31:30because. Black panther i mean does that the entire
- 31:34premise of the film is that this is a kind of
- 31:36africa that has never been imagined before right
- 31:40so it's already trying to step outside of cultural
- 31:42norms. And Glenn, you're talking about how this
- 31:45is a cultural battle, and I couldn't agree more.
- 31:48It's just a series of preconceptions that have
- 31:52been handed down to us, right? So that makes
- 31:55it seem as if it's something that we can overcome.
- 31:58Oh, well, if it's cultural and not biological,
- 32:01then it should be easier, right? But I think
- 32:04if anything, it adds a number of problems, right?
- 32:08Because it's so culturally ingrained that it's
- 32:11sort of like telling people, Wars would stop
- 32:15if there was no more religion. I'm not saying
- 32:17that's true, but it's another cultural trait
- 32:19that because it's been reproduced over and over
- 32:21again through the generations, it's really hard
- 32:24to let go of them. There are so many things that
- 32:26are built up around it. For example, on your
- 32:29film, you have the Passover dinner that they're
- 32:32talking about. You have to come to Passover and
- 32:34have some brisket. I don't eat that. I've lived
- 32:39that because I'm originally from Mexico. and
- 32:42meat's a big part of most Mexican meals. This
- 32:48is fascinating because historically, right before
- 32:52the Spaniards arrived, indigenous Mexicans didn't
- 32:55eat a lot of meat. They were mostly vegans and
- 32:58vegetarians. But after the conquest and after
- 33:02cows and chickens and pigs arrived, then meat
- 33:05was incorporated into into that cuisine. But
- 33:08so now it's part of the culture. Right. And so
- 33:10for me, family gatherings are really hard, just
- 33:13like for your character, because it's like, well,
- 33:15I want to be around family. But also, you know
- 33:18what? I'm not going to lie. I do. I do miss the
- 33:21taste of meat like I grew up with it. So like
- 33:24I smell it and immediately like my mouth starts
- 33:26watering. Right. And for me, it's hard for me.
- 33:28It's a struggle. So, yeah, I totally relate to
- 33:34part of the film, by the way. But so, yeah, you
- 33:40do see the occasional positive representation,
- 33:44like even on popular media. But then the one
- 33:48reference that I always remember is Wanderlust.
- 33:51I don't know if you guys have seen it with Paul
- 33:53Rudd and Jennifer Aniston. And they meet like
- 33:57a commune of hippies, very hypocritical hippies,
- 34:01and they're all vegans, right? And so I think
- 34:03that's sort of like the image that is kind of
- 34:06ingrained in popular culture, even to this day,
- 34:09which is, well, they're hippies, and they say
- 34:13that they hold a moral high ground, but in reality,
- 34:16they're all hypocrites because of X and Y and
- 34:19Z reason, right? I think that's what I see most
- 34:23often, and that's a cultural battle that we're
- 34:27in, right? Yeah. I remember the vegan in Yellowstone,
- 34:37the TV series, which is not watched by many vegans
- 34:40for obvious reasons, but there is a vegan there
- 34:45and it's just the worst. She's supposed to be
- 34:49this militant environmentalist vegan, but she
- 34:54misses every opportunity to make good points,
- 34:57to present good arguments, align her behavior
- 35:03with her values. And you get the feeling truly
- 35:08that it is a producer, the creator, the director,
- 35:14the writers behind that TV series are just taking
- 35:18that role, taking that character and just destroying
- 35:25veganism through her, which I find very dishonest.
- 35:34And yeah, those are the kinds of, you know, representations
- 35:40of veganism that come to mind. Can I make a point
- 35:46about a difference between my movie as an indie
- 35:50movie and a Hollywood movie? Yes, go ahead. There
- 35:54is a scene in which my lead character, Lou, He's
- 36:03talking about animal agriculture. He's talking
- 36:10to his cousin, who is immediate. He says, it's
- 36:14a vicious lying industry, and it's a holocaust
- 36:20for the animals. Now, his cousin, who was born
- 36:24Jewish, as he was, says, oh my God, how can you
- 36:29say that? He says, All right. All right. I guess
- 36:33animals don't matter as much as people do, but
- 36:37you know, they don't see it that way. A bad in
- 36:41a way gets at the essence of what we as vegans
- 36:45feel is the moral case for why we shouldn't be
- 36:50treating animals this way. But I would just ask
- 36:53you, could you imagine a Hollywood movie that
- 36:58has the line It's a vicious lying industry, and
- 37:03it's a holocaust. It couldn't happen. The committees
- 37:08that would be overseeing the production would
- 37:12never let a line like that in a Hollywood script.
- 37:18So this is the value of indie cinema to the extent
- 37:23that we can... celebrating this, not just as
- 37:26a movie with a vegan cause, but this is indie
- 37:29cinema, which I think is worth supporting in
- 37:33general. I'm trying to get the case out in language
- 37:41that you will never encounter in a Hollywood
- 37:44movie. I'm not saying every line in the movie
- 37:47is like that, but it happened. It was, if I may,
- 37:54I noticed that line. And so I don't know, because
- 37:59now that I know that you're a vegan, that you've
- 38:01been a vegan for 35 years, perhaps you drew inspiration
- 38:06from someone or perhaps not. Perhaps this is
- 38:09something that came to you independently, right?
- 38:12But this is a comparison that has been made before.
- 38:17I think in academia, it is sometimes known as
- 38:19the dreaded comparison. because it's scandalous,
- 38:24right? It's understood to be like an impossible
- 38:27comparison to make. Like how dare you, right?
- 38:29Kind of like how the cousin reacted. So yeah,
- 38:33I 100 % agree with what you just said. Like finding
- 38:35those venues when these sort of opinions can
- 38:38be voiced and put out there is quintessential
- 38:42because they're shunned, right? They are considered,
- 38:47or vote them, they're considered, you know, Yeah,
- 38:53scandalous. But it is a perfectly fair comparison
- 38:57to make, as a matter of fact, as we probably
- 39:00all know here, right? The techniques of industrial
- 39:03farming were essentially what inspired the camps,
- 39:08right? So it's a perfectly reasonable comparison
- 39:11to make, except that the powers that be don't
- 39:13want us to make it, right? They call them cattle
- 39:18cores, right? Right, exactly. Exactly. So I really
- 39:22appreciated it when the character said it, especially
- 39:25as a Jewish character, right? Being able to avoid
- 39:27that opinion, even if his cousin found it, you
- 39:30know, irrational or whatever, right? Just the
- 39:33fact that you have a member of that community
- 39:35being willing and able to say that. I think that's
- 39:38hugely significant, right? So yeah, I really
- 39:41appreciated that. Well, I do recommend, I think,
- 39:46a book called, I think, Forever Treblinka. Which
- 39:50is amazing and exactly about that, you know,
- 39:53comparing the Holocaust to what's happening to
- 39:55animals. So Yellowstone, I mentioned Yellowstone
- 39:59and how, you know, the representation of the
- 40:02vegan there was just insidious in the way, you
- 40:05know, they wanted to just highlight how good
- 40:09people ranchers were and how ranching was just
- 40:14this innocent thing that was actually good. Then
- 40:18I see, you know, characters like that. Scott
- 40:20Pilgrim character, you know, being Canadian here.
- 40:23I need to mention him. He's a vegan with superpowers.
- 40:28Actually, I think his veganism is his superpower
- 40:31or something. And, you know, in the movie he
- 40:35abandons his veganism at some point, but he's
- 40:38just this over -the -top, comical character.
- 40:43I always use the line, you know, the vegan police,
- 40:45I will call the vegan police on you because of
- 40:48that movie. It brings me joy, but also I would
- 40:53not classify it as, you know, a good representation
- 40:56of a vegan. Do you agree with me, Alex? You watched
- 40:59that movie. Yeah, I did. I was actually wondering
- 41:03if that was too obscure a reference to make,
- 41:05because I do remember that character. I believe
- 41:07it wasn't. I don't know if it was. Wasn't it
- 41:10Ian, though? I think it was the character Ian,
- 41:13right? Who was a vegan. Yeah, but yeah, I would
- 41:17agree that just the very fact that that part
- 41:20of the journey entails part of that coming of
- 41:22age journey entails abandoning his veganism.
- 41:25I think that's already kind of a problem, right?
- 41:27Because it sort of suggests a certain infantilism
- 41:30and the idea that that you're not supposed to
- 41:33eat meat. Like, oh, you're still an idealist.
- 41:35You have to overcome that kind of thing. Right.
- 41:38I wanna draw a comparison that perhaps is a little
- 41:41unusual here, but now that Glenn mentioned it,
- 41:44and you're also talking about popular culture
- 41:46again, and I think something that was, we've
- 41:52already mentioned this, that was really valuable
- 41:53or really noteworthy about Glenn's film, Lou's
- 41:57character, was that, again, those instances when
- 42:03his veganism shows, they are... important, they're
- 42:07powerful, but they're not out there. Like they're
- 42:11not overt, right? That's not who he is. It's
- 42:14part of who he is. And it's not entirely who
- 42:17he is. And so I think those are perhaps the sort
- 42:22of references to veganism and popular culture
- 42:26that I think, and I acknowledge that the film
- 42:28is not a pop film, right? As you said, it's independent
- 42:31cinema. But I think when those sort of uh moments
- 42:34appear in popular culture i think those are important
- 42:36right not when it's a central aspect of a particular
- 42:39character but when you get to know a character
- 42:43and then you find out that in addition to all
- 42:45the traits that that character embodies they're
- 42:48also vegan right because it's not reductive it's
- 42:52not like oh this guy is the vegan it's more like
- 42:54this guy is x y and z and also happens to be
- 42:57a vegan right he's a human being um and and i've
- 43:01seen that just on a few occasions, right? But
- 43:04one of them was, I distinctly remember The Expanse,
- 43:10a television show on Amazon Prime. And it's about
- 43:12the future, right? It's about like space and
- 43:15whatnot. And there's a scene when one of the
- 43:19characters is flipping through dating sites.
- 43:23And on the screen, you can see the information
- 43:27of all the characters. Like, oh, this person
- 43:28is like, you know. straight, bisexual, whatever,
- 43:32right? They like to do this. They like to do
- 43:33that. But the vast majority of them also say
- 43:36that they're vegan. And I remember noticing then,
- 43:39I'm like, oh, that's interesting. They're all
- 43:41vegan. And then it dawned on me, well, of course
- 43:43they are because this is in the future, right?
- 43:46When there's like an ecological crisis. And so
- 43:50it would be the reasonable thing to do for most
- 43:52people by then to just be vegan, right? And I
- 43:55don't know how many people catch that when they're
- 43:57watching the show. But I think that if one or
- 43:59two notice that, and they think about it for
- 44:02a minute, they'll realize that it has a lot to
- 44:04do with the ecological premise of the show. This
- 44:07is a post -civicalyptic sort of society when
- 44:10it's the only option left because it's only ever
- 44:14been the only real option. Even today, we've
- 44:18mentioned the book on your background there,
- 44:21Glenn. It's part... It's not just a moral issue
- 44:24in the sense that, like, we have to acknowledge
- 44:26the sentience of the animals, but it's also a
- 44:29moral issue in the sense that it's killing the
- 44:31planet, right? Yeah. France is burning now in
- 44:37Spain, and it's still extremely rare to get any
- 44:46climate spokesman to recognize that the leading
- 44:51cause of planetary warming and climate change
- 44:55is animal agriculture. They do the math and they
- 44:59leave out the part about land use and how 40
- 45:06% of the non -ice land surface of the earth is
- 45:09given over to animals for grazing. They just
- 45:12leave that out of the math. And the media has
- 45:18no curiosity about that. And even the scientists
- 45:22just leave it out of the math. It's amazing.
- 45:26Yeah, how strange that so many science fiction
- 45:30movies depict a vegan future. I was thinking
- 45:33also about travelers. It's on Netflix. It's a
- 45:36TV series. And, you know, humans get wiped out
- 45:41in the future. And the few that remain are vegan.
- 45:45And I think it's even the law. that you need
- 45:48to be vegan and so they're shocked you know from
- 45:51seeing how people in the past were eating animals
- 45:55and there's also a french movie i don't remember
- 45:59the name but it was made i think a decade Yeah,
- 46:03it was made like 20 years ago and in there also
- 46:06the future is vegan and the future is seen as
- 46:10a utopia and everyone there lives in harmony
- 46:14with nature and the animals. How come we're comfortable
- 46:20depicting a vegan future yet in the present vegans
- 46:26are distorted into this over the top character
- 46:31or into this obnoxious activist or any other,
- 46:36you know, typical character we see in movies.
- 46:39What is this time component about? That's a great
- 46:43question. I don't have the answer to it, but
- 46:46it seems to have something to do with cognitive
- 46:48dissonance. Alex, do you have a theory? Yeah,
- 46:53I do. I don't know. I agree that it's a great
- 46:59question. It's something I've been thinking about
- 47:03for a few years now, because it's a trend. I
- 47:06mean, it's great that you noticed it too, because
- 47:08I thought I was just imagining things. But it's
- 47:10something that seems to be out there, right?
- 47:12That we look at representations of the future
- 47:15and we see it. But then when it comes to talking
- 47:20about what's happening right now, the time to
- 47:22act is now, the president is here and all that.
- 47:25We bury it. And yeah, I don't know. I think it's
- 47:32evidently it's some sort of subconscious process.
- 47:34I don't think it's something that's done on purpose,
- 47:36right? But perhaps it speaks to the realization
- 47:39that ultimately it is dissolution. We're just
- 47:43not ready to admit it as a society, perhaps,
- 47:46right? Sort of like what happens with fossil
- 47:48fuels, right? I mean, you haven't... Big boy
- 47:51countries. When I talk to Julie about the sort
- 47:55of stuff, to my partner, we have the mature big
- 48:00boy countries that see the writing on the wall
- 48:03and they're working towards climate solutions.
- 48:05There aren't that many of them, but there are
- 48:07a couple. And there are the ones that are in
- 48:09denial and they refuse to see it and they just
- 48:12keep on investing into oil extraction and natural
- 48:16gas extraction and so on and so forth. I think
- 48:19it's a matter, to a certain extent, it's a matter
- 48:22of maturity, social maturity, cultural maturity,
- 48:25perhaps realizing that it is the only viable
- 48:29solution. Or perhaps some cultures, most cultures,
- 48:33the dominant cultures are just not ready to acknowledge
- 48:35it consciously yet, but it seems to be in there,
- 48:39right? It seems to be kind of like poking a hole
- 48:41in the cultural sort of psyche. So perhaps it's
- 48:46a good sign, but as activists as people who were
- 48:50already there, I think we find it a little frustrating.
- 48:53Perhaps I definitely, if I see it and I'm like,
- 48:56okay, so you can tell that that's the way to
- 48:58go, but you're just not ready to embrace. Okay.
- 49:01You know, in my what is now a fairly long lifetime,
- 49:06I've seen a lot of cultural changes. So, you
- 49:10know, when I was a kid, there weren't personal
- 49:12computers, there weren't cell phones. And that
- 49:16had their There wasn't YouTube. So all of that
- 49:24has come about, but it's a case of all those
- 49:29changes were changes that the corporate world
- 49:34made available to consumers, and consumers wanted
- 49:38it, so it happened, and the changes were made.
- 49:42I could tell you about another change that was
- 49:45coming when I was 10 years old. When I was 10
- 49:48years old, my teacher explained to the class
- 49:51that in five years, we're going to be going on
- 49:54the metric system. That was a long time ago.
- 49:59That was a change that would have required the
- 50:02culture to change. And that's what we don't do.
- 50:07Consumerism will change things, but we don't
- 50:10make efforts to change ourselves, to even go
- 50:15from inches and yards to meters. Oh, man, he
- 50:22just blew my mind with that because I think you're
- 50:26onto something in that. Not yet. I don't even
- 50:32make an effort to learn the inches and miles
- 50:36and stuff. Right. I'm dogmatic about the metric
- 50:41system. Actually, Rayan, if you don't mind, do
- 50:44you mind if I ask a couple of questions about
- 50:46his film? Yes, go ahead. Because I, I was intrigued
- 50:50by some choices. Some we've already talked about,
- 50:52which was dumb, but, but I want to come back
- 50:55to that. So, so, so Lou describes himself. So
- 51:02the main character, right? Uh, he describes himself
- 51:05as a vegetarian, but as you mentioned already,
- 51:07He later reveals that he also doesn't drink milk
- 51:11or eat eggs, so he's actually a vegan, right?
- 51:14Or at least for the most part, he seems to be
- 51:17a vegan, presumably, right? I was wondering what
- 51:21informed that choice, because I have a theory,
- 51:23but I want to hear it from you. Well, I think,
- 51:27you know, I just thought of him as a character
- 51:31who would be vegan, but In 1993, it was a little
- 51:35unusual to say that. I'm sure there were some
- 51:38people who did, but it was a little unusual.
- 51:42And so I was just being true to the time. And
- 51:49so that's all that was about, but I did want
- 51:54to make it clear. that he was really a vegan.
- 51:57And so he declines the cake with the milk and
- 51:59the eggs. And also that scene where the cake
- 52:03is served and he says, where's the box? Let me
- 52:06look at the ingredients. Well, that's what life
- 52:08is like for us. We have to look at the ingredients.
- 52:11So that's part of it. That's part of being separated
- 52:15from the mainstream culture is you got to look
- 52:18at the box, if you care, whether you're caring
- 52:23about your own health or caring about you know,
- 52:26the morality of treating the way we treat animals.
- 52:31So he's going to look at the box. That's going
- 52:33to annoy the hell out of his cousin who can't
- 52:36imagine why anybody would do that since the cake
- 52:38tastes good. And he declines it and his girlfriend
- 52:43eats it. And they're not going to wind up together,
- 52:46are they? That's right. Yeah. So I was wondering
- 52:51if it had to do with the dating of the film because
- 52:53it all begins by You began the film by stating
- 52:56that this takes place in 1993. I remember that
- 53:01earlier on the episode, I mentioned that episode
- 53:03from The Simpsons when a poo also comes out as
- 53:05a vegan, but he doesn't use the word, right?
- 53:08And I think it's precisely because of what you're
- 53:10pointing out. It was just not common currency
- 53:12back then. But then you already also mentioned
- 53:15where I was going to go with this, which was
- 53:18what happens after, right? Which is that he checks
- 53:21the box for ingredients. And we were talking
- 53:25about what may be more effective in terms of
- 53:30representation of vegans in the media or not.
- 53:32And I thought this was spot on, right? Because
- 53:34this is like, as you mentioned it, lived reality
- 53:38for us, right? But something that perhaps people
- 53:40don't really think about. So yeah, that was great.
- 53:46Just one more question, if you don't mind, Rayyan.
- 53:48I was really curious about these things. I was
- 53:52wondering about the cinematography, if there
- 53:57was a choice behind the style in which you filmed
- 54:01the movie, if there was a particular reason why
- 54:06you went the way you went. Well, my DP is a talented
- 54:11guy named Hezekiah Condren. We talked about the
- 54:17look we wanted, and he wanted that somewhat hazy
- 54:23look of the past, St. Louis, 1993. We agreed
- 54:35on that. Had I had more time, we shot the movie
- 54:42in 10 days. Oh, had I had more time, I might
- 54:48have freed him up to to move the camera more
- 54:53than we did. But we just had to get it in the
- 54:57can. And we ran into some obstacles getting,
- 55:01you know, getting some scenes done. And, you
- 55:07know, when you're making a movie, you got to
- 55:09deal with the practicalities as well as your
- 55:13aesthetic vision and I just I couldn't come back
- 55:16to my executive producer and say we didn't get
- 55:19it in the can so I made some decisions just to
- 55:23get get it all in the can and get it but I think
- 55:26it looks very good for you know for an independent
- 55:29movie I mean on a very low budget what did you
- 55:33think yeah I I I don't know I I I thought I could
- 55:40see the vision behind it But I wasn't sure. And
- 55:43maybe I had it wrong. But the impression that
- 55:47I got and it was occasionally distracting was
- 55:50that it had this 90s feel to it. Right. It definitely
- 55:54evoked the 90s in some way. And I couldn't quite
- 55:58blaze it. I couldn't quite tell why it was conveying
- 56:02that temporal scheme. And then it dawned on me
- 56:06that it's to me, it was kind of reminiscent of
- 56:09like 90s television shows. Right. TV shows from
- 56:13the nineties, especially like some soap operas
- 56:15that I've seen. Right. And so I think perhaps
- 56:19that that was one of the aspects of the film
- 56:23that I personally enjoyed the least because again,
- 56:26we've talked about cultural baggage, right? That
- 56:29there's some cultural baggage there. I was forced
- 56:31to watch those shows when I was a kid. So, so
- 56:35having that aesthetic, it wasn't personally something
- 56:38that I enjoyed, but it was distinctive. And I
- 56:40think There will most likely be some people who
- 56:43like are more appreciative of it. I tried to
- 56:47avoid that by avoiding, you know, because if
- 56:51you look at a TV sitcom, it's close up, close
- 56:54up, close up, close up, you know, jumpy. And
- 56:57I tried to have more wider shots. That's true.
- 57:01I appreciate it. Yeah. Longer takes. Yeah. The
- 57:06longer takes were impressive because as I mentioned
- 57:08before, the dialogue was really good. And so
- 57:14the, the, the, I got the sense of the actors
- 57:17really shown through, right? Cause they got to
- 57:20play the character for longer stretches of time.
- 57:23And so you could see how they embodied the emotions
- 57:26a lot clearer than you do when you're just going
- 57:29from jump cut to jump cut, right? So those longer
- 57:32takes, I certainly appreciate it. I love how
- 57:38You can be such a nerd around Glenn, Alex. Oh,
- 57:42yeah. And that we have this counterexample of
- 57:45a good representation of a vegan character that
- 57:49we can compare other movies to. I want to wrap
- 57:53up the bad representation of veganism in movies
- 57:57with this last example. So we talked about having
- 58:01bad vegan characters for various reasons. Well,
- 58:06something else that bothers me about movies where
- 58:12veganism is not depicted well, or at least, you
- 58:19know, it's not that it's not depicted well, it's
- 58:22that it's absent. Let me give you an example.
- 58:26Have you watched the animation Sausage Party?
- 58:29Yeah, yes. So it's an animation about food of
- 58:35all sorts that has sentience. And basically,
- 58:39humans become those monsters. We're not aware
- 58:43that they're sentient, but we bring them home
- 58:45and then we cut them and all of that. And they
- 58:49scream and we're just ignorant of that reality.
- 58:52Well, during that entire movie, I kept thinking,
- 58:56well, what about animals? How come the hot dog
- 59:02bun has sentience? But the fact that some of
- 59:07that food is made of animals that were actually
- 59:10sentient is completely ignored. And I get that
- 59:15a lot with movies where the plot is to save a
- 59:20certain, let's say ET, to save ET or to save
- 59:24some endangered species. And you think, well,
- 59:29what about the animals? Here they are eating
- 59:32a steak. and thinking about that species that
- 59:36they need to save. What about the other species
- 59:39that are endangered? What about those that are
- 59:42not special, that don't have special powers or
- 59:45are not in the world of the fantastic, you know?
- 59:48And those movies, I don't think they're trying
- 59:53to depict veganism as a bad thing, but just the
- 59:57fact that they completely ignore that message.
- 1:00:02what we're representing feels kind of harmful
- 1:00:05to the cause. Yeah, I mean, you're talking about
- 1:00:07missed opportunities, right? You're talking about
- 1:00:10missed opportunities in the media where perhaps
- 1:00:12you come across a film or a show or even a book
- 1:00:16where you think that whether intentionally or
- 1:00:22not they are communicating a point that has resonances
- 1:00:28or that resonates with the message that's coming
- 1:00:30from animal rights activists, vegans from conservationist
- 1:00:34environmentalists, and they just don't see the
- 1:00:37connection, right? To go back to your example
- 1:00:43of Sausage Party, I think with that particular
- 1:00:48film, it's almost certainly a reflection of the
- 1:00:53lack of introspection coming from the people
- 1:00:56who were involved. I mean, I would never expect
- 1:00:58someone like Seth Rogen to make a hugely insightful
- 1:01:03point about veganism, you know what I mean? He
- 1:01:04may have something really good to say about drugs,
- 1:01:07but when it comes to other issues, he's probably
- 1:01:10just not aware of it at all, right? Correct me
- 1:01:14if I'm wrong, but wasn't he like a producer?
- 1:01:16He was certainly in the film, right? He was involved.
- 1:01:19So I wouldn't expect a film that features uh
- 1:01:22so Drogon to to to have that sort of message
- 1:01:25right um but there I I see your point and I think
- 1:01:29I think that that that is sadly very very common
- 1:01:33in in other kinds of eco media right environmentalist
- 1:01:36media like like Len was saying right they'll
- 1:01:39talk about like the need to change um because
- 1:01:42of climate change because of biodiversity laws
- 1:01:45and this and that but they completely missed
- 1:01:46the point when it comes to how um you know how
- 1:01:49animal agriculture they hear us into those problems.
- 1:01:54And it goes back to that, just the cultural blindness
- 1:01:58to the issue as a whole, and also a known willingness
- 1:02:02to engage with it because it's controversial.
- 1:02:04Remember that when we did that episode on David
- 1:02:07Attenborough, we talked about how long it took
- 1:02:09him to be able to comfortably say, to embrace
- 1:02:13a plant -based diet because it was just controversial.
- 1:02:17The BBC would just not have it. You can't say
- 1:02:20that. So yeah, I think that's a part of it. I
- 1:02:25think it's also just people not seeing the connection,
- 1:02:29right? And you see it in other regards, not just
- 1:02:33in regards to veganism. Sometimes you'll see
- 1:02:35a film that makes a really good point about race
- 1:02:38or about LGBTQ issues or about immigration. And
- 1:02:41then they completely miss the point on what they
- 1:02:46just said also weighs in on other issues like
- 1:02:49capitalism or what have you. So I think unfortunately,
- 1:02:53we're all blind to one thing or another. And
- 1:02:55when it comes to this particular issue, the vast
- 1:02:58majority of our society is still just very blind
- 1:03:01to it, or just unwilling to even consider it
- 1:03:05because it's concerning, right? And to go back
- 1:03:07to Glenn's film earlier, you mentioned how Lou's
- 1:03:12cousin, I forgot her name. Susan. Yeah, how Susan
- 1:03:16is just kind of blind to the issue, right? And
- 1:03:21the way you said it, because you specifically
- 1:03:23used the word blind, and I was captivated by
- 1:03:27it because she was also blind to another issue
- 1:03:29in the film, wasn't she? Or at least according
- 1:03:31to her ex -husband, she was blind to something
- 1:03:34that was happening to her kids, right? To her
- 1:03:36kids, yeah. Exactly. So I think it was, I don't
- 1:03:39know if this was on purpose or not, but I took
- 1:03:41it to mean that she was just generally prone,
- 1:03:44or is a comment on how prone we are to not see...
- 1:03:47what's staring at us in the face because we're
- 1:03:50perhaps not willing to see it or because we're
- 1:03:52too concerned with other things that we think
- 1:03:54are more important, but perhaps they're not.
- 1:03:56Perhaps we're missing out on something that is
- 1:03:59deeply troubling. Yeah, I don't know if you want
- 1:04:02to say something about that, Gwen. Well, that's
- 1:04:05a good insight. Yes, I portrayed a character
- 1:04:09who is somewhat of a controlling character. who
- 1:04:14seems likable in a lot of ways, but has blind
- 1:04:19spots. And her somewhat drug -addled, deranged
- 1:04:27ex -husband comes in and has more clarity about
- 1:04:31their children than she does. Yeah, I think you
- 1:04:40could make the analogy that that goes towards
- 1:04:44the issue of diet as well. People don't see it.
- 1:04:50Look, I'm on the politically left side of the
- 1:04:54spectrum, and I have friends or politicians who
- 1:05:02I like who, you know, if there's a Let's say
- 1:05:06a labor movement progressive cause and come to
- 1:05:10the hot dog picnic where we'll discuss workers
- 1:05:13rights, you know Right. They they care very much
- 1:05:18about the workers rights, but they don't give
- 1:05:21a thought to what's in the hot dog So I I have
- 1:05:25a little trouble understanding it but that's
- 1:05:27the reality Thank you so much for translating
- 1:05:31my word salads, yes blind spots and uh It is
- 1:05:36frustration that I'm feeling towards those movies.
- 1:05:40So to conclude this conversation, I want to talk
- 1:05:44about good representations of veganism and animal
- 1:05:48rights in general in movies. Oh, then I would
- 1:05:55recommend the movie Buddhist Blues. Yeah, I've
- 1:05:58heard it's good. Well, it can be found at its
- 1:06:03website, Buddhist Blues dot com. Well, I want
- 1:06:07to highlight one movie where it is more, you
- 1:06:11know, blatant, you know, the veganism in it.
- 1:06:18But weirdly enough, and it's just like that in
- 1:06:21Buddhist blues, we don't hear the word vegan
- 1:06:25explicitly. And that movie is Okja. Have you
- 1:06:32heard of Okja? Yeah, I didn't like it. Interesting.
- 1:06:41Because, you know, I, if you're watching the
- 1:06:43movie, it was clearly Okja, the creature was
- 1:06:47clearly a pig, you know, or some kind of farm
- 1:06:51animal that was rescued from a factory farm.
- 1:06:56And you have an insider look into what that factory
- 1:07:01farm looks like. The greed of that industry is
- 1:07:06very well depicted. And Direct Action is also
- 1:07:11a team of the movie. And I was just baffled by
- 1:07:14that, that this could become mainstream and be
- 1:07:19promoted by Netflix and become kind of a feature
- 1:07:23feature, you know, feature movie of Netflix.
- 1:07:28But what didn't you like it, Alex? So earlier,
- 1:07:35we were talking about kind of what we find appealing
- 1:07:40in films, right? And we both agreed that a film
- 1:07:43that's visually engaging makes a big difference,
- 1:07:46right? I think, however, that there are occasions
- 1:07:50on which that can be detrimental to the film.
- 1:07:56So Aukia, I thought, was visually, it was impressive.
- 1:08:00Um, it had a good combination of CGI and just,
- 1:08:04um, good old fashioned practical effects. Um,
- 1:08:10more CGI though. But I think the problem with
- 1:08:14it is that because it's trying to make a point
- 1:08:18about factory farming, but also trying to be
- 1:08:23a fantasy film or perhaps like a some sort of
- 1:08:27sci -fi, right? Um, It kind of ultimately for
- 1:08:31me, right? For me, it fails at both, but more
- 1:08:36as an activist film because I think the risk
- 1:08:38when you watch something like that and you're
- 1:08:40not coming from a vegan standpoint, the risk
- 1:08:43is that you'll see it as just a fantasy. Like,
- 1:08:46oh, okay. Well, yeah, like obviously those conditions
- 1:08:49are horrible, but I still get my chicken from
- 1:08:51like the farm down the street in my head. You
- 1:08:53know what I mean? Because it's a fantasy. And
- 1:08:55so you dissociate it from reality. I think that's
- 1:08:58the risk with a film like that one. Um, but I
- 1:09:01will concede the point because I agree that a
- 1:09:06lot of people that watch that someone first came
- 1:09:09out who were not vegan, um, started making some
- 1:09:13changes after it. So, you know, maybe that's
- 1:09:16maybe, maybe I'm wrong here. It's very likely
- 1:09:18that I'm wrong here because I do distinctly remember
- 1:09:20like two or three different people that I talked
- 1:09:22to after watching that film. They said they weren't
- 1:09:24so sure about eating. Okay. Fair enough. You
- 1:09:28know, maybe it's very likely I'm wrong here.
- 1:09:31So it's perhaps it's just the personal choice.
- 1:09:33I just didn't care for it. But but yeah, I'll
- 1:09:36admit that it went mainstream and mainstream
- 1:09:37and it seems to have made an impact. It seems
- 1:09:41to have spoken to some people. Glenn, if we had
- 1:09:46to choose, you know, to which audience, which
- 1:09:52audience we should target with mainstream movies.
- 1:09:56that have a strong vegan message. Who should
- 1:10:01we choose? The adults, the kids? I guess my bent
- 1:10:08would be towards young people. My movie is set
- 1:10:13in the 90s and it might have more appeal to my
- 1:10:17generation. But if I... If we could make a magical
- 1:10:24question of if you could make a movie that 100
- 1:10:28million people watch, would you prefer it be
- 1:10:31100 million young people or 100 million old people?
- 1:10:34I'll go with the young. But you don't get to
- 1:10:37have that choice. I have a line in the script
- 1:10:46I'm writing now. Somebody says, a young person
- 1:10:53says, you know, my future belongs to my generation.
- 1:11:00And his father says, don't believe it. That's
- 1:11:02what they told me when I was a kid. But yeah,
- 1:11:09I would target the young if I had that choice.
- 1:11:13That's a great line. Another movie I want to
- 1:11:17highlight and I think is amazing around the theme
- 1:11:21of fecundism and animal rights is the Darwin
- 1:11:25Initiative. Have you heard of that? No, that's
- 1:11:29new to me. It's an animation from Japan, and
- 1:11:34it is the story of a humanzy, I think a chimp,
- 1:11:41the crossbreed of a chimp and a human, and basically
- 1:11:46a sentient you know like comparably intelligent
- 1:11:51creature animal creature to humans and he lives
- 1:11:57in the US and navigates the legal system the
- 1:12:02going to school and confronts all sorts of animal
- 1:12:06rights questions and vegan issues and it you
- 1:12:12know i've watched i think seven i think there
- 1:12:15are eight episodes and i watched seven of them
- 1:12:18and it is just incredible how far they went with
- 1:12:22it. The artist, you know, the one who draw the
- 1:12:27the manga because it is based on a manga is not
- 1:12:31vegan, but he has research that the issue of
- 1:12:35veganism and animal rights so well. And it gave
- 1:12:39me hope, you know, to see art going this far.
- 1:12:43Truly. So I do recommend to watch the movie,
- 1:12:49but I would love to hear if you have any recommendations.
- 1:12:54And what do you think about the future? Do you
- 1:12:56think we'll see more movies and TV series like
- 1:13:00The Darwin Initiative? Glenn, do you want to
- 1:13:09go? I'm just going to guess that. whether or
- 1:13:15not vegans are getting more or less popular at
- 1:13:18the moment, the reality is that this diet is
- 1:13:23necessary to save the planet. So I'm going to
- 1:13:27guess that you're going to see more media that
- 1:13:32is vegan -centric, I hope. Alex? Yeah. I would
- 1:13:41echo that, actually. I think that activist media
- 1:13:46will continue. And I would consider your film
- 1:13:50activist media in the sense that, as you mentioned,
- 1:13:52it was important for you to develop that point
- 1:13:56that Lou as a character is a vegan and that that's
- 1:14:00a big part of who he is and why he's going and
- 1:14:02why he's gone. So consider that to have an activist
- 1:14:06orientation because you're thinking with and
- 1:14:10through all these moral philosophical issues
- 1:14:12that go along with veganism. But I think that
- 1:14:19ultimately what's going to win the battle, the
- 1:14:21representational battle, is just sheer necessity.
- 1:14:25As you were saying, I think that the planet demands
- 1:14:29it in many ways, and I think that it'll representations
- 1:14:35of of plant -based diets and veganism are going
- 1:14:38to grow not so much because people are promoting
- 1:14:41it from an animal rights perspective, but because
- 1:14:45the times will call for it. Just like other forms
- 1:14:51of social change have been sort of promoted out
- 1:14:59of necessity, right? Like more representation
- 1:15:03of, for example, representation of African Americans
- 1:15:06in the 60s and 70s in order to facilitate the
- 1:15:08integration after segregation, right? And I'm
- 1:15:13not saying that that's a good reason for these
- 1:15:15changes to take place. I just think that ultimately
- 1:15:18that's what's going to win the battle. The fact
- 1:15:23that it'll have to become more normalized in
- 1:15:27order for our civilization as we know it to not
- 1:15:31go the way of the dodo. Now, with that being
- 1:15:35said, I don't know if we should try to preserve
- 1:15:41our civilization as it is, to be honest with
- 1:15:45you. But anyway, that's the question for another
- 1:15:49episode, perhaps. Rayann, can I recommend the
- 1:15:52film? Yes, please. You know that I'm all about
- 1:15:55documentaries, right? So there's this Czech documentary,
- 1:15:59Chickens, Virus, and Us, by I can type the information
- 1:16:07down for you later, if you want. So he made this
- 1:16:11film, he began the project at the beginning of
- 1:16:14the COVID pandemic. And that project was originally
- 1:16:19about how to live sustainably during COVID out
- 1:16:22in the cottage, out in his cottage out in the
- 1:16:26countryside. And over the course of that endeavor,
- 1:16:31the film, the project, and everything that he
- 1:16:33was working for pivoted towards veganism because
- 1:16:37he came to that realization. He came to the realization
- 1:16:40that what he wanted to do in order to keep his
- 1:16:43family safe during the pandemic was intricately
- 1:16:46tied to animal rights and veganism. And it was
- 1:16:51involuntary. That was not the point of his film.
- 1:16:53It just kind of happened. And you get to see
- 1:16:55that in the film. And I think it's brilliant
- 1:16:57because It was, it was totally organic. You know,
- 1:17:01that was not the intent. It just happened because
- 1:17:04the situation called for it. And so I think,
- 1:17:07I think that is quite interesting. And then,
- 1:17:09and I personally found it very intriguing, but
- 1:17:13also again, right. My taste in movies may not
- 1:17:17be, um, other people. So, you know, um, it is
- 1:17:21still a documentary and it is still a chick film.
- 1:17:24So perhaps audiences in North America may find
- 1:17:27it a little odd. But, uh, give it a shot. It's
- 1:17:31out there. You may be able to find it on the
- 1:17:34internet. Now, when you say a Czech film, you
- 1:17:36mean? Czech, as in from the Czech Republic. Oh,
- 1:17:39a Czech film. Oh, okay. Yeah, Czech. It sounds
- 1:17:44very intriguing. Yeah, I'll check it out. Glenn,
- 1:17:50any recommendations? Well, I guess I'll go back
- 1:17:54to the sheep detectives. Did anyone else see
- 1:17:58them? Now You know, it's a it's kind of you know,
- 1:18:02it's a I think was on Netflix I can't remember
- 1:18:06is Netflix or Amazon Prime, but it's You know
- 1:18:09Hugh Jackman. It's a major commercial release
- 1:18:12And I like the thought of millions of people
- 1:18:15seeing this message that Eating sheep is a mistake.
- 1:18:24I Mean again someone might complain from a militant
- 1:18:31point of view that sheep are being used as commodities
- 1:18:34for wool. But I think if you come away thinking
- 1:18:41that way, you're not really focusing on the movie's
- 1:18:45message. Someone will always complain. Okay,
- 1:18:48so thank you so much, both of you for this conversation.
- 1:18:54Did you have? Anything more to add before we
- 1:18:57stop the recording? Well, I just want to say
- 1:19:02thank you to both of you for watching the film
- 1:19:05and discussing it. And I would love it if the
- 1:19:09vegan community would support this film and spread
- 1:19:15the word about it. BuddhistBlues .com is for
- 1:19:20now the only place where it can be rented. Wonderful,
- 1:19:25thank you. Yeah, likewise. I just wanted to say
- 1:19:27thanks and and yeah to congratulate Glenn for
- 1:19:32the film and and yeah, hopefully, you know, I
- 1:19:35know right now it's just available on the site,
- 1:19:37but it would be great if you could in the future
- 1:19:40perhaps get some sort of distribution deal because
- 1:19:43it's it's it's worth watching and I think I think
- 1:19:46there's definitely a market for it. And again,
- 1:19:51right, as you mentioned that. The community,
- 1:19:53I think, will definitely enjoy seeing a character
- 1:19:58that represents us up on the screen. So yeah,
- 1:20:03definitely go ahead and watch it. And yeah, thanks,
- 1:20:05Rhian, for inviting me again. Of course. And
- 1:20:09yes, congratulations, Glenn. I forgot to congratulate
- 1:20:12you. I think I congratulated you on email, but
- 1:20:16I'm forgetting now. And thank you, Alex. Always.
- 1:20:20I appreciate your expert opinion. It's so wonderful
- 1:20:24to have someone who knows what movies are about
- 1:20:26and who can construct, you know, constructive
- 1:20:31feedback and criticism about movies and media.
- 1:20:38So thank you both of you. It was a pleasure.
- 1:20:43Thank you. Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:20:45I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 1:20:48the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:20:51to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 1:20:55caring.