Latest / Bloomberg Law / Best of Bloomberg Law: The Supreme Court
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law.
- 0:04Speaker 2: Are plaintiff's leries involved in a kind of competition in Congress?
- 0:08Speaker 2: Force a judicial code on the justices?
- 0:10Speaker 1: Interviews with prominent attorneys in Bloomberg Legal Experts.
- 0:13Speaker 2: My guest is former federal prosecutor Robert Mint Joining me
- 0:16Speaker 2: is Bloomberg Law reporter Kyle Janner.
- 0:18Speaker 1: And analysis of important legal issues, cases and headlines.
- 0:22Speaker 2: Is it unusual a grand jury like this to suspect
- 0:25Speaker 2: people aren't telling the truth? One of the first times
- 0:27Speaker 2: the Justice Department has called for the breakup of a
- 0:30Speaker 2: major company.
- 0:31Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:39Speaker 2: Welcome to the best of Bloomberg Law. I'm June Grosso.
- 0:42Speaker 2: Ahead in this hour, the Supreme Court will consider overturning
- 0:46Speaker 2: a decade's old doctrine on the power of agencies. The
- 0:50Speaker 2: justices signal there's a high bar for when speakers can
- 0:53Speaker 2: be punished for so called true threats. The next defamation
- 0:57Speaker 2: case against Fox and the Supreme Court justices are richer
- 1:02Speaker 2: than ninety percent of Americans.
- 1:10Speaker 3: Two and a half years of sending somebody unwanted emails
- 1:14Speaker 3: when that person has consistently tried to block them, and
- 1:17Speaker 3: tried to stop them, some of those emails being pretty violent,
- 1:22Speaker 3: die don't need you f off permanently. Others of those
- 1:27Speaker 3: emails suggesting pretty strongly that he is watching the person.
- 1:34Speaker 3: Only a couple of physical sightings with it was that
- 1:37Speaker 3: you and the white cheap. So I want to take
- 1:40Speaker 3: it as a given that this can be objectively.
- 1:42Speaker 2: Terrifying, just as Elena Kagan described the online threats made
- 1:47Speaker 2: to a Colorado musician for years, threats that made her
- 1:51Speaker 2: so fearful that, after trying to block them and getting
- 1:54Speaker 2: a protective order, she canceled planned performances. Billy Kounterman was
- 1:59Speaker 2: convicted of stalking and sentenced to four and a half
- 2:02Speaker 2: years in prison. The Supreme Court was considering Counterman's appeal
- 2:06Speaker 2: and his argument that his speech should have been protected
- 2:09Speaker 2: by the First Amendment because it wasn't what's known as
- 2:12Speaker 2: true threats. Many of the justices indicated that the speaker's
- 2:17Speaker 2: state of mind was important, and whether the speaker intended
- 2:20Speaker 2: to cause fear here's Justice Sonya Sotomayor.
- 2:24Speaker 4: But here the court and the prosecutor argued that the
- 2:28Speaker 4: intent was irrelevant, that he couldn't present any evidence about
- 2:33Speaker 4: his intent.
- 2:34Speaker 5: Correct that is exactly what about his mental state.
- 2:37Speaker 4: About what he thought. They precluded him completely from doing that.
- 2:41Speaker 2: But several justices like Brett Kavanaugh expressed concerns about the
- 2:45Speaker 2: implications for cases involving stalking, domestic violence, school threats, and
- 2:50Speaker 2: the like if the court were to require an approach
- 2:53Speaker 2: based on the speaker's intent.
- 2:55Speaker 5: A defense like the one that would be present with
- 2:59Speaker 5: your men would make it too easy for someone to
- 3:03Speaker 5: say I was just joking, I was just kidding, And
- 3:05Speaker 5: therefore threats that would be really quite dangerous in terms
- 3:10Speaker 5: of leading to the next step of actually carrying through
- 3:13Speaker 5: with the threat will not be addressed.
- 3:16Speaker 2: Joining me is mc snaila, a partner with the Complex
- 3:20Speaker 2: Appellate Litigation group MC explain what's meant by a true threat.
- 3:25Speaker 6: So, if it's determined to be a true threat, then
- 3:28Speaker 6: the whole question of what the constitutional floor, which is
- 3:31Speaker 6: where the prosecution sort of goes away saying Okay, if
- 3:34Speaker 6: it's a true threat, then we're not concerned about first
- 3:37Speaker 6: mement implications because we don't see societal value and protecting
- 3:43Speaker 6: in that kind of speech, because we're more concerned in
- 3:45Speaker 6: that context about individuals fear from violence. You know that
- 3:48Speaker 6: that's speech and genders. So because of that value judgment,
- 3:53Speaker 6: if it's a true threat, then we're outside of this
- 3:55Speaker 6: whole question for cementa production and.
- 3:58Speaker 2: What was the core is in this case?
- 4:01Speaker 6: In this case, the question is what kind of intent
- 4:04Speaker 6: is required? As a constitutional matter, Is some kind of
- 4:08Speaker 6: specific intent required to convict someone of stocking or crimes
- 4:14Speaker 6: involving threats? And so if it is a true threat
- 4:18Speaker 6: and we're outside that, you're not going to have any
- 4:20Speaker 6: kind of requirement because the First Amendment doesn't put on
- 4:23Speaker 6: another layer on top of the criminal statues or even
- 4:26Speaker 6: the civil statutes. So that's the question really a narrow
- 4:29Speaker 6: intent question, but it has major ramifications, as the State
- 4:35Speaker 6: of Colorado and the Slister General pointed out, at arguments
- 4:38Speaker 6: of what kinds of crimes will we be able to
- 4:42Speaker 6: charge and what kind of crimes will go unredressed if
- 4:46Speaker 6: a specific intent is required.
- 4:48Speaker 2: So in Colorado they look at whether the victim would
- 4:52Speaker 2: reasonably experience the fear of physical violence because of the
- 4:56Speaker 2: nature of the threat. So in Colorado they're taking it
- 4:59Speaker 2: from the victims point of view, and the defendant here
- 5:02Speaker 2: says you should take it from the defendant's point of
- 5:05Speaker 2: view what the defendant's intent is.
- 5:07Speaker 6: Well, it's kind of both. Counterman Council says, Okay, that's
- 5:10Speaker 6: fine if you have this objective reasonable recipient of the
- 5:14Speaker 6: thread test in the law, But you need more than that.
- 5:17Speaker 6: You also need to look at what was the intent
- 5:20Speaker 6: of the speaker. Did the speaker know in making her
- 5:25Speaker 6: comments that the reasonable person receiving them would interpret them
- 5:29Speaker 6: as being threatening or fear physical violence as a result
- 5:32Speaker 6: of that, And so they're really arguing kind of both
- 5:35Speaker 6: of those requires.
- 5:36Speaker 2: So in this case it's so over the top. She
- 5:40Speaker 2: got a temporary restraining order, she stopped going outside. I mean,
- 5:44Speaker 2: I don't understand how this could be considered not a
- 5:47Speaker 2: true threat.
- 5:48Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean, that's putainly what we argued in our
- 5:52Speaker 6: Meekas brief, and what we pointed out was the importance
- 5:55Speaker 6: of the constellation of behavior. That stocking statues in particular
- 5:59Speaker 6: usually require two or three threats or overt acts. It
- 6:03Speaker 6: is the pattern itself that gives rise to the stocking
- 6:06Speaker 6: charge or convictions. And here there were thousands of emails
- 6:10Speaker 6: over many years and direct messages on Facebook to her,
- 6:15Speaker 6: and many of those seemed to indicate that he might
- 6:18Speaker 6: physically be tracking her also and had some threats within
- 6:23Speaker 6: some of the discrete messages, like die and things like that,
- 6:27Speaker 6: which JEEF Justice Roberts pointed out a argument, But in
- 6:30Speaker 6: his questions that argument, he took each of those statements
- 6:34Speaker 6: that had particularly fairy language in them and said, well,
- 6:39Speaker 6: would someone interpret this as a threat? Couldn't it be
- 6:42Speaker 6: interpreted in some other way? Don't we need more context?
- 6:46Speaker 6: And the context that we argued, and that is really
- 6:48Speaker 6: part of stocking and domestic violence, is the entire context
- 6:52Speaker 6: of that relationship and prior threats and prior behaviors. So,
- 6:56Speaker 6: in other words, looking at one discrete direct message wouldn't
- 7:00Speaker 6: be sufficient, because you'd have to look at the thousands
- 7:03Speaker 6: of emails that happened despite her blocking this person on
- 7:07Speaker 6: Facebook six times at least, thereby indicating hey, you know,
- 7:10Speaker 6: don't reach out to me, and then the language in
- 7:13Speaker 6: them escalates and indicates that there might be some physical
- 7:17Speaker 6: stocking conduct going on with it. So when you look
- 7:19Speaker 6: at it, particularly in the context of the whole constellation
- 7:23Speaker 6: of threats and behaviors and the doggedness and determination that
- 7:27Speaker 6: this particular person seemed to have in communicating with.
- 7:30Speaker 2: Her, dude, most of the justices seem to be leaning
- 7:34Speaker 2: toward the notion that the speaker's intent is important. Justice
- 7:40Speaker 2: Sodo Mayors said that this Colorado man convicted of stalking
- 7:44Speaker 2: wasn't given the opportunity to explain the intention behind the speech.
- 7:49Speaker 6: Yeah, that was an interesting part of the argument, which
- 7:52Speaker 6: was the difference between being allowed to testify and explain
- 7:55Speaker 6: whatever you want to explain in a case like this
- 7:58Speaker 6: and having that an element or a requirement that the
- 8:03Speaker 6: prosecution proved that you specifically intended something. In other words, sure,
- 8:07Speaker 6: you can go up and say that if you like,
- 8:08Speaker 6: but as a First Amendment matter, you know, it's not
- 8:11Speaker 6: required for the prosecution to prove that kind of intent
- 8:15Speaker 6: beyond a reasonable doubt. That discussion came up because in
- 8:18Speaker 6: this particular case, as a result of the conclusion that
- 8:22Speaker 6: there was no First Amendment requirement for this specific intent,
- 8:25Speaker 6: the court in this case ended up not allowing Tuntermen
- 8:29Speaker 6: to testify about what he meant or didn't mean in
- 8:32Speaker 6: this circumstance. Perhaps there might have been another reason they
- 8:35Speaker 6: didn't do that, which is that he had two prior
- 8:38Speaker 6: convictions for stocking other women, one of which had ended
- 8:42Speaker 6: up in violence. So perhaps they wouldn't want that to
- 8:44Speaker 6: come out.
- 8:45Speaker 2: So does it seem as if the justices are going
- 8:47Speaker 2: to end up requiring some kind of proof of intent
- 8:51Speaker 2: in these cases.
- 8:52Speaker 6: There was one possible somewhat middle ground, which was a
- 8:56Speaker 6: ground that we urged if the court is going to
- 8:58Speaker 6: require some kind of intent First Amendment matter, that at
- 9:01Speaker 6: the most it should require a recklessness standard, a recklessness
- 9:05Speaker 6: standard rather than specific intent with regard to knowledge as
- 9:09Speaker 6: to whether what they were doing would cause a reasonable
- 9:12Speaker 6: person to bear violence. So that's an alternate standard also
- 9:17Speaker 6: that the SG urged, and so that got a lot
- 9:19Speaker 6: of airtime at argument in terms of would this be
- 9:22Speaker 6: something that you might be a middle ground for the
- 9:25Speaker 6: justices like Soda, Mayor, Gorsich and Alito who seemed, you know,
- 9:29Speaker 6: maybe somewhat skeptical of not having any intent requirement at all,
- 9:33Speaker 6: and then those like Higgan and Tabnaugh who were sympathetic
- 9:36Speaker 6: to the question of would you be impeding prosecutions if
- 9:41Speaker 6: you required some kind of specific intent.
- 9:44Speaker 2: It's an important case. Thanks so much, MC. That's mc
- 9:48Speaker 2: sun Gaila of the Complex Appellate Litigation Group. Coming up
- 9:52Speaker 2: next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show. The next defamation case
- 9:56Speaker 2: against Fox is also being brought by a voting machine company,
- 10:01Speaker 2: and later in the show, the Supreme Court will consider
- 10:04Speaker 2: overturning a decade's old doctrine on the power of agencies. Plus,
- 10:10Speaker 2: the Supreme Court justices are richer than ninety percent of Americans. Remember,
- 10:16Speaker 2: you can always get the latest legal news by listening
- 10:19Speaker 2: to our Bloomberg Lawn podcasts. You can find them on
- 10:22Speaker 2: Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at www dot Bloomberg dot com,
- 10:27Speaker 2: Slash podcast, Slash Law and attorneys looking for legal research.
- 10:32Speaker 2: Whether you're an in house council or in private practice,
- 10:35Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law gives you the edge with the latest in
- 10:38Speaker 2: AI powered legal analytics, business insights, and workflow tools. With
- 10:43Speaker 2: guidance from our experts, you'll grasp the latest trends in
- 10:46Speaker 2: the legal industry, helping you achieve better results for the
- 10:50Speaker 2: practice of law, the business of law, the future of law.
- 10:53Speaker 2: Visit Bloomberg Law dot com. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 10:57Speaker 2: listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 11:08Speaker 7: Foxers did apologize. We got them to be held accountable
- 11:11Speaker 7: and we got them to pay us a historic settlement amount.
- 11:16Speaker 7: I believe it is the largest settlement in the history
- 11:19Speaker 7: of any defamation suit by a factor of several.
- 11:22Speaker 2: But will the nearly eight hundred million dollars settlement between
- 11:26Speaker 2: Fox News and voting machine company Dominion remain the largest
- 11:30Speaker 2: defamation settlement and historic, as attorney da Vita Brooks said.
- 11:35Speaker 2: Next up is Smartmatic, another voting machine company, suing Fox
- 11:40Speaker 2: in a very similar defamation case over false twenty twenty
- 11:43Speaker 2: election claims. Only Smartmatic is asking for two point seven
- 11:48Speaker 2: billion dollars. That's one point one billion more than Dominion
- 11:52Speaker 2: was suing. Four Joining me is an expert in defamation,
- 11:56Speaker 2: David Korzenik of Miller Corsenic Summrs Raymond it. Outside of
- 12:00Speaker 2: the monetary amount, how significant is this settlement, It's.
- 12:05Speaker 8: Worth considering what the impact is of this settlement on
- 12:09Speaker 8: the law on Fox News, on democracy propaganda from an
- 12:14Speaker 8: historical point of view, and what it will do for
- 12:17Speaker 8: libel claiming in the future. So on the issue of
- 12:22Speaker 8: impact on libel law, I think it will have no
- 12:24Speaker 8: immediate impact, but it probably affirms the viability of the
- 12:29Speaker 8: soundness of New York Times versus Sullivan and the actual
- 12:32Speaker 8: malice standard. Because it shows that that standard works. Second,
- 12:38Speaker 8: as far as the impact on Fox News going forward,
- 12:42Speaker 8: hard to know. I don't think that it will change.
- 12:44Speaker 8: They are reporting because in a certain way, Fox is
- 12:47Speaker 8: riding at Tiger and can't get off it. But the
- 12:51Speaker 8: recent shift with Doucar Carlson is interesting but may or
- 12:55Speaker 8: may not be indicative of anything on that point. But
- 12:58Speaker 8: another thing to keep in mind here is that while
- 13:02Speaker 8: Fox dead in the settlement that they acknowledge the judge's decision,
- 13:06Speaker 8: the judge's decision has actually more force here than just that.
- 13:11Speaker 8: It's a factual ruling and a legal ruling on falsehood
- 13:15Speaker 8: that's legally binding on Fox going forward and legally binding
- 13:19Speaker 8: on them well collateral estopel as to any plaintiff that
- 13:24Speaker 8: goes after them based on related facts. The second, there
- 13:28Speaker 8: are obviously these other inbound suits that are taking place.
- 13:32Speaker 8: There is the Smartmatic case that's really advancing kind of
- 13:36Speaker 8: feverishly while we were paying attention to Dominion, But it's
- 13:40Speaker 8: the huge numbers of filings and decisions in that lawsuit,
- 13:44Speaker 8: and that's advancing. There's evidence on the public record that
- 13:48Speaker 8: was extracted in the course of the dominion case that
- 13:52Speaker 8: will be accessible and usable by anyone who makes claims
- 13:56Speaker 8: against Fox, not just pr wise but legally obviously. Then
- 14:01Speaker 8: there's also shareholder actions that are now underway, and they
- 14:06Speaker 8: may be more significant than we realized. Still to evaluate
- 14:09Speaker 8: their impact, but they're quite serious because they are shareholder
- 14:14Speaker 8: claims about the irresponsibility of Fox promoting these fictions when
- 14:20Speaker 8: it was clearly going to be to the detriment of
- 14:22Speaker 8: the company financially.
- 14:23Speaker 2: How do the judge's rulings in the Dominion case help Smartmatic?
- 14:28Speaker 2: What does it have to prove? What doesn't it have
- 14:30Speaker 2: to prove?
- 14:31Speaker 8: Well, it has to prove that to the extent that
- 14:34Speaker 8: the Fox broadcasts they're attacking are different in substance from
- 14:38Speaker 8: the allegations made against Dominion, but they do seem to
- 14:42Speaker 8: be overlapping because they do relate more broadly about whether
- 14:46Speaker 8: or not there was any evidence at all to support
- 14:49Speaker 8: the election fraud claim. And second, there is a kind
- 14:53Speaker 8: of overlap between Dominion and Smartmatic in the sense that
- 14:58Speaker 8: dominions machines use this is smartmatic software, so that even
- 15:02Speaker 8: though smart Matic chains were only used in LA and not,
- 15:07Speaker 8: as Fox had allege, in many of the swing states. Nonetheless,
- 15:11Speaker 8: at issue is the vote switching features of the software
- 15:17Speaker 8: that was used as well at dominions. So there's a
- 15:19Speaker 8: lot of overlap there, and there's no question that ruling
- 15:23Speaker 8: by Judge Davis in the dominion case will work to
- 15:27Speaker 8: the advantage locked in advantage of smart Matic not on everything,
- 15:32Speaker 8: but on a lot of it. Also, keep in mind
- 15:34Speaker 8: that the smart Matic case is pending in New York.
- 15:36Speaker 8: The dominion case was pending in Delaware, but there was
- 15:40Speaker 8: no question that New York law of libel applied in
- 15:44Speaker 8: both cases. Though the law applies just as well here
- 15:48Speaker 8: in the Smartmatic case in Manhattan.
- 15:51Speaker 2: So Fox said that Smartmatics damages claims are implausible, disconnected
- 15:57Speaker 2: from reality, and on its face, intended to chill First
- 16:00Speaker 2: Amendment freedoms. Does that sound a lot like claims that
- 16:04Speaker 2: the judge dismissed in the dominion suit.
- 16:07Speaker 8: Yes, you know, there's always an issue when there's a
- 16:10Speaker 8: product disparagement claim about the adequacy of damage pleading, the
- 16:16Speaker 8: specificity of those pleadings, and the ability to show causation.
- 16:20Speaker 8: But if the claims are really just straight libel claims,
- 16:25Speaker 8: corporate plaintiffs still has real obstacle to proving things. Corporate
- 16:29Speaker 8: plantiffs if it points to any specific loss is going
- 16:33Speaker 8: to have to show causation, and once that happens, becomes
- 16:36Speaker 8: more complicated for them. So yeah, damages for a human being,
- 16:41Speaker 8: for an individual is very different in libel than damages
- 16:44Speaker 8: for a corporation, So they are hard to show. And
- 16:48Speaker 8: it probably would have been a complicated battle for dominion,
- 16:52Speaker 8: and though those of all the different parts of their
- 16:54Speaker 8: case that would have been perhaps the more vulnerable that
- 16:58Speaker 8: would have been it, And that will be the case
- 17:00Speaker 8: here too. But you know, you do have punitives that
- 17:03Speaker 8: are eventually in the wings here, and those could really
- 17:07Speaker 8: kick up the value of the claim, even if the
- 17:10Speaker 8: underlying actual damage to the plaintiffs is less.
- 17:15Speaker 2: Fox said one has nothing to do with the other.
- 17:17Speaker 2: But the fact that they settle the dominion is that
- 17:20Speaker 2: sort of an indication that they'll settle the smartmatic as well?
- 17:25Speaker 8: It could be. I mean, I think we all feel
- 17:27Speaker 8: that the reason for the settlement was the risk of
- 17:31Speaker 8: having all these news anchors having to testify and the
- 17:35Speaker 8: damage that that could do to Fox over a long
- 17:38Speaker 8: and extended period of time while the trial was going on.
- 17:41Speaker 8: That can happen here too, And just because an anchor
- 17:44Speaker 8: or someone isn't named as a party to the lawsuit
- 17:47Speaker 8: doesn't mean that they won't be a witness to it,
- 17:49Speaker 8: because remember the dominion cases really just against the Fox entities. Here,
- 17:54Speaker 8: they're also against Bartiromo and Hero and Dobs and specific
- 18:00Speaker 8: but they don't have to be named in order to
- 18:02Speaker 8: land a punch on Fox. And so I would guess
- 18:06Speaker 8: I would think when you read this three hundred page complaint,
- 18:11Speaker 8: there are a lot of different names of anchors who
- 18:13Speaker 8: come up here other than Dobbs and Bartiromo and Piro,
- 18:18Speaker 8: and there's no reason that they couldn't be brought in
- 18:20Speaker 8: as witnesses too, and that may be something that's going
- 18:23Speaker 8: to be very hard fought, and there'll be more discovery
- 18:26Speaker 8: that probably comes out in this case. So yeah, they're
- 18:30Speaker 8: probably great incentives for settlement as well. But then you know,
- 18:34Speaker 8: in the wings again there's the shareholder actions that could
- 18:38Speaker 8: be problematic. Employees who either resigned or fired that could
- 18:42Speaker 8: create a problem. Is one of them that I know of.
- 18:45Speaker 8: It's problematic for them. There's a lot happening, and there's
- 18:48Speaker 8: a lot of blood in the water, and it makes
- 18:50Speaker 8: it both more valuable for them to settle, but also
- 18:54Speaker 8: more difficult to settle.
- 18:55Speaker 2: What do you think the long term impact of these
- 18:58Speaker 2: cases is going to be?
- 19:01Speaker 8: So I think that what's going to happen is that
- 19:03Speaker 8: because of a case like this, it will fuel plaintiffs
- 19:06Speaker 8: imagination and they will all be trying to frame their
- 19:11Speaker 8: own Fox type cases that they think they have against
- 19:15Speaker 8: some other news organization. I don't think that those will
- 19:18Speaker 8: be successful. They will be attempted, but I think they'll fail,
- 19:22Speaker 8: partly because I don't think that you can actually get
- 19:25Speaker 8: the kind of discovery of news organization's internal deliberations and
- 19:30Speaker 8: sourcing as was the case here. Because this was unusual,
- 19:34Speaker 8: they were able to get inside stuff and overcome what's
- 19:38Speaker 8: called the reporter's privilege that protects against disclosure of internal
- 19:43Speaker 8: editorial deliberations in contact with sources and so on. They're
- 19:46Speaker 8: able to get around it because you know, there were
- 19:48Speaker 8: insiders who were talking to news organizations saying I saw
- 19:52Speaker 8: this email, I was in that meeting. Once you have
- 19:55Speaker 8: that kind of specificity and you say there was this email,
- 19:58Speaker 8: I know it was there, I know it, they said,
- 20:00Speaker 8: then you're more likely than to be able to get it.
- 20:03Speaker 8: If you don't know what you're looking for, you can't
- 20:05Speaker 8: get it.
- 20:06Speaker 2: Thanks so much for your insights, David. That's David Korzenic
- 20:09Speaker 2: of Miller Corsenic, Summrs Raymond. Coming up next, the Supreme
- 20:13Speaker 2: Court will consider reversing a forty year old president. You're
- 20:17Speaker 2: listening to Bloomberg.
- 20:21Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 20:28Speaker 2: The Supreme Court will consider overturning a nearly forty year
- 20:31Speaker 2: old legal precedent called the Chevron Doctrine. It's given federal
- 20:35Speaker 2: regulators brought power to define their authority, and it's something
- 20:40Speaker 2: conservatives have been pushing to get rid of for years,
- 20:43Speaker 2: saying it's empowered the administrative state. Several conservative justices have
- 20:49Speaker 2: soured on the doctrine, and Justice Neil Gorsich is one
- 20:52Speaker 2: of them. He was even questioned about Chevron during his
- 20:55Speaker 2: Senate confirmation hearings because he'd criticized the doctrine in a opinion,
- 21:00Speaker 2: saying it allowed quote, executive bureaucracies to swallow huge amounts
- 21:05Speaker 2: of core judicial and legislative power.
- 21:08Speaker 9: I thought the judges were supposed to say what the
- 21:11Speaker 9: law is. I thought that's what Justice Marshall said, and
- 21:18Speaker 9: I thought the point of having judges decide the law
- 21:22Speaker 9: is because you wanted someone who's neutral and independent to
- 21:25Speaker 9: say what the law means, someone who doesn't have a
- 21:28Speaker 9: dog in the hunt.
- 21:30Speaker 2: And next term the justices will consider a case testing
- 21:34Speaker 2: the doctrine. Joining me is an expert on the separation
- 21:37Speaker 2: of powers, Harold Krant, a professor at the Chicago Kent
- 21:41Speaker 2: College of Law. How will you explain just what the
- 21:44Speaker 2: Chevron doctrine is?
- 21:46Speaker 10: The ship on doctrine sets the tone, or if you will,
- 21:49Speaker 10: between the reviewing court and the agency which is promulgated
- 21:54Speaker 10: rule or conducted an adjudication to settle rights between the
- 21:59Speaker 10: government and either you know, individuals or regulated businesses. And
- 22:03Speaker 10: oftentimes agencies engage in very complicated decision making, dealing with
- 22:08Speaker 10: questions about hearing rights for disabled, questions about kinds of
- 22:12Speaker 10: nuclear discharge, how to gauge it, what kind of drugs
- 22:16Speaker 10: should be regulated, how do we know if it's safe.
- 22:19Speaker 10: There's so many areas in which regulators have to make decisions,
- 22:23Speaker 10: and Congress can't foresee all of the details. Congress therefore
- 22:27Speaker 10: gives of why leash to agencies, leeway to the agency
- 22:31Speaker 10: to flesh out those regulations as social conditions and indeed
- 22:35Speaker 10: as political conditions change, subject to the oversight of the President.
- 22:40Speaker 10: But the Court is fighting back. The Court is thought
- 22:43Speaker 10: that agencies shouldn't have this power. It's okay if Congress
- 22:46Speaker 10: cuts the details itself, but the Court doesn't want agencies
- 22:50Speaker 10: to have the ability to reinterpret their own enacting statues,
- 22:54Speaker 10: to reinterpret and refashion rules as these conditions change, and
- 22:59Speaker 10: therefore trying to straight jacket administrative agency power.
- 23:03Speaker 2: And the doctrine has sort of a two step approach.
- 23:07Speaker 10: The Chamon doctrine is a two step doctrine which first
- 23:10Speaker 10: asked if Congress has clearly specified what the agency should do,
- 23:14Speaker 10: and if it does, then the Court will just either
- 23:16Speaker 10: say agency acted appropriately or not. But if there is ambiguity,
- 23:21Speaker 10: and there's almost always ambiguity, then the doctrine suggests that
- 23:25Speaker 10: the Court will agree to any kind of reasonable interpretation
- 23:29Speaker 10: of the satutory language that the agency has reached. So
- 23:32Speaker 10: they are giving deference, in other words, to agencies because
- 23:35Speaker 10: the agencies are more expert, They have more experience in
- 23:38Speaker 10: the areas of pollution, of drug safety, of labor management relations,
- 23:44Speaker 10: and therefore they should be the ones to decide the
- 23:46Speaker 10: issue as long as they're acting reasonably. But the Court,
- 23:49Speaker 10: i think, has battled back because it thinks that it's
- 23:53Speaker 10: not right for agencies to share with the Court the
- 23:57Speaker 10: power to interpret congressional language. The Court thinks it's their
- 24:01Speaker 10: own prerogative to interpret what Congress says, and therefore to
- 24:06Speaker 10: share it with agencies. By giving this leeway to reasonable
- 24:09Speaker 10: agency interpretation of satutory language would be to limit their
- 24:14Speaker 10: own power. So, in some ways, Chevron is an ideological
- 24:17Speaker 10: war that the Court is waging in order to affirm
- 24:21Speaker 10: its own superiority in terms of satutory interpretation.
- 24:26Speaker 2: The Court has chipped away at Chevron, including in a
- 24:29Speaker 2: case last month involving the SEC and the FTC. But
- 24:34Speaker 2: is this the first direct challenge to Chevron.
- 24:38Speaker 10: So the Court has not upheld a case on the
- 24:41Speaker 10: basis of the Chevron doctrine for over six years. Lower courts, however,
- 24:45Speaker 10: have continuously applied Chevron. But the Court has occasionally asked
- 24:49Speaker 10: whether the Chevron doctrine should be not just limited, which
- 24:53Speaker 10: it has done, but whether it should be overruled in
- 24:56Speaker 10: its entirety. And this case may or may not be
- 24:58Speaker 10: the right vehicle in this case. There's a very narrow
- 25:01Speaker 10: question has to do with a herring fishing industry about
- 25:04Speaker 10: whether the industry itself has to pay for agency observers.
- 25:08Speaker 10: And agency observers are unquestionably permitted under the statutory scheme
- 25:13Speaker 10: to make sure that the fishing boats conserve resources, don't overfish,
- 25:17Speaker 10: et cetera. So there's question is that they have to
- 25:19Speaker 10: pay for it. Maybe it's implicit in the statute, but
- 25:21Speaker 10: it's not explicit. And the Court has taken two questions
- 25:25Speaker 10: on the case. One is whether the Chevan doctrine should
- 25:27Speaker 10: be overruled in its entirety, and the second is whether
- 25:30Speaker 10: the fact that there is no explicit power given by
- 25:34Speaker 10: Congress to the agency to make the private fishing industry
- 25:38Speaker 10: pay for observers, whether the fact that there's congressional silence
- 25:41Speaker 10: should be a reason to deprive the agency of the
- 25:45Speaker 10: power to determine that the fishing industry should pay for
- 25:49Speaker 10: these observers.
- 25:50Speaker 2: Do you think that they intend to get rid of
- 25:52Speaker 2: Chevron because the justices didn't have to take this case,
- 25:57Speaker 2: there's no split in the circuits. The administration said the
- 26:00Speaker 2: fishery dispute has no practical importance now because the monitoring
- 26:05Speaker 2: program is on hold, and the court took an unusually
- 26:08Speaker 2: long time to decide how to handle the case. It
- 26:11Speaker 2: scheduled it for potential discussion at five private conferences.
- 26:15Speaker 10: This is a minor regulatory issue about who pays, so
- 26:18Speaker 10: this is not like a major questions case. This case
- 26:21Speaker 10: is all about the Supreme Court, and the only reason
- 26:23Speaker 10: the Court took this case is because they wanted some
- 26:26Speaker 10: kind of context in which they could decide whether to
- 26:29Speaker 10: scuttle Chevron, to inter it completely, or whether it to
- 26:32Speaker 10: limit it even more than it has been in the
- 26:34Speaker 10: prior ten years. And again, I think the challenge of Chevron,
- 26:38Speaker 10: I don't think it makes that big of a difference
- 26:39Speaker 10: in terms of number of cases the agency's winner lose.
- 26:43Speaker 10: But it's a thorn in the Court's side because the
- 26:46Speaker 10: Court thinks that they have the superiority in terms of
- 26:50Speaker 10: interpreting statutes, and to publicly announce that agencies should have
- 26:54Speaker 10: a role in interpreting language of Congress as well as
- 26:58Speaker 10: they do, it's sort of an insult to the court.
- 27:01Speaker 10: To the Court I think wants to wipe this insult away.
- 27:04Speaker 2: There's a lot of gloom and doom about what would
- 27:07Speaker 2: happen if Chevron were eliminated. Do you think that's warranted.
- 27:11Speaker 10: Well, what I think is interesting is to think about
- 27:14Speaker 10: what happened before Chevron, Because before Chevron, what courts would
- 27:17Speaker 10: do would say, you know, this is a kind of
- 27:20Speaker 10: complicated agency issue. Agencies have more expertise than we do.
- 27:24Speaker 10: We'll defer to agency. And there was this sort of
- 27:26Speaker 10: patchwork of deference that grew up amongst courts. And what
- 27:31Speaker 10: Chevron did was to try to take this kind of
- 27:35Speaker 10: scheme of uncertain deference and try to give it a
- 27:39Speaker 10: uniform two step package, which would then unify and systematize
- 27:44Speaker 10: difference across the country. So even if Chevron is wiped out,
- 27:49Speaker 10: I think over time courts would say, you know, I
- 27:52Speaker 10: don't really know about nuclear discharge. What the agency did
- 27:56Speaker 10: here there is technical, It seems pretty minor. Refer to
- 28:00Speaker 10: the agency, because who knows what Congress really intended, and
- 28:05Speaker 10: the agency is familiar with it. The agency is applying
- 28:08Speaker 10: the statute, It has the expertise, it knows what Congress
- 28:12Speaker 10: meant by that vague language better than we do. So
- 28:14Speaker 10: I think that over time, even if the court scuttles Chevron,
- 28:18Speaker 10: it's not going to make a dramatic difference on the
- 28:21Speaker 10: other side of the coin if the court really cares
- 28:25Speaker 10: about an issue, the Court's going to come up with
- 28:27Speaker 10: a decision as to what the statute means, irrespective of
- 28:31Speaker 10: whether Chevron applies or not. And we've seen many instances
- 28:34Speaker 10: of that.
- 28:35Speaker 2: Early on, Conservatives embraced the Chevron doctrine. What happened to change.
- 28:40Speaker 10: That Chevron grew in the midst of the Reagan administration,
- 28:44Speaker 10: and the Reagan administration was engaging in somewhat of a
- 28:46Speaker 10: radical deregulation at the time, and the Republicans supported Chevron
- 28:51Speaker 10: because they supported the regulatory regime that the Reagan administration
- 28:55Speaker 10: was forwarding. And it was only during the Obama administration
- 28:58Speaker 10: when Republicans then began to attack Chevron because they saw
- 29:03Speaker 10: that Chevron helped the Obama administration's effort in Obamacare, effort
- 29:08Speaker 10: in reforming the welfare system, that they thought that having
- 29:11Speaker 10: stricter judicial controls on the administration would be more beneficial
- 29:16Speaker 10: to their political interests. So Chevron's really neutral. It can
- 29:20Speaker 10: help administrations, whether the Republican or Democratic. It just suggests
- 29:25Speaker 10: a reality of our political system, which is Congress doesn't
- 29:28Speaker 10: like to deal with details. There's a lot of gridlock
- 29:31Speaker 10: in Congress. But even aside from the gridlock. Congress looks
- 29:34Speaker 10: at some issues, but it prefers only to look at
- 29:37Speaker 10: some issues, and it doesn't want to get into details
- 29:40Speaker 10: of vaccines, the details of even the herring industry, not
- 29:44Speaker 10: to mention pollution, labor management relations, and so much more.
- 29:48Speaker 10: And so for years, Congress has decided that it's better
- 29:51Speaker 10: to have agencies take the first crack at many of
- 29:54Speaker 10: those important issues, and it sits back and only gets
- 29:57Speaker 10: involved if they are convinced that the agencies have messed
- 30:00Speaker 10: it up. That's been a reality of our governance now
- 30:03Speaker 10: for generations.
- 30:04Speaker 2: Well, we'll have to wait until next term to find
- 30:06Speaker 2: out what they do about Chevron. Thanks so much. How
- 30:09Speaker 2: that's Professor Harold Krent of the Chicago Kent College of
- 30:12Speaker 2: Law coming up, the abrupt reversal of the North Carolina
- 30:16Speaker 2: Supreme Court. You're listening to Bloomberg coming up, how many
- 30:20Speaker 2: Supreme Court justices are multimillionaires. This is Bloomberg.
- 30:27Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 30:51Speaker 2: From Pink Floyd to Lil Wayne, artists of every genre
- 30:55Speaker 2: have sung about the corrupting influence of money, and it
- 30:58Speaker 2: seems that the nine justices on the Supreme Court have
- 31:01Speaker 2: done well in amassing wealth and leading a privileged lifestyle.
- 31:05Speaker 2: In fact, they're significantly richer than ninety percent of Americans.
- 31:09Speaker 2: According to an analysis by Bloomberg News, at least six
- 31:12Speaker 2: of the Supreme Court justices are multimillionaires, with as much
- 31:16Speaker 2: as twenty seven million dollars in assets, and the numbers
- 31:19Speaker 2: could be even higher. Joining me is Bloomberg Legal reporter
- 31:23Speaker 2: Emily Burnbaum, who's look at the numbers. Emily explain why
- 31:27Speaker 2: you just can't get specific numbers about the justice's wealth.
- 31:32Speaker 11: The Supreme Court justices are required to file these annual
- 31:37Speaker 11: financial disclosures, but the disclosures aren't meant to tell you
- 31:42Speaker 11: the justices net worth. Basically when they were constructed, they
- 31:46Speaker 11: were constructed pretty narrowly, and they're just supposed to tell
- 31:49Speaker 11: you about potential conflicts of interest. And so there's definitely
- 31:54Speaker 11: been a lot of discussion about why don't justices have
- 31:58Speaker 11: to disclose the value of their personal residences on the forums,
- 32:02Speaker 11: or why do the justices have to disclose how much
- 32:06Speaker 11: money they have in their government retirement account That is
- 32:10Speaker 11: sometimes a place where justice can keep a lot of
- 32:13Speaker 11: money and the public doesn't know about it, So it's
- 32:15Speaker 11: a law with a lot of loopholes essentially.
- 32:17Speaker 2: So who is the richest justice.
- 32:20Speaker 11: The richest justice is Chief Justice John Roberts. So he
- 32:24Speaker 11: reported in twenty twenty one between nine point nine million
- 32:27Speaker 11: and twenty seven million dollars in assets. He owns two
- 32:32Speaker 11: properties on a little remote island in Maine that that's
- 32:36Speaker 11: only accessible by boats. He owned part of a cottage
- 32:39Speaker 11: in Ireland, and he has a really nice house worth
- 32:43Speaker 11: you know, over two million dollars in Chevy Chase, Maryland.
- 32:47Speaker 11: So Chief Justice John Roberts is the richest buy a
- 32:50Speaker 11: pretty significant amount, followed by Justice Neil Gorses, who has
- 32:54Speaker 11: between four million and twelve million dollars in assets.
- 32:57Speaker 2: Justice Samuel Alito, who comes into the race on the list,
- 33:01Speaker 2: has a lot of stock and that's caused him to
- 33:04Speaker 2: have to recuse himself several times.
- 33:07Speaker 11: Yeah, there's no rules barring the justices from owning stock
- 33:12Speaker 11: and individual companies, but there is increasingly a culture that
- 33:16Speaker 11: discourages it. So there's been a lot of scrutiny on
- 33:20Speaker 11: Justice Alido for the individual stock he owns in dozens
- 33:25Speaker 11: of companies. So he is the only Supreme Court justice
- 33:29Speaker 11: that owns that much stock in individual companies.
- 33:31Speaker 2: And some of the justices have made a lot of
- 33:35Speaker 2: money from book deals.
- 33:37Speaker 11: Yes, this is an increasing trend among Supreme Court justices.
- 33:41Speaker 11: You know, some of them have gotten a million dollars
- 33:45Speaker 11: in advances, two million dollars for advances. Justice Amy Cony
- 33:49Speaker 11: Barrett broke records by getting a huge advance for her autobiography.
- 33:54Speaker 11: So Garrett collected about four hundred and twenty five thousand
- 33:58Speaker 11: dollars in royalties for her book in twenty twenty one,
- 34:01Speaker 11: and it hasn't been released yet.
- 34:03Speaker 2: Justice Barrett is number four on the list, followed by
- 34:05Speaker 2: Justices Elena Kegan and Sonia Sotomayor, who also had a
- 34:09Speaker 2: huge book deal something like three million dollars a few
- 34:12Speaker 2: years ago. So who is the justice at the bottom
- 34:15Speaker 2: of the list.
- 34:16Speaker 11: At the bottom of the list is Brett Kavanaugh, which
- 34:19Speaker 11: you know, was kind of surprising when he was being
- 34:22Speaker 11: considered by the Senate. He was framed in public as
- 34:26Speaker 11: this rich guy. He comes from the suburbs in Maryland,
- 34:29Speaker 11: he went to private school. But he has reported between
- 34:33Speaker 11: fifteen thousand and sixty five thousand in asset. What's possible
- 34:38Speaker 11: is that he has a lot of money in places
- 34:41Speaker 11: that he doesn't have to disclose. So for instance, it
- 34:43Speaker 11: could be in his government retirement plan, or it could
- 34:47Speaker 11: come down to his personal residence. But it's possible that
- 34:50Speaker 11: he's worth more than he has to close on Zillo.
- 34:53Speaker 2: His home is worth about one point seven million dollars,
- 34:56Speaker 2: so that just shows how it's so hard to figure
- 34:59Speaker 2: out what they're worth. Thanks Emily. That's Bloomberg Legal reporter
- 35:03Speaker 2: Emily Burned Bown and that's it for this edition of
- 35:06Speaker 2: the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 35:09Speaker 2: to Bloomberg