Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 17. Why joint accounts can become a trap if your relationship breaks down: Rebecca Glenn uncut
Transcript
- 0:00joint products are just so sticky, right?
- 0:02Yeah.
- 0:03Because joint products don't work unless both people are pulling in the same direction.
- 0:08Yeah.
- 0:09And as soon as you get to, you know, well, as soon as there's abuse, someone's not.
- 0:14And that is all about exerting their power and control over the other person.
- 0:19So it doesn't even matter if there's a financial incentive for them to do the right thing.
- 0:24They need to show control.
- 0:25Music.
- 0:28I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick.
- 0:29I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed.
- 0:38This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love.
- 0:49So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 1:20I'm Rebecca Glenn.
- 1:21I'm the founder and CEO of the Centre for Women's Economic Safety.
- 1:25We're a registered charity that supports women experiencing economic abuse in the context of family violence and we work to catalyse action improving women's economic safety.
- 1:35Our biggest initiative is our Money Clinics which provides direct one-to-one support, free, confidential, independent support for women who are concerned about their finances in the context of domestic violence.
- 1:47We also published the Financial Safety website, which is a great resource for people who are looking to secure their finances, thinking about their next steps, concerned about what is happening in their relationship when it comes to the money and finances.
- 2:03I'm so glad that you're here.
- 2:05Before we really get stuck into the conversation, I want to know a bit more about why do you do this work?
- 2:11This work really came from a personal experience I had, and I know that's not uncommon in this territory.
- 2:17But many years ago, I was working in financial literacy and was talking with an organisation that was proposing a piece of work around economic abuse.
- 2:28That was not a term that I had ever heard, and so I asked them to talk about it.
- 2:33And when they explained what it was that this is how, you know, someone restricts or exploits or sabotages someone else's finances, undermining their financial security, like limiting their autonomy.
- 2:47And they gave some examples of the kinds of things that could look like money being spent without consent.
- 2:53It could be having debts put in your name that you either didn't consent to or you didn't even know.
- 2:57And as they sort of talked through those tactics, it was really one of those penny drop moments where I went, that's what's happening to someone I'm very, very close to.
- 3:08And I had been talking with her a lot about these money problems in the relationship.
- 3:13but actually looking at it through this lens of oh this isn't just a stressful moment in time with differences of opinion this is a pattern of control and deliberate action by one person that's causing harm to another person
- 3:29And I think what really motivated me was then supporting my friend through that period of time and helping to disentangle things was, it was a terrible experience.
- 3:40And everywhere we turned for support and I worked in the area so I knew what you were supposed to do.
- 3:46And in fact, it was pretty crap what we went through.
- 3:49And so that really stayed with me.
- 3:52And, you know, over the years became, you know, I just see this problem that is so big that most people don't know the name of and very few people understand and are more than willing to respond, I should say.
- 4:06And so it just became one of those things of we've got this massive problem in this country and we don't have a commensurate size response.
- 4:13And I think I've got something to bring.
- 4:16Well, you absolutely do.
- 4:17We've known each other for a long time.
- 4:19We've worked together in various different capacities.
- 4:22And you got a Churchill Fellowship to go and study this, which is what led you to set up those money clinics and set up CWIS, right?
- 4:29That's right.
- 4:30And you were in the room when I had the moment of saying to myself, and I think to the room, this is what I want to spend the rest of my life doing.
- 4:39This is too important.
- 4:40So yeah, we have history.
- 4:42This podcast is really about helping people to understand what financial abuse is.
- 4:48But I also really want to focus on how do you set yourself up that if the worst happens, if that kind of abuse happens to you, you might be a bit protected because you understand the ways that your products and services and your accounts and the way you're sharing money.
- 5:07You might have set yourself up that it might protect you a bit.
- 5:11I'm not saying that it's going to stop people from trying to control another person through their money, but I do want people to recognise the signs.
- 5:23So we're going to focus on that a lot, but you really see what happens later.
- 5:28At that point, your team is seeing, it could even be years later, even after someone's separated,
- 5:36What are the most common situations that you're seeing where people need to disentangle those finances?
- 5:42Yeah, well, you're absolutely right.
- 5:43Where we work is with people who have realised, oh, hell, things have gone terribly wrong here.
- 5:49And so the most common situation for us and our money clinics is people who have had to leave an abusive partner in a hurry.
- 5:58They're now in refuge or in shelter and their caseworker has gone through, you know, the safety planning with them and realised that there's a financial element to this.
- 6:08And that's when they get in touch with us and our money clinics can sit down and work through some financial safety planning, even just to sort of learn what is the lay of the land here?
- 6:17What products do you have?
- 6:18What liabilities do you have?
- 6:20So that's a really common, probably, you know, the bulk of the work that we do.
- 6:25But I think it is important, you alluded to it, to say that actually years later there can be issues that arise.
- 6:32And so that's something else that we do see.
- 6:35Women who come to us, they've left an abusive partner maybe some months ago, maybe some years ago, and suddenly they're being chased either by a debt collector or they might receive a direct penalty notice.
- 6:47They're a company director of something they didn't know even existed.
- 6:51And so, you know, they can be sent for a loop many years later and have no idea where to even start.
- 7:00So that's something that, again, we can help with and get the right support around them.
- 7:05But increasingly, and I think to the point of this podcast, what is interesting, and I'm really encouraged by this, is...
- 7:14we are seeing women who come to us thinking about leaving an abusive partner.
- 7:20And I think that's important because we know that point of separation is not only physically dangerous, it is the point at which so much can go horribly wrong really quickly with the finances.
- 7:34And so seeing women taking those proactive steps to say, okay,
- 7:38I no longer believe he has my best interests at heart.
- 7:42This relationship is over.
- 7:44And what can I do to protect myself?
- 7:48And so, you know, obviously, I don't want any woman to ever have to come to a money clinics.
- 7:53I wish we didn't exist.
- 7:55But to have someone come to us and say, I'm thinking about this, but I'm terrified about what is going to happen if I pull that cord.
- 8:04is great because we can start to go, okay, let's look at some options here.
- 8:10Let's look at your liabilities.
- 8:12What steps can we quietly take to reduce the risk and have some more protective measures exactly as you're talking about?
- 8:21Yeah.
- 8:22So can you tell me a little bit about that?
- 8:24I know you've got on your brilliant financial safety website's got lots of steps that you can take.
- 8:32Every circumstance is different.
- 8:34But what would be the most common things you would say to somebody?
- 8:37If you're starting to think about, I need to go, here's the steps you could do to secure your safety and make sure you're not leaving with nothing.
- 8:49It's so interesting you're saying, you know, every situation is different.
- 8:52And I feel like all of these conversations, there's so many caveats and asterisks.
- 8:56And, you know, this isn't going to help everyone, but it could help a lot of people.
- 8:59So, yes, that's absolutely the case.
- 9:03But certainly we are now living in such a digital world.
- 9:06And I know you talk a lot about the, you know, the digital aspects, the tech aspects of financial abuse.
- 9:13But the number one thing is to have a way to communicate with service providers, product providers, that is not going to be intercepted or monitored by the person doing you harm.
- 9:26And so setting up an email address that they're not aware of, that's not connected to the cloud, that's completely separate from the life that you've otherwise built together is the starting point.
- 9:37Of course, that has to be done on a device that that person can't access that you don't usually use and so on.
- 9:43So there's a lot of, I guess, kind of tech hygiene that sits behind those first financial safety steps.
- 9:52And then I would say once you've got those kind of those building blocks in place, you want to be sure that you have, if you don't already have,
- 10:01A bank account that's in your name only that sits separate from all of the joint products and so on.
- 10:08Now, sometimes you might want that to be at a bank you're already with because it's simpler.
- 10:13You don't need to prove your identity and all of those kinds of things if you possibly can.
- 10:20go to a bank that's a different institution to one you currently bank with.
- 10:25And the reason for that is not because we shouldn't trust banks, but because banks are full of human beings and human beings make mistakes.
- 10:33And unfortunately, with a lot of the sort of, you know, data matching, the automation that sits behind some of these systems, it's just too easy for there to be a breach and for a new account or an address or something to be shared inadvertently.
- 10:48So they're probably some of the first steps.
- 10:51As you mentioned, there's a lot more detail on our website.
- 10:54Yeah, it's really interesting you mentioned that about a different bank account.
- 10:59Also, it happens with energy and water as well.
- 11:03Notifications that are sent by energy or water companies.
- 11:07We're going to be shutting down the water today or we're doing some maintenance on the energy grid.
- 11:12And the alert is sent to somebody else.
- 11:15And if you're still on the shared account, they might know where you are.
- 11:19But what I was really thinking about as you were saying, here's the steps to financial safety if you're thinking about leaving.
- 11:27What about if you applied them when everything's hunky-dory and you're starting the relationship, you're just starting to think about, I'm going to share money, we're going to put names on accounts because we're moving in together.
- 11:39Yeah.
- 11:40Does that still apply then and how does that apply?
- 11:43What should people be thinking about?
- 11:45Well, I love that idea.
- 11:46I love this idea of, okay, what steps could we put in place if things were to go wrong?
- 11:52Not, you know, that they would, of course.
- 11:55Yeah.
- 11:55Because that's, I think that's one of the big challenges, right, is that we just don't want to look into the reality of, you know,
- 12:03things going wrong.
- 12:04Yeah.
- 12:04You know, half of marriages end in divorce.
- 12:08You know, people don't stay together forever, even, you know, when things are healthy.
- 12:13So we need to get better at having conversations about marriage
- 12:19how are we going to manage this if things don't last or if one of us is sick?
- 12:25And sometimes, you know, thinking about things with a lens of illness or accident rather than you decide to become an abusive person or develop a terrible, you know, addiction or whatever.
- 12:38I'd love to hear that conversation.
- 12:39Well, what about this then?
- 12:41Yeah, yeah.
- 12:43So I...
- 12:45The healthy money conversation is something that I think has the greatest preventative power possibly.
- 12:56Because it says, okay, you and I are two separate individuals.
- 13:00We have our own lives and but we're choosing to bring them together at this point.
- 13:06That doesn't mean we have to completely abandon our own financial identity.
- 13:11I think that's a really key proposition.
- 13:14Yeah, I've seen a lot of older women who have managed the accounts in their house for a very long time by using the credit card.
- 13:24And it happens to be a credit card that is actually in their husband's name or their partner's name.
- 13:29And unfortunately, when they're widowed, they get told, sorry, you can't have a credit card anymore.
- 13:35It wasn't no credit rating.
- 13:36That's right.
- 13:37So going in a bit eyes wide open, I think, is very helpful, but hard to do because, you know,
- 13:44Young people are talking about consent when it comes to sex.
- 13:47How do I ask you for consent?
- 13:49What is it?
- 13:50How do I give it?
- 13:51How do I take it away?
- 13:52How do we keep negotiating?
- 13:54We're not having the same conversation about money.
- 13:58No, but you know, that's a great lens through which to see it.
- 14:01If that is something that is already a conversation that young people are having to be able to, you know, to add that lens to it.
- 14:10I mean, I think it's been a big missed opportunity.
- 14:12The Respectful Relationships curriculum, talking about all of these things, but not talking
- 14:17about money.
- 14:18So, you know, it is important and it's important that we start having those conversations from a pretty young age.
- 14:24You know, people are getting jobs, they're, you know, sharing costs of a dinner.
- 14:29You're already a financial identity, you know, in current society.
- 14:33So why not have those conversations from teens?
- 14:37Let's hope that we're starting that conversation or helping to give it a little bit of rocket fuel.
- 14:42I'd like to go back to when people need to separate or change their financial arrangements.
- 14:49What makes it really complicated and what is the thing that might surprise people about this is hard to do?
- 14:59So my brain automatically goes to it's really hard when someone's being obstructive, right?
- 15:04So when someone's being abusive, that's where the problems come.
- 15:06And you and I have talked about this, you know, for many, many, many hours.
- 15:11Joint products are just so sticky, right?
- 15:14Yeah.
- 15:14Because joint products don't work unless both people are pulling in the same direction.
- 15:19Yeah.
- 15:20And as soon as you get to, you know, as soon as there's abuse, someone's not.
- 15:26And that is all about exerting their power and control over the other person.
- 15:30So it doesn't even matter if there's a financial incentive for them to do the right thing.
- 15:35They need to show control.
- 15:36So obviously, you know, having an obstructive person is the biggest challenge.
- 15:42But I think there are other challenges.
- 15:44There are, you know, challenges where there's a mismatch between, you know, one person's income and another person's income.
- 15:52And there might be an informal arrangement between a couple.
- 15:55Well, I'll pay for this, but you can pay for all those things.
- 15:59Fair enough.
- 15:59You know, we all manage our finances in couples in varying ways that make sense to us.
- 16:06But if it turns out that that informal arrangement is, well, you pay the mortgage and I'll pay all of these bills, and actually what you have is...
- 16:16you know, one liability in one person's name and all of the informal things and someone else has taken care of.
- 16:24Actually, one person can be left with the liability.
- 16:26Yeah.
- 16:27So, you know, I was taking responsibility for these things, but actually there's no, you know, the groceries and all of the day to day expenses that, you know, I can just stop tomorrow.
- 16:38Yeah.
- 16:39And someone else has got the bill in their name.
- 16:40So it's the joint accounts, but it's also then the accounts where, well, I'll put the rego in my name for the car.
- 16:47And that's fantastic.
- 16:49You're going to pay that.
- 16:50I'll have paid this other stuff.
- 16:51But if I then don't pay the rego or someone doesn't pay the rego, but I'm driving the car, I'm the one who gets pulled over.
- 16:58Yeah.
- 16:59With invalid rego.
- 17:01So how would you encourage people to look at that in the setup?
- 17:08Because it's really common that you might say, well, we'll just sort it out like this and not really pay a lot of attention to whose name is on what bill.
- 17:18What would you be saying to them, well, if you are setting it up, here's how you need to think about that?
- 17:26I think one of the challenges is we don't like to think about abuse and so one helpful lens can be and I sort of touched on this a bit earlier.
- 17:35One helpful lens to look at this can be what happens if one of us is in an accident?
- 17:41What happens if one of us is sick?
- 17:44What happens if one of us dies?
- 17:46Again that's not something people like to look into either.
- 17:51can I keep driving this car if you're sick or in a coma in hospital?
- 17:59Well, in the case where the reg is in that person's name, no, so maybe we need to think about if it's the car that I drive, the reg should be in my name.
- 18:07So is there an alignment between the actual way a product is being used and who has the responsibility on paper?
- 18:15That's one way to get into the nitty-gritty without going all the way to you might abuse me one day.
- 18:23Yeah, yeah.
- 18:24And, you know, we're not trying to scare people about this too.
- 18:27It is a very, very serious problem, domestic and financial abuse.
- 18:31It's a big, widespread, hidden problem that,
- 18:36But there are simple things you can do that are going to protect you regardless.
- 18:41If someone's sick, if someone does die, awful, terrible, loses their job for a long period of time.
- 18:49Exactly.
- 18:49And there are two elements to this.
- 18:51One is what we choose to do potentially as a couple.
- 18:54How do we set this up so that we both are decision makers on this product?
- 18:59And then the other bit is obviously what organisations can do, and I'm sure we'll get to that.
- 19:04But so, you know, if I think about the example, you know, the paper that Designed to Disrupt Reimagining Insurance, you know, that situation where, you know, this woman had been paying the insurance policy for years and then realises actually the insurance policy that she's been paying isn't in her name.
- 19:25And he refuses to acknowledge that, to, you know, take any responsibility.
- 19:30The only way she can have insurance is now to set up entirely new products, losing those no claim bonuses, the loyalty bonuses and so on.
- 19:38So, you know, she's had to, there's a loss there.
- 19:43despite her having done everything right.
- 19:45Now, no doubt if that had been a joint policy, he still wouldn't have been, you know, willing to make the changes that she wanted.
- 19:54But she would have the record of a policy in her name.
- 19:58She would be able to at least start a conversation if, on the other side, the organisation had done its work on being ready to have that conversation as well.
- 20:07I think I do want to come to this now, actually, because we've talked a lot about those assumptions that are in the financial system, but also across every system.
- 20:18I started doing this work looking at banking in particular, then general insurance, but I've now looked at cross energy and water and telecommunications and government services.
- 20:29And there's a lot of assumptions in the way that those products that we use every single day have been set up.
- 20:38Can you talk to me a little bit about that?
- 20:41Because we had this really good discussion a long time ago and many years ago about what that assumption is and what the consequence of that is.
- 20:51Yeah.
- 20:52So the assumption is you get married or you move in together as life partners and you live happily ever after.
- 21:00And there's never a problem that when you want to make a change to the product, you both agree that that's in both of your best interests.
- 21:08And it simply isn't set up for a disagreement, for one party to think differently about a product, or for people to separate often, you know, unless they both have each other's best interests at heart.
- 21:23And unfortunately, even where there hasn't been abuse in a relationship, when a relationship breaks down, things can get a lot more heated up.
- 21:32But particularly where there is abuse, of course, this is a problem because the joint product in particular requires both parties to consent.
- 21:43And there really just hasn't been a contemplation of what if they don't agree?
- 21:48Forget about abuse.
- 21:49What if two parties to a contract don't agree?
- 21:52It's pretty common business practice to have the exit clause, which is if both parties disagree, you will end this contract in this way.
- 22:00Yeah.
- 22:00Why isn't it the case with financial products?
- 22:03It's so true.
- 22:04And I think about financial products not just as a bank account or a loan.
- 22:09I think about it as your energy bill, which is a credit product, your water bill, which is a credit product.
- 22:16Telco tends to be the same.
- 22:18Yeah, your phone or your internet.
- 22:20Yeah.
- 22:21All of those things are you are getting something that you have to pay a bill for later.
- 22:26And you're right, there is normally those exit clauses, but it feels like it's been a bit icky to step into that when we're in love.
- 22:34And so we surely cannot talk about that as a contract term.
- 22:40If you were to go back in time and you're with someone who's about to sign up to their contract,
- 22:47bank account, they might have a joint bank account, or they're getting a loan together for the first time, or even they're just working out whose name's going to be on the electricity bill, or are both of them going to be on the electricity bill?
- 23:03What would you want them to understand at that moment and then ask for, maybe ask their provider about, how does this work?
- 23:13Yeah, I think we would want people to ask, what is my liability with this product?
- 23:20We talked previously about illness and accident.
- 23:23What happens if?
- 23:24And I think if they understand that, then there's at least some options around, well, we should both be on that one or alternatively not.
- 23:34If maybe one person has an income, you know, there are different decisions that people are going to make.
- 23:39Unfortunately, perpetrators will always find a way to game the system.
- 23:42And so what I'd be really keen to see is providers providing more options.
- 23:48So whether that is, you know, a term and condition that allows for, look, if both parties can't agree, then this product is just going to be ended, null and void.
- 23:59I think that would give people options where they could have a conversation to say, that sounds like something we want to go in for.
- 24:09Yeah, and we are now starting to see more terms come through.
- 24:13Not that people read the fine print.
- 24:15It's very dense.
- 24:17I think I saw an artwork actually where they put up from start to finish printing of.
- 24:25the terms and conditions for various social media accounts.
- 24:29And some of them were just so long.
- 24:31They were down a long wall.
- 24:33And who's going to read that information?
- 24:35So I do think it's really incumbent on one, we need to ask the questions, but also of ourselves and educate ourselves and be a nerd.
- 24:44Do, you know, control F and try and find some of these words.
- 24:48But also the organisations that we're dealing with every day.
- 24:52need to be able to tell us this is what it means.
- 24:55I really love the way you describe that too.
- 24:57What if this happens?
- 24:59Yeah, what if.
- 25:01And the terms and conditions, you know, that campaign to have financial abuse mentioned in the terms and conditions means that the organisation has brought itself some flexibility together.
- 25:13in that situation and so that is a good point that's a great starting point say have you contemplated as an organization this possibility there's more chance you gonna be on my side if the worst happens
- 25:26Yeah, and we've seen also the new terms in insurance policies like conduct of others and others, which I'll talk about in later episodes.
- 25:37So I'm hopeful that things are changing, but there's still a long way to go, isn't there?
- 25:42There is a long way to go.
- 25:43And I think having a conversation that means more people recognise financial abuse
- 25:51early is really a positive step.
- 25:54And as we're having those conversations for product providers to recognise the role that they can play, and I think we can't forget the difference in the amount of knowledge and information and power that our financial institutions and our essential services, our telcos, that they have compared to any individual trying to navigate their way through life, trying to navigate their way through life
- 26:19I mean, how many products must we all have just to get by day to day?
- 26:22Like there's, you know, dozens.
- 26:24Yeah, exactly, and they're all on our phone.
- 26:27And then you never remember which one you've subscribed to anyway.
- 26:30And then you get the bit, what?
- 26:32What do you mean I've subscribed to five gyms?
- 26:37So before we finish, is there anything else that we haven't covered that you'd really like to talk about in the context of how do we set people up?
- 26:47How do we help people understand that there are some problems
- 26:50points in time when you're making decisions about how you're sharing money or bills and managing those in a relationship.
- 27:00I think the game changing piece of the last decade has really been the manner in which smartphones have become our everything.
- 27:13And I, on holiday a year ago, ended up in a foreign country where my phone just stopped working.
- 27:22And so, you know, you're traveling, you want access to your bank account.
- 27:27I'm trying to sort things out, but all of the notifications to, you know, multi-factor authentication are going to the phone that's not working.
- 27:35And so you're just in this loop where that was everything and now I'm stuck.
- 27:40Now, I give you that example outside of a context of abuse to say it's just become so central.
- 27:47We've supported at the money clinics recently young women who, while they were sleeping, their partner used their phone to take out a personal loan.
- 27:59The money was taken out of their accounts by their partner before they even realized they had a loan.
- 28:06And it's just so easy now if you have a few pieces of personal information about someone and their smartphone, that's all you need.
- 28:17And unfortunately, while the financial institutions have really upped their game around frauds and scams,
- 28:23In this case, this young woman went to the bank and said what had happened.
- 28:29The fraud team investigated, said she hadn't reported her phone stolen.
- 28:33Her IP address says she's right here.
- 28:36So no, no can do.
- 28:38We can't help.
- 28:38So I think...
- 28:40The sophistication around frauds and scams, you know, it's about how do we bring that?
- 28:44And I agree it is a much more complex issue, but how do we start to become more sophisticated about what is happening, particularly in intimate partners, but it could also be obviously, you know, a sibling, a carer, a family member.
- 28:58I think that's where we've got to look at.
- 29:00In heated agreement with you there, there's a lot of the tactics that,
- 29:06that scammers use, social engineering, the grooming, I'm going to trick you into it, I'm even going to make you complicit in helping me to get access to that money.
- 29:16And that's not some guy in a hoodie.
- 29:17It's a guy that's sitting with their farms of people who are enslaved as part of organised crime to do that.
- 29:26We've seen a big step up, I think, because we've understood what's going on a bit more and there's now this concerted effort happening.
- 29:33As you know, I think we're united in arguing there need to be some similar approaches.
- 29:39Thank you so much for your time.
- 29:40For each guest, we are asking them to complete this sentence, which is, before you say yes, do what?
- 29:50How would you say that sentence?
- 29:53Before you say yes, have the conversation with your partner, with your sibling, with your family member.
- 30:01What happens if one of us gets sick?
- 30:04What happens if one of us is no longer able to pay?
- 30:08Have the conversation.
- 30:11Rebecca Glenn, thank you so much for joining us today.
- 30:14Really appreciate it.
- 30:16Welcome.
- 30:17Welcome.