Latest / Markets to Menus by ArrowStream / Hormuz Watch, Restaurant Reality Check
Transcript
- speaker-0: Labor's a tremendous problem for restaurants right now. A minimum wage has been going up tremendously. And what we're also seeing is because of the costs going up, we see restaurants actually reducing their headcount to try to control some of these costs. We ran some numbers recently where over the last two years actually. We're seeing six percent less heads at a given restaurant. And so what that means is that the restaurants are having to do far more with less people than they've done before. It can be a very difficult situation for them. speaker-1: Yeah. Hey everyone, welcome back to Markets to Menus. Today we've got a great lineup to help you make sense of what's happening in the food supply chain from the global markets all the way down to your bottom line. First up, we're joined by John Goodwin, senior commodity analyst at Aerostream. We're discussing what's moving the markets right now, including an update on the Strait of Hermuz and what you need to know about chicken supplies. Stick around because it's definitely worth paying attention to. Then we switch gears and bring in Brian Foster, president of Back Office Solutions at Buyer's Edge. Brian's giving us a read on how independent restaurant industry is holding up today, plus some real practical best practices that operators can actually use. Before we jump in, a quick shout out to our sponsor, which is us, Aerostream Commodity One. With over four decades of industry experience and deep learning, cutting-edge AI to power your food commodity solutions. We can help you from everything from smart forecasting to contracting. To learn more, check us out at aerostream.com. All right, let's get into it. In the grain markets last week, mostly lower. The one exception was soybean oil. Was marginally higher, but still below the $70 level or 70 cent per pound level. Still would like to see that go lower. Almost all these markets are trading 12 to 23% above last year. Dairy markets mixed cheese lower, butter higher, nonfat dry milk higher. In the grand scheme of things, they've been mostly range bound. It's kind of the same story there. We've got big supplies, we've got big exports, but those exports really aren't big enough to significantly pressure the markets higher. Chicken output last week was down about one and a half percent from the prior year. Year to date is up two and a half percent year on year. Markets were mostly lower. The one exception was chicken wings, which, don't get me wrong, are still relatively engaging, but they're trading at their highest prices in nearly a year. Pork, I'll put up three tenths week on week, down almost a percentage point from the prior year. Gear to date, up a half percentage point, and that's just a half percentage point, folks, with most of these markets trading well below year ago levels. Prices were mixed last week, although bellies continued to seasonally move higher. And they're also near one-year highs. Beef output last week down a half percentage point week on week, down 2.7% versus last year. But that's better than we've been year to date. Year to date is down 5.6%. That's output and slaughter down 8.1% year on year. Prices were mostly firm last week. Trim was one of the exceptions there. Interesting to see a lot of these markets tracking below year-ago levels, even though. Output has been also been below Eurogo levels. USDA Choice and Select Box Beef Cutouts both trading below Eurogo, and those are kind of your index of overall ⁓ box beef markets. But the loins, the rounds, the flanks, the plates, beef 50s, B50 trim, beef 85 trim, all trading below year ago levels. Energy markets, crude oil was lower despite. The challenge in the Strait of Hormuz, which we'll talk about more in a minute. Gasoline marginally lower, but still the second highest in eight weeks, still up 44% from a year ago. And for our clients, no, we remain concerned around these continued elevated gas prices and the impact on the consumer. Diesel, nine week highs last week, and it's over a dollar fifty versus a year ago. So John, obviously fuel prices aren't down as we just mentioned. The straits not open yet fully and it looks like it'll be a slow reopening once it occurs. What does this mean for the markets, in particular fertilizer prices, which we haven't heard a lot about recently? speaker-2: Yeah, well there's a good reason for that. So fertilizer spiked right at the offset of this war, right as the strait was closed, but has been coming back down to earth ever since then. So I wouldn't say we're back to normal per se, but we're trending in the right direction and hopefully we'll have some kind of resolution here by the time South America's harvest com ⁓ planting season comes around. That's the first real concern with fertilizer and you know, we hear them in the In North America we won't start planting until next spring and most of the farmers who were planting this past spring already had their fertilizer needs covered before this thing started. But South America is a concern, but I don't think it's as much of a concern as some people are making it out to be. At the end of the day, fertilizer prices have come back down. speaker-1: So speaking of not being perhaps concerned as earlier, clients would know that we've been concerned about chicken producer margins due to the kind of atypical moves we've seen in the chicken markets during the spring and ⁓ in the summer so far. And you know, when chicken producers can have poor margins, folks, that can lead to a pullback in output. And we've seen some data along those lines. Well, maybe I shouldn't say pullback in output, but more so maybe a tap the brakes on output. Growth or supply growth. But we've seen some data points that kind of back up our concerns as of late. One, ⁓ chick placements, which is kind of the availability of birds for slaughter, think one to three months out. The six-week average of that is just eight tenths above a year ago. A couple months ago, we were tracking closer to two and a half percent above a year ago. So that that has tempered some. And then the broiler layers, broiler meaning chicken for the chicken meat supply layer is your mama hens laying the eggs that eventually are gonna hatch and the chick's gonna be fed and then set into the meat supply. But the broiler layers in May and June declined by the second most amount since 2012, still above a year ago. So with those two data points, you know, we got some key quarterly reports here over the last ⁓ week and a half. First, Pilgrim's Pride, second largest chicken producer. In the United States, they reaffirmed our concerns for chicken producer margins as their operating income as a share of revenue was the worst for any quarter in 13 quarters. Okay, so that does reflect our concerns around the chicken producer margins. But a few days later, Tyson reported earnings, and in their chickens segment, they kind of blew it out of the water. They were really good. They were actually better than a year ago, which was really surprising. And it's because this Somewhere around 15 to 25 percent of their chicken supply and only, I should say, is on the commodity markets. The rest is contracted. So what does this mean as we go forward? I mean, I I think we're seeing some indications that growth is going to be slowed some, but at the same time, maybe as not as drastically as we've seen in the past. We are hearing pilgrims and Tyson saying a key phrase, kind of matching supply with demand, which tells me that, hey, You know, they might be slow and grow some, but it's something that we need to watch. Now, something else we need to watch, John, right, is sugar. What's going on there? speaker-2: Yeah, so sugar kind of the whole market kind of exploded last week. You know, we've been under pressure for a while now, maybe close to a year at this point, kind of stuck in a bear market cycle, but prices have come roaring back to life. I think what got it started was some private estimates calling for the global sugar market to dip back into a into deficit territory next year. But what really accelerated it was last week's Unica report. So Unico releases this report every month detailing Brazil's sugarcane harvest in the South Central region, this one through June, and it wasn't great. You know, production was down across both the first and second half of June, down pretty hard due to a combination of above average rainfall, particularly in Sao Paulo, Brazil's big sugar producing state, and the higher crude oil prices we had back then. Those two things don't sound related right off the bat, but A lot of Brazil's ethanol is produced from sugar cane. Their corn ethanol industry is growing, but still most of the ethanol they produce is produced from sugar cane. So when crude oil is expensive, that tends to raise the demand for ethanol, raising production margins for ethanol, and drawing more sugar cane away from sugar production. So those two things combine to result in a really disappointing production total for June. And while July to August is usually the height of Brazil's sugarcane harvest. That report really put us in a hole that be nearly impossible to dig us out of. So I think the the sugar market was kind of asleep at the wheel for a while. You know, we knew about that h above average rainfall in Sao Paulo for a while, but it seems like the market was kind of not taking full account of it until that report came out on Thursday. So Yeah, we'll see what happens from here now that they have the data to prove that it was a disappointing month altogether. I imagine sugar has some more upside from here. speaker-1: Thanks, John. speaker-0: Okay. speaker-1: All right, Brian. Welcome to the show. Tell us a little bit about yourself. speaker-0: Hey David, thanks for having me on. Yeah, Brian Foster, I'm the president of the back office division and happy to be here. speaker-1: Yeah. So back office is part of the broader buyer's edge platform, right? Which includes Aerostream in the software division as well as Insight Track, right? So can you walk us through what does back office mean? speaker-0: That's correct. Yeah, Back Office is really it's a financial and cost management operating system for restaurants. It's a very diverse solution set, focusing really heavily on restaurant operations. So think about inventory, recipe costing, really in-store tactical operational controls. And then in addition to that, it's a full accounting software suite. So think of full profit and loss statements, balance sheets, cash flow statements, bank reconciliation, right? All the core accounting functionality, as well as a full payroll suite. So we fully wrap our arms around a restaurant from their operational, their financial perspective, as well as their payroll. And then we also offer. ⁓ heavy service components. So we do bookkeeping services as well. So we can really provide a full suite to help restaurants understand their business, their cost structure, how they're doing, and give them really actionable information to improve their business. I actually started back out of college, I actually started in manufacturing with a family business. I started trailer manufacturing business for the construction industry with my father. speaker-1: How did you get here? speaker-0: And the way I ended up in software is as growing a manufacturing business, we tried to implement a manufacturing software and just utterly failed with it because it was just far too complex. And so what I ended up doing is I went to ⁓ remember when Borders Bookstore was still around, like the Barnes and Nobles book? Yeah, yeah. I went and bought a book. three inches thick called ⁓ how to program Microsoft Access. And I ended up building my entire ERP system that we ran our manufacturing system on for 15 years. And it was bills of materials, it was vendors, it was purchasing and procurement, it was quoting everything that we really are doing today, you know, with recipe costing and ingredients and the rest of it. And so back then I really fell in love with software and bootstrapped again my own ERP system. And ultimately then we ended up selling that business ⁓ fifteen years later. And I had an opportunity to get into business with my ⁓ relative, my cousins actually, that were an N C R Aloha dealer. And that's how I got into the food service, but always ⁓ obviously had a very deep ⁓ connection with software. And that just steamrolled and ended up joining the CFO and the CEO of Aloha when NCR bought that business. And they started a company called Orderly, which was the genesis of what John Davy ultimately bought for us, helping the independent restaurants really compete with the big chains by offering them a great software solution that kind of leveled the playing field from a tech stack perspective. speaker-1: Yeah, great story. So you mentioned John Davy, founder and of Buyer's Edge Platform, and Black Office sits inside the Buyers Edge platform, ⁓ which touches over two hundred thousand restaurant locations. What does that kind of data footprint tell you about the health of the independent restaurant segment right now? Like what are you seeing in back office? What does it tell you about the industry? speaker-0: Yeah. So, you know, with the buyer's edge connection and with that many restaurants, I think we're up to over a hundred billion dollars in invoice data capture as the buyer's edge platform. It's less at back office because we're obviously a part of that. But what that insight and what that data provides us is real time understanding of cost structures and what's happening with individual ingredients and not just commodity generalization but specific pricing for individual ingredients. And so that provides us a lot of insight. And in particular for back office customers as well as the buyer's edge customers is tremendous benchmarking because we have such extensive data. It helps us and helps our customers understand where do they fit in their own individual pricing relative to businesses in similar size and concept. So it helps give them a better understanding of their costs relative to their competitors and where do they have opportunities or where are their opportunities to do better from a cross cost perspective. speaker-1: Very cool. And we actually at Aerostream, also, for those of you don't know, part of the Buyer's Edge platform and kind of even a more sister company to back office since we fall under the software umbrella, right? We started benchmarking it for chains here earlier this year. So very cool. So what does that data tell you about cost for operators today? Are there any trends you're seeing? speaker-0: Yeah. I mean twenty twenty six has been a rough year for operators. Costs have continued to go up and these are cycles, obviously. We're our customers really worry about a handful of things, in particular beef and poultry in particular are areas that we hear a lot from our customers of concern. And even recently with oil prices going up and shipping costs going up, trucking, you know, diesel fuel, etc., they're feeling these pinches. Food costs for restaurants is obviously a huge percentage, right? It's food and labor, or the two the prime cost for the independence ⁓ or for all restaurants. But we're seeing a lot of our restaurant customers having to raise menu prices at this point because they're not. They're having a really hard time finding enough savings with just the general cost increases. I think the NRA published a figure this year. 90% of the independents have had to raise menu prices in some way or another. And that's a really tough place for restaurants because, as you know, that's the last place a restaurant wants to turn to to improve their bottom line. And for the independents, it's such a razor-thin line, four to five percent on average, that when they're having to default to raising prices, that is a huge risk for them because that there's a direct correlation of the volume of business. And I saw another metric, I think, up to this point in this year, it's a little concerning. I mean, I think there's 7600 restaurants that have had the closed doors. So far this year, and a lot of it is because of the pricing pressure. speaker-1: Mm, interesting. How about on the labor side? Is there anything that your division captures on the labor side for these restaurants? speaker-0: Yeah, labor's a tremendous problem for restaurants right now. ⁓ minimum wage has been going up tremendously. And ⁓ what we're also seeing is because of the costs going up, we see restaurants actually reducing their headcount to try to control some of these costs. We ran some numbers recently where over the last two years actually. We're seeing six percent less heads at a given restaurant. And so what that means is that the restaurants are having to do far more with less people than they've had to do before. So it's a really it can be a very difficult situation for them. And from a product perspective, we are seeing some encouraging things from the back office side is. We're seeing about a thirty-five, forty percent increase in certain segments of our product, like waste, like inventory, like recipe costing. Because restaurants can do more to try to manage their costs for food than they can with labor, because the state will define what the minimum minimum wage is. It's kind of out of their hands. On the food side, they have more control to say, well, maybe I adjust my portion, maybe I change. one ingredient for another that may be less less expensive but same have the same flavor profile. And so with some of these tools like recipe costing, waste logs, these are ways for them to really tactically on a day in and day out basis have greater control and try to claw back some of that margin loss that they're seeing from these higher costs for food and as well as a higher cost with minimum wages. speaker-1: Mm-hmm. And that's done through back office too. speaker-0: Yeah, that's done through back office, exactly. speaker-1: Yeah. So just I was looking at some stats just to prepare for this call. And just looking at the number of jobs in the food service industry since COVID, it's up a little bit. I mean, less than a percentage point, I think, since January 2020. But wages in that period are up forty one percent. Right. Sounds like it's not just independence, but but chains are also probably having the same challenges. speaker-0: That's right. ⁓ speaker-1: So speaking of that, there's been a lot of conversation about independence losing ground to chains. Is that narrative backed up with your CN? speaker-0: Terms of I guess depending on what you're looking at, right? From a payroll perspective, what we see is it is a little bit regional and that six percent headcount reduction, you know, I was looking at we have some IHOP customers particular and they fall right in that same range. So I think I see some similarities. I think from a technology perspective, if you look at it from that view. The larger chains obviously have a bigger footprint, have more financial scale to look at investing in technologies to help improve efficiency and allow restaurants to do more, but the independents don't have that ability. And so that's where I think AI, it's gonna take a little bit more time, maybe six, twelve, eighteen months. But AI as it disperses into the mid market and lower segments SMB is going to, I believe, be a very positive influence and have a positive impact for these businesses because AI is going to, you know, through the proper tools, is going to empower businesses to be able to do more with less, be able to help ⁓ with analyzing data. You know, this is part of what we're doing at Back Office where It's a very interesting topic where you have solutions called system of records, where core data is housed, like general ledger activity, like ingredient purchases, right? System of record. And that's think of back office. Think of even our competitors like restaurant 365. Think of Salesforce. That's a system of record. Applying AI and a system of intelligence on top of that. is what then allows a restaurant to do far more with analysis of that information, pulling systems together, bringing the point of sale data, this the payroll data, and as well as all of your accounting data together and having a more holistic system of intelligence that can help guide the restaurant with greater and deeper analysis and ultimately transition to then doing things on behalf of the restaurant as an employee might do. So those are areas that we are really focusing on at Back Office. Again, because we are really focused on the SMB, the emerging and mid-market space. And that's the space that's going to need the most help in harnessing what AI can really bring to the table for them. speaker-1: Yeah. Can you give us an example? Like what is your moonshot here, Brian? Like what do you think that looks like five or ten years from now from a back office in your customer's perspective? speaker-0: ⁓ man, the opportunities are endless. But to give you a couple of quick examples of things that restaurant operators face every single day that that are trying to manage their costs, you have purchases coming in. We'll just use a very easy example, right? A restaurant, David's pizza, right? You're buying sauce, you're buying speaker-1: Best piece in town. Right. Right. Yeah. speaker-0: You you're buying pepperoni, you're buying mozzarella cheese, right? And you might have several vendors that you're buying all these products from, but you have hundreds and hundreds of ingredients because you sell subs, you sell salads, right? Everything. Well, when you're bringing all that information in, it's a really high volume of information and data. And you have to digitize it. If you want to do inventory, if you want to have Accurate recipe costing. If you want to understand, if I just wasted six ounces of cheese because it accidentally dropped on the floor, how do I know how much that costs? Well, the AI part of what we do is digitizing that, but the AI is going to help when you need help with categorizing things. The AI could proactively reach out and say, Hey David, I see some purchases here. That seem like they're similar, would you like me to group them together so that your costs are in alignment? And you can simply reply back and say, yeah, that sounds good. And the AI will get to the point where it will go actually do the work within the technology, within the system of record, and make those updates. Now, we're not quite there yet, but my point is that not only are we going to be able to capture data, digitize it for a restaurant to use in reporting or analysis, but the AI is going to empower action that will go in and do things on their behalf. We're actually running proofs of concept to say, hey, here's a picture of a cheeseburger. Go build me a recipe for that so I could play around with should I add that to our my menu or not? Scenario play, right? These are things that someone has today, someone has to sit down at a computer and type that out or sit in front of a spreadsheet, find their invoices. How much is ground beef? How much is a bun? Type that in to get the cost of a burger to then decide should I include it on my menu or what price should I charge? These are the types of things that AI will be partner in crime and help you operate and do things on your behalf. This is how I think the AI is going to be just a tremendous tailwind, especially for the small independents, because those are the folks that are most constrained from a labor perspective. I mean, so many of our customers, David, are working 80, 100 hours a week, right? And they're doing just the things that are most important to keep that door open. But there's so much more that could be done. For them to have a better understanding of their business, have more options of how should they strategically move their business one direction or another, but that you need intelligence, you need information to help guide that decision making. And through better intelligence that AI will bring, as well as actual things that the AI is going to do on your behalf, that's going to be a tremendous tailwind. And drive productivity for the small independent restaurants. speaker-1: Yeah, great stuff. So I I think you know this, but our family owns a restaurant in downtown Sarasota. Yeah. It's incredibly hard to sit back. It is. It's an incredibly difficult low margin business. And it's really hard to do those things today. All right. That's great stuff. So let's say you're an independent operator today and you're saying, Brian, that's great. I can't wait. But what should I focus on now? How can I improve my business now? speaker-0: Well, I think if you look at it from the perspective of what should I be doing as I need to wrap my mind around AI and develop a strategy, I I think first and foremost, I think r people in general really need to dive into AI. That could be as simple as signing up for any one of the the major models today, whether it's Anthropic and Claude or OpenAI, Gemini, but there's so much capability today in these models. And people just need to get started and get to orient themselves around using the products because there's so much capability, even and it's not even just obvious things like drop ⁓ some invoices versus a quote in and say, Am I being charged properly? The AI will spit back and say, yeah, you were charged properly according to what you were quoted, or no, here's an area that you were incorrectly charged. But you can actually use AI to do some of the administrative parts of your business. Things like even HR, right? Evaluate resumes. Have an AI help you determine which of these resumes is the best fit. have it help you write a ⁓ employee handbook, right? Because you don't have the administrative. So there's lots and lots of applications that the AI can help with that can even today, right, alleviate some of that work that has to be done that is part of that 80, 100 hours that someone's putting in on a weekly basis that has to get done. So take small little steps and just use the tool. And then as you get more comfortable with just the very basics, when you start to evaluate systems like a back office, you're gonna be far more ready to really get the most out of those kinds of solutions and and what they can bring with the AI component. Cool. speaker-1: Very cool. So how do people learn more about back office and connect with you? speaker-0: Yeah, you can jump on our website. It's www.bep back office dot com. Learn more about our operations. We call it food cost management, accounting, payroll, and click the learn more button and ⁓ shoot us a note. We'd love to talk with speaker-1: Cool. Well thanks for talking to us today, Brian. speaker-0: Thanks for having me, David. speaker-1: Thanks for joining us today. We hope you walked away with valuable insights you can put to work right away. If you found this content helpful, we'd greatly appreciate it if you could take a quick moment to leave us a review. Your feedback generally helps us grow and reach more professionals like yourself. And if you know a colleague, teammate, or industry peer who could benefit from these insights, please do them a favor and forward this alone. Before we sign off, don't forget to explore Aerostream Commodity One. It's built to give you the visibility, real-time data and control you need to manage commodity risk, streamline sourcing, and make confident, data-driven purchasing decisions. Thanks again for your support and we'll see you next time on Markets to Menus.