Latest / Stories of Change: Helping You Navigate What's Next / How Writing Retreats Unlock Creativity: Insight from Dr. Vani Naik
Transcript
- 0:02Judy Oskam: Are you a professor or a writer and have you ever struggled with finding the time to get your writing done?
- 0:09Judy Oskam: Well, I can certainly relate.
- 0:11Judy Oskam: Welcome to Stories of Change and Creativity.
- 0:14Judy Oskam: I'm Judy Oskam.
- 0:16Judy Oskam: While teaching a class for Texas State at Queen Margaret University in Scotland, I stumbled upon a writing retreat designed for academics and the coordinator, Vani Naik, was open to a short interview on my iPhone.
- 0:32Judy Oskam: Vani and I talked about writing creativity and the challenges we all face when staring at the blank page or computer screen, and she should know.
- 0:42Judy Oskam: Dr Vani Naik is an expert on academic careers.
- 0:46Judy Oskam: Her PhD work focused on women professors in engineering.
- 0:51Judy Oskam: In one of her roles, she serves as a researcher developer at Edinburgh Napier University in Scotland.
- 0:59Judy Oskam: Our conversation focuses on the purpose of the writing retreat and offers some tips for dealing with distraction.
- 1:07Judy Oskam: I hope you enjoy our conversation.
- 1:12Vani Naik: And what we're doing here is a three-day writing retreat for academics and postgraduate researchers doing PhDs, and we bring them away to this separate space and there's an option to stay residentially so staying overnight in the halls of residence and we provide all the um, the food that you need your breakfast, lunch and dinner.
- 1:34Vani Naik: So essentially they can just focus on their writing projects, whatever that may be.
- 1:38Vani Naik: So it could be the writing an article for phd researchers could be working on their thesis um, so it's whatever writing projects that they want to kind of focus on.
- 1:48Vani Naik: So we bring that here as a separate space from their day-to-day lives.
- 1:53Judy Oskam: And why is that important to really separate?
- 1:57Vani Naik: I think many people try to get writing done in between lots of daily demands, but, as you might know as a professor yourself that it's very, very difficult to get that done when there's lots of daily demands.
- 2:06Vani Naik: But, as you might know as a professor yourself that it's very, very difficult to get that done when there's lots of email creep or people say, oh, can I just ask you a question?
- 2:10Vani Naik: There's lots of distractions.
- 2:11Vani Naik: So the idea here is really to provide as much as possible a distraction-free space, plus the separation, I think, of a different physical environment hopefully stimulates that creative energy that they might need to get started on some projects or things they've left behind.
- 2:27Vani Naik: Um, the feedback that we've get um is always that they really value being in that completely different space, that it really does spark something different for them well, and the way you've got it designed.
- 2:39Judy Oskam: You just came back from a walk, yeah, so you went out for a walk in nature.
- 2:43Vani Naik: yeah.
- 2:44Vani Naik: So I mean I would say that that's something that I have brought in, because when I first took over it was purely just writing sessions there was.
- 2:51Vani Naik: It was literally turn it right and me and one thing that I really wanted to inject is that creativity, and partly because sessions are quite long than 90 minute sessions and I think doing four of those a day is quite intense, and I decided that the third session I want it to be optional, so I even put that you can have a nap, because if they're staying in their residences they can go and have a nap.
- 3:12Vani Naik: And I put walk and I'm happy to lead a walk and I've actually been delighted at how many people have come for the walk.
- 3:17Vani Naik: I've also put in again, new for this year is some yoga stretching, uh, just lunch.
- 3:23Vani Naik: So we had just today we did yoga for fingers, hands and wrists and we also now also do a 50 second breathing bubble before each writing session just to get them into the zone.
- 3:34Vani Naik: And you might have seen I also brought a jigsaw in as well.
- 3:36Vani Naik: So I just put that out there to people to just have a little play, do something a little bit different.
- 3:42Vani Naik: So trying to sort of inject little elements of creativity just for fun, but I think I'm sure there's someone who's doing a research study that somewhere.
- 3:50Vani Naik: But I like to think that it helps get them.
- 3:52Vani Naik: Um, you know, it will help them eventually in their projects, but if not, it just gives them an idea that when they're writing in their own environment, maybe they can also go for a walk.
- 4:02Vani Naik: We know there's loads so much research that shows how beneficial it is.
- 4:05Vani Naik: So, um, yeah, just trying to give them options of things they can do, not just here while they're with us, but also things they can do in their own lives so you're actually teaching them models and formats and structures that that might might help them be more productive.
- 4:20Vani Naik: Yeah, yeah, I'd like to show them that, you know, one of the things that I think is really important is when you're writing, you're writing, and when you're not writing, you're not writing, because so many people try to write and do other things, and I think it's a clear focus, which is so important, and I think that's one of the real benefits.
- 4:38Vani Naik: They always say how amazed they are how much they can get done in a short space of time, and that's easier to do when you're purely focused on that.
- 4:48Judy Oskam: Why, do you think I mean, we're so distracted in our day to day?
- 4:51Judy Oskam: Is that why this has been a successful conference for so long?
- 5:13Vani Naik: for academics generally, but having the space and time to do that and I think people also just, you know, someone said to me that there's a grant proposal they want to write and it's, you know, 10,000 words and they just haven't had the headspace to get into it and having the time to do that deep thinking and that deep work without being distracted, I think is really helpful.
- 5:29Judy Oskam: Well, I know when I've worked on projects in the past and I've done documentary and editing and you need blocks and blocks of time.
- 5:37Vani Naik: Yeah.
- 5:38Judy Oskam: And it's impossible sometimes to rearrange your schedule for that.
- 5:43Vani Naik: Yes, we try to organize these well in advance so people can kind of almost breathe a sigh of relief even in.
- 5:49Vani Naik: We're in June now, so let's say even I think I announced it like February, March, so that they know the days are coming, so they can sort of be calm knowing that time is coming, Because once you block it in a diary it's there, you know.
- 6:01Vani Naik: I think creating a space afterwards can be tricky, but once it's in, it's in.
- 6:05Judy Oskam: Yeah, yeah.
- 6:06Judy Oskam: What are some tips that you've that you've learned from doing the conference on things that really work for people, because you put out the puzzles this year, so you're kind of iterating as you go.
- 6:17Vani Naik: Yeah, absolutely, I like to innovate, I like to.
- 6:19Vani Naik: One of the things that has been really helpful is giving them the permission at the very beginning and saying please put your out-of-office reply on your emails, like setting that tone, also just being very explicit.
- 6:31Vani Naik: Explicit, like, please put your phones away if you can.
- 6:33Vani Naik: Obviously some people have reasons where they need to have their phones nearby, but please physically put them away.
- 6:39Vani Naik: You know, you don't need to even look at them again.
- 6:41Vani Naik: Just having that community of people buying into that really, really helps.
- 6:46Vani Naik: Um, and one thing I've been so delightfully um, surprised that people were willing to give the yoga a go.
- 6:53Vani Naik: I wasn't sure it was an experiment this year, but no shoes came off and I chose yoga sessions that were standing, only ones that you didn't have to do and you know sort of pretzel like shapes.
- 7:02Vani Naik: That would be good for me.
- 7:05Vani Naik: I could not do that, yeah, so, but I made it kind of ones that would be.
- 7:08Vani Naik: The first one was office yoga, next one was for hands and wrists, and people have gone into it and I think that's really good.
- 7:18Vani Naik: But for me, a really key part of whether people are willing to do that is how included they feel.
- 7:22Vani Naik: So I really make sure on the first day we spend time on introductions.
- 7:25Vani Naik: I put everyone's name up so that because they all don't know each other Some of them of them, you know they come from all over, yeah, and use their names and I get to know them a little bit and I think those small things mean that they are willing to buy in because they're not nobody, they're somebody to me.
- 7:41Vani Naik: Um, I don't know them really well, but I think they know.
- 7:44Vani Naik: Like, if they don't come, I just say are you okay?
- 7:46Vani Naik: Just checking you're fine, um, and I think that might be a little bit absent, I think, from everyday academic life.
- 7:51Vani Naik: You know, people are quite independent, as rightly so, um, but just to for them to know that you know I care about them and making sure that they're okay and that that seems to hopefully, and you know, foster the environment where people are willing to try things well, I think everyone needs to be seen, right, everybody wants to be seen absolutely and especially when their work is so personal.
- 8:13Judy Oskam: Yes, it's writing and it's their.
- 8:15Judy Oskam: It's their livelihood and their life.
- 8:17Judy Oskam: Yeah, so I think you have some elements there, but have you tried meditation at all?
- 8:22Judy Oskam: Have you included some of that?
- 8:25Vani Naik: oh we, I won't call it meditation, but it'd be a breathing, like a really slow inhale and exhale because, um, you know, meditation can have religious roots.
- 8:34Vani Naik: I want to make sure I just keep that kind of secular, but that has gone down well.
- 8:39Vani Naik: But yeah, that's something that you know.
- 8:42Vani Naik: I can always invite people at the end if they would like to do that a bit more.
- 8:45Vani Naik: That could be next year's innovation.
- 8:48Judy Oskam: Well, what is your background to get you into this?
- 8:51Judy Oskam: Oh wow, how okay you get into this uh, it's a great question.
- 8:55Vani Naik: So I'm a teacher by background originally, but then I did a PhD and through PhD, the bits that I was doing was always trying to foster community.
- 9:04Vani Naik: I set up a writing group even when I was a PhD student and I really enjoyed those things that were distractions, quote, unquote and then I realized that this was an actual job.
- 9:13Vani Naik: So I had the pleasure of getting this job at Edinburgh and AP University as research developer and that basically allows me to try out all these things.
- 9:22Vani Naik: And, honestly, I had a terrible time during my PhD which I'm very open about and for me it was during that time to really think about all the ways that I could try to build community things that I needed, and having the position now to make those things happen for other people.
- 9:40Vani Naik: You know, hopefully most people are having a much better time, but even whether you're having a good time or less good time, these kind of activities are there to help you.
- 9:47Vani Naik: You know they're there for everyone.
- 9:49Vani Naik: So, um, you know, most of the time I'm doing it for myself because I'm like, hey, a jigsaw will be fun, you know, just to do another.
- 9:55Vani Naik: You know it's when the break.
- 9:56Vani Naik: The teachers are right.
- 9:57Judy Oskam: We we keep making it fun so that we enjoy this bell and students come along.
- 10:02Judy Oskam: They're good.
- 10:03Judy Oskam: So, yeah, I think that's part of it too, and I love that that you really are pulling from your own background.
- 10:09Vani Naik: Oh, oh definitely, yeah, I, I, I know that community was really important for me, for people to see me and and to recognize how I worked, and I know I feel very fortunate that in my role I have the freedom to to be, to innovate and bring new things in and say, oh, let's try this.
- 10:25Vani Naik: Oh, actually, I think we should.
- 10:26Vani Naik: You know, I didn't ask for anyone permission, anyone's permission.
- 10:29Vani Naik: I okay, I'm bringing it.
- 10:30Vani Naik: It's a jigsaw, but you know, some micromanagers might say, no, that's um, not serious, too fun, it's not serious enough.
- 10:37Vani Naik: So I just brought it.
- 10:37Vani Naik: I didn't force anyone, I just put a count of the pieces, make sure they were all there, and and then people seem to be doing them like okay, yeah, okay, yeah.
- 10:45Vani Naik: So I only brought one and someone seems to be finishing it as we speak.
- 10:47Vani Naik: So well, you have to shake it up again.
- 10:49Judy Oskam: Yeah, maybe I love that.
- 10:52Judy Oskam: I've heard you use the word permission a couple times and I think that's something that you know.
- 10:58Judy Oskam: Giving people permission to get out of the box or to do things differently yeah, I think that's so important and if you start with that mindset, it sounds like that's the whole premise of the conference, right Is yeah, be yourself, let's find a way to move forward.
- 11:14Vani Naik: So yeah, I think the trouble I have is that I don't think it's different, I think it's normal.
- 11:19Judy Oskam: No, but yeah.
- 11:22Vani Naik: Not stream, think it's different, I think it's normal, but I think, oh, but yeah, not, I will not stream exactly that's what they discover, but people are very willing to give things a go and um, yeah, I am really delighted that they also seem to be making progress with their writing.
- 11:32Vani Naik: It's not a.
- 11:32Vani Naik: Sometimes I think there's a reductive, um, way of thinking in academia.
- 11:37Vani Naik: It says you can either be a serious writer or you can do a jigsaw, you know, know, whereas you can do both, and in fact they, they foster each other.
- 11:43Vani Naik: So I'm all about the and you can be a serious academic and you can do all these other things as well.
- 11:50Judy Oskam: Well, and I think you're the way you have it structured, where the goal is to recognize distraction yeah and then how to move beyond distraction.
- 12:02Judy Oskam: I think that's what he's using it and how using it yeah, or whatever what you want.
- 12:07Vani Naik: I love that and just I mean this is a bit random but in terms of one of the participants even offered to do a guitar recital tonight after dinner and I love that, so I'm so excited about that.
- 12:17Vani Naik: So, yeah, it's great that he, you know, he offered and I was like I'm really proud that I've made an environment where I feel that they want to do it.
- 12:25Judy Oskam: Oh, that's fantastic, and I think too, writing it really is a creative endeavor, even if it's academic writing, yeah, so I think you tend to think it's different than writing a novel or creative writing, yes, but really writing is so much creativity and so much up to the individual.
- 12:45Judy Oskam: And how, how do you, how do you face that writer's block?
- 12:49Vani Naik: yep, right, yeah, so we do some example again.
- 12:52Vani Naik: This year we've done some free writing prompts at the start just to kind of get people, you know, moving, because you know that initial first day can be a bit tricky.
- 12:59Vani Naik: Um, but yeah, no, I would totally agree with that creative element.
- 13:02Vani Naik: You know, phd is an original contribution to knowledge.
- 13:06Vani Naik: I mean, the word creative isn't there, but it is creativity and I completely agree with you that sometimes in academia there's a bit of frowning upon of creativity.
- 13:15Vani Naik: But actually I totally agree that needs to be more creativity within not just academia but all walks of life.
- 13:21Vani Naik: You know, that's what we need.
- 13:27Vani Naik: As we're moving into the world changing constantly, we need to adapt and I think being creative is definitely one of the key skills.
- 13:30Judy Oskam: Yeah, I love that.
- 13:31Judy Oskam: Any parting words you would like to that we haven't covered that you want to touch?
- 13:41Vani Naik: So I would say just say yes to things.
- 13:42Vani Naik: I mean, we met like five minutes ago, I don't I yeah.
- 13:43Vani Naik: So I would say just say yes to things.
- 13:45Vani Naik: You never know what might happen, so yeah.
- 13:47Judy Oskam: Well, I love your spirit and your energy is infectious and I'm sure some of my faculty would love to come over here to Scotland.
- 13:55Vani Naik: I'm a fan Retreat.
- 13:56Vani Naik: Yes.
- 14:01Judy Oskam: Because I'm thinking this would be something that other organizations and departments not just academia but other organizations could model People have retreats all the time but to actually include some of those other elements that help build culture.
- 14:13Vani Naik: I think Absolutely, because I think, the more you know, there's lots of change in the world with technology, but I really believe it's that connection, human to human, that ultimately is what brings us together.
- 14:24Vani Naik: So to foster that in a working environment I think is really key and totally agree it could be any organization.
- 14:32Vani Naik: I have a friend who's an ecologist and he's like you know they have to write reports and they find it tricky to write reports.
- 14:36Vani Naik: You know, exactly the same thing could work as well.
- 14:40Vani Naik: I love that Just say yes, just say yes, just say yes.
- 14:43Vani Naik: I love that, thank you.
- 14:44Vani Naik: Thank you so much, Judy, I delight.
- 14:48Judy Oskam: I'll add some information about the writing retreat in the show notes.
- 14:52Judy Oskam: You can also reach out to Vani on LinkedIn.
- 14:56Judy Oskam: Well, remember if you've got a story to share or know someone who does reach out to me at judyoskam.
- 15:02Judy Oskam: com Thanks for listening.