Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Discovery: Managing Time Constraints to Improve Efficiency
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Discovery, Managing Time Constraints
- 0:07to Improve Efficiency. I am Laurie Crimm Martin,
- 0:10a Certified Family Law Specialist and a former
- 0:12Vice Chair of BHBA's Litigation Section. I'm
- 0:15delighted to introduce our speaker, the Honorable
- 0:18Susan L. Greenberg. Judge Greenberg is a mediator,
- 0:22arbitrator, and discovery referee with signature
- 0:24resolution, where she also serves as a special
- 0:27master and judge pro tap. Judge Greenberg spent
- 0:3026 years on the San Mateo County Superior Court.
- 0:34benched with supervising assignments in civil,
- 0:38family law, and probate, and a docket that ranged
- 0:41from jury trials to complex civil matters. During
- 0:45her tenure, she developed the court's informal
- 0:48discovery conference program, giving her a firsthand
- 0:51view of where discovery stalled and how to keep
- 0:54it moving. She also founded and chaired the court's
- 0:58AI committee and led its ADR programming. Before
- 1:02the bench, Judge Greenberg served as a deputy
- 1:06district attorney and handled civil litigation
- 1:08and private practice. She was named Judge of
- 1:11the Year by the San Mateo County Trial Lawyers
- 1:15Association in 2024 and has taught at Golden
- 1:19Gate University. And now let's get started. Thank
- 1:23you so much, Lloyd. And welcome to part two of
- 1:27Discovery. Part one was dealing with bottlenecks.
- 1:30And at the end of this month, we will have part
- 1:32three. So we will move on through the slides.
- 1:35That is the initial slide. And then there's next
- 1:38slide, the slide about me, which you've just
- 1:42heard all about, except what you didn't hear
- 1:44was that Lori and I are both graduates of Claremont
- 1:47Men's now Claremont McKenna College. So that
- 1:49was very fun to find out this afternoon. Let's
- 1:52get started. What does high efficiency mean in
- 1:55discovery? And what are our objectives? Well,
- 1:58our objectives are to reduce the cycle time.
- 2:02The cycle means collection, review, and production.
- 2:07We're also going to learn how to reduce rework,
- 2:10such as redoing searches, privilege logs, and
- 2:14productions. We need to make sure we reduce risk.
- 2:17Spoliation, waiver, Sanctions and confidentiality
- 2:21breaches are all part of risk. You don't want
- 2:25to have any discovery get spoiled or lost. You
- 2:28don't want to have anything waived because you
- 2:30didn't produce it. You certainly don't want to
- 2:32be subject to sanctions and confidentiality breaches
- 2:36are a complete nightmare for any attorney. We'll
- 2:41describe all of these a little bit later. We're
- 2:43also going to improve defensibility, which means
- 2:46what you're doing in discovery must be repeatable.
- 2:50Someone else must be able to repeat it, or you
- 2:53must be able to repeat it for the judge if it's
- 2:56been contested by the other side. To be defensible,
- 3:02it must be documented and an auditable process,
- 3:06meaning someone else can go through, look at
- 3:08it, and make sure it was done appropriately.
- 3:11But let's set our expectations. Efficiency does
- 3:15not mean cutting corners. It does mean front
- 3:19loading decisions and standardizing execution.
- 3:24Next slide, please. So we're going to build first
- 3:29an effective ESI protocol. Next slide, please.
- 3:34ESI is electronically stored information, which
- 3:37is how almost all of our information is being
- 3:40stored these days. Our bank accounts, our medical
- 3:44records, everything is on a computer. So what
- 3:48are we going to worry about when we're worrying
- 3:50about electronically stored information? We want
- 3:53to control the risk. We want to control the cost.
- 3:57And we want a dispute prevention tool. So when
- 4:01are we going to propose talking about these things?
- 4:04Do we wait under the federal rules of civil procedure
- 4:06for the initial case management conference? No,
- 4:09we do not. We have an initial first meet and
- 4:13confer, and that's true under the state rules
- 4:17as well in California. You have a very early
- 4:20meet and confer with opposing counsel, and we'll
- 4:23talk about what you're going to talk about in
- 4:25that meet and confer in a little bit, but you
- 4:27do that right away or you're going to be in violation
- 4:29of the federal as well as California rules of
- 4:33civil procedure. Next slide, please. So the scope
- 4:38and sources. of your information. There are custodians
- 4:42of record. There are non -custodial sources.
- 4:46There are shared drives, drives that are shared
- 4:49by multiple employees, for an example. There
- 4:52are apps in the cloud. There are mobile apps.
- 4:55collaboration tools such as Teams and Zoom, which
- 4:58you know have internal abilities to record information.
- 5:02And there are databases. You also need to understand
- 5:06the scope of what the time period is that you're
- 5:08looking for, the geographies, and the business
- 5:12units. So when you're doing discovery, you want
- 5:14to make it narrow as possible without really
- 5:19making it too narrow because, first of all, you
- 5:22want it slightly narrowed in order to not raise
- 5:25an objection, but not too narrow that you don't
- 5:27get what you need. So have a specific time period
- 5:30in mind that gets you what you need and is not
- 5:33too over broad. Have a geography in mind. If
- 5:36it's a business with multiple locations throughout
- 5:40the United States, for example, pick California.
- 5:44Pick where it's important for you. and then don't
- 5:48say all offices throughout the United States
- 5:51when that's way over broad, and business units.
- 5:54What exactly are you looking for? Make sure you're
- 5:57specific about that. Next slide, please. Preservation
- 6:03is very important. You want to make sure that
- 6:07you have a litigation hold. And if you need something
- 6:12issued, get a TRO, get a temporary restraining
- 6:15order. If you and opposing counsel can't agree
- 6:19that nothing is going to be destroyed and you
- 6:22don't trust them, even if you do trust them,
- 6:26you might need a temporary restraining order.
- 6:28You want to make sure you preserve... ephemeral
- 6:31data, such as the chats, the texts, and have
- 6:35an auto delete policy. Make sure that you and
- 6:38opposing counsel agree that nothing is to be
- 6:41deleted. And you make sure that none of your
- 6:44people delete anything from the chat or any texts,
- 6:49because quite frankly, a lot of times those items
- 6:52can still be found. And it will also be known
- 6:56that your client or your party or somebody on
- 7:00your team actually deleted something and that's
- 7:02not going to go over well with the court. Also,
- 7:06in your preservation checklist, you need to handle
- 7:09the issue of departing employees and device swaps.
- 7:14So if you're representing a business and you've
- 7:16got employees departing that have information,
- 7:19perhaps on a business cell phone, perhaps on
- 7:24their own cell phone, you need to deal with that
- 7:27right away and make sure that you are preserving
- 7:29what you need for litigation. Next slide, please.
- 7:36Also within your court checklist, you need to
- 7:39talk about the collection methodology. Who's
- 7:43going to collect the information that you need
- 7:47for your side? Is it going to be someone internal?
- 7:50an internal IT person in the business that you're
- 7:53representing? Is it a vendor? Is it, for example,
- 7:57a service level agreement person or group? Actually,
- 8:00it would be a business that's going to do the
- 8:03collection for you. If so, you need to make sure
- 8:07you have the chain of custody, the appropriate
- 8:10declarations put together so you have a full
- 8:13chain of custody. And you have to make sure that
- 8:17that vendor or their internal IT department knows
- 8:20that you're going for targeted items within a
- 8:23mailbox, for example. and not a full mailbox
- 8:26because again that's going to be objected to
- 8:29and with a motion to compel you're going to lose
- 8:31on something like i i want judge you to compel
- 8:35uh this business to give up everything in this
- 8:37particular mailbox It's not going to happen.
- 8:41You're going to have to be much, much more specific
- 8:43than that. If you specify what you're looking
- 8:45for, you may end up getting every email within
- 8:48a full mailbox, for example. But you can't just
- 8:51say, I want the whole mailbox without being more
- 8:54specific than that. Also, the handling of structured
- 8:58data. How are you going to receive it? Are you
- 9:01going to get an export out of Excel? Are you
- 9:04going to get an actual report? Are you going
- 9:06to get snapshots of the database? Decide that
- 9:10ahead of time with your internal IT staff, with
- 9:14the vendor. But make sure that you get what you
- 9:18need. You might need a bit of all three. You
- 9:21might want data that's exported. You might want
- 9:23a report. And frankly, you might want some database
- 9:26snapshots. So you can verify. quality control
- 9:30of what you are receiving. Always consider a
- 9:34stipulation with the other side regarding foundation
- 9:37and admissibility. I can tell you from my experience
- 9:41on the bench, you'll often get a stipulation
- 9:44as to foundation and rarely as to admissibility,
- 9:47but it can't hurt to ask and a stipulation as
- 9:50to foundation is super helpful because you don't
- 9:53have to bring in your records custodians, or
- 9:56the people in the IT department who collected
- 10:00and did the whole chain of custody. It's so much
- 10:03nicer if you don't have to do that and consider
- 10:06a stipulation always. I'm saying it at this point,
- 10:09but there may be many points throughout discovery
- 10:11that you might want to consider a stipulation.
- 10:15Next slide, please. All right, the processing
- 10:20and culling of the information. So you want to
- 10:25denist it to automatically remove non -user generated
- 10:31system and application files and get rid of duplication.
- 10:36So what is denisting? Denisting means that there's
- 10:40an application you can use that will take out
- 10:45the operating system. via original applications.
- 10:49When you're, for example, copying an entire computer,
- 10:52if it's something that is a standard application
- 10:57or operating system, you don't need to copy that
- 11:00and it will take up too much time, too much money
- 11:04to do so. So you need to make sure that what
- 11:07you're getting is denisted and you're not getting
- 11:10anything that's a duplication. You want possibly
- 11:14to get near duplications if something's been
- 11:16messed within that software. And you always want
- 11:19to consider threading. And we'll talk about threading
- 11:22a little bit later. But boy, threading is like
- 11:25the bane of every judge's existence and very
- 11:27often lawyers as well. Date filters. So you want
- 11:32to make sure that you are dealing with the date
- 11:36filters appropriately. You want to exclude certain
- 11:39file types. but again with caution and you want
- 11:44to deal with language filters so when you're
- 11:47using these filters what you're doing is you're
- 11:49processing and going through the data and you're
- 11:53filtering it for example I want everything for
- 11:56this state range I want to exclude everything
- 11:59that was in a word document be careful with that
- 12:01because some people use word documents they're
- 12:05not well versed in excel maybe not so much these
- 12:07days but I've seen people do it Use a Word document
- 12:10to keep financial information. So you might not
- 12:14always want to exclude Word documents, but just
- 12:17an example. And you might want to filter for
- 12:19language. You may think that there's something
- 12:21in a foreign language or in a specific coding
- 12:25language that you're interested in. So be careful
- 12:27about that as well. Next slide, please. All right,
- 12:33the search and review approach. So you have to
- 12:38negotiate framework of keywords you want specific
- 12:42seed terms you want hit reports you want iterative
- 12:45refinement what does this mean my god these words
- 12:48are also weird right so you're going to start
- 12:51with specific terms that you're going to search
- 12:53for you may want to search for everything on
- 12:56somebody's computer that has the word sales okay
- 13:00really over broad you're going to find out right
- 13:03away that that's not the seed term you want and
- 13:06when you get you're going to get a hit of reports
- 13:09that go on for probably tens of thousands, if
- 13:12not hundreds of thousands of pages. But if you're
- 13:15looking for, for example, sales of a specific
- 13:19product like WD -40, that might be something
- 13:23in your case, right? So now you make your C term
- 13:27a little bit more refined. And every time you
- 13:29go through this, it's another iteration and you're
- 13:32refining what your keywords are in your search.
- 13:36I'll tell you later on that it's really important
- 13:39to start keeping a list of these things, especially
- 13:41if you're representing a business that may be
- 13:44sued more than one time. It'll be helpful to
- 13:46keep this keyword list for the future. Technology
- 13:51-assisted review and continuous active learning.
- 13:54That approach, if you use, is basically the AI
- 13:58version of what we just talked about. You're
- 14:01developing a training set. It's going to validate
- 14:03itself. There's going to be a transparency level,
- 14:06and it's going to refine itself because it's
- 14:09going to be doing continuous active learning.
- 14:13Next slide, please. Privilege and confidentiality.
- 14:19Really super important. There are privilege categories
- 14:22that you need to think about with regard to in
- 14:25-house counsel. But don't forget, if you're dealing
- 14:28with a client and you are producing documents,
- 14:32for example, pursuant to a request for production,
- 14:35and there are some documents that are covered
- 14:38by a privilege, such as a therapist -patient
- 14:42privilege, you need to remember those two, not
- 14:45just the attorney -client privilege, because
- 14:48the clawback rules in the federal rules of evidence
- 14:52as well as California rules, and I've given you
- 14:54all of those. They should be in your documents.
- 15:00You might get things clawed back because of inadvertent
- 15:04production. You might not. So you don't want
- 15:09to have to go there. You don't want to have to
- 15:11make the motion. You don't have to deal with
- 15:12the law. You want to make sure that when you
- 15:15produce something, you've been really careful
- 15:16about your privilege categories. And when you
- 15:20redact something, make sure that you put the
- 15:23reason for it in the privilege log. Because if
- 15:27you don't, there's going to be a fight about
- 15:29that. Be careful about metadata redactions. Metadata,
- 15:35the date in which a document is initially written
- 15:40and refined over various times is often very
- 15:44important in a case. And if you redact metadata,
- 15:47you're going to get an objection. Next slide,
- 15:50please. All right, so. You also have to think
- 15:55about production specifications. What format
- 15:58do you want? Do you want it as a TIFF, which
- 16:00is, I'm sure you all know this, but it's basically
- 16:03a photo. Do you want it as a PDF? Do you want
- 16:07it in its native format? When are native formats
- 16:10required? Often for Excel, audio, video, not
- 16:15necessarily for Word docs, because then you can
- 16:18just take it in a PDF. Smart, because then it's
- 16:21not as easily modifiable. You want to talk about
- 16:25load files, metadata fields. Load files are basically
- 16:29files that have everything in them. They have
- 16:32the metadata, they have the text, they have confidentiality
- 16:36legends. You know that in a lot of the files
- 16:39that we use, there are hidden embedded objects
- 16:43in them and a load file has everything in it.
- 16:47For example, a family relationship, parent -child
- 16:50does not mean mom, dad, and kid. It means you've
- 16:54got a document that's the parent document, and
- 16:57it's making, baby documents is making additional
- 17:01documents, but there are embedded objects in
- 17:04there, there are attachments in there, and you
- 17:06have to consider that actual relationship between
- 17:10the documents. Next slide, please. Quality control
- 17:17and dispute resolution. Quality control is so
- 17:21important. Before you produce documents, do your
- 17:26quality control. And don't pick one out of every
- 17:291 ,000 documents unless it's a 10 ,000 document
- 17:32or more production. Do a decent quality control.
- 17:38Try to at least for a while, check one out of
- 17:40a 10, one out of every 20. And if it's looking
- 17:43good, you can continue with one out of every
- 17:45100. But make sure you're doing a decent job
- 17:48with your quality control and correct any errors
- 17:52in the process. You meet and confer cadence.
- 17:57You need to decide what that is within your own
- 17:59law firm. Are you meeting and conferring every
- 18:03time? I think you should. Are you meeting and
- 18:06conferring once a week? Might be a little much,
- 18:09but you definitely want to meet and confer whenever
- 18:11there's an issue. And then determine in your
- 18:14law firm, how are you going to escalate that?
- 18:17If you don't come up with an agreement with the
- 18:19opposing counsel, are you escalating that to
- 18:22the partner? And what's going to trigger your
- 18:24motion practice? I will tell you, the bane of
- 18:28every judge's existence is discovery disputes.
- 18:32I love them, but a lot of them don't. And the
- 18:36bane of every legal research attorney's existence
- 18:39is also discovery disputes, because it's so hard
- 18:43for us when we're doing this on the fly when
- 18:47we've got sometimes 15, 20 cases a day to deal
- 18:50with in discovery, and we don't have the entire
- 18:53picture. And it's so hard to learn the entire
- 18:56picture. So if you can avoid discovery disputes,
- 18:59or get rid of them in your meet and confers and
- 19:02with your stipulations. All the better for everybody.
- 19:06Next slide, please. Negotiation tactics that
- 19:12will prevent later bottlenecks. Have your first
- 19:16meet and confer early. Bring a draft protocol
- 19:19and perhaps a data map if you're at that point
- 19:23where you can make one. If you have an idea,
- 19:25where the data is located, for example, in your
- 19:28client's business. Bring a data map. Have a draft
- 19:31protocol like, this is what we think the protocol
- 19:34should be. This is what we think the key search
- 19:37terms should be, at least to start out with.
- 19:40And then have a decision menu, which you might
- 19:43develop with the other side. And talk about the
- 19:46options with regard to cost, risk, and what the
- 19:49trade -offs are. Because if you have that initial
- 19:53start and that initial agreement, it'll get you
- 19:56so much farther down the road than if you just
- 19:58say, we're only going to produce this. You'll
- 20:01immediately get an objection out the gate. And
- 20:04if you say, let's agree on what we're going to
- 20:06produce initially and then see if you need anything
- 20:08more, that's a lot nicer way to put it. And it's
- 20:13frankly going to get you a lot farther down the
- 20:14road without needing to escalate or have motion
- 20:18practice. Lock down your definitions with the
- 20:21other side. What do you mean by when you say
- 20:24document? Is that a text? Is that a word doc?
- 20:28Does it include Excel? Does it include audio
- 20:30and video files? What is ESI? Not everybody understands
- 20:35what that could possibly even be. What are the
- 20:38custodians? Who has control and what does reasonably
- 20:41accessible mean? Does it mean something your
- 20:44client has? Of course. Does it mean something
- 20:47that your client's former employee has that's
- 20:50now moved to Canada, maybe? What if they moved
- 20:54to Europe? You have to really come up with an
- 20:58idea of what's reasonably accessible and then
- 21:02obtain stipulations if possible. I can't stress
- 21:05that enough. It's better for you. It's better,
- 21:09frankly, for both sides or how many sides you
- 21:11have. And it's definitely better for the court.
- 21:15Next slide, please. All right, so let's talk
- 21:20about a chat heavy case. How do you preserve
- 21:23a chat? What format are you going to export it
- 21:25in? Are you going to take screenshots? There's
- 21:28so much threading in a chat. If you guys look
- 21:31at a chat, I look at my chats and I do this all
- 21:33the time. Wait, who said that? Oh, yeah, that
- 21:36was me. Which side of the screen is it on? Happens
- 21:39also with emails, but wow, with chats, it can
- 21:42be just crazy. How do you redact a chat, especially
- 21:46one where... You've said the same thing multiple
- 21:49times over many, many pages, because once you
- 21:52produce that, it will look like pages. And then
- 21:55what's your format going to be? You have to have
- 21:57production format decisions. And frankly, the
- 22:01same thing is true about emails. Emails and the
- 22:04threading are a nightmare. Even now with my Gmail,
- 22:10it's so hard if I start replying and there's
- 22:15seven or eight in a thread, in a string, and
- 22:19I say, wait, I've got to go look back, then I've
- 22:21got to find where I was again. Nightmare, right?
- 22:24Especially when they're long and there's a thread
- 22:27that goes on for many, many, many emails. It's
- 22:31super important to really know how you want to
- 22:35present that. And the last thing you want to
- 22:37do is, and I saw this, it was presented to me
- 22:39so many times, you don't really want to present
- 22:42the judge with pages and pages of threaded emails,
- 22:46when frankly, there were three total, and they
- 22:49were just repeating what other, you know, themselves
- 22:52over and over. It's, you want to format that
- 22:56appropriately. Next slide, please. All right,
- 23:01discovery document and data management. Next
- 23:03slide. So you've got to build a defensible data
- 23:07map. This is what you're going to talk about
- 23:09at your first meet and confer. So you need a
- 23:14template. I love templates. They're super important
- 23:17for everything you do in discovery. Of course,
- 23:20they're meant to be modified, but they give every
- 23:22attorney a really good start. Your custodian
- 23:25interview template. Your custodian is going to
- 23:28need to state the systems that were used. the
- 23:31storage locations, naming conventions, which
- 23:34means how were things named, and the business's
- 23:38retention policies. How long do you retain documents
- 23:41for? Is it two years? Is it 20? I mean, that
- 23:43all needs to be determined and placed in the
- 23:47custodian interview template. You need to identify
- 23:51hidden sources of information, personal devices.
- 23:56So a lot of businesses will give their employees
- 23:59a work phone. but some people use their personal
- 24:02phones their personal um temp their personal
- 24:07um ipads right so Those things you have to be
- 24:12thinking about. Those are PSTs, iPads, shared
- 24:16mailboxes. People share things all the time.
- 24:18They share them in their mailboxes. They share
- 24:20them on Google Drive. They share them in so many
- 24:23different places. You have to think about identifying
- 24:26these hidden sources. Legacy systems. What's
- 24:30that? A legacy system is somebody who has a really
- 24:33old computer. It's something that could have
- 24:36and should have been updated, but it hasn't been.
- 24:39Often they're super hard to extract data from
- 24:42but there are companies that can help do it.
- 24:45There are experts that can do that and the best
- 24:48way to do that is to stipulate that each side
- 24:51has an expert that's going to observe while this
- 24:54is being done to make sure it's being done without
- 24:57any data or information being destroyed. and
- 25:01third -party platforms. There are so many companies
- 25:04out there that create their niche type of apps
- 25:08that you may need to find information about that
- 25:11to be able to extract data from that third -party
- 25:14platform. What do you want to track on a data
- 25:18map? You want to track the source owner, the
- 25:23access method. How did you access the data? What
- 25:26export format did you use? How did you export
- 25:30it? Did you keep it in Excel? Did you export
- 25:32it into something else? What constraints were
- 25:35used? In other words, which types of items did
- 25:40you say you were specifying? So a constraint
- 25:43could be, I only want everything from the last
- 25:46three years, just as an example. And what is
- 25:49your cost and time estimate to do this data?
- 25:53Map, not to do the map, but to do everything
- 25:56that's listed in the map is what I meant to say.
- 25:59All right, next slide please. All right, the
- 26:04matter workspace architecture. Whew, big names,
- 26:08but it's really important to know this. There
- 26:11has to be one single source of truth. One matter,
- 26:16one case folder. that has structure, that permissions
- 26:21are needed for, and that is one folder that can
- 26:25never be modified because you're going to find
- 26:28that people are going to add and subtract for
- 26:31the case. Let them do that in a separate folder.
- 26:34Have one single source of the truth. Otherwise,
- 26:37you're going to find yourself in a big problem
- 26:39down the line when you don't have the ability
- 26:43to say, This was the single source. Nobody modified
- 26:46it. Nobody took anything out. Nobody changed
- 26:49it. So you need to have version control. You
- 26:52need to control any requests, responses, meet
- 26:56and confer letters, search term lists, and production
- 26:59specs. Keep them in a separate file folder. Also,
- 27:04while you're doing this, make sure you have good
- 27:06naming conventions, meaning Make sure you name
- 27:09things appropriately. Don't say just request
- 27:12for production one, request for production two
- 27:15when number one went to defendant A and number
- 27:17two went to defendant B. Request for production
- 27:21from defendant A, set one. Request for production
- 27:25from defendant B, set two. It's like keeping
- 27:30letters inside an envelope and keeping those
- 27:33envelopes in a file folder. You have to open
- 27:35the envelope each time to see what the letter
- 27:38is. You don't want to have to open an RFP to
- 27:42see who it went to. If you're trying to find
- 27:44the RFP for defendant Z, you don't want to have
- 27:48to open all these file folders. You want it to
- 27:50be labeled appropriately. Same with your rolling
- 27:53sets. Number them consecutively. Same with your
- 27:56privilege logs. State, this is the privilege
- 28:00log for attorney -client privilege or for defendant
- 28:04so -and -so. Same with your deficiency letters.
- 28:07Make sure you use appropriate naming conventions.
- 28:10It will save you so much time in the long run.
- 28:13And then as to security, what has the least privilege?
- 28:17What has the most? Who's going to be able to
- 28:19do the audit and then you have to keep the audit
- 28:22logs? What kind of encryption are you using?
- 28:25Make sure you have excellent IT sources and recommendations
- 28:30for your encryption and for secure transfer.
- 28:34If you are going to have somebody such as an
- 28:38expert, look at these documents. You want them
- 28:41placed in a very secure file folder and then
- 28:44that file folder which will have copies, because
- 28:48remember you have a single source of truth, you
- 28:51put copies of the documents that you want your
- 28:53expert to see into a file folder that is encrypted
- 28:57and secure so that the expert can use that information.
- 29:02Next slide, please. Workflow management. Okay,
- 29:07here's what we have. We intake something. For
- 29:10example, we're getting information in on a request
- 29:13for production that was served for us. We're
- 29:15going to process it. We're going to review it.
- 29:17We're going to quality control it. And then we
- 29:20are going to do our production. And then there'll
- 29:23be post production issues potentially, hopefully
- 29:28not. You need to assign owners and service level
- 29:33agreements. So is it going to be 24 hours to
- 29:36triage any deficiency? Assign somebody, when
- 29:41I say an owner, I mean somebody in the firm and
- 29:44whatever SLA you have your agreement with to
- 29:46do these things and make sure that you give them
- 29:50a time frame, 24 hours to triage the deficiency
- 29:53and then within 48 hours we're approving that
- 29:56production set. Use a critical path board. You
- 30:01can actually do this for fun with a bunch of
- 30:03people in a room with a white board. Wow, when's
- 30:06the last time you did that? And find out. What
- 30:09is blocking your depositions or your expert reports
- 30:15or your dispositive motions? When you're trying
- 30:18to deal with workflow management, any of these
- 30:21are very, very important methods to use. Next
- 30:25slide, please. And that is it. So I am happy
- 30:30to answer questions. I know it's 5 o 'clock.
- 30:3230 minutes is short, but we got through it. Any
- 30:36thoughts or questions? I'm happy to stay for
- 30:37a moment. I am looking at the Q &A. Well, I think
- 30:45not, unless you see somebody typing. Thank you
- 30:50all for your time. Much appreciated. Part three
- 30:52is at the end of the month. This concludes today's
- 30:57presentation. Thank you so much, Judge Greenberg,
- 30:59for an excellent presentation today. And thank
- 31:01you so much to our audience for joining us. Have
- 31:03a great evening, everyone. Thank you all. Bye.