Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Make Sub Rosa Take a Back Seat to Your Client's Damages
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to this evening's program, Make Sibrosa
- 0:07Take a Backseat to Your Client's Damages. I'm
- 0:09Allapoli Castro, CLE advisor for the Beverly
- 0:12Hills Bar Association. And today I'm delighted
- 0:14to introduce our speaker, Arnold Reed II. Arnold
- 0:18is an attorney at BD &J Injury Lawyers and a
- 0:212024 Los Angeles Business Journal leader of influence.
- 0:26Arnold is a Michigan native and University of
- 0:28Michigan and Indiana University School of Law
- 0:31alum. Arnold's career is built on a passion for
- 0:35justice and excellence in advocacy. Before joining
- 0:39BD &J, Arnold externed from multiple federal
- 0:41judges in Detroit and San Diego and was an attorney
- 0:44at other prominent local personal injury law
- 0:47firms. Today, Arnold continuously uses and builds
- 0:51upon the knowledge he has gained from his past
- 0:53experiences to serve his clients and recover
- 0:56life -changing multimillion -dollar results across
- 0:59Southern California. We can't wait to hear what
- 1:01he has to share with us today. Arnold. Hi, everybody.
- 1:05Thank you so much for that warm welcome. I really
- 1:08appreciate it. And I am thankful for everybody
- 1:10that has taken their time this evening to log
- 1:13on and to learn a couple things about CBROSA.
- 1:18As litigators in California, we have all seen
- 1:21how sometimes a single clip of surveillance video
- 1:25can completely change the tides of litigation.
- 1:29For those of you who represent plaintiffs, we've
- 1:32seen that Sub Rosa has that power and it can
- 1:35unravel months, sometimes years of carefully
- 1:39developed casework. All of the sudden, the case
- 1:42that you've invested your time, money, blood,
- 1:46sweat and tears in is up in smoke, just like
- 1:50that. Today, what we're going to do is take a
- 1:53deep dive into how to manage this threat of surveillance,
- 1:58a .k .a. Sub Rosa, preemptively, strategically,
- 2:02and lawfully. So it's funny. I was barred in
- 2:07Michigan before being barred in California. And
- 2:11when I first got to California, I remember hearing
- 2:14this term, sabrosa, sabrosa, sabrosa. And it
- 2:18just sounded so odd to me. And I remember being
- 2:20so curious about it. And I looked into it, and
- 2:24I'm excited to share a few of those things that
- 2:25I found. First of all, basics, that phrase, sabrosa.
- 2:30It sounds unique, maybe even exotic. And we're
- 2:34going to talk about the lore behind this phrase
- 2:37for a moment here. There's a person, well, she's
- 2:41a goddess, rather. Her name is Aphrodite. She's
- 2:43the goddess of love and beauty. And she has a
- 2:47son. Her son is Cupid. Yes, the Cupid who we
- 2:52all associate the holiday Valentine's Day with.
- 2:56So Aphrodite has a son named Cupid. Cupid is
- 2:59the goddess of love and desire. And Aphrodite,
- 3:02she's pretty popular, but she's known for her
- 3:07frequent love affairs. And what she wants to
- 3:10do is have her love affairs in peace. She wants
- 3:15discretion. So she gives a rose to her son, Cupid.
- 3:21And in turn, Cupid gives this rose to Harpocrates.
- 3:26And basically, this rose is a bribe to keep all
- 3:30of Aphrodite's affairs secret. From there, this
- 3:35mythology led to the association of roses with
- 3:39secrecy, right? And then we get this Latin term,
- 3:43sub rosa. And what it translates to is underneath
- 3:47the rose. which means in confidence or secretly.
- 3:51And in the Middle Ages, rose statues and designs
- 3:55were placed on ceilings of guest rooms, over
- 3:58doorways of Catholic confessional booths, and
- 4:01other places as a symbol of confidentiality.
- 4:05So you may be wondering, well, Arnold, what does
- 4:08that have to do with the law? In our context
- 4:11as lawyers, this phrase refers to covert surveillance,
- 4:15typically conducted by insurance companies or
- 4:18defense teams to record plaintiffs when they
- 4:22think nobody is watching. And this can be footage
- 4:25of somebody, for instance, walking to a mailbox,
- 4:29unloading groceries, or in the defense's dream
- 4:33scenario, hiking a mountain after claiming having
- 4:37a horrible back injury. So that's generally what
- 4:43Subrosa is. I also today want to talk about a
- 4:46term that I believe I've coined called flub rosa.
- 4:51F -L -U -B rosa. Or when a plaintiff creates
- 4:57sabrosa of themselves and hands it over to the
- 5:01defense unknowingly. Almost like an unforced
- 5:04error in baseball. Again, I think that's kind
- 5:07of a funny term, flub rosa. So we'll talk about
- 5:11that as well. But before I move on, I want to
- 5:14emphasize that while the act of surveillance
- 5:18itself in litigation is not illegal per se, how
- 5:23this surveillance is obtained, disclosed, and
- 5:27used in litigation has very serious legal implications.
- 5:31And that's why particularly plaintiffs' attorneys
- 5:34must stay very vigilant. Okay, so let's talk
- 5:43about why sabrosa matters. In a personal injury
- 5:48lawsuit, a plaintiff must prove several things.
- 5:53First, he or she must prove that the defendant
- 5:56was negligent. Second, the plaintiff must prove
- 6:01that they were harmed. And third, they must prove
- 6:05that the defendant's negligence was a substantial
- 6:08factor in causing their harm. Again, and perhaps
- 6:12most important for our purposes here today, is
- 6:15that a plaintiff must prove they were harmed.
- 6:18In personal injury context, one of the harms
- 6:21that a plaintiff is trying to demonstrate is
- 6:24in the form of a bodily injury that they suffered.
- 6:29Now naturally, along with any injury come certain
- 6:33bodily limitations and restrictions. The validity
- 6:37of one's injury can be seen in the ways that
- 6:41that injury affects their day -to -day activities.
- 6:47The amount of damages a plaintiff is awarded
- 6:50is often directly correlated to the severity
- 6:53of the injuries that they're claiming, and the
- 6:56injuries, more importantly, that they can prove.
- 6:59And this is why Subrosa matters. Like I said
- 7:02earlier, it can have a direct impact upon the
- 7:05plaintiff's perceived credibility. If the jury
- 7:08sees a 15 -second clip that appears to contradict
- 7:12months of testimony or medical reports. They
- 7:16suddenly forget about the pain journals that
- 7:19this plaintiff is writing. They'll forget about
- 7:22all of these fancy diagnostic scans or surgical
- 7:25histories. And in the context of trial work,
- 7:29that's why Sobrosa can be so deadly. But we also
- 7:33can't forget that Sobrosa can dampen a case outside
- 7:37of the trial context, okay? So for example, if
- 7:42there's SubRosa footage, the insurance adjusters
- 7:45will automatically slot your case in the low
- 7:48value category, right? And this is before trial.
- 7:52This could be before trial and they might have
- 7:54this footage before they even make that apparent.
- 7:57And again, once they have this footage, they're
- 8:00slotting your case in that lower value category.
- 8:06Or even if you're going into a mediation, for
- 8:09example, if there's some sabrosa that comes to
- 8:13light right around mediation, that sabrosa will
- 8:18lower your client's credibility in the mediator's
- 8:21eyes. How is a mediator really going to go back
- 8:25and forth with the defense to try to advocate
- 8:29for your client and show them all these injuries
- 8:31if they're seen hiking? or they're seen playing
- 8:36in a 3v3 basketball tournament when they're supposed
- 8:40to have serious lumbar injuries, right? So the
- 8:44prospect of this sabrosa surveillance is not
- 8:47only dangerous in the context of trial where
- 8:50it might be viewed by a jury, but also throughout
- 8:54litigation during the various points where you're
- 8:57trying to settle your matter. So we'll talk about
- 8:59all of those today, making sure that you know
- 9:02how to protect your plaintiff. And again, I understand
- 9:06that the BHBA, which I'm a proud member of, is
- 9:09not just a home for plaintiff's lawyers. In fact,
- 9:12it's a home for lawyers on both sides of the
- 9:15V, and this is bigger than just personal injury.
- 9:19Although I am speaking from a plaintiff's lawyer's
- 9:22perspective, I hope that there's things that
- 9:24anybody watching can gain. One of the things
- 9:29that we'll also talk about are ways to make sure
- 9:33that if this footage does come into evidence,
- 9:36or if this footage does get in front of a mediator,
- 9:39that you have the tools needed to make its impact
- 9:44dampened. And one of those ways that we can somewhat
- 9:48downplay sabrosa is by focusing on a very important
- 9:52truth, that pain is invisible. So it would behoove
- 9:57a plaintiff lawyers to educate juries on this
- 9:59point mediators or whoever whatever decision
- 10:02-makers they're going up against right pain is
- 10:06invisible and We're going to talk about ways
- 10:10to structure discovery and pre -trial strategies
- 10:13to prevent this footage from blindsighting your
- 10:16case or worse becoming a silver bullet for the
- 10:20defense So there's a couple of forms of sabrosa
- 10:26And in the days of, I guess we're now in a digital
- 10:30era, clearly, but prior to this digital era,
- 10:35the main form of sabrosa was video footage. And
- 10:39that was created by someone sitting in a van
- 10:42with an old school camera that had a super long
- 10:44lens. And they would sit in that van, taking
- 10:47photos, click, click, click all day and night
- 10:51of that plaintiff. But today, things could not
- 10:57be more different. The technological landscape
- 11:00is rapidly changing every single day, and that's
- 11:05greatly affected how cases are litigated. Today,
- 11:09sub rosa includes multiple forms of evidence,
- 11:12right? So first we have that physical surveillance.
- 11:16And this is no surprise because this is how it
- 11:19has been for ages. This is the old method, like
- 11:22I said, of somebody sitting in a van or a car
- 11:25and taking photos of the plaintiff. And then
- 11:30after that, we have hidden photos and video recordings.
- 11:34And this is a lot more prevalent these days.
- 11:37In the 1980s, we, and I say we, but I wasn't
- 11:42born in the 1980s, so I was nowhere around this
- 11:45point, but these are from things that I've studied
- 11:47and observed. But in the 1980s, we saw the early
- 11:52stages of digital photography and the development
- 11:56of solid state image sensors and cameras. In
- 12:001986 in particular, Canon released the first
- 12:04commercially available analog electric camera.
- 12:08So this is the precursor to the mid 2000s. And
- 12:11this is when I'm growing up in the mid 2000s.
- 12:14And this is when there's a rush in the industry,
- 12:17the camera industry that is, towards miniarization,
- 12:21which has allowed for the creation of smaller
- 12:23and lighter digital cameras. Smaller cameras
- 12:27and footage devices allow for this footage to
- 12:30be taken in a number of discrete ways that were
- 12:33previously unimaginable. Another thing that we
- 12:37have these days is social media monitoring. And
- 12:39this will be linked to that concept I spoke about
- 12:43earlier called Flubrosa. But social media is
- 12:46a big one. The proliferation of social media
- 12:49has changed the world and how humans communicate
- 12:51with one another. And in turn, that has influenced
- 12:55the landscape of litigation. Next is drones and
- 13:00GPS tracking. Now, these things are pretty interesting.
- 13:03For those who may not know, a drone is a remote
- 13:07controlled pilotless aircraft. Now, initially
- 13:12drones were developed for war, but in the technology
- 13:17era that we're in now, they've become smaller,
- 13:20more nimble, more widely produced. And if you
- 13:24were to go to a park or the beach on any given
- 13:27weekend, you may see someone piloting a drone
- 13:30for fun. And I really believe that drones are
- 13:34perhaps the future of CBROSA surveillance. Right
- 13:39now, they're already being used by police in
- 13:42the criminal realm. And the advantage for them
- 13:46of using these drones is primarily stealth. Again,
- 13:51that's in the criminal context. In the civil
- 13:54context, I haven't seen too too too much usage
- 13:58of drones. Again, I think that's coming in the
- 14:02future though. We also have this concept of GPS
- 14:06tracking. I've had a few cases in the past where
- 14:10defense has asked for my clients Strava information.
- 14:15Strava, S -T -R -A -V -A, is a health app and
- 14:20that lets users track their running and their
- 14:22bicycle riding with the GPS. This information
- 14:26tends to show how physically active somebody
- 14:30is, and therefore it could be used to contradict
- 14:33their claims of an injury. In addition to that,
- 14:38Strava information allows you to see the routes
- 14:41that someone is traveling and what times they
- 14:45reached certain destinations along the routes.
- 14:49Other fitness apps and even social media apps
- 14:51have started to infuse a location GPS feature
- 14:57amongst their other social features. So this
- 15:00is definitely something to be aware of. We've
- 15:03touched on physical surveillance, hidden recordings,
- 15:07social media monitoring, and drones and GPS tracking.
- 15:12Due to the ways that this sub rosa and surveillance
- 15:15can be attained, you have to make sure that your
- 15:19clients are assuming they are always watched.
- 15:24When it comes to surveillance and sub rosa. There
- 15:30is no explicit statute in California that authorizes
- 15:34this practice. But general evidence law governs
- 15:39the admissibility of evidence and in turn, the
- 15:43admissibility of any video surveillance. And
- 15:48there's a few key provisions that I think any
- 15:51litigator trying to protect against the prospect
- 15:54of surveillance must No. The first is evidence
- 16:00code section 350, and you can see it on the slides
- 16:03here. Evidence code section 350 says that no
- 16:08evidence is admissible except relevant evidence.
- 16:13That's pretty simple, but as we continue, we're
- 16:17going to talk about the exclusion of evidence
- 16:19that's unduly prejudicial. After evidence code
- 16:24section 350, we have evidence code section 351,
- 16:29which states that except as otherwise provided
- 16:32by statute, all relevant evidence is admissible.
- 16:39You take that in conjunction with the next section,
- 16:42which is section 352. That says that the court
- 16:47in its discretion may exclude evidence if it's
- 16:51probative value is substantially outweighed by
- 16:57the probability that its admission will either
- 17:01A, necessitate undue consumption of time, or
- 17:06B, create substantial danger of undue prejudice
- 17:10of confusing the issues or misleading the jury.
- 17:14Again, that's evidence code section 352. The
- 17:18next one that's super important is going to be
- 17:201400, section 1400 that is. That says that the
- 17:25authentication of a writing means A, the introduction
- 17:30of evidence sufficient to sustain a finding that
- 17:34it is the writing that the proponent of the evidence
- 17:38claims it is, or B, the establishment of such
- 17:43facts by any other means provided by law. So
- 17:47essentially, What this rule is saying is, hey,
- 17:51if you're trying to enter something into evidence,
- 17:55you have to prove that that thing is whatever
- 17:57you're saying it is. That's the concept of authentication.
- 18:03Next, I find this pretty interesting. This is
- 18:05Code of Civil Procedure Section 2031 .010. And
- 18:12this allows for any party to obtain discovery
- 18:16by inspecting copying, testing, or sampling documents,
- 18:23tangible things, land, or other property, and
- 18:27electronically stored information in the possession,
- 18:30custody, or control of any party to the action.
- 18:35This is one of the most powerful devices, I believe,
- 18:39for plaintiff's attorneys to attempt to procure
- 18:43sub rosa. Again, Subroza is footage, obviously,
- 18:48and this section says that any party can obtain
- 18:53the discovery by expecting, copying, testing,
- 18:57or sampling documents. It uses this word documents,
- 19:01but Subroza surveillance is actually underneath
- 19:06that umbrella of documents. So again, this is
- 19:102031 .010. and we will talk more in depth about
- 19:16how plaintiff's lawyers can use that provision
- 19:19to discover and interrogate potential sub rosa
- 19:24footage. We've got a few more kind of code sections
- 19:30that I want to go over before we move on. This
- 19:34next one is civil code section 1708 .8. Okay,
- 19:40now this is a way for plaintiffs' attorneys to
- 19:44protect themselves and their clients if they
- 19:47feel sub rosa has been procured illegally. Now,
- 19:52provision A of the civil code section says that
- 19:56a person is liable for physical invasion of privacy
- 20:01when that person knowingly enters onto the land
- 20:06or into the airspace above the land of another
- 20:10person without permission or otherwise commits
- 20:14a trespass in order to capture any type of visual
- 20:18image, sound recording, or other physical impression
- 20:22of the plaintiff engaging in a private, personal,
- 20:27or familial activity, and the invasion occurs
- 20:30in a manner that is offensive to a reasonable
- 20:34person. Now, provision A works in tandem with
- 20:39the next provision, which is provision B, and
- 20:43it provides that a person is liable for the constructive
- 20:48invasion of privacy when that person attempts
- 20:51to capture in a manner that is offensive to a
- 20:54reasonable person any type of visual image, sound
- 20:58recording, or other physical impression of the
- 21:01plaintiff engaging in a private, personal, or
- 21:04familial activity through the use of any device.
- 21:07regardless of whether there is a physical trespass.
- 21:12Now, you might be wondering, well, what happens
- 21:15to the people or the person that is procuring
- 21:18this sabrosa in this illegal manner? Essentially,
- 21:23if these provisions are violated, you then look
- 21:27to Civil Code Section 1708 .8d, and that provides
- 21:33the penalty. The penalty is up to three times
- 21:37the amount of any general and special damages
- 21:42that are approximately caused by the violation.
- 21:45And that person may also be liable for punitive
- 21:49damages subject to proof. It's also interesting
- 21:54to note that there is a civil fine of not less
- 21:58than $5 ,000 and not more than $50 ,000. for
- 22:04this violation. So for any defense lawyers that
- 22:09may be out there watching this, just know if
- 22:12you're going to be trying to procure this surveillance,
- 22:17you want to do it the right way. Obviously, as
- 22:20a plaintiff's lawyer, I don't necessarily believe
- 22:23in this. I don't believe that there's a right
- 22:26way to procure this footage. I wish there was
- 22:30no footage on my clients. I do believe it's highly
- 22:33invasive. But again, for the defense lawyers
- 22:36and insurance adjusters watching, perhaps, just
- 22:40know that you want to make sure you're looking
- 22:43at this provision to ensure you're doing those
- 22:46things the correct way and not infringing on
- 22:49those plaintiff's rights. So again, this is the
- 22:54framework of the couple provisions that I think
- 22:56are super important when it comes to CBROSA,
- 22:59because again, there is no one statute or provision
- 23:06that mentions CBROSA or instructs you on how
- 23:11to procure that. Again, and this is all in the
- 23:15slides, but we've got evidence code 350, 351,
- 23:20352, and section 1400. And then we also discussed
- 23:25CCP 2031. 010, that's what I believe is one of
- 23:30the best discovery devices through which plaintiffs
- 23:33can, plaintiff's attorneys can procure this abroza
- 23:37if it exists. And then lastly, we talked about
- 23:40civil code section 1708 .8. So we went over a
- 23:48couple of the statutes. Let's talk a little bit
- 23:52about case law. because obviously case law and
- 23:57the statutes together are going to govern what's
- 24:01right, what's wrong, what's allowed, and what's
- 24:04not allowed when it comes to Soprosa. First,
- 24:12we have a case, Hernandez v. Superior Court,
- 24:16and we'll talk about this a little bit more in
- 24:19depth when we go. But essentially, if an interrogatory
- 24:23asks the responding party to identify a document.
- 24:27An adequate response must include a description
- 24:31of the document. You will find this on page 293
- 24:37of this Hernandez case. So the responding party
- 24:41may object to the interrogatory, and they might
- 24:45say, hey, this request is seeking privileged
- 24:49information. The one thing about this that's
- 24:55important for plaintiff's lawyers to understand
- 24:58is that the existence, the mere existence of
- 25:02a document that contains privileged information
- 25:05is not privileged. So oftentimes, you might propound
- 25:11discovery to the defendant asking for surveillance.
- 25:17And you'll get this blanket objection Just saying
- 25:22privilege, privilege, privilege. But again, when
- 25:26you look at Hernandez, the important thing here
- 25:30is that the existence of a document that contains
- 25:34privilege information is not privileged. That's
- 25:38going to be on page 293. Surveillance is discoverable.
- 25:43It's not protected by work product doctrine unless
- 25:48it includes an attorney's mental impressions.
- 25:52So for plaintiffs' attorneys, it's very important,
- 25:55if you see this blanket objection, you continue
- 25:58to push, especially because the question from
- 26:04Form Interrogatory 12 .3, which we'll talk about
- 26:08here shortly, should not be something that just
- 26:12has a ton of blanket objections. And if you get
- 26:14those, again, you're going to have to push. And
- 26:17at the very least, you want to know if the surveillance
- 26:22exists. And again, the existence of surveillance
- 26:25itself is not privileged. Next, we've got a pretty
- 26:29important case here. And I know we've all at
- 26:33least seen something cite to this, but this is
- 26:37Swayzaki versus Superior Court. This is a foundational
- 26:41case affirming that surveillance is not privileged
- 26:45or protected, even when shared with counsel and
- 26:47it must be disclosed. does support the aggressive
- 26:51use of form interrogatories 13 .1 and 13 .2,
- 26:57along with the other vehicle, which I think is
- 27:00great for discovering surveillance, but those
- 27:02are the requests for production of documents.
- 27:12I want to talk about a case. It's not actually
- 27:14in the PowerPoint, but this is something that
- 27:17you have probably seen cited too as well. This
- 27:21is Nacht and Lewis Architects v. Superior Court.
- 27:26This case is often used in objections, along
- 27:29with arguments that discovery at issue requests
- 27:32information that is protected by attorney work
- 27:35product privilege. But if you're plaintiff's
- 27:40lawyer and you see this Nacht case, one, obviously
- 27:43read it, even though I'm going to tell you what
- 27:45the holding is. Don't just take this case and
- 27:49then sit back and rest. Understand that the holding
- 27:54in this case is about the production of a list
- 27:57containing the identities of individuals the
- 28:01defense counsel interviewed during its investigation.
- 28:06Okay, again, this holding is about the production
- 28:08of a list containing identities of individuals
- 28:11interviewed by defense counsel. The court denied
- 28:15production of this list on the grounds that it
- 28:17would reveal the attorney's impressions of the
- 28:21case. So some basic things to remember about,
- 28:26you know, requesting documents, requesting surveillance
- 28:29is that there is a distinction between something
- 28:32that has the attorney's mental impressions versus
- 28:38something that is strictly factual. If a video
- 28:43is just showing the plaintiff, you know, checking
- 28:46the mailbox, you want to, you know, that is just
- 28:53a factual thing. Whereas if, as here in Swayzaki,
- 28:59right, defense counsel has gone to the lengths
- 29:03of making their impressions or making specific
- 29:06lists with specific witnesses for specific reasons,
- 29:10you probably won't be able to access that information.
- 29:14And we'll talk about essentially how you can
- 29:16sniff out whether these objections are legitimate
- 29:19or not a little bit later. Specifically, we're
- 29:21gonna talk about privilege logs, okay? Before
- 29:25moving on from Swayzaki, just a couple basic
- 29:28things to remember. There are foundational evidentiary
- 29:32requirements, right? And these require that surveillance
- 29:36has to be authenticated. It has to be relevant
- 29:40to material issues in the case and it cannot
- 29:44mislead or confuse the court or the jury. Another
- 29:56thing to remember is that you need to be timely
- 29:59with your objections to surveillance videos or
- 30:04any surveillance that is given to you late, okay?
- 30:09You need to file your motions in limine, right?
- 30:14And you can file those early, right? You don't
- 30:17want to wait till the last second to get in front
- 30:19of the court to say, hey, I've been given this
- 30:22surveillance, it's after the close of discovery,
- 30:26and it's unfair, right? You want to use the court
- 30:29and use motions in limine to your advantage.
- 30:33And we'll talk about that a little bit later,
- 30:36but specifically through these motions in Lemonade,
- 30:39where you're asking for certain evidence to be
- 30:42precluded, you need to demonstrate the imbalance
- 30:45of the probative value with the prejudicial harm.
- 30:48And you're going to refer to section 352, like
- 30:51we spoke about earlier, okay? And this is because,
- 30:56listen, if you have this evidence, right? Again,
- 31:00showing your plaintiff doing What might appear
- 31:04to be something that is routine and regular but
- 31:07that contradicts their injuries? Right all that
- 31:11All that hard work that you've done over the
- 31:14previous months to get the case ready for litigation
- 31:16can be up in smoke Okay, so let's talk more about
- 31:20some key admissibility factors Sabrosa cannot
- 31:26be sprung as a courtroom surprise if you as a
- 31:30plaintiff's lawyer have done your job early and
- 31:33often to be aggressive in your hunt for cebrosa.
- 31:38There are a couple of key things that you need
- 31:41to know and most importantly right discovery
- 31:45closes 30 days before trial. This is according
- 31:49to CCP 2024 .020A and that is any party shall
- 31:56be entitled as a matter of right to complete
- 31:59discovery proceeding on or before the 30th day
- 32:04and to have motions concerning discovery heard
- 32:07on or before the 15th day before the date initially
- 32:12set for the trial of the action. So again, when
- 32:17you have a case, there's no secret what the discovery
- 32:21deadlines are. You have to be proactive in making
- 32:25sure that you have requested Soprosa and that
- 32:29you've done it timely. If you request CBROSA
- 32:32and you request it later after discovery is closed,
- 32:36good luck. So that's for trial, but there's another
- 32:41kind of key caveat that you should know. Discovery
- 32:44closes 15 days before an arbitration, and you're
- 32:48gonna find the support for this in California
- 32:52rule of court 3 .822, specifically 3 .822A. And
- 33:00that sets forth the right to discovery in arbitrations.
- 33:04And if you move to B, that mandates that all
- 33:08discovery must be completed not later than 15
- 33:13days before the date set for the arbitration
- 33:16hearing, unless the court, upon a showing of
- 33:19good cause, makes an order granting an extension
- 33:23of time within which discovery must be completed.
- 33:27So again, you want to be timely. Discovery closes
- 33:3130 days before trial. Discovery closes 15 days
- 33:34before arbitration. And again, also when you're
- 33:38agreeing to an arbitration, you want to make
- 33:42sure that you know what rules govern your arbitration.
- 33:46A lot of times those track with the CCP, but
- 33:49sometimes the particular arbitrator might have
- 33:53a flavor for something special. So make sure
- 33:56you know those rules, make sure you're on top
- 33:58of that and do not be late. You want to require
- 34:05this authentication. And again, this is from
- 34:08evidence code section 1400. And this is a key
- 34:12admissibility factor. Now, the process of authentication
- 34:15aims to ensure that the writing, okay, it's called
- 34:19a writing per code, but understand that under
- 34:22that umbrella of writing, you're going to find
- 34:25that CBROSA surveillance is included. So the
- 34:28process of authentication aims to ensure that
- 34:31that writing or footage is what it purports to
- 34:34be. The authentication process all centers around
- 34:39ensuring that anything admitted into evidence
- 34:42for the consideration of the jury is reliable.
- 34:46and trustworthy. Now, per section 1042 of the
- 34:53evidence code, evidence can be authenticated
- 34:56through testimony of a witness with personal
- 35:00knowledge. As it relates to sub rosa footage,
- 35:05this means that the originators of that surveillance
- 35:08must testify regarding the video surveillance,
- 35:12the sound, the silent motion pictures, photographs,
- 35:17or anything else that they have created prior
- 35:20to its admission into evidence. We're going to
- 35:26jump back to 352 here because I think that this
- 35:29is also very important for plaintiff's lawyers
- 35:31to understand. The court has the power to exclude
- 35:35evidence if its pro to value is substantially
- 35:38outweighed by the probability that its admission
- 35:41will necessitate the undue consumption of time
- 35:44or create a substantial danger of undue prejudice
- 35:48of confusing the issues or misleading a jury.
- 35:52So when deciding whether or not to admit video
- 35:56surveillance into evidence, the court weighs
- 35:59its prejudicial impact against its value in assisting
- 36:03the jury to understand and evaluate the other
- 36:06evidence presented in the case. The court is
- 36:10going to have to look at whether or not the surveillance
- 36:14is a reasonable representation of that which
- 36:17it is alleged to portray. And secondly, the court
- 36:21will look at whether or not the use of this surveillance
- 36:24is going to assist jurors in their determination
- 36:27of the facts of the case, or whether it's just
- 36:31gonna mislead them and lead them on a wild goose
- 36:33hunt. So something you'll want to do, and if
- 36:41you're a plaintiff's lawyer, this is really important.
- 36:43Something that you're going to want to do is
- 36:45advise your clients early, early, early, early,
- 36:51as early as possible of the threat of social
- 36:54media and having an online presence. Now, one
- 36:59of the things is that depending on however you
- 37:02work a case or what happens along the way, sometimes
- 37:06cases can take years to resolve. Clients have
- 37:12short term memory. And what that means is that
- 37:16you as that plaintiff's attorney who's supposed
- 37:18to protect them should remind them over and over
- 37:22and over. And that can become almost like a mantra.
- 37:27The defense is always watching. Again, they're
- 37:32gonna and sometimes right and this, this is the
- 37:37concept that I've called Flub Rosa. A flub is
- 37:41essentially an F -L -U -B is a blunder. Flub
- 37:46Rosa is almost like an unforced error that your
- 37:51client makes. Why would the defense hire all
- 37:54these fancy private investigators if your client
- 37:57is spilling away their life through every Instagram
- 38:01post? They're alleging that they can't walk,
- 38:08they're alleging, my neck, my back. Well, explain
- 38:13your TikTok from last week where you're dancing
- 38:17on top of a table in a bar, right? Again, a single
- 38:21Facebook post can slice your damages, award,
- 38:25and half. Surveillance footage and social media
- 38:29contradictions are a credibility disaster. when
- 38:34the jury doubts your client's credibility, every
- 38:37other part of your case goes out the window and
- 38:42will begin to unravel. And this is not just necessarily
- 38:47about advising your clients to post carefully.
- 38:51This is about the litigation hygiene, right?
- 38:56You want to get the client to buy in. Understand
- 38:58that they have a vested stake and what happens
- 39:03in litigation and that the things they do can
- 39:05actually unfortunately destroy their case. So
- 39:08at intake, any plaintiff's attorney should educate
- 39:12their client about these risks. Let's talk a
- 39:16little bit more about that. Now, again, the basic
- 39:21part of this is no posting about your case or
- 39:26your injuries. But let's get a little bit deeper.
- 39:31and specific things you can tell your clients.
- 39:35One, never, ever, ever, ever, ever delete old
- 39:41posts. What you'll have to explain to your clients
- 39:44is that this is what's called spoliation. Spoliation
- 39:49of evidence is the destruction or significant
- 39:53alteration of evidence or the failure to preserve
- 39:57it for another's use in pending or future litigation.
- 40:03Now, remember, and this is very, very important,
- 40:08sometimes we get cases and we have no intention
- 40:13on filing on that case. We believe, hey, I might
- 40:19be able to resolve this case in pre -litigation.
- 40:24And obviously, sometimes the things that happen
- 40:27in pre -lit are a lot more informal, a little
- 40:31bit more casual than after your lawsuit is filed.
- 40:36But you have to stress to your client, hey, it
- 40:40doesn't matter that I have not filed your lawsuit
- 40:44yet. It doesn't matter. You still have a duty
- 40:48to preserve evidence once litigation is reasonably
- 40:52anticipated. I'll say that again. You have the
- 40:58duty to preserve evidence once litigation is
- 41:02reasonably anticipated. So this includes things
- 41:06that are posted by your client on social media.
- 41:11Something else that I like to tell my clients
- 41:14after I've explained, hey, never delete anything,
- 41:18is to enable strict privacy settings. I warn
- 41:22them though, even if your account is locked.
- 41:26even if your account doesn't use your full name,
- 41:31even if your account doesn't have an accurate
- 41:35profile picture or any profile picture for that
- 41:39matter. If something is online, it's never truly
- 41:45private. And so I try to let my clients know
- 41:49that the other side is going to be able to obtain
- 41:54these things. My clients sometimes ask, well,
- 41:58hey, I had a post online, but I archived it.
- 42:03For those of you who don't know what archiving
- 42:06is, this is a feature where, say you upload on
- 42:09Instagram a photo, and then for whatever reason,
- 42:12maybe 20, 30 days later, you don't like the photo
- 42:15anymore. You don't have to delete it. You can
- 42:19just archive it. And when you archive something,
- 42:22it's no longer visible if I were to go to your
- 42:25Instagram page. And you have to tell clients
- 42:29that, hey, look, even if you're archiving these
- 42:33photos, they can still be found. Nothing online
- 42:39is private. That's just the age and era that
- 42:43we live in. I tell my clients, that about the
- 42:48archive posts. And then I explained to them that
- 42:51if we are going to file on this case, meaning
- 42:54that, you know, we write up the complaint, we
- 42:57file it in court, and now we're live. If we file
- 43:03a lawsuit, the other side of that lawsuit is
- 43:08going to gain subpoena power. These allow, the
- 43:12subpoena powers allow the other side to have
- 43:15even more of a chance to get to your social media
- 43:19for the savvy defense lawyers out there. These
- 43:23extrajudicial means allow them to, such as the
- 43:27subpoena powers, and then even if outside of
- 43:31the subpoena powers, I explain to my clients
- 43:33that there are certain digital capture tools
- 43:37that show what a website looked like on a specific
- 43:40date that's in the past. So if they were to delete
- 43:44or to archive or to somehow alter their social
- 43:47media, doesn't matter. There are certain tools
- 43:50and apps that the defense lawyers use to see
- 43:53how your page looked in the past. So you have
- 43:57to be very, very careful of this. And there's
- 44:00actually a rule in the California Rules of Professional
- 44:03Conduct that I read to my clients. This is 3
- 44:07.3A. And that's more so about lawyers, but I
- 44:11try to make my clients understand that, hey,
- 44:13we're in this together, and this is not a one
- 44:16-sided thing. And as a team, I have to know that
- 44:20you have my back, and in turn, I'll have your
- 44:22back. But again, rule 3 .3a provides that a lawyer
- 44:29shall not knowingly make a false statement of
- 44:32fact or law to a tribunal. or fail to correct
- 44:36a false statement of material fact or law previously
- 44:39made to the tribunal by the lawyer, or offer
- 44:44evidence that the lawyer knows to be false. Rule
- 44:483 .4 of the California Rules of Professional
- 44:52Conduct adds that a lawyer shall not unlawfully
- 44:56obstruct another party's access to evidence or
- 45:00unlawfully alter, destroy, or conceal a document
- 45:05or other material having potential evidentiary
- 45:08value. You're also not able to suppress any evidence
- 45:13that the lawyer or the lawyer's client has a
- 45:17legal obligation to reveal or produce. Obviously,
- 45:21you also cannot falsify any evidence. There's
- 45:24another key provision that is found in the business
- 45:29and professions code. This is section 6068. D.
- 45:34And that states that it is the duty of the attorney
- 45:38to employ means only consistent with truth and
- 45:43never to seek to mislead the judge or any judicial
- 45:46officer by an artifice or false statement of
- 45:50fact or law. Okay, so it's super important. Any
- 45:55lawyer who fails to produce relevant evidence
- 45:58or compromises existing evidence could be subject
- 46:03to state bar discipline. And I don't know about
- 46:06you, but I know about me. I love the ability
- 46:08to practice law. And that is something that I
- 46:13protect with my life essentially. And so my clients
- 46:17also need to know, hey, there are certain things
- 46:19you just can't do. And you need to tell me what's
- 46:23going on. That way I can only make accurate representations
- 46:28to the court. So I actually go to the length
- 46:32of when I'm signing clients up, I say, hey, I
- 46:36need access to all your socials. I take screenshots
- 46:39of everything for myself. That way I can have
- 46:43pretty much everything that was in existence.
- 46:46And I'll try to do it for at least a year prior
- 46:50to when they sign up with me. That way I can
- 46:54for myself know and verify that my client is
- 46:58telling me the truth. And I do believe that a
- 47:02good amount of my clients are always telling
- 47:03me the truth, but I'm also cognizant that sometimes
- 47:06we forget things. So I try to monitor those on
- 47:09my own, just to make sure that everything is
- 47:13what it should be. We talked about these contradictory
- 47:17posts a little bit earlier, and this is certainly
- 47:21the danger of social media. I had a case which
- 47:27is now closed and done with, but essentially
- 47:31one of my clients had terrible back issues. And
- 47:36then all of a sudden there's an Instagram post
- 47:39of them riding a dune buggy. So, you know, just
- 47:43like here on the screen, if somebody is claiming
- 47:47that they can't walk and they have this social
- 47:49media post of them hiking in Big Sur, it's over.
- 47:54They claim that they can't drive but then they
- 47:58take a five -hour road trip to Vegas Doesn't
- 48:02look good These are things that really will taint
- 48:06the jury's perception of your client and again
- 48:11Let's let's actually go back to that These things
- 48:16that I'm talking about here specifically fall
- 48:19into the flub rosa category Because these are
- 48:23unforced errors. And if you do your job as a
- 48:27plaintiff's attorney to really hop on these things
- 48:29and make sure that your clients understand the
- 48:32importance of their own social media, then hopefully
- 48:36you will never have to deal with these. Again,
- 48:40you want to avoid the flub rosa to any extent
- 48:43possible. And again, sometimes you do all you
- 48:47can and the defense still finds something. I
- 48:49don't know how they do it, but they do it. But
- 48:52you want to minimize that prospect as much as
- 48:55you can. So that's the contradictory piece of
- 49:01it. And then, like I said, if there's so many
- 49:04contradicting things, then your client's credibility
- 49:07is going to be tainted by the jury. So something
- 49:14else, and this is a step that I like to do, is
- 49:20I have a little kind of client social media disclaimer,
- 49:24where I explain everything that I just told you
- 49:27guys that are listening today. And it's just
- 49:31a paragraph or two just with the summary of that.
- 49:34And they take a look at it, and they sign it,
- 49:37and they say, hey, I understand. The important
- 49:41about this is that I would hate to get the trial.
- 49:47find some that the defense has a ton of sub rows
- 49:50of my client's social media, and then have my
- 49:53client look at me and say, well, you never told
- 49:55me about this. You never told me that they would
- 49:59be looking at my social media. If that were to
- 50:04ever occur, I just whip out the piece of paper
- 50:06and say, well, hey, this is your signature, right?
- 50:08We actually did talk about this. So again, you
- 50:14really need to make it clear to your clients
- 50:16that the things they do can harm their case.
- 50:18And I do it via a social media disclaimer because
- 50:22if it's not written, it didn't happen. So that's
- 50:28something that I do. And I've found that when
- 50:31you really have them sign that and you talk to
- 50:33them, the light bulb goes off and they understand
- 50:36how serious it is. So what are the best ways
- 50:44to try to figure out whether SBROSA exists and
- 50:48to get it? Those things are going to be formant
- 50:52derogatories, specifically 13 .1. That's very
- 50:56important because it asks straight up whether
- 50:58or not surveillance has been conducted. And again,
- 51:01that's why it's important when you get the response
- 51:04to this question, you really need to figure out,
- 51:09okay, What is the defense saying? Is there objection
- 51:13per code or is it a bunch of mumbo jumbo with
- 51:16some case sites? And you have to be willing to
- 51:20go to the mat on this if you're getting a bunch
- 51:23of random objections. 13 .1 is a huge tool. Outside
- 51:28of that, you can use special interrogatories
- 51:30to ask for the dates, the times, the locations,
- 51:34and the identities of any investigators. or people
- 51:40that took surveillance, or even the people who
- 51:42viewed this surveillance. And as soon as you
- 51:45get these names, you want to send out a notice
- 51:47of depo for these people, or subpoenas for these
- 51:50people, and make sure that you're asking them
- 51:52what they know. You can also use, and we talked
- 51:57about this a little bit earlier, but requests
- 51:59for production of documents. That's personally
- 52:01probably my favorite way other than maybe 13
- 52:04.1 to get. the Subrosa footage, but you can demand
- 52:08footage, you can demand surveillance logs, you
- 52:11can demand notes, you can demand reports and
- 52:15emails. Now again, when it comes to notes, obviously
- 52:19you can't have the defense lawyer's notes about
- 52:22Subrosa. But if the surveillance, the person
- 52:26who's doing the surveillance has notes on what
- 52:30the plaintiff looked like or anything they did,
- 52:33you might be able to try and get those. So you
- 52:36should always use special interrogatories and
- 52:40requests for production of documents to try to
- 52:43get those. Lastly, our requests for admissions.
- 52:47I like to use those to try to lock in the other
- 52:50side. It can be as simple as admit that you retained
- 52:54a private investigator to surveil the plaintiff.
- 52:59Depositions are great, too. Once you know who
- 53:03did the footage or once you know who's viewed
- 53:05it, you're going to try to take those depots.
- 53:12Again, form interrogatory 13 .1 is super, super,
- 53:16super important. And please know that you are
- 53:21able to ask for any supplemental information
- 53:25that has just been created and you can do this
- 53:31twice during litigation. So it's important to
- 53:34send 13 .1 and realize like, if you're sending
- 53:37discovery early on as you should, right, you
- 53:39want to kind of send discovery at the earliest
- 53:42possible point, but understand that if you do
- 53:44that, It's likely there probably isn't any footage,
- 53:48right? If you're sending it literally at the
- 53:50first possible point in discovery when things
- 53:53are brand new, you probably haven't even answered
- 53:55discovery. So maybe the defense doesn't even
- 53:58really know what your client's injuries are.
- 54:00Then just know, you're going to have to send
- 54:04out supplemental interrogatories later on. That
- 54:07way, if in the interim, they have had that footage
- 54:10taken, you'll know about it. We talked again,
- 54:16we talked about special interrogatories. These
- 54:18can be really powerful if you're asking for the
- 54:21name, date and location of the surveillance.
- 54:24And they are also pretty good if you're using
- 54:28definitions for identified because you can use
- 54:31that to try to call out as much information as
- 54:34possible. We talked about requests for production
- 54:39of documents, and this is in the slide. So these
- 54:41are things that you can directly use. We've got
- 54:46the request for admissions that you can use to
- 54:48lock down the defense on whether or not they
- 54:51have retained a private investigator. And we
- 54:56talked about this a little bit earlier, but it's
- 54:57very, very, very important that you meet and
- 54:59confer. There's no point in spending all this
- 55:02time in discovery if when you receive discovery,
- 55:07You let a month, month and a half go by before
- 55:10looking at it. And then you have to ask for an
- 55:13extension on your motion to compel and do those
- 55:17things. It's just very sloppy. What you want
- 55:20to do is when you get discovery responses, look
- 55:22at them early. And then that way you don't have
- 55:25to rush in the meeting confer process. You can
- 55:27at first pick up the phone, try and establish
- 55:31a relationship with your opposing counsel. And
- 55:34then you can send a confirming letter. or you
- 55:37can just send a letter. However you do it, you
- 55:39want to make sure you meet and confer, especially
- 55:41if you're getting evasive responses. Again, you
- 55:49know, there's certain things you can do in depositions
- 55:52that you can't do in written discovery. So one
- 55:54of the ways to figure out kind of what's going
- 55:57on is maybe you'll notice the deposition of a
- 56:00person most knowledgeable. Maybe you'll notice
- 56:03that deposition and when you have that deposition,
- 56:06You want to make sure that you're asking a variety
- 56:10of questions to try to pin down the time and
- 56:12scope of any surveillance, try and figure out
- 56:15who took it, what does it depict, when was it
- 56:19conducted, right? And so you can get creative
- 56:21in depositions and those are something that you
- 56:25definitely want to do. You also want to make
- 56:27sure that you're taking advantage of the 1987
- 56:30notice of appearance. This is when you're asking
- 56:33the party to, hey, come to trial. And when you're
- 56:36doing this, you can request documents along with
- 56:41it, such as surveillance. You always want to
- 56:44do that. Again, that's a notice of appearance,
- 56:461987. We've talked a little bit about these motions
- 56:52and limine to preclude Subroza. But as trial
- 56:55nears, the productive and proactive plaintiff's
- 56:58advocate takes the fight to the other side because
- 57:01you're going to file that motion to exclude any
- 57:04reference. to evidence of Subroza footage. So
- 57:07this motion should have a main plan and an alternative
- 57:11plan. The main plan is to preclude Subroza in
- 57:16its entirety. Now, sometimes, right, a lot of
- 57:22times, that just doesn't work. So the alternative
- 57:26plan, which you're going to lay out in your motion
- 57:28for the judge, is... suggesting certain strictures
- 57:32on this evidence should it be admitted, such
- 57:37as authentication. And you want the evidence
- 57:41and the surveillance to be authenticated outside
- 57:45of the presence of the jury. Okay, and that's
- 57:48important, super, super important. And if you're
- 57:53unable to have Subrosa included, right? it can
- 57:56still somewhat be neutralized by doing these
- 57:59things through your motions in the M &A and through
- 58:01the authentication process. You definitely want
- 58:05to do everything you can before the jury is allowed
- 58:07to take this with them in the deliberation room.
- 58:12Now, the motion for the preclusion of Subroza
- 58:15should seek to convince the court of three things
- 58:17at minimum. One is that the defendant failed
- 58:20to acknowledge the existence of Subroza in response
- 58:23to form interrogatory 13. right, and supplemental
- 58:28discovery propounded on the defendant thereafter.
- 58:31Two, you want to argue that sub rosa is actually
- 58:34irrelevant for impeachment, because, you know,
- 58:39and obviously, there are certain situations where
- 58:44you want to use 352 to basically tell the judge,
- 58:49hey, these are things that are going to just
- 58:51confuse the jury, they're not actually going
- 58:54to educate the jury. And what you're going to
- 58:57see on that footage is nothing other than a goose
- 59:00hunt. Three, you want to just really harp that
- 59:05the Subroza materials lack that probative value.
- 59:08Their disclosure is outweighed by the risk of
- 59:10wasting the jury's time and the likelihood of
- 59:13causing undue prejudice because it's just going
- 59:15to confuse the issues. The evidence code supports
- 59:18this motion for the exclusion of Subroza and
- 59:21alerts the court. And you want to just alert
- 59:23the court. that in ruling upon admissibility,
- 59:26it has a duty to ensure that the surveillance
- 59:29is a reasonable representation of what the defense
- 59:32purports it to be. There is essentially times
- 59:40where Subrosa will be taken after the close of
- 59:44discovery. That's really what, especially if
- 59:47you know a case is going to trial, you really
- 59:50want to make sure that Once discovery has closed,
- 59:54you don't sit back and rest and relax. That's
- 59:57when you need to be alert because that sabrosa
- 1:00:01can find its way into court if you're not careful.
- 1:00:06You want to challenge the foundation of any sabrosa,
- 1:00:10challenge when was it taken, the camera angle.
- 1:00:14There's unclear visibility here. And if it's
- 1:00:18not authenticated by any witness, you wanna move
- 1:00:20for its total exclusion. Again, this is just
- 1:00:26that the mill, this is the mill for saying, hey,
- 1:00:29look, this evidence is more prejudicial than
- 1:00:31probative. And something that you can really
- 1:00:34argue or something that you might think about
- 1:00:37arguing is, hey, here's this footage, but this
- 1:00:41is just one good day out of a thousand bad days,
- 1:00:44right? This is one good day out of a thousand
- 1:00:48bad days. This clip is literally only meant to
- 1:00:52mislead and confuse the jurors. It doesn't represent
- 1:00:58what the typical paying levels of my client are.
- 1:01:01So there's a few things in Mills that you want
- 1:01:05to have and just structurally. First, you want
- 1:01:08to talk about CCP Section 128. That's what gives
- 1:01:11the court the jurisdiction to grant the motions
- 1:01:14in the M &A. The court also has the power to
- 1:01:17preserve and enforce an order and it's an immediate
- 1:01:21presence and to enforce and provide for the orderly
- 1:01:24conduct of proceedings before it. So essentially
- 1:01:27you just mentioned CCP 128, it grounds kind of
- 1:01:30your motion and it's kind of the hook that gets
- 1:01:33you started. You then move to evidence code section
- 1:01:35402B, which is telling the court essentially,
- 1:01:38hey, you have the power to determine questions
- 1:01:41of admissibility of evidence and you can do so
- 1:01:45outside of the presence of the jury. You also
- 1:01:48want to, in your mill, let the court know that
- 1:01:51this is the proper vehicle through which you
- 1:01:55can make a ruling on whether or not a witness
- 1:01:58can be precluded from testifying. You also want
- 1:02:02to harp on the fact that, listen, when the bell
- 1:02:06is rung, I can't unring it. When the cat's out
- 1:02:09of the bag, the cat's out of the bag. If they
- 1:02:11see this evidence, It's done for, and it's so
- 1:02:17unfair that that's why we need to prevent that
- 1:02:20bell from ever being rung. Now, the court should
- 1:02:24preclude the defendant from offering evidence
- 1:02:27not previously disclosed in response to pretrial
- 1:02:30discovery, right? They should do that, but sometimes
- 1:02:34crazy things happen, right? But you definitely
- 1:02:37want to have that in your motion if that's the
- 1:02:39case where you propounded your 13 series and
- 1:02:42then you propounded your supplementals. and you
- 1:02:45got nothing in return, right? If that's the case,
- 1:02:50then you definitely need to include that in your
- 1:02:52motion, just letting the judge know that you
- 1:02:54propounded timely discovery and there was no
- 1:02:56response. So the fact that defense now all of
- 1:02:59a sudden has a sabrosa is completely unfair.
- 1:03:04Again, do not let the defense use work product
- 1:03:08privilege as a shield in discovery, but then
- 1:03:11a sword at trial. That is trial by ambush. And
- 1:03:14you have to do everything you can to alert the
- 1:03:16judge if that's going on in your case. So these
- 1:03:24are some things that you can also throw in your
- 1:03:27motion and lemonade. I've talked about most of
- 1:03:29these. This is a case I don't have time to go
- 1:03:32over, but it's pretty good to read. Same with
- 1:03:36Thorin. So read those cases. I'm sure you can
- 1:03:40throw those in your mills. We also, this is the
- 1:03:45thing about footage too, although it can be pretty
- 1:03:47damning for your case. Sometimes, you can have,
- 1:03:55sometimes it can be a way to demonstrate that
- 1:04:00the defense is going to such great lengths to.
- 1:04:05show you that this person is allegedly a liar,
- 1:04:08but they're doing it in a way that's untowards,
- 1:04:11and that does not demonstrate the full picture
- 1:04:14of what's going on with my client. You can talk
- 1:04:17about pain fluctuations, right? You can talk
- 1:04:20about the fact that, hey, maybe on this day the
- 1:04:23footage was taken, the client was actually heavily
- 1:04:28medicated. They took their pain pills that their
- 1:04:33doctors prescribed them, And once they did that,
- 1:04:36they had a few minutes where they could get their
- 1:04:38household chores done. They had a few minutes
- 1:04:41where they could hobble to the mailbox with less
- 1:04:44pain. Right? And this video doesn't show them
- 1:04:48that pain, the painkiller that was prescribed
- 1:04:52to them. All it shows is this misleading clip,
- 1:04:56and that was done purposely. So, again, you know,
- 1:05:00pain is invisible. This clip is not everything.
- 1:05:04this is one good day out of a thousand. Those
- 1:05:06are some of the things that you can use if the
- 1:05:09evidence is actually admitted to let people know
- 1:05:13that this should not be the tail of the tape
- 1:05:15and your client does have serious injuries. Something
- 1:05:21else is you want expert testimony, right? Your
- 1:05:25doctors that have treated your client are going
- 1:05:28to be able to testify to what their limitations
- 1:05:31are. And it's very important while you're building
- 1:05:34a case, you need to be reading medical records
- 1:05:37and figuring out what these restrictions are
- 1:05:39that your doctor is giving to the clients early
- 1:05:42on. Talk to your clients about these restrictions.
- 1:05:45Make sure they're aware of these restrictions.
- 1:05:48And as long as you are kind of within the realm
- 1:05:51of whatever the doctor recommends, that's all
- 1:05:55you can do. So If there is CBROSA and you get
- 1:06:01it, you definitely want to go over it with the
- 1:06:05doctors. Obviously, if that's early enough and
- 1:06:09there's time, because that might change their
- 1:06:11opinions. But that's something that's going to
- 1:06:18be useful. If you know what your experts are
- 1:06:20saying, your clients can and can't do, you do
- 1:06:23want to make sure that this footage, is one of
- 1:06:26the things that they can't do. So in closing,
- 1:06:32and I know I guess I've gone over just a little
- 1:06:34bit here, but in closing, pain is invisible.
- 1:06:38One good day doesn't erase an injury. And you
- 1:06:41want to build your trial story to embrace this
- 1:06:44truth from day one. So with that, everybody,
- 1:06:50I have nothing further. And I'm really, really
- 1:06:55thankful that you guys tuned in and I hope you
- 1:06:57learned something that will help you build your
- 1:07:00cases. Thank you.