Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Hollywood Enters The Legal Battle Over AI: The Midjourney Case From The Studio Perspective
Transcript
- 0:02I'm Randi Bandman, chair of the entertainment
- 0:05law section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:08Welcome to our program. Hollywood enters the
- 0:11legal battle over AI, the mid -journey case from
- 0:14the studio perspective. It is my honor to introduce
- 0:17today's speaker, David Schrage. David is a private
- 0:21mediator specializing in entertainment, media,
- 0:25and intellectual property. Having worked on all
- 0:28sides of the Hollywood ecosystem for more than
- 0:3120 years, David offers rare insight and experience
- 0:34as a neutral. For the first dozen years of his
- 0:37career, David was a trial lawyer focused on cases
- 0:40involving celebrities, entrepreneurs, and bet
- 0:43the company litigation. He trained as a senior
- 0:46associate at the prominent law firm Altshuler
- 0:48Grossman Stein and Cahan, after which he started
- 0:51his own firm, KSW LLP. David then pivoted. and
- 0:56for the next decade worked in -house as a studio
- 0:59executive, where he advised studio presidents,
- 1:02mega producers, and other senior leadership.
- 1:05His roles have included senior vice president
- 1:07and head of global television business and legal
- 1:10affairs for Maramax, vice president of business
- 1:13and legal affairs for NBC Universal's International
- 1:16Television Studio, and senior counsel for legal
- 1:19affairs at Universal Pictures, where he handled
- 1:21negotiations for prominent producers, including
- 1:24working title television, Haiti Television, Carnival
- 1:27Films, Matchbox Pictures, and a wide range of
- 1:31other term deal producers. As a studio executive,
- 1:35David became intimately familiar with all aspects
- 1:38of domestic and international production, oversaw
- 1:41billions in deals and budgets, and negotiated
- 1:43countless agreements with the top agents, lawyers,
- 1:46talent, studios, and distributors in the global
- 1:49television and film industries. With his uncommon
- 1:52background, as both a talent side litigator and
- 1:55an in -house dealmaker, David offers a unique
- 1:58ability to understand and appreciate the complex
- 2:00considerations, studios, sophisticated parties,
- 2:04and their teams of representatives must balance
- 2:06while making deals, while in litigation, and
- 2:09while mediating practical solutions to emotionally
- 2:12charged disputes. David was on law review while
- 2:16at the University of Southern California School
- 2:18of Law, Extern, for the honorable Dean Prageron
- 2:21and received his BA from Yale University. When
- 2:25it comes to community engagement, David is committed
- 2:28to fostering access to justice and promoting
- 2:31mediation. He is the outright coordinator and
- 2:34a co -host for the Will Work for Food Project,
- 2:37a webinar series on mediation, which also raises
- 2:40donations for food banks worldwide. He serves
- 2:43as a volunteer mediator for the Los Angeles Superior
- 2:46Court. volunteers with the Western Center on
- 2:48Law and Poverty to train high school mediators,
- 2:51is on the volunteer mediation panel for the California
- 2:53Lawyers for the Arts, is a member of the Southern
- 2:57California Mediation Association and a speaker
- 2:59at their upcoming conference, and is a member
- 3:02of the executive committee of the entertainment
- 3:04law section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 3:07On a personal note, David is the proud father
- 3:09of two young boys, an avid cyclist, a student
- 3:12of the stoic philosophers, and loves spending
- 3:15time with his family in their garden. Thank you
- 3:17very much, David. Thank you very much, Randy,
- 3:21for that very generous introduction. I really
- 3:23appreciate it. I think my mom would be blushing
- 3:25for me. It's very warm. I just want to also thank
- 3:30you very much for your service to the Beverly
- 3:31Hills Bar and to the entertainment law section.
- 3:33You've been a tremendous supporter. And we really
- 3:37appreciate everything you do for the organization.
- 3:38And if anybody's interested in getting involved,
- 3:40Randy, it's an extraordinary resource along with
- 3:42the rest of the board for the entertainment law
- 3:44section. So thank you for that as well. OK, so
- 3:48you're welcome. So with that, let's get started.
- 3:51I'm going to go ahead and share my screen. I
- 3:58think that should do it for us, correct? Yes.
- 4:04OK, great. So today we're going to talk about
- 4:09the mid -journey case that was filed by Disney
- 4:11and NBC Universal against the company Mid Journey.
- 4:15And what I'm going to try to do today is give
- 4:17you some insight into what the studio considerations
- 4:19are when a case like this is being filed, not
- 4:22just from a legal perspective in terms of what
- 4:24the claims and defenses are, but also from a
- 4:27practical perspective. as far as what the business
- 4:29considerations are, what's happening in the industry
- 4:32and what the future is in terms of where things
- 4:34are going. And to frame our conversation today,
- 4:38what I'll say is that people in studios often
- 4:41talk about and think about themselves as storytellers.
- 4:45When you work in a studio, what people say is
- 4:47our mission is to really tell compelling stories
- 4:50that have exciting characters and propulsive
- 4:53elements and plot twists and and that hopefully
- 4:56tell us a little something about our world and
- 4:58what our values are and the complexity of these
- 5:00issues that we're constantly balancing as human
- 5:02beings. And so today I'm going to try and tell
- 5:05you a story about this case and what I think
- 5:08is a really great and compelling story here in
- 5:10terms of what's happening in the world of AI
- 5:11litigation. And I think it has a lot of these
- 5:13twists and turns. And all of us who are learning
- 5:18about AI and using the various tools that are
- 5:20out there are familiar with with the term prompts.
- 5:23And we really know that it's the prompts that
- 5:24will dictate where you go in terms of what the
- 5:26outputs are. And this slide gives you a sense
- 5:29of some of the things that we're going to try
- 5:30and talk about today as we tell this story about
- 5:33what's happening in this case and what the different
- 5:35considerations are. And I just want to emphasize,
- 5:38these are not just the considerations of the
- 5:39studios, but these are the considerations in
- 5:41terms of both sides of this case. And a lot of
- 5:43what we've seen so far in the course of litigation
- 5:46has come from the studios. But there's always
- 5:49going to be more that's coming back from the
- 5:51side of the defendant mid -journey who has answered.
- 5:52And we're still in very early stages. So we're
- 5:55going to try and talk about both perspectives.
- 5:58today as well. And I think what you'll see is
- 6:00that this case is really a microcosm of what's
- 6:02going on in the world and in the legal community.
- 6:05I mean, we're in this age of tremendous change.
- 6:08The technology that we're all dealing with is
- 6:10advancing so rapidly. And what we're doing is
- 6:14watching the law try and keep up and evolve in
- 6:16parallel, effectively. It can be very difficult,
- 6:20obviously, for the courts and the legislatures
- 6:23to keep up with this. And so it's really the
- 6:26lawyers who are our peers in this community who
- 6:29are really at the forefront of all of these issues
- 6:31and doing an incredible job litigating on both
- 6:34sides of these cases for all the different stakeholders
- 6:37who are involved. I really tip my hat to them
- 6:39as well. And then like any good story, you know,
- 6:44this story hopefully could have a happy ending.
- 6:46I guess we'll have to see how the litigation
- 6:47plays out. But since I am a mediator, what I'm
- 6:50going to do is engage in some rank speculation
- 6:52at the end of this talk about maybe some ways
- 6:55that this case could settle and some of the ways
- 6:56that we could think about what a potential resolution
- 6:59should look like or could look like. And then
- 7:02lastly, it's also important to understand today
- 7:05that You know, in large part, there's a lot more
- 7:08questions that are our answers when it comes
- 7:09to the issues that we're discussing today because
- 7:11we're in such a nascent stage in terms of what's
- 7:14happening in this world of AI litigation. So
- 7:16I'll pose a lot of them and I'll try and answer
- 7:18any questions we have maybe towards the end.
- 7:20But I can't guarantee I'm going to have many
- 7:22of the answers. So like any good story, there's
- 7:29always an inciting event. There's always something
- 7:31that has to happen to get the story started.
- 7:33And In terms of who the characters are in this
- 7:37litigation, we all know who Disney and NBC Universal
- 7:40are, obviously. But the first question is really,
- 7:44who is Mid Journey? And for the most part, the
- 7:46information I'm going to be sharing with you
- 7:47about these companies, about Mid Journey, I should
- 7:49say, is laid out in NBC and Disney's complaint.
- 7:53There's other publicly available information,
- 7:55of course. But from a 10 ,000 foot level, Mid
- 8:01Journey was founded in 2021 by an entrepreneur
- 8:03named David Holtz up in the San Francisco Bay
- 8:05area who had had some previous success as a founder
- 8:08with other companies. So somebody who really
- 8:10knows the community, knows the resources that
- 8:12are out there and is a successful founder. MidJourney,
- 8:19interestingly, is independent. They do not take
- 8:21venture capital money, so they don't have ownership
- 8:23stake from any of the funds that are out there.
- 8:25They launched their AI image generator software
- 8:28that we're going to talk about in February of
- 8:302022 as a bot on Discord, which is another sort
- 8:32of platform to access these types of tools. Although
- 8:36eventually, in 2023, they offered their service
- 8:40to customers around the world just through their
- 8:42website. And then eventually by August 2024,
- 8:46it was available to everyone around the world.
- 8:50Mid Journey, I guess the question is, how do
- 8:52they make money? They offer a subscription -based
- 8:54model in order to use their service. There's
- 8:58a tiered pricing structure, so it could be anywhere
- 9:00from $10 to $120 per month. And there's other
- 9:03plans available generally. But the idea here
- 9:06is that the more you pay, the more processing
- 9:08time you get. So the more images you can generate
- 9:10in a shorter period of time. You can imagine
- 9:11just the. the resources that are necessary to
- 9:15generate all these images are incredible. So
- 9:18the more you pay, the more access you have to
- 9:21that functionality. They're a relatively small
- 9:24company in terms of this space. I think they
- 9:26have something like 100 and change employees,
- 9:28but they've reportedly had revenue in 2023 of
- 9:32$200 million. By 2024, they had $300 million
- 9:36in revenue. And in 2024, it also looks like they
- 9:40have about 21 million users. So they're really
- 9:43taking off and growing tremendously. So the first
- 9:47real question is, What does this image generator
- 9:50do and how does it work? So what I'm going to
- 9:53do is show you some images that are pulled from
- 9:56Disney and NBC Universal's complaint. And we're
- 9:59going to play a little game here. I'll show you
- 10:01the images. And before I advance the slide, you
- 10:04can decide for yourself whether or not you can
- 10:06tell which one is the original copyrighted work
- 10:07and which one is the mid -journey generated image.
- 10:11So obviously, we all know Deadpool here. The
- 10:14image on the left is actually output from mid
- 10:17-journey. And so the prompt here asks to see
- 10:23Deadpool on a 35 -millimeter portrait. And before
- 10:27I go further, I want to just back up for a second
- 10:29and say, whenever we're looking at this type
- 10:33of tool, another important question is to say,
- 10:37well, What does the tool train on? Where does
- 10:40the data come from? Because in terms of these
- 10:41large language models, if you've been following
- 10:43the news, they ingest a tremendous amount of
- 10:46data and they learn how to generate these outputs,
- 10:49right? Hi, David. I'm sorry to interrupt. It
- 10:52looks like the screen is currently stuck on your
- 10:55past slides before entering in here. Do you see
- 11:00Deadpool here? No, I don't actually. Could you
- 11:02try to perhaps turn off the screen share and
- 11:05then try it on again? Sure thing. OK. OK. Can
- 11:18you see Elsa? Yes. OK, great. So I'm going to
- 11:21go back for a second, OK? And so actually, let
- 11:24me just jump back to this one. So the question
- 11:26is, what is? What does MidJourney train on in
- 11:29order to develop this functionality? And the
- 11:31complaint explains that the founder had said
- 11:35publicly that it pulls off all the data it can,
- 11:39all the text it can, all the images it can. It
- 11:42grabs everything they can. They dump it in a
- 11:43huge file. And they kind of set it on fire to
- 11:46train some huge thing. And the founder of the
- 11:49company has acknowledged that they don't seek
- 11:50consent from the creators of this content before
- 11:54they ingest it and use it in order to train the
- 11:56model. And the question of what did they train
- 11:58on comes up later in some of the cases we're
- 12:00going to talk about. And it presents some interesting
- 12:02issues that the studios in Mid Journey are going
- 12:04to have to deal with. So jumping ahead here,
- 12:08we have Deadpool. On this slide, you can see
- 12:12it's Mid Journey's output on the left, Disney
- 12:14on the right. And the prompt here asks to see
- 12:16Deadpool. 35 millimeter portrait. Okay, in our
- 12:20next slide, the prompt here is Princess Elsa
- 12:23singing in front of an ice castle frozen animated
- 12:26movie. Okay. Same thing mid journey on the left
- 12:31Disney's original character on the right. We
- 12:35keep going. Right. We've got the Little Mermaid
- 12:38here. Which one's original? The one on the right.
- 12:46We all know Bart Simpson, which one's original,
- 12:50the one on the right again. If we advance to
- 12:54this slide, this one's interesting because the
- 13:00prompt here, let me just jump in here. You can
- 13:02see here that it's Mid -Journey's output on the
- 13:04right this time and Disney's original character
- 13:06on the left. But unlike the prior slides where
- 13:08the prompt actually specifically referenced the
- 13:12characters, this prompt just says Pixar. And
- 13:16if you just enter the word Pixar, this is what
- 13:18comes up. And so it shows this character, Sully,
- 13:21obviously on the right. And so part of what Disney
- 13:24and NBC talk about in their complaint is that
- 13:26the use of generic terms within the prompts.
- 13:29in generic terms, in terms of referencing their
- 13:31company as opposed to specific characters, without
- 13:34even having to invoke the specific elements of
- 13:36the copyrighted works can lead to these types
- 13:38of outputs. And there are other examples of this
- 13:41in the complaint. If you type in superhero fight
- 13:43scene, it brings up images of Marvel characters.
- 13:46If you put in the word screen cap, it might pull
- 13:48up Spider -Man and Loki and some others. Black
- 13:51armor with light sword, movie screen cap, pulls
- 13:53up, you guessed it, Darth Vader, okay? And so
- 13:57here's another example. The prompt here is Yoda
- 14:01with lightsaber. OK. And you may have noticed
- 14:04my bad joke about intent here with this reference
- 14:07to the Empire Strikes Back. But. You know, this
- 14:10is something that comes up later. The question
- 14:12of willfulness and whether or not mid -journey
- 14:14is aware of what's going on in terms of these
- 14:16outputs and how it may potentially be able to
- 14:18control these things. And so this is something
- 14:21that movies that call it an Easter egg and we'll
- 14:23come back to this question of intent and willfulness
- 14:25later. And of course, the complaint includes...
- 14:29Many other examples of characters that are being
- 14:32generated in this same way. Buzz Lightyear, Chewbacca,
- 14:36Iron Man, Simba the Lion King, Aladdin, Olaf
- 14:39from Frozen, Minions, Big Boss Baby, Shrek, Kung
- 14:43Fu Panda, Thanos from the Avengers. the Cars
- 14:46franchise, the Lightning McQueen, Guardians of
- 14:49the Galaxy, you name it. So we're talking about
- 14:52things that really look like copies of these
- 14:54characters that are being generated. And the
- 14:55legal question, of course, is whether or not
- 14:57this amounts to something that's actionable under
- 14:59the Copyright Act, or whether or not there are
- 15:00defenses that mid -journey can invoke. And it
- 15:03doesn't choke -voke these defenses, of course.
- 15:05And so this next slide talks about something
- 15:08that the complaint describes as the explore feature.
- 15:14This is where things kind of get even more interesting
- 15:16and juicy from a legal perspective in terms of
- 15:18these complaints. The claim explains that Mid
- 15:22Journey has this explore page and it's a feature
- 15:24that lets you input a search term and then Mid
- 15:27Journey generates examples of various images
- 15:29that. have been used or generated through the
- 15:34program and can mainly serve as inspiration or,
- 15:38I guess, a reference point and suggestions for
- 15:40the potential user. So if you put in the term
- 15:43Groot, this is what you would see. Another example,
- 15:50you put in the term Buzz Lightyear, and you get
- 15:53this sort of landing screen in terms of other
- 15:57images that you can see. And as we'll discuss
- 15:59later, the studio sees on this. And they argue
- 16:02that this is a way that Mid Journey facilitates
- 16:04and encourages users to generate images that
- 16:07they claim are infringements of their copyrights,
- 16:10obviously. And they're encouraging users to try
- 16:12and generate these results by creating a gallery.
- 16:15And it demonstrates their knowledge of this allegedly
- 16:18infringing conduct. Again, that's the studio's
- 16:20position on this. And Mid Journey has answers.
- 16:22And we'll talk about those as well in defenses.
- 16:27Yeah, the real issue is, is this something that's
- 16:29going to be actionable? And the litigation is
- 16:31going to develop that, obviously. So back to
- 16:34this slide where we talk about the inciting event.
- 16:38And the real question before we get into a litigation
- 16:40like this is, what's going on before the lawsuit
- 16:43is filed? And what do you do if you're a studio
- 16:47that has this GA, or generative AI, platform
- 16:50that's spitting out copies of these copyrighted
- 16:52characters, and they're potentially so good that
- 16:54you can't tell the difference? You know they
- 16:56didn't pay to train the model, and you know that
- 16:58they're making money through their program. And
- 17:00what do you do? Well, you start with sending
- 17:02a cease and desist letter, right? Because you
- 17:05want to try and avoid getting into a litigation
- 17:06potentially, if that's possible. We'll talk more
- 17:09about that, too. So what was the timeline that
- 17:11preceded the filing of the studios lawsuit? Just
- 17:13to kind of go through it quickly, in November
- 17:15of 2024, so just this past fall, Disney sent
- 17:20a cease and desist letter to Mid Journey, and
- 17:22what they say in that letter is that you have
- 17:25infringed our copyrights by training on our data
- 17:28without consent and without compensating us,
- 17:30that you're displaying our works through the
- 17:33platform without authorization, and that's an
- 17:35infringement as well. And what they also talk
- 17:40about is that there are no technical measures
- 17:43that are present in order to prevent this from
- 17:45happening. And it's something sort of a term
- 17:46that we refer to generically as more guardrails.
- 17:50And what the studios point out and say in these
- 17:53letters is they asked Majority to let us know
- 17:54what guardrails are in place. And what they point
- 17:56out is that there's something of an industry
- 17:58standard in place where companies like JetChatGPT,
- 18:02who have these types of similar platforms and
- 18:03can generate images, have limitations on terms
- 18:06of what can be generated. And so if you enter
- 18:10terminology that might result in the display
- 18:13of potentially infringing work, some of these
- 18:15platforms have technical measures in place that
- 18:18won't let you actually generate the image. And
- 18:20what the studios argue in their complaint and
- 18:22talk about in these letters is the fact that
- 18:24MidJourney does have guardrails that are available
- 18:26or in place to prevent certain things like pornographic
- 18:29content or gore or extreme violence and other
- 18:31things that generally violate their community
- 18:34standards. So. This is a big part of what this
- 18:38complaint talks about as well. We'll talk about
- 18:40that some more. So the studios send their cease
- 18:42and desist letters November of last year, December
- 18:45of 24 mid -journey response. And they say, we're
- 18:48reviewing the letter. Then they kind of go quiet
- 18:50for a while, according to the complaint. In April
- 18:5325, however, so just a handful of months ago.
- 18:56Mid Journey released a new and improved version
- 18:58of his service, and it did not have any additional
- 19:01guardrails in place. So the conduct that the
- 19:03studios are upset about is continuing. Then in
- 19:06May of 25, NBC jumps in, and they send a cease
- 19:08and desist letter to Mid Journey. And then in
- 19:11early June, Mid Journey teased the release of
- 19:14a new video generator service that they said
- 19:17would work well with their image generating service.
- 19:18And I think this is probably when the alarms
- 19:20really went on within the studios. It's one thing
- 19:23to generate these images, but the bread and butter
- 19:24for these studios is audio visual content. And
- 19:28now it seems pretty clear that there's a tool
- 19:29that's going to come out that can make videos.
- 19:32And within days of that, the studios filed. Clearly,
- 19:35they felt their hands were being forced. It seems
- 19:38like there are some other things that were going
- 19:40on also. For those of you who follow Puck News,
- 19:44Eric Gardner is a reporter there who covers the
- 19:46legal beat and does some fantastic work covering
- 19:48the industry, but also has covered this topic.
- 19:51And what he has reported on this is that Apparently,
- 19:54part of what really raised the alarms within
- 19:56the studios as well is that around that same
- 19:58time, the government had invited comments in
- 20:02terms of suggestions for what its policy should
- 20:04be on AI. And there were some feedback that came
- 20:07from some of these high level VC companies that
- 20:10basically suggested that the Justice Department
- 20:13should come in on the side of these AI companies
- 20:16in order to intervene and support their ability
- 20:19to train on these types of materials. We'll talk
- 20:24more eventually about what the government has
- 20:25to say about this, but that's a big factor, I
- 20:28think, in terms of these folks jumping in and
- 20:29really got their attention. Clearly, it's a tough
- 20:31decision for the studios. They want to avoid
- 20:33this. Generally, they want to try and avoid deep
- 20:36-pocketed defendants. I'm sure they've been paying
- 20:38attention to OpenAI and what they're doing with
- 20:40their platforms as well. But if there was somebody
- 20:45they're going to sue, MidJourney is a relatively
- 20:47better target than maybe some of the more gigantic
- 20:49companies because they're relatively small. Litigators
- 20:53say, don't punch up when you're going after somebody
- 20:56and go after a company that has tremendous resources.
- 20:58It can make things even more difficult, obviously.
- 21:04This case, you can see from the images, it gives
- 21:07the student a pretty tangible and compelling
- 21:09way to tell their story that this isn't just
- 21:11a case that's about training, but it's about
- 21:13outputs that are really very tangibly look just
- 21:17like their characters. So they're going to jump
- 21:20in. This seems like potentially a good way to
- 21:21do it. There's other concerns, like there's precedents
- 21:25in the past where CBS Viacom sued YouTube, and
- 21:27that litigation lasted 10 years and didn't necessarily
- 21:29shake out the way the studio wanted. And the
- 21:31studio doesn't want to get into a morass like
- 21:34that. There's a whack -a -mole problem where
- 21:37you sue one company and another one pops up,
- 21:39and you've got to go after them as well. And
- 21:41then there's always the risk of an adverse ruling
- 21:43and not wanting to make bad law that hurts you.
- 21:45But to some degree, The studio's hand is forced.
- 21:48This stuff is going on. The clock is ticking.
- 21:50They're worried about other factors that could
- 21:51be in play, and they had to do something and
- 21:53jump in. So in terms of the studio considerations
- 21:59when they're filing this type of lawsuit, aside
- 22:01from these sort of big picture issues we're talking
- 22:02about, there's The first thing you sort of have
- 22:08to ask about when you're talking about the considerations
- 22:10is, who's at the table at the studio side before
- 22:12a lawsuit like this is filed? And what you need
- 22:16to appreciate is something like this, when it's
- 22:18an industry -wide type of issue, this kind of
- 22:21issue goes straight to the top at the company,
- 22:23right? It's the CEO of the company. It's the
- 22:26general counsel who's going to be involved in
- 22:28these types of decisions. The most senior leadership
- 22:30of the company is weighing in on what the studios
- 22:32are going to do about this, obviously. There's
- 22:34teams of in -house lawyers who advise the businesses,
- 22:37right, the film folks and the TV folks about
- 22:39how they want to deal with these issues. There's
- 22:41teams of in -house IP lawyers like copyright
- 22:43lawyers and patent lawyers and technology experts.
- 22:45There's in -house litigators. There's their outside
- 22:47counsel. And then they're also talking to the
- 22:49production people and the people inside the studio
- 22:51who are working with these tools because they
- 22:52want to understand what the impact of this litigation
- 22:54is going to be on them as well in terms of what
- 22:56they can do. And that's something we'll talk
- 22:58about more as well. So the big point here is
- 23:00there is a complex interplay of considerations
- 23:02for the studios when they're filing a lawsuit
- 23:04like this. They're not thinking about just what
- 23:07the state of the law is, but they're thinking
- 23:08about how it plays out in the court of public
- 23:10opinion, what it means to their business to file.
- 23:12And I think from a big picture perspective, these
- 23:15considerations fall into three categories. They're
- 23:17almost sort of like three legs of a stool. The
- 23:21first thing the studios are, and there's a tension,
- 23:23I should say, between these competing considerations.
- 23:25And the first thing the studios are really thinking
- 23:27about is the fact that they are libraries. They
- 23:30have invested countless billions of dollars to
- 23:32create these properties, to protect these properties,
- 23:34to go after infringers, to distribute their catalogs.
- 23:38I mean, this is fundamentally the core business
- 23:40of the studio is to create these types of work
- 23:42and distribute them. And you just look at the
- 23:45work they've done politically over the years
- 23:46to extend the Copyright Act and enhance IP protections
- 23:49for this type of work. Studios are also builders
- 23:52of franchises, right? I mean, the works that
- 23:54we are talking about are the bread and butter.
- 23:57in terms of franchises that generate revenue.
- 24:00It's harder and harder in this environment to
- 24:02compete for eyeballs and to make money. And when
- 24:04a Minions movie comes out, it makes a billion
- 24:06dollars just in theatrical revenue alone worldwide.
- 24:09And obviously, there's all the licensing relationships.
- 24:12There's the merchandising. There's all the ancillary
- 24:14exploitation as well. So we are really talking
- 24:17about the fundamental elements of how the studio
- 24:21builds and promotes its business and develops
- 24:23their slates. You know, like I said, they license
- 24:28these rights. They have licensees. They have
- 24:31exclusive relationships. They exercise tight
- 24:33control over how these properties are exploited.
- 24:35They have very specific approvals over what the
- 24:38images look like. They don't want to tarnish
- 24:39their properties based on what else might be
- 24:41out there. And interestingly, as the technology
- 24:45evolves, the studios themselves are looking at
- 24:47how do they license their own works into the
- 24:49AI ecosystem to try and use the underlying content
- 24:52to generate revenue for themselves. So this is
- 24:56a fundamental aspect of what they do, and it's
- 24:58critically important for them to protect their
- 25:00libraries. The other thing that studios think
- 25:02about is the fact that they are people companies
- 25:05with core values. I mean, studios employ thousands
- 25:07upon thousands of people around the world. aspect
- 25:12of what they do is they work with guilds and
- 25:15unions. And we've all seen in the most recent
- 25:18rounds of strikes involving SAG and the WGA how
- 25:22prominent these AI issues were in terms of what
- 25:25was being discussed and what was ending up in
- 25:27the papers. Just in December of last year, Deadline
- 25:31reported on a story that a letter had been sent
- 25:34by the guilds to the studios. to sort of point
- 25:39out that there were these various uses of the
- 25:41underlying material that were going on out there.
- 25:43And they asked the studios, what are you doing
- 25:44about it? So the studios are under pressure from
- 25:47the guilds who represent the talent to say, we
- 25:50need you to protect these folks. We need you
- 25:51to protect these works. And we need to make sure
- 25:53that they have the ability to be compensated
- 25:56for their work. You know, a related issue is
- 26:00they have obligations to participants, right?
- 26:02People who participate in the profits of these
- 26:05films and things like that. They need to be paid.
- 26:08Their share in the studio is policing things
- 26:10and trying to maximize their revenue. And then
- 26:13the second thing in terms of being people companies
- 26:15is the studios, they want to be the home for
- 26:17the greatest creative artists and talent in the
- 26:19world. I mean, you want to have the best directors,
- 26:22the best performers, the best writers wanting
- 26:24to work at your studio. And these people are
- 26:26sophisticated, and they want to be able to use
- 26:29these tools. They see where the future is going.
- 26:32They see the potential of these tools. They want
- 26:34to be able to create the greatest forms of artistic
- 26:36expression for themselves. And the studios are
- 26:41conscious of that. They want to create an environment
- 26:43where the artists can come to them and feel like
- 26:44they have access to the best creative environment
- 26:47that's possible. And it creates a pressure for
- 26:49them, obviously, to keep up. And that really
- 26:51sort of ties into the third leg of the stool.
- 26:54And this is where things get a bit more tricky
- 26:55for the studios, because studios are, of course,
- 26:59smart. They want to be able to use this technology
- 27:02for their own benefit. They want to make sure
- 27:04that they can provide access to these tools,
- 27:07to their production folks, and like I said, their
- 27:09creative folks as well, and enhance the efficiencies
- 27:12of what they're doing too. They are very conscious
- 27:14of the fact that these tools are going to change
- 27:16the world. And so this is where it gets a bit
- 27:19complicated because it kind of creates a potential
- 27:22contradiction here. And what the studios are
- 27:24obviously going to be concerned about when filing
- 27:25this kind of lawsuit is how not to be seen as
- 27:29talking out of both sides of their mouth, right?
- 27:31Like right now, studios are using these tools
- 27:33in production for post and audio cleanup, for
- 27:36visual effects, for ideation to generate concepts
- 27:39for stories. And what they'll tell you is that
- 27:44this actually supports their relationship with
- 27:46the talent and the guilds, and it fosters creativity
- 27:49because they're able to save money in certain
- 27:51areas and put more money on the screen to enhance
- 27:53the creative. And they're able to generate more
- 27:56content and create more audiovisual programming
- 27:59in a shorter period of time, and all the boats
- 28:01rise together, right? But again, the concern
- 28:04for them is how do they make sure they're not
- 28:08seen as speaking out of both sides of their mouths?
- 28:10Because on the one hand, they want to be able
- 28:11to go to mid -journey and say, you can't train
- 28:13on our tools. You need to pay us. We don't need
- 28:15to have these limitations. And at the same time,
- 28:18they want these tools to exist so that they can
- 28:20use them for themselves. I mean, the studios,
- 28:25I'm sure I can say there's a middle ground there
- 28:27in a way these things can coexist. But that's
- 28:29one of the tensions in terms of the optics. And
- 28:32just sort of spoiler alert. And when mid -journey
- 28:34answers, they seize on this. And they make a
- 28:37lot of hay out of it. Just. Other general considerations
- 28:41the studios are thinking about. I mean, they're
- 28:44concerned about legal issues when it comes to
- 28:46using this technology. Most studios have language
- 28:48in their writing agreements that say writers
- 28:51can't have to represent and warrant that they
- 28:53are not using generative AI technology in their
- 28:56creative process, because there's been guidance
- 28:58from the US Copyright Office that says anything
- 29:00that was created by GAI is not necessarily protectable
- 29:03under copyright. So the studios want to make
- 29:05sure that they can protect everything that they're
- 29:07paying for in terms of what's being created.
- 29:11Netflix recently put out some guidelines on the
- 29:13use of generative AI for their productions as
- 29:16well. The same ideas are present. Make sure you're
- 29:19not using it for anything that's original. Don't
- 29:21use other people's copyrighted works as the basis
- 29:23for creation. Let us know everything that you're
- 29:26doing. There's more to it and all that's out
- 29:28there as well. And then let's not forget that
- 29:31the legacy media companies haven't had the easiest
- 29:33time of it recently in terms of what's going
- 29:35on in the ecosystem of Hollywood. They're in
- 29:37the fight for their lives. Streamers have come
- 29:39in. They've taken market share. Linear is dying
- 29:43is what everyone says. There's consolidation.
- 29:45And then here comes this new threat. It's not
- 29:48a lot unlike the record labels when they were
- 29:49dealing with streaming music and how to deal
- 29:52with the ecosystem. You know, faced with the
- 29:55prospect of having to file in the midst of this
- 29:57landscape and all these competing tensions, you
- 30:00know, the studios weren't necessarily looking
- 30:02to jump into this and they probably waited as
- 30:03long as they thought that they could. You know,
- 30:07the other thing to keep in mind is that every
- 30:09litigation exists within a time and in a context.
- 30:14And something else the studios are going to be
- 30:15thinking about obviously when they file is, well,
- 30:17what's the current state of the law? and what's
- 30:21happening in the landscape right now. And this
- 30:22chart is taken from a website, a blog called
- 30:25ChatGPT is entering, is eating the world, excuse
- 30:28me. And its author is Professor Edward Lee from
- 30:31Santa Clara Law School. He's one of the leading
- 30:33voices on what's happening in the world of AI
- 30:36law, is an incredible resource. If you're not
- 30:39following him on LinkedIn, if you're not following
- 30:40his blog, this is really just, this is the place
- 30:44to go to find out what's going on. And he's spoken
- 30:46to the Beverly Hills Bar before as well. And
- 30:50this is a chart that he creates and he updates
- 30:52it pretty frequently to show all the different
- 30:55AI lawsuits or related copyright related lawsuits
- 30:57that have been filed around the country. And
- 31:01this kind of takes us back to early June of 2025.
- 31:04At that point, if we took a snapshot, this is
- 31:07what it looked like in the United States in terms
- 31:09of what the landscape was for AI litigation.
- 31:16The studio doesn't want to get involved in the
- 31:17middle of this if they can avoid it, right? I
- 31:19mean, this is a morass. There's something like
- 31:2118 different cases, I think, against CHAT GPT
- 31:23that have been consolidated into one multi -district
- 31:26litigation. And there's cases in jurisdictions
- 31:28around the country. And a lot of them, for the
- 31:30most part, are at pretty preliminary stages without
- 31:33a lot of rulings that have already been issued.
- 31:37And Professor Lee has pointed out that even if
- 31:38there are rulings in these different jurisdictions,
- 31:41they're going to be appealed. These are cases
- 31:43of such novel issues and there's such national
- 31:46importance, these types of things are gonna go
- 31:48up to the Supreme Court before this real clear
- 31:50resolution on the legal issues that they present.
- 31:55There's been 50 cases filed total since then
- 31:57if you go to his blog and see the latest. And
- 32:00that was just in the United States, okay? So
- 32:02this gives you a snapshot of what's happening
- 32:04globally. And of course, these studios are...
- 32:07They're developing shows and producing shows
- 32:09around the world. They're distributing them around
- 32:11the world. And this just gives you a sense of
- 32:14the greater complexity that's sort of present.
- 32:19So we're going to try and sort of focus on this
- 32:21issue of fair use and copyright law within this
- 32:23landscape. It's uncertain to say the least. There's
- 32:28probably three main cases to discuss that really
- 32:30inform our considerations today and what the
- 32:33studios have been looking at. There's this one
- 32:36case out of Delaware, the Ross case. And then
- 32:39there are two cases out of the Northern District
- 32:41of California as well. And the Ross case is actually
- 32:46a published decision, or any opinions have been
- 32:47issued, I should say. And in terms of these cases
- 32:51from the Northern District, it's interesting
- 32:53that we'll talk about the history of those. But
- 32:55as of the time the studio filed, the Ross case
- 32:57was decided. And the two cases, Bart's and Kadri,
- 33:01They were in the Northern District. There had
- 33:04been summary judgment hearings, but those cases
- 33:07hadn't been decided yet. So let's talk about
- 33:09each of those individually briefly. So Ross is
- 33:15referred to as a Westlaw headnotes case. The
- 33:17general idea is that this company, Ross, ingested
- 33:20all of Westlaw's headnotes or something like
- 33:222 ,000 different headnotes in order to create
- 33:25a competing headnote product. What Judge Bibas
- 33:30in Delaware found is that on the summary judgment
- 33:33motion was training on Westlaw's headnotes to
- 33:36generate a competing product effectively that
- 33:38was creating additional headnotes for Ross was
- 33:41not a fair use. The purpose was commercial, not
- 33:45transformative. And we'll talk more about some
- 33:47of this, the legal standards for this. But there's
- 33:51obviously a lot more nuance here, but it's very
- 33:53much a fact -specific case about what was being
- 33:55done in that case. And all of these copyright
- 33:56cases around fair use are always going to be
- 33:59very fact -specific. And then... In the Northern
- 34:02District, we have Barz versus Anthropic and Kadri
- 34:05versus Mehta. Anthropic's tool is Claude. Mehta
- 34:08has Lama, obviously. And these are two cases
- 34:12that are filed in the same courthouse in front
- 34:13of two different judges who are one floor apart
- 34:15from each other. Barz was a class action case
- 34:19brought by book authors claiming that the maker
- 34:23of Claude did two things, basically. They acquired
- 34:27books, some of them they acquired legally, but
- 34:29some of them they acquired from shadow libraries
- 34:32that they pirated through torrenting sites. They
- 34:35then essentially created a giant archive of materials
- 34:38that they used to train the models. And the general
- 34:43allegation is that that constitutes infringements
- 34:46in terms of the copying and the maintaining of
- 34:48these materials as well. There's a lot more issues,
- 34:51like I said, more nuance, but that's the general
- 34:54gist of the claim. There isn't really an allegation
- 34:57that the outputs that came out on the other end
- 34:59of Claude, for example, looked exactly like the
- 35:02books that had been ingested. The books are being
- 35:05ingested to learn how to write and for their
- 35:08knowledge, obviously. The Cadre versus Meta case
- 35:12is conceptually very similar. This was brought
- 35:15by 13 authors, one of whom was Sarah Silverman.
- 35:19mostly non -fiction writers, suing again, claiming
- 35:23that Lama was training on their copyrighted works,
- 35:26that they weren't being compensated, was done
- 35:28without their consent. They were more conscious
- 35:30or afraid of snippets of their work appearing
- 35:33in the outputs as well, but they also were a
- 35:36bit more concerned about this concept of market
- 35:38dilution, which is a critical factor in the fair
- 35:40use analysis, and saying that these tools are
- 35:44going to be creating and flooding the market
- 35:45with potentially competing works. Again, sort
- 35:49of both of these cases are all three of these
- 35:51cases, at least the two from the Northern District,
- 35:53I should say, really fundamentally focused on
- 35:55the act of ingesting and copying these materials
- 35:58without consent, and to some extent using pirated
- 36:02materials. Again, in both of these cases, summary
- 36:06judgment hearings have been held, but there was
- 36:08no decision yet. So then you fast forward to
- 36:11June 11th, 2025, and the CEDU has to decide what
- 36:14to do. What are we going to allege? How are we
- 36:16going to frame our claims? What are the theories
- 36:19going to be? And what they do is essentially
- 36:23four things. They focus, number one, on the massive
- 36:26investment and money that they have made to develop
- 36:30all these properties. And they focus on this
- 36:34sort of concept that mid -journeys being a free
- 36:37rider, they're making money off of all of their
- 36:39product and they're not paying for it and the
- 36:41studio needs to be compensated and the Copyright
- 36:44Act is supposed to protect them and encourage
- 36:46investment. The other thing they do is they focus
- 36:48on the outputs and they don't necessarily focus
- 36:51as much on the training, although they have an
- 36:52issue with that, but they really say, look at
- 36:54what's being generated. by this tool. And that's
- 36:58one way where this case is very different from
- 37:00the ones that have come before it. It's really
- 37:02focused on the outputs or what they call the
- 37:04outcomes. They also focus on the absence of these
- 37:07guardrails. And they talk about the fact that
- 37:10Mid Journey has the ability potentially to prevent
- 37:13this from happening, but they're not doing it.
- 37:15And they're not doing it because they know that
- 37:18their users want this product and this service,
- 37:20and they're using it in order to draw more people
- 37:22in to make more money for themselves. And then
- 37:25they have this very interesting theory of secondary
- 37:27liability that's built around this explore page.
- 37:30And they say, just look at what they're doing
- 37:33in terms of this explore page. It shows that.
- 37:36They're actually taking potentially infringing
- 37:39images. They're putting them out there. They're
- 37:41using them to demonstrate to the users what the
- 37:44tool can potentially do. And they're trading
- 37:46off of this in order to, again, draw more users
- 37:49in and generate more revenue for themselves.
- 37:53So it really goes to the issue of they really
- 37:56know what's going on here, and they're manipulating
- 37:58these images to make more money. That's the complaint.
- 38:00Now, again, MidJourney has defenses, and we'll
- 38:03talk about those as well. But in terms of this
- 38:08secondary liability theory, it's kind of a way
- 38:09around a lot of different problems for the studios.
- 38:12Mid -Journey may want to say, look, it's not
- 38:15us. This is just a tool. And the users are doing
- 38:16this. And they do allege some of these things
- 38:18in their answer. But the studio is really trying
- 38:21to get away from the concern about the summary
- 38:24judgment hearings that are in the district and
- 38:26the potential problem that there's going to be
- 38:27a fair use determination that cuts against them
- 38:29and says that learning on these materials is
- 38:33a fair use. I don't know if I mentioned this
- 38:35before, but at both of these hearings, critically,
- 38:37these judges both said they were leaning towards
- 38:40a finding that the learning on these materials
- 38:42was transformative under the Copyright Act, and
- 38:45it could potentially be of fair use. So there
- 38:47were concerns about the impact on the market.
- 38:51So one interesting question that's presented
- 38:54by this case is, where are the other studios
- 38:57and the streamers? There's a lot of other studios
- 39:00here in town. Why is it only Disney and NBC Universal
- 39:04that suit? Well, clearly, in terms of libraries,
- 39:07they probably have the biggest stake in a lawsuit
- 39:09like this. They have probably some of the most
- 39:13famous, obviously, characters and franchises
- 39:17built around these characters in the world. Paramount,
- 39:20not as much in terms of what their library is
- 39:22around these types of characters. They probably
- 39:25also had their hands full earlier this year dealing
- 39:27with the whole Sky Dance merger and the issues
- 39:31that they were dealing with, too. Sony, again,
- 39:34tremendously successful studio, but not the same
- 39:37focus in terms of these types of underlying works.
- 39:40Warner Brothers is the big one, right? They had
- 39:41the whole DC Comics universe. Where were they?
- 39:44Again, Puck has reported on this and said that
- 39:47they were in these conversations, apparently,
- 39:49but they decided to back out at the end. And
- 39:54one of the things that... that Eric Gardner talks
- 39:57about is that you want to be at the table when
- 40:01this type of litigation is going on. Because
- 40:03people who don't jump in and aren't part of litigation
- 40:05aren't there when the deals are getting made
- 40:07that dictate what's going to happen. So just
- 40:10sort of spoiler alert, WB does come in later.
- 40:13And we'll talk about that as well. Then, of course,
- 40:15where are the streamers? Where is? Amazon, well,
- 40:19they've got the Prime service, but they've also
- 40:21got an $80 billion investment in Anthropic. Netflix
- 40:25and Apple, why wouldn't they come in? Well, I
- 40:28guess the question becomes, what's the core business
- 40:30for these companies? They are, in large part,
- 40:33distributors of content. Of course, they're producing
- 40:35and commissioning their own content. But in large
- 40:40part, they're licensing content from third parties.
- 40:44You know, you kind of have to ask yourself more
- 40:46broadly, what is really the core business of
- 40:47these companies? You know, folks who work at
- 40:49these companies will say that, you know, they
- 40:52are very much tech companies, okay, with all
- 40:54the benefits that come with that and different
- 40:56priorities sometimes as well. And so there's
- 40:58an interesting perspective on tech companies
- 41:01and IP that's offered by a professor from USC
- 41:03named Jonathan Barnett who did a seminar for
- 41:07the Beverly Hills Bar for the IP section where
- 41:09he basically talks about, the reality is that
- 41:11these tech companies in large part, are distributors
- 41:14of content and that content is an input that
- 41:17goes into their system and inputs cost money
- 41:20and in general they don't want to take positions
- 41:22that are going to make it more expensive to utilize
- 41:24inputs as part of their business model and he
- 41:27does a really fascinating analysis on this his
- 41:29book is called the big steel ideology interest
- 41:35in the undoing of intellectual property. So I
- 41:37think you can tell where he comes out on this
- 41:40issue. But obviously these companies like Netflix
- 41:42and Apple, they have their own AI strategies
- 41:45and their own perspective on where the world
- 41:48is going, how they want to use these tools, what
- 41:50they're potentially building themselves, what
- 41:52potential acquisition opportunities are out there.
- 41:54And they're all going to be very conscious of
- 41:56not wanting to take positions in litigation that
- 41:57could ultimately come back and bite them. So
- 42:02right after NBCU and Disney filed their lawsuit,
- 42:06the other shoe drops and Mid Journey launches
- 42:09its video generator on June 18th. But the big
- 42:11plot twist here in our story is the video generator
- 42:14actually contains guardrails. And this time when
- 42:16you enter the prompts that could result in Elsa
- 42:20coming up on screen, Mid Journey comes back and
- 42:23it says that prompt violates our community standards
- 42:25and we can't generate that image. Why? That's
- 42:28a fascinating question. I mean, the studios would
- 42:30say it's an implicit admission in response to
- 42:33their lawsuit. But the lawyers on the other side
- 42:35would tell you any types of remedial measures
- 42:38that they potentially arguably take can't be
- 42:41held against them, because it would discourage
- 42:42folks from changing course. Demonstrates that
- 42:47they do have the ability to put these guardrails
- 42:49in place, obviously. Maybe it's just a hedge
- 42:52from mid journey in terms of limiting their exposure.
- 42:54Maybe it's something different. And spoiler alert,
- 42:56the plot thickens on that as well too. The next
- 43:02big plot twist comes a little bit later when
- 43:04these two courts in the Northern District come
- 43:06out and they issue their decisions. on fair use.
- 43:09And there's a lot of seminars out there talking
- 43:12about this because they effectively get to the
- 43:15same place, but they take very different perspectives
- 43:17on it. So in terms of the fair use analysis under
- 43:19the Copyright Act, it's a four -factor analysis.
- 43:22But the two main ones typically are the first
- 43:24factor is what's the purpose and character of
- 43:27the use, whether it's commercial or transformative.
- 43:30And then the fourth factor is the potential harm
- 43:32the use has on the market. And on the first factor,
- 43:36the judges basically agree, right? And Judge
- 43:39Alsop says in Barts that it's spectacular, transformative.
- 43:42Judge Chabria says in Kadri that it's highly
- 43:45transformative. But then the real rub becomes,
- 43:48how do they deal with the fourth factor? And
- 43:51Professor Lee talks about this again, too. There's
- 43:53a fantastic blog out there from Aaron Moss. He's
- 43:55a litigator here in town of Mitchell -Silberberg
- 43:57and Nupp, who addresses these cases as they come
- 44:00out. Another great resource for you if you want
- 44:02to follow these developments. On the fourth factor,
- 44:05though, they split. And to just back up, Judge
- 44:10Alsop says training on these materials is really
- 44:13just like the way kids learn. You read something
- 44:16and you learn it and you absorb it and it helps
- 44:18you create something new that's out there and
- 44:20create additional input, right? And Judge Chabria
- 44:24sees things differently. He doesn't think that's
- 44:26really an accurate analogy and it oversimplifies
- 44:29things because obviously these tools have a capacity
- 44:31that your average person who's reading something
- 44:33or writing books doesn't have in terms of flooding
- 44:35the market. Joseph and Barth, he rejects the
- 44:40market dilution theory. He doesn't see it as
- 44:42a problem, like I mentioned. And what he really
- 44:44is focused on is the fact that some of these
- 44:46books have been pirated. And even if there's
- 44:49a fair use justification for the learning, it
- 44:53doesn't justify theft. So he really focuses on
- 44:56piracy as the issue and he ultimately certifies
- 44:57a class based on the pirated books. But he says
- 45:00the other learning is transformative and it is
- 45:02a fair use. Judge Chabria focused on this market
- 45:07dilution theory. And what he sees is something
- 45:10a bit more ominous, and something Aaron Moss
- 45:12talks about, that really that these tools can
- 45:15become basically a content factory that can just
- 45:18bury creativity under an avalanche of AI materials,
- 45:21as he describes it. And it could discourage authors
- 45:23from being creative if they don't think their
- 45:25work's ever going to be able to break through.
- 45:28And what Judge Chabria says is the potentially
- 45:29winning argument here that the plaintiffs really
- 45:31didn't develop a lot of evidence on was was the
- 45:35market harm theory. And he kind of gives a roadmap
- 45:38in terms of what evidence needs to be shown in
- 45:41order to win a case like this and demonstrate
- 45:43that even though it's transformative under the
- 45:44first factor, the market harm is too great under
- 45:47the fourth factor and outweighs that potential
- 45:49transformative use. And he says, you probably
- 45:52need to show the markets being flooded, that
- 45:54sales are declining, that you have to quantify
- 45:56the impact of what's going on. This is sort of
- 45:59reading between the lines, I should say, from
- 46:01what he says in his opinion. and talk about how
- 46:03these works displace human work and really harm
- 46:06the people whose copyrighted images are being
- 46:08used. So he tries to sort of say this is not
- 46:11necessarily a very far -reaching argument that
- 46:13is going to protect the AI companies in terms
- 46:15of how they can train. He really just says the
- 46:18evidence to demonstrate why this is not a fair
- 46:20use hasn't been established. And he's not concerned
- 46:23about piracy. He just sort of sees it as part
- 46:25and parcel of the learning. So now we're dealing
- 46:32with this split in the landscape of decisions.
- 46:37And we then get the president's statement on
- 46:40AI comes out at the end of July 2025. This is
- 46:42the latest plot twist in the story, maybe a month
- 46:45after the studio filed. And to sort of focus
- 46:48on. from the highlight portion. And maybe some
- 46:50of you remember this coming out. I mean, it does
- 46:53seem like maybe Disney's concerns about what
- 46:55the government was going to say about this were
- 46:57somewhat justified if that was really going on.
- 47:00And the president makes a point about the need
- 47:03for speed and to be competitive. And he basically
- 47:05says that licensing isn't feasible in terms of
- 47:08his remarks. And there's a lot more that is in
- 47:10the government's policy on AI as well. This is
- 47:13just one very small piece of it, obviously. But
- 47:17it shows sort of where the focus is from the
- 47:19government. And I think it raises the question
- 47:22if this licensing, is it problematic? Is it possible?
- 47:26That's something we'll talk about. Ultimately,
- 47:29mid -joining answers in the beginning of August.
- 47:31And they do exactly what you might expect, right?
- 47:34They reframe the narrative and they pose these
- 47:36defenses. And the first thing they do is they
- 47:38come out swinging and they say, the studios are
- 47:41talking out of both sides of their mouth and
- 47:43they're hypocrites because they're these industry
- 47:44behemoths that want to squash the little guy.
- 47:47And at the same time, they want to have access
- 47:49to these tools too. And interestingly, they argue
- 47:52in their, they say in their answer that there's
- 47:54lots of emails from the studios, people with
- 47:57NBC email addresses and Disney addresses. who
- 48:00have accounts and are using these tools. And
- 48:02they say, you can't have it both ways. And they
- 48:04have unclean hands. And that's sort of the first
- 48:09argument they make. Again, to reframe the narrative
- 48:11and the optics of what's being discussed. Again,
- 48:15they go to sort of Barts and Kadri. And they
- 48:19focus on the learning aspect of this. And they
- 48:21say, we use publicly available materials. And
- 48:23it's not clear where that comes from. But they
- 48:24say, we use these materials. And this is just
- 48:27a fair use. under these already established precedents,
- 48:31OK? And again, we'll see how that develops throughout
- 48:34the courts. But they're really hammering on this
- 48:37case, which kind of went probably the direction
- 48:40that Disney and NBC anticipated and that they're
- 48:42trying to get around, obviously, by their secondary
- 48:44liability theories. And then Mediterranean makes
- 48:47a very interesting argument. They say, well,
- 48:48we're just an ISP. We're an internet service
- 48:51provider. And our users agree to our terms of
- 48:55service. And they say our terms of service say
- 48:57you're not allowed to use our tool to infringe
- 48:58anyone's works. And at the same time, however,
- 49:03our users are entitled to the First Amendment
- 49:05protections. And they are. They are fans, and
- 49:09they are people who want to be able to generate
- 49:10these works for what are potentially very legitimate
- 49:12purposes. And they say, we don't know what's
- 49:15infringing. And it's really the burden should
- 49:17be on the studios in order to send Digital Millennium
- 49:19Copyright Act takedown notices to tell us what's
- 49:21infringing. There's a process they should have
- 49:23gone through here that they didn't go through.
- 49:27raises some questions. How is the studio supposed
- 49:29to do that if they don't know what a third party
- 49:31is doing? Is it really so innocent? The explore
- 49:34feature is something that they don't really fully
- 49:36explain how they're going to deal with that in
- 49:38terms of how does the system work? How does the
- 49:43explore page get generated? What is really available
- 49:45to them? And I think these are all the things
- 49:47that are going to have to be evaluated or developed
- 49:50through the litigation to really get a better
- 49:52sense of how some of this works and whether or
- 49:54not it would be an adequate defense. And ultimately,
- 49:57they make the argument as well that, look, we're
- 49:59here to expand creativity. We are creating these
- 50:02tools that are changing the world. We're not
- 50:04profiteering. And ultimately, they're saying
- 50:08Disney and NBC haven't even identified any harm
- 50:10yet that they're actually suffering. Now, of
- 50:12course, infringement under the Copyright Act
- 50:14is presumed damages. There are statutory damages.
- 50:17And really, what Disney and Mid -Journey are
- 50:21going to have to do in order to move this case
- 50:22forward in terms of an evidentiary perspective,
- 50:25I think, is to be able to show how their licensee
- 50:27relationships are being harmed, how their products
- 50:29are being tarnished, how the absence of guardrails
- 50:32is something that would be available in order
- 50:35to remedy this, how sales could be down, how
- 50:38talent could potentially be shortchanged, and
- 50:42et cetera. Moving along, then the next twist
- 50:47happens, right? About a week later, the Barthes
- 50:50class action up in the Northern District of California
- 50:52settles, right? And after this finding that the
- 50:55pirated libraries were subject to a trial for
- 50:59damages and Judge Alsop certified the class,
- 51:02commentators like Professor Lee were doing the
- 51:04math and saying, based upon the number of works
- 51:06that are in these learning libraries, something
- 51:07like 500 ,000 books, And the statutory damages,
- 51:11potentially of, I think, $250 per work for willful
- 51:14infringement, you're looking at potential damages
- 51:17of $900 billion. And these are company killing
- 51:21damages. I mean, Anthropic, their valuation is
- 51:24about $183 million is the most recent one. Apple
- 51:26is $3 trillion. So if you're going into this
- 51:29territory, these are company killers. This is
- 51:33all really just developed in the last week or
- 51:34so. The motion for preliminary approval was filed.
- 51:37There was a hearing on it yesterday. And in the
- 51:41motion preliminary approval, the lawyers say
- 51:43that the settlement is about no less than $1
- 51:46.5 billion. OK, for about 500 ,000 pirated works
- 51:50in the class. And this translates to about $3
- 51:53,000 per work. It's the largest settlement, they
- 51:56say, in the history of copyright. It's four times
- 52:00larger per work than the statutory damages. I
- 52:02guess it's $750, excuse me, for willful damages.
- 52:04So it's four times more than they would get potentially
- 52:06for the class members at trial. It only covers
- 52:09past infringement. It doesn't cover things moving
- 52:12forward. And there are some other terms as well
- 52:15in terms of how they identify the class. But
- 52:17at this hearing yesterday, Judge Alsop actually
- 52:19denied the motion. And he said he still had a
- 52:21lot of concerns about how this is going to be
- 52:22administered, how they are going to identify
- 52:25all the works that are at issue, how the opt
- 52:26-out is going to work. He doesn't want class
- 52:28members to feel like sort of a settlement is
- 52:30being forced upon them in this way. And something
- 52:33that Aaron Moss has commented on very recently
- 52:35as well is like, well, he kind of refers to it
- 52:38as a speeding ticket for Anthropic. I mean, it's
- 52:42$1 .5 billion. It's kind of a cost of doing business.
- 52:46You move forward, you move fast, you don't get
- 52:48permission. And if the product takes off, then
- 52:51you have the lawyers clean it up, and it becomes
- 52:53a line item. So it's a very interesting perspective
- 52:55on this as well. Is it really a deterrent? And
- 53:00so we'll see how the additional cases settle
- 53:04out based on this. Then after that settlement
- 53:08was announced, then Warner Brothers sued just
- 53:11like a week ago. And now their complaint talks
- 53:14about the video generator. They've got the same
- 53:16lawyers. It's a very similar structure to the
- 53:18complaint in theories. But amazingly, now in
- 53:21their complaint, they say that MidJourney has
- 53:22dropped the guardrails. And they say that MidJourney
- 53:26deliberately removed these protection measures
- 53:28on its video service. And they heralded this
- 53:31change by formally announcing a so -called improvement
- 53:33in their video moderation and touted that its
- 53:36subscribers would experience fewer back jobs.
- 53:39OK, now MidJourney is obviously going to have
- 53:41a lot to say about this as well. But the message
- 53:44from Warner Brothers is that people wanted the
- 53:47service and they changed what they were doing
- 53:49to make it available. So it's an amazing sort
- 53:52of change in terms of how this works in the back
- 53:55and forth. And now apparently there's a YouTube
- 53:58channel where images that are generated on Mid
- 54:01Journey can be viewed as well as some other forms
- 54:04of dissemination as well. So the scope of what
- 54:08the studios are potentially dealing with here
- 54:10is even larger. Look, the last thing I would
- 54:13say is how does Mid Journey resolve? OK? One
- 54:16thing you could do, obviously, and as a mediator,
- 54:19we can talk about money, but there's also a lot
- 54:20of creative solutions you can potentially talk
- 54:22about. Is a damages payment going to be enough
- 54:26to satisfy NBC and Disney? Probably not, right?
- 54:29They're concerned about how this is being done.
- 54:31They want control over their IP. And then, of
- 54:33course, even if they were going to take a damages
- 54:35payment for the past infringement or the learning
- 54:39component, they're going to be concerned about
- 54:42the outputs as well. Are there licensing and
- 54:46partnership relationships that could potentially
- 54:48be put in place? I mean, at the last entertainment
- 54:52symposium for UCLA, there was a guy from OpenAI
- 54:55talking about how they're trying to develop partnership
- 54:57relationships with content owners. And is there
- 55:00a licensing relationship? The studios want to
- 55:02use these tools. Is there a way to promote the
- 55:04studios through the results? Is there a cross
- 55:07-licensing relationship that might be available
- 55:09where the studios are using these tools again?
- 55:12And does it end up in sort of a place where they're
- 55:14working together to moderate content on these
- 55:16platforms in order to give users the best experience
- 55:19possible while still protecting the studio IP?
- 55:22Fundamentally, that's sort of, I think, how things
- 55:24shook out and developed in the YouTube universe.
- 55:26And the studio is embracing the technology, but
- 55:28doing it in a way with the providers where it
- 55:30also protected their interests as well. So I
- 55:35want to thank you for. For listening and for
- 55:38attending today with a lot of material to get
- 55:40through if there's any other questions I know
- 55:41we might have a couple of minutes. I'm happy
- 55:43to stay a few minutes longer And again, it's
- 55:47just an exciting time to be a lawyer who deals
- 55:49with these types of issues. And our hats are
- 55:52off to the lawyers who are handling these cases.
- 55:55And they're complex issues. And there's two sides
- 55:57to all these stories. And it's really going to
- 55:59be interesting to see how MidJourney continues
- 56:01to respond to this and defend itself and how
- 56:04the law evolves in parallel. So thank you very
- 56:06much. Hey, David. Maybe just a couple of broad
- 56:11questions for you. I think you touched upon how
- 56:15the studios are considering or dealing with this
- 56:18concept of proactively licensing content. Do
- 56:21you have any other further insights that you'd
- 56:23like to share? Yeah, I mean, I do think that
- 56:26one of the things that they're exploring is working
- 56:29with different types of companies that are working
- 56:36with sort of What is the term I'm looking for?
- 56:40It escapes me with the headsets and virtual reality.
- 56:46How do we use our materials in virtual reality
- 56:49spaces? How can the underlying materials potentially
- 56:51be the basis of bots and new tools and interactive
- 56:56AI models that they control that could potentially
- 57:00be exploited in that way? So I think. I'll be
- 57:02honest, Randy. I mean, the experts here are probably
- 57:05so far ahead of some of these concepts that I'm
- 57:07suggesting in terms of what the technology could
- 57:09potentially do and what's being discussed that
- 57:12it really remains to be seen for the practitioner
- 57:14in terms of what else is out there. But I think
- 57:17no doubt about it, there's a lot of exciting
- 57:18conversations that are happening about how to
- 57:20exploit this technology. Well, thank you very
- 57:24much. So I would just like to. tell you that
- 57:30on behalf of the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 57:32we truly appreciated your unique insights from
- 57:36the Hollywood studio perspective on AI and look
- 57:40forward to hearing from you again as both the
- 57:43law and the technology continue to evolve. I
- 57:46guess my last question is someone asked, do you
- 57:48have any thoughts on the death of copyright?
- 57:53Yeah, I mean, I think that it's a broad question,
- 57:57obviously, but You know, fundamentally what we
- 58:00have to think about is what are the incentives
- 58:02behind the act, right? Is it about fostering
- 58:06additional expression from people moving forward
- 58:09in terms of the creative outputs? I think it's
- 58:10sort of the Judge Alsop perspective on it, or
- 58:14is it about protecting the people who are in
- 58:16the market as well so that they are continually
- 58:18encouraged to invest the time and money in order
- 58:21to create and aren't flooded? I mean, I think
- 58:23it's just... There's such a tension between those
- 58:25two issues. But I do think that copyright protections
- 58:30are important. They serve a very important purpose.
- 58:32And they have to evolve, I think, in parallel.
- 58:35And I think what the studios would say about
- 58:36that is we support these tools. We appreciate
- 58:40that there's an aspect of learning and ingesting
- 58:42what's come before it. But there has to be a
- 58:44way where it can be done responsibly. And I think
- 58:47that's always going to be the balance that needs
- 58:49to be struck. Do you have any thoughts about
- 58:54how this was dealt with during, I guess someone
- 58:58mentioned radio in terms of Napster and licensing
- 59:01rights back then. Are there any lessons that
- 59:03can be applied now? I mean, I think some of the
- 59:06lessons come with sort of how those issues were
- 59:08resolved. And there are cases out there like
- 59:11the Grokster case that talk about secondary liability
- 59:14and. I just saw something with this Supreme Court
- 59:17case that's going to address the standard associated
- 59:19with secondary liability as well. And I think
- 59:23fundamentally, the question becomes, do you fight
- 59:26the technology and try and squash it, or do you
- 59:28embrace it? But again, try and have it be exploited
- 59:32in a way that's responsible and takes into account
- 59:35the interests of both parties. As a mediator,
- 59:38we talk about sort of the difference between
- 59:41a party's positions and their interests. And
- 59:44fundamentally, the interests of the studios and
- 59:46the interests of Mid Journey have to be aligned
- 59:49if we're going to get a resolution of something
- 59:50like this. And the studios, like I said, they
- 59:53have an interest in protecting their IP, but
- 59:55they also have an interest in moving forward
- 59:57and having access to these tools. And Mid Journey,
- 1:00:00they obviously don't want to be facing that potential
- 1:00:03damages award that could kill the company. They
- 1:00:05want to change the world. I don't have easy answers,
- 1:00:09as I said from the beginning, but it's definitely
- 1:00:10an exciting time. Thank you very much. We could
- 1:00:14continue this conversation for quite a long time.
- 1:00:18I'll keep dodging trying to give a direct answer.
- 1:00:22That's your talent as a mediator, so thank you.
- 1:00:25All right. Well, thank you very much, everyone.
- 1:00:27We look forward to seeing you again soon, David.
- 1:00:29Thank you very much, Randy. Thanks, everyone.