Latest / Raising Men / The Truth about Testosterone
Transcript
- 0:07In April 2025, the Secretary of Health and Human Services went on Fox News and said this quote A teenager today, an American teenager, has less testosterone than a sixty-eight
- 0:24year old man, end quote.
- 0:26Hold on to that sentence.
- 0:28By the end of next week's episode, you'll know exactly how much weight it can carry.
- 0:36This is
- 0:37is raising men.
- 0:39Now, this is a new kind of episode for us, and we're probably gonna do more of it.
- 0:43I think maybe one of the most challenging and important skills in modern masculinity is knowing what's actually true and knowing why you believe it.
- 0:57And that's hard right now.
- 0:59Our boys are gonna meet claims like this on their phones.
- 1:05And we might never even know.
- 1:06We might never even get the chance to help them address it.
- 1:10So we need to give them that skill.
- 1:13Let's practice evaluating claims like this.
- 1:17And frankly, I'm making claims too.
- 1:20And you should catch me when I get it wrong.
- 1:23And I do.
- 1:24For years, I was an avid drinker of Diet Coke.
- 1:27I loved it.
- 1:28I drank tons of Diet Coke.
- 1:30And I really bristled when people told me that it.
- 1:33Caused cancer or whatever.
- 1:36I reviewed the studies.
- 1:37I knew the science down pat.
- 1:41And then one year I went to the doctor, and my blood work came back with elevated A1C numbers.
- 1:48And A1C numbers mean that, and in my case, it meant that I was getting close to being diabetic.
- 1:56Now my diet at the time was very low on carbs and sugar, but it was very high.
- 2:03On Diet Coke.
- 2:05And that was the only explanation I could think of for those numbers.
- 2:09So I researched it again.
- 2:10And the research in that intervening time period had moved.
- 2:15On their own, artificial sweeteners mostly don't raise your blood sugar the way that sugar does.
- 2:22But in a 2022 trial, all four sweeteners that they tested changed people's gut bacteria.
- 2:31And in two of them,
- 2:32Sucralose and sacchar made people's blood sugar responses worse.
- 2:37And not the same way in everybody.
- 2:39A 2025 trial found that a month of sucralose cut insulin sensitivity by about a fifth in healthy lean adults.
- 2:48So the naysayers all that time ago had a point.
- 2:53Artificial sweeteners might not be the free lunch I thought they were.
- 2:58But, and this is important, it wasn't.
- 3:02For the reasons they thought.
- 3:04The direct effect on me was that it made it easy for me to quit Diet Coke, and I did, and my A1C numbers went down.
- 3:12So hooray for science.
- 3:15Now, when I was a kid, there was a moral panic about subliminal messages, records played backwards, a tenth of a second image that your conscious mind couldn't see, but somehow it
- 3:27reached in and changed how you behave.
- 3:30There was this huge uproar about it, and it turned out not to be real.
- 3:35But I've also watched worries that sounded like panics turn out to be at least partly right.
- 3:44So doubting everything doesn't get you there either.
- 3:47You have to go and find out for yourself.
- 3:50You have to check.
- 3:52Epitetis had a line for this.
- 3:54He called these things harsh appearances.
- 3:58And he told his students to remember you are but an appearance and not absolutely the thing you appear to be, and then to examine it.
- 4:10It's the same move that I talk about when I talk about the Conan brain and the Sherlock Holmes brain.
- 4:15A claim like this hits the Conan brain first.
- 4:18It's designed to do that.
- 4:21That's the whole point.
- 4:23And our job is to hand it over to Sherlock.
- 4:28Before we do anything with it, and to teach our boys to do the same.
- 4:32So, this is how these episodes are gonna work.
- 4:35This week, I'm gonna talk about the claim.
- 4:37I'm gonna talk about who's making it.
- 4:39And then next week, I'll show you how to check yourself step by step, and how you can get the highest quality knowledge that humans have on the subject.
- 4:52So let's start with the claim itself.
- 4:56And
- 4:56When you do this, it's tempting to kind of create a straw man, to create a an easily defeatable.
- 5:02Well, it depends on what you want.
- 5:03You either create a straw man, which is an easily defeatable version of the claim, or you create a steel man, which is a one that's very difficult to defeat.
- 5:11Whenever you're doing it, you should always look for the steel man.
- 5:14What is the hardest to defeat version of the claim?
- 5:16So this is what I'm gonna try to do here.
- 5:19It goes like this: men's testosterone has been falling for decades.
- 5:25A man today has less testosterone in his body than a man that same age had a generation ago.
- 5:34In fact, that extends to teenagers.
- 5:37And teenagers today have less testosterone than old men today.
- 5:42It's a bold claim.
- 5:44It would matter.
- 5:45Testosterone does a lot of work in a man's body.
- 5:48It promotes muscle, bone, energy, sex drive, mood, and
- 5:52That serious version of the claim has serious people behind it.
- 5:55In July 2026, a team of researchers presented an analysis at a big European fertility conference and it pooled studies going back to 1972.
- 6:05And the headlines said that men's testosterone had fallen by half.
- 6:12And some of the people on that team also led big studies on falling sperm counts.
- 6:16They described what they found as a serious deterioration in male reproductive health.
- 6:22Now, if that's true, it's one of the biggest health stories in the world.
- 6:26So you can see why people are really passionate about it.
- 6:31And I think that this kind of headline hits differently if you're a man past 40 or if you're raising a boy, because it might even read like a verdict or an admonition on you or
- 6:45on him or on our culture in general.
- 6:50And that's exactly why it's worth slowing down.
- 6:53and figuring out what's really going on here.
- 6:56So there are three camps that I see in this fight, and I want to give each one of them its best case.
- 7:03The first camp says that this is a crisis and that it explains a lot of what's going wrong with men.
- 7:12For example, in 2022, Tucker Carlson made a special called The End of Men.
- 7:16One segment featured red light therapy aimed at a man's groin, which Carlson called testicle tanning.
- 7:25In 2025, Robert F.
- 7:26Kennedy made the teenager claim in a segment about artificial.
- 7:30Food dyes.
- 7:31So the implication was that artificial food dyes were causing testosterone decline in teenagers such that their level of testosterone was less than a 68-year-old man would be.
- 7:45In the same appearance, he said testosterone levels had dropped 50% from historic levels.
- 7:51Then in 2000 and July 2026, Defense Secretary
- 7:55Pete Heggseth announced that the military would screen every service member over 30 for low testosterone every year and offer treatment, offer gender affirming care.
- 8:08He called it the high T Department of War.
- 8:12His pitch was simple.
- 8:13It's about restoring and optimizing your natural capabilities, he said.
- 8:19Now, if you believe that the decline in testosterone is real and
- 8:24That it matters, and you believe that the future of war is going to be about physique and bodies, well, then screening people like that and addressing the deficiencies are
- 8:35reasonable.
- 8:37So depending on who you listen to in this camp, the cause might be soy, or it's seed oils, or plastics, or porn, or it's a culture that's gone soft on boys.
- 8:48And the f and the fix is usually.
- 8:50a supplement or a clinic or some kind of lifestyle change, sometimes all three of those things.
- 8:55And it always it almost always involves writing some kind of check or another.
- 9:01Now, this is the part in this camp's claims that I feel is particularly weak because the connection, I mean, even if the problem exists, and we're gonna assess that here in a
- 9:13minute, the connection to how to fix it or what the cause is is a totally different question.
- 9:20So, and by the way, let's give you a fair warning here.
- 9:23Some of what these guys are saying is gonna hold up.
- 9:27So stay tuned.
- 9:29The second camp is that this is moral panic.
- 9:32And they hear this, and all they do is roll their eyes, and they think it's not a problem.
- 9:37When Hegseth announced his policy, Slate ran a piece by Christina Kattarucci, arguing that this is just all part of a much bigger right-wing phenomenon.
- 9:48Her case is that testosterone has turned into kind of a magic potion for manhood.
- 9:54And low T is an insult.
- 9:56Doctors quoted in the in the coverage said that screening everyone is expensive and it's unnecessary for most people.
- 10:06And this camp has a fair point about the insult.
- 10:09Nobody's hormones should be political scorecard.
- 10:12They also told you that the teenager line is just false on its face.
- 10:19Testosterone peaks at age 19.
- 10:22And in a national sample of lean, healthy American men, the ones over 60 had about a third less than men's in their 20s and 30s.
- 10:32So typical older teenager has more testosterone than a typical 68-year-old.
- 10:39What RFK Jr.
- 10:41claimed on that TV show is just totally false compared to this camp according to this camp.
- 10:48And if he meant that teenagers today
- 10:51Have less than teenagers used to, that's a different claim, and it's a much smaller one.
- 10:58Now, the study behind that, they did a study behind that too, and it changed lab tests partly through, according to this camp.
- 11:06And so we're actually going to open up that study next week and look into it.
- 11:10Here's the rest of this camp's case, one argument at a time.
- 11:13Number one, it's overblown.
- 11:14A falling average isn't the same thing as men being sick.
- 11:17Diet doctors diagnose low testosterone from symptoms plus low results on
- 11:22Repeated tests, and experts don't even agree on a single number that counts as too low.
- 11:28Second is that it's a measurement problem.
- 11:30Different lab tests can give different numbers for the same blood.
- 11:33When researchers lined up four big studies of men, they found that a lot of the difference between them came from differences in the actual tests.
- 11:44The third claim is that it's mostly weight gain.
- 11:46Obesity is a condition.
- 11:48That is most strongly linked to lower testosterone in men.
- 11:52And the share of American adults with obesity went from about 30% to over 40% in less than 20 years.
- 11:59A heavier country will show lower numbers, even if nothing else changed.
- 12:04And so when and when men lose weight, their testosterone levels tend to go back up.
- 12:11The other thing is it's political.
- 12:12The whole subject has become a story that one political
- 12:16Team tells about itself and the other political team tells about the other guys.
- 12:20And so that is just absolutely a recipe for disinformation, for misinformation, and for people in bad faith all over the place.
- 12:30If you've ever felt talked down to about being a man, this camp might sound more of like more of the same.
- 12:39It tends to make light of something that might.
- 12:43that that that could be a very, very major important thing.
- 12:47And I understand that.
- 12:48So stay with me on this because next week we're gonna find out that some of what these people say holds true also.
- 12:56And then there's a third group and the third group doesn't care much who wins at all.
- 13:00They just want the controversy.
- 13:03Between 2001 and 2011, the share of American men over 40 using testosterone therapy more than tripled
- 13:12Now there are telehealth companies that will prescribe it to you from your couch.
- 13:17And there's a whole shelf of supplements promising to boost it.
- 13:21So here's the pattern that I want you to notice about this camp, or about all the camps.
- 13:26Every camp gets something if you believe them.
- 13:30The alarm camp gets your attention.
- 13:34And a story about who ruined things.
- 13:38The skeptical camp gets your attention too.
- 13:41And they get a story about how silly and unserious the other side is.
- 13:46And the sellers get your money.
- 13:48So I've said on this show a lot that outrage is a business model.
- 13:54And that rule doesn't care what side you're on.
- 13:57They make money as long as you're talking about it.
- 14:00None of that makes anybody wrong.
- 14:03A guy selling umbrellas, talking about how if you walk outside in the rain, you're gonna get wet.
- 14:09Is right.
- 14:11But it is a reason to bring healthy skepticism to the conversation.
- 14:14And if you're going to take that tidbit in as part of your corpus of knowledge, if you're going to repeat it to other people, you need to go and check.
- 14:25So that's the claim, and that's the fight.
- 14:28I haven't yet told you what we actually do know, and I did that on purpose.
- 14:32So before next week, pick one version that you've seen.
- 14:36Post, a clip, a headline, forget who said it for a minute, and then chase down where the number came from.
- 14:42Click the link and then click the link inside that one and see if you can make it the way to an actual study.
- 14:50Next week, I will walk you through one click at a time how we can actually look into these claims and how we can evaluate them, and I'll show you how you can find the real story.
- 15:00We'll open and read the actual studies together.
- 15:03So have a phone or a laptop handy because every link will be in the show notes.
- 15:09And I think you might be surprised, but what happens when you type that teenager claim into a search engine built for scientists?
- 15:19This
- 15:19is raising men and you are a great parent.