Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Cycles of Fortune: Lessons from 125 Years of Global Markets
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. You know, we often find
- 0:03ourselves just lost in the noise of daily market headlines.
- 0:06Oh absolutely. The Fed's next move?
- 0:08Some earnings miss geopolitical flare up.
- 0:11Right. But if you zoom out, I mean
- 0:13really zoom out, all that short term drama just kind of
- 0:16evaporates and you realize that equity markets, they move to the
- 0:18beat of a much, much slower drum.
- 0:21A more cyclical 1. Exactly O Today we are taking a
- 0:25deep dive into over a century of market data.
- 0:28We're tracking indices like the Dow all the way back to 1898.
- 0:32And our mission really is to filter out all that distraction.
- 0:35And find the true historical heartbeat of investing this
- 0:39punishing cycle of, well, flatness and euphoria that
- 0:42really determines your returns over the long haul.
- 0:44So let's unpack. That it's essential, I mean,
- 0:47understand this history is absolutely key to gauging what
- 0:50we call market temperature. Market temperature I.
- 0:52Like that, you're only looking at the last two quarters.
- 0:54You can easily mistake a cyclical high for some, you
- 0:57know, sustainable new normal. But when you look at the 50 or
- 0:59100 year charts, a pattern emerges.
- 1:02It's it's really critical. Long term sustained growth is
- 1:07always, and I mean always, punctuated by these surprisingly
- 1:10long agonizing periods where returns just disappear.
- 1:15And for those of you who want to track this market temperature
- 1:18day-to-day? Right, there are tools for that,
- 1:20analyzing things that compare total market cap against
- 1:23economic output. Sometimes it's called the
- 1:25Buffett indicator can give you really crucial contact about
- 1:28market risk. It helps you see beyond the
- 1:30daily stuff. Exactly.
- 1:31It helps you understand the structural over or
- 1:33undervaluation of the whole system.
- 1:35And that leads us right into the the, well, the stunning
- 1:37historical reality of the US market.
- 1:39When we look at the Dow Jones Industrial Average, these
- 1:42periods of stagnation, they're not just minor dips.
- 1:45No, not at all. They are multi decade flatlines
- 1:47that challenge the whole idea of continuous growth.
- 1:50Let's start with the big one. The famous 17 year wait.
- 1:53OK, so if you bought the Dow in 1965, the index was sitting
- 1:56around 870. You could have held that
- 1:58position until 1981 and guess what?
- 2:01The Dow was still at 870. 17 years, 0 nominal return at the
- 2:06endpoints. It's incredible.
- 2:08And that's just nominal, right? That's the key.
- 2:10If we factor in the high inflation that, you know,
- 2:13characterized the elite 60s and 70s, your real purchasing power
- 2:17actually went down substantially.
- 2:19So you were. Poorer.
- 2:20You're much poorer in real terms is profound lesson in
- 2:23psychology. You have to sit there for almost
- 2:252 decades watching the index gyrate wildly.
- 2:28It did just sit still. Oh, I'm sure.
- 2:30Big drops, big rallies. Huge drops and huge rallies
- 2:33inside that period only to end up exactly where you started.
- 2:36OK. Wait, so if the market was flat,
- 2:38was the US economy flat during that time too?
- 2:40Not at all. And that is the most critical
- 2:42point. the US economy actually grew significantly from 1965 to
- 2:451981. So there's a.
- 2:46Total disconnect. A fundamental disconnect.
- 2:48It shows that economic health and immediate stock returns are
- 2:51not always in lockstep. The market in that period was a
- 2:54actually just working off a massive overvaluation for the
- 2:56prior boom. So like a structural correction
- 2:58playing out over a generation? That's the perfect way to put
- 3:00it. It was a painful cleanup phase,
- 3:02but. The reward for holding through
- 3:04all that pain? It must have been immense.
- 3:07Absolutely. That correction, that cleanup,
- 3:09it cleared the way for the spectacular boom that followed.
- 3:12From 1982 to 1999, the Dow went from less than 900 to over
- 3:1612,000. That period delivered annualized
- 3:19returns of about 15% a year. It's a powerful validation of
- 3:22that long term upward bias, but you know it required enduring
- 3:26the stagnation first. And then, almost like clockwork,
- 3:29the pattern repeated itself after that spectacular 90s boom.
- 3:33Another flatline, The 12 year period from 1999.
- 3:36Right after that Millennium euphoria until around 2012 was
- 3:39again, basically. Flat and that second flatline is
- 3:42just as destructive, but for different reasons.
- 3:44It didn't have the inflation drag of the first one, but it
- 3:47included the twin shocksofthe.com bust and the
- 3:502000 and eight 2009 global financial crisis.
- 3:53Two huge events. Massive declines, peaks,
- 3:55troughs, followed by a huge comeback rally only to net out
- 3:58to 0 / 12 years. It just underscores how deeply
- 4:03cyclical these trends are. So the US shows us this brutal
- 4:07on again off again switch, but is this just an American thing
- 4:10or does this kind of cyclical pain play out everywhere?
- 4:14Oh, it's universal. The underlying structure of
- 4:16moving between periods of, let's call it extreme euphoria and
- 4:19extreme pessimism is global. Different markets hit these
- 4:23points at different times, but the pattern is there.
- 4:26So let's look at just how brutal that shift can be.
- 4:28A classic case study. The nasdaq.com bubble.
- 4:31A perfect example. The run up was, I mean it was
- 4:33incredible for two decades from 1980 to 2000, the NASDAQ, you
- 4:37returned something like 20% per year.
- 4:39Building a truly monumental level of euphoria.
- 4:41A lot of it was centered on companies with, well, no proven
- 4:43business model. And the correction was just
- 4:45immediate and destructive. Staggering a 75% decline, the
- 4:49index went from 5000 down to 12,250.
- 4:52And we have to emphasize, this wasn't just a few meme stocks.
- 4:55No, this was a major broad based index, the backbone of the tech
- 4:58world. Losing 3 orders of its value.
- 5:01And the most shopping statistic from that, the one that should
- 5:03really sink in for any long term investor is the recovery time.
- 5:07It's the killer detail. It took the NASDAQ you a
- 5:10devastating 16 years to get back to its previous 5000 peak.
- 5:15And that 16 year wait happened even while those foundational
- 5:18companies, the future Titans, you know, Amazon, Apple,
- 5:21Netflix, were growing revenues and profits exponentially.
- 5:26Wait, hold on. So if you have companies as
- 5:27transformative as Apple becoming the giant it is today, how on
- 5:31earth did the index still take 16 years to recover?
- 5:34It just speaks to the sheer irrationality of the initial
- 5:36euphoria. The valuations in 2000 were so
- 5:39divorced from reality that even 2 decades of world beating
- 5:42growth from the best innovators, it still had to work off the
- 5:45impossible expectations of that bubble.
- 5:47So the gains weren't creating new wealth for people who bought
- 5:49at the top. Not at all.
- 5:50Most of the game from 2000 to 2016 went purely toward
- 5:53neutralizing the original overvaluation.
- 5:55That's it. That is a very tough lesson in
- 5:57valuation. It tells us that if we see that
- 6:00kind of euphoric behavior now, we could be signing up for
- 6:02another decade plus of stagnation.
- 6:04Exactly. The growth happens, but the
- 6:07investor doesn't benefit until the prior SINS evaluation are,
- 6:11you know, absolved. OK, let's look at some other
- 6:13markets where economic growth was phenomenal, but the stock
- 6:15market just kind of shrugged. Right, Let's look at India and
- 6:18its Sensex index. India liberalized its economy
- 6:21around 1992 after a huge balance of payments crisis.
- 6:24And that spurred massive growth, right, and economic renaissance?
- 6:27World altering growth for the country, but the market
- 6:29reaction. Muted.
- 6:31Muted is an understatement. Despite that explosion in GDP,
- 6:35the market was flat for the next 12 years.
- 6:37Another huge disconnect. Exactly.
- 6:39The market needed time to mature, to build regulatory
- 6:42confidence and to shake out structural imbalances before it
- 6:45could truly reflect that economic reality.
- 6:48And we see this everywhere. The German DAX, a core European
- 6:50index, had a similar flat line recently.
- 6:53No net returns over an 11 year stretch.
- 6:55The pressure is universal. But maybe the most illustrative
- 6:58example of this stagnation happening alongside enormous
- 7:01progress is South Korea's Co SPI index.
- 7:04Oh, that's a great one. Look at the. 30 year span from
- 7:061989 to 2019. The Kospi went from 1000 to
- 7:112000. That's just a little over 2% per
- 7:14year for three decades. We call this the Samsung
- 7:16paradox. I mean, that 30 year window is
- 7:19the incredible world changing rise of South Korea.
- 7:22We're talking about the emergence of global giants like
- 7:24Samsung, Hyundai, LG. They fundamentally altered
- 7:27global tech and manufacturing. And yet the broad equity index
- 7:31delivered virtually 0 meaningful returns.
- 7:34It just shows you how sticky and painful these flatlines can be.
- 7:37So if Korea is a case study and a growth disconnect, then Japan.
- 7:40Japan is the worst case scenario.
- 7:41The ultimate hangover after the mother of all bubble.
- 7:44Mother of all bubbles for sure. The Nikki Index peaked at a
- 7:46staggering 40,000 back in 1990. The exuberance was unbound.
- 7:50As the sources say, the bigger the party, the greater the
- 7:53hangover. And man, that hangover has
- 7:54lasted a generation. It has.
- 7:56By 20/19/29 years later, the Nikki still hadn't returned to
- 8:00its peak. It was sitting at about 50% of
- 8:03the 1990 level. Just think about the
- 8:04psychological toll. 3 decades and you're still not back to
- 8:08par. And the size of the bubble that
- 8:10caused this is it's just hard to grasp today.
- 8:14It wasn't just stocks. Japan experienced the mother of
- 8:18all property bubbles. Oh, yeah.
- 8:19Here's the crucial detail. At the time, the Imperial Palace
- 8:23in Tokyo was valued at more than all the real estate in the
- 8:26entire state of California. The entire state.
- 8:28It's a truly stunning measure of unsustainable euphoria.
- 8:31And that destruction seeped into the corporate structure.
- 8:34It did. The recovery is Hanford not just
- 8:35by the asset destruction, but by a deep seated corporate culture.
- 8:39Japanese companies famously tend to prioritize their employees,
- 8:42their banks, their stakeholders. And shareholders are aware on
- 8:45that. List much, much lower on the
- 8:46priority. List and this structural issue.
- 8:48It leads to a fascinating valuation nuance.
- 8:50Right, it does. Because of this reluctance to
- 8:53cater to shareholders, you find many Japanese companies trading
- 8:56below cash. This is a genuine Ben Graham era
- 9:00valuation. Their net current assets minus
- 9:03liabilities exceed their entire market cap.
- 9:06They're fundamentally cheap. Precisely.
- 9:08You see these wonderful deep value numbers, but the problem
- 9:11is the corporate boards are often unwilling to release that
- 9:14cash, either through buybacks or dividends.
- 9:17So the cash is an illusion from a shareholder's perspective.
- 9:20It's an illusion. The value is real on the balance
- 9:22sheet, but you can't unlock it. It's cheap, but it's stuck.
- 9:25So this brings us back to synthesizing all of this.
- 9:27We see these cycles of painful flat lines and spectacular booms
- 9:31play out again and again across all these markets.
- 9:34And the essential synthesis is this.
- 9:35Equity markets usually only clearly signal their true
- 9:39position, whether they're extremely cheap or extremely
- 9:41expensive, when they reach one of these dramatic extremes.
- 9:44And that's a rare event. Very rare.
- 9:46It happens maybe once every 15 or 20 years.
- 9:48So if we apply this historical lens to the current landscape
- 9:52based on the metrics from the time of this analysis, what do
- 9:55the signals tell us about market temperature?
- 9:58Well, based on historical valuation extremes, you can
- 10:01clearly identify Japan and Korea as markets showing signs of
- 10:05being cheap Tria despite the impediments we talked about
- 10:09language culture, it's noted in the sources as a fertile hunting
- 10:13ground. What kind of valuations are we
- 10:15talking about? You can find quality stocks
- 10:17trading at valuations as low as 3 times earnings there.
- 10:20They're still working off those structural issues.
- 10:22And the US market? The US market, however, is not
- 10:24showing those extreme signals. It's certainly hard to find much
- 10:27that's outright cheap using these measures, but things
- 10:30aren't necessarily showing the mania level of 1999 either.
- 10:33So somewhere in the middle. They may be fully valued or only
- 10:37slightly above fully valued, which means they might need a
- 10:39long flat line period, but they could also grow into those
- 10:42valuations without needing a devastating crash.
- 10:45So what does this all mean for you, the listener?
- 10:48The volatility, the flat lines, the multi decade weights, it's
- 10:51all inherent to the market structure.
- 10:53It is. You have to accept it.
- 10:54You have to. Accept that the market moves in
- 10:56these long, painful cycles, not smooth, predictable upward
- 11:00lines. And that acceptance is the
- 11:02critical strategy. What truly matters is how you
- 11:04manage the psychological toll during the downside and how
- 11:07accurately you gauge the upside potential during the booms.
- 11:10The key is just surviving the long cyclical corrections.
- 11:13But there is a reassuring thought here, isn't there?
- 11:16There is, and it's drawn from this whole century of history.
- 11:18Despite the deep flat lines and the brutal hangovers, in the
- 11:21long run the market is fundamentally designed to move
- 11:24upward. Economic Rd. always seeks
- 11:26expansion, so focus on holding high quality stocks that can
- 11:29survive those long cycles. That is a phenomenal and
- 11:32necessary reminder. Now here's our provocative
- 11:34thought for you to chew on, based on the historical patterns
- 11:37of euphoria, stagnation, and pessimism we've discussed today
- 11:40across the US, Japan, Korea. Are the markets you follow most
- 11:43close currently closer to the agonizing flatline, the
- 11:46spectacular boom, or the brutal hangover phase?
- 11:49All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 11:52may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 11:55The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 11:58constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own due
- 12:01diligence before making investment decisions.
- 12:03And if you want to track total market temperature, we encourage
- 12:06you to search and download the iOS app Buffett Indicator from
- 12:09the Apple App Store today. If you want to listen to our
- 12:11full deep dive at this topic or access more advanced content,
- 12:14welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to us on
- 12:17Apple or Spotify Podcast Channel, Deep Value Investing
- 12:20and lulavc.com.