Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 4)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserved listeners. This is chapter four in our deep dive on the
- 0:04Duggers. Let's get into it. What do you say, Berto, Let's
- 0:07do it. This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast. I'm your host,
- 0:10doctor Kirkanda. I'm a therapist and I'm also a professor. My name is
- 0:15and I make Grass looked Green. So to start off where we left off
- 0:20last time, we are now at two thousand and four, so that's the
- 0:25point we are in the timeline. And just to catch up and the patron
- 0:29section. In chapter three, we went into the early reports that were being
- 0:36made from Josh and the family about Josh's sexual abusive behavior to five younger children,
- 0:44four of which were his younger sisters and another girl was one of the
- 0:49babysitters that were younger than him. And at this point, Josh's in his
- 0:54teen years and this is before they actually are are on television. So let's
- 1:00start off on two thousand and four. So the family knows about the sexual
- 1:04abuse. There's other people that know about it as well. The police quote
- 1:08unquote have been notified, although it was one police officer who has a very
- 1:14problem. He's now in prison, by the way, because of multiple accounts
- 1:19of child pornography, and the police officer might have also been friends of Jim
- 1:26Bob, right, so maybe went easy on Josh. There's no indication that
- 1:32this was on purpose, Like, Oh, this guy's into this stuff anyway,
- 1:34so let's go to him. However, what a freaking horrible coincidence.
- 1:38And I hypothesized that for all we know, since it was a family friend,
- 1:44like, it's possible he had something to do with Josh when Josh was
- 1:47younger, maybe introduced him to this stuff, who knows. But in either
- 1:49case, yeah, really bizarre that he goes to this dude to maybe scare
- 1:53Josh out of it, right, like put you know, some cop fear
- 1:57into him. It doesn't work, obviously, and to make matters where the
- 2:00guy himself is like either already or going to be involved in the same problem.
- 2:05Yeah. So now two thousand and four, TLC, the television channel,
- 2:10approach the family to have a special, just a one off special,
- 2:17one episode special that they would film and publish on their on their channel.
- 2:24So Berto, why do you think the family would accept this offer? So
- 2:30a couple of things. The father was already interested in politics and was already
- 2:35trying to you know get I think their community they were a part of.
- 2:38I think they wanted more, more prominence. More specifically, I think they
- 2:42wanted to send a message about their religion and a way to live. As
- 2:46to why the family as a whole, well, I don't know. It
- 2:50doesn't sound like most of the family had too much of a say in most
- 2:53of the dealings. Like certainly when when some of the daughters were interviewed in
- 2:57that documentary they were like, yeah, we had no my dad did all
- 3:00the negotiating and stuff like that. So but as far as I can tell
- 3:02and imagine, I think that it was a case of like, hey,
- 3:06this will really help us bring prominence to our movement, to our way of
- 3:09life, our way of thinking right exactly Well on their blog along those lines
- 3:15from their words, I think from the parents' words, they said, our
- 3:20desire in opening our home to the world has been to make Christ known and
- 3:25to share Bible principles that are the answers to life's problems. Exclamation point.
- 3:32We pray that everyone will find true hope in trusting Jesus Christ. Exclamation point.
- 3:38So that was their stated reason, which I think is probably their real
- 3:43reasons. So the first Dugger Family TV special titled Fourteen Children and Pregnant Again,
- 3:51and it airs on TLC back when TLC was shifting away from learning and
- 3:57more towards eventually what they are now, which is wall to wall new programming
- 4:02in reality television of various different types. And the special was about how such
- 4:10a large family handled chores and parenting. I don't think it went that much
- 4:14into their religion. I think it was more just the spectacle of like,
- 4:18how is it possible that you manage with fourteen children and you're having another child?
- 4:24How does that exactly work? Yeah, in the sense that they indicated
- 4:29why TLC was initially interested was from that angle of like it was. It
- 4:32was definitely not like, oh, and there's this religion. No, it
- 4:35was how can you how can it physically work? First of all, and
- 4:38then how can you make it work? Yeah? Yeah, And we were
- 4:40talking earlier about it was kind of like a freak show for many people,
- 4:46but also highly appealing to not only fundamentalist Christians but also just people looking for
- 4:54more wholesome programming, of which there isn't much of that even in and especially
- 5:00in reality TV. Right. So in the show they come across like the
- 5:05happiest family in the world. And of course classic white family, blonde kids,
- 5:13this kind of thing. They come across as very wholesome, very close
- 5:16knit, obedient, but happy about it apparently, and none of the problems
- 5:23that are often present in families, like addiction or anger, or rebellion or
- 5:27sex. Apparently, no problems. There were problems, but by the way,
- 5:32we shouldn't like, you know, we grew up in the eighties,
- 5:35and essentially we were shown we were showing families that seemed perfect as well,
- 5:40right where the big problem was like you looked over your shoulder during that test,
- 5:44oh you know, or you you hid the sugar from your sister.
- 5:49You know. It was like these kinds of things, and and that's you
- 5:53know, we saw these families on TV. They weren't reality shows, but
- 5:56it was presented as like, hey, these are these perfect little families.
- 5:58Yeah, I think it's I think it's to both And because of course there
- 6:01was a lot of that your family ties, your different strokes, that kind
- 6:06of thing. Not the Duggers, but the Huxtables. Well, and yeah,
- 6:12think of how in that case, not only was like it may be
- 6:15unfair to present like these beautiful, perfect little families. But behind the scenes,
- 6:19you know, the head of this family was a monster. Yeah,
- 6:23Bill Cosby was raping people who would want to be on the show and were
- 6:28on the show. There are allegations, pretty credible allegations from actresses who were
- 6:33on the show and would appeal to Bill Cosby to be on the show and
- 6:39also be propelled in their career, and he would take them upstairs. And
- 6:44it was a well understood thing, not necessarily the raping, but that Bill
- 6:48Cosby was getting together with young women on the casting couch. But on the
- 6:55surface you had very wholesome storylines. However, it's hard to remember these sorts
- 7:00of things because we haven't watched these shows. But there are famous episodes of
- 7:04Different Strokes and Family Ties where they do go into some pretty hairy areas,
- 7:10some risky areas, Like there was an episode of Different Strokes where the kids
- 7:15are being groomed for child pornography and being abused, and that was family Television
- 7:21after Dinner at seven o'clock on NBC or whatever, and they were really going
- 7:27into that and I remember watching that episode when I was a kid in and
- 7:30just being like, what is happening. So they did take risks, you
- 7:34know. I think at the same time, these shows like The Duggers on
- 7:40reality TV, I think it appeals to people because it doesn't have any of
- 7:45those things. You know, people just want to relax. They don't want
- 7:47to necessarily be challenged, which you know, I can respect. Yeah,
- 7:51I was going to say that it is a progression, of course, because
- 7:54you know, back when I was young and I watched The Brady Bunch or
- 7:58the Partridge Family, there were even simpler So you're right that by the eighties
- 8:03now they're starting to sprinkle in a few more difficult topics. And it's true,
- 8:07It's my analogy was really more that like, and I'm not saying it's
- 8:11even wrong, Like, obviously you want to be shown a good like,
- 8:13hey, aspire to this, right, You don't want to always be shown
- 8:16here's how horrible and crappy life can be. That's not that inspirational as a
- 8:20kid. So it's nice to say, hey, look look at this,
- 8:24your life could be like this if you follow certain things. That's true.
- 8:26At the same time, there is an unrealistic expectation being set that if you
- 8:31don't balance it, then yeah, you're like, oh, everyone's perfect except
- 8:35me. For some reason, and that can be really heartbreaking for one's own
- 8:39self esteem. Right, no family is perfect. All families have problems,
- 8:45and these shows absolutely give the impression. You hear from lots of people that
- 8:50they would watch these shows and think, Wow, my family is broken compared
- 8:56to these television families. And I would say ninety five percent of people think
- 9:03that because no families are very few families share their problems that are having.
- 9:09So everyone is in the norm and that their family is going through difficulties,
- 9:13but they think they're in the minority and there's something deeply shameful about what they're
- 9:18going through. So now it's not NBC's responsibility to somehow correct for that.
- 9:24It's it's other people's responsibility. But anyway, so they get their first special
- 9:31so I think it'd be worthy to So I think it'd be worth actually going
- 9:35a little bit into how the family is structured because prentification is a thing.
- 9:41So oh, because what parentification. Parentification? Oh, the thing where kids
- 9:48start having to act as parents, right, or they're just elevated, they're
- 9:50elevated too high and the hierarchy given their age. But and we'll get in
- 9:56more this later when we get into the religious section, which might be a
- 10:01number of chapters from now given my notes, but just briefly which is depicted
- 10:09in the special here and throughout the series that they eventually get the father is
- 10:15in absolute authority, and then it's the mother and the mother. Michelle is
- 10:20completely happy, apparently with being subservient to her husband. She's doating. Whenever
- 10:31Jim Bob is talking, Michelle is just like staring at him. That can't
- 10:35be real. You know, she sees him behind closed doors. You know,
- 10:43when you first start dating someone, maybe there's that glowing look that you
- 10:48have towards your partner, but especially after fourteen children, you just got a
- 10:52figure that it's not all glowing. So she had a pretty good face that
- 10:58she would put on. I think you were saying that it would creep you
- 11:01out when you would watch it, and look, you're probably right. I'm
- 11:05unsure how much she really like believed and ingested all of it. But in
- 11:11either case I did get an uneasy feeling because of what you're saying was he
- 11:15would talk, and yeah, there's so many times where they would show and
- 11:18she's just looking up as if he's holy, And I was like, that
- 11:22creeped me out for a couple of reasons. One, the hierarchy they established
- 11:26that was no accident, that was on purpose, right is, and it's
- 11:31all hierarchy based on men first. Two, it did mean in the context
- 11:35of what I'm watching that she's probably not there to protect that much because she's
- 11:39there to like listen and be quiet and be subservient. So I don't know,
- 11:43like that that whole aspect gives me the hebe gebis she's not there to
- 11:48protect the children. Yeah, in the sense that like when your main concern
- 11:54is following the law that I've been given and I have to look up never
- 11:58like never will I look like peers. I will always look up here.
- 12:03I feel like in the process, plus, you have like so many kids,
- 12:07you're probably not going to be paying as much attention to the needs of
- 12:11the kids. Maybe I'm exaggerating that point, but it just seems like the
- 12:15biggest, the biggest important part of that situation wasn't so much like what little
- 12:22one of the little kids might need, but it's really like, are we
- 12:24following the laws here? And am I listening to the one above me?
- 12:26And the one above me right now is my husband? Yeah, I hadn't
- 12:30thought of that. I think another angle to that is that you'res trained from
- 12:35you know, and she wasn't raised in this model, but by the time
- 12:39you have fourteen kids, yeah, I think it had been twenty years at
- 12:41this point. She has this very deeply ingrained paradigm of I don't think for
- 12:50myself, right, so I don't necessarily think of myself as someone that is
- 12:56responsible for monitoring the kids safety or thinking about the child welfare because I have
- 13:03been trained, and I've been training myself to constantly defer to my husband.
- 13:09So until he tells me to do something about it, then maybe I don't.
- 13:15I don't know. I mean, maybe Michelle had a lot of self
- 13:18directed behavior behind the scenes, but it certainly doesn't look that way when she's
- 13:22in his presence, you know. And it seems to me like the hierarchy
- 13:26goes beyond just the dad, in that males in the family also get preference
- 13:31I don't know if to the mom, but certainly within their siblings. Yeah.
- 13:35Well, the explicit hierarchy is that the kids, regardless of gender,
- 13:41are under the parents, So there's not the explicit that it's not explicit that
- 13:48the mother is below Josh, that sort of thing. But anyway, so
- 13:50you have the father absolute authority, then you have the mother, and then
- 13:54you have the children that are underneath that by age. And another structure that
- 14:01we should mention is that they have the buddy system. And I don't know
- 14:05if this is inherently to their cult religion, but it was a big part
- 14:11and a focus of the various different TV episodes that they made and the way
- 14:16that the did you see the buddy system? Did you see how they did?
- 14:20You run into this? I heard it, I heard about it.
- 14:22I guess I didn't catch enough about how it worked. So wait till you
- 14:26hear this. As soon as the baby is weaned, often with another baby
- 14:31being born right then that weened baby, a very very small child, it
- 14:39is given to an older sibling. So that's the that's the buddy You know,
- 14:43when you hear buddy system, you think you think more close age or
- 14:46something. Yeah, you think like a ten year old who looks after a
- 14:50seven year old? No, no, no, this is and it's always
- 14:54the girls. It's always the sisters, the daughters that are literally just hand
- 15:00the next child in line. And sometimes the older sister would be pretty young
- 15:07I'm guessing I don't know the exact configuration, but I'm guessing that some of
- 15:11the big sisters, basically the moms that are taking care are like seven years
- 15:16old, maybe ten, I don't know, but but really young. And
- 15:18then the boys were supposed to do outdoor, outdoor work, and did a
- 15:24lot of outdoor work because the cult actually has a lot of child labor,
- 15:28child labor that we would not only in the home, but also they built
- 15:33a lot of stuff. Yeah, not only for the cult religion, but
- 15:37also other parishioners in the church. A guy would have a business that would
- 15:41say like, well, you know, I have a construction business just completely
- 15:46separate from the cult, and he would recruit children from the congregation because it
- 15:52was a mandate that children learn how to do hard work, you know,
- 15:58and it benefits this business owner because you literally have free labor. I mean,
- 16:03it's it's one thing if it's like there's a rotation, and it helps
- 16:07the kids because they learn some stuff. But it does feel like, I
- 16:10don't know if they presented it this way incorrectly, but it does feel like
- 16:11it was an abused part of the religion, like they overused it. Well,
- 16:17when you have no checks and balances, then at the very least you're
- 16:21going to have bad actors who are going to take it too far, you
- 16:25know. And there were many accounts of not only these you know, non
- 16:32sanctioned parishioners in employing children, but also the cult organization themselves taking children and
- 16:40say, you know, you've been tapped to come to headquarters, and the
- 16:42kids would be like, oh my god. And then they'd go to headquarters
- 16:45and they'd spend twelve hours a day hauling bricks to build a new facility.
- 16:52And yeah, if it was half an hour here and there to build character,
- 16:57so to speak, maybe weed the bushes or something as a team.
- 17:03And then yet have you know, this learned lesson after no From the accounts
- 17:08and from the videos that we saw in the documentary the kids, it's looks
- 17:14like we're looking at another country in which there are no child labor laws.
- 17:17The kids are the kids have like work gloves and they have wheelbarrows. You
- 17:22know, we're talking like seven year old ten year old kids who aren't hammering
- 17:26nails into stuff. You know it. You know, they probably have like
- 17:30a really deep voice. By now, it's just like it's Miller time.
- 17:33Or whatever. Anyway, so the buddy system is as soon you know,
- 17:38maybe the kid is eighteen months, twenty four, twenty four months, right,
- 17:45boom, They're just given to one of the older siblings and the older
- 17:49sibling is now completely in charge. And there is a really horrific scene on
- 17:57the show years later where one of the infants has a seizure disorder of some
- 18:03sort and a lot of other health problems. And while the cameras are shooting,
- 18:07did you see this? Yeah? Yeah, While while the cameras are
- 18:11shooting, one of this younger girl, I think she's five years old or
- 18:15something, has a pretty significant seizure that lasts for a while, and the
- 18:22buddy, the surrogate mother, which is this I think fifteen year old sisters,
- 18:29is suddenly just like, oh my god, what do I do?
- 18:32And well and at the very least like maybe leave some instructions for that child.
- 18:37I don't know, and who knows if that was provided, but it
- 18:41just it was a stark example of how these children were left alone to parent
- 18:48these these younger children. And then you just think about all of you,
- 18:51know, you have, you have daughters, Just imagine if your daughters were
- 18:56kind of free range the way that the duggers were, and then imagine all
- 19:00the situations that arise throughout the day. And these kids are homeschooled as well,
- 19:06So it's twenty four to seven that you would have like a ten year
- 19:10old sister that's responsible for a young child that wants to run around or wants
- 19:15to get into things, or fights with their next inline sibling, or won't
- 19:22do their homework or you know, just think about all the annoyances and it's
- 19:27hard enough for adults to do. I'd imagine a child doing this. Dude,
- 19:32I was gonna say that, Like, first of all, so I
- 19:33have twelve and seven right that there's their ages. It's almost every weekend,
- 19:37let alone during the summer. Well, I'll find normally it's like the seven
- 19:41year old doing something either dangerous or destructive or then she doesn't mean to be
- 19:47and I'll be like, what are you doing? And then I'll call on
- 19:49the twelve year old like why didn't you It's like either I told her or
- 19:53not to or I don't know or I was. It's always like that.
- 19:57And the other thing. Twelve ye went for the first time this summer,
- 20:00went to a camp. It was a one week a week long camp,
- 20:04and I was terrified to send her because you know, I just the idea,
- 20:08like my little baby is not here, but I thought, you know,
- 20:11I'll be fine. Stuff. Well, it was fun and all this,
- 20:14but there was a cabin bully that they had to kick out of the
- 20:17camp was affecting her directly, and it's like that's her first outing. So
- 20:22like, this is what happens when you have unsuper well and this kids they
- 20:26were supervised, but you know at a camp there's less supervision. There's strangers
- 20:29and stuff, and there's lots of kids together. And there's a reason why
- 20:32Lord of the Flies was Lord of the Flies, like things. Kids are
- 20:34not structured, well thought out, you know, functioning adult humans. They
- 20:41are not, and so you put kids in charge of kids, yeah,
- 20:42of course chaos and bad things might happen. Right, So let's talk about
- 20:47pronification. This is a concept and family therapy that we have been talking about
- 20:53for decades and it's a pretty complicated concept, but generally speaking, it is
- 21:00the parentifying of a child. Now, the child might be appear to the
- 21:07parents, or might even be parent to the parents, or they're just elevated
- 21:12way too high. They might not be parent level like the Dugger kids,
- 21:17but they have parent like responsibilities. So the problem is when you socialize or
- 21:22force or continually reward a child for taking care of their younger siblings, the
- 21:30child, the older child, ends up running into a dilemma where they want
- 21:36love. They also don't want to be punished. They want attention, They
- 21:41want to feel competent, right, they want it's like, oh, you
- 21:45know, I'm I'm giving a big a big girl responsibility. So they are
- 21:51at a dilemma and they have to give up childhood. They have to give
- 21:56up their needs as well, because when you're ten twelve years old, you
- 22:00have a lot of childish, selfish needs, and when those emerge for the
- 22:07child, they run into that dilemma of well, if I express this,
- 22:11I might get punished or abused, but at the very least I might lose
- 22:15the love and attention that I very much get. When I actually suppress my
- 22:21feelings and my needs and I rise to the occasion to take care of my
- 22:25younger sibling or whatever, the printification you know process is happening. And so
- 22:30the problem is is that from the outside and maybe even from the inside of
- 22:34the parents, it'll look like the parentified child is capable and is enjoying it.
- 22:41In fact, by after a while, if you try to take away
- 22:45the the prentification role from the child, even if it's a little bit,
- 22:51and I would say almost every family goes through this with multiple children. You
- 22:55know, the older siblings will feel somewhat responsible for their younger siblings and that
- 23:02has to be navigated very carefully. And even if you do that pretty well
- 23:07the older sibling, sometimes you need to have a conversation with that older child,
- 23:11say like, it's great that you care about your younger sibling and keeping
- 23:15her on track, but understand, you're not her mom. You know,
- 23:18I'm her parent, and you do not have that much authority. One,
- 23:25don't worry about it. But two, you're really coming down hard on your
- 23:29younger sibling and that's just not okay, So knock it off kind of a
- 23:33thing. But also for your sake, you should be allowed to just be
- 23:37a kid, so you know, don't worry about that. But you know,
- 23:41when it's more pathological than that, then you have children that look like
- 23:48they love it and like they're very mature. Like one of the big red
- 23:53flags for prantification is when I meet a child and think that they're three,
- 24:00four or five six years older than they actually are. They talk in a
- 24:04very mature way. It's not a slam dunk indication, but it is a
- 24:11red flag for that, particularly if they seem to have an understanding of responsibility
- 24:17and even when they have a really in depth understanding of adult feelings. Like
- 24:23as a therapist, when I would have, say a ten year old that
- 24:26seemed to empathize with me a lot, I would find later that they learned
- 24:30that because they had to be that way, because the parents were socializing them
- 24:34to be that way. And empathy is good, but you know, the
- 24:37normal course of development, maturity and empathy is a ten year old shouldn't need
- 24:45that much awareness of adult feelings or really anyone else's feelings because they're very selfish,
- 24:51and which is good. You know, it's a good thing that they're
- 24:55selfish and self centered and they should be allowed to really stew in their own
- 25:00development and focus on that. So it's another major red flag. So it's
- 25:04hard to detect this because the truly prentified children will seem like the most perfect
- 25:11children. They'll they'll be very good in class because you know they're terrified all
- 25:17the time of disappointing the teacher. They will be helpful to the other kids,
- 25:22They'll seem very mature, they'll have a lot of empathy for adults.
- 25:26And it's this, you know, hidden massive amounts of abuse that's happening to
- 25:32the child. So what happens for these individuals is they suppress their hurt feelings.
- 25:37They suppress their childhood, they suppress their anger. They don't have a
- 25:41connection with the self, potentially because they were never allowed that even when they
- 25:45were younger. They have a very conflicted feeling between selfishness and self selflessness.
- 25:53You know, one of the major things in therapy with folks like this is
- 25:57really wrestling with their schemas and distortions around is it okay for me to focus
- 26:03on myself? Is it okay for me to get what I want? I
- 26:07mean, these kinds of questions for people like you and me Berto, who
- 26:11didn't weren't raised in a prentified manner, it's obvious. It's like, yeah,
- 26:15of course, you know, within reason, But yeah, of course,
- 26:18you know, if I want something, I deserve to at least entertain
- 26:22the idea of getting it, do you know what I mean? But these
- 26:25people, it's just completely off the table. And and you can imagine that
- 26:29these people are thus very angry about that. Not only was that imposed on
- 26:33them, but they actually are doing it to themselves. So they're they're continually
- 26:38just massively angry and just building up this anger, and a big part of
- 26:42the therapy is actually getting them to express it. These individuals are very prone
- 26:48to becoming codependent or overfunctioning for an underfunctioner because of obvious reasons, they need
- 26:55to take care of an underfunctioner in order to feel like they're worthy or even
- 26:59just safe that you know, they could literally, given the context of the
- 27:03socialization to be prentified, they might literally have tremendous anxiety if they're not taking
- 27:10care of somebody, if they're not in that role of overfunctioning. Also,
- 27:15there's a massive conflict internally between freedom and responsibility, right, because they've been
- 27:19over responsible and they haven't been able to exert their freedom at all, and
- 27:26so they might not only internally, but they might externally. So printified parents
- 27:32overfunctioning parents can continue the problem. Right. You would think they wouldn't because
- 27:37they went through it, but sometimes when they have a ten year old,
- 27:40you know, say you're a printified parent. You have a ten year old
- 27:42daughter, and the ten year old daughter is starting to express selfish, normal
- 27:48selfishness and normal freedom, desire for freedom, and for you given all the
- 27:53internalized voices and the conflict you have inside of yourself about these because by the
- 28:00time you're an adult, people on the outside aren't necessarily the ones telling you
- 28:03have to be this way. It's all internalized. So you're you're the one
- 28:06breeding yourself. And so the ten year old is starting to act normal,
- 28:10and you start to come down in the ten year old because in your heart
- 28:15you think that that is too selfish and too free, too too chaotic,
- 28:21too risky. And you know, also there's a bit of well, when
- 28:26I was ten, I was taking care of three of my younger siblings and
- 28:29you're only taking care of one, So suck it up, kid. You
- 28:30know, there's a the normal range of what a child should be going through
- 28:36has been a skew, and so the so it's like, well, I
- 28:38know things weren't great for me as a child, and for my daughter things
- 28:42are better, but they don't realize they're they're they're still kind of in that
- 28:48zone of prentifying their children. So these these individuals go through a lot of
- 28:52troubles in life. They have to find themselves. They have to express their
- 28:56anger. They have to extract themselves from over functioning under functioning relationships. They
- 29:02have to learn how to not be attracted to under functioners as partners. They
- 29:07have to learn how to be selfish. They have to learn how to be
- 29:11assertive, how to One of the phrases I often hear from these folks is
- 29:15they will assert themselves. You know, after years of therapy, they'll finally
- 29:19start to assert themselves and then they'll report to me and they'll be like,
- 29:22I really feel like I'm being mean that that phrase, you know, I
- 29:26really feel like I'm being really mean to people. And when I hear them
- 29:30tell the story of it, I'm like, that's not mean. You're,
- 29:34if anything, you have a long way to go to be fair to yourself,
- 29:38but at least you're kind of asserting yourself and your needs and your worth.
- 29:45And so there's you know, it's an internal voice of like there is
- 29:48something deeply wrong with you if you assert yourself. So the kids in this
- 29:52in this family, of the Dugger family, it's a breeding ground for that
- 29:57kind of psychology and personality. Usually in families you have you know, three
- 30:03four kids, so you know the amount of kids who can be parentified or
- 30:07you know, maybe two or something. In this family, you could literally
- 30:11have all the girls and the boys too, maybe because they're put to work
- 30:15early being parentified in this way. And so by the time all of these
- 30:18allegations start to come out and they start getting interviewed on Megan Kelly, which
- 30:22will get to in a second, there's no ability for the children to check
- 30:26in with themselves and say, how do I feel about this? And because
- 30:32they've they've never been allowed to ask that question to begin with, because right
- 30:36from the get go they're responsible that the love and attention that they get is
- 30:41completely dependent on how good of a parent they are at the age of seven
- 30:45years old. It's just it's it's really awful. It's really awful. But
- 30:49first Berto, actually let's take a little break. What do you say,
- 30:52Let's do it. You know, as you were describing all this, I
- 31:00was obviously not prentified in these ways because I didn't live with siblings. My
- 31:06brother lived in the States, and so I didn't live with him until I
- 31:10was older, and once I did, I was certainly not parentified with him
- 31:12and stuff like that. However, a couple of interesting things came to mind,
- 31:15because when I was living in New York I was five, there were
- 31:18some things, you know, you were describing how sometimes you'll meet with kids
- 31:22and they seem like they're a couple of years older or something. I have
- 31:25these stories that my aunt tells me about me at five in New York and
- 31:29where I would take her, and I would like be like, I know
- 31:33the shortcuts, I know how to get like I seemed very like independent,
- 31:36like I know how to get around. And there were these times where,
- 31:40for example, I've told this one before where my dad left me, dropped
- 31:44me off where I was supposed to be being watched until his school time,
- 31:47but he was late to a big meeting or something, so he couldn't they
- 31:51weren't answering the door, but he just left me there and then they weren't
- 31:55there, and I had to walk myself to school at five, you know,
- 31:57like in New York City. And so when I think of that,
- 32:00I'm like, I think my dad was, you know, single parent,
- 32:04doing med post graduate stuff, so really really busy trying to raise me.
- 32:08I think there were some aspects where I had to self parentify or something.
- 32:15And then later when I was in Columbia, the other thing that came to
- 32:16mind was since since my dad unfortunately started, you know, not not working
- 32:22when I was I guess eleven and having problems and really struggling in life,
- 32:28I feel like there were some aspects where I had to try to parent him
- 32:31a little bit. I was unsuccessful entirely, but so yeah, And because
- 32:36then when you were talking about some of the struggles, I've certainly had some
- 32:38of those struggles where I haven't been able to draw boundaries for myself that easily
- 32:44sometimes or you know not I'd like bend over backwards sometimes when I shouldn't,
- 32:49or not be able to say no when I And I wonder if some of
- 32:52the stems from that, Like you, I can't deal with my feelings right
- 32:54now, because you know, someone's got to be responsible here. You absolutely
- 32:59were defied, and I'm glad you're bring this up because many of the listeners
- 33:02might relate to what I was saying, but they weren't in a cult family
- 33:07like this, where they were made to take care of the younger children.
- 33:10Your prentification didn't come from taking care of a younger sibling. Your prentification came
- 33:15from the fact that your dad he treated you like you were an adult a
- 33:22lot, which can be a good thing, right to try to help a
- 33:27child to mature in terms of intelligence or rhetoric in this kind of thing.
- 33:31But I'm guessing from an early age emotionally, your dad wasn't the most protective
- 33:37of your childhood and your fragility as a young person, you know. But
- 33:43at the very least, at some point, when you're eleven and his life
- 33:47started to take a downturn, you were in some emotional instances his father.
- 33:53You could see his problems and you had to manage him in ways that you
- 34:00shouldn't have had to as a as a child of his, you know.
- 34:04So at the very least you were prentified during then, But I'm guessing that
- 34:07prentification began earlier. And yeah, you're major. The crux of your therapy
- 34:15throughout your adult life has been focusing on you and focusing on your body and
- 34:21your emotions in this kind and for you, the dilemma between freedom and responsibility,
- 34:27you could argue, has been a major conflict in your psyche and in
- 34:32your behavior throughout your adult life, not so much more recently, but in
- 34:37the past, you know, with the spending or with your marital issues where
- 34:43you're you know, you have all these urges to maybe you could argue,
- 34:46want to be a kid. You know, it's like, I don't want
- 34:50to have the kinds of responsibilities that I have as a as a as a
- 34:54as an adult, and I was never given a chance to just be a
- 35:00kid. And that's the theme that you'll hear from prentified people is they really
- 35:06were just never allowed to just so a big part of my therapy with them
- 35:10is to frame it this way because it can be kind of alarming. Some
- 35:15people will feel like I feel like I'm having urges and thoughts like a thirteen
- 35:20year old would and I'm forty five. What's wrong with me? And it's
- 35:23like it's totally normal. Of course, you know, let's monitor it,
- 35:27but let's go with it in a way that is controlled and healthy for you
- 35:31to actually get those needs met where because you know, there's a reason why
- 35:36thirteen year olds are the way that they often are. There's a developmental reason
- 35:39for it. They need to go through those steps of I am who I
- 35:45am, and I'm very insecure about who I am, but I don't want
- 35:50to admit that, and so I'm just gonna assume that I'm awesome and my
- 35:53parents are idiots because that feels good to me. And I can't really handle
- 35:59me at this point, and so I am going to find myself and maybe
- 36:05even find things that I know are going to piss off my parents, because
- 36:08at least that's a stark way of identifying that this is me and not my
- 36:15parents. You know, doesn't always necessarily go down that way, but there's
- 36:17a reason why kids go through you know, the Terrible two is a terrible
- 36:21force. There's reasons why kids go through those and different versions of it.
- 36:24It's because these are tests. These are a playground for the child to play
- 36:30around with who I am and is it okay for me to not be my
- 36:34parents? And through that process, and you have parents that are there,
- 36:38caring and holding it. The parents don't necessarily say yes to everything, right,
- 36:45but but they don't punish it out of a child. They don't eliminate
- 36:49the opportunity for the child to play on in that playground. And then with
- 36:53enough time, then the child graduates to a more nuanced point of view of
- 36:59yes I do matter, and yes my feelings are important, and there are
- 37:02other people in the world besides me that I have to think about. Without
- 37:07going through that phase, you never graduate. You only do things for other
- 37:12people's benefit because you feel like you have to. You you're rarely doing it
- 37:16because you just want to. From inside of your heart, you're terrified if
- 37:21you don't do it. That's and from the outside, it'll look like this
- 37:24person is very selfless and very caring, but there's a chance that they're only
- 37:30that way because of fear. It's a fear based altruism. It's a fear
- 37:34based giving, which is a recipe for disaster, you know what I mean.
- 37:39So, yeah, I would say you absolutely were prentified. Yeah,
- 37:44just to some extent. And you know the thing with you were mentioning of
- 37:47being a kid and not knowing how much to be selfish, how much to
- 37:52be selfless. Yeah, that's definitely been a theme. And so I think
- 37:55a lot of times I have treated myself two things because gosh darn it,
- 38:00I deserve it, but sometimes overcompensating being like, gosh darn it, I
- 38:05deserve everything because I didn't get a lot, and so right, and you
- 38:09recently bought a Porsche, and you could argue, you could argue that that
- 38:15was part of it. You know, your conflict between freedom and responsibility throughout
- 38:19your life has created a lot of strife, sometimes compulsive spending or hurtful behavior
- 38:25to others in your life. And you've been really working on in therapy and
- 38:31with your relationships, and you've reached a point at in your late forties where
- 38:38you have an impulse say, you know, I don't know what age we
- 38:42want to put to it, but it's certainly reminiscent of your teenage life.
- 38:45And you even said that the contact you had with your childhood friend that from
- 38:52Columbia that you would often talk about cars, you know, reconnected you with
- 38:57those feelings, and then you re at them now and you're thinking, well,
- 39:01ten years ago, I would have either acted on it in this really
- 39:06horrible way, like I would have bought the expensive portion when into debt tremendously,
- 39:10or I would have shut the whole thing down because I would have identified
- 39:15as this too much responsibility. But now I'm at a point, you know,
- 39:20if I might talk from your mind that I actually feel like I can
- 39:25navigate these things better and can evaluate these things, you know, the freedom
- 39:30to buy this pointless object, this this portion has always been a dream of
- 39:37mine, and it would be this gift for myself, you know, this
- 39:43selfish gift that that I want, that would satisfy the teenage version of me
- 39:49that I was never really able to satisfy because of all the ups and downs
- 39:53of this whole story, you know what I mean totally. Yeah, I
- 39:55mean I think what it was is a matter of extremes in either direct.
- 40:00Like with some things, I overcompensated, and with some things I completely shut
- 40:05down, or at least I like, for example, I really never felt
- 40:07like I deserved or should be allowed to buy a special car, like something
- 40:13that I really loved, Like, well, that's wrong. Like whereas with
- 40:16clothes, I'm like, yeah, I need to go and prove to the
- 40:19world that I need to own the most expensive clothing in the world. Uh.
- 40:22And so yeah, it's like extremes in either direction. And with this
- 40:24is more like all right, well, okay, I'm gonna I'm gonna buy
- 40:28a car toy, but but in my terms, like something I that I
- 40:32can feel good about and blah blah blah. And so it's it's a more
- 40:36yeah, it's a more balanced approach, I guess. I mean it still
- 40:38wasn't entirely balanced, because if you had been entirely balanced, you would have
- 40:45given us a little bit more time, I think, and also informed your
- 40:49wife about your thinking process. True. The weird thing is like, I
- 40:52think, if something hadn't awakened this, which was definitely this, this experience
- 41:00with having my friend here and stuff, I just don't think and you know,
- 41:02on the one hand, I would have saved some money. On the
- 41:04other hand, I've been really happy with my car. So it's like,
- 41:07I don't know. It's one of these weird things where I don't know if
- 41:12this hadn't happened and triggered it, if I would have even because obviously the
- 41:15best way to do it. It's like, there's this thing I really want.
- 41:19Okay, I'm gonna plan for it. I'm gonna set a plan.
- 41:21I'm gonna say no, no, it could have literally been the same day.
- 41:23But you, in your heart, I think, because it's logical that
- 41:29you would have at the very least revealed to your wife that, by the
- 41:34way, today I'm buying a Porsche. Oh she knew, I mean,
- 41:37she knew we were going to go look at it. She wasn't. She
- 41:39just wasn't thinking I was actually gonna buy it and be since she has no
- 41:44concept of prices and things, she thought that thing was like almost three times
- 41:47as much as what it was. Well, that's my point, is the
- 41:50fact that she was not told so you could have the timeline could have been
- 41:53exactly the same. But because of your inner shame of I don't deserve things.
- 42:00Sure, then you don't say, in fact, you know you were
- 42:05telling me that you were afraid that I was going to judge you. Right,
- 42:08It's possible that at the core of it was this of just this childhood
- 42:14experience that you went through, either explicitly or implicably, where well, actually
- 42:19having response or having freedom and enacting on that freedom and that selfishness was terribly
- 42:28and you know what, you got a lot of messages there was there was
- 42:30something deeply wrong with you if you did those sorts of things. Yeah,
- 42:34I mean, I've told this story before that I can count on one hand
- 42:37less than all five fingers the times I got into deep trouble with my dad,
- 42:42And one of them was because on the way home from school, I
- 42:44was really little, like I don't second grade or something. Someone was selling
- 42:47a Michael Jackson poster and I bought it, and when I got home,
- 42:51I was terrified to tell my dad that I had bought a poster, so
- 42:55instead I lied and I told him I wanted in a spelling bee. And
- 42:59then of course he caught me in the lie because I couldn't keep it straight.
- 43:01And then I got in trouble for that, But like, why would
- 43:05I And that's totally it, Like, well, I'm not allowed to.
- 43:08I'm not allowed to just spend my money on a poster. That's I don't
- 43:13deserve that. So this is how the pathology perpetuates itself, even when you're
- 43:17a child, because the way you enact your freedom is pathological and almost forces
- 43:22people to come down on you about it because you ended up lying to your
- 43:28dad. If you had just told him or hey, dad, I saw
- 43:31this poster, I'm gonna buy it, and I don't care what you say,
- 43:35because I really wanted this poster. Well, of course I'm a little
- 43:37kid, so I'm like your dad probably would have been like, okay,
- 43:40you know whatever. I certainly got in trouble not for the poster. I
- 43:44got in trouble for lying about it, right, right, So that's the
- 43:47pathology of it is that because you're still busted up on the inside, you
- 43:52avoid telling him and thus push him into a position where he has to discipline
- 43:58you for the entire ball of ax. And so you walk away with yet
- 44:02another example an experience where you screwed things up and and and thus you shouldn't
- 44:09be taking freedoms about this sort of thing. And then that, you know,
- 44:15continues to grow until you have this compulsive spending thing. Dude, I
- 44:19think we've we've uncovered this whole other side of my coin, because you know,
- 44:23for years, the struggle was mainly with the over access, right,
- 44:28the darn it I never had, and now I can and I deserve,
- 44:30so I'm going to go crazy improve to the world that I'm worthy, right
- 44:34And in the meantime, and you know, like we've talked about before,
- 44:37I've addressed a lot of that. But in the meantime, there was the
- 44:39other side of the coin, which was, well, how to handle it
- 44:42when I can or are should be able to, you know, deserve something
- 44:46whatever, how to handle that because apparently they're still hurt there, yeah,
- 44:51right, I mean it's possible that the compulsion is mostly based on what we're
- 44:55talking about right now. I mean, maybe you call it prentification, maybe
- 44:59call it something else, the denial of your feelings and the disallowance of you
- 45:06being able to be selfish like a normal child would be. You know,
- 45:08well, and then money, money couldn't be spent because like money at one
- 45:12point became a thing that if there's any money, it has to go to
- 45:14my dad and it's going to go into a black hole, will never see
- 45:16it again. So for me to spend money, like, what are you
- 45:19talking about, that's crazy talk. Yeah, a lot of kids will go
- 45:22through that kind of experience, but I imagine only some develop this kind of
- 45:28complex between spending that last a lifetime. You know, you could imagine that
- 45:32there would be always a little bit of that. It's like any kid that
- 45:36emerges out of poverty and makes their own career like you, like you did,
- 45:40has a bit of an issue or some kind of path regarding like spending
- 45:45and that sort of well. But but not just the poverty, but the
- 45:49fact that there was this conduit like whenever I had cash, or anyone had
- 45:52cash, it would go to my dad because he needed it for mysterious needs
- 45:55and then the money would just be gone, but you yourself couldn't spend the
- 45:59money, right, And so to me, in terms of how I weigh
- 46:04these things out, that emotional side of things for you, I think was
- 46:09probably more foundational to this, to this problem of the denial of you being
- 46:15allowed to be a kid and being selfish and having freedoms, you know what
- 46:21I mean, that that are normal and that conflict internally results. So the
- 46:27reason why I really want to emphasize this is because when one is prentified and
- 46:32an over functioner, then you become your own monster, because unless you are
- 46:37aware of it and you start to heal from it in therapy, then you
- 46:42perpetuate the problems, even if you don't have kids, you know, Like
- 46:45a common example would be that you, as an overfunctioner, having been abused,
- 46:51growing up emotionally in this way prentified, and you are very attracted to
- 46:54people who are very under functioning, maybe people suffering from addiction or depression or
- 47:00shady behavior something like this, irresponsibility immaturity, and you end up engaging in
- 47:07a relationship with that person and you end up being very controlling of them or
- 47:13over concerned. You know, there's basically two different The different styles of codependency
- 47:16that I identified in my work are the accommodating codependent, the controlling codependant,
- 47:22and the chameleon codependant, which is not a common the third one, but
- 47:29usually they're either accommodating or they're controlling. So anyway, and the dynamic is
- 47:34created by you, you end up pushing someone who might be kind of under
- 47:39functioning to be more and more under functioning, which gives you more and more
- 47:44reason to be overfunctioning and overly concerned. And so that's my point is like
- 47:50it works against you, and it is tragic in that way. You know,
- 47:54trauma and parentification is, jokingly, I say, is the gift that
- 47:59keeps on giving because you go through the difficulty and then it just sticks with
- 48:02you and continues to perpetuate the problem and compounds it. You know. It's
- 48:07just it's yeah, it's just a new dimension that I find interesting that I
- 48:09want to dive a little more into myself because yeah, like you know,
- 48:14if you if we had had a conversation about the spending and stuff, I
- 48:16would have said, yeah, well I used to have a lot of problems
- 48:19with that, and I'm much better now. But I didn't. I didn't
- 48:21I didn't catch on to this other side of it, which is the guilt
- 48:23of spending correctly or spending when it's okay or whatever. And because I didn't
- 48:28have this dimension of parentification, I hadn't even thought of that. And again,
- 48:30obviously I'm not in the same boat. I didn't have to raise twenty
- 48:34kids by myself or any of that. But interesting, some of these aspects
- 48:37I feel like I can slightly relate to. Yeah, so okay, so
- 48:42Berto. The rest of this episode is just going to be for patrons of
- 48:45the podcast. We're going to continue with this discussion, but it's just going
- 48:50to be for patrons because we want to reward the patrons for becoming patrons.
- 48:53So for the rest of you, if you're not a patron and you want
- 48:57to hear the rest of us, become a patron, go to patreon dot
- 48:59com. And if not everyone in that category, please take care of yourself
- 49:02because you deserve it.