Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 110
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five four, three, two one one. Welcome
- 0:28back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are all ready
- 0:31to dive into some dark, creepy stories, So let's get started. Possessed
- 0:40by a demon, the chilling murderer Arnee Cheyenne Johnson. There have been countless
- 0:48reasons given to justify the murder of another human being. Revenge, love,
- 0:54pain, money, The list goes on and on. The reality is,
- 1:00though, no one ever expected someone to walk into a court room and have
- 1:03his attorney make the statement that his client was not guilty on account of demonic
- 1:08possession. This particular reason to find a person not guilty was the first of
- 1:15its kind and American law. The lawyer's thinking was that courts had debated the
- 1:19existence of God, and thus it would stand to reason that the same could
- 1:23be done for the devil. The cast of characters that would be paraded into
- 1:27the court room would include none other than the famous paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine
- 1:34Ward, who under oath would attest to the possession. But I am getting
- 1:38ahead of myself. Since a crime has to occur before a trial begins.
- 1:42For the first one hundred ninety three years that the town of Brookfield, Connecticut
- 1:47existed, there wasn't a single murder on the town's books. All that changed
- 1:53on February sixteenth, nineteen eighty one, when our day Cheyenne Johnson stabbed his
- 1:59then land lord, Alan Bana with a five inch pocket knife. His wounds
- 2:02would prove fatal, and the teen was charged with murder. Police were stunned
- 2:07by the sudden outburst of violence by are they He was, by all accounts,
- 2:13a regular guy, and before this had no criminal history. He was
- 2:16even engaged to be married to a girl by the name of Debbie Gletzel.
- 2:22Despite the sudden change of behavior, though, the case was for all intents
- 2:24and purposes, pretty open and shut. That was until his attorney made the
- 2:30startling claim he did. Despite the seemingly outlandish nature of the claim, his
- 2:37attorney was insistent on proving this to be true. The crime may have occurred
- 2:42in February, but everything began the year before. In the summer of nineteen
- 2:46eighty Debbie's eleven year old brother, David, had insisted that he'd come in
- 2:52contact with an old man that was taunting him. The two lovebirds didn't really
- 2:57believe what the younger boy said, thinking it was a ploy to avoid doing
- 3:00his chores. This didn't dissuade her younger brother, though, from continuing his
- 3:06claims, and they only became more frequent and violent in nature. It wasn't
- 3:12until David began waking up in the middle of the night sobbing that they finally
- 3:15took the problem seriously. He told them of the dreams of a man that
- 3:20had big black eyes, a thin, animalistic face, jagged teeth, pointed
- 3:24ears, horns, and hoofs. When the nightly visions didn't debate, they
- 3:30went to seek help from a nearby priest. He conducted a blessing upon their
- 3:34home, but it did nothing to quell the problem. This is when they
- 3:38first reached out to the Warrens, desperately hoping they could help their son.
- 3:44In a description of the events, the family told the Warrens that David would
- 3:47kick, bite, spit, and swear. He would act as if someone
- 3:53were trying to strangle him, even though there wasn't anyone there, and he
- 3:57would be tossed around by some powerful va force. Arne spent a lot of
- 4:01time at his fiancees hall trying to lend a hand in any way he could,
- 4:06but things only seemed to be getting progressively worse. The visions that had
- 4:12only come thus far at night began to appear in the day as well.
- 4:15Most of these included the same old man that he'd complained about before. It
- 4:21was also during this time that unexplainable noises began coming from the attic. As
- 4:28David's condition worsened, he began hissing and experiencing seizures. He also started speaking
- 4:34in a voice not of his own, while quoting Milton's Paradise Lost and the
- 4:40Bible. The Warrens looked into the claims made by the glat Sell family and
- 4:45determined that it was, in fact a case of demonic possession. This belief
- 4:50wasn't shared by everyone who examined the boy. More than one psychiatrist claimed that
- 4:56it was just a type of learning disability. This didn't ed and Lorraine Warren
- 5:00from conducting three separate exorcisms on David, all of which were overseen by a
- 5:06priest. During these battles with the demonic force within him, they claimed David
- 5:12levitated, cursed, and even stopped breathing. They even went on to state
- 5:16that David foretold of the murder Arne himself would later commit. Meanwhile, Arnay
- 5:21took it upon himself to find another solution to the problem. He started imploring
- 5:28the presence within David to come into his own body and leave the boy alone.
- 5:32All of this had been going on up until the day of the murder.
- 5:36From what police gathered, the two had been having a violent argument that
- 5:41had been centered around Arney's fiancee, Debbi. When he drew the knife,
- 5:46he proceeded to stab Bono multiple times in both the chest and stomach, before
- 5:49leaving the fatally injured man to bleed to death. Arnee would be arrested an
- 5:55hour later. The wards didn't buy the claims that the argument was simply over
- 6:00a woman. Up until this point, the two men had been friendly with
- 6:03one another, even to the point where Arnay would call into work so he
- 6:08could spend time with Bono at the kennel he worked at. It was also
- 6:12the events that took place before the stabbing that led them to this conclusion.
- 6:16As stated before, Arnae had been tauning the presence within David. Part of
- 6:21this had been him going to the sight of an old well where the boy
- 6:26had claimed to have had his first run in with the old man. He'd
- 6:30been warned by the Warrens to stay away from this place, but he went
- 6:33anyways. It was inside this well where he saw the demon who possessed his
- 6:39body up until the point he murdered Bono. Give the police in Brookfield credit.
- 6:45They did look into the claims made by the Warrens, but the law
- 6:47doesn't really have any way for to take into account supernatural forces when it comes
- 6:53to murder. This left them with only one choice believe that it had been
- 6:58a result of a fight over and make the arrest. During the trial,
- 7:02Martin Minninelli, Arne's attorney, did his best to prove his client's case.
- 7:08There was even a plan to subpoena the four priests who had assisted the Warrens
- 7:12during the three exorcisms. He implored them to break the commonly held traditions that
- 7:17would remain silent in such matters. The only thing the church would say was
- 7:23that they tried to help David during a difficult period in his life, but
- 7:27the priests themselves kept their mouths shut. Other evidence that was presented included Bono's
- 7:33clothing that he was wearing at the time of his death. The defense claimed
- 7:38that a lack of blood rips or tears led credence to the possibility of demonic
- 7:43possession. Despite the attorney's valiant attempt and warned support, no one in the
- 7:48court would accept the plea. Even attempting it had led to ridicule from their
- 7:54peers, most of which were revolved around the Warrens being frauds and Mininell trying
- 7:59to profit from the tragedy. Benninele eventually put in a play of not guilty
- 8:03because Arnay was acting in self defense. The trial itself went about as well
- 8:09as the hearings did, and he was convicted of first degree manslaughter. The
- 8:13judge would sentence him to attend to twenty years in prison, but he would
- 8:18be released in nineteen eighty six after only serving about five years. During this
- 8:22time behind bars, he and Debbi would remain together and eventually marry. Before
- 8:28his release, She continued to remain steadfast in support of her husband, stating
- 8:33he should not have challenged the demon who had inhabited her brother. The story
- 8:37would eventually be the inspiration for a book, a made for TV movie,
- 8:41before finally making it to the big screen. In the fictional tale The conjuring
- 8:46the devil made me do it.