Latest / The Events of 1848, Especially in Their Relation to Great Britain / Part 4
Transcript
- 0:00Section four of the Events of eighteen forty eight, especially in their relation to
- 0:05Great Britain, by Richard Munkton Millns. This LibriVox recording is in the public
- 0:11domain. Part four. With the form of government in France, Great Britain
- 0:18has given the most signal assurance that it has no intention in the slightest degree
- 0:23to interfere, and we heartily desire that the one may be established which shall
- 0:29receive the full and free consent of the French people. Whether the chief magistrate
- 0:34should be elective or hereditary cannot concern us un the less so as experience has
- 0:39taught us the fallacy of the Roman notion that liberty depends on an elected sovereignty.
- 0:46In co libertas posita irat populi romani quad non nascibatur, say to elijibato
- 0:52princeps tacitus. The only combination which could affect us would be acension of the
- 0:59throne of France by that branch of the Bourbon family, whose natural sympathies would
- 1:04lie rather with absolute than constitutional powers, and who cannot look with preference on
- 1:11a country which has so readily accepted the political changes by which that family has
- 1:15suffered. But even this contingency could little effect the external relations of France.
- 1:22Now that all the governments of Germany have been compelled to assume a constitutional form,
- 1:27that which was easy to an arbitrary power is impossible to a legal one
- 1:33obliged to assign legitimate motives for his acts. The scandal of the partition of
- 1:38Poland, for instance, would never have come from powers constitutionally organized. And
- 1:44Bancroft informs me he saw in the archives at Paris a letter from the Minister
- 1:49to England after the Peace of seventeen eighty three, stating that George the third
- 1:55had expressed to him a hope that Lewis the sixteenth and himself might remain good
- 2:00friends, and added, if we do so, such an event as the
- 2:05partition of Poland would be impossible. The virtuous and uncompromising minister, who has
- 2:12governed France for a longer period than any other statesman since Cardinal Fleury, has
- 2:17lately given to the world is gloomy prospects of the future of French democracy.
- 2:23And yet it is no doubt to the expression of the most democratic portion of
- 2:27the constitution viz. To universal suffrage, that the present highly conservative tone of
- 2:34French politics is owing the very large number of landed proprietors in France gives a
- 2:40preponderance to fixed property which we could not expect to find under a similar system
- 2:46in this country. If it turns out, as is not improbable, that
- 2:52the possession of this franchise inspires the masses with political interests, they may be
- 2:57induced to acquire the knowledge ofical economy, the want of which is really at
- 3:02the bottom of all those tumultuous theories of life that at a distance seem so
- 3:08fair. And by fairly partitioning public opinion between the towns and the country,
- 3:15it may tend to decentralize France without weakening her energies or thwarting her inclination.
- 3:23I have attempted in these pages to enunciate what appear to me the simple principles
- 3:27on which it becomes our diplomatic relations with Europe to be conducted consistent with treaty
- 3:32rights and the eternal obligations of justice. I have not entered into close diplomatic
- 3:38detail, because the events of last year have gone far to take matters out
- 3:43of the hands of diplomatists. Diplomatic relations lately observed Lord Palmerston, Lie in
- 3:49reality between nation and nation, and the governments are the organs through which they
- 3:54communicate a large and statesmanlike opinion and adapted to the exigencies of these times.
- 4:03For on reviewing the movements of the continent, it is singularly clear how untenable
- 4:11have been the conditions even of the Great Compact of eighteen fifteen that have not
- 4:15been ratified by the respective peoples. Belgium, Poland, Lombardy, Venice and
- 4:23the Italian Duchess all have changed the political aspect which was then attempted to be
- 4:28impressed upon them, and are either successfully independent or ruthlessly enslaved. The later
- 4:35efforts of Austrian state craft to stifle the constitutional principle in southern Italy through the
- 4:42means of the King of Naples have resulted in an Internissan struggle which are shocked
- 4:47the hardened nerves of experienced warriors and revived the memory of the Sicilian vespers.
- 4:56Yet there is nothing in this view either dangerous to public law or even condemnatory
- 5:01of the more formal and arbitrary system of former ages. While the greater part
- 5:08of the civilized portions of Europe remained in that passive political state, in which
- 5:13the character of the governing power was comparatively unimportant. As long as no new,
- 5:17unaccustomed acts of personal oppression were committed, and no violent change attempted to
- 5:23be brought about in the domestic habits of the people. There was of course,
- 5:28no other check to the ambition of kings or states but the strength of
- 5:31their antagonists, and no fitter mode of settling the external relations of mankind than
- 5:38engagements binding on the honor of the contending parties. As long as men were
- 5:44chattels, they were subject to be treated as such and to be transferred in
- 5:48the same manner. And how late in history this doctrine prevailed, is evident
- 5:55from the claim of Lewis the fourteenth to the sovereignty over the Belgian provinces of
- 6:00Spain founded on the peculiar laws that regulated the disposition of property in those countries.
- 6:08The impropriations admitted into the treaties between Buonaparte and the German princes were a
- 6:14continuation of the same principle. But with a change in the notion of sovereignty
- 6:19necessarily comes a change in the notion of its power in the disposition of its
- 6:25subjects. Pure force will always keep its own. But then it has nothing
- 6:30to do with law, which cannot exist without some ingredient of justice or micron
- 6:35mech orn vr v d ron d. Here professedly, there is none except
- 6:43what is assumed by the law itself. And therefore diplomacy is now reduced to
- 6:47two modes of action, the consent of the nations it represents, and the
- 6:53use of material violence. Not but that another field is already open to de
- 7:00plomatic skill, prudence, and energy, which, if rightly used, will
- 7:04confer on them a far higher function and a far wider participation in the destinies
- 7:10of mankind than they have ever enjoyed in the palmiest days of intrigue or the
- 7:15most profitable reign of duplicity. There is better work for diplomatists nowadays than there
- 7:21ever was for Gondomar or Barillon. They indeed could threaten or promise the intervention
- 7:29of armaments, but these can wield the moral force of nations. A wise
- 7:34mediation is a nobler work than a prudent peace. And although an evil from
- 7:40which we are preserved may not be appreciated as one from which we are rescued,
- 7:45yet history will learn to appreciate these more silent glories, and day by
- 7:50day will be less inclined to let the fame of men depend on the single
- 7:56moral faculty of personal courage and the single in intellectual talent of military combination.
- 8:05Without regarding the amiable enthusiasm of the members of universal peace societies with more interest
- 8:11or sympathy than one gives to men who propose to themselves an admirable object but
- 8:16have little or no means of accomplishing it, it is impossible not to feel
- 8:20that they only represent the exaggeration of a conviction rapidly growing in public opinion of
- 8:26the fault as well as the crime of war. A cessation from arms of
- 8:31more than thirty years has not had the effect which has been so often attributed
- 8:37to peace, of fattening men for destruction. The world has not been accumulating
- 8:43wrath it is desirous to discharge, or violence it is laboring to vomit.
- 8:48Forth, the discontents and vexations of men have taken another direction, and are
- 8:54spending themselves on their own political or social condition. Now, although it may
- 9:01be very useful to every highly civilized and orderly nation to have some such outlet
- 9:05for the fiercer instincts of our nature, as India, Algeria or Mexico.
- 9:11It does not at all follow that the warlike spirit holds the same position it
- 9:16did in the necessary constitution of society. These conquests and contests have something about
- 9:24them of fatal and compulsory, and are not calculated to produce the same immoral
- 9:28consequences that follow from regarding war as a science or a pastime. What a
- 9:35large majority of men wish for is at once accomplished. What the wisest and
- 9:41best desire comes to, but not at once, and he must indeed be
- 9:45dull to ethical and political conclusions. Who does not perceive in the tone of
- 9:50popular thought, and in the declarations of public men, and in the spirit
- 9:54of the literature of England, France and Germany, indications of the moral sense
- 10:01that war is either a duty or a crime, and that the acts of
- 10:03violence on the part of states are amenable to just the same rules as acts
- 10:09of violence between man and man. Thus, in the invasion of Lombardy by
- 10:16Sardinia, the excuse I will not discuss its validity was assistance to a cognate
- 10:22and conterminous nation in throwing off the oppressive yoke of a stranger, without which
- 10:26liberation no union, either federal or absolute, of the Italian peoples was possible.
- 10:33The interference of Germany in Denmark arose from the presumed incompatibility of the characters
- 10:39of King of Denmark and the German Prince, and the supposed necessity of either
- 10:45closely incorporating those provinces in the new Confederation of Germany or separating them altogether from
- 10:52it against their will. Apart from the right or wrong on these matters,
- 10:56it is evident that they are not to be confounded with wars of conquest or
- 11:01aggression, for in both cases it was admitted that the aid was demanded by
- 11:07the parties most interested, namely the populations whose political destiny depended on the issue.
- 11:15Have far Therefore, the peaceful mediations, which have averted so many evils
- 11:20and palliated so many more, will become the rule or habit of modern Europe,
- 11:24and substitute, as it were, a high court of public opinion,
- 11:28not only for regular and open wars, but also for such armed interventions as
- 11:33I have just mentioned, will no doubt mainly depend on the firm establishment of
- 11:39representative institutions throughout Europe. As the rulers and ruling classes of communities have usually
- 11:48been those who have suffered least from wars. It is not to be expected
- 11:52that such a considerable change could take place only or mainly through their means.
- 12:00It is by the popular feeling making its way in representative assemblies, by the
- 12:05determination of the people legally expressed not to be taxed for any hostile purposes,
- 12:11however gilded with promised glory, that war will become the rare phenomenon instead of
- 12:16the staple of history. Nor does it follow that in any degree the spirit
- 12:22of national defense will grow weak in the hearts of the people, nor even
- 12:26that one nation may not offer its physical force to support another in its defense
- 12:31against overpowering aggression, such as the invasion of the Turks in past times,
- 12:35or the possible eruptions of the Slavonic races in the present. In such cases,
- 12:41representative governments would be no more likely to hold back than absolute ones,
- 12:46and indeed they would possess a concentrated energy and unity of action which would make
- 12:52them doubly formidable. It would appear almost superfluous to add how much the chances
- 13:00of civil peace are increased in constitutional states. There it usually happens that the
- 13:05snow melts where it falls. Difficulties are resolved, passions are spent, crises
- 13:11are tided over, Conciliations are accomplished that under personal government would be impracticable.
- 13:18For by the very theory of representation, you procure the consent of the masses
- 13:24without their actual interference, and the satisfaction of their will without its violence and
- 13:31caprice. But for this end it is above all things necessary that the representing
- 13:37body should have the respect and confidence of the people, and for that purpose
- 13:43its constitution must change from time to time according as public opinion modifies or extends
- 13:48itself. In the old Hungarian constitution, where populace meant the nobility, public
- 13:58opinion was really represent because the nobility comprised nearly the whole of the invading and
- 14:03ruling race. In time, the invaded became populous also, and the neglect
- 14:11to consolidate their interests with those of the old rulers has led to the destruction
- 14:15of the independence of Hungary. In France, the refusal of progressive reform in
- 14:20the representation has caused the Late Revolution caused it apparently and immediately, for although
- 14:28the demand for a change in the electoral system was not expressed with the general
- 14:31enthusiasm that won the English Reform Bill. Yet the refusal of the government to
- 14:37grant, except with the bayonet at its throat, even the smallest and most
- 14:41gradual concessions, went far to alienate the confidence of the population in their prudence
- 14:48and sagacity, and to arouse the expectations of the determined men, who saw
- 14:54that the opportunity was coming to get far more than the nation desired to ask,
- 15:00and to wring from tumult and disorder, far more than they could have
- 15:03hoped to gain from peaceful progression. La religion on politique writes a statesman certainly
- 15:11not addicted to radical politics. Baron Wessenberg consist assavoir faire and sacrifice Arton pra
- 15:18de la initiative don comte de jean d'avenue inevitable I le sur moien dont atteignue
- 15:24lu pois d'Or avite ern plurent PONSEI. Now Count Molais has mentioned, I
- 15:31think in an address to the French Academy that Napoleon said to him, I
- 15:35close the book of the French Revolution, but when I go the book will
- 15:39open at the page I left off, and he and other real conservative French
- 15:45statesmen have surely been blinded, either by fears or by doctrines, who thought
- 15:50that so small a body of electors as France possessed thirteen months ago, could
- 15:56guarantee to the government such a national confidence as would defend them in a struggle
- 16:00with the bold, earnest, unscrupulous men who believed themselves commissioned to continue the
- 16:07work of the revolution, and who were connected with it by a chain of
- 16:11conspiracies extending through the Empire and the Restoration. Thus, when the day of
- 16:18battle came, the monarchy and the Republic met and fought, and the people
- 16:25looked on. The form and name of the executive power in France may change,
- 16:30but universal suffrage will remain, and, as I have already stated,
- 16:36under very advantageous circumstances, the chief of these is, I conceive the absence
- 16:42of any such heavy national burden in the way of debt as that we labor
- 16:47under, and which invests with so solemn a responsibility the electoral body and pledges
- 16:52them to support, at any sacrifice the character and credit of the country.
- 17:00These events, therefore, my dear Lord, are not without some possible application
- 17:03to ourselves. It is not likely unless France should become the scene of misfortunes
- 17:11which we have no reason to anticipate, and which we should most seriously deplore,
- 17:15that the English people will remain unaffected by the extension to all citizens of
- 17:22political rights in a country with which we are physically so closely connected, and
- 17:26whose moral influences over other nations have always been remarkable. And for this we
- 17:33must be prepared. We are all conscious of the voice of Providence in the
- 17:37tempest and the earthquake, but a true statesman, as the true prophet,
- 17:42hears it in whispers inaudible to the common world. These last impressive words are
- 17:51some of those I now mournfully recall recollections of the beloved conversation of a man
- 17:56to whose worth as a colleague and friend you are no doubt ready to pay
- 18:02every homage, but in whom only those that knew him most intimately can estimate
- 18:07what his country has lost. Mister Charles Buller, I am thankful to have
- 18:14brought most of the thoughts and sentiments of these pages to the test of his
- 18:18large, just and discerning spirit, and to have acquired more confidence in the
- 18:23truth of my opinions on foreign politics from their coincidence with his own. For
- 18:30with him the finest sagacity was compatible with the purest enthusiasm, though many who
- 18:37only saw the clearness of the stream were totally unconscious of its depth or of
- 18:41the rapidity of its flow. In him, the toleration of error never implied
- 18:47the indifference to truth. But he could perceive in the theories and principles of
- 18:52other men truths and leadings to truth of which they were themselves perhaps hardly aware.
- 19:00And thus his consciousness of the value of the institutions of his country and
- 19:04of the character of his countrymen never obscured from him the merits and meaning of
- 19:10the ideas and efforts of other nations. He was one of the few practical
- 19:15English statesmen whom I happen to have known, who believed that Englishmen could derive
- 19:19any clear additional views in public matters from the observation of foreign politics, or
- 19:26who cared much more about revolutions on the continent than to see that they did
- 19:30not produce a troublesome echo in Trafalgar Square. Let us, then, in
- 19:38all our spheres, you, my Lord, in the highest as Minister of
- 19:42Education in this country, as far as our unhappy dissensions permit us to have
- 19:47one do all in our power so to advance the enlightenment and intelligence of the
- 19:52English people. That in proportion that political power is extended, the sense of
- 19:59political responsibility and the knowledge of political truths may not fail. I am sure
- 20:07we never consider sufficiently how much of our real present social security we owe not
- 20:11only to the practical sense, but to the information, however imperfect, of
- 20:18the multitude. In our large towns. The political economy may be rude,
- 20:23but it is not the less useful by which those men are intimately convinced that
- 20:29an illegal and tumultuous attack on the property or persons of their wealthier fellow subjects
- 20:34would not answer the objects they have in view, that violence would not only
- 20:40lead to repression and punishment by the law, but that even if it succeeded,
- 20:45the consequences of a forcible change in the distribution of wealth, or of
- 20:51a disturbance of the ranks of society, must rather injure than improve the condition
- 20:57of the masses of the community. It is a plain knowledge of the conditions
- 21:03of production and distribution, though occasionally suspended by passion or blinded by misery,
- 21:10that keeps tranquility in our crowded streets and order among our eager and anxious artisans.
- 21:18Thus the schemes of society, which as matters of political science engage the
- 21:23controversy of Aristotle against Plato, which as ideals, have been held up by
- 21:29men as wholly and as wise as Sir Thomas Moore, and have been aimed
- 21:33at in practical life by exceptional bodies as numerous and in many respects as excellent
- 21:40as the monastic institutions of the Middle Ages. These dreams of a past paradise
- 21:45or visions of a future Atlantis are found, and are likely to find little
- 21:51favour with Englishmen of any class under any pressure of the present mode of existence.
- 21:56To this result, the uaginativeness of our character contributes something its sturdy individuality.
- 22:04Still more, but the real obstacle, which no extravagance can overcome,
- 22:11is the strong impression that anything brought about by mere force will not last,
- 22:15and that there are certain sufferings and evils for which the laws of nature and
- 22:22not the laws of man, are accountable. Let this knowledge be only still
- 22:26further widened. This conviction still more deeply felt, and all discussion and examination
- 22:34of the phenomena of social life, and those who suffer will discuss and examine,
- 22:40will be instructive, suggestive, elevated, purifying, instead of fostering hates
- 22:45and animosities of class against class and threatening all classes with common Ruin this,
- 22:55if in any degree accomplished or furthered, will be one of the results of
- 23:00the events of eighteen forty eight that will remain when the fume and the tumult
- 23:06have passed away. Already we can perceive the forms of other substantial benefits to
- 23:11humanity, standing forth and vindicating the ways of God to man. Open courts
- 23:18of justice and trial by jury have taken the place of those antiquated forms,
- 23:22which, however honestly administered, could never give confidence to the people or elevation
- 23:29to public opinion. Through the greater part of Central Europe, the freedom of
- 23:33the press may be suspended by military ordinances in some places, but these measures
- 23:40are professedly exceptional and prohibit little more than was before. Systematically prevented, incontrollable
- 23:48events have put an end to the struggle between thought and expression, which raised
- 23:52into importance every worth that's forbidden book and damned up the healthy stream of open
- 23:57debate, which carries off so many of the impurities of society and fertilizes even
- 24:03the ground that it overflows. Representative institutions on a wide basis are the inevitable
- 24:11foundations of future government in northern and Western Germany. While Austria herself will with
- 24:18difficulty throw off the constitutional form, however irreconcilable it may be, with military
- 24:23occupation and not only discordant but inveterate nationalities, a separate provincial organization is what
- 24:33may be there expected, and that is no weak security for future freedom.
- 24:40The national sympathies that have played so considerable a part in the politics of the
- 24:44year will probably lose much of their exclusive action, but their defensive strength will
- 24:49remain encouraging the principle of patriotism and self sacrifice in resistance against a common enemy.
- 24:57Nor do I think that I am either lording or justifying the stupid and
- 25:02wicked spirit of causeless revolution in expressing an opinion that, whatever be the political
- 25:07issue, it is satisfactory to the Christian moralist to have witnessed that all the
- 25:12delight and indulgence of animal life that filled the hereditary dominions of Austria, and
- 25:18all the pleasant sloth that nature and art and governments encouraged throughout Italy were not
- 25:23sufficient for the soul of man, but that he was still ready to imperil
- 25:29all this for the idea of some better and higher condition of existence aspirations.
- 25:37Indeed, however, noble will of themselves do little more than disappoint and disappointment
- 25:44may generate despair, but they may also produce a wise humility, a just
- 25:49appreciation of self, and a determination to endure to the end. This is
- 25:56the hope of the friends of Italy. Peace and the free institutions, which
- 26:03alone can unite peace and progress, are the fruit which Great Britain desires that
- 26:08Europe should gather from this wondrous year. Theorize as we may about non intervention
- 26:15and isolation, we cannot cast off the relations that hold together the nations of
- 26:21the world. The system which would make of England the peaceful forge of arms
- 26:26with which the rest of the world is fighting, and the comfortable manufacture of
- 26:32clothes which other countries are too busy slaying one another to fabricate, is just
- 26:37as vain as that which would surround our islands with a wall of glass,
- 26:41grow all our own food, and live wholly on the produce of our own
- 26:47labor. Indeed, of the two, the latter scheme is the more consequent
- 26:52and intelligible. For free trade above all other theories, interests us in and
- 27:00in a certain sense makes us dependent on the foreigner. If our fabrics were
- 27:07diffused, as they might and ought to be, a revolution in China would
- 27:11affect the clothiers of Leeds, and the tranquility of the South American republics would
- 27:15be as important to the men of Manchester as the order of their own streets.
- 27:22Incomplete, as is our present interchange of commodities, we have yet suffered
- 27:26grievously from the confusions of the continent, and unless they lead to a more
- 27:32general well being and an increased prosperity, they will have been to us an
- 27:37unmixed commercial evil. And we own no thanks except to the English Minister,
- 27:44who has enabled this country to preserve an honorable peace, and whenever he has
- 27:49had the opportunity abroad, has mitigated violence and impeded war. In one quarter,
- 27:56measures of force have been abstained from, even at some apparent risk of
- 28:00our national dignity. The vainglorious and passionate minister, who, for the sake
- 28:06of a coupd'etta expelled to h Bulwark from the court of a sovereign whom English
- 28:11arms and money had largely contributed to place on her throne, has remained unpunished,
- 28:18Strong as we are in the sense of our generosity to a weak and
- 28:21imprudent adversary, and well as to h. Bulwer, can rest on his
- 28:26character and his worth. Yet some such act, as the blockade of a
- 28:30Spanish port or colony, might have been of real advantage to that fine people,
- 28:34whose overweening conceit is the only impediment in the way of their enjoyment of
- 28:41their free institutions and their general prosperity. In conclusion, let us not overlook
- 28:49the evidences of the sense of the value of social order which have shown themselves
- 28:55in the very centers of revolution. Most of the great cities of unth been
- 29:00not metaphorically but absolutely in the hands of the lowest class of the people for
- 29:07weeks together, and yet property has generally been untouched. Woman respected, religion,
- 29:14revered, obnoxious persons, uninjured, strangers unterrified, While some acts abhorrent
- 29:22to humanity have not failed to meet with signal retribution. No stronger proof could
- 29:29be given of the force of the social instincts in these masses of men than
- 29:34society going on for some time as it were, of itself preserved by the
- 29:40habit of law and the sense of duty. And no higher test could be
- 29:45required of the fitness of the people to share in the benefits and responsibilities of
- 29:52representative institutions. Nor is it a chimerical hope that this country, which under
- 30:00the divine favor, has been and continues to be, the example of free
- 30:06political life and peaceful constitutional progress, will be regarded with increased interest, sympathy,
- 30:15and confidence, and gain as much gratitude as men ought to give for
- 30:19blessings which in the main they must owe to themselves. I have the honor
- 30:30to be, dear Lord Lansdowne, yours truly and obedient. Richard Moncton Millns,
- 30:41end of section four, end of the Events of eighteen forty eight,
- 30:45especially in their relation to Great Britain, by Richard Moncton Milns, Read by
- 30:51Brin Roberts Kingswinford, October twenty twenty three,