Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Racket (1928)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello, everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars,
- 0:41the show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:44nominee from 1927 to today. I'm your host, Kyle.
- 0:48And I'm Ryan. And we're back again with another
- 0:51film from the very first Academy Awards season,
- 0:54The Racket. Our second of the year. Yeah. If
- 0:59you tuned in last week for the episode covering
- 1:02Seventh Heaven, welcome back. You're now a regular
- 1:05listener. Congratulations. Good job. Well done.
- 1:08And if this is your first time tuning in, what
- 1:10we do here is we cover every single movie that's
- 1:12ever been nominated for Best Picture. Like I
- 1:15said earlier, starting from 1927 and going all
- 1:17the way to the modern day. Which is where we
- 1:20are currently. We're still very much in the beginning
- 1:21of the first year, which was the actual award
- 1:24ceremony was 1929, correct? Correct. Yeah. But
- 1:27that does encompass movies from 27 and 28. Correct.
- 1:32The Academy was like... Look, we started this
- 1:35in the middle of the year, so let's just stretch
- 1:37it back a little bit. Right. That way we can
- 1:39get my boy. I forgot his name from last year.
- 1:42Who's the main actor? Chico. Oh, man. Oh, God.
- 1:45That's trivia. Don't do this to me. That's trivia.
- 1:48Janet Gaynor. My boy, Janet Gaynor. My boy, Janet
- 1:51Gaynor. I think that's going to be my next musical
- 1:54project is my boy, Janet Gaynor. Dude, I love
- 1:58it. Taylor Swift has a Clara Bow song, doesn't
- 2:00she? She does. Perfect. I've never listened to
- 2:03it. I say that with 100 % confidence and 30 %
- 2:08certainty. Excellent. That sounds like her. I'll
- 2:11reach out to the 21 -year -old girl that works
- 2:13with me. There you go. And just be like, hey,
- 2:15I need help. Give her 10 seconds to get through
- 2:18the face palm that she does. Right. And then
- 2:20she'll answer your question. The face palm, the
- 2:22fist bump when she starts talking about T -Swift.
- 2:24Maybe offer her tickets to go for that new Taylor
- 2:28Swift movie that's coming out. Okay, I thought
- 2:29you were going to say a concert. No, no, no.
- 2:32I'll save you like, you know, $1 ,000. Thanks,
- 2:34appreciate it. Did you hear about that movie?
- 2:35Yeah, I did, from her. Okay, so that makes sense.
- 2:40Thank you, 21 -year -old coworker. I don't even
- 2:41know what it is, though. It's like her music
- 2:44video. So it's like a 90 -minute thing, and it
- 2:47includes the first music video of this album,
- 2:49and then it includes like behind the scenes,
- 2:51and then there's like visual like aids to the
- 2:54album, but it's not a visual album. Gotcha. It's
- 2:57not like a lemonade kind of thing. Okay. It's
- 3:00more like, hey, congratulations. The album came
- 3:02out. Here's a fun little thing. And it's like
- 3:04two or three days of a run. Money, please. The
- 3:08only thing that I think is very funny about it
- 3:10is like, you know, it's going to make a ton of
- 3:12money. So much so that it's going to be number
- 3:14one of the box office of that week. Yeah. And
- 3:16it's coming out at the same time, same week as
- 3:18The Smashing Machine, which Dwayne The Rock Johnson
- 3:21was like, this is my number one. This is my Oscars
- 3:24contender. And Taylor Swift was like, you can
- 3:26sit down. Right. We love movies here. We do.
- 3:31And if you love movies and Taylor Swift, this
- 3:35is the place for you. Maybe not this episode.
- 3:37Well, the beginning of this episode. I'm sure
- 3:39Taylor Swift loves this movie, though. Probably.
- 3:42I'm sure that somewhere in this movie, there's
- 3:44like a metaphor for her career or something.
- 3:47Actually, a good bit of her role in Amsterdam
- 3:50kind of mimics a little bit of the racket here.
- 3:52Oh, okay. There you go. Was that the movie Amsterdam?
- 3:55Am I making that up? That's a movie that came
- 3:57out that I never saw. The old Russell movie?
- 3:59Yes. Yes. She's in that. It's definitely called
- 4:03Amsterdam, right? It is called Amsterdam. I just
- 4:05don't know what it is. I didn't see it. No, she
- 4:07definitely gets hit by a car in that movie. Oh.
- 4:09Spoiler. Damn. Sorry, 21 -year -old co -worker.
- 4:13Who hasn't caught up on the Taylor Swift movie
- 4:14from two or three years ago. Well, anyway, let's
- 4:18get back into a movie that predates Taylor Swift
- 4:20by almost 100 years. Yikes. So, The Racket, directed
- 4:23by Lewis Milestone. We were just looking, and
- 4:27this is the first of many Oscar nominations for
- 4:30him. Almost in a row. Yeah. It's pretty exciting.
- 4:35I'm a big fan of the movies that I've seen from
- 4:37him, and I'm looking forward to covering them
- 4:39on the show with you. Mm -hmm. As am I. Also
- 4:43starring Thomas Meehan, Marie Prevost, Lewis
- 4:47Wolheim, and our favorite rat. George E. Stone.
- 4:52Aw, was he, uh, wait. He wasn't, uh, Sewer Rat
- 4:55from 7th Heaven. Sewer Rat, yeah. He was Sewer
- 4:58Rat? That was him. Wow, my guy was busy. He was.
- 5:00I know it's a year later, but still. It's good
- 5:02to see people taking off. Right? I'm glad he's
- 5:04finding work. Good for him. What's interesting
- 5:07about this is that compared to 7th Heaven, which
- 5:10had so many nominations, this is only nominated
- 5:13for Best Picture. Yeah, which, how do you feel
- 5:16about that when that happens in the modern day?
- 5:19I always have some questions about how a movie
- 5:22can be nominated for Best Picture, but not anything
- 5:24else. Because to me, Best Picture is the culmination
- 5:26of everything else, right? Did you have some
- 5:29excellence in acting? Did you have excellence
- 5:32in directing, writing? Like there has to be something
- 5:35that leads into that. This being the first ceremony,
- 5:39I'm willing to look past that a little bit. But
- 5:41also there's some performances in this that kind
- 5:43of felt like, you know, especially with other
- 5:45categories. I'm not sure with the... what those
- 5:48contenders were, but specifically the character
- 5:51of Nick Scarcy is pretty rich. He's pretty solid,
- 5:54right? Like, I mean, the Lieutenant is very good
- 5:56too, but Scarcy alone is kind of like, well,
- 5:58that's your winner. Yeah. He was really great.
- 6:00And that's, that's Lewis Wolheim you're talking
- 6:02about. Correct. So he plays the gangster Nick
- 6:05Scarcy and the, just what his face does in this
- 6:09movie is so impressive and. Definitely campy
- 6:14by today's standards. The word that came to mind
- 6:17so many times watching it was punchable. Yeah.
- 6:19He just has such a great punchable look of like,
- 6:22oh, I got you right where I want you. Yeah. He
- 6:24has this severe underbite where he's almost bulldogging.
- 6:29Yes. He just looks like a gangster. He does nail
- 6:33it, yeah. And specifically Captain McQuig, Thomas
- 6:37Megan. I thought he did really well, but he has
- 6:41to kind of play more. There's nothing comedic
- 6:43about those performances. Well, kind of. But
- 6:45it's mostly a serious performance on both sides.
- 6:47But he kind of has to play the straight man to
- 6:50the Nick Scarcy character and his more intimidating,
- 6:55to your point, campy character. Yeah. And Wolheim
- 7:00definitely had way more fun with this role, I'm
- 7:02imagining. Oh, yeah. But like you said, Meehan,
- 7:05this straight character, not only is he kind
- 7:09of limited in what he's able to do, I think his
- 7:13character's a little boring, personally. Yeah,
- 7:16no, I agree. As I was watching this movie, this
- 7:19is my second time seeing it now, and I had originally
- 7:24given this movie one and a half stars on Letterboxd.
- 7:27Spoiler alert. Interesting. And as I'm watching
- 7:30it, up until like halfway through, I was like,
- 7:32what was I thinking? I actually really like this.
- 7:35There's some really interesting shots. The story
- 7:38is compelling enough. What was I talking about?
- 7:40And then I think right after there's a funeral
- 7:44scene, right after that takes place, right around
- 7:45the halfway mark, I completely lost interest
- 7:48in this. Yeah, that's fair. Because it kind of
- 7:51turns into a bottle episode, right? Like it is
- 7:54very contained to the police precinct. Yes. And
- 7:57that's kind of the rest of the movie. Almost
- 7:59play -ish. Yeah. Like, the camera really does
- 8:02say, like, okay, well, here's side A of the office,
- 8:05here's side B, here's McQuig's office, and then
- 8:09here's the basement where the prison actually
- 8:12is. And that's it. Exactly. Yeah, there's some
- 8:15wonderful camera play early on in the movie,
- 8:18and that completely goes away. And like you said,
- 8:20it's a stage play from that point on. Which...
- 8:24Isn't always a bad thing, but when you've showcased
- 8:26so many cool things prior, you really just lose
- 8:30interest. There's a really fun shot at the club.
- 8:34You see from the same angle, actually, you see
- 8:37Scarcy and his gang come in, his group, and they
- 8:40just walk down the stairs. And it's a really
- 8:43great shot because it's almost like... Like it
- 8:46feels like they kind of found like a crack in
- 8:48like curtains where you can see them walk in,
- 8:50but they're not the focal frame or the, the focus
- 8:53on the frame. But then they show the shot a second
- 8:56time when the police arrive and the, maybe it's
- 9:00the score change that happens with it. But that
- 9:02was just such an interesting, like it wasn't
- 9:04like a technically amazing shot, but it was just
- 9:06such like a, you didn't just do this straight
- 9:08on. You found a different way to do it. Right.
- 9:09And that, and then the chase sequence that happens
- 9:11with a chick and Helen. And then the police.
- 9:15I thought that was such an interesting thing
- 9:17that the rest of it felt more contained. And
- 9:20contained isn't really something that you want
- 9:22to hear in the second half of a movie. Right.
- 9:24That's only an hour and 22 minutes long. Yeah.
- 9:28That club scene you brought up is definitely
- 9:31the highlight of the movie for me. Right. The
- 9:34blocking in the entire club is so cool. Like
- 9:38you said, nobody's centered up in frame. Nope.
- 9:40They... There's a part where a rival gang shows
- 9:43up. Yes. And there's this really cool shot underneath
- 9:47the table, kind of sitting at the hip of Nick
- 9:51Scarzi. You see him holding a pistol. And down
- 9:54deep at the other end of the frame is the rival
- 9:58gang member. And it's so cool because the focus
- 10:01is on the rival gang leader. If this would have
- 10:05been filmed a few years later or now. They would
- 10:08have used what's called a split diopter shot.
- 10:10Yes. Oh, it's so cool. I was going through my
- 10:14notes while I was watching this movie from the
- 10:16first time I watched it. And just like with Seven
- 10:18Heaven, I wasn't adding a whole lot because I'm
- 10:20like, oh, I think exactly the same as I did four
- 10:23years ago. Great. I've evolved so much. But one
- 10:26thing I did add was the idea that they probably
- 10:29would have used a split diopter. And that's something
- 10:32that I picked up the last couple of years, like
- 10:34working in the film industry. So I was like.
- 10:37I still have the same thoughts, but now I'm educated.
- 10:42Yeah, I'm sure back then you were thinking like
- 10:44similar to me of like, it'd be great if this
- 10:46guy on the left was in frame, but like also the
- 10:48group in the right wasn't. Yeah. And then now
- 10:50you're just like, that's called split diopter.
- 10:52Right. Right. I think that that would have been
- 10:54a great shot of like Nick kind of like realizing
- 10:56that something was happening and having him in
- 10:57the left. And then the split diopter is the rival
- 11:00game coming in from that shot. Like that would
- 11:02have been fantastic. But again, you know, and
- 11:05we'll talk about this more next week when we
- 11:07talk about wings, but there's just so many. amazing
- 11:11things that they were able to accomplish at the
- 11:12time with these cameras, because, you know, I
- 11:15think that we look now as a society and say like
- 11:17oners are like fantastic and like, wow, look
- 11:20how cool this shot was. But like, those are all,
- 11:23they've watched these movies and gotten the inspiration
- 11:26that they needed from them. This was kind of
- 11:28just like on its own. Like they, they made these
- 11:30things up in real time. And again, we'll talk
- 11:33way more about this next week, but this one wasn't
- 11:36as flashy. But I thought the way that they used
- 11:39these angles were very effective. Yeah. I think
- 11:41this not being nominated for anything but Outstanding
- 11:45Picture gives you an opportunity to see Lewis
- 11:49Milestone's ability as a director. And that's
- 11:53something that we'll see as early as next year
- 11:55with All Quiet on the Western Front. His blocking,
- 11:58his camera work, it's all very, very impressive.
- 12:01And had there been a category for anything like
- 12:05that other than director. Right. absolutely,
- 12:08this would have gotten a nomination. Over Seventh
- 12:10Heaven, I agree. I think it's fair to talk about
- 12:13what we've already talked about and exclude Wings
- 12:16for right now, but I think that what we've seen
- 12:19of Seventh Heaven and The Racket, I would easily
- 12:21give it to The Racket over Seventh Heaven, just
- 12:24for direction. Yeah, which is so funny because
- 12:26Seventh Heaven got that director nom. Yeah. And
- 12:31maybe it was because like, you know, earlier
- 12:32on, like maybe it was, I don't want to say participation,
- 12:35but like maybe because it was earlier on and
- 12:37it adopted some of those things. And like a year
- 12:39later, it's like, of course it was a little bit
- 12:41different. Maybe they gave it to him for that,
- 12:44but I don't see it. Yeah. I think a lot of it
- 12:47too has to do with the low amount of people nominated
- 12:50in each category in general. Definitely. What
- 12:53did you think about Marie Provost as Helen Hayes?
- 12:57So I like the way her character is written. She's
- 13:00very no -nonsense, very, you know, you're not
- 13:03the boss of me. Yeah. And that's a lot of fun.
- 13:06But beyond Lewis Wolheim, I didn't think anybody
- 13:10was super interesting to watch in this movie,
- 13:12including Thomas Meehan. Because they're not
- 13:14scarcy. Right. Yeah. What about you? I thought
- 13:19she was fine. Granted, I don't want to necessarily
- 13:22label her as this because it was so early on
- 13:25that she was probably like, you know. the foundation
- 13:27of this archetype, but she was very much that
- 13:30archetype of like the, you know, we first see
- 13:33her as an entertainer and she attaches herself
- 13:36to, uh, Scarcy's gang to get that notoriety and
- 13:39kind of like get, you know, um, somewhere in
- 13:41life. And then she makes a turn and that turn
- 13:46happens almost extremely suddenly. Yeah. Um,
- 13:49and what's kind of interesting and to your point,
- 13:51boring is that uh the captain or yeah captain
- 13:56mcquick he specifically is the central morality
- 13:59of the movie and everyone around him is kind
- 14:02of dancing with morality and inevitably helen
- 14:06hayes and uh is it is it chick who uh the individual
- 14:10she ends up with at the end uh that's actually
- 14:12joe scarzi nick's brother nick's brother okay
- 14:15oh i'm sorry the one she ends up with correct
- 14:18Because Nick's brother is who she leaves the
- 14:20club with. Right. I don't remember who that is.
- 14:23I don't know if it's Chick because Chick was
- 14:24arrested. It's not Chick. I think he may have
- 14:26been a reporter. Yeah, he's just like some nice
- 14:28guy. Yeah, he's just a nice guy. So she kind
- 14:31of like uses him a little bit throughout the
- 14:34movie, but then inevitably realizes that no one
- 14:37cares about her but him. And maybe technically
- 14:41that individual she ends up with. Uh, maybe that's
- 14:44the other like morally centered character, but
- 14:47again, it's kind of boring seeing these characters
- 14:49in Helen included, but mostly Scarcy act circles
- 14:53around McQuig and just have a lot of fun with
- 14:56the scene. And McQuig is just like these fools
- 14:59like the whole time. And it's not a bad movie.
- 15:01It's just, you know, I think it gets a little,
- 15:04to your point, boring when the majority of the
- 15:06second half is focused on McQuig. in his precinct
- 15:09and his team. But if there are some standouts
- 15:12outside of Scarcy for me, it's the two journalists
- 15:14that almost behave like hyenas. Yeah. Just like
- 15:19tear, chomp into the bit for like some kind of
- 15:21meat. I thought they were excellent and so much
- 15:25fun to watch. I would have loved if they, the
- 15:28casting would have been replaced with like, uh,
- 15:30Laurel and Hardy or, uh, like Abbott and Costello
- 15:34kind of. Absolutely. Or they weren't dumb. No,
- 15:37no, no. They were definitely just played more
- 15:39as like this is their role and you have to be
- 15:41this way to kind of get by. Yeah. But if they
- 15:43were played a bit more comedically, maybe. Right,
- 15:45right, right. But I agree. That would have been
- 15:47amazing. Because one of them is a drunk. Correct.
- 15:50The whole time he's just plastered. And the other
- 15:53one's kind of the like, hey, man, like we've
- 15:55got stuff to do. Let's go. Or Simon Pegg and
- 15:59Nick Frost. Yes. Oh, my God. If they did like
- 16:02a remake of that, that'd be perfect. This would
- 16:04be a great movie to do. a hot fuzz style remake
- 16:07of now that's a really interesting thing that
- 16:10you brought up and i think that's an interesting
- 16:11segue to talk about how watching this movie to
- 16:14me it just felt so vanilla might be the term
- 16:18where it's just kind of like yeah okay cool there's
- 16:20absolutely nothing offensive about this story
- 16:23that they're telling at the time that wasn't
- 16:24the case right right back then like this was
- 16:27an extremely controversial movie that actually
- 16:29limited its release because the depicting such
- 16:32a corrupt level of chicago Was not cool back
- 16:36then. No. Was not appreciated. Does that surprise
- 16:40you to think that a movie like this was considered
- 16:43controversial at the time? During this time,
- 16:47I could definitely see it because we're talking
- 16:49about Prohibition. Yeah, sure. And they're showing
- 16:53cops drinking on the job and things. Right. Or
- 16:56stealing hooch out of the trucks of gangsters.
- 16:59So I can see how that would be. taken from the
- 17:03police in Chicago as a super negative image for
- 17:06them. Right. Yeah. So it was banned in Chicago,
- 17:10like you're talking about. Specifically Chicago.
- 17:11And that was because of the police force and
- 17:13city government specifically is what they cited.
- 17:15Obviously with Nick Scarcy, it makes sense that
- 17:18there's going to be some like comparisons to
- 17:20Al Capone. Sure. Right. That's what he's modeled
- 17:22after the most. But I do think, and maybe it's
- 17:24just the way that they chew the scenery on this,
- 17:27but way more of a camp performance than Capone.
- 17:32Like he's still intimidating. Yeah. There's a
- 17:34shot that I really like, a moment that I really
- 17:36like, where he's being, sorry, Nick is being
- 17:40interrogated within the police force because
- 17:43he's come to get his brother. And the police
- 17:45officer talking to him isn't moving at all, isn't
- 17:48budging. And there's like this really great tense
- 17:50moment where he's kind of like unfolding all
- 17:53seemingly seven parts of his jacket. Right. And
- 17:56obviously he's reaching for a gun, but he's not.
- 18:00Things escalate and the police officer turns
- 18:03around and then Scarcy just shoots him immediately.
- 18:05And to your point, the campy performance is that's
- 18:08a very tense moment that just there's no comedy
- 18:11to it. It's just very tense. It's played off
- 18:12really well. Great moment of release. But then
- 18:15Scarcy does something where he drives off. And
- 18:18then seemingly three minutes later just comes
- 18:19back around. He's like, what's going on? Yeah.
- 18:22What happened here? I heard there was trouble
- 18:24at the police precinct. Does anybody need help?
- 18:27And that to me is just so Looney Tunes. Yes.
- 18:29Like that's a Daffy Duck logic of like, I know
- 18:32what will make them think it's not me. Yeah.
- 18:33If I show up. They'll never guess. Yeah. It does
- 18:39get very, very cliche. Sure. And I don't, I really
- 18:43don't know if that's what it felt like back then.
- 18:45I'm sure it didn't. But. boy, by today's standards,
- 18:48by, by the end of this, the second half, I'm
- 18:51just like, I've seen this and I've seen it done
- 18:53way better. Yeah. I mean, I, I appreciate it.
- 18:57I think the, the intro is very engaging, right?
- 19:00There's a lot of outside shots of like people
- 19:04who aren't in the focus, but you can see kind
- 19:06of like peering over like buildings and like
- 19:08out of windows. It's just, it feels very realized
- 19:10and lived in. And I thought that was very engaging.
- 19:13And again, that club scene was just like so tense
- 19:15and thrilling. But then you get to that second
- 19:17part and it's more like, well, this happens and
- 19:19then this happens and then this happens. And
- 19:21there's a great Scarcy moment, but then this
- 19:22happens. Right. And it just doesn't really come
- 19:24together. So part of me is a little perplexed
- 19:28as to how it ended up in the best picture. But
- 19:31it's good to know that even in its first year
- 19:34compared to its like, you know, 50th, 75th, 90th,
- 19:37that the Oscars still love a little controversial
- 19:39moment. So I'm sure this getting banned in Chicago
- 19:41was a pretty interesting thing for them to include
- 19:43as best outstanding picture. But outside of that,
- 19:47watching this, I was like, this one, this is
- 19:50what got nominated for outstanding picture. Yeah.
- 19:52But I'm trying to table that with 2025 expectations
- 19:55of like, you know, Scorsese probably saw this
- 19:58and was like, oh, yeah, this is what I should
- 20:00be doing. Yeah. I am always curious what like
- 20:04kings of the genres think about these very early
- 20:07genre pictures. I have to think that they herald
- 20:10them in some sense, right? But not all of them.
- 20:13Not all of them. I mean, granted, I think this
- 20:15is so early on that it inspired something from
- 20:18the 40s or 50s that individuals like Scorsese
- 20:21do cite. Right. Right. They're seeing more from
- 20:24the 40s and 50s than this. And also, just with
- 20:26technological achievements, it's probably more
- 20:28likely that they're going to cite something from
- 20:29the 50s than like a silent film from 1928. Yeah.
- 20:32I imagine there's a lot of love for Public Enemy,
- 20:35you know, which was what, the 30s? That's not
- 20:38too far off from this, but I've never really
- 20:42heard this movie talked about. And I don't think
- 20:44it's just the silent aspect of it. I just think
- 20:47people kind of don't hold it to as high a degree
- 20:51as things like Little Caesar or Public Enemy
- 20:54from the 30s and 40s. Right. I think that there's
- 20:58something that I want to discuss here, and that
- 21:00was the racket itself, right? The titular racket.
- 21:03And I think that the racket that they're trying
- 21:05to tell us is very much that corruption. within
- 21:07the police force, within Scorsese overall. I
- 21:12think the real racket that I want to talk to
- 21:14you about is that this is the second movie that
- 21:16I watched on Tubi. Oh, yes. The second movie
- 21:19that I watched on Tubi for this podcast, and
- 21:22the second movie in a row where the incorrect
- 21:25score was used. Now, it makes sense to me that
- 21:28there are... music rights. There's liabilities,
- 21:32things that you may not have the rights to. My
- 21:34understanding is that if you didn't have the
- 21:36rights to those things, you wouldn't get the
- 21:37movie. Right. Not that you'd have to change the
- 21:40score. So it's interesting to me that this is
- 21:42the second movie out of seemingly how many. Like,
- 21:46who knows? Right. Could be a plethora of silent
- 21:49films on Tubi that are using the incorrect score.
- 21:51And I realized that about halfway through, maybe
- 21:54a little under, when, and I decided this to you,
- 21:57The score was effective, right? It wasn't the
- 21:59same song over and over. This wasn't offensive
- 22:00like Seventh Heavens was. But specifically, the
- 22:03nutcracker, the ballad of the nutcracker came
- 22:05on in that club scene. I was like, all right,
- 22:08I have some suspicions here. And I went to YouTube
- 22:10and watched the rest of it in its correct score.
- 22:13And the score was serviceable. But my question
- 22:16to you is this, right? I want to complain about
- 22:18that a little bit. So everyone be on your toes
- 22:20when you go on Tubi and watch these movies. Buy
- 22:22them if you can. What was your thoughts on the
- 22:25score? of the racket compared to seventh heaven
- 22:28so the score for this movie is really interesting
- 22:31to me because it's the the score from seventh
- 22:35heaven is the score that existed for at least
- 22:3950 years this was a score that was recorded and
- 22:44composed in 2004 when the film was recovered
- 22:49because this was a lost film until 2004 Oh, so
- 22:53we don't know for certain what the original score
- 22:55was. No, we don't. Interesting. So this was recorded,
- 22:58I forget which orchestra did it, but because
- 23:01this film was lost for so long, it was found
- 23:03in 2004 in Howard Hughes's private collection.
- 23:06Interesting. Then they remastered, they preserved
- 23:09the film. If you watch it on YouTube, it has
- 23:11the long list of credits, not from the actual
- 23:13film, but from the restoration of it. Right.
- 23:16Including the score. So it's interesting to think.
- 23:20of composing a score for a film that came out
- 23:22almost 100 years ago, 80 years later. Right.
- 23:25Even just the instruments used are different.
- 23:28I don't know. It does have kind of more of a,
- 23:31I keep using the word, but like a cliche score,
- 23:34probably because it had so many gangster films
- 23:38to build off of. Right. The inspiration for what
- 23:42we know to be gangster now. was used to make
- 23:46the score right so it's so it's so weird to think
- 23:48about this this inception of sound well i think
- 23:52it's it's inherently it's inherent nature for
- 23:55us to want to like discuss certain movies and
- 23:58say you know this felt like um derivative might
- 24:01be a word but also like a amalgamation of certain
- 24:04things right but that's interesting because in
- 24:07that sense it's almost like a game of telephone
- 24:10over 80 years right of like well the score kind
- 24:13of sounded like this and then also inspired this
- 24:15but then we take what it inspired and then kind
- 24:18of turn it back into itself and it's a blend
- 24:20now it's a blender of like what it is what it
- 24:24was and what it inspired and that's interesting
- 24:26because and this is my final point on it score's
- 24:29fine yeah not memorable nothing great like it's
- 24:33it's serviceable Um, but going back and watching
- 24:36seventh heaven with the correct score, it very
- 24:39much looks for the moment and says, here's what
- 24:41we want you to feel in this moment. And it is
- 24:43memorable in that sense. This was more, and this
- 24:46kind of led to my overall opinion of the movie.
- 24:48Pretty good movie, like pretty great overall.
- 24:51Um, very good for its time, but the score that's
- 24:54available now is just not anything special. Yeah.
- 24:58Unfortunately. And when you're talking about
- 25:00an outstanding picture, especially compared to
- 25:02seventh heaven and what's to come, there's a
- 25:04lot more interest that I have a lot more. That's
- 25:08like morally interesting than this is. Yeah.
- 25:11But because it was controversial at the time,
- 25:13I'm sure it was very much a point of interest
- 25:16with this of, can you depict this? Is it safe
- 25:18to depict this? Something that we've seen later
- 25:20on with all the president's men. And even later
- 25:23on with like killers of flower moon, like, can
- 25:24we talk about this? And if it's held in that
- 25:27same. kind of conversation and weight that we
- 25:30didn't have with Killers of the Flower Moon,
- 25:32then it just seems all the more important. Yeah.
- 25:35And this, I don't think the discussion in this
- 25:39movie is as heavy as Killers of the Flower Moon.
- 25:41But beyond Chicago, I do wonder how widespread
- 25:45that controversy went. I was thinking about the
- 25:49Untouchables earlier today. Sure. You talked
- 25:52about McQuig being like this very, very morally
- 25:55good police chief. Yeah. But he lets so many
- 25:58people get away with so many things, even at
- 26:00the police station. They're drinking. He's like,
- 26:02hey, you shouldn't do that, man. Anyway, let's
- 26:05go catch Scarzy, maybe. I don't know. But there's
- 26:10that famous scene at the end of Untouchables
- 26:12where they catch Capone. They book him, whatever.
- 26:17And they ask Kevin Costner's character, like,
- 26:20what are you going to do now that it's over?
- 26:22And Prohibition is ending. And he's like, oh,
- 26:24I think I'm going to go have a drink. And he
- 26:25spent his whole career. you know, fighting against
- 26:29alcohol running and things like that. So it's,
- 26:32I really don't know what the everyday man's feelings
- 26:37were about prohibition or organized crime or
- 26:42corrupt police departments. Probably not great
- 26:45about the organized crime and the corruption.
- 26:48But was anybody really, really concerned the
- 26:51same way that Chicago was because they were directly
- 26:54targeted by this movie? I would say no. I can't
- 26:58imagine they were because the thing that I keep
- 27:00thinking about was like, again, I enjoyed the
- 27:02movie overall. It's definitely not a bad movie,
- 27:04but in terms of importance and in terms of what
- 27:07it's doing, I'm trying not to have the 2025 lens
- 27:10here when I talk about this, but it feels kind
- 27:12of like a fifth graders report on Chinatown.
- 27:16Yeah. Where they're like, this happens and then
- 27:18this happens and then forget it, kid. It's Chinatown.
- 27:20And like, that's kind of the end of this movie.
- 27:23Right. Is like. Hey, did this go down the way
- 27:26I want it to? No, but I guess that's just life.
- 27:30Yeah. And things happen. That's Chinatown. And
- 27:32it just ends. And it just doesn't seem that inspired.
- 27:36It doesn't seem very well thought out. It almost
- 27:39seems kind of like the decision was made to make
- 27:42a controversial film and not do too much else
- 27:45with it. Yeah. But again, I'm very much trying
- 27:48to watch the movie as a standalone project and
- 27:50not think about what's inspired or what came
- 27:52after. And I think that the main thing is that
- 27:56if this did not have Scarcy and did not have
- 27:59that role played specifically by, if Wolheim
- 28:02wasn't playing Scarcy, this movie is dead in
- 28:05the water. Yeah, I agree. Scarcy and also some
- 28:08of the camera work in the first half. Yeah, you're
- 28:11right. And I did like some of the supporting
- 28:13characters, the journalists specifically. But
- 28:15it's funny that you mentioned Sewer Rat is in
- 28:17this movie because I feel like there's like five
- 28:19or six Sewer Rats in this movie. of just characters
- 28:22who are just kind of like, listen, see, get over
- 28:25here. There's a lot of like Muggsy kind of. A
- 28:28lot of Muggsy. Yeah, especially that the club
- 28:32scene. It's literally Scarcy, like Helen, and
- 28:37then like everyone else is just Muggsy. Yeah,
- 28:40they're all the weasels from Who Framed Roger
- 28:41Rabbit. They totally are. It's pretty solid at
- 28:46that point. Man, this would have been a great
- 28:48movie if it was all weasels. Wouldn't it? Like
- 28:50if this was like a Muppets, but one character
- 28:52is played by a human type movie. Yes. This is
- 28:54a great one. Dude, I was talking about some of
- 28:56these old movies that are kind of out of the
- 29:01mainstream eye now, like The Racket. I would
- 29:04love to go back and remake these movies with
- 29:06some kind of twist. Yeah. And I think that...
- 29:11the weasels from frame Roger Rabbit would be
- 29:13so good here. Let me pitch something to you.
- 29:14And what I'm going to pitch, I already have the
- 29:16confidence and is a thousand times better than
- 29:18this movie. If the Muppets were to make a series
- 29:22where they would remake 100 year old movies.
- 29:24Yes. Right. So it's in the public eye and now
- 29:27they can remake these movies and make it like,
- 29:28you know, aware to another audience, uh, do this
- 29:31movie. All of them are Muppets. Weasels maybe
- 29:36is the Muggsy characters, but maybe rats. Right.
- 29:39Yeah. Bunch of Rizzo's. Bunch of Rizzo's. The
- 29:43McQuig character is Sam the Eagle. Yeah. Easiest
- 29:46cast I've ever done in my life. Yep. Miss Piggy
- 29:49is Helen. The individual she ends up with is
- 29:52Kermit. And the only human, my proposition here,
- 29:56Brandon Gleeson as Scarcy. Okay. Put Brandon
- 29:59Gleeson in the Scarcy role, chewing scenery around
- 30:02the Muppets. This movie rocks. That's pretty
- 30:04solid. That's what I'm trying to say. And maybe
- 30:07that's not such an inspired casting choice because
- 30:09so much of Woolheim invokes a Gleeson type. Yeah.
- 30:14You talked about that bulldog nature and like
- 30:16that chin that just kind of extends somehow further
- 30:19than you would think it should. Right. But he
- 30:22just has this like, it's not even charisma, but
- 30:25just like he absolutely wears his emotions on
- 30:27his sleeve because you can tell him the look
- 30:29on his face when he's thinking. There's no, like,
- 30:31you know, enigma to this man. Like, he is corrupt.
- 30:33You can tell he's corrupt. The way he's smiling
- 30:35at you, you know he's corrupt. The way he's talking
- 30:37to you, you know he's corrupt. Yeah. But he's
- 30:39enjoying being able to get away with it. He's
- 30:42untouchable, so to speak. Oh -ho. Oh -ho. I think
- 30:45that there are people like that who have done
- 30:47such a great job now. Gleeson is one of the best,
- 30:50I think, doing it. I would love to see something
- 30:52like that. If that ends up happening in two or
- 30:54three years, I'm expecting a paycheck. You'll
- 30:56probably still be expecting that paycheck. I
- 30:58imagine I will. Disney, please. Right, yeah.
- 31:01Disney, please do something for us. So you mentioned
- 31:05the second half of this film kind of feeling
- 31:08like a stage play. I did. This was adapted from
- 31:11a Broadway play by, I can't read my own writing,
- 31:14Barlet Cormac. I really hope you got that like
- 31:17so wrong because of your handwriting. Yeah, it's
- 31:19Jeff Smith. That says Bill Murray? Yeah. But
- 31:22that's always interesting to me because as we'll
- 31:26progress through these movies a little bit. especially
- 31:28once sound becomes a concept. There are lots
- 31:32of films that have been adapted from stage plays
- 31:36where they translate them to the screen and they
- 31:40quite literally are just filmed stage plays.
- 31:44And those are always really hard to watch. There's
- 31:47not a whole lot of movement going on with the
- 31:49characters. They feel really, really stationary
- 31:52and dull. It's fun. For these silent films, when
- 31:56they're adapting them that way, you get people
- 31:59like Scarzy, who's, you know, really kind of
- 32:01eaten up just all of his body language and things.
- 32:04That all exists now. And that's going to go away
- 32:07very soon in our show. With the invention of
- 32:12sound, that became a, hey, you've got to stand
- 32:14right here. Don't make any other noise other
- 32:18than the lines we've given you. And it makes
- 32:20for such dull movies. As much as I complain about
- 32:24the second half of this movie and everybody just
- 32:27kind of standing around and stage play in it,
- 32:30it's still so much better than what will come
- 32:32in like four or five years for this type of movie.
- 32:35You know, and maybe it makes us appreciate, you
- 32:37know, that's the reason that we draw ourselves
- 32:38more to these Wollheim performances is that we
- 32:42don't get to see this as often, right? Like we
- 32:45see people pretending that they can choose scenery
- 32:47like that, but no one really captivating like
- 32:50Scarcy. There's some great. uh character work
- 32:53in seventh heaven but you don't have a character
- 32:56like nick scarcy right you don't so i think the
- 32:59reason that even in 2025 we look back and you
- 33:02know we reflect on that kind of performance is
- 33:04exactly to your point because like you don't
- 33:06really get that again you do but it takes like
- 33:09another i don't know 20 30 years yeah to get
- 33:12to that point where you kind of have someone
- 33:14you know your eastwoods that kind of can almost
- 33:17literally choose scenery around them right so
- 33:21I think you're dead on. And, you know, that's
- 33:22why maybe this is acknowledged because of the
- 33:26individual performances and its controversial
- 33:27nature. But again, kind of begs the question,
- 33:30why wasn't it nominated for anything else when
- 33:32clearly you have supporting actor or even best
- 33:35actor right there? Right. I think that really,
- 33:39really just kind of boils down to, hey, we're
- 33:41going to nominate three people. Sure. And this
- 33:44was probably number four. you know, in the list
- 33:46of nominations. True. Because with Wings alone,
- 33:49I'm sure there's multiple opportunities. Yeah,
- 33:51I don't remember. The winner of Best Actor is
- 33:56not in a film that we're going to watch this
- 33:58year. I'll spoil that right now. It was Emil
- 34:01Jannings, and I've not seen any of the movies
- 34:04that he was in for this Oscar year. So it's hard
- 34:08for me to say, like, oh, yeah, he absolutely
- 34:10deserved it. We shouldn't even be talking about
- 34:12Lewis Willheim. But I agree with you. This is
- 34:15the strongest performance of this movie. It really
- 34:18showcases Lewis Wolheim's talents. Yeah. It's
- 34:21very sad. He actually passed away a few years
- 34:23after this from stomach cancer. Oh, no. So we'll
- 34:25be seeing him in All Quiet on the Western Front,
- 34:27and he's fantastic there as well. But that's
- 34:29kind of like the very end of his career. Thomas
- 34:33Meehan, on the other hand. On the Meehan. Right,
- 34:37yeah. We kind of talked about it. His character's
- 34:41just not really written in a super interesting
- 34:42way. Right. I wish he was more like 100 % morally
- 34:49good. Yes. His flip -flopping makes him way less
- 34:54interesting to me. I was more invested in the
- 34:56police officer that Scarzy does the, pulls the
- 35:00gun on him and shoots him in the back. Way more
- 35:02interested in him because he was very, very stoic
- 35:05and very hard cut. I'm a good guy. Yeah. I don't
- 35:09take money. I bribery, whatever. And then, you
- 35:12know, he got shot in the back. So there's that.
- 35:14I just keep thinking about that scene specifically
- 35:17because it does feel like, and maybe this is
- 35:19hindsight, it does feel like a good 25 seconds
- 35:22goes by that Scarcy reaches in his pocket and
- 35:25something comes out where I felt like I was in
- 35:27a horror movie where I was like, get out of there!
- 35:29What are you doing? Leave! See, and in the Muppets
- 35:32remake, this is where he would reach into his
- 35:34pockets, his like 27 different pockets, and constantly
- 35:37pull out something ridiculous. Rubber chicken
- 35:39is guaranteed. Exactly. Yeah, no, that's completely
- 35:43true. A gun at one point, but the cops just like,
- 35:46whatever. Yeah, just like multiple drugs and
- 35:49everything's being popped out, and they're like,
- 35:50what else do you have? Something I wanted to
- 35:52talk about with this was kind of the way that
- 35:54we look back on these movies. And one way that
- 35:56you can do that is obviously by looking at like
- 35:58Rotten Tomatoes, IMDb reviews and all that. So
- 36:01Rotten Tomatoes is interesting because there
- 36:02are a collective, hope you're sitting down for
- 36:05this, six reviews of this movie on Rotten Tomatoes.
- 36:08We need to get on there. Seven, hello. So seven
- 36:12critics specifically. The aggregate review or
- 36:15percentage is 100 % for this movie based on their
- 36:18reviews, right? Wow. And here are what the critics
- 36:21are saying. The critics are raving. Right. Variety
- 36:24said, a good story, plus good direction, plus
- 36:28a great cast, and minus dumb supervision, is
- 36:31responsible for another great underworld film.
- 36:33That is the most underwhelming review. It is.
- 36:36For 100 % reviewed. From Variety? From Variety,
- 36:40yes. Why don't I work for Variety? Like, I think
- 36:45good pops up two or three times in that sentence.
- 36:48Good. Good. great cast minus dumb supervision.
- 36:51It just feels kind of like a participation trophy
- 36:55of like, yeah. Like that review to me is the
- 36:59word. Yeah. I'm just like, yeah. Yeah. Watch
- 37:02it. Yeah. Don't like if there was like a, if
- 37:05there was a written out way of communicating,
- 37:08like, yeah, that's that review. It's, it's how
- 37:13everybody complains now that, that our media
- 37:16literacy is going out the window. And, You hop
- 37:19on TikTok and you see a review and people are
- 37:21like, yeah, Superman was mid. That's half a step
- 37:24above mid. At least mid has a definition behind
- 37:29it that you have to go and look up. And it's
- 37:31just like, good, great, stupid, dumb. Okay, thank
- 37:35you. Five stars. Great underworld film. Yeah,
- 37:39it's... It's interesting, and it's certainly
- 37:41not bad. I enjoyed my time with the racket a
- 37:44good bit, especially when I was watching the
- 37:46correct score, Tubi. Or listening to the correct
- 37:48score, rather. Or the intended score, I should
- 37:51say, for 2004 and on. But beyond that, it just
- 37:55felt like it was lacking any urgency. It felt
- 37:58like it was lacking any compassion. And it felt
- 38:00like just another nominated film, and not one
- 38:05that was particularly interesting. Do you think
- 38:08that's fair to say or do you think that's like
- 38:10looking back in hindsight? It's one of those
- 38:13things where unless you were living through the
- 38:16time or you've managed to watch all of the best
- 38:19films that have come out that year now, it's
- 38:23hard to say like, yeah, this one you could probably
- 38:26overlook and be okay with or feel the opposite
- 38:30and be like, hey, what are you talking about,
- 38:32Ryan? This is one of the greatest films ever
- 38:34to come out of 1928. From today's lens, it does
- 38:39feel like, okay, they nominated this. Cool, it's
- 38:42a gangster movie. It has some good this, some
- 38:44good that, as Variety so graciously put it. Eloquently
- 38:48put it. Right. But it is kind of a, look, we've
- 38:53seen it. Other people have done it better, told
- 38:56the story better, shot it better, acted it better.
- 38:59And I don't think that's a terrible thing to
- 39:02say about a movie that's 100 years old. Especially,
- 39:05you know, we're not downplaying its strengths.
- 39:07No. So from like your movie journey guides, I
- 39:14think what we're saying is this is worth checking
- 39:16out if you're interested in the historical value
- 39:19of these movies. If you're interested in seeing
- 39:21like really unique camera work from a time where
- 39:25they were just learning how to do this stuff.
- 39:27They were making it up as they went. It's strong
- 39:29for that. And Lewis Woolheim. Those two alone,
- 39:32I would agree. I think I can't remember if we
- 39:35use this phrasing offer on pod. So in the just
- 39:39to err on the side of caution, I'll say it again.
- 39:41It's not flashy. It is effective. Yeah. Right.
- 39:44The camera work is nothing. You know, we'll see
- 39:47differently in next week's episode. We'll talk
- 39:49about it. But it's so effective what's captured
- 39:51here. And what's disappointing, I guess the best
- 39:54way to put it is that that effectiveness that
- 39:57we see in the camera work is almost thrown to
- 39:59the wayside in the second half. To kind of embrace
- 40:02that play -like element that you pointed out
- 40:05was an adaptation. So of course it is. But the
- 40:08intention is if you're ever going to play something
- 40:10differently as you do on a play and as you do
- 40:13in a movie, you have to stage that a certain
- 40:15way. We can't just say, well, I filmed a play,
- 40:17so here's my movie. That's the play. So you have
- 40:21to be very careful about how you do that. And
- 40:22I think that it falls on its sword a bit in that
- 40:26second half. But that first half, so many great
- 40:29moments that... again, are thrilling and otherwise
- 40:32very just like, you know, by the numbers situation.
- 40:35So I agree that the camera work is great. I think
- 40:39it's a bit different than what we're going to
- 40:40see moving forward here this year, but still
- 40:44very interesting. And it's a good stepping stone
- 40:47for, like you mentioned, you know, the director
- 40:48goes on to do All Quiet on the Western Front.
- 40:50He goes on to do Ocean's Eleven. Like there's
- 40:53a lot of great work that he goes on to do because
- 40:55of this. So it's a really great stepping stone.
- 40:58It's in the same sense that I don't know many
- 40:59people who would say memento or following is
- 41:01Nolan's best work, but it's the stepping stone
- 41:04of how he got to those places. Right. So it's
- 41:07good to admire it for that alone. One thing I
- 41:10wanted to mention about this is that we complain
- 41:12in big 2025, 21st century, really, that all we
- 41:16see are remakes, right? We're intellectually
- 41:20bankrupt as a studio, as a community, because
- 41:25we're just watching all these remakes. It's important
- 41:27to point out that this was remade, right? A lot
- 41:31of the movies that we're going to be talking
- 41:32about here were remade as early as the 50s. Yeah.
- 41:36I think even earlier, Seventh Heaven was remade
- 41:39in the 40s with Jimmy Stewart. There you go.
- 41:41So two of the two movies we covered have already,
- 41:43we found out, been remade. Within 20 to 30 years
- 41:47later, were being remade. So it's important,
- 41:50and we'll talk about those remakes, but it's
- 41:52important to remember that this is just how things
- 41:55tend to go. People look at what was popular before,
- 41:58they find a way to reinvent that, and they remake
- 42:01it. So this specifically was a remake in 1951.
- 42:05Robert Mitchum, Robert Ryan were the two leads
- 42:08on it. You said that the 1940s is when Seventh
- 42:10Heaven was remade, right? I believe so, yeah.
- 42:12And we'll be talking about next year, All Quiet
- 42:15on the Western Front. That was remade by the
- 42:18same director who did Conclave, actually. Blanking
- 42:20on the name. I shouldn't have mentioned him without
- 42:22knowing his name. My apologies to this man. It's
- 42:24okay. I actually almost wore, this is not a video
- 42:26podcast, but I almost wore my other Super Yaki
- 42:29t -shirt. I'm wearing my Go to the Movies shirt
- 42:32today. I almost wore my Conclave shirt that has
- 42:35Stanley Tucci on the front. And it says, vote
- 42:37Bellini. And on the back, it says, don't be a
- 42:39meanie, vote Bellini. That's so good. That's
- 42:42so good. So in, what, five years, ten years,
- 42:46when we get to 2025 Oscars and we can talk about
- 42:49Conclave, outfit is picked out. Perfect. It's
- 42:52either that or I'll be wearing a Cardinals outfit.
- 42:54So whichever one I can find. Wouldn't that be
- 42:56a great idea? Patreon goal. Patreon exclusive.
- 43:00Yeah. Get Ryan and Kyle. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And
- 43:03a Cardinal outfit. That'd be pretty solid. I
- 43:06want to dress like Isabella Rossellini though.
- 43:08I think you could pull it off. Yeah. I think
- 43:10that I could pull off a Stanley Tucci, a Bellini
- 43:14performance, if not just for, there's a line
- 43:18where he says, it's like. And I wish they did
- 43:20this for the Oscars, the Academy Awards ceremony
- 43:22in 1929. But when there's always like one line
- 43:26that was written and performed in the movie that
- 43:28you're like, oh, that's the highlight reel. Right.
- 43:30In Conclave, it's Tucci talking with Ray Fiennes.
- 43:35And Ray Fiennes says, I don't want to start a
- 43:37war. And Stanley Tucci says, this is a war! And
- 43:40like slaps his hand on the counter. You're like,
- 43:42yeah, that's the stuff. I'm sure there's a Scarcy
- 43:45performance or line in here that does feel like
- 43:47there's your highlight reel. Yeah. But I think
- 43:50it's mostly just everything he does. Right, right,
- 43:52right. Bringing him up one more time before we
- 43:54get into like, what was your rating and blah,
- 43:57blah, blah. Sure. You mentioned last week with
- 43:59Seventh Heaven, the title cards, how there weren't
- 44:02enough. Yeah. There's a ton in this movie. I
- 44:05appreciated that. Okay, you appreciated it. That's
- 44:07how you feel about it? I didn't think it was
- 44:09too much because, you know, it was something
- 44:10that we talked about and going back and replaying
- 44:12it in my head, it definitely sounded like Toddler
- 44:13Learns How to Walk. No. Where it's kind of like,
- 44:16yeah, it made me like have to like infer what
- 44:19they were doing and like when they nod their
- 44:20head what that means. Of course, that's what
- 44:22that means. But in this, there's still very much
- 44:25that, but there's also just a lot more dialogue.
- 44:28right right i feel like there is probably a similar
- 44:32amount of dialogue in seventh heaven that we
- 44:34just don't get to see and in here we get to see
- 44:36it and there's a speech actually that mcquigg
- 44:38gives towards the end where i think he's talking
- 44:40to scarcy and i can't remember exactly what he
- 44:42says but it has like a three or four parter right
- 44:45where he's kind of like one card would say like
- 44:47it's not going to happen and the next card is
- 44:49like not here hyphen next card is not now hyphen
- 44:53not ever and that to me feels like the staging
- 44:55of it makes it feel much more dramatic and i
- 44:58like that way better than putting it on one card
- 45:00or like you inferring that he's saying something
- 45:02for a little bit longer it felt like whenever
- 45:04someone's talking you never have to do the leo
- 45:07thing and be like what they say what was that
- 45:08like you knew what it was so i wasn't bothered
- 45:12by how much there was and maybe it's because
- 45:15it was an hour and 22 minute movie and compared
- 45:17to the two hours of seventh heaven i felt like
- 45:20there was much more opportunity within seventh
- 45:21heaven to have those title cards and share what
- 45:25was happening between these characters where
- 45:26i didn't feel that gap in the racket yeah i i
- 45:30think these two movies specifically are a great
- 45:32example of the the artistry that goes into title
- 45:36card writing for sure Because Seventh Heaven
- 45:38being a romance film, sure, you say a little
- 45:41bit with the actual title cards, but then you
- 45:43show the romance. It's easier to do that with
- 45:47the man and a woman in love than to showcase
- 45:49kind of this arch enemy kind of relationship
- 45:54between Scarzy and McQuig. So also you want to
- 46:00highlight like the gangster lingo and slang and
- 46:02everything. So it relies heavier on. Like, quippy
- 46:06lines and cool dialogue. It's cool that the genres
- 46:11are kind of what dictate how many title cards
- 46:13are going to be used. I wasn't, like, bored by
- 46:17the amount of title cards. I just thought it
- 46:19was so interesting. Someone had to decide, like,
- 46:22oh, I need more. Right. For this reason. Well,
- 46:25it's interesting because I think that there's,
- 46:26like, a lack of narrative guidance that's needed
- 46:30for things like the racket and even inherently
- 46:33Seventh Heaven. We'll talk about it next week,
- 46:35but I think that there are some situations, some
- 46:38examples within Wings where there's a few too
- 46:41many title cards, in my opinion, because there's
- 46:43more of a narration that's provided, right? It's
- 46:47not these characters kind of telling you what's
- 46:49happening with them. It's more an overview provided
- 46:53by a distant voice that's telling you what's
- 46:56happening, and that makes up a lot of those cards.
- 46:59And that's something that we didn't see with
- 47:007th Heaven and The Racket. So it does feel more
- 47:03like a story rather than like, you know, an experience
- 47:06that we're watching. Yeah. And tune in for next
- 47:09week. I don't think that some might be surprised
- 47:11what that means. I think it's effective, but
- 47:13it is a lot more of the screen time that's taken
- 47:16up by the physical title card. Yeah. Which no
- 47:19surprise makes it the longest running entrant.
- 47:22Sure. These nominations. Yeah. Yeah. I'll be
- 47:24interested to see your opinion on the use of
- 47:27title cards. You'll hear it. Cool. You'll hear
- 47:30it. Cool, cool. So what would you rate The Wreck
- 47:33then? Like I said, I had done one and a half
- 47:35stars. Felt weird about that. How long ago was
- 47:38that that you watched it and gave it that review?
- 47:40That was the first run of Once Upon a Time at
- 47:42the Oscars. So 2021, I think. Okay, so like four
- 47:46years. Yeah. Okay. First half of this movie,
- 47:49I was like, what was I thinking? There's so many
- 47:51cool things. Yeah. I need to rate this higher.
- 47:53By the end of the movie, I was like... I know
- 47:56what I was thinking. I did bump it up to two
- 47:58stars. Okay. I love the camera work in the first
- 48:03half of the movie. I really do. You can see the
- 48:06influence that it's had on later movies so clearly.
- 48:09I just wish it stuck around through the whole
- 48:12film. Yeah, I agree. You know, I think that this,
- 48:15the review system in general, and let's say we're
- 48:18going off letterboxd, right? Should be 10 stars.
- 48:22Because that allows for more nuance, right? Like
- 48:25what's bad and like what's good. So there are
- 48:28movies that I've liked far less than The Racket
- 48:32that I feel like I've given a two star where
- 48:34I was like, yeah, not for me. And maybe it's
- 48:36because I hate disappointing people. So even
- 48:39though like, you know, while I'm never going
- 48:41to see my Letterboxd review, I'm still like,
- 48:44good job, buddy. Three and a half stars. Yeah,
- 48:47yeah. Maybe I need to like be a little more like.
- 48:49cold -blooded and just be like, half star. Sorry,
- 48:52Michael Bay. But I think for this, two stars
- 48:55sounds about right. I'd probably go two and a
- 48:57half. I enjoyed myself fine. But again, I feel
- 49:01like three stars is kind of like, uh -oh. That's
- 49:04my uh -oh review of like, something's not right
- 49:06here. And I don't think that this is inherently
- 49:08wrong. There's nothing that's really wrong with
- 49:11this. It's just the lack of direction that I
- 49:14felt in the second half. And for the shortest
- 49:17entrant of these nominations, It's kind of surprising,
- 49:20right? Yeah. So a reluctant 2 .5 with the intention
- 49:24of a 3 is maybe where you can put me down. But
- 49:27that's where I think we need a 10. Not us specifically,
- 49:30but as a universe, we need the 10 star. I do
- 49:34think you're right, because a 2 sounds damning.
- 49:38Yeah. But if it's a 4, that's, you know... Participation.
- 49:42Right. You're like, good job, buddy. Yeah, yeah.
- 49:45I liked some of this. I have to think of it more
- 49:48like in the teaching aspect where like if you
- 49:49get like a 56, that's not like, hey, you're the
- 49:52worst person who's ever existed. It's like, I
- 49:54see what you're trying to do. You just didn't
- 49:55get there. Yeah. Whereas if I got a 15, it's
- 49:58like, all right, you need to just redo this altogether.
- 50:01So I need to think of it more in that style.
- 50:04And that's more on me than it is this podcast
- 50:07and our review system. But I think I've just
- 50:09been too generous. So what I mean to say is if
- 50:11you're a director out there and I've given you
- 50:13four stars. Just be on the lookout. Watch your
- 50:16back. Watch your back. A two and a half is coming.
- 50:19Yeah. All I need is one rewatch and everything
- 50:22changes. Is that not the truth? That's pretty
- 50:27much everything I have to say about The Racket.
- 50:29I do recommend it. Honestly, I'll probably recommend
- 50:32every single one of the movies we watch because
- 50:35I want people to see these. for the educational
- 50:38value of it, of understanding where we came from.
- 50:41Well, and you know, this is only our second,
- 50:43our third episode, but our second movie that
- 50:46we reviewed for this, I guess, re -entry in the
- 50:50podcast series. But it's already kind of changed
- 50:52my outlook on the way that I clearly review things,
- 50:56but also just the way that you watch these things,
- 50:58because it's not just, hey, I've heard this movie's
- 51:01good, check it out. Like, this is literal history.
- 51:04This is how we got to this point. This is how
- 51:06people... I was saying, forget it, kid, it's
- 51:10Chinatown, before I saw the movie. Because that's
- 51:13something that just lingers with you. And maybe
- 51:15not one -to -one, but this is the foundation
- 51:18of that. This is what starts that kind of concept
- 51:21that rolls into those movies. So I agree with
- 51:25you. I think inherently, these movies are all
- 51:27something that I would recommend. And I'm so
- 51:30glad that I went back to revisit these. I understand
- 51:33that we don't have enough time to talk about
- 51:35everything we want to talk about and see all
- 51:37the things we want to see. But it's important
- 51:38to make time for the things that are historical
- 51:40because, yes, I love to go to the movies and
- 51:43watch these things. And in a just world, we would
- 51:45have more historical theaters that are playing
- 51:47these movies that we can revisit. So I want to
- 51:50take a quick moment to shout out an experience
- 51:52that I actually didn't have, but you had. The
- 51:55Strand Theater for playing older movies that
- 51:57we can go back and revisit and see these things
- 51:59in real time and kind of experience history a
- 52:02bit more. So thank you to The Strand. And hopefully
- 52:05there are more theaters out there that are capable,
- 52:08not just willing, but capable of playing movies
- 52:10of this caliber so we can share those experiences
- 52:12with you guys. Yeah, that brings me to a good
- 52:15point. Talking about theaters that take the time
- 52:18and the energy and have the ability to show these
- 52:21movies. If you want to write into the show, let
- 52:23us know, like, if there is a theater by you and
- 52:26if you've ever had an experience going to see
- 52:27a classic film in a theater. And, you know, that
- 52:30can be anything as old as going to see Wings
- 52:32on the 4th of July. Or, you know, maybe you went
- 52:35and saw The Batman from 1989. I guess just Batman
- 52:38is what it would be called. Not something in
- 52:41the way of Batman. Yeah, yeah. But that's a really
- 52:45exciting experience. And I was thinking of putting
- 52:47together a list of, like, not movies you need
- 52:50to see. movie -going experiences that are important,
- 52:53like seeing a live organ or seeing a 3D movie,
- 52:57drive -in movie, that kind of stuff. And I think
- 53:00just going to see any classic movie is such a
- 53:03big deal. So if you want to write into the show
- 53:05and let us know. anything like that, but also
- 53:08your thoughts on any of the movies we're watching
- 53:10for this Academy season, shoot us an email at
- 53:13outaopodcast at gmail .com. You can also follow
- 53:17us on social media. Most of that is outaopodcast
- 53:20or Once Upon a Time at the Oscars. And check
- 53:23us out on Patreon, patreon .com slash outaopodcast.
- 53:28All of this is going to be linked in the show
- 53:29notes, but we've got some early episode content
- 53:33on Patreon. We're going to... I do a newsletter
- 53:35every month, and we're still working out some
- 53:38other things that we're going to include. But
- 53:40it should be good stuff. Yeah, it's going to
- 53:43be great. I mean, so just to touch on the thing
- 53:45you mentioned there at the end, I think that
- 53:46theatrical experiences are really important.
- 53:48And just to inspire everyone with the decisions,
- 53:51the suggestions that they can bring in or experiences
- 53:54that they've had in theaters, one of my favorite
- 53:56things that I did was... early on in the pandemic
- 54:00it was 2021 for my birthday taylor and i actually
- 54:03my wife um we rented out the strand uh theater
- 54:07uh for the two of us to watch a movie and they
- 54:09just say like if you can provide the dvd or the
- 54:12blu -ray we'll play it and i was like i'd love
- 54:16to see gremlins one of my all -time favorite
- 54:18movies But I feel like anyone's going to play
- 54:20Gremlins. I can see Gremlins in a theater without
- 54:23me having to orchestrate it easily. And that's
- 54:26true. That has happened since then. So I opted
- 54:28for the next best thing, which is why don't I
- 54:30play Gremlins the new batch, which is never going
- 54:33to happen. And I talked with the guy up front
- 54:37when we did this, and he was like, would you
- 54:39be cool if I played the key and peel sketch of
- 54:42how they made Gremlins 2 right before the movie?
- 54:46And not only is it impossible. Very unlikely,
- 54:49because I believe in a beautiful world. Very
- 54:52unlikely that someone, some theaters can be like,
- 54:54hey, here's Gremlins, the new batch. You're never
- 54:57going to find a theater that is like, by the
- 54:59way, here's a double feature with the Key & Peele
- 55:01sketch about Gremlins The New Batch. You're saying
- 55:04he suggested it. He suggested playing the YouTube
- 55:06video before the movie. So it's like, instead
- 55:10of your Pixar short in front of Pixar, you're
- 55:12getting the Key & Peele sketch about Gremlins
- 55:14The New Batch before Gremlins The New Batch.
- 55:16That's cool. And I was like, if I wasn't married,
- 55:19let's get married. That's a beautiful suggestion
- 55:22to make to me. So that's the kind of thing where
- 55:24it's like, You're never going to be able to see
- 55:26that kind of thing. Yeah. And it's goofy. And
- 55:29it's literally a Looney Tunes movie. Almost literally
- 55:32a Looney Tunes movie. But that's the glory of
- 55:34these experiences. That you have these movies
- 55:37that maybe aren't the best thing in the world.
- 55:38But they mean a lot to you. And you have that
- 55:40shared community. Yeah. And that's what I love
- 55:42about this podcast. Is we have that historical
- 55:44accuracy. And going back and revisiting these
- 55:46movies. But it's all about community. And it's
- 55:48about how these movies talk to us. And we talk
- 55:51to each other. So, to Kyle's point. Reach out
- 55:54with those experiences with your favorite things
- 55:56that you've experienced in theaters, whether
- 55:58it be something glorious like seeing Jaws at
- 56:00the fabulous Fox Theater with Mighty Moe playing
- 56:03a performance beforehand, or seeing Joe Dante's
- 56:07sequel to the Gremlins in a theater before a
- 56:10Key & Peele sketch. So write in, share us your
- 56:13experiences, and we look forward to sharing those
- 56:15on the pod in the future episodes. Yeah, and
- 56:16support your local indie theaters. Please. I
- 56:19mean, clearly, theater people or movie people.
- 56:23Love movies. Yes. And so do we. And we are theater
- 56:26people inherently. And we'll go ahead and just
- 56:28put that stake in the ground. We'll see you soon
- 56:31at the Plaza. And hopefully we'll have a screening
- 56:33within years. That'd be so cool. Of one of the
- 56:35movies that we're talking about here at a place
- 56:37like the Strand or the Plaza. Because you got
- 56:40to support your theaters, not just your AMCs
- 56:41and your Regals and your Cinemarks, but your
- 56:43local theaters because they care about these
- 56:45preservations as well. Yes. 100%. That's going
- 56:48to do it for this week's episode, though. As
- 56:51always, I'm Kyle. And I'm Ryan. And we'll see
- 56:54you at the movies.