Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Late fees debates, resenting good families, and Bob Qs
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, lightning round, what do you say, Ah, it's
- 0:03been promised before. Patron Roxy from California, She says, Hi, doctor
- 0:08Kirk, and Bob, I am opening a private practice soon and trying to
- 0:13determine my late cancelation no show fee policy. So, for those who don't
- 0:19know, what is a late cancelation no show fee policy, Bob, it's
- 0:26usually most people do twenty four hours. I do forty eight. My therapist
- 0:29is seventy two. It's if you no show or cancel inside whatever the window
- 0:34is, you have to pay the fee, the full fee, the full
- 0:38fee, right, Some people I think will charge a lower figure half fee
- 0:43or some Yeah, I don't do that. And your policy is what forty
- 0:46eight hours toll fee? Traditionally it was twenty four yep, But eventually people
- 0:51are like, well that's not really enough time to slot someone else in or
- 0:58figure out some other thing to do with your work day. We had a
- 1:00couple therapists for her it was seven days. Yeah, which makes more sense
- 1:03to me. It does. Practically speaking, a therapist can't do anything with
- 1:08twenty four hours of time, or even two days isn't enough. Yeah.
- 1:12Yeah. Now my policy is I think forty eight hours. I'm not sure.
- 1:18It's been a while since I've looked at it, but the principle that
- 1:23I follow is that if there's a viable excuse, which there usually is,
- 1:26then I don't charge people. If it's like they're sick or their kid is
- 1:32in the hospital or something like that, it's like, well, you didn't
- 1:38mean for that to happen, and it's pretty rare that those kinds of things
- 1:42will happen, So no harm, no foul. I would feel bad to
- 1:45charge. Having said that, if a therapist wants to charge, I'm totally
- 1:49supportive of that. Yeah, because it's your business and it sucks. But
- 1:55you know, it's sort of like if you buy a vase from a store
- 2:01and you take it home and you drop it, or there's an earthquake maybe
- 2:06that's a better example, and the vase falls down and breaks. You could
- 2:10understand a store saying I'm not going to give you your money back. I'm
- 2:14sorry, it's not your fault that the vase broke, but I will lose
- 2:19too much money if I allow these kinds of refunds, right, And I'm
- 2:23you know, that's just kind of the risks that you take when you do
- 2:27that, And so when you make an appointment, you're kind of taking a
- 2:29risk of like if some act of God causes me not to have the ability
- 2:35to come disappointment, I'm accepting that risk that I still have to pay for
- 2:38that because this individual's in you know, private practice, they are their whole
- 2:47family depends on this income. And so, you know, like the broken
- 2:52vase, it's like, I'd go out of business if I if I just
- 2:54refunded people like that. But I don't. I just you know, I've
- 3:00had the luxury or the I don't know, the guilt or something to just
- 3:05let it go. And if a client makes a mistake regarding like scheduling,
- 3:12like if they say, oh my god, I'm so sorry I forgot or
- 3:15oh my god, I double booked myself, then I also will not charge
- 3:22them the first time just out of guilt. It's not okay, I tell
- 3:27my superviss, don't be like, don't be like me, don't do what
- 3:30I do. It's like, you know, Mama, don't let your kids
- 3:36grow up to be cowboys. What's that's that song? I think that's that
- 3:39song. Yeah, isn't that like a song from a cowboy to his girlfriend
- 3:46or wife or someone I don't know. I barely know the line, and
- 3:50it's like, don't let your boys grow up to be like me. That's
- 3:53the point. So that's what I'm saying to my supervis e's and then but
- 4:00I also say, but if it happens again, then I'll have to charge
- 4:04you. Yeah, And then when I charge them the second time, then
- 4:10I don't feel guilty about it or anything. I always give everybody the first
- 4:13one free, even if it's very good, even if it's you know,
- 4:17I would otherwise charge. I will say to everybody, you get the first
- 4:21one free. And the reason for that is so that you tell them upfront.
- 4:25Oh, I tell them when it happens like I don't tell anybody this,
- 4:28but everybody gets the first one free, and the reason for that is
- 4:30to orient and to create goodwill. There are times when I don't charge either
- 4:36though I think that one shouldn't have a policy around that. One should be
- 4:40mindful and careful because you can break the frame and you can make life worse
- 4:45for both you and the client by not holding to what you say you're going
- 4:48to do. That could be destabilizing for people. So depending on you know,
- 4:53it's important to not be an asshole, but there's nothing wrong with having
- 4:57a boundary right. Also, in my experience, therapists that break that frame
- 5:04out of guilt in particular, will resent their clients eventually, Yes, nicket
- 5:11and be upset and burn out, and that's not a good thing for any
- 5:16client. Right. So there's that if it's guilt you're looking at, the
- 5:20flip side is going to be resentment at some point, and it is not
- 5:24worth it. I mean the fee, it's yeah, I guess you could
- 5:28say, oh, that's a lot of money. I mean I charged two
- 5:30sixty five for couples. Yeah, but it's also not that much money,
- 5:34yeah, to a seattleite I suppose. Also, it's not covered by insurance.
- 5:44So for those that use insurance like I used to, if they came
- 5:48to an appointment, their cope was twenty bucks. If they didn't come to
- 5:54an appointment, then I can't build their insurance. You cannot. So they
- 5:59have to not only pay what the insurance read it would reimburse me, but
- 6:02my full fee, which is often more, oh usually than So they don't
- 6:08pay me the twenty dollars copay as if they missed it, they have to
- 6:11pay a fee that they are not even used to paying normally, you know
- 6:15what I mean. So there's that. Having said that, I have almost
- 6:19never had a client that pushed back on this. If anything, clients are
- 6:27tripping over themselves to apologize and are very quick to say and I've already you
- 6:32the money and all this kind of stuff, and I'm like, oh,
- 6:34okay, cool, let's reschedule, you know, like I with the clients
- 6:41that I've worked with, it's it's always totally. If anything, I'm saying,
- 6:45oh no, no, no, don't know. I mean, your
- 6:47kid is sick in the hospital, don't please, do not worry about it.
- 6:50Everything we're good. So anyway, getting back to Roxy's question, the
- 6:58so she's saying she's opening a pride practice and just trying to determine our policy.
- 7:02The standard I've learned since grad school is that we should charge these fees,
- 7:06largely in the name of modeling boundaries. So what do you think about
- 7:12that modeling boundaries? Well, the way it's certain here sounds like that's some
- 7:15kind of bogus thing, but actually it's both therapeutically sound and personally sound.
- 7:23You should have boundaries. You should have boundaries like if you don't have boundaries,
- 7:27What the hell are you doing? Yeah, I mean not helpful.
- 7:29It depends on what's happening in the circumstance and what's being communicated in the overall
- 7:36frame. Right, if this is the only part of the frame that is
- 7:41being played around with. But often if you're weird about this boundary, particularly
- 7:47if you have a hard policy that you don't follow when push comes to show,
- 7:54Yeah, and it's out of your own guilt or enmeshments or inadequacy or
- 8:00apologizing for your therapy or something, then in all likelihood, you're going to
- 8:05break the frame in other ways, like you're going to become overly desperate if
- 8:11the client seems to not be changing very quickly. More, if the client
- 8:18wants to go over in a session or something like that, you know,
- 8:22or they want to meet you at the Starbucks instead of come to your office
- 8:24or whatever. If you start breaking one boundary, then research shows that you'll
- 8:33start breaking others and it could result in some bad things for the clients and
- 8:35you. So there's that going on. But I've been seeing more and more
- 8:41folks in my therapist Facebook groups making excellent arguments for completely doing away with cancelation
- 8:48charges since they see it as a compassionate thing to do. I'm curious what
- 8:54your thoughts are to charge or not to charge, Bob, what do you
- 8:58think. I don't think that's as rigid as charging. Not doing it is
- 9:03as rigid as doing it. So, like most things, rigidity is not
- 9:07going to work. Let's not presume that because I think I'm being nice that
- 9:11that's actually compassion. It could just be guilt. It could be you know,
- 9:16how many therapists have you trained that felt bad about charging a fee?
- 9:20All of them? Yeah, well, shit, that's a that's quite a
- 9:26statistic. Yeah. Therapists are you know, lovely carrying, non greedy people,
- 9:33and none of them are excited about even charging clients, let alone charging
- 9:39them for no sessions. I'm usually telling my supervisors to allow themselves to consider
- 9:48this a money making venture and that they deserve to be fucking paid in the
- 9:54same way that a dentist or a surgeon deserves to be paid. Right,
- 9:58well, you deserve to be paid and Maista and Starbucks, but particularly a
- 10:03clinician who's been through a shit ton of of annoying graduate school to get to
- 10:09where you are, you deserve to be compensated at the very least to live
- 10:15comfortably while you pay off your student loans and you don't have to, you
- 10:20know. And the problem is is there's a lot of this sounds funny,
- 10:26but wait until I finish this sentence. It's made worse because a lot of
- 10:33therapists are women, Comma, because women are socialized to be self sacrificial,
- 10:39and given our current landscape regarding economic awareness of oppression and hardship for people,
- 10:48it creates this conundrum. And you know, yeah, we all should think
- 10:54about oppression and unfairness and how so many people are just a paycheck away from
- 11:03not having a home or not being able to feed their kids or whatever.
- 11:07That is not okay. And when someone comes to us and they can't afford
- 11:13us, and we're loving, aware people, what do we do with that?
- 11:22Well, what I tell people, particularly novice therapists, is it's not
- 11:26your fucking fault that our society is the way that it is. And if
- 11:31anyone should be pulling up the slack, it's seasoned therapists. They're the ones
- 11:37that have paid off their student loans and have paid off half their mortgage and
- 11:41have the privilege and the space to do pro bono services or to give back
- 11:48or whatever. Not People directly out of graduate school that are still eating top
- 11:54ramen and are in debt like one hundred and twenty thousand dollars and slowly going
- 11:58in more debt because of the interest rate on it, and have a couch
- 12:03that they were donated from their uncle who put the couch out on the street.
- 12:11And you said, hey, that's a couch. I mean this is
- 12:13me and you when we graduated from graduate school. So yeah, it sucks,
- 12:20but it's not your fault and it's not your responsibility to make up for
- 12:26the deficits of the economic disparities in our society. If you want to,
- 12:31then great. But I've never felt guilty about being able to pay my bills
- 12:37because I work hard in this career and I want others, and particularly women
- 12:43to feel that way. And I have to give them a fair amount of
- 12:48pep talking to be able to. And the problem is is that a lot
- 12:52of these novice therapists have been told by professors and supervisors that it's the opposite
- 13:01that they're supposed to be focusing on. There are professors and supervisors that will
- 13:05say it's unethical to start a private practice right out of graduate school because you're
- 13:13not going to be serving lower income people in private practice because that because typically
- 13:20in private practice, clients with money are the only people that are going to
- 13:22be able to afford to show. Low income people are at agencies, right,
- 13:26And so that's the choice typically is do I work at an agency after
- 13:30graduation or do I go into private practice. And so these professors are telling
- 13:33them that it's wrong to go into private practice directly after graduate school. It's
- 13:39a little bit of hubris to tell people what they should do. Yeah.
- 13:43Also they'll say that you're not ready for private practice because you need more time
- 13:50postgrad. That makes no sense. Why does it make no sense? Because
- 13:52if you're not ready for private practice, how the fuck could you possibly be
- 13:56ready for an agency job. If anything, I began to see people who
- 14:00are have are more difficult to work with, not that they're because of the
- 14:05troubles that they bring. Yeah, multi problem families, that's what we call
- 14:07them, meaning that they have problems coming at them from a lot of directions.
- 14:13And Yeah, there's a hidden prejudice and classism in that of like,
- 14:22well, you're not a good therapist, so you should work with the low
- 14:24income people first, because they don't deserve good therapists or something. Now,
- 14:31do we have a problem here. We do. Low income people, and
- 14:35particularly people who are just above low income, who don't qualify for welfare services,
- 14:43are being underserved. They can't one they might not even have a therapist
- 14:48that's available, but particularly they can't choose a therapist to find a good one
- 14:54that is a good fit, or they have to deal with a lot of
- 14:58people that are very very green to the profession and have yet to learn a
- 15:03lot. And that's a problem. But that's not my fault. And I'm
- 15:09doing everything that I can to advocate otherwise and to vote otherwise, and to
- 15:11advocate for raising taxes and allocating that money. But I'm not gonna, you
- 15:18know, live paycheck to paycheck because the system is fucking people over, you
- 15:22know what I mean. That's not my fault. If I wanted to,
- 15:28and as I gained privilege and power, I started giving back by taking on
- 15:33pro bono clients, clients that wouldn't be able to afford any therapy otherwise.
- 15:39But I only did that once I was out of the woods regarding finances,
- 15:43you know. So, so I think that this notion of like not charging
- 15:50late fees is sort of in that camp. It's like, if you support
- 15:56you know, in these Facebook groups, if you support charging people, it
- 16:00only takes one person to say, like, well, what about people who
- 16:03are struggling monetarily, Like you're going to charge those people? That is classists,
- 16:10that is participating in the capitalistic oppression of the underclass. There's not going
- 16:15to be many people on Facebook that are going to say that's not how I
- 16:19see it, and why is that my fault? You're going to see a
- 16:25lot of up votes, and it's a good point, and let's talk about
- 16:29it. But what's the solution? Is the thing? Well, the problem
- 16:32is rigid. It's a one size fits all opinion opinion that just silly.
- 16:42I mean silly to be rigid. So yeah, my opinion. Whoever was
- 16:48their name, Roxy, Roxy, you shouldn't do that. Roxy, you
- 16:52should you should come up with a policy that fits for you. But it
- 16:57shouldn't be I don't think it should be rigid on either end. And the
- 17:03justification what Roxy is exhibiting is very This is the last point I'll make about
- 17:11this, is that Roxy is providing that dichotomy that I often hear, which
- 17:18is you're either a capitalistic a pressor or you need to model boundaries, you
- 17:27need to like provide therapy through this policy, you know what I mean.
- 17:33They'll say it's it's harming the client by not charging them that you know,
- 17:37that's what you'll hear, right, you know what I mean, because that's
- 17:41essentially and that's a valid point that you could bring up. But to me,
- 17:48it's totally fine to just admit to ourselves that we don't like losing money.
- 17:53Yeah, when we allocate an appointment time one o'clock on a Wednesday,
- 18:00and we're charging one hundred and fifty dollars and depending on that revenue to pay
- 18:07for the taxes and the all the you know, the office and the graduate
- 18:11school and my own bills, and someone no shows or they late cancel,
- 18:18that client is essentially taking one hundred and fifty dollars out of my business account.
- 18:22And I don't want that to happen, and I don't deserve that to
- 18:26happen. And they could have called me forty eight hours ago, or they
- 18:30could have contacted me last week, or they could have managed their life better,
- 18:36or even if it was an act of God, like an earthquake or
- 18:38their kid gets sick or something. Yeah, it sucks, and I have
- 18:42bills to pay. It's okay to admit that I don't understand why therapists have
- 18:49such a hard time. You ask a dry cleaner owner, or a restaurant
- 18:55owner, or a car lot owner, or I don't know, Bill Gates.
- 19:00You ask these people, why do you charge money for your product?
- 19:07They're like, well, because I want money? Is that? Why would
- 19:12I Why would I just volunteer my time to give people things and therefore not
- 19:22be able to live a life where I can actually function as a person in
- 19:26a capitalistic republic of our society. You know, Like I like money.
- 19:33Money buys shit, and I want to save money for a retirement. I
- 19:38want to buy a car that isn't constantly breaking down. I want to buy
- 19:45a condo that's in a neighborhood that I feel safe to walk to the store.
- 19:51I want to buy better shoes. I want to have faster internet.
- 19:57Or I want to go to the movies and not have to worry about buying
- 20:03popcorn. Oh my god, I went to the movies with my family the
- 20:08other day and got popcorn and drinks, and it was like fifty five bucks
- 20:12or something many of these three people? Three people? Yeah, and there's
- 20:18fifty five dollars for snacks. Yeah, something like that. I mean,
- 20:21I don't quote me on that, but it was I was. I was
- 20:25like, whoa, it was outrageous? What it Wow? How was your
- 20:29popcorn? It was good? Yeah? Yeah? Is that Kung Fu panafoor?
- 20:33Worth a watch? Not as good as the other three in my opinion,
- 20:37but you know, as seven out of ten. And it's okay as
- 20:42a therapist and as a woman to say you like money, Yeah, you
- 20:48like getting paid for your career. But because of our sexist society and because
- 20:53of our all or nothing, bleeding heart culture in our industry, it's like
- 21:00we can't admit that to ourselves. We have to say, well, it's
- 21:02bad for the client if we don't charge them. Okay, maybe, but
- 21:07also you deserve to get paid at work. It's bad for me if I
- 21:10don't charge them, Right, it's bad for me. Can't you say it's
- 21:14bad for me? Yeah? To tie everything to compassion and then you know,
- 21:21and then people can say, well, it's mean to charge people.
- 21:23It's like, no, it's not. Do you say that a McDonald's it's
- 21:27mean to charge for a big mac. It's it's the way it works.
- 21:33It's the way our society works. You can have a complaint about our society
- 21:37and about the system. You could say we should have a different system,
- 21:41for sure, but if an individual is trying to exist within a system that
- 21:45they can't change, then you can't blame them for the system. It's take
- 21:48a break, Yep, let's do an opp Bob. These are all people
- 21:57that became patrons in late twenty one. They are middle tier patrons, all
- 22:03from the United States. We have Kerrie from Bella Vista, Arkansas. Ar
- 22:10Right, that's Arkansas because Arizona is Azyz so Bella Vista, Arkansas. Elizabeth
- 22:17from Phoenix, Arizona, Kit from San Diego, Mary from Panorama City,
- 22:23California, or Mariy Megan from Hermosa Beach, California, and Nikki from Jacksonville,
- 22:29Florida. Seth from Atlanta, Georgia, Carla from Woodstock, Georgia,
- 22:33Laura from Lilburn, Georgiamarra from Pekin, Illinois, Melanie from Cambridge, mass
- 22:44A, Moon from Jersey City, New Jersey, Joe from Albuquerque, Rebecca
- 22:48from Columbus, Ohio, Dana from Providence, Rhode Island. Anna from Sioux
- 22:52Falls, San South Dakota, Zana from Hurst, Texas, Sam from Fort
- 22:59Worth, Texas, Julia from Leyton, Utah, Kayleen from Olympia, Washington,
- 23:04Susan from Tacoma, Washington, Nancy from Seattle, Washington, wo Chiara
- 23:10from Brookline, Mass And from God knows where we have Heather Earth and Laura.
- 23:17Laura, thank you so much for becoming a patron and staying a patron
- 23:21this whole time. So let's read an email, Bob. This is from
- 23:26an honest patron. She says, I want to express my deep gratitude for
- 23:30the empathy and consideration you bring to discussions on disordered attachment styles and personality disorders
- 23:37in your podcast. Though I've been estranged from my parents for three years,
- 23:41having a partner with a close knit family brings mixed emotions. So she's saying,
- 23:48I've been a strange for my parents for three years, so probably a
- 23:52lifetime of difficulty with her parents, and she has a partner in a close
- 23:56knit family and that causes her to have mixed emotions. While their warmth and
- 24:03their family is comforting, it sometimes stirs both joy and grief, highlighting the
- 24:08stark contrast form my own family. When I express my feelings of loneliness to
- 24:12my partner, it seems to imply an adequacy on their part. I think
- 24:18that they feel blamed or something, and articulating the desire for loving parents to
- 24:22my partner can feel draining on my partner. The intensity of this pain reaches
- 24:29a point where when I attempt to share it with my partner now, I
- 24:32often become nonverbal, shutting down and struggling to continue speaking. The struggle to
- 24:37verbalize my feelings impedes my ability to request the love and it to be see
- 24:41that I seek. How does one convey this kind of grief and plead for
- 24:45love? Bob? What do you think it is it necessary to talk about
- 24:51your grief in your requests for care and attention from your sweetheart? Does it
- 24:56have to be that way? I'm not sure it does. It sounds like
- 25:03pretty garden variety envy, you know, like they have something that you wish
- 25:07you had. So, yeah, of course you feel that way. What's
- 25:11the so I just I just keep coming back to the same thing, which
- 25:14is, what's the purpose of talking about your history or your pain? If
- 25:21what you want is, you know, for them to hug you or give
- 25:25you a kiss, or make love with you, or care about you,
- 25:29or listen to you talk about your day or whatever it is that you know,
- 25:32all that normal stuff that you know humans partners ask of one another.
- 25:37What makes it important to preface it with the fact that you were traumatized or
- 25:42abused or neglected or or or that you're saying just ask directly? Yeah,
- 25:48why not? Now listen. I'm not saying that's easy. I'm saying it's
- 25:55possible, and perhaps it would help you to what you want, what you
- 26:00actually want, and maybe spare your partner whatever comes up for them. On
- 26:06the other hand, you could always just talk about that too. You could
- 26:10always just talk about with your partner, what's it like when I tell you
- 26:14about because you know they deserve careen too, Just just they had a different
- 26:18experience. Does it mean that they don't want or deserve your care and love
- 26:22around whatever comes up for them whenever they come in contact with what you should
- 26:30have had that didn't you didn't have. So I'm sure that's no picnic.
- 26:33Yeah, yeah, yeah, I've heard this before because I have one of
- 26:40those semi ideal families. And people will tell me that they have that feeling
- 26:48when they learn about this. In fact, when I made the episodes with
- 26:53my parents, a lot of people emailed in or commented on YouTube saying that
- 26:59they had those mixed emotions. On one hand, it's like very endearing and
- 27:03it's nice to know that good families are out there where parents truly care about
- 27:11their kids, and intellectually they know that, but they don't often see it
- 27:15firsthand. So it felt good and heartwarming and optimistic and those things. And
- 27:23at the same time, they would feel an upwelling of pain because they're contrasting
- 27:30their own childhood with mine, and that's totally understandable. Now you're asking,
- 27:40how, anonymous patron, how to talk about this with your partner, and
- 27:44it's known to me what the dynamic is, So let me throw a lot
- 27:49of things at the wall. One simple possibility is that your partner feels responsible
- 27:56when you are experiencing something negative, and that needs to be addressed because if
- 28:03every time you're having a negative experience, that could be solved by him or
- 28:10her them listening to you, and instead they have an anxiety reaction and try
- 28:17to snuff it out or reject it. Or something. Then that's not going
- 28:22to go well, and so I don't know. If that's the case,
- 28:27then I wouldn't know how to get out of that, but couple therapy can
- 28:30help with that. It also could be that when you are presenting your feelings
- 28:37to your partner, you might be coming across in a hostile manner, like
- 28:45you might say, wow, your family sure does communicate often, and in
- 28:52your heart, you're grieving the fact that you didn't have that closeness and you
- 28:59wish you did, and it's coming out though as hostile and judgmental and critical.
- 29:07You're not saying that in your email. There's no evidence of that,
- 29:11But that's another thing to kind of look at. But the thing that I
- 29:15would say generally to my partner if I was experiencing this is something like,
- 29:23Hey, you know, there's been this dynamic going back and forth for a
- 29:27while. I just want to tell you what's going on for me is that
- 29:33you know, I grew up with not great parents and it has had a
- 29:41lot of effects on me and it makes me very sad. And you have
- 29:45been raised by parents that are really good and you're really close and I'm really
- 29:51happy for you for that and this is not your fault, but when I
- 29:59see it, it reminds me of how shitty my childhood was, and I
- 30:03feel sad. Sometimes your family isn't quote unquote making me feel sad, but
- 30:11it's just a reminder of how shitty I had it. And when I have
- 30:18those feelings, it's not your fault, of obviously, but it's my parent's
- 30:25fault. It's their fucking fault. And when I have those feelings that are
- 30:32always there, by the way, they just become more felt when I'm in
- 30:36this state. All I'm looking for from you is that you just understand that's
- 30:42it. There's no fix. We can't go back in time. I certainly
- 30:48don't want you to feel guilty for having a good family. I just when
- 30:55I have those feelings, all I'm looking for is what my parents really never
- 30:59gave me, which is just someone that listens to me and understands. And
- 31:02that's all I'm looking for, you know, There's just all you gotta do
- 31:07is say, yeah, that sucks, I'm so sorry, honey, and
- 31:10hug me or something. You know that that'll I'll probably have this feeling for
- 31:15the rest of our life together. So it just it's the it's a package
- 31:19deal. The other thing I'll say, anonymous patron, is I don't know
- 31:25if you're doing this, but a solution overall is to adopt them and have
- 31:30them adopt you. You know, you can start anew into the from now,
- 31:36moving into the future. So yeah, you can ask for that.
- 31:41I don't know if they'll give it. Sounds like they would, but you
- 31:45deserve it. Yeah, all right, just take a break, we get
- 31:47back, let's finish this episode. What do you say? Yeah, all
- 31:55right? Or back from the break, let's do another opp Oh there are
- 31:57no more opps. I've run out of opps on my list. How did
- 32:04that happen? Well, I need to update the list. That's how it
- 32:07happened. What it might mean is that we've done all the twenty twenty one
- 32:13people. So you're coming to the end of the pandemic. Then in your
- 32:16opps right twenty twenty two? Right spring, Yeah, and I think maybe
- 32:21most of our patrons signed up pre twenty twenty two. I'm not sure about
- 32:27that, but I was an early adopter. But another thing, Bob,
- 32:32Yeah, let's get to the emails. Oh yeah, I'm all out of
- 32:36emails. What yeah, what are we going to talk about. I'm just
- 32:38going to ask you random questions. Oh, all right. Do you have
- 32:42a favorite flower tulips? Do you have a favorite like soda? Diet coke?
- 32:47Why? Because it's not sugary, yeah, regular sugar like coke.
- 32:52Have you always liked die coke? No? No, no, I like
- 32:53coke, but I can't drink it anymore because it's too sweet. If you're
- 32:57drinking enough diet coke, you can't go back to coke. It's the one
- 33:00door. Sorry, it just can't be done. What about DIEPEPSI nobody has
- 33:04that, so I never buy it. I don't know. Is it any
- 33:07good? I mean it's different. What about coke zero? No? No,
- 33:12no, I've had that coke zero no gross. In France they call
- 33:16it Coke Light, Tye, Coke Coke Light, Coke Max. Sometimes I'll
- 33:21see that places Coke Max. What's your favorite season? Spring? Why?
- 33:28I like the the green comes back and the leaves and the flowers start coming,
- 33:31and the birds and the squirrels and all that. I mean, they're
- 33:34there in my house all the year around, because Colin is a very good
- 33:37steward of the birds and squirrels. But spring, because it's like hope,
- 33:43but not summer. No, summer's good. But if I had to have
- 33:45a favorite, it's it's that transition from the winter. Seattle can be pretty
- 33:51dreary in the spring. It's been a crap spring this year. No,
- 33:54we had like two or three weeks where it was like really nice weather.
- 33:58It's been really cold and rainy, and my memorily goes back two weeks maybe,
- 34:04So it's always cold and rainy in the spring. And see, I
- 34:07always expect that. I always say fifty one degrees an overcast until July one.
- 34:13Yeah, and then when you get a nice day, they're like,
- 34:15oh, that's that's a change of place. Well, when we have the
- 34:19nice days, they are they're really deluxe. Yeah. Yeah. Do you
- 34:22miss the East Coast in general? Yeah? For anything? Oh uh No.
- 34:30The spring in the East Coast and the fall in the East Coast is
- 34:32fantastic. Like I like the fall here too, but the fall on the
- 34:37East Coast is this explosion of color and it's really wonderful. And I have
- 34:42nostalgia for Penn State and that part of the world, and I have nostalgia
- 34:45for wille Grove. Though my mom don't live in our grown up house no
- 34:47more, and so I don't know if I'll ever go back to my grown
- 34:51up house, even though she still owns it. She's in a memory care
- 34:57place, and you know, she's never gone back to that house, so
- 35:00I'm not sure I ever will either. So the last time we were there
- 35:02was last Thanksgiving, and I, you know, I was like, yeah,
- 35:07I guess it's all right with me to let this go. I don't
- 35:10have attachment to the place anymore, though sometimes I'm nostalgic for the places I
- 35:15was when I was growing up, the places I lived, and the you
- 35:19know, the experiences that I had. And a couple of years ago,
- 35:23I went back to the psych hospital where I cut my teeth, and you
- 35:28know, you can't go in, but it's this, it's this big old
- 35:31farm. You can fake a mental illness. I could, I could,
- 35:35but I worked on the children's unit and I couldn't fake a kid's mental illness.
- 35:43But it's beautiful there, and you know, being in a place reminds
- 35:46you of what it is, and that was really cool. And I worked
- 35:50at a runaway shelter and I knocked on the door and it's now, Oh,
- 35:54you did a whole kind of circuit. Yeah, I did like a
- 35:58tour of my place and really fun to do. And they wouldn't let me
- 36:06into the runaway shelter because it's not a runaway shelter anymore and there's hipper rules
- 36:09and it's now it's a group home for girls for you know, teens.
- 36:15And I was like, oh, yeah, I get it, I get
- 36:17while you're Yes, of course I go. But it's just a house on
- 36:21a street in State College and it's not special, except it's special to me
- 36:27because that was where I worked when I first got out of college, and
- 36:30I like that town quite a bit. If I was going to live somewhere
- 36:32in the East Coast, I just live in State College because I just like
- 36:36it there. And yeah, so but other than that, no, I
- 36:39don't really miss food East Coast. Miss Well, cheese steaks are really good.
- 36:45You can't eat those every day, but yes I do. I like
- 36:47a cheese steak. Yeah, yeah, and you haven't found a good one
- 36:50out here, Colleen member super Bowl, Oh she made good cheese steaks.
- 36:54Well, you had like a variety, right, there was like choices,
- 36:59I remember, don't I don't know. I got the roles from a place
- 37:02in down Rainier Valley that gets their roles from Philadelphia. Oh, bread makes
- 37:09good, bread makes a good sandwich. Yeah, yeah, so they were.
- 37:14They were pretty deluxe. Some of the pizza there is really good.
- 37:17Mmm. No, but you know not really. No. I wasn't much
- 37:22interested in food when I was a kid. What do you want to do
- 37:25before you die? What I want to do before I die? What I
- 37:30want to do before I die? I could finish my book. Yeah.
- 37:36I like to have my house paid off. It'd be nice to be out
- 37:39of debt, like, really out of debt. I've been out of debt
- 37:42since I was a kid. I don't think people consider mortgage debt. I
- 37:45consider it debt. I know it's dumb to do that, but I do.
- 37:50I consider it debt, and I look forward to the day when it's
- 37:52not on me anymore. Yeah, I guess. Uh. Yeah, are
- 38:00modest ambitions? Yeah? Is there a sex position you want to try before
- 38:05you die? I like to do them all again, every single one?
- 38:10Well why not? I mean, actually they're getting some cardiovascular shape. Sex
- 38:15is work, man, I mean, have you seen the Of course you've
- 38:17seen the Kama Sutra because you made your own pop. I did book yep,
- 38:22yep. Yeah. So yeah, there's a lot of stuff in there
- 38:24that's you wanna try all of them extracurricular. I don't want to do that
- 38:29swing thing, you know, like that that's okay, I don't need that,
- 38:31okay, yeah yeah, but like the standing ones and the standing ones
- 38:37are hard. Have you noticed that. It's like it's really hard on the
- 38:39legs, and my knees are not what they used to be. Yeah.
- 38:44I just got knee pads the other day that are like roller skates for Khama
- 38:47Sutra. No, no, for my garage. But they have wheels,
- 38:55yeah, garage sutra. Yeah, yeah, they have wheels on it so
- 39:00that she can roll around on your knees. And because it's hard for me
- 39:02to get up when once I get down there, and it's too hard to
- 39:06not have some pad on mine. And so anyways, they're like, well
- 39:09dual use. Yeah, they don't roll good on carpet, is what I'm
- 39:14told. So you know, yeah, yeah, when you first open your
- 39:20eyes in the morning, what do you think? I think I gotta turn
- 39:27on the hot water recirculation system. So I haven't an app on my phone
- 39:35that does that for oh inst hot water. Yeah, well for you.
- 39:40Yeah, when you shower. Yeah, and then you shower right away,
- 39:45brush my teeth, do my water pick pretty good about that shave, and
- 39:50then I'll shower you. Because you're a night sweater. Oh yeah, I
- 39:55can be at times. Mostly I'm just for restless and I toss and turn.
- 39:59I'm not I don't actually sweat much anymore, but I like you just
- 40:01hop out of bed and walk to the shower pretty much most every day.
- 40:06That's my wake up routine. And if I don't take a shower often,
- 40:09I don't feel like I ever really wake up. Yeah, and you have
- 40:14a coffee every day. Yeah, Colleen makes my coffee. She's my personal
- 40:17barista. And what kind of coffee is it? It's a vanilla latte,
- 40:22vanilla latte. Yeah. Yeah. Espresso machine, yeah, like an actual
- 40:29like a real espresso machine. You have to tamp though, yeah. Yeah.
- 40:34Yeah. She's gotten really good and I can do it for myself when
- 40:37I have to. I have to do this weekend because I got to get
- 40:38up early for a training and that's too early, you know, seven o'clock
- 40:42too early for Colleen. So I'll make my own butt. I don't do
- 40:45as good a job you used to go to Starbucks every day, used to,
- 40:50but you don't anymore. Now she makes me a sixteen ounce latte every
- 40:54day. Do you miss going to Starbucks? No, My Starbucks is different
- 41:00now. It doesn't have seating anymore, like start, and they actually shrunk
- 41:05the store because since they don't have seating, they don't need the floor space.
- 41:07So it's really a pickup joint. Like you just go and you pick
- 41:10up your coffee and you go. You don't stay. I thought you meant
- 41:14like a pickup joint for dating. It was probably more a pickup joint for
- 41:17dating back when they had seating. Now it's just getting it out because we
- 41:21used to call them that, like before we call them. I'm just reminded
- 41:24that before we call them meat markets, you know, like a club where
- 41:30you meet people. It's expected me. It wasn't the meat et market that
- 41:37we call them pickup joints. Pick up joints. Yeah, yeah, yeah
- 41:42uh. And then you take a shower, yeah, and then what do
- 41:47you do? Put some clothing on and check my email and most days go
- 41:53to work. Do you respond to emails? You probably don't get very many
- 41:58emails compared to other people. How many do you get Well, I don't
- 42:02know. I mean, I get a lot of work emails, but I'm
- 42:07just guessing that the average person wakes up in the morning and there's like twenty
- 42:12five emails. Oh five, Yeah, yeah, what sort of emails do
- 42:15you get? I get one from you if you publish new content or on
- 42:19Tuesdays, the tougher bluff. Oh, I get one from Rex Krueger.
- 42:22So you get notifications from Patreon. Yeah, yeah, I get one from
- 42:28the EFT group. There's like a list serve, and they don't call a
- 42:32list serve. They called it, so I don't know what they call it.
- 42:35I never read it. And I get emails from clients, either prospective
- 42:42or current. That's that's pretty much it. Oh and I have two emails.
- 42:47I have a Yahoo and then one for my practice, and the Yahoo
- 42:51one gets all the business stuff. And I do get a lot of those,
- 42:53you know, like Netflix published a new thing or oh you get email
- 43:00to register things, and then you know, I get a lot of political
- 43:02emails like Nancy Pelosi blah blah blah. I don't read those things, not
- 43:07really from anybody. But yeah, if you want to email Bob, email
- 43:10us through the website and then you can all forward. Stacy will forward it
- 43:16to you. And by the way I updated or I have been updating the
- 43:22website, it's not drastically different, but it's better, so I should look
- 43:30at it. Yeah, I mean I spend a lot of time composing and
- 43:37choosing pictures for two pages. One is about the podcast and the other is
- 43:43about me. So you are in both of those. You should read those,
- 43:49yeah, I should. Yeah. It was interesting, you know because
- 43:53the website people that I was working with, Joscelyn in particular, was saying
- 44:01that I needed to have something like that, and so she was telling me
- 44:07to write a summary of me in my life or something like a like a
- 44:12bioe like a yeah, but longer than your typical like little blurb, you
- 44:15know. Oh, and I sent it to her. I spent a lot
- 44:20of time writing that sucker, and I sent it to her. She's like,
- 44:23yeah, it's got to be shorter, and so I was like,
- 44:25oh, okay. So I tried to refine it and send it. She's
- 44:30like, yeah, should be shorter. I was like, crap, okay.
- 44:35So I kept you know, like inducing and reducing and so. But
- 44:40it also made me think, well, what's the most important things I should
- 44:45be saying, and that's good. What do I want to What can't I
- 44:50edit out? You know? What? What are what's? What are things
- 44:53that I will say? I can't edit that bit out, you know?
- 44:58And I revised it several times because I'm not a natural writer, but I
- 45:04do. I think eventually get to a written piece that is getting the point
- 45:12across in a semi fluid and maybe slightly interesting way. But I don't get
- 45:17there immediately. I have to like read it like a month later and go
- 45:22like, yeah, I don't that's so funny. That sounds like every writer.
- 45:25Yeah, well, I think writers like you. It's much faster and
- 45:30the end result is better. But I don't know if that's true. I
- 45:35mean, I'm I can communicate, Yeah you can. I read your book,
- 45:38but it's not well written. Is that it's not like literature or something?
- 45:45You know? I don't. I don't have that skill. But anyway,
- 45:51so you can go to the you go to the website and check those
- 45:54things out. Does that have a link to buy your book? Uh,
- 45:58there's a page with link that should have there. But all you got to
- 46:01do is just google my name on Amazon and the book will come up and
- 46:08it still sells that book every month. Handful of people buy that book.
- 46:14That's fantastic. It's a really good book. It's very strange to me because
- 46:17I don't talk about it no much, if at all. Do you know
- 46:22who? You? Who? Your I don't Customers are, I don't know.
- 46:24I don't know who's buying it. Podcasters maybe podcast listeners. Well it's
- 46:30a supervision book, so oh listeners. Yeah. I always assume it's got
- 46:37to be Why would anyone else buy my book? But my fantasy is that
- 46:43it's being assigned in supervision classes. That's what I was thinking, classes on
- 46:49how to be a supervisor or a new supervisor is looking for guidance. There's
- 46:53a number of books out there that are pretty good, but my book's different
- 46:58because it's of a different style. It's more of the style of like a
- 47:04yallam style where I'm talking about myself and experiences. But I also am really
- 47:10buttoned up regarding research in that fucker. Do you have to do a new
- 47:15addition at some point, have to well, you know, update it for
- 47:21research wise? No, I mean the principles and observations of supervision. It's
- 47:29not one of those things. That's going to change with technology or anything.
- 47:31I mean, well, I suppose eventually it will be slightly out of date
- 47:37because AI will probably play a role at some point, like oh, I
- 47:43hadn't even really thought about that that anybody. But just to personalize it to
- 47:50me, two things. One, I could create a product that people paid
- 47:55very little for because it would be very easy to set up. It was
- 48:00unofficial supervision consultation that was AI trained on everything that I've ever said in the
- 48:07podcast related to clinical work. And also I could feed in principles, like
- 48:15spend a week just going through questions that the AI might ask me, like
- 48:20well, what would you say if someone asked this question of you know,
- 48:22in supervision or or how do you think about this or that? Or what
- 48:30else should I incorporate? Because I could literally just tell the AI to incorporate
- 48:35other literature or the ethical codes of you know, and what I think of
- 48:40those things or whatever. And then for you know, five bucks a month
- 48:46or something, people could pay to have this AI and it's not like official,
- 48:52and it would have all these disclaimers of like, the AI can have
- 48:57issues, so you just have to take it for what it's worth. But
- 49:00people and I'm not saying that it's just me, you know, it could
- 49:04be anybody. It could be you could have someone put together an AI that's
- 49:08trained on Freud. I was just thinking that, Yeah, you can have
- 49:12psychoanalysis with Freud. Well that and also supervision, and supervision probably easier because
- 49:19his literature was focused on communicating to other psychoanalysts and there's a lot of letters.
- 49:25I have a book behind me that is this huge tome, like eight
- 49:29hundred pages, and it's just the letters between Freud and Jung. It's just
- 49:36their correspondence and Freud is trying to guide Jung, you know. So you
- 49:42could have that service that you pay for that that will come down the line
- 49:45at some point. Or you are a therapist yourself and you just say,
- 49:52I want to have my own personal Freud or Kirk or Bob, and I'll
- 50:00just tell it to train itself on all the available online free material. And
- 50:10I want the AI to create a personal supervisor for me that I can't use
- 50:15it officially, you know, but I want that. So is that Can
- 50:21you do that now? Yeah? You can do that right now, and
- 50:27you can train it on someone's voice. And there are recordings of Freud talking,
- 50:31so it would talk to you. You could speak out loud to it.
- 50:35You wouldn't have to type in, you could just talk to it.
- 50:37I never have to see you in person again. And because there's so much
- 50:42video of me online, you could just even have a video of me talking.
- 50:45You know, you could do this right now, A deep big kirk.
- 50:50Yeah, essentially, but it can be used for you know, not
- 50:55unethical things, you know, Yeah, it could be used for good.
- 51:00Yeah. An AI version of you and me as therapists will be eventually made
- 51:07by somebody, barring any sort of legal but even because eventually people will have
- 51:13their own AI software on their personal computer unless there's some sort of DRM thing
- 51:19that prevents you from doing it. I won't borrow details, we don't have
- 51:22time. But the point is that people can have their own software AI on
- 51:27their own personal computers or on their phone, and they and you can't stop
- 51:31that one individual from It's sort of like if I want to use photoshop to
- 51:37change Hillary Clinton's outfit, you know, you can't stop me from doing that.
- 51:43Now I can take a picture of Hillary Clinton, put it on my
- 51:45computer and use Photoshop to do whatever I want to to her image on my
- 51:51I don't I can't sell that. Or it sounds like mixtapes from when we
- 51:54were kids. Yeah, these record your own mixtape. In the same way
- 52:00AI, you'll have your own software and your computer, and you will be
- 52:02able to just tell that AI in your computer to do whatever you want it
- 52:07to do to whoever you want it. You could have an AI combine you
- 52:12and me visually and our voices and our minds. You could have this like
- 52:16Bob Kirk hybrid as a therapist or a Cob Cob and you could have That's
- 52:25that's available now. It's just either expensive or it would require cobbling together a
- 52:36number of services like you have. You have an AI service for language,
- 52:39you have an AI service for a voice, you have an AI service for
- 52:42image. But eventually it's just going to be one one product and it'll be
- 52:46on your phone. That's scary. Curb, I think we should be called
- 52:52Curb crob Bork. That stuff scares me. Man. I'm not interested in
- 53:02learning it or knowing it. I don't want to. It is what it
- 53:06is, and it's happening. It's already happened, and I'm actually kind of
- 53:12excited for the positive side. The downside of course is terrifying, But I'd
- 53:19be curious, you know, wouldn't you be curious to create an AI If
- 53:22I could stap my fingers and create an AI of you based on everything that
- 53:28you've said, and it would be a version of you, of course,
- 53:30because it wouldn't know how you really are in the real world, but it
- 53:32would be like your therapy persona. Right. Wouldn't you find it interesting to
- 53:38have a verbal conversation with yourself where you just asked it questions? Interesting?
- 53:44Yeah, you could ask that AI bob to be your therapist for a couple
- 53:50hours and just see what happens. I mean, wouldn't you be curious?
- 53:52I would be curious what it would do, how it would feel to be
- 53:58in the other person shoes from you? I would handle my sexual transferreds.
- 54:04Wait, would you be horny for each other? I'm horny for myself.
- 54:14That is trippy. Yeah, And that's just one. Yeah, that's just
- 54:17one. You could have an AI trained on one of your parents and have
- 54:24some kind of conversation and just play around with it, just be like,
- 54:29I wonder what what anyway? Well that does it for that episode? Well,
- 54:35for the record, do you mind if someone in the future uses their
- 54:43AI software because it'll happen. But do you mind if they create an AI
- 54:47Bob therapist that these people in the future interact with and they're not like considering
- 54:55it therapy therapy because it's not a real human being, but they STI into
- 55:00that into that interaction trying to get a therapy because you know, a lot
- 55:06of people want you as their therapist, and so in the future, someone
- 55:09will be motivated by that to create an AI version of you as a therapist
- 55:15and interact with you. Do you mind about that? No, I don't
- 55:19mind that. Is it going to be open source for they can like it
- 55:22might be? Well, that would be another question because if you don't want
- 55:29to say that, because that's ill actual property essentially, you don't want someone
- 55:32you don't want to give. I mean you can, but I wouldn't give
- 55:36permission for people to own you. Got So if they do a mixtape in
- 55:40their own and it's just their own thing and maybe they give it to a
- 55:44few, Yeah, no, I don't care about that. I mean,
- 55:46good luck. I who knows if it's going to be any good? So
- 55:52but yeah, yeah, that'd be right you. Yeah, I'm going to
- 55:55create a version of you to be my therapist. How are you going to
- 56:00handle the sexual transfer? That is it? For that episode of psychology in
- 56:06Seattle. Everyone out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it. Mm hmmm