Latest / The Christy-Faith Show / Ep. 21 - Alternative Career Roadmaps (Part 1 of 2) // Hannah Maruyama
Transcript
- Christy Faith (00:00.078) few years ago, colleges were told by the Department of Education to design a test that would show whether or not they were actually teaching critical thinking skills. And this was at major universities and colleges across the country. The colleges designed this test for themselves and then proceeded to fail it at a 45 % rate. Welcome to the Christy Faith Show, where we share game changing ideas with intentional parents like you. I'm your host, Christy Faith, experienced educational advisor and homeschool enthusiast. Together, We'll explore ways to enrich and transform both your life and the lives of your children. Welcome everybody to today's podcast of the Christy Faith Show. I am so excited about our guest. I have been stalking you, Ms. Hannah, on TikTok for several years. And I don't know if you know this, but I was gonna start a podcast over a year ago, but then Wiley came to me with a book deal and I couldn't do both things at the same time because I am a homeschool mom too. And so I actually put my podcast on hold to write my book. And so as soon as I started up my podcast that is the dream of mine, it's what I've been wanting to do all along. I knew that I had to have you as a guest on the show because I love your message. I love how empowering it is. And in getting to know you before filming, I found out that you yourself were homeschooled. So let me just give you a brief introduction of who Hannah is. Hannah and her husband, Ryan, build custom career roadmaps to help. 16 to 20 year olds get great jobs without needing college degrees. They also run Degree Free, which is a top US careers podcast. Thank you so much for being on the show, Hannah. First, I want to ask you, before I ask you about your own homeschooling journey, I'd love to hear how you got into helping kids find career roadmaps in a degree free way. Christy Faith (01:53.71) Absolutely. And this is my favorite question to answer. And it's one that people always go, how did you start with this age group? And it's a pretty interesting story. I like to think. My story actually goes way back to 2020. During COVID, I lost my job on March 17th of 2020. At the time I was working at a call center, I'm making about $20 ,000 a year. Then I came home and Ryan and I strategically decided to figure out what skills were valuable, teach myself. And then I decided which skills I was going to learn after that. took me 31 days to get a tech certification and within 45 days of starting studying, I had my first remote tech job that was $70 ,000 a year that said it required a computer science degree that it obviously didn't require. And that for me, I had always suspected that requirements on almost all jobs are actually requests and that just really hammered at home for me. It was the final nail in the coffin where I just went, all right, it's time to start talking about this, unpacking this, teaching other people how to do this. So Ryan and I actually were working with adult job seekers and interestingly, we had a community. So we were teaching like co -workhorses of teaching people how to do what I had done and just strategically find work that made sense for them and that would get them to the type of life they want to live. And we asked in our community, we asked about how people needed help teaching their kids who are about to face the college decision. And I have never seen anything like the type of response that we got. Like, paragraphs, stories, even it was overwhelming. And we just went, this matters a lot because all of the people that we were coaching, most of them had very large student debt burdens, were not working in the field that they were in, or they were having to switch jobs much older with kids with a lower budget than they would have had available to them if they had started correctly. And that's when we realized that we have the greatest leverage with our skill set. by preventing kids to going into student debt as opposed to trying to help adults get out of it after the fact. The way we think about it now is first we're going to fix the flow of people into the college industrial, the academic industrial complex, and then we will go back and we will build out resources for those who are still stranded and stuck in it. So that's what we're doing right now. Christy Faith (04:06.126) Now, what is, for those of you who have never heard this term before, the academic industrial complex, what is that? Absolutely. So for those who aren't aware, there's currently $1 .7 trillion of student debt in the United States that is owed by Americans to our college system. A lot of people are not aware that colleges are functionally head funds. They function, they buy assets, and then they grow wealth tax free. The endowments of the large colleges and universities in the US are collectively worth $848 billion. It's the only industry that is allowed to sell to minors bankruptcy except debt. Like legally they are allowed to market, sell unethically and I think fraudulently market a result that they cannot get to children and then the children cannot get out of it. Yes, now can you explain that? What is this result that they cannot get? So there's two, this comes with two things. Usually what I say is college is not a good way to get work that will make your money back. And then people say, well, then it's learning. And I just say, okay, well, the stats say that it's not learning because the CLA, which is the Collegiate Learning Assessment, a few years ago, colleges were told by the Department of Education to design a test that would show whether or not they were actually teaching critical thinking skills. And this was at major universities and colleges across the country. The colleges designed this test for themselves and then proceeded to fail it at a 45 % rate after four years. No change in critical thinking. And so, What I mean when I see they can't get the result is, one, they can't get people jobs because they're not job training. And two, they can't even teach critical thinking because if you've been on a college campus recently, there's zero critical thinking on campus. You know, and this was 10 years ago, the study was done. And so Gracious only knows how deeply that's declined since, right? Because I would say that that's an escalating trend, not one that's de -escalated. And then you can look at the recent trials of plagiarism at the highest levels of universities. and then question how it's allowed, how someone can be the dean of a prestigious university and entirely have plagiarized every academic achievement that they have. And yet still hold tenure positions at colleges and we still hold these people up. And it's this protected class of people that for some reason are academics, but they have no real skills and they don't really produce much value. You know, it's so fascinating. I'm smiling for those of you listening, just know I'm smiling on YouTube. You can see me smiling. Christy Faith (06:26.414) because I have an undergraduate degree in history and then, well, I want to be a college professor. So I went and got an assistantship, scholarships and all that, and got my graduate degree in history. I get my first adjunct position teaching history and I cried when I saw how much they were actually going to pay me to be a college history professor adjunct, right? And so I feel like that a lot of people in America, they, just like why you send your kid through the system. It's just what everybody does. And of course you need an education. That is the pathway to open doors. What do you say to the people who tell you that, well, yeah, sure, Hannah, it's a piece of paper, but that piece of paper is gonna give my kid more options rather than maybe a trade route. What would you say to a parent who says that? Like, I just don't want any doors closed for my kids, so I'm going to put them through a four year. Before we continue, I want to share with you a program that has been a game changer for our family. At our learning center, we instructed and helped kids through pretty much every program on the market. So we know firsthand just how important a solid math foundation is for our kids' futures. Finding the right homeschool math curriculum that didn't compromise academic excellence, but also didn't put me... and my kids through the wringer was a challenge. Until one day, I found CTC math. You guys, the rest was history. First off, it's a mastery -based program, which means your child gets a full grasp of the material. It's also loaded with mixed reviews, ensuring your kids don't forget anything they've learned. The questions are adaptive too, which keeps students confident and progressing at their own pace. But the best part, all the teaching, grading, and testing, Done for you! With CTC Math, there is no compromise on excellence. Your child gets a top -notch education and you just made your homeschool life easier. Visit CTC Math to get your free trial today. Whether you're newer to homeschooling or you've been homeschooling over a decade, the fact is creating a streamlined, successful homeschool is hard. The pressure is high and the weight of responsibility often leads to self -doubt, second -guessing. Christy Faith (08:47.502) and feeling completely overwhelmed with the excessive amounts of opinions and curricula options out there. We love our kids and at the same time, the stakes are high. We don't want to mess this up. So how do we build a homeschool that our kids will thank us for when they're adults and one that you have a hundred percent confidence in? The first step to pulling all of that off is joining Thrive Homeschool Community. Thrive Homeschool Community is where you learn the eight -step homeschool success framework. to build an undeniably successful homeschool. Each year and each kid presents us with uncharted territory. But when you have a good plan, the right plan, you can rest in the security and confidence that you are doing a great job. The path is easy. Join Thrive, say a quick hello to your new friends, start the eight step homeschool success framework, and kiss anxiety goodbye. It's risk -free. No contracts. You can cancel anytime no questions asked. Go to chrissey -faith .com. That's C -H -R -I -S -T -Y -F -A -I -T -H .com. Enter promo code podcast for $10 off your first month. See you inside. That is such a good question, Chrissy. So there's a couple of things that I want to unpack there. The first thing is I don't want doors closed to my children. There is nothing that will slam a door in your child's face like $100 ,000 worth of debt. And so people say, if they don't purchase a degree, doors will be closed to them. You know what's going to close off options in their life is having to service a student debt burden that they can't service. That will close so many options to them. Not only, and I'm not even talking about career, I'm not talking about spouse. I'm talking about home. I'm talking about things that they want to have in their life that their options won't be narrowed drastically because of the debt burden that they carry with them. And so I think it's just flipping that on its head because we talk about college like it's a foregone conclusion instead of a financial decision and a purchase. And so for a lot of people, they say, you know, well, I don't want doors closed in my child's face. Can you afford to open those doors? And then are you also okay with the doors you will close as a result of purchasing a degree that your child can't afford or forcing your child to purchase a degree that they can't afford? The second thing that I want to unpack was, and I hear this a lot. I got into it with a guidance counselor on TikTok, as I, as I do. Christy Faith (11:05.998) And this somehow I'm not surprised. You guys think I'm mouthy. You should go to her content. Sometimes I'll record responses to Ryan just because don't post that. I'm like, but I want to. I know, I know you get the filtered version. You get Ryan going, don't say that. I'm like, but someone should. I got into it with a guidance counselor on TikTok who, and I actually, I will go on the record. If somebody goes through, I think I have like a thousand more plus TikToks posted. There is. hundreds of hours of content, thousands maybe hours of content that I've posted on the internet, I have never, not a single time, told people not to buy college degrees, not once. I've never said don't buy a college degree, I've never said that, those words have never come out of my mouth because that's not what I believe. What I believe is being strategic in your choices and if you need a college degree, that's an entirely different thing and I'll get into need later, but basically to unpack the... story about the guidance counselor is I made a video about, hey, you need to have these conversations with your child. And I said, your schools are not teaching these options to these kids. They're not. And one of the guidance counselors said, I'm a guidance counselor. I teach kids all their options, college, trades, the military. And I was like, okay, so that's the problem. That's the problem. Not to yell, but those, that's exactly what I mean. The options are not college, trades, or the military. And this is something where I've gotten into it on TikTok before. I'm not Mike Rowe. I'm not saying don't send your kid to college. Instead, tell them to go pick up a wrench. What I'm talking about is don't go to college. Go be an AI machine learning engineer. That's what I'm saying. I'm saying don't go to college. Go be a midwife. Don't go to college. And now this is the first time I've ever said don't go to college. Don't go to college. Don't buy a college degree. And instead, go get trained as a watchmaker. Don't buy a college degree. Instead, write a book. Don't buy a college degree, instead start a business. And that's what I'm saying. I'm not all saying that like, don't buy a degree, go into the trades. I can't stand that actually when people say, well, Ken Coleman on the Dave Ramsey show is real big into that. And like, he's a good dude and stuff, but he constantly is like, we need electricians. And what I want to say is you're not an electrician. Your children are probably not going to be electricians. I don't think he's telling them that either. And what I want to say is no, they could do your job, Ken. They could build businesses, you know. Christy Faith (13:23.278) Anyway, that's just how I feel. Right. Well, and that's just the name of the game. Like they see a 15 second short form video and they just extrapolate. I mean, all that. I've never shamed teachers. I was a teacher, a classroom teacher. I love them. A lot of us go into the profession because we care. I can't tell you how many times people tell me that I am, you know, throwing teachers under the bus. Never have. Or mom shaming. Where in literally chapter one of my book, I say one, not everyone can homeschool. And I make sure to also say, Not everyone should. And I mean that from my heart. So can you talk about this, what you said, purchase a college degree? Never in my life, in all of my years of going through undergrad or graduate school did I ever think I was purchasing a college degree. Can you help us make that mind shift, mindset shift? Absolutely. And this is something that one of my more viral videos was, I got picked up by Newsweek and USA Today because what I just said is I said it's really cool for parents to not talk about the fact that there's some kid college degrees that their children cannot afford to buy. And that's really dependent on the family and the kid. And I personally was, I say that because I was one of those people. I couldn't afford to buy a bachelor's degree. So for people that don't know, I actually dual enrolled where I'm from in Georgia, in Savannah. I ended up dual enrolling at a local public high school. So I was fully dual enrolled. I was going to a local university that says it's been bought by Georgia Southern. And I was at the university full time. I was taking full time college classes and password was covered by a Pell Grant in high school, which I'm for. People should absolutely test out college while they're in high school, especially if it's free to them. But for me, I just, I had no business buying that. I had no business buying that because I couldn't afford it. And I think people, one of the things that commonly hear is like, well, you know, education should be accessible. Education is accessible. College is inaccessible. Those are not the same thing. That drives me absolutely nuts. Education and college are not synonyms. They never have been. And the academic industrial complex is one of the most potent marketing cheats we've ever seen. It's like a timeshare basically. That convince the entire generation of people that in order to enter into a certain social class or have access to any good jobs, you have to buy paper and you do not. Christy Faith (15:44.718) ZipRecruiter just released their stats. ZipRecruiter has really good data on the job market and current trends because of their interaction with both businesses and job seekers. And they have an AI component to their business that gives them very good information on the behavior of both sides of that marketplace. Do you want to take a wild guess how many of those jobs that they had on the entire site required a bachelor's degree? The show will resume in just a minute, but first I want to share with you an incredible resource that is totally free to homeschooling families everywhere. Have you ever felt like you were on trial for your homeschooling choice when visiting a doctor or another service provider? It's unsettling, especially when someone misinformed has the power to threaten your family. Unfortunately, we have heard countless stories of parents who have felt trapped in offices and met with suspicion rather than support. simply because they were homeschoolers. I've been profiled and interrogated myself and I'm sure many of you have as well. Enough is enough. It's time we proactively vet service providers before giving them our business and our money. Enter Christy Faith's List, a directory 100 % free to homeschooling families connecting you with homeschool friendly service providers who pro - promise to support you in your homeschooling choice. We want every homeschooler in America to know about and be using this list. So here's how to make Christy Faith's list a household name. One, tell all your friends about it. Let's show the market just how powerful the homeschool movement is. Number two, Check Christy Face List website before stepping foot into any service provider's office to make sure they are on there. And number three, if your favorite service provider isn't on the list, make sure to refer them. There's a button on the homepage of the website. It takes only 30 seconds and that way we can send them a lovely invite. If you're listening and you are a homeschool friendly professional, we want you on the list. Christy Faith (17:42.126) We're eager to connect homeschooling families with you, shout your name from the rooftops, and bring you tons and tons of business. We have plans for every type of business, both small, local, nationwide, and worldwide. Check out ChristyFacelist .com today. Hi, mama. If you like my social media content and my show, I'm pretty sure you will love my book, Homeschool Rising, Shattering Myths, Finding Courage, and Opting Out of the School System. My book is for homeschool parents, both veteran and new, and the perfect book to hand any homeschool skeptics in your life so they can better understand why you've chosen this amazing lifestyle. This book will challenge you, empower you, encourage you, and give you solid, mindful answers to all those questions you get about your homeschooling choice. Grab your copy and maybe an extra one for your mother -in -law today. Homeschool Rising is available wherever books are sold. I would guess less than half. Nine percent. Now that is surprising to me. And then not only that, but like the NC Burning Glass Institute has done a ton of research on this. And since this is a lot of people think that this started in COVID in 2020, it didn't. It started in 2014. There has been a steady trend of down credentialing because what happened was there was a knee jerk reaction to silter job applicants in 2008 after the crisis. And then after that, companies just left that requirement to thin the herd as it were. And then the people that got hired on as HR during that time had spent a lot of money on their degrees. Women value college degrees more than men. So now what you have is you have HR hiring staff that don't rewrite job descriptions for one. That's a huge problem. And then the second is they have a paper bias, which is they are very biased towards believing a college degree is an indicator of individual value. And so, the whole industry, all the job, the entire like job seekers versus companies right now is in a giant state of upheaval due to the shift, but also due to the people who are still kind of influencing these hiring decisions, even as the market trends towards degree for your hiring. Yeah, so that's so fascinating. And Scott, my husband, he has a degree in marketing and he says, he has told me so many times, everything I learned in undergrad, Christy Faith (20:06.894) does not even apply. The marketing that was taught in undergrad to business majors does not even apply anymore whatsoever. He's like, I basically have given myself through my own education, three MBAs without actually getting an MBA. And we already know as well, there's been great books like Carol Dweck's Mindset and things like that, that are saying, hey, look, it's more the soft skills anyway. What makes you, yeah, you do need. hard skills and all of that, but true success and fulfillment and happiness in life has more to do with soft skills. In my membership, we joke, it's kind of a de -schooling place where, because parents are like, what does my kid need to know for fifth grade? And I'm like, well, let's take that as a grain of salt and let's talk about what's actually going to make your kid happy, what you really want as the outcome for your kid. When you picture your kid at 25 and 30, 40 even, What do you picture? And that's what we can work towards now. And it may or may not involve a degree. Is there a time and a place where you do tell parents, no, your kid needs to go to college for this dream? Absolutely. If it's legally required. A good example of that. I just finished a career curriculum, a roadmap for a girl who is outside of LA in one of the larger sub -oops, determined to be an OR nurse. Her sisters are nurses. She's done the shadowing. I was a big fan of that. I'm very cautionary with girls who want to go into and actually anybody, but specifically girls. If they've been in public school and they want to go into medicine, social work, psychology or teaching because girls at public school specifically are always funneled to those things. They're just, they're just go, you care about people. Here you go. Like here's a loping job with a high cost degree. Enjoy. Good luck with the outcome of that. So. her dad found me and I ended up working with both of them to create her career roadmap. All the jobs that made it to her final three were medical jobs that required legal licensure. Some medical jobs do not require legal licensure. Some of them require training and increasingly hospitals are doing on the job training. But for her, you know, there's no what size fits all. So for her, the goal is, our nurse. I'm like, all right, well, how do we get you there? You know, the most efficiently and the fastest and to become a registered nurse, the only way is to get a degree. That's the only path. Christy Faith (22:31.662) There's no way around it. It just is. And well, kind of. So I gave her two options and this is how I'll just discuss the process here because then people can understand how dynamic this whole thing is. So I found her two options. One was to go get an E degree that has clinicals built into it in South Dakota, which is doing what I'm calling educational tourism at this point. They know that there are, there's a shortage of medical colleges that are cost efficient. and useful. And so they have designed a really good program that fits people that are coming from out of state to get RN licenses or LPN licenses or LVN licenses. LPN is what it's called everywhere else. LVN is what it is in Texas and California. Same thing. There's no practical difference. It's just a different term. But for her, there was another path, which was to go her high school has a medical assisting program. That medical assisting program made her a good candidate. for a CNA program that was being held at her local community college so that there wasn't a huge long wait list for that didn't cost $70 ,000. And that was $800 for that CNA course. Once you have a CNA, you can work in the state of California and then test into PN license, right? One of the things she wanted to do was move to San Diego and live with her sisters. I said, okay, one of your options here is to do this, go live with your sisters, work and experience, be sure you wanna be a nurse. And then after you've gotten your test into your LPN, she needed 54 months of consecutive bedside nursing experience and a firm recall. And then after that, you can apply to a bridge program at a local college to get an associate for your RN. And that would take a much shorter time for her and cost way less money overall. But it ended up being that I think the direction they're going to take is that RN program in South Dakota takes 13 months. I think it's roughly $12 ,000, which is laughable. compared to what they were going to spend at a local community college. Laughable. So that's an example of where I said, this is your only option. You have to get a degree, you have to go to college. If you're enjoying the show and you don't want to miss out on future episodes, hit that like and subscribe button and show us some love with your comments. Those five star reviews really do make a difference. Because it's a license. That's incredibly fascinating. Now, you were homeschooled. Tell us about your homeschooling experience. Christy Faith (24:54.99) I grew up in the military, so we moved around quite a lot. And like a lot of military families, the in and out of different schools gets really tough. So for part of elementary school due to necessity and then all of middle school, I was homeschooled. And that I think was one, I've become a firm believer that no middle schooler should go to middle school because that's a terrible time. I tend to agree with Maria Montessori that during that age they just need to be in the fields outside or just not in the not inside because they're crazy during that time. But yeah, so that was my homeschooling experience. I read voraciously and then did horrible math, awful, hated math, still do. But that was my homeschooling experiences. A lot of reading, a lot of Individual at the time my family lived in Hawaii, which is actually I ended up moving back later Which is where I met my husband where I met riot But this was middle school years. So my mom did a ton of amazing stuff. There's four kids in my family So we did you know, we all swam competitively at Pearl Harbor. That was really cool Like right over Pearl Harbor. So we would go to swim practice and see the Arizona every day, which is really neat Yeah, we did like sail, you know MWR sailing we volunteered at a homeless shelter down at the pier in Honolulu. And then we also helped restore an 1800 ceiling ship that was at a boat museum that was there, which is really cool. Took some writing classes, like a lot of homeschoolers do. We were very big into the activities, did all kinds of stuff, always outside. You had mentioned that you see in the homeschooling space, this pressure for us homeschooling families to prepare our kids for college. Can you talk about that a little more? Because I... definitely agree that because society is skeptical of us, we are constantly put in a defensive position. And what is the easiest way to prove that you did a great job homeschooling your kid? Well, do such a great job that they get into a great four -year school. Can you speak to that a little more and kind of demystify that? Christy Faith (27:04.942) Yeah, that's such a, there's so much here too, because there's a couple things. Yeah, that's a big topic. I think there's about five sub -topics in there. I know. Well, you know, it's the reality that we face and it's not gonna go away. There is a general distrust in our society because of news and a couple articles and some famous books that have made outliers awful situations. become somehow part of this narrative. And there's a general distrust and we feel it. We have the mother -in -law who's looking over our shoulder to see what our three -year -old's doing. Yeah, it's one of the things where you might have even seen me get into it in the comments, but it's so funny people say, well, homeschoolers, you know, they're homeschoolers. what? I just say homeschoolers demolish every other traditional school kit. It's not close in every metric, in every success metric that traditional education values. Homeschoolers. destroy them every single time. So it's always interesting to me that they could be so hypercritical of people who are excelling at their own game and beating them at their own game. I've always thought that was really interesting because for me, I'm not about the numbers, which is why I'm so vehement about degree free because I can see in the numbers, I can see in the data that this is not a good thing. We shouldn't all be doing this. And that's my same feeling about the homeschoolers where to me, I'm looking at this going, okay, if you spend all this time and all this money and all this effort, to teach your kids differently, why in the world would you then funnel them into what is essentially a reduced distilled version of exactly what you just spent 12 years avoiding? That to me is, it really speaks to the strength of college marketing because that's what it is. It is absolutely cultural. It's absolutely, well, look, I didn't neglect my children. They got into Stanford, right? It's absolute. And I'm not throwing shade. I'm just saying. It is a way, it is an outward way that you can convey to other people that you were a good parent. And homeschool parents, because they've been told, everyone's put them under a microscope, even though they're outperforming everybody else and said, you need to validate your decision to teach your child by having someone else who honestly will not do as good of a job as you or as good of a job as just working teach your child. And by the way, you will pay every bit of money that you didn't spend. Christy Faith (29:29.07) at a private school or on extracurricular educational activities, then your child will be paying down that debt until they're 55. That's what you have to do to prove to me that you were beating us at our own game. That's crazy. That's an insane thing to do. And so I just want to say that to the parents that are listening to you, because that's great. Don't let people do that to you. You are strong enough to put your kid on this path and teach them a different way. You are also strong enough to say, no, they don't have to buy paper from this academic industrial complex to validate the fact that they're going to be fine. from what I taught them. Right, or that you did a good job. And to prove somehow that you did a good job at this because we're doing this to ignite that fire within our kids and college might be the path for them because of a specific degree necessity. But like my son wants to be a lawyer. He doesn't want to be a paralegal. He wants to be a lawyer. So it's like, all right, okay, well, we got to start planning that. Or move to Washington or California. Yeah, exactly. So for those that don't know, you can read the law for a state still. And California and Washington are two of them. Washington state has the highest pass rate, 52 % for reading the law, which used to be how lawyers were until the ABA. interesting. Okay. Well, I love that. Thanks for joining us for part one. We hope you gain some valuable insights. Be sure to catch part two where we're going to continue this great conversation.