Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / Baker’s 13 vs. Knob Creek 13 Year Old Single Barrel Store Pick Bourbon Review
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Bourbon Bytes podcast, I'm comparing Baker's 13-year-old bourbon with a 13-year-old
- 0:05single barrel pick from Knob Creek, talking about a nation facing a major bourbon shortage,
- 0:10and one of Kentucky's top tasters starting her own whiskey brand.
- 0:22Hello everyone and welcome to the Bourbon Bytes podcast. I'm your host Clifton and today's episode
- 0:28is super special to me because it is brought to me by two friends of the show who provided
- 0:34the samples for review on two separate occasions unrelated to each other,
- 0:38but I thought it would be really fun to compare these two whiskeys. So what I have in front of me
- 0:44is a 13-year-old Baker's bourbon from Jim Beam from my friend David from Whiskey in My Wedding
- 0:50Ring as well as a 13 and a half year Knob Creek single barrel pick from my friend Swan. So I
- 0:58thought what other time I'm going to have a chance to compare two 13-year-old products from Jim Beam,
- 1:04one of my favorite distilleries, and kind of decide you know what are the differences between
- 1:08the two, especially the older age statement which we kind of hardly ever see anymore.
- 1:12And also this is my first time trying a Baker's 13-year-old so I'm extremely excited for that,
- 1:18but I think it makes the most sense for me to start with my beloved Knob Creek,
- 1:22one of my favorite bourbons. Now I was lucky enough to get access to some of the 14, 15,
- 1:27and even 16-year-old Knob Creeks a couple years ago when those are very prevalent around the area,
- 1:32at least here in Southern California. So this is a pick, like I said, that Swan sent along. Of
- 1:39course my friend Fred also has had a chance to try this one. This is a 13.5-year pick. It was part of
- 1:45a flight that OBC Kitchen in Kentucky did where they had three different whiskeys, one an 11-year,
- 1:52the 13.5, and a 15-year, and this was actually their favorite. So Swan picked up a bottle and
- 1:58sent me a very, very generous sample of that one. So I'm going to start with that one and then
- 2:03give you my thoughts. Of course they're probably going to be pretty amazing because y'all know I
- 2:06love Knob Creek. But then we're going to do a comparison with the 13-year-old Bakers, which
- 2:10I have a little bit of a cheat sheet here to see what the differences between these two are
- 2:14because they are both coming from the Jim Beam Distillery out of Claremont, Kentucky.
- 2:19They actually have the same mash bill, but there is one subtle difference between these two that
- 2:23maybe we'll be able to pick out on the palate. So without further ado, let's go and get that
- 2:27Knob Creek poured. So like I said, we're dealing with the same mash bill here, the same barrel
- 2:33entry proof. However, these two whiskeys do come off the still at two different proofs that may
- 2:39contribute to the difference in taste. So our beloved Knob Creek comes off the still at 130
- 2:44proof, where Bakers typically comes off the still at 125 proof. So it seems like a very subtle
- 2:50difference, but I'm really excited to see the differences between these two. I have had Bakers
- 2:55before, the older release as well as the newer single barrel, but that's the 7-year, not the 13-
- 3:00year. So I'm gonna get that poured at the same time. But first, let me try Knob Creek. Now this
- 3:05comes in at 120 proof, which is the standard proof for their single barrel selections. It's also
- 3:11worth mentioning that this is a pick compared to the Bakers that is not a pick. However, you know,
- 3:1513 years at the distillery, there's got to be something special about that barrel. They wouldn't
- 3:19have kept it so long. So let's go and give this a nose. Ah, man, everything I love about Knob Creek.
- 3:25That is just such a typical, standard, nutty kind of flavor profile. One that I've missed because I
- 3:32know that we can't get these older picks anymore. But man, when I smell it, I just fall in love.
- 3:38Now being a 13 and a half year pick, this is a good bit older than the more recent ones that
- 3:43are coming out. So there is a ton of wood on this. It's definitely not a new oak. It's more of a
- 3:49older, rich, saturated oak as I often say. And it's just bursting on the nose along with that
- 3:54nuttiness. I mean, this is a very dark, rich bourbon and I can't wait to take a sip. So I'm
- 4:00gonna go ahead and do that. Cheers. Oh man, holy moly is that dark. I forget. It's been a minute
- 4:08since I've had one of these older Knob Creek picks. But wow, that is so tannic, like oaky tannins,
- 4:15which I do typically enjoy. I love my bourbons big and bold and oaky and nutty. And this is
- 4:22checking all of those dark boxes. Now, I will say I remember these being a bit sweeter. Maybe it's
- 4:29just this pick, but there's so much oak and so much dark richness on there that I'm not getting
- 4:35as much of the brown sugar, some of the caramel that I typically get on a Knob Creek. It's nutty,
- 4:39but like a roasted peanut, kind of like a dry, maybe a little salty, but those dry roasted peanuts
- 4:45you get like in a bag. None of the sweet, you know, like peanut butter kind of notes or anything
- 4:49like that. This one, like I said, man, this is dark, which at 13 and a half years, I mean,
- 4:55obviously you expect that, but wow, I guess it's just been so long since I've had this.
- 5:00And even though this Knob Creek is so dark, there's a bit of like a bright citrus kind of
- 5:06sweetness to it, almost like a candied lemon that kind of leaves you with like a bit of tartness,
- 5:10along with that tannic element of the oak. And honestly, I think that's what really makes this
- 5:15Knob Creek pick so unique. To me, it's unlike any other pick I've ever had. I think I was a bit
- 5:20caught off guard by that. That's kind of why I was so surprised by how dark and deep this was in
- 5:25flavor. But when you look at it a little bit further and take another sip, you really get
- 5:29that bright, yeah, like a bit of a citrus tartness to it that really, really complements that dry,
- 5:36dark, oaky flavor. This one is just, I mean, if you're having a really rough day and you want
- 5:40something really dark, then that might be the one to go for. Maybe if you're Alessio on Dungeons
- 5:45and Drams. If y'all aren't yet watching our live streams we do every Tuesday night, it's so much
- 5:50fun. We do a Dungeons and Dragons campaign with Jason from The Mash & Drum, Bill from The Whiskey
- 5:55Dic is our Dungeon Master, Ed from The Rotgut Review is another player, as well as Molly from
- 5:59Hugging the Cactus. We have so much fun for that. There's actually a podcast version of it now,
- 6:03so just search your favorite podcast app for Dungeons and Drams. You'll find that. But
- 6:09Alessio or Jason's character is his big thing. He's like, he's so dark. Well, this is the bourbon
- 6:14for him because this is one of the darkest bourbons I've ever had. This one personally for me is
- 6:20missing a little bit of the sweetness and that's where I'm hoping this Baker's brings it back out
- 6:24because my experience with Baker's, at least the younger ones, the younger single barrels,
- 6:28it has a bit more of a fruity note to it. So I'm really excited to try this 13-year-old version of
- 6:32it and see how it compares directly with this Knob Creek because other than the off the still
- 6:37proof, these two are very, very similar. Now the Baker's 13-year comes in at 107 proof,
- 6:43so it's a little bit lower proof. I only wanted to try the Knob Creek first because that's my
- 6:48go-to Jim Beam product, especially at the older ages. But this one is going to be a little bit
- 6:52lower proof, about 13 proof points lower. The MSRP was $100, but again, I saw it one time in a store,
- 6:59they were charging $150 and I was like, yeah, I'll find it cheaper and never did. So thank you.
- 7:04Thank you, David, for the opportunity to try it. So let's go ahead and move on over to
- 7:08the Baker's 13-year single barrel. Now first glance, by the way, I have both of these poured
- 7:14at the same time. The Baker's is a little bit lighter in color. I'm actually surprised about
- 7:18that. Now it is lower proof. There is a little bit more water added to it, which is most likely
- 7:23contributing to that, but I definitely wasn't expecting it to be so different just color-wise.
- 7:28But let's go ahead and give it a nose. Oh yeah. Wow. Very different. I kind of was expecting it,
- 7:34but I'm also kind of caught off guard by how different it is. I will still say it has those
- 7:39lovely oaky notes that are there, but this one's to me less nutty. It's more of like a sweeter note.
- 7:45I can't quite place the sweetness on the nose. I've always said, you know, I'm not the best at
- 7:50nosing. I think I really can understand flavors a bit more once I've tried them, but on the nose,
- 7:54I think I'm getting a little bit of that caramel brown sugar sweetness that I kind of thought I
- 7:57would find on the Knob Creek, but maybe that's more of like the younger ones or even some Booker's
- 8:02releases. Yeah. It wasn't getting any of that sweet caramel kind of vanilla note on the Knob
- 8:08Creek, but let's go ahead and try the Baker's 13 and get a first taste of that one. Cheers.
- 8:15Oh wow. Wow. That is so good. And this is coming from a Knob Creek lover. That
- 8:22just caught me off guard with how fruity, how like, I almost feel like it's rye forward. I'm
- 8:28getting a lot more rye spicy, even though this is the same mash bill, as far as I'm aware.
- 8:32All of my charts, you know, link them together. It's the same, the same mash bill, but man,
- 8:37there's a lot more fruitiness, a lot more sweetness. You know, they do age these in different,
- 8:42you know, parts of the Rickhouse as well. It's not just the off the still proof. There are other
- 8:46factors that contribute to them being different flavors, but wow. Was not expecting this 13 year
- 8:52Jim Beam produced bourbon to taste like this. This one, to me, it still has the richness and
- 8:58the depth of the 13 year old Knob Creek, but it doesn't go as dark. It has the oak. I would say
- 9:03the oak is probably equally as dark, but it's definitely a bit toned down. The nuttiness again
- 9:07is maybe, I don't want to say nowhere to be found because there's a little hint of it there as with
- 9:12all Jim Beam products, but there's something about the fact that this has so much influence from this
- 9:18fruitiness, the sweetness that to me that screams bakers. Like I said, I've had some of the seven
- 9:23year old Baker's. I've had even some of the eight year old single barrels. I think I've had the
- 9:26oldest I've had. It's like eight years, nine months. This one though, fruity, sweet pokey,
- 9:32man, this is my jam. And that's coming from someone that absolutely adores Knob Creek.
- 9:37Now this one, MSRP is a hundred dollars. Have I found it for that? No, it came out back in 2019.
- 9:42I've never seen another bottle other than that one that I saw for 150. I would absolutely love
- 9:48if this were a regular on the shelf. Again, a hundred dollars, you know, you're getting a 13
- 9:52year old bourbon. How often can you find a bourbon over the age of 12 years? That's basically that
- 9:57price. Of course, I've got to talk about, you know, Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, one of my favorite
- 10:01bourbons from my other favorite distillery, Heaven Hill. That one is a 12 year old barrel strength,
- 10:06you know, batch release. There are some single barrels coming out. I know the single barrels of
- 10:11Elijah Craig Barrel Proof that I've seen that are picks, especially are somewhat younger. Some
- 10:16of them are like the nine, 10, 11 year old range. I'm paying around 80 to 90 for those.
- 10:21So for a single barrel Jim Beam, 13 year old product for a hundred dollars with bakers,
- 10:28I think that's a solid win. Now, again, both of these are wins. Again, the Knob Creek was $60.
- 10:33At least, I don't know about this particular pick again. This is sent to me, thankfully,
- 10:36from my friend Swan. But if you are a Knob Creek fan, you can often find single barrel picks for
- 10:41around 50 or $60. Now, nowadays, they're going to be a bit younger than the age statement of,
- 10:48you know, 13, 14, 15 years, like we saw a few years ago. But I mean, for the price, the proof,
- 10:55those are fantastic. However, if these were the same price, the Knob Creek 13 versus the Baker's
- 11:0113, I'd have to go with the Baker's. I think it's more balanced. I think it's more interesting. It
- 11:06has that fruitiness, that sweetness. It's all these layers of, you know, age where it comes
- 11:11from the oakiness. There's a bit of like a leather note there as well, combined with the sweetness,
- 11:16the brown sugar. There's like a bit of a fruitiness. There's a dark fruit. But I mean,
- 11:21it's way more balanced. Yeah, the finish is a little bit shorter than the Knob Creek. I think
- 11:26the Knob Creek definitely was the winner there. But overall experience and flavor profile and
- 11:32based on my love of Jim Beam, Baker's 13 has the win here. Like I said, that's based on if these
- 11:38were the same price, you know, the Knob Creek's a good bit cheaper. They're both winners in their
- 11:43own category. I just don't think these are comparable. I think the Baker's 13 year is a
- 11:48step above, significantly above Knob Creek. Now, compared to like a Booker's, again, this is like
- 11:54over twice the age of a Booker's, about the same price these days. I'll be honest with you. You
- 12:00know, last week's podcast I reviewed a vintage Booker's from 1995 compared to a Booker's from
- 12:062020. I would take this Baker's 13 year over both of those any day for the same price. So I know
- 12:13I've been on a little bit of a Jim Beam kick here, but like I said, one of my favorite distilleries.
- 12:17So I wanted to share my thoughts with you guys about these two releases. I'm curious to hear
- 12:21if any of you have had either of these, you know, do you love the older Knob Creek's, you know,
- 12:25the 13, 14, 15 year releases? Or do you prefer the younger ones that are coming out now that are,
- 12:30you know, nine to 10 years old? Let me know if you want me to come back and try this, you know,
- 12:34older Knob Creek release versus one of the more recent, you know, nine to 10 year old releases.
- 12:40Maybe I prefer the younger ones. I don't know. I've never done a side-by-side, but if that's
- 12:43something you want to see, let me know on our Whiskey and Gaming Lounge Discord server,
- 12:47or you can find it at bourbonbytes.com. We have a channel to discuss all the episodes of the
- 12:51podcast. So really looking forward to your feedback on this episode. But yeah, I mean,
- 12:56I'm so glad to try both of these side-by-side. Bakers gets the win today, but I don't plan on
- 13:01stopping buying Knob Creek. I love them both. I just wish I could get the Bakers 13 in 2022
- 13:07for a decent price. So we do have a couple pieces of news here to discuss, one of which was brought
- 13:13to my attention by patrons of the show on our last Hangout. Apparently the nation of New Zealand is
- 13:20having a pretty severe bourbon shortage. Now, of course, you know, we're experiencing a lot of
- 13:26across the world right now with supply chain and things like that. But apparently the supply
- 13:31chain issues, the shipping delays and a growing popularity of hard liquor, especially bourbon
- 13:36in New Zealand is really causing such a bottleneck on the spirit. So this has been kind of an
- 13:41international issue since 2021, you know, the pandemic kind of shutting things down.
- 13:46But New Zealand seems to be hit hard by this, especially when it comes to bourbon.
- 13:50They say that people were drinking significantly more during the pandemic, which I'm right there
- 13:54with them. But they say for months, retailers and especially the customers have been struggling to
- 13:59get some of their favorite brands. Now in New Zealand and Australia, ready to drink bourbon
- 14:04cocktails are very popular. I know there's quite a few wild turkey ones that are exclusive
- 14:09overseas. A lot of those have been hit by the fact that bourbon is hard to get as well as
- 14:14CO2. They're facing a pretty significant CO2 shortage, which is really hitting the ready
- 14:19to drink cocktail industry hard. And we saw how popular those have been rising. I mean,
- 14:23I just did a stream with my friend Brandon where we compared a bunch of different canned cocktails
- 14:27that were, you know, most of them carbonated. So apparently overseas, they're having trouble
- 14:31keeping up with the demand. It says this year there was a 22% increase compared to two years ago
- 14:37when it comes to the demand for bourbon buyers. People are buying more than 2 million liters of
- 14:42bourbon a year in a nation that has only got 3.65 million adults. So that's like a pretty big
- 14:49increase compared to previous years. And fun fact, there's also a shortage of chicken nuggets
- 14:54in New Zealand. This is also apparently impacted by the lack of CO2 access. Sounds like one of the
- 15:00major factories down there is under maintenance until August. So they're not able to create their
- 15:04own CO2 and their sources are having to be shipped in and it's a whole mess. So if you want your
- 15:09bourbon and nuggies, you may not want to go to New Zealand anytime soon. But in more positive news,
- 15:15this has kind of been talked about on several podcasts and shows, but we have to mention
- 15:20the legend herself. Jackie Zykan, former master taster of Old Forester, is leaving the company
- 15:27to start her own lineup of bourbon. So she's launching Hidden Barn Spirits in collaboration
- 15:34with 5280 Whiskey Society as well as Neeley Family Distillery President Royce Neeley. So she's going
- 15:40to be working as the master blender there, which is super exciting. It's going to be a very small team
- 15:45but I feel like this is well-deserved. I mean, she's obviously one of the best tasters,
- 15:51one of the most prominent, not just women in the Kentucky bourbon industry, but
- 15:56she's known as the master taster. So I'm so excited for her to kind of go on, branch out.
- 16:02She's made such a name for herself at Brown Foreman and Old Forrester. I can't wait to see
- 16:07what she does as a master blender. She's been doing quite a bit of that kind of with the,
- 16:11I think it was the 117 Series at Old Forester. So she definitely has, you know, incredible
- 16:15experience she's learned there. But to go on and do her own thing, I think this is the perfect
- 16:20time for her. I think last year that was the first time she ever got her name on a bottle
- 16:24at Old Forester. So she's left her mark figuratively and literally at Old Forester
- 16:30and this seems like a very, very exciting move. It says, at Hidden Barn, she'll be focused on
- 16:35tasting and ensuring post-distillation quality, similar to the experience she had at Old Forester.
- 16:41She tells Forbes Magazine that she's looking forward to transitioning into ownership at
- 16:45Hidden Barn and using her tasting skills to grow a brand on her own. And apparently as early as later
- 16:51this month, Hidden Barn will be releasing their first small batch Kentucky Straight bourbon
- 16:55whiskey. It's going to be from the Neeley Family Distillery. Now, of course, this is the first
- 17:00release. We don't know how long this has been aging. I have no info on it other than it's going
- 17:03to be a small batch Kentucky Straight bourbon whiskey. So definitely not super young, but still
- 17:08it makes me excited for things to come. And most of all, congratulations, Jackie. That's
- 17:11such a big move. Not that she's really listening to this, but she might, you never know. Super
- 17:16excited for you, not just for making a name for yourself, but just being a champion for women in
- 17:22the industry. I think you are just a role model inspiration and just an amazing person. So
- 17:26congratulations. So that does it for this week's episode. I know it was very whiskey focused,
- 17:31but we're going to have to throw in some video game references at least next episode. Thank y'all
- 17:36so much for listening. If you do want to support the show, make sure you follow me on your favorite
- 17:40podcast platform. Leave me a rating and review if it's available and make sure to tune into my
- 17:44Thursday night YouTube live streams at youtube.com/BourbonBytes. Thank you to all my patrons
- 17:50and Byte Club members over on YouTube. Y'all really make this show possible and couldn't do
- 17:54it without you. So until next time, this has been the Bourbon Bytes podcast. Cheers. And I'll talk
- 17:59to you next episode.