Latest / Carbon Weekly News / RMI Maps 14 CDR Pathways, Gold Standard on OER | CWN EP10
Transcript
- speaker-0: The CDR products that we have today are either too expensive or not durable enough. 10 years ago, CDR, durable CDR, was not a field. I mean it's no secret that DAC has remained very expensive. You know, one of the things we identify in here as a breakthrough shot for DAC is reactive capture. The answer, look beyond the 14. speaker-2: No company wants to be sued for their claims. Do you need something else? Do you need the new carbon neutral? Because if you slip off target for a few years, you want to keep them in the tent. There's a reason they don't let people like me name exciting things, right? speaker-3: Hey everyone to another episode of CWN. I think we already talked about that before then, but this after climate week in New York until the end of year, it feels like news coming in every day. It has been quite crazy and there's also reports coming out. So yeah, I'm not sure how you feel about it, but it has been a crazy time. speaker-1: Yeah, it is. I think we've seen a number of deals announced here, a bunch of activity on debt financing and new projects getting underway in addition to a number of off takes being signed. So it seems like things are are really picking up. We have speaker-2: Have speaker-1: elections happening in many countries around the world at the same time. Some that seem like Brazil's result just a few days ago that seems overall positive from a climate perspective. obviously we'll we'll see where where the midterms land us in the US in just a few short weeks here. So but no, it's there's there's news on all fronts. speaker-3: News in All France and also reports, as I just mentioned. I'm really happy to have Rudy over from RMI, Rocky Mountain Institute. And you just published this new report, the new Frontiers report for CDR. I mean, I think Rocky Mountain Institute already did a lot of work in the carbon credit space, CDR space and so on. And this report is 124 pages long and I first thought, it's going to be one of the reports, a lot of text. And then when I opened it, I saw, no, this is actually super visual and also goes really detailed into each pathway and so on. So then I was actually really excited to go for 124 pages. That doesn't happen really often. So Rudy. Thanks for coming. Maybe you can tell me a little bit about yourself, how you got into carbon markets, to RMI and so on. And then we jump into the report. speaker-0: Well, first I'll say I'm glad to hear that you were excited to read our whole report because it is long. and thank you for having me on the podcast. It's great to be here. so yeah, I'm Rudy Kesar. I'm a principal on RMI's industry program. and I've been working on carbon management and carbon removal for maybe about four or five years now. just in to put it in context, so as you say, this This new frontiers report that we just released is about 124 or something, 130 pages in a slide format. those of your listeners who have been following our work for the last couple of years, we put out a a sort of big report that was about 300 pages back in 2023, I believe. our applied innovation roadmap, which for CDR, which was we looked at 32 approaches. So In a way this one is smaller than that one. but I think what we hope is that this will be a complement to that report. speaker-3: Amazing, fantastic. So maybe before we jump in very detailed, can you just give us a small overview? Like, what are you doing in this report? Like, what is it actually about? speaker-0: Yeah. So you know, one of the things, and I think this is the the core frame of this report is as we've looked at the way the CDR space has evolved over the last five or ten years, you know, it's really emerged out of not much. Like ten years ago, CDR, durable CDR, was not a field. In fact, in the climate community, it wasn't even really accepted as a climate solution until 20 exactly the 2018 special report on one point five C. put it on the map as something that we might need. then there were a flurry of reports after that that basically said, wow, maybe this is something we should look into. And the years following that, obviously we had a bunch of investment, a lot of new companies created. and I think we're at a bit of a moment right now where we say, well, what is the next, what is the next move in the carbon removal space, right? We've seen CDR 1.0 move, but you know, I think the question is what happens next? And you know There's a lot of different opinions about this, but I think the way we look at the space is to say there is still more to be done on the innovative frontier of CDR. And what we mean by that is developing approaches or solutions, technologies that don't exist today. Right. So there's a lot of talk and conversation of what can we do to push forward the technologies we already have. And what we're saying is maybe those technologies actually aren't sufficient to get to whatever the long-term goals are that we have. Another way of saying this is like the products that we have today, the CDR products that we have today are either too expensive or not durable enough, or they have certain flaws that make it so, we say, people aren't buying this stuff, right? It's like, well, if you're selling a product that is overpriced for what you're getting, of course people aren't going to buy it. And that's a difficult, you know, I mean, I think there's a very important role for the CDR that we have today. But what we're saying in this report is we need to not lose sight of the fact that we're still in the very early stages of this space. And the role of innovation for advancing or unlocking new technologies is important for getting to ten, twenty years from now and having a healthy, robust carbon removal ecosystem. speaker-3: not talking about your boring AR projects then, but rather about your enhanced rock weathering side where we're still trying to figure out things. Now just joking, obviously. But if we look at the report, and I think I like what you say, especially now about the pricing side, because I think exactly that sentence you just said, people are not buying what I'm offering at, I don't know, $1,000. I think this is something as mentioned, I heard so many times, but it's still really important to figure out that, but how do procurement teams need to look on this whole topic? Because you write that durability is the product, but in procurement teams, it's mostly like price per ton. So if a credit lasts, let's say a hundred years and another 1000 years, how should the procurement team actually weigh that on a scorecard or something? like that. speaker-0: Yeah, it's a tough question to answer exactly. What I'll say is, there are multiple reasons that anyone might want to buy a carbon removal credit. And one is simply, I want a durable removal that either offsets emissions or retroactively removes emissions that I previously had. And it's as simple as that. But another reason that you sometimes see, and I think that some of the leading CDR buyers, a lot of tech companies, I think, take this approach is to say, We're actually purchasing more expensive removals because we want to de-risk a technology that we think is going to be important in the future. And that's as important as simply procuring as many credits as you can today. Right. So the question then is I think you know what you're asking, like, how do you balance that as a buyer? I mean, you know, we've we've made this case in previous reports that our team has released. And I would say, you know, having a portfolio that somehow brings in pieces of those different motivations, maybe different types of CDR into your portfolio, similar to what you would do in a retirement portfolio, right? Is probably the best way to go. in your retirement portfolio, you don't want all your money in cryptocurrencies, right? But you also don't want all of it in bonds, right? You want some kind of mix. And I think that if you're a sort of responsible CDR buyer, Or maybe if you have, a little bit more money or interest to invest in the CDR space, likewise you would want to have some balanced portfolio. Then of course, I think there's some companies out there that are working to think about what that balance should be. And probably, you know, there's some subtleties in and kind of the amounts of long term, sort of more expensive, something like DAC that you would want in your portfolio versus something that's less expensive, more available like biochar, but I would generally say having a balance and having some kind of mix is is going to be the way to go to advance the space. speaker-1: Ray, do you see that balance coming more from the standpoint of balancing a range of durabilities? Or is it betting on the fact that some of these companies could fail or some of the approaches may not actually hold up in science in the long term? Like how how do you think about the different things that you might be trying to balance as you as you weigh investments across multiple technologies? speaker-0: Yeah, I definitely think both of those come into play. And I'll say I'm a technologist, right? So I'm not like a I'm not an investor. I'm not like thinking on the the the way of sort of, you know, I need to get this many removals to meet my company's standards. I'm speaker-1: nature is what I understand from what you're saying. speaker-0: I'm commenting from the perspective of how do we best advance a technological portfolio of new solutions? And so my answer to that would be to say, you know, we want to think about sort of, you know, as you say, Dan, right, there's certain technologies are going to fail. And maybe we want to take a small bet on a number of them because we don't know which ones are going to succeed. But if we want to see this space advanced technologically, we need to sort of like give a lot of people a chance to try to make it. speaker-1: Yeah, it makes sense. I one of the things that we hear from buyers is like in addition to durability, right, there are at least on the nature side and a number of other technologies, right? There are a lot of co-benefits that are coming from these technologies. And today, in the nascent market that we have, these are not really priced or understood well as separate things. And so as a result of that, a lot of buyers seem to be in this approach of, well, I maybe I want a project that I can talk about and I can associate these other elements with the project investment, even if it means the durability of the credit is ultimately shorter. So just curious, how do you think about that as a technology first person looking at this? Like what's the what's the like kind of beginning and the end of how you think a buyer should be thinking about a portfolio as they look at investing in this space? speaker-0: Yeah, no doubt. this is also very important. So if I step out of my technologic, technology hat and say what's going to be good overall for, let's say, the environment, which is ultimately, I think, you know, why people are interested in buying CDR in the first place, right? Is to say, well, what are our goals if we're buyer? Right. You know, do we, you know, are we're we're interested maybe in developing the technology of carbon removal more durable, carbon removal long-term solutions, but we're also interested in having a positive impact now. in ways that we can. And I think you're right. there's, you know there are organizations like RMI that are working on trying to better account for environ positive environmental impacts of some of these removal technologies. You know, there's whole sort of adjacent fields now related to superpollutants. You guys probably talk about that from time to time. You know, I think all of these things are well within scope. Of a procurement department thinking about how they can have a positive impact. And then the question is going to be sort of what are your goals? Right. I think there are buyers out there that are really focused on de-risking long-term technologies. And I think that's a fair way for them to allocate their money. But I think it's very fair for other companies, maybe, maybe companies that have more of contact with local environments, per perhaps, to say, hey, look, we want to actually put more money into some of these solutions that have. positive side effects or co-benefits. They aren't as measurable, but we know that we're having a kind of positive impact. I'll say one other thing about this. I heard this said a long time ago and I I still think about it from time to time is that some of these open systems interventions, whether they're CDR or superpollutants, they are inherently difficult to measure. Some of them are very difficult to measure. And you know, there there is a camp I would say That I still sometimes think about, which says, well, maybe we shouldn't even attempt to measure it. We should just be, you know, working to sort of, you know, create these environmental benefits or co-benefits simply because we know that they are happening. We just, you know, don't worry about measuring them. So that's a you know, kind of provocative sort of sidestep, I would say, to the carbon market space entirely. speaker-3: If we jump back to the report and you said already, it's a dance down report, right? You have 14 different approaches and one big bet in each bucket, like engineered cultivars for biogenic, like reactive deck and so on. If a buyer really only can pick two pathways for the next five years. Which two would that be? speaker-0: Yeah. I always get this question. Everyone wants to know which one should we go all in on? And you can maybe tell based on what I've said so far that I don't really like just picking a single answer because we just don't know. you know, I think that there's in some of what we call the synthetic pathways, so this would include direct air capture, electrochemical approaches, the ones that require inputs of energy, I think there's a lot of potential there for breakthroughs. But on the flip side, and and Dan, maybe this is a bit more where you're coming from, is like, gosh, we have a lot of biomass. We can do a lot with it pretty quickly. maybe there's some bets to place there. So those are probably my safe answers. But I actually I want to step outside of your question a little bit apropos of our report and give you a couple other things to think about here. So number one, I mean, we already talked about the importance of breakthrough innovation, right? and I think that Breakthrough innovation is not something that happens necessarily within the 14 approaches that we identified in the report. This is something where it's like totally cross-cutting. It could be advances in drones or AI or sensors. I mean, just looking at the way sensors and drones and coupled with AI, those three things together, have advanced in the last 10 years. You could imagine a CDR company that's like developing drones that do underwater stuff for algae on land, measuring enhanced rock weathering. all kinds of advances that can happen there. So, so thinking outside those 14 approaches, I would say number one. Another one is building out carbon management infrastructure generally. so this is something you know, we see it happening in bits in the EU, here and there in the US, but this is like transportation, storage infrastructure. It might even be CCS related. you know, building out that kind of infrastructure gives you a place for. Once you build a DAC plant, maybe in the future, if you already have pipelines, you already have wells, you already have a way to deal with that carbon, it makes it a lot easier to bring those technologies up to speed, 10, 15, 20 years in the future. And then the third thing I'll also say, again, stepping outside of the 14 approaches, is this idea of industrial integration. And this is something that our team at RMI has pushed for the last almost two years now. We published a report almost two years ago. advocating for an industrial integration. And the idea here is instead of building up new approaches from scratch, how can we take advantage of existing infrastructure to deploy approaches? And you know, I'll just also make a a quick note of this. This is the focus, as I understand it, of this year's COP and how they're thinking about sort of the frontier carbon removal. And the idea is like Wow, we already have all these water treatment facilities. Can we integrate CDR? Wow, we already have all this forage management infrastructure. How can we integrate CDR? Right? Any of these large industries where there's a potential to quickly scale solutions that we already have, and maybe even looking across approaches that we have. So another example of this would be integration of carbon into materials. This is another focus I know that a number of groups are taking to COP this year, right? And And again, all of these approaches step outside of I think the way CDR one point has thought about the CDR challenge and they try to look for things that are beyond the fourteen approaches. So maybe that's what I would say is you know, the answer, look beyond the fourteen. speaker-3: I have hoped so much to get some secret inter where we as a marketplace can put all our bets onto and then we just run all speaker-0: Everyone wants that. speaker-3: the options on this specific project that can do CDR for 40 euros and we're gonna rock it. But I understand that we've heard the same, for instance, we Stacey from Isometric and she was saying the same, the integration into and like a full on plant, industrial plant where maybe you have different kind of CDR methodologies running at the same time. We had one to DPO, which is obviously another great integration to existing environments. So understand it. obviously, mean, Dan, probably if you look at mineralization or like enhanced rock weathering, a big bottleneck is just the measurement, right? We know if we have some breakthrough on the measurement and suddenly we can measure way better. We can also bring the cost down quite drastically. speaker-1: Yeah, it's somewhat. I think there is a big question in some of these approaches of I fundamentally I've got to get feedstock and I've got to move that feedstock around and spread it. And then I need to come and measure it. And so depending upon where things go, I think that feedstock could get more expensive. It could get more expensive to transport it. MRV costs could come down, but you will reach some fundamental ceiling or or floor in this case, right? Of of kind of where you can get those costs. but I do I do completely agree with Rudy. There, could be novel approaches both on the generation, transportation, spreading, and then maybe measurement of a lot of these different approaches. So one maybe the inverse of the question that that Adrian asked, what do you see right now like losing favor or where you're the like we're we're sort of starting to get ahead of this in our maybe towards 2.0 thinking where 1.0 we thought something was was gonna play a heavy role and now it just looks like that that approach is is unlikely to to hit the right inflection point. speaker-0: Okay. yeah, I mean I think I mentioned this a little bit about you know, DAC earlier. And, you know, there was a lot of hype for DAC. And I don't want to say that DAC is, you know, completely in the doldrums. I mean, there's still some projects that are moving along in certain ways, but I mean it's no secret that DAC has remained very expensive. There were a lot of promises, I think five years ago, ten years ago even about how much it was going to come down in price. I would like to think that our team was ahead a little bit in saying, hey, like what we're looking at, it doesn't look like there's potential for these approaches to come down that much. in our New Frontiers report, we attempted to articulate these costs with a little bit more detail. We we broke out cost stacks for each of our 14 approaches and DAC is one of them. And there's of course many, you know, sim simplifications that we had to make, you know, condensing all of DAC into basically one cost stack that is obviously an impossible. This doesn't represent any individual facility, but hopefully it helps give a sense of where we think, some of those contributions to cost come from. And I'll just say, I think DAC is an ex a perfect example of where we would say the need for innovation is great, right? Is like, yes, there are the approaches that we have today. I think, you know, you guys mentioned Vaulted Deep. DAC has the same kind of thing where there are There are technologies companies today that are building out the first large facilities. and that's going to be very important for getting financing for future facilities. But that doesn't mean that those future facilities need to use the same technology as that first facility that was built today. Right. And I think this is where we would say, again, looking at the new frontier report, what is that new way of doing DAC? Is it some kind of, you know, one of the things we identify in here as a breakthrough shot for DAC is. reactive capture. Is there a way to react carbon out of the environment into some kind of usable product that could completely revolutionize the way we think about this? 'cause currently, you know, for many DAC facilities, it's purely just a machine to extract CO two and then provide no additional value. And that's a tough proposition for a large industrial facility to overcome. speaker-3: Now it's true. I, I gonna be honest when I read through or like first I skimmed through the report to just go to the pricing. I was just like, what is the pricing for each of these 14? And I was quite surprised when I think that was as free 60 or something like that. was the future. And there were biochar went quite down a lot, think 80 or 60 or something along these lines. So I was quite surprised. And I mean, definitely a great insight. I also thought when I saw that you didn't just say this is the price, but rather these are the different parts of the price and how it will look like in the future and what kind of specific prices can go down. I saw someone put some thought behind it. speaker-0: Do I do want to caution just briefly on this because I think a lot of people will look at this. So, you know, we talk to a lot of experts, and a lot of experts, when they look at these cost curves, they say, you know, I'm an expert in such and such pathway, and it's this particular niche, and this isn't exactly the cost, right? It's like, well, the costs that we put together here, these are meant to be illustrative sort of averages each of these approaches. So that's the first thing. And then the second, you know, looking at those future cost stacks, what we were really trying to do there is capture. you know, it's almost like scenario planning when you look at sort of like what the IPCC or IEA does, right? It's not a prediction of the future, it's an assessment of how the future could go if the technology or the space evolves, how you know we we imagine it might. And so basically what we're saying there is, you know, if if DAC, for example, were to build out in some of the ways that we identify in the report, we think it could achieve that price. However, it might not. And if there's certain certain kinds of radical breakthroughs, maybe it actually could do even better than that. So I think it's a way to help understand sort of, hopefully it's a way to help understand where there's potential for drawdowns in cost and gives investors and innovators a way to look at sort of the breakdown the cost and say, okay, I can target in at this particular part of the cost stack and try to bring that piece down. speaker-3: Fantastic. That's, that's good to mention. because that means someone shouldn't just open the report and go off and say, Hey, so can you basically do an offtake for this and this price? Because I know that's going to be the future price. And I think this is important to mention for a procurement or buyer that maybe we'll look at that report and take out some, some good insights, but maybe the same mistake, the me and just. quickly skim through and see the prices and okay. speaker-0: But I think for folks that are are less knowledgeable about CDR, it's incredibly helpful. And this is the thing where I think RMI as an organization, we try to sit between the companies that are on the bleeding edge. They're like, I'm wrestling with my own cost stack. And there's the the scientists who are working in a lab and they're working on a particular thing. And then there's investors who come by the space very fleetingly and they're like, How am I supposed to understand this? We hope that our report, and again, I think that our institution really sits at that interface. And can at least give a snapshot to say, roughly speaking, this is what, this particular approach costs today and roughly where we think it could get with investment. speaker-3: Right, Rudy, thanks so much for coming and sharing some thoughts on an Intel on the reports, which I think is fantastic. And I think as mentioned before, it was quick 124 because it's quite visual. So thanks so much. speaker-0: Very good. Thanks again for having me. Thanks, Rudy. speaker-3: Thanks, bye. Owen, it's fantastic to have you on the CWN. Great. Thanks for joining. You sit on SBTI's technical council, the GHG protocol, standards board and so on. You're also the CTO at Gold Standard. think it's a long vita and at least a reach to me. And so I think we can be honored that you joined the show. Maybe we can... Can you give us a small intro? What are you doing in these all these different fancy frameworks and what are you doing at gold standard? Before we jump into the very juicy other abbreviations, PACM, UCF, SBTI, GHG, and we could probably continue. speaker-2: Yeah, sure. The common thread, I think, or the lens that makes sense of all of the different hats that I wear is that my work is most interested in the intersection between responsible corporate strategies and the way those strategies lead to action, climate mitigation action specifically. What I've found over the years starting in carbon markets is that if you don't pay attention to what good corporate responsibility is, you can make some very wonky arguments about, for example, how to use carbon credits. so the career trajectory, I suppose you could sum up as saying, has walked this tightrope between those two things. How do we use these good mechanisms like carbon markets or commodity certificates or anything that in acts climate mitigation in the context of responsible corporate climate strategies and put those two things together and you've got something very powerful, I hope. And so yeah, that's my role at Gold Standard actually is specifically across those two areas. So we have our Gold Standard for the Global Goals, carbon crediting, climate action program, which we're probably best known for, but we also have a corporate facing program, which is looking much more at corporate climate strategies. publish an annual climate and nature. corporate strategy framework, for example. And yeah, that makes sense of why I sit on all of those other bodies, I suppose, trying to bring that angle to their work. I'd like to think I add something in the world of standard setting generally, but I think it's primarily because our work and my work has trod that line between good action and good responsibility and where that meets you hopefully get good results. speaker-3: And I think this is also where Gold Standard for me always from the outside perspective took a really different role where they're not only like, here are some credits, but rather also giving guidance because we all know like, if there is no climate, I would say ambition from the companies or if there's no framework that they can use, then you can have as many credits as you like, and you can even have the best credits in the world, will not help you. But if we piece all these different things together, so we have the Paris Agreement, we have PACM, we have SBTI, we have ISO, we have GHG, they're all sort of try to help corporates at a certain point, right, to contribute to a net zero or also other things. can you give us a picture how do these things fit together and where is there maybe a disconnect in today's world, but more so from a corporate perspective, I would say. speaker-2: Yeah. Well, think the first thing to acknowledge is there's a lot going on and there's a lot for companies to get a handle on. There's a lot of acronyms to learn. There's a lot of pages of standards. so I think somebody like me that sits across a lot of these things and is across the detail, I think it's worth putting our heads back up above the surface and saying, you know, there's probably too much of this stuff. There's too much detail to cope with if you're a company right now. So would acknowledge that first. Then I would say, if you step back from it all, the picture of the last five years, I see a consolidation of what companies would ideally be doing. So let's put it as simply as that. So we know we've got a climate emergency. We've got a pretty good handle on the science and the direction of the temperature goals. And in that context, and with an understanding of how business works, there's a movement towards trying to capture, primarily in standards frameworks. what it is a good company would be doing in that crisis. And I think you can read science-based targets as that. And we try and capture something similar in gold standards frameworks. Now you can get into whether you think they've captured it right. That's another question, but that is ultimately what it's trying to do. And then there's other frameworks. The greenhouse gas protocol has a role to play in that in accounting and reporting mechanisms like ours or PACM have a role to play in how you enact some of responsibilities, but the movement is towards what is a good company doing. I think the change, and it happened between Kyoto and the Paris Agreement, the change in mentality went from what I would call arbitrary and relative definitions to absolute sort logic-based definitions. So you could sum up science-based targets in a really simple way, which is we move from what was a world of reduce as much as you can and offset the rest to something which is science-based, as the name suggests. I think that's really important. Paris does the same thing. Kyoto was somewhat arbitrary legally binding, but somewhat arbitrary negotiated targets and was replaced by Paris, which has a temperature goal. Not legally binding, lots of other stuff going on, but much more logic-based. That's the era we're in. What you're seeing, I think, is the blossoming, I hope, or maybe sprouting is another word. of lots of standards that are trying to address different moving parts of that responsibility ecosystem. What I would say is the flip side of that coin though. I think it's very good that we have critically reasoned, science-based, logic-based definitions of responsibility, even if that's complex. I don't have a lot of sympathy for complexity if complexity is the answer to the problem. What I would say we maybe lack at the moment is what to do if you're not able to hit all of those good practices. So what does a company just starting out do? Where's the guidance for that? Where's the guidance for a company that maybe started out doing great things on their science-based targets, but has hit walls, right? Because they don't control everything. What do you do then? And I think some of that, what to do when you're maybe not on target or what to do when you're thinking about targets. What does responsibility look like in those margins, I think, is a really important question that's not really being addressed. speaker-1: we hear some from our buyers. I'm curious how this resonates with you that yeah, obviously we need frameworks for companies to do this setting themselves and we need a common standard that everybody is thinking across. But I often hear this hesitation of well, there's not clear guidance beyond X year. And as a result of that, I'm just gonna sit on my hands for now and not do anything. And if sometimes it feels to me as a supplier who hope who kind of wishes that speaker-2: this result. speaker-1: crystal clear for a buyer so they would know how to interact with a company like me. Now I wish it was cleaner for them and didn't give them a an ability to to sit on the sidelines. How how do you think or how how are you working through these different coalitions to try to address that point to get to a spot where a company actually does see this as motivation and clear, clear alignment now as opposed to wow, this is really complicated. Let's just give it a few more years and see where it all lands. speaker-2: Yeah, good question. And I think that speaks to what I was saying about this lack of definition in the margins, I suppose, as we move towards what good looks like. And I think there's consensus emerging around what good looks like, even if there's not necessarily full clarity on every detail. But it's what you do in the space leading up to that, that is still an open series of questions. And so I think it's a good question to ask. How do we ensure that while things are developing or things aren't clear or when a company is struggling or when geopolitics changes the way companies address some of these issues, what do we do then? I think if you step back from the complexity of the ecosystem that's emerged, it's still at heart an intent slash action slash claim mantra. You have to have an intent. You want to do something about the climate crisis. Ideally, you follow good practice and address it that way. But in some way, your company is thinking about this for different reasons. And you have to act on it. There's lots of levers you could pull from internal to supplier engagement to things like the mechanisms that you guys in Gold Standard works on in the carbon markets. And then you have to talk about it. It's those three things really. And I think there does need to emerge a simple... what to do if you can't do everything framework, which is a lot simpler, not necessarily standardized. you know, you're waiting for science-based targets. Here's what you do while you're waiting. And it has to include, I think those three levers. What is the intent? What are the actions you take and how do you talk about them? And I think if you can get that right. And I think where a lot of effort has maybe struggled in the past is the gap between that intent, action and claim. Then, you know, good things follow. So in terms of what. those frameworks are doing while those frameworks are really focusing on their good practice. hope to see interim guidance from some of them. They're standards after all, so there's going to have to be things like grandfathering and sunset clauses for earlier versions. So you hope to see transitionary guidance, but I actually think something else needs to emerge, which is this. speaker-1: yeah. speaker-2: as you build up to, or as you're getting yourself back on track, whenever that situation your company finds itself in, here's some good principles for how to set an intent, how to take action, how to talk about it. And I think it's challenging because efforts to do that, if not done well, incredibly can also lead to a kind of more intentional version of what you just described down, which is, it's not clear. So I'm actually going to take advantage of that and delay action. Right. I don't think that is generally the case with companies. think most companies saying we need more clarity, genuinely need more clarity. I hope there's not too much nefarious action going on. I'm sure it goes on, but you don't want to enable that. You don't want to create a guidance that says, actually it's totally fine. And just to do this little bit over here, what the complexity sorts itself out. So it's hard. It's hard to find that balance, but I do think that that guidance needs to exist. I hope to see it in the next couple of years. speaker-3: Yeah, because what what I'm seeing is basically what you just mentioned is that there are some industries, let's say, for instance, automotive, right? Automotive was one of the biggest buyers of common credits. But especially in Europe, the automotive space is not in best shape. So suddenly, we see all the automotive companies pulling out of the market completely because they said, like, look, first of all, I can't make the claims that I did before, right with co and so on. Like they were carbon neutral cars, think the one car is Volkswagen. That is not there anymore. then a lot of them are in SBTI. But SBTI, like at least in the past, also said, look, you don't necessarily have to take responsibility for your emissions at the moment. You obviously have to reduce, but for the rest, it's fine. So we see the automotive industry struggling. So no one is investing from automotive space in New York. And that's basically it. So the first thing that cuts obviously is the things that are not mandatory. And then we see other industries like pharmaceuticals. pharmaceuticals work really well. Everyone's sick basically. That's what they're trying to say. But now, okay, pharmaceutical companies, are buying credits, or at least there's a lot of movement at the moment. And it feels like there's a direct correlation always when companies doing really well, then they will invest in climate. But there's now in between, feels like, or at least at this moment. I hope, this is actually what I want to allude to, is the whole SBTI ongoing emission responsibility. So from my perspective, I haven't seen a lot of companies because it's not live yet, right? but I feel like that's maybe the 1 % are the first step. I think it's engaged status. Maybe could be a default, where you can always fall back to because it's not that high. Like how do you think about this whole OER and have you seen that companies are taking that up positively or like what is your whole thinking as we are really close to it? from your perspective on SBTI but also called standard. speaker-2: Yeah. OER has been a real, even in the acronym that labels it, it's been an evolving journey over the last 10 years. Even just immediately post Paris, we were still very much in a carbon neutral claims world. Then those things started to get attacked more and more and litigated critically. think that's the change, not just criticized, but litigated. Once you've got litigation, companies will run a mile. And some companies can live with some criticism. They'll fight back. Some would prefer not to engage, but no company wants to be sued for their claims. That's really not where you want to be, especially when you're trying to do a good thing. I think that litigation, that sort of litigation era changed a lot. But I think at the same time, there was a good robust conversation about in this ecosystem of overall good practice, what is it we want companies to do? And I think the discussion there was to say, well, look, yes, you can be reducing your emissions, you know, towards a science-based targets towards a global definition. But what do you do on the journey to that? Cause you're still emitting and what is the, what is that decision that says we should emit for this, but not for that? You know, do we make candy bars, but cancel opera, for example? And, you know, these sounds like absurd. conversations, but the world's on fire here. At some point, those conversations will end up happening one way or another, or they'll just happen to us. But you also can't really choose between candy bars and opera or sport or technology. It doesn't make any sense. You end up in really nebulous conversations. so the right way to think about that is that you take responsibility for those emissions on the journey. if those responsibility for those emissions becomes very expensive or unviable, that's telling you something. That's telling you something about the viability of that source of emissions overall. It's a very logical construct, just a difficult one to sell, I think. I think it does help that the legitimacy and credibility of SPTI to say, actually there should be responsibility for your ongoing emissions on that journey. Recognizing that the bar for entry should be low, because it's a difficult thing to, I'm sure, for a sustainability officer to sell to their board. That attracts people in. What I would say is the two things. One is that carbon neutral, although it was a a claim that's difficult to technically defend and at risk of litigation was somewhat charismatic and easily understood. And that simplicity was useful. speaker-3: a lot of volume. It was straightforward and a board would say, I understand carbon neutral. speaker-2: Yeah, speaker-3: to a company. speaker-2: you don't need any lecture explaining it. It makes easy sense to a board member, whereas OER, you have to explain the acronym, you have to explain what it fits in the ecosystem and that's difficult. So I think we did lose something with that change. And I think we have to think really carefully about is SBTI as a brand and legitimate endorser of that act enough? Do need something else? Do you need the new carbon neutral or is it just the fact that it's legitimized enough? That I don't know the answer to. I think that's an interesting topic for conversation. I would also say, and David Kennedy, the CEO of SPTI made some really interesting points this year, I thought around and got some criticism for it. I would maybe step in and defend a little bit. I some criticism for saying, we want companies to stay in even if they're off track for their targets. We don't want to be kicking people out of the tent. I think that is a dose of reality because the chances of every company on an upward or downward curve for their emissions to stay on track perfectly till 2022, it doesn't sound right even just saying it on that. Of course, there's going to be companies off track. Why would you want to kick them out? I maybe there's egregious cases of gaming and various malfeasance or whatever, but for most companies, if you slip off target for a few years, you kind of want to keep them in the tent. There's also a discussion I think to be had around if you are in that situation, again, back to my earlier point, what should you do? Because your ongoing emissions responsibility is effectively going up in that situation, right? Maybe you're 5 % off target. So what? What do you do? There's a balance to be struck there. Some companies might be better off reinvesting that money to get back on target, or maybe some companies that are off target have no ability to do that at the moment because of some political thing or some control aspect. So OER might be the act they need to take in those interim years. I think there's a lot of discussion not just to be had around the good of OER, that I'm on target and I'm taking responsibility for my ongoing emissions. think that's the optimal case. But there's also this, how do you use the same toolbox to support those companies that need to get back on track? think that'll be really interesting. Then as I say, and I think SBTI announced this and others have talked about it too, there needs to be work done on claims. I mentioned litigation earlier. You could characterize the last 10 years of claims discussion are very much led by two things. One is what not to do. so don't do carbon neutral, you get sued for it. And the other is that it's led logically by technical people like me. So this is what a credit represents. This is what the act is. Therefore it's a contribution and this ongoing emissions responsibility. There's a reason they don't let people like me name exciting things, right? It's like we know what it is under the hood. I'm not a salesman. My colleagues in things like technical councils and standards boards are generally not salesmen either. What we can tell you is what it represents. Then smarter people than us in that field can make it sexier than I can, I hope. speaker-1: Just to change gears a little bit, there's been a a huge proliferation of new standards bodies, groups that have that popped up, you know, Rainbow and Isometric and Equitable Earth and many others, right? That are that are looking at kind of new ways of whether it's digital MRV kind of coupled with a new approach or new methodologies expanding into areas that the traditional registries sort of hadn't ever hadn't ever looked at before. How you view that that motion right now? You know, I've I've heard other groups start to feel a little bit of I created that idea, that that new methodology was was ours and should have maybe we should have patented it or trademarked it in some way because now the same concept seems like it's going other w I you know, I see that as positive progress and and one kind of bouncing off another, but I'm just curious where where do you guys sit in that world of the proliferation of standards? You know, is this is this positive or Or or confusing from your standpoint. speaker-2: Yeah, I personally think it's a positive thing. I like to see competitive innovation. I don't see any harm in more standards, provided that we are on an upward curve in terms of ambition and quality and we're thinking about the use of our instruments, not just how many we can issue. Then I see innovation as a competitive competition for innovation as an exciting time. Gold standard is an interesting institution in that sense. I think we started in 2003, but maybe registered in 2006. So it's 20 years old, right? So relatively young in organizational terms, but a dinosaur in terms of the carbon markets. But it's an interesting NGO in the sense that it is quite competitive itself. Not competitive to make a profit, that's not on our minds at all, but competitive in the market sense, in the sense that we want to offer a great product. we want to be efficient, that we want to offer quality. I think that makes it really exciting as a place to be. We see some really interesting innovations from those other bodies. What I would say, think maybe two things that do somewhat concern me sometimes is how we think about the market and how it affects the action that we want companies to support. What I mean by that is there's been a move in the last 10 years to focus on certain activity types. So, CDR being big one and CDR is an important part of the spectrum. But if you were to lay out a theory of change for CDR in something like science-based targets and for company strategies, it would go something along the lines of the IPCC told us that we have to achieve net zero and that involves a temperature goal by 2050 and neutralizing residual emissions with durable or whatever the word was, CDR. That was the scientific basis. And secondly, you can infer from that and other reports that it should be part of company targets because it must be funded and supported by the private sector. There's no public purse coming to support this stuff. So there's your two inputs and the output is companies support CDR, CDR grows. We saved the world, hopefully. And that is also true of some things that... tend to be forgotten. It's also true of nature. I'm not just saying that as an opinion. I'm saying that IPCC reports say the same thing, that it is essential to net zero and the same reports that say CDR should be funded say the private sector needs to support nature. That would also be true of access to energy services for communities, for example, clean cooking, safe water, solar lighting. Exactly the same science that IEA says that needs to be private sector funded for us to hit their preferred net zero scenario for energy. I think it's really important that in those rush to new standards, in new buyers and new entrants to the market, which is already exciting, we just keep an eye on the market bias, I suppose, that pulls us in certain directions. Is that useful for climate change or is that useful for certain buyer mentalities or seller mentalities? I think we just have to keep an eye on that. necessarily in favor of the instrument being used for just one thing. But otherwise, yeah, a very exciting time, I think. And you asked a question there about digital MRV. So Gold Sound is an interesting actor in this space. So we moved quite fast and we're pretty far ahead in terms of project side DMRV. Right now there's a consultation out that looks at requirements for projects in terms of use of technology within the standards. So you can bring forward the technology you want to use. have it assessed. Where we're maybe slightly behind is in the end-to-end digital certification process that new entrants have been able to build from scratch. I mentioned being a dinosaur somewhat unkindly. There's a history of PDFs and Word documents and Excel spreadsheets that we are changing. So the platform, those that watch Gold Standard, you'll know we have an assurance platform that launched last year. And over the next two years, you'll see that become fully digital. So we'll catch that up. And it will be interesting to see how much of a USP it is to go first, I guess. speaker-3: So we see Mombak on Gold Standard. speaker-2: Sorry. speaker-3: We're gonna see Mombak on Gold Standard. speaker-2: Exactly. I tell you the other thing that, sorry to rattle on, but the other thing that occurs to me in lots of new entrants and standards, and I say this not as a competitor, but as the more that do this well and successfully, the better for the climate, is it's very important to see how a standard system responds when there's a problem. We, being 20 years in the market, have been through several of those. So standards aren't there to get everything right all the time. I always think a good standard is there to have requirements that mitigate as many of the risks as you can possibly be aware of. But then second to that, a good standard system knows how to and will respond well to a crisis. So we've had crises, you can go on our website and see the grievances that have affected gold standard. We navigated through the Guardian crisis pretty well, I think. So the proof I think of a good standard startup is when it really hits the fan, will they do the right thing? And that's hard. That's really hard. You look at your own work and go, you know what, we didn't get that right. That's a hard thing to do. takes courage to do that. So I guess it's my sort of too long in the market, supportive advice to everybody is just do the right thing when something goes wrong and then you'll be fine. speaker-1: Yeah. Well, with with the growth in a lot of these new methodologies and projects coming online and so on, I think they're they're we're bound to have some moments of correction speaker-2: Yeah. speaker-0: Let's see. speaker-1: where where some of these newer standards evolve. And yeah, maybe I'll be knocking on your door in a year's time saying, I break some project. No, I think you know, we're we're excited about isometric and a number of these others standards right now, but but obviously, you know, everyone has has has work to do to push push this whole the the science forward, the, simplifying and streamlining this for both suppliers and buyers and and continue to bring more confidence to to every credit that's issued. So I think we're we're excited to see we have how the innovation cycle happens here. speaker-2: And I think, you know, I have high hopes. know lots of the professionals at various newsstands and existing standards bodies and, you know, those kind of crucible moments when something goes wrong or where you really prove what you stand for. So high hopes. speaker-3: Fantastic, on maybe to wrap it up. Is it like one thing that you see currently in the market where you say like, if you could solve that, that would bring us forward by quite a bit. speaker-2: Yeah, I think we've touched on some of it already. the use of the market in the context of starting up your climate strategy or not being on target or correcting course or whatever, I would love to see that emerge. And I'm sure Goal Standard will play a role as it does emerge. The other area I would say that's interesting to me at the moment is You may have seen in the science-based targets and greenhouse gas protocol, this emergence of a discussion on actions and market instruments, which sounds really another thing for technical people rather than marketing people. But I think it's a really interesting moment because what it's doing, if I can explain it in a nutshell, is historically corporate climate target achievement was based on what I would call, or what the space would call the physical inventory. Emission sources that you can directly trace to your action basically. And if you wanted to achieve a target, you reduce your footprint, but the only things that could reduce your footprint would be traceable. So you need to find all your suppliers, you'd need to work with them and you'd need to cut emissions with them. Now that in the real world doesn't work. There's no way, for example, a big company can know every supplier and those suppliers would change. And while you could make a case that, that's tough. There are also cases like if you were buying from a cooperative of farmers, are you going to force those farmers to tell you which one supplied you? That's not very ethical. So clearly the focus of targets on just the physical traceable inventory is a busted flush. And what emerges is this space where we think about what else might count. Now, there was a big blow up around carbon credits generally counting towards corporate targets. And that wasn't because they're carbon credits almost, some people would make out that it was. It was more because You can't have operations making steel in Poland and say you're on target because you bought red plus credits from Brazil. It just doesn't make sense. It's clearly not true. But there is a space in between, which is I don't know which exactly my steel suppliers were, so I'm going to work with a group of them. If that were my supplier, then this is what my inventory would now look like. Similarly with farmers, maybe I don't know which smallholder supplies me and actually trying to find out is a waste of money and time and probably harmful. But if I work with a group of farmers in that sourcing region, then that should count in some ways. So it loosens the grip of physical traceability. And the reason I share all of that is that projects, I think that we see in the carbon markets, like the ones I've just mentioned, for example, they have an opportunity to serve multiple responsibilities that a company might have. So maybe an agriculture project is in somebody's Scope 3 inventory and they can count some of the results there. Or maybe it's in a sourcing region, not traceable, but can count towards a target that a company has. And maybe they want to sell some of that to the carbon markets as carbon credits, or maybe there's a mix of on-farm and off-farm or on-farm and farmer domestic situation support. The flexibility I think that can bring to projects, so setting aside the market a second is enormous and increases the sources of funding. The challenge with it is it's complex. So how do you flip from one use case to another? Can you do more than one in the same year? I think we're starting to see some of those ideas emerge. The Greenhouse Gas Protocol published their white paper on it. think it's isometric. Have a book and claim. a system that they're looking at. is scope three program. So we're starting to see standards grapple with that. I don't think we've got the right answers yet in this space, but it's great to see people innovating. But what I think we'll see more and more of is companies have lots of reasons to support a project. The carbon market can be a really good vehicle for that. And if we can make it so that it's a vehicle that's flexible enough to work across those use cases, then the market expands. That's what I really hope to see. You mentioned earlier the general sense that OER and good claims can grow the market. I think that's totally true. That's one way of doing it. think another way is regulation, domestic markets emerging. I think this is exciting emerging third way, which is enabling those same projects, same instrument to cross into other responsibilities that companies might have. I'd love to see all of those things working together. The challenge is how do you make them all work together without tripping over each other, double counting? people understand what you're talking about even. So, exciting, but complex time as always. speaker-3: 100 % that I think it's very interesting because it would also solve the whole market instrument thing. The thing I said before, maybe a company still works towards a reduction target and gets budget for that, but they don't get budget for offsetting or contribution or whatever. If suddenly you can use this for your reduction goal, then suddenly you solved something again. and have budget again, magically. So I think from that perspective, it's, I think it could be an attractive solution, but we obviously also have to learn from everything that didn't work and how can we make it better. But I think we actually have all the verification infrastructure already, but we can just use and apply for that. speaker-2: think so. We've got a habit, I think, in the carbon market of maybe disaggregating or siloing, I'm not sure what the word is, along specific lines. So maybe it's a use case. You know, we think of ITMOs or we think of OER or we think of offsetting and then we do the same thing along activity types. So there's a CDR space, there's a cook stove space, there's a red plus space. But companies don't really, I mean that's... None of those overlays make any sense to a company. There's no company talking about those overlays in their strategy. They're thinking about what do they have to do? How do they hit their targets? Where else can they claim? I think it's hard, but if we can step back a little bit from the minutiae, even the market itself is a strata in some ways. Just saying, we work in the carbon market as opposed to a commodity certificate, as opposed to a fund. If we can step back from all of those strata and see how they fit together. the same action is countable in several places. You could have in your scenario there, you could have a company that does have the budget to support it from a target perspective, but it also frees up that project to issue carbon credits for the balance that funds it in another way and makes it profitable that way. Maybe they work together with the company to free up even more budget. There's lots of ways, I think, to approach this that become unlocked if you can see the whole picture, which is what led Gold Standard in the first place to this thinking about corporate responsibility as well as the carbon market. But, know, boy, when you step back from adult and you see all the different threads, you can see why people do silo. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-2: It's a lot of complexity to manage all at once. That's the challenge. How do we, how do we make that simple? That's the, that's the challenge of the next five years, I think. speaker-3: Fantastic. So in five years, everything will be solved. speaker-2: years. Heard it here first. Yep. Do we'll do this again in 2031. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-3: actually nothing has changed. No, let's work out to not end up in the same spot again at five years. So thanks so much, And yeah, have a fantastic day and talk in five years. speaker-1: Thanks, both. All right. See you. speaker-3: If you've loved this episode, please, please, please hit the subscribe button. The more followers we have, the more guests we can get and the more coverage we will be able to provide. So thank you so much for your support.