Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 24 - Not All is Lost (Just Some)
Transcript
- 0:00Good
- 0:00to
- 0:00see
- 0:00you.
- 0:01Good
- 0:01to
- 0:01see
- 0:01you
- 0:01too.
- 0:02Since
- 0:02I
- 0:02saw
- 0:02you
- 0:02last,
- 0:03I
- 0:03mean,
- 0:03you
- 0:03are
- 0:03like
- 0:03a
- 0:04podcast
- 0:04phenomenon.
- 0:05I
- 0:06mean,
- 0:06I
- 0:06see.
- 0:07I
- 0:07can't
- 0:07even
- 0:08keep
- 0:08up
- 0:08with
- 0:08all
- 0:09the
- 0:09great
- 0:09conversations
- 0:10you're
- 0:10having
- 0:10here.
- 0:10And
- 0:10now
- 0:11you
- 0:11show
- 0:11up,
- 0:11you
- 0:12got
- 0:12a
- 0:12jacket
- 0:12on,
- 0:13you
- 0:13got
- 0:13a
- 0:13collar
- 0:14shirt
- 0:14on,
- 0:14you
- 0:15got
- 0:15a
- 0:15new
- 0:15background.
- 0:16I
- 0:16mean,
- 0:16dude,
- 0:16you're
- 0:16going
- 0:16legit
- 0:17on
- 0:17the
- 0:17year.
- 0:18I
- 0:18don't
- 0:18know.
- 0:18I
- 0:18don't
- 0:19know.
- 0:19I
- 0:19don't
- 0:19know.
- 0:19I
- 0:19don't
- 0:19know
- 0:20about
- 0:20any
- 0:20of
- 0:20that.
- 0:21But
- 0:21yeah,
- 0:22there's
- 0:22been
- 0:22a
- 0:22lot
- 0:23going
- 0:23on.
- 0:23What
- 0:23I've
- 0:23been
- 0:23doing.
- 0:24I've
- 0:24just
- 0:24been
- 0:24traveling
- 0:24a
- 0:25ton
- 0:25since
- 0:25I
- 0:25last
- 0:25saw
- 0:26you.
- 0:26I've
- 0:26been.
- 0:26I've
- 0:26been
- 0:27all
- 0:27over
- 0:27the
- 0:27place.
- 0:28Out
- 0:29west,
- 0:29New
- 0:30Orleans,
- 0:31all
- 0:31through
- 0:31New
- 0:31England.
- 0:33And
- 0:34I
- 0:34got
- 0:34a
- 0:34little
- 0:34bit
- 0:34of
- 0:35time
- 0:35off
- 0:35and
- 0:35I
- 0:35got
- 0:36a
- 0:36little
- 0:36time
- 0:36in
- 0:36Colorado
- 0:37with
- 0:37one
- 0:37of
- 0:37my
- 0:37kids
- 0:37skiing.
- 0:38So
- 0:38what
- 0:38have
- 0:38you
- 0:38been
- 0:39up
- 0:39to?
- 0:39Hey,
- 0:40I've
- 0:40been
- 0:40traveling
- 0:40a
- 0:40lot,
- 0:41too.
- 0:41I
- 0:41was
- 0:41in.
- 0:42After
- 0:42I
- 0:42was
- 0:42in
- 0:43dc,
- 0:43I
- 0:43got
- 0:43to
- 0:43Colorado
- 0:44and
- 0:46have
- 0:47been
- 0:47doing
- 0:47a
- 0:47lot
- 0:47of
- 0:48work
- 0:48in.
- 0:48In
- 0:49various
- 0:49places
- 0:49a
- 0:50lot
- 0:50of
- 0:50times.
- 0:50A
- 0:51lot
- 0:51of
- 0:51work
- 0:51in
- 0:51Texas
- 0:52right
- 0:52now.
- 0:53A
- 0:53lot
- 0:53of
- 0:53interesting
- 0:54stuff,
- 0:54you
- 0:54know,
- 0:55going
- 0:55on
- 0:55in.
- 0:56In.
- 0:56In
- 0:57Delaware
- 0:58even,
- 0:58and,
- 0:58and
- 0:59Tennessee.
- 0:59So
- 1:00there's
- 1:00a
- 1:00lot
- 1:00of
- 1:00good
- 1:00stuff
- 1:00going
- 1:01on
- 1:01in
- 1:01charter
- 1:01folk,
- 1:01these
- 1:01at
- 1:02Charter
- 1:02World
- 1:02these
- 1:02days,
- 1:03but
- 1:04also
- 1:04just
- 1:04craziness
- 1:05in
- 1:05the
- 1:05space.
- 1:06Texas
- 1:07is
- 1:07just
- 1:07such
- 1:07an
- 1:08interesting
- 1:08state
- 1:09right
- 1:09now.
- 1:10Like,
- 1:10it's
- 1:11going
- 1:11in
- 1:11so
- 1:12many
- 1:12directions.
- 1:15Some
- 1:16that
- 1:16are
- 1:16really
- 1:17interesting,
- 1:17some
- 1:17that
- 1:17are
- 1:17concerning.
- 1:18Like,
- 1:18all.
- 1:18It
- 1:18was
- 1:19like
- 1:19a
- 1:19bundle
- 1:19of
- 1:19contradictions
- 1:20and
- 1:20it's
- 1:21like,
- 1:21not
- 1:21exactly
- 1:22clear
- 1:22how
- 1:22it
- 1:23plays
- 1:23out
- 1:23and
- 1:23yet.
- 1:23And
- 1:24people
- 1:24are
- 1:24like
- 1:24moving
- 1:24there
- 1:24in
- 1:25droves.
- 1:25It's
- 1:25really
- 1:26interesting.
- 1:27Fascinating,
- 1:27for
- 1:27sure.
- 1:28And
- 1:28then
- 1:28I'll
- 1:28be
- 1:29writing
- 1:29about
- 1:29this
- 1:29later.
- 1:29I
- 1:30had
- 1:30an
- 1:30amazing
- 1:31weekend.
- 1:31I
- 1:32had
- 1:32students
- 1:33from
- 1:33Hooper
- 1:34Avenue
- 1:34that
- 1:35I
- 1:35had
- 1:3525
- 1:36years
- 1:36ago
- 1:37got
- 1:37together
- 1:37for
- 1:38reunion,
- 1:38had
- 1:38me
- 1:38come
- 1:39down.
- 1:39So
- 1:40I
- 1:40got
- 1:40to
- 1:40see
- 1:40a
- 1:40half
- 1:41dozen
- 1:41students,
- 1:42one
- 1:42teacher
- 1:43that
- 1:43we
- 1:43worked
- 1:43with
- 1:44all
- 1:44this
- 1:44time.
- 1:45And
- 1:45to
- 1:45hear
- 1:45these
- 1:45amazing,
- 1:46amazing
- 1:47stories,
- 1:47Andy,
- 1:48it's
- 1:48just
- 1:48so.
- 1:49Yes,
- 1:49say
- 1:49a
- 1:49little
- 1:50bit
- 1:50more
- 1:50about
- 1:50that.
- 1:50What
- 1:50was
- 1:50that
- 1:51like
- 1:51for
- 1:51you?
- 1:52It's
- 1:52incredible.
- 1:53I
- 1:53just,
- 1:53you
- 1:53know,
- 1:54these.
- 1:54These
- 1:54kids
- 1:55have
- 1:56come
- 1:56through
- 1:57such
- 1:57challenges
- 1:58and
- 1:59a
- 1:59lot
- 1:59of
- 2:00them,
- 2:00about
- 2:00half
- 2:01ended
- 2:01up
- 2:01getting
- 2:01undergraduate
- 2:02degrees
- 2:03and
- 2:04others
- 2:04are
- 2:04on
- 2:05the
- 2:05cusp
- 2:05of
- 2:05finally
- 2:06finishing.
- 2:08They're
- 2:08all
- 2:09in.
- 2:09In
- 2:10strong
- 2:10relationships.
- 2:11They
- 2:11have
- 2:12kids,
- 2:12they
- 2:12found
- 2:13ways
- 2:13to
- 2:13buy
- 2:14houses.
- 2:15One
- 2:17student
- 2:17is
- 2:18still
- 2:18living
- 2:18right
- 2:18near
- 2:19Hooper
- 2:19Avenue,
- 2:20so
- 2:21she
- 2:21is
- 2:21still
- 2:22renting.
- 2:22But
- 2:23it's
- 2:23just
- 2:23amazing
- 2:24to
- 2:24hear
- 2:25how
- 2:25they've
- 2:25pushed
- 2:25through
- 2:26so
- 2:26many
- 2:26things.
- 2:27A
- 2:27particular
- 2:27student
- 2:28also
- 2:29not
- 2:29having
- 2:29his
- 2:30documents,
- 2:31had
- 2:31to
- 2:31go
- 2:32back
- 2:32to
- 2:32Mexico
- 2:33for
- 2:33some
- 2:33period
- 2:33of
- 2:34time
- 2:34before
- 2:35he
- 2:35came
- 2:35back.
- 2:36And
- 2:37I
- 2:37mean,
- 2:37gosh,
- 2:38what
- 2:38the
- 2:38tearjerker
- 2:39story
- 2:39was,
- 2:40he
- 2:40didn't
- 2:40tell
- 2:41his
- 2:41family
- 2:42that
- 2:42he
- 2:42had
- 2:42gotten
- 2:43his
- 2:43papers.
- 2:44He
- 2:44got
- 2:44them
- 2:45right
- 2:45before
- 2:45Christmas.
- 2:46He
- 2:46literally
- 2:47showed
- 2:47up
- 2:47on
- 2:48Christmas
- 2:48Day
- 2:49back
- 2:49in
- 2:50Los
- 2:50Angeles.
- 2:50You
- 2:51know,
- 2:51he
- 2:52finally
- 2:52had
- 2:52his
- 2:52residency.
- 2:53He
- 2:54went
- 2:54on,
- 2:54got
- 2:54himself
- 2:55his
- 2:55undergraduate
- 2:56degree,
- 2:57is
- 2:57an
- 2:57accountant
- 2:58right
- 2:58now.
- 2:58It's
- 2:59just.
- 2:59It's
- 2:59just
- 2:59amazing.
- 3:00Just
- 3:00absolutely
- 3:00amazing.
- 3:01So.
- 3:02And
- 3:02whatever.
- 3:03Some
- 3:03of
- 3:03this
- 3:03gets
- 3:04wrapped
- 3:04up
- 3:04into,
- 3:04like,
- 3:04immigration
- 3:05stuff
- 3:05and
- 3:06whatever
- 3:07people's
- 3:07politics,
- 3:08I
- 3:08just.
- 3:08But
- 3:09I
- 3:09don't
- 3:09know,
- 3:09I
- 3:09feel
- 3:09like
- 3:10you
- 3:10get
- 3:10closer
- 3:10to
- 3:10these
- 3:11families
- 3:11and
- 3:11you
- 3:11get
- 3:11closer
- 3:12to
- 3:12these
- 3:12people,
- 3:12you're
- 3:13like,
- 3:13who
- 3:14would
- 3:14not
- 3:14want
- 3:14these
- 3:15folks
- 3:15as
- 3:15a
- 3:15part
- 3:16of
- 3:16our,
- 3:16our
- 3:17world
- 3:17right
- 3:17now?
- 3:18They're
- 3:18making
- 3:18such
- 3:19important
- 3:19contributions,
- 3:20and
- 3:21I
- 3:21take
- 3:21such
- 3:21inspiration
- 3:22from
- 3:22them.
- 3:23Yeah,
- 3:23I
- 3:23mean,
- 3:24look,
- 3:24I
- 3:24think,
- 3:24you
- 3:25know,
- 3:26I
- 3:26think
- 3:26most
- 3:27people
- 3:27actually,
- 3:27our
- 3:28politics
- 3:28are
- 3:28divisive
- 3:29around
- 3:29this.
- 3:29Most
- 3:29people
- 3:29agree
- 3:30on
- 3:30two
- 3:30things.
- 3:30We
- 3:30need
- 3:31like
- 3:31a
- 3:31proper
- 3:31border
- 3:32and
- 3:32some
- 3:33order
- 3:33at
- 3:33the
- 3:33border.
- 3:34But
- 3:34also,
- 3:34like,
- 3:35immigration
- 3:35makes
- 3:36this
- 3:36country
- 3:36better.
- 3:37It
- 3:37always
- 3:37has.
- 3:38And
- 3:38you
- 3:39know,
- 3:39that.
- 3:39That's.
- 3:39That's
- 3:40sort
- 3:40of
- 3:40been
- 3:40our
- 3:40secret
- 3:41strength.
- 3:41And
- 3:42honestly,
- 3:42if
- 3:42you
- 3:42look
- 3:42at
- 3:43the
- 3:43data
- 3:43on
- 3:43the
- 3:43labor
- 3:43market,
- 3:44we
- 3:44also,
- 3:44like,
- 3:44even
- 3:45if
- 3:45you're
- 3:45not
- 3:45persuaded
- 3:46by
- 3:46sort
- 3:47of
- 3:47that
- 3:47immigration
- 3:47makes,
- 3:48then
- 3:48diversity
- 3:48makes
- 3:49this
- 3:49country
- 3:50stronger
- 3:50and
- 3:50better
- 3:51and
- 3:51more
- 3:51innovative
- 3:51over
- 3:52time.
- 3:52If
- 3:52you're
- 3:52not
- 3:52persuaded
- 3:52by
- 3:53any
- 3:53of
- 3:53that,
- 3:53you
- 3:53should
- 3:53just
- 3:53be
- 3:53persuaded
- 3:54by
- 3:54the
- 3:54numbers
- 3:54we
- 3:55need.
- 3:55We
- 3:56don't
- 3:56have
- 3:56enough
- 3:56Americans
- 3:57right
- 3:57now,
- 3:57and
- 3:57so
- 3:58we
- 3:58need.
- 3:58We
- 3:58need
- 3:59people.
- 4:01It's
- 4:01a
- 4:01debate
- 4:02that
- 4:02does.
- 4:02I
- 4:02mean,
- 4:02I'm
- 4:03biased.
- 4:03Like,
- 4:03you
- 4:03know,
- 4:04my
- 4:04family
- 4:04not
- 4:04very
- 4:05long
- 4:05ago
- 4:05immigrated
- 4:05here.
- 4:06So
- 4:06I
- 4:06guess
- 4:06I'm
- 4:06biased.
- 4:07But,
- 4:07like,
- 4:07the
- 4:08debate
- 4:09doesn't
- 4:09make,
- 4:09outside
- 4:10of
- 4:10the
- 4:10obvious
- 4:10stuff
- 4:11around,
- 4:11like
- 4:11border
- 4:11security
- 4:12and
- 4:12stuff
- 4:12doesn't
- 4:12make
- 4:13a
- 4:13lot
- 4:13of
- 4:13sense
- 4:14to
- 4:14me.
- 4:15Absolutely.
- 4:15And
- 4:15then
- 4:16Claudia,
- 4:16I
- 4:16knew
- 4:17her
- 4:17as
- 4:17Claudia
- 4:17Granada.
- 4:18She's
- 4:18now
- 4:19married
- 4:19and
- 4:20has
- 4:20a
- 4:20different
- 4:20last
- 4:20name,
- 4:21but
- 4:21she
- 4:21was
- 4:21our
- 4:22kindergarten
- 4:22teacher.
- 4:23We
- 4:23created
- 4:24a
- 4:24school
- 4:24within
- 4:24the
- 4:24school.
- 4:25And
- 4:25our
- 4:26theory
- 4:26was
- 4:26when
- 4:27I
- 4:27was
- 4:27hired,
- 4:27and
- 4:27it
- 4:28was
- 4:28funny
- 4:28because
- 4:28Claudia
- 4:28and
- 4:28I
- 4:29were
- 4:29both
- 4:29reminiscing
- 4:30that
- 4:30the
- 4:30school
- 4:31principal
- 4:31that
- 4:31hired
- 4:31us
- 4:32hired
- 4:33in
- 4:33the
- 4:33same
- 4:33year.
- 4:34And
- 4:34he
- 4:35told
- 4:35both
- 4:35of
- 4:35us
- 4:35in
- 4:35the
- 4:36interview
- 4:36process
- 4:37that
- 4:37Hooper
- 4:37Avenue
- 4:37was
- 4:38the
- 4:38largest
- 4:38elementary
- 4:39school
- 4:39west
- 4:40of
- 4:40the
- 4:40Mississippi.
- 4:41But
- 4:41then
- 4:42he
- 4:42cut
- 4:42out.
- 4:43He
- 4:43was
- 4:43never
- 4:43even
- 4:43there
- 4:44for
- 4:44our
- 4:44first
- 4:45days
- 4:45together.
- 4:45But
- 4:46Claudia
- 4:46now
- 4:47has
- 4:47stayed
- 4:47at
- 4:48hooper
- 4:48Avenue.
- 4:49She's
- 4:4932
- 4:50years
- 4:50of
- 4:50service
- 4:51at
- 4:51hooper.
- 4:51I
- 4:52was
- 4:52there
- 4:52for
- 4:52seven.
- 4:53Right.
- 4:53What
- 4:54seen
- 4:54and
- 4:54the
- 4:55commitment
- 4:55that
- 4:55she
- 4:55has
- 4:55shown
- 4:56to
- 4:56that
- 4:56place.
- 4:56It's
- 4:57just,
- 4:57just
- 4:58so
- 4:58incredible.
- 5:00That's
- 5:00fantastic.
- 5:01Yeah,
- 5:01those.
- 5:02We
- 5:02moved
- 5:03when
- 5:04my
- 5:04kids
- 5:04were
- 5:04really
- 5:04little
- 5:05to
- 5:05a
- 5:05neighborhood
- 5:06because
- 5:06it
- 5:06was
- 5:06a
- 5:06long
- 5:07time
- 5:07educator.
- 5:07We
- 5:08really
- 5:08wanted
- 5:08them
- 5:09to
- 5:09experience
- 5:10and
- 5:10so
- 5:10forth.
- 5:11And
- 5:11then
- 5:11the
- 5:11district
- 5:12where
- 5:12we
- 5:12were
- 5:12in
- 5:12their
- 5:12infinite
- 5:13wisdom
- 5:13decided
- 5:13that
- 5:13was
- 5:14the
- 5:14time
- 5:14to.
- 5:14To
- 5:15make
- 5:16a
- 5:16change.
- 5:18After,
- 5:18after
- 5:18I
- 5:19took
- 5:19it
- 5:19to
- 5:19get
- 5:19these.
- 5:19She
- 5:19had
- 5:20been
- 5:20there
- 5:20for
- 5:20years
- 5:21and
- 5:21it
- 5:21just
- 5:21built
- 5:22a
- 5:22culture
- 5:23and
- 5:23community
- 5:24and,
- 5:24and
- 5:25loyalty
- 5:25was
- 5:25great.
- 5:26So
- 5:27most
- 5:27people
- 5:28listen
- 5:28to
- 5:28this
- 5:28podcast
- 5:29wherever
- 5:29they
- 5:30get
- 5:30podcasts,
- 5:30and
- 5:31we'll
- 5:31introduce
- 5:31the
- 5:31podcast
- 5:32in
- 5:32a
- 5:32moment.
- 5:32If
- 5:32you're
- 5:33watching,
- 5:33you'll
- 5:33notice
- 5:34I
- 5:34suddenly
- 5:34had
- 5:34to
- 5:35switch
- 5:35into
- 5:35podcaster
- 5:36mode.
- 5:36We
- 5:36were
- 5:36getting
- 5:37a
- 5:37little
- 5:37feedback,
- 5:38so
- 5:38I
- 5:38had
- 5:39to
- 5:39put
- 5:39on
- 5:39my
- 5:39actual
- 5:40podcaster
- 5:42headphones.
- 5:43But
- 5:44that
- 5:44actually
- 5:45is
- 5:45fortuitous
- 5:46because
- 5:46we
- 5:46usually
- 5:46forget
- 5:47to
- 5:47introduce
- 5:47the
- 5:47podcast.
- 5:48And
- 5:48that
- 5:48will
- 5:48remind
- 5:49us
- 5:49to
- 5:49do
- 5:49it.
- 5:50This
- 5:50is
- 5:51Wonky
- 5:51Folk.
- 5:52I'm
- 5:52Andy
- 5:52Rotherham.
- 5:54I'm
- 5:54Jed
- 5:54Wallace.
- 5:56You
- 5:57can
- 5:57get
- 5:58us
- 5:58wherever
- 5:58you
- 5:58get
- 5:58podcasts.
- 5:59You
- 5:59can
- 6:00listen
- 6:00on
- 6:01YouTube.
- 6:02We
- 6:02urge
- 6:02you
- 6:03to
- 6:03like
- 6:03it.
- 6:03That
- 6:03apparently
- 6:04helps
- 6:04us.
- 6:05And
- 6:05then
- 6:07you
- 6:07can
- 6:07find
- 6:08me@eduonk.com
- 6:09and
- 6:09eduwonk@
- 6:10substack
- 6:11and
- 6:11you
- 6:11can
- 6:11find
- 6:11Jed
- 6:12at
- 6:12Charterfolk,
- 6:13where
- 6:13you
- 6:13can
- 6:13also
- 6:14sign
- 6:14up
- 6:15to
- 6:15make
- 6:15sure
- 6:15you
- 6:15get
- 6:15these
- 6:16episodes
- 6:16as
- 6:16they
- 6:17come
- 6:17out.
- 6:19All
- 6:19good.
- 6:19All
- 6:20good.
- 6:20Well,
- 6:20you
- 6:20know,
- 6:21again,
- 6:21Andy,
- 6:21you're
- 6:21looking
- 6:22just
- 6:22so,
- 6:23so
- 6:23official
- 6:23now,
- 6:24man.
- 6:24You
- 6:24are
- 6:24a,
- 6:25you're
- 6:25a
- 6:25professional
- 6:26podcaster.
- 6:26But.
- 6:29I
- 6:29am
- 6:30really
- 6:30curious,
- 6:30though,
- 6:30to
- 6:31ask
- 6:31you
- 6:31about
- 6:31it.
- 6:31I
- 6:31mean,
- 6:31I
- 6:32understand.
- 6:32Look,
- 6:32I
- 6:33know
- 6:33how
- 6:33much
- 6:33I
- 6:33offended
- 6:34you
- 6:34by
- 6:34saying
- 6:34that
- 6:35you
- 6:35and
- 6:35Bellwether
- 6:35are
- 6:36so
- 6:36damn
- 6:36smart,
- 6:36you
- 6:36know,
- 6:37at
- 6:37our,
- 6:37at
- 6:37our.
- 6:37In
- 6:37person
- 6:38in
- 6:38Washington.
- 6:38But,
- 6:39you
- 6:39know,
- 6:39there,
- 6:40I
- 6:40actually
- 6:40have
- 6:40these
- 6:41times
- 6:41in
- 6:41between
- 6:41our
- 6:42conversations
- 6:42where
- 6:42I
- 6:43say
- 6:43I
- 6:43really
- 6:43wonder
- 6:43what
- 6:43Andy
- 6:44thinks
- 6:44about
- 6:44this.
- 6:45And
- 6:45you
- 6:45know,
- 6:45I'm
- 6:46really
- 6:46curious
- 6:46what
- 6:46you.
- 6:47And
- 6:47then,
- 6:47and
- 6:47then
- 6:47the
- 6:47moment
- 6:48passes.
- 6:50I
- 6:51know
- 6:51I'm
- 6:51gonna
- 6:51get.
- 6:52Get
- 6:52a
- 6:52chance
- 6:52to
- 6:53hear
- 6:53you,
- 6:53you
- 6:53know,
- 6:53bungle
- 6:54an
- 6:54answer
- 6:54to
- 6:54another
- 6:55question
- 6:55I
- 6:55have
- 6:55for
- 6:55you.
- 6:56So
- 6:56let
- 6:56me
- 6:56throw.
- 6:57I
- 6:57mean,
- 6:57but
- 6:58look,
- 6:58what
- 6:58is
- 6:58happening
- 6:59in
- 6:59higher
- 6:59ed
- 6:59right
- 7:00now
- 7:00is
- 7:01just
- 7:01fascinating
- 7:02to
- 7:02watch.
- 7:03And
- 7:03look,
- 7:04I
- 7:04get
- 7:05some
- 7:05more
- 7:05blowback,
- 7:06or
- 7:06not
- 7:06blowback,
- 7:07but
- 7:07I
- 7:07get
- 7:07some
- 7:07more
- 7:07criticism
- 7:08or
- 7:08people
- 7:09questioning
- 7:09some
- 7:10of
- 7:10my
- 7:10posts
- 7:10these
- 7:11days
- 7:11when
- 7:11I'm
- 7:12not
- 7:13blanket.
- 7:14More
- 7:14blanket
- 7:15protective
- 7:15of
- 7:16higher
- 7:16ed,
- 7:16more
- 7:16blanket
- 7:17protective
- 7:17of
- 7:17the
- 7:17department
- 7:18of
- 7:18Ed,
- 7:18that
- 7:18kind
- 7:18of
- 7:18stuff.
- 7:19I
- 7:19get
- 7:19it.
- 7:19I
- 7:20get
- 7:20it.
- 7:21But
- 7:21I
- 7:21also
- 7:22have.
- 7:22I
- 7:22stand
- 7:23by
- 7:23what
- 7:23I
- 7:23wrote
- 7:24originally,
- 7:24which
- 7:24was
- 7:25I
- 7:25kind
- 7:25of
- 7:25feel
- 7:25like
- 7:26this
- 7:26is
- 7:26chicken
- 7:26coming
- 7:26home
- 7:26to
- 7:27roost
- 7:27when
- 7:27you
- 7:28are
- 7:28higher
- 7:28ed.
- 7:28And
- 7:29you
- 7:29know,
- 7:29you,
- 7:29you
- 7:30have
- 7:30a,
- 7:30this
- 7:30level
- 7:31of
- 7:31dependency
- 7:32on
- 7:32the
- 7:32federal
- 7:32government
- 7:33for
- 7:33your
- 7:33entire
- 7:34economic
- 7:34model.
- 7:35And
- 7:35you've
- 7:36allowed
- 7:36your,
- 7:36basically
- 7:38the
- 7:38curriculum
- 7:39and
- 7:39the
- 7:39entire
- 7:40culture
- 7:41of
- 7:41your
- 7:41organization
- 7:41to
- 7:42veer
- 7:42very
- 7:42far
- 7:43left.
- 7:43That
- 7:43just
- 7:44seems
- 7:44like
- 7:44a
- 7:45disequilibrium
- 7:46that
- 7:46is
- 7:47waiting
- 7:47to
- 7:47be
- 7:47tripped.
- 7:48And
- 7:48that's
- 7:49what
- 7:49Trump
- 7:49has
- 7:49done
- 7:50in
- 7:50the
- 7:50last
- 7:50month
- 7:50or
- 7:51so.
- 7:52Yeah,
- 7:52I
- 7:53mean,
- 7:53there's
- 7:53a
- 7:53lot
- 7:53there.
- 7:53I
- 7:54don't
- 7:54know,
- 7:54I
- 7:54think
- 7:54like
- 7:55it's,
- 7:55it's
- 7:55a
- 7:55really
- 7:56challenging
- 7:57time.
- 7:57So,
- 7:57for
- 7:57example,
- 7:58like,
- 7:58what's
- 7:59happening
- 7:59with
- 8:00Mahmoud.
- 8:01I
- 8:01think
- 8:01I'm
- 8:01saying
- 8:01his
- 8:01name
- 8:01right.
- 8:02Mahmoud
- 8:02Khalil,
- 8:03the
- 8:03Columbia
- 8:04or
- 8:04former
- 8:05Columbia
- 8:05student.
- 8:05Like,
- 8:06from
- 8:06where
- 8:06I
- 8:07sit,
- 8:07that's
- 8:07like
- 8:07a
- 8:07pretty
- 8:08core
- 8:08First
- 8:08Amendment
- 8:09issue.
- 8:10There's
- 8:10due
- 8:11process
- 8:11questions
- 8:11there
- 8:12that
- 8:12are
- 8:12pretty
- 8:13just
- 8:13concerning
- 8:14from,
- 8:14you
- 8:15know,
- 8:15just
- 8:15from
- 8:15a
- 8:15basic,
- 8:16again,
- 8:16process,
- 8:17civil
- 8:17liberties
- 8:18standpoint.
- 8:18And
- 8:19I
- 8:19think
- 8:19you
- 8:19can
- 8:19hold
- 8:20two
- 8:20ideas
- 8:20in
- 8:20your
- 8:21head
- 8:21at
- 8:21the
- 8:21same
- 8:21time
- 8:21that
- 8:22higher
- 8:22ed
- 8:22has
- 8:22in
- 8:23some
- 8:23ways
- 8:23made
- 8:23its
- 8:23bed
- 8:24with
- 8:25some
- 8:25of
- 8:25the
- 8:25things
- 8:25it's
- 8:25done
- 8:26and
- 8:26that
- 8:26that
- 8:26is
- 8:27like
- 8:27over
- 8:27the
- 8:28line.
- 8:28And
- 8:29I
- 8:29do
- 8:29worry
- 8:30now
- 8:30we're
- 8:31in
- 8:31this
- 8:31point
- 8:32where
- 8:32people
- 8:32are
- 8:33feeling
- 8:33very
- 8:33sort
- 8:34of
- 8:35retributive
- 8:36and
- 8:36they
- 8:37want
- 8:37to
- 8:38push
- 8:38back
- 8:39on
- 8:39things
- 8:39and
- 8:39they're
- 8:39losing
- 8:40sight
- 8:40of
- 8:40things
- 8:40like
- 8:41due
- 8:41process
- 8:41and
- 8:42so
- 8:42forth.
- 8:42Like
- 8:42when
- 8:42you
- 8:43say
- 8:43this
- 8:44might
- 8:44be
- 8:44a
- 8:44First
- 8:44Amendment
- 8:45or
- 8:45due
- 8:45process
- 8:46issue,
- 8:46I
- 8:47don't
- 8:47think
- 8:47an
- 8:47acceptable
- 8:48response
- 8:48is,
- 8:49well,
- 8:49look
- 8:49at
- 8:49everything
- 8:49higher
- 8:50ed's
- 8:50done.
- 8:50You
- 8:51could
- 8:51say,
- 8:51yeah,
- 8:51higher
- 8:52EDS
- 8:52made
- 8:52some
- 8:52mistakes
- 8:53and
- 8:53the
- 8:53way
- 8:53they
- 8:53handled
- 8:54some
- 8:54things
- 8:54is
- 8:55not
- 8:55great
- 8:55in
- 8:56the
- 8:56business
- 8:56model.
- 8:57And
- 8:57this
- 8:57is
- 8:57bad.
- 8:58These
- 8:58are
- 8:58not
- 8:58like,
- 8:59this
- 8:59is
- 8:59not
- 8:59an
- 8:59either
- 8:59or,
- 9:00this
- 9:00can
- 9:00be
- 9:00an
- 9:01and
- 9:01and
- 9:02it
- 9:02feels
- 9:02like
- 9:03an
- 9:03end.
- 9:04So
- 9:04yeah,
- 9:05I
- 9:05mean,
- 9:05their
- 9:05business
- 9:06model
- 9:06is
- 9:07challenging
- 9:08and
- 9:08they
- 9:09are
- 9:09heavily
- 9:09dependent
- 9:10on
- 9:10federal
- 9:11dollars.
- 9:12And
- 9:12also,
- 9:13I
- 9:13mean,
- 9:13the
- 9:13fact
- 9:13that
- 9:14they,
- 9:15the
- 9:16inability
- 9:16to
- 9:16stand
- 9:17up
- 9:17against
- 9:19not
- 9:20sort
- 9:20of
- 9:20sanctioned
- 9:22free
- 9:22speech
- 9:22first
- 9:23amendment
- 9:23activity,
- 9:23but
- 9:24stuff
- 9:24that
- 9:24crossed
- 9:25the
- 9:25line
- 9:25into
- 9:25violence
- 9:26and
- 9:26so
- 9:26forth,
- 9:26the
- 9:27inability
- 9:27to
- 9:27stand
- 9:28up
- 9:28against
- 9:28that.
- 9:28If
- 9:28you're
- 9:29not
- 9:29gonna
- 9:29stand
- 9:29up
- 9:29against
- 9:29that,
- 9:29then
- 9:30why
- 9:30are
- 9:30you
- 9:30going
- 9:30to
- 9:30stand
- 9:30up
- 9:30against
- 9:30Donald
- 9:31Trump?
- 9:31So
- 9:31it's
- 9:31sort
- 9:32of
- 9:32like
- 9:32one
- 9:33way
- 9:33to
- 9:33look
- 9:33at
- 9:33it
- 9:33is
- 9:34just,
- 9:34it's
- 9:34just
- 9:34a
- 9:35mess.
- 9:37And
- 9:37I
- 9:37don't
- 9:37necessarily
- 9:38think
- 9:38Donald
- 9:38Trump's
- 9:39going
- 9:39to
- 9:39be
- 9:39the
- 9:39guy
- 9:39to,
- 9:40to
- 9:40clean
- 9:40it
- 9:41up.
- 9:41And
- 9:41in
- 9:41fact,
- 9:42he
- 9:42seems
- 9:42potentially
- 9:43to
- 9:43make
- 9:43it
- 9:43worse.
- 9:43But
- 9:44yeah,
- 9:44higher
- 9:44ed
- 9:44has
- 9:45enormous
- 9:46problems
- 9:47at
- 9:47a
- 9:47time.
- 9:47I
- 9:47think
- 9:47people
- 9:48are
- 9:48questioning
- 9:48the
- 9:48value
- 9:49proposition
- 9:50a
- 9:50lot,
- 9:50particularly
- 9:51elite
- 9:51higher
- 9:51ed.
- 9:52It
- 9:52seems
- 9:52like
- 9:52it's
- 9:53probably
- 9:53a
- 9:53great
- 9:53moment
- 9:54for
- 9:54sort
- 9:54of
- 9:54high
- 9:55quality
- 9:55state
- 9:56schools
- 9:56to
- 9:56really
- 9:57show
- 9:57why
- 9:58they're
- 9:58so
- 9:58important
- 9:59and,
- 10:00and
- 10:00such
- 10:01a,
- 10:01you
- 10:01know,
- 10:01instrumental
- 10:02part
- 10:02of
- 10:02the
- 10:02education
- 10:03system.
- 10:04Well,
- 10:05I've
- 10:05seen
- 10:05the
- 10:06reporting
- 10:06that
- 10:07Columbia
- 10:07has
- 10:0820%
- 10:09of
- 10:09their
- 10:09funding
- 10:10coming
- 10:10from
- 10:10the
- 10:10federal
- 10:10government.
- 10:12I
- 10:12don't
- 10:12think
- 10:12that
- 10:13tells
- 10:13the
- 10:13whole
- 10:13story
- 10:14even
- 10:14close
- 10:15because
- 10:15you
- 10:16have
- 10:16the,
- 10:17you
- 10:17have
- 10:17other
- 10:18parts
- 10:18of
- 10:18this
- 10:19where
- 10:19you've
- 10:19got
- 10:20guaranteed
- 10:20student
- 10:21loans
- 10:21that
- 10:22are
- 10:22coming
- 10:22from
- 10:22the
- 10:23government
- 10:24that
- 10:24are
- 10:24basically
- 10:25subsidizing
- 10:26the
- 10:26entire
- 10:27higher
- 10:27ed
- 10:28market.
- 10:28And
- 10:28I
- 10:28think,
- 10:29you
- 10:29know,
- 10:29the
- 10:29elite
- 10:30schools
- 10:30probably
- 10:31benefit
- 10:32at
- 10:32least
- 10:33proportionately,
- 10:33you
- 10:33know,
- 10:34in
- 10:34that
- 10:34area
- 10:35too.
- 10:35And
- 10:35then
- 10:35you've
- 10:36got
- 10:36the
- 10:36whole
- 10:36exposure
- 10:37of
- 10:37the
- 10:37higher
- 10:38ed
- 10:38institutions
- 10:39on
- 10:39their,
- 10:40their
- 10:40endowments
- 10:41and
- 10:41whether
- 10:42or
- 10:42not
- 10:42they're
- 10:42going
- 10:42to
- 10:42get
- 10:42taxed
- 10:43at
- 10:43high
- 10:44rates.
- 10:44And
- 10:45so
- 10:45I,
- 10:45I,
- 10:46I
- 10:46think
- 10:47it's
- 10:47very
- 10:47possible.
- 10:47And
- 10:48the
- 10:48reason
- 10:48I
- 10:48think
- 10:48that
- 10:49Colombia
- 10:49is
- 10:49cutting
- 10:50the
- 10:50deal
- 10:50right
- 10:50now,
- 10:51everybody's
- 10:51saying,
- 10:51oh
- 10:51gosh,
- 10:52it's
- 10:52all
- 10:52about
- 10:52this
- 10:5320%.
- 10:53I
- 10:53don't
- 10:54think
- 10:54it's
- 10:54about
- 10:54the
- 10:5420%.
- 10:55I
- 10:55think
- 10:56it's
- 10:56about
- 10:56basically
- 10:58or
- 10:59enough
- 10:59to
- 10:59top.
- 11:00The
- 11:00entire
- 11:01dang
- 11:01institution
- 11:02is
- 11:02actually
- 11:03wrapped
- 11:03into
- 11:03things
- 11:04that
- 11:04are
- 11:05subsidized,
- 11:05propped
- 11:06up
- 11:06by
- 11:06the
- 11:06federal
- 11:07government.
- 11:08No,
- 11:08they
- 11:08clearly
- 11:09want
- 11:09to
- 11:09put
- 11:09this
- 11:10behind
- 11:10them.
- 11:11But
- 11:11I
- 11:11think
- 11:11the
- 11:11thing
- 11:11you're
- 11:12raising
- 11:12is
- 11:12important
- 11:13if
- 11:13you,
- 11:13you
- 11:13know,
- 11:14it's
- 11:14the
- 11:14same
- 11:14thing
- 11:15thing
- 11:15that
- 11:15allowed,
- 11:16you
- 11:16know,
- 11:16the
- 11:16Biden
- 11:17and
- 11:17Obama
- 11:17people
- 11:18to
- 11:18come
- 11:18in
- 11:18with
- 11:19Title
- 11:199
- 11:20guidance
- 11:21around
- 11:21sexual
- 11:22assaults.
- 11:22A
- 11:22lot
- 11:22of
- 11:22people
- 11:23said,
- 11:23again,
- 11:24huge
- 11:24due
- 11:24process
- 11:25issues.
- 11:25Federal
- 11:26court
- 11:26said
- 11:26huge,
- 11:27you
- 11:27know,
- 11:27don't
- 11:27take
- 11:27my
- 11:27word
- 11:28for
- 11:28it.
- 11:28The
- 11:28federal
- 11:28court
- 11:29said
- 11:29multiple
- 11:30occasions,
- 11:30this
- 11:30raises
- 11:31big
- 11:31due
- 11:31process
- 11:32concerns.
- 11:33Ended
- 11:33up,
- 11:34you
- 11:34know,
- 11:34by
- 11:34Emily
- 11:34Yoff's
- 11:35reporting
- 11:35in
- 11:36the
- 11:36Atlantic
- 11:36had
- 11:36a
- 11:36disparate
- 11:37impact
- 11:38on
- 11:38black
- 11:38guys,
- 11:39which,
- 11:39like,
- 11:40why,
- 11:40you
- 11:40know,
- 11:40if
- 11:41you
- 11:41think
- 11:41that
- 11:41that's
- 11:42an
- 11:42issue
- 11:42in
- 11:43sort
- 11:43of
- 11:43criminal
- 11:44justice
- 11:44and,
- 11:45you
- 11:45know,
- 11:45so
- 11:45forth
- 11:45in
- 11:46general,
- 11:46why
- 11:46wouldn't
- 11:46it
- 11:46be
- 11:47an
- 11:47issue
- 11:47here
- 11:48as
- 11:48well?
- 11:48But
- 11:48they
- 11:48were
- 11:49able
- 11:49to
- 11:49do
- 11:49that
- 11:49because
- 11:49no
- 11:49one
- 11:50could
- 11:50say
- 11:50no,
- 11:50because
- 11:50everyone's
- 11:51dependent
- 11:52on
- 11:52the
- 11:52money.
- 11:52And
- 11:53this
- 11:53is
- 11:53the
- 11:53flip
- 11:53side.
- 11:54So
- 11:54now
- 11:54the
- 11:54Trump
- 11:54administration
- 11:55is
- 11:55coming
- 11:55in
- 11:55with
- 11:55a
- 11:56different
- 11:56set
- 11:56of
- 11:56priorities
- 11:57and
- 11:57they're
- 11:58going
- 11:58to
- 11:58be
- 11:58able
- 11:58to,
- 11:59to
- 11:59push
- 12:00on
- 12:00it.
- 12:00I
- 12:00do
- 12:01think
- 12:01the
- 12:01one
- 12:01thing
- 12:02that,
- 12:02like,
- 12:02you
- 12:02know,
- 12:02you're
- 12:02starting
- 12:03to
- 12:03see
- 12:03the
- 12:03courts
- 12:04are
- 12:05getting
- 12:05involved,
- 12:06their,
- 12:06their
- 12:07executive
- 12:08order
- 12:08on
- 12:08DEI
- 12:09and,
- 12:09and
- 12:10then
- 12:10the
- 12:10dear
- 12:10Colleague
- 12:11letter
- 12:11that
- 12:11they
- 12:11sent
- 12:12out
- 12:12and
- 12:12so
- 12:12forth
- 12:13is
- 12:13sufficiently
- 12:14vague
- 12:15to
- 12:15raise
- 12:16questions.
- 12:16And
- 12:17I
- 12:17think
- 12:17you,
- 12:17even
- 12:18people
- 12:18who
- 12:19have
- 12:19had
- 12:19some
- 12:19questions
- 12:20and
- 12:20concerns
- 12:20about
- 12:21DEI
- 12:21on
- 12:21campus
- 12:22and
- 12:22how
- 12:22that's
- 12:22manifested
- 12:23itself
- 12:23were
- 12:23also
- 12:24like,
- 12:24this
- 12:24goes
- 12:25really
- 12:25far
- 12:26in
- 12:26the
- 12:26other
- 12:26direction.
- 12:27So
- 12:27I
- 12:27think
- 12:27that's
- 12:28going
- 12:28to
- 12:28take
- 12:28some
- 12:28time,
- 12:30that's
- 12:30going
- 12:30to
- 12:30take
- 12:30some
- 12:31time
- 12:31to
- 12:31unwind.
- 12:32But
- 12:33what
- 12:33do
- 12:33you
- 12:33think
- 12:33this
- 12:34means
- 12:34for
- 12:34higher
- 12:34ed
- 12:35longer
- 12:36term?
- 12:36So
- 12:36we've,
- 12:37because
- 12:37look,
- 12:38I've
- 12:38been
- 12:38writing
- 12:38about,
- 12:39I've
- 12:39long
- 12:40argued
- 12:40about
- 12:42the
- 12:42higher
- 12:42ed
- 12:43economic
- 12:44model,
- 12:44its
- 12:44dependency
- 12:45on
- 12:45these
- 12:45guaranteed
- 12:46student
- 12:46loans.
- 12:47I
- 12:47mean,
- 12:47when
- 12:48I've
- 12:48written
- 12:48repeatedly
- 12:49about
- 12:49the
- 12:50graph
- 12:50of
- 12:50the
- 12:50century,
- 12:51which
- 12:52has
- 12:52been
- 12:52titled
- 12:52by
- 12:53some
- 12:53other
- 12:53person.
- 12:53Right.
- 12:54I
- 12:54don't
- 12:54even
- 12:54remember
- 12:54who
- 12:54first
- 12:55came
- 12:55up
- 12:55with
- 12:55this
- 12:55title
- 12:56for
- 12:56that,
- 12:56but
- 12:57it
- 12:57shows
- 12:57the
- 12:58inflation
- 12:58rates
- 12:59in
- 12:59different
- 12:59parts
- 12:59of
- 13:00the
- 13:00economy
- 13:01and
- 13:01hospital
- 13:02stays
- 13:02and
- 13:03higher
- 13:03ed
- 13:04are
- 13:04the
- 13:04two
- 13:04that
- 13:04have
- 13:05had
- 13:05the
- 13:05highest
- 13:05inflation
- 13:06rates
- 13:06going,
- 13:07going
- 13:07back
- 13:07to
- 13:07before
- 13:07the
- 13:082000s.
- 13:08Right.
- 13:09That
- 13:09is
- 13:10just
- 13:10not
- 13:10sustainable.
- 13:12And,
- 13:12and
- 13:12it's
- 13:12also,
- 13:13it's
- 13:13not
- 13:13just
- 13:14bad
- 13:14economics
- 13:15generally
- 13:15and
- 13:15it's
- 13:16warped,
- 13:16but
- 13:17it
- 13:17puts
- 13:18burden
- 13:18on
- 13:18the
- 13:18young
- 13:19people
- 13:19who
- 13:19are
- 13:20supposed
- 13:20to
- 13:20be
- 13:20benefiting
- 13:21from
- 13:21these
- 13:21places.
- 13:23I
- 13:23just
- 13:23feel
- 13:24like
- 13:24we've
- 13:24got
- 13:25this.
- 13:25I
- 13:26think
- 13:26this
- 13:26is
- 13:26just
- 13:26the
- 13:26beginning,
- 13:27Andy.
- 13:27I
- 13:27think
- 13:27there's
- 13:28going
- 13:28to
- 13:28be
- 13:28much,
- 13:28much
- 13:29more
- 13:29impact
- 13:30as,
- 13:31as
- 13:31Trump
- 13:31continues
- 13:32to
- 13:32hammer
- 13:32away.
- 13:33Well,
- 13:34it's
- 13:34been
- 13:34financed
- 13:35essentially
- 13:35in
- 13:35these
- 13:36various
- 13:36third
- 13:36party
- 13:37ways.
- 13:37So
- 13:37it
- 13:37was
- 13:37home
- 13:38equity
- 13:38and
- 13:38mortgages.
- 13:39When
- 13:39that
- 13:39kind
- 13:40of
- 13:40dried
- 13:41up,
- 13:41then
- 13:41it
- 13:41was
- 13:42student
- 13:42loans
- 13:43and
- 13:43that.
- 13:43So
- 13:43we've
- 13:44always
- 13:44had
- 13:44these
- 13:44sort
- 13:45of
- 13:45third
- 13:45party
- 13:45ways
- 13:46to
- 13:46do
- 13:46it.
- 13:47And
- 13:48now
- 13:49that
- 13:49that's
- 13:49under
- 13:50pressure
- 13:50raises
- 13:51some
- 13:51questions.
- 13:51I've
- 13:52always
- 13:52felt
- 13:52like
- 13:53you
- 13:53have
- 13:53to
- 13:53hold
- 13:54a
- 13:54couple
- 13:54of
- 13:54things
- 13:54in
- 13:55your
- 13:55head
- 13:55at
- 13:55the,
- 13:55at
- 13:55the
- 13:56same
- 13:56time.
- 13:56One
- 13:57is
- 13:57that
- 13:57it's
- 13:57a
- 13:57mess.
- 13:58To
- 13:58your
- 13:58point,
- 13:59economically
- 13:59it's,
- 14:00it's
- 14:00a
- 14:00mess.
- 14:00The
- 14:00cost
- 14:01structure
- 14:01and
- 14:01the
- 14:02price
- 14:02structure
- 14:02is
- 14:03crazy.
- 14:04And
- 14:05particularly
- 14:05if
- 14:05you're
- 14:06a
- 14:06low
- 14:06income
- 14:06American,
- 14:07it's
- 14:07a,
- 14:07probably
- 14:08a
- 14:08good
- 14:08idea
- 14:08to
- 14:09go.
- 14:09It's,
- 14:09it's
- 14:09pretty
- 14:09important
- 14:10for
- 14:10social
- 14:10mobility.
- 14:11And
- 14:11we
- 14:11can
- 14:12argue,
- 14:12you
- 14:12know,
- 14:13now
- 14:13we're
- 14:13creating
- 14:13degree
- 14:14inflation
- 14:14so
- 14:14people
- 14:15are
- 14:15going
- 14:15to,
- 14:15to
- 14:16grad
- 14:16school
- 14:16and
- 14:16so
- 14:16forth.
- 14:17But
- 14:17there,
- 14:17you
- 14:17know,
- 14:18there's,
- 14:18there's
- 14:18some
- 14:18evidence
- 14:19that
- 14:19the
- 14:19premium
- 14:19you
- 14:20get
- 14:20if
- 14:21you're
- 14:21low
- 14:21income
- 14:22and
- 14:22you
- 14:22go
- 14:22to
- 14:22a
- 14:23good
- 14:23school,
- 14:25that
- 14:25that's
- 14:25important.
- 14:26And
- 14:26frankly,
- 14:26with
- 14:27the
- 14:27way
- 14:27schools
- 14:27are
- 14:27moving
- 14:28on,
- 14:28that
- 14:28if
- 14:28you're
- 14:29low
- 14:29income,
- 14:29a
- 14:30lot
- 14:30of
- 14:30these
- 14:30schools,
- 14:30your,
- 14:31your
- 14:31actual
- 14:31cost
- 14:31of
- 14:32attendance
- 14:32is
- 14:32going
- 14:32to
- 14:32be
- 14:32pretty
- 14:33low.
- 14:33And
- 14:33I
- 14:33think
- 14:33one
- 14:33of
- 14:33the
- 14:33more
- 14:34irresponsible
- 14:35things
- 14:35this
- 14:36sector's
- 14:36done
- 14:36is
- 14:36sort
- 14:37of
- 14:37scare
- 14:37kids
- 14:38about
- 14:38the
- 14:38high
- 14:39cost
- 14:39rather
- 14:39than
- 14:40saying
- 14:40if
- 14:40you're,
- 14:40if
- 14:40you're
- 14:41situated
- 14:41where
- 14:42you're
- 14:42low
- 14:42income,
- 14:43it's
- 14:43actually
- 14:43not
- 14:43going
- 14:43to
- 14:43be
- 14:44very
- 14:45high
- 14:45cost
- 14:46for
- 14:46you.
- 14:46And
- 14:46I
- 14:46think
- 14:46we've
- 14:47done
- 14:47I
- 14:47think
- 14:47we've
- 14:47done
- 14:47a
- 14:48poor
- 14:48job
- 14:49there.
- 14:50So
- 14:50you
- 14:50have
- 14:50to
- 14:50sort
- 14:50of
- 14:50hold
- 14:51all
- 14:51those
- 14:51ideas
- 14:51in
- 14:52your
- 14:52head
- 14:52at
- 14:52the
- 14:53same
- 14:53time.
- 14:53But
- 14:53yeah,
- 14:53I
- 14:53don't
- 14:54think
- 14:54it's
- 14:54sustainable.
- 14:56And
- 14:56I
- 14:56think
- 14:57you're
- 14:57going
- 14:57to
- 14:57start.
- 14:57You're
- 14:57seeing
- 14:58these
- 14:58smaller
- 14:58colleges
- 14:59are
- 14:59closing
- 15:00and
- 15:00consolidating
- 15:01and
- 15:02you're
- 15:02seeing
- 15:02smaller
- 15:03colleges
- 15:03try
- 15:04to
- 15:04figure
- 15:04out
- 15:04what's
- 15:04their
- 15:05niche,
- 15:05if
- 15:05it's
- 15:05sports
- 15:06or
- 15:06whatever.
- 15:06And
- 15:06I
- 15:06think
- 15:06you're
- 15:07going
- 15:07to
- 15:07see
- 15:07a
- 15:07fairly
- 15:08substantial
- 15:09contraction.
- 15:11But
- 15:11what
- 15:11I
- 15:12hope
- 15:12we
- 15:12also
- 15:13see
- 15:13is
- 15:14we've
- 15:14had
- 15:14this
- 15:14debate,
- 15:15this
- 15:15is
- 15:16completely
- 15:16driven
- 15:16by
- 15:17the
- 15:17top
- 15:17like
- 15:1815,
- 15:1820
- 15:19schools
- 15:20and
- 15:20that
- 15:20we
- 15:21actually
- 15:21have
- 15:21like
- 15:21a
- 15:21whole
- 15:22tier
- 15:22of,
- 15:23of
- 15:23just
- 15:23fantastic
- 15:24schools.
- 15:24And
- 15:24I'm
- 15:24a
- 15:24little
- 15:24bit
- 15:25of
- 15:25a
- 15:25homer
- 15:25here
- 15:25because,
- 15:26you
- 15:26know,
- 15:26Virginia,
- 15:27like
- 15:27we're
- 15:27really
- 15:28blessed
- 15:28with
- 15:28just
- 15:29fantastic
- 15:30public
- 15:30universities
- 15:31and
- 15:31everybody
- 15:32focuses
- 15:32on
- 15:33a
- 15:33couple
- 15:33of
- 15:33them,
- 15:33but
- 15:33there's
- 15:34like
- 15:34a
- 15:34much
- 15:34wider
- 15:35swath
- 15:36of
- 15:36them
- 15:37and
- 15:38we,
- 15:38that's.
- 15:38That
- 15:39to
- 15:39me
- 15:39is
- 15:39the
- 15:39kind
- 15:39of
- 15:40system
- 15:41that,
- 15:42that
- 15:42we
- 15:42need,
- 15:43that
- 15:43we
- 15:43need
- 15:43more
- 15:44of.
- 15:44We
- 15:44need
- 15:44and
- 15:44we
- 15:44need
- 15:45more
- 15:45investment
- 15:45in.
- 15:45And
- 15:46what
- 15:46we
- 15:46tend
- 15:46to
- 15:47key
- 15:47on
- 15:48these,
- 15:48this,
- 15:48this
- 15:48handful
- 15:49of
- 15:49elite
- 15:49schools,
- 15:50which
- 15:50is,
- 15:50I
- 15:50mean,
- 15:51there's
- 15:51a
- 15:51reason
- 15:51those
- 15:51are
- 15:52the
- 15:52ones
- 15:52that
- 15:52Congress
- 15:53dragged
- 15:53in
- 15:53and
- 15:53sort
- 15:53of
- 15:54set
- 15:54this
- 15:54whole
- 15:54thing
- 15:54off,
- 15:56you
- 15:56know,
- 15:56post.
- 15:57You
- 15:58know,
- 15:58post
- 16:00October
- 16:016th.
- 16:01Right.
- 16:02Well,
- 16:03I
- 16:03guess
- 16:03you're
- 16:03a
- 16:03little
- 16:04bit
- 16:04more
- 16:04optimistic
- 16:05than
- 16:05I
- 16:05am.
- 16:05I
- 16:06just
- 16:06feel
- 16:06like
- 16:07the
- 16:07economics
- 16:08that
- 16:08are
- 16:08bad
- 16:08at
- 16:09the
- 16:09elite
- 16:09institutions
- 16:10are
- 16:11actually
- 16:11almost
- 16:12as
- 16:12bad
- 16:13in
- 16:14the
- 16:14colleges
- 16:15and
- 16:15universities
- 16:15that
- 16:15you're
- 16:16talking
- 16:16about.
- 16:16I
- 16:16understand
- 16:16that
- 16:17the
- 16:17price
- 16:17points
- 16:17are
- 16:18lower,
- 16:18the
- 16:18state
- 16:19schools
- 16:19are
- 16:19lower,
- 16:20but
- 16:20the
- 16:21entire
- 16:21industry
- 16:22has
- 16:22just
- 16:23had
- 16:23artificial
- 16:25costs
- 16:26introduced
- 16:26into
- 16:26it
- 16:27and
- 16:28entirely
- 16:29artificial.
- 16:29I
- 16:29mean,
- 16:30are
- 16:30you
- 16:30like
- 16:30some
- 16:31of
- 16:31it
- 16:31is
- 16:31the
- 16:31way
- 16:31they
- 16:31compete
- 16:32now?
- 16:32I
- 16:32mean,
- 16:32like
- 16:33you,
- 16:33I
- 16:33know
- 16:33you
- 16:34recently
- 16:34went
- 16:34through
- 16:34a
- 16:35college
- 16:35search.
- 16:35I
- 16:35mean,
- 16:35you
- 16:36just
- 16:36like
- 16:36spend
- 16:36time
- 16:36like
- 16:37these
- 16:37dining
- 16:37halls
- 16:38and
- 16:38these
- 16:38dorms.
- 16:38They
- 16:38are
- 16:39not
- 16:39like
- 16:39it
- 16:39was
- 16:39when
- 16:39we
- 16:40went
- 16:40to
- 16:40college.
- 16:41They
- 16:41are
- 16:41competing
- 16:42on
- 16:43quality
- 16:43of
- 16:43life
- 16:44and
- 16:44other
- 16:44things.
- 16:44That's
- 16:45driving.
- 16:46I
- 16:46mean,
- 16:47I
- 16:47don't
- 16:47think
- 16:47anyone
- 16:48can
- 16:48defend
- 16:48like
- 16:48the
- 16:48lazy
- 16:49rivers
- 16:49and
- 16:50so
- 16:50forth.
- 16:50But
- 16:51you,
- 16:52you
- 16:52do
- 16:52get,
- 16:53you
- 16:53do
- 16:53get
- 16:54competition
- 16:54around
- 16:54quality
- 16:55of
- 16:55life
- 16:55that
- 16:56students
- 16:56want.
- 16:56It's.
- 16:57The
- 16:57schools
- 16:57are.
- 16:57Schools
- 16:57are
- 16:58competing
- 16:58and
- 16:59they're,
- 17:00they're
- 17:00offering
- 17:00different
- 17:01things
- 17:01and
- 17:01just
- 17:01tastes
- 17:02have
- 17:02changed
- 17:03from
- 17:03when
- 17:03you
- 17:03and
- 17:03I
- 17:04went.
- 17:04I
- 17:04mean,
- 17:04I'm
- 17:05sure.
- 17:05Did
- 17:05you
- 17:05see
- 17:05that,
- 17:06maybe
- 17:06you
- 17:06see.
- 17:06That
- 17:07as
- 17:07a
- 17:07healthy
- 17:07expression
- 17:08of
- 17:08competition.
- 17:08I
- 17:09just
- 17:09see
- 17:09it
- 17:10as
- 17:10an
- 17:11industry
- 17:11that
- 17:11is
- 17:11out
- 17:12of
- 17:12whack.
- 17:13Yes.
- 17:13I
- 17:13want
- 17:13to
- 17:13see
- 17:14universities
- 17:14have
- 17:15nice
- 17:15facilities
- 17:15and
- 17:15those
- 17:16kinds
- 17:16of
- 17:16things,
- 17:16but
- 17:16you
- 17:17look
- 17:17at
- 17:17like
- 17:17university
- 17:17facilities
- 17:18versus
- 17:18K12
- 17:19facilities
- 17:19and
- 17:20stuff.
- 17:20I
- 17:20mean,
- 17:20come
- 17:20on.
- 17:21There's
- 17:22something
- 17:22that's
- 17:22fundamentally
- 17:23different
- 17:23here
- 17:24and
- 17:24I
- 17:25feel
- 17:25like
- 17:25these
- 17:25chickens
- 17:25are
- 17:26going
- 17:26to
- 17:26come
- 17:26home
- 17:26to
- 17:26roost.
- 17:27And
- 17:28I
- 17:28see
- 17:29it
- 17:29as
- 17:29something
- 17:29where
- 17:30the
- 17:30country
- 17:30didn't
- 17:31have
- 17:31the
- 17:31courage
- 17:31to
- 17:32direct
- 17:32the
- 17:32subsidy
- 17:33and
- 17:33the
- 17:33support
- 17:33for
- 17:33the
- 17:34low
- 17:34income
- 17:34kids
- 17:34that
- 17:35actually
- 17:35needed
- 17:35it
- 17:36and
- 17:36decided
- 17:36to
- 17:37do
- 17:37it
- 17:37for
- 17:37absolutely
- 17:38everybody
- 17:39and
- 17:39for
- 17:39doing
- 17:39it
- 17:39for
- 17:40everybody,
- 17:40making
- 17:40it
- 17:41universal,
- 17:42they
- 17:42warped
- 17:42and
- 17:43distrenched,
- 17:43essentially
- 17:44destroyed
- 17:44the,
- 17:45the
- 17:46economy
- 17:46or
- 17:47the
- 17:47economics
- 17:47for
- 17:48an
- 17:48entire
- 17:48industry.
- 17:49That's
- 17:49what
- 17:49I
- 17:49worry
- 17:49about.
- 17:50Universal.
- 17:52You
- 17:52know,
- 17:52as
- 17:52well
- 17:53there,
- 17:53well,
- 17:53there's.
- 17:53Some
- 17:53evidence
- 17:54and
- 17:54maybe
- 17:54it's
- 17:54analogous
- 17:55to,
- 17:55to
- 17:55the
- 17:56voucher.
- 17:56There's
- 17:56some
- 17:56evidence.
- 17:57I'll
- 17:57give
- 17:57a
- 17:57shout
- 17:58out
- 17:58to
- 17:58a
- 17:58longtime
- 17:59education
- 17:59analyst
- 18:00guy
- 18:00named
- 18:00Art
- 18:00Hotman
- 18:01who
- 18:01sort
- 18:02of
- 18:02spoke
- 18:03some
- 18:03uncomfortable
- 18:03truths
- 18:04about
- 18:04higher
- 18:04ed
- 18:04and
- 18:05paid
- 18:05a,
- 18:05paid
- 18:05a
- 18:05price
- 18:05for
- 18:06that.
- 18:06And
- 18:06one
- 18:06of
- 18:07the
- 18:07things
- 18:07that
- 18:07his
- 18:08research
- 18:09showed
- 18:10was
- 18:11that
- 18:11you
- 18:12essentially
- 18:12with
- 18:12what
- 18:12you're
- 18:12talking
- 18:13about,
- 18:13you
- 18:13got
- 18:13a
- 18:13substitution
- 18:14effect.
- 18:14So
- 18:14schools
- 18:15were
- 18:15taking
- 18:15this
- 18:15money
- 18:16for
- 18:16low
- 18:16income
- 18:17students
- 18:17and
- 18:17then
- 18:18were
- 18:18bumping
- 18:18their
- 18:18aid
- 18:19up
- 18:19the
- 18:19food
- 18:19chain
- 18:20to
- 18:20appeal
- 18:21to
- 18:21middle
- 18:21class
- 18:22students
- 18:22and
- 18:23yeah,
- 18:23he
- 18:23did.
- 18:23And
- 18:24obviously
- 18:25one
- 18:25of
- 18:25the,
- 18:25one
- 18:25of
- 18:26the
- 18:26things
- 18:26I've
- 18:26never
- 18:26understood
- 18:27about
- 18:27higher
- 18:27ed
- 18:27finance
- 18:28is
- 18:29you
- 18:30assume
- 18:30of
- 18:31course
- 18:31that
- 18:31if
- 18:31you
- 18:31subsidize
- 18:32something
- 18:33you're
- 18:33going
- 18:33to
- 18:33get
- 18:33more
- 18:34of
- 18:34it
- 18:34and
- 18:34you're
- 18:34going
- 18:35to
- 18:35see,
- 18:36you
- 18:36know,
- 18:36distortions
- 18:37and
- 18:37effects
- 18:37on
- 18:37prices.
- 18:38But
- 18:38everybody
- 18:38just
- 18:38assumes
- 18:39for
- 18:39some
- 18:39reason
- 18:39that
- 18:40doesn't
- 18:40happen
- 18:40in
- 18:40higher
- 18:41ed.
- 18:41And
- 18:42we're
- 18:42now
- 18:42starting
- 18:42to
- 18:43get
- 18:43that
- 18:43in
- 18:43K12.
- 18:44That
- 18:44argument
- 18:45too
- 18:45where
- 18:45you're
- 18:45like,
- 18:45well
- 18:45if
- 18:46you
- 18:46do
- 18:46this,
- 18:46private
- 18:47schools
- 18:47are
- 18:47going
- 18:47to
- 18:47respond.
- 18:48It's
- 18:48like,
- 18:48oh
- 18:48no,
- 18:49they're
- 18:49not.
- 18:49It's
- 18:49like,
- 18:50you
- 18:50know,
- 18:50these,
- 18:50these
- 18:51like
- 18:51rules
- 18:51of
- 18:52economics
- 18:52seem
- 18:52to
- 18:53like,
- 18:53there's
- 18:53no
- 18:53reason
- 18:54to
- 18:54believe
- 18:54they
- 18:54don't
- 18:55generally,
- 18:55generally
- 18:56apply.
- 18:57And
- 18:57so
- 18:57I
- 18:57think
- 18:58you're
- 18:58right
- 18:58about
- 18:58the,
- 18:58the,
- 18:59the
- 18:59aid
- 18:59structure,
- 19:00I
- 19:00guess.
- 19:00I
- 19:01don't
- 19:01know
- 19:01if
- 19:01I'm,
- 19:01I'm
- 19:01more.
- 19:02You
- 19:02make
- 19:02good
- 19:02points.
- 19:02I
- 19:03don't
- 19:03know
- 19:03if
- 19:03I'm
- 19:03more
- 19:03optimistic
- 19:04than
- 19:05you
- 19:05or
- 19:05just
- 19:05more
- 19:06like
- 19:07this
- 19:07is,
- 19:08it's
- 19:08just
- 19:09how
- 19:09it
- 19:09is.
- 19:09And
- 19:09I
- 19:10do
- 19:10think
- 19:10I'm
- 19:10a
- 19:10big
- 19:11believer
- 19:11in,
- 19:12I
- 19:12think
- 19:12I'm
- 19:12just
- 19:13a
- 19:13big
- 19:13believer
- 19:13in
- 19:13big
- 19:14public
- 19:14universities.
- 19:15I
- 19:16think
- 19:16they're
- 19:16important
- 19:17and
- 19:18we
- 19:18have
- 19:18underinvested
- 19:19in
- 19:19them
- 19:19in
- 19:20some
- 19:20ways
- 19:20and
- 19:20we
- 19:20need
- 19:21to
- 19:21figure
- 19:21out,
- 19:23you
- 19:23know,
- 19:24how
- 19:24to
- 19:25rectify
- 19:25that
- 19:26in
- 19:26a
- 19:26responsible,
- 19:27in
- 19:27a
- 19:27responsible
- 19:28way.
- 19:28Yeah.
- 19:29And
- 19:29I
- 19:29just
- 19:29think
- 19:29that
- 19:30when
- 19:30K12
- 19:31has
- 19:31this
- 19:32exit
- 19:32point
- 19:33or
- 19:33one
- 19:33of
- 19:33Its
- 19:34primary
- 19:34exit
- 19:34points.
- 19:35Higher
- 19:36ed
- 19:36continuation
- 19:37being
- 19:38so
- 19:39dysfunctional
- 19:40right
- 19:40now,
- 19:40I
- 19:41think
- 19:41it's
- 19:41going
- 19:41to
- 19:41ripple
- 19:41through
- 19:42in
- 19:42all
- 19:42sorts
- 19:42of
- 19:42ways.
- 19:43My
- 19:43daughter's
- 19:44going
- 19:44to
- 19:44be
- 19:44applying
- 19:44to
- 19:45graduate
- 19:45school
- 19:45programs
- 19:46shortly.
- 19:47The
- 19:47number
- 19:47of
- 19:48graduate
- 19:49school
- 19:49students
- 19:50that
- 19:50are
- 19:51having
- 19:51their
- 19:51offers
- 19:52rescinded
- 19:52right
- 19:53now,
- 19:54also
- 19:55the
- 19:55whole,
- 19:55the
- 19:56whole
- 19:56Higher
- 19:57Ed
- 19:57PhD,
- 20:00you
- 20:00know,
- 20:01the
- 20:01students
- 20:02that
- 20:02are,
- 20:03that
- 20:03are
- 20:04receiving
- 20:05stipends
- 20:05as
- 20:06they
- 20:06get
- 20:06their
- 20:07PhD
- 20:07programs.
- 20:08A
- 20:08lot
- 20:08of
- 20:09the
- 20:09work
- 20:09that
- 20:09these
- 20:09research
- 20:10assistants
- 20:10are
- 20:10doing
- 20:11can
- 20:11now
- 20:11be
- 20:11done
- 20:11by
- 20:12AI.
- 20:12You
- 20:13know,
- 20:13I
- 20:14just
- 20:14feel
- 20:14like
- 20:14there's
- 20:15going
- 20:15to
- 20:15be
- 20:15this
- 20:15level
- 20:15of
- 20:15disruption
- 20:16and
- 20:16then
- 20:16all
- 20:17that
- 20:17disruption
- 20:17is
- 20:17happening.
- 20:18And
- 20:18it
- 20:19makes
- 20:19it
- 20:19easy,
- 20:20I
- 20:20think,
- 20:20for
- 20:21K12
- 20:21to
- 20:22sag
- 20:22back
- 20:22to
- 20:23this
- 20:23idea.
- 20:24Higher
- 20:24ed's
- 20:24not
- 20:24for
- 20:25everyone.
- 20:25College
- 20:25is
- 20:25not
- 20:26for
- 20:26everyone.
- 20:26And
- 20:26it's
- 20:26actually
- 20:27true.
- 20:27Yes,
- 20:28it's
- 20:28true.
- 20:29But
- 20:29you
- 20:29know,
- 20:29to
- 20:30like
- 20:30make
- 20:30it
- 20:31really
- 20:31simple
- 20:32and
- 20:32easy
- 20:32or
- 20:33even
- 20:33more
- 20:33compelling
- 20:34to
- 20:34make
- 20:35that
- 20:35argument
- 20:35without
- 20:36having
- 20:36to
- 20:36like
- 20:37confront
- 20:38some
- 20:38of
- 20:38the
- 20:38unfairness
- 20:39that's
- 20:39inherently
- 20:40cooked
- 20:40therein,
- 20:41I
- 20:42just
- 20:42think
- 20:42is
- 20:42not
- 20:43helpful
- 20:43for
- 20:43where
- 20:43K12
- 20:44is
- 20:44right
- 20:44now.
- 20:45Well,
- 20:45yeah,
- 20:45higher
- 20:46ed's
- 20:46not
- 20:46for
- 20:47everyone,
- 20:47but
- 20:48I
- 20:48feel
- 20:48like
- 20:48we've
- 20:49decided
- 20:49it's
- 20:49not
- 20:50for
- 20:50everyone
- 20:51based
- 20:51on
- 20:52markers
- 20:52that
- 20:53I
- 20:53reject.
- 20:54So
- 20:54income,
- 20:55race,
- 20:55things
- 20:55like
- 20:55that.
- 20:56Like,
- 20:57we
- 20:57need
- 20:57to
- 20:57do
- 20:58a
- 20:58much
- 20:58better
- 20:58job
- 20:59exposing
- 21:00kids
- 21:00to
- 21:00different,
- 21:00different
- 21:01kinds
- 21:01of
- 21:01options
- 21:02than
- 21:02letting
- 21:02them
- 21:03make
- 21:03their
- 21:04own
- 21:04choices.
- 21:05And
- 21:05instead
- 21:06we
- 21:06decided
- 21:06to
- 21:07make
- 21:07these
- 21:07choices
- 21:07for
- 21:07them
- 21:08or
- 21:08again,
- 21:09tried
- 21:09to.
- 21:09Like,
- 21:10we've
- 21:10gone
- 21:10from
- 21:11a
- 21:11movement
- 21:12that
- 21:12was
- 21:12about
- 21:13like
- 21:13making
- 21:13sure
- 21:14that
- 21:14poor
- 21:14kids
- 21:15who
- 21:15wanted
- 21:15to
- 21:15go
- 21:15to
- 21:15college
- 21:16could
- 21:16to
- 21:16a
- 21:16movement
- 21:17that's
- 21:17questioning
- 21:17whether
- 21:18that's
- 21:18a
- 21:18good
- 21:18goal.
- 21:18And
- 21:19I,
- 21:19I
- 21:19just
- 21:19reject
- 21:20that.
- 21:21The
- 21:21data
- 21:22is
- 21:22really
- 21:22clear.
- 21:22It's
- 21:23a
- 21:23good
- 21:23thing
- 21:23to
- 21:24do
- 21:24from
- 21:24a
- 21:25social
- 21:25mobility
- 21:25standpoint
- 21:26insofar
- 21:27as
- 21:28it's
- 21:28something
- 21:28that
- 21:29you
- 21:29want
- 21:29to
- 21:29do.
- 21:29You're
- 21:29interested
- 21:30in
- 21:30those
- 21:30things.
- 21:30Obviously,
- 21:31if
- 21:32your
- 21:32interests
- 21:32lie
- 21:33elsewhere.
- 21:34But
- 21:34the
- 21:34data
- 21:35is
- 21:35pretty
- 21:35clear
- 21:35that
- 21:36in
- 21:36general
- 21:36you're
- 21:37better
- 21:37off.
- 21:37And
- 21:37one
- 21:37of
- 21:37the
- 21:37things
- 21:38you
- 21:38see
- 21:38is
- 21:38even
- 21:38though
- 21:38people
- 21:38are
- 21:39like,
- 21:39well,
- 21:39you
- 21:39can
- 21:40make
- 21:40more
- 21:40money
- 21:41working
- 21:41as
- 21:42a
- 21:42plumber,
- 21:42H
- 21:42Vac.
- 21:43That's
- 21:43true,
- 21:44except
- 21:45we
- 21:45even
- 21:45see
- 21:45their
- 21:46wage
- 21:46premium.
- 21:47College
- 21:47educated
- 21:48people
- 21:48working,
- 21:48plumbing
- 21:49and
- 21:49H
- 21:49vac
- 21:49make
- 21:50more
- 21:50money,
- 21:51there's
- 21:51something
- 21:51to
- 21:51be
- 21:52said
- 21:52for
- 21:52it.
- 21:52And
- 21:54it,
- 21:54it
- 21:55just
- 21:55shows
- 21:55up
- 21:55across
- 21:56the
- 21:56board.
- 21:57And
- 21:57one
- 21:58of
- 21:58the
- 21:58most
- 21:58interesting
- 21:58things
- 21:58you
- 21:59look
- 21:59at
- 21:59like,
- 21:59and
- 21:59this
- 21:59goes
- 21:59back
- 22:00to
- 22:00like
- 22:00research
- 22:00like
- 22:00Ron
- 22:01Haskins
- 22:01at
- 22:02Brookings
- 22:02years
- 22:02ago,
- 22:03you,
- 22:03if
- 22:03you,
- 22:04if
- 22:04you're
- 22:04low
- 22:04income
- 22:04and
- 22:05you
- 22:05go
- 22:05to
- 22:05college,
- 22:05your
- 22:06economic
- 22:06mobility,
- 22:07the
- 22:07effect
- 22:07is
- 22:07going
- 22:07to
- 22:07be
- 22:07greater
- 22:08than
- 22:08if
- 22:08you're
- 22:08high
- 22:09income
- 22:09and
- 22:09you
- 22:09don't.
- 22:10And
- 22:10which
- 22:10is
- 22:10like
- 22:10that
- 22:11social
- 22:11like
- 22:12instructional
- 22:12inequality,
- 22:13like
- 22:13just,
- 22:14you
- 22:14know,
- 22:15laid,
- 22:15laid
- 22:15bare.
- 22:16And
- 22:16so
- 22:16I've
- 22:17been
- 22:17just
- 22:17kind
- 22:17of
- 22:17dismayed
- 22:18at
- 22:19the
- 22:19sort
- 22:19of
- 22:20retreat
- 22:21from
- 22:21again,
- 22:22not
- 22:22no
- 22:22one.
- 22:23I
- 22:23didn't
- 22:23ever
- 22:23bump
- 22:24in
- 22:24anybody's
- 22:24college
- 22:25for
- 22:25all.
- 22:25Like
- 22:26everybody
- 22:26should
- 22:26go
- 22:26to
- 22:26college.
- 22:27Yeah.
- 22:27I
- 22:27bumped
- 22:27into
- 22:28a
- 22:28lot
- 22:28of
- 22:28people
- 22:28and
- 22:28I
- 22:29was
- 22:29one
- 22:29who
- 22:29are
- 22:29like
- 22:30the
- 22:30opportunity
- 22:30to
- 22:31go
- 22:31to
- 22:31college
- 22:31for
- 22:32all.
- 22:32And
- 22:32that
- 22:32opportunity
- 22:33is
- 22:33not
- 22:33at
- 22:33all
- 22:34equitably
- 22:35distributed.
- 22:35And
- 22:35so
- 22:35regardless
- 22:36of
- 22:36your
- 22:36zip
- 22:36code,
- 22:37if
- 22:37that's
- 22:37something
- 22:38you
- 22:38want,
- 22:38you
- 22:38should,
- 22:38you
- 22:39should
- 22:39go
- 22:39for
- 22:39it.
- 22:39And
- 22:40I,
- 22:40I
- 22:40don't
- 22:41think
- 22:41we
- 22:41should
- 22:41back
- 22:41away
- 22:42from
- 22:42that.
- 22:42There's
- 22:43a
- 22:43article
- 22:44in
- 22:44the
- 22:44New
- 22:44York
- 22:44Times
- 22:45the
- 22:45other
- 22:45day
- 22:45by
- 22:45Dana
- 22:45Goldstein
- 22:46getting
- 22:46at
- 22:47that
- 22:47whole
- 22:47question
- 22:48and
- 22:48I
- 22:48just
- 22:48think
- 22:49that
- 22:49is
- 22:49not
- 22:50something
- 22:50we
- 22:50should
- 22:51back
- 22:51away
- 22:51from.
- 22:52Sending
- 22:52low
- 22:53income
- 22:53kids
- 22:53to
- 22:54college,
- 22:54getting
- 22:54them
- 22:54to
- 22:55and
- 22:55through
- 22:56so
- 22:56they're
- 22:56prepared
- 22:56to
- 22:57get
- 22:57through.
- 22:58It
- 22:58just
- 22:58seems
- 22:59like,
- 22:59you
- 22:59know,
- 23:00that
- 23:00seems
- 23:00like
- 23:00a
- 23:00core
- 23:01goal
- 23:01if
- 23:01you're
- 23:01in
- 23:02education.
- 23:03Yeah,
- 23:04well,
- 23:04let's,
- 23:04let's
- 23:04bring
- 23:05it
- 23:05to
- 23:05Department
- 23:06of
- 23:06Department
- 23:07of
- 23:07Education.
- 23:07Let's
- 23:07bring
- 23:07it
- 23:07to
- 23:07K12
- 23:09because
- 23:10I,
- 23:10I
- 23:10have
- 23:10gotten.
- 23:11Do
- 23:11you
- 23:11have
- 23:11a
- 23:11Department
- 23:12of
- 23:12Education?
- 23:13Well,
- 23:15I
- 23:15mean
- 23:16I
- 23:16find
- 23:16this
- 23:16whole
- 23:16conversation
- 23:17fascinating
- 23:18too
- 23:18because
- 23:18I've
- 23:19had
- 23:19a
- 23:19few
- 23:19readers
- 23:20send
- 23:20me
- 23:20emails
- 23:21saying
- 23:21hey
- 23:22Jed,
- 23:22you're,
- 23:23you're,
- 23:23you're
- 23:24not
- 23:24concerned
- 23:25enough
- 23:25about
- 23:26the
- 23:26damage
- 23:26that's
- 23:27being
- 23:27done
- 23:27to
- 23:27the
- 23:27department.
- 23:28And
- 23:28there's
- 23:28all
- 23:28these
- 23:28protections
- 23:29of,
- 23:30of
- 23:31our
- 23:31most
- 23:31vulnerable
- 23:32kids
- 23:32that
- 23:32we
- 23:33should
- 23:33be
- 23:34fighting
- 23:34to
- 23:34protect.
- 23:35My,
- 23:36my
- 23:36statement
- 23:36on
- 23:36that
- 23:37was,
- 23:37yeah,
- 23:37I
- 23:38can
- 23:38understand
- 23:38us
- 23:38being
- 23:38concerned
- 23:39about
- 23:39protecting
- 23:39kids
- 23:40civil
- 23:40rights,
- 23:41but
- 23:41as
- 23:41far
- 23:41as
- 23:41I'm
- 23:42concerned,
- 23:42the
- 23:42way
- 23:42public
- 23:43education
- 23:43is
- 23:44done
- 23:45writ
- 23:45large
- 23:45in
- 23:46our
- 23:46country
- 23:46is
- 23:47one
- 23:47violation
- 23:47of
- 23:48civil
- 23:48rights.
- 23:49I
- 23:50mean,
- 23:50and
- 23:51who
- 23:51are
- 23:51we
- 23:51kidding
- 23:52that
- 23:52the
- 23:52Department
- 23:53of
- 23:53Education
- 23:53has
- 23:54been
- 23:54a
- 23:55very
- 23:55strong
- 23:56force
- 23:57to
- 23:58push
- 23:58things
- 23:59in
- 23:59a
- 23:59positive
- 23:59direction.
- 24:00And
- 24:00I
- 24:00just
- 24:00feel
- 24:01like
- 24:01when
- 24:02the
- 24:02entire
- 24:03department
- 24:03has
- 24:04just
- 24:04become
- 24:05a
- 24:06enforcer
- 24:07of
- 24:07a
- 24:07blob
- 24:07of
- 24:08regulation
- 24:08that's
- 24:09just
- 24:09so
- 24:10disempowering
- 24:11to
- 24:11schools
- 24:12that
- 24:13this
- 24:13again
- 24:14feels
- 24:14like
- 24:14a
- 24:15disequilibrium
- 24:16that
- 24:16was
- 24:17just
- 24:17waiting
- 24:18to
- 24:18be
- 24:19adjusted
- 24:20to
- 24:20be
- 24:21corrected,
- 24:21to
- 24:21be
- 24:22toppled.
- 24:24Yeah,
- 24:24it's
- 24:25interesting.
- 24:25One
- 24:25thing
- 24:25you
- 24:25say.
- 24:26Yeah,
- 24:26like
- 24:26what
- 24:27do
- 24:27you
- 24:27think?
- 24:27Because
- 24:27I've
- 24:27been
- 24:28struck
- 24:28how
- 24:29whatever
- 24:29you
- 24:30think,
- 24:30if
- 24:30we
- 24:30could
- 24:30talk
- 24:30about
- 24:31our
- 24:31views
- 24:31on
- 24:31the
- 24:31department.
- 24:32The
- 24:32conversation
- 24:33about
- 24:33it
- 24:33seems
- 24:34is
- 24:34very
- 24:34decontextualized
- 24:36from
- 24:37these
- 24:37changes
- 24:37in
- 24:37education
- 24:38around
- 24:38the
- 24:38country
- 24:39to
- 24:39everything
- 24:39that's
- 24:40been
- 24:41happening.
- 24:42It's
- 24:42like
- 24:43Washington
- 24:44off
- 24:44as
- 24:44an
- 24:44island
- 24:45rather
- 24:45than
- 24:46this
- 24:46is
- 24:46just
- 24:46downstream
- 24:47of
- 24:49this
- 24:49complete
- 24:50loss
- 24:50of
- 24:50faith
- 24:51and
- 24:51decline
- 24:52in
- 24:52achievement,
- 24:53all
- 24:53of
- 24:53it
- 24:53over
- 24:54the
- 24:54last
- 24:54decade.
- 24:55Yeah.
- 24:55For
- 24:56me,
- 24:57the
- 24:58big
- 24:58things
- 24:58are,
- 24:58does
- 24:59special
- 24:59ed
- 24:59funding
- 25:00continue
- 25:00to
- 25:00flow?
- 25:01Does
- 25:01Title
- 25:011
- 25:02funding
- 25:02continue
- 25:02to
- 25:03flow?
- 25:04And
- 25:05hey,
- 25:05I
- 25:05want
- 25:05the
- 25:06testing
- 25:06and
- 25:06I
- 25:06want
- 25:07the
- 25:07research
- 25:07and
- 25:08the
- 25:08identification
- 25:08of
- 25:09best
- 25:09practices,
- 25:09but
- 25:09that's
- 25:10kind
- 25:10of,
- 25:10you
- 25:10know,
- 25:12secondary
- 25:12to
- 25:13the
- 25:13funding
- 25:13continuing
- 25:14to
- 25:14flow.
- 25:15So.
- 25:15And
- 25:15I
- 25:15don't
- 25:15care.
- 25:16Does
- 25:16a
- 25:16Small
- 25:16Business
- 25:17administration
- 25:17manage
- 25:18the
- 25:18trillion
- 25:18dollars
- 25:19of
- 25:19student
- 25:19debt?
- 25:20You
- 25:20know,
- 25:22I
- 25:23don't
- 25:23have
- 25:23strong
- 25:23feelings
- 25:23about
- 25:24that.
- 25:24I
- 25:24honestly
- 25:25want
- 25:25there
- 25:25to
- 25:26be
- 25:26a
- 25:26continued
- 25:27investment
- 25:28in
- 25:28low
- 25:28income
- 25:28kids.
- 25:29I
- 25:29thought
- 25:29it
- 25:29was
- 25:29interesting
- 25:30that
- 25:30McMahon
- 25:31was
- 25:31clear,
- 25:32hey,
- 25:33cut
- 25:33everything
- 25:33else,
- 25:33but
- 25:34I
- 25:34want
- 25:34to
- 25:34keep
- 25:34having
- 25:34the
- 25:35Title
- 25:351
- 25:35money.
- 25:37So
- 25:37the
- 25:37question
- 25:37I
- 25:37have
- 25:38for,
- 25:38you
- 25:38know,
- 25:39my,
- 25:39my
- 25:39favorite
- 25:40walk
- 25:40here
- 25:41is
- 25:43the
- 25:43sub,
- 25:44the,
- 25:44the,
- 25:45the
- 25:45thumbnail
- 25:45is,
- 25:46hey,
- 25:47keep
- 25:47the
- 25:47money
- 25:47flowing.
- 25:49Get,
- 25:50get
- 25:50the
- 25:50feds
- 25:50out
- 25:50of,
- 25:50Let
- 25:51the
- 25:51states
- 25:51do
- 25:51what
- 25:51they
- 25:51want
- 25:52to
- 25:52do.
- 25:53But
- 25:53all
- 25:54the
- 25:54regulations
- 25:55for
- 25:56Title
- 25:561
- 25:56through
- 25:579
- 25:57funds,
- 25:58they're
- 25:58all
- 25:59still
- 25:59there.
- 26:00So
- 26:00as
- 26:00far
- 26:01as
- 26:01I
- 26:01can
- 26:01tell,
- 26:02they're
- 26:03all
- 26:03obligated
- 26:04to
- 26:05adhere
- 26:06to
- 26:06those
- 26:06regs.
- 26:06And
- 26:07even
- 26:07if
- 26:07the
- 26:07feds
- 26:08decide
- 26:09not
- 26:09to
- 26:09enforce
- 26:10those
- 26:10things,
- 26:11any
- 26:12court
- 26:13would,
- 26:13would
- 26:14happily
- 26:15say
- 26:17you
- 26:17can't
- 26:18spend
- 26:18money
- 26:18in
- 26:18a
- 26:18way
- 26:19that's
- 26:19not
- 26:19consistent
- 26:20with
- 26:20these
- 26:20federal
- 26:21regs.
- 26:22So
- 26:22I
- 26:22mean,
- 26:22if
- 26:23I
- 26:23were
- 26:23to
- 26:23say
- 26:23what
- 26:24would,
- 26:24would
- 26:24be
- 26:25an
- 26:25important
- 26:26next
- 26:26step
- 26:26or
- 26:27an
- 26:27additional
- 26:27step
- 26:28or
- 26:28maybe
- 26:28what
- 26:28I
- 26:28would
- 26:29have
- 26:29preferred
- 26:29from
- 26:29the
- 26:29very
- 26:30beginning,
- 26:30keep
- 26:31more
- 26:31capacity
- 26:32within
- 26:32the
- 26:32department
- 26:33so
- 26:33that
- 26:33you
- 26:33can
- 26:33manage
- 26:34the
- 26:34administrative
- 26:35process
- 26:35of
- 26:36sunsetting
- 26:37or,
- 26:37you
- 26:38know,
- 26:38just
- 26:38narrowing
- 26:39all
- 26:39of
- 26:39these
- 26:40regulations
- 26:40on,
- 26:41on
- 26:41all
- 26:41these
- 26:41programs.
- 26:42I'm
- 26:42afraid
- 26:42that
- 26:42they're
- 26:43gonna
- 26:43have
- 26:43so
- 26:43little
- 26:43capacity
- 26:44within
- 26:45the
- 26:45department
- 26:46that
- 26:46all
- 26:46of
- 26:46these
- 26:46regs
- 26:47are
- 26:47going
- 26:47to
- 26:47essentially
- 26:48stay
- 26:48in
- 26:48place
- 26:49and
- 26:49the
- 26:49idea
- 26:50of
- 26:50deregulation
- 26:50is
- 26:51going
- 26:51to
- 26:51turn
- 26:51out
- 26:51to
- 26:51be
- 26:51a
- 26:51fantasy
- 26:52in
- 26:52the
- 26:52end.
- 26:53You're
- 26:53the
- 26:53walk.
- 26:53So
- 26:54tell
- 26:54me,
- 26:54where
- 26:54am
- 26:54I
- 26:54wrong
- 26:55here?
- 26:55Yeah,
- 26:56I
- 26:56mean,
- 26:56a
- 26:56couple
- 26:56of
- 26:57things.
- 26:57One,
- 26:57I
- 26:57do
- 26:57think
- 26:58I
- 26:58get
- 26:58the
- 26:58same
- 26:58thing
- 26:58I
- 26:58get.
- 26:59People
- 26:59are
- 26:59like,
- 26:59you're
- 26:59not
- 26:59freaked
- 27:00out
- 27:00enough.
- 27:00And
- 27:01like,
- 27:02I
- 27:02think
- 27:02that
- 27:02you
- 27:02have
- 27:03to
- 27:03like,
- 27:03like
- 27:05what
- 27:05we're
- 27:05talking
- 27:06about
- 27:06in
- 27:06education.
- 27:06For
- 27:07the
- 27:07most
- 27:07part,
- 27:08these
- 27:08are
- 27:08policy
- 27:08questions.
- 27:09I'm
- 27:10not
- 27:10a
- 27:10fan
- 27:10of
- 27:10moving
- 27:11student
- 27:11loans
- 27:11to
- 27:11Small
- 27:12Business
- 27:12Administration,
- 27:13but
- 27:13like,
- 27:13you
- 27:13want
- 27:13to
- 27:13move
- 27:14into
- 27:14the
- 27:14Department
- 27:14of
- 27:14Treasury.
- 27:15That
- 27:15didn't
- 27:16seem
- 27:16like
- 27:16a
- 27:16crazy
- 27:17idea
- 27:17to
- 27:17me.
- 27:18I
- 27:18don't
- 27:18think
- 27:18we
- 27:18should
- 27:19move
- 27:19HH
- 27:19or
- 27:20idea
- 27:21Special
- 27:21Ed
- 27:21to
- 27:21hhs.
- 27:22Yeah,
- 27:23yeah.
- 27:23But
- 27:23like,
- 27:24it's,
- 27:24I
- 27:25think,
- 27:25you
- 27:25know,
- 27:25in
- 27:26fact,
- 27:26I
- 27:26think
- 27:26we
- 27:26should
- 27:26probably
- 27:27move
- 27:27Head
- 27:27Start
- 27:27from
- 27:28HHS
- 27:28to
- 27:29education.
- 27:29But
- 27:29like
- 27:29These
- 27:30are,
- 27:30those
- 27:30are
- 27:30policy
- 27:31questions
- 27:31fundamentally,
- 27:33other
- 27:33parts
- 27:34of
- 27:34government.
- 27:34Right
- 27:34now
- 27:35we're
- 27:35having
- 27:35constitutional
- 27:36questions.
- 27:37You
- 27:38know,
- 27:38we're
- 27:38having
- 27:38like,
- 27:38in
- 27:38the
- 27:39judiciary,
- 27:40there's
- 27:40like
- 27:40fairly
- 27:41substantial
- 27:41questions
- 27:42about,
- 27:44about
- 27:45executive
- 27:45authority,
- 27:46about
- 27:46Article
- 27:472
- 27:47authority
- 27:48and
- 27:48so
- 27:49forth.
- 27:49Like
- 27:49that's
- 27:50constitutional.
- 27:50And
- 27:51we,
- 27:51we
- 27:51talked
- 27:51about
- 27:52one
- 27:52earlier
- 27:52in
- 27:52this
- 27:52podcast
- 27:53with
- 27:53like
- 27:53the,
- 27:54the,
- 27:55the
- 27:55Columbia
- 27:56guy
- 27:56in
- 27:56due
- 27:56process.
- 27:57And
- 27:57so
- 27:57I
- 27:57feel
- 27:58like,
- 27:58like
- 27:58education,
- 27:59we
- 27:59need
- 27:59to
- 27:59be.
- 28:00I
- 28:00don't
- 28:00want
- 28:00to
- 28:00say
- 28:00this
- 28:00stuff
- 28:01doesn't
- 28:01matter.
- 28:01I
- 28:01don't
- 28:01want
- 28:01to
- 28:01say
- 28:02it's
- 28:02trivial.
- 28:02A
- 28:02lot
- 28:02of
- 28:02people
- 28:03have
- 28:03lost
- 28:03their
- 28:03jobs.
- 28:04It's
- 28:04all
- 28:04very
- 28:05consequential.
- 28:06But
- 28:06I
- 28:06think,
- 28:06like,
- 28:07the,
- 28:08the
- 28:08degrees
- 28:08of
- 28:08what
- 28:09we're
- 28:09arguing
- 28:09about,
- 28:09it
- 28:10is
- 28:10important,
- 28:10it
- 28:11is
- 28:11important
- 28:11to
- 28:11keep,
- 28:12to
- 28:12keep
- 28:12in
- 28:12mind.
- 28:13I
- 28:13would
- 28:14watch
- 28:14for
- 28:14them.
- 28:14The
- 28:14short
- 28:15answer
- 28:15to
- 28:15your
- 28:15question
- 28:16is
- 28:16waivers.
- 28:16I
- 28:17think
- 28:17they're,
- 28:17I
- 28:17think
- 28:18they're
- 28:18going
- 28:18to,
- 28:20in
- 28:20part
- 28:20because
- 28:21they
- 28:21seem
- 28:21to
- 28:21really
- 28:22like
- 28:22executive
- 28:22authority
- 28:23and
- 28:23want
- 28:23to
- 28:23push
- 28:24it
- 28:24as
- 28:24far
- 28:24as
- 28:24they
- 28:24can,
- 28:25that
- 28:25waivers
- 28:26are
- 28:26a
- 28:26way
- 28:26to
- 28:26get
- 28:26around
- 28:27some
- 28:27of
- 28:27those
- 28:27regulations
- 28:28and
- 28:28so
- 28:28forth,
- 28:29give
- 28:29flexibility.
- 28:31I
- 28:31think
- 28:31Trump
- 28:33would
- 28:33really
- 28:34like
- 28:34the
- 28:34spectacle
- 28:35of
- 28:35these
- 28:35governors
- 28:36having
- 28:36to
- 28:36come
- 28:36and
- 28:36ask
- 28:37for
- 28:38the
- 28:38flexibility.
- 28:39And
- 28:39then
- 28:39you
- 28:39have
- 28:39some
- 28:39kind
- 28:40of
- 28:40a
- 28:40deal
- 28:40that
- 28:41seems
- 28:41to
- 28:41really
- 28:41appeal
- 28:42to
- 28:42his,
- 28:43his
- 28:44idea
- 28:44of
- 28:44how
- 28:44we
- 28:45should
- 28:45do
- 28:45government.
- 28:46And
- 28:46so
- 28:46that's,
- 28:47that's
- 28:47what
- 28:47I
- 28:47would
- 28:47pay
- 28:47attention
- 28:48to
- 28:48because
- 28:49I
- 28:49don't
- 28:49think,
- 28:49look,
- 28:50there's,
- 28:50I
- 28:50don't
- 28:50think
- 28:50there's
- 28:50218
- 28:51votes
- 28:52or,
- 28:53or
- 28:5360,
- 28:54let
- 28:54alone
- 28:5451
- 28:55in
- 28:55the
- 28:55Senate
- 28:56to
- 28:57really
- 28:57undo
- 28:57a
- 28:57lot
- 28:57of
- 28:57this
- 28:58stuff.
- 28:58And
- 28:58so
- 28:58they'll
- 28:58just
- 28:59be
- 28:59looking
- 28:59for
- 28:59other
- 28:59ways
- 29:00to
- 29:00do
- 29:00it.
- 29:00So
- 29:00that's
- 29:01what
- 29:01I
- 29:01would,
- 29:01that's
- 29:02what
- 29:02I
- 29:02would
- 29:02pay
- 29:03attention
- 29:03to.
- 29:03And
- 29:03I
- 29:04do
- 29:04think
- 29:04you're
- 29:04raising
- 29:05a
- 29:05really
- 29:05important
- 29:06point.
- 29:06There
- 29:07is
- 29:07a
- 29:08sort
- 29:08of
- 29:08shoot,
- 29:09aim,
- 29:09load
- 29:10kind
- 29:10of
- 29:10quality
- 29:11to
- 29:11this.
- 29:12And
- 29:13they've
- 29:14like
- 29:14gotten
- 29:15rid
- 29:15of
- 29:15a
- 29:15lot
- 29:15of
- 29:15the
- 29:15people
- 29:15they
- 29:16would
- 29:16have
- 29:16needed
- 29:16to
- 29:16do
- 29:16this
- 29:17in
- 29:17a
- 29:17more
- 29:17orderly,
- 29:18serious
- 29:18way.
- 29:18You're
- 29:19seeing
- 29:19that
- 29:19in
- 29:19particular
- 29:19right
- 29:20now
- 29:20on
- 29:20why
- 29:20they're
- 29:21trying
- 29:21to
- 29:21fix
- 29:21some
- 29:22of
- 29:22the
- 29:22problems
- 29:22that
- 29:22they've
- 29:23created
- 29:23at
- 29:24around
- 29:25the
- 29:25nape
- 29:25test
- 29:26and
- 29:26at
- 29:26ies.
- 29:28They've
- 29:28just
- 29:28let
- 29:28go
- 29:29some
- 29:29of
- 29:29the
- 29:29people
- 29:29you
- 29:30need
- 29:30to
- 29:30do
- 29:30that
- 29:30work.
- 29:31I
- 29:31think
- 29:31you're
- 29:31gonna
- 29:32have
- 29:32the
- 29:32same,
- 29:32you're
- 29:32gonna
- 29:32have
- 29:33the
- 29:33same
- 29:33thing.
- 29:33The
- 29:33way
- 29:33they
- 29:33decided
- 29:34to
- 29:34go
- 29:34do
- 29:34this
- 29:35at
- 29:35main
- 29:35ed
- 29:36means
- 29:37if
- 29:37you
- 29:37want
- 29:38to
- 29:38have
- 29:38sort
- 29:38of
- 29:38an
- 29:38orderly
- 29:39process
- 29:40around
- 29:41this,
- 29:41it's
- 29:41going
- 29:41to
- 29:41be
- 29:41difficult.
- 29:42And
- 29:42so
- 29:42it
- 29:42may
- 29:42end
- 29:42up
- 29:42being
- 29:43chaotic
- 29:45and,
- 29:45and,
- 29:46and
- 29:46sloppy.
- 29:47Yeah,
- 29:49well,
- 29:50I
- 29:50feel
- 29:50like
- 29:51I
- 29:51don't
- 29:52Feel
- 29:52like
- 29:52this
- 29:52is
- 29:52a
- 29:53landing
- 29:53spot
- 29:54for
- 29:54us.
- 29:54And
- 29:54I
- 29:54kind
- 29:54of
- 29:55had
- 29:55a
- 29:55question.
- 29:55For
- 29:55you
- 29:55just
- 29:55about
- 29:56how
- 29:56much
- 29:57something
- 29:58more,
- 29:58more
- 29:58uplifting.
- 30:00But
- 30:01look,
- 30:01I
- 30:01mean,
- 30:01I
- 30:02do
- 30:02think.
- 30:03Oh,
- 30:03go
- 30:03ahead.
- 30:04Well,
- 30:04I
- 30:04mean,
- 30:05I
- 30:05just
- 30:05don't
- 30:05think
- 30:05that
- 30:06this
- 30:06is
- 30:07a
- 30:07set
- 30:07of
- 30:07policies
- 30:08built
- 30:08to
- 30:09last.
- 30:09As
- 30:09soon
- 30:10as
- 30:10there
- 30:10is
- 30:10some
- 30:11national
- 30:12imperative,
- 30:12as
- 30:13soon
- 30:13as
- 30:13the
- 30:13Chinese
- 30:14do
- 30:14something
- 30:14that
- 30:15kick
- 30:15our
- 30:15ass
- 30:15in
- 30:16some
- 30:16way
- 30:16where
- 30:17it's
- 30:17felt
- 30:17like,
- 30:17you
- 30:17know,
- 30:18it's,
- 30:18it's
- 30:18an
- 30:18intellectual
- 30:19academic
- 30:21competency
- 30:22issue,
- 30:22you
- 30:22know
- 30:23damn
- 30:23well
- 30:23the
- 30:24feds
- 30:24are
- 30:24going
- 30:24to
- 30:24say
- 30:24we
- 30:25want
- 30:25to
- 30:25have
- 30:25a
- 30:25way
- 30:26to
- 30:26invest
- 30:26in
- 30:26education
- 30:27that's
- 30:27going
- 30:27to
- 30:27be
- 30:27able
- 30:27to
- 30:27keep
- 30:27up
- 30:28with
- 30:28these
- 30:28other
- 30:28countries.
- 30:29And
- 30:29so.
- 30:30And
- 30:30we're
- 30:30just
- 30:30waiting
- 30:31for
- 30:31that.
- 30:31Right.
- 30:33That's
- 30:33the
- 30:34whole
- 30:34problem.
- 30:34That's
- 30:34the
- 30:35whole
- 30:35problem.
- 30:35Like
- 30:35the
- 30:36Chinese
- 30:36are
- 30:37not
- 30:38disinvesting
- 30:39or
- 30:40like
- 30:40totally
- 30:41just.
- 30:41They're
- 30:41going
- 30:41in
- 30:41the
- 30:41opposite
- 30:42direction.
- 30:42Absolute
- 30:43opposite
- 30:43direction.
- 30:44Absolutely.
- 30:45This
- 30:45is
- 30:45the
- 30:45rest.
- 30:45I
- 30:45mean
- 30:46this.
- 30:46I,
- 30:46I
- 30:46think
- 30:46we
- 30:46should
- 30:47be
- 30:47honest.
- 30:47Like,
- 30:47are
- 30:48there
- 30:48some
- 30:48states
- 30:48that
- 30:48gonna
- 30:49do
- 30:49really
- 30:49cool
- 30:49stuff?
- 30:50Yeah,
- 30:50absolutely.
- 30:52That's
- 30:52always,
- 30:53that's
- 30:53always
- 30:53been
- 30:53the
- 30:53case.
- 30:53But
- 30:53we're
- 30:54also
- 30:54going
- 30:54to
- 30:54increase
- 30:54the
- 30:55variance.
- 30:55And
- 30:55if
- 30:56you
- 30:56want
- 30:56to
- 30:56have
- 30:56sort
- 30:56of
- 30:56a
- 30:56national
- 30:57competitiveness
- 30:58strategy,
- 30:59we
- 30:59should
- 30:59be
- 30:59trying
- 30:59to
- 30:59figure
- 31:00out
- 31:00what
- 31:00are
- 31:00the
- 31:00ways
- 31:01we
- 31:01can
- 31:01shave
- 31:02some
- 31:02of
- 31:02the
- 31:02sharp
- 31:03edges
- 31:03off
- 31:03of
- 31:03that
- 31:04variance
- 31:04and,
- 31:05and
- 31:05have
- 31:05those
- 31:06guardrails.
- 31:06And
- 31:06so,
- 31:07yeah,
- 31:07I
- 31:07mean
- 31:07that's,
- 31:08that's
- 31:08where
- 31:08I
- 31:08sort
- 31:09of
- 31:09part
- 31:09ways
- 31:10on
- 31:10this
- 31:10is.
- 31:10I
- 31:10don't
- 31:11know
- 31:11how
- 31:11you
- 31:11can
- 31:12talk
- 31:12about
- 31:12any
- 31:12kind
- 31:13of
- 31:13a
- 31:13national
- 31:14strategy
- 31:15for
- 31:15competitiveness
- 31:16and
- 31:16national
- 31:17strategy
- 31:17around
- 31:17human
- 31:18capital,
- 31:18any
- 31:18of
- 31:19it,
- 31:19without,
- 31:19you
- 31:20know,
- 31:20national
- 31:21leadership
- 31:21at
- 31:22a
- 31:22cabinet
- 31:22level.
- 31:22And
- 31:23I
- 31:23know
- 31:23people
- 31:23like,
- 31:23well,
- 31:23you
- 31:24could
- 31:24do
- 31:24it
- 31:24other
- 31:24ways.
- 31:24We
- 31:25could
- 31:25have
- 31:25a
- 31:25czar.
- 31:26We
- 31:26could
- 31:26do
- 31:26this.
- 31:27Like,
- 31:27I
- 31:27just
- 31:27think
- 31:27like,
- 31:27you
- 31:28need
- 31:28this,
- 31:29this
- 31:29is
- 31:30important
- 31:30enough
- 31:31in
- 31:31the,
- 31:31in
- 31:32the
- 31:32modern
- 31:33world
- 31:34that
- 31:34you
- 31:34need
- 31:34cabinet
- 31:35level
- 31:35leadership
- 31:36on
- 31:36it.
- 31:37People
- 31:37can
- 31:37disagree.
- 31:38I
- 31:38mean,
- 31:38that's
- 31:38obviously
- 31:38a
- 31:38falsifiable
- 31:40premise.
- 31:40But
- 31:40I
- 31:40just,
- 31:41and
- 31:41I
- 31:41think
- 31:41you're
- 31:41right.
- 31:42As
- 31:42soon
- 31:42as
- 31:43you
- 31:43know,
- 31:43we'll.
- 31:44History
- 31:44will
- 31:44repeat.
- 31:45We'll
- 31:45have
- 31:45some
- 31:45sort
- 31:45of
- 31:45a
- 31:45Sputnik
- 31:46moment
- 31:46and
- 31:47everybody
- 31:47will
- 31:48freak
- 31:48out.
- 31:48And
- 31:48so
- 31:49it's
- 31:49kind
- 31:49of
- 31:49like,
- 31:49maybe
- 31:50let's
- 31:50skip
- 31:50those
- 31:50chapters
- 31:51and
- 31:51just
- 31:51get
- 31:51to
- 31:51the
- 31:51part
- 31:52where
- 31:52we
- 31:52get
- 31:52serious
- 31:53about
- 31:53a
- 31:53national
- 31:54human
- 31:54capital
- 31:54and
- 31:55talent
- 31:55strategy
- 31:55because
- 31:56it's
- 31:56so
- 31:56important.
- 31:57Yep.
- 31:58So
- 31:58look,
- 31:58I
- 31:58want
- 31:59to
- 31:59keep
- 31:59going
- 31:59off
- 32:00on
- 32:00other
- 32:00things
- 32:01that
- 32:01concern
- 32:02me
- 32:02or
- 32:03other
- 32:03disequilibria.
- 32:05Disequilibria.
- 32:07But
- 32:08you
- 32:08seem
- 32:08to
- 32:08want
- 32:08to,
- 32:09you
- 32:09had
- 32:09an,
- 32:10a
- 32:10more
- 32:10chipper
- 32:11notion
- 32:12to
- 32:12throw
- 32:12into
- 32:12the
- 32:13discussion
- 32:13here.
- 32:13So
- 32:14I
- 32:14don't
- 32:14want
- 32:14to
- 32:14get
- 32:14in
- 32:14the
- 32:14way
- 32:14of
- 32:15your,
- 32:16your,
- 32:16you
- 32:16know.
- 32:17Like,
- 32:17it
- 32:17goes
- 32:18back
- 32:18to
- 32:18what
- 32:18you
- 32:18said.
- 32:19I'm
- 32:19not
- 32:19a
- 32:19fan
- 32:20of
- 32:20a
- 32:20lot
- 32:20of
- 32:21what's
- 32:21happening,
- 32:21but
- 32:22I
- 32:22do
- 32:22think
- 32:22it's
- 32:22been
- 32:23decontextualized.
- 32:24I
- 32:24mean,
- 32:25you,
- 32:25you,
- 32:25you
- 32:26can't
- 32:26look
- 32:26at
- 32:27the
- 32:27last
- 32:27decade
- 32:28and
- 32:29be
- 32:29like,
- 32:29oh,
- 32:29my
- 32:29God,
- 32:30don't
- 32:30put
- 32:30all
- 32:30that
- 32:30at
- 32:30risk.
- 32:31Because
- 32:31what
- 32:31you'd
- 32:31be
- 32:32putting
- 32:32at
- 32:32risk
- 32:32is
- 32:32like
- 32:33a
- 32:33steady
- 32:33decline
- 32:34in
- 32:34scores.
- 32:35Then
- 32:35they
- 32:35went
- 32:36off
- 32:36the
- 32:36cliff.
- 32:37This
- 32:37sector
- 32:38proved
- 32:38to
- 32:38be
- 32:39pretty
- 32:40unreliable
- 32:42during
- 32:42COVID
- 32:43after
- 32:43Covid
- 32:43and
- 32:43became
- 32:44hyper
- 32:44politicized.
- 32:45And
- 32:46I
- 32:46don't
- 32:46think
- 32:46you,
- 32:46you
- 32:47don't
- 32:47have
- 32:47to
- 32:47like,
- 32:47look
- 32:47at
- 32:47that
- 32:47and
- 32:47be
- 32:48like,
- 32:48okay,
- 32:48the
- 32:48answer
- 32:48is
- 32:48choice
- 32:49or
- 32:49the
- 32:49answer
- 32:49is
- 32:49getting
- 32:49rid
- 32:50of
- 32:50the
- 32:50department,
- 32:50Department
- 32:50of
- 32:50Education.
- 32:51People
- 32:51can
- 32:51disagree
- 32:52about
- 32:52all
- 32:53that,
- 32:53but
- 32:53I
- 32:53feel
- 32:53like
- 32:53we
- 32:53do
- 32:53need
- 32:54to
- 32:54have
- 32:54like
- 32:54an
- 32:54honest
- 32:55accounting
- 32:56of
- 32:56where
- 32:56we
- 32:57are
- 32:57and
- 32:57we
- 32:57need
- 32:57to
- 32:57try
- 32:58some
- 32:58different
- 32:59things
- 32:59because
- 33:00what
- 33:00we're
- 33:00doing
- 33:01now,
- 33:01if
- 33:02you
- 33:02are
- 33:02committed
- 33:03to
- 33:03whatever
- 33:04you
- 33:04want
- 33:04to
- 33:04call
- 33:04it,
- 33:05social
- 33:05mobility,
- 33:06equity,
- 33:06any
- 33:07of
- 33:07it,
- 33:07like,
- 33:07we're
- 33:08clearly
- 33:08not
- 33:08reaching
- 33:09those
- 33:09goals.
- 33:10And
- 33:10so
- 33:10we
- 33:10do
- 33:11need
- 33:11to
- 33:12have
- 33:12some
- 33:13conversations.
- 33:14And
- 33:15even
- 33:15if
- 33:15you
- 33:15don't
- 33:15believe
- 33:16Donald
- 33:16Trump
- 33:17is
- 33:17a
- 33:17position
- 33:18to
- 33:18lead
- 33:18those
- 33:18conversations,
- 33:19I
- 33:19don't
- 33:19believe
- 33:20Donald
- 33:20Trump
- 33:20is
- 33:20in
- 33:20a
- 33:21position
- 33:21to
- 33:21lead
- 33:22those
- 33:22conversations.
- 33:23They're
- 33:23still
- 33:23important
- 33:24conversations
- 33:25to
- 33:25have.
- 33:25And
- 33:26some
- 33:26of
- 33:26this
- 33:26is
- 33:26going
- 33:27to,
- 33:27is
- 33:27going
- 33:27to
- 33:27create
- 33:27space
- 33:28for,
- 33:28for
- 33:29some,
- 33:29for
- 33:29some
- 33:29important
- 33:30conversations
- 33:31about
- 33:31where,
- 33:32where
- 33:32are
- 33:32we
- 33:32trying
- 33:33to
- 33:33go?
- 33:33And
- 33:33I
- 33:33don't
- 33:34think
- 33:34the
- 33:34answer
- 33:35can
- 33:35just
- 33:35be,
- 33:36let's
- 33:36just
- 33:36rebuild
- 33:37all
- 33:37the
- 33:37stuff.
- 33:37Like,
- 33:38it
- 33:38was
- 33:38like,
- 33:39I,
- 33:39I
- 33:39don't,
- 33:39I
- 33:39don't
- 33:40like
- 33:40what
- 33:40happened
- 33:40to
- 33:40ies,
- 33:41that
- 33:41IES
- 33:42did
- 33:42need
- 33:43reform,
- 33:43education
- 33:47needed
- 33:47reform
- 33:48as
- 33:49well.
- 33:49And
- 33:49so
- 33:50I
- 33:50think
- 33:50it's
- 33:51hard
- 33:51to
- 33:51balance
- 33:51all
- 33:51those
- 33:52things,
- 33:52but
- 33:52you
- 33:52can
- 33:52be
- 33:52kind
- 33:52of
- 33:53appalled
- 33:53at
- 33:53the
- 33:53sloppiness
- 33:54in
- 33:54the
- 33:54way
- 33:55it's
- 33:55happening,
- 33:56but
- 33:56also
- 33:56be
- 33:56like,
- 33:57we
- 33:57do
- 33:57need
- 33:58some
- 33:58changes
- 33:58in
- 33:58how
- 33:58we
- 33:59do
- 33:59business.
- 34:00Yeah.
- 34:00And
- 34:00if
- 34:01I
- 34:01were
- 34:01to
- 34:01predict,
- 34:01I
- 34:01think
- 34:02there's
- 34:03more
- 34:03coming,
- 34:04we
- 34:05got
- 34:05the
- 34:05problems
- 34:05in
- 34:06higher
- 34:06ed,
- 34:06we
- 34:06have
- 34:06these
- 34:07problems
- 34:07now
- 34:08within
- 34:08the
- 34:08department
- 34:09and
- 34:09federal
- 34:10investment,
- 34:10all
- 34:10those
- 34:10things.
- 34:11I
- 34:12write
- 34:12a
- 34:12lot,
- 34:13you
- 34:13know,
- 34:13about
- 34:13the
- 34:14brokenness
- 34:14within
- 34:14our
- 34:14urban
- 34:15public
- 34:15school
- 34:15districts.
- 34:16And
- 34:16I'm
- 34:17starting
- 34:17to
- 34:17hear
- 34:17more
- 34:18about
- 34:18Republican
- 34:19governors
- 34:20who
- 34:20are
- 34:20realizing
- 34:21that
- 34:21audits
- 34:22of
- 34:22large
- 34:22urban
- 34:23school
- 34:23districts
- 34:24reveal
- 34:24things
- 34:25that
- 34:25are
- 34:25just
- 34:25so
- 34:26appalling.
- 34:26I
- 34:27mean,
- 34:28I
- 34:28mean,
- 34:28whatever
- 34:29Elon
- 34:30Musk
- 34:30goes
- 34:30looking
- 34:31for
- 34:32problems
- 34:32in
- 34:33usaid,
- 34:34imagine,
- 34:36imagine
- 34:36the
- 34:36same,
- 34:38same
- 34:39posture
- 34:39brought
- 34:40to
- 34:41our
- 34:41large
- 34:41urban
- 34:41school
- 34:42districts.
- 34:42You
- 34:43Know,
- 34:43and,
- 34:44and
- 34:44the,
- 34:44the
- 34:45underperformance
- 34:45of
- 34:46these
- 34:46school
- 34:46districts,
- 34:46the
- 34:47broken
- 34:47economics,
- 34:48the
- 34:48dysfunctional
- 34:49governance.
- 34:50I
- 34:50mean,
- 34:51I
- 34:51feel
- 34:51like
- 34:52this
- 34:52is
- 34:52the
- 34:52next
- 34:53place
- 34:53that
- 34:54Republicans
- 34:54are
- 34:54very
- 34:55likely
- 34:55to
- 34:55turn,
- 34:56and
- 34:56I
- 34:56think
- 34:56they're
- 34:56going
- 34:56to
- 34:56have
- 34:57an
- 34:57easier
- 34:57time
- 34:58with,
- 34:59with
- 34:59those
- 34:59entities.
- 35:00Now
- 35:00that
- 35:00may
- 35:01be
- 35:01a
- 35:01little
- 35:01bit
- 35:01more
- 35:01difficult
- 35:02because
- 35:02there's,
- 35:02it's
- 35:03closer
- 35:03to
- 35:03kids.
- 35:04And
- 35:04so
- 35:04the
- 35:04disruption
- 35:05could
- 35:05really
- 35:06be
- 35:07heartbreaking
- 35:08in
- 35:08its
- 35:08very
- 35:09tangible
- 35:09manifestation.
- 35:11On
- 35:11the
- 35:11other
- 35:11hand,
- 35:12these
- 35:12school
- 35:12districts
- 35:13are
- 35:13doing
- 35:13such
- 35:13a
- 35:13crummy
- 35:14job
- 35:15serving
- 35:15these
- 35:15very
- 35:16communities
- 35:17that
- 35:17there
- 35:17may
- 35:17be
- 35:18real
- 35:18tolerance
- 35:19for
- 35:20disruption
- 35:20there
- 35:21in
- 35:21hopes
- 35:21of
- 35:21something
- 35:22better
- 35:22emerging
- 35:22soon.
- 35:23I
- 35:24think
- 35:24you're
- 35:24right.
- 35:24And
- 35:24if
- 35:25we
- 35:25have
- 35:25an
- 35:25economic
- 35:25downturn,
- 35:26you'll
- 35:26have
- 35:26a
- 35:26number
- 35:27of
- 35:27these
- 35:27districts
- 35:27in
- 35:27fiscal
- 35:28distress,
- 35:28which
- 35:28will
- 35:29create
- 35:29a
- 35:29pretext
- 35:30for
- 35:30some
- 35:30of
- 35:30this.
- 35:31And
- 35:32as
- 35:32we've
- 35:33seen
- 35:33in
- 35:33the
- 35:33social
- 35:34media
- 35:34age,
- 35:35I
- 35:35mean,
- 35:36you
- 35:36people
- 35:36can
- 35:36be
- 35:37sort
- 35:37of
- 35:37aghast
- 35:38at
- 35:38the
- 35:38way
- 35:39the
- 35:39Department
- 35:39of
- 35:39Education,
- 35:41they
- 35:41are,
- 35:41you
- 35:41know,
- 35:42finding
- 35:42these
- 35:42examples
- 35:43of
- 35:43things
- 35:43money
- 35:44is
- 35:44being
- 35:44spent
- 35:44on
- 35:45and
- 35:45then
- 35:45holding
- 35:45it
- 35:45up
- 35:46as
- 35:46exemplars.
- 35:47You
- 35:47can,
- 35:47you
- 35:47can
- 35:48say,
- 35:48okay,
- 35:48that's
- 35:48not
- 35:49accurate.
- 35:49And
- 35:49I
- 35:49think,
- 35:50like,
- 35:50we
- 35:50don't
- 35:50do,
- 35:51like,
- 35:51large
- 35:52numbers.
- 35:52So
- 35:52you
- 35:52spend,
- 35:53you
- 35:53know,
- 35:54you
- 35:54know,
- 35:55you
- 35:55spend,
- 35:56you
- 35:56know,
- 35:56$500
- 35:56million
- 35:57and
- 35:57you
- 35:57find
- 35:57a
- 35:58few
- 35:58examples.
- 35:58It
- 35:58doesn't
- 35:59discredit
- 35:59the
- 35:59entire
- 36:00500
- 36:00million.
- 36:01We
- 36:01don't
- 36:01do
- 36:01that.
- 36:02But
- 36:02the
- 36:02fact
- 36:02is,
- 36:02in
- 36:02the
- 36:03social
- 36:03media
- 36:03age,
- 36:04that
- 36:04stuff
- 36:04goes
- 36:05around
- 36:05and
- 36:05no
- 36:05one,
- 36:06no
- 36:06one's
- 36:06accusing
- 36:06them
- 36:07of,
- 36:07like,
- 36:07making
- 36:07this
- 36:07stuff
- 36:08up.
- 36:08They're
- 36:09just
- 36:09finding
- 36:09these
- 36:09outlier
- 36:10examples.
- 36:10And
- 36:11in
- 36:11the
- 36:11social
- 36:11media
- 36:11age,
- 36:12the
- 36:12outlier
- 36:13example
- 36:13then
- 36:13becomes
- 36:14the
- 36:14defining
- 36:15example.
- 36:15And
- 36:16we've
- 36:16seen
- 36:16that
- 36:16again
- 36:16and
- 36:17again.
- 36:17And
- 36:18you'll,
- 36:18you
- 36:18will
- 36:18find
- 36:19that
- 36:19in
- 36:19urban
- 36:20school
- 36:20districts,
- 36:21there'll
- 36:21be
- 36:21plenty
- 36:21of
- 36:21those
- 36:22examples.
- 36:23And
- 36:23they,
- 36:23they
- 36:23will,
- 36:24they
- 36:24will
- 36:24get
- 36:25held
- 36:25up.
- 36:26And
- 36:26yeah,
- 36:26I
- 36:26mean,
- 36:27I
- 36:27don't
- 36:27think,
- 36:27I
- 36:27mean,
- 36:28one
- 36:28of
- 36:28the
- 36:28things
- 36:28that's
- 36:28been
- 36:28a
- 36:29little
- 36:29shocking
- 36:29to
- 36:29me
- 36:30is
- 36:30just
- 36:31the
- 36:31arguments
- 36:32for
- 36:33the
- 36:33Department
- 36:34of
- 36:34Education,
- 36:34the
- 36:34arguments
- 36:35against
- 36:35what
- 36:36the
- 36:36Trump
- 36:36people
- 36:37are
- 36:37doing
- 36:38are
- 36:38not
- 36:38especially
- 36:39sharp.
- 36:40And
- 36:40I
- 36:40don't
- 36:40think
- 36:41it'll
- 36:41be
- 36:41any
- 36:41different
- 36:41with
- 36:42urban
- 36:42districts.
- 36:42And
- 36:43it
- 36:43behooves
- 36:43this
- 36:44sector
- 36:44to
- 36:45sort
- 36:45of
- 36:45figure
- 36:45out
- 36:45how
- 36:45to
- 36:46get
- 36:46into
- 36:46its
- 36:46fighting
- 36:47trim
- 36:47and
- 36:48actually
- 36:49have
- 36:49some
- 36:49arguments
- 36:50that
- 36:50are
- 36:50not
- 36:50just
- 36:50appeals
- 36:51to
- 36:51sort
- 36:51of
- 36:52lofty
- 36:52ideals
- 36:53about
- 36:54democracy
- 36:54and
- 36:55Horace
- 36:55Mann,
- 36:55but
- 36:56are
- 36:56much
- 36:56more
- 36:57politically
- 36:58salient,
- 36:58able
- 36:58to
- 36:58get
- 36:59political
- 36:59traction.
- 36:59I
- 36:59don't
- 37:00see
- 37:00those
- 37:00right
- 37:00now,
- 37:00and
- 37:01I
- 37:01think
- 37:01that's
- 37:01a
- 37:01problem.
- 37:02The
- 37:02vacuousness
- 37:03of
- 37:04the
- 37:04Dems
- 37:05in
- 37:05particular,
- 37:06that
- 37:06are
- 37:07the
- 37:07key
- 37:08policymakers
- 37:10in
- 37:10urban
- 37:10school
- 37:10districts,
- 37:11but
- 37:11also
- 37:11in
- 37:11terms
- 37:12of
- 37:12protecting
- 37:12the
- 37:13education
- 37:13establishment
- 37:14itself.
- 37:14I,
- 37:14you
- 37:15know,
- 37:15I've
- 37:15been,
- 37:15I'm
- 37:16pretty,
- 37:16I've
- 37:16been
- 37:17very
- 37:17impressed
- 37:18by
- 37:18some
- 37:18things
- 37:18that
- 37:18Ezra
- 37:19Klein
- 37:19writes
- 37:20and
- 37:20by
- 37:20some
- 37:20of
- 37:21his
- 37:21interviews.
- 37:21I
- 37:21thought
- 37:21his
- 37:22interview
- 37:22with
- 37:23the
- 37:23pollster.
- 37:24What,
- 37:25what's
- 37:25the
- 37:25pollster's
- 37:26name
- 37:26that
- 37:26he.
- 37:26David
- 37:27Shore.
- 37:27Yeah.
- 37:28Or,
- 37:28Yeah.
- 37:29I
- 37:29mean,
- 37:29I
- 37:29learned
- 37:30so
- 37:30much
- 37:30from
- 37:30that.
- 37:30That
- 37:31was
- 37:31just
- 37:31a
- 37:31great,
- 37:32great
- 37:32podcast.
- 37:33But
- 37:33we'll
- 37:33put
- 37:34that
- 37:34on
- 37:34the,
- 37:34we'll
- 37:34put
- 37:34that
- 37:34in
- 37:35the
- 37:35show
- 37:35Notes.
- 37:35Yeah,
- 37:36I
- 37:36mean,
- 37:36that
- 37:36David's
- 37:37data,
- 37:37I
- 37:38saw
- 37:38a
- 37:38presentation
- 37:39he
- 37:39did
- 37:39a
- 37:39few
- 37:40months
- 37:40ago,
- 37:40and
- 37:41yeah,
- 37:42it's,
- 37:44People
- 37:44need
- 37:44to
- 37:44reckon
- 37:45with
- 37:45this.
- 37:46And
- 37:46I
- 37:46don't
- 37:47think
- 37:47there
- 37:47has
- 37:47been
- 37:48yet
- 37:48a
- 37:48reckoning
- 37:49around
- 37:49some
- 37:49of
- 37:50this.
- 37:52And
- 37:52some
- 37:52of
- 37:52it's
- 37:52about
- 37:53Democratic
- 37:53politics,
- 37:54but
- 37:54some
- 37:54of
- 37:54it's
- 37:55about
- 37:55public
- 37:56schools
- 37:56and
- 37:58how
- 37:58we
- 37:58position
- 37:59them,
- 38:00and
- 38:01it's
- 38:01a
- 38:01problem.
- 38:02So,
- 38:02and
- 38:02I
- 38:02think
- 38:03that
- 38:03Klein
- 38:03has
- 38:04been,
- 38:04by
- 38:04the
- 38:04way,
- 38:04you
- 38:05know,
- 38:05Klein's
- 38:05brother
- 38:06is
- 38:06a
- 38:06charter
- 38:06school
- 38:07teacher
- 38:07in
- 38:07Los
- 38:07Angeles,
- 38:08so
- 38:09he's
- 38:09got,
- 38:09you
- 38:09know,
- 38:10fairly
- 38:10good
- 38:11view
- 38:12into
- 38:12our
- 38:12world.
- 38:13But,
- 38:14you
- 38:15know,
- 38:15I
- 38:15went
- 38:16out
- 38:16and
- 38:16bought
- 38:16abundance.
- 38:17I've
- 38:17been
- 38:17waiting
- 38:17for
- 38:17it,
- 38:19and
- 38:19I'm
- 38:20just
- 38:20very
- 38:20disappointed
- 38:21by
- 38:21it.
- 38:22Maybe
- 38:22other
- 38:22people
- 38:23will
- 38:23like
- 38:23it
- 38:25because
- 38:25maybe
- 38:25there
- 38:25are
- 38:26things
- 38:26in
- 38:26there
- 38:26that
- 38:26are
- 38:27specific
- 38:27to
- 38:27housing
- 38:28or
- 38:28maybe
- 38:28there
- 38:28are
- 38:29things
- 38:29in
- 38:29there
- 38:29that
- 38:29are
- 38:29specific
- 38:30to
- 38:30infrastructure
- 38:31building
- 38:31or
- 38:32to
- 38:34public
- 38:34health
- 38:35and
- 38:35this
- 38:35kind
- 38:35of
- 38:35stuff.
- 38:35But
- 38:36you
- 38:36cannot
- 38:37find
- 38:37the
- 38:37word
- 38:38education
- 38:39or
- 38:40schools
- 38:41anywhere
- 38:41in
- 38:41the
- 38:42index.
- 38:42And,
- 38:43and
- 38:43in
- 38:43my
- 38:44reading
- 38:44of
- 38:44it
- 38:44pretty
- 38:45quickly
- 38:45over
- 38:45the
- 38:45weekend,
- 38:46I
- 38:46could
- 38:47not
- 38:47find
- 38:47a
- 38:47reference
- 38:47to
- 38:47education
- 38:48anywhere.
- 38:48I
- 38:48could
- 38:49find
- 38:49references
- 38:50to
- 38:50cities
- 38:50being
- 38:51broken.
- 38:51And
- 38:51look
- 38:51at
- 38:51all
- 38:51these
- 38:52things
- 38:52are
- 38:52broken
- 38:52about
- 38:53cities
- 38:53and
- 38:53why
- 38:53they
- 38:53can't
- 38:53live,
- 38:54their
- 38:54cost
- 38:54of
- 38:54living
- 38:54and
- 38:55crime
- 38:55and
- 38:55blah,
- 38:55blah,
- 38:56blah.
- 38:56Not
- 38:56one
- 38:57mentioning.
- 38:58I'll
- 38:59have
- 38:59to
- 38:59check
- 38:59that
- 38:59out
- 38:59because
- 39:00I've
- 39:00always
- 39:00thought,
- 39:00like,
- 39:01we,
- 39:01we
- 39:01can't
- 39:01dis,
- 39:02like,
- 39:02if
- 39:02you
- 39:03want
- 39:03to
- 39:03have,
- 39:05you
- 39:06know,
- 39:06a,
- 39:07if
- 39:07you
- 39:07want
- 39:07a
- 39:07part
- 39:07of
- 39:07address,
- 39:08I
- 39:08mean,
- 39:08there's
- 39:08a
- 39:08bunch
- 39:08of
- 39:09things
- 39:09to
- 39:09address.
- 39:09Housing,
- 39:10some
- 39:10of
- 39:10which
- 39:10don't
- 39:10have
- 39:10a
- 39:10lot
- 39:10to
- 39:11do
- 39:11with
- 39:11education.
- 39:11But
- 39:12having
- 39:12a
- 39:12thriving
- 39:13middle
- 39:13class
- 39:13that
- 39:13wants
- 39:14to
- 39:14live
- 39:14in
- 39:14your
- 39:15cities
- 39:15is
- 39:15really
- 39:15important.
- 39:16And
- 39:16if
- 39:16you
- 39:16want
- 39:16that,
- 39:16you
- 39:17need
- 39:17really
- 39:17good
- 39:17public
- 39:18schools
- 39:18and
- 39:19public
- 39:19options
- 39:19that
- 39:20people
- 39:20don't
- 39:20feel
- 39:20like
- 39:20they
- 39:20have
- 39:21to,
- 39:21like,
- 39:21navigate
- 39:21and
- 39:22thread
- 39:22a
- 39:22needle.
- 39:23So
- 39:23I
- 39:23haven't
- 39:23had
- 39:23a
- 39:23chance
- 39:24to,
- 39:24to
- 39:25read
- 39:25it
- 39:25yet.
- 39:25I
- 39:25just
- 39:25finished
- 39:26Mark
- 39:27Dunkelman
- 39:27has
- 39:27a
- 39:28great
- 39:28book
- 39:28on,
- 39:28on
- 39:29why
- 39:29Nothing
- 39:29Works.
- 39:30That
- 39:30sort
- 39:30of,
- 39:30that's
- 39:30being
- 39:31paired
- 39:31with
- 39:31the
- 39:31abundance,
- 39:32this
- 39:32book,
- 39:32so
- 39:32that
- 39:33I,
- 39:33I,
- 39:33I
- 39:33will
- 39:33have
- 39:34more
- 39:34to
- 39:34Say
- 39:34once
- 39:34I've
- 39:34had
- 39:35a
- 39:35chance
- 39:35to
- 39:35read
- 39:35it,
- 39:36but
- 39:36that's
- 39:36the,
- 39:37the,
- 39:37the
- 39:37early
- 39:38Jed
- 39:38Wallace
- 39:39review
- 39:39is
- 39:39disappointing.
- 39:40Look,
- 39:41I
- 39:42also
- 39:42care
- 39:42a
- 39:42lot
- 39:42about
- 39:43housing.
- 39:43I
- 39:43care
- 39:43about,
- 39:44you
- 39:44know,
- 39:44some
- 39:44of
- 39:44these
- 39:44other
- 39:44things
- 39:45and
- 39:45I
- 39:45really
- 39:45appreciate
- 39:46Klein
- 39:46doing
- 39:46that.
- 39:46But
- 39:46I
- 39:47just
- 39:47feel
- 39:47as
- 39:47though
- 39:48from
- 39:48an
- 39:48education
- 39:49standpoint,
- 39:50given
- 39:50the
- 39:51overweight
- 39:52of
- 39:52influence
- 39:53that
- 39:53the
- 39:53teacher
- 39:53unions
- 39:54have,
- 39:55I
- 39:55think
- 39:56it's
- 39:56a
- 39:56good
- 39:56litmus
- 39:57test.
- 39:57Are
- 39:58you
- 39:58serious
- 39:59about
- 40:00contending
- 40:00with
- 40:01the
- 40:01power
- 40:02dynamics
- 40:03within
- 40:03the
- 40:04Democratic
- 40:04Party,
- 40:05within
- 40:05progressive
- 40:05wing
- 40:06of
- 40:06the
- 40:06party,
- 40:07or
- 40:07are
- 40:08you
- 40:08just
- 40:08providing
- 40:09lip
- 40:09service?
- 40:10And
- 40:10I'm
- 40:11sorry
- 40:11if
- 40:11you
- 40:11cannot
- 40:12address
- 40:13issues
- 40:13of
- 40:14education
- 40:14within
- 40:15your
- 40:15conversation
- 40:16about
- 40:16abundance.
- 40:17You
- 40:17failed
- 40:18a
- 40:18litmus
- 40:19test.
- 40:20Yeah,
- 40:21yeah.
- 40:21And
- 40:22the
- 40:22abundance
- 40:22agenda,
- 40:22again,
- 40:23like
- 40:23I
- 40:23said,
- 40:23I
- 40:23haven't
- 40:23read
- 40:23the
- 40:23book,
- 40:24but
- 40:24the
- 40:24abundance
- 40:24agenda
- 40:25more
- 40:25generally,
- 40:25like
- 40:26school
- 40:26choice
- 40:26has
- 40:27to
- 40:27be
- 40:27a
- 40:27piece
- 40:27of
- 40:27that.
- 40:27And
- 40:28it's.
- 40:28We
- 40:29do
- 40:29not
- 40:29have
- 40:29to
- 40:29have
- 40:29a
- 40:30static
- 40:30supply
- 40:31of
- 40:31public
- 40:31schools.
- 40:32And
- 40:32it
- 40:32goes
- 40:32back
- 40:32to
- 40:33what
- 40:33we
- 40:33were
- 40:33talking
- 40:33about,
- 40:34like
- 40:34with
- 40:34the
- 40:34context
- 40:35of
- 40:35the
- 40:35department.
- 40:35You've
- 40:35got
- 40:35all
- 40:36these
- 40:36micro
- 40:36schools
- 40:37opening
- 40:37and
- 40:38little
- 40:38independent
- 40:39options
- 40:40and
- 40:40different
- 40:40things.
- 40:41And
- 40:41like,
- 40:42again,
- 40:42I
- 40:42think
- 40:43people
- 40:43get
- 40:43all
- 40:43hung
- 40:43up
- 40:43on
- 40:43whether
- 40:44or
- 40:44not
- 40:44they
- 40:44like
- 40:44those
- 40:45or
- 40:45not,
- 40:45or
- 40:45where
- 40:45do
- 40:45they
- 40:46stand
- 40:46or
- 40:46where
- 40:46do
- 40:46they
- 40:47think
- 40:47they
- 40:47should
- 40:48stand?
- 40:48Because
- 40:48rather
- 40:49than
- 40:49like,
- 40:49this
- 40:50is
- 40:50something
- 40:50that's
- 40:50just
- 40:50happening
- 40:51and
- 40:51you
- 40:51have
- 40:51to,
- 40:52you
- 40:53have
- 40:53to
- 40:53engage
- 40:53with
- 40:54it
- 40:54and
- 40:54understand
- 40:54it
- 40:55as
- 40:55kind
- 40:55because
- 40:56it
- 40:56is
- 40:56happening.
- 40:57And
- 40:57I
- 40:58think
- 40:58it
- 40:58offers
- 40:58a
- 40:58way
- 40:58through
- 40:59some
- 40:59of
- 40:59these
- 40:59things.
- 40:59I
- 41:00mean,
- 41:00the
- 41:00charter
- 41:00school
- 41:00referendum
- 41:01in
- 41:01Massachusetts,
- 41:02one
- 41:02of
- 41:02the
- 41:03reasons
- 41:03that
- 41:03it
- 41:04went
- 41:04down
- 41:04was
- 41:05people
- 41:05perceived
- 41:06charters
- 41:06as
- 41:06a
- 41:06scarcity
- 41:07thing
- 41:07that
- 41:08there
- 41:08weren't
- 41:08going
- 41:08to
- 41:08be
- 41:08enough
- 41:09of.
- 41:09And
- 41:09so
- 41:09like
- 41:10this
- 41:10general
- 41:11frame
- 41:11of
- 41:12we
- 41:12can
- 41:13actually
- 41:13have
- 41:13more
- 41:13and
- 41:14this
- 41:14is
- 41:14not
- 41:14just
- 41:15slicing
- 41:15up
- 41:15the
- 41:16same
- 41:16amount
- 41:16in
- 41:16different
- 41:17ways.
- 41:17I
- 41:17think
- 41:17is
- 41:18really
- 41:18important
- 41:18to
- 41:19get
- 41:19to
- 41:19a
- 41:19healthier
- 41:20education
- 41:20politics.
- 41:22I
- 41:22just
- 41:22don't
- 41:23think
- 41:23that
- 41:24the.
- 41:24Give
- 41:25the.
- 41:25The
- 41:25current
- 41:26Dems.
- 41:27Yes,
- 41:28Klein
- 41:28can
- 41:28say
- 41:29we
- 41:29need
- 41:30new
- 41:31thinking
- 41:31within
- 41:32the
- 41:32Democratic
- 41:32Party.
- 41:33Almost
- 41:34all
- 41:34of
- 41:34the
- 41:34Dems
- 41:35that
- 41:35are
- 41:35currently
- 41:35in
- 41:36power
- 41:37are
- 41:38not.
- 41:38They
- 41:38are
- 41:38bought
- 41:38and
- 41:39paid
- 41:39for
- 41:39already
- 41:40by
- 41:41status
- 41:41quo
- 41:42interests.
- 41:43I
- 41:43just
- 41:43don't.
- 41:43And
- 41:44we're
- 41:44seeing
- 41:44that
- 41:44in
- 41:44Massachusetts
- 41:45turn
- 41:46down
- 41:46every
- 41:46charter.
- 41:46You've
- 41:46turned
- 41:47out
- 41:47an
- 41:47incredible
- 41:48KIP
- 41:48charter
- 41:48in
- 41:48Lynn,
- 41:49you
- 41:49know,
- 41:49and
- 41:50yeah,
- 41:50that.
- 41:51Massachusetts
- 41:51board
- 41:52meeting
- 41:52the
- 41:52other
- 41:52day
- 41:53was.
- 41:53That
- 41:53was
- 41:53something
- 41:54and
- 41:54not.
- 41:54And
- 41:55I
- 41:55just
- 41:55looked
- 41:55at
- 41:55that
- 41:55and
- 41:55I
- 41:56was
- 41:56like,
- 41:56okay,
- 41:56they
- 41:56have
- 41:56not
- 41:57gotten
- 41:57the
- 41:57memo
- 41:57yet.
- 41:58And
- 41:58in
- 41:59Massachusetts,
- 42:00the
- 42:00political
- 42:00cost
- 42:01of
- 42:01that
- 42:01is
- 42:01probably
- 42:01more
- 42:02negligible,
- 42:03but
- 42:03that's
- 42:03not
- 42:03the
- 42:04case
- 42:04everywhere.
- 42:06And
- 42:07like
- 42:07the
- 42:07Democrats,
- 42:08problem
- 42:08is
- 42:09they
- 42:09need
- 42:09to
- 42:09be
- 42:09competitive
- 42:10in
- 42:10many
- 42:10More
- 42:10places.
- 42:11So
- 42:11they're
- 42:11going
- 42:11to
- 42:11have
- 42:11to
- 42:12figure
- 42:12out
- 42:12how
- 42:13to
- 42:13be
- 42:13competitive
- 42:13on
- 42:14issues
- 42:14like
- 42:14this.
- 42:15Because
- 42:16the
- 42:16crazy
- 42:16thing
- 42:16about
- 42:16the
- 42:16David
- 42:17Shore
- 42:17data
- 42:17is
- 42:18I,
- 42:19I
- 42:19would
- 42:19argue
- 42:19the
- 42:19Republicans,
- 42:20I
- 42:20mean,
- 42:20Trump
- 42:21said
- 42:21some
- 42:21stuff
- 42:22that
- 42:22he,
- 42:22you
- 42:22know,
- 42:22but
- 42:23like,
- 42:23they
- 42:23didn't
- 42:23really
- 42:24contest
- 42:24the
- 42:25issue
- 42:25that
- 42:25hard.
- 42:26Right.
- 42:28And
- 42:29like,
- 42:29if
- 42:29you
- 42:29look
- 42:30at
- 42:30how,
- 42:30like
- 42:30Republican
- 42:31governors
- 42:32can
- 42:32contest
- 42:32the
- 42:32issue
- 42:33and
- 42:33you
- 42:33look
- 42:33at
- 42:33what
- 42:33Trump
- 42:33did,
- 42:34there's
- 42:34a
- 42:34gap.
- 42:35And
- 42:35so
- 42:35the,
- 42:36so
- 42:36in
- 42:36Shore's
- 42:37data,
- 42:37we
- 42:37basically
- 42:38had
- 42:38a
- 42:38draw
- 42:39on
- 42:39who
- 42:39do
- 42:39you
- 42:39trust
- 42:40on
- 42:40education
- 42:40without
- 42:41the
- 42:41Republicans
- 42:42really
- 42:42contesting
- 42:43the
- 42:43issue.
- 42:43And
- 42:44that,
- 42:44I
- 42:44think,
- 42:44should,
- 42:45that
- 42:45should
- 42:45wake
- 42:46the
- 42:46Democrats
- 42:47up.
- 42:47Yeah,
- 42:48it's
- 42:48a
- 42:48draw
- 42:49now
- 42:49when
- 42:49Democrats
- 42:50have
- 42:50historically
- 42:51been
- 42:5120
- 42:52points
- 42:52or
- 42:52so.
- 42:53And,
- 42:53and
- 42:54so,
- 42:54yeah,
- 42:54I
- 42:54thought
- 42:55all
- 42:55that.
- 42:55And
- 42:55it's
- 42:55a
- 42:55draw
- 42:56again
- 42:56without
- 42:56the
- 42:56Republicans
- 42:57coming
- 42:57forward.
- 42:57Some
- 42:58super
- 42:58compelling
- 42:59agenda
- 43:00which
- 43:00they
- 43:00could
- 43:00find
- 43:01there,
- 43:01which
- 43:01they
- 43:01could
- 43:01find
- 43:02their
- 43:02way
- 43:02to.
- 43:03And
- 43:04so,
- 43:04yeah,
- 43:04no,
- 43:04I
- 43:04think
- 43:04the
- 43:04Democrats,
- 43:05they're
- 43:05out
- 43:05of
- 43:05position.
- 43:06We
- 43:06know,
- 43:07we
- 43:07know
- 43:07why.
- 43:07It's,
- 43:08it's
- 43:08institutional.
- 43:10It'll
- 43:10be
- 43:10interesting
- 43:11to
- 43:11see.
- 43:11You've
- 43:12got
- 43:12some
- 43:12younger
- 43:13ones,
- 43:13you
- 43:14know,
- 43:14so
- 43:14you
- 43:14look
- 43:14at
- 43:14like,
- 43:15Polis,
- 43:15Pritzker,
- 43:16Shapiro.
- 43:17So
- 43:17those
- 43:17are
- 43:17the
- 43:17governors
- 43:18of
- 43:18Colorado,
- 43:19Illinois,
- 43:19Pennsylvania,
- 43:20like,
- 43:21they're
- 43:21all
- 43:21pushing
- 43:21the
- 43:22envelope.
- 43:22Will
- 43:22they
- 43:22continue
- 43:23to.
- 43:23I
- 43:24don't
- 43:24know.
- 43:25I
- 43:25was
- 43:25listening
- 43:26the
- 43:26other
- 43:26day
- 43:26to
- 43:28Shapiro
- 43:28was
- 43:29on
- 43:29the
- 43:29Bill
- 43:29Maher
- 43:29show
- 43:30and
- 43:30like,
- 43:30yeah,
- 43:31yeah.
- 43:32And
- 43:32Bill,
- 43:32Bill
- 43:32Maher
- 43:33went
- 43:33after
- 43:33him
- 43:33on
- 43:33the
- 43:33education
- 43:34questions
- 43:35about
- 43:35some
- 43:35of
- 43:35the
- 43:35stuff
- 43:35we're
- 43:36talking
- 43:36about
- 43:36here,
- 43:36and
- 43:36he
- 43:37kind
- 43:37of
- 43:37deflected
- 43:38and
- 43:38so
- 43:38forth.
- 43:38But,
- 43:39like,
- 43:39you
- 43:39know,
- 43:39we're
- 43:39a
- 43:39long
- 43:39way
- 43:40out
- 43:40for
- 43:40a
- 43:40primary.
- 43:41But
- 43:41how
- 43:42will
- 43:42that,
- 43:42you
- 43:43know,
- 43:43who's
- 43:43going
- 43:44to
- 43:44be
- 43:44the
- 43:44one?
- 43:45Gina
- 43:45Raimondo
- 43:46has
- 43:46shown
- 43:46a
- 43:46willingness
- 43:47to,
- 43:47to
- 43:47take
- 43:47them
- 43:48on.
- 43:48Who's
- 43:48going
- 43:48to
- 43:49be
- 43:49the
- 43:49person
- 43:49who
- 43:49realizes
- 43:50that
- 43:50actually
- 43:51doing
- 43:52that
- 43:52is
- 43:52how
- 43:53you
- 43:53show
- 43:53people
- 43:54that
- 43:54you're
- 43:54a
- 43:55fighter
- 43:55and
- 43:55you're
- 43:55tough,
- 43:56is
- 43:56that
- 43:56you're
- 43:56willing
- 43:56to
- 43:57actually
- 43:57take
- 43:58these
- 43:58things
- 43:58on.
- 43:58I've
- 43:59always
- 43:59felt
- 43:59like
- 44:00people
- 44:00like,
- 44:00if
- 44:00you're
- 44:00not
- 44:00going
- 44:00to
- 44:01stand
- 44:01up
- 44:01to
- 44:01the
- 44:01teachers
- 44:01unions,
- 44:02why
- 44:02would
- 44:02people
- 44:02expect
- 44:03you
- 44:03to
- 44:03stand
- 44:04up
- 44:04to
- 44:04one
- 44:04of
- 44:04our,
- 44:05a
- 44:05foreign
- 44:05adversary
- 44:07or
- 44:08on
- 44:08other
- 44:08things?
- 44:08So
- 44:08it's
- 44:08a
- 44:09way
- 44:09to
- 44:09show,
- 44:09I'm
- 44:10a
- 44:10reformer,
- 44:11I
- 44:11will
- 44:11look
- 44:12out
- 44:12for
- 44:12your
- 44:12interests.
- 44:14That
- 44:14this
- 44:15whole
- 44:15idea
- 44:15of,
- 44:15like,
- 44:16the
- 44:16people
- 44:16against
- 44:16the
- 44:16powerful,
- 44:17there's
- 44:17not
- 44:17like
- 44:17an
- 44:18asterisk
- 44:18on
- 44:18powerful,
- 44:19just
- 44:19the
- 44:19powerful
- 44:20who
- 44:20we
- 44:20don't
- 44:20like.
- 44:20It's
- 44:21like,
- 44:21I
- 44:21will,
- 44:21I
- 44:22will
- 44:22fight
- 44:22for
- 44:22you.
- 44:23And
- 44:23in
- 44:23a
- 44:23populist
- 44:24moment
- 44:24like
- 44:25this,
- 44:25which
- 44:25is
- 44:25really
- 44:26what
- 44:26we're
- 44:26living
- 44:26through
- 44:27that,
- 44:27that
- 44:28seems
- 44:28important.
- 44:30Obama
- 44:30had
- 44:31kind
- 44:31of,
- 44:31as
- 44:31you
- 44:31said,
- 44:32as
- 44:32Trump
- 44:32has
- 44:32shown,
- 44:33that
- 44:33the
- 44:34emperor
- 44:34doesn't
- 44:34have
- 44:35clothes.
- 44:35I
- 44:36think
- 44:36you
- 44:36could.
- 44:36Education
- 44:37politics
- 44:37is
- 44:38ripe
- 44:38for
- 44:38somebody
- 44:39ready
- 44:39to
- 44:39show
- 44:40that
- 44:40like
- 44:40a
- 44:40lot
- 44:40of
- 44:40these
- 44:41shy
- 44:41ballists
- 44:42about
- 44:43sort
- 44:43of
- 44:43Democratic
- 44:44politics
- 44:44and
- 44:44the
- 44:44teachers
- 44:45unions,
- 44:45like
- 44:46they
- 44:47can
- 44:47be
- 44:47disrupted.
- 44:48Yeah,
- 44:48I
- 44:48think
- 44:49Obama,
- 44:49there's
- 44:49a
- 44:49path
- 44:50there
- 44:50for
- 44:50a
- 44:50reformer.
- 44:51Yeah,
- 44:52well,
- 44:52I
- 44:52mean,
- 44:52Obama
- 44:52did
- 44:53it
- 44:53masterfully.
- 44:53You
- 44:54know,
- 44:54he,
- 44:54he
- 44:55clearly
- 44:55came
- 44:55out
- 44:55and
- 44:56took
- 44:56some
- 44:57pro
- 44:57charter
- 44:58school
- 44:58positions
- 44:58that,
- 44:59that
- 44:59rankled
- 45:00the
- 45:00teacher
- 45:00union.
- 45:01And
- 45:01Obama's
- 45:02like,
- 45:02that's
- 45:02exactly
- 45:03what
- 45:03I
- 45:03need
- 45:03in
- 45:03the
- 45:04public
- 45:04sphere.
- 45:04And
- 45:05I
- 45:05just
- 45:05think
- 45:05the
- 45:06people
- 45:06have
- 45:07essentially
- 45:07forgotten
- 45:07that
- 45:08Polis
- 45:08is.
- 45:09But
- 45:09then
- 45:09he
- 45:09got
- 45:09tired.
- 45:10But
- 45:10then
- 45:10he
- 45:11got
- 45:11tired.
- 45:11Right.
- 45:12I
- 45:12feel
- 45:12like,
- 45:12you
- 45:12know,
- 45:13Obama's
- 45:13line,
- 45:14he
- 45:14said
- 45:14about
- 45:15with
- 45:15Russia
- 45:15and
- 45:15he
- 45:16said,
- 45:16you
- 45:16know,
- 45:16they're
- 45:16never
- 45:16going
- 45:16to
- 45:16care
- 45:17as
- 45:17much
- 45:17about
- 45:17Crimea,
- 45:18we
- 45:19will
- 45:19never
- 45:19care
- 45:19as
- 45:19much
- 45:20about
- 45:20Crimea
- 45:20and
- 45:20the
- 45:20Ukraine
- 45:21border
- 45:21as
- 45:22the
- 45:22Russians
- 45:22do.
- 45:23Which
- 45:23was
- 45:23his
- 45:23reason
- 45:24for,
- 45:24for
- 45:24not
- 45:25defending
- 45:25that
- 45:25red
- 45:26line.
- 45:26Like,
- 45:27I
- 45:27feel
- 45:27like
- 45:27the
- 45:27same
- 45:27thing
- 45:28might
- 45:28end
- 45:28up
- 45:28being
- 45:28true
- 45:29often
- 45:29on
- 45:29education.
- 45:30So
- 45:31Obama
- 45:31came
- 45:32in
- 45:32guns
- 45:32a
- 45:32blazing
- 45:33on
- 45:33Reform,
- 45:34but
- 45:35by
- 45:352013
- 45:36they
- 45:36were
- 45:36backing
- 45:37off
- 45:37on
- 45:37all
- 45:37this
- 45:38stuff.
- 45:38And
- 45:38by
- 45:392015
- 45:40with
- 45:40Essa,
- 45:41you
- 45:41know,
- 45:41the
- 45:41reauthorization
- 45:42of
- 45:43the
- 45:43elementary
- 45:44and
- 45:44Secondary
- 45:44Education
- 45:44act,
- 45:45they
- 45:45were
- 45:45basically
- 45:45throwing
- 45:46in
- 45:46the
- 45:46towel.
- 45:47And
- 45:47I
- 45:47think
- 45:47it
- 45:47was
- 45:47like
- 45:48they're
- 45:48never
- 45:49going
- 45:49to
- 45:49care
- 45:49about
- 45:50some
- 45:50of
- 45:50these
- 45:50core
- 45:51issues
- 45:51around
- 45:52charter
- 45:52schools,
- 45:53teacher
- 45:53policy
- 45:54as
- 45:54much
- 45:54as
- 45:54the
- 45:54unions
- 45:55do.
- 45:56And,
- 45:57and
- 45:57I
- 45:57think
- 45:57that's
- 45:57a
- 45:58fixture
- 45:59of
- 45:59education
- 46:00politics
- 46:00we
- 46:00have
- 46:00to
- 46:00engage
- 46:01with
- 46:01too.
- 46:02Well,
- 46:02I
- 46:02haven't
- 46:03been
- 46:03in
- 46:03the
- 46:03room
- 46:03for
- 46:04the
- 46:04governor's
- 46:04meetings,
- 46:05but
- 46:05I
- 46:05understand
- 46:05that
- 46:06Polis
- 46:06is
- 46:06standing
- 46:07up
- 46:07in
- 46:07front
- 46:07of
- 46:07all
- 46:07the
- 46:08governors
- 46:08and
- 46:08saying,
- 46:08how
- 46:08many
- 46:08of
- 46:09you
- 46:09guys
- 46:09have
- 46:09opened
- 46:09a
- 46:09charter
- 46:10school,
- 46:10you
- 46:10know,
- 46:10these
- 46:11kinds
- 46:11of
- 46:11things,
- 46:11leading
- 46:11his
- 46:12comments
- 46:12on
- 46:12charter.
- 46:13So
- 46:13that's
- 46:13really
- 46:13interesting.
- 46:14Michael
- 46:14Bennett,
- 46:15you
- 46:15know,
- 46:15is
- 46:15apparently
- 46:16going
- 46:16to
- 46:16come
- 46:16home
- 46:16and
- 46:17run
- 46:17for
- 46:17governor
- 46:17in
- 46:18Colorado,
- 46:18which
- 46:18would
- 46:19be
- 46:20amazing
- 46:21in
- 46:21terms
- 46:22of
- 46:22like
- 46:22having
- 46:22another
- 46:23Dem
- 46:23governor
- 46:24supportive
- 46:24of
- 46:25ed
- 46:25reform
- 46:26driving
- 46:26an
- 46:26agenda.
- 46:27So
- 46:27I
- 46:27mean,
- 46:28I,
- 46:28I,
- 46:28yeah,
- 46:29I've.
- 46:29Never
- 46:29understood
- 46:30why
- 46:30more
- 46:30senators
- 46:31don't
- 46:31leave.
- 46:32Like,
- 46:32the
- 46:32traditional
- 46:32thing
- 46:33is
- 46:33you're
- 46:33a
- 46:33governor
- 46:33and
- 46:33then
- 46:34you
- 46:34go
- 46:34to
- 46:34the
- 46:34Senate
- 46:35and
- 46:35then
- 46:35they
- 46:35all
- 46:35sit
- 46:35there
- 46:36and
- 46:36when
- 46:36you,
- 46:36and
- 46:36they're
- 46:36frustrated
- 46:37when
- 46:37they
- 46:37get
- 46:37there,
- 46:37they're
- 46:38like,
- 46:38I
- 46:38can't
- 46:38do
- 46:38anything.
- 46:39I
- 46:39miss
- 46:39being
- 46:39a
- 46:39governor.
- 46:41I
- 46:41mean
- 46:41that's
- 46:41like,
- 46:41I
- 46:42mean,
- 46:42that's
- 46:42bipartisan
- 46:43for
- 46:43a
- 46:43long
- 46:43time.
- 46:43So
- 46:44I've
- 46:44never
- 46:44understood
- 46:44why
- 46:45more
- 46:45of
- 46:45them.
- 46:45So
- 46:45I'm
- 46:45very
- 46:46excited.
- 46:46I
- 46:46think
- 46:46Michael
- 46:47is
- 46:47a
- 46:47fantastic
- 46:48politician,
- 46:50just,
- 46:51I
- 46:51mean,
- 46:51just
- 46:51a
- 46:52phenomenally
- 46:53smart
- 46:53individual
- 46:55and
- 46:57would
- 46:57be
- 46:57great.
- 46:57And
- 46:58Jared
- 46:58has
- 46:58been,
- 46:59I
- 46:59think,
- 46:59a
- 46:59great
- 47:00governor
- 47:00and
- 47:01is
- 47:01a
- 47:01breath
- 47:02of
- 47:02fresh
- 47:02air,
- 47:02and
- 47:03I
- 47:03think
- 47:03it
- 47:03would
- 47:03be
- 47:03a
- 47:03fantastic
- 47:04entrant
- 47:05in
- 47:05the,
- 47:06in
- 47:07the
- 47:07presidential
- 47:07race.
- 47:08I
- 47:08think
- 47:08he's.
- 47:08He,
- 47:08in
- 47:09so
- 47:09many
- 47:09ways,
- 47:10he
- 47:10represents
- 47:11the
- 47:11future.
- 47:12So
- 47:14here's
- 47:15a
- 47:15little
- 47:15trivia
- 47:15question.
- 47:16Do
- 47:16you
- 47:16know
- 47:16before
- 47:17Michael,
- 47:17do
- 47:17you
- 47:17know
- 47:17who
- 47:17the
- 47:18last
- 47:18school
- 47:18superintendent
- 47:19to
- 47:19serve
- 47:19in
- 47:19the
- 47:19United
- 47:20States
- 47:20Senate
- 47:20was
- 47:21before
- 47:21Michael?
- 47:24Nope.
- 47:25Strom
- 47:26Thurmond.
- 47:27No
- 47:27way.
- 47:32I
- 47:32introduced
- 47:32Michael
- 47:33once
- 47:33or
- 47:33twice
- 47:33with
- 47:34that.
- 47:34I
- 47:34don't
- 47:34think
- 47:34he
- 47:34thought
- 47:34it
- 47:35was
- 47:35funny,
- 47:37but,
- 47:37yeah,
- 47:38you
- 47:38have
- 47:38to
- 47:38go
- 47:38back.
- 47:39You
- 47:39have
- 47:39to
- 47:39go
- 47:39back
- 47:40a
- 47:40long
- 47:40way
- 47:40to
- 47:40have
- 47:40a
- 47:40superintendent
- 47:41in
- 47:41the
- 47:41Senate.
- 47:42I
- 47:42think
- 47:42that
- 47:42also
- 47:42that
- 47:43he,
- 47:43the
- 47:43sensibility
- 47:44he
- 47:44brings
- 47:44to
- 47:44this
- 47:45stuff
- 47:45is
- 47:45great.
- 47:46So
- 47:46let
- 47:47me
- 47:47just,
- 47:47let's,
- 47:48let's
- 47:48wrap
- 47:48it
- 47:48up
- 47:48here.
- 47:48I
- 47:48got,
- 47:49you
- 47:49know,
- 47:50one.
- 47:51Well,
- 47:51hang
- 47:51on.
- 47:51Tell
- 47:52me,
- 47:52what
- 47:52other
- 47:52Democrats
- 47:52are
- 47:53you
- 47:53watching?
- 47:53You're
- 47:53a
- 47:53California
- 47:54guy,
- 47:54so
- 47:54I
- 47:54expect
- 47:55we
- 47:55didn't
- 47:55talk
- 47:55about
- 47:55Rom,
- 47:56and
- 47:56Rom
- 47:56has
- 47:56come
- 47:57in
- 47:58pretty
- 47:58aggressive
- 47:59on
- 47:59the
- 47:59Democrats
- 48:00need
- 48:00to
- 48:00get
- 48:00better
- 48:00on
- 48:00education.
- 48:01And
- 48:01then
- 48:02I.
- 48:02You
- 48:02didn't.
- 48:02I
- 48:02figured
- 48:03you
- 48:03were
- 48:03going
- 48:03to
- 48:03speak
- 48:03up
- 48:03for,
- 48:04for
- 48:04Gavin
- 48:04Newsom
- 48:07like
- 48:07a
- 48:07pot.
- 48:07Another.
- 48:08A
- 48:08fellow
- 48:08podcaster.
- 48:09Oh,
- 48:10my
- 48:10God.
- 48:11Yeah.
- 48:11I'll
- 48:11leave
- 48:12Gavin
- 48:12Newsom
- 48:13stuff
- 48:13until
- 48:13that
- 48:13guy's
- 48:14out
- 48:14of
- 48:14office.
- 48:14I
- 48:14don't,
- 48:15I
- 48:15don't.
- 48:15You
- 48:15know,
- 48:15I
- 48:15try
- 48:16to
- 48:16stay
- 48:16out
- 48:16of
- 48:16that
- 48:16one.
- 48:17It'll
- 48:17be
- 48:18interesting
- 48:18on
- 48:18the
- 48:18Delaware
- 48:19governor.
- 48:20I
- 48:20mean,
- 48:21there's
- 48:21a
- 48:21lot
- 48:21of.
- 48:22Of
- 48:25additional
- 48:26diligence
- 48:26being
- 48:26done
- 48:27because
- 48:27he,
- 48:27he
- 48:28comes
- 48:28from
- 48:28a
- 48:28chart
- 48:28school
- 48:28background,
- 48:29you
- 48:29know,
- 48:30was
- 48:30TFA
- 48:30himself
- 48:31then
- 48:32appoint
- 48:33Cindy
- 48:33Martin
- 48:34as
- 48:35his
- 48:35soup.
- 48:36But
- 48:37then,
- 48:37you
- 48:37know,
- 48:38just
- 48:38last
- 48:38week
- 48:38he
- 48:39went
- 48:39to
- 48:39the
- 48:39charter
- 48:39school
- 48:40conference.
- 48:41Unapologetic.
- 48:42Hey,
- 48:43you
- 48:43people
- 48:43are
- 48:43the
- 48:43future
- 48:44of
- 48:44education.
- 48:44You
- 48:44should
- 48:45be
- 48:45suffered.
- 48:45You
- 48:45should
- 48:45be
- 48:46celebrated
- 48:46more.
- 48:47You
- 48:47know,
- 48:47sends
- 48:48out
- 48:48tweets,
- 48:48all
- 48:48that
- 48:49kind.
- 48:49So
- 48:50what's
- 48:50going
- 48:50to
- 48:50happen
- 48:50with
- 48:50this
- 48:50guy?
- 48:51And
- 48:51I
- 48:51don't
- 48:51know,
- 48:52in
- 48:52the
- 48:52chattering
- 48:53among
- 48:53reformers,
- 48:53he's
- 48:54like
- 48:54a
- 48:54MEM
- 48:54stock.
- 48:55He
- 48:55goes
- 48:55up
- 48:55and
- 48:55down.
- 48:56Exactly.
- 48:57You
- 48:57know,
- 48:57like,
- 48:58everybody's
- 48:58like,
- 48:59oh,
- 48:59my
- 48:59God,
- 48:59this
- 48:59guy,
- 49:00he
- 49:00loves
- 49:00me.
- 49:01He
- 49:01loves.
- 49:01And
- 49:02then
- 49:02they're
- 49:02like,
- 49:02oh,
- 49:02he's
- 49:03not.
- 49:03And
- 49:03then
- 49:03like,
- 49:03yeah,
- 49:04so,
- 49:04so
- 49:04I
- 49:05think,
- 49:05look,
- 49:06I
- 49:06mean,
- 49:06he,
- 49:07I,
- 49:07I
- 49:07think
- 49:08people
- 49:08always
- 49:08forget,
- 49:09like,
- 49:10once
- 49:10you
- 49:10go
- 49:11into
- 49:11that,
- 49:11you're
- 49:11a
- 49:11pol.
- 49:11He's
- 49:12a
- 49:12politician.
- 49:12And
- 49:12so
- 49:13we,
- 49:13we
- 49:13should
- 49:14expect
- 49:14him
- 49:14to
- 49:14conduct
- 49:15himself
- 49:15accordingly.
- 49:16And
- 49:16I
- 49:16don't
- 49:16think
- 49:17that
- 49:17chapter
- 49:17is
- 49:18at
- 49:18all
- 49:19written
- 49:19yet.
- 49:20Yeah,
- 49:21well,
- 49:22here's,
- 49:22here's
- 49:23My
- 49:23last
- 49:23big
- 49:23category
- 49:24for
- 49:24you.
- 49:24I
- 49:24just,
- 49:24I
- 49:25feel
- 49:25like
- 49:25a
- 49:25lot
- 49:26of
- 49:26this
- 49:26stuff
- 49:26coming
- 49:26from
- 49:27the
- 49:27executive
- 49:27orders,
- 49:28it
- 49:29feels
- 49:29just
- 49:29chaotic.
- 49:30It
- 49:30feels
- 49:31just,
- 49:31hey,
- 49:31drag
- 49:32it
- 49:32to
- 49:32the
- 49:32ground
- 49:33and
- 49:33we'll
- 49:33see
- 49:33what
- 49:33gets
- 49:34built
- 49:34up
- 49:34on
- 49:34the
- 49:34other
- 49:34side.
- 49:35The
- 49:35counter
- 49:35to
- 49:36that
- 49:36argument
- 49:36is
- 49:37that,
- 49:37you
- 49:37know,
- 49:37Project
- 49:382025
- 49:39was
- 49:39in
- 49:40the
- 49:40Heritage
- 49:40foundation
- 49:40and
- 49:41all
- 49:41those
- 49:41others.
- 49:42They
- 49:42were
- 49:42actually
- 49:42working
- 49:43on
- 49:43a
- 49:43playbook
- 49:44for
- 49:44years.
- 49:45And
- 49:45it's
- 49:46actually
- 49:46probably
- 49:47made
- 49:48the
- 49:48difference
- 49:48between
- 49:49Trump's
- 49:49first
- 49:49two
- 49:49or
- 49:50three
- 49:50months
- 49:50now
- 49:51versus
- 49:51his
- 49:51two
- 49:51or
- 49:52three
- 49:52months
- 49:52in
- 49:522017.
- 49:54My
- 49:54question
- 49:55for
- 49:55and,
- 49:55and
- 49:55so
- 49:56there's
- 49:56some
- 49:56intention,
- 49:57there's
- 49:58some
- 49:58intention
- 49:59to
- 49:59parts
- 50:00of
- 50:00what
- 50:00they're
- 50:00doing
- 50:00here.
- 50:01And
- 50:02as
- 50:02it
- 50:02relates
- 50:03to
- 50:03education,
- 50:03though,
- 50:07most
- 50:07of
- 50:07what
- 50:07we've
- 50:08been
- 50:08talking
- 50:08about
- 50:08right
- 50:08now
- 50:09is
- 50:09rip
- 50:09it
- 50:09down,
- 50:10rip
- 50:10it
- 50:10down.
- 50:10Hey,
- 50:11there's
- 50:11some
- 50:11people
- 50:11on
- 50:11the
- 50:11school
- 50:12choice
- 50:12side
- 50:12and
- 50:13how
- 50:13they're
- 50:13designing
- 50:14their
- 50:14program.
- 50:14There's
- 50:14some
- 50:14intention
- 50:15there
- 50:15for
- 50:15sure.
- 50:15And
- 50:16they've
- 50:16been
- 50:16doing
- 50:16some
- 50:16thinking
- 50:17for
- 50:17a
- 50:17long
- 50:17time.
- 50:18But
- 50:20aside
- 50:20from
- 50:21that,
- 50:21is
- 50:22anybody
- 50:22working
- 50:24on
- 50:25something
- 50:26intentional
- 50:27that
- 50:27if
- 50:28we
- 50:28ever
- 50:28get
- 50:29other
- 50:30policymakers
- 50:31in
- 50:31place
- 50:31that
- 50:32would
- 50:32be
- 50:32willing
- 50:32to
- 50:32act
- 50:33with
- 50:33courage,
- 50:34there's
- 50:35something
- 50:35for
- 50:35them
- 50:36to
- 50:37run
- 50:37with?
- 50:38Yeah,
- 50:38you're
- 50:38gonna
- 50:39feel
- 50:39like
- 50:39you're
- 50:39teeing
- 50:39me
- 50:40up
- 50:40because
- 50:40I
- 50:40do
- 50:40think
- 50:40there's,
- 50:41I'll
- 50:42share.
- 50:42I
- 50:42do
- 50:42think.
- 50:42Yeah,
- 50:43look,
- 50:43I
- 50:43think
- 50:44they
- 50:44are
- 50:44moving
- 50:45very
- 50:45fast
- 50:45because
- 50:45they
- 50:45realize
- 50:46they
- 50:46don't
- 50:46have
- 50:46a
- 50:46lot
- 50:46of
- 50:47time.
- 50:47It
- 50:47will
- 50:48be
- 50:48a
- 50:48lame
- 50:48duck
- 50:49soon.
- 50:49Like,
- 50:50I
- 50:50think
- 50:50you
- 50:50have
- 50:50to
- 50:50assume
- 50:51the
- 50:51Democrats
- 50:51are
- 50:51going
- 50:52to
- 50:52be
- 50:52well
- 50:52positioned
- 50:53to
- 50:53get
- 50:53the
- 50:53House
- 50:53even.
- 50:54Even
- 50:54as
- 50:54tight
- 50:54as
- 50:55the
- 50:55House
- 50:55margin
- 50:56is
- 50:57the
- 50:57number
- 50:57of
- 50:57competitive
- 50:58seats.
- 50:59Like,
- 50:59unless,
- 51:00unless
- 51:00things
- 51:01really
- 51:01turn
- 51:01around,
- 51:03I
- 51:03think
- 51:03there's
- 51:03gonna
- 51:03be
- 51:03a
- 51:04backlash.
- 51:04The
- 51:04Democrats
- 51:05will,
- 51:05will
- 51:05benefit
- 51:06mightily
- 51:06from
- 51:06it.
- 51:10So
- 51:10they
- 51:10know
- 51:10they're
- 51:10time
- 51:11limited
- 51:11and
- 51:11so
- 51:11they
- 51:11are
- 51:11focused
- 51:12on
- 51:12tearing
- 51:12things
- 51:12down.
- 51:13They
- 51:13are
- 51:13literally
- 51:13there's
- 51:14going
- 51:14fast
- 51:14and
- 51:14breaking
- 51:15things,
- 51:15which
- 51:15I
- 51:15don't
- 51:16think
- 51:16is
- 51:16a
- 51:16great
- 51:16way
- 51:17to
- 51:17govern.
- 51:17But
- 51:18you
- 51:18can
- 51:18certainly
- 51:18understand
- 51:19why
- 51:19they're,
- 51:19why
- 51:19they're
- 51:20doing
- 51:20it,
- 51:21given
- 51:21the
- 51:21context.
- 51:23So
- 51:23Margaret
- 51:24Spellings,
- 51:24I
- 51:24think
- 51:24we've
- 51:24talked
- 51:25about
- 51:25this,
- 51:25has
- 51:25this
- 51:25bipartisan
- 51:27commission
- 51:27on
- 51:27education
- 51:28in
- 51:28the
- 51:28workforce,
- 51:29former
- 51:30Tennessee
- 51:31Governor
- 51:31Bill
- 51:31Haslam,
- 51:32former
- 51:32Massachusetts
- 51:33Governor
- 51:33Deval
- 51:33Patrick
- 51:34are
- 51:34co
- 51:34chairing
- 51:35it.
- 51:35You
- 51:35get
- 51:35a
- 51:36range
- 51:36of
- 51:36people,
- 51:36you've
- 51:37got,
- 51:37you
- 51:37know,
- 51:38you
- 51:39know,
- 51:39the
- 51:39head
- 51:39of
- 51:39the
- 51:39Lumina
- 51:40Foundation,
- 51:41John
- 51:41King,
- 51:42people
- 51:42like
- 51:42this.
- 51:42And
- 51:43then
- 51:43like
- 51:43Mike
- 51:44Rogers
- 51:44who
- 51:44runs
- 51:45workforce,
- 51:45Katie
- 51:46Jenner
- 51:46in
- 51:46our
- 51:46workforce
- 51:47in
- 51:47Arkansas,
- 51:48Katie
- 51:48Jenner,
- 51:49who
- 51:49is
- 51:49a
- 51:50fantastic
- 51:51state
- 51:51chief
- 51:52in
- 51:52Indiana.
- 51:52So
- 51:52it's
- 51:53just
- 51:53a
- 51:53total
- 51:53mix
- 51:54of
- 51:54people.
- 51:54John
- 51:54Bailey,
- 51:55who's
- 51:55you
- 51:55know,
- 51:56known
- 51:56to
- 51:56the,
- 51:56to
- 51:57the
- 51:57wonk
- 51:57set.
- 51:58Just
- 51:58a
- 51:58really
- 51:58interesting
- 51:58range
- 51:59of
- 51:59commissioners
- 52:00and
- 52:01the
- 52:03ideas
- 52:03to
- 52:04come
- 52:04up
- 52:04with
- 52:04a
- 52:04bunch
- 52:04of
- 52:04bipartisan
- 52:05ideas
- 52:05on
- 52:06education,
- 52:06workforce,
- 52:07human
- 52:07capital.
- 52:08And
- 52:08I
- 52:08think,
- 52:08like,
- 52:08yeah,
- 52:08there
- 52:09will
- 52:09be
- 52:09once
- 52:10we
- 52:10get
- 52:10through
- 52:10this
- 52:11first
- 52:11period,
- 52:11which
- 52:12again,
- 52:12courts
- 52:13are
- 52:13still
- 52:13working
- 52:13a
- 52:13lot
- 52:13of
- 52:14this
- 52:14stuff
- 52:14out.
- 52:15Like,
- 52:15a
- 52:15lot
- 52:15of,
- 52:15you
- 52:15know,
- 52:15things
- 52:16are
- 52:16getting
- 52:16undone
- 52:17and,
- 52:17or
- 52:17getting
- 52:18changed
- 52:19and
- 52:19parsed.
- 52:20Some
- 52:20of
- 52:20the
- 52:20stuff
- 52:21they
- 52:21cut
- 52:21at
- 52:21education,
- 52:22they're
- 52:22going
- 52:22to
- 52:22have
- 52:22to
- 52:22put
- 52:23back
- 52:23out.
- 52:23It's
- 52:23congressionally
- 52:24mandated,
- 52:24so
- 52:24they're
- 52:25gonna
- 52:25taken
- 52:26out
- 52:26the
- 52:26aspects
- 52:26of
- 52:27it
- 52:27they
- 52:27didn't
- 52:27like
- 52:27around,
- 52:28like
- 52:28DEI
- 52:28and
- 52:29whatever,
- 52:29and
- 52:29then
- 52:29they're
- 52:29gonna
- 52:30put
- 52:30it
- 52:30back
- 52:30out.
- 52:30So
- 52:30I
- 52:31feel
- 52:31like
- 52:31it's
- 52:31still,
- 52:32like,
- 52:33I
- 52:33mean,
- 52:33it's
- 52:33been
- 52:33an
- 52:34exhausting
- 52:34period,
- 52:35but
- 52:35it's
- 52:35still
- 52:35kind
- 52:35of
- 52:35early
- 52:36going.
- 52:36And
- 52:36so
- 52:36I
- 52:36do
- 52:37think,
- 52:37yeah,
- 52:37they'll
- 52:37hopefully
- 52:38be
- 52:38an
- 52:38opportunity
- 52:40for
- 52:41some
- 52:41ideas
- 52:42and,
- 52:42and
- 52:42so
- 52:43forth.
- 52:43And,
- 52:43and,
- 52:44you
- 52:44know,
- 52:44so
- 52:44I,
- 52:44that's
- 52:44one
- 52:45thing
- 52:45I
- 52:45would,
- 52:45I
- 52:45would
- 52:46certainly
- 52:46keep
- 52:47an
- 52:47eye
- 52:47on.
- 52:49Well,
- 52:49if
- 52:50not,
- 52:50like,
- 52:50everybody's
- 52:51like,
- 52:51everything's
- 52:51lost.
- 52:52Like,
- 52:52I
- 52:52don't
- 52:53know
- 52:53if,
- 52:53if
- 52:54ever,
- 52:54then,
- 52:54if
- 52:54everything's
- 52:55lost,
- 52:55we
- 52:55will,
- 52:56we
- 52:56will
- 52:56address
- 52:56that
- 52:57when
- 52:57we
- 52:57get
- 52:57there.
- 52:57But,
- 52:58like,
- 52:58we're
- 52:58not,
- 52:58we
- 52:59are,
- 52:59we
- 52:59are
- 53:00not
- 53:00there.
- 53:01We
- 53:01are
- 53:01not
- 53:01there
- 53:01at
- 53:01this
- 53:02point.
- 53:02So,
- 53:02like,
- 53:02we
- 53:02should
- 53:03all
- 53:03continue
- 53:03to
- 53:04do
- 53:04the
- 53:04best
- 53:04we
- 53:05can
- 53:05to
- 53:05try
- 53:05to
- 53:05address
- 53:05the
- 53:06problems
- 53:06we
- 53:06care
- 53:06about.
- 53:07Well,
- 53:07I
- 53:07wasn't
- 53:08going
- 53:08to
- 53:08go
- 53:08here,
- 53:08but
- 53:08I
- 53:08can't
- 53:09help
- 53:09just
- 53:09wrap
- 53:10up
- 53:10coming
- 53:11back
- 53:11to
- 53:11the
- 53:11Supreme
- 53:12Court
- 53:12case.
- 53:12You
- 53:12know,
- 53:12it's
- 53:12the
- 53:12thing
- 53:13I
- 53:13worry
- 53:13the
- 53:13most
- 53:13about
- 53:13in
- 53:14the
- 53:14landscape.
- 53:15And,
- 53:15you
- 53:16know,
- 53:16I've
- 53:17had
- 53:17a
- 53:17chance
- 53:17to
- 53:17do
- 53:17a
- 53:18lot
- 53:18of
- 53:18work
- 53:18on
- 53:18the
- 53:18case
- 53:19now,
- 53:19and
- 53:19I've
- 53:19learned
- 53:19a
- 53:19lot
- 53:20about
- 53:20the
- 53:20legal
- 53:20arguments
- 53:21and
- 53:21some
- 53:21of
- 53:22the
- 53:22original
- 53:22intent
- 53:23for
- 53:23charter
- 53:23school.
- 53:23They
- 53:23can
- 53:24talk
- 53:24more
- 53:24about
- 53:24the
- 53:24work
- 53:24I've
- 53:25been
- 53:25doing
- 53:25probably
- 53:26in
- 53:26the,
- 53:26in
- 53:27the
- 53:27weeks
- 53:27and
- 53:27the
- 53:27months
- 53:27ahead.
- 53:28But
- 53:29one
- 53:30thing
- 53:30that's
- 53:30become
- 53:30apparent
- 53:31to
- 53:31me
- 53:31is
- 53:32if
- 53:32you
- 53:32really
- 53:33read
- 53:33the
- 53:33religious
- 53:34liberty
- 53:34arguments,
- 53:35it's,
- 53:36it's,
- 53:36you
- 53:36don't
- 53:37have
- 53:37to
- 53:37have
- 53:37a
- 53:37charter
- 53:37school
- 53:37law,
- 53:38but
- 53:38if
- 53:38you
- 53:38do,
- 53:40you
- 53:40cannot
- 53:40discriminate
- 53:41against,
- 53:42you
- 53:42know,
- 53:43religious
- 53:44institutions
- 53:44wanting
- 53:44to
- 53:45operate
- 53:45there.
- 53:46And
- 53:46they
- 53:46say
- 53:46it
- 53:46over
- 53:46and
- 53:47over
- 53:47again,
- 53:47and
- 53:47I
- 53:47think
- 53:47they
- 53:48say
- 53:48it
- 53:48over
- 53:48and
- 53:48over
- 53:48again
- 53:49because
- 53:49they
- 53:49think
- 53:49it's
- 53:49a
- 53:49winning
- 53:50argument
- 53:50and,
- 53:51and
- 53:52maybe
- 53:52it
- 53:52will
- 53:52be.
- 53:53We'll
- 53:53see.
- 53:53Well,
- 53:53you
- 53:54can
- 53:54see
- 53:54the
- 53:54path
- 53:54dependence
- 53:55there
- 53:55with
- 53:55earlier
- 53:55decisions.
- 53:56You
- 53:56can,
- 53:56you
- 53:57can
- 53:57see
- 53:57why
- 53:58they're
- 53:58arguing
- 53:58it
- 53:58that
- 53:59way.
- 54:00What
- 54:00it
- 54:00could
- 54:01very
- 54:01well
- 54:01end
- 54:01up,
- 54:02you
- 54:02know,
- 54:03translating
- 54:03into
- 54:04is
- 54:06a
- 54:06Shorthand
- 54:07that
- 54:07runs
- 54:07like
- 54:07this.
- 54:08If
- 54:08you're
- 54:09going
- 54:09to
- 54:09have
- 54:09public
- 54:09education,
- 54:11it
- 54:11has
- 54:11to
- 54:11be
- 54:12directly
- 54:13operated
- 54:13by
- 54:14the
- 54:14government.
- 54:15There
- 54:15is
- 54:15no
- 54:16way
- 54:17to
- 54:17have,
- 54:18you
- 54:18know,
- 54:18a.
- 54:19In
- 54:20autonomous
- 54:20parties
- 54:22operating
- 54:22unless
- 54:23you're
- 54:23also
- 54:23going
- 54:23to
- 54:23have
- 54:23religious
- 54:24schools,
- 54:24which
- 54:24is
- 54:25just
- 54:25not
- 54:25tolerable
- 54:26to
- 54:26half
- 54:26of
- 54:27the
- 54:27political
- 54:27establishment,
- 54:28which
- 54:30will
- 54:30likely
- 54:30mean
- 54:31in
- 54:31all
- 54:31blue
- 54:31states,
- 54:31you
- 54:32know,
- 54:32charter
- 54:32schools
- 54:32will
- 54:33get
- 54:33absorbed
- 54:33back
- 54:34into
- 54:34the
- 54:34board.
- 54:35In
- 54:35red
- 54:35states,
- 54:36they've
- 54:36got
- 54:37the
- 54:37complication
- 54:38of
- 54:39all
- 54:39of
- 54:39these
- 54:39state
- 54:40constitutions
- 54:40that
- 54:40say
- 54:41that
- 54:41they
- 54:41can't
- 54:41direct
- 54:41fund
- 54:42sectarian
- 54:43schools,
- 54:43in
- 54:44which
- 54:44case
- 54:44a
- 54:45lot
- 54:45of
- 54:45the
- 54:45red
- 54:46states
- 54:46could
- 54:46just
- 54:46say,
- 54:47ah,
- 54:47just
- 54:47make
- 54:47the
- 54:48charters
- 54:48vouchers,
- 54:49you
- 54:49know.
- 54:49So
- 54:49your
- 54:49idea,
- 54:50hey,
- 54:50charter
- 54:50schools
- 54:51are
- 54:51going
- 54:51to
- 54:51be
- 54:51left
- 54:51without
- 54:51a,
- 54:52without
- 54:52a
- 54:52chair
- 54:52in
- 54:53the
- 54:53game
- 54:53of
- 54:53musical
- 54:53chairs
- 54:54here.
- 54:54Well,
- 54:54you
- 54:55know,
- 54:55maybe
- 54:55it
- 54:55turns
- 54:55out
- 54:56right,
- 54:56what
- 54:57it,
- 54:57what
- 54:57it,
- 54:57what
- 54:57it
- 54:58does
- 54:58though
- 54:58is
- 54:58it
- 54:59just
- 54:59creates
- 54:59a
- 54:59situation
- 55:00where
- 55:00either
- 55:01the
- 55:01government's
- 55:01going
- 55:01to
- 55:02do
- 55:02it
- 55:02or
- 55:02it's
- 55:03completely
- 55:03and
- 55:03utterly
- 55:05must
- 55:05be
- 55:05private,
- 55:06you
- 55:07know.
- 55:07And
- 55:07so
- 55:07for
- 55:07all
- 55:08these
- 55:08conversations
- 55:08going
- 55:08on
- 55:09with
- 55:09Margaret
- 55:09and
- 55:09with
- 55:09John
- 55:10King
- 55:10and
- 55:10whatever,
- 55:10it
- 55:10would
- 55:11seem
- 55:11as
- 55:11though
- 55:12they're
- 55:12all
- 55:12going
- 55:12to
- 55:12be
- 55:13focused
- 55:13in
- 55:13this
- 55:14middle
- 55:14ground
- 55:15where
- 55:15like
- 55:15we
- 55:15got
- 55:15to
- 55:15be
- 55:16doing
- 55:16hybrid
- 55:16things
- 55:16we
- 55:16gotta
- 55:17have.
- 55:17And
- 55:17it
- 55:17just
- 55:18feels
- 55:18like
- 55:18the
- 55:19Supreme
- 55:19Court
- 55:20could
- 55:20very
- 55:20well
- 55:21hamstring
- 55:22future
- 55:23reformers
- 55:24with
- 55:24this
- 55:25case
- 55:26in
- 55:26ways
- 55:26that
- 55:27they
- 55:27may
- 55:28be
- 55:28far
- 55:29more,
- 55:29far
- 55:29wider
- 55:30reaching
- 55:31than
- 55:31something
- 55:31specific
- 55:32to
- 55:32just
- 55:32charter
- 55:33schools
- 55:33or
- 55:33religious
- 55:34education.
- 55:35I
- 55:35hope,
- 55:36Look,
- 55:36I
- 55:36mean
- 55:37we
- 55:37talked
- 55:37about
- 55:38this
- 55:38on
- 55:38the
- 55:38last
- 55:38one.
- 55:38I'm
- 55:39hoping
- 55:39the
- 55:39court
- 55:40realizes
- 55:40would
- 55:41really
- 55:41be
- 55:41crossing
- 55:41the
- 55:41Rubicon
- 55:42a
- 55:42bunch
- 55:42of
- 55:42ways
- 55:43and
- 55:44decides
- 55:45that
- 55:45you
- 55:45don't
- 55:45actually
- 55:46need
- 55:46to
- 55:47do
- 55:47this.
- 55:48But
- 55:49we,
- 55:49We.
- 55:49We
- 55:49will
- 55:50see.
- 55:50It's
- 55:50be
- 55:50interesting
- 55:50case
- 55:51because
- 55:51again
- 55:51we,
- 55:51as
- 55:52we
- 55:52talked
- 55:52about,
- 55:52there's
- 55:52only
- 55:52eight.
- 55:53Eight
- 55:53votes
- 55:54because
- 55:54Justice
- 55:55Barrett
- 55:56has
- 55:56recused
- 55:56herself
- 55:57and
- 55:57so
- 55:58it'll
- 55:58be
- 55:58interesting
- 55:58to
- 55:58see
- 55:58what
- 55:59happens.
- 55:59Yeah,
- 55:59I
- 55:59think
- 55:59it's
- 56:00pretty.
- 56:00I
- 56:00think
- 56:00it
- 56:00is
- 56:00potentially
- 56:01consequential
- 56:03in,
- 56:04in
- 56:04ways
- 56:04like
- 56:04what
- 56:04you're.
- 56:05The.
- 56:05The.
- 56:06The
- 56:06effects
- 56:07of
- 56:07it.
- 56:07Unless
- 56:08I
- 56:08think
- 56:08it,
- 56:08it
- 56:08could
- 56:09really
- 56:09cleave
- 56:09things.
- 56:10I'm.
- 56:11I'm
- 56:11less
- 56:11worried
- 56:12about
- 56:14the,
- 56:14the
- 56:14idea
- 56:14that
- 56:14all
- 56:15the
- 56:15public
- 56:15schools
- 56:15are
- 56:15going
- 56:15to
- 56:15become
- 56:16religious
- 56:16and
- 56:16things
- 56:17like
- 56:17that.
- 56:17Then
- 56:17it's.
- 56:18I
- 56:18think
- 56:18it
- 56:18could
- 56:18potentially
- 56:18really,
- 56:19really
- 56:19cleave
- 56:20things
- 56:20again.
- 56:20I
- 56:20think
- 56:21the
- 56:21dog
- 56:21that
- 56:21didn't
- 56:21bark.
- 56:22If
- 56:22you've
- 56:22noticed,
- 56:22the
- 56:22unions
- 56:23have
- 56:23been
- 56:23really
- 56:23quiet
- 56:23on
- 56:24this.
- 56:24No,
- 56:25I
- 56:25think
- 56:25they
- 56:25think,
- 56:25I
- 56:26think
- 56:26they
- 56:26think
- 56:26it's
- 56:27really
- 56:27bad
- 56:27for
- 56:27charters.
- 56:28And
- 56:28so
- 56:28they
- 56:28are
- 56:28doing
- 56:28that
- 56:28old
- 56:29thing
- 56:29in
- 56:29politics
- 56:29where
- 56:30when
- 56:30somebody's
- 56:31like
- 56:31shooting
- 56:31themselves
- 56:31in
- 56:32the
- 56:32foot
- 56:32don't
- 56:32get
- 56:32in
- 56:32the
- 56:32way.
- 56:33And
- 56:33I
- 56:33think
- 56:34that's
- 56:34really
- 56:35telling.
- 56:36You
- 56:36know,
- 56:37they're
- 56:37pretty
- 56:38smart
- 56:38on
- 56:38this
- 56:38stuff
- 56:39often.
- 56:39And
- 56:39I
- 56:40think
- 56:40that's
- 56:41really
- 56:41telling
- 56:42in
- 56:42terms
- 56:42of
- 56:42how
- 56:42they're
- 56:42reading
- 56:43the.
- 56:44They're
- 56:44reading
- 56:44the
- 56:44potential
- 56:45outcome.
- 56:46Well,
- 56:46we'll
- 56:47hope
- 56:47that
- 56:47they
- 56:48are
- 56:48careful
- 56:48about
- 56:49what
- 56:49they
- 56:49do
- 56:49here,
- 56:49but
- 56:50who
- 56:50knows?
- 56:50In
- 56:50this
- 56:51environment,
- 56:52careful
- 56:52doesn't
- 56:52seem
- 56:53to
- 56:53be
- 56:53an
- 56:53operative
- 56:53word
- 56:54in
- 56:54most
- 56:55contexts.
- 56:55So
- 56:55we'll.
- 56:56We'll
- 56:56just
- 56:56have
- 56:56to
- 56:56see.
- 56:57Yeah,
- 56:57no,
- 56:57I
- 56:57mean
- 56:58the
- 56:58case.
- 56:58Yeah,
- 56:58it's
- 56:58like
- 56:59the
- 56:59timing
- 56:59of
- 57:00it
- 57:00is.
- 57:00These
- 57:00things
- 57:00sometimes
- 57:01are
- 57:01coming
- 57:01at
- 57:01the.
- 57:01When
- 57:02all
- 57:02the
- 57:02rest
- 57:02of
- 57:02this
- 57:02stuff
- 57:02is
- 57:03happening.
- 57:04It's
- 57:04something
- 57:04again
- 57:05on
- 57:05the
- 57:05musical
- 57:05chairs
- 57:06thing.
- 57:06Look,
- 57:06I
- 57:06hope,
- 57:06I
- 57:06hope
- 57:07I'm
- 57:07wrong.
- 57:07I
- 57:07want.
- 57:07That's
- 57:07one
- 57:08I
- 57:08want
- 57:08to
- 57:08be
- 57:08wrong
- 57:09on.
- 57:09But.
- 57:10So
- 57:10now
- 57:10does
- 57:11this
- 57:11mean
- 57:11next
- 57:11time
- 57:11I
- 57:11got
- 57:12to
- 57:12wear
- 57:12a
- 57:12collared
- 57:12shirt
- 57:13and
- 57:13I
- 57:13got
- 57:13to
- 57:13wear,
- 57:13you
- 57:14know,
- 57:14professional
- 57:14headphones
- 57:15and
- 57:15I
- 57:15got
- 57:15to
- 57:16have
- 57:16a
- 57:16new
- 57:16background?
- 57:17So
- 57:17I'm,
- 57:17you
- 57:18know,
- 57:18I
- 57:18don't
- 57:18know.
- 57:18It's
- 57:19springtime.
- 57:20It's
- 57:20springtime.
- 57:21You
- 57:21may
- 57:21find
- 57:21me
- 57:22in
- 57:22a.
- 57:22You
- 57:22may
- 57:22find
- 57:23me
- 57:23in
- 57:23a
- 57:23T
- 57:23shirt
- 57:24for
- 57:24the
- 57:24next
- 57:24one.
- 57:24You
- 57:25just.
- 57:25You
- 57:25just
- 57:25never
- 57:25know.
- 57:25I
- 57:25had
- 57:26to.
- 57:26I
- 57:27did
- 57:27a
- 57:27couple
- 57:27of
- 57:27presentations
- 57:28today
- 57:28on
- 57:28stuff
- 57:29so
- 57:29you
- 57:29could
- 57:29caught
- 57:29me.
- 57:30You
- 57:30caught.
- 57:30You
- 57:30caught
- 57:31me.
- 57:31You
- 57:32caught
- 57:32me
- 57:32dressed
- 57:32up.
- 57:33Yeah,
- 57:33I'm,
- 57:33you
- 57:33know,
- 57:34I
- 57:34mean,
- 57:34I'm
- 57:34more
- 57:34used
- 57:34to
- 57:35seeing
- 57:35you
- 57:35in
- 57:35tacky
- 57:35Christmas
- 57:36sweaters
- 57:36and
- 57:36muscle
- 57:37shirts
- 57:37and
- 57:37whatever.
- 57:38So.
- 57:38What?
- 57:39Muscle
- 57:39shirts?
- 57:41No,
- 57:41my.
- 57:43I
- 57:43spent
- 57:43the
- 57:43weekend.
- 57:44My
- 57:44wife.
- 57:46No
- 57:46hoodies.
- 57:47We
- 57:47did
- 57:47hoodies
- 57:47one
- 57:48time.
- 57:48We
- 57:48did.
- 57:48I
- 57:48was
- 57:48wearing
- 57:49a
- 57:49hoodie.
- 57:49I
- 57:49was
- 57:49wearing
- 57:49a
- 57:49hoodie
- 57:50this
- 57:50morning,
- 57:50actually,
- 57:51for
- 57:51my
- 57:51first
- 57:51meeting.
- 57:51And
- 57:52then
- 57:52I
- 57:52had
- 57:52to
- 57:52get
- 57:52work
- 57:53out
- 57:53and
- 57:53get
- 57:53cleaned
- 57:53up
- 57:53and
- 57:54all
- 57:54that,
- 57:55so
- 57:56you're
- 57:57catching.
- 57:57So
- 57:57we'll
- 57:58see.
- 57:58We'll.
- 57:58Maybe
- 57:58we'll
- 57:58try
- 57:59to
- 57:59plan
- 57:59for
- 57:59the.
- 57:59For
- 57:59the
- 58:00next
- 58:00one.
- 58:00We
- 58:00need
- 58:00walkie
- 58:01folk
- 58:02hoodies
- 58:02is
- 58:02what
- 58:03we
- 58:03need.
- 58:04Hey,
- 58:04good
- 58:04idea.
- 58:05I
- 58:05like
- 58:05that.
- 58:06We
- 58:06actually
- 58:07give
- 58:07swag
- 58:07away
- 58:08to
- 58:08the
- 58:08listeners,
- 58:08which
- 58:09could
- 58:09be
- 58:09kind
- 58:09of
- 58:09fun.
- 58:11Maybe
- 58:11we'll
- 58:11be
- 58:12doing
- 58:12an
- 58:12in
- 58:12person
- 58:12one
- 58:13in
- 58:13a
- 58:13backyard.
- 58:13That'll
- 58:14be
- 58:14fun.
- 58:14And
- 58:14if
- 58:14we
- 58:14had
- 58:15like
- 58:15three
- 58:15wonky
- 58:15folk
- 58:16sweatshirts
- 58:16for
- 58:16that
- 58:16one,
- 58:17that
- 58:17might
- 58:17be
- 58:17kind
- 58:17of
- 58:17cool.
- 58:18Or
- 58:18we
- 58:18could
- 58:18do
- 58:18something
- 58:19different,
- 58:19like
- 58:19wonky
- 58:19folk
- 58:19tank
- 58:20tops.
- 58:20Could
- 58:20be
- 58:21fantastic.
- 58:23All
- 58:24right.
- 58:24I
- 58:24like
- 58:24it.
- 58:25Always
- 58:25enjoy
- 58:25our
- 58:25time
- 58:26together.
- 58:26Andy.
- 58:26Hey,
- 58:26it's
- 58:27great
- 58:27to
- 58:27see
- 58:27you,
- 58:27Jen.
- 58:28It's
- 58:28been
- 58:28too
- 58:28long.
- 58:28And
- 58:28I'll
- 58:29look
- 58:29forward
- 58:29to
- 58:29seeing
- 58:29you
- 58:29soon.
- 58:30Okay,
- 58:30Take
- 58:31care.