Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: On Topic - How do you put that on a button?
Transcript
- 0:10This is AV Super Friends On Topic,
- 0:12a thirty-minute monthly roundtable focused
- 0:14on a single topic.
- 0:15This discussion will be opinionated,
- 0:17to the point,
- 0:17and saturated with our well-known blend of
- 0:19painfully-won expertise and
- 0:21deeply-embraned immaturity.
- 0:29For September eleventh, twenty-twenty-six,
- 0:31it's the best-sounding and most
- 0:32conspiracy-minded podcast in higher ed,
- 0:35this is the AV Super Friends On Topic
- 0:37episode number seventy-nine.
- 0:39Broadcasting live across three time zones
- 0:41from the Jersey waterfront where
- 0:43somebody's cousin definitely saw a van
- 0:44full of guys filming the whole thing to
- 0:46an undisclosed command bunker where the
- 0:48stand down order was either never given,
- 0:50already rescinded or classified until
- 0:51twenty eighty seven.
- 0:53I'm your NORAD scrambled transponder loss
- 0:55war game confused local host Chris Decker
- 0:56and you're tuned in for another Friday
- 0:57afternoon podcast with the higher Friday
- 1:01afternoon podcast with the ABC for
- 1:02friends.
- 1:03What is happening on my screen over here?
- 1:06words nor as I don't know, confused me.
- 1:08Well,
- 1:08a team's message popped up and blocked
- 1:10like half of what I'm looking at vibrate.
- 1:12Good team did not vibrate.
- 1:13So anyway,
- 1:15another Friday afternoon podcast adventure
- 1:16all that stuff anyway.
- 1:18And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 1:20August a V super friends with this screen
- 1:22doing this on three computer sucks.
- 1:26Hold on.
- 1:26There we go.
- 1:27All right.
- 1:27Our first panelist manages facilities
- 1:29technology with particular expertise in
- 1:31systems that experience catastrophic
- 1:33end-of-life events despite not appearing
- 1:35on the original incident roadmap.
- 1:36He's a director of unscheduled building
- 1:38lifecycle events from Kansas City,
- 1:40say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:42Like a paramedic,
- 1:43I come in with pure oxygen and double
- 1:45the voltage.
- 1:46See if I can't get that thing coming
- 1:47up again.
- 1:50Fire.
- 1:50Might work.
- 1:52Our next panelist ensures distributed
- 1:54control platforms, airspace resources,
- 1:56and support personnel all know exactly
- 1:58when to intervene, and more importantly,
- 2:00when not to.
- 2:02He's a senior manager of stand-down
- 2:03coordination from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 2:05Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolosinski.
- 2:07It's a very elaborate structure of pagers
- 2:11and phones,
- 2:13like phone booths around campus.
- 2:15It works sometimes.
- 2:16Mm-hmm.
- 2:17Our next panelist leads next-generation
- 2:20media workflows capable of announcing
- 2:21major infrastructure failures before the
- 2:24infrastructure itself has received the
- 2:25notification.
- 2:26He's an associate director of premature
- 2:28broadcast and predictive services from
- 2:29Greensboro, North Carolina.
- 2:30Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:32I don't actually like this job because if
- 2:35you predict too many things,
- 2:37they start blaming you for them.
- 2:40Quit unplugging it.
- 2:41Mm-hmm.
- 2:43look directly at it and our final panelist
- 2:45oversees the strategic retirement of
- 2:47buildings and systems that for reasons
- 2:49nobody can adequately explain were
- 2:51apparently never important anyway he's a
- 2:53vice president of redundant infrastructure
- 2:55and controlled demolition demolition
- 2:57readiness from bowling green kentucky say
- 2:58hello mr justin rexing you did this on
- 3:01purpose this is all theme all of this
- 3:05is intentional yes well no i think you
- 3:07i think it's theme but i don't know
- 3:10if i can comment on that based on
- 3:13Just tear it all down, man.
- 3:14Just tear it all down.
- 3:15Oh, it gets worse.
- 3:16Ready for it?
- 3:18So on today's show,
- 3:19we're going to discuss why your touch
- 3:21panel GUI is terrible, and so is mine.
- 3:24But first, some housekeeping.
- 3:26If you're listening,
- 3:27this is a recorded MP three.
- 3:28We do stream live on Fridays at about
- 3:29three fifteen Eastern,
- 3:30twelve fifteen Pacific,
- 3:31or whenever Mark says, let's roll.
- 3:33Join us on Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube,
- 3:35and assuming NORAD doesn't mysteriously
- 3:37lose track of the feed,
- 3:38you can find us there on all those
- 3:39streaming services.
- 3:40If you can't join us live,
- 3:41please follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 3:42YouTube,
- 3:42and Blue Sky by searching for AV Super
- 3:44Friends.
- 3:45And please spread the word.
- 3:46Share this show with your friends,
- 3:47colleagues, enemies, strangers,
- 3:49BBC reporters with remarkable timing,
- 3:50demolition engineers who suddenly won't
- 3:52return your calls,
- 3:52and anyone else who was ever quietly
- 3:54asked, wait, what about Building Seven?
- 3:56If you want to support the show,
- 3:57please consider donating.
- 3:58Your contributions help to keep us
- 4:00independent from multinational
- 4:01corporations, intelligence agencies,
- 4:02defense contractors,
- 4:03mysterious foreign businessmen,
- 4:04Israeli art students,
- 4:04and anyone else associated with a white
- 4:06van in New Jersey.
- 4:07Look it up.
- 4:08You'll find the donation link in the show
- 4:09notes or on our website.
- 4:10So please subscribe, follow, donate,
- 4:11and leave us a review.
- 4:12In fact, on those reviews,
- 4:13five stars means you enjoy the show.
- 4:15Four stars starts to raise some questions.
- 4:17Three stars means you probably know
- 4:19something.
- 4:20Two stars is a nod to Building Seven.
- 4:22And one star means somebody told you to
- 4:24pull it.
- 4:26Oh, what?
- 4:28Look it up.
- 4:29ABC for Friends because jet fuel may not
- 4:31melt steel beams,
- 4:32but apparently can melt your ability to
- 4:33hit subscribe.
- 4:34Thank you for your support.
- 4:35We couldn't do this show without you.
- 4:38I don't like any of that innuendo.
- 4:40None of it.
- 4:41There's like three percent of our audience
- 4:43that got a lot of that stuff.
- 4:44Yeah,
- 4:45and the rest of them just hit unsubscribe.
- 4:47I'm not part of that.
- 4:49The other rest are depressed and not going
- 4:52to have a great weekend.
- 4:52You guys don't want to dig into that
- 4:55stuff.
- 4:55Okay, sorry.
- 4:58Anyway, let's talk touch panels.
- 5:01So this topic came up on Wednesday because
- 5:04some of us were on a call on
- 5:05Wednesday where somebody demonstrated the
- 5:08proposed layout, which raised many, many,
- 5:11many,
- 5:11many questions and they were shared widely
- 5:13on
- 5:14these are terrible, terrible things to do.
- 5:16So that led to the thing of like,
- 5:18hey, why don't we talk about this?
- 5:19Because we did a bit of research.
- 5:20We had our friendly AI bot Al go
- 5:23back in time and dug up like the
- 5:25twenty seven thousand times we've talked
- 5:26about touch panels and GUIs and user
- 5:28interfaces and user experience and found
- 5:31that we never actually made that the full
- 5:33topic.
- 5:34It was all we bring it up obliquely
- 5:36and in reference to other things,
- 5:37but never directly.
- 5:38So it kind of raised the question of
- 5:40like,
- 5:40maybe this is time to kind of hash
- 5:42through some of this stuff.
- 5:45Yes,
- 5:45Al proved that we did not have a
- 5:47full episode dedicated to this.
- 5:48Al's a good dude,
- 5:49except when his API key breaks and then
- 5:51he pukes back.
- 5:51Yes, well, thanks.
- 5:52Which honestly tracks,
- 5:54because with all the training our
- 5:55programmers, AV programmers get,
- 5:58none of it's in GUI design or how
- 6:00GUI should work.
- 6:02Like,
- 6:02that's just not something that's ever
- 6:03really covered.
- 6:04Yeah,
- 6:05but you know who has that experience?
- 6:08Who?
- 6:08The template makers from all these
- 6:10manufacturers who give us bullshit
- 6:13templates.
- 6:15They're terrible templates.
- 6:17You're making a pretty big assumption
- 6:18there.
- 6:19That they have it.
- 6:20Those templates are for home use, sir.
- 6:22Yeah.
- 6:23Where you want every possible button that
- 6:26comes with that.
- 6:27Do you?
- 6:27Do you want every possible button?
- 6:31We are assuming that they did employ
- 6:33somebody who has graphic design and user
- 6:36interface experience.
- 6:37Those aren't the same.
- 6:40Not the same at all.
- 6:41They have experience and said things.
- 6:44They have a whole team.
- 6:45It's not like it's just one Joe Moak
- 6:46sitting in the basement.
- 6:48Well, it could be, I guess.
- 6:50Where are we going with this?
- 6:52They give us terrible templates.
- 6:54And that's what most of our brethren use
- 6:56is those terrible templates.
- 6:58The templates say, hey, start here or...
- 7:01Let's have a countdown.
- 7:02It's awful.
- 7:03Edit them.
- 7:04I don't know.
- 7:05It's not what you can do.
- 7:07It's what everybody really does.
- 7:09And integrators are terrible about.
- 7:10Here's your template.
- 7:11We put your logo on it.
- 7:13Are you happy?
- 7:13No.
- 7:14Great.
- 7:14There you go.
- 7:15By the way,
- 7:16if you go to the if you go
- 7:17to the advanced page,
- 7:18you can see your logo actually is somebody
- 7:19else's.
- 7:19Let me remove that real quick.
- 7:23Yeah,
- 7:23that's by pressing the logo for two
- 7:25seconds,
- 7:25and then you get to the advanced page
- 7:27where you'll see the other person's logo.
- 7:30Yeah.
- 7:30Everyone try the default when you get that
- 7:33ten-key keypad for your four-digit code.
- 7:38Everyone try in
- 7:42It was a good year,
- 7:43a real good year.
- 7:45Anyway, so yeah,
- 7:47I think one of the things we talk
- 7:49about a lot is don't put in touch
- 7:50panels when you don't need to.
- 7:51And I think we would all agree that
- 7:52if you don't need a touch panel,
- 7:53if you can do a simple button panel
- 7:54interface or something like that,
- 7:55or even no interface or whatever,
- 7:57or nothing, those are valid options.
- 7:59But let's get past all of that.
- 8:01And now you're in a space,
- 8:02in a project, whatever it is,
- 8:04where you now have some sort of touch
- 8:07press panel, touch thing in your space,
- 8:10And we're talking about what those need,
- 8:12what those should be doing what they need
- 8:14to look like what they should not be
- 8:15doing.
- 8:16You know, I'll give you a freebie here.
- 8:18Don't do the press here to begin,
- 8:19because now you're asking someone to
- 8:20immediately start by doing an unnecessary
- 8:23interaction.
- 8:24But what do you want to raise like,
- 8:31damn it, my favorite page,
- 8:31as little to almost zero button press as
- 8:35possible.
- 8:36That's what your goal is.
- 8:38a touch panel with zero button presses i
- 8:40like it maybe maybe touch me with one
- 8:43button you just breathe on it facial
- 8:44recognition you know talk to it um so
- 8:49yeah yeah where do we want to start
- 8:50on this when when we're when when you
- 8:51find yourself in a situation where you
- 8:53yeah we're already past you have to have
- 8:55for whatever reason when you need it it's
- 8:57there it's there you're not going to throw
- 8:59it away so what's it doing let's let's
- 9:02out do each of you have an on
- 9:04and off button
- 9:07I have an on button,
- 9:08but any source also turns it on.
- 9:11I was going to say,
- 9:11why do you have an on button?
- 9:12If you plug in a laptop,
- 9:14it also turns it on.
- 9:15Wait,
- 9:15is your on button press here to begin?
- 9:17No, it's just on.
- 9:19But the same thing,
- 9:20any way the instructor thinks they want to
- 9:24turn it on,
- 9:25I want the system to work for them.
- 9:28Where's the on button then?
- 9:30In the corner.
- 9:33stuff there in the corner yeah there's a
- 9:37power are we talking you turn it on
- 9:39i want to set some expectations here are
- 9:40we talking like basic classroom spaces
- 9:43because
- 9:44We have to do some large event spaces.
- 9:49Let's just go generic.
- 9:50If you're just going to put in the
- 9:51generic seven-inch panel and generic
- 9:54spaces, we all know the big spaces,
- 9:57they do require a more complicated system
- 9:59and touch panels and things.
- 10:01Talk about the base.
- 10:02Let's go with the base.
- 10:04The only rooms on campus are the large
- 10:07ones.
- 10:09We need to get past the where we
- 10:11do or do not need one.
- 10:12Whatever space you need,
- 10:14there's going to be one.
- 10:15It's there.
- 10:16Yes.
- 10:16We're already past that.
- 10:18This is not that conversation.
- 10:19The conversation is you have a touch panel
- 10:21for whatever reason.
- 10:23This is user-driven and this is weird.
- 10:25I understand.
- 10:26But touch panels are in our big spaces.
- 10:28And what happens in big spaces,
- 10:30sometimes you have someone talking that
- 10:32you don't need projection or the display.
- 10:35So
- 10:37i'm using just speakers today i'm using
- 10:39speakers and video and it's not just on
- 10:42you don't just have the mics work when
- 10:45the system's off no because that's been a
- 10:48problem too okay yeah so you're already
- 10:54way past okay minimal button pushes but
- 10:57it's just really unmuting the system is
- 10:59really what it's doing
- 11:01Everything's already on.
- 11:03I believe we have a wake-up thing that
- 11:04we do,
- 11:05and it's not a press here to begin
- 11:06all the time.
- 11:07It gets you to the page where it's
- 11:08not the screensaver.
- 11:09Wait, what's it say?
- 11:09Press here to wake up?
- 11:11Press here to wake up?
- 11:11That's cheating.
- 11:12I think it's just a logo.
- 11:14So you have a press to begin is
- 11:15what you're saying.
- 11:18It doesn't do anything.
- 11:19Ours just says screensaver or whatever the
- 11:20hell it is.
- 11:21Get out of that.
- 11:21Screensaver?
- 11:22Ooh, screensaver.
- 11:23Not that we've tried it.
- 11:24It just goes into its...
- 11:26It goes into off mode when not being
- 11:28used.
- 11:28It's not just burning away.
- 11:29So you do have to wake it up
- 11:31of some sort.
- 11:32So the motion.
- 11:33Don't find the motion when you walk up
- 11:35to it.
- 11:35Right.
- 11:36Whatever.
- 11:37That's fine.
- 11:37So we get out of that.
- 11:38And then when we're there,
- 11:38you're presented with the sources in the
- 11:40room.
- 11:41Volume up, volume down and off.
- 11:43Right.
- 11:44Yes.
- 11:44That is the bare minimum that should be
- 11:46required.
- 11:47Right.
- 11:50I'm playing that hand.
- 11:52Must you need more than that?
- 11:53No.
- 11:54That's it.
- 11:55Like ours says,
- 11:57choose the source you want to use.
- 11:59Computer, laptop, whatever.
- 12:01Click that, everything turns on.
- 12:02I want to just choose microphone.
- 12:03What if I just want audio and not
- 12:05the projector on?
- 12:06You reach up and turn on the microphone?
- 12:09There you go.
- 12:10Audio only, right?
- 12:12I think what you're saying is if you
- 12:14want just the mic, it's on.
- 12:16Pick up the wireless mic and you talk
- 12:18and it works.
- 12:19Or press the button on the push to
- 12:21talk.
- 12:22So what do you do?
- 12:22You just leave your goosenecks on too all
- 12:24the time?
- 12:27It's on.
- 12:28It's push to talk.
- 12:29They can turn it off there if they
- 12:30want.
- 12:30Yeah, that's been a...
- 12:32problem just don't have those yeah they're
- 12:36i mean i don't know why yeah that's
- 12:37it's easier to solve for that we don't
- 12:38know i think it's great to have that
- 12:40built-in mic there because then it's
- 12:41available for when people forget to wear
- 12:42their law for the first half of their
- 12:44class but it doesn't introduce another
- 12:46layer of like something that's going to
- 12:48fail and fall apart so i'm not really
- 12:50talking about classes i'm talking about
- 12:51event spaces that are in large classrooms
- 12:55like called auditoriums okay okay so we've
- 12:58done this for the event style scenarios
- 13:03And I think that is a similar but
- 13:06different use case than, like,
- 13:09traditional class learning thing.
- 13:12Not saying they cannot be the same.
- 13:14I'm, like,
- 13:15in a forty-five person room here, blah,
- 13:17blah, blah, whatever.
- 13:17Like, that's my, in my mind,
- 13:19that's what I'm talking about here.
- 13:21Don't get hung up on the forty-five
- 13:22people.
- 13:24The size of it.
- 13:24What if it was forty six?
- 13:26No, that's a that's a large.
- 13:27Absolutely not.
- 13:28Nothing that I said.
- 13:29That's tier three.
- 13:30Yes.
- 13:31So so we have some sources.
- 13:33What else may find its way onto this
- 13:35touch panel?
- 13:36The PTZ camera is really what drives
- 13:38whether or not I have.
- 13:40Let's dive in.
- 13:40So I can call the preset one, two,
- 13:43six, twelve.
- 13:45What are we talking about?
- 13:46I do.
- 13:47I do PTZs with button panels all day
- 13:49long.
- 13:49I'm not saying you can't.
- 13:51Today,
- 13:52you are putting something on this touch
- 13:53panel, sir.
- 13:54What are you doing?
- 13:57Preset one, two, three.
- 13:59Okay.
- 13:59I'm into that.
- 14:00I can get behind that.
- 14:02And tracking on and off.
- 14:03Tracking on off, yeah.
- 14:04Tracking on off.
- 14:06You should never have tracking.
- 14:08No, they should always have tracking.
- 14:10Jamie.
- 14:12Tracking is the worst thing ever.
- 14:13We have more tickets on tracking than any
- 14:15other thing.
- 14:16It's dumb.
- 14:16It's stupid.
- 14:18Here's why I do tracking now.
- 14:19You're doing it wrong.
- 14:20Two reasons.
- 14:21One, the cost has come down.
- 14:22That delta is basically zero.
- 14:24It's not a cost.
- 14:25It's not a cost.
- 14:26It works better.
- 14:26It works a lot better.
- 14:28Two, they have gotten better.
- 14:29They work well enough that most people
- 14:32just leave.
- 14:33I'd say good.
- 14:34I'd say I'd one step your well enough
- 14:37to good.
- 14:37Okay.
- 14:38I'd say it's not great.
- 14:40Not great.
- 14:41It works good.
- 14:42One hundred is perfect.
- 14:43Seven.
- 14:43Where are we at?
- 14:44Seven.
- 14:45Out of a hundred?
- 14:46Seven.
- 14:46Seven out of a hundred?
- 14:47Out of what?
- 14:48I don't know what.
- 14:48Seven out of ten?
- 14:50I would say it's in that, Justin.
- 14:52Out of a hundred, it's seventy.
- 14:53Okay.
- 14:53I want to say I'm solidly in the,
- 14:55I was thinking eighty percent.
- 14:56Thirty percent of you is I'm getting
- 14:57tickets.
- 14:58Yeah, seventy.
- 14:58I don't get tickets.
- 14:59And that's why you have the button to
- 15:00turn it off.
- 15:01Okay.
- 15:01Yeah, exactly.
- 15:02I'm not going to.
- 15:03Ours is not happening.
- 15:05I have too much old stock to be
- 15:06able to do that yet.
- 15:08I'm not saying go throw all the other
- 15:09ones away, but moving forward,
- 15:11why wouldn't you?
- 15:12Because it sucks.
- 15:15It doesn't suck.
- 15:16Update your firmware.
- 15:19Buy different cameras.
- 15:20Real quick, just for tallying's sake,
- 15:23how many sources do we have?
- 15:25This is not a whole conversation around
- 15:27how many you need, but I'm saying three.
- 15:32Three?
- 15:32Sometimes there's a fourth, and I hate it.
- 15:35Because it's the worst kind.
- 15:36So we have three source buttons.
- 15:38Maybe an on slash off,
- 15:40or is it just an off?
- 15:41Okay, I'm going to give you that.
- 15:43On slash off, generic power, whatever.
- 15:48Power off only appears when it's on.
- 15:51And then three presets maybe,
- 15:53and a tracking on off?
- 15:57this is where it gets dicey because
- 15:59depending on how many cameras you have in
- 16:01the room wait a minute are you doing
- 16:04presets like under camera one do I have
- 16:06preset you know one two three and you
- 16:08know so is it like to show me
- 16:11let's pull this out when I hit a
- 16:12preset it switches a camera and a location
- 16:15of that camera right and that's the fair
- 16:18way to do it where's your second camera
- 16:22see it's not Jamie's language you don't
- 16:24control it you just leave it wide
- 16:28I will do a wide and a close
- 16:30and then a see students or whatever
- 16:32equivalent of that is.
- 16:33Correct.
- 16:34And it switches the camera and moves the
- 16:36camera all in one shot.
- 16:37What about in larger rooms where that wide
- 16:39shot of the students,
- 16:40now you're seeing tiny little heads,
- 16:42so maybe you want a couple of shots
- 16:43across the room?
- 16:44No.
- 16:45Where?
- 16:45For what?
- 16:46Why?
- 16:47That gets into another complexity level.
- 16:50Who's doing that?
- 16:50Who's moving that?
- 16:51I'm just saying,
- 16:52these are the sorts of things which all
- 16:53of a sudden you end up with touch
- 16:55panels with twenty seven thousand buttons.
- 16:56Yeah.
- 16:56This is how you have the full integrators
- 16:58take.
- 16:59Well, the module has all these things.
- 17:00It's just a page flip to the advanced.
- 17:02Right.
- 17:03Oh, I want full iris.
- 17:04So when you think about it.
- 17:06Color manual.
- 17:07If I'm in a big room,
- 17:08there's five hundred people there and
- 17:10you're trying to home in on a section
- 17:11of students.
- 17:12As a presenter, live in the room,
- 17:14your eyes,
- 17:15you don't have binoculars where you're
- 17:16like, you back there, question.
- 17:18It doesn't work that way.
- 17:19It doesn't work like that.
- 17:20Well, that's not a good location.
- 17:21You're seeing the whole room anyway.
- 17:23This is not a good location for a
- 17:24student cam anyway.
- 17:25The audience camera should just see the
- 17:27whole room just like the presenter would.
- 17:30What is the tangent?
- 17:32Let's spend one minute here and come back.
- 17:34What is the use of that student-facing
- 17:37camera?
- 17:38For guest lecturers coming in on Zoom.
- 17:41For anybody who's remote to be able to
- 17:43see what's going on in the room.
- 17:44Yes.
- 17:44That's it.
- 17:45It's not about who is in the room.
- 17:47Okay.
- 17:48I'm going to use this against you all
- 17:49later on.
- 17:49Okay.
- 17:50I don't care.
- 17:50You always try to do this.
- 17:52Larry, back me up on this.
- 17:54If you have some sort of...
- 17:55I don't know.
- 17:56Larry's like, nope, nope.
- 17:58Can't guarantee that.
- 17:59Before the show,
- 17:59we were talking about rooms with only one
- 18:01camera.
- 18:01And it's like,
- 18:01it seems to me you need a camera
- 18:03at the front to see the people in
- 18:04the room because how are they
- 18:05participating with anybody who's remote?
- 18:06I thought this was a touch panel
- 18:08conversation.
- 18:08It is.
- 18:09Well, we're all over the place.
- 18:10I promised you.
- 18:11One minute tangent.
- 18:11We're coming back.
- 18:12Okay, we're back to the touch panel.
- 18:13Now,
- 18:14you're asking all these questions and
- 18:15you're counting on your fingers.
- 18:17Ten.
- 18:18But he's forgotten at least two.
- 18:20Which ones are those?
- 18:21Well, but I don't understand.
- 18:22Press here to begin.
- 18:24No.
- 18:24Video mute, audio mute.
- 18:29Are all these buttons always available all
- 18:31the time?
- 18:34As of right now, yes.
- 18:35Everything is flat.
- 18:36No.
- 18:37They're all flashing because they want
- 18:39your attention.
- 18:41Only if they're muted.
- 18:42I like mine to move around.
- 18:44I don't like my buttons to ever be
- 18:45in the same spot.
- 18:47I do have Clippy pop up all the
- 18:49time and remind you what all the buttons
- 18:51do.
- 18:52just in case you're trying to mute your
- 18:54mic it's a big transparent one that covers
- 18:57up all the other buttons right and you
- 18:58can't get can't get rid of it because
- 18:59the x is actually underneath the right in
- 19:03in a normal situation everything's flat i
- 19:05don't i we have not no met the
- 19:07threshold of any paid clips or advanced
- 19:10yet okay no you say no why convince
- 19:12me otherwise sir where are we at no
- 19:14because not all features are available at
- 19:16all times
- 19:17all features what are we talking about no
- 19:19so tease that out okay um so we
- 19:22have on on just the main just the
- 19:24primary main screen is this right and he
- 19:26starts digging his hole i think there's no
- 19:28hole i'm doing it right um just pull
- 19:32us down in this thing look just because
- 19:34you're trying to climb on my shoulders to
- 19:36be better doesn't mean i'm in the hole
- 19:39You're in Missouri.
- 19:41Ooh.
- 19:41Comes from the guy from Kentucky.
- 19:43That lives in Missouri.
- 19:44Right.
- 19:45Okay, anyway.
- 19:46It's a different level of...
- 19:47We are a different level of redneck here,
- 19:49buddy.
- 19:49Exactly what functions aren't available on
- 19:53your panel?
- 19:54I'm curious.
- 19:54Okay, so, in my case, right?
- 19:57You got a shutter?
- 19:58You still doing shutter?
- 19:59If... No,
- 20:00but that drives me absolutely bonkers.
- 20:02I bet you're doing shutter.
- 20:02Or projector mute or freeze.
- 20:04Bullshit.
- 20:05Freeze is stupid.
- 20:06People will die on the hill of freeze.
- 20:08Oh, it's stupid.
- 20:10We have to do it.
- 20:11Nope.
- 20:12It's requested by faculty.
- 20:14No.
- 20:15Right.
- 20:15So when you come in, it's like,
- 20:17you know, choose your source, PC, laptop,
- 20:19whatever the other thing is.
- 20:21Right.
- 20:22And then on the bottom section is,
- 20:25to Larry's point,
- 20:25there's the microphone mute,
- 20:26like the master,
- 20:27if there's a student microphone,
- 20:29the main mic mute.
- 20:30Is that mic mute versus audio mute?
- 20:32Are those different?
- 20:33Yes, because there is room.
- 20:36Because we want the mic mute,
- 20:40especially if they're ceiling microphones
- 20:41for students, for privacy purposes.
- 20:46It's just one quick button,
- 20:47and it's usually attached to whatever...
- 20:49It's all just one quick button.
- 20:50You can't use that as your...
- 20:51It's attached to the arcade button.
- 20:53So does your one Pac-Man button do all
- 20:55these things?
- 20:56No, that's a completely different deal.
- 20:58But the mic mute is attached to the
- 21:02push button,
- 21:03so they can hit the push button and
- 21:04turn on and off the mic mute.
- 21:07Is this an auxiliary push button?
- 21:09Like you've got a sidecar?
- 21:10Yeah, it's separate.
- 21:12So they can just put their hand on
- 21:14the mic.
- 21:14It's three-D printed and on the side of
- 21:15the touch panel.
- 21:17I've done that too.
- 21:19And then there's a volume thing that
- 21:22brings up the volume slider like it would
- 21:24on your phone.
- 21:25If you hit volume or something,
- 21:27it brings up the slider.
- 21:28But it goes away because it doesn't need
- 21:29to be up there all the time.
- 21:31It usually never gets touched.
- 21:32Most anybody, nobody touches it.
- 21:34That's true.
- 21:35So it's just like your phone.
- 21:37It pops up a little slider,
- 21:38and you move the slider,
- 21:39and you go back.
- 21:41The volume thing, the program volume,
- 21:42the output volume,
- 21:43whatever you want to call it,
- 21:43your room source volume,
- 21:47Way back in the day,
- 21:48I think Crestron made one as well.
- 21:49Like,
- 21:50Extron had one with a knob on it,
- 21:51which I missed because you never have to
- 21:54tell anybody what the knob does.
- 21:55Yes.
- 21:56And it's saved putting crap on your
- 21:58panels.
- 21:59I wish Biamp would make that tech X
- 22:01thing actually functional.
- 22:03Hold on.
- 22:06Stick with me, right?
- 22:08At this point, there's five buttons.
- 22:10That's it.
- 22:11Now, if you go...
- 22:12You're six foot down right now.
- 22:14But the cameras are only available to the
- 22:17room PC.
- 22:18So when you hit PC,
- 22:20it actually tells you, hey,
- 22:21use your sign-in to log in.
- 22:22Oh, so you're hiding things now.
- 22:24It's just a layer that pops up on
- 22:26top of it.
- 22:26I don't necessarily disagree with that.
- 22:28It's a layer that pops up,
- 22:29and on that layer is usually...
- 22:31Now we have the camera features or the
- 22:33extra mic things.
- 22:33It's for the zoomification of...
- 22:37Since I have double screens, it also says,
- 22:39see left screen, see right screen.
- 22:41Show left, show right,
- 22:43or the camera presets.
- 22:44No, you're not doing that, right?
- 22:46Yeah, all the time.
- 22:48So they have to go within a source
- 22:50to select their source?
- 22:52Get them, Larry!
- 22:53What do you mean?
- 22:54Well, if they hit PC,
- 22:55but they want to show the left screen
- 22:57versus the right screen,
- 22:58that's a sub-menu, just a selection.
- 22:59So, when you hit PC,
- 23:02there is a menu that says show left,
- 23:04show right.
- 23:04But now it's already showing the left.
- 23:06They get to choose the right.
- 23:07You know what would be amazing?
- 23:08If we had technology to actually, like,
- 23:10pull this up and do a screen share.
- 23:12I know that would suck for you audio-only
- 23:14people.
- 23:14So...
- 23:15Well, we could.
- 23:16I'm with you on this.
- 23:17But none of this crap has to be
- 23:19on the main page.
- 23:20None of it.
- 23:21None of it needs to be anywhere.
- 23:23We've already determined that.
- 23:25But if you have multiple monitors,
- 23:27you have to have a way to change
- 23:29it.
- 23:29So do you put multiple monitors on the
- 23:31main page?
- 23:32Jamie, I want to ask something.
- 23:34What?
- 23:35I'm an instructor in your room.
- 23:37I'm sharing something on my right screen.
- 23:39Correct.
- 23:40And now I want to bounce and show
- 23:42something on the document camera.
- 23:44I hit that button.
- 23:45Why would you do that?
- 23:46Because the document camera is USB only.
- 23:48Are you going to tell your faculty that?
- 23:50Document camera is USB only.
- 23:55I hit that button.
- 23:57Is there any way to show the right
- 23:59screen of the PC again without showing the
- 24:02left screen first?
- 24:07As soon as I hit the PC,
- 24:08it's going to pull up the left screen.
- 24:09That's what you said, right?
- 24:10No, it remembers the last one was on.
- 24:13I think what he says is the default
- 24:14state on boot is left screen showing.
- 24:16Yeah,
- 24:16but it remembers whatever the last one you
- 24:18were on.
- 24:19So if you were on PowerPoint presentation
- 24:20mode and you're switching between your
- 24:23dual screen and your laptop and your
- 24:25fucking dot cam,
- 24:26then you're quite possibly
- 24:27overcomplicating this whole stupid thing
- 24:29anyway and you should rethink your
- 24:30approach to teaching.
- 24:31But I would like to also allow the
- 24:32students to share through my wireless
- 24:34sharing gateway.
- 24:35Oh, yeah, because that'd be smart.
- 24:36That'd be the best thing ever.
- 24:38And while we're at it,
- 24:39can we go ahead and broadcast this thing
- 24:40over YouTube so that way...
- 24:42Auntie Mama can call in from wherever and
- 24:45say, you said a bad word.
- 24:48But it needs to also be routable to
- 24:49the room next door.
- 24:51Right.
- 24:51Yes.
- 24:51This is all dumb.
- 24:53But you have to hit both panels at
- 24:54exactly the same time.
- 24:55Three, two, one, turn.
- 24:56Damn it.
- 24:56Try again.
- 24:56No, no, no.
- 24:59But I do.
- 25:00I try to.
- 25:01That means that main page has to be
- 25:04as clean as possible.
- 25:05And then some of these other features,
- 25:07they don't need to be available all the
- 25:08time,
- 25:08which is where everybody gets into
- 25:09trouble.
- 25:10Why do you need cameras on the main
- 25:12page?
- 25:12Why do you need people to reroute their
- 25:13monitor?
- 25:15Because you have two,
- 25:16but you only have one projector.
- 25:17But one of them should never be routable
- 25:18away from the computer.
- 25:19Why?
- 25:21So you always see the computer.
- 25:24But why?
- 25:25You can.
- 25:26You just flip back and forth.
- 25:28Now you can queue up on one and
- 25:29put up the other.
- 25:30Now you can have PowerPoint presentation
- 25:32mode.
- 25:33Now if you're in Zoom,
- 25:34you can show the gallery and or your
- 25:36PowerPoint.
- 25:39I get you on that.
- 25:41I hear you.
- 25:41There's only one screen.
- 25:42You've got to be able to go back
- 25:43and forth.
- 25:43Real quick question for you, Jamie.
- 25:44Larry, you just raised your hand.
- 25:45That doesn't work.
- 25:46I've got another question for him after
- 25:47your question.
- 25:48All right.
- 25:48So my quick question was you said when
- 25:50some of the information,
- 25:52I think we all are guilty of this
- 25:53at times.
- 25:54some of the information that is specific
- 25:56to a source is only available when that
- 25:58source, you select that source,
- 26:00you see some information on it,
- 26:01maybe there's additional controls,
- 26:02whatever that is.
- 26:03When you go to a source that has
- 26:04no additional controls or features or
- 26:06whatever, like, you know, your laptop,
- 26:07for example,
- 26:08do you put up one of my favorite
- 26:10pet peeves?
- 26:11There are no additional controls for this
- 26:13source or whatever, you know,
- 26:14like that explainer page that means
- 26:15nothing.
- 26:16It's like,
- 26:16why are you complicating things?
- 26:17No, it just, it just,
- 26:18demonstrates that the source is selected.
- 26:20So it's highlighted.
- 26:21You know what you could do?
- 26:22Whatever.
- 26:22The button is in its on state.
- 26:24Justin, say live preview.
- 26:25Say live preview.
- 26:26Say live preview.
- 26:27This comes from the guy that uses remote
- 26:29controls with the buttons cut off of it.
- 26:32Put some words there that they could read.
- 26:35Reading words on how to do extended
- 26:38desktop from the laptop, quick keys,
- 26:41and some quick troubleshooting right
- 26:42there.
- 26:43That saved our ass.
- 26:44Along that same lines,
- 26:46I will show pictures of the connection.
- 26:49For the laptop,
- 26:51I'll show a picture of where it is
- 26:52located on the lectern so that they can
- 26:55select it.
- 26:56Yeah, when you hit laptop,
- 26:57there are other instructions on there.
- 26:59Like, hey, if you're using Windows,
- 27:00do this thing.
- 27:01If you're using an Apple,
- 27:02make sure you do this.
- 27:03You just said there was nothing there.
- 27:05Yeah, you did.
- 27:06Speaking of not being there.
- 27:10Justin,
- 27:10he's changing it in real time while he's
- 27:11doing it right now.
- 27:12No, but some other ones you don't have.
- 27:15Doesn't matter.
- 27:16So your camera controls,
- 27:17that only show up on the PC?
- 27:20Yes.
- 27:22I thought your rooms were set up that
- 27:23the laptop and the PC can both do
- 27:27zoom calls.
- 27:28Lies!
- 27:29In the ones that are capable of,
- 27:31they are now...
- 27:32Both of those selections would invoke the
- 27:36camera controls.
- 27:37I don't do a lot of PTCs anymore.
- 27:39They're mostly box cams with, you know,
- 27:42zoom in, zoom out.
- 27:43Yeah, it's medium shot, nose hair shot,
- 27:48right?
- 27:49How close can it go?
- 27:51I don't understand why we have to buy
- 27:52box cams with a thirty-time zoom on them.
- 27:54I'm confused because Jamie has like three
- 27:56buttons,
- 27:56but every button exposes more buttons.
- 27:59The question is,
- 28:00your total button count on your touch
- 28:03panel is... Eighteen.
- 28:07Eighteen buttons.
- 28:08We haven't even gotten to the idea of
- 28:09a tech page yet.
- 28:11Oh, that's... There is no tech page.
- 28:14Why?
- 28:16for advanced features into hide crap.
- 28:18You're going to make your tech sign in.
- 28:21There's no reason for a tech page.
- 28:22Like, well, I did a room check,
- 28:24so I'm going to sign into the touch
- 28:25panel.
- 28:26Next,
- 28:26you're going to say there's nothing on it.
- 28:28It's just a QR code,
- 28:29and you do it all from your phone.
- 28:30Yeah, InfoSec loves that.
- 28:33That's what I do for the tech page,
- 28:34actually.
- 28:34It's just a QR code.
- 28:36It's for the technicians all.
- 28:37They can just go in there and scan
- 28:39it and go right to the tech page.
- 28:41It's technicians only.
- 28:43So so let me give an example of
- 28:45what I would consider a technician focused
- 28:47feature that I do like to put on
- 28:49touch panels and things that is hidden
- 28:51away.
- 28:51However,
- 28:52you want to get to your secret hidden
- 28:53page, which everybody knows,
- 28:55press and hold on the university logo and
- 28:57then put in nineteen eighty eight because
- 28:58that works everywhere.
- 28:59Yes.
- 29:00And a bunch of people just got pissed.
- 29:03What about advanced features like
- 29:04resetting POE-powered devices or I want
- 29:08PDU control on that page?
- 29:10Why wouldn't I put that there?
- 29:11If I'm going to expose it remotely to
- 29:12people in the service desk,
- 29:14why wouldn't I put it there if someone's
- 29:15in the room?
- 29:18One,
- 29:19you shouldn't have that in there anyway,
- 29:20but two, no.
- 29:22You've never had to recycle a POE-powered
- 29:24device?
- 29:25I don't have smart PDUs.
- 29:28Yeah, you go in there and you clunk,
- 29:30clunk, done.
- 29:32Finished.
- 29:33Clunk a clunk.
- 29:34Clunk.
- 29:35You hit the big red switch.
- 29:36Done.
- 29:37Every time I say that about flipping a
- 29:39rocker,
- 29:39you guys are giving me shit about that
- 29:41too.
- 29:42Smart PDUs.
- 29:43That's a waste of money.
- 29:44They're three hundred dollars.
- 29:47Right.
- 29:47That I could use for other things like
- 29:49arcade buttons.
- 29:51You literally have the flat network that
- 29:54allows them to be used.
- 29:56So Jamie calls his network team and has
- 29:57them reboot it.
- 30:00Well, let's...
- 30:01deviates later.
- 30:02Chris, you brought it up prior.
- 30:03Uh-oh.
- 30:04And...
- 30:06Are any of you,
- 30:08and if one of you listening is doing
- 30:10this,
- 30:10are you doing the live stream nonsense?
- 30:15Live preview?
- 30:16No, never.
- 30:16I've not done live preview to a touchdown
- 30:18since like,
- 30:19you can do live feed and RSS feeds
- 30:21directly on this thing or whatever it is.
- 30:23Only when I need to impress somebody.
- 30:25Larry's going to give us the shit right
- 30:27now.
- 30:27Classrooms,
- 30:28I will do that because I want them
- 30:30to be able to set up the camera
- 30:31before they take it.
- 30:34I don't allow that either.
- 30:36They don't have to,
- 30:37but they can go to the camera.
- 30:40You know you can do that in Zoom.
- 30:42They actually get less camera controls in
- 30:45some of those rooms because they are
- 30:46overburdened with too many other things to
- 30:48deal with.
- 30:52The next phase,
- 30:53they're not getting those anymore.
- 30:54I'm going to automate it.
- 30:56You're doing it for camera.
- 30:59Camera preview sort of thing.
- 31:00Go ahead.
- 31:02I have a question.
- 31:05Are you doing any of these?
- 31:06Before you ask your question,
- 31:09do you do anything at the touch panel?
- 31:12You're just sitting there just
- 31:14bad-mouthing us?
- 31:14He only does large venues.
- 31:16Stadiums are larger.
- 31:17I haven't been bad-mouthing.
- 31:18I've been listening to your antics.
- 31:20I haven't been saying anything.
- 31:21I've just been sitting back like a fly
- 31:23on the wall.
- 31:23Now I've got a question.
- 31:27In your live preview...
- 31:31Now you distracted me.
- 31:32You guys did this on purpose.
- 31:33Sabotage.
- 31:35I don't know.
- 31:36Something about life.
- 31:36No live previews.
- 31:37No.
- 31:37Why wouldn't you do that through Zoom or
- 31:39Teams?
- 31:41You don't need it on your touch panel.
- 31:42You pull up Zoom or Teams.
- 31:44It gives you the live preview of your
- 31:45camera.
- 31:46You can make adjustments there when you
- 31:48run the app.
- 31:49Why do you need a secondary...
- 31:51In the high-fledged rooms,
- 31:52it's so they can set up the camera
- 31:54before they take the shot.
- 31:55It's separate.
- 31:56For what?
- 32:02It's primarily being used in rooms where I
- 32:05have multiple cameras and I have the
- 32:07ability for a technical director to run it
- 32:10outside of the instructor.
- 32:14Your classrooms have a technical director
- 32:15now?
- 32:16Only in a couple of our larger HyFlex
- 32:18spaces.
- 32:18Whoa, HyFlex, what?
- 32:19Because a lot of those spaces,
- 32:21they'll have tag team instructors where
- 32:24one person is managing the online class
- 32:27and the technology and the other one's
- 32:29teaching the class.
- 32:30We don't.
- 32:31That sounds complicated.
- 32:31So I have some of those as well,
- 32:33but we don't usually put that on the
- 32:35touch panel.
- 32:35They have all the software.
- 32:38What about its weird cousin?
- 32:41You can have a whole browser on here.
- 32:43No.
- 32:43No.
- 32:46Okay.
- 32:47Only if that browser has an AI chatbot
- 32:50that can pull stuff from the knowledge
- 32:52base.
- 32:52Sure, that sounds great.
- 32:53No.
- 32:53I mean,
- 32:55you all understand what I'm saying, right?
- 32:56I mean, you're using Zoom for this, Larry?
- 32:58Is that correct?
- 32:59Zoom, I guess?
- 33:00I am using Zoom, but again,
- 33:01the cameras have multiple cameras,
- 33:03and they can set up the camera that's
- 33:04not going to Zoom live.
- 33:06Okay, so when you start a Zoom.
- 33:09Maybe this is just me.
- 33:11It comes up with a preview window before
- 33:13you go into the meeting.
- 33:14Okay.
- 33:16Yeah, but this doesn't happen before.
- 33:18No, no, let him go.
- 33:19We're going to tear him down here in
- 33:21a minute.
- 33:21Yeah, okay.
- 33:22No, that was it.
- 33:24The preview window is now on your computer
- 33:27before you get into the meeting.
- 33:29That way you can adjust your camera there
- 33:31and not get it back through the touch
- 33:33panel.
- 33:34Once you're in the meeting and you have
- 33:35five cameras,
- 33:36how do you adjust the third one?
- 33:39That.
- 33:42Why would you do that?
- 33:44Okay, next.
- 33:46So he talks to his technical director.
- 33:48Why would you do that?
- 33:49Do any of you have the routing table?
- 33:53Take input one and two, output three,
- 33:55five, and seven.
- 33:56Do any of you put the whole routing
- 33:58table?
- 33:58Advanced routing page?
- 34:00You're talking about Dante controller?
- 34:03Well, same.
- 34:04Same principle.
- 34:04It is a matrix, yeah.
- 34:07I'm guilty of that in spaces.
- 34:09But we do have an event center where
- 34:10they have a full.
- 34:12Yeah, I guess, yeah.
- 34:14And Larry,
- 34:15do you call that the tech page?
- 34:18It is a touch panel mounted to the
- 34:22AV rack.
- 34:22So it's not out there in the main.
- 34:24Oh,
- 34:24you have to go back in the room
- 34:25where you can't see what you're actually
- 34:26doing.
- 34:27You got to go back and do that.
- 34:29So how is that exposed to the user,
- 34:30though?
- 34:31It's not one of my spaces.
- 34:32Okay.
- 34:33I was like, that's a normal classroom.
- 34:35That's an event space.
- 34:36We do have an event space that has
- 34:38like the user panel,
- 34:39but it shows like on projector a and
- 34:42then the four wall boxes and you choose
- 34:44whichever wall box you want to use for
- 34:45that.
- 34:46But in the back room,
- 34:47it's the matrix thing.
- 34:48Yeah, the routing your touch panels are.
- 34:51I'm shocked.
- 34:55I don't think we are as guilty as
- 34:57other folks because I have seen some
- 34:59complex such panels.
- 35:01When we talk about the old VTC days
- 35:04and all the aspects of making calls, dial,
- 35:07all that other wackadoo stuff.
- 35:08Dial pad.
- 35:08And I've really scaled back because there
- 35:10was a long time.
- 35:12Now, what am I routing to people?
- 35:13What am I routing to content?
- 35:14Which camera am I sending to where?
- 35:15Yeah.
- 35:17I did in the past.
- 35:18I was very guilty of having,
- 35:20if you could control it by God,
- 35:21we were going to try to control it.
- 35:24Because we didn't bring up Blu-ray or
- 35:26DVDs.
- 35:27Oh, I have those too.
- 35:29Who's doing transport controls?
- 35:31Come on.
- 35:32Going back to your preview window,
- 35:34how are you switching the preview versus
- 35:36what's actually getting sent out to Zoom?
- 35:39Because if you have five cameras in a
- 35:42room,
- 35:43Like, okay, camera four.
- 35:45No.
- 35:45You got to bring that.
- 35:46Are you showing all previews of all
- 35:49cameras at the same time?
- 35:50I'll never have five cameras in a room.
- 35:54Like, how many cameras you got going on?
- 35:56In that room, I have four.
- 35:58Okay, so.
- 35:58Four cameras in it,
- 35:59and that was the first one.
- 36:01It's overbuilt because the place it was
- 36:04replacing, and this is a tangent,
- 36:06so we can just cut it here.
- 36:07You're down.
- 36:09You finished.
- 36:09You're down.
- 36:10The room we were replacing.
- 36:11You stepped in this.
- 36:14Did you all have those distance education
- 36:17spaces that was permanently staffed by a
- 36:21full-time person that all they did was
- 36:24white glove the distance education
- 36:26program?
- 36:26Did they or do we currently?
- 36:28Okay, we used to, and then they retired,
- 36:33and I was tasked with creating something
- 36:35that looks like it could be done like
- 36:37that,
- 36:38but will be automated and let the
- 36:39instructors do it themselves.
- 36:41We've talked about this on our show one
- 36:42time,
- 36:42when you have to put those mechanical
- 36:44touch points in to comply with that
- 36:47physical intervention layer.
- 36:48So it's overbuilt.
- 36:50Eventually you remove them because
- 36:52everybody realizes that that was dumb.
- 36:54How do you deal with switching preview
- 36:56versus what's actually getting sent out,
- 36:58though?
- 36:59I have,
- 37:00it's SDI coming out of all my cameras.
- 37:02They're going to two switchers.
- 37:04There's going to a preview switcher.
- 37:05No, what's the buttons on the touch panel?
- 37:06Like, what's the actual buttons to make?
- 37:09Because you have the preview window there
- 37:11that shows one camera, right?
- 37:13Yeah.
- 37:13So you select the camera to see.
- 37:16And then you say take.
- 37:18You don't say tape.
- 37:19Do you really?
- 37:20There it is.
- 37:20You've got to throw the T-bar.
- 37:22Mine is a preview page and a regular
- 37:25page.
- 37:25Star wipe?
- 37:25Star wipe?
- 37:28Okay.
- 37:29So your preview buttons,
- 37:31you hit camera one, two, three, four,
- 37:33and seventy, whatever.
- 37:34Yep, and you can just look through.
- 37:36And you set your view,
- 37:38and then how do you,
- 37:39do you just have a go button and
- 37:40it switches the camera after you get it?
- 37:42No, you go back to your program page.
- 37:43Oh, my God.
- 37:45That's even worse.
- 37:46It says PGM.
- 37:46It says PGM.
- 37:47Just take it.
- 37:50FTB.
- 37:51Mark's being quiet for a reason.
- 37:52He's holding back.
- 37:53Matt, this is amazing.
- 37:54Larry,
- 37:54are there upstream and downstream keys on
- 37:56this?
- 37:56I mean, how are you?
- 37:57No,
- 37:57it's going to come back here in a
- 37:59minute.
- 37:59There's the previews,
- 38:00and then your main page where you select
- 38:01them.
- 38:02You don't have to do the preview first.
- 38:04You can just take the camera.
- 38:05Larry, how big is this fly pack?
- 38:10I managed to get all of this on
- 38:11a forty inch touch screen I mean we're
- 38:13okay I envision his lectern in the space
- 38:16is like there's three guys there and
- 38:18they've all got ponytails and
- 38:20Larry feels attacked.
- 38:22A producer who's just in the background.
- 38:27He's got to have a piece of paper
- 38:28and be like, hey,
- 38:28we got a break in four minutes.
- 38:30I got to pay the bills.
- 38:32Camera two, ready?
- 38:32Camera two, go.
- 38:33This is one weird one.
- 38:35All right, back to touch panels.
- 38:37Back to regular touch panels.
- 38:39Mark,
- 38:39you've been scoffing this whole damn time.
- 38:41Spit it out, buddy.
- 38:43So in the standardized room that we were
- 38:45talking about, we had the sources,
- 38:48the volume up, volume down.
- 38:49I wanted to dive into that program versus
- 38:51microphone conversation because are
- 38:54there...
- 38:55Four to six buttons dedicated to those two
- 38:58features.
- 38:59Volume up, down,
- 39:00mute for program and volume up, down,
- 39:04mute for microphone.
- 39:04Oh, there's no volume up,
- 39:05down for microphone.
- 39:06Why am I letting them control microphones?
- 39:08There's the question.
- 39:09They don't control microphones.
- 39:11They get to hear them or not hear
- 39:12them.
- 39:13Guess where I put that.
- 39:16That's on the tech page.
- 39:17Oh, no.
- 39:19You really have a tech page?
- 39:20Yeah,
- 39:20that's called open up your laptop and log
- 39:23on to the DSP.
- 39:24Yeah, my techs have that page,
- 39:26so they don't need a tech page.
- 39:28So some of you may have heard you
- 39:31have help support features on said touch
- 39:34panels.
- 39:34Is that true?
- 39:35Yeah.
- 39:37Let me give you a bit of history.
- 39:39I have a help button that basically the
- 39:41help button brings up a thing that says
- 39:44call.
- 39:46Yeah,
- 39:47do you use your touch panels to invoke
- 39:48support?
- 39:49No, it's just,
- 39:49it's basically the information.
- 39:51Yeah, so years ago,
- 39:53I inherited a whole bunch of spaces where
- 39:55that was the option.
- 39:56Oh, help, what sort, I'm not shitting you,
- 39:58page flip,
- 39:59what sort of help would you like?
- 40:01I'm having trouble with my, you know,
- 40:03audio, a video, a projector,
- 40:05all these different things.
- 40:05Now,
- 40:05they all went to the same exact place.
- 40:07So I think the idea was,
- 40:09ten years earlier, oh,
- 40:10we can log these as they come in,
- 40:13and then we'll know what sort of help
- 40:14requests we get most often.
- 40:17now of course because they all go to
- 40:18the same place and there was no stepper
- 40:20or delay between these people realized
- 40:22they could mash every button and now they
- 40:24have like twenty seven swarm of tickets
- 40:26uh-huh oh there must be something really
- 40:29important going on in that room because
- 40:30they submitted nine tickets and so as i
- 40:33would modernize as i modernize these
- 40:35spaces um i well it lasted until fusion
- 40:38on prem died but um
- 40:41I would monitor these spaces by removing
- 40:42that.
- 40:42And so the help button now is more
- 40:44of a if you need help,
- 40:45here's how to request it through the help
- 40:47desk, here's the number to call,
- 40:48here's the QR code to scan, whatever.
- 40:50It's just an info page.
- 40:51Right?
- 40:52Because we want to drive everything
- 40:53through the through the help desk through
- 40:57the help desk.
- 40:57So there's a single source of contact at
- 40:59that point.
- 41:00But there is still that little question
- 41:02mark button or whatever it is on some
- 41:03of them that yeah, that's,
- 41:05that's still there.
- 41:06Yeah,
- 41:07it's just a pointer where to find help.
- 41:10Though, honestly,
- 41:11you can replace that now by putting that
- 41:12information on the main screen and just
- 41:15leaving it there all the time because
- 41:16that's all it's doing.
- 41:18But the template has a help button.
- 41:20Extra words.
- 41:21So we're up to, like, what?
- 41:22A couple of baker's dozens worth of
- 41:23buttons here now?
- 41:25It depends who you're talking to.
- 41:28Yeah.
- 41:28Most of my rooms that would have it
- 41:30would only have thirteen or so.
- 41:32I heard eighteen from somebody or
- 41:34something.
- 41:35I don't know.
- 41:36It's there-ish for most spaces.
- 41:40By the way,
- 41:41does anybody else have anything on this?
- 41:42Because I want to rattle through a couple
- 41:43of high-level things and get some
- 41:44feedback.
- 41:45Get in there.
- 41:46Go.
- 41:47What about the concept of labeling things
- 41:49and whatnot based on what the user's
- 41:51doing, not like the show laptop?
- 41:54I don't care about that.
- 41:54Am I teaching from my laptop?
- 41:58How are we labeling the source selection?
- 42:00HDMI one, two, three, four.
- 42:02And I hate that because what the hell
- 42:03is that?
- 42:03No, no, no.
- 42:05Please tell me.
- 42:08I was like, dude,
- 42:09we're going to have colors, not numbers.
- 42:11Yeah.
- 42:12Green, red, blue, orange.
- 42:15I'm colorblind.
- 42:17Shit.
- 42:17So is it show PC or is there
- 42:19a button that just says PC?
- 42:20Or do we not have PCs,
- 42:21but show laptop or is it a button
- 42:23that says laptop?
- 42:26Mine says choose what you're using today.
- 42:31PC, laptop, whatever else.
- 42:32It's just written above them.
- 42:34and then the buttons are below it really
- 42:37really small textures no it's giant i mean
- 42:39these things these buttons are the size of
- 42:41a they are dinner plate basically yes
- 42:44they're like they're like two inches by
- 42:46two inches so they go across that whole
- 42:48screen that cost five million dollars well
- 42:51for all his sub menus they don't actually
- 42:53like pop up beside it they just pop
- 42:55up inside not all not all one
- 43:00Okay.
- 43:01Yeah, it's... What else did you get?
- 43:03You had some other...
- 43:04Some other things on here.
- 43:05What was I going to do in here?
- 43:09Consistent terminology.
- 43:10I'm guilty of this as anybody's.
- 43:11You update spaces.
- 43:12The older ones say something else,
- 43:13and it's not great,
- 43:14but do you ever go back and try
- 43:16to
- 43:17make them all match i feel like that's
- 43:18like the the bane of touch panels like
- 43:21you will make a decision five years ago
- 43:23that you're in that somewhere you're like
- 43:24oh god that i have to go back
- 43:26and deal with all these updates now and
- 43:27it becomes a web page updating mark i
- 43:30got an idea let me sell you something
- 43:31i can put a control processor in a
- 43:34building and you update that once and
- 43:35update all the touch panels at the same
- 43:37time no problem yeah a single one that
- 43:39runs a whole building though yeah
- 43:41Perfect.
- 43:41Yeah.
- 43:42Solves the problem.
- 43:42Don't worry about it.
- 43:43Hey, by the way, manufacturers,
- 43:44talk to your sales engineers.
- 43:46And if the next time they suggest that,
- 43:49fire them.
- 43:50Because please stop that.
- 43:51I do all the firmware while we're at
- 43:53it.
- 43:53What could go wrong?
- 43:54Exactly.
- 43:54It'll keep track of your firmware and
- 43:56update all your- We need to do it
- 43:57at ten AM on a Tuesday.
- 43:58Mm-hmm .
- 43:59Oh, is that a bad time?
- 44:00I think touch panels across the classrooms
- 44:03over the years are very interesting.
- 44:04It's like that AV archeology we say when
- 44:06we do- It's like troubleshooting.
- 44:08As you get into a rack,
- 44:10you can see where all of the problems
- 44:11were or all of the things that you
- 44:13had to fix over the years.
- 44:14You're like, oh,
- 44:15I remember how we did this now.
- 44:17And you go into that room and you're
- 44:19like, oh, how is this still here?
- 44:21I made this in, like, eighteen years ago.
- 44:26How is this still here?
- 44:27That's every project on our campus.
- 44:29That's every project everywhere.
- 44:31That user interface,
- 44:32because sometimes you just kind of forget
- 44:34that there was a touch panel in there,
- 44:36or...
- 44:37It's not worth updating it.
- 44:39It's running.
- 44:40Why would I just go over there and
- 44:41update it?
- 44:41If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
- 44:43But then you see it, you're like, oh,
- 44:44my God,
- 44:45I should have come over here and updated
- 44:46this.
- 44:47Besides, I like Jet Two.
- 44:48See, look, the buttons are shiny.
- 44:50Jet Two is awful.
- 44:51I feel like touch panels,
- 44:53once you have one,
- 44:53you've just invested in immediate debt.
- 44:55You have to be on that thing because...
- 44:59All the time.
- 45:00You have to be on it all the
- 45:00time.
- 45:01It's a web page.
- 45:02You have to keep it up to date
- 45:03or it's going to just be this risky
- 45:05thing out there.
- 45:07We didn't even get into some of your
- 45:08shit touch panels, Mark.
- 45:11All the additional sources at the bottom
- 45:12that slide as you swipe.
- 45:14Oh, good God.
- 45:15You don't do that, do you?
- 45:16I remember those.
- 45:17I was like, what the crap, dude?
- 45:18We had an integrator who delivered those.
- 45:20It doesn't matter.
- 45:21They were on your campus, sir.
- 45:22Yeah, they existed.
- 45:23So those were like the active learning
- 45:24rooms where you had to like do the...
- 45:26No.
- 45:27Okay.
- 45:27To that regard, does anybody use those?
- 45:29IU had those too.
- 45:31It bugged the crap out of me.
- 45:32Do you use some of the gestures?
- 45:34Do you use... No.
- 45:35No, we got rid of those.
- 45:37I like to pinch to zoom to show
- 45:38the laptop,
- 45:39but then swipe left to show the PC
- 45:41and swipe right for doc cam.
- 45:43I wonder if anyone's ever done PTZ
- 45:44controls with gestures.
- 45:46i have tried well there's there's the
- 45:48old-fashioned remember the the video
- 45:50preview with the overlay and then you
- 45:52touch and it's always like two seconds
- 45:53behind and you're like and then like you
- 45:56know some of those cameras have gestures
- 45:58built into it is that what you're talking
- 46:00about or gesturing at the touch panel what
- 46:01were you talking about no you you could
- 46:04do it directly at the camera
- 46:06I would show you the gesture thing,
- 46:07but the camera I'm using actually has
- 46:09that, and I don't want to do it.
- 46:14I have tried the multi-touch zoom in,
- 46:17zoom out thing,
- 46:17and they're such a slow processor.
- 46:19It's terrible.
- 46:20It seems fraught with peril.
- 46:22It was my own.
- 46:23That was my own.
- 46:24I'm just playing around kind of.
- 46:27Just because we're unearthing some
- 46:29archaeological gems here,
- 46:30did any of you have the dinosaur days
- 46:33with rooms with multiple touch panels?
- 46:35Wait, wait, wait.
- 46:38Multiple touch panels of different
- 46:40manufacturers?
- 46:41Well, technically, yes.
- 46:43technically like so if you had your this
- 46:45is my tanberg panel and this is my
- 46:47restaurant oh but that's not even that old
- 46:51between them because if if you were i
- 46:53mean we are we already know that like
- 46:55for a while there zoom pulled all of
- 46:57their apis right and you had to have
- 46:59the zoom i was about to say touch
- 47:01panel and whatever room control touch
- 47:03panel because they didn't talk to each
- 47:05other cisco's terrible about it
- 47:08they're terrible about a lot of things go
- 47:09ahead and run the usb mode macro it's
- 47:12fine right so yeah the two touch panel
- 47:15thing oh my god we've had to do
- 47:18that for the zoom problem that we've had
- 47:21we somehow let it go back to one
- 47:22it's gonna work and we're just like it's
- 47:25just this quick start process and you're
- 47:27in to me that's like putting two steering
- 47:29wheels in a car like good luck
- 47:31Yeah, but one steers the right wheel.
- 47:36It's like those fire trucks where they got
- 47:37the guy in the back.
- 47:38Guy in the back, yeah.
- 47:40I'm Cisco.
- 47:44Every now and then he turns the other
- 47:45way just to drift.
- 47:46Okay, so that was a fun exercise.
- 47:49The only other thing I had on my
- 47:50list, I think we all agree,
- 47:51don't put the press to start or push
- 47:53here to bin again or whatever it is.
- 47:55Get rid of buttons.
- 47:55Just look at your touch panel and start
- 47:56deleting buttons.
- 47:58i'm fine with hiding on an advanced page
- 47:59but whatever um the other thing i would
- 48:02i'm trying to and i i'm guilty this
- 48:04is anybody but like the um the using
- 48:07like av technician or programmer language
- 48:10like you know what are you you know
- 48:12route here or something and that means
- 48:14nothing to nobody no um i do like
- 48:16preset one preset two preset one preset
- 48:18two which is like yeah what do you
- 48:21name yours
- 48:23Camera presets, what do you name them?
- 48:25I think I'm guilty of... Yeah,
- 48:30wide medium.
- 48:31Whiteboard.
- 48:32There it is.
- 48:33Whiteboard's a wrong answer, by the way,
- 48:36for that, Larry.
- 48:37You need to cut that shit out.
- 48:40This feels like another show.
- 48:41He only has that on his preview page.
- 48:44Leave him alone.
- 48:46What is the right answer for that,
- 48:47just so I know in the future?
- 48:50Put a whiteboard camera in.
- 48:51Well,
- 48:52I'm not using it to capture the
- 48:53whiteboard.
- 48:54Well, even if it was a whiteboard camera,
- 48:56it would still be labeled whiteboard when
- 48:57I press that button.
- 48:58It shows it.
- 48:59No,
- 48:59you don't have a button for whiteboard
- 49:01camera because that's on your PC.
- 49:01You're talking about USB only, not iMac.
- 49:04Yes.
- 49:05Not if you're doing the new stuff.
- 49:07It's a different conversation.
- 49:09I like using the term iMac on my
- 49:11pages, too.
- 49:13What is this?
- 49:13Because we're all a bunch of churches.
- 49:14I'm supposed to say iMac?
- 49:16What does that mean?
- 49:17I like to put, look at me.
- 49:19No, really, look at me.
- 49:22I label my cameras camera one and the
- 49:24other one.
- 49:26Not camera one.
- 49:27Not that one, the other one.
- 49:28No, the other one.
- 49:29Okay, do you label,
- 49:30if you have multiple displays,
- 49:32do you label them one, two, three, four,
- 49:33five, six?
- 49:35Or for instance,
- 49:36if you have two projectors and two
- 49:36displays.
- 49:37I label them north, south, east, and west.
- 49:38Do you though, do you?
- 49:40Cameras, do you label them that way?
- 49:43No.
- 49:45I always think it's funny when they do
- 49:46front back because that is that stage
- 49:51right or am I even when you put
- 49:53even if it's an interview,
- 49:55if you put presenter and you put,
- 49:57you know, students,
- 49:58sometimes they're like, well,
- 49:59is that the one that's over the students
- 50:00or is that the one that's over the
- 50:01one they can see or the one I
- 50:02can see of them?
- 50:03Mm hmm.
- 50:04right there's no audience view audience by
- 50:06the way and mark i don't know i
- 50:08don't know who came up with it but
- 50:09it it was at osu in link one
- 50:11hundred whoever came up with the plan
- 50:13about and i want to blame lenny but
- 50:15it may not be lenny who went and
- 50:16bought the mailbox letters yes to put we
- 50:19put it on the projector and on the
- 50:20displays when you have eight displays in a
- 50:21room that came out of the support we're
- 50:23like what
- 50:24That's like a sports bar.
- 50:25TV one, two, three.
- 50:27But it makes sense when someone's on the
- 50:28phone with you.
- 50:29The projector to the left.
- 50:30No, well, it's not all the way.
- 50:32It's by the door.
- 50:32Stakes left.
- 50:33But when you come in,
- 50:34it's to the right.
- 50:35If you have round rooms,
- 50:36you know what I'm talking about.
- 50:37That's all I'm going to tell you.
- 50:39And I've used that on active learnings
- 50:40moving forward.
- 50:41Like all the student pods,
- 50:42that says pod fourteen on it.
- 50:43That says pod three.
- 50:44Don't do fourteen pods.
- 50:45But whatever.
- 50:46You know what I mean.
- 50:46Put a big label on there.
- 50:49I've done just like print it out,
- 50:50laminate it,
- 50:50and have a student go stick them on
- 50:52the wall above each one.
- 50:53So it just...
- 50:53just to label those things.
- 50:55Yeah.
- 50:56Didn't they call.
- 50:57By the way,
- 50:58touch panels in active learning rooms
- 50:59don't give individual routing to things.
- 51:01Just like student group breakout mode,
- 51:03whatever you want to call it,
- 51:04and then everyone sees the same thing.
- 51:05Wait,
- 51:05you mean you don't want to have individual
- 51:07source controls of the sixteen input
- 51:09switcher at each one of those pods on
- 51:10an advanced matrix that looks worse than
- 51:12any dumpy route you've ever had?
- 51:13Why is there a switcher at the pod?
- 51:14What's happening?
- 51:15I know.
- 51:15I don't know.
- 51:16I'm just saying.
- 51:17I've seen it.
- 51:18I've seen it.
- 51:19Oh, on your campus?
- 51:20I've seen it too.
- 51:20No.
- 51:21Yeah.
- 51:22I've built them, but yeah.
- 51:23Yeah, that's years ago, right?
- 51:25But you have the advanced thing.
- 51:27Pod six wants to see pod eight.
- 51:29I built one with Mark that had,
- 51:31you guys are going to piss me off.
- 51:32There was a DMPS at each one of
- 51:36them.
- 51:36At every pod.
- 51:37And then there was a chassis in the
- 51:39back.
- 51:39Yes.
- 51:40Oh, my God.
- 51:40All right.
- 51:41We went way out of touch panel land.
- 51:44We got there.
- 51:44We are out of scope.
- 51:45But we did also build a touch panel
- 51:47page that had some,
- 51:48there was that one professor who wanted
- 51:50it.
- 51:50every possible source and destination.
- 51:52And there were, like, an eight by eight.
- 51:55And they used it exactly once during the
- 51:57training.
- 51:58And they left the university the next
- 51:59year.
- 52:00Then they were fired.
- 52:02Well, touch panels, lean and mean, right?
- 52:05As lean as you can with simple language.
- 52:07Can we all agree with this?
- 52:09I forgot other things than touch panels.
- 52:13Don't put your freaking room number on
- 52:14there.
- 52:14I know what room I'm in.
- 52:15That's one of my pet peeves.
- 52:16I've heard people argue against that.
- 52:17I want the weather.
- 52:18We need clock and weather.
- 52:20I've heard people argue that some
- 52:22professors use the clock.
- 52:23What was the other one I was thinking
- 52:26about?
- 52:26Oh, the branding.
- 52:27I mean,
- 52:27I understand school colors and whatnot,
- 52:29but do I need a branding logo on
- 52:30every page or something?
- 52:31Or can I get rid of it?
- 52:32I think philosophically,
- 52:37just because you can doesn't mean you
- 52:38should.
- 52:39for touch panels.
- 52:40I would say if we could challenge
- 52:41everybody with one thing,
- 52:43just one thing from this,
- 52:45look at your touch panels and delete.
- 52:47Try to remove one thing.
- 52:49Yes.
- 52:50The whole touch panel.
- 52:51Well, there's that.
- 52:53Just get rid of that one thing and
- 52:54you'll be fine.
- 52:54Okay.
- 52:55Any other thoughts on touch panel
- 52:57interfaces, user interfaces,
- 52:58all that fun stuff?
- 52:59We're all guilty, every single one of us.
- 53:00Yes, we've all done this.
- 53:02I will keep doing it.
- 53:03I'm going to go label a – I'm
- 53:05going to get a ten-inch touch panel,
- 53:07and I'm going to put every button on
- 53:08there for the module,
- 53:09and I'm going to label them things like
- 53:11one through six and A through G.
- 53:14I'm going to go.
- 53:16Like the Crestron ones where you had to
- 53:17use the whole damn smart module in order
- 53:20to even use one button on it?
- 53:21You could put some of them off the
- 53:23page to hide them.
- 53:23You didn't have to do that.
- 53:24What was that?
- 53:27You don't want to talk about the smart
- 53:28graphics or something?
- 53:29Oh, I know.
- 53:30Yeah, you didn't have to do that.
- 53:32They were so hot in that, too.
- 53:34So dumb.
- 53:35I like going to Google Image Search to
- 53:37find pictures of things and just
- 53:38screenshotting it and then pasting it into
- 53:39VTP.
- 53:40That's fine.
- 53:40There you go.
- 53:43With the background still.
- 53:44Or you resize the picture to fit the
- 53:47button.
- 53:48And so now you have.
- 53:49I like using Comic Sans fonts on my
- 53:50touch panels.
- 53:50All right.
- 53:53Okay.
- 53:54Any other last thoughts we're just going
- 53:55to leave?
- 53:56We're way over.
- 53:56I'm just going to get out of here.
- 53:57Sorry for that.
- 53:58Sorry for that one, guys.
- 53:59I got a little bit.
- 53:59Why on your wingdings?
- 54:00Thirty minutes on the button.
- 54:03Perfect.
- 54:03Perfect.
- 54:07yet another episode of AV Superfriends On
- 54:09Topic.
- 54:10You can contact us with questions,
- 54:11topic ideas,
- 54:12or general complaints at
- 54:13avsuperfriends.com.
- 54:22Nice work, everyone.
- 54:24Sharp broadcast.
- 54:25Really good.
- 54:26Everyone on the floor as well.
- 54:28Really a lot of hustle.
- 54:29I liked it.
- 54:30The opinions expressed by the AV
- 54:31Superfriends are solely those of the
- 54:32individuals and do not represent their
- 54:34respective institutions, organizations,
- 54:36companies, or clients.