Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Book Talk: In Congress We Trust? Enforcing Voting Rights from the Founding to the Jim Crow Era
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Book Talk, In Congress We Trust, Enforcing Voting
- 0:10Rights from the Founding to the Jim Crow Era.
- 0:13I'm Alla Policastro, BHBA's Director of Education
- 0:17and Professional Development, and today I am
- 0:19very delighted to introduce our speakers, Dean
- 0:21Fernita Tolson and Dean Erwin Chemerinsky. Fernita
- 0:25Tulson is Dean and Carl Mason Franklin Chair
- 0:28in Law at USC Gold School of Law. Her scholarship
- 0:32focuses on election law, constitution law, and
- 0:35voting rights. A nationally recognized election
- 0:38law expert, she has testified before Congress,
- 0:41worked as an election analyst for CNN and NBC,
- 0:44and co -host the podcast. Free and Fair with
- 0:47Fernita and Foley. She is here today to discuss
- 0:50her fascinating new book. If you haven't already
- 0:53bought it, there is a link in your materials
- 0:54in the chat. And when we asked Dean Tolson who
- 0:58she would ideally like to moderate the conversation,
- 1:00her immediate response was Irwin Chemerinsky.
- 1:03And when Irwin said yes to the invitation just
- 1:06as quickly, we knew we had a fantastic program
- 1:09for you. Dean Chemerinsky of Berkeley Law probably
- 1:13needs no introduction to this audience. He is
- 1:15a prolific legal scholar and author of 22 books
- 1:19and over 200 law review articles on constitutional
- 1:22law and related fields, as well as a frequent
- 1:25Supreme Court advocate and newspaper columnist.
- 1:28His full bio and Dean Tolson's are in your materials.
- 1:32So let's get right to why you're here today.
- 1:34I'm honored to turn the program over to Deans
- 1:37Tolson and Chemerinsky. Thank you so much. It's
- 1:41truly my great honor and pleasure to get to have
- 1:43this conversation with Pernita. I finished reading
- 1:45her book over the weekend. It's In Congress We
- 1:48Trust, and it's really a terrific book about
- 1:51the history of voting in Congress. Let me start,
- 1:54Pernita, by asking the question, why did you
- 1:56write this book? Okay, so first I just have to,
- 2:01I'm like fangirling right now because I've always
- 2:03been such a fan of your work and I'm so honored
- 2:06that you were willing to have this conversation
- 2:07with me. I wrote the book in part because I couldn't
- 2:11find sources that I needed to write the articles
- 2:15that I was trying to write. And so that's what
- 2:17initially prompted me because I realized I was
- 2:20writing about voting rights from a perspective
- 2:22that we don't usually talk about, at least not
- 2:25extensively in election law. So I was more focused
- 2:28on the question of who regulates, Congress or
- 2:30the states, which is a bit different from the
- 2:33question of who should be able to vote. Of course,
- 2:35all of this is interrelated, but I was really
- 2:38laser focused on that specific question. And
- 2:41so part of the goal, I guess, was to be able
- 2:44to tell a fuller story about voting and democracy
- 2:48in this country, but from the perspective of
- 2:50regulation. I think that the conventional story
- 2:52is a bit too court -centered. And it's also too
- 2:55state -centered. And in the course of research
- 2:58in this book, I realized that the Constitution
- 2:59gives Congress tremendous authority and really
- 3:02extraordinary tools to protect democratic participation.
- 3:05And so I really wanted to tell that story. The
- 3:08book focuses almost exclusively on the 19th century.
- 3:13There's certainly discussion about the framing
- 3:15of the Constitution. And there's an epilogue
- 3:18where you talk a little bit about the 21st century.
- 3:21Why did you choose to focus on the 19th century
- 3:24in this way? Well, part of the focus of the timeline.
- 3:30I initially set out to write a book about Section
- 3:322 of the 14th Amendment. which is, it's odd because
- 3:35section two has never been enforced. So section
- 3:38two allows Congress to reduce the state's delegation
- 3:41in the House of Representatives if the state
- 3:43abridges or denies the right to vote. So at least
- 3:46initially in starting to write a book about that,
- 3:49that brought me to the reconstruction moment.
- 3:51But then I realized, I'm like, you look, no one's
- 3:53going to read a book just about section two.
- 3:55It's never been enforced. I can tell you all
- 3:57kinds of interesting theories about it, which
- 3:58actually make it into this book, but I didn't
- 4:01think it necessarily needed a book length. But
- 4:04in the course of trying to do that research,
- 4:06I realized that there's a much more interesting
- 4:07story about what Congress has done. Not only
- 4:11was section 2, but with respect to provisions
- 4:13that delegate power specifically to Congress.
- 4:16Right? So you have the guarantee clause, which
- 4:18allows the federal government to. guaranteed
- 4:21to each state a Republican form of government.
- 4:23You have the elections clause, which allows Congress
- 4:26to make or alter state regulations that pertain
- 4:28to federal elections. You have article one, section
- 4:31five, which allows Congress to judge the elections
- 4:34of its members. And then you also have section
- 4:36two. And so, you know, for me, telling a more
- 4:39comprehensive story starting at the founding
- 4:41was really important for understanding the authority
- 4:44that Congress had going into the reconstruction
- 4:46moment. Because I think we can look at reconstruction
- 4:49and we say, OK, we had this unprecedented civil
- 4:51war. Congress comes in, they rebuild southern
- 4:54political systems. But Congress was actually
- 4:56building on power that it already had prior to
- 4:58the war. So in order to tell the story about
- 5:01the reconstruction moment, I really did have
- 5:03to start at the beginning. And so once I did
- 5:05that and got to almost 500 pages, I realized
- 5:08I would have to write a second book. I so hope
- 5:12you do. I'm eager to hear what comes next after
- 5:16it, including, of course, the Voting Rights Act
- 5:18of 1965 and what the Supreme Court has done to
- 5:21it since. But before we get to the second book,
- 5:25I wanted you a chance to describe, and you've
- 5:27already begun, what was the thesis of this book?
- 5:31If you were to tell the readers in a few paragraphs,
- 5:35The thesis of my book is, how would you answer
- 5:38that question? So the thesis of my book is that
- 5:41Congress has greater authority over voting and
- 5:45elections than we previously understood. And
- 5:48that's the book simply. And it's really important
- 5:52to understand what that means for the way that
- 5:55the Supreme Court Court currently approaches
- 5:57the right to vote, right? So currently we have
- 6:00a narrative from the Supreme Court that really
- 6:02focuses on the states, right? They're very deferential
- 6:05to the states. They view any federal legislation
- 6:07that intrudes on state authority as contrary
- 6:12to what the Constitution provides. And that's
- 6:14how we ended up with cases like Shelby County
- 6:16and more recent voting rights cases. The Calais
- 6:19case, for example, all of those cases are premised
- 6:21on this idea that the Voting Rights Act should
- 6:23be viewed as an intrusion on state sovereignty
- 6:26that has to be justified. And so I really wanted
- 6:30to push back on the federalism narrative, not
- 6:33in the sense of saying that Congress has so much
- 6:36power that the states play no role. I'm not saying
- 6:38that federalism isn't important, but the thesis
- 6:41of the book really is to clarify what Congress
- 6:44has done in this space. So it was unusual for
- 6:47me in a sense in writing this book, because it
- 6:49is largely descriptive. I tried to be very careful
- 6:52about making any normative takeaways from the
- 6:55book, especially since it stops at 1910. I have
- 6:57a whole other century of history that I have
- 7:00to talk about before I feel comfortable making
- 7:01normative conclusions. But I did think it was
- 7:04important to complicate the historical story
- 7:07enough to show that we shouldn't just take the
- 7:09Supreme Court's federalism narrative at face
- 7:12value. And I think for a court that's comprised
- 7:15of a majority of originalists, They should pay
- 7:17attention to this in the way that you've written
- 7:19it because it is very much a Neutrally presented
- 7:23history going back to the start of the drafting
- 7:26of the constitution I want to talk about some
- 7:29of the concepts that you raise in the book and
- 7:32then some of the constitutional provisions that
- 7:33you alluded to You draw a distinction early on
- 7:36in the book between quote the constitution of
- 7:39political structure as opposed to quote the constitution
- 7:42of political rights Could you explain that distinction
- 7:46and why it matters? So I was trying to conceptualize
- 7:52really which entity is responsible for constitutional
- 7:55interpretation when it comes to the right to
- 7:57vote in elections. I went to law school at a
- 8:00time where we really venerated the Warren court.
- 8:02And so when I became a law professor, the Warren
- 8:05court was kind of my ideal for a Supreme Court
- 8:08who expanded access to the right to vote. And
- 8:12this was really proactive in that space. And
- 8:13so I ignored all of the other branches. But in
- 8:16research in this book, I realized the story of
- 8:19regulation is actually much more complicated
- 8:20than that. And this notion of a constitution
- 8:22of political rights and a constitutional political
- 8:25structure tries to capture that. the dynamic
- 8:29nature of our system of elections. So the constitutional
- 8:31political structure refers to those provisions
- 8:35of the Constitution that delegate authority to
- 8:37Congress. It was really important for me in writing
- 8:41a book about Congress's power over election that
- 8:43I think about what Congress could do separate
- 8:45from the court. And so the constitutional political
- 8:48structure, in reference to the provisions that
- 8:51I've already alluded to, the guarantee clause,
- 8:54the elections clause, Article 1, Section 5, and
- 8:57Section 2 of the 14th Amendments are provisions
- 9:00that anticipate that Congress will take the lead
- 9:02in regulating under these provisions. This does
- 9:06not mean that the court has no oversight. In
- 9:08fact, in the Rucho case, which dealt with the
- 9:11question of whether or not there's a judicial
- 9:12remedy for partisan gerrymandering. The court
- 9:15says there is no remedy, but declined to say
- 9:17that it didn't have any oversight of legislation
- 9:20passed pursuant to the elections clause. So clearly,
- 9:23the court sees some role for itself. But generally
- 9:26speaking, these provisions empower Congress to
- 9:29protect the right to vote and to protect elections.
- 9:32Deemed that the constitutional political structure
- 9:35on the other hand is the constitutional political
- 9:37rights and that's that tends to encompass the
- 9:40rights we think of when we talk about the right
- 9:41to vote. Now, of course, the right to vote and
- 9:45one thing that is implicit in the book is that
- 9:47it was quite dynamic, right? There really was
- 9:49this right to vote that was covered under state
- 9:52law and state constitutions prior to the Civil
- 9:54War and Congress did not really weigh in that
- 9:57extensively when it came to regulating the right
- 9:59to vote. But I also talk about something called
- 10:03the right to alter abolish government, because
- 10:05I was really interested to think about political
- 10:07power broadly. If one cannot exercise the right
- 10:10to vote, then what political power do you have?
- 10:13Well, it turned out that prior to the Civil War,
- 10:16the people writ large retained the right to alter
- 10:18abolish government. And it's the same right of
- 10:21revolution that the American colonists exercised
- 10:23in 1776 to break from the British. And there
- 10:27were actually times over the course of the 19th
- 10:29century where the people sought to exercise their
- 10:31right to alter abolish government. And so by
- 10:34the time we get to the reconstruction moment,
- 10:35we really do see this convergence between the
- 10:37right to alter abolish government and the right
- 10:40to vote, in part because the Confederacy exercised
- 10:43the right to alter abolish government and leaving
- 10:45the union. And so all of a sudden, we're faced
- 10:48with a difficult situation in which this natural
- 10:51right has been used for these terrible reasons.
- 10:53And so one of the responses to this is, well,
- 10:56we enfranchise more people, right? We want to
- 10:58encourage individuals to exercise their right
- 11:00to vote when they are dissatisfied with the government,
- 11:03as opposed to exercising their right to auto
- 11:04abolish government. And so that is the constitution
- 11:07of political rights. I want to focus on one small
- 11:11thing here that I learned an enormous amount
- 11:13from reading the book. But one thing I did not
- 11:15know before reading a book was there was actually
- 11:18an effort by northerners for secession in 1800.
- 11:23I've written about secession. I've read a lot
- 11:26about it, but I never knew that, that you talk
- 11:29about in the book. And so given that you were
- 11:31talking about the right to abolish government,
- 11:32I thought that might be a good example because
- 11:34my guess is most people like me had never heard
- 11:36about this before. Right, so the election of
- 11:39Thomas Jefferson really did sort of trigger these
- 11:41concerns among the federalists about the future
- 11:44of American government. And so there was this
- 11:46movement towards northern secession. I think
- 11:49most people are familiar with southern secession
- 11:52in 1860, but I also learned a lot about other
- 11:56efforts throughout American history to exercise
- 11:59the right to ultra abolish government. We just
- 12:01never really talked about it like that. So the
- 12:03door rebellion is probably familiar to some people.
- 12:06So there was a revolt in the 1840s where you
- 12:09had a movement to try to enfranchise more people
- 12:12in Rhode Island, which was still under its colonial
- 12:16charter. And so not only did it. limit the right
- 12:19to vote to a very small subset of the population.
- 12:22There really was no path to being a voter. And
- 12:25so the door rebellion was designed to push back
- 12:27against this, but it raised fundamental questions
- 12:29about whether or not the ultra abolish right
- 12:31remained robust. because one might say that the
- 12:35folks in Rhode Island probably had a stronger
- 12:37claim to exercising their auto -abolish right
- 12:40as the revolutionaries in 1776. They tried to
- 12:43do it the right way. They couldn't. They passed
- 12:46their own constitution. They elected their own
- 12:48governor. They tried to operate within the system
- 12:51as it existed, and it just didn't work. But their
- 12:54efforts failed, and I really think it signaled
- 12:56this discomfort with the right to abolish government
- 12:59that culminated in Southern secession in 1860.
- 13:02But by no means were these like the only instances
- 13:05in which the right to ultra -Abbottist government
- 13:07had been invoked. It's great examples. And I
- 13:11want to come back to the Dora Valley in a moment.
- 13:13But I want, before doing so, to talk about another
- 13:16concept that you introduce into the book, and
- 13:18that you call We the Voters. And what did you
- 13:22mean by that? And when did We the Voters become
- 13:26something important? Because as you read the
- 13:28Constitution, there's not a lot about voting
- 13:30in the Constitution. Right. And maybe that's
- 13:35what pushed me towards more structural questions
- 13:36about power. Because one thing I've never really
- 13:39been comfortable with is trying to infer strong
- 13:42voting protections in a constitution that has
- 13:44just very little to say about voting per se.
- 13:48But the dichotomy between we the people and we
- 13:51the voters was a way of trying to understand
- 13:53the scope of these rights. So when we talk about
- 13:55the right to alter abolish government, I think
- 13:57about that as a right exercised by everyone.
- 14:01to the Dred Scott decision, which said that African
- 14:04Americans couldn't be citizens, I was comfortable
- 14:06in saying that this right really belonged to
- 14:10everyone. So for example, Crispus Attucks, who
- 14:13was one of the four individuals killed in the
- 14:15Boston Massacre, was an African American and
- 14:18Native American, and he was arguably exercising
- 14:21his right to alter or abolish government, right?
- 14:24One could even be comfortable in saying that
- 14:25African Americans, free African Americans at
- 14:28the very least, had that right. Whereas the right
- 14:31to vote was much more circumscribed. And so I
- 14:35think about them as two different political communities
- 14:37that sometimes overlap. So arguably those in
- 14:41the community of We the Voters are part of the
- 14:43community of We the People. But the people who
- 14:46are in We the People aren't necessarily in the
- 14:48community of We the Voters. And so the reconstruction
- 14:52moment really was an attempt to bring these communities
- 14:54more in line with each other, where you have
- 14:56more people from We the People exercising the
- 14:59rights of those in We the Voters in order to
- 15:02neutralize the right to auto -abolish government.
- 15:05I think it's such a terrific point. When you
- 15:07look at the Constitution itself, the president
- 15:10isn't chosen by a vote of the people to this
- 15:13day. In fact, in the early 19th century, as many
- 15:16states used the state legislatures to choose
- 15:19the electors, not... a vote of the people. The
- 15:21Senate was chosen by state legislatures until
- 15:24the early 20th century. The judiciary isn't chosen
- 15:27by the people. Only the House is chosen by the
- 15:30people. And one of the other things I learned
- 15:31in your book is that in some states, the House
- 15:34was chosen by at -large elections. It wasn't
- 15:36even by districts, all of which makes the adoption
- 15:41of the 15th Amendment in 1870, which says the
- 15:44right to vote shall not be denied in a kind of
- 15:47race or previous condition of servitude. Seeming
- 15:49so important in a shift to we the voters and
- 15:52then which you talk about the emergent women's
- 15:55suffrage movement It doesn't succeed until 1920
- 15:58but certainly begins in the 19th century Right,
- 16:02right. They started having conversations about
- 16:05the language in section 2 section 2 is the first
- 16:08reference to male in the Constitution, right?
- 16:12Like, this caused so much alarm in the women's
- 16:15suffrage movement, because I forget who said
- 16:17it, but she said something to the effect of once
- 16:20we get the mail in, we'll never get it out, right?
- 16:23Like, so, you know, but it also, I think, caused
- 16:26tension between natural allies. the early women's
- 16:29suffrage movement was one in which there were
- 16:32definitely some prominent black men involved
- 16:33in that because there was kind of the shared
- 16:36interest in expanding the right to vote to constituencies
- 16:39that hadn't been able to get it. But section
- 16:43two is important, not only because it introduced
- 16:46the word male in a way that undermined the women's
- 16:48suffrage movement, but also because it... at
- 16:51the same time recognize the political identity
- 16:54of Black men and they did not have one before.
- 16:57One of the things I wanted to clarify in the
- 16:59book was that the 13th Amendment was important.
- 17:04It really laid the foundation for everything
- 17:05that came after it, but it did not give Black
- 17:07men a political role in a way that the Civil
- 17:10Rights Act of 1866 gave them citizenship, which
- 17:13laid the foundation for them to have the right
- 17:15to vote as protected by Section 2. And I want
- 17:19to be clear, I'm saying as protected because
- 17:21you are absolutely right that the U .S. Constitution
- 17:23does not create an affirmative right to vote,
- 17:25and it does not even do that by the time Congress
- 17:28adopts the language in Section 2. But what it
- 17:30does is it tells us something very important
- 17:32about the nature of Republican government. So
- 17:36one might say that prior to the Civil War, what
- 17:40counted as Republican government was very contested,
- 17:42right? There were questions raised. repeatedly
- 17:45about whether or not the institution of slavery
- 17:47was consistent with Republican government. Disenfranchising
- 17:52women, is that consistent with Republican government?
- 17:57And so the reconstruction moment gave Congress
- 17:59an opportunity through Section 2 to redefine
- 18:02what Republicanism requires. So now we have a
- 18:05situation where states can lose representation
- 18:07for abridging or denying the right to vote. And
- 18:11let me be clear, Irwin, not abridging and denying
- 18:13the right to vote on the basis of race. There's
- 18:16no race reference in Section 2 of the 14th Amendment.
- 18:18It's any abridgment or denial of the right to
- 18:20vote. And in adopting this language, Congress
- 18:22was saying something very distinctive about its
- 18:24expectations for state political representation
- 18:27moving forward. And one of my arguments in the
- 18:30book is that this remains true even though Section
- 18:322 was never enforced. So often we write off constitutional
- 18:36provisions if they don't reach their full potential,
- 18:39but I really wanted to remind the readers that
- 18:42Section 2 was a reset for our understanding of
- 18:44what Republican government requires, which is
- 18:46full Democratic participation. I see the book
- 18:50is focusing on a number of constitutional provisions
- 18:53and their significance with regard to empowering
- 18:55Congress. You listed some of these. I'd like
- 18:58to go through them and have you talk about what
- 19:01should mean the way you're understanding the
- 19:04Constitution and what it's actually meant. Let
- 19:06me start with one that fits, I think, with what
- 19:08you were just talking about. And that's the Guarantee
- 19:10Clause or some called Republican form of government
- 19:13clause. It's an Article IV section for the Constitution.
- 19:16This is the United States shall guarantee to
- 19:19each state a republican form of government. Earlier
- 19:23you were talking about the Dora rebellion. It
- 19:26led to a case about the guarantee clause, a case
- 19:30called Luther versus Borden. You tell the story
- 19:33of it in your book. But the Supreme Court said
- 19:35cases under the guarantee clause are not just
- 19:39disabled political questions. And the Supreme
- 19:42Court has continued to adhere to that. So be
- 19:45really interested in knowing what you think the
- 19:48guaranteed clause should have meant. And also,
- 19:51what, if any, significance has it had in light
- 19:54of the Supreme Court seemingly reading it out
- 19:56of the enforceable Constitution? So I think this
- 20:00book has, you know, it's changed my mind a little
- 20:03bit. I think prior to writing this book, I would
- 20:05have said Luther versus Borden was probably wrongly
- 20:07decided. But that's definitely coming from the
- 20:09lens of someone who believed in strong judicial
- 20:12enforcement. Right, especially of, you know,
- 20:14and that's again the Warren court, right? Because
- 20:16the Warren court, you know, reputed representation
- 20:19reinforcement, right? The Warren court was about
- 20:21making sure that the channels of democracy were
- 20:24open that people could participate. It seems
- 20:26like the guarantee clause would have been a good
- 20:28way to do that. There's a case decided in nineteen
- 20:31sixties called Baker versus car. where the court
- 20:33opens the door for the one person one vote standard
- 20:37in trying to make sure that people are that districts
- 20:40are not malapportioned. And one of the things
- 20:43that the court had to do in that case is get
- 20:44around Luther versus Borden. And they basically
- 20:48read the equal protection clause in a way that
- 20:49allows them to hear these cases. But honestly,
- 20:53the outcome would have been no different had
- 20:55they resolved that case on the guarantee clause.
- 20:57Right. So in some ways, it's like. Yeah, maybe
- 21:00it's right. Maybe it's wrong. But at the end
- 21:02of the day, the court figured out a way to do
- 21:03what it needed to do anyway. But for me, the
- 21:08question is a little bit different after writing
- 21:10the book. So the court says that the guarantee
- 21:14clause is non -justiciable. But also true in
- 21:16the context of the door rebellion is Congress
- 21:18refusing to intervene to decide which government
- 21:22of Rhode Island is the rightful government. Right.
- 21:24So what do we do in situations like that? Should
- 21:27the court revisit this idea that maybe this intervention
- 21:30is necessary if Congress or the president is
- 21:33refusing to enforce the principles of the guarantee
- 21:35clause? Probably a close modern parallel would
- 21:39be with partisan gerrymandering. The Rucho case
- 21:42was very much premised on the idea of the court
- 21:43saying, look, we don't have a justiciable standard
- 21:46here, but Congress could do all of these things
- 21:48that Congress is currently refusing to do. For
- 21:51me, the question is, well, where does that leave
- 21:53the voters? Is there some broader institutional
- 21:57commitment that we have that requires the court
- 21:59to intervene when the other branches who are
- 22:02arguably tasked with enforcing these provisions
- 22:05refuse to intervene? And the answer to that might
- 22:07actually be yes. And so you would say that the
- 22:11guaranteed clause should be enforced by the courts
- 22:14if Congress isn't taking its responsibility to
- 22:17do so seriously. I think so. Let me take another
- 22:21provision that plays a large role in your book.
- 22:25That's not one you mentioned earlier. And that's
- 22:27the 12th Amendment. And I've not thought a lot
- 22:31about the 12th Amendment. It certainly has come
- 22:35up recently, and that makes clear that somebody
- 22:37who's ineligible to be president can't run for
- 22:41vice president either. So many people said, well,
- 22:43Donald Trump will run for vice president in 2028.
- 22:47And then the person elected president will step
- 22:50aside and go, no, no, no, the 12th Amendment
- 22:52means you can't run for vice president. You can't
- 22:54run for president. That doesn't work. But other
- 22:57than that, people don't focus a lot on the 12th
- 22:59Amendment. Your book discusses it in detail.
- 23:02Can you explain how we got it, what it means,
- 23:06and why you think it's important? So let me start
- 23:09with your last question first, because I don't
- 23:10think it's obvious to, at least the... You know,
- 23:13in discussions and conversations about the book,
- 23:15if you read the book, it becomes obvious what
- 23:17role it plays, but it's not immediately obvious
- 23:19why the 12th Amendment should be part of this
- 23:20discussion at all outside of the fact that it
- 23:22touches on presidential elections because in
- 23:25many ways when it was adopted, it was treated
- 23:26as a technical fix, right? So you had the election
- 23:29of 1800 and you had a tie in electoral votes
- 23:32between Aaron Burr and Thomas Jefferson. And
- 23:36it went to the House of Representatives and there
- 23:38was a very real chance that Aaron Burr could
- 23:40have ended up. being present. And so for purposes
- 23:43of understanding what the founding generation
- 23:46thought about Republican government, the conversations
- 23:48around the 12th Amendment, which. You know, post
- 23:52election of eighteen hundred now required the
- 23:54president and the vice president to be on different
- 23:56ballots as opposed to having the first and second
- 23:59place finisher on the same ballot. And it also
- 24:02sent three people in cases where no one gets
- 24:05a majority. It sends the top three instead of
- 24:07the top five to Congress. So I was more interested
- 24:11in the conversations around the adoption of the
- 24:1312th Amendment to understand how they thought
- 24:15about Republican government as opposed to what
- 24:18the 12th Amendment actually did. And with the
- 24:2012th Amendment, you really do see this embrace
- 24:22of majoritarianism, right? There's a lot of concern,
- 24:25not that Aaron Burr was like. not a valid choice
- 24:29because he was somehow outside of the rules in
- 24:32existence. It's because he wasn't a choice of
- 24:34the people, right? There was this clear expectation
- 24:37that Thomas Jefferson would be the next president
- 24:39and that he was the choice of the majority. And
- 24:41Aaron Burr really undermined that. And so in
- 24:45some ways, the 12th Amendment is important because
- 24:47it embraces this idea of majoritarian government
- 24:50in a way that didn't exist before. And I also
- 24:53teach my students that the 12th Amendment, although
- 24:55we... quote unquote, sometimes don't care about
- 24:58it because it's a technical fix, is really the
- 25:00first time that the Constitution anticipates
- 25:02parties, right? So, you know, any conversations
- 25:07about the Constitution and the Constitution being
- 25:09anti -party is only true up until the 11th Amendment.
- 25:13By the 12th Amendment, the Founding Generation
- 25:16is clearly operating from the perspective that
- 25:17parties exist, and they are the best ways to
- 25:20facilitate majoritarian preferences. And parties
- 25:23had come into existence before the 12th Amendment.
- 25:27The framers didn't anticipate or want them. The
- 25:3012th Amendment very much is based on a recognition
- 25:32of the role of political parties in that regard.
- 25:38Let me ask you about another provision that you
- 25:40talk about, the so -called elections clause.
- 25:44So the elections clause, I'm a big fan. Actually,
- 25:48I wrote about the elections clause quite a bit
- 25:49before I wrote this book because I was really,
- 25:55there were a couple parts of the elections clause
- 25:59that. I don't want to say confused me, but if
- 26:03you step back and ask just basic questions about
- 26:05it. So it gives states control over the time,
- 26:08places and manner of federal elections, but subject
- 26:11to Congress's power to make or alter those regulations.
- 26:14So as a junior scholar, one of the questions
- 26:17I had was what does those words actually mean?
- 26:19What do we mean by manner regulation? How have
- 26:22we thought about that historically? And when
- 26:24has Congress exercised this authority to make
- 26:26or alter certain state regulations? Probably
- 26:30most famously in modern times is the National
- 26:33Voter Registration Act, the Motor Voter Law.
- 26:36Most people are familiar with that. That was
- 26:37passed pursuant to the elections cause. But I
- 26:40became very, very interested to think about how
- 26:42Congress has exercised this power historically.
- 26:45And one thing I ran across was the Apportionment
- 26:48Act of 1842. So the Apportionment Act of 1842
- 26:51was the first time Congress passed federal election
- 26:55legislation. And it was very contentious. Today,
- 26:59we would take for granted what Congress sought
- 27:01to impose. They imposed single -member district
- 27:03for congressional elections, which is a rule
- 27:04we still have today. But it was treated as instances
- 27:09in which Congress has overstepped its authority,
- 27:11because Congress had never done that before.
- 27:14But for my purposes, I really thought it was
- 27:17interesting how they talked about federalism
- 27:18in the context of that debate. The 1842 Apportionment
- 27:23Act was treated as an instance of federal overreach,
- 27:25but very few people contested the power of Congress
- 27:28to impose the legislation. So it was less about
- 27:31federalism in the sense that this power lies
- 27:35with the states, Congress should not intervene,
- 27:37because the Constitution does not permit it,
- 27:40and more so about politics and political will.
- 27:43And I thought that that was a very, very important
- 27:45distinction that I wanted to, that I wanted to
- 27:49sort of make at various points in the book, right?
- 27:52When I get to the reconstruction moment, and
- 27:54I'm sure we'll talk about this, part of the failure
- 27:56of reconstruction is about political will. And
- 27:59so to see how that argument plays out in this
- 28:02early piece of federal legislation was very illuminating
- 28:06for me. I want to talk a little bit about the
- 28:10tension between localism is reflected in this
- 28:13provision and national control. And it's not
- 28:18just something of the 19th century. Donald Trump
- 28:21is trying very hard to have Congress exercise
- 28:24much more control and failing that to have the
- 28:27United States Postal Service exercise much more
- 28:29control. On the other hand, many believe today
- 28:31that part of our protection against a president
- 28:35might want to do that. is the elections clause
- 28:37and how much is left to state and local government.
- 28:40After the election of 2000, when many believe
- 28:43that an error in designing a ballot in Florida
- 28:45decided election, there's a desire for much more
- 28:47federal control. Today I think there's much more
- 28:50desire for state control. How do you see that
- 28:54in terms of the Constitution? So I think the
- 28:57Constitution leaves room for both. So let's talk
- 29:01about the first premise of your question, how
- 29:03President Trump wants to nationalize everything,
- 29:06because he has a very specific agenda that he's
- 29:08pushing with respect to voting in elections.
- 29:11One of the pieces of legislation that was under
- 29:13consideration to that end was the SAVE Act. So
- 29:17the SAVE Act would have required documentary
- 29:19proof of citizenship to vote in federal elections.
- 29:22And it would have disenfranchised a lot of people.
- 29:26And it was my belief that it would have disenfranchised
- 29:28have disenfranchised a lot of people regardless
- 29:30of partisan affiliation by virtue of the documents
- 29:33that would have been necessary in order to comply
- 29:35with the law. Like a lot of people don't have
- 29:37a passport. And that's just true regardless of
- 29:40partisan affiliation. But one of the reasons
- 29:42why it felt unconstitutional and unprecedented
- 29:46to me is because in my book, I talk a lot about
- 29:49Congress's role. And Congress's role had typically
- 29:51been to stand in the gap when states have passed
- 29:55laws or engaged in behavior that disenfranchises
- 29:57people. You don't typically see Congress becoming
- 30:00involved in election regulation to itself disenfranchise
- 30:04people, right? And that felt contrary to its
- 30:07obligation to ensure that each state has a Republican
- 30:11form of government, right? Because remember,
- 30:13Republicanism, post 12th Amendment, post Civil
- 30:16War moment focuses on majoritarian preferences.
- 30:19And so it seemed counter to me for Congress to
- 30:22view its role as shrinking the electorate. That's
- 30:26not the role that Congress has typically had.
- 30:29But from a scholarly perspective, and this is
- 30:31something I want to talk about in the next book,
- 30:32it does raise the question of whether or not
- 30:34Congress's authority under the guarantee clause
- 30:37is an ongoing obligation to ensure that states
- 30:40have a Republican form of government. There are
- 30:42certainly some things in our history that suggested
- 30:44so. But, you know, typically, states have been
- 30:49admitted. Congress kind of does a gut check to
- 30:52see if it's Republican and then it moves on.
- 30:55But there's something about this reconstruction
- 30:57moment and the legislation that Congress passed
- 31:00to readmit the former Confederate states back
- 31:03into the union under federal legislation that
- 31:06actually prevented them from changing their state
- 31:08constitutions to disenfranchise people that suggests
- 31:11that Congress has an ongoing obligation to ensure
- 31:14a Republican form of government. And if that's
- 31:16true, then that makes the SAVE Act even more
- 31:18pernicious than one might even think. That's
- 31:21a great point. And I very much look forward to
- 31:23your writing it, not only for the next book,
- 31:26but because I think it's crucial at this point
- 31:28in time to bring that to people's attention.
- 31:30Let me, before I move on to the history, talk
- 31:32about one other provision that you discussed.
- 31:35And that's, of course, the constitutional vision
- 31:36that each house gets to be the judge of the election
- 31:39of its members. And I'm interested in your talking
- 31:42about its significance in the Constitution. But
- 31:45also, if I can take you from the 19th century
- 31:48to the possibilities of what might occur in January
- 31:50of 2027, many are concerned that if the House
- 31:55depends on a few elections, or the composition
- 31:59of the Senate turns on a few, that perhaps the
- 32:02House could decide not to seat certain Democrats
- 32:06of one, the Republicans in the new Congress saying
- 32:09that they'll declare the Republicans who were
- 32:11in those races the victor or the same thing in
- 32:14the Senate and throw the election to the Republicans.
- 32:18Your thoughts of that provision, what it was
- 32:20meant to be about, and what might happen in January
- 32:23of 2027? So I have to say this is the provision
- 32:27that surprised me the most. Maybe I just didn't
- 32:30know that much about it prior to writing this
- 32:32book. But Congress had been pretty Aggressive
- 32:37and policing the elections of its members. So
- 32:40I want to familiarize our listeners with a couple
- 32:43things that they may not realize about this power.
- 32:45Article one, section five and Congress's authority
- 32:47to judge the elections of this member is treated
- 32:49as judicially non reviewable. So once Congress
- 32:52decides who wins the seat, that's it. It's been
- 32:55used in incredibly partisan ways, right? So if
- 32:58you are a Republican candidate who's trying to
- 33:02get a seat that was declared, you know, won by
- 33:05the Democrat and it's a Republican House, you
- 33:08may or may not have a better chance of prevailing
- 33:10on your claim than if you are a Democrat. in
- 33:13a similar situation with a Republican House,
- 33:15right? So it's judicially not reviewable. It's
- 33:18been used in very partisan ways, but it has also
- 33:21been used in ways that reinforce some of the
- 33:23Constitution's most treasured values, right?
- 33:26So during Reconstruction, and honestly, in the
- 33:30decades following Reconstruction, Congress used
- 33:32this authority under Article I, Section 5 to
- 33:34refuse to see individuals who had been elected
- 33:36in races punctuated by racial discrimination
- 33:38and voting, by violence, by fraud. And because
- 33:43the Supreme Court had become so hostile to Reconstruction,
- 33:45that power became very, very important for providing
- 33:49some sort of check on what was going on in the
- 33:51former Confederacy. So I can understand why,
- 33:55given how broad it is, it can generate some concerns
- 33:58today about what happens in January 2027. But
- 34:02there are a couple rays of sun here. So January
- 34:053rd, the next Congress will decide who wins any
- 34:10contested elections, right? So it's not the current
- 34:12kind. And I think that that sometimes gets lost
- 34:14in the narrative, but it's actually the next
- 34:16Congress who's sworn in who will decide any contested
- 34:19election rates, uh, races from November, 2026.
- 34:23Um, I read something really interesting today
- 34:25by Ned Foley, where he talks about whether or
- 34:27not Mike Johnson can install a clerk of the house
- 34:29who can, you know, refuse to honor, um, certificates
- 34:33of elections from, you know, democratic governors
- 34:35who might declare that, you know, a Democrat
- 34:38has won a race and, um, maybe, maybe not. If
- 34:42the November 2026 election provides the Democrats
- 34:47with enough of a cushion, then it's hard to imagine
- 34:51that the clerk would have any grounds for challenging
- 34:54a dozen, two dozen races. But generally speaking,
- 34:58I don't think that Article 1, Section 5 would
- 35:00be the source of any shenanigans in January 2027.
- 35:08It's reassuring, and I hope you're right. It
- 35:11may also be either the Democrats win by enough
- 35:15that there's no incentive for Republicans to
- 35:17do this. It may be that the Republicans win by
- 35:19enough that it doesn't happen. But what we experienced
- 35:23in 2021 and what was attempted on January 6th
- 35:27makes one worry about what might happen in that
- 35:29regard. Yeah, if the Republicans maintain a narrow
- 35:33lead in the House in January 2027, then the positiveness
- 35:38of my prediction goes down considerably. right,
- 35:40because they have an incentive to hear challenges
- 35:43in order to increase their margin. But it's interesting,
- 35:47as you mentioned January 6, I actually thought
- 35:48about that in the context of the book, because,
- 35:50you know, I talk about the right to alter abolish
- 35:52government and the people who stormed the Capitol
- 35:54on January 6 invoked, you know, the revolutionaries
- 35:57in 1776 as a justification for what they were
- 36:00doing. This is one reason why I was so glad that
- 36:04I wrote the book, because it made me realize,
- 36:06I'm like, no, you know, where we have free and
- 36:08fair elections, you don't get to claim the mantle
- 36:10of 1776, right? That's the whole point of the
- 36:13reconstruction moment, replacing voting, replacing
- 36:16the right to alter about this government with
- 36:18voting in order to democratize this natural right.
- 36:23So it was nice to have a moment where I can sort
- 36:26of think about the modern implications of the
- 36:28book, although I was very sad on January 6th.
- 36:32You've spoken a lot in the book Focus Understandably
- 36:35a Great Deal on Reconstruction. You talk a lot
- 36:38about the statutes that were adopted between
- 36:401868 and 1872. Do you want to talk about that
- 36:45and how it shapes your understanding with regard
- 36:48to the electoral system, but even today why it
- 36:51matters so much? So the Supreme Court's review
- 36:57of congressional power tends to be clause based,
- 36:59right? So with the Voting Rights Act, In particular,
- 37:03they'll say, well, the voting rights act was
- 37:05passed pursuant to the 15th amendment. Then it
- 37:07was later renewed and reauthorized pursuant to
- 37:09the 14th and 15th amendments. And when we talk
- 37:12about questions of constitutionality, they'll
- 37:13limit their assessment to that. I wrote a piece,
- 37:16I guess about 10 years ago, where I argued that,
- 37:19well, you know, the elections clause is also
- 37:21a relevant source of authority for the Voting
- 37:23Rights Act, even though Congress didn't invoke
- 37:25it. And there are other instances in which the
- 37:27Supreme Court has looked at congressional power
- 37:30writ large and thinking about whether or not
- 37:32a federal statute is constitutional. And when
- 37:35I wrote this book, I felt justified in that approach
- 37:37because the reconstruction moment where Congress
- 37:39is relying on all of these different sources
- 37:41of authority and passing this federal legislation
- 37:44to protect elections and the right to vote really
- 37:47suggests that there's something to this idea
- 37:48that congressional power should be viewed cumulative.
- 37:52And so, for example, you had the 1870 and 1871
- 37:56enforcement acts, which were passed to enforce
- 37:58the 15th Amendment, but they also addressed fraud
- 38:01in federal elections. So Congress invoked his
- 38:03power on the elections clause. Congress invoked
- 38:05his power under the 14th Amendment as well, right?
- 38:08So we often talk about the enforcement acts as
- 38:10exercises of power under the 15th Amendment,
- 38:12and we just kind of ignore them. rest of it when,
- 38:15in fact, it's really, really important when we
- 38:16think about questions of constitutionality. The
- 38:20Reconstruction Moment also told us a lot about
- 38:23how Congress used its power to rebuild the South
- 38:25and how we should think about that power today.
- 38:28So Congress doesn't often rely on its power under
- 38:31the Guarantee Clause in passing federal legislation.
- 38:35But the Guarantee Clause was a very, very important
- 38:37part of rebuilding the Southern political systems.
- 38:40It's just that so much of what we saw in the
- 38:43was Congress responded to the court that invalidated
- 38:46a lot of the early reconstruction legislation,
- 38:49right? So this is why we get the 1964 Civil Rights
- 38:51Act passed under the Commerce Clause and not
- 38:54the 14th Amendment, right? Because Congress wanted
- 38:57to reach private discrimination and they couldn't
- 39:00get past the state action requirements, so they
- 39:02used the Commerce Clause, right? But it turns
- 39:04out that Congress can also... you know, invoke
- 39:07all of these other provisions to bolster what
- 39:10it's trying to do with political systems, what
- 39:12it's trying to do with private discriminators.
- 39:15Congress passed legislation in the 1870s to try
- 39:18to police the Klan, right? So Congress has done
- 39:21all of these things, but because Congress is
- 39:23responding to the judicial invalidation of earlier
- 39:27legislation, Congress has ignored what it can
- 39:29do in terms of its affirmative obligation to
- 39:31protect the right to vote in elections. And to
- 39:33me, that is the importance of the reconstruction.
- 39:35moment. So important. I want to go to the next
- 39:39era that you discuss when you talk about the
- 39:42backlash of the 1870s. And I've always focused
- 39:45very much on what happens after the election
- 39:47of 1876, the corrupt bargain that brings about
- 39:51the end of Reconstruction and the like. But you
- 39:54really tie this much before 1877 and talk about
- 39:59a backlash that was occurring. And one of the
- 40:01things I also didn't know that I learned from
- 40:03your book is the tensions that occurred between
- 40:06Congress and the Supreme Court during the 1870s.
- 40:10So, you know, one of the in the introduction
- 40:13of the book, I start off with a story about a
- 40:15brigadier general from the Confederacy. His name
- 40:18is Charles Miller Shelley, and he runs for Congress
- 40:21in the mid 1870s and he runs for Congress in
- 40:24the fourth district in Alabama. And he wins.
- 40:30Now, interestingly enough, part of the reason
- 40:33that he wins is because the, you know, private
- 40:37actors. state election officials, local election
- 40:41officials, massively disenfranchised African
- 40:43Americans in this district. They were subject
- 40:45to violence, they were subject to attempts to
- 40:48prevent them from registering and so on. So he
- 40:51won because there was massive disenfranchisement
- 40:53and fraud. Now the court in a case called United
- 40:56States versus Reese invalidated section four
- 40:59of the Enforcement Act, which basically prohibited
- 41:01people from being disenfranchised. But it didn't
- 41:04say disenfranchised on the basis of race. So
- 41:07the Supreme Court said, look, Congress has overstepped.
- 41:10It does not have a general power to prevent just
- 41:13general disenfranchisement. And so they invalidated
- 41:16section four. So when you think about what's
- 41:20going on at the time, often that's the end of
- 41:21the story. But then I realized that there was
- 41:24actually a contested election that came out of
- 41:26this race and Congress opted to seat his opponent
- 41:29because of the fraud and the disenfranchisement
- 41:32that happened in the context of that election.
- 41:34And so I think part of it is we have to complicate
- 41:38this narrative in a way that really forces people
- 41:44to think about this as multi -institutional.
- 41:47The book is not just about Congress in a pure
- 41:49sense. It's about the interaction between Congress
- 41:51and the court, Congress and the voters, Congress
- 41:54and these congressional candidates. But it also
- 41:59is a story about how Congress in the end advocated
- 42:03its responsibilities, which is why I was really
- 42:05intentional about going past that 1876 moment.
- 42:09If you notice, Erwin, I don't spend a lot of
- 42:11time talking about the 1876 election. General
- 42:15narrative is that that is the moment right when
- 42:17they withdrew southern troops from the south.
- 42:20That is the end of reconstruction. I was laser
- 42:23focused on what happened in the 25 years after
- 42:25that moment because I think that was what the
- 42:28real story is when we talk about congressional
- 42:29power over voting. In 1888, you get a new contingent
- 42:33of Republicans who are elected to Congress who
- 42:34feel like they have to pick up the mantle of
- 42:37the Republicans, the radical Republicans who
- 42:39changed the Constitution in the late 1860s, early
- 42:421870s. And so in the 1890s, you actually have
- 42:46more contested elections where they are refusing
- 42:49to seat people. You have a new attempt to pass
- 42:52federal legislation, the Federal Elections Bill
- 42:54of 1890. You have two different attempts to enforce
- 42:58Section 2 of the 14th Amendment against the South,
- 43:01because they had disenfranchised so many African
- 43:03Americans. So you have a whole new crop of Republicans
- 43:06who are attempting to kind of hold the Constitution
- 43:09to the promise of the Reconstruction Amendments.
- 43:12And if you just focus on 1876, you really lose
- 43:15that story. In some ways, the last chapter of
- 43:17the book, chapter nine, is the chapter I'm most
- 43:19proud of because it really does justify the question
- 43:23mark in the title, right? In Congress We Trust,
- 43:26because you get this mixed record of Congress
- 43:29refusing to see people, but at the same time,
- 43:31Congress, in other cases, abdicating its duty
- 43:33to protect African Americans in the South. Could
- 43:36you talk more about what happens, what you cover
- 43:38in Chapter 9? You have some great stories. In
- 43:40fact, I think one from Alabama you even referred
- 43:43to, and I apologize, like the ghost of Charles
- 43:45Miller Shelley. So Charles Miller Shelley's story
- 43:50is, I think it's a good paradigm for thinking
- 43:55about the potential that Congress had. to push
- 43:59back against the hostile Supreme Court and also
- 44:02Southern efforts to disenfranchise African Americans.
- 44:05So what happens is that in 1890, Mississippi
- 44:08amends its constitution to disenfranchise Black
- 44:11people in the state. The reason it's notable,
- 44:14I think most people in the audience are probably
- 44:15familiar with attempts to disenfranchise Black
- 44:17people, but the reason it's notable is that they
- 44:20use race -neutral language to disenfranchise
- 44:22Black people, because the understanding was that
- 44:24if it's race -neutral, then it doesn't violate
- 44:26the 15th Amendment. And there's no predicate
- 44:28for federal intervention, right? Because it turns
- 44:31out that when Congress tried to pass the federal
- 44:33elections bill of 1890, it really triggered this
- 44:35concern across the South that Congress will now
- 44:39start to intrude in Southern political systems
- 44:41again. And so Mississippi figured that, yes,
- 44:45we can disenfranchise Black people, but as long
- 44:47as we use race -neutral language, there's no
- 44:48predicate for federal intervention. So Mississippi
- 44:51in 1890, and then the rest of the Confederacy
- 44:54followed suit across the rest of the 1890s. 90s
- 44:57into the early 20th century. The Supreme Court
- 45:00in a case called Giles versus Harris determined
- 45:03that there's nothing that they could do about
- 45:05it. Right. They heard a challenge to Alabama
- 45:07state constitution and they basically said that
- 45:10accepting that Mr. Giles is claims that the Alabama
- 45:13constitution disenfranchised him and it was passed
- 45:17for nefarious reasons. We cannot add him to a
- 45:21unconstitutional voter registration. Right. So
- 45:24the court basically said, look, There's nothing
- 45:27we can do, go to Congress. So this was 1903.
- 45:301904, Congress decides a case called Dantzler
- 45:33versus Lever. And this is a contested election
- 45:35case where Alexander Dantzler was challenging
- 45:40his loss in a congressional race in South Carolina.
- 45:43His argument was that the South Carolina Constitution
- 45:46of 1895 was unconstitutional and violated the
- 45:50U .S. Constitution because it disenfranchised
- 45:52Black people in the state. Now, Congress in an
- 45:55earlier contested election case had actually
- 45:57found that South Carolina's 1882 voter registration
- 46:00law was unconstitutional, and they basically
- 46:02found that the opponent should have gotten a
- 46:04seat. So you had an instance where Congress itself
- 46:06was deciding on the constitutionality of a state
- 46:09law. But by the time we get to Dantzler in 1904,
- 46:13Congress says, go to the courts. They completely
- 46:16wipe their hands of any obligation to police
- 46:20Southern political systems. And this could have
- 46:23been true for a number of reasons. I think the
- 46:25primary motivation behind this is one of political
- 46:28will, but also the nature of the argument being
- 46:31made. So Dantzler is saying, look, the South
- 46:34Carolina constitution is invalid. That could
- 46:37be true for every constitution passed across
- 46:39the South. That entire decade and Congress did
- 46:43not want to put itself in the position of invalidating,
- 46:45you know, most of the congressional races across
- 46:49the South during this time period. And so it
- 46:51really does become an issue of institutional
- 46:54capability and political will. So within and
- 46:58this is also, I want to make one more point.
- 47:00In 1902, Congress had heard Congress heard a
- 47:04contested election case where. they vindicated
- 47:07these principles, right? These principles that
- 47:10there should be no racial discrimination in voting,
- 47:12but within two years, they completely changed
- 47:14their tune. So 1903 Supreme Court is out, 1904
- 47:18Congress is out. These voters have no recourse.
- 47:22I had a couple of last questions that I wanted
- 47:25to go to, and you really point in the direction
- 47:28of, to me, what was the most important one. You
- 47:30mentioned, and I was going to, the title of your
- 47:33book is In Congress We Trust Question mark. What's
- 47:38the lesson to draw from the 19th century about
- 47:42Congress? Congress is dysfunctional today, as
- 47:45it's ever been in history. There are a lot of
- 47:49points of being dysfunctional, but hard to imagine
- 47:51being more dysfunctional than it is now. Congress
- 47:53has its lowest approval ratings ever. I think
- 47:56Congress' approval rating right now is at 16.
- 47:59That might be 16 people, not 16%. And yet, As
- 48:05you said at the beginning of our conversation,
- 48:07you say in the book, you want to champion Congress's
- 48:11role in enforcing all these provisions of the
- 48:13Constitution. Can we, based on the history you
- 48:16tell, turn to Congress? I think it's our right.
- 48:21And I think that's different, right? We have
- 48:23a right to turn to Congress. Congress, we have
- 48:26to start viewing Congress as having an affirmative
- 48:29obligation to police elections and protect voters.
- 48:33And we don't do that. That's why it's become
- 48:35optional, right? So it's not a question of, do
- 48:39we want to interpret constitutional power in
- 48:42this way, given that Congress has tied its own
- 48:45hands? Congress has no right to do that. And
- 48:48this is why I want to write the second book,
- 48:49which is In the People We Trust, question mark,
- 48:52because there are also question marks there too.
- 48:54But it does reinforce this idea of thinking about
- 48:57The power to police elections and voters is not
- 49:01lying solely with Congress But it's also idea
- 49:04of Congress interacting with these other entities
- 49:06because although this book is called in Congress
- 49:08we trust it is still a Narrative about how Congress
- 49:11has interacted with the states and the courts,
- 49:13right? So how have what how do the people fit
- 49:16into this, right? But fundamentally, I think
- 49:18we have to stop treating Congress as if Congress
- 49:21has a choice Section 2 of the 14th Amendment
- 49:24says Congress shall So enforcing the penalty
- 49:28of reduced representation, Congress has to. It
- 49:31has a constitutional obligation to do this, and
- 49:34it just has not honored that obligation. So that's
- 49:37why I feel comfortable saying, in Congress we
- 49:39trust, but the question mark, I think, captures
- 49:42the complicated history of this. One other point
- 49:46I want to make, and I've always been sort of
- 49:47hesitant to make this point, given the times
- 49:50that we live in, but... I also had some concerns
- 49:53about writing this because of the language of
- 49:55the guarantee clause. The federal government
- 49:57should guarantee to each state a Republican form
- 49:59of government. That includes the president, right?
- 50:02That keeps me up at night, right? Because you
- 50:06can sort of think about all the different ways
- 50:08that this provision could be justified given
- 50:09the political moment that we live in. My sense
- 50:13of things is that's why the people become very,
- 50:16very important actors in all of this because
- 50:18we are actually the entity that should constrain
- 50:20or alternatively encourage these political actors
- 50:24to do what they need to do in order to protect
- 50:25our system of government. That's very powerful.
- 50:29Let me just push back for a second and ask, why
- 50:32is it that Congress has consistently, though
- 50:36not always, failed? Part of what you tell in
- 50:39the story of the 19th century is what Congress
- 50:41at times has succeeded. But Congress has never
- 50:43enforced the Guarantee Clause. It's never enforced
- 50:46Section 2 of the 14th Amendment. And then the
- 50:49question is, why not? Is it the politics of the
- 50:54situation that Congress wasn't going to declare
- 50:57malapportionment to be a violation of the Guarantee
- 50:59Clause because there were too many members of
- 51:01Congress that benefited from malapportionment?
- 51:04And so if we can assess why has Congress failed,
- 51:08does that help give any sense of how to assess
- 51:11that question mark? I think so. So I will say
- 51:15just one slight pushback. Congress has enforced
- 51:17the guarantee clause. So when Congress readmitted
- 51:19the former Confederate states back into the union,
- 51:22that was the guarantee clause. But I think that
- 51:26they're called the Reconstruction Acts. They
- 51:28don't get a ton of attention, but I do think
- 51:30they provide a model for how we should think
- 51:32about Republican government. But I think we learn
- 51:37a lot from both the successes and the failures.
- 51:39And if you think about the arc of American history,
- 51:42so much of our high points are unprecedented,
- 51:46right? So Reconstruction was an unprecedented
- 51:48moment in American history. You had some of the
- 51:51most diverse state legislatures that this country
- 51:54had ever seen. That had never happened before.
- 51:56And then, you know, there's the backlash and
- 52:00then we have kind of 70 years where there's nothing
- 52:03resembling democracy in the South at all. And
- 52:05then you have the civil rights movement and we
- 52:07have another moment where we've reached unprecedented
- 52:09heights in terms of inclusive democratic participation.
- 52:13And so for me, the lesson is that. It's not even
- 52:16necessarily about Congress. It's more so about
- 52:18the fact that democracy is an ongoing project.
- 52:21I think the next time that we reach unprecedented
- 52:23heights, it'll be unprecedented that we will
- 52:26surpass the reconstruction moment. We will surpass
- 52:28the civil rights movement. And we have the capability
- 52:32of reaching another pinnacle, a third reconstruction
- 52:35that really does reflect the potential in our
- 52:40governing documents. But I think one thing that
- 52:43we lose in these efforts to make ourselves a
- 52:47more perfect union is the fact that the effort
- 52:50has to be ongoing. It's like we've reached these
- 52:52pinnacles and we get comfortable. Then all of
- 52:55a sudden we're having conversations again that
- 52:57we had 25 years ago. But yeah, so I think that's
- 53:02why I'm hopeful. Yeah, I so hope that you're
- 53:05right. I wanted to ask though as we're concluding
- 53:08about the role of the courts. You began in our
- 53:11conversation by saying that when you and I went
- 53:13to law school, it was in the shadow of the Warren
- 53:15court, and we were very focused on the courts.
- 53:19And you said part of what you want to do is tell
- 53:20the story about Congress's role and what the
- 53:2319th century tells about that. And you do so
- 53:25brilliantly in this book. But when Congress fails,
- 53:31and Congress has largely not enforced the Guarantee
- 53:33Clause, largely not enforced Section 2 of the
- 53:35Constitution, what do you see the role of the
- 53:37judiciary in those circumstances? The funny thing
- 53:40is I don't think I have to fully abdicate this
- 53:43idea that the court plays a role in in constitutional
- 53:45interpretation, like they're definitely. some
- 53:49legal scholars who think constitutional interpretation
- 53:52outside of the courts is like the way to go.
- 53:54I'm actually not advocating for that. I think
- 53:57about it in terms of deference, right? If Congress
- 53:59is passing federal legislation pursuant to more
- 54:02than one source of constitutional authority,
- 54:04perhaps that's a situation in which the Supreme
- 54:05Court should be more deferential to whether or
- 54:07not that legislation is constitutional. Right.
- 54:10The history in some ways informs our view of
- 54:13how the court should approach Congress's efforts
- 54:16to protect voting and elections, particularly
- 54:18since there are provisions in the Constitution
- 54:20that envision congressional and not court enforcement.
- 54:24I think it's a terrific point. Of course, in
- 54:25your epilogue, you talk about the Supreme Court
- 54:27in Shelby County versus Holder in 2013, striking
- 54:31down key provisions of the Voting Rights Act.
- 54:34Louisiana versus Calais from April 29th this
- 54:36year. Essentially gutting another key provision
- 54:39of the Voting Rights Act, which I think reflects
- 54:43what you're talking about now, but also tells
- 54:45us why if we're going to advance, it has to be
- 54:48in Congress we trust. Yeah, I think so. Or in
- 54:52Congress we trust in partnership with others.
- 54:56I know we're at the lecture. Was there anything
- 54:58that I didn't ask you that you really wanted
- 55:01to talk about that we should be sure we get in
- 55:04before we have to finish? No, I think we did
- 55:07a pretty good job of canvassing the major themes
- 55:09in the book. I look forward to writing the next
- 55:12part so that I can bring some more insights into
- 55:15the current moment. But I will say it has been
- 55:18remarkable to see how much this history, even
- 55:21though it stops in 1910, is still really relevant
- 55:24to what's going on in our politics today. I'm
- 55:30so excited to read the next book, but I want
- 55:31to conclude by recommending to everybody that
- 55:34they read this book, is hopefully I've been able
- 55:36to communicate. It's a brilliant book, and I've
- 55:40learned a tremendous amount from it. And I do
- 55:42have to include, I always like reading people's
- 55:45acknowledgments, and yours are very touching.
- 55:47But I have to tell you that your dog, Liberty,
- 55:49has asked me to advocate for being able to be
- 55:52on the couch. The acknowledgments say that, quote,
- 55:56also stay off my couch. So I'm here to advocate
- 55:58the dog being able to have the right to be on
- 56:01the couch, even lacking congressional or Supreme
- 56:04Court action for it. Thank you. She doesn't listen,
- 56:07so she ends up out. Why should she be different
- 56:11than any other dogs? Franita, thank you for giving
- 56:14me the pleasure of being able to have this conversation.
- 56:16And I'm thrilled to look forward to doing it
- 56:18again when the new book comes out. Thank you
- 56:20so much, Erwin.