Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / Sitting Still Is Not Learning
Transcript
- Ilana: What if I told you that for some students, sitting still actually blocks their learning? not distracts from their learning, it doesn't make learning harder for those students, it actually blocks it. And yet, every single day in our modern classrooms, we ask children to suppress movement for hours at a time. And then we wonder why so many of our students are disengaged, they become dysregulated, or they get labeled as behavioral challenges. And that's if they don't have a teacher who keeps them in during recess because they haven't completed their work. Okay. We have built entire school systems around the idea that quiet bodies equals focused minds. But for millions of learners, movement isn't a distraction from cognition. Movement is cognition. And when schools punish movement, instead of trying to understand where it's coming from, we don't just lose student engagement, we lose thinkers, we lose creators and builders, we lose problem solvers. We completely lose those kids whose brains were never designed to learn passively. So today, we're talking about why modern classrooms are failing our learners and how compliance culture became mistaken for education and what we can actually do differently. Welcome back to the podcast. is Pedagogically Speaking. My name is Alana Huffer. I've been teaching for 16 years and I am currently working both in classroom setting and as an inclusive education teacher. created this podcast so that we as teachers ⁓ have a community to lean on and to come and learn from one another ⁓ some laughs ⁓ our collective knowledge and take a breath really. Teaching is so hard right now and there's nothing on the horizon that would suggest it's going to get any easier anytime soon. So hopefully we can talk about everything they don't cover in those textbooks they make us read. Okay today's conversation is one I think a lot of teachers, parents, and honestly former students are going to feel deeply in their nervous systems because we're talking about movements, learning, and the dangerous myth that good students sit still, right? And I mean, honestly... This conversation matters because so many of our students spend their entire school careers internalizing this idea that their bodies are somehow wrong, their bodies are not helpful for learning. ⁓ their bodies behave in a way that's not natural to learn. These are the students who tap, who rock, who need to pace when they're thinking. This is the child who focuses better when they're doodling. The student who learns math fastest when they're physically manipulating objects. This is the child who melts down after hours of force. stillness and we are often framing these students as distracted and disruptive and unfocused impulsive or even behavioral but one of But what if many of them are actually responding normally to the educational environment that they find themselves in, but that is fundamentally mismatched to their own human development? So that's the conversation I'm really hoping that we can have here today. And I think it's really interesting to kind of think about how did the institution of education start equating stillness with learning? I mean, think, colonially, right, we can say that that happened fairly early on with, ⁓ yeah, education as a concept. ⁓ Yeah, as like a colonizing power. You know, I remember watching, so I grew up in Toronto and so we would go to, I forget what it's called, but like this place, think a lot of, I think people go there for like fun. I know it was definitely like a common field trip in the 80s and 90s at least, where you would go and you would see how people, know, white colonizers lived back then. And so you would see like steel mills and they'd always make us eat like candied orange peel. Weird. And then you would see the schoolhouse and I grew up also watching like Rota Emily. ⁓ So also like, you sit still and don't move. And that's what like learning looks like, right? Or that's what education is. So I think we can definitely say that it's stuff that it has started. It's been a part of this institutionalization of education, at least, you know, in ⁓ North America since colonization and I'm sure it came over from colonizing countries like England and so it's most likely quite similar. ⁓ And it hasn't changed much. I've already said modern education and talking about that, that's another episode, what is modern education? But I think that's kind of what we're looking at and dissecting here, right? Because somewhere along the way, education became visually tied to stillness. Rows of desks, quiet bodies, eyes forward, hands folded, minimal movement, ⁓ passive listening, everyone looking at the teacher and this idea that you can only learn from the teacher, learning only happens in the classroom. what we do in the classroom, so you must be learning, And 100%, to be fair, schools didn't invent this out of nowhere, of course. And right now what we're dealing with with large class sizes and this like industrial era efficiency model, right? Like the more kids you can cram into a classroom, the more learning that's gonna happen, right? It's so opposite to what we know through lived experiences as teachers and through research. It's not the more bodies are in there, the more people are learning at all. It's the opposite, right? Quite frankly, you need less bodies in there so more enriched learning happens and learning for meaning and respected learning with dignity as well. And the more kids you have in there, the less learning that's gonna happen. ⁓ So yeah, this is also happening because of what's happening to us. as educators in education, like including limited staffing and standardized testing pressure and everything that comes along with that. And this like institutional control, you know, it's all contributed to classrooms that prioritize manageability and compliance. How could it not? You know, there's no EAs, there's counselors, there's not enough anything to go. around and teachers are clinging onto this right now because stillness is easier to supervise. And with classroom spaces becoming smaller and smaller with more and more students, with more and more needs being put into these teeny tiny classrooms with little to no support or resources, supervision and being able to get through the day is what education is turning into within our underfunded school systems. But I digress. As we all know, all of this does not lead to the best learning. And easier to supervise does not necessarily mean better for learning. OK. And this is where we need to start separating behavior management from cognitive science. Because many classrooms unintentionally reward students whose nervous systems are able to tolerate the sedentary learning while penalizing students whose brains require movement. and tactile learning and interaction and sensory engagement in order to be able to process the information that they're being bombarded with effectively. ⁓ It's hard because we all know those kids that fly under the radar, right? Those kids that, ⁓ well, they're just quiet. So I think they're working. And then it's not until however long it is for you as a teacher before you realize that that student doesn't know what's going on. Or yes, that student's handed things in and they're not done or they're not done correctly or anything. And that's part of what we're talking about here today. It's those students who will also just fly under the radar. It's that quiet student who may not be learning. And an active student may actually be deeply engaged. But schools visually reward one and correct the other. Which is tough. You know, when people hear like this idea of a kinesthetic learner, they can sometimes reduce it to, ⁓ well, they just like to move around. But it's much deeper than that, right? Kinesthetic learning involves many different things, know, and involves processing information through physical interaction and movement and, you know, being able to touch things and work things through and experiment and manipulate different things, you know, this embodied experience for these learners. Because for many students, movement increases attention and tactile input improves memory, right? Physical engagement supports emotional regulation and sensory interaction strengthens comprehension. So. Basically, some students literally think more clearly when they're moving. And I mean, come on, we all know adults who do this too, right? Pacing when they're brainstorming, walking while talking on the phone, pacing when they're reading something short, fidgeting during meetings, clicking our pens, exercising so they can regulate their stress or improve their focus, right? So we know adults like this. But for some reason, we expect children whose brains and nervous systems are still developing to remain motionless for hours and call that readiness to learn, right? But it's not developmentally natural. So. the nervous system and this like piece that we're ignoring. I think that's the part education systems still profoundly underestimate. know, movement is not just preference. Movement is regulation. And I really do think we need to stop thinking of movement as a choice. aren't choosing it. It's a requirement. Students aren't choosing to annoy you. They're not choosing to move. Their body is making them move. And we need to respect that. For many students, movement helps them with their sensory input. It helps them to maintain alertness. It helps them to manage the anxiety they're feeling, to increase the oxygen flow. It helps them organize their thinking. And movement helps them sustain their executive functioning. So when we remove that system entirely, some students do not become more focused. They become actively dysregulated and then they're dysregulating everyone else and they're impacting other students learning because you've taken away the thing that helps them learn. And then schools often respond to that dysregulation with further restrictions. Sit properly, stop fidgeting, don't do that. Hands to yourself, eyes on me, stay in your seat, don't kick the... the table, stop scrunching the piece of paper. And what does that do for that student, right? Like it creates an exhausting cycle. where students are spending more cognitive energy suppressing their natural regulation systems and strategies than they are actually learning any content. ⁓ So do you think they're learning anything? Because now all of sudden, all of that brain space that was freed up because they were moving and they could listen and process and... ⁓ you know, like apply their own personal context to what they're learning and learn how to apply mathematical concepts, whatever it is that you're teaching, all of that cognitive power now is going to like, I need to sit still, don't move, you need to move, don't move, don't move, you need to move, da da da da da da, right? Now they're not taking anything in. and then what's going to happen? You're going to come over and ask them a question. They have no idea. They have not been listening because they're desperately trying to suppress their natural behavior. And that's not education, that's survival masking. So then who gets harmed the most, right? This system disproportionately impacts kinesthetic learners, neurodivergent students, highly sensory learners, younger students, students with attention regulation difficulties. students experiencing stress and students experiencing trauma. And what really worries me is how quickly movement gets moralized. You know, we often interpret stillness as respect. And then we see movement as defiance. But really, we need to take ourselves and our egos. out of what the student is doing for themselves. Because movement is not automatic disrespect. Sometimes movement is adaptation. Sometimes movement is regulation. Sometimes movement is literally the brain trying desperately to stay engaged. These students want to be learning. They want to be active participants. at school, okay? But when students repeatedly receive negative feedback for how they naturally regulate themselves, they will often internalize shame around the learning itself. And I'm gonna repeat that for you because it is important, okay? When students repeatedly receive negative feedback for natural regulation needs, they often internalize shame around learning itself. And that's not what we want to do. We want to create lifelong learners who see themselves as learners. We want to take those barriers away from learning. We don't want students to say things like, I'm just bad at school or teachers don't like me. I can't focus and I'm always in trouble. Okay? When in reality, it's not them. The environment simply does not respect the way that they process information. The learning environment does not work with how they process information. Now don't take this away and mean like, well, you just want like the classroom to be chaotic. No, I don't. You know, this does not mean that classrooms become... like free for alls, you know, that's usually the fear, right? It's one or the other, but it doesn't need to be like that. You know, like, I think we just need to like, let's just stop and remember this has nothing about you. This is biology, right? This is how the students are combined with what the education system means when it's... Not just underfunded this year, but chronically underfunded and with no resources, right? So let's not forget that and let's not succumb to that fear, right? So we forget that... You know, movement-friendly learning can happen. It can be highly structured as well. And it looks like, you know, flexible seating. Standing desks. Movement breaks. Not being, you know, like, we got to get rid of this thing of like, ⁓ does the student take too many bathroom breaks? Fair enough. It's good to note that and then check in, right? Like, one, is it a physical problem? Good to note. Two, is it a cognitive thing? Do they need those movement breaks? Maybe you can give them movement breaks instead of them wandering the halls. I don't know what you've got. But it looks like that's one of the things that you can do. Movement breaks, I really like using floor work. Obviously, I use a lot of hands-on manipulatives. Interactive stations with one of them being outside, if you can. Outdoor learning, role play is a good one. Building-based projects. Walk and talk discussions, very good. sensory tools, learning through creation rather than passive consumption. You know, I love having like little math stations. I'm sure you all do this because I've been doing it since I started and I and I do it because I one of my practicum teachers did it and I was like genius, know, like with like like I think sometimes it's done like where you pass out the cards like like there'll be like a mathematical equation let's say and then like will be the base of it and then like in the top corner there'll be like the number. right? And they'll have to find it. I just kind of like having that's one way to do it. And I do that more like at the beginning of each term and definitely the beginning of the year, because we're also getting to know to know the classroom and stuff. But I go to like, I'll go to the school playground or somewhere close by the school, but like a little bit of a walk. And while they're playing, I'll be taping things up. And I'll give them a chart. And like, they have to tell me, like, so all of them will be either numbered or like numerically or like alphabetically. So they need to tell me the answer to the main question that's on the chart and then what letter had that right answer, right? So they have to, so it's just a bunch of different things. And it's nice because we go outside, they're moving around, they're learning, they're checking for their own learning too, which I think is really important as well. And like, and then we're outside and it's fun. You know what I mean? And so we're just hitting all those different things, getting outside time, they're moving around, they're learning, they're checking their learning. And I think that's really, that's great. And you can do that with anything, right? You can do that in like socials or history or different things like that. And you can do it for different grades as well. I've done it for, I've honestly done it for K to two, no, I was gonna say 12, but not 12, probably K to 10 over 16 years. So, you know, it's a really great way to do that. Yeah, so we just trying to avoid that passive consumption. And I think another thing to just remember is that movement doesn't reduce rigor, right? A student can deeply understand math while they're standing or walking around. You know, a student can certainly analyze literature while they're walking. ⁓ Students can demonstrate scientific thinking ⁓ through building and ⁓ obviously through experimentation. That's the whole point. You know, the problem isn't movement. I think also sometimes when we talk about these things, teachers get really nervous. Fair enough. There's so much going on. There's no collab time. When are you, know, like, and I think also, I mean, when you're stressed and burnt out and overwhelmed, you already have like, think, a thin layer of like... It's hard to have self-esteem and like a full sense of self. So you'll often think, well, I don't know how to do that, right? Sometimes I'll talk to teachers and like, okay, like we need some visuals. Well, what are visuals? I don't know what's a visual. And I'm like, and I'll go into the classroom like that's a visual. Look, see, you've got the visual timetable right there. ⁓ look, I can see, you know, you've got the work that you're doing up on the projector. Everyone's following along. I'm like, those are all visuals. And so these are probably also things that you're all already doing to help your students and maybe you just need to, we just need to increase it, right? Like it can be, you can take things outside. Students can be doing things when they're walking. It doesn't need to be a big thing. Doesn't need to be a big change, right? What can you implement that will help your students who need to move? ⁓ that's also not completely throwing off your lessons, right? And I bet you can think of some things. And if not, email or talk to some of your colleagues. We can all work on this together, okay? And I do love getting your emails, so please keep emailing me at pedagogicallyspeakingpod at gmail.com. I absolutely love reading your emails, so thank you so much. So yeah, another problem I think. know, education systems still define learning through that passive observation. And also that teachers do want quick fixes that let their students move while they're staying at their desks. This one I really wrote, I really care deeply about this part. I don't know if you can tell, because I keep being like, OK, here we go. So like this idea that, well, this kid needs to move, so I'm gonna put something on their desk to help them move, right? And it'll be like a band around their desk so that they can push against it and different things like that. But like, if a student needs to move, can they really be at their desks? And I think yes, for a short term, absolutely. Have a standing desk, you know, ⁓ have those rubber bands on the desk so the kids can push against instead of kick it or bounce their feet. Great. But that's not actually meant to keep them there for the whole time. That's not something that it's like, okay, great, now you can sit there for an hour until recess and then an hour until lunch and then two hours straight after lunch until the last bell, right? Or whatever it is. Fidgets and bike tires, those are all great for 15 minutes that they need to be doing something, but it's never meant for the students to be able to sit all day at their desk, okay? These great tools, ⁓ but it's meant to be used for a small part of the day. reality check. And I do, I do want to be careful here. Okay, because teachers are not the villains in this conversation at all. I'm a teacher. You know, we're all teachers here and we're all already overwhelmed for reasons that we've talked about already. Large class sizes, limited EA support, minimal prep time, no collab time, pressure on curriculum pacing, behavior complexity, having to be what? We have to be everything all the time. ⁓ We're always on our prep times used to take in with meetings lunchtime meetings before and after school meetings never enough time to do anything standardized expectations over stimulating classroom environments. We are trying to survive systems that were never designed around actual human learning let's face it or human nervous systems either right and So sometimes these rigid classroom structures emerge because teachers are managing impossible demands. know, teachers are meant to be so many different people ⁓ before even teaching happens, right? conversation become ⁓ just need to try ⁓ No, teachers are trying as as they can. This is systemic, okay? ⁓ Meaningful movement, space, learning, often requires smaller ratios, better funding, more flexibility, training, training in sensory-informed practice, outdoor spaces, collaborative support, all mixed less obsession on standardized compliance. I don't know what your schools are like. I don't know what your classroom is like. I know that I work in two very different schools. And one school I can get outside easily. One school I can have students work on a station. I can put two stations outside. And I can still see them. And I can still hear them. And I know what's going on. That's not, I was going to say that's not normal, but that's not everywhere, right? I mean in New Zealand I could do that easy as well, but where I teach now, no. And that's just one classroom, or that's just one school. But if you, but you know your space as well and you know what you can handle and you know what you can manage. And I think trying it right now is great to see what's to see if it works. You've got nothing left to lose. There's six weeks left of school. Whoa. ⁓ yeah, I really think we need to fundamentally rethink ⁓ what engagement can look like your classroom right now, because we want to engage and learning does not always look quiet, right? Sometimes it looks noisy. It's curious. It's experimental. It's collaborative. It's physical and hopefully creative. And you know, it's just like many workplaces already understand this better than schools. So like, what's up with that? What's up with the fact that we know that there's we know that the workforce is changing and changing what the expectations of workers are. You know, and in these kind of places, are encouraged to brainstorm dynamically and collaborate actively and move during meetings and use flexible workspaces and personalize their productivity strategies. But that is not happening in schools. That's not happening with teachers, education assistants. ⁓ It's not. And it's certainly not happening with children because too often, too often children are expected to learn in one very rigid physical format regardless of neurological need. And that disconnect matters, especially when we know more now about cognition, we know more now about sensory processing, about regulation and neurodiversity than ever before. And how are the schools that we work at actually using that research? I often don't go to Pro-D days at my school because we are supposed to sit there and take information, then we get asked. And then it always sucks when we get asked at the end of it, wasn't that great? And if you have anything... to say that's meaningful, that's not like, ⁓ that was amazing. You get shot down. You get told you're not like a team player and all that. You get told like, well, anyone can find meaning in anything. Like how could you, you really couldn't take any, you didn't take anything away from that. I just think, what is this shame? Like it isn't like, why, why are people's egos so involved in things. Do you know what I mean? Whether it's whoever it is, I guess. What is the point of that? ⁓ What is the point of shaming people and what is the point? of putting your ego in something that you don't need to put it in. You weren't the one that did the pro-D, you know? It's okay. And then what do you do? Do you play the game so you just lie, you smile and nod? Yeah, it was great, dah, dah. I'm not that teacher and I'm not the teacher that's gonna talk about someone behind their back either. I will vent. Final reflection. This has been a big episode for me. ⁓ ⁓ I think one the most damaging things schools can do. is convince students that their natural way of engaging with the world is wrong. Because when children are here, because when children repeatedly hear, stop moving, sit still, calm down, you're distracting. You need better self control. You need to regulate yourself. they may eventually stop seeing themselves as learners, as capable learners altogether. And that loss of identity is incredibly hard to undo. Movement is not the enemy of learning. For many students, movement is the pathway into learning. So maybe the question isn't, how do we make kids sit still longer? Maybe the real question is, why are our systems still demanding stillness at the expense of cognition? Because if our classrooms only work for students who can tolerate prolonged passive learning, then we know the problem isn't the students. It's the structure. and institutionalization of education. Thank you so much for listening today. If this episode resonates to you, I would love for you to share it with an educator, a teacher, a parent, a support worker, or anyone who you think needs to hear this conversation. And if you were a student who spent years feeling bad at school simply because your body needed movement, I hope this episode helped reframe some of that experience. You were never failing at learning. Learning environments may have been failing you. Okay, I'll see you next time.