Latest / Foth and Friends: Stories from the Road / Making Money and Making Glad
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, I'm Dick Foth, and I'd like to welcome you to known stories to make sense of it all.
- 0:09These stories are what I call walking books, real-life people, different places, different
- 0:16ages, different cultures, and I want to have some conversations with them across disciplines
- 0:21and generations and cultures in order to encourage a kind of knowing fresh lenses through
- 0:29which to see the world. One of those lenses will be Scripture, or more specifically, Jesus
- 0:36of Nazareth, whose life I believe changed the course of the history of the world. So thanks
- 0:44for listening in. Great to have you with us.
- 0:48My guest today is Mike Messner, a friend of many years who travels the world and works
- 0:54with folks in a variety of missions and causes around the world. So, Mike, great to have
- 1:00you here with me this morning. Thanks. Great to be here. I want to ask you a question that
- 1:05has some multicyllable words in it. Why is social entrepreneurship becoming so popular among
- 1:18younger folks around the world? First of all, to find that form of what I just shared.
- 1:23Well, let's start with just entrepreneurship. That's a word and a concept that's been
- 1:29around for as long as any of us can remember. Entrepreneurship is just simply the idea
- 1:36going out, starting businesses or starting enterprises and running those to accomplish
- 1:44some purpose. Most of the time it's all done around profit. But what's becoming very
- 1:50popular with both large corporations, publicly traded companies as well as small startups
- 1:57is having some blend between creating shareholder wealth and a higher purpose. That's where
- 2:05the social part comes in. Entrepreneurship is that startup of a new business. Social,
- 2:12that part of it means we're helping someone or some group of people in a way that
- 2:18betters their life, but we're doing it through a business. So, would it be fair to synthesize
- 2:27it or make a synoptic statement about it that we want to both do well and do good at
- 2:36the same time? Well, that's exactly spot on. That's exactly what it's about. You're doing
- 2:41well. That's shareholder wealth development and you're doing good to others. That's the
- 2:48higher purpose part. So, higher purpose, at least in our circles, is often thought about
- 2:55faith-based stuff. But higher purpose in the business context is helping people in any
- 3:01number of ways. It could be creating jobs. It could be helping the environment. It could
- 3:07be any way that you can bring value to and kind of raise the bar that betters people's
- 3:13lives in a given setting. So, where do you, you know, you and I are both Jesus followers,
- 3:18right? Exactly. And I say that simply but not in an off-hand way. How does the way he thinks
- 3:29or the way you read him in scriptures shape that or fit what you are just talking about?
- 3:37Well, one of the hallmarks of Jesus teaching and the way he dealt with people, at least
- 3:43for me, the way I read the gospels and about Jesus is Jesus never shied away from dealing
- 3:49with hard issues in people's lives. But he always did it in a way that preserved the dignity
- 3:54of the individual. And so, that nugget of teaching of how Jesus went about dealing with
- 4:03people you see in social entrepreneurship. So, for instance, I have a friend that runs
- 4:08a coffee shop in Greece. No, the economy of Greece is probably one of the toughest in the
- 4:14world arguably today. And so, what you find in small businesses, small and medium enterprises,
- 4:21SEMs, is that you'll have people that say that again. I mean SMEs, excuse me. SME is a small
- 4:29medium enterprise. So, most of the economies of the world, in fact I would say all the economies
- 4:36of the world are driven not by the multinational corporations, but they're driven by the mom and
- 4:43pop small companies, small medium enterprise. So, the small and medium enterprise in Greece,
- 4:51you'll have employees come and they work and they don't get paid because there's no money. You'll
- 4:57have vendors that will provide goods and services and won't get paid. You'll have taxes that are
- 5:02due that don't get paid. That's the norm in Greece. So, when a social entrepreneur comes in and forms
- 5:13a company and has a value proposition like a coffee shop, so you've got money coming in, you've got
- 5:19employees, you've got the exchange of goods and services, but they pay their employees, they operate
- 5:26their company in such a way that they're conservative and they pay their vendors and they pay their
- 5:33taxes and they do it following the teachings of Jesus. Every time they pay that employee and don't
- 5:41cheat them out of work, I mean out of their pay for their work, they're treating them with dignity.
- 5:47And they're giving them a decent wage for a good day's work and it helps the individual,
- 5:55it helps the economy, it creates jobs, it does all those kinds of things. So, thus it's a social
- 6:01enterprise that they're doing well and they're doing good at the same time. How did you get involved
- 6:07in this? Where did that start for you? Well, I've been fascinated with business my entire life.
- 6:17So, I like the idea of creating an idea, having a dream and then pursuing it and creating an
- 6:25organization that brings that about. So, later in life, I've had several decades of working with
- 6:33nonprofit organizations and so forth. I just felt like the world is changing and I need to stay
- 6:42up with it. So, in my mid-50s, I went back to school, went to Washington University and got an
- 6:49MBA in St. Louis and the reason I did that wasn't so that I could further my career. I was too old,
- 6:57too far along, but I wanted the long into tooth as we say. Exactly. Too many gray hairs or too many
- 7:05hairs have turned loose. What are the other? So, I did that not for career advancement. I did it so
- 7:15number one, I could understand the language of business and number two, I would have the tools
- 7:20to be able to help others because that's been a life mission of mine is to come alongside
- 7:26visionary leaders and help them to operationalize their vision. Well, if I don't understand the
- 7:32language of the marketplace as much as I should or want to and I don't have the tools, then I can
- 7:40only help them so much. So, having gone back and gone through that process and earning an MBA
- 7:48and going through the academic rigors, it just invigorated me in the idea that the marketplace
- 7:56can be one of the most effective platforms to show people who Jesus is and the teachings of
- 8:03Jesus because when you come into the marketplace and you're competing in the marketplace,
- 8:08you have access to everybody. You have access to the customers, to fellow entrepreneurs, to the
- 8:14people that you're serving the people you're competing with and what better platform can you find
- 8:21to demonstrate how Jesus interacted with people. So, let's wrap this up. Let me see if I can
- 8:27synthesize or capture what I hear you saying. Social entrepreneurship essentially is creating
- 8:36an enterprise that both does well, provides profit and does good, provides value at the same time
- 8:46and most often, or it's easiest to see this in SMEs which are small to medium enterprises.
- 8:55Small, medium enterprise. Mom and pop operations, things that many of us have been involved in
- 9:02or might be involved in as we see, driving through any town in America, any town around the world,
- 9:07you see this. Entrepreneurship is something a lot of folks talk about and a lot of folks try and
- 9:15fail so getting to the how is big. Let's see what Mike has to say about that.
- 9:25We talked about social entrepreneurship, which in a phrase is creating an enterprise that both
- 9:32does well on the one hand, i.e. makes a profit and does good on the other hand, that is adds value
- 9:40to somebody's life out there. We talked about the why of that and we talked about the why of it,
- 9:48but let's talk a little bit about the how. Where do we, how, if I wanted to do this,
- 9:56if I wanted to create a small to medium enterprise, and I assume the smallest filter toward the
- 10:03medium that I don't want to stay small. How do we go there and talk to me about what is the bottom
- 10:11line of that look like? Sure. Well, let's start at that point talking out the bottom line because
- 10:17in social entrepreneurship, there are multiple bottom lines. So you reference one, one is profit,
- 10:26that's the most obvious. If you have a sustainable business, you have to have profit.
- 10:33The old adage goes, if you don't have profit, you don't have tomorrow, if you don't have cash,
- 10:37you don't have today. So you've got to be generating cash and you have to ultimately be generating
- 10:43profit from the business. So that's the, let's call that the economic bottom line. Then there's the
- 10:51social bottom line and that bottom line is the value proposition and that's just a simple little
- 10:59phrase that says, I have this idea, that's the proposition, that is a value, that's what helps
- 11:07other people. So you create a value proposition by looking around, most great ideas on products
- 11:16and services, great companies are built because somebody has a need or they have a job that needs to
- 11:23get done and they have an idea, hey, this idea, this value proposition would help meet that need.
- 11:32So with the original value proposition for say, Tom Shoes, which has become
- 11:39internationally famous, where I buy a pair of shoes here and Tom's gives a pair to someone
- 11:46in a developing nation that needs shoes. Would that be your value proposition? Yeah, I can think
- 11:51immediately of three different types of value propositions there. Number one, you have the
- 11:56value proposition that you offer to the customer that buys the shoes. They need a new pair of shoes
- 12:02that are stylish for today. Number two value proposition is the person that is going to receive
- 12:11the free pair, they have a need and that is they need shoes and most often I've been in India,
- 12:20I've worked with a client of mine that distributed a million pairs of those Tom Shoes and most of
- 12:25those go to children and so these children are out there, many times literally barefoot or in old
- 12:33shoes or shoes that don't fit. So the value proposition for them is they get a new pair of shoes
- 12:39that fits while the child's growing up. Value proposition number three is back to the person
- 12:46that buys the shoes, they have a need and this would be kind of the social part of it. They have a
- 12:53need to help other people and they don't necessarily know how to do it. So Tom's provides a vehicle
- 13:01for them to not only buy a pair of shoes but to help somebody that's in need by doing it. So it's a
- 13:07great example of having layers in this case of value proposition. So I don't know somebody in
- 13:16Coimbatore South India and I only know that name because I grew up there as a kid in that part of
- 13:21the world but Tom Shoes then becomes sort of a social broker for my need to help somebody that I
- 13:33don't know and I can always help people I do know but for those I don't know but they have a need
- 13:39that's a way for me to engage in the larger planet if you will. Exactly. So bringing it back to
- 13:45home if your listener is listening to this let's say in the United States right and they're in a
- 13:51place where they look around them and they may see here are some young people that are you know
- 14:00let's say that you know they they have a lot of time on their hands they don't have a lot to do
- 14:06they're out on the street maybe they're into mischief one kind or another and that person wants
- 14:12to help them so they could go directly and you know talk to them and try to convince them you
- 14:17know this that or another and and change them that way or maybe they start a business and that
- 14:25business is built around the idea of I'm going to deliver let's say that they start you know a
- 14:32pizza business right I'm going to make the best pizza in town and and we're going to build our
- 14:37business on delivery we deliver the quickest and the best of anybody at town but I'm going to
- 14:45hire young people that are unemployed on the street and so now you're connecting a profit business
- 14:53to a need that you see right around the corner from you you know that's that's kind of a weak
- 14:57example but but the the elements are there right so if you you start looking around at what could
- 15:07be done so let's say you go to the to the wide open spaces of Wyoming and you say you know I'm
- 15:14going to I'm going to start a business of taking care of horses for people that travel a lot
- 15:22and I'm going to hire young people to be my employees and so again it's the same concept but in a
- 15:29completely different environment sure different value proposition so value propositions are as
- 15:36is creative as the person that is creating them there is no limit to how innovative you can get
- 15:44in creating a value proposition and then building an enterprise around it so this this shows my
- 15:49ignorance which and I have plenty to show because most of the things there are to know in the world
- 15:56I don't know yeah I'm loving this conversation is a value proposition the same as multiple
- 16:03bottom lines well that's the equivalent well the multiple bottom lines I when I talk about that I'm
- 16:09talking about the business overall okay but so you have profit that yeah you have profit you have
- 16:16social you have environmental let's say well environmental in many places around the world and
- 16:24this is probably very observable in third world countries right let's say they take the garbage from
- 16:32their coffee shop and they throw it out the back window right you know it hurts the environment
- 16:38well if everybody does it and they're and you and I both know there's places that everybody does
- 16:43that sure now you're a business and when you have garbage you bag it up or you go you burn it or
- 16:51you take care of it or you bury it and so it now becomes a value to the environment you're helping
- 16:59or let's say you you process your waste water and rather than dumping sewage out in the street
- 17:07you put in a water processing element of your business and you help the environment and there
- 17:14are people that are very motivated to do that kind of stuff so again these are these are very simple
- 17:21examples but you have bottom multiple bottom lines there so that is about the company itself
- 17:27every company that has a product or a service has to have a value proposition that attracts
- 17:36customers to come so a cake company their value proposition might be good cake and a great
- 17:43environment Starbucks the value proposition of Starbucks is beyond coffee it's when you go in
- 17:49there it's a social environment you go and you sit and you you know you interact with people so
- 17:57those are those are related but those are those are two different ideas the multiple back to
- 18:03the multiple bottom line if you look around and you say how can I help people and how can I make a
- 18:10profit then think about what you can do to create profit create a business that has something of
- 18:22value you're offering to a customer and you get them to pay you money for it sure is there
- 18:29is there a difference and and maybe there is none is there a difference in which part of that
- 18:35question or which of those questions I asked first that is if I say it how do I make a profit
- 18:44and how do I help people is that different in terms of either motivation or intensity generally
- 18:54is that different than saying how do I help people and at the same time make a profit okay
- 19:00given the idea that we're talking about social entrepreneurship right the answer to your question
- 19:05is let me answer it with a question which is more important to an airplane the left wing or the
- 19:11right wing sure they're both are yeah so if if the idea here is social entrepreneurship not just
- 19:18entrepreneurship right then you've got two wings of an airplane that need to be present so you can
- 19:25address either one of them first but you have to have them both because if you've got a great idea
- 19:31to help people and let's say you're going to just give away water to people that doesn't have water
- 19:36well if you don't have a economic engine to your business that creates money you can only give away
- 19:45a certain amount of water and you're done you're finished thus if you don't have profit you don't
- 19:50have tomorrow okay so for our listeners why do if if you could think of one or two
- 20:00pictures or snapshots of businesses we've talked about Tom Shoes before but just in in places
- 20:08you're working around the world today without naming names but talking about models of what you're
- 20:15talking of what you're describing here what one or two models come to mind and you you talked
- 20:24about a coffee shop in Greece do you have one or two others that sure let me give you two of them
- 20:30one is CrossFit I've got several friends that live in the Arab world and throughout Eurasia
- 20:37that have CrossFit gyms and the if you know anything about CrossFit gyms the people that go
- 20:44and work out on a regular basis create community and that community grows and they they intertwine
- 20:53their lives and they take care of each other and it becomes a community where they're they're helping
- 20:59each other well the owners of that business they are creating profit but they're also helping people
- 21:06because they come in contact with people that they wouldn't have access to otherwise so that could
- 21:12be done that kind of athletic enterprise can be done on a very small scale CrossFit is a branded
- 21:20gym because and I use it because everybody knows what that is but it's also a style of training
- 21:25it's a style of training it can literally be done one-on-one or in small groups or whatever
- 21:31another I have I have a couple of friends a merry couple Mike and Cindy that have lived in
- 21:38Uzbekistan for 20 years and they run a small farm and the farm creates honey and they have
- 21:47some cows and they they do the milk products and all of that but in Uzbekistan a person who
- 21:57is special needs and who is an orphan has no standing with the government so they have been
- 22:04there for 20 years to to take in these special needs people and train them with a skill and prepare
- 22:13them for life because the average special needs orphan that goes out of an orphanage the government
- 22:20will put them into an orphanage when they go out at the age of 18 on average they die by 21
- 22:26because they have no coping skills right so what they do Mike and Cindy they use their small farm
- 22:34and the skills of not only animal husbandry and the honey and all of that they they will create
- 22:43certain small items and but they teach these people skills and their track record over the 20
- 22:48years is these people come out at age 18 they go into society and they have enough coping skills
- 22:55for life that they can survive and so you talk about a social enterprise that has a higher
- 23:02purpose and shareholder wealth development the money that comes in honey sells for a lot of money
- 23:07in that part of the world so they use that money to help fund the work that they do right so those
- 23:14are two examples Michael thank you for taking the time to be with me I is I'm listening to you
- 23:22I'm I'm hearing a phrase come back that's ancient wisdom it's an old biblical phrase from way
- 23:30back in the book of Genesis that is it is not good that man should be alone and what happens when
- 23:40you do social entrepreneurial activities it allows the recipient whether it's the worker or the
- 23:49recipient of the gift of whatever it is to understand that someone cares to in some cases be
- 23:57involved in community i.e. the CrossFit or the the beekeepers farm which is a which is a fascinating
- 24:04thing it's it's all of us know what alone feels like and to be able to to solve that challenge
- 24:13so that we can be together using the skills that are found in a social entrepreneurial environment
- 24:25is a powerful thing thank you for sharing your wisdom appreciate it glad to be with you