Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Primary Care, Special Guest Jamie Oledershaw of DealerRater, FTC Comments.
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Kyle, I don't know if you've noticed this, but September 11th is only three days away from September 8th. And September 11th- [laughs]... is the first day of ASOTU CON.
- 0:10We're counting down the hours at this point. Hmm. Everyone know. The people really wanna know. Woo. Who I is and who I be. Woo. Woo. They got to stay with me. Oh. That's kinda my, that's kinda my mode.
- 0:20I kinda, every hour I go, "Woo. Woo. Woo." [laughs] Like someone, like someone just played a great guitar riff or something.
- 0:28Right You know, like, why is the res- why is the response when a great musician does something or someone just plays, like, just pulls off something nasty, you laugh.
- 0:35Just get a little stanky in your face, and you're like, "Woo." You laugh, you get a little stank face. Why is that the reaction? I don't know. We hope that reaction, people have that a lot at ASOTU CON.
- 0:43[laughs] As, as the, the people are gonna be on stage, like, just dropping what they're gonna drop, and I know it. People are gonna be like... Maybe we should give some white hankies, right? Ooh, yeah.
- 0:51Just have a little- And then just, like, church. [laughs] Just go to church a little bit. I love it. You know what's crazy? So we've done some live shows at, like, outside of our office before.
- 1:01We've sat at VADA and that type of stuff. This will be the first time in, what, four days' time, that you and I will sit on a stage and let people kinda peek into the BTS- That's true...
- 1:14the behind the scenes of The Automotive Troublemaker. Yeah, we've never done that before. I wonder how that's gonna go. Yeah.
- 1:18I mean, if you're listening, if you're gonna be at ASOTU CON, we are doing The Automotive Troublemaker every morning from the main stage. Um, that may just be Kyle and I in a big empty room [laughs] doing it.
- 1:28Everybody's like, "Ho." But we'll just keep the camera shots tight. [laughs] We'll put in some B roll of some very interested crowd, right? You know what I mean? Yes. We sh- [laughs] Yeah.
- 1:35I don't know what we're gonna do. [laughs] But either way, uh, there's still time. If you're a dealer and you wanna go to ASOTU CON, you can still get tickets at asotucon.com.
- 1:42If you're, like, within an hour or two hours of driving distance, you really should just be there. [notification sound] Just, just come. Um, trust us. Yeah.
- 1:48If you're listening to this show, and if you're listening to this show and you know a dealer who is in that area who should be there, everyone's got 20 groups and dealer networks, right? You don't even have to be- Yes...
- 1:58in the same state.
- 1:58But if you know people that are in that area, let them know what's going on because that's part of the cool thing about bringing national level auto conference and a national level speaking roster to a new city.
- 2:08I, I can't think of one auto event that's been in Philly, um, that's been that national level, can you? Can't think of one. Uh, one. ISG20 was there a couple years ago. Oh, that's right. That's right. Yeah.
- 2:19Okay, we can think of one. There we go. We got one. [laughs] Only one, but only one.
- 2:23Um, and also, we've never, ever in the industry seen an event that opened its doors to everyone in the industry from the top to the bottom, rank and file. Yo. I don't care if you're just got hired.
- 2:33Oh, we're gonna have, like, almost 2,000 people there on Monday night just to buy.
- 2:36There's still a few days, and there's still that whole thing that's gonna happen, like, where people are sharing with their friends, right? That all happens last minute. Yes. "What are you doing this weekend?"
- 2:44"I'm going to this thing." "Oh, that exists?" My wife last night was like, "What are you even doing again?" I was like- [laughs] "Yeah, there's gonna be, like, a couple thousand people there," you know?
- 2:52And she was, [laughs] and, and she was like, "Oh, man, that's right down your alley." I was like, "Yeah. [laughs] It kinda is." Yeah. It's gonna be great. "Kinda is." We're gonna whisk out of the VIP dinner- [laughs]...
- 3:01over to go up on stage and try to get some more people fired up about being in the industry that they're in. 'Cause that is one of our missions at ASOTU: draw a big circle around everyone in the industry.
- 3:11Because the more people in the industry that are paying attention, I don't care if you're a lot porter, BDC rep, receptionist, service advisor, IT, whatever, the more people that are paying attention to what's going on in this industry- Exactly...
- 3:22the faster innovation is going to go and the more we can get the great things that dealers are doing out into the open and out into the wild. So- Yes... that's why we're doing what we're doing. Thank you. End rant.
- 3:34Let's go. [laughs] All right. Oh, hey, look. R- real quick, if you've been paying attention to Auto Collabs, one, the Dan Moore episode is out live on podcast platforms.
- 3:44It's also, uh, gonna drop live at noon, uh, from a video podcast perspective. That, that conversation, so good. One of my favorite intros ever. It's just so good.
- 3:54I mean, when Dan comes- Yeah, the intro is so, so much fun. Yeah. [laughs] Like, it's, it's just a good one.
- 3:59You're gonna wanna, you're gonna wanna listen to it if you're, if you're going about your day-to-day and, and a podcast listener, for sure. No doubt. Stick, stick with it.
- 4:06Stick with it through, through the middle and the end because the, the... It just get... It's one of those conversations that gets- It goes, like, deeper and deeper and deeper and deeper...
- 4:12more and more substantial as the conversation goes on. We had to cut it off at, like, 25 minutes just because, uh, you know, everyone doesn't have all day. [laughs] Walking the dog doesn't take that long.
- 4:21Dan'll be at ASOTU CON too, so it'll be a great way to follow up on the conversation. Speaking of following up. Stop. Ooh. Segway time. [upbeat music] All right. Today- I can do that in my sleep.
- 4:33Oh, well, you know what we didn't talk about? We actually have a special guest today. We just spent- Whoa... like, 10 minutes talking with him be- backstage. [laughs] We have a special guest coming up in just a moment.
- 4:44Jamie Oldershaw, GM at DealerRater, VP of Reputation Strategy at CARS, is gonna come and share some very Switzerland-like data on customer sentiment toward dealers. So- That's a great way of putting it. I like that.
- 4:57That's a great way of putting it. That's, uh, I think that should be his job title. Oh, Switzerland-like data. Provider of Switzerland-like data- [laughs]... on customer sentiment toward auto dealers. I love it.
- 5:06I love it. That's why our... I love it. Okay, so first story today. Speaking of following up, how will the reputation of primary care services in the US change as a result of these well-known new entrants to the game?
- 5:18This is a key question following CVS's recent announcement of C- of their definitive agreement to acquire Signify Health in an all-cash deal valued at about $8 billion. Now, Signify- [laughs] Y- eight b- b- billion.
- 5:31You said "billion." [laughs] Signify- Oh, boy. So basically what they do is they use proprietary technology, analytics to support doctors, nurse practitioners, and physicians assistants who make house calls.
- 5:42Let's get back to sending house calls- Yeah... to over two and a half million patients across all 50 states. And here's the kicker. Signify says that when primary care is delivered this way,
- 5:54care providers spend an addit- they spend two and a half times more time with the patient. Wow. Uh, you gotta think that that's a good thing, right? Like- I don't know. Have you ever had a primary care experience, Kyle?
- 6:06[laughs]Primary care. Like, you mean like a primary... I mean, I've been to a primary care doctor- Yeah... but you mean like, like, a- And, and how much... No, I me- I meant that.
- 6:16And how, how much time do you feel like the doctor really spends with you? Not just- Oh... not just in physical time, but actually, like, mental time. They walk in. All right, I'm...
- 6:26Okay, I'm giving- No, that, well, that's what I'm saying, is like, is like, the two and a half more times seems like a good thing to me- Absolutely...
- 6:33because when I'm, when I visit a doctor, I'm like, "Okay, you just looked at my tongue and diagnosed my toe somehow in the last 33 seconds," right? [laughs] It's, they walk in, they go something like this, right?
- 6:45They walk in, got the clipboard thing, and they're like, "All right." [laughs] And you get the, you get the sound. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yep, and then it's like- Mm-hmm... it's like- Mm-hmm...
- 6:52it's like, "All right, so tell me a little bit w- about what's going on. Okay." Take, take these pills. "I got a prescription for you." Yeah. [laughs] All right.
- 6:59All right, so obviously we are, we are going grossly, uh, high level on this. Oh. [laughs] But I, I think, I, I searched on this, right?
- 7:07Because it's so applicable to the next thing we're gonna talk about, which is consumer perception of the automotive industry. Yeah, exactly.
- 7:13I could not find a single score, metric, overarching figure on customer satisfaction or patient satisfaction with primary care. Wow.
- 7:23Everything was some like s- like way over my head study, you know, doctorate level, published document that is like, I don't have six years to read this. And like no one was like- Ah...
- 7:38it's actually three stars on average or it's actually this. And I would bet, I- No... I would bet- That's interesting... that if you got some honest reviews on the entire primary care experience, they'd be pretty low.
- 7:51Yeah. It's like long wait times. Crappy scheduling systems, right? Like calling, like the whole situation. Dealing with insurance. Jamie's in the background. He's actually on the thing right now.
- 8:02He's like- PhysicianRater.com... "Doctor Rater.com." Yeah. [laughs] Primary Care Rater. No, bec- I, and I couldn't find a single thing.
- 8:10And I was like, "You know, I wonder if it has something to do with the fact that it's healthcare and if people feel better, right, you kind of like forget the rest of the experience, or you just accept it- Ah...
- 8:19as a terrible experience so it doesn't take that much to just like, 'Oh, it's just terrible.'" Or maybe people love their... I don't know. Maybe people- That's not true... like, and maybe it's a general whole love it.
- 8:27I don't know. Not true. Not true at all. [laughs] You said, "Not true." There's no way that's true.
- 8:31I bet there are some that have gotten it, right, like the, the troublemakers in primary care who got the scheduling- Yeah... component down and they have the experience component down, right?
- 8:41But the whole process is terrible, right? First of all, you start off sick. It's almost like a service experience. Yeah. I'll tell you this, primary care could learn a lot from dentists.
- 8:52Dentists have scheduling, timing, attention- [laughs] Dude... bedside man- Why are dentists- They got it all down... has the best, like, has the best sales funnel I've ever seen in my life. Ever.
- 9:04And their customer retention capacity is out of this world. I don't wanna be s- It's like every industry needs to be like, "What are dentists doing?" I know, but I don't- We'll take that.
- 9:12I, I don't like being sold on my health. "Well, your, your tooth could be fine, or it could rot out of your face." [laughs] "I mean, let's get that enamel coating, should we?" Right? [laughs] There we go.
- 9:22And so- Yeah, right...
- 9:23but, but all that to say, like, the rivals, you know, uh, CVS' rivals like Walgreens, Walmart, Amazon, everybody, there's a big push into primary care and there's a big push into personalization, um, you know, uh, access to telemedicine.
- 9:37And I think, like, the scheduling- Yeah... of it, the payment of it, right? Insurance is a nightmare to navigate.
- 9:42Um, it'll be interesting to see how this starts to translate into maybe some actual patient reviews because I feel like people are going to be much more willing to rate CVS than they are, you know, Family Practice Associates LLP- Well, yeah, and not just that-...
- 9:58to the hospital... but like whenever you, whenever you have, like, this, this obviously comes with an app-based system, so you've got to look at retention, you've got to look at things like customer sentiment.
- 10:07And so- It's easier to gather information, right"... whenever you're doing virtual visits or, or in-person visits, you start to widen the, the capacity for technology to be involved.
- 10:16And, and I, I think that it's prime for just figuring out, hey, what's the best pl- best way that the, the primary care industry can service customers. So speaking of the best way an industry can care for customers.
- 10:29Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] All right, bring him in, Isaac. Come on. Here he comes. There's Jamie. What's up? He's already smiling. We got him laughing, so that's good.
- 10:41Well, I, I ju- I just found that, uh, I, I was just kind of checking this out, Doctor Rater is available. So, uh, you, you, you guys can- It wa- you mean it was available five minutes ago, is what you mean.
- 10:51Well, yeah, I just, yeah, I just got it. [laughs] Yeah, if you haven't secured that on GoDaddy- Yeah... just know, like, we- Right... we get 10% of w- the company whenever you start. We make, yeah, yeah.
- 10:59Kyle's pumping the overlap agreement already. [laughs] Rest my day right there, so thank you. That's great. That's great. It really is.
- 11:05Well, hey, uh, so we, a couple weeks ago, and, and just to set the stage here, a couple weeks ago and, and really for the past couple months, we've been talking about the story around the FTC and the comment section that they've allowed on these FTC guidelines.
- 11:20And, um, we- we've just been kind of, you know, talking to dealers, talking to industry partners, uh, through Auto Collabs, through some of the content that we've been, uh, that, that we've been putting out about, you know, what the overall sentiment, what actually is going on in the industry.
- 11:36Like, are the things that the FTC is bringing to the table actually going to help solve for a better customer experience or are they gonna inhibit that?
- 11:46And, uh, and even more, our, our question has been, Paul and my question has been, hey, is, is it really in need of, like, an overhaul and, and in fixing?
- 11:56And, and we know that there are segments of our industry that are in need of an overhaul. And yes, we continually have to push the boundaries of customer experience.
- 12:03Um, but one of our questions has kind of been like, "Hey, what, what do customers really think about their sales and service experience? Like, what's the real sentiment?
- 12:14Um, is, is the net promoter score of our industry as a whole-Like positive or poor. Right. And so friend of mine, Jamie Oldershaw, the GM of DealerRater and VP of Reputation Strategy at CARS, is now here with us.
- 12:30He's sitting right below, Paul and I, if you're watching on video and if you, and if you're listening, uh, he's joined us.
- 12:36And, and I asked him to kind of come on, and I've asked you, Jamie, to kind of come on and give us a little bit of an overview because DealerRater, how, how many reviews are you up to as a platform at this point?
- 12:48Oh, gosh. So as a platform, um, on DealerRater we're up to, uh, just under nine million. And if you kind of zoom out and look at CARS Inc., which is DealerRater and CARS, it's about 11 and a half million reviews.
- 12:59And so just- Yeah... to maybe, you know, back up for a sec, you know, just kind of a quick disclaimer and context. Um, I, I've, I've read all the same articles you guys have, have, have read.
- 13:09Um, and, uh, I, I mean, look, you know, no industry, no business is perfect. Automotive is certainly no exception. Kyle, as you just mentioned, there are pockets, uh, of areas where dealers need to improve.
- 13:21There are, you know, bad actors. There are things that we certainly need to focus on and fix as an industry. Um, you know, DealerRater's been around since 2002.
- 13:30That's when we collected our first consumer review, so we're about 20 years into this. Um, you know, we, uh, we take a lot of pride in the fact that we are an open, transparent platform.
- 13:42Um, we started collecting reviews before Yelp was even a company, before Google had any reviews. Um, so- What does open and transparent platform mean? Explain that for us. Yeah.
- 13:51We, so we have all the dealerships across the country, new and used, represented on the site.
- 13:56So any consumer who has had a dealership experience is free to come to the site, share their experience, and have that out and available for, um, any customers who come, you know, any shoppers who come to our site to do dealership, uh, research can read all those reviews.
- 14:12So there's no- And that, that is unfiltered reviews. There's no combing, there's no dealers- There's no-... paying to get bad reviews removed, any of that, right? Absolutely not.
- 14:23And that, that's, it's been very important to us since day one.
- 14:25Content moderation is important, so we wanna make sure that we can filter out the fraud and certainly, uh, there, there's been a fair share of fraudulent reviews, you know, over the years.
- 14:35Um, you know, consumers who didn't have an experience there but had a grudge or dealership employees- Mm-hmm... writing reviews. We've, we've, you know, we've s- seen it all, right?
- 14:43[laughs] Um, but we, we take a w- a lot of pride in the fact that we have very strict content moderation. We have community guidelines.
- 14:51There's, there's, you know, certain things that you can't write about just because, you know, obviously it's... And, and the, and these are things that are sort of specific across all review platforms. Mm-hmm.
- 15:00You know, referencing crime or other things like that. Um, but, you know, so, so we, we have an open p- uh, uh, platform, so anyone can share their experience.
- 15:10It's very important to us because we wanna make sure that, that, you know, dealers, um, can leverage our platform to get better, right? And I think- Yeah...
- 15:17our mission from day one has been to improve the automotive retail experience for buyers and sellers, right? And we take a lot of pride in the fact that we are the definitive voice of the customer for automotive.
- 15:28And, and that's what we wanna continue to provide innovations on. We can also rate the specific employee at the dealership that you did business with. So it's not just the dealership, but it's also the person.
- 15:39Who do I ask for when I go to the dealership? Um, which is something that, that, you know, only we do on our platform. So we are deep in automotive. We're not collecting reviews on hotels or restaurants or salons.
- 15:50[laughs] We are specialists in automotive. That's all we do. Or doctors, right? [laughs] Not doctors. Yet. Although that, that, that could change after today.
- 15:58But, um, but, you know, all, all joking aside, you know, we, we, we've collected a lot of content. So if you just sort of zoom out, uh, and look at, um, you know, j- just over the past 10 years, right?
- 16:09Eight million reviews across 30,000 dealerships in the US. Wow. 94% positive feedback from consumers. So- Wow... almost 6% negative.
- 16:21So again, that is a, that's a lot of content across a lot of dealerships, and 94% positive. And you sort of take one sort of step further into that, um, service lane feedback is about 91% positive.
- 16:35Sales, uh, used is about 92 and a half, and sales new is 96. The average is about 94. Um- So what...
- 16:43Okay, that's, that's a great, that's a great point because especially when we think about, like, franchise dealers and the FTC.
- 16:50And not, and, and, and I, I do wanna be clear, like, Paul and I are not asking you, Jamie, and for the, for the listening audience, we're not asking Jamie to kind of comment on whether or not the guidelines of the FTC are right.
- 17:04But a lot of the conversation around these FTC guidelines has been about the overall customer experience, transparency, honesty of the dealer, all of that type of stuff.
- 17:14And so the sentiment of the dealer is an important pa- has an important part to play in how w- in, in how our culture and the government perceive the retail auto dealer.
- 17:25So for me, seeing that interesting, it's, it's kind of wild to me. Like, I would have probably flipped all those numbers. If you would've just asked me, like, "Where's the average?"
- 17:35around 94%, I probably would've flipped that seeing, like, new car purchasing being the lowest, uh, overall sentiment.
- 17:42But what you're saying is that new car purchasers are expressing the highest overall sentiment for dealers. Is that right? Yeah. I mean, people walk out of the dealership generally very happy with their new car.
- 17:53And, and they wanna share that experience. Now, we also get our fair share of customers who aren't happy. Yeah, sure. Who drive off the lot and something's wrong.
- 18:01Um, and the dealer- Yeah, 6% of eight million is a lot, [laughs] right? Right. [laughs] That's still...
- 18:07You know, that's 500,000 people over the past 10 years who came to DealerRater and said, "Something went wrong, and I'm not happy."
- 18:14Um, now, you know, I'm sure that many of those negative experiences have turned positive in the meantime.
- 18:20Um, and I think again, we'll, maybe we'll talk a little bit about sort of the hallmark of a good dealer, someone who sort of takes that feedback and uses it to actually change-... processes.
- 18:30Um, but yeah, I mean, it, it's still a f- a fair share of customers who have walked off the lot, um, not happy with what they just experienced.
- 18:38And I think, um, the, the, the more we can sort of encourage dealers and train the industry to sort of leverage feedback as a gift and use it to change, uh, their processes, you know, train employees, um, just, you know, do things differently, um, those are the dealers that ultimately win in, in their marketplace, and the dealers that we wanna reward on our platform to make sure that we're giving them the lion's share of the leads on Cars.com and others, so.
- 19:04Well, and I, I, I love the way you position that because whether you're getting reviews on Google or DealerRater or Facebook or any, any review platform that's out there, or you're sim- or you're reading these 7,761 comments on the FTC, uh, guidelines, wherever you're at, if you're a dealer or industry partner, taking that and, and learning from the comments that are being made, especially the ones that have some sort of negative sentiment, whether it's of your dealership or of another dealership or of dealerships as a whole, is an important...
- 19:40Uh, like, uh, I, I, I used to always say, like, I loved the bad reviews, i- as, as a marketer and, and, and as a business development person on the, on the retail side, was because that's the time where we got to spring into action and either make things right or fix a process that was clearly broken.
- 19:57Mm. 'Cause if, if it broke for one person, then it probably broke for more. Yeah. And- 10 others that never left a review... exactly. Yeah.
- 20:04And so those are the golden opportunities that we have right now as an industry to kinda look at and, and, and zero in on. Yeah.
- 20:12And I think you'd be surprised at the number of dealers that still don't read their reviews on a regular basis, right? I don't think so. And- I don't think we'd be surprised. [laughs] Yeah. [laughs] But many might be.
- 20:22I don't think we would be. [laughs] Yeah. I mean, it's, it's... If, if, if you're not, it's a missed opportunity. Big time.
- 20:28And I think if, if you wanna know where to focus, uh, I mean, you know, we, we tell dealers just Google your dealership name and see what shows up on the first page of search engine results.
- 20:38You know, spoiler alert, it's probably gonna be Google, Cars.com, DealerRater, and Facebook. And just pay attention to those sites. And most importantly, you, you gotta respond to these reviews too.
- 20:47It's an open door to, to, to provide great SEO value for your dealership, to have that conversation so it's not a one-sided conversation. Um, and it's free to respond on all these platforms.
- 20:59DealerRater and Cars, you don't need to, you know, pay us a dime to respond to your customer and engage with them, particularly- Right... if it's a negative review. And, and, again, not a lot of dealers...
- 21:08You know, on our platform, only 40% of dealers are actively responding to reviews. Mm-hmm. That's not enough. Wow. And when you look at dealers- Yeah...
- 21:16you know, when, when we look at dealers who are perennial Dealer of the Year Award winners on our platform, 80% of those are responding.
- 21:23So if you sort of talk about, like, the healthy habits of a dealer that's providing a good experience- Mm-hmm...
- 21:29and gets rewarded for it by being scored highly on our platform and others, they're not only reading reviews, they're actively res- responding and they're- You mean they're engaging with their customer base?
- 21:40[laughs] I know. It's a- To, like-... crazy concept... have a better customer experience? [laughs] Oh. Just, yeah. Well, here, here's the thing. That's the obvious sort of as- yeah.
- 21:48This morning, uh, we all know this FTC proposed legislation. Commenting on this proposal is closing in three day or four days. It's actually closing on September 12th, first day of a s- full day of ASOTU Con.
- 22:01Uh, I checked in with the site this morning, and there are currently 7,700, uh, plus reviews on the site. I actually grabbed the, the top four, right? Just in... They're in chronological order, so most recent first.
- 22:14And I was like, "Well, let me check in and see what people are saying." Actually, the top four were more substantive than ones I had seen in the past that had only been, like, a line or two.
- 22:22Um, and so I'm gonna read a couple of them now, and then we're also going to, uh, make sure that you have the link, everyone listening in. We have, uh, some suggestions on how to weigh in on the FTC.
- 22:32We'll probably make a separate post about this. But all the links are in the show notes, so you can go right to the proposal and the comments section.
- 22:38But we'll, we'll, we'll talk about a couple of these comments for a second. So here's the first one from an anonymous commenter.
- 22:45By the way, our first suggestion is don't be an anonymous commenter because they get discounted. [laughs] So here we go: "We have too many forms as it is.
- 22:52My goal always is to make the purchase experience as easy and uncomplicated as possible for my customers." Obviously, this is an anonymous dealer.
- 22:59"We are a franchise dealership in a small town, and repeat customers are a large part of our business. More forms and complicating the process will simply make things worse for the customer.
- 23:08The customer's interests are protected by Truth in Lending, buyer's guides, privacy rights, credit disclosures, approval dec- uh, declination letters, et cetera.
- 23:15Any issues seemingly addressed in the above regulation is already covered, established, and in place." So obviously a very, um, a very clear- That is such an astute comment.
- 23:25You could literally take that, copy it out of our show notes, edit a c- few things, take... Put your name on it, and, uh, and probably, like, the... [laughs] I'm just saying, that is astute. Yes. That is dialed in.
- 23:36I wouldn't approach it that way. [laughs] I mean, I wouldn't quite approach it that way 'cause, because what...
- 23:42I- I'm just like, put your empathy hat on and like how's a consumer, a, a consumer frustrated with the process gonna read that? "I'm a dealer and don't change anything because you're already fine, so shut up."
- 23:52[laughs] Right. Maybe. Yeah, yeah. No, I'm just saying if I'm the cust- you know, if I'm the customer and I have a qualm or I have a stigma in my mind already, like, of course you're gonna say that.
- 24:00So they're just making this proposal up because nothing's wrong and everything's fine, right? Okay. The next, very next comment, this is from, um, I'm gonna mess the name up, Mr. Zeblata.
- 24:11He says, "To the FTC, I am not anonymous!" This is my name. I've been a car enthusiast before I could even drive. I owned enough vehicles, that has become a joke, that I rotate vehicles every four months.
- 24:23I even started renting out vehicles on Turo, which has me visiting dealers even more regularly. Your proposed rules are," all caps-Desperately needed. In fact- Mm... I would state that they're only a beginning.
- 24:35Saying we need dealers to state the true price of a vehicle is mind-boggling how we have not let this go, how we've let this go on for so long.
- 24:42The fact that NADA and dealers are trying to sabotage this proposal with anonymous against statements shows that this needs to be concrete and enforced by the FTC. Thank you. Now, that is a credible comment. Right?
- 24:58When you read that, you're like, "That's a real person with a real story," right? And real legitimate experience with dealerships, and they articulate themselves well.
- 25:07If I'm the FTC people reading these comments, I'm like, "We're gonna weigh that one heavy." Hm. Uh, what are your thought- Yeah... I mean, I'm, I'm open to thoughts on that. Just the com- Well, I'm, I mean, like,
- 25:20wh- when I, when I read something and I see spelling errors, and I see all caps with three exclamation points, and, you know, uh, calling out NADA, and then saying they're being anonymous about it, it, it, it, that's, that's kinda interesting to me.
- 25:35Mm-hmm. Uh, you know, I, I don't know who this person is- I'm searching him right now... but, like, wh- when I- Let's see what we can get... when I read that, I, I, I, I become very curious.
- 25:43You know, the, the, the first statement, for me, was very well approached. It says, you know, "Hey, look, w- look, I'm trying to provide a great experience.
- 25:51But if we put more and more things in place, it's gonna cause a lengthened experience. And all of these guidelines are in place already, and we follow them."
- 26:00Like, that seems, uh, you know, uh, that, that seems really strong.
- 26:04And, and, and, and I would say, you know, the, the, the problem is, is this is, this is similar to probably what Jamie sees, is like, the, the people that leave bad reviews are typically anecdotal.
- 26:16They, they are based on a single or, or a few experiences. Now, I get rotating vehicles every four months.
- 26:23But, like, I mean, my response to that is probably that that guy has a hard time trading in and out of cars, you know? And, and that's a, that's something that, uh... And, and so it's gonna lengthen his process.
- 26:34It's gonna be tough for him from a pricing perspective. And, and it's just something, like, you go deeper into those sales processes and, and it's hard to derive exactly what's going on. So I don't know.
- 26:46It's, it's tough for me. You know, I come from 12 years of, of being o- on the retail side. And so- [laughs]... I read these with a particular bent. [laughs] I get that. But I, I think that we can...
- 26:56I, I think that approached, maybe not anonymously, that I think that that's a big deal.
- 26:59Like, if you are a dealership or work for a dealership, you probably shouldn't post anonymously because that's the fear already, that we're not transparent enough as an industry. So that's, I mean, that's- That is-...
- 27:10the biggest thing that I see in his comment... it's, it's a, it's a great counterpoint. I'm, I'm, I'm research- I mean, it's such a unique name. Bebick Zable- Zableda. I believe he's a firefighter in Miami-Dade.
- 27:22And I'm, I'm looking on Facebook right now, and I have a letter to a GM about some Chevy Equinox talking about his dealership experience in a service department. He's actually got his email address on this. Interesting.
- 27:39All right. Let's get him on the show. We're gonna get him on the show. [laughs] That's how this works. We know who you- I love it. I love it.
- 27:47Ja- Jamie, what, what is your perception of just when people leave comments, right?
- 27:51You have, just in general, not about this comment in specific, but what insights can you give us about the way people leave comments, either the positive or negative? What makes them seem more credible?
- 28:01What makes them seem suspicious? Right? You have eight million to go on. [laughs] Yeah. I mean, I, you know, I, there's... Gosh, that's probably a whole nother show. I mean, I think- Sure...
- 28:12you know, we, we, we do see, um, a lot of very detailed reviews, which I think is, is important. And we actually encourage, uh, reviewers to write more. Uh, you, you've gotta write at least 15 words.
- 28:25So, uh, you know, uh, unlike Google where you can just do, like, one star and then nothing,
- 28:31if, you know, if you're gonna share your experience on DealerRater, we want you to share the story 'cause I think the story is what's important. Mm-hmm.
- 28:39Um, you know, negative reviews can take all different shapes and sizes.
- 28:42I think, you know, uh, largely, and again this is not necessarily scientific but just kind of anecdotal from what I've observed, negative reviews tend to be a bit longer than positive reviews because they wanna share the whole story from start to finish- Mm-hmm...
- 28:55to make sure that there's context that lends credibility. Instead of just walked into the showroom, had a bad experience- One star...
- 29:02you know, um, uh, um, Bob, Bob was, uh, not a great, you know, salesperson, one star, right? Mm-hmm. That's maybe not great for Bob. Generally not helpful for the dealership. It doesn't tell- Right...
- 29:14it doesn't give me as the GM or the GSM any information for how I can make things better.
- 29:19And so I think the best negative reviews that we get on the site are those that actually sort of, you know, provide actionable things for dealers to do. And I will say that the,
- 29:29the sort of primary bucket of negative con- And, and again, just sort of, like, zooming in even further, like, just over the past three years, the primary bucket of negative content that we get is around poor communication.
- 29:39So, like- Ooh... no calls back, um, long hold times- [laughs]... misunderstandings.
- 29:45In fact, over the past couple years, we've seen a pretty sharp rise, um, in fact, uh, the, the number of reviews of, um, uh, you know, constructive reviews that have been written on the site, uh, negative, um, that sort of, you know, reference the fact that de- that, um, consumers didn't get any, any call back.
- 30:04Those have doubled over the past year. Wow. And so I think that's probably symptomatic of the supply and demand imbalance that, you know, uh, dealers are getting all these leads for a limited amount of cars.
- 30:17And they're selling it, and they're not calling the other people back. And I think that's, i- it's, you know- Interesting...
- 30:23as a dealer, I would sort of take note of that and take heed that, like, these are consumers that are walking away unhappy, that when, you know, you need these folks down the road nine months, a year, you know, year, year and a half later, they may not come back to you because, you know-You're just fine with the sale and, and now, again, this is sort of my in- interpretation of- Sure...
- 30:43that. And- Yeah... I, I think it's instructive for dealers to hear that.
- 30:45We're gonna start to, um, collect feedback from, uh, lead submitters on cars so we can, uh, provide that information back to dealers so they can help to train their BDC and, and get better.
- 30:57And then ultimately use that data to kind of curate the marketplace on cars so we're making sure that when we push people to vehicles, we are pushing them to dealers that are really good at responding in a timely fashion.
- 31:08Well, let me say this. For years and years and decades and centuries and millennia- [laughs] There are two things that every single relationship breaks down because of. There are two primary things.
- 31:23Number one- How you put the toilet paper on the roll. [laughs] Sorry, I couldn't help myself. One, one is finances and two is communication. And you- [laughs]...
- 31:33and dealers are dealing in finances and in communication every single day.
- 31:37So if those aren't your primary ways in which you're exper- ex- explaining and making sure that you have great customer experiences, then shame on you. Shame on you. Oh, snap.
- 31:47That, that, that, that comment right there got me all fired up. Man, Jamey, thank you so much for being on today. I think that, uh- Yes...
- 31:55I think that dealers are well-served by some of the sentiment and the analysis and the, and the understanding that you've given us.
- 32:00And, and thanks for, uh, allowing us to kind of weave you into this, this story, uh, and, and bring, um, uh, some analysis to the overall, uh, sentiment of the, of the industry.
- 32:13Uh, it's, it's a, it's a well-placed guidance that you've given us, so appreciate you. My pleasure. Thank you, Paul. Thank you, Kyle. Love what you guys are doing, and, uh, have a great show. Thank you so much.
- 32:24Take care. All right. So we could easily do a two-hour special on this. Two-hour special. [laughs] I have so many comments that I wanna read, but we don't have time for that.
- 32:36Um, what we'll probably make a, a post on LinkedIn. If you're not following us on LinkedIn, go to LinkedIn, follow us so too, um, and hit notifications on.
- 32:44We're gonna do a post about this and try to just continue this rally of people posting good comments. For just listening, have a few suggestions for leaving a comment here. The link is in the show notes.
- 32:55It'll g- it'll take you to, basically takes you to the homepage of the proposal, and in the upper left-hand corner, there's a little button that says Comment. You can do that. Um, couple things.
- 33:03Number one, don't be anonymous, right? Bingo. That doesn't really work. Don't be anonymous. Number two, I don't see a lot of this. Talk about the great things that dealers are doing and give examples, right?
- 33:14I think the focus is so myopic on, you know, like whether a product brings value or not or some bets.
- 33:21We need to broaden the lens out a little bit and just talk about the good things that dealers are doing and contributing. Um, talk about the great overall reviews on deal- Dealer Rater, right?
- 33:32Point people, say, "This, you know, open platform has 94% positive sentiment, 8 million reviews," right?
- 33:40Not 7,000 on the FTC proposal, but 8 million reviews of verified buyers that are properly moderated and open to anyone. No reviews are deleted that are negative. Dealers can't pay to adjust their ratings.
- 33:51Talk about that. I would say- Yep... suggest amendment of the rules instead of strike them up. Scrapping, right. Exactly. 'Cause there are good things in there, right? 'Cause the second you're like- Yep...
- 34:01"These all are terrible," that's gonna- Exactly... get discounted, right? Because Kyle, like, there are things in here that, that need to be the case, right? That need to happen, without a doubt. Yep.
- 34:09Uh, th- there's things that need to happen, and there's some things that are gonna harm all dealers, some things that are gonna, like, let the good rise to the top, which is good, you know? Yeah, for sure.
- 34:16Finally, um, look, get your friends and family to leave reviews on this FTC proposal, honestly, right? Like, tell them why you're trying to do it, and if they've had good reviews, tell them to, like, make that known.
- 34:27The commenting period is only three more days or four more days, whatever. It ends on September 12th. Three. So it ends on September 12th.
- 34:34What we wanna make sure that we can do is make sure the last couple thousand comments- Right... on this are ones that really express- The men strong...
- 34:43the nature and desire of auto dealers and the automotive industry to truly serve consumers, to give them what's best, but to let them know, like, this is half-baked, right? Yep. We need to fully bake this.
- 34:53So I know a little longer of an episode today, but we think, uh, there's no better reason to have a long episode.
- 35:00Kyle and I are about to go dive right back into a SoTwo Con prep so we can make sure we're ready for you in Philly. If you're not gonna be there, try to get there, even if it's Monday night. Come for the party.
- 35:09It's free. We'll let you in. We promise. [upbeat music]