Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Asbury Buys Herb’s 52 Franchises, Honda-Nissan Back On?, Amazon Physical Store Struggles
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Oh, good morning. You know what? I'm just warming up into Tuesday, February 18th. We're talking about a, a major acquisition. Ooh.
- 0:09Honda, Nissan maybe being back on, and Amazon having trouble with its in-person stores. Wherever I go. Hey. The people really wanna know who I am. Not so easy. Call up the car dealers, man. Not so easy.
- 0:19Call up the car dealers. Amazon should pay attention to what to do with the car buying thing next. Ah, got 'em. Not as easy as you think. Got 'em. What do we know, though? [laughs] I don't, I don't know.
- 0:30We know a couple, two, three things. One or two. We know some people that know th- some things. We know a lot of people that know things. That's my whole strategy. Speaking of people that know some things- Can we segue?
- 0:38Oh, a segue into the thing. [laughs] Uh, Matt Murray knows a whole bunch of things. We're gonna be talking to him tomorrow, 2:00 PM Eastern. It's one of our ASOTU Quickshot Edge webinars.
- 0:48They're only 30 minutes, that's all you get, but it's packed full of information. We've seen the deck. We know what it is. You're gonna wanna pay attention.
- 0:56So you can go to asotu.com, scroll down just a wee bitsy, uh, and you can register for that ASOTU Edge webinar with Matt Murray of Wide Whale. You're not gonna wanna miss it. Yeah, these things have been hot. Yeah.
- 1:07Like, the last ones we did at the end of last year, registration was through the roof. It was big. 'Cause people love them. 'Cause they're fast. Yeah. And you get the recording, and it's still fast.
- 1:15[laughs] It's still fast. How about that? I feel... It's edu- it's edutainment. Ed- You know what? Edutainment- It's a whole new category...
- 1:22'cause you and I, you and I will show up and f- certainly try our best to make fools of ourselves and make you laugh- [laughs]... while you learn something. Ah. Accomplishing our goal most of the time.
- 1:33I'm great at, I'm great at making a fool of myself. It's fun. Most of the time. Listen, everybody, asotcon.com is live. You can buy your ASOTU CON tickets. It was so fun yesterday to watch.
- 1:43Now, now we have a little tracker. So on our internal Slack, we watch tickets roll in now every day. It's that time of the year. Yep. It's like the 90 days before Christmas. Nathan, put that graphic back up.
- 1:52When you come to ASOTU CON, uh, we've locked in the topics we're gonna be talking about.
- 1:56Soon to come, schedule, um, like the refined schedule, speakers, et cetera, but our topics we're gonna cover, of course, AI and some of the people being the most progressive users of it.
- 2:06Uh, we're talking compliance, culture, fixed ops, um, leadership, marketing, multi-roof, top and group dynamics, technology, a whole bunch of other stuff. So much.
- 2:16But when you come to ASOTU CON, it is like, we've been starting to call it, it's like an automotive accelerator. It's not a conference. It moves the conversation forward- So great...
- 2:25so fast because all the right people are there to have all the right conversations. Here's what... People keep asking me, like, why is it different?
- 2:32And I think the resounding thing that I've gotten from so many people that have been there, and it's something that, like, I think we experience so often because it's just part of the way that we work, is the speed to a real conversation.
- 2:45Oh, speed to a real... That's good. People, people, people come and they're like, "No, you don't understand.
- 2:50I talked about things with people today on the floor, after the sessions," all that type of stuff, "that I never get to just in, like, regular conversation on a Zoom call or at other events," because there's this like-hearted, like-minded, like, similar focus and pursuit that you just...
- 3:06Like, there's a base level agreement, says we're after that. Absolutely. Now I can get to the real stuff. That's absolutely true. I mean, the vibe is different.
- 3:13You don't know until you get there, but everyone's ready, ready to talk, and share, and be open-handed, and help one another. Even industry partner and industry partner, we see so much collaboration happening.
- 3:23So much of that. We actually see so many products and collaboration products developed coming out of conversations that happened on a stage- Yep... at ASOTU CON. Um, trust us, it's not hype. It's actually the real thing.
- 3:33You can ask everybody that's been here. There was, like, uh, between 500 and 600 people there last year. There's gonna be even more this year.
- 3:38So make sure you get your tickets early, primarily so you can get your ticket, and then you can book your hotel room- Hey... because the main hotel where the event is- That's for real... is going to book out fast.
- 3:47I think we only have, like, 203 rooms. We're probably... I don't even know if we're approaching... Might... That... They might be half gone. [laughs] I don't know. They...
- 3:54It's every single day there's more and more booked, so- Yep... I'm excited. So don't, don't get caught out if you're coming. Make sure you can stay at the event hotel if you want. There's also a lot of other options.
- 4:03Um, um, I would say there's budget options, 'cause there are. Um, you know, like the Courtyard Marriott, we have a rate of, like, I think it's, like, $98. It's ridiculous. Yep. Um, but the main event hotel is only 179.
- 4:14It is, it is the nicest hotel room you're gonna get in the East Coast. For... It's a, that's a $400 or $500 a night hotel. Yeah. I think literally the nicest hotel room in the country under $200.
- 4:24Oh, that, that's for sure. I'm calling it. That's for sure. Yeah. All right. Well, let's get into some news. Uh- Let's do it... big news today.
- 4:29One of the biggest dealership acquisitions in US auto retail history is on the horizon as Asbury Automotive Group signs a definitive agreement to acquire the Herb Chambers companies.
- 4:40Uh, this $1.3 billion deal includes 33 dealerships, 52 franchises, three collision centers, adding to Asbury's already, uh, pretty large nationwide footprint. My goodness. Represents...
- 4:52This, uh, represents 2.9 billion in revenue in 2024 alone, making it one of the most significant transactions in the industry. Herb Chambers is going to retain ownership of Mercedes-Benz Boston. I love it.
- 5:05It's like, "Ah, I'm gonna keep the Mercedes store." [laughs] "Ah, I'll keep this one just for, just for good measure." Little something to do on the weekends.
- 5:12Uh, the deal's expected to close late in Q2 2025, uh, pending all the customary approvals. Asbury CEO, David Holt, praised the move, saying, "Herb is an icon in Boston and he has built a world-class organization."
- 5:25Herb Chambers said regarding the sale, quote, "As I look back on the last 40 years in business, I do so with immense pride, and as I look forward, I do so with great satisfaction knowing what we will build together...
- 5:36what we built together will be in trusted hands." Look, I think the, the story here... Well, one, it's just massive, right? And you've seen Asbury- That is big... last year... Uh, this year get Herb Chambers.
- 5:49They're already top 25 groups that they're acquiring into the trying to go after that number one spot. This is, this is what I think he...
- 5:59Like, if you're looking to sell any time in the next two yearsThe, the major players are no longer going after the failing groups- Yep... to revive them.
- 6:12There's, there's no one that's saying, like, "Let me go f- fix a failing group." Nope. There is enough success out there- They're selling those, actually. Right... they're selling them away.
- 6:20There's enough success in the industry where mid to large-sized groups are going after already profitable, already mainstays, already great in their cities, right?
- 6:29You see a Koons in the DC area that owns the, the lion's share of the, the knowledge, uh, of, like, the, the, the customer's mind gap. And then same thing in Boston, like Herb.
- 6:39Mass- like, if you don't know the Herb Chambers organization in auto, you've just missed it because they are well trusted in the Boston organization.
- 6:46So you see this massive group going after other large groups that are already trusted and already profitable. So if you're looking to sell, it's not wait to get it fixed. No. Fix it now.
- 6:56It's fix it, get it good, do something innovative. You know, even with the, with the Koons acquisition, right, you see a, a tech savvy, a tech forward-thinking group get acquired.
- 7:06And just, just the way, like, one company acquires another company, it's not just that they want the revenue, it's not just that they want the footprint.
- 7:13A lot of these now, they're looking for groups that are thriving because they have technology, they have systems and processes- Yeah... they have culture that they would like to- That's right...
- 7:21now deploy across the rest of the store network, and they see that as a multiplier effect. Um, yeah, that's a good insight, and this is just another example of that happening.
- 7:30Asbury putting the pedal down in a major way. Speaking of putting the pedal down. Whoa. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] I can't tell you, man. This is, this- Unbelievable... this is like a sitcom now.
- 7:39This is- The possibility of Honda and Nissan merging from the world's fourth largest automaker is back on the table, but with one major condition.
- 7:48Honda is saying Nissan CEO Makoto Uchida must step down according to the Financial Times. Talks to create a $60 billion company did collapse last week, deepening Nissan's struggles amidst all their shortages.
- 8:01Kyle, you're gonna have to finish reading this 'cause I'm about to cough. You're about to cough.
- 8:04Uh, Renault and Nissan's board are repeatedly pushing Uchida to exit with informal discussions on his departure already underway.
- 8:11Uh, so the Honda CEO, uh, Toshihiro Mibe, has ruled out a hostile takeover, but is open to renewed negotiations if there's new Nissan leadership.
- 8:22On the news, Mitsu- Mitsubishi shares, which is, uh, a part of the Nissan, uh, world, uh, a lot of times because you can stabilize that, uh, increased 8.6%.
- 8:33Analyst Tatsuo Yoshida sees a potential Honda-Nissan partnership as a win-win, but warns that Nissan must first, quote, "get its act together." Okay.
- 8:42So one of the reasons- Speaking of the first story, getting your act together- Oh, my gosh... getting the car out. You know what I mean? Yeah, this is never gonna be that situation. Um- [laughs]
- 8:49One of, one of the things that was mentioned, and I think this is, like, all according to, like, a reliable source, right? Um, all, this whole story.
- 8:57But Honda was saying they need a leader at Nissan who is better capable of handling, um, like, dissenting opinions- Mm... within the organization.
- 9:07So they're saying, like, "Look, yes, there are a lot of opinions," and they don't have confidence that the Nissan CEO can actually navigate that in a productive way and kind of- Wow...
- 9:15getting all those points of focus into, like, this is how we go into the future. So it is interesting to say, like, "We'll talk, but not if they're here," right? Interesting. I've ne- I've never heard of that before.
- 9:26I, I mean, I would say, like, when you're a CEO of an organization like that, you are much more a PR arm, and we've seen that with, with your, you know, like, with the, the, the PR arm itself, Elon Musk, right?
- 9:39Like, whatever the f- the visible presence of, like, kind of consuming all of the inputs and, and spitting them out well- Mm-hmm... is extremely important in these large organizations. It really is.
- 9:51Like, we talk about new media, right? It's the opportunity to get on podcasts and pull, pull in these opinions and be a real person and, and kinda cons- Yeah, aggregate support- Oh, my goodness... for your position.
- 10:01I mean, even just, like, uh, and, and we saw the, the whole stuff with Delta yesterday.
- 10:06Like, the resolve of the Delta CEO and, like, his presence and poise in his social media posts, things like that, as I watch, like, that's important to an organization. Mm-hmm. Right? It sure is. It sure is. Yeah.
- 10:19Well, uh, uh, we'll see what happens next week. We'll see. [laughs] On As, As the Merger Turns. Stay tuned for merger talks on- Merger [laughs]... Automotive News. The new show. Absolutely.
- 10:28[laughs] Uh, speaking of things getting rolled back. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. We all know that Amazon has quite a dominance in e-commerce, but they have continued to stumble in physical retail.
- 10:43Uh, as a detailed Wall Street Journal report ha- comes out, from Amazon Go to Amazon Style, the company has repeatedly failed to make in-person stores work, raising questions about its brick-and-mortar strategy.
- 10:53Uh, Amazon Go is down to 16 stores after cutting half its locations since 2023. Amazon Books, Amazon 4 Star, and Amazon Style all shut down within the past three years. Mm-hmm.
- 11:04Uh, all of their Just Walk Out tech was moved from Amazon Fresh stores in April of 2024, so that, like, in and out stuff, as customers preferred Dash Cart, uh, smart shopping carts instead, which are, uh, part of, like, a phone app.
- 11:17Um, critics argue Amazon, quote-unquote, "doesn't understand retail" with poor store design, lack of clear purpose in past concepts. Um, Whole Foods obviously still remains a success story- Yeah...
- 11:30uh, where Amazon has made price cuts and tested smaller formats, uh, like Whole Foods Market Daily Shops.
- 11:36But I, I think that's an outlier because, like, that was an acquisition, and Whole Foods kind of knows what they're doing. It was an acquisition, and Whole Foods is- Yeah... an established premium product- Right...
- 11:44that understands how to merchandise, that understands- Yep... why their customers shop there. I think Amazon understands why their customers shop online, and they've...
- 11:53I've, I was able to go in a number of these stores that, that were mentioned in here. Yeah.
- 11:56And you know, it did come out last year that, you know, they had this breakthrough camera tech where you could pick up one thing and, like, put it in and then just walk out of the store, and I, I've done it.
- 12:04There's one in the Nashville airport. Yep. Right? They have all the, all the tech there.
- 12:07And then it came out last year, actually, there's actually humans manning the cameras.It's wild And, and it's, like, not actually an algorithm. It's the humans watching- [laughs]... or, like, being supported.
- 12:17But, and the, the, I remember when I f- saw the first Amazon bookstore I ever saw in New York City, I was like, "Oh, they just replaced Barnes & Noble," right? They're just going the same playbook.
- 12:25But this is obvious that there is a gap between them understanding why people show up at a physical location.
- 12:31Um, in the article it mentions, like, disparate product offerings and, like, almost taking the warehouse approach to, like, oh- Well-... there's a lot of random stuff- I mean, you think about, like-...
- 12:39and, like, I don't have a destination or reason I'm going here. Yeah, the way they do online is, like, some level of controlled chaos. It's like, "Hey, you didn't know you wanted this.
- 12:48Let me pop it right in front of you." Right. And it's so personalized. And it's so personalized. And so, like, maintaining that level of controlled chaos in a retail shopping environment is not as possible, right?
- 12:59There's a reason why grocery stores are structured certain ways, that you know where everything's gonna be, that it, you know, the milk is in the back in the grocery- Well, and book stores...
- 13:07uh, you know, the veggies are on the one side and, like, you understand the flow, right? You have to have kinda that flow.
- 13:14And so, you know, getting the controlled chaos of online in- into offline, I think, was, was some of where this maybe missed.
- 13:20You know, it's, it's surprising because you feel like a company with the resources they have and as savvy as they are would be able to do anything they want.
- 13:28I think just this goes and proves the point, you can't do anything you want with all these resources. You have to understand, uh, some core elements of the business.
- 13:37And I think this spills over into the automotive conversation, right? Absolutely. Amazon selling cars online, saying they wanna keep selling cars online. They wanna get into more, they wanna get into more manufacturers.
- 13:47They wanna get into used cars. Like, this is kind of dripping out now.
- 13:50And I think when you look at that aspiration, but then you look at what dealers do every single day who understand what actually happens, what the customers actually ask, what they actually want when they show up, um, I, I just think that there's, there's some, like, comparison here between how they didn't understand that, and they likely don't understand what they're trying to do on the, on the auto side.
- 14:10Well, and it... This, for me, this is like, go find the experts, right? Like, it's proof with the Whole Foods thing, right?
- 14:15They went and found an expert that knew what they were doing in a retail grocery store en- store environment. It's like if you are great at the in-store experience, go find an expert that knows the digital experience.
- 14:26Trust them. Allow them to, to drive how your digital experience does.
- 14:32If you're an operator that, like, understands digital and lives in that lane, but, like, the in-person experience, you're always trying to replicate what's online, go find an operator that understands the internal experience, the in sh- in-store shopping experience.
- 14:46Don't feel like you have to manage both. Because if a company like Amazon can't, then you per- you personally probably can't either. Probably can't either.
- 14:53Uh, on the, the final little anecdotal thing, I made a LinkedIn post about this. [upbeat music] I did see a Barnes & Noble in my shopping mall- Whoa... that just popped up.
- 15:00[laughs] I'm like, "We're back to Barnes & Nobles- We're back... in shopping malls, everyone." Look, it's Tuesday. You have a big week in front of you.
- 15:06Make sure you take care of the people, pay attention to the people, and everything else will come along. [upbeat music]