Latest / exploreHVAC and Home Services with Pam Mashburn / Financing Growth in HVAC & Home Services
Transcript
- speaker-0: Welcome to explore HVAC and home services where we uncover the stories, strategies and some secrets behind successful businesses. ⁓ I'm your host Pam Meshburn and today we're joined by a different guest. It's not a HVAC owner, but ⁓ this is Dylan Carraway from Live Oak Bank. If you as an owner have ever thought about getting a loan or expanding your business or buying another business, he is a great resource to know. So I thought we'd kind of ⁓ Kick off and Dylan, tell me like your title, you know, how you got into this business. Cause you guys are focused mainly on HVAC and the trades, right? speaker-1: So my team specifically, so I think it will be helpful just to first introduce myself and can kind of introduce the bank and how we got into the wonderful world of, you know, working with home and commercial service contractors. But so my name is Dylan Carraway. I'm a senior loan officer at Live Oak Bank. Been with the company since 2017, have held a different roles, but I've been in this role specifically since 2020. And, you know, kind of my day to day is working with contractors, business owners, and different industry partners. So I think everything from manufacturers to distributors to success groups, coaching groups. And what I do is I really help contractors evaluate potential growth and transition opportunities for their business. So review financials, kind of help put budgets together and really explain to them different products and services that are available through our lending and SBA lending program to help them grow their business. So long story short, I do a little bit of traveling, get out and meet with a lot of people in person, but for the most part, working with contractors, reviewing their financials and trying to put creative loan solutions together for them. speaker-0: love that. Well, I know we you and I even had a discussion when we were buying our building just to kind of understand what all the opportunities were. ⁓ What, you know, how long have you been working with just the HVAC and home services industry specifically? Because I know you've been in this business for a while, although it doesn't look like it. You look so young. speaker-1: So our bank was founded in 2008. We made SBA loans to veterinarians and we helped vet owners by their first practice, by their second, third practice, help them buy their buildings, things of that nature. And we got really good at doing that and started researching different industries in the US that had ⁓ low default rates through their SBA lending programs. So it took a lot of research and you know fast forward to today. We're specializing in 40 plus industries everything from like self storage facility financing to funeral home financing and I work on our service contractor team And that's primarily HVAC plumbing electrical We're starting to see a lot more roofing and garage door service companies as well, but we've been in this industry specifically since 2018 I joined in early 2020 So coming up on eight to nine years in the industry, and we've seen a lot of growth, think, and year one, we closed $17 million in loan production. And last year we closed 70. So we're growing ⁓ every year and a lot of what we try to do on our team is just educate the industry because we feel like this industry has been heavily underserved by financial institutions. in terms of working capital financing, acquisition financing, debt refinancing. ⁓ Banks are really good at making loan to value commercial real estate loans because there's tangible collateral they can touch, but ⁓ they're not super comfortable making goodwill loans where there's not available collateral to secure the debt. So that's where we come into play through the SBA 7A program to help provide financing based on cash flow and goodwill of the business. speaker-0: So, yeah, this is interesting. I've heard, I haven't got an SBA loan, but I have looked into it, you know, just as an in-case thing. But I've heard that it's a little bit more complex ⁓ to apply for an SBA loan as opposed to just a regular loan. Is that true? speaker-1: So there's, you know, so government guaranteed lending program that is facilitated through banks such as Libok. So there's going to be a lot of paperwork involved, but my one piece of advice when I'm working with contractors or discussing benefits, pros and cons of SBA versus conventional and like traditional bank loans is if you're applying for an SBA loan, it's important to apply through a preferred lender through the SBA program. ⁓ Libok is a preferred lender. So we have the ability to collect documentation, approve loans and disperse funds in-house versus kind of packaging that up and submitting it to the SBA for their review process. So essentially like expedites the timeline. But also, a lot of local banks are really good at again, that commercial real estate loan or making your mortgage loan or an auto loan, but they may do one or two SBA loans per year. So if they try to process that application, they're kind of learning on the fly. ⁓ So another piece of advice is you don't really want to be ⁓ the guinea pig for that bank for the year to have them explore the SBA program. I would do research and see if the bank you're applying with has a lot of SBA volume ⁓ because it's They're one of the top producers in the SBA program. They probably got their systems and processes in place to help make it as smooth and seamless of a process as possible. speaker-0: That's great. I think that's great advice. That's just stuff I wouldn't have known. ⁓ You play such an important role in a business owner's ⁓ kind of tool chest, right? Like we have the accountant, we have the insurance guy. And I think as a really ⁓ important thing is to have that person that you can call and say, hey, I'm thinking about this. What do I need? And so do you have, do people have you on speed dial and ask you questions before they do things? Like someone approaches them about buying a business or whatever. Do they have you on speed dial? speaker-1: I would say on average, and this is going to sound crazy, but I probably take 20 to 30 calls with a customer before a loan ever funds. we're working years in advance because a lot of what we do is succession planning. So helping a owner sell their business to a key employee or a family member. And oftentimes you're planning one to five years out for that transaction. So I'm able to help guide them through the process, you know, kind of let them know what their numbers look like, where they need to be to get that certain price they want to sell for, things that we would look for in a buyer. So oftentimes, you know, I'm working with business owners well in advance of what we would ever even start the process. So the most of my days are spent on the phone, just kind of help educating and guiding folks in the right direction and helping make sure that when they are ready to apply, know, that they have kind of everything cleaned up on their financial side for personal and business purposes. speaker-0: Who else is involved? Who is it? Who are there other players that if you were wanting to sell your business ⁓ to like a family member, key employee or whatever, ⁓ because neither party is probably real well versed in this. So what other, what other resources would you want to get involved in this? And do you have ⁓ recommendations on that? speaker-1: That's a great question. think having a broker is always important. We do have some relationships with industry specific brokers that are great people and know the industry very well. So I think engaging in a broker even with like, you know, selling your business to a family member can be really important because you don't know what you don't know. Right. speaker-0: mean, you don't do it million times in your lifetime. know, I mean, it's like buying a house. By the fourth one, you figured it out. But the first and second, you make a lot of mistakes, right? speaker-1: This is often the largest financial transaction of their life. So you want to make sure you have professionals in your corner. I think also CPAs are super important to engage in the process. ⁓ Legal counsel, making sure that ⁓ everything is buttoned up in your purchase agreement and everything like that to make sure both buyer and seller are being protected. I think a financial planner. to say if you want to sell your business for three million bucks, how does that look after retirement? Because you're not going to be collecting income from that business anymore. You're going to be relying on essentially the assets that you have after selling the business. So making sure you're thinking about the tax burden, ⁓ the lifestyle plan moving forward. So if I had to really sum it up in three. three different buckets, I would say a broker, an attorney, and a CPA and legal counsel, so four actually. speaker-0: Mm-hmm. I like the financial planner piece too. I know we bought a building that we're in and I was in the market I had some cash. I'm like, I want to buy the building I'm tired of paying rent and the people that we bought from this this commercial office building Was an LLC of family members and they did not want the tax implications of it So they they made a really incredible deal with us Where it was basically like a lease to purchase. Yep, and it was I mean It was really a sweet deal and it also gave me the opportunity to get out of it. But I remember going, I've never heard of this kind of situation. And so I was really having to ask people, like, where, I think I'm getting scammed, but I'm not sure. And so I did have to go out and find that, that counsel. And I found out that it's, it's not something that you do quickly. speaker-1: Yeah, and we see something very similar on the business side as well. think historically how a lot of these businesses have transitioned because this has been an underserved industry in terms of like banking and financial institutions is with seller financing. So if you owned your heating and air business and you wanted to sell it to me as your key employee, typically, you know, done with a handshake agreement in the past. ⁓ That can come with some benefits, but it's puts all of the risk really on you, is if I don't operate the business to the same levels that you did, or if I take my eye off the ball, then the business starts declining and you're really left with asset that doesn't have any value. And that puts kind of that sale or purchase price in jeopardy for you. So when you're able to engage a bank that kind of helps spread the risk and it helps the seller get paid for all the years of dedication and hard work they put into building and growing that business. And it also holds the buyer accountable because they know they have to make the payment to the bank. speaker-0: Well, and think there's something I've talked to several businesses, HVAC businesses that were family owned. And you know, a few of them, because we've been to conferences together and ⁓ there's one father son team and there was a grandfather involved. ⁓ you know, it was interesting because he said they're utilizing some coaching programs and the father was able to get out of it. And I said, well, how much are you showing up? And he goes, I'm not. I'm not, you know, I got bought out. I'm done with that. And it's really freeing for that next generation to be able to say it's mine and do not have to keep it. And then on the flip side, I've got a couple of clients where their 80 year old father still coming in and it's, it's, it's, it is old school versus new school. And it's a lot. So I think there's a lot of benefits to going ahead and doing kind of a clean break. ⁓ Not to say that you wouldn't be able to counsel them, but financially to be clean of that, speaker-1: Yeah, I agree. think having a transition period is super important to really just get a feel for how the previous owner has operated the business on a day to day or month to month basis. ⁓ But, know, kind of to your point, that new owner is often going to bring new perspective, new ideas, new growth strategies into the business. So maybe that old owner was a paper based company. and our new owner wants to come in and implement field management software, or maybe they kind of want to rewrap trucks and give it a fresh look. ⁓ And, if you have old owner and new owner both in the building, you know, they can start to butt heads and then that kind of funnels down to employees where employees have answered to their previous owner for the last 20 years, but now they have a new owner. So it can kind of, you know, cause some confusion as well. So ⁓ we typically see transition periods, I would say between three to six months. Sometimes they're shorter than that, sometimes they're longer than that. ⁓ But it's also, you think really important for sellers to realize ⁓ what does their life look like after they sell the business. Because I think one of the hardest things to realize is that's not their business anymore. ⁓ you know, emotionally being able to let go of the business, I think is always important. speaker-0: Yeah, we had somebody on the podcast, ⁓ Patrick Carr with Blue Collar Media, we were talking about branding and how a company has got your name on it. And I said, so, you know, do you make the branding about the owner or not? Or, you know, do you make it about just the business? he said, one thing to consider, and it goes along with what you're saying, is if you're going to sell the business, are you going to be okay with driving by? that business and seeing your name on it and knowing you have nothing, no control of what's going on in there. And that's hard for a lot of business owners because they have blood, sweat and tears in there, right? Yeah, so tell me like the most successful transition that you've seen, like what they did to make it successful. speaker-1: certainly. I think buying a company for the right reasons is always super important. You hear a lot about business owners or first-time buyers wanting to acquire and roll up companies just to kind of build revenue without really thinking about growing strategically. So maybe they get so enticed by a revenue or EBITDA purchase price multiple that they kind of lose sight of the asset they're actually buying. ⁓ so I think growing strategically is super important. ⁓ you know, figuring out what synergies you have with your existing business and the one you're going to buy. ⁓ you know, maybe you're a heating and air company and you've wanted to get into plumbing for a really long time and you didn't really want to start that division from the ground up. So you want to go acquire, ⁓ an existing plumbing company. ⁓ and that brings a load of benefits. You plumbing is not quite as seasonal as heating and air. ⁓ And then you're kind of combining two customer lists that will essentially you'll be able to cross sell to each other. ⁓ So I think the most successful transactions are always with folks that grow strategically and really kind of think through what this looks like in year one, but also what it looks like in year five ⁓ and kind of where they want to be. speaker-0: I love that advice. I'm actually writing some notes because I think it's really good. So sometimes people come, so ⁓ let's shift to the other side of offerings that you do. It's not just selling your business or buying a business, but it might be expanding your business. How are you able to help, what are some opportunities for HVAC companies? speaker-1: So right now, what we're really seeing trending in the market is working capital financing and commercial real estate financing. And that really helps support the organic growth of your business. So if you think on the working capital side, investing in marketing, advertising, hiring, trainings, ⁓ maybe personnel can really help position your business well for growth. And there's two ways to do that. You can either spend the cash off your balance sheet to do that. or you can take a loan to do that. you know, if you're going to take cash off your balance sheet, you always want to make sure that you have some level of cash reserves. As you know, I've mentioned, this is a very seasonal industry. And I always think it's really important to make sure you kind of have that treasure chest of cash if you ever need to access it to help make payroll during the shoulder season. on the flip side, if you're going to take debt, make sure you're taking on the right type of debt. There's a lot of ⁓ lenders and financial institutions that will make short-term high interest debt ⁓ very easily accessible for business owners. So they'll get a pop-up in their field management software or through their email to say click here and apply for a loan, get cash now. And they don't really read through the fine print. And the next thing they know, they have a one to two year term loan that's charging them 50 % interest that they'll never be able to get out of. ⁓ speaker-0: Gosh, sounds like a payday line. speaker-1: It is, yeah. see a ton of them. Really? And sometimes they are difficult to refinance. ⁓ Our main goal is to be able to refinance those for as many business owners as possible, but sometimes they get so deep into them that it's hard to kind of lift that burden. if you are... speaker-0: Yeah, because if you can't make payroll, you don't have employees. So I mean, I can see how you can get into a desperate situation, but... speaker-1: But yeah, I mean, there's also really good working capital financing products. We have, it's called Live Oak Express. ⁓ Minimum starts at 10,000. We can go up to 500,000 if cash flow coverage is strong. And that's a 10-year loan, 10-year amortization, no prepayment penalty. Your interest rate's gonna be about 10 % based on today's rates. So very favorable terms. Can I access those funds in about three to four weeks from start to finish? So it's not like a 90 day process, but it's also not like a one to two day process. So trying to think about financial planning for next quarter, kind of what growth do you want to see, what investments do you want to make, ⁓ to make sure you can select the right financial tool to help get you there. speaker-0: Yeah. And then this is the planning. That's the important part. What are we going to say? speaker-1: And then on real estate, we've seen a ton of real estate interests over the last, I'd say, 18 months. We're in somewhat of a declining rate environment. Rates have gone down a decent amount last 12, 24 months. And I think a lot of folks are kind of like yourself. They want to start building equity for themselves instead of for their landlord. They want to take advantage of tax and depreciation write-offs. They want to have control over their own facility. And I think one of the most stressful things that a business owner can go through is have their landlord reach out and say, we're selling the building. I need you out in 90 days. ⁓ speaker-0: your Google business profile on it and it's just it's a real hassle, right? speaker-1: Yeah, especially if you're in the middle of busy season where like you literally are working 12 to 16 hour days. ⁓ So having control ⁓ and freedom over, you know, kind of how the business operates out of that facility is super important. So we're seeing a lot of real estate transactions right now more than I've ever seen since I've been lending in this industry. And folks are able to take advantage of 25 year terms, 25 year amortization. So their payback period. Oftentimes, if you're an existing business owner, you can apply for 100 % financing, so not having to put cash into the deal. It's called the SBA expansion program. And essentially, we take your existing business as a co-borrow on the loan and use the equity from that business balance sheet to kind of satisfy that requirement. So it's super impactful and that applies for working capital and acquisitions as well. speaker-0: I didn't even know that was out there. speaker-1: So if you're an existing business owner again that's been generating revenue for over 12 months, the SPA loan program has great and flexible down payment options. speaker-0: Hey, I have a question because it came up in a forum that I'm in. And it was, does it help if you are a woman-owned business or veteran-owned business in the SBA loan process? speaker-1: So I will say we love working with women-owned, minority-owned business owners. ⁓ To my knowledge, at least the programs that I participate in on a daily basis, there's no like tangible benefit. I think it really comes into play post-close when you're actually operating the business. think it helps you with a lot of, depending on what type of work the business does with like winning certain contracts and certain types of jobs. speaker-0: Yeah, how big the jobs are. Yeah, especially government backed jobs. They really do. But it doesn't really help you in the loan process. It just helps you in the ⁓ contract award. speaker-1: Yeah, again, we love that type of ⁓ business owner profile, but we're also taking a look at personal credit, industry experience, liquidity, things of that nature as well. speaker-0: So it wouldn't make sense to make the woman, if it was a husband-wife team, it doesn't make sense to necessarily put the woman as the primary owner in a loan situation. speaker-1: I mean, I don't want to speak to that. see a lot of folks structure that way and a lot of very successful businesses run in that manner. Really, we kind of look at them as a whole. whether they're 51 or 49, that's correct. speaker-0: the whole business, not just the person. Gotcha. Yeah, sorry, I put you on the spot there. Well, this is really interesting. The real estate piece is really interesting. And I'm going to add just from a marketing standpoint, that one thing that owners should really be looking at is the location, because that's really important to Google. I know I've worked with a lot of clients that are moving out of a building, and it is kind of a pain in the rear to speaker-1: No worries. ⁓ speaker-0: to get re-certified and depending on when you move can affect the number of leads you're gonna get. So you wanna try to do that in a time where cashflow isn't gonna be an issue, where you're gonna be okay with not having as many phone calls because Google's gonna re-verify that. if you go, like I've had a client that was on the outskirts of town, like in a technology park, way far away from residential and he was a residential HVAC. moved into more of the center of a residential area and his leads just automatically increased. So not only just buying the building, but where the building is can really increase the revenue on your business. speaker-1: Yeah, I think as a business owner, you really have to be strategic about every move you make. speaker-0: Mm hmm. Yeah. Well, and it can impact the technicians that you hire and where they're located. mean, there's just a lot. ⁓ But we work with a lot of growing. Like we we don't really take clients on unless they're planning to grow their business. So ⁓ there's a lot of strategy that goes into not just being five mile famous, you know, where you own the five mile radius of your business. But as you start extending into 10 mile and 50 mile, a lot of that doesn't that includes you know, buying real estate or at least renting to buy. Yeah, this is some really great stuff. ⁓ So is there any business that's too small for you to work with or too big? speaker-1: I would say ⁓ probably revenue has to be at least 250K. That's probably our minimum threshold. ⁓ And then we have contractors in our portfolio that are doing 40 to $50 million just on my team. We have a middle market lending team here at the bank as well that has great conventional products that have businesses that scale way above and beyond 40 to 50 million. ⁓ The smallest line our team has made has been 10,000 bucks. So the largest my team has made has been 30 million bucks. So kind of a wide variety of products. Yeah. But I would say our average customer is doing revenue between one and 10 million bucks. That's kind of the sweet spot for our products. speaker-0: That's a wide range. So over a million is usually where people, yeah, because it's almost like that next hurdle, right? It's like that next growth that's going on. I always think that when you hit a million, that's when things start breaking. know, all of a sudden you've got to make sure you've got a full-time person doing your books, a full-time person answering the phone, more texts. There's a lot more burden there, I think. And so I can see why you would need the capital. ⁓ speaker-1: Yeah, growth can come with a lot of challenges, that's for sure. speaker-0: ⁓ huh. there anybody, if somebody came to you, have you ever had somebody come to you you said, I just, don't think this is a good idea for you to borrow money. speaker-1: Yeah, I mean, if they're over leveraged on their personal side, ⁓ you know, might not be a good idea to take out a government guaranteed loan. ⁓ If they can't manage their personal finances, that probably isn't going to translate to managing their business finances appropriately. ⁓ Work mix is really important for us. We really like residential, like commercial service repair, add-on replacement. So we try to, you know, be cautious when lending businesses that do a lot of revenue with new construction installation, just because that revenue is not as sticky and reoccurring. ⁓ And I'll be the first one to tell a customer, hey, I don't think it's a good fit for us. And these are the reasons why. Because if I make a loan to a customer, oftentimes it's a goodwill loan. So we're not taking collateral to fully secure our debt. So if that loan goes bad, The bank doesn't have any collateral to liquidate and then you know our customer has defaulted on a government guaranteed loan so nobody wins. you know sometimes it is a hard conversation but I'm you more than willing to have that to be transparent to make sure we're not putting anybody in a tough situation just to close the line. speaker-0: Yeah, no, I like that. ⁓ If somebody is, I mean, do most of the people that you meet, they have they already with those $1 million ones, are they coming to you and they're like, yeah, I don't have any debt in the business, but now I'm ready to grow or do most people have debt in the business and they just need additional funding? speaker-1: I think most folks are typically always going to have vehicle loans. Vehicle equipment loans is typically what we see most often. know, sometimes if it's a business owner that's going to acquire their first business, know, typically they don't have any type of business debt outside of those vehicle or equipment loans. But we'll also see real estate involved with businesses as well on their balance sheet. But most of the time, you know, I would say folks in this industry manage their debt very responsibly and aren't just going out taking loans just to take them out. speaker-0: Yeah, I would concur with you on that. mean, the people that are, one of the reasons that we niched down to HVAC and Home Services is it's just really good people. Like they just have, they're conservative and they're running in their business and they're just, they're people that are looking out for their customers, their community involved. And I just feel like they're just in general, just good people. speaker-1: Yeah, they truly value culture and relationships, I think can be difficult in certain industries, especially when you really start growing and making a lot of money, can kind of lose sight of that sometimes. But I think this industry does a really good job of making sure they're looking out for their people. speaker-0: Absolutely, absolutely. I'm looking over my questions that, because I totally went off, I always give my guests a list of questions. And I haven't asked Dylan any of these questions. We totally went off script. this is how good you are, Dylan. So we kind of talked a little bit about notable trends in the industry right now. And you said you talked about that there's a lot more real estate. financing. Are there any other trends that you've been seeing in the industry? speaker-1: Yeah, I think really we're seeing it from all different angles. And I think, you know, ⁓ each year that we're in the industry, ⁓ we're able to further educate the industry. ⁓ so it's kind of a lag effect. Like I work with a lot of contractors that I met multiple years ago. ⁓ they'll say, Hey, I met you down at a contractor event. ⁓ I got your business card and you know, I'd love to have a conversation and I'll kind of look back at my notes and that that was three years ago. ⁓ So we really just try to educate the industry. And I think the more we educate the industry on available tools and products available to them to grow and transition their business, the more interest we're going to see. But I really think declining interest rates ⁓ lowers the cost of capital. And I think a lot of folks are really going to take advantage of that to try to grow strategically with. interest rates being a little bit lower than they have been last few years. speaker-0: Yeah. So if you could give one piece of financial advice to a business owner who wants to build a 10 million plus company, what would it be? speaker-1: have clean books. you go to apply for a loan and your financials are all messy and you're trying to make all these different types of adjustments to your profitability, ⁓ that can cause kind of a lot of noise in the financials and it takes a lot of diligence and you know providing additional documentation and providing additional narratives to try to figure out if it makes sense or not. ⁓ So really just ⁓ having clean financials is the first step. And then I think too, is really trying to grow strategically. Do you want to buy your local competitor just because you think it's a good price for the business and you really don't know much about what that business actually does? Or do you think it's truly a good fit for your long-term growth plans and your vision for where you see yourself in 10 years? So I think clean financials growing strategically are probably the top two that I would mention. ⁓ speaker-0: Yeah, I think those are great. Those are great. That's great advice. Okay, so last question. If any of our listeners are interested in financing, or at least on a discussion with Dylan at Live Oak Bank, what would their next steps need to be? speaker-1: Yeah, it starts with just a conversation. ⁓ Again, you don't know what you don't know. I'm always open to just have a conversation, phone call, shoot emails back and forth or text and just kind of explain this is kind of where I see your business currently. This is what I think we can do to improve it with, you know, our certain products. Or if your goal is to sell your business for this amount, this is kind of where you need to be. So reaching out. And just, you know, having that initial phone call is the most important step. And I'm sure that you can share my cell number or my email address or contact information in the show notes maybe. I'm not sure how that works. speaker-0: Absolutely. We'll get them on the bottom here. So, hey, thank you for joining us, Dylan. And thank you, listeners, for joining us here at Explore HVAC and Home Services. ⁓ I learned as much as y'all did. I think it was really interesting. And for our listeners, remember to subscribe for more insights, more stories, more tips from all these leaders in HVAC and Home Services. And until next time. speaker-1: That's perfect. speaker-0: Keep learning, keep growing and keep exploring. speaker-1: Thanks for having me, Pam.