She Hid Her Scorecard: How Connie Outsmarted Her Captor

Missing person stories · Jul 25, 2026 · 21m

She Hid Her Scorecard: How Connie Outsmarted Her Captor

A laminated bowling scorecard with three games, spring through August scores, and the name "Connie" was found wedged inside a hollow fence post four miles from the nearest paved road on September 9, 2017 - eleven days after a thirty-two-year-old bookkeeper vanished. The card was not a random scrap: Connie tracked every game, averaged 162 and aimed for 170; was this a message she left, and if so, what exactly was she trying to tell rescuers?

In this episode, we follow the sequence of discoveries that shifted the case from a standard…