Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / Beyond States and Spies
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to EyeSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg.
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspect of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:25Louis Sage-Passant is an adjunct professor teaching intelligence and espionage in the
- 0:31public and private sectors of Sciences Po Paris.
- 0:34He is a former British military intelligence officer, holds a PhD from Royal Royal University
- 0:39in Intelligence Studies and is the founder of Encyclopedia Geopolitica, as well as the
- 0:43thrilling podcast, How to Get on a Watchlist.
- 0:50It's such an honour to have you here today.
- 0:53Thank you for joining us on iSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:57Welcome.
- 0:58Thanks very much for having me.
- 1:01So my first question is, I wanted to really unpack the topic of private sector intelligence
- 1:10and why you thought it was the right moment to focus on private corporations and move
- 1:15away from the common perception that nation states are the main preservers and benefactors
- 1:19of intelligence.
- 1:22It's a great question.
- 1:23It kind of happened by accident, I think, in terms of the moment.
- 1:27I started my PhD during Covid as my kind of lockdown hobby project.
- 1:34And what I found going into this, and you know, I've been in this field for about 10
- 1:38years or so, I kind of took it as a given that private sector intelligence existed.
- 1:43And I took it as a given that people would understand what I meant when I said private
- 1:48sector intelligence.
- 1:49And in fact, what happened was I went to my university and said, you know, I'd love to
- 1:53do a PhD on this topic.
- 1:55I'd really like to look at kind of a comparative study of government and private sector intelligence
- 1:59to see kind of where the similarities, the differences, who's doing what better and so
- 2:03on.
- 2:04And the response I got was, what on earth are you talking about?
- 2:08What do you mean, private sector intelligence?
- 2:10And after sort of overcoming that first confusion, it kind of came down to, oh, you mean government
- 2:15contractors.
- 2:16You mean corporations that do intelligence for the CIA or the NSA and get paid to do
- 2:21it?
- 2:22To which I said, no, no, I'm talking about corporations as in, you know, Disney, Starbucks,
- 2:27any household name corporation doing intelligence for themselves and for their own purposes.
- 2:32And the response then I got was, oh, this is about corporate espionage.
- 2:36And so there was this real confusion about what the topic really is.
- 2:39Now, corporate espionage is, of course, a part of the landscape, just like espionage
- 2:43is part of the intelligence landscape.
- 2:46But any intelligence scholar will tell you that intelligence is more than just espionage.
- 2:51It's a tool in the toolkit.
- 2:53And the field that I've worked in, the kind of security intelligence field in particular,
- 2:58is very far away from the espionage piece.
- 3:01It protects against corporate espionage, but it's all about things like keeping employees
- 3:04safe, helping the company navigate geopolitical risks, helping kind of navigate crisis situations,
- 3:11terrorist attacks and things like that.
- 3:13And things like corporate espionage are more in the domain of competitive intelligence.
- 3:18So what I realized was that there was just this, I wouldn't say lack of understanding,
- 3:23but just a miscalibration of what the term private sector intelligence means in the academic
- 3:28world.
- 3:29And that there was a bit of an overlooking of it as a result of it.
- 3:33And I thought that was really interesting because there's some scholarship on government
- 3:39consulting and government contracting and intelligence.
- 3:42And don't get me wrong, it's a fascinating field.
- 3:44It's an important field to study.
- 3:46But I didn't think that the fundamental nature of intelligence was being challenged by the
- 3:50fact that was happening.
- 3:53When I look at a remunerated sort of government contracting relationship, let's say like Boozal
- 3:58Hamilton has with the NSA, it's super, super interesting.
- 4:03You've got this outside of government body that is contributing to intelligence production.
- 4:08But then when I thought about it a bit more, I thought that's not that much different to
- 4:12what happens when collection is outsourced.
- 4:14For example, if the CIA during the Cold War recruits a mole inside a Soviet agency, that
- 4:21individual, that agent is not part of the CIA's bureaucracy.
- 4:24There may even be a remunerated agreement.
- 4:26They might be getting paid for the intelligence.
- 4:29But they're still undoubtedly doing government intelligence.
- 4:32They're still part of that intelligence process for government.
- 4:36So I felt that the term private sector intelligence would be more useful to academia if we applied
- 4:41it to mean intelligence being done for consumption in the private sector.
- 4:46Because then something really interesting is happening.
- 4:48Because when we think of intelligence, we think of it as a very sovereign state centric
- 4:54process.
- 4:55It's something that governments do.
- 4:56And a lot of the definitions say as much.
- 4:58If you look at some of the, especially some of the more traditional definitions of intelligence,
- 5:04it's a secret state activity to influence foreign adversaries and so on.
- 5:09And it doesn't leave room for this idea that actually it can be happening outside of the
- 5:13state by corporations, non-state actors, terrorist groups, criminal groups, whoever you'd like.
- 5:18So I thought that would be worth diving into and studying.
- 5:22So that was really what I think drove the overall theme of the book.
- 5:27Because I realized that as much as I'd love to study who's doing better in certain crisis
- 5:31situations, there was a bit more of a groundwork to be laid there.
- 5:36And this was quite a frustrating thing because there were a number of really good scholars
- 5:39who actually went ahead of me writing about private sector intelligence as I would define
- 5:44it.
- 5:45People like Dr. Maria Robsomaro at Harvard University, Dr. Angela Lewis at Pepperdine,
- 5:50now at Georgetown, Dr. Dileen Duvenage, a bunch of other people who have written about
- 5:56this looking at specific mechanisms within private sector intelligence.
- 6:01But there was still this confusion in the broader literature about what this thing was.
- 6:04And I felt like a lot of their work was getting overlooked as a result of it.
- 6:07So I set out to write this piece to kind of say, what actually is this field?
- 6:11Where has it come from?
- 6:12Is it new or is it older than we think?
- 6:15Is something actually happening here that we could label intelligence?
- 6:18So I thought it was a really interesting project to dive into.
- 6:21And obviously the timing with COVID turned out to be great because it gave me a bit of
- 6:24free time to work on writing.
- 6:26Absolutely.
- 6:28So do debates around the definition of private sector intelligence impact the legitimacy
- 6:33and scope of this field?
- 6:36And does private sector intelligence truly exist as a distinct entity or is it just simply
- 6:41an extension of traditional state intelligence?
- 6:47It's a really tough question to answer.
- 6:49I would say to your first question, the debates I think are now moving to a place where we're
- 6:55starting to accept that there is intelligence happening outside of the state.
- 7:00I think things have really moved that conversation on in recent years, in particular the war
- 7:04in Ukraine.
- 7:05I think the OSINT community and the tracking of the war that was happening outside of government
- 7:12agencies, often in real time, has really helped people understand that this isn't just something
- 7:17governments can do.
- 7:18Obviously there are some things that are mainly done by governments, but the concept of intelligence
- 7:23as a whole, it can happen outside of the state.
- 7:27I think the other part of it was there were interventions in the conflict by non-state
- 7:32actors.
- 7:33There's a phenomenal article that's titled something like, first the tanks rolled into
- 7:38Ukraine and then Microsoft joined the war.
- 7:41Talking about their role in the cyber conflict, we've seen the debates around Starlink and
- 7:47SpaceX being used to drive drones and there were some interventions there that potentially
- 7:55changed the course of the war.
- 7:56I think people have grown to accept that there is something going on here, but those debates
- 8:01do still happen.
- 8:03I do find there is a degree of sometimes dismissiveness of private sector intelligence.
- 8:09There's not real intelligence.
- 8:11It's people playing intelligence.
- 8:14I find that overwhelmingly comes from people who've never really come into contact with
- 8:18it or they've come into contact with some of the lower quality vendors and services
- 8:24that are out there.
- 8:25Like any market, you go from some really exquisite intelligence capabilities being sold by some
- 8:30amazing vendors through to folks who are maybe not quite so impressive, but it's a free market
- 8:38and it's a market that's pretty unregulated so anyone can act on it without having to
- 8:43pass any kind of bar of qualifications.
- 8:48I find often that there is this semi-dismissiveness.
- 8:52I have a very good friend who's in a military intelligence role and he insists on referring
- 8:58to it as private sector information because his definition is very much it's a state-centric
- 9:03thing and the private sector cannot be operating on this same level.
- 9:07Whereas from inside the field, what I'm seeing is something really different.
- 9:11There are actually some practitioners, some teams and some vendors out there that are
- 9:16doing things that are truly nation state level that are really, really impressive.
- 9:21When my researcher came across some really interesting examples of places like the ODNI
- 9:26in the US actually pulling in private sector teams to basically debrief them and say, hey,
- 9:32you just beat us at this game.
- 9:34How did you do that?
- 9:35Please explain to us how you were able to anticipate this particular development when
- 9:39we got it so wrong.
- 9:42There was a lot there that I thought was really interesting.
- 9:45The debate is moving on, but it's still bubbling away there to a degree.
- 9:49I see this a lot in comments by other scholar practitioners, people like Amy Ziegart.
- 9:54She's commented on this that people say, oh, it's just looking at stuff on Twitter.
- 9:59It's not real intelligence and not realizing that that sort of OSINT work is really the
- 10:03tip of the iceberg, that there's a whole world of very interesting intelligence work happening
- 10:08below the surface.
- 10:09To a question about whether it's a distinct entity or whether it's an extension of state
- 10:13intelligence, that's a really fascinating question because I think there's a couple
- 10:17of things happening here.
- 10:19Firstly, it's really important to note that corporations are doing intelligence for themselves,
- 10:24for their own decision making.
- 10:26The reason they do that is because the idea of interests don't always align with that
- 10:33of their home state.
- 10:34If they even have a home state, when you think about your average multinational corporation,
- 10:38they may have very different views about what's in their interests compared to their home
- 10:42government.
- 10:43I find that motivates them to do intelligence for their own purposes.
- 10:50One example I came across, I interviewed someone when writing the book and doing my fieldwork
- 10:55who told me that their whole business model was based on this idea that, yeah, nation
- 11:00states give good advice to companies, but at times that advice is being used for diplomatic
- 11:06purposes.
- 11:07It's being used for the nation state's purposes rather than for the business.
- 11:10The example they gave me was a situation in which two countries in Southeast Asia, they
- 11:17were in a kind of escalatory period where it looked like it might break out into an
- 11:21outright conflict.
- 11:22As a result, this particular government issued a warning to all of its national businesses
- 11:28saying you should leave these two countries, we think there's a war that's going to break
- 11:31out.
- 11:32However, this individual that I interviewed said that at the time the government didn't
- 11:36actually believe that a war was going to break out, that they were using the warning to these
- 11:41businesses as a way of telling the two countries, you guys need to calm down, look at the stakes
- 11:47here, it's going to hurt your economies.
- 11:48It was a really clever tool.
- 11:50There's absolutely nothing wrong with that.
- 11:52I think from a diplomatic perspective, that's actually a really clever piece of peace maintenance
- 11:57work.
- 11:58If you're a company that's putting your entire business or maybe a major investment on the
- 12:02line, people's jobs on that information, you're not gleaning decision advantage if you're
- 12:08being misled for those purposes.
- 12:10This individual told me that's why we set up our business so that we could give people
- 12:14impartial advice that isn't grounded in what a government might necessarily want out of
- 12:23that interaction.
- 12:25At the same time though, we're seeing in very real time, especially here in Europe, how
- 12:31the economic sphere is in many ways an extension of the national security sphere.
- 12:36The recent wave of sabotage incidents across Europe have really hammered this home, that
- 12:41private sector corporations are being targeted by nation states as part of state on state
- 12:45competition because they don't like what that particular state, their policy is with regards
- 12:50to supporting Ukraine and so on.
- 12:54We're seeing this with economic espionage taking place from certain states that are
- 12:59looking to bolster their own economies at the expense of foreign companies.
- 13:04A lot of the reaction to that is becoming this joint private sector and government effort.
- 13:11To a degree, there is still a need for cooperation there.
- 13:15That's not entirely clear how separate these are.
- 13:18That's also not entirely new.
- 13:20When you look back through the history, as I do in one of the chapters of the book, trying
- 13:24to figure out when private sector intelligence began, one of the hardest parts of that was
- 13:28actually it's really hard to know, looking back through the history, what was purely
- 13:32private and what was more state and what was something to do with both of them because
- 13:37it's a very braided history.
- 13:38There's a lot of cooperation, co-option, coercion in some cases.
- 13:43It's a very, very messy one.
- 13:44I'm afraid I don't have a really clear-cut answer for you because it's just not that
- 13:47clear-cut.
- 13:50Something that just came to mind as well as you were speaking is, do you think that private
- 13:56sector intelligence could ever actually come to replace national intelligence?
- 14:03That's a very interesting question.
- 14:05I would say, I mean, I find the work of people like Bobbitt, his Shield of Achilles book,
- 14:12I don't know if you ever read that way, he talks about this move away from the idea of
- 14:16the nation state towards the idea of a market state, where the role of the government is
- 14:21significantly reduced and the private sector essentially becomes the standing for that.
- 14:28Now, to make it clear, he makes it very clear in this book that this is not a positive thing,
- 14:32that there will be entire segments of society that are left behind in that kind of transition.
- 14:39It's not at all a positive move.
- 14:42I could see if something like Bobbittism came to pass.
- 14:46I could absolutely see more of an enhanced role that is pushed onto the private sector.
- 14:52I don't know if it could ever be fully replaced because it's such a central sovereign part
- 14:57of government intelligence.
- 15:00Like I say, I mean, more and more outsourcing, sure, we see that all the time.
- 15:04Even then, even in the peak of the outsourcing era, there are some things that governments
- 15:07will only trust their own government people to do.
- 15:11To come back to my previous point about the misaligned interests, even a company that
- 15:16is from, let's say, the United States is going to have overseas interests, overseas employees,
- 15:21all those kinds of things.
- 15:22I'm a British citizen, but I work for a company that is not British for another country.
- 15:29The trust dynamics are very different in the private sector.
- 15:33The other thing that makes it a very fascinating place is if you think about state intelligence,
- 15:39moving from one state to another's intelligence services is a big deal.
- 15:42There's defection, you go to prison, there's all sorts of controls to stop those kind of
- 15:47things happening.
- 15:48In the private sector, moving from company A to company B is just career progression.
- 15:52It happens very normally.
- 15:54The concept of trust in this field is much more fluid.
- 15:57The concept of loyalty is much more fluid.
- 15:59I don't think they can be entirely connected in that same way.
- 16:04I don't think one could entirely replace the other.
- 16:07I think what we will see is much more cooperation.
- 16:10We are already seeing this.
- 16:12I find that a lot more of my work is now about connecting with various state agencies, talking
- 16:18with them, sharing information, trying to figure out is there a joint response to some
- 16:23of these threats we're facing.
- 16:25It comes back to my very first point, though, that not everyone really understands the private
- 16:29sector.
- 16:30I found some state agencies that we work with really understand how the private sector works
- 16:35and what we need and how to support us.
- 16:37Others, they just don't understand what we do.
- 16:39They have really very little idea of how to interface with us.
- 16:43It's making challenges like the current sabotage threat here in Europe quite interesting because
- 16:48governments know they have to respond to this, but they don't necessarily understand the
- 16:52private sector well enough to know who to interact with or how to interact with them.
- 16:58It's a fascinating question.
- 16:59Again, it's one that I don't have a clear cut answer for you, I'm afraid.
- 17:03No, absolutely fascinating answer.
- 17:05Yeah, thank you.
- 17:06How does the structure of your book contribute to the understanding of private sector intelligence
- 17:12and what methodological or archival research challenges did you encounter during the process
- 17:17of writing your book?
- 17:20So the structure, I started out by basing it, or at least trying to riff off of Michael
- 17:27Herman's Intelligence, Power and Peace and War, because I thought that was a really good
- 17:31book for explaining what is state intelligence.
- 17:33If you found someone who had never encountered the idea of intelligence in government, that
- 17:38would be the book that I would say, read this and you'll come over with a fairly good idea
- 17:41of what it is.
- 17:42And I wanted to create something similar for the private sector.
- 17:47What I realized very quickly was that there was a bit more groundwork to be done on explaining
- 17:51the history of it in particular.
- 17:53So the way the book works is I start out, you know, the literature review, all the kind
- 17:58of standard academic background on it.
- 18:00I then look at the history of the field, trying to point out that this is not something new.
- 18:08In the literature where we do find examples of how private sector intelligence does exist,
- 18:14often the scholars will say something like, and this is new, this has happened since 911
- 18:18or since the end of the Cold War.
- 18:20And I found that a little bit odd because I personally know people who have worked in
- 18:24this field since the 60s, 70s, so I kind of thought that didn't really make sense to me.
- 18:30But looking back through the history, what I found was in fact, it goes back centuries
- 18:35and that the history of the private sector is incredibly rich.
- 18:39And we can talk more about that a little bit later if you'd like.
- 18:42So I start by looking at the history to sort of say, is this new or is this something that's
- 18:45been around for a while?
- 18:47I then look at the intelligence cycle and say, you know, like any good study of intelligence,
- 18:52we know the intelligence cycle is imperfect, but it's a really good vehicle for taking
- 18:57a comparative look and saying, OK, here's state intelligence, here's how it does it.
- 19:01What does the private sector look like in the same way?
- 19:04And that was quite interesting because that's where I really was able to unpack a lot of
- 19:07the similarities and differences.
- 19:09So going through all stages of the intelligence cycle, interviewing practitioners about how
- 19:14their teams did it, and then comparing that to what we know about state intelligence agencies.
- 19:21Then I take a look at the applications of intelligence.
- 19:24So what is this actually being used for by companies?
- 19:27Why would they do this?
- 19:30And I found that really interesting to wrestle with because as someone who works in the field,
- 19:33I've seen firsthand the budget challenges, the fact that some companies, they will have
- 19:39an intelligence team and then over time decide actually we're less interesting in having
- 19:43this.
- 19:44And I couldn't think of any comparable example of that in governments other than the Belgian
- 19:50government, which after the Cold War closed its intelligence services very briefly and
- 19:54then brought them straight back.
- 19:56And that's a really common thing by comparison in the private sector.
- 19:59So I want to look at why is this?
- 20:00Why is there this difference?
- 20:02So looking at what they're using it for was really interesting to help me explore that
- 20:06and a little bit of how that was changing over time.
- 20:09And then finally, I look at some of the ethical risks around the field and look at, you know,
- 20:14is there something we should worry about this happening?
- 20:17And I did that in particular because coming at this from a practitioner scholar perspective,
- 20:22I wanted to make sure I was showing the industry warts and all that I wasn't just sort of giving
- 20:27this very shiny polished view of the field.
- 20:30And especially because a lot of the practitioners I was interviewing are people that I know
- 20:34professionally and there are social desirability biases that get introduced to interviews and
- 20:40surveys as a result of that.
- 20:42The interviews are all anonymized, but even still, people don't want to sit in front of
- 20:45someone they know professionally and say, you know, this is what I do at work and these
- 20:50are the problems with it without, you know, having to be prompted into that.
- 20:53So I designed my questions around the ethics to try and draw out some of the things practitioners
- 20:58were less comfortable with.
- 21:01And I thought that was quite interesting because it's actually a very transparent field.
- 21:05People are really willing to sit down and talk.
- 21:08In terms of kind of methodological and archival research challenges, from the archival perspective,
- 21:14one huge challenge is that there is no archive, essentially, whereas state intelligence in
- 21:19many cases is legally required to keep certain numbers of documents.
- 21:23And we all know the challenges of researching state intelligence.
- 21:27I think Richard Aldrich put the figure at something like 2% of all archival documents
- 21:33are released for study when it comes to intelligence.
- 21:36In the private sector, the intelligence archive probably doesn't exist in the first place.
- 21:40And there's no mechanism to, you know, compel those kind of releases in any kind of historical
- 21:47way.
- 21:49What I found looking at looking at the field was most companies weren't even aware they
- 21:53had an intelligence team or they weren't aware of the team's history because there wasn't
- 21:57really an institutional memory around it.
- 21:59In some cases, because as I mentioned before, companies would have an intelligence team
- 22:04and then close it and then open it again later.
- 22:07That institutional memory, if there was one, was lost.
- 22:10And what I found was I had to do a lot of lateral research.
- 22:13I had to look at corporate biographies, read papers of individuals who I had been told
- 22:21had worked in some sort of field or some sort of adjacent field.
- 22:25And from that, I was able to get glimpses of this stuff that was happening.
- 22:30And once you start looking at it laterally, you do start to find quite a lot of references
- 22:35to this stuff.
- 22:37The big challenge was always finding the start of one of those threads to pull on.
- 22:41That's where I really relied on a lot of the existing scholars across intelligence studies,
- 22:47especially intelligence historians.
- 22:49There are some amazing people out there, folks like Mark Stout, like Johanne Jordanu.
- 22:54There's too many to name.
- 22:56I'm always terrified that in the acknowledgments of the book that I've left some out because
- 23:00there are so many people who were so helpful in this that would just be chatting and say,
- 23:04oh, I actually once read about this company that was doing this.
- 23:09I think I saw it over here.
- 23:11And just that brief hint that something existed was enough to go on.
- 23:15And with that, you could then start looking.
- 23:17And often that would lead to a huge trove of archival materials.
- 23:22And then that would often link to others because they would say, oh, our company does this
- 23:25just like that other company over there were doing the same thing around the same time.
- 23:28And then you can follow that lead.
- 23:30So it's really useful once you have those leads and you're able to pull on them.
- 23:35But it was still a bit of a challenge.
- 23:37I think all the traditional challenges are there.
- 23:40Just reading archival material is actually really challenging.
- 23:43I hadn't realized how bad I was at reading handwriting until I got into archival reading.
- 23:49So that was pretty hard.
- 23:50COVID presented a barrier because I wasn't able to travel physically to a lot of these
- 23:55archives.
- 23:56So I was relying on those that were able to digitize copies of documents for me, which
- 24:01was super, super helpful.
- 24:03And some universities in particular just went above and beyond in doing that, which was
- 24:08really a lifesaver.
- 24:09And those I could travel to, obviously, I made the most of that.
- 24:14And then in terms of the interviews themselves, it's something that I find really interesting
- 24:19about this field is all of the scholarships so far has been done by existing practitioners
- 24:25in the field.
- 24:26It's something that you kind of need access to be able to study.
- 24:30That is changing.
- 24:31I was at a conference a couple of weeks ago and I listened to a presentation by a fantastic
- 24:35scholar who actually is researching this from an outside perspective.
- 24:40So it is starting to change.
- 24:41I think that's a really healthy thing because I don't think any field should exclusively
- 24:44study itself.
- 24:46But it does represent one of the challenges in the methodology of this kind of research
- 24:51is getting people to talk to you.
- 24:53If you're on the outside, it's a little bit more challenging.
- 24:56Once you're inside, it's actually really easy.
- 24:58People are, I would describe them as frustrated at how misrepresented their field is in both
- 25:03the literature and the popular media.
- 25:05And they're very eager to actually tell you how they do things.
- 25:09The other side of it is that in terms of the day to day practice, private sector intelligence
- 25:14is extremely cooperative.
- 25:16It's something that always surprises people.
- 25:18James Olsen once quipped that there are, there may be friendly countries, but there are no
- 25:23friendly intelligence services.
- 25:25In the private sector, you can reverse that.
- 25:26There are companies that are in bitter commercial rivalries with one another, but chances are
- 25:32the intelligence team are actually on a first name term basis.
- 25:35They're probably on some sort of group chat together and they're probably sharing intelligence
- 25:39on a daily basis because the threats we face tend to be common.
- 25:43And because it's typically about protecting people, life safety and so on, no one wants
- 25:48to see even a rival company get hit by one of these incidents.
- 25:51So people really do cooperate.
- 25:53And that does translate into the research that you can leverage that cooperative side
- 25:59of it.
- 26:00You can post surveys and interview requests in some of these group chats.
- 26:04And what you find is people are really willing and keen to talk to you.
- 26:08Like I say, that does introduce challenges of its own that you have to address to kind
- 26:11of mitigate social desirability biases.
- 26:15It's one of the reasons, one of the other reasons I anonymized my practitioners was
- 26:20that their companies may not necessarily always be happy that they were talking to me about
- 26:23the work they do, mainly because the companies themselves don't fully understand what these
- 26:28people do all day.
- 26:29They just hear intelligence and assume that something a bit shady or that could be controversial.
- 26:34So they're more willing to talk to you if you do it anonymously.
- 26:38My ethics committee at the university also insisted on that.
- 26:41So if you read the book, you'll find a lot of code names referencing them because as
- 26:45soon as they heard the word intelligence, they said, oh my God, people are going to
- 26:47get killed if you talk about this.
- 26:49And as much as I tried to explain that, no, this is actually really safe, I kind of wish
- 26:54I had told the ethics committee I was interviewing risk assessment professionals or something
- 26:58that just sounds much more tame.
- 27:01But as a result, they really did insist on this anonymization.
- 27:04But that did have that added advantage of allowing people to really speak freely, which
- 27:08was really nice.
- 27:10Absolutely.
- 27:11Very, very interesting.
- 27:15So some scholars like historian Richard Aldrich have purported that the very foundation of
- 27:21a concept like surveillance is shifting as entities like Facebook, Google and Microsoft
- 27:26are all increasingly becoming more akin to state actors.
- 27:31So how does private sector intelligence converge with state intelligence or differ, especially
- 27:39looking at analysis collection and dissemination practices?
- 27:43It's a good question.
- 27:45So Richard was actually my PhD examiner, and I was really keen to have him as an examiner
- 27:52because of his view of things like this, that he had this really interesting view that the
- 27:57states were able, sorry, the private sector actors were able to do intelligence, which
- 28:01in the UK is actually a fairly novel position.
- 28:04That's something that hasn't really been established before in the scholarship.
- 28:07So it's really interesting that you bring him up because I think that view is a really
- 28:11interesting one.
- 28:13In terms of how it kind of operates, and this is what I really looked at in my intelligence
- 28:17cycle chapter, there's a lot of similarities.
- 28:20A lot of that is driven by the fact that the majority of practitioners are former government
- 28:25intelligence professionals.
- 28:27Some research conducted by Dr. Maria Robson-Morrow, which has been replicated by a number of us
- 28:33throughout the field, has shown that the number is fixed at about 57% of the industry is made
- 28:39up of people with a background in some sort of state intelligence function.
- 28:43So as a result, they bring a lot of that trade craft, a lot of that methodology with them.
- 28:48And what you also find is that because they're often joining companies that have maybe not
- 28:53done intelligence before, or it's a brand new team, and there's no established playbook
- 28:59in most companies of here's how we do intelligence, and there's no real training framework around
- 29:04them.
- 29:05There are some companies that are offering training, but it's very scattered and it's
- 29:08not uniform at all.
- 29:10They often have to rely on their government background to tell them how to do this job.
- 29:14It's something that is really, I find quite unique.
- 29:17If you join the CIA, the CIA is going to train you in how they do intelligence in their particular
- 29:23way.
- 29:24But if you join CIA Limited, a private sector company, they probably maybe have an intelligence
- 29:30team or they've had one analyst doing this job for a while.
- 29:34Maybe you're replacing them so they've left, so they can't even tell you how they did their
- 29:37job.
- 29:38And even if they've got a big intelligence team with dozens of analysts, they probably
- 29:42don't have the resources or the time to train you in their way of doing it.
- 29:46So people will come in from the government and they'll say, okay, well, here's how I
- 29:50did in government.
- 29:51I'm going to try and do something similar here.
- 29:54I would say in terms of the big differences, a lot of these are introduced by sources and
- 29:59methods.
- 30:01The private sector relies a lot less on clandestine sources.
- 30:04Now, really important caveat, it can do them and it has.
- 30:08There are examples of private organizations placing covert human agents inside adversarial
- 30:14groups, activist groups, protest movements and so on.
- 30:19So this has happened.
- 30:21But broadly, that is not the norm.
- 30:23That's considered pretty shady work.
- 30:25It's not something that I think most companies would even touch because they don't really
- 30:29have the business need to be doing that.
- 30:32They don't want the controversy that would come with something like that.
- 30:35It's just a pretty wild thing to do.
- 30:38So most companies by comparison are relying a lot more on the open source.
- 30:43They are not entirely rooted in open source intelligence.
- 30:46They're also conducting a lot of what I would say is you could kind of call it non-clandestine
- 30:52human intelligence.
- 30:53It's a lot of meeting with academics, other business leaders, employees of the company
- 30:58based in certain countries who can tell you what ground atmospheric is like, who can report
- 31:03things that are going on.
- 31:05They will talk to peers and other companies, which I would say is probably one of the largest
- 31:08sources of intelligence that's used by the field.
- 31:12They will rely on pretty much any source they can get their hands on to answer the questions
- 31:16they need answered.
- 31:19They also rely on a very interesting economy of intelligence vendors.
- 31:24So these are companies who sell intelligence to other companies, much like those government
- 31:29contractors.
- 31:30These are companies that will employ analysts who specialize in certain parts of the world,
- 31:35often have like linguistic skills.
- 31:37And their job is to collect everything about, I don't know, let's say Algeria all day long,
- 31:42and they write up their Algeria reports.
- 31:44And then I get a report once a day, once a week, whatever the cadence is.
- 31:48And it's here's what's happening in Algeria, followed by Bahrain, followed by Chile, wherever
- 31:53it is, going through every country telling us what are the latest updates we're seeing
- 31:57there that are relevant to our industry or to what we're interested in.
- 32:02There are other tools out there that are being driven by kind of the use of social media.
- 32:09So things like data miner, fact tool, these are tools that will scan pretty much any social
- 32:15media site, any open news site.
- 32:19And they look for certain keywords.
- 32:20They look for certain indicators that something interesting is happening.
- 32:23And they ping you and they say, hey, there's reports on social media that a bomb has gone
- 32:28off in this city.
- 32:29You should take a look at that.
- 32:30And they use various algorithmic magic that I don't fully understand, that essentially
- 32:35says, you know, we've seen one person tweeting that this has happened, it's probably a hoax,
- 32:40versus we've seen 100 tweets in the last two minutes saying this has happened, something
- 32:44might be going on here.
- 32:46And then some of those also add a layer of human verification to then take the stuff
- 32:49out and say, okay, we're going to get some journalistic style fact checkers to look and
- 32:53see if this is really happening.
- 32:55So in the collection field, it really depends.
- 32:58It's a lot more resource constrained.
- 33:00You know, the private sector doesn't have the typical need to be putting satellites
- 33:05up there doing persistent monitoring, to be running vast signals, intelligence arrays,
- 33:10and so on.
- 33:11Again, some of that stuff does happen.
- 33:13There are private companies out there that do have satellite capabilities.
- 33:16There are examples that I talk about in the history chapter of companies using satellite
- 33:21imagery for competitive intelligence purposes, looking at rivals factories to see if their
- 33:28output is slowing down and things like that.
- 33:32And to Richard Aldrich's point, some of the biggest engines of data surveillance are now
- 33:39private sector corporations.
- 33:40The amount of kind of signals intelligence that they're able to hoover up is absolutely
- 33:45huge.
- 33:46But for security intelligence purposes, that's really not something they tend to use.
- 33:50The folks in those companies tell me in the security intelligence teams tell me they don't
- 33:53have platform data access.
- 33:55They don't need it.
- 33:56It's not part of their day-to-day work and that it would be too controversial for them
- 34:01to use it if they did.
- 34:03In terms of analysis, I think that's another area where there's some difference.
- 34:07Again, a lot of this is rooted in the lack of uniform training.
- 34:10I came across some teams who are doing rigorous structured analytic techniques.
- 34:16They're doing it very much based on some of their former government training or training
- 34:20they've received in the private sector in this type of analysis.
- 34:23There are others who tell me, yeah, I was trained in structured analytic techniques,
- 34:27but I just don't have the time to do them.
- 34:29We're a two-person intelligence team.
- 34:32And therefore, we basically do really quick common sense analysis.
- 34:36It's very vulnerable to all sorts of heuristics and biases and other things.
- 34:41And we know it's not good enough, but we don't have the time for anything else through to
- 34:46companies that do this in a really rigorous way.
- 34:49So there's a lot of variation there.
- 34:52Dissemination is another area where it definitely depends.
- 34:55I think some of the biggest differences I've noticed in the dissemination phase, one is
- 35:01private sector intelligence practitioners are often also giving policy advice, something
- 35:07that I think would absolutely horrify the Sherman-Kent School of Policymaking as for
- 35:12the policymakers, intelligence is about this raw, unfiltered analysis that doesn't ever
- 35:18touch or is influenced by policy.
- 35:20The private sector doesn't always have that luxury.
- 35:22Chances are if you're briefing a corporate executive on a certain security issue, you're
- 35:27probably the security expert in that room.
- 35:30And it's something that this executive doesn't think about all day.
- 35:33They don't think about security policies in the way a government principle would.
- 35:37Their work is all about commercial things.
- 35:39You've come in to tell them some very bad news, something's in the way of that.
- 35:43And the logical question they will ask is, so what should we do about this?
- 35:46And a lot of the practitioners I interviewed would tell me variations of, this was actually
- 35:51really uncomfortable for me because I spent my whole government career being told, you
- 35:54never give advice.
- 35:55Your job is purely on the analytic side.
- 35:58And then suddenly they're in this position where you're actually encouraged to give advice
- 36:02you need to do it because it's your job.
- 36:04So I think that's one area that's a big difference.
- 36:06I think a lot of that is rooted, the second difference is rooted very heavily in that
- 36:11same issue, which is in government, you're typically briefing audiences that are, if
- 36:16not trained to receive intelligence, they're used to it.
- 36:19They understand what it is.
- 36:20When the president gets the president's daily brief, they understand what goes on behind
- 36:25that.
- 36:26I always appreciate that as we've seen in recent years, but they broadly understand
- 36:30the purpose of this thing and what goes into it.
- 36:33Most corporate executives, if they get an intelligence briefing, there's a good chance
- 36:36it's the first one they've ever had and they don't necessarily know what this is, what
- 36:41to do with it.
- 36:42So you spend a lot of your time educating them, talking about, here's what probabilistic
- 36:46language means.
- 36:47If I say something's likely, here's what I'm specifically saying the chances are here because
- 36:52they won't necessarily know these things.
- 36:55And helping them shape requirements is also a big part of it, that you're dealing with
- 37:00consumers who in the direction phase, they don't know how this works.
- 37:05So they will kind of say, okay, can you tell me about, I don't know, tell me about Saudi
- 37:10Arabia.
- 37:11And that's about as specific as the request gets.
- 37:14And that's a huge question.
- 37:15So you have to help them distill it down.
- 37:17What is it you're interested in?
- 37:18What's the business plan here so that I can hone my requirements in in a more useful way?
- 37:25And then often it's that they don't even know that they can express a requirement to you.
- 37:32They just think your job is to tell them stuff.
- 37:34And sometimes you have to be very self-directed.
- 37:37Something I found really common in responses from practitioners when I interviewed them
- 37:41was when I sort of asked them about how does direction and requirements, how do they work
- 37:46in your company, it was, we don't really have them.
- 37:49What I do is every day sit there watching all of these intelligence feeds and asking
- 37:54the same question over and over, which is, does this impact the company?
- 37:58If yes, that's a requirement.
- 37:59I now need to look at this thing.
- 38:01If no, that's fine.
- 38:02I can pass this on.
- 38:03And that's quite a challenge because companies are very complex organisms.
- 38:07They have territorial footprints that are unlike any nation state.
- 38:13When you think about the offices, production facilities and supply chains, they have, they're
- 38:18dispersed geographically all over the world.
- 38:20So understanding that kind of contact surface with the problems to understand what is relevant
- 38:24is a really daunting task in a lot of companies.
- 38:28So there's a lot of differences, a lot of similarities.
- 38:30That's why I really liked structuring it around the intelligence cycle so I could spend time
- 38:35in the book getting into these questions about what is similar, what's different.
- 38:38And honestly, a lot of the answers fascinated me.
- 38:41I really thought I had a good grasp on those similarities and differences, but once I started
- 38:45interviewing practitioners, I realized how much there was I didn't know and how different
- 38:50this was from company to company.
- 38:54And pivoting a little to historical case studies, what do the British East India Company and
- 39:01detective agencies such as the Pinkerton's tell us about the origins of private sector
- 39:06intelligence?
- 39:08And can you trace this genealogical lineage to modern times with UBER strategic services
- 39:13group and corporate espionage in general?
- 39:18So the history I think was so fun to explore because to come back to your early question
- 39:23about how kind of do they exist as a distinct entity from governments, the British East
- 39:29India Company was such a great example of that because this was a private company.
- 39:33It had some really impressive intelligence capabilities.
- 39:37It operated like a nation state.
- 39:39It had a corporate army that was twice as big as the British Army at the time.
- 39:45Its corporate vessels outclassed Royal Navy military vessels at the time.
- 39:51They were a true sovereign power despite being a private company, but eventually they were
- 39:57folded into the British state.
- 39:59But it was really interesting because reading through their histories, there were so many
- 40:02references of outposts in India being told off because they weren't collecting good enough
- 40:07intelligence and the threats they were facing required they really did that they were facing
- 40:15terrorism issues that were facing rival essentially states that they were facing all sorts of
- 40:22challenges.
- 40:23They also did some very interesting offensive intelligence operations.
- 40:27So the origins of the Indian tea industry can be traced back to essentially an early
- 40:35industrial espionage operation mounted by a guy called Robert Fortune, who was an employee
- 40:40of the East India Company who was sent to China to discover how Chinese tea production
- 40:45worked.
- 40:46He disguised himself to look like a local.
- 40:49He had a team of local translators with him and he basically turned up at a production
- 40:53facility and said, I'm a supervisor from a neighboring district and I'm here to do an
- 40:58inspection.
- 40:59This is an official government inspection.
- 41:02This tea production facility gave him access to everything, showed him how it worked.
- 41:06They gave him some seed samples and he returned to India with those and was able to introduce
- 41:13tea production on a scale that was profitable for the East India Company.
- 41:18They also ran a really interesting influence campaign.
- 41:21At the same time as launching the Indian tea, a number of stories popped up in the British
- 41:27media at the time saying that they had discovered that the Chinese tea production was using
- 41:34dangerous chemicals and people were getting poisoned, that the tea leaves were being dyed
- 41:38to give them a color that the Chinese producers thought British consumers would prefer and
- 41:44therefore you should drink the Indian tea because it's far safer.
- 41:48I have no idea if that is a true claim or not, but the timing I thought was really interesting
- 41:53and it's a really convenient thing to discover right as you've stolen a rival's secrets like
- 41:58that.
- 41:59They were a really interesting example, but I wouldn't class them as the first example
- 42:04of private sector intelligence purely because they were really a nation state run by a corporation.
- 42:11They were very governmental and like I say, they did get rolled into the British government
- 42:15by the regulating act.
- 42:16Eventually they did become part of the British Empire.
- 42:20They weren't the first example.
- 42:22We've seen examples of Venetian merchants, other European powers that were using merchants
- 42:29for intelligence collection, but also merchant groups themselves running intelligence for
- 42:33their own business requirements.
- 42:37Other examples such as the Pinkerton's that came along a little bit later, I find them
- 42:41particularly interesting because they weave in and out of the corporate and government
- 42:46space.
- 42:47Pinkerton worked for the US government for a long period as well as worked for a number
- 42:50of private sector railway companies and so on.
- 42:54I find them particularly interesting because if you look at the origins of some of the
- 43:00modern state intelligence agencies, MI6's predecessor was founded in the offices of
- 43:07a private detective in London like Pinkerton's.
- 43:10They were facing down German Admiralty Intelligence that was trained by the Pinkerton agency.
- 43:15You saw actually this kind of reverse flow of skills from the private sector to the public
- 43:20sector as governments were scaling up these kind of capabilities.
- 43:24The first example of what I would call true private sector intelligence under the definitions
- 43:30I use in the book, however, I would say it was none of these.
- 43:33It was the insurance company Lloyd's of London.
- 43:37They set up an intelligence capability called the Lloyd's Agency to manage their absolutely
- 43:42sprawling human intelligence network that they were using to essentially assess risk
- 43:47around the world so that they could underwrite it.
- 43:50They held about 25% of, I believe it was the UK's GDP on their books underwritten.
- 43:57They were responsible for a massive segment of global trade and ensuring it.
- 44:01If you're carrying so much risk, you have to be able to assess what the risk levels
- 44:04are.
- 44:05It's only natural they have this huge intelligence apparatus.
- 44:08I consider them the first example because they were the first one where it's truly happening
- 44:13for a company, purely for a company as we would recognize it today.
- 44:19What I found really interesting is that the Lloyd's Agency predates the creation of MI6,
- 44:24which is often referred to as the oldest continually running intelligence agency by about a century.
- 44:31Even if you look at those non-continuous intelligence services such as the Belgians or the Vatican's
- 44:35intelligence service, they even predate them by about a decade.
- 44:40This is a really long running organization.
- 44:43I really like that example because it really dispels this idea that the private sector
- 44:48is crashing a government monopoly on intelligence because that monopoly actually, it looks like
- 44:52it never really existed, that there was always this commercial intelligence happening in
- 44:57the background.
- 44:58There was a lot there that I found really interesting.
- 45:02That was the distant origins.
- 45:04If you skip through to the modern day, I think what happened was you see throughout the history
- 45:09that I've managed to pull together and this history is a patchwork.
- 45:13It's the glimpses I can find in random corporate biographies and that lateral research I talked
- 45:19about earlier.
- 45:20It's no way near conclusive.
- 45:22Every time I talk about this, I get someone come to me and say, hey, I heard about this
- 45:26company that's doing intelligence.
- 45:27Absolutely love that.
- 45:28If anyone's listening to this and is thinking there are other examples of old companies
- 45:33doing intelligence, please do get in touch and let me know because it's one of the best
- 45:36ways for me to help fill out this history.
- 45:40It was very patchwork.
- 45:42It's not until much later on, the 60s, 70s, and 80s that you start to see it become a
- 45:47more habitual part of business.
- 45:48It was a rare thing that some companies were doing because of the unique nature of where
- 45:54they were operating or how much risk they were facing.
- 45:57Then you skip through into the late 20th century and what you start seeing is this is now a
- 46:00standard business function.
- 46:02It's something companies need to do.
- 46:04I've been working on a second book with Maria Robson-Morrow and Angela Lewis that will also
- 46:11look at the history, but we're looking a little bit more at the modern history of the field.
- 46:16What we found there, and this is based on some really great work by Dr. Maria Robson-Morrow,
- 46:20which examines how the oil companies were really trendsetters in making this a standard
- 46:25thing, that oil companies operating across the Middle East and other more turbulent parts
- 46:29of the world drove this becoming a standard function of business.
- 46:34What we've seen since then is waves of expansion of the field.
- 46:37Every time we see global crises, every time we see geopolitical unrest, the field expands.
- 46:44Companies hire more people like me and we see more and more of this.
- 46:48We're going through one of these right now.
- 46:49I think the various conflicts happening in the world, the return of great power geopolitical
- 46:53competition has meant that the field is expanding like never before.
- 46:59I don't think I've ever seen so many LinkedIn job postings and so on.
- 47:02I thought tracing that historical origin was really useful because it allowed me to understand
- 47:06what's happening today and why is this happening.
- 47:09So a very long-winded answer to a great question, but hopefully that gives you an example of
- 47:13how it's developed over time.
- 47:15Absolutely.
- 47:16So what ethical considerations must be addressed as the role of private sector intelligence
- 47:21expands?
- 47:24This is one of my favourite questions.
- 47:26I think ethics and intelligence is such an important area to examine, and especially
- 47:31private sector intelligence.
- 47:33Something I always talk about with my students is private sector corporations are not democratic.
- 47:39So as a result, their intelligence services risk, if they don't have a grounding in good
- 47:44ethics, looking more like the intelligence services of an authoritarian state.
- 47:49They may be beholden to shareholders, but if you think about a shareholder, it's almost
- 47:54like the economic elite of an authoritarian state.
- 47:57That relationship looks very similar.
- 48:00You have a CEO who in many cases is almost like a king or a queen.
- 48:04The amount of power they have over the direction of the entity is huge.
- 48:09So understanding ethics is really important.
- 48:11Now, that's not to say that private sector teams are behaving like dictatorial nation
- 48:16state intelligence services is very much not the case.
- 48:19The vast majority of practitioners I interviewed were very willing to engage on some pretty
- 48:25in-depth discussions on the ethics of how they operate.
- 48:28And my takeaway was that I think the vast majority of the field is acting really appropriately.
- 48:33I think especially a lot of people coming from government backgrounds and coming into
- 48:37this job with this mindset of, I'm here to keep people safe, I think keeps people grounded
- 48:41in a pretty good place.
- 48:43A lot of practitioners gave me examples of times where they've refused to do certain
- 48:48things that they just felt were not appropriate and that executives have maybe requested because
- 48:52they didn't really understand what they were requesting.
- 48:56That said, there have been examples in the field of where it's gone wrong.
- 48:59So a case that you can read about online is the infamous in the field, the eBay case.
- 49:08So the e-commerce company a few years ago, their intelligence team were caught stalking
- 49:13and harassing a couple who were running a website that was critical of the company.
- 49:19And the stories are pretty horrific, involves sending them kind of threatening messages,
- 49:25boxes of insects and cockroaches and so on, and stalking them and using some pretty questionable
- 49:34techniques to do this.
- 49:36And a number of individuals from that team were sentenced to prison over this.
- 49:41So it was very much a very dark story for the industry.
- 49:47But what I found particularly interesting was the individuals who were sentenced and
- 49:51sent to prison were done so under everyday stalking and harassment laws.
- 49:56But these weren't everyday stalkers and harassers.
- 49:58These were people using intelligence methodology that had at times been honed in government.
- 50:04They were using some very sophisticated capabilities that now exist in the private sector.
- 50:09And as a result, I thought it was really interesting the law only had a framework for dealing with
- 50:13them as if they were just regular people.
- 50:16And so that's why I think the ethics are so important.
- 50:19The other side of it is that corporations increasingly have a huge degree of influence
- 50:23in our lives.
- 50:24The information we consume, the food we get, all of these things are very much rooted in
- 50:29the private sector.
- 50:30And as a result, there's a huge requirement for those companies to behave appropriately.
- 50:34And looking at the history of intelligence in the private sector, what stood out were
- 50:39there were a number of cases where companies have misbehaved.
- 50:43So I've already talked about the eBay example.
- 50:45There's been examples of energy companies infiltrating activist groups to try and discredit
- 50:50them and so on.
- 50:51There have been cases of private individuals who have been accused of various nasty things
- 50:58using private intelligence companies to try and target their accusers, to discredit them
- 51:05as well.
- 51:06So it's something we really do need to understand.
- 51:10The other risk is that the capabilities in the private sector are not going to always
- 51:14stay in the corporate world or the government world.
- 51:17So we've seen recently one of the biggest kind of intelligence scandals was the Pegasus
- 51:22phone surveillance scandal that was created by a private sector company.
- 51:27Now this was only sold to governments as far as we know.
- 51:31The nation where it came from has some pretty strict export controls that were able to limit
- 51:36the spread of that.
- 51:37But there do seem to be instances of that product being misused.
- 51:40If one company could develop it in one country, then someone else could do that elsewhere.
- 51:47And perhaps in a country that is less restrictive on who this can be sold to.
- 51:52We've also seen examples throughout history of criminal organizations using intelligence
- 51:57methodology to root out informers in their organization by conducting early versions
- 52:03of crude signals intelligence.
- 52:05So basically getting access to leaked phone company data and then using some sophisticated
- 52:14computer technology to data mine that to find people within their organization making phone
- 52:18calls to government offices and so on.
- 52:21So this is something that does have the possibility of being misused.
- 52:25So I thought it was really interesting to understand the ethical grounding of the field.
- 52:30What I found made me quite uncomfortable actually because the vast majority of practitioners
- 52:35that I spoke to, like I say, they really gave me the impression that they are good people.
- 52:39They're very clear on what they will and won't do.
- 52:42But when I asked them, what are the ethical guardrails around the work you do, the overwhelming
- 52:47response was my personal ethics.
- 52:50I just want to be a good person.
- 52:52And that works when it's good people.
- 52:54But what happens when it's not good people?
- 52:55That's how we end up with some of the cases that we've seen, some of the scandals.
- 53:01And industry regulation largely doesn't exist.
- 53:04There are a few kind of industry ethical codes that are not widely adhered to.
- 53:10They're not really widely understood.
- 53:13So that doesn't really exist as a regulating factor.
- 53:16In terms of legislation, there basically is none.
- 53:20Like I say, most people are being treated under just regular everyday law.
- 53:23So there's a, it's really, there is room for this to go wrong.
- 53:27So I thought it was really important to understand that ethical grounding.
- 53:30And like I said, I was reassured that the vast majority of practitioners and teams really
- 53:35do seem to be behaving appropriately.
- 53:37People were very open.
- 53:38They were willing to share intelligence products, briefings, really walk me through their work.
- 53:43And with a very close eye on it, I saw a very clear discomfort with that ethical misbehavior
- 53:48that had been reported elsewhere.
- 53:50As soon as I started talking about ethics, often practitioners would say, we don't want
- 53:54to come to the next eBay.
- 53:55It's really important because we avoid doing anything like that.
- 53:58So people are aware of this risk, but the lack of other guardrails around it, I thought
- 54:02was really problematic.
- 54:03Yeah, that's definitely very frightening.
- 54:08My last question is what key points would you consider vital for your readers to take
- 54:12away from your book?
- 54:15I would say that to understand that this field really does exist.
- 54:18I think that debate is moving forward, but I think it's important that we don't just
- 54:22say, okay, private sector intelligence exists.
- 54:25It's a bunch of people looking at Twitter and doing OSINT to date.
- 54:29There is much more to it.
- 54:30There is a really deep and rich tapestry of intelligence work happening here that has
- 54:35some really meaningful impacts on the way we live.
- 54:39So it's important we understand this stuff.
- 54:42I would say that's probably the main thing.
- 54:44I would say specifically to scholars, one of the big frustrations scholars face in studying
- 54:49intelligence as in government intelligence is we can either look at it from 50 years
- 54:54ago because that's when they'll release documents.
- 54:56They'll have to be 50 years old or they'll be able to look at scandals and leaks, but
- 55:02getting day to day a view of the humdrum of day to day contemporary intelligence is actually
- 55:07really hard to do because it's protected by classifications and so on.
- 55:11Private sector intelligence is quite interesting because the vast majority of practitioners
- 55:14come from that government background.
- 55:16They offer this comparative window through which you can actually glimpse contemporary
- 55:21intelligence practice inside the state.
- 55:24What I found was in my interviews sitting down with practitioners, if I said to them,
- 55:27you used to work in the CIA, tell me about your work there, they would say, I can't talk
- 55:32about that.
- 55:33But when you start talking to them about how do you do this in your company, they'll say,
- 55:36oh, this is how we do it.
- 55:37And what's really interesting is when I used to work in the CIA, we did something similar
- 55:40that looked like this.
- 55:41And there are only brief glimpses, but it's a really useful mechanism to understand contemporary
- 55:46intelligence practice in the state as well as the private sector.
- 55:50So I think that's something that's really useful.
- 55:52So if you are a scholar in the field, I think that understanding this field exists and that
- 55:56actually has real use for not just private sector intelligence studies, but for intelligence
- 56:00studies as a whole, I would say is one of the big takeaways.
- 56:03Absolutely fascinating speaking with you.
- 56:05Thank you so much for joining me on iSpy, the intelligence history podcast.
- 56:09Thanks very much for having me.
- 56:12We enjoyed the conversation.