Latest / New Teacher Talk / EP 191: Redirecting Behavior #4: Stop Punishing the Class

Transcript

EP 191: Redirecting Behavior #4: Stop Punishing the Class · New Teacher Talk

Welcome back to New Teacher Talk.
I'm Dr.
Anna,
and today we're wrapping up our four-part series on redirecting
and managing behavior in the classroom.
This is part four,
and we're going to talk about some of the bigger picture
strategies that can make all the difference in your
classroom management, especially on the really tough days.
Over the past three episodes,
we've covered prevention strategies, initial interventions,
and practical tools like routines and consequences.
Today,
I want to focus on five critical areas that will help you
not just survive challenging moments,
but actually build a thriving classroom community.
We're talking about persistence when things get hard,
front-loading your tasks, avoiding collective punishment,
prioritizing relationships, and building a class narrative.
Let's get started.
First,
I need to talk about something that every teacher experiences,
but nobody really wants to admit.
There are days when it feels like the class has won.
You know what I'm talking about.
Those days when nothing worked, when the lesson fell apart,
when the students were off the walls,
and you just want to pick up your pencils, go home,
and call in sick the next day.
Here's what I need you to hear.
Don't do that.
Giving up is not an option.
I'm not saying this to be harsh or unsympathetic.
I know how hard these days are.
Everyone has been there at one point in their careers.
I've been there.
Your mentor teacher has been there.
That veteran teacher down the hall who seems to have
everything together, they've been there too.
So what do you do instead?
Look for help, reach out,
start the next day's lesson with 20 minutes of quiet,
independent work to reset the tone.
Seek out your coach or administrator and tell them what
happened.
They're there to support you, not judge you.
Speak to the students who started the trouble after class,
privately, calmly, not in anger.
Call their families.
Make those connections.
The worst thing you can do is isolate yourself and pretend
everything is fine.
When you're struggling, get support.
That's not weakness.
That's professional growth.
And remember,
walking away or calling in sick might feel like relief in
the moment, but it doesn't solve anything.
Those same students will be there the next day and the
problems will still exist.
Face them.
Get help and work through them.
And let's talk about something that can prevent so many
behavior issues before they even start.
Front-loading each task with explicit instructions.
I see this all the time with new teachers.
They assume students know what to do,
especially if it's a task they've done before.
So they say something like, you know what to do,
get started.
And then they're surprised when chaos breaks out,
when students are off task,
when half the class is doing the wrong thing.
Here's the reality.
Even if it's the 10th time you've done a similar task,
students need clear, explicit instructions.
Ask yourself, what meets your goal better?
You know what to do, get started.
Or this.
This is independent work to be completed in silence.
To complete the work by the end of the period,
you should get through two questions every five minutes.
You have 30 minutes,
which means you should aim to complete 12 questions.
I'll be walking around to answer individual questions,
but remember, this is silent, independent work.
See the difference?
The second version tells students exactly what's expected,
how much time they have, what the pace should be,
and what kind of work environment you're creating.
It removes ambiguity.
Front loading doesn't mean you're talking for 10 minutes
before every activity.
It means you're being crystal clear about expectations
before students begin.
What's the task?
What's the time frame?
What does success look like?
What's the noise level?
What should students do when they finish early?
Answer these questions up front and you'll see behavior
issues drop significantly.
Students aren't trying to frustrate you when they don't
follow directions.
Often they genuinely don't know what you want from them.
So be explicit every single time.
Now I want to address something that's really tempting when
you're frustrated,
but I need you to resist it at all costs.
Even when the room is chaos, do not punish the whole class.
Just don't.
I know why teachers do this.
When the class is out of control,
it feels impossible to identify every individual who's
misbehaving.
It's easier to say, that's it, everyone loses recess,
or no one is going to the assembly now.
It feels like the only way to regain control.
But you know in your heart that this is not the way to go.
Think about the students who were doing exactly what you
asked.
Think about the kid who was sitting quietly trying to focus
while chaos erupted around them.
Now you're punishing them for other students' choices?
How is that fair?
And more importantly, what does it teach everyone?
Well,
it teaches students that individual choices don't matter,
that they might as well misbehave since they'll be punished
anyway.
It damages your relationship with the students who are
following expectations.
And honestly,
it makes you look like you don't have control,
like you can't handle individual accountability.
Yes, addressing individual behaviors is harder.
And yes, it takes more time and energy.
But it's the right thing to do.
When behavior is widespread,
you might need to stop the activity,
reset expectations with the whole class,
and then address specific students individually,
either immediately or after class.
You might need to change your lesson plan on the fly,
and that's okay.
Collective punishment is lazy management,
and it doesn't work.
You're better than that,
and your students deserve better than that.
Let's talk about relationships,
because this is absolutely fundamental to everything else
we've discussed in this series.
If you think you'll be able to build good relationships
with students only during instruction,
it may become too much effort.
Relationships just can't happen during your lesson on
polynomial functions or while you're teaching the American
Revolution.
You need to think about times where you can connect with
students outside of formal instruction.
It might be during transitions,
those two minutes when students are packing up or getting
materials out.
It might be during recess or lunch duty when you can have a
casual conversation about their weekends.
It might be in passing periods before and after school or
in the hallway when you see them between classes.
These micro moments matter.
When you ask a student about their soccer game,
when you compliment someone's new sneakers,
when you remember that a student had a doctor's appointment
and you ask how it went,
these little interactions build a relationship bank account
that you can draw on when things get tough.
And consider attending school-sponsored activities that
take place outside the school day.
Go to the basketball game, show up at the fall play,
attend the robotics competition.
You don't have to go to everything,
but when students see you there,
supporting them in activities they care about,
it deepens your connection with them.
Here's what's important to understand.
Students are much more likely to respect your classroom
expectations and positively respond to redirection when
they know you genuinely care about them as people,
not just as students in your class.
Management becomes so much easier when you're invested in
relationships.
So don't neglect this.
Make it a priority.
Five minutes of relationship building today can save you
hours of behavior management tomorrow.
And finally, let's talk about building a class narrative.
Students want to know where the class is going.
They need to understand the bigger picture,
not just what they're doing today, but how it all connects.
Keep short-term and long-term goals in the conversation.
This doesn't mean you're constantly talking about test
scores or end-of-year objectives.
It means you're creating a shared sense of purpose and
progress.
Here's what this sounds like in practice.
We're a bit closer to our goal of writing a strong small
moment narrative by the time of the assessment.
Let's all get there together.
Or remember,
we're working toward being able to solve multi-step
equations independently.
Last week we mastered combining like terms.
This week we're adding the distributive property.
We're building this skill step by step.
Notice the language.
We, not you.
You're addressing success as a class,
as a community working towards shared goals.
This creates a sense of collective identity and purpose.
A strong class narrative does several things.
First,
it helps students understand why they're doing what they're
doing.
When today's lesson connects to tomorrow's lesson and next
week's goal, it all makes more sense.
Second, it creates momentum.
When students can see progress,
we couldn't do this in September,
but look at what we can do now.
They feel motivated to keep growing.
Third, it builds community.
You're not 25 individual students and one teacher.
You're a class moving forward together.
You can build this narrative through your daily language,
through bulletin boards that track progress,
through celebrations of milestones,
make the journey visible,
help students see how far they've come and where they're
headed.
When students buy into the class narrative,
behavior improves naturally because they don't want to let
the class down.
They're invested in collective success.
So let me bring all of this together.
Over these four episodes,
we've covered a lot of ground on redirecting and managing
behavior.
Today, we've focused on five critical ideas.
First, giving up is not an option.
When you have a terrible day,
reach out for help and keep moving forward.
Second, front-load every task with explicit instructions.
Never assume students know what to do.
Third,
don't punish the whole class for the behavior of a few.
Fourth,
prioritize building relationships with students in all
those small moments throughout the day.
And fifth,
build a class narrative that gives students a sense of
shared purpose and progress.
These strategies,
combined with everything we've talked about in the previous
three episodes,
will help you create a classroom environment where students
feel safe, supported, and ready to learn.
Remember,
classroom management isn't about control or compliance.
It's about creating conditions where learning can happen.
It's about building relationships,
setting clear expectations, following through consistently,
and helping students develop self-regulation and
responsibility.
You're going to have hard days.
You are going to make mistakes.
But if you keep showing up, keep learning,
keep refining your practice,
and keep caring about your students,
you're going to be okay.
More than okay.
You're going to be great.
Thanks for sticking with me through this four-part series.
I hope these ideas have given you practical tools and
renewed confidence as you work with your students.
Take care of yourselves, new teachers.
You're doing important work,
and thanks for listening to New Teacher Talk.