Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / The Spielworxx Bulletin-The Evolution Episode
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the most informed boardgame new show on the Internet with the beating heart
- 0:04of the German ballgame industry Julie Bleeman and Sam BLOKEI found slammed outside of a
- 0:09pub in a pool of his own offerings, Ben Meadows, this is the
- 0:14Spielworks work. So hello, welcome to what month? Is this only?
- 0:22June? To June? My god, the years gone quickly to June's episode
- 0:26of the Spielworks bulletin. How are you doing the beating heart of German ballgames?
- 0:33I'm doing fine, Ben, thanks for having me, and yeah,
- 0:36it's it's amazing that almost half of this year has already done crazy, isn't
- 0:41it absolutely crazy? And so have you been sued by hands in glok yet
- 0:48games? No? I haven't. Actually I'm I'm rarely using people, so
- 0:53I may have used them, but that is not because I I was in
- 0:59danger of being sued by looks. So can we change the name of this
- 1:02podcast to Meeple Meeple, Meeple, me Pule screw you hams inlok me the
- 1:07podcast? Yes, so we should do so, and then we should move
- 1:11the podcast to the US and we are protected by Corey Thompson because he is
- 1:18acquiring for the trademark of Meeple Overseas. So it's such a strange story.
- 1:23Such a strange story, isn't it. And we were going to talk about
- 1:26it, but Steve Syrek fulfilled the brief so much, and so you know,
- 1:33so we're talking here in this first section about games we played, so
- 1:38can you. I can't pronounce this only so you're gonna have to. I
- 1:42do my very best and here and and I'm sorry if I'm mispronounced this.
- 1:48It's the game. It's another GMT game, you see. I'm playing a
- 1:53lot of GMT games lately. It's vj Ya Nagara and it's medieval India in
- 2:01the thirteenth and fourteenth century. It's a threeplayer game. It's one to three,
- 2:07but I think three player is the player account for the game. And
- 2:13first I have to admit, typical of Vesterna, I know nothing about India
- 2:20at that time. So sorry for my ignorance. And I'm so happy that
- 2:23GMT and some designers are bringing this to the attention of gamers. Finally,
- 2:30because it is interesting what is happening three players. One is playing the daily
- 2:35sultanat Sultanate, and then there is a Vijana Gara Empire and the famous Bamani
- 2:42kingdom. These are the three players. So I think it's fascinating, right,
- 2:47this is an area because India is such a significant country, rich in
- 2:51hits. Yes, and in the West we know virtually nothing, especially considering
- 2:54there's been so much South Asian immigration to Europe over the years. And yet
- 3:00and yet you might say, well, it's just Western chauvinism. But at
- 3:04the same time, we know a lot about the Warring States period in Japan,
- 3:07we know a lot about sort of China at that time, Korea are
- 3:10suddenly cropped up into the sort of public consciousness. How did you think it's
- 3:15interesting that India hasn't quite caught fire the way that other cultures have yet,
- 3:23Right, Yeah, I agree, And what you just said made me thinking,
- 3:28because you're right, we know a lot more about Japan and about China,
- 3:34and I never thought about this, but you're right. And I'm happy
- 3:37that there is an historical info booklet included by a GMT, because at least
- 3:43you have some starting sources for this. So it's really good. Yeah,
- 3:49And so how does this work as a game. As a game, it
- 3:53works very nicely, So it's called or it's the first game in the so
- 3:58called Irregular Flick series. So and some people describe it and I think it's
- 4:04a pretty good description as a coin light game. Okay, So it is
- 4:10definitely easier. It has less actions that you may select. You cannot look
- 4:15into the future because there's just a single card on the table, and it's
- 4:23the decision making do I play the event liking coin or do I use it?
- 4:28For some points Here is easier because two third of the events let your
- 4:32faction be eligible for the next card, So you are often pretty happy to
- 4:38play play the card, and the deck isn't that huge. So I think
- 4:43the playing time is between two and three hours, okay, And so what
- 4:46do you think then, because I've noticed that recently you've got this one that
- 4:49I'm not even going to attempt to pronounce a jest of robin Hood a lot
- 4:54of people talking about at the moment. And these are from and Richard Garfield
- 4:59is just announced the having a game published. It seems GMT leaning towards lighter,
- 5:04more accessible wargames. What do you think of this development? I think
- 5:09it's wonderful because it will attract different people to the company. Because Hex's encounter.
- 5:16For some people, it's simply too much. Playing time of a lot
- 5:20of GMT titles is long, so you have to basically play them online otherwise
- 5:27you won't finish a single game. So I think it's great, and I
- 5:31love Volcal Roonkey and I love his work, but often his coin games they
- 5:39feel mechanistic to me. It is my problem because of course coin games are
- 5:45very popular. I know this, but this igs is News series coin Light
- 5:50seems to be more to my liking. So I haven't played a Robin Hood
- 5:56and I think it's just two player, but I'm definitely because it's also in
- 6:00this same series, i think I'm now way more interested to give it a
- 6:05try. And so I've noticed that it may be just the designers on social
- 6:13media, but I've noticed there's been a sort of politicization from war game designers
- 6:19going out there talking about politics in public. Does the game have a political
- 6:25perspective, a viewpoint? Is it trying to tell you something? No,
- 6:29it is. It is definitely not in my opinion at least. As I
- 6:32said, I'm very ignorant about this period, but in my opinion it isn't
- 6:39at all. So it's just for me as a game player, it feels
- 6:43interesting because his three factions really played differently, and as a daily start in
- 6:47that you also have to deal with a Mongol invaders. So yeah, each
- 6:54faction plays differently. But I think it's an unpolitical game. Yeah, but
- 7:00what do I know? Right? Excellent? So I'm going to talk about
- 7:03a game now that I've been playing quite a lot over the last week.
- 7:08And you might know you might have heard of this, I'm not sure,
- 7:12ok, And this one is el Burrow, published by published by an incredible
- 7:17publisher out of West Germany. I mean, the owner of the company is
- 7:25unquestionably one of the worst people I've ever met, but the company itself is
- 7:29great. So what I wanted to talk about. So I've played this twice
- 7:32over the last couple of days, and I've read some reviews about it,
- 7:40and I got the impression that it was going to be a real big,
- 7:45heavy brain burner, and actually realized after playing it a couple of times that
- 7:50it's a solid midweight euro I think, I don't think it's I don't think
- 7:54it's it's not a Lacerda game, for instance, right, And but well
- 8:00I was. We played it the first time, because I made the big
- 8:03mistake of getting someone else to learn the rules, and this person who I
- 8:05asked to learn the rules is a disaster, and so we ended up playing
- 8:09the game completely wrong the first time, and we ran out of scoring track
- 8:15space because we were playing. So in the game, you're delivering stuff.
- 8:20Yeah, there are certain things you deliver and if you put them in your
- 8:22tableau, they block up your tableau until the end of the game. Well,
- 8:26we didn't play it that way. We just played you could deliver them
- 8:30and then constantly deliver them. So but I was very interested and I'd like
- 8:35your insight on this. The rule book was interesting in that it gave you
- 8:41all the game concepts before it gave you the flow of play. Was why
- 8:46did you do that? What was the decision behind that? Yeah, we
- 8:50did this a couple of times now and yeah it's not to everyone's liking.
- 8:56So first thing is, of course people expect something in the woods, so
- 9:01often it is sequence of play first, or in other rules are in the
- 9:05flow, like the sequence of play, and this is the usual way.
- 9:09But we thought, because some concepts in the game are pretty different, that
- 9:13we have the concepts first and the rules also tell you, and you obviously
- 9:20did not read the rules booklet what to do in a teach, So it
- 9:26tells you, if you're teaching the game, just explain this now and leave
- 9:31the rest for later. So yeah, some people like it a lot.
- 9:35Some people apparently do not like it a lot. But I think it has
- 9:39merit in a complex game. Yeah, And I would say to people playing
- 9:43Elborrow after So I did read the rule book after we played it, and
- 9:48I found the rule book what I find. I found the realle book was
- 9:50a great reference book. That structure really helped me when I was going back
- 9:58and there were little things I didn't know, Right, you could go back
- 10:01and it would highlight go to this section, and then you could go And
- 10:03I think I think was there any degree to which so when I've played wargames,
- 10:09wargames are great reference books, right, do you think there was a
- 10:16factor that was anything to do with your predilections as a wargamer? No,
- 10:20nothing, absolutely nothing. I'd even say that wargame rules booklets are ninety nine
- 10:26percent different because they follow the sequence of play strictly, although there are a
- 10:33few examples. So for example, Jerry White's Atlantic Chase, the first thing
- 10:39is, it's a great game, but if you have a chance, just
- 10:46take a look at the PDF of the rules and how they are made.
- 10:48They are different. I think I like the style very much, but normally
- 10:52it's sequence of play, So no, it has nothing to do with this.
- 10:56So it's really interesting. On Thursday night, we played Elberta at our
- 11:00local game night, and there was me and a friend and then we got
- 11:03two people who we didn't know, and one of them was a person who's
- 11:09not played a lot of games and not played a lot of heavy games.
- 11:13And by the end she was really into it, right, she really enjoyed
- 11:18it. And you know that way people look when they've had a real good
- 11:20gaming experience, and it's It's something I've always said, and I'm I stand
- 11:26by this because my second, the second game I ever bought, was Trajan,
- 11:31right, yeah, And I'm always of the view that it's not the
- 11:37weight of the game, particularly, it's the way the game is taught to
- 11:41the player. And if you can explain concepts to people, especially if someone's
- 11:46at a game night because they're there because they want to learn these things,
- 11:50right, if you could explain the game well, and I explained it and
- 11:52I thought I did a reasonable job. Then then people and you can help
- 11:58people through the decision process of a game, they'll be able to grasp these
- 12:03concepts. Because fundamentally, apart from some war games I've played, I've not
- 12:09played a eurogame that is, unless it's badly designed. I've not played a
- 12:13eurogame that's incredibly impossible to get your head around. Right. I've played some
- 12:18eurogames that just have a million rules for no good reason. But I think
- 12:22El Burrow is a game that is easily grockable. Right, I agree here,
- 12:28and that you made an interesting observation. So what I noticed is that
- 12:35if you really have an interest two game that you want to play a board
- 12:41game complexity, complexity is hardly the hurdle unless there are so many exceptions to
- 12:48a role and another counter exception, and sell would be an issue, right
- 12:52right, right, But normally, if the interest is there, you will
- 12:56learn a game and enjoy it. Not evergame, but you will enjoy the
- 13:01experience. So when I started in gaming seriously in seventy nine, so I
- 13:07came from Risk and Monopoly and just the set eighteen eighteen seventy nine, so
- 13:15we still celebrated a little bit the unification of the German Empires or that eight
- 13:20years ago. So that was fantastic. It was Bismarck, like, was
- 13:24he nice in person? Bismarck was okay, so sometimes very like a bully,
- 13:28but otherwise a nice person. So yeah, and so yeah, I
- 13:33visited him a couple of times on his East Prussian estates and that was wonderful.
- 13:39So getting back to gaming, So my first game was a wargame after
- 13:45these games, and yes it was a pretty simple wargame, but still all
- 13:50concepts were alien. But I was so interested to enjoy it. Although we
- 13:56made some mistakes, a couple of rules were wrong the first time, we
- 14:01enjoyed it. And so and normally nowadays you say, ah, you need
- 14:07a gateway game, you need an entry level game. Obviously that makes it
- 14:11a lot easier to get into gaming. But it's not mandatory, no,
- 14:18I think, and and it is that key. If you're into it,
- 14:20you'll you'll, you'll put up with the learning. If you're not, you
- 14:22won't. That's the right. Yeah. And one final thing, I recently,
- 14:28so I'm slow here. I recently listened to your of the Wonderful five
- 14:35Games for Doomsday Interview series to Joel Toppen's interview. He's also wargamer and he
- 14:43self taught himself as l so it is interesting if you are really interested in
- 14:48the topic, you learn and if you see that rules booklet, it is
- 14:54it is hard, yeah, but it can be done. Excellent. All
- 14:58right, let's move on to in act cross self promotion. Uly bleddem Guts
- 15:03of the German board game industry will tell you what's happening in Speworks all right,
- 15:11So only you got five minutes to pitch what you've got in the spiel
- 15:16Works, the the voluminous Spielworks warehouse. You what have you got to pitch?
- 15:24I just want to focus on two games today, So Raising Chicago,
- 15:28which I mentioned here several times over several months, and we are so slow,
- 15:33but we finally now have a really pre order date for this, so
- 15:39in August. So in August the game will go to pre order. It
- 15:43will at the same time you will be able to pre order it from Spielworks
- 15:48the German edition. It will also go to Spielish Media, the German crowdfunding
- 15:54site, and in the US you will be able to pre order English language
- 15:58why our Capstone. So in August, definitely after jam con so look for
- 16:04mid August, so probably next month in July, I know the exact date.
- 16:11So how does this compare in sort of complexity to Squaring Circleville. Oh,
- 16:17it's about the same complexity level, so, but it's totally different mechanics
- 16:22because you raise the city of Chicago. So it's a two to four player
- 16:26game, seventy five to one hundred minutes probably depending on play account. Excellent.
- 16:34And the next one something that I've been intimately involved with in the last
- 16:38week. Yeah, that's Apos again, this game by Chefan Ristous. So
- 16:42we have also a crowdfunding date. We had to postpone it a couple of
- 16:48times. The rules because we have per language. We have ten rules booklets.
- 16:53Of course for the scenarios. The rules booklet are pretty short, but
- 16:56you have to describe the composer and so it's not easy to do this.
- 17:02So the crowdfunding release date at both game found and Spiedish Media is July twenty
- 17:08three, so only after Essen convention, but doing it before and then being
- 17:15away or during the convention. So we said we postponed it a little bit
- 17:21to July twenty Essen or did you mean Berlin? Berlin? Sorry, Berlin
- 17:26Conn. Yeah, yeah, Essen is hopefully not in July. So otherwise
- 17:32I'm pretty I'm a little bit unprepared for us in in July. And so
- 17:40will eposs be it Essen, do you think? Or no? It can't,
- 17:44No, it can't make it. So if we are in July late
- 17:48July, the campaign will stop. Sometimes in August we will have late pledges.
- 17:53Then the production has to be done, so it will be very late
- 17:56this year, I guess, maybe even January. So and I assume that
- 18:00on the crowdfunding page there will be the interview I did with Stefan Ristos,
- 18:06Yes, exactly. So if you want to know more about the game,
- 18:10you can go to the crowdfunding page. And I did an interview with Stefan
- 18:12and he explained all aspects of the game. So yeah, so that will
- 18:17be on the crowdfunding page. Part it will go to the preview page even
- 18:22earlier, so a couple of days before the start you can learn already more
- 18:26about the game and about what is Ben, what Ben and Chefan are saying
- 18:30about it excellence. Well, with that shameless plugging, let's move on to
- 18:37do you like informed opinions on board game topics that are important to you,
- 18:41then don't listen to Ben. It's our topic of the week, all right,
- 18:48Olie. So I wanted to talk to you because I think Spielworks have
- 18:56participated in this over the last sort of five is, I think, especially
- 19:00since you pivoted to do in crowdfunding for games, and this is the different
- 19:07esthetic demands that game publishers have, you know, because we we you know,
- 19:17you go back maybe ten fifteen years, especially in wargames, and a
- 19:21paper map was an acceptable thing, and it seems that that's not acceptable anymore.
- 19:26If you go back and you look at older games, the art isn't
- 19:30as good as it is now. And so what sort of changes of you
- 19:36seen in game production in the time you've been in the industry. Yeah,
- 19:40it is really a different world. So I think that graphics in two thousand
- 19:45or twenty ten were nice, and they were good, and they were very
- 19:52functional in almost all the cases, which is also an important thing. But
- 19:59I think the viewers there what they think aesthetics in a game should be that
- 20:07has changed a lot. So people have lots of people have played video games,
- 20:12lots of people are reading graphic novels and all this has an influence on
- 20:18how you see games. And of course people because it's a global market,
- 20:26have played French games, so games that are coming from especially from France or
- 20:30the French speaking countries, which are very colorful, colorful and look very nice.
- 20:37They were doing amazing art in games before everyone else, right, I
- 20:44think so exactly, At least it feels like it is that case. So
- 20:51you have to adjust. You have to adjust and see how you keep your
- 20:56brand style. If you have a brand style, I don't want a point
- 21:02on somebody else. But of course most companies do not even have a brand
- 21:06style, which is strange, but it is what it is. So I
- 21:11think you should have a certain brand style of graphics. But still you have
- 21:17to adjust. You have to be flexible and try to find new ways that
- 21:22a lot of people like. And so you always use Harold right, and
- 21:27he does your graphic design and the art and so why is this? Why
- 21:34have you kept with the same person over this length of time. Yeah?
- 21:41First, and so I've used in the last two years other artists. I've
- 21:45used the wonderful David David Schneider from Austria. He did you none for example,
- 21:51he will do future staff. I've used Las beston he will do DOGI
- 21:57ma Vita, I've view. I'm using Anton Hallmann from Sweden or these Germany
- 22:06will do the new edition of Quebec. So I'm using others because I have
- 22:10so many projects. But I like to use Hard because he's a wonderful person
- 22:15at he's local, so he lives in Munster, so I can sit together
- 22:21with him and discuss graphic design. And so what do you think is driven
- 22:27this demand? Because I speak to people in my game group and sometimes they
- 22:33will say, someone said to me, we've played a Richard Breese game,
- 22:37and they said, unless you have suggested this, I have never played this
- 22:41game simply based on how it looks. So what do you think is driven
- 22:45the gaming consumer to be kind of so obsessed with the art in a game,
- 22:52especially when board games are so mechanically driven. Yeah, but at first
- 22:57it makes me sad if somebody is as well, I don't want to play
- 23:00this game, or I've never picked this game because of the graphics, because
- 23:06yeah, but times have definitely changed. I'm also a cube pusher. It's
- 23:12not the cover style has changed, but also people are now demanding different wooden
- 23:22pieces, screen printed wooden pieces, lots of people are now demanding plastic minishures.
- 23:29Environmental issues can go to hell. I want my plastics in there.
- 23:33But what has driven this? I think, yeah, different, different things
- 23:40like movies and video games, but also crowdfunding, because at crowdfunding pages you
- 23:48see every single item and can download it. And even if the game board
- 23:56isn't looking, let's say the game board is prep Sometimes it is for a
- 24:03reason because there are lots of colorful pieces on it, and otherwise you cannot
- 24:07make out the functional things on the game board. But put that some people
- 24:14would call it drap game board. As a signal piece on a crowdfunding page,
- 24:18people will cry, They will say this board has to change, we
- 24:22need colorful things. And don't try to ever argue with these people because everybody
- 24:27is a critic and it's an art critic, and everybody knows everything. So
- 24:33that makes it difficult, very difficult for all publishers but also to and also
- 24:41it will change the look of games towards more colorful, bright colors, although
- 24:48it's not always more functional. Do you think that? So when I think
- 24:55about this, this kind of demand for more feels now, I apologize to
- 25:00the people listening to this and I might be completely off and you're willing to
- 25:04join the discord five GfG dot com click the pinpost and tell me I'm an
- 25:08idiot. But it feels like since America has been such a strong vocal presence
- 25:18within eurogames in the last ten to fifteen years, you could pretty much if
- 25:22you looked at an American publisher fifteen years ago, you could pretty much say,
- 25:27Okay, they're going to publish American style games, and a German publisher
- 25:32they're going to start, you know, published German style games. And yet
- 25:34that is completely dissolved now. Yeah, there's a lot of great eurogames coming
- 25:38out of America. Do you think it's Americans demand for glits that has promoted
- 25:45this. I'm not sure. I'm not sure it could be the reason.
- 25:53But I think visuals are so important to people because people are if you are
- 26:00going to BGG, which is an American side but also the global side for
- 26:07gamers, there are visuals on there, so you click on a picture,
- 26:11you enlarge it the illustration, and you already have an opinion. So yeah,
- 26:18I think it US is influential, but I see no real difference here
- 26:22to German gamers. They demand different things and it's not only esthetics, it's
- 26:27also more stuff in the box because you also want to be the cool kid.
- 26:33You don't want to play with wooden cubes, although they may be more
- 26:37functional. You want to play with plastic minisuers although you can't really stack them
- 26:42in the game, And we now see several examples of games where the pieces
- 26:48wooden or plastics make it harder to play it. Well, right, that's
- 26:53what it will on that. I mean, I think it's on the idea
- 26:57that I may be destroying my own argum here. But the company that is
- 27:02really famous for the big dildos in the box aren't American, right, They're
- 27:06Polish Awaken Realms of that big company, it was Siemon, but but they've
- 27:11kind of almost they've gone into the shade in comparison to Awaken Realms R.
- 27:15And Awaken Realms are raising ten million on crowdfunding and stuff. It's it's crazy.
- 27:21So what's really interesting is I was playing El Borrow the other night and
- 27:25there are dual layerboards and I remember Scythe was the first game to do that,
- 27:29and how kind of revolutionary that felt when Scythe did it. And then
- 27:37they're just like like mushrooms in a forest. Loads of Chinese producers who were
- 27:45willing to do that kind of stuff popped up, Panda being the kind of
- 27:51biggest So to what degree do you think? I guess my question is to
- 27:57what degree is it the publishers pushing it? All the producers in China offering
- 28:07services that you just go, oh, yeah, well then why not?
- 28:11Right? I think it's bos It's both. It's demand by publishers, but
- 28:17it's also the producers, and it's not only the wonderful Panda company. It's
- 28:22now basically everybody can do it. Yes, some have problems, especially if
- 28:26you have the dual boats all glued together. And I've now seen trickle boats,
- 28:33so wait till that is happening more often. But they can do it,
- 28:40and for prices that really surprise you. So the increase is not that
- 28:47much. So yeah, I think you're right, let's do this. And
- 28:51again you as a gamer, you have seen this, you demand it again,
- 28:56although it's definitely not always necessary to do so. When I'm looking back
- 29:03at the Weimar Matias Kamas game production, yeah, we were looking into double
- 29:07lay at boats and this, but then the producer told us we can do
- 29:12this big game board double lay at, which we had never thought about that
- 29:19we want to do the boat double a at and so we said, ah,
- 29:23interesting, we have wooden pieces, we can put them in the spaces.
- 29:27Seems all right, And we asked just for a price, let's see
- 29:32how much more this is, and when we saw the difference, we said,
- 29:34yeah, we are definitely going to do this. So I think you're
- 29:40right. It's driven sometimes by the producers asking for something, but also by
- 29:45the by the producer, by the publishers, and sometimes by the producers.
- 29:51And yeah, it is what it is. And you can't tell the customer,
- 29:57well, we are not doing this and for this we are fifty cents
- 30:03cheaper than the other ones. It's impossible. And so all of these companies
- 30:08that do these lavish productions are all based in China, right, And you
- 30:15have to be incredibly naive or blinker to suggest that there are moral problems with
- 30:22the Chinese Communist Party in the way that they treat their citizens. And also
- 30:27there is a reason that these companies are in China because they're a lot cheaper,
- 30:33and there's a reason they're a lot cheaper, right, I mean,
- 30:36should we do we have a moral obligation to think about our relationship with Chinese
- 30:41production and the CCP. We have to. We have a moral obligation for
- 30:48sure, because yes, we are seeing this in China. The oppression we
- 30:55see towards other countries, Taiwan, I'm sure they will. There will be
- 31:00something happening in the next couple of years, for sure. And we see
- 31:04it now that China is the huge supporter of Russia. Without China, Russia
- 31:08can't sustain the warf aggression in the Ukraine. So we have moral obligations.
- 31:15So then why is Spielwork still doing some games in China if we know about
- 31:22this? So for getting back that we need more de risking and not decoupling.
- 31:30It's totally impossible to stop importing stuff from China because then nothing is probably
- 31:37all my closes here I haven't checked, or a lot or what is inside
- 31:41this room is ultimately coming from or came from China. Well this is this
- 31:45is the thing, right. I don't think we would be able to record
- 31:48this podcast without production in China because I'm sure this microphone is made in China.
- 31:56This computer I'm recording on is made in China, right, So it's
- 32:00a really difficult question. And I'd love to do all my games in Europe
- 32:08or in some other countries where I know this wood is according to certificates and
- 32:16everything. Although I get the certificates from China, do I trust every certificate
- 32:22there? No, I do not, but I have to trust the people
- 32:25I'm working with. So you can try to find out about the companies from
- 32:32here. But we have killed the EU Lifa, kate and gazettes. I
- 32:37do not even know the English term for this as the laws. We have
- 32:43killed this. Germany has killed it because it is basically what it means for
- 32:49companies that I think have at least twenty employees. Yet you have to have
- 32:54you have to know all the raw materials, everything in production, how it
- 33:00is done, from where it is coming. But it has been killed because
- 33:06it is very difficult to do and at and of course we here in the
- 33:12EU, in the European Union, it is easier and we can sleep still
- 33:17sleep while we are not knowing what is happening over there. So I'd love
- 33:24to change this. But if my games, first thing is they would be
- 33:32and they are not inexpensive. They are because of the low print runs already
- 33:37pretty expensive. They would cost at least sixty percent more. Plus they would
- 33:43not include screen printed wooden pieces. They would not for that price include double
- 33:50layered boats. And yeah, I'd lose a substantial base of my customers.
- 33:58That's the reality. And yes, moral obligations are fine, but they cannot
- 34:05be the only thing we had. We are living in the world. We
- 34:08are living with the last thing in this boring monologue. So when when the
- 34:15war in the Ukraine started and Germany was so dependent because we we are,
- 34:23we were stupid and are still stupid. We depended on the Russian guests,
- 34:29and then the German economy minister he had to and he's agreed, so he
- 34:34had to go to Qatar to ask for for guests from there, from a
- 34:39country that is also not known for human rights exactly. But and afterwards he
- 34:50said, I'd rather not go to Qatar. I'd rather not ask for guests.
- 34:55But the only alternative is not heavy any guests over over here. And
- 35:01what I'm am I then telling my people here, So on paper, it's
- 35:08an easy answer. No, it's easy to go on Twitter and tell people
- 35:13what to do. When the rubber meets the roads, they're always compromises to
- 35:17be made, right, exactly. It is what it is. Does it
- 35:22make us good people? Not know? Does it make us bad people?
- 35:28Not either? And yeah, so talking about that, then, you know
- 35:34when I when I got El Burrow, I opened it and I went,
- 35:37wow, this felt like a shift in spiel Works. Not that I think
- 35:44spiar Works had produced had bad production before, but this felt a different level.
- 35:50And I assume EPOS is going to be a different level again. Yes,
- 35:53what drove that change? Why why decide to pop that production level?
- 36:01Yeah, we thought that we have to. So the gaming industry seems to
- 36:09be a very nice industry and everybody loves everybody and it's fine, but it's
- 36:14also fierce competition. There are many many players in this field, so many
- 36:19companies are doing great things and they improve, so you at least I feel
- 36:24that I have to be at the same level, not with necessarily with all
- 36:30games, but with the flagships, with the flagship once, thank you,
- 36:36we are so I will continue to do so in the next future as well,
- 36:43and so can you. What's really interesting is that you pivoted to crowdfunding
- 36:52a few years ago, and I think it was because you were working with
- 36:53indie boards and cards and they wanted to do, and previously you'd not wanted
- 36:58to do it, and now it seems that you've that for these bigger games,
- 37:04it's the option to do crowdfunding. Can you ever hope to do productions
- 37:08like this without going to crowdfunding first and having the capital security going in?
- 37:15Yeah, one step back. So I did crowdfunding already in twenty twelve thirteen,
- 37:20briefly at Kickstarter with some early games. But you can't compete it compare
- 37:23it to different size. Kickstarter was so small, Speelworks was even smaller,
- 37:28so let's forget this. But I had some experience and good experience being at
- 37:31crowdfunding, so that was okay. But going back to your question, now,
- 37:43crowdfunding I think is important because I can determine the demand for a game,
- 37:52so I know, ah, there are lots of people for this one,
- 37:54they're not that many for this one. That is great. Can I
- 37:59go the standard route via distribution? Of course I can, And I'm not
- 38:06saying that Spielworks won't be in standard distribution in a couple of years. I'm
- 38:12not sure about this right now. I don't think so. I think for
- 38:15the at least for the next two years, I'm not doing this, But
- 38:19it's a lot more risky because why is crowdfunding good for small independent companies?
- 38:24You get some money in advance for production, you know, especially if you're
- 38:31not interested in huge amounts of stock. It is way easier to determine how
- 38:37much money I need to spend, how much copies to print? And this
- 38:42distribution if you're lucky, if you are getting fifty percent back, it's often
- 38:46forty percent that you're getting from your dollar or euro and the rest is gone.
- 38:52So I would need distribution partners who are willing to take a considerable amount
- 38:59in advance and take there these games and purchase them. And still the market
- 39:06is way over crowded, so distribution is still difficult. And do you it
- 39:15must be a big advantage to sell directly to the customer, right? I
- 39:21think it is. I think it is. Of course, it depends on
- 39:24the company. It depends on the company. Let's say you are Jamie Stadmeire,
- 39:30so you have crowdfunding, so you're getting a lot of direct money,
- 39:35but still he sells a ton afterwards in retail in distribution. In some games,
- 39:42if I'm not mistaken, never make it to crowdfunding. They are immediately
- 39:45sold So if I know there's this new game, and I have five thousand
- 39:52or you have five thousand orders in advance from distribution partners, not do crowdfunding
- 40:01because it is a huge amount of work to do crowdfunding even a modest page
- 40:07and all this. So I'm not saying these campaigns of Awakened Realms, so
- 40:13they spend hundreds of thousands in marketing dollars for such a campaign. Even a
- 40:19modest campaign takes a lot of money and a lot of effort to do right.
- 40:24And so do you think with modern production techniques and this arms race that
- 40:30is developing between publishers, do you think we are in danger of entering a
- 40:37period in games where it's style over content. I think it has already.
- 40:44It is often style over content these days, so and it's a dangerous thing.
- 40:50We briefly talked about some companies were not seeing the game board completely because
- 40:58of huge pieces on the board. This is a bad thing. And ten
- 41:01years ago you'd say, no, we have to change this because it's hurting
- 41:07the game, and nowadays you say, ah, ah, it's hurting the
- 41:10game a little bit, But it's so brilliant that the militias look so nice
- 41:16we include them, So it's definitely dangerous and of course quite a few of
- 41:21these production costs so much money that it's difficult to find not only hardcore gamers
- 41:31who are willing to spend two hundred to two hundred and fifty euros on a
- 41:36single game, especially because it's not that easy to have the deluxe production and
- 41:44also the retail production at the same time. Because if you see often see
- 41:49these two versions next to each other, you'd say, what is this?
- 41:53Although the retail version is fine compared to the deluxe edition, of course it
- 41:59looks cheap. And so just to just to wrap this up, then,
- 42:05so when are you going to do minis? And am I gonna be one
- 42:10of the minutes in the game? First thing is I have to check with
- 42:17Ignazi about your your game design. I was expecting loads of minutes in that
- 42:22actually and especially yeah, hopefully I'm not saying too much. It's a card
- 42:29game, but we don't have yout a thirty minute card game with a with
- 42:32a box of five hundred minut and go with it. That's what I'm suggesting.
- 42:37So so having three to four minitious per card, right per card and
- 42:45put them on the card in for so that nobody can see. You don't
- 42:50need even some some screens to hide your pieces. The minitious are doing this,
- 42:54so I think that's something I need to investigate with Nazi. So how
- 43:00we make this happen? All right? Well, with that incredible news,
- 43:07let's move on to now the big toe of the German board gaming industry.
- 43:12Uli Bledemm will regale you with industry. All right, so tails from the
- 43:21industry, Uli, and I usually ask you, because you're an industry legend,
- 43:25I usually ask you to come up with this section, and basically you
- 43:30want to talk about flexibility within the publishing world. How being a publisher requires
- 43:39a lot of flexibility. So can you sort of fill us in on what
- 43:45your idea is? Yeah, I thought it is fitting for this episode,
- 43:49but because it directly connects to what we were talking about, and it's not.
- 43:54But this section isn't about esthetics. It's about how you, in my
- 44:00opinion, should behave in the industry. Of course, if you are having
- 44:05a tabletop company or running a tabletop company, a tabletop board gaming company,
- 44:09who is having one classic so let's say Katan or Carcasson or Ticket to write
- 44:16you don't care about flexibility. Basically you can just do expansions for this and
- 44:22try to market this game. I also, if we are talking about Jamie,
- 44:28I think he can do whatever he wants in the next couple of years
- 44:30because people will come and will purchase his games. So that's one thing.
- 44:36But as a small company you have to be you have to look at the
- 44:42matter game. So each year at least once, so what did work well
- 44:47and what did not work well? Or how can I improve social feedworks?
- 44:52In two thousand and nine when I formed it and we start in twenty ten,
- 44:57my aim was to localize English language wargames into German language and do five
- 45:04hundred copies and that would be enough. I could I can do this,
- 45:07so I localized. First game was Washington's War by Mark Herman, and I
- 45:12did a couple of them in addition. But then Martin Wallace approached me and
- 45:16he said, you can do It's an advanced heavy eurogame and it's based on
- 45:22Seven Empires or what's the title of this? Is it seven? No,
- 45:27it's not Seven Empires, the Struggle of Empires, so sorry for this Struggle
- 45:30of Empires. So it's a variant and we are doing some card and you
- 45:35can do. You can have worldwide rights for this, So I did English
- 45:39and German inside Alta del Farnon. We had just had a German title,
- 45:45so I did this. That was successful, and then Order came into the
- 45:51picture, the wonderful order elboard designer, and he offered La Granja, so
- 45:58a eurogame, a really eurogame, heavy eurogame, and I did a thousand
- 46:04because I knew this game can sell a thousand in English and a German language.
- 46:09And then because I knew it from earlier years, I just said this.
- 46:16We started crowdfunding, and because I wanted to demand the or to see
- 46:23what the demand is. So that is another change because it is a lot
- 46:28of work, as I said, to do crowdfunding. And now we have
- 46:32a partnership with a US company with Clay and Capstone Games. So let's twelve
- 46:42months from here, let's see how well this worked out. But it is
- 46:45way easier for me. And the reason behind this is even if I'm selling
- 46:52out of a one thousand print run, or let's say, with crowdfunding,
- 46:57fifteen hundred print run, if I'm selling half into English language countries, I
- 47:01know most people won't ever see the game because fifteen hundred copies eight hundred to
- 47:08English language people. It's gone. It's simply gone, and Capstone will print
- 47:15more. So more people are seeing these games. So hopefully Spielworks gets more
- 47:21recognition, brand recognition out of this. And yeah, because Cole Whorley,
- 47:28he really asked me to do more localizations, and actually so in twenty twelve
- 47:35thirteen, I said, I'm not doing any localizations again. I don't want
- 47:38to do this because it's also hard work. You need good people to work
- 47:44on tight deadlines. But he said, let's try it. So I'm localizing
- 47:51again. And this is also different from what I normally do because here I'm
- 47:58having distribution partner, so it's not B to C but B to be business
- 48:04to business things, so totally different things at es in different talks and all
- 48:09this is now included. But I do I know where Spielworks is in twenty
- 48:16six No, I don't know. I have some ideas and hopefully I can
- 48:22realize them, but I don't know them. So I know a lot of
- 48:28German people and German people to be polite. German people are risk averse,
- 48:32right, they don't and what that means is a certain desire not to be
- 48:40flexible before before they know every facet of what's going to be the case,
- 48:46they won't pivot and your your I mean this is a compliment. You're very
- 48:52German. I mean, how how have you developed this, this attitude towards
- 48:59flexibility and this going away from a sort of very safe, conservative kind of
- 49:06business life. Yeah, but one reason definitely is that I hate risks too,
- 49:13So yes, I'm German. I think by being flexible, my risks
- 49:17are lower because if you do the same thing over and over, in my
- 49:23opinion, a small independent company will have some problems. So I try to
- 49:30adjust. And of course being in the industry for more than thirty years is
- 49:34also helpful because I'm not only looking at German sits plus BGG. I try
- 49:40to talk to a lot of people and what they are thinking, and I
- 49:45listen to people what they are thinking. So then I try to adjust,
- 49:50and each year I do for myself a small retreat where I'm thinking about the
- 49:57bigger picture. So, because let's face it, normally, when I start
- 50:01working on a day, I do not see the forest. I just see
- 50:05individual trees or that project we need to change a punchboard too. Afterwards,
- 50:10Oh that project there are graphics designer find them, but that is not how
- 50:16you can hopefully develop in a good way a company. It's totally different.
- 50:21And I'm not a businessman, and I'm also not a CEO that I've never
- 50:30learned this. I have no business background, so it's hard work. You
- 50:34better listen. You better listen to people who know a lot more. That
- 50:37does not mean that I follow all advice than Speelworks would be dead for for
- 50:43several years. But yeah, so I'm fascinated by Epos just because Epos feels
- 50:51different because spiel Works usually goes for medium to heavy euro type games that are
- 51:00self contained products that you know come in a ticket to size, ticket to
- 51:06ride size box, right, and Epos is different. It's a narrative game,
- 51:10it's a it's a big game. You put a picture on social media
- 51:14where you had one game box, then the Elborrow game box, which is
- 51:17big, and then the Epos game box just double the size of el Burrow.
- 51:21And I've I've held Elburrow and that's a big box. So this Epos
- 51:25box must be gigantic, and so it's it's a very it's an unsafe risk.
- 51:32I think that's that's a complete tautology and unsafe risk. If it's a
- 51:36risk, it's unsafe by the very nature. But but it feels like you're
- 51:40going into an area that should be which has never gone into before. Are
- 51:45you nervous about this or have you done your work to make sure it's safe?
- 51:51No, I'm always nervous. I'm always nervous when a new product is
- 51:54being done. So I try to minimize risk, but you never know what
- 51:59you So, yes, I'm I'm nervous about this, but I have I
- 52:07think, I think, what what do I what do I know? But
- 52:09I think I've found a way to make this happen without risking the company.
- 52:16Uh and yeah, And the key to this again is crowdfunding because I can
- 52:23manage demand. So just one last thing on this then, So, what
- 52:31would you say to a fledgling publisher starting today how to approach flexibility within the
- 52:38industry? The first thing is if if I knows, if i'd know something
- 52:46about the So I'm a new partner, I'm a person interested entering the industry,
- 52:52and I've known something about the industry, I would not start these days,
- 52:57which we works has advantage that was formed in different times when there were
- 53:01less publishers and the competition was not that so I'd be scared. Knowing myself,
- 53:07I'd be simply scared. These days, I would not start it.
- 53:10But if you started, I would look into what you think. What are
- 53:17your aims for the nearer future. You want to become rich quick? Don't
- 53:22do it. You want to just do a single game, no matter how
- 53:29well it does, and you have the money, do it. Do it
- 53:31and see if this can be sustained or if this can be a line of
- 53:37games. And my standard advice is have money for the first year. So
- 53:44even if you're not getting a single euro in the first year, you need
- 53:51to survive if you have that much money to live on very modest terms for
- 53:55a year. Give it a try, but with a plan, and talk
- 54:00to a lot of people. Listen to a lot of people, because one
- 54:02thing is, yes, this industry is competitive, but a lot of people
- 54:07will talk to you and will give them their advice and yeah, excellent.
- 54:13Well so that's this month Spearworks bulletins. Firstly, where can we find spiel
- 54:19works on the internet. Just drop me an email at uli Ed Spearworks dot
- 54:23e that is uli Ede Speedworks dot e. Or you will find my website
- 54:29at speedworks dot do. I'm also at x at Julie Blaze or U L
- 54:36I b l E, and also at blue Sky. When was the last
- 54:39time you logged into Blue Sky? Because I've got a Blue Sky account and
- 54:43I haven't logged in for months. I'm I'M. I logged in probably some
- 54:47days ago. So i'm i'm. If you drop me a message there,
- 54:52I will read it. Same thing is true for BGG. You can send
- 54:55me a direct message and I will answer, but don't expect an answer in
- 55:01the next twenty four for an hours. That's definitely not the case. Yeah,
- 55:07And so I'd just like to say, if you like this and you
- 55:10like five games for Doomsday, you can join the discord and tell me how
- 55:15wrong I am and I right Uli is by going to five gfd dot com,
- 55:17clicking on the pinpost and coming to the discord. And if you want
- 55:21to help support the show and help podcasts, get major at a pictureon dot
- 55:24com forward slash five g fo d and you can back there at five euros
- 55:30a month. You get access to loads of bonus content, which is quite
- 55:36the silliest thing you will have ever heard. And just to wrap up,
- 55:39then Uli one minute rundown. What can we get ath beer works right now?
- 55:45Yeah. For German companies, there are quite a few pre orders for
- 55:50a root from Leader Games to German editions. They should arrive the new products
- 55:53this fall. A few companies Packspamire again by Worley. It is on pre
- 56:00order, should also arrive in the fall. And then we have a few
- 56:06remaining copies of Weimar German edition. There is also a new edition English and
- 56:10German planned for this fall to arrive. We have a few elbows are still
- 56:16in stock and that's basically it. There is Sparta, there are a few
- 56:22o's, but yeah, check out the website please excellent. All right,
- 56:27well, so Ulie Blake, thank you very much. Yeah, it was
- 56:31my pleasure, Ben, and let's talk to you soon indeed, And that
- 56:37was this month should be a works bulletin, So thank you for listening and
- 56:43come back next month for another