Latest / Newcomer Pod / Dogfood Your Ideals (w/Ellen Huet)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome Sally. Alright everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to Dead cat Tom dote on here.
- 0:17And then I'm Eric newcomer author of newcomer.
- 0:21And with us we have Ellen, Hewitt, my old colleague at
- 0:25Bloomberg. You can see your former
- 0:27colleague at Bloomberg. I know I'm actually old I do.
- 0:30I mean old like she's not your. I'm just slightly older than you
- 0:33Eric, but not by that much. Oh, you are by like months.
- 0:37We used to sit next to each other at the Office.
- 0:39Doc, when people used to go to the office.
- 0:41Oh, that must've been a nightmare.
- 0:42It was, I mean, okay. You know what happened?
- 0:45I would be on the phone with like, you know, Source or
- 0:48talking to somebody Eric would get on the phone at the same
- 0:51time, having his own phone conversation and the person I
- 0:53would be talking to on the phone would be like.
- 0:55Did someone else just join our call?
- 0:57I hear a voice a character solo. That he would sound like someone
- 1:01who had dialed into our call rather, that's what I was
- 1:03sitting next to me. Yeah.
- 1:06Is this a secure line? It sounds like someone else is
- 1:08listening. You know, the other thing that
- 1:09would drive me crazy about that. I'm loudest when I'm getting the
- 1:12best information, like I'm loudest when I'm getting real
- 1:15Scoops. So all of a sudden, everybody
- 1:17started criticizing me, I'm like, I'm doing great work right
- 1:20now, you know? I mean it was fucking
- 1:21Bloomberg's, OpenOffice, but anyway, you know me not sitting
- 1:25next to Ellen, was certainly a path that led down to me,
- 1:28leaving, Bluebird. French Lee.
- 1:29It's Like, when you know, I left San Francisco, but then when she
- 1:32don't have to go to the office anymore, it's like, oh, why, why
- 1:35I should work for myself anyway? Yeah, we're Ellen is one of the
- 1:40foremost experts on. We work having written about it
- 1:43as a be reporter and then creating, I guess, you say host
- 1:49reporting and hosting a seven-part podcast about we were
- 1:53called foundering. So Bloomberg has a like
- 1:57award-winning, right? I have to some water.
- 2:00Winning podcast. Yeah.
- 2:02Bloomberg has a podcast series called Foundry where each season
- 2:06tells a different story. First one was that we work and
- 2:08I'm the host of down and second one, it's not like Tick-Tock and
- 2:10other stuff, it's really good and I highly recommend you check
- 2:13it out. I can vouch for that.
- 2:14I mean you're just saying it because you were on it but
- 2:16actually it is a very good podcast and with the Adam Newman
- 2:19story and specific you kind of delve into the early Adam Newman
- 2:22years which you know for those of us who are listening, who
- 2:26just watched the TV show or was another podcast, you kind of get
- 2:29you know, Young Adam Newman has its own story.
- 2:31You get all the kibbutz. Here's, yeah, we sent a reporter
- 2:33to Adam Newman's qubits, which was great and like, interviewed
- 2:37people who knew him and all this stuff.
- 2:39So that's really fun. It's the prequel.
- 2:41It's like before Newman was Newman and I think it's a
- 2:44valuable part of the story. Thanks Tom.
- 2:46All right, so and we're going to go back a little bit and explain
- 2:49some of the Adam Newman stuff but just to frame up why we're
- 2:52having the conversation right now you know Andreessen Horowitz
- 2:55has invested 350 million dollars and out of Newman's new company.
- 3:00Flow, which is some sort of real estate company.
- 3:02Marc Andreessen. Himself is taking the board
- 3:05seat. Adam Newman is back.
- 3:07We work. You know, is I checked earlier
- 3:09today like a 3.6 billion market cap company after 10 billion
- 3:14plus getting invest into that, we work is not what it once was.
- 3:17But Adam Newman is is back. And then related to that we've
- 3:21got sort of Marc Andreessen, you know, interested in solving our
- 3:25real estate problems, but also himself NIMBY an extreme NIMBY.
- 3:31Anyway, so that's the conversation and as background
- 3:35for what it's worth. I am also now an expert octus, a
- 3:37certain public housing debacle because I read literally every
- 3:41single page of that like 270 page document.
- 3:44So it's something you want to know about it, just ask great.
- 3:48Tom, what do you want to start off with here?
- 3:50I want to start off with Atherton.
- 3:52Let's let's take a trip down to 80 and check out our leafy,
- 3:56Peninsula suburb of the richest people in the Bay Area.
- 4:00It is I think literally the richest the richest city in an
- 4:04already. Overpriced over Stone.
- 4:07Oh, it's the richest city in America.
- 4:09I was Googling the names in this public comment.
- 4:11Listen, like every single, like it was rare for someone to not
- 4:14be like, have a Wikipedia page about how rich and influential,
- 4:18they are Bruce Dunleavy that we work board member from Benchmark
- 4:21apparent, right lives, right? It's just like the story.
- 4:24Even enters the all these stories intersect because
- 4:26obviously, Silicon Valley is a small world.
- 4:30The African experience before we get into the story, but just
- 4:32maybe the stage set a little bit for our audience is a lot of
- 4:35reporters. Go down to atherton's to meet
- 4:37with VC sources. It's pretty, it's pretty common
- 4:40that you take the trip down to 80 in Atherton.
- 4:43This is like the town where correct me if I'm wrong.
- 4:45Marissa Mayer used to host her crazy like Halloween parties and
- 4:50all the like like Google. ATMs would go there and she
- 4:54would have like an ice rink in the backyard and rented like a
- 4:57tiger and I'm making this up. So, you know, You're correct
- 5:00from the stories that I believe. She also drove his in bony
- 5:03around. The ice rink is like a famous
- 5:05story with Marissa Mayer when she was the CEO of Yahoo.
- 5:08Yeah, and then the other thing, I think of, in terms of
- 5:10extravagant executive parties, there is Joe.
- 5:14Lonsdale used to throw, this is the palantir co-founder and he
- 5:19used to throw like an annual party at his mansion that I
- 5:21think is also is that an Atherton?
- 5:23That was Joe. Lonsdale is now fully in that
- 5:27one. I don't know for sure but Yeah,
- 5:29but I'm sure he lives. Okay?
- 5:31He had a Game of Thrones chair. That was made for the weekly
- 5:35Game Room. Yes, I remember the king of the
- 5:38monsters. I've seen it.
- 5:39I've seen, I didn't dare sit in it, but yeah, it's a real thing.
- 5:43So, yeah, that's the kind of place we're talking about here.
- 5:45It's the, it's, it's comical. In terms of its concentration of
- 5:50what also, in terms of nimbyism, it has minimum sort of lot
- 5:53sizes. Yeah, it has it has a the town,
- 5:56the town like rule. You'll basically, is that you
- 6:00shall not have housing density, that's above one house per acre.
- 6:06So this is why people are so upset talking about enforcing
- 6:10wealthy, you know, minimum yeah, making sure everyone's wealthy.
- 6:13It's like it's expensive neighborhood and you need to be
- 6:15able to buy. You're saying an acre an acre of
- 6:17land. Yeah.
- 6:18So basically the general understanding of Atherton that
- 6:21has existed for decades is that this is a place where there are
- 6:24not that many people, it's also a small town but you know
- 6:26probably 10,000 people or fewer and You, you know, average house
- 6:31advertised price. I'm sure it's like, in many
- 6:33millions of dollars, I read an article that said it was seven
- 6:35or eight million that makes total sense to me, and you end
- 6:39up with these large properties, which means the houses are very
- 6:42far spaced apart. And so, a lot of people buy it
- 6:45if they're like rich and very interested in privacy and
- 6:50wanting to have cut it this like Suburban feel professionally
- 6:54their interest in destroying privacy, but personally, they're
- 6:56interested in yes, right? You know, first and it's not, it
- 7:01is a lot of technical. There are also a lot of like,
- 7:03you know, it's like the founder of KK our lives.
- 7:05There, there's a lot of like banking execs, Steph Curry and
- 7:09his family live in Atherton, like Joel a couple.
- 7:12I guess is both Tech and warriors Associated lives and
- 7:15lives in Atherton. And so part of why this is
- 7:17happening is on a policy lens. Gavin Newsom is and state of
- 7:22California are pushing cities to start actually building housing.
- 7:26And after this whole long yet Pro, Housing in be Crusade.
- 7:30Finally it seems like the state is starting to turn the screws
- 7:34to cities like San Francisco, Atherton to say, okay, you're
- 7:38gonna have to build and if you don't you have to sort of prove
- 7:42why your have to give us sort of good reason why you're not.
- 7:45And so everybody starts writing letters in Atherton.
- 7:49What are the letters that were also like why are rich people in
- 7:53Atherton taking their time to write in to give their public
- 7:57comment? What's funny is okay?
- 7:58So the you know the large-scale picture is basically.
- 8:01Yeah, there are there are multiple things happening at the
- 8:03state level that are requiring cities across the state to have
- 8:07to like proposed plans for how they're going to add a certain
- 8:10amount of housing, like the exact details.
- 8:12I think are kind of like depending on the region and the
- 8:15place and that kind of thing that Atherton is basically on
- 8:17the hook to build something like 350 ish new housing units in the
- 8:22next X years. I think it's like 10 or
- 8:25something like that it regardless of what the actual.
- 8:28Puzzles are they were also. So part of the like Town Council
- 8:33had proposed a change to the housing element, which is
- 8:37basically like their housing plan for the city which allowed
- 8:40overlay zones. So basically like exceptions to
- 8:43the town wide understanding of one house per acre.
- 8:46So these are places where all of a sudden, like you could have
- 8:49multi-family housing, which like I could be wrong.
- 8:52But as far as I know, does not exist in Atherton at all and
- 8:55multi-family housing, like was ringing.
- 8:57All sorts of alarm bells for these.
- 8:58'Well, it's unclear that there were actually necessarily going
- 9:01to be plans for these things to even be built.
- 9:03But they were upset at the changes in zoning that were
- 9:06being proposed. And look my understanding from
- 9:09reading the ladders is like, you know, people were alleging that
- 9:12the Town Council was not very clear that this was happening.
- 9:16They were very upset, you know, it seems like there's a very
- 9:19strong neighbor whisper Network in Atherton because they were
- 9:22all talking about, like, oh, we were at this meeting.
- 9:25We were at a zoom meeting where we all the neighbors discussed
- 9:27this and like I heard about it from my And I'm very upset.
- 9:29I love that the billionaires are also in like next door, like
- 9:34misinformation threads. Just sort of like cobbling
- 9:36together, what's happening? And sort of like totally can't
- 9:39take it like a briefer. Who like, I don't know.
- 9:41Goes to all the meetings and gives him like a really like in
- 9:43form download of what's going on me.
- 9:46My sense is that like some neighbors who were very
- 9:49motivated about this raised the alarm because if you read
- 9:51through the letters, you actually start to see a lot of
- 9:54the same form responses and in so many people sending in, it's
- 9:58like it's like Like you know we lightly change the phrasing of
- 10:00exactly the same phrase real. Like we believe that changes to
- 10:03the community like to the plan should be done only with like
- 10:06strong input from the community or whatever.
- 10:08And everyone has a slightly different for.
- 10:09It's like those Facebook viral posts where it's just like on
- 10:13March 13th. Facebook is going to publicly
- 10:15release. Yes.
- 10:16Your personal data. If you do not post this message
- 10:18saying Mark, please do not tell everybody when I was born and in
- 10:22what hospital and then you see, like three of your dumbest
- 10:24friends on Facebook. Posting it.
- 10:26This is like the billionaire Next Door version and then they
- 10:28get Elected to congress. But yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:31So that people, people were very upset about the proposals that
- 10:34came up with all sorts of reasons for why this wouldn't
- 10:36be, you know, a good idea, mean not living in a certain.
- 10:39I don't know how legitimate they are, but it's like, oh, it's,
- 10:41you know, to, there's too much traffic already on this tree.
- 10:43Like, well, there's a guy who's like, a former Nest Labs, exact
- 10:48Eric Charlton is his name, he says Atherton, as we know, it
- 10:50will be gone and only you have the power to stop that from
- 10:53happening. If you care about our city, be
- 10:55walking down the sidewalk and ask somebody about their pool.
- 10:58And they're like, actually, I don't have a pool and I have an
- 11:01upstairs neighbor ruin the character of.
- 11:04Yeah, there's a lot of like ruining the character and the
- 11:07character is not knowing that you have neighbors.
- 11:09I mean, that seems to be when you're dealing with one house
- 11:12per acre, you know, up in Fairly hilly areas, there was a letter,
- 11:15I believe from Anthony no, do, who is the CEO of?
- 11:18So Phi, former Twitter exec who was complaining about the crime
- 11:22rates that had just been skyrocketing?
- 11:24He says the crime has become so bad.
- 11:26Many families are employing private security.
- 11:28Including our family to be clear.
- 11:30We are writing this letter to communicate our objection to the
- 11:32creation of multifamily overlay zones in Atherton, so which have
- 11:36not even happened yet, right? So his wish Brian is
- 11:39skyrocketing in town. If you were to add multi-family
- 11:42housing, we're talking about a like, you know, warrior style
- 11:46situation where we're living on the streets.
- 12:02The funny thing about the Anthony Noto letter is it like
- 12:05feels very stream of Consciousness and like they kind
- 12:07of get riled up there. Like this is going to be bad for
- 12:09this reason and and this and this and then also we have a lot
- 12:12of crime, which like may or may not be true and then they kind
- 12:15of like rain themselves in and okay so you bring you bring this
- 12:17up. Do you mind if I cause I I'd
- 12:19spend ten seconds on this before we started recording to see what
- 12:22the crime stats were in Atherton, okay?
- 12:25So at certain violent crime per 1,000 residents is 2.0, 2009 in
- 12:32California. The rate is four point four.
- 12:35So it's half the crime rate, overall in California and it is
- 12:38below the national media so far. There have been.
- 12:43Yeah, I see. I don't have the trend so it
- 12:44could be slightly. Ticked up there.
- 12:46Have been zero murders this year.
- 12:49There have been three rapes there have been two robberies
- 12:52and there have been 10 assaults. So what I don't know what the
- 12:56veteran a certain would be a good mystery novel.
- 12:58Yeah. Like immediately the scene is
- 13:00set, right? And I don't know if it's like an
- 13:03African cop that had to do something for the first time in
- 13:05his life, having assaulted or you got to get like caught from
- 13:08the big city to come down among these rich people.
- 13:10And listen, we're not advocating for murder, but if you did
- 13:14murder someone, we would have a good book on our hands.
- 13:17Yeah, it would be a good story. The other good recurring tidbit
- 13:20from these letters is rich, people suggesting that their
- 13:24pool houses could be counted as additional housing units for the
- 13:28steamer and this is multiple people.
- 13:31This is like a guy named dick elkes who was like a former like
- 13:35see of a bunch of companies and then Bruce Dunleavy.
- 13:37And his wife say this, as well, they're like by the way, have we
- 13:40considered have we considered counting pool house has?
- 13:43I would say shows up in several suitors, sometimes we work our
- 13:47staff to exhaustion and Sleep in the pool house overnight.
- 13:51So I think it should count. Funny thing is like, do they
- 13:53actually want to rent out their pool house to someone?
- 13:57I don't think they want to so like I think this isn't going to
- 13:59count and there are other I think there are other like, more
- 14:02in the weeds reasons to like, push back against those.
- 14:05Like it wouldn't necessarily, I think create a ton of affordable
- 14:08housing because like even the townhouses in Atherton are going
- 14:10to be super expensive. But I am no housing policy
- 14:13experts have that can we? I don't know if you're willing
- 14:16to take a position on the substance or not or what your
- 14:19Neutral reporter Scruples are on this but I guess there are two
- 14:23competing intuitions like on the one hand.
- 14:26You know, what's the point of being rich?
- 14:28You want, you want to be rich to live in like a nice neighborhood
- 14:31and like you shopped for the nice neighborhood and like, like
- 14:34should there never be like I don't like I guess that's
- 14:38certainly not what I have. I mean the the sort of hypocrisy
- 14:41of course is just that like these are all like extreme
- 14:45capitalist. And here they are trying to use
- 14:46like government protectionism to like, Stop the market from, you
- 14:51know, like building where it's desirable I think the hypocrisy
- 14:56is like strongest with Andreessen right.
- 14:59Someone who has staked his entire like public brand on
- 15:03being like America doesn't build enough anymore.
- 15:06And I'm going to write a big essay about how people should
- 15:08build and it's gonna be a little vague.
- 15:09Don't worry about it, but I am going to specific.
- 15:11Talk to me. How we don't how we don't build
- 15:13enough housing and like this is a problem and like housing is
- 15:15such a, you know, how is it that like we, you know?
- 15:19No, can no longer. Like, figure out how to, like,
- 15:22get the economic realities lined up so that we can like build
- 15:25enough. Housing was like, Well, turns
- 15:26out people like you are a part of the problem.
- 15:29I'm not saying he's the only problem obviously, but like that
- 15:33sort of Rouse me up a bit. But I would say, you know, I
- 15:37think with the other people it's like a little bit harder, you
- 15:39know, it's a little bit more of a stretch.
- 15:40It's like, okay. Well in general I think tech
- 15:42companies do try to Champion like you know.
- 15:45Okay. The the idea that there's Thing
- 15:49is way too expensive in California means that we should
- 15:51build more of. This is like, how the markets
- 15:52work and I think that like, in Aaron Griffis piece in the times
- 15:56points out that, like, these companies at large have
- 15:59supported housing forward policy.
- 16:01And this is Aaron. Griffith is the guest has
- 16:03appeared on this show, I think, the most times, right?
- 16:06So she's basically writing on behalf of dead cat, you know,
- 16:09amazing, I mean, don't I mean, I'm secondary employment to her
- 16:12her dead cat appearance. I'm a huge Aaron fan.
- 16:15What can I say? And, yeah, she came out with a
- 16:18great piece and I think, She pointed out like yeah the
- 16:20companies that these these execs work for like have also taken
- 16:23stances in favor of building more housing will like turns
- 16:26out. Yeah.
- 16:26When you build more housing people who live right next to it
- 16:29do get kind of annoyed but like that's that's just like the
- 16:32trade-off you had on the whole NIMBY thing like the right?
- 16:34Yeah. That's why it's not in my
- 16:36backyard. Everybody is for building in
- 16:39some abstract. It's like sure.
- 16:40Yeah. I get these peoples around
- 16:42somewhere. It's like the whole point of the
- 16:44Indie movement is you have to be willing to say, yes, right here,
- 16:47where we are, where we have? Coal Power, we're willing to
- 16:50make it happen. So there's nothing novel about
- 16:53being like, Oh yeah, I like building generally.
- 16:55I just don't like it when an inconvenience is me like duh,
- 16:57everybody would subscribe to that.
- 16:59Like, when so many people, I feel now know the concept of
- 17:04being an MD and understand the like sort of the negative
- 17:08effects overall, to like our society that comes with
- 17:11nimbyism, it's a little sad that like, even in that position,
- 17:15these people are still exerting like classic nimbyism, right
- 17:18there. Just like oh, Oh my God, it
- 17:19could not like it is in fact unfathomable that this would
- 17:22happen in Atherton. Dear God, like please let it
- 17:26happen somewhere else, right? And we sort of already made this
- 17:29point, I think it's worth emphasizing a multi-family
- 17:31housing unit or few in Atherton, his who can do ship to fix the
- 17:36housing crisis across California.
- 17:38These are you know this is housing that will probably be a
- 17:40million dollars for the low-end lowest lowest end unit.
- 17:44So really what this is just is a hilarious display of nimbyism
- 17:48and You know, at the most outsized and comical level what
- 17:52is going on in areas, where it actually would be meaningful.
- 17:56But is being prevented by people who do not want to have any sort
- 17:59of housing affect their way of life, because people in
- 18:01California, and in the Bay Area, specifically, cling so hard to
- 18:05their land and like, their perceived status and privacy or
- 18:09whatever that they're refusing to allow developers to do
- 18:12anything. And at, you know, look, I think
- 18:14there's some complications and I don't know, we can talk about
- 18:17this at a different episode here, but like, Like the Indie
- 18:19movement is also very tied up in with, you know what developers
- 18:22want to do doesn't always allow for, you know, public housing in
- 18:26the kind of low cost that would actually affect the rates of
- 18:30people that don't have a lot of money to find places to live,
- 18:33but we can find that one, Tom's, Tom thinks he's the leftist on
- 18:36this podcast with and I'm like, I listen, I'm back.
- 18:38I'm like, you don't, you don't sound that leftist on this
- 18:41podcast. But now he's now.
- 18:43But I'm saying that client, that comment was one of the first
- 18:45rose. I go.
- 18:45Now he's trying to get some, some real left is Imani.
- 18:49Yeah, I'm on the anti um be mean train my God, that we could have
- 18:53a little fight about that. Anyway I'm gonna not and not get
- 18:56drawn into that. I mean let we've talked around
- 18:59Marc Andreessen. I mean Marc Andreessen is wife
- 19:02like her family is like a major California real estate
- 19:05developer, right? Like he's like yeah and this
- 19:08isn't just some like they should know better, right?
- 19:10They know this whole thing, I can give a tiny bit of
- 19:14background which is I was a student at Stanford and so Laura
- 19:19Laura was Mark intrusions wife Laura Arriaga Andreessen and
- 19:22anyone who recognizes the name, Arriaga knows that like, yeah,
- 19:25John Arriaga was just like, you know, now this is embarrassing.
- 19:29I don't actually know what he did to gain his fortune, but he
- 19:32definitely is. His name is on like half of the
- 19:36buildings at Stanford or has like it's like the Arriaga
- 19:40dining. Commons, do you like Arriaga gym
- 19:43like that? There's like three others and
- 19:45then there's a bunch more that he also paid for, but like,
- 19:47didn't want his name on, for some And this was like spending
- 19:51a lot of time. Yeah, I remember trying to dig
- 19:55into this, when I was like a student reporter at Stanford,
- 19:57obviously didn't end up getting that far.
- 19:59But yeah, he's a, you know, the the hospital like if you go to
- 20:02the emergency room which like one time, my roommate fell while
- 20:06like and I had to drive her to the ER and we're sitting there
- 20:08and it's like Laura Arriaga Andreessen emergency rooms and
- 20:11you just see the name. See, that's real reporting.
- 20:13It's like I learned this in the emergency room.
- 20:17Yeah. All you got out your little
- 20:18know. Notebook.
- 20:19You started. You haven't seen ya Mars
- 20:21someday, anyway. Then you think your friends are
- 20:24getting and you're like, that's, that's good.
- 20:26Did you get too close to the truth at some point?
- 20:28Did you like get called into like the Arriaga conference room
- 20:31fold? Like you got the bed baby speech
- 20:33from Network? Without like I remember like
- 20:35there was like we thought that he was funding the like
- 20:39Renovations of some of the like row houses that are like things
- 20:43like dorms and be like, I don't know if we ever actually staked
- 20:47it out, but I think we like wanted to stake it out.
- 20:49To like, talk to the construction crew because we
- 20:52were convinced there was some sort of like, Kickback scheme.
- 20:54I don't know. It didn't it didn't get off the
- 20:55ground but basically he's, you know, he's a huge name.
- 20:57Tons of money and very much like especially in the in the sort of
- 21:02Greater Bay Area announced tons of land tons of land.
- 21:05Yes. And I think, I don't know what
- 21:06you're getting at, but I guess it's just like the, the
- 21:08privileged of the privileged. Yeah.
- 21:10And they should know. Like, I feel like, one of the
- 21:12biggest issues with California is the tax policy that if you
- 21:16early landowner, you get taxed in that tax rate.
- 21:19Like this is a family that deeply understands housing and
- 21:23real estate in California and is in a blur of the status quote.
- 21:27So it is, yeah. It is just like, it's not like,
- 21:31oh yeah, they're like some generically rich person who's,
- 21:34like, trying to protect their house.
- 21:36It's also like they have perhaps like the greatest one, some of
- 21:40the greatest reach in California, real estate and
- 21:42power of anybody. You know what I mean?
- 21:45Like, yeah. So, so then they The and
- 21:49riesen's together and we don't really know if it's a more Mark,
- 21:52or Laura thing. Right?
- 21:53I feel like that's sort of gotten everybody's talking about
- 21:55him but they wrote it together, right?
- 21:57Yeah, they wrote it together. I mean, many of the letters.
- 22:00I will say those having read those letters.
- 22:01Many of the letters are written and signed by both in general I
- 22:06would say all the couples ended up being a man and a woman but
- 22:08like yeah. Both the husband and the wife of
- 22:10this of this couple look, you could read you could try to do a
- 22:13little bit of interpretation by looking at whose name was
- 22:17written first. But certainly I wouldn't like
- 22:20assume, you know, based on the order of the names and the
- 22:23signature who actually like shirt the letter.
- 22:25If it was one or two and they had great all caps, right?
- 22:28The other was in all caps, we are immensely.
- 22:30Opposed to this thing. I'm, there is also someone who
- 22:33was dying. I got it.
- 22:35I've read enough tweets a Twitter poster.
- 22:38Yeah, I feel confident in saying he was like, no, no, no, honey.
- 22:42I like that one all caps. Yeah, yeah.
- 22:45And there's a yeah, there's someone else who had like a
- 22:47really funny Some of some of the letters are clearly like, you
- 22:52know, Miss punctuated. A lot of all caps, like, Angry
- 22:55Angry residents, like deciding to really make their emotions
- 22:59known. I mean, the best part of parks
- 23:01and rec was always when they did sort of the Town, sort of Talons
- 23:05people coming in and giving their feedback and it was always
- 23:07insane. I feel like, oh my God.
- 23:09So this could just be a show where it's just, you know, the
- 23:12wealthy people trying to engage with like, you know, just the
- 23:15people like they're done with their job.
- 23:17They retired and they just need like Like meaning.
- 23:19So they're fighting with like they're super anyway or it's a
- 23:22co-op board or so you know all those things that's endlessly.
- 23:25Anyway. Okay.
- 23:26So can we talk about flow now? I did you have having missed
- 23:30anything on this piece of it? No I'm good.
- 23:32I guess what? Before we before we go up the
- 23:34flow I guess the last thing I want to say on this topic that I
- 23:36find so fitting and hilarious is that Tech is also trying to
- 23:41figure out solutions to the housing crisis through their
- 23:44companies. Right there are a lot of venture
- 23:47back real estate companies actually this does Leaving the
- 23:49flow who think that, like, you know, where is they do
- 23:53recognize. There's a problem, there are
- 23:54some who are nominally in bees there ones who will give a lot
- 23:57to give me movements and causes. And they also think that their
- 24:00technology can somehow solve this, right that there's some
- 24:03way in which you can apply. Whether it's, I don't know,
- 24:05algorithms or some version of Co-op living to fix the housing
- 24:08problem. And yet, when it comes to their
- 24:11particular area, it doesn't seem that they're willing to if
- 24:13they're not going to dog food it right?
- 24:15They're not going to be using their own products in order to
- 24:17fix this larger issue. My perfect word for this.
- 24:20Yeah, that's exactly the whole Tech.
- 24:22Philosophy is dog, food your product do the thing that you're
- 24:27suffer through your terrible tech product, you're trying to
- 24:29force on the world and they won't even dog food the world
- 24:33that they want, which is a dense urban life that is.
- 24:37That's a great distillation of the.
- 24:39Yeah, I think exactly. And I think like, if what
- 24:42they're promising is actually going to be great if they are
- 24:45creating a new future that is very livable and is something
- 24:49They are promising as, you know give us your money, you know,
- 24:52investors and you as users. Take part in it, you should be
- 24:56all about that sort of thing. And it seems like either the
- 24:59tech companies that they're building, aren't that useful and
- 25:02aren't actually going to do any of this or they just never
- 25:04believed it in the first place. I have my thoughts on which that
- 25:08is specifically but anyway so that leads into flow and our
- 25:11good friend, Adam Newman, who is cycling.
- 25:13If you're going to support we work you need to stay in an open
- 25:16Office every hour of the day instead of your Or you know yeah
- 25:20it's like hardwood table. You need a drink fucking water
- 25:23out of the cold makeup. That's always half full time.
- 25:28It's always because it says so on the cup.
- 25:31Yeah. Does it even I actually can?
- 25:33I don't read these things. It does it does.
- 25:35Oh, that's okay. What are you guys referencing?
- 25:37Which is a metal, as you go to a, we work the cups that you can
- 25:41like get to like get your sparkling water from the top or
- 25:43your whenever they're metal and they say always have full.
- 25:47At least they did a couple years ago.
- 25:49I don't know if possible if they've changed but they I think
- 25:51actually, you know, after all the turmoil, we work, they had
- 25:53to legally remove them, it wasn't accurate advertising.
- 25:57I haven't noticed that coffee mugs, used to say, do what you
- 25:59love? I didn't like I gotta say, I
- 26:01kind of miss the era of like we worked aggressive branding.
- 26:06You can't see Ellen's apartment right now but she has life is
- 26:09good merchandise, all over the place.
- 26:11She just she has just like hang in there cat posters on her wall
- 26:15everywhere. It's just Soul, just like Bland
- 26:18affirmation. It's just paint covering every
- 26:21inch of things. I'm beyond live laugh.
- 26:23Love. I like the plastic.
- 26:25I know I'm actually with you because I do work, occasionally
- 26:28out of a, we work inside her, you know, Lisa's one in downtown
- 26:32SF. And I also used to go to a, we
- 26:34work occasionally when I was at the information they have one in
- 26:38New York. And yeah.
- 26:40The, the before, and after are, they are of Plenty and they are
- 26:43of now is Stark and I mean, let's take away, you know, the
- 26:47beer on tap and the kombucha. And the flavored water.
- 26:51There's just less kind of camaraderie.
- 26:52The kind of bullshit that I do moon was really grafting on when
- 26:56he was making, these companies is long gone, but they did keep
- 26:58the metal cups, which if you eat a frigid, I like, I feel like my
- 27:04hand will like, to use to them at times.
- 27:06But but anyway, so that is the Adam Newman fantasy.
- 27:09He is working his hardest to solve our office issues and now
- 27:12our domestic housing issues. So, why don't you explain to
- 27:15poor? We get into 3 since and And what
- 27:19Eric believes is the back story as to why injuries and Horowitz
- 27:23is making the largest investment ever in to Adam, Newman's come
- 27:26back. Can you tell us about flow?
- 27:28What is flow? Yeah, so there's some fun stuff
- 27:31going on here, which is to backup, even farther.
- 27:34Adam Newman. Apparently, his new.
- 27:36Favorite word is Flo, I'm not kidding.
- 27:37This is like in an FDA article from like, six months ago.
- 27:41And that has led to two different Ventures.
- 27:43One of them is called flow carbon which as far as I
- 27:46understand, he is a co-founder of, but has no real.
- 27:49Operational like day today in and probably put money into, but
- 27:51I think maybe he like had the idea and then got other people
- 27:54to start building it flow carbon is a something related to like
- 27:59using the blockchain to track carbon credits.
- 28:01So imagine it has to do with sort of like renewable energy
- 28:04accounting and crypto and then he decided to have this other
- 28:08cop. So and then four months, there
- 28:10had been stories about like, oh, Adam Newman is doing like a
- 28:12residential real estate play. So like we kind of knew that
- 28:14this was coming. He there were, you know, people
- 28:17who cover like commercial real estate.
- 28:18Had tracked places where he had entities that had bought like
- 28:24residential towers and a lot of them like in Florida, Atlanta
- 28:28and like other parts of kind of the US.
- 28:32And so we knew that he was like interested in residential real
- 28:34plant like real estate what we found out with this announcement
- 28:38is that this other companies also called flow which is just
- 28:41hilarious to me. So we have low carbon and we
- 28:43have flow there. Two different ones.
- 28:45This is I guess, flow trademark, you know, there are okay.
- 28:48And the funny thing is With the flow carbon.
- 28:50They have a token called, like, I'm going to get it wrong.
- 28:53It's like goddess Earth or something like that.
- 28:57Like there's, they have a very funny name for the token by
- 29:00Rebecca. Nice to see your contribution
- 29:02again. My hat tip to Rebecca for a
- 29:04reasserting, her brand genius. Well, sure her brand.
- 29:08These days is student of life for life, and if you've heard
- 29:11about Soulful, that's how you say, the acronym, Sol SL student
- 29:16of Life, For Life soulful. They still together.
- 29:20Of course, they're together. Do you not believe in love?
- 29:22I say I mean I think so they actually had another that
- 29:24another kid recently. Not, I have sex.
- 29:27I'm not 100% sure about that. I'm pretty sure they have six
- 29:30kids. All right, anonymous tips.
- 29:31Are raising questions about this relationship to me?
- 29:34But whatever. Yeah, we're definitely keeping
- 29:36that in. Yeah.
- 29:38Oh well, we had the background you know we work obviously Adam.
- 29:42Yeah. So the name to the company which
- 29:44is one of his many scandals. So that's that's yeah.
- 29:46That's what we had trademark out without gluing.
- 29:49Into for the last five minutes tired.
- 29:50So now you're in on the joke. Okay.
- 29:52Yeah, that's who knows? Who knows about the trademark
- 29:54for flaw look into it. The yacht.
- 29:57So it's a little unclear now and then so yeah.
- 29:59Flow as the residential real estate play.
- 30:03Now we know has raised money from injuries and a lot of
- 30:05money. People are still sort of up
- 30:07there about what exactly it does and the terms of it are.
- 30:09So it's 250 million but like Adams bringing some out any
- 30:12items bringing some real estate, we don't want the protections.
- 30:15They don't expressly say it's not dead like so there.
- 30:19And I want to point out, so we all went crazy on this.
- 30:22The New York Times story said, biggest single, check, ever from
- 30:25Andreas and 350 million and reason, definitely wanted to
- 30:29blast us out to the world. I mean, this was in the New York
- 30:31Times, they wrote a bar up blog post Marc Andreessen on the
- 30:34board. They could have done tons of
- 30:36stuff to caveat it. They could have been like, sure
- 30:38it's a billion but you know, think about our ownership, you
- 30:41know, they're they almost like oversold, how ridiculous of a
- 30:44deal. This was in ways where you start
- 30:46to ask questions, you're like, well, what did they At four.
- 30:50Anyway, I just I just want to flag that but it's still
- 30:53optically and withdrew and fifty million in some form.
- 30:56They went all-in again on Adam Newman.
- 30:58A person that many people, you know, would never invest in
- 31:02again, in their life and some yeah.
- 31:04Well, and what's funny is Adam, doing residential real estate is
- 31:09not new. So, we work for those who
- 31:10haven't been, like, totally in the weeds in it, they had a
- 31:13venture called we lived for several years, which had two
- 31:15locations, one of them in New York, on Wall Street and the
- 31:19other one in DC and they were basically, like, communal living
- 31:25sort of adult dorms would, maybe be like an uncharitable way to
- 31:28describe them. I stayed in one for a story and
- 31:30I'm kind of the like communal living X4.
- 31:32Like I lived in a cop for five years in San Francisco.
- 31:34It's like uh, it's a, it's a, it's an intentional community
- 31:38area. Thank you very much where we
- 31:41share resources such as our grocery shopping and share
- 31:45communal space. My people still call them Cuba
- 31:47seen. By the way, Yeah, well, Ellen is
- 31:50writing a book on an alleged cult.
- 31:51By the way, about one tastes. So we're teasing.
- 31:54All the Bloomberg books. Mark, Bergen is going to come on
- 31:57soon. So, I anyway.
- 31:59Nice. Well marks.
- 32:00Marks book is actually coming out soon - now maybe not going
- 32:03to come out until 2024, but in two years, keep an eye out for
- 32:07you to build anticipation, you know, keep an eye out for my
- 32:09book about the alleged sex. Yeah, by the way, I was going to
- 32:12say between yours and Mark will see, which one is sexier Marxist
- 32:16longer righteous very long. I'm trying to make Nice work
- 32:19that's actually in the book like I'm running some pieces about it
- 32:25for Insider because I'm now covering YouTube so I hope it's
- 32:27not too long before you're like it's really weird.
- 32:30You have it ready yet? No.
- 32:31We I don't have it. You have it.
- 32:32No, I don't. It was supposed to be in the
- 32:33mail. I had to get one from like the
- 32:35Pirate Bay. Have a digital copy.
- 32:37Do you really will? Keep that in?
- 32:40But like kind of sort of? Anyway, the funny thing is that
- 32:43like we live was a flop, staying there, it was like the people
- 32:46who stay there, like didn't give a shit about like, Community.
- 32:49They just wanted like a cheap apartment that came furnished
- 32:51and it was like they were happy hours but it was just kind of
- 32:54like, I don't know, you know, I think there are some people
- 32:56really liked it but it didn't take off it, you know, at some
- 32:58point we work had projected happy.
- 33:00I was like there were snacks in the lunchroom kind of thing,
- 33:02right? Like it was no, they did have
- 33:04like it's like they had a bar on like the 13th floor of the
- 33:07building and like it, you know, you could send out a message on
- 33:10the app being like we got chicken wings and like
- 33:12margaritas, like come by, and people would come by and like
- 33:15chitchat. And I was nice and there was a
- 33:16hot tub on the roof and they would Have parties at the hot
- 33:19tub on the roof and it was very like kind of like, you know,
- 33:22Millennial dream dream scene of like, oh, life in the city.
- 33:27Regardless of what the subjective experience of living
- 33:30at we live. Was it was objectively, much
- 33:33smaller than Adam had ever predicted like they used to give
- 33:36these presentations about how big we live was going to be an
- 33:39it like never progressed past these two locations, and they
- 33:42ended up getting rid of them, selling them off to like other
- 33:45coding. This is a company that spent,
- 33:47what 10? Plus just like through endless
- 33:51amounts of money and they look like they had is much money in
- 33:53the world to make this thing work.
- 33:54I mean, yeah. I mean I think at some point it
- 33:57stopped being a priority for them so but you know of course
- 33:59it ties very well into atoms like lifelong, you know,
- 34:05explorations of community by liking, you can draw this thing
- 34:08where it's like, okay lived at the kibbutz when he was a teen
- 34:10and like he was very interested in like building community at
- 34:13the office and now baby. That's what he'll do is low,
- 34:16like maybe holders and he is good at it.
- 34:18It's funny with Tom was saying earlier where it was shitting
- 34:21on. We work having lost a sense of
- 34:22community. It's like funny, how could
- 34:24losing Adam Newman, I get that money makes Community possible.
- 34:28You have free food and people come around it, but it is sort
- 34:31of funny that like it did feel like atoms like Essence was able
- 34:35to sort of trickle down in some ways, to the actual we work
- 34:39experience. Yeah.
- 34:41Look if I may for a minute it's like having spent a lot of time
- 34:44talking to people who worked really closely with Adam.
- 34:46I've spent time with Adam, like we made this whole podcast about
- 34:48Kind of analyzing like his effects on this company.
- 34:51It's like he is like really just an exciting person to be around
- 34:57and I think people underestimate how important that is like
- 34:59people would meet him and they would just like have fun and
- 35:02like feel inspired and feel this Vision.
- 35:04He has he's like crazy ideas and he's so convinced that they're
- 35:07going to happen and people have told me that that's like his
- 35:10greatest gift is kids. This crazy idea.
- 35:12People are kind of like what and then he just convinces you like
- 35:15oh it's going to work and then it does and then you feel
- 35:17amazing. You feel like you were part.
- 35:18Part of this, like kind of ability to move Beyond like the
- 35:23limitations that you thought existed in your life and he's I
- 35:27don't know, he's just like I think I think I certainly would
- 35:31not underestimate the sort of qualitative excitement that he
- 35:36bring, he would be a good alleged cult leader, you know,
- 35:40he would be an amazing lesson. He Fashions himself in that way.
- 35:44That's what the flowy shirts and bare feet are all about.
- 35:47I'm not joking, right? It's all part of the central
- 35:49appeal, that him. And I mean, the criticism with
- 35:52we work and L, and I know you probably have a lot of thoughts
- 35:55here, is that there wasn't anything all that Innovative
- 35:57about the communal work office idea?
- 36:00There were other co-working spaces publicly traded
- 36:03companies, that offered short term, limited rental space in
- 36:07large, apartment buildings and, you know, we work as a, maybe
- 36:11more branded version of it. And there may have been some
- 36:13kind of clever real estate tricks about, like, upgrading or
- 36:16upzoning a building, you know? Because it had the, we were
- 36:19brand name on, it was therefore more valuable, there are some
- 36:22smart stuff there, they had raised so much money, they had
- 36:24to spend this money and suddenly, it became not just
- 36:28like, you know, a nice branding on an existing idea of
- 36:31co-working spaces. But this all-encompassing
- 36:34communal idea that, you know, people were trying to argue was
- 36:38a, what was it 50 billion dollar company or some 4747 top?
- 36:43Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 36:44I mean and I think like look probably in the like just some
- 36:48of the things that Is that they made a rodent trust and like
- 36:50were you know? But and in the company grew to
- 36:52this like enormous is and because they were able to make
- 36:55this very effective height machine and then there were some
- 36:59mistakes that they made along the way that I think like kind
- 37:00of undercut, a lot of that in the new tumbled that because
- 37:03they're able to convince Massa, like, I really like.
- 37:05Yeah. Looks like right Adams still
- 37:07good at that and I think he's done it again, right?
- 37:10Convince a I mean Andreessen is very similar to soft baked.
- 37:14I mean, they're both like have more money than their like
- 37:16competitors. Need to deploy a A lot of it
- 37:19consider themselves, like, idea, driven sort of geniuses.
- 37:23And so, yeah, Flo I know, we sort of said, you know, we don't
- 37:27know a lot about it. We've obviously said it has to
- 37:29do with residential but I don't know what's what do we know
- 37:34about it or it has to do with apartments, right?
- 37:36Yeah, I mean, it seems like they've bought apartment space
- 37:39as well as some retail space. And I, you know, there's there
- 37:44was a story that says that they also are going to offer like
- 37:46basically a crypto wall So my guess is that there's a crypto
- 37:51elements, I don't know exactly what and then there are also in
- 37:55the injuries and posted kind of hint at like, oh, you know, like
- 38:00this way renters can like get ownership of some kind or maybe
- 38:04it wasn't quite that broad, right?
- 38:05That's what I don't understand it, addresses ownership, but
- 38:08it's renter thing that we that's the big leap.
- 38:11We don't has a closer look. I think.
- 38:14Well, first of all, there's some funny things in that blog post
- 38:16in which Marc Andreessen basically like, It's on renters
- 38:19and he's like renters don't care about anything.
- 38:20Renters never have Community with the place they live.
- 38:22Which is like, I think a very that's like exactly what
- 38:25homeowners think. I don't know.
- 38:26I found that a little princess but and I'm like, when I would
- 38:29love to know, Marc Andreessen is ability to do these huge things.
- 38:32We're all talking about him, and he doesn't answer like
- 38:35fundamental questions. Anybody would have if you
- 38:37announced it like, Mark, please answer these questions, when is
- 38:40the last time you ever lived in apartment ever?
- 38:43You know what I mean? Like, what I just feel like
- 38:46that's relevant. Obviously, the other thing that
- 38:48That I'm really thinking about is, please reconcile your
- 38:52nimbyism and Atherton with your it's time to build.
- 38:55Like, how do you put out? He literally, I think the first
- 38:57line of it was like, it's time to build, like, he puts out this
- 39:00post. It's clearly in line with
- 39:02building any. He he's so Shameless that he
- 39:06feels no need to answer. Like, all the public stuff about
- 39:10Atherton, like he can just pretend they say nothing about
- 39:13it. It's galling to me like it in
- 39:16some ways. The media just is like call.
- 39:18Palpable here in that. We're so willing to just move on
- 39:21to the next headline and it just like, okay, he doesn't even, he
- 39:25does want to talk about it. We're still willing to get super
- 39:27excited about his new thing because it's such a good story
- 39:29line. And I do find, I mean, the media
- 39:31is powerless these days. We have were just we take the
- 39:34stories as they come. There's no control and he never
- 39:38has to face any questions that he doesn't want to.
- 39:40And by the way, we will link to eretz article about this topic
- 39:43in the show, description of this episode.
- 39:45So we can see that the media is complicit all around here.
- 39:49I'm complicit or what do you say?
- 39:51Yeah, you wrote the article. Oh, but yours was about Wyatt.
- 39:54Yeah. But I and I talked about the
- 39:56Atherton and like I'm talking I'm critical like to some degree
- 40:01and it with maybe he's going to be calling Elizabeth Holmes.
- 40:03Next. I mean it was partially just
- 40:05yeah. We're all riding the narrative
- 40:06wave sure if yeah. It would do.
- 40:08I follow the news like everyone? Yes.
- 40:10Yeah I think real estate is a fascinating topic for Venture
- 40:14Capital because the idea that there can really be innovation.
- 40:18In real estate, which is the core.
- 40:21I mean, that is the foundational element of tech and a venture
- 40:24capital is that these things maybe exist, some of it doesn't,
- 40:27but if we just put the right minds and enough Venture Capital
- 40:30dollars towards it can transform it and there is nothing to be
- 40:34transformed with real estate. You can it's just branding at
- 40:37the end of the day, right? We can just take an area, put a
- 40:40different name on it, slap a new coat of paint and suddenly,
- 40:42we've decided it has more value. And yet you see Venture Capital
- 40:46over and over again, trying to Do something in a space because
- 40:50it's there. If so in, you know, the tan is
- 40:52enormous. And so we don't really know a
- 40:54ton about this one here. This idea of like what rent rent
- 40:58to own or like ownership in Vault renting, that just kind of
- 41:01sounds like a mortgage at a certain level?
- 41:03Maybe with as much as I think not as much credit checking.
- 41:06I mean it's always funny to I were you just going to rent and
- 41:09you own a coin or something you know you got my work here.
- 41:13Just like you can speculate alongside your rental and like
- 41:16lose all your wealth through the coin.
- 41:18Into or what. Anyway, right, you have no
- 41:20ownership but there's some sort of like liquid Market that's
- 41:23it's like on top of it which you can maybe trade up some value
- 41:26but also lose a huge amount in the process.
- 41:28Brilliant brilliant. But yeah I think it's it's it's
- 41:32so funny to watch because every time they go into real estate it
- 41:36does reveal what I think, one of the weaknesses of tech and
- 41:39venture capitalist which is they end up just back in themselves
- 41:41into already existing products. And and so like that was kind of
- 41:45the case of we work they sort of just did co-working spaces and
- 41:48then this Of thing. I guess we don't really know
- 41:50enough yet to cast judgment, but it sounds to me, it's just going
- 41:52to end up being some version of like communal communal living
- 41:56with like a rental ownership and then maybe like a dowel wrapper
- 41:59on it or some sort of like crypto.
- 42:01Yeah. My best guess.
- 42:02Is it's going to be like, in the same sense that, like, we people
- 42:05think that we work was co-working, but it's actually
- 42:08more like offices alongside each other with shirt amenities.
- 42:11You're not usually like unless you're kind of like the
- 42:13freelancer and, and steadily over the years, the percentage
- 42:17of we Works customer Base. That was like small business
- 42:20Freelancers. Entrepreneur type single units
- 42:23looking for like, community in their office has gotten, has
- 42:26gotten smaller, and it has become more and more like large
- 42:30companies, you know, insiders are classic example, right?
- 42:33Like you know, established company is being like, well, we
- 42:35need an office in San Francisco, like I guess we'll get some we
- 42:38work space and so then like presumably you have like your
- 42:42own little office corner where it's like you and your
- 42:45colleagues and you just happen to like share an elevator with
- 42:48other Like maybe when you get the coffee, you like walk next
- 42:51to Someone Like You don't really know and I think if I were to
- 42:55guess, this is complete speculation but that like, you
- 42:58know, maybe the apartment buildings are going to be a
- 43:00little bit more like that because, like, existing real
- 43:02estate as it is, is not that amenable to like, actual shared
- 43:07communal living. It is still like individual
- 43:09units, for everyone has their own kitchen.
- 43:11Everyone has their own stuff and then maybe you share a like,
- 43:13share it amenities like the gym, or the lobby, or things like
- 43:16that. Yeah, I always hate those
- 43:18shares. Amenity buildings.
- 43:19I mean, I live in old style buildings but yeah, you could
- 43:22see why two people who that's appealing.
- 43:25You could say, well what if we cut out the kitchen, you shared
- 43:27a kitchen, you saved even more. Anyway now we're just speculate
- 43:30but I mean there there is you know sometimes these things need
- 43:35to get shaken up and if you can put like a good brand sheen on
- 43:37it, it's an opportunity I mean isn't Mark Laurie.
- 43:40Trying to reinvent the city or do you give up on that already
- 43:43and now he's isn't he doing delivering?
- 43:45He's doing food trucks. I believe that's his mother
- 43:47wasn't he? The one In a building new city,
- 43:49Reinventing the city comes up a lot.
- 43:51I mean, Google had sidewalk Labs that there's there's always
- 43:53attempts to try to do that and isn't there that Saudi Arabian
- 43:56like numeracy on neom go? Well the Saudi Arabia thing is
- 44:01interesting because that really ties into your post I believe
- 44:05about what exactly is Mark injuries and trying to do here
- 44:09and why did he make the investment that he did or why
- 44:12did the firm egg divestment? Yeah, it's all about your troll
- 44:14Theory. Eric, I want to hear more about
- 44:15that. First of all, I think he did it
- 44:18and this This is not the answer. You guys want to hear because he
- 44:21believes in American, dynamism he has a ton of money.
- 44:23He wants to use capitalism to try and reform this market.
- 44:27Like I what I'm saying with the trolling piece is that I think
- 44:31Marc Andreessen Andreessen, Horowitz are perfectly happy to
- 44:34drive everyone, crazy and doing this.
- 44:36And that's what I was trying to emphasize in how they gave it to
- 44:38New York Times. They emphasized.
- 44:40How much money was? They did a big check when they
- 44:42could have done a small one. They are totally happy to drive
- 44:46most people crazy and think what these For crits.
- 44:49I mean, the fact that it was coming right after the Atherton
- 44:51thing. They know, you know, the fact
- 44:54that it's going to drive, liberals crazy.
- 44:55They know that they like that, that's their branding.
- 44:57The Branding is appeal to Founders, you're telling the
- 45:01Press go, fuck yourselves, all your we work reporting.
- 45:03Sorry, Ellen. The guy's fine.
- 45:05He goes on again, doesn't matter and then it tells Founders that
- 45:10they're willing. If you're an exciting ambitious,
- 45:12founder there, they're here for you and so, yeah, I mean, I
- 45:16don't think they're, I don't think it's just like I don't
- 45:18know. But Marc Andreessen does love to
- 45:20troll. I mean, I don't think it's
- 45:21purely trolling. They've a strong articulated
- 45:23thesis around American dynamism and sort of trying to Branch out
- 45:26attack. They have too much money, but I
- 45:28do think there's an Impulse there, which is fuck the left.
- 45:32Like, fuck. All these people who say oh and
- 45:35I, you know, I was just on a podcast today.
- 45:37I mean there is like you listen to liberals sometimes talk about
- 45:39this stuff you know and I am a liberal but like they're like oh
- 45:42policy we need government to solve these things and it's like
- 45:45well government's not really maybe it slowly.
- 45:48Open now in California. But like what harm is there in?
- 45:52If he was going to invest, 250 million dollars in some software
- 45:56company, nobody's going to eject to that for the public.
- 45:59It's probably better that he's using the 350 million dollars.
- 46:02Maybe for his LPS, which are another constituent of mine.
- 46:05Maybe it's not good for them, but like, you know, I think the
- 46:09average person should be like, great, they're throwing some
- 46:11money is something that could help me, but I feel the, the
- 46:14reaction is like or and that that I think they drive some Joy
- 46:18from that sort of stupidity. I mean it is it is in line with
- 46:23like yeah his whole point and it's time to build his like oh
- 46:26we should the private markets should be trying to do some of
- 46:31these things better and if they can do them better like we
- 46:33shouldn't be like oh this is a thing that government needs to
- 46:35solve like so if it if it turns out that flow helped solve
- 46:39housing crises, I'm all for it, but I guess we'll have to see.
- 46:44Yes, right. Yes.
- 46:45But then I think the piece is like is Adam Newman, worthy of
- 46:50redemption. I mean, this is a very
- 46:52complicated question, but and I obviously have lots lots of
- 46:56opinions. But Ellen, I mean, maybe just
- 47:00just begin to answer that. You have a stack ranking of his
- 47:04sins are like, this is always the challenge with Uber people
- 47:07are, like, what do you think of uber?
- 47:08And I'm like, well, which issue like, but like what do you think
- 47:11are like the sins of Adam Newman?
- 47:14So I think there's a few interesting things that most
- 47:17people get wrong. About what happened at we work.
- 47:20Well, first of all, many people think that we work is like
- 47:22bankrupt. It's not.
- 47:23It's still around. They're just selling off his
- 47:24face. He's never been accused of
- 47:26crime. He's never been knowing that.
- 47:27That's and that's an important thing is, he has never been
- 47:30accused of a crime as far as I can tell.
- 47:33I don't know that he has like committed any sort of crime or
- 47:37done anything illegal like it's just doesn't seem like that's
- 47:40really what happened and it had happened.
- 47:42I think people would have liked if it had been able to be found
- 47:46out, you know, there's been a career-making move if you Yeah,
- 47:48there's a couple, there's been a couple very good books about we
- 47:50work. I would be surprised if those
- 47:52reporters had surfaced things like that.
- 47:54And the people who in my mind, got hurt the most on sort of a
- 48:01like, you know, received kind of like a disproportionate amount
- 48:05of hurt for it. Were employees, who joined, we
- 48:07were late in, you know, later on, in the company's, I guess
- 48:12maybe in the last few years between 2017, and 2018, and that
- 48:17sucked. And I think for a lot of those
- 48:18people, it really suck to have bought into this like, you know,
- 48:21this this vision of what the outcome could have been for the
- 48:25company and for themselves on and maybe put like the one hand.
- 48:28It's a bunch of white collar workers.
- 48:29You thought they're going to get super rich and then they didn't,
- 48:33but he gots. Yeah, Rich and they had.
- 48:36So I think I think that's the most egregious like unfairness
- 48:39of it, which is that like he did have the leverage in order to
- 48:42extract himself in a way that left other employees, like tons
- 48:46of people lost their jobs. A lot of people at stock that
- 48:48Like worthless and like of course that's part of being in a
- 48:52start-up like you are taking a Gamble and we crash, there's
- 48:55that scene where you like lays off a bunch of people and then
- 48:57they have what like some rapper come in.
- 49:00I mean, do you know if that's true or yeah.
- 49:03It's Run DMC. And that did really happen.
- 49:05It's true, it's true. My understanding is there were
- 49:08like, it was, like, a couple weeks later wasn't like that
- 49:10night or something, but the point is, yes, I think some of
- 49:13Adam's worst actions are were like his callousness, his greed,
- 49:17his kind of It's harder with victims.
- 49:19It's like, well, he acted unfairly in business sort of,
- 49:22you know? Yeah, there were, like, I think
- 49:24some, some financial decisions that were really not Kosher.
- 49:28But again, there's also, I would say, running a business that
- 49:31seemed like, it was just gonna like, collapse, if you, it was
- 49:34allowed to continue, like it was just like, when he didn't get
- 49:37the extra like, wasn't he supposed to be like a 10 billion
- 49:39dollar investment or something from SoftBank, right?
- 49:41What something? Yeah, something like that
- 49:44fortitude. Trying to get a company to go
- 49:46public at like 100 billion that ends up being worth.
- 49:48And there's there's a certain like delusion there like that
- 49:51that was gonna come crashing down.
- 49:53Well, and also the atom apologists will say that.
- 49:57The problem really wasn't so much with the idea of we work or
- 50:00its growth but was when SoftBank came in and Massa because of his
- 50:03need to have super-sized Returns on his vision fund, you know,
- 50:09thesis pushed him to go crazier and crazier.
- 50:11That's when you have stuff like we were, or we live and we learn
- 50:15and the really, really stupid shit that, you know, we grow We
- 50:18grow. Yeah.
- 50:19I mean, the stuff that became the worst aspects of the busy
- 50:22basically built a school for his own children.
- 50:25Like I again remember. We live in, you know, and he
- 50:26was, he had a hot tub in the office, like that's not an ice
- 50:30bath. Oh, that's good.
- 50:31Fact check. Yeah, no, but here's what I was
- 50:33going to say about about this, is that, okay?
- 50:35So that's that's one element of the we work story, but from a
- 50:39pure Venture Capital perspective, we work with a
- 50:42success Benchmark made money from.
- 50:44We were early in, we work. That was a great check if you
- 50:47were late, That was that right? My real takeaway from my piece,
- 50:51whatever you took about trolling was that the beauty of the
- 50:54Venture model is its staged Capital.
- 50:57You have a seed round, you have an a round your the be round if
- 51:00Andreessen had just written a 20 million dollar.
- 51:02Check in this thing, people would have still wind about it,
- 51:04but I think it would have been more reasonable.
- 51:06It's like okay. He is like really let's give him
- 51:08another shot and see if the risk goes down over time.
- 51:11It's the fact that they gave him 350 million that.
- 51:14It's just like we're going to do the SoftBank thing all over
- 51:16again. Yeah.
- 51:17I mean You guys are a little like, glassy-eyed on that one or
- 51:21what? You don't know if you agree or
- 51:23not. I don't realize.
- 51:24I just don't, I didn't get as worked up about it, other than
- 51:27it was funny. There's no question.
- 51:28It was funny. And that is one of the goals of
- 51:30trolling, which is why I Do by your trolling Theses to a degree
- 51:34is that there are certain people that are going to get mad and
- 51:36people getting mad about stuff is funny and Adam Newman is a
- 51:38clown. And when I see him back on the
- 51:41scene and makes me happy again, so I'm not against the idea of
- 51:44spending this money which as you pointed out in your piece and
- 51:47recent needs to deploy. Somehow he had billions and
- 51:50billions of dollars spread across multiple funds.
- 51:53There are only so many places to put it Adam Newman as you
- 51:56pointed out is very good at spending money and so if you
- 51:59want to get someone to like, that was a good line.
- 52:01What is it? What better way to deploy excess
- 52:03Capital than a real estate company run by Adam Newman or
- 52:06something like that? To quote myself?
- 52:08Yeah, I like your Kaufman here line.
- 52:09And then quoting it. And yeah.
- 52:11So in specific this is way too much.
- 52:14I don't know if that was word for word you know, but but you
- 52:17know, I I agree with you, I'm sorry to say like, I think all
- 52:21of that makes, you know, a ton of sense at least to a degree.
- 52:25I'm sure Andreessen would love for the money to give returns
- 52:27that. They can please their LPS, but I
- 52:30guess if you were to think about what is wrong with this picture
- 52:33here, if you really want to get mad about something, is that
- 52:36why? You know, we're also talking
- 52:38about this several weeks after the, you know, the Democrats
- 52:42have put forth a bill that remove the, you know, you know,
- 52:45they weren't able to get rid of the carried interest loophole.
- 52:48Which would have taxed. A lot of these people to a
- 52:52degree that they had never been taxed before that.
- 52:54Maybe would have cried a little bit more equity in the kind of
- 52:57government and public returns from the kind of excess wealth
- 53:01that is on display here because of all of these kinds of, you
- 53:05know, tech companies in the Venture Capital firms are
- 53:07raising a bunch of money here. So I guess if you really want to
- 53:10be mad about something, it should be just like the fact
- 53:12that injuries it has so much money to deploy that they're
- 53:15willing to take a certain percentage of it, you know,
- 53:17wrapped up in a troll. Owl and a money-losing scheme
- 53:19like that, that that makes a little more sense to me than the
- 53:22specific company that they invested in because it's someone
- 53:25else's money. It's the LPS problem, it's not
- 53:27mine. Well, I have a thought, which is
- 53:28like, I don't do. I mean, I think, Eric, you know,
- 53:30a little bit more about like sort of the decision-making
- 53:33behind-the-scenes and injuries and or at least have theories
- 53:37about it. So I think also a lot of people
- 53:39could rightfully be really just sort of like mad when they see
- 53:43this news because they feel that there are like other companies
- 53:47with other founders. Are not out of Newman who are
- 53:49more deserving in some way of getting the chance to build a
- 53:54business. I'm just curious if you think
- 53:56that and reason would eat. Like, I don't know, is that even
- 53:59is that even like a realistic? Is it even realistic to think
- 54:01that if they had chosen not to invest in an atom that they
- 54:04would have invested in the sort of people that, like, yeah, like
- 54:08our, I don't know like less likely to get some awesome.
- 54:12Somebody was saying to me in my mentions, like, or I forget
- 54:15where one of them but like, I mean there is just like a A
- 54:18reality, I think, among the wealthy, and like, Silicon
- 54:21Valley is guilty of this too, where it's like once you've been
- 54:24a Founder once you've been sea level, it's like, there's almost
- 54:27like a labor union that never let you fall back.
- 54:29There's almost it's sort of like the bigger you've gone.
- 54:31The more they're like, no, you're in our class.
- 54:34You're like, you're you're gonna get there.
- 54:35We're going to help you get there.
- 54:36We'll give you another shot. Like failed.
- 54:38Founders are some of the most desirable Founders.
- 54:40There is like, you've been in the class, like, instead of
- 54:43being like, oh, well, there's this new person, they haven't
- 54:45even failed. They could they, they have
- 54:48Fucked up is never even lived in Atherton.
- 54:50It's not to give them a chance, right?
- 54:53It's sort of like, he's in the club, he's got, he needs to have
- 54:55his, we're gonna give him the wig.
- 54:58I do feel like that's not how anyone, you know, in the world
- 55:01would articulate it. But I do think that sort of, I
- 55:03mean, the flip side of that, of course, is that they've had the
- 55:06experiences, he's sort of seen what jams him up, he knows how
- 55:09to do it, he was able to do some of the things like that, that
- 55:12sort of, that's the argument for the repeat founder and I do you
- 55:15think repeat Founders are somewhat successful but but
- 55:17there is also So this sense that.
- 55:19Yeah, once you've broken into the club, now the club isn't
- 55:22thankfully in America entirely old money, it is very male and
- 55:25white. But yeah, once you broken in
- 55:27somehow, it's like, oh now you're in it.
- 55:30Yeah, but I mean these things are totally zero.
- 55:32So I'm obviously, there's still lots of other money that's not
- 55:35necessarily going to meet diverse Founders as they should.
- 55:38But I do agree with the sentiment that it's like.
- 55:42Oh man, there's almost a preference.
- 55:44Like the guy who did badly like the thing.
- 55:47The thing that It badly on a big scale is what they like, you
- 55:50know, well, I guess I would just I think we should challenge
- 55:53Andreessen and all these other investors out there who have a
- 55:56lot of money, they need to deploy work a little bit harder.
- 55:59There are women there are minorities.
- 56:01They're people you wouldn't expect that have really, really
- 56:03bad ideas. That could be good at Burning
- 56:06through your money in ways that you wouldn't expect.
- 56:09And I think you need to look a little bit harder to find but I
- 56:11was really worried about this tank.
- 56:12I was like, what is he just gonna give like some sincere and
- 56:16okay. Yeah.
- 56:18The world of bad ideas. I just think there are all kinds
- 56:22of ideas out there that are awful that we haven't explored.
- 56:25And I think if you expand the Horizon of the kinds of people
- 56:28who are willing to invest in, you will find new and exciting
- 56:31ways to do that. And I want to see ya more
- 56:33diversity of Dylan's personally. Yeah.
- 56:35And like, look Adam Newman. Did it in one way.
- 56:38But who's to say, you know, a woman or a minority or other
- 56:40other kind of in wouldn't do it a different way.
- 56:41And way, that's fun. I can get their own show and
- 56:43we've seen Elizabeth Holmes. That's fine.
- 56:45She's kind of a token, bad female founder.
- 56:47There are others There are others and I think we should try
- 56:49to find them. Yeah, don't let Elizabeth Holmes
- 56:51being the only, yeah, representative team of Founders.
- 56:56Making bad decisions, right? Unfortunately, she's the one
- 56:59that actually did get charged with the crime to.
- 57:01I've even right. She is the worst of them.
- 57:04Yeah, it is. It is a fortunate, right?
- 57:06So this is actually a question is, do you think people actually
- 57:08wouldn't back Elizabeth Holmes again, or do you think if it's
- 57:10like, the criminal aspect is, that's the line.
- 57:13People are like, we won't, we won't go there if she had not
- 57:15been charged with the crime, 100%.
- 57:18Yes. 100%, yes, and because she has been charged with a crime.
- 57:21What do you think's going to? Like, what do you think?
- 57:23Elizabeth Holmes going to be doing?
- 57:24I think she's crossed the line that they're not.
- 57:26It's, there's only so much. You can actually troll it.
- 57:29I do think maybe in a couple of years, when we really get black
- 57:31pilled about stuff. You could see, Elizabeth,
- 57:34Holmes, getting money again for stuff.
- 57:36And I don't know if she actually, is she legally barred
- 57:38from running a company and points Crowley's, sort of coming
- 57:42back and he's trying to find their ways around the law.
- 57:44But yeah, I do think I do think Elizabeth Holmes because she You
- 57:49know, she built something to a degree and she was able to
- 57:52successfully raise a lot of money.
- 57:53She had that kind of Messianic cult leader type ability to
- 57:57convince investors that she had a Grand Vision.
- 57:59I do think she had a Grand Vision but I love we skirted
- 58:02this whole thing with Travis kalanick because what he raised
- 58:04from like the Saudis use like fuck everybody.
- 58:06Like I'm gonna do it just like it is, I don't know.
- 58:10Yeah, he's not doing PR but I mean, Travis is already raised a
- 58:13ton of money. So yeah, and an Uber is of the
- 58:17three of the most valuable companies.
- 58:18P'nay. So it's, you know, he wouldn't
- 58:20even really be considered. Like, that would nothing Event
- 58:22Horizon surprising at all. His was just a fight with his
- 58:26board and stuff. But but yeah, I think Elizabeth,
- 58:30Holmes, 100% would be able to raise a new round if it weren't
- 58:33for the criminally, only a couple of people to think it's a
- 58:35good idea right now. That's that's the thing, people
- 58:38always underestimate about the Venture model, you know.
- 58:41This was yeah I mean with we work it was really like two
- 58:45people had to agree that we work was worth, forty seven billion.
- 58:48It was a demand Masa and they did that's why that's why the
- 58:51company had that tag and now now that the value of we work is
- 58:57being decided by many people, it's less, right?
- 58:59Exactly. Maybe we can just close here on
- 59:02this aspect because this is a perfect question for you Ln
- 59:05because you do have experience with intentional living and
- 59:08these sort of things. I mean what would it take for
- 59:11you to live in an Adam Newman started and branded code living
- 59:15situation? What do you look for?
- 59:18What It needs to be Innovative. I mean, well, the, the
- 59:20translators I would do it for a story today.
- 59:22So, yeah, sign me. Sign me up, send me to South,
- 59:24Florida. I mean, you know, maybe like
- 59:27they give you some Burning Man, like software tools to prepare
- 59:31your Camp. Then then you go.
- 59:33I mean if I can get on my communal living soapbox for just
- 59:36a second. I don't think that shared
- 59:38amenity Apartments count as to me, like, actual co-living to
- 59:42me, I think I have, I have found that the way that you bring
- 59:45people together at their home, is by sharing a kitchen.
- 59:48That's all. Thank you.
- 59:49I just have to share a kitchen and Shirin occurrence.
- 59:52Gina currency within the household of sure token and
- 59:55everybody votes on the down. Let's just make sure that those
- 59:59are need housing script, that's it.
- 1:00:01I was thinking on the day, I mean, part of what's cool about
- 1:00:04your sort of intentional living is, you know, you guys have
- 1:00:07these, like, governing documents.
- 1:00:08I mean, it is sort of if you bring it up, dude.
- 1:00:10Yeah. We were down before.
- 1:00:11Doubts like work. Right, right.
- 1:00:13We don't have a token. But I did write a story a couple
- 1:00:16months ago about like a Company that's trying to do like van
- 1:00:19lice and communal living and they are going to run a lot of
- 1:00:23their business by a down and they're like really into the
- 1:00:26idea that web three philosophy and Technologies can help scale
- 1:00:31communities by having this sort of governance token type thing.
- 1:00:34I won't get too much into it but that, you know, there are, you
- 1:00:36know, people who are into Community are looking at.
- 1:00:41Yeah. Sort of crypto tools to help
- 1:00:43manage it but just to be clear, your advice to Adam Newman.
- 1:00:47Is it for this too? Work.
- 1:00:48You need people fighting over the leftovers in the fridge.
- 1:00:51No, in fact, the opposite is I think fighting like, it takes so
- 1:00:54much effort to fight over the kitchen.
- 1:00:56So, like, no one actually wants that, so I think he's, it's like
- 1:01:00they're calling it. I guess, what?
- 1:01:01I'm arguing is not there. They might, they might call it
- 1:01:04and we don't know that they're calling it co-living.
- 1:01:05I we work. They like sort of called it
- 1:01:07co-living and I argue that that's not the real deal.
- 1:01:09The Real Deals when you have to argue, you're saying they want.
- 1:01:12I think they will see me what I want and they don't do any of
- 1:01:14you community. Like yes, what do you think they
- 1:01:16could apply that at scale like Do you think your no one is
- 1:01:19sharing a kitchen and they still call it Community?
- 1:01:22I argue that that's false Community.
- 1:01:24I agree with you. You need to be forced to break
- 1:01:26bread. Yeah.
- 1:01:27And and, and you can take it a step further.
- 1:01:30I mean, I have cousins in Israel that live on kibbutz, teaming
- 1:01:33and raise their children. Communally, like there are
- 1:01:36multiple parents there, the, you know, that, that all call
- 1:01:38themselves at their most people, they call Mom and Dad because of
- 1:01:41that, which is something Adam Newman is probably very familiar
- 1:01:43with. I think that's really cool.
- 1:01:45So, of Andreessen, Horowitz does this.
- 1:01:47The right way, they can be Game with people's children before we
- 1:01:49know it. You know Jesus Christ I read was
- 1:01:52I wouldn't be surprised if you want to be living in these
- 1:01:55things. Like if it's not even an
- 1:01:57overstatement like you know, it's I mean yeah it would be
- 1:02:02cool to have like if they you know to have like tween old
- 1:02:05child care and stuff like that, I'd be like, that's something
- 1:02:08people would probably be really into, but I don't know if that's
- 1:02:10exactly the demographic, they're going for, we don't really know
- 1:02:12what Rebecca in charge of it. Yeah, well that's part of the
- 1:02:15idea here to, for sure. And, you know, plus You know,
- 1:02:18with Ilan trying to repopulate the world.
- 1:02:20We're seeing a lot of different approaches to both the creation
- 1:02:22and the earrings. So I think we should be more
- 1:02:25open to The Innovation that they think that they're that they're
- 1:02:28stumbling across. But anyway, we should probably
- 1:02:31wrap it up here. This is so fun.
- 1:02:32I mean, it's just nice, it's always good.
- 1:02:34When you have a podcast where you're like, oh I just want to
- 1:02:36hang out with this person anyway so we can have them on.
- 1:02:39Thanks for coming. We hope the feeling's mutual.
- 1:02:41Yeah. This was very fun.
- 1:02:43I'm glad to be part of the Year best Rolodex.
- 1:02:46Yeah, exactly. It's a who's who?
- 1:02:48Ooh. Yeah, our podcast Co-op we like
- 1:02:50to call it. You're now part of the dead.
- 1:02:52Cat communal, living situation. Goodbye,
- 1:03:07goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:03:09Goodbye goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:03:11Goodbye.